ac noi 2010

Upload: bogdanovici-barbu

Post on 04-Apr-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    1/104

    N O V E M B E R 2 0 1 0

    $5.95Canada $6.95

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    2/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    3/104

    M E M B E R P O R T R A I T

    Donald A. Morgan, ASC

    W W W . T H E A S C . C O M

    TO SUBSCRIBE BY PHONE:

    Call (800) 448-0145 (U.S. only)

    (323) 969-4333 or visit the ASC Web site

    hen I was young, I

    watched black-and-whit

    movies with wonder and

    amazement, always wanting to

    know how such drama could be

    created with shadow and light.

    When I discoveredAmerican

    Cinematographer, the magazin

    provided me with a wealth of

    information and helped me

    develop my own ability to strike

    the right balance of shadow and

    light in my work.

    Visual images are how

    we communicate in the modern

    world, and cinematography is th

    key to telling a story visually. AC

    continues to fuel the magic of the

    moving picture. I am so proud to

    be part of a society of visual

    storytellers.

    Donald A. Morgan, AS

    W

    photobyOwenRoizman,ASC

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    4/104

    LitepanelsSola Fresnels & 1x1s both feature:

    Extreme portability 100%-0 dial-in dimming Dial-up brightnessRuns on battery or AC Cool to the touch Ultra-lightweight Integrated DMX

    Fits where other lights cannot go Battery option for wireless lightingLow Power Draw: under 10% of conventional lights

    xtrem port ty 0%-0 - n mm ng a -up r tn ssRun n b ttery or A ool to the touch Ultra-li ht eight Int grat d DMX

    Fits w h re th r lights c nn t go B tt ry option for wir l ss lightinLow Pow r Dr w: und r 10% of nv ntional lights

    Litepanels 1x1

    SeriesIf the need is for a single light out in the field or in-tegrating a full studio, Litepanels award-winning1x1s are the answer. Versatile, cool-to-the-touch,low energy draw, these 30.48 x 30.48 cm(1x1)1.36 kg (3 lbs) square fixtures can be combinedas needed to suit the situation.

    Choose from 5600 or 3200 Spot or Flood.Go with the Bi-Color for the ultimate controlof tungsten and daylight.Or get variable Flood,Spot or Super-Spot withthe Bi-Focus. For a tightlong throw with no spillcheck out the 15 Super-Spot. Litepanels award-winning technology isready to save you time,weight and energy.

    LitepanelsSola

    LED Fresnel SeriesSee the first production models of Sola Fresnels thatcombine single-shadow Fresnel benefits with Litepanelsaward-winning LED advantages. The most versatileFresnels ever, these daylight-balanced fixtures offervariable beam control from 10 to 70 and full-rangedimming in lightweight, no-ballast, user-friendlyfixtures.SolaENGdraws just 30W yet outputs equivalentto 250W Tungsten Fresnel and is sized for mountingon camcorders.Sola6draws 75W with output equivalent to 650WTungsten Fresnel. With 3 innovative ways to control: Traditional on-fixture

    knobs access motorizedmechanical focus &electronic dimming

    Touch Screen for dimming,focus, status indicator,temperature gauge,& DMX address

    Integrated DMX interfaceSola6 features touch

    screen controls &DMX built-in.

    1x1 models are alsoavailable in Low-Profile

    versions which useonly 3" headroom

    Litepanels

    A Vitec Group brand

    www.litepanels.com

    Visit litepanels.com for behind-the-scene video clips.

    Winner of2009

    Technical

    Emmy

    LitepanelsEarth-friendly

    LED technology

    THE LIGHTING REVOLUTION:

    LED BY LITEPANELS

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    5/104

    The International Journal of Motion Imaging

    30 Horse PowerDean Semler, ASC, ACS bets on Secretariat

    42 The Worlds Most Wanted ManDenis Lenoir, ASC, AFC and Yorick Le Saux help profilea terrorist for Carlos

    54 A Modern RomanceTom Stern, ASC, AFC provides hope for an afterlifein Hereafter

    64 King of CoolAChonors the memory of ASC icon William A. Fraker

    80 Primetime ArtistryThis years Emmy-nominated cinematographers take a bowDEPARTMENTS

    FEATURES

    VISIT WWW.THEASC.COM TO ENJOY THESE WEB EXCLUSIVES Podcast: Morten Sborg and Nicolas Winding Refn on Valhalla Rising

    DVD Playback: Apocalypse Now Fantmas Whats Up, Doc?

    On Our Cover: A legendary thoroughbred racehorse wins the Triple CrowninSecretariat, shot by Dean Semler, ASC, ACS. (Photo by John Bramley, courtesy ofDisney Enterprises.)

    8 Editors Note10 Presidents Desk12 Short Takes: Sextape18 Production Slate: The LXD Monsters82 Post Focus: New Hat

    86Tricks of the Trade

    88 New Products & Services94 International Marketplace96 Classified Ads96 Ad Index98 Clubhouse News

    100 ASC Close-Up: Phedon Papamichael

    N O V E M B E R 2 0 1 0 V O L . 9 1 N O . 1 1

    54

    64

    42

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    6/104

    N o v e m b e r 2 0 1 0 V o l . 9 1 , N o . 1 1

    T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f M o t i o n I m a g i n g

    Visit us online at

    www.theasc.com

    PUBLISHER Martha Winterhalter

    EDITORIAL

    EXECUTIVE EDITOR Stephen Pizzello

    SENIOR EDITOR Rachael K. Bosley

    ASSOCIATE EDITORJon D. Witmer

    TECHNICAL EDITOR Christopher Probst

    CONTRIBUTING WRITERS

    Stephanie Argy, Benjamin B, Douglas Bankston, Robert S. Birchard,John Calhoun, Bob Fisher, Michael Goldman, Simon Gray, Jim Hemphill,

