abhyaas law bulletin - march 2012
TRANSCRIPT
8/2/2019 Abhyaas Law Bulletin - March 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/abhyaas-law-bulletin-march-2012 1/4Rma Ijv Oqiiarce… \jfa : vvv%jomsjjp%ce
omsjjp Ijv Oqiiarce …Ndr ma zqceappaecji @IJR jp|crje
jr`m:<m ?<:? JIO?<:?<0<0
Rma Abcdr–p @diqge
Bajr Pqbae)
Vai`dga d ma Gjr m abccde dn ma Jomsjjp Ijv
Oqiiace% Rma ijp gdem vceappab faearji aia`cdep
d Jppagoicap ce nc~a pjap% Rma @defrapp |jrs–p
|arndrgje`a `dqib j oap oa bap`rcoab jp bcpjprdqp%
Rma |jrs ncecpmab ndqrm ce Q\) idp Fdj jeb \qekjo% Cfd kqp dea paj gdra mje OK\ ce Qjrjhmjeb jeb c
rafjceab |dvar vcm je cg|rappc~a gjkdrcs ce
Gjec|qr% Rma rapqip p|aii rdqoia ndr ma rqicef Q\J
vcm ma jiicapa}|a ab d j dqfm%
Rma OK\ rqiab pjap jeb pjap rqiab os rafcdeji
|jrcap d||dpa ma @aera&p |ijep d `raja j Ejcdeji
@dqear'Rarrdrcpg @aera -E@R@# jiiafcef jj`h de
|dvarp dn ma pja% Rma RJRJp nciab j ra~cav |accde
ce ma Pq|raga @dqr de ma ?F p|a`rqg ~arbc`%
Rma Cebcje Gae–p Md`has ajg zqjicncab ndr ma ?<:?
Idebde Disg|c`p jnar banajcef Nrje`a ce ma
zqjicncarp% J`a Cebcje ojpgje _jmqi Brj~cb
jeedqe`ab mcp racragae nrdg Cearejcdeji `rc`ha
jnar je ciiqprcdqp `jraar p|jeecef :> sajrp% Rma 13m
Ejcdeji Ncig Jvjrbp vara jeedqe`ab jeb jp
a}|a`ab) ^cbsj Ojije vde ma Oap J`rapp jvjrb ndr
mar rdia ce ”Rma Bcrs \c`qra–%
Mj||s _ajbcef *
-_jhapm Bqoqbq# Ceba};
\jfa ?; Ejcdeji
\jfa 0; Cearejcdeji
\jfa 2; P|dicfm
Rma P`dd| Dn Rma Gdem
P\ pvaa|p Q\ Aia`cdep jeb mrdvp OP\
dq dn |dvar%
e j pqeecef aia`drji |arndrgje`a mj
ba`cgjab ma rqicef Ojmqkje Pjgjk \jrs ce Qjr
\rjbapm) Gqijsjg Pcefm&p Pjgjkvjbc \jrs vde
??2 Jppagois pajp) raiafjcef ma ejcdeji |jrcap
OK\ jeb @defrapp d j |ddr 0rb jeb 2m |ij`a
ap|a c~ais% A~ae mdqfm ma fj| ce pajp
oavaae ma P\ jeb ma OP\ vjp d~ar :2<) ma
~da pmjra bcnnarae`a vjp deis jodq ?%1 |ar `ae)
ebc`jcef mj ma dqfdcef @mcan Gcecpar)
Gjsjvjc) mjb rajceab mar dra ~da%
e ma dmar ndqr Pjap vmdpa rapqip vara jipd
ba`ijrab de Gjr`m >m) ma Pmcrdgjec Jhjic Bji
PJB#'iab fd~aregae ce \qekjo bancab ma
|diiparp jeb gjba mcpdrs) oa`dgcef ma ncrp
ce`a ma Pja vjp `rajab ce :3>> d vce vd`depa`qc~a aia`cdep% Ce Fdj) ma OK\ dqpab ma
@defrapp nrdg |dvar8 vceecef ?: d ma ijar&p 3%
Rma @defrapp raqreab ma `dg|icgae ce
Qjrjhmjeb) ejrrdvis banajcef ma OK\) vmcia
`dgndrjois rajcecef ma edrm ajpare Pja dn
Gjec|qr%
n ma |ad|ia&p ~arbc` ce ma nc~a Pjap ordqfm
cia `maar d ma vd ejcdeji |jrcap) ndr ma
qicef @defrapp) c vjp |jrc`qijris frcg; os `dgcef
e ndqrm ce Q%\%) jbbcef iapp mje j mjin j bd{ae@deb…%%
8/2/2019 Abhyaas Law Bulletin - March 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/abhyaas-law-bulletin-march-2012 2/4Rma Ijv Oqiiarce… \jfa ? vvv%jomsjjp%ce
jr`m:<m ?<:?
