aace cost engineering journal

7/27/2019 AACE Cost Engineering Journal

1/48

www.aacei.o

ENGINEERING

July 20

THE JOURNAL OF AACE INTERNATIONAL -

THE AUTHORITY FOR TOTAL COST MANAGEMENTTM

COSTCOSTCOSTLESSONS LEARNED

SCHEDULE

DEVELOPMENT

USING PRIMAVERA P6

TM

PRESIDENTS

MESSAGE

ON THE

SHOULDERS

OF GIANTS

PRACTICAPROBLEMS WIT

PRICING DEL

USING EICHLE

AACE INTERNATIONALAUNCHES COMPREHENSIV

MENTORINPROGRA

LESSONS

GEESE

SPECIAL FOCUS

LESSONSFROM

Dr. McNeishs

GEESE

SPECIAL FOCUS


2/48


3/48COST ENGINEERING JULY ^__

CONTENTS

COST ENGINEERING

TECHNICAL ARTICLES

13 Le--)(- Lea,(ed B Sc"ed1&e De2e&)*'e(. U-#(! P,#'a2e,a PR

TM

Ha))a# E< Sc#2(ac#e-9 PSP9 a)d C#a-'$e Jac&.*)

Ma-< c.-31ac3 d.c8,e-32 a1e -.: 1e08(1(-& 3'e 82e .f 3'e +a3e23 9e12(.- .f P1(,a9e1a2.f3:a1e OP\ beca82e .f (32 e-3e1/1(2e ca/ab(+(3(e2 a-d (32 82e .f +a3e23 3ec'-.+.&(e2@ (-c+8d(-&3'e ca/ab(+(3(e2 3. (-3e1ac3 .3'e1 2.f3:a1e a//+(ca3(.-2 3'e1ef.1e (3 (2 (,/.13a-3 f.1 3'e 2c'ed8+e13. 8-de123a-d '.: 3. 82e 3'(2 2.f3:a1e ,.23 eff(c(e-3+< (- 3'e(1 ba33+e 3. c.,/+e3e 3'e(1 /1.)ec32(- a 3(,e+< ,a--e1 P1(,a9e1a2 +a3e23 1e+ea2e .f P\ c.-3a(-2 ,a-< fea381e2 3'a3 ca- a22(23 (-de9e+./(-& 2c'ed8+e2 08(c*+< a-d eff(c(e-3+


4/482 COST ENGINEERING JULY 5344

5 P&e'de#(+' Me''ageO" The Sh#*de%& #f Gia"'&

8 S%eca! F$c)'D%0 McNei&h1& Le&"& f%#! Gee&e

11 S%eca! Fea()&eAACE I"'e%"a'i#"a La*"che&C#!$%ehe"&i+e Me"'#%i"g P%#g%a!

36 The AACEI#(ea($#a! B)!!e(#Sec'i#" Ne,& f%#! A%#*"d 'he W#%d

4 AACE I"'e%"a'i#"a B#a%d #f Di%ec'#%&

4 C#&' E"gi"ee%i"g J#*%"a I"f#%!a'i#"

34 AACE Ne,& Fa&h

35 P%#fe&&i#"a Se%+ice& Di%ec'#%.

35 I"de- '# Ad+e%'i&e%&

42 AACE1& 67'h A""*a Mee'i"g

CONTENTS

DEPARTMENTS

ALSO FEATURED

COST ENGINEERING

41 I# Me"$&a"Re!e!be%i"g D##%e& E+a" Nei/ F%ed G0

O1D#""e/ a"d J#h" Da+i& Wa%%e"

43 A&(c!e Re%('a#d Pe&"''$#'Sha%i"g #*% A%'ice& a"d E-$e%ie"ce

44 Ca!e#da& $f E*e#('AACE I"'e%"a'i#"a E+e"'& a"d M#%e

THE AACE INTERNATIONAL ONLINE BUTTON 2 Thi& edi(#"

#f 'he Cost Engineeringj#*%"a ha& acce&& '# addi(#"a !a2

'e%ia #" 'he AACE I"'e%"a(#"a ,eb&i'e/ www.aacei.org0

A".(!e .#* &ee 'he &.!b# a' ce"'e%/ 'he%e i& addi(#"a

c#"'e"' #"i"e a&cia'ed ,i'h 'ha' a%(ce #% fea'*%e0 Di%ec'