    David Heuring, Jay Holben, Mark Hope-Jones, Noah Kadner, Jean Oppenheimer,John Pavlus, Chris Pizzello, Jon Silberg, Iain Stasukevich,

    Kenneth Sweeney, Patricia Thomson

    ART DEPARTMENT

    CREATIVE DIRECTOR Marion Gore

    ADVERTISING

    ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTORAngie Gollmann

    323-936-3769 FAX 323-936-9188

    e-mail: [email protected]

    ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Sanja Pearce

    323-952-2114 FAX 323-876-4973

    e-mail: [email protected]

    ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Scott Burnell

    323-936-0672 FAX 323-936-9188

    e-mail: [email protected]

    CLASSIFIEDS/ADVERTISING COORDINATORDiella Nepomuceno

    323-952-2124 FAX 323-876-4973

    e-mail: [email protected]

    CIRCULATION, BOOKS & PRODUCTS

    CIRCULATION DIRECTOR Saul Molina

    CIRCULATION MANAGERAlex Lopez

    SHIPPING MANAGER Miguel Madrigal

    ASC GENERAL MANAGER Brett Grauman

    ASC EVENTS COORDINATOR Patricia Armacost

    ASC PRESIDENTS ASSISTANT Kim Weston

    ASC ACCOUNTING MANAGER Mila Basely

    ASC ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE Corey Clark

    American Cinematographer(ISSN 0002-7928), established 1920 and in its 90th year of publication, is published

    monthly in Hollywood by ASC Holding Corp., 1782 N. Orange Dr., Hollywood, CA 90028, U.S.A.,(800) 448-0145, (323) 969-4333, Fax (323) 876-4973, direct line for subscription inquiries (323) 969-4344.

    Subscriptions: U.S. $50; Canada/Mexico $70; all other foreign countries $95 a year (remit internationalMoney Order or other exchange payable in U.S. $). Advertising: Rate card upon request from Hollywood

    office. Article Reprints: Requests for high-quality article reprints (or electronic reprints) should be made toSheridan Reprints at (800) 635-7181 ext. 8065 or by e-mail [email protected].

    Copyright 2010 ASC Holding Corp. (All rights reserved.) Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles, CAand at additional mailing offices. Printed in the USA.

    POSTMASTER: Send address change to American Cinematographer, P.O. Box 2230, Hollywood, CA 90078.

    4

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    7/104

    HIGHERDEFINITION x3As our family grows, so do the possibilities of filmmaking. The KODAK VISION3 Film family has raised

    the bar for high-definition capture with unrivaled highlight latitude, reduced grain in shadows, flexibility in

    post, and of course, proven archival stability. Now with the addition of KODAK VISION3 200T Color Negative

    Film 5213/7213, weve developed a film that performs superbly in both controlled interiors and in challenging

    high-contrast exteriors. Its time to look forward to the future with more options and no compromise.

    Learn more at kodak.com/go/200t

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    8/104

    OFFICERS - 2010/2011

    Michael GoiPresident

    Richard CrudoVice President

    Owen RoizmanVice President

    John C. Flinn IIIVice President

    Matthew LeonettiTreasurer

    Rodney TaylorSecretary

    Ron GarciaSergeant At Arms

    MEMBERS OF THE

    BOARD

    John BaileyStephen Burum

    Curtis ClarkGeorge Spiro Dibie

    Richard EdlundJohn C. Flinn III

    Michael GoiStephen LighthillIsidore Mankofsky

    Daryn OkadaRobert Primes

    Nancy Schreiber

    Kees Van OostrumHaskell Wexler

    Vilmos Zsigmond

    ALTERNATES

    Fred ElmesRodney Taylor

    Michael D. OSheaSol Negrin

    Michael B. Negrin

    MUSEUM CURATOR

    Steve Gainer

    American Society of Cine matographers

    The ASC is not a labor union or a guild, butan educational, cultural and pro fes sion al

    or ga ni za tion. Membership is by invitationto those who are actively en gaged asdi rec tors of photography and have

    dem on strated out stand ing ability. ASCmembership has be come one of the highest

    honors that can be bestowed upon apro fes sional cin e ma tog ra pher a mark

    of prestige and excellence.

    CookeOpticsLimitedBritish Optical Innovation and

    Quality Since 1893.

    The Cooke Look

    One Look. All Speeds

    S4/

    T2.0

    5/

    T1.4

    Pa

    nchro/

    T2.8

    cookeoptics.com

    T: +44 (0)116 264 0700

    Canada, South America, USA:

    T: +1-973-335-4460

    sss*ejpanhk_daj*knc

    IkpekjLe_pqna=npobkndecdo_dkkhhii]gano

    ?khh]^kn]pa(ha]nj(]j`bk_qoukqnp]hajpoOqiian=npo?]ilBeja=npo>k]n`ejcO_dkkh

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    9/104

    All the performance and range to capture your imagination.The Angenieux Optimo Digital Production (DP) Series.

    The best lenses to express what you have in mind . . .

    for over75years . . .973.812.3858

    [email protected] Uwww.angenieux.com

    Our 16-42mm and 30-80mm Optimo DP Series Zoom Lenses set new

    expectations for excellence. Featuring Angenieuxs award winning optics,

    the Optimo DP Series Zooms deliver the extreme details ideal for todays 2K,

    3.5K, 4K and 5K digital cinema cameras with resolution to spare for

    generations of cameras to come. And theyre already quickly becoming the

    lenses of choice for 3D production now available in perfectly matched pairs

    packaged in a durable travel case ready to go on the road whenever you are.