Ejrcdeji;
ajp d cp ?<<6 p`dra dn ??) zqapcdep jodq ma
@defrapp& jocics d p|ajrmajb j ra~c~ji ce ma Mcebc
majrijeb oafje d oa jphab jfjce) vcm cp macr
j||jrae _jmqi Fjebmc ce ma bd`h% Rma |jrs&p ~c`drs
e Qjrjhmjeb) os j vmcphar) vjp `dib `dgndr) a~ae
mdqfm c aepqrab mj ma OK\&p @mcan Gcecpar) O%H%Hmjebqrc) idp mcp dve paj% Deis Dhrjg Codoc Pcefm)
vmd vjp ~crqjiis vrcae dnn jnar ijp sajr&p `rc||icef
a`dedgc` oid`hjba ce Gjec|qr) p`rc|ab j p|iaebcb mj'
rc`h ndr ma @defrapp ce ma prcna'dre Pja%
Ndr ma OK\) cp kds ce pej`mcef Fdj nrdg ma @defrapp
jeb raqrecef d |dvar ce \qekjo jp ma kqecdr |jrear)
vjp gdra mje dnnpa os cp bcpgji pmdvcef ce Q%\%)
vmara c `dqib ed a~ae gjcejce cp ?<<6 p`dra dn 1:%
Rma OK\) icha ma @defrapp) mjb pjhab j fraj baji ce
Q%\%) md|cef mj je cg|rd~agae ce cp ndrqeap vdqib
|j~a ma vjs ndr ma ocf ejcdeji pmdvbdve ce ?<:2% Cn
ma @defrapp&p |ddr prjafs jeb ij`h dn drfjecpjcde
jciab c ce ma Pja) ma OK\ vjp ed kqp j bc~cbab
mdqpa ‒ cp jbgccef ma jceab Ojoqrjg Hqpmvjmj
arjpab ma fjcep c mjb gjba os cp phcinqi rcbcef de ma
`djjcip dn ma Jeej Mj{jra jec'`drrq|cde gd~agae%
Rma ocf pdrs vjp) dn `dqrpa) ma njmar'pde bqd dn
Gqijsjg Pcefm jeb Jhmciapm Sjbj~ vmd |dvarab ma
P\ d j orciicjeis prjafcpab aia`drji rcqg|m% Cn Gr%
Gqijsjg Pcefm) vmd vcii oa ma ea} @mcan Gcecpar dn
Q%\%) ndr j ndqrm cga) vjp ma cep|crjcde ndr mcp `ije dn Sjbj~p) bap|arja d oa oj`h ce |dvar jnar j nc~a sajr
brdqfm) c vjp mcp 03'sajr'dib pde vmd vjp ma pjr dn
ma pmdv%
Jhmciapm Sjbj~ `d~arab :<)<<< hg de mcp ’`s`ia dn
md|a)‗ jbbrappab =<< rjiicap ce pc} gdemp jeb
rjepndrgab ma cgjfa dn ma |jrs% Ce bdcef pd) ma
jbbab j vmdia eav `depcqae`s d mcp |jrs )cn mcp
ena`cdqp pgcia jeb ajps gjeear j`ab icha j gjfea
dr ma sdqm) mcp a`m pj~~ceapp) `dgoceab vcm ma
|jrs&p gjecnapd |rdgcpa dn ij|d|p jeb joiap ndrqbaep) fj~a ma |jrs j `deag|drjrs iddh% Ncejiis)
mcp pmqeecef dn prdefgje B%\% Sjbj~ pae dq ma
gappjfa mj ma P\ vjeab d pmab cp cgjfa dn j |jrs
dn gqp`iab ijvorajharp%
e \qekjo) jedmar njmar'pde bqd) \jrhjpm Pcefm Ojbji
jeb Pqhmocr Pcefm) rdba oj`h d |dvar ojicef
j``qpjcdep dn ea|dcpg jeb `drrq|cde) vceecef 1>
ajp ce ma ::6'gagoar Jppagois) jfjcep ma