.#*% b%#,&e% '# www.aacei.orga"d ##k f#% 'he #"i"e b*'2

'#" '# acce&& addi(#"a %e*%ce&0 If .#* a%e a%ead. %eadi"g

'he eec'%#"ic +e%&i#"/ j*&' cick 'he #"i"e b*)#" di%ec'.0


5/48


6/48

COSTENGINEERING

4 COST ENGINEERING JULY `^__

HEADQUARTERS_` S8-c1e23 T.:-e Ce-31e D1

M.1&a-3.:-@ WV `^

^^COST fa; ^`g_`

CONTENTSAACE INTERNATIONALBOARD OF DIRECTORS

PRESIDENTM(c'ae+ R N.2b(2c'@ CCC PSP

``` /1e2(de-3aace(.1&

PRESIDENT@ELECTMa1+e-e H


7/48

I- 3'(2 "123 P1e2(de-32 Me22a&e .f ,< ad,(-(231a5.-@

I 3'.8&'3 I :.8+d 3a*e 2.,e 5,e 3. 1e$ec3 .- fa,.82

+eade12 3'1.8&'.83 '(23.1


8/486 COST ENGINEERING JULY 5344

if I had "aken "he #me "o ead i" back "hen 1along 'i"h "he o"he

book! po!cibed on "he Commandan",! Li!"2+ I hadn," eall)

"ho%gh" of i" befoe* b%" "hee ma) be an elemen" of !%bcon0

!cio%! g%il" behind "he ea!on "ha" I am !o en"halled 'i"h

eading abo%" hi!"oical leade! no'+

The abili") "o lean fom gea" leade! of "he pa!" i! one of

"he ke) ea!on! "ha" I popo!ed la!" )ea "o hold a -Pa!" Pe!i0

den",! Fo%m. d%ing each Ann%al Mee#ng* an idea "ha" I ad0

mi$edl) copied fom an a!!ocia#on "ha" 'e ha&e a coopea#&eageemen" 'i"h* PMI,! EVM Comm%ni") of Pac#ce 1pe&io%!l)

"he College of Pefomance Managemen"2+

I,m defini"el) no" a!hamed "o boo' a good idea fom an0

o"he go%p "ha" ha! had a !%cce!! 'i"h i"* and I,m defini"el)

no" a!hamed "o look "o "he pe&io%! leade! of AACE "o ge"

"hei inp%" and "ho%gh"! a! "o "he c%en" !"a"e of "he a!!ocia0

#on and 'hee 'e !ho%ld be headed in "he f%"%e+

La!" )ea,! e&en" 'a! %nde!"andabl) lo' ke)* b%" i" 'a!

a$ended b) !e&eal Pa!" Pe!iden"! of "he A!!ocia#on* and

man) ha&e been eq%e!#ng !pecific! on "hi! )ea,! mee#ng in

Anaheim* 'hich 'ill be m%ch moe fomal in na"%e "han "he

5343 &e!ion+ Mo&ing fo'ad* I in"end fo i" "o be a cone0

!"one of "he Ann%al Mee#ng* b%" "he ela#on!hip! "ha" I hope"o b%ild 'i"h "he pa!" leade! of AACE 'ill e("end "ho%gho%"

m) "em and in"o m) follo'0on ole a! Pa!" Pe!iden"+

EDITORS NOTE: To engage in o"he di!c%!!ion!* check o%" AACE

In"ena"ional,! Online Fo%m! a" '''+aacei+og/fo%m!+

Now:If sched ulesnee d ed an alysis,Pr imave r awou ld have includ ed it.

Seemoreathttp://ScheduleAnalyzer.c om

Wh atisth ediffe rence betwe enrevie wing yourP6 sch edulea ndre viewin gyou rP6 XERfile ?Every thing

Inte rfacesDirectly withDatabas eHu ndredso fRepo rts&Analyse sAd vanced Longes tPathAnalysisBu ilt-inReport&Editin gFacilit yDril l-down fromDashbo ardtoP6

Now: If schedules needed analysis,

Primavera would have included it.

See more at

http://ScheduleAnalyzer.com

What is the difference betweenreviewing your P6 schedule and

reviewing your P6 XER file?

Everything

Interfaces Directly with Database

Hundreds of Reports & Analyses

Advanced Longest Path Analysis

Built-in Report & Editing Facility

Drill-down from Dashboard to P6