    Any way you use them, our Optimo DP Series will capture much more than

    your imagination.

    Optimo DP 16 - 42 Optimo DP 30 - 80

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    10/104

    This months tribute to the late, great William A. Fraker,ASC, BSC (King of Cool, page 64),is a salute to a cine-matographer who brought positive vibes to the set and joyto all who knew him. A true professional who also knewhow to have fun, Billy was the charismatic embodiment ofan era when moviemaking was the most glamorous andexciting career one could ever hope to pursue. Whenever heambled into the ASC Clubhouse, sporting his mirroredshades, we all experienced a frisson of true Hollywoodhipness,especially when Billy bent an elbow at the bar andentertained us with stories about Roman Polanski, SteveMcQueen or the car chase from Bullitt. Trust me, there wasno cooler way to enjoy a scotch on the rocks.

    Dramatizing real-life events can be tricky when most of the audience knows how thestory ends, but Secretariatdoes a fine job of creating suspense while telling the saga of themost famous Triple Crown winner in history. We wanted to capture the excitement of the raceand were willing to do it in ways that no one else had tried, director Randall Wallace tells ACcontributor Patricia Thomson (Horse Power, page 30). We were skimming cameras an inchover the ground, so close to the hooves that you can see the light reflected in the horseshoes.The dirt is flying, and its all real. Of course, that kind of work requires careful planning, as cine-matographer Dean Semler, ASC, ACS relates: We did a careful, analytical study of every race.Each was designed on a corkboard with the exact position for the starting gate, the finish line,and the positions for all the horses throughout the race . Wed pull this corkboard out everymorning and dribble our breakfast burritos over it as wed plan the days events.

    The makers of Carlos faced similar challenges in dramatizing the true story of Ilich

    Ramrez Snchez, a.k.a. Carlos the Jackal, a terrorist described by director Olivier Assayas asthe Bin Laden of his time. Released in two versions a 5 12-hour cut broadcast on theSundance Channel and a 212-hour theatrical cut the ambitious film was shot in nine coun-tries, on 135 locations and in eight languages, by two cinematographers: Yorick Le Saux andDenis Lenoir, ASC, AFC. Assayas method, which often involves handheld cameras, tested thecinematographers mettle. Lighting for his films is more difficult because you have to cover180, 270 or even 360 degrees, Lenoir tells European correspondent Benjamin B (The WorldsMost Wanted Man, page 42), so you have to compromise; you have to light from the ceil-ing or find ways to not light at all.

    OnHereafter, a romantic story with supernatural overtones, Tom Stern, ASC, AFC addednew twists to the tried-and-true methods he usually employs on his collaborations with direc-tor Clint Eastwood. Normally a classicist, Eastwood found himself embracing the latest digital

    techniques, including previsualization, CGI and the digital-intermediate process. We startedwith the DI about six years ago, and there was tension about it back then, Stern concedes inhis interview with Michael Goldman (A Modern Romance, page 54). Now, its a standardpart of what we do. The point is, as technologies become stable, more interesting tools becomeavailable. Clint will always take a conservative approach, but things do evolve, and were opento whatever develops.

    Stephen PizzelloExecutive Editor

    Editors Note

    8

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    11/104

    Introducing the Canon XF305 and XF300, with a codec that gives you the image quality and streamlined

    workflow to meet a broad range of production needs. The XF series also employs non-proprietary dual

    CF card recording, and for efficient file management, the MXF File Wrapper facilitates metadata handling

    throughout the workflow. And then theres the 18x HD L-Series lens

    (35mm equivalent of 29.3527.4mm) and three native 1920x1080 Canon CMOS

    Image Sensors. Which combined, offer a versatile zoom range and unsurpassed image quality.

    Finally, a feature-laden hand-held thats ready for any assignment. usa.canon.com/camcorder

    50Mbps MPEG-2 4:2:2

    CF Card Recording

    MXF File Wrapper

    18x HD L-Series Lens

    3 Native 1920x1080CMOS Image Sensors

    HD-SDI Output

    Genlock Input

    SMPTE Time Code In/Out

    Your production just got more productive.

    2010 Canon U.S.A., Inc. All r ights reserved. Canon is a registered trademark of Canon Inc. in the United States and IMAGE ANY WARE is a trademark of Canon. All other referenced products and

    brand names are trademarks of their respective owners and are hereby acknowledged. HD-SDI output, Genlock input, and SMP TE time code in/out available on XF30 5 only.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    12/104

    As things continue to progress and evolve in the ever-changing production world, I find thatone element is starting to erode from the lexicon of communication. In a word, trust. Trust savestimeand money and creates a better product. Trust takes many forms.

    When watching a 17"or smaller monitor on set, one cannot make an informed judgmentabout the merits of a shot as well as the camera operator, who is living the shot as it happens,moving in unison with the flow of the actors and the dolly. When my operator, Michael Stumpf,tells me the shot was great, I dont need to rewind a tape to check it. I move on. And when he saysit wasnt good and we should go again, I usually understand why without having to ask, becauseI usually plant myself near the camera as the shot is happening so I can see the lighting on theactors faces. Peripherally, I can sense the motion of the camera and its timing to their moves.