@defrapp& 2>) bjpmcef @j|jce Jgjrcebar Pcefm&p md|ap
dn oa`dgcef ma @mcan Gcecpar%
Rma PJB&p |jrear) ma OK\) idp pa~ae pajp)
vceecef deis :? jfjcep :3 ce ?<<6% Rvd id`ji
|jrcap) ma \ad|ia&p \jrs dn \qekjo) iab os
Gje|raa Pcefm Ojbji) j raoai `dqpce dn ma
Ojbjip) jeb ma Pmcrdgjec Jhjic Bji -Jgrcpjr#
majbab os ma gj~arc`h a}'`d|) Pcgrjekc Pcefm
Gjee) dfamar pa`qrab :< |ar `ae dn ma ~da)
a~cbaeis bjgjfcef ma @defrapp rjmar mje maPJB&p |rdp|a`p% Jp ce ma `jpa dn ma P\ ce Q%\%)
Pqhmocr Ojbji dib kdqrejicpp mj mcp
d`dfaejrcje njmar vdqib oa ma @mcan Gcecpar
jfjce%
Ce Fdj) ma CCR'abq`jab Gjedmjr \jrrchjr) vmdpa
`jg|jcfe jfjcep ma @defrapp'iab fd~aregae
de ma cppqa dn ciiafji gcecef oa`jga j rjiiscef
|dce ndr jec'@defrapp paecgae ce ma Pja) vcii
oa ma @mcan Gcecpar ndr j mcrb cga%
Pq|raga @dqr prchap bdve Jrgp J` |rd~cpcde
ndr gjebjdrs bajm |aejis
Rma Pq|raga @dqr de Naorqjrs :p ba ijrab
qe`depcqcdeji Pa`cde ?6 -0# dn ma Jrgp J`)
vmc`m |rd~cbap ndr gjebjdrs bajm paeae`a d
je j``qpab `mjrfab vcm je dnnae`a qebar mcp
|rd~cpcde%
Pa`cde ?6-0# pjsp; ’Vmda~ar qpap jes |rdmcocab
jrgp dr |rdmcocab jggqeccde dr bdap jes j` ce
`derj~aecde dn Pa`cde 6 jeb pq`m qpa dr j`
rapqip ce ma bajm dn jes dmar |arpde pmjii oa
|qecpmjoia vcm bajm%‗
J Oae`m dn Kqpc`ap J%H% Fjefqis jeb K%P% Hmamjr
pjcb; ’J ijv vmc`m cp ed `depcpae vcm edcdep
dn njcreapp vmcia c cg|dpap je crra~arpcoia |aejis
icha bajm cp ra|qfeje d ma `de`a| dn rcfm jeb
rajpde%‗
Vrccef ma kqbfgae) Kqpc`a Fjefqis pjcb ma
p`d|a dn Pa`cde ?6-0# vjp ~ars vcba ce mj
jesmcef bdea ce `derj~aecde dn Pa`cde 6 jebvcm ma qpa dn |rdmcocab jrgp jeb jggqeccde
rapqicef ce bajm vdqib jrj` ma bajm |aejis%
’A~ae cn je j` bdea ce `derj~aecde dn Pa`cde 6)
ejgais) j`zqcpccde dr |dppappcde dr gjeqnj`qra
dr pjia dn |rdmcocab jrgp rapqip ce ma bajm dn
jes |arpde) ma |arpde ce `derj~aecde dn
Pa`cde 6 pmjii oa |qecpmab vcm bajm%‗
Rma Oae`m maib mj mcp |rd~cpcde vjp jfjcep ma
nqebjgaeji aeap dn ma `depcqcdeji ijv
jeb qirj ~crap ma @depcqcde%
8/2/2019 Abhyaas Law Bulletin - March 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/abhyaas-law-bulletin-march-2012 3/4Rma Ijv Oqiiarce… \jfa 0 vvv%jomsjjp%ce
jr`m:<m ?<:?