9/48

Fuse is an enterprise project analysis software which uses libraries of metrics to offer not only

advanced schedule quality analysis, but additionally assesses cost forecast accuracy, risk morealism, earned value, project performance, logic integrity and project forensics.

Fuse is more than just a schedule critique, it is a comprehensive project analysistool spanning

numerous facets and phases that make up a complete project.

Acumen Fuse

Project analysis andvisualization software

Download a trial version at: www.projectacumen.com/tria

Acumen Fuseintegrates with Primavera, Microsoft Project, Deltek, Asta, and MicrosoftExcel

V LID TEVALIDATEschedulequality and build more

realistic plans

IDENTIFYIDENTIFYlogic flawsin a single project or aportfolio

OMP RECOMPAREmultipleschedule iterations andpinpoint variances

TTR KRACKprojectperformance fromplanning throughexecution and close-out

EV LU TEEVALUATEschedulecost, and earned valuetrending

LIGNALIGNschedule withcost and risk information

Enterprise Project nalysisEnterprise Project Analysis


10/488 COST ENGINEERING JULY `^__

D1 R.be13 McNe(2'@ a 2c(e-ce 3eac'e1 :'. be

ca,e a 1e2/ec3ed 2c'..+ ad,(-(231a3.1 (- Ba+

5,.1e@ MD@ :a2 a +(fe+.-& .b2e19e1 .f 3'e

,(&1a3.1< 'ab(32 .f 3'e &1ea3 $.c*2 .f &ee2e

3'a3 /a22ed 3'1.8&' 3'e C'e2a/ea*e :e3

+a-d2 eac' fa++ a-d 2/1(-& I- _g`@ 'e c.,

,(6ed 3. /a/e1 '(2 .b2e19a5.-2 .- &ee2e a-d ,a-*(-d :'e-

'e :1.3e@ Le22.-2 f1., 3'e Gee2e@ a2 /a13 .f a 2e1,.- f.1 '(2

c'81c' H(2 c+e9e1 /1.2e beca,e a- .% 1e/ea3ed@ b83 2e+d.,

/1./e1+< c(3ed ,.59a5.-a+ 23.1< f.1 &1.8/2 1a-&(-& f1., T.a23

,a23e12 3. 3'e B.< Sc.832

A3 3'e ^__ A--8a+ Mee5-& a:a1d2 +8-c'e.- (- A-a'e(,@

CA@ AACE I-3e1-a5.-a+ e,/+.


11/48

*ec'g&!4ed ,ec&!ca$ a/,'*!,3 !& c'+, a&d +ced/$e %a&age=

%e&, f'* (*'g*a%+7 (*'"ec,+7 (*'d/c,+7 a++e,+7 a&d +e*0!ce+9


20/48

3'a- ,(+e23.-e2 T'e 2ec.-d 3(e (2 f(-(2'

3.f(-(2'@ 3'(1d (2 23a133.23a13@ a-d

f.813' (2 23a133.f(-(2'

T'e 82e1 2'.8+d be ca1ef8+ :'e-

a22(&-(-& 1e+a3(.-2'(/2 82(-& 3'(2

,e3'.d 2(-ce P a++.:2 f.1 ,8+3(/+e

1e+a3(.-2'(/ a22(&-,e-32 O(e@ f(-(2'3.

23a13 :(3' a f(-(2'3.f(-(2' :(3' a 23a13

3.23a13 :(3' a 23a133.f(-(2' U2e 3'e

8-d. 3. de+e3e 3'e +a23 3(e c1ea3ed

O(-d(9(d8a+ 3(e .-+



ca+c8+a3(.-2 f.1 3'e /1.)ec3 O(CeC@ da



:(3'(- ac1.22 ,8+3(/+e /1.)ec32 :(3'(-

3'e EPS

I- P c.23 +.ad(-& (2 3


23/48

/e1f.1,a-ce (- P (2 8/da3ed

a83.,a3(ca++< 8-+e22 2/ec(f(ed (-

P1(,a9e1a 82(-& /e1ce-3 c.,/+e3e

T'e1e a1e 3'1ee /e1ce-3 c.,/+e3e 3



defa8+3@ ba2ed .- 3'e /1edece22.12

ca+e-da1 .1 :.1* /e1(.d T'e 82e1@

3'1.8&' 3'e 2c'ed8+(-& ./3(.-2@ ca-

c'..2e 3. 82e 3'e 28cce22.12 ca+e-da1

f.1 +a& ,ea281e,e-3 a2 :e++ a2 3'e

/1.)ec32 defa8+3 ca+e-da1 /1.)ec3

de3a(+2@ defa8+32 3ab@ .1 a ` '.81

ca+e-da1

O3'e1 ca+c8+a3(.- 18+e2 a1e def(-ed

b< de3e1,(-(-& '.: P d(2/+a



C'a1+(e Jac*2.- (2 :(3' H(++