    As digital intermediates grew in popularity, the color-timing processsuddenly morphed fromthe cinematographer and lab timer working in a small room with a Hazeltine into a dozen peoplecrowding a color-correction theater,complete with leather seats and cappuccinos. Sometimes thecinematographer was even locked out of the process. Cinematographers retaliated by embracingtechnologies that enabled them to establish the proper color and contrast balance on set andensure that the information would follow the workflow to the end product. This put pressure onthe DIT to become the colorist, and minimized the job of the dailies colorist, an artist who was

    reduced to applying the data from a memory stick onto the transfer.I dont have any desire to determine the final color of my work on set in the midst of tight shooting schedules and rapidly

    changing location conditions in which my eyes dont havethe proper time to adjust to the light level in the DIT tent. I like to discussthe look Im going for with the DIT and have them balance it accordingly for the on-set monitors so that the director doesnt h aveto look at a raw, flat image. Then I like to have Dennis Mackelburg, who is one of the best dailies colorists Ive worked with, takethat footage at night and, within the controlled environment of his suite,away from the chaos of the set, bring the look of tho sedailies to where it should be for distribution to everyone.

    For most of the past 20years Ive worked with two gaffers, John Magallon and Terry Meadows, and three key grips, Jean-

    Pierre Marangakis, Kenny King and Porfirio Dominguez (who passed away from cancer two years ago). Though I started out as agaffer myself, I dont feel compelled to dictate every single instrument that will be used on set. In our initial conversations, they pickup on what Im intending to do stylistically and plug into the concept. Based on their experience, they suggest instruments toachievecertain effects that I may be unaware of, or offer alternate solutions to a plan that I propose. And theyre usually right.

    I love to edit, and Ive edited quite a few projects. I feel that editing teaches you more about directing and shot structure thanjust about anything else, because it forces you to acknowledge what you actually needed to get on set,as opposed to what youthink you needed. However, as much as I love to edit, I like having the perspective that a great editor like Marc Leif brings t o theproject. Marc has edited eight films that Ive shot, and I never have to worry if the visual intention of a scene is going to g et lost inthe process, because he can look at a shot and understand conceptually why we took the time to get it.

    Finally, trust builds your future. Ive shot every one of director Charlie Carners films for the past 15years. Weve known eachother (and Marc Leif) since college. When Charlie and I are on the set, people remark that we never seem to talk to each other. Wedont need to. Prior to the start of production, we do our prep by spending nights watching movies, eating Italian beef sandwic hes

    and chatting about ideas. By the time the cameras roll, we can complete each others thoughts.I love working with people who are better at their jobs than I am at their jobs. I trust my team to approach each project with

    the same passion and commitment that I do. And they trust me to trust them.

    Michael Goi, ASCPresident

    Presidents Desk

    10 November 2010 American Cinematographer

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    13/104

    Set your imagination free and bring your most amaz

    ideas to life with Dell Precision workstations.

    If you can imagine ityou can create it.

    Call 1-800-873-1290 or visit www.dell.com/smb/imagine

    4QFFEZPVSXBZUISPVHIUIFNPTUDPNQMFYUBTLTXJUIQPXFSGVMNVMUJDPSFQSPDFTTPST

    $PMMBCPSBUFNVMUJUBTLSFOEFSBOENPSFXJUIBTZTUFN*47DFSUJFEUPSVOBQQMJDBUJPOT

    JODMVEJOH"VUPEFTL.BZB"VUPEFTLET.BYBOE"EPCF$4

    ,FFQZPVSTPGUXBSFBOEIBSEXBSFXPSLJOHTFBNMFTTMZXJUIPQUJPOBM%FMM1SP4VQQPSUZPVS

    TJOHMFQPJOUPGDPOUBDUUPPWFSTPGUXBSFWFOEPSTGPSGBTUFDJFOUQSPCMFNSFTPMVUJPO

    In the studio and now on the road, you have the power to keep up withyour ideas and stay on top of your schedule.

    Learn More

    Windows 7 Professional operating system makes the things you do everyday faster and easier. With fewer clicks, faster searching, easier browsing, asimpler ways to connect, theres less between you and what you want to d

    "WBJMBCJMJUZBOEUFSNTPG%FMM4FSWJDFTWBSZCZSFHJPO'PSNPSFJOGPSNBUJPOWJTJUXXXEFMMDPNTFSWJDFEFTDSJQUJPOT

    Windows. Life without Walls. Dell recommends Windows 7.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    14/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    15/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    16/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    17/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    18/104

    16 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    of specialty prisms. After discovering theGates Deep Red housing, however, they real-ized they could make the rainbows feel morethree-dimensional by arranging the prismsalong the curve of the housings acrylic dome.

    Certain scenes in Sextape have alook reminiscent of the night vision settings

    on some DV camcorders; the effect wasachieved in-camera by lighting with a puregreen spectrum of laser light and applying a-100 magenta tint in the cameras imagesettings. We fell in love with the subtletexture the single channel gave us for thosescenes, preferring the natural color, saturationand noise levels of the Mysterium-X sensor toperforming the color correction in post.Weve always loved what happens to brightercolors when they clip in the older firmwarebuilds, and we lit certain things with that inmind and processed them with older versionsof RedAlert.

    This approach is apparent in the middlesection of the video, as memories flash bywhile the characters literally pull on andbecome entangled in the fabric of the story-line. We wanted these scenes to have thefuturistic sense of nostalgia you might find ina [William] Gibson-esque home movie fromthe future, the filmmakers say. Weachieved this by shooting Redcode 28processed with Build 16 at a half-standard de-bayer, which gave us a lower resolution and

    noisier image,and also gave the highlights apleasingly dissonant clip gradient.