Ijhpmsj':& ap'nidve pq``appnqiis
ebcj&p cebcfaedqpis ba~aid|ab gc`rd'icfm |cidiapp
jrfa jcr`rjn ”Ijhpmsj':& vjp pq``appnqiis ap'nidve
rdg ma Ceafrjab Rap _jefa j @mjebc|qr) ce
Drcppj de Nao =m%
13m
Ejcdeji Ncig Jvjrbp jeedqe`abOap Najqra Ncig; Pmjrab os Baddi -Gjrjmc# jeb
Osjrc -Osjrc#
ebcrj Fjebmc Jvjrb Ndr Oap Baoq Ncig dn j
Bcra`dr; Jjrjesjhjebjg -Rjgci#
Jvjrb ndr Oap \d|qijr Ncig \rd~cbcef Vmdiapdga
Aearjcegae; J{mjfjrpjgcsceHqmcrjc-Rjgci#
Oap @mcibrae–p Ncig; @mciijr \jrs-Mcebc#
Oap Bcra`cde; Fqr~cebarPcefm ndr Jema Fmdras Bj
Bjje -\qekjoc#Oap J`dr; Fcrcpm Hqihjrec ndr Baddi -Gjrjmc#
Oap J`rapp; ^cbsj Ojije ndr Rma Bcrs \c`qra -Mcebc#
Oap Pq||drcef J`dr; J||q Hqs ndr J{mjfjrpjgcsce
Hqmcrjc -Rjgci#
Oap Pq||drcef J`rapp; Iacpmjefmag
Rdemdcefjgoc Ba~c ndr \mckcfaa Gjec-Gjec|qrc#
Oap @mcib Jrcp -Pmjrab#; \jrmd Fq|a ndr Pjeias hj
Bjooj -Mcebc# Crrnje Hmje) Pjejm Gaede) _dmje
Frd~ar) Ejgje Kjce) Jjrj~ Hmjeej) ^cpmapm Rcvjrc)
@mcegjc @mjebrjepmqm) ^abje Bapjc) Bc~ck Mjebj jeb
Pmrcsj Pmjrgj ndr @mciijr \jrs-Mcebc#
Oap Gjia \ijsoj`h Pcefar; Jejeb Omja ndr
Ojifjebmjr~j-Gjrjmc#
Oap Nagjia \ijsoj`h Pcefar; _dd|jFjefqis ndr
Jodpmaspmas -Oaefjic#
Pq|raga @dqr jphp vmj j`cde mjp oaae jhae
jfjcep a}'@KC
Rma Pq|raga @dqr de Naorqjrs :0
m
jphab ma @aerad orcan c de vmamar c mjb `debq`ab je cezqcrs de
ma bcp|rd|drcdeja jppap jiiafjcde jfjcep ma
drgar @mcan Kqpc`a dn Cebcj jeb Ejcdeji Mqgje
_cfmp @dggcppcde -EM_@# `mcan H%F% Ojijhrcpmeje%
J Oae`m majbab os @mcan Kqpc`a P%M% Hj|jbcj bcra`ab
ma fd~aregae d rap|deb vcmce j gdem de ma
j`cde jhae dr ceaebab d oa jhae de ma jiiafjcde
mj ma ndrgar @KC j`zqcrab |rd|arcap vdrm _p% 2<
`rdra ce mcp raijc~ap& ejgap oavaae ?<<2 jeb ?<<3%
Vdrib Ojeh mcan [daiic`h ba`cbap d pa| bdve
Vdrib Ojeh \rapcbae _doar [daiic`h mjp
jeedqe`ab d pa| bdve j ma aeb dn mcp nc~a'