I-3e1-a3(.-a+ He ca- be

c.-3ac3ed b< 2e-d(-& e

,a(+ 3.B

c'a1+(e)ac*2.-'(++(-3+c.,

Expertise. Technology. Results.

Energy and Sustainability

Management

Capital Budgeting and

Programming

Sustainable Planningand

Design

Program and Construction

Management

Capital Asset Management

www.mocasystems.com

C O N S T R U C T I O N

C O N S U L T I N G S E R V I C E S

www.mbpce.com | 800-898-9088

Project Closeout

NAMED A BEST SMALL COMPANY TO WORK

FOR IN AMERICA FOR 2010

TOP 100 CONSTRUCTION MAN AGEMENT FIRM

D#,ec. D)3(&)ad-

a2a#&ab&e a. ."e

AACE O((e S.),eAACE I-3e1-a5.-a+ (2 -.:

.!e1(-& d(1ec3 d(&(3a+ d.:-+.ad2 .f

,a-< .f .81 /8b+(ca5.-2 a3 3'e

AACE O-+(-e S3.1e D.:-+.ad(-& d(

1ec3+< (2 a fa23 a-d ea2< :a< 3. &e3

3'e c.-3e-3


26/48

Dela+ i% a c!mm! !cc'$$ece !

c!%&$'c&i! "$!jec&%0 Dela+

ma+ be ca'%ed b+ ac&i! !$

iac&i! !f &he !)e$. &hei$ de%ige$ !$

c!%&$'c&i! maage$/ !$ b+ &he

c!&$ac&!$. &hei$ %'bc!&$ac&!$%.

%'""lie$%. !$ deli(e$+me/ !$ b+ !'&%ide

f!$ce% %'ch a% )ea&he$. lab!$ ac&i!%. )a$

!$ ac&% !f &e$$!$i%m. ma&e$ial %h!$&age%.

e&c0 The li%& !f "!&e&ial ca'%e% !f dela+ i%

e*&e%i(e0 Wha& !)e$% ad c!&$ac&!$%

f!c'% ! i &he e(e& !f dela+ i% h!) &!

deal )i&h &he i%%'e 'de$ &he &e$m% adc!di&i!% !f &he c!&$ac&0

M!%& %&ada$d f!$m c!&$ac&%. i

b!&h &he "'blic ad &he "$i(a&e %ec&!$.

deal )i&h a& lea%& &h$ee &+"e% !f dela+ i

&hei$ &e$m% ad c!di&i!%. a% f!ll!)%0

Inexcusable Delay 6 Thi% i% dela+

ca'%ed b+ &he c!&$ac&!$. !$ !e hi%

%'bc!&$ac&!$% !$ %'""lie$% a& a+ &ie$0

T+"icall+. m!%& c!&$ac&% de+ a+ &ime !$

c!%& $ec!(e$+ &! &he c!&$ac&!$ i &he

e(e& !f ie*c'%able dela+ ad $e#'i$e

&he c!&$ac&!$ &! $ec!(e$ &he l!%& &ime. !$

"a+ ac&'al !$ li#'ida&ed damage% f!$ la&e

c!m"le&i!0

Excusable Delay 6 Thi% i% dela+

b$!'gh& ab!'& b+ a &hi$d "a$&+ 7&ha& i%.

ei&he$ &he !)e$ !$ &he c!&$ac&!$8 !$

%!me !'&%ide f!$ce %'ch a% )ea&he$. ac&%

!f G!d. ac&% !f )a$ !$ &e$$!$i%m. lab!$

ac&i!%. e&c0 P$i(a&e c!&$ac&% f$e#'e&l+

deal )i&h &hi% %i&'a&i! i &he F!$ce

Maje'$e cla'%e. )hile ma+ "'blic

c!&$ac&% icl'de &hi% &+"e !f dela+ i &he

Te$mia&i! f!$ Defa'l& cla'%e 9


27/48COST ENGINEERING JULY >:04

HOOH- ge!e%all,- a%e 'h"&e c"&'&

i!c(%%ed b, a c"!'%ac'"% f"% 'he be!efi'

"f all #%"jec'& i! #%"g%e&&0 Thi& i& a!

ac'(al c"&'- *hich i& a! e&&e!'ial #a%' "f

'he c"&' "f d"i!g b(&i!e&& 9@



S3a3ed ,.1e d(1ec3+

Le32 -.: e;a,(-e 3'e /1ac3(ca+

/1.b+e,2 :(3' 3'e 82e .f 3'e E(c'+ea

C&a1-e U-de1 3'(2 a//1.ac' 3'e

.:-e1 ,a< e23ab+(2'@ b< c.-31ac3@ a

&1ace /e1(.d .1 dead ba-d be


32/48

Ad,(-(231a3(.-@ 3'e Ve3e1a-2

Ad,(-(231a3(.- a-d 3'e US P.23a+

Se19(ce 'a9e a++ ad./3ed

c.-31ac38a++< f(;ed .9e1'ead 1a3e2

:'(c' 'a9e :(3'23..d c.813

c'a++e-&e2 Qg T. 2ee 3'e

Ve3e1a-2 Ad,(-(231a3(.- .9e1'ead

+(,(3a3(.- c+a82e 2ee FAR P@OK O:-e12 ,a

aace cost engineering journal

Documents