    While editing Sextape, Forrest andLiebenguth eschewed all computer effects,transitions and fades in favor of straight cuts.We try to get it to a point where the imagessimply morph into one another and the narra-tive flows across the screen in one continu-ous, kinetic piece, the directors remark. Astronger, deeper narrative always emerges inthe editing process. Because the video wasnot shot upfront with this in mind, this new

    narrative is hidden and we are the only peoplewho know the secret stories of each video.

    Top and middle: Underwater sequences were shot with the Red One in a Gates Deep Red housing andvarious fixtures sealed in military-grade zipper bags. Bottom: Forrest readies multiple fixtures above

    the swimming pool used for the videos underwater action.

    ErratumGaffer Paul Samaniegos name wasmisspelled in our September Short Takescolumn (Taking Arris Alexa to the WorldCup, page 12).

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    19/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    20/104

    Lethal Dance MovesBy Jean Oppenheimer

    In the Web series The Legion of Extraordinary Dancers (TheLXD), dance has emerged as the newest battleground in the strug-

    gle between good and evil. The show follows a disparate group ofindividuals whose mind-blowing dance moves make them a newbreed of superhero. Each has a specific talent: hip-hop, krumping,popping, break-dancing, jazz, and even some tap and ballet.

    The Paramount-produced series is one of the most ambitiousever mounted for the Internet; now in its second U.S. season onHulu, The LXD has consistently ranked in the sites top 10 most popu-lar shows every week. Director Jon M. Chu ( Step Up 2: The Streets ,Step Up 3-D) created the show specifically for the Web, and one ofhis first calls was to cinematographer Alice Brooks, a former class-mate from the University of Southern Californias undergraduate filmprogram. Brooks entered USC knowing she wanted to be a cine-

    matographer, and she honed her skills shooting a lot of thesis films,including Chus 2002 thesis, When the Kids Are Away . When Chucalled her about The LXD, she immediately signed on.

    We are doing stuff on this show that is experimental anddifferent, says Chu. We wanted to create a world where, eventhough its fantasy, you feel the texture and the light, you see flaresand patterns on patterns.

    Shooting dance isnt easy, he adds. Theres a choreogra-phy not just of whats within the frame but of the frame itself. Aliceunderstands that there is a duet between our audience and thedancers. She and the choreographers work together, figuring out

    how the camera can move with the dancers bodies. Each dancerhas such a different style; Alice has to pick up a new language witheach one. She has really [helped to] define our tone.

    When you think of a Web series, you think prosumercameras, but it was always our intention to shoot The LXD as if it

    would play on the big screen, says Brooks, who recently beganshooting the shows third season. When shooting began on the firstseason, in February 2009, the Red One was the new kid on theblock. It also turned out to be the easiest camera for the productionto acquire: digital-imaging technician Dan Haas, another USC class-mate, already owned one. (Haas also served as cinematographer onone episode of the first season.)

    Production on the first two seasons was spread out over 18months, and when it ramped up for season two, Brooks upgradedto Reds Mysterium-X sensor, which, at 800 ASA, is considerablyfaster than the cameras original chip. Brooks shoots the series inRaw mode, Redcode 36 or Redcode 42,monitors in Redspace, and

    records onto CF cards and hard drives. We shoot 3K HD, 4K 2:1and 4K HD, depending upon the aspect ratio and frame rate, andthose vary depending on the dance style and genre of each piece.

    We originally hoped to shoot the entire series 2:1, butbecause of different delivery standards, we decided to stick with16x9, she continues. However, a number of episodes begin in16x9 and are matted to 2.40 at different story points. The greatthing about a web series is that there are no rules, so we get to makethem up as we go, including playing with the aspect ratio within anepisode.

    Brooks tested a number of lens and filter combinations

    Production Slate

    Chadd MaddChadd Smith

    leads the pack asthe character

    Sp3cimen in TheLXD, a popular

    Web series thatmakes dance a

    battlegroundbetween good

    and evil.

    I

    18 November 2010 American Cinematographer

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    21/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    22/104

    20 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    before choosing Zeiss Super Speeds. Ifound the Red lenses too crisp, whereas theSuper Speeds, in conjunction with differentincrements of Schneider Classic Softs andthe use of smoke, produce the soft, magi-cal feel we wanted. In order to get full-length shots of the dancers, shorter focallengths are used, primarily 18mm, 25mm

    and 35mm. At bigger locations that involvea number of dancers, a 50mm or 85mmwill often be used.

    According to Brooks, Chu envisagedthe project as a tapestry of different colors,feelings, tones, moods and genres.Although the series jumps back and forth intime, stretching from the 1920s to the year3000, Jon wanted a sense of timeless-ness, she adds. So you never see anycars, and wardrobe isnt specific to any

    period.Early on, we decided we loved lens

    flares and blown-out windows, continuesBrooks. She recalls contemplating how tolight the long, dark hallway at one of thefirst locations, an abandoned hospital usedin the episode Robot Love Story, noting,I love to go to the location by myself and

    just sit quietly until the idea comes to me.The scene involves a dancer who

    specializes in the robot technique an evilcharacter has turned him into a robot byplanting a mechanical box in him. Brooksrecalls, There were three huge windows atone end of the room, and I decided to turnoff all the interior lights and just blast Nine-light Maxis through the windows. The wallswere pale green and naturally aged, whichbounced the light beautifully on the

    dancers. We used dichroic bulbs. That gaveme the punch I needed, and for thatepisode, I liked the quality of light theyprovided much more than that of HMIs.