sajr'arg ce Kqea) fc~cef rcpa d p|a`qijcde mj
ma Pa rajrs dn Pja) Mciijrs @icede) gjs oa
majbab d ra|ij`a mcg) vmc`m vjp cggabcjaisbaecab os mar jcba%
Cebcje bc|idgj jphab d |js ":%1 gciicde d a}
Gjcb
J Eav Sdrh @cs Gjfcprja ra`dggaebab mj je
Cebcje bc|idgj) Eaaej Gjimdrj) jeb mar
mqpojeb Kdfapm oa razqcrab d |js dq eajris ":%1
gciicde ndr ndr`cef je Cebcje fcri) Pmjec Fqrqef) j
ma cga pjcb d oa qebarjfa) d vdrh vcmdq |jsjeb gacef dq ’ojrojrc` rajgae‗ d mar ce
macr |iqpm Ajp 20rb Praa Gjemjje j|jrgae%
J``drbcef d ra|drp ma Gjimdrjp cebq`ab Gp%
Fqrqef d ’vdrh vcmdq |js os pac{cef mar
|jpp|dr jeb ~cpj) raprc`cef mar jocics d iaj~a
macr j|jrgae) jeb `depjeis vjrecef mar mj cn
pma rj~aiab de mar dve vcmdq macr |argcppcde)
pma vdqib oa jrrapab) oajae) rj|ab jeb pae
oj`h d Cebcj jp ”`jrfd&)‗ ce ma vdrbp dn
Gjfcprja Kqbfa Nrjeh Gjjp%
Cebcj ed gdra j |dicd'aebagc dqers; VMD
Rma Vdrib Majim Drfjecpjcde -VMD# mjp
ragd~ab Cebcj nrdg ma icp dn |dicd'aebagc`
`dqercap) pqffapcef mj ma vcib |dicd ~crqp mjb
oaae djiis aicgcejab nrdg ma ae~crdegae% Rma
bcpajpa |jrjispab mdqpjebp dn `mcibrae a~ars sajr
ndr pa~arji ba`jbap% Rmcp jeedqe`agae vjp gjba
os Majim jeb Njgcis \ijeecef Gcecpar Fmqijg
Ejoc J{jb mara j ma \dicd Pqggc ?<:? ce ma|rapae`a dn \rcga Gcecpar Gjegdmje Pcefm)
jgcbp j mqebardqp j||ijqpa% Rma naj `jga jnar
Cebcj pq``appnqiis `dg|iaab je aecra sajr
vcmdq je ce`cbae`a dn |dicd%
Gr% J{jb pjcb ma ra`ac~ab j iaar nrdg ma Qecab
Ejcdep odbs pjcef mj ma ’VMD mjp jhae
Cebcj&p ejga dnn ma icp dn |dicd aebagc` `dqercap
ce ~cav dn ma ragjrhjoia |rdfrapp mj va mj~a
gjba bqrcef ma |jp dea sajr%‗
Cearejcdeji
8/2/2019 Abhyaas Law Bulletin - March 2012
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/abhyaas-law-bulletin-march-2012 4/4Rma Ijv Oqiiarce… \jfa 2 vvv%jomsjjp%ce
jr`m:<m ?<:?