    The entire series has been shot onlocation, mostly indoors. Locations have sofar included a high-school gym, an aban-doned warehouse, and a bank that was re-dressed as an art museum. Brooks mustdevise a lighting plan that will work for theentire day; rearranging fixtures between

    shots is not an option. The solution is acombination of backlight and skip bounce.We never set lamps in front of thedancers, she says. If we did, [Steadicamoperator] Nick Franco would constantly becrossing the light or we would be inhibitingthe choreography. We cant rig units up highbecause we dont get any pre-rigging time.

    She estimates that 95 percent of theshow is shot with the Steadicam. Nick is atrue artist, she declares. Weve beenworking together for almost 10 years, since

    I started shooting, and weve developed aneasy and fast way of communicating withone another. Thats especially helpful inlight of the short production schedule: eachepisode is shot in one day, occasionally two.And because Brooks only has three hours tocolor-time each episode, she tries to get asclose to the intended look as possible in-camera. (Post is handled by LightIron Digi-tal in Hollywood.)

    To offset the demanding shooting

    Top photos:Three Nine-light

    Maxi-Brutesilluminate a

    dance sequencefrom a balconyabove the set.

    Bottom:Cinematographer

    Alice Brooksconfers withLXD creator

    and directorJon M. Chu.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    23/104

    Over the years I have used just about every piece of equipment Clairmont Camera has ever owned; time-lapse film cameras to super high-speed digital

    cameras and now the Alexa. I love Clairmonts custom gear and incredible service; it keeps me coming back! In visual effect shooting we always are

    inventing on the fly. With difficult setups like hanging off a 70-story building, complex driving rigs or doing in camera visual effects having equipment

    and service you can depend on is essential. I would recommend Clairmont Camera to anyone in the industry.Sam Nicholson, ASC

    Chairman / CEO Stargate Studios

    H o l l y w o o d

    8 1 8 - 7 6 1 - 4 4 4 0

    V a n c o u v e r

    6 0 4 - 9 8 4 - 4 5 6 3

    T o r o n t o

    4 1 6 - 4 6 7 - 1 7 0 0

    A l b u q u e r q u e

    5 0 5 - 2 2 7 - 2 5 2 5

    M o n t r e a l

    5 1 4 - 5 2 5 - 6 5 5 6

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    24/104

    22 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    aid of wires or special effects.The Greater of Two Evils, one of

    the most ambitious episodes from season

    two, introduces viewers to two sets ofvillains: the Umbras, who wear bowler hatsand use umbrellas as weapons, and a groupof misfits called Organization X. Bothtroupes want to destroy the heroes, butthey must first battle each other. Theepisode was shot in a 1920s bank dressedas an art museum. The location provided agiant, open space with a number of pillarsthat were perfect spots to hide small lights;it also featured second-floor balconies thatallowed Brooks to light the battle below.

    We wanted to create a film-noirlook with lots of shadows, but we had toshoot during the day, recalls Brooks.There were huge windows on all sides ofthe building, and we hung 20-by-20 piecesof black Duvetyn outside all of them, exceptfor one that faced an alley we couldntaccess. As luck would have it, the inacces-sible windows were directly behind thedancers, exactly where the camera wouldbe pointing. Since she was unable to black

    the windows out, Brooks decided to createenough light inside the building that thewindows wouldnt key the scene. Sheaccomplished this by placing three Nine-light Maxi-Brutes gelled with 216 on thecamera-left balcony above the dancers, justout of frame. In addition to the backlight, a

    number of 1Ks and 2Ks were hiddenbehind pillars; some were dimmed down orgelled with 14 or 12 CTO. Smoke was alsoused in the scene.

    The floor was made of old, warm,beautiful marble that bounced light into thedancers faces, recalls Brooks. Because itwas one of the larger locations, we shotfrom slightly farther away than we did inother episodes, using the 85mm or 50mmlens.

    One dancer was in the foreground,and the camera was focused on his face.There was a whole row of dancers recedingthrough to the background. They weredancing the exact same moves as the fore-ground dancer we were focused on, and itwas nice how the focus fell off with eachdancer. Charles Oliver, who directed thatepisode, wanted a very shallow depth offield, and the use of selective focus is some-thing weve played with throughout theseries. Im really happy with the way itturned out.

    Brooks has worked with most of her

    crew on The LXD for years. Nick isfrequently my Steadicam operator, andElliott Schackne is often my first AC. Elliottdoes an amazing job pulling focus; fromtake to take on this show, the camera isnever in the same place, and neither are thedancers! The key grip, Rocky Rodriguez,and the gaffer, Jay Muranaka, are incrediblycollaborative, which makes my work somuch easier.

    The LXD has been a very intenseexperience, because the dancers have an

    incredible amount of energy, and Ive neverseen a crew work so hard. Everyone lovesbeing there. When I get to the set in themorning, the energy just blows me away.

    TECHNICAL SPECS

    16x9 and 2:1Digital CaptureRed OneZeiss lenses

    and post schedules, prep for 5 episodes(half a season) is 14 days. We shoot a nine-day stretch with one day off, and during

    that period well shoot four or fiveepisodes, says Brooks. Then we break fora while and come back for another ninedays. A major part of prep involves dancerehearsals, which Brooks observes regularly.I become intimately familiar with everystep the dancers make, says Brooks. Istudy their bodies and how their musclesmove. I wander around the room observingthe routines to figure out which angle willbe best to use. She shoots the rehearsalson her Flip camera and sends the footage to

    Franco, her gaffer (Jay Muranaka in seasonstwo and three, Michael Roy in season one)and her key grip (Rocky Rodriguez) to givethem an idea of the feel, size and scope ofeach number.

    Most of the dance scenes are shot at48 fps. We determined our frame rate andshutter angle based on the specific dancestyle, says Brooks. Though many of thedancers moves appear physically impossi-ble, they are, in fact, performed without the

    Top: Sp3cimenbreaks into a

    routine set in a

    hospital.Bottom: Part ofthe detail from

    a dancefeaturing the

    Dark Nurse(Shelby Rabara).

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    25/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    26/104

    24 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    Creature FeatureBy Jon D. Witmer

    Gareth Edwards feature debut,Monsters, springs from an intriguingpremise: after a probe carrying bacteriasamples from the Jovian moon Europaburns up during re-entry into Earths atmos-phere, huge alien creatures begin to appearin Central America, forcing officials to quar-antine Mexico as an uninhabitableinfected zone. Rather than focusing on

    the creatures initial appearance on ourplanet, Edwards sets his tale a few yearslater to follow the journey of two Ameri-cans, Sam Wynden (Whitney Able) andAndrew Kaulder (Scoot McNairy), who mustwend their way through the infected zone and elude the tentacled monstrositieslurking there to get home to the UnitedStates.

    Edwards specialized in cinematogra-phy while attending film school at the

    Surrey Institute of Art & Design, but hefound the experience frustrating. I wasused to having an idea for a shot, picking upa camera and trying to get it, saysEdwards, who recently sat down with ACwhile promoting his film in Los Angeles.Learning to do it properly meant thatwhat used to be as simple as picking up acamera and shooting became an all-dayevent costing thousands of pounds. To me,filmmaking shouldnt be about logistics andmoney.

    After graduating, Edwards pursuedwork in visual effects and quickly made hismark, earning honors that included aBAFTA Award for Hiroshima (2005) and anEmmy nomination for Perfect Disaster(2006). In 2008, Edwards applied his CGskills tothe kind of small-footprint produc-tion he prefers, entering and winning theSci-Fi-London 48-Hour Film Challenge withthe short film Factory Farmed, which hemade by himself with just a few actors. He

    essentially applied the same methodologyto Monsters, serving asthe shows writer,director, cinematographer and visual-effectssupervisor. The movies six-week shoot tookEdwards, editor Colin Goudie, assistanteditor Justin Hall, sound recordist Ian Macla-gan, line producer Jim Spencer and the twolead actors on a journey through Mexico,Belize, Guatemala, Texas and Costa Rica.

    American Cinematographer :How did your work in visual effectsprepare you for your responsibilities onMonsters?

    Gareth Edwards: I think CGI isgreat training for cinematography. Whenyou make a bad composition with acamera, you can see it straightaway andcorrect it within seconds, but when youmake a bad composition in the computer,you cant tell until its fully rendered youcan end up wasting a whole day. Its apainful way to learn what makes an imagelook good or bad, and the lessons reallystick. By comparison, being able to movethe camera and change a composition in

    real time on location is the most liberatingfeeling in the world.

    More than anything, CGI taught menot to compose images based on theobjects in the scene, but to compose basedon shapes formed by lights and darks.When you see a wireframe version of ascene, the objects outlines seem to be thestrongest shapes to compose the shotaround, but once those objects are properlylit, you realize the strongest shapes are actu-

    Right: Sam Wynden(Whitney Able) dons

    a gas mask whileexploring the

    wreckage left in thewake of giant,

    space-bornecreatures in

    Monsters. Below:

    Andrew Kaulder(Scoot McNairy),Wyndens

    companion throughthe creature-infested

    infected zone,stands before a

    mural thatfilmmaker GarethEdwards digitally

    painted onto thewall in post.

    I

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    27/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    28/104

    ally where strong shadows lie or randomhighlights catch something. Its these shapesI compose for, not the objects themselves. Ithink the same difference exists on locationbetween storyboard stick figures and natu-rally lit scenes; I learned to ignore the objectsin front of me and focus on balancing theshapes created by light and dark areas in theframe.

    Nevertheless, there are shots thatappear to have been planned, particu-larly as far as production design isconcerned.

    Edwards: If it looks like there wasproduction value, it was done after the fact

    on the computer. Because of the computergraphics, we could shoot anything on loca-tion and manipulate it afterwards, makingone-off happy accidents fit in with the story.For instance, theres a shot of two guys in awagon carrying a jet engine with an Ameri-can flag on it; they were just guys with anempty wagon I filmed as they went past. Inthe edit, we decided what CGI I would putin there. I also kept filming advertisementsigns everywhere we went, and later, in thecomputer, I painted over them to create

    warning signs about the Infected Zone. Aswell as being cheaper, it meant we didnthave to stop filming or carry lots of propswith us.

    What software did you use forthe CGI?

    Edwards: We edited in [Adobe]Premiere, and I used Photoshop and AfterEffects. All of the creature animation wasdone in Autodesk 3ds Max, and I did all ofthe tracking in Mocha, which is the only way

    I know of to track out-of-focus areas. Thatwas a lifesaver!

    What camera did you shootwith?

    Edwards: It was a Sony PMW-EX3,and it had a Letus35 Ultimate adapter onthe front for our Nikon lenses. We had threelenses during the shoot a 28mm, a50mm and an 80mm all with an aper-ture of 1.2. I fell in love with the 50mm andsecretly wanted it to get stuck on thecamera!