P|dicfm; Br% _jg Gjedmjr Idmcj Ejcdeji Ijv Qec~arpcs) Iq`hedv
Br% _jg Gjedmjr Idmcj Ejcdeji Ijv Qec~arpcs -_GIEIQ#)cp
j qec~arpcs ce Iq`hedv)Qjr \rjbapm% Rma Qec~arpcs cp nqiis nqebab os
ma pja fd~aregae% Rma qec~arpcs vjp apjoicpmab os je j dn
ma fd~aregae dn Qjr \rjbapm ce ?<<1 -Q%\% J` Ed% ?=# jeb dnnc`cjiis
d|aeab de 2 Kjeqjrs ?<<1% Rma qec~arpcs mjp oaae ba`ijrab /nc d ra`ac~a
frjep/ os ma QF@ qebar Pa`cde :? -o# dn ma QF@ J`) ce Ba`agoar ?<::%
Jbgcppcde d ma qec~arpcs cp mrdqfm ma @dggde Ijv Jbgcppcde Rap% Rma
cejha ndr ma 1 sajr O%J%) II%O `dqrpa cp :>< ce iqbcef jii rapar~jcdep%
Rma Qec~arpcs pqpjcep cp ~corje ceaiia`qji icna jeb prdef `dggqecs p|crc
os ae`dqrjfcef `diijodrjcde jeb eav vjsp dn mcehcef) paahcef eav vjsp d
pq||dr cp vdrh) jeb |rd~cbcef ma nceap nj ciccap d cp pqbaep%
ai nraa d vrca d; ijv|ra|Ljomsjjp%ce Va bde– vcpm d |rce mcp kdqreji) pj~a |j|ar) j~dcb |rcecef
Rmcp gdem ce |c`qrap;
jmqi Brj~cb racrab nrdg
arejcdeji @rc`ha
Kjgap Gqrbd`m rapcfeab jp
a}a`qc~a `mjcrgje dn Eavp
Cearejcdeji jgcb nrapm jiiafjcdep
mj ma jag|ab d `d~ar'q| ma
p`jebji%
Rma _jkc~ Fjebmc Cearejcde
Jcr|dr -_FCJ# mjp oaae jbkqbfab
ma mcrb oap jcr|dr ce ma vdrib
ma 1':1 GG\J `jafdrs os @dqe
Cearejcdeji -J@C#%
Gjbmqhje Fcrbmjriji
Pjefm~c cp ma eav @GB dn
Psebc`ja Ojeh
ma Cebcje Gae–p md`has ajg
qjicncab ndr ma ?<:? Disg|c`p os
anajcef Nrje`a ce ma zqjicncarp
J\ Fd~aredr API Ejrjpcgmje
raka`ab ndqr ejgap |rd|dpab os
ma fd~aregae ndr ma |dp dn
Cendrgjcde @dggcppcdearp
Rd |rd~cba ajps j``app d ma cearea) `jg|qp vcba vc'nc nj`cics mjp oaae gjba j~jcijoia d ma pqbaep% Rma
icorjrs jipd |rd~cbap ma pqbaep vcm j vao fjavjs) c mdqpap >< `dg|qarp vmc`m jra d|ae d jii% Rma
qec~arpcs jhap qgdp `jra dn |mspc`ji majim dn ma pqbaep% ^jrcdqp p|drp jeb dmar ra`rajcdeji nj`ciccap
jra j~jcijoia d ma pqbaep vmc`m ce`iqba j |iqpm fsg vcm mcfm aeb gdbare azqc|gaep) nddojii ncaib) j
gqic|qr|dpa cebddr p|drp `dg|ia}) jeb q|`dgcef Disg|c` pc{a pvcggcef |ddi) Ijve aeecp jeb ojbgcede
`dqrp % Rma qec~arpcs odjpp dn mcfm'a`m pagcejr mjiip jeb gdd `dqr mjiip) vcm jqbcd'~cpqji ra`drbcef
nj`ciccap%