    The camera shot 23.97, 1080p MXFfiles to SxS cards. We could get about threehours on two cards, and you can take one

    card out while keeping the other onerolling. We had an editor and an assistantwho pulled the footage off the cards,checked to make sure it wasnt corrupted,cloned the footage so we were totally safe,and then deleted the cards.

    A lot of times at night I would set thecamera to 9dB. We did a few tests at 0dB innight conditions with the grade whackedup so you could see into the blacks, and at9dB with some de-graining. We printedboth tests to 35mm, and they looked pretty

    identical. I chose 9dB because it meant Icould see what was in focus when I lookedin the viewfinder.

    The EX3 records in 16x9, but themovies final aspect ratio is 2.35:1. Whydid you decide to crop the image?

    Edwards: Im just a big fan of2.35:1. Im always disappointed when I goto the cinema and the curtain doesnt openup that extra bit after the trailers. I also thinkits how our brains work peripheral vision

    feels like extreme letterbox and, to behonest, [at that width] its easier to make acomposition look stronger. In theviewfinder, I stuck some tape roughly wherethe 2.35:1 markers should be and then, inthe grade, we could reposition the frame upor down.

    Did you have a chance to scoutany of the locations during prep?

    Edwards: I hadnt actually seenanything until we landed to start filming,but we did use Google Earth, which is areally useful tool. We made a wish list of[the locations] we thought we wanted, andthen mapped out a route through Mexico,

    Belize and Guatemala.Did you try to map your route so

    you could shoot chronologically, or wasit more of a catch as catch canmethodology?

    Edwards: The actors, completelyrightly, get nervous about ad-libbing a filmout of order, but it became impossible [toshoot chronologically]. It really becamestandard issue to keep a lookout foranything a bit weird as we were drivingalong in the van, and then wed jump out,

    make some shots, jump back into the vanand carry on.

    How did you keep track of cover-age with all of the ad-libbing?

    Edwards: It was kind of aheadache. We got our best stuff when wewere letting the scenes happen sponta-neously without much planning, but theproblem was that wed do a half-hour takeand then Id say, Great, can we do thatagain from this angle? What wound up

    Left: Sound recordist Ian Maclagan (left), Edwards (center) and line producer Jim Spencer prepare to capture a traveling shot o n location in Mexico.Right: Edwards set the Sony PMW-EX3s gain to 9dB when shooting with available light at night.

    26 November 2010 American Cinematographer

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    29/104

    JMR Electronics new BlueStor DigiLab Cart solutions willnever have you guessing whether or not you got the shot

    beore you strike a hot set.

    DigiLab Cart easily processes RAW content in real-time,allowing you to work and view uncompressed ull resolutionRAW fles in 4K 12 bit RGB mode.

    Just transer the fles rom your digital camera into DigiLab;Drag and Drop the RAW fles into the timeline andpress Play. Its that simple.

    DigiLab also lets you apply frst pass color correction right onlocation and even burn a Blu-ray disc or dailies with theviewing LUTs (Look Up Tables) applied. Real-time debayering and decoding o RAW fles in ull 4K

    resolution Drag-n-Drop RAW fles into timeline and view fles in real-time Color grade with DPX fle sequences Generate digital dailies with comprehensive burn-ins rom

    RAW fles Sophisticated conorming o R3D fles with EDL, XML and Avid

    ALE support Generate DPX fle sequences in ull 4K RGB 16-bit

    To learn more about DigiLab, contact JMR at 818.993.4801or email to [email protected].

    www.jmr.com

    RAW TO DAILIESIN REAL TIME

    DigiLab let me store, color time, process ootage and createdailies right on the set a huge time and cost savings.

    Michael LohmannDirector o photography

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    30/104

    28 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    happening was more like a documentary. Iwanted random pieces you can only getonce youve been doing something for ahalf hour your body language changes,the people around you behave a certainway, and they dont care about the cameraanymore. I would start recording withouttelling anyone, and then, without making abig deal out of it, I would say, Wheneveryou want, Im ready, and there would be acasual flow into what felt like normal behav-ior.

    While rolling, I would literally pretendI was in the theater watching the movie,and when I got bored or when I becamemore interested in something else, I wouldmove the camera. There wasnt time tothink too much; I had to just feel it. Then,when the scene was over, I would get someneutral cutaways to help the editor: reactionshots, Scoot or Whitney listening, or just

    their hands. Still, if you ask Colin to namethe hardest thing hes ever had to edit, with-out a shadow of a doubt he would say itwas this film!

    While filming, did you everreview the days footage?

    Edwards: I didnt like looking backat it because Id get paranoid that I didnthave everything I needed. We alwaysplanned to shoot for six weeks and thenedit. Foranything we hadnt gotten orwanted to go backand do better, we would

    do a week of pickups. Even if we looked atthe rough footage and it wasnt right, goingback to reshoot the next day would havekilled another scene on the schedule.

    Did you have to do any reshoots?Edwards: We did reshoot some

    scenes, but never for technical reasons orperformance. We reshot because of exposi-tion. Because we ad-libbed everything, wedidnt always say everything we needed tosay in a scene to keep the audience up to

    speed. In the edit, we picked a few scenesand said, Weve got them, but we can getthem better. We went to Costa Rica for thepickups.

    What sort of lighting gear didyou carry?

    Edwards: We had a bounce board,but we hardly used it and I dont think anyof those shots made the cut. We also hadlittle LED boxes powered by AA batteries.We used those by the campfire, to add tothe flame light, and in the scene with Whit-ney at the doorway of her hotel room. Shekept leaning into the doorway while talkingwith Scoot, and she was really dark, so JimSpencer, the line producer, stood with oneof those lights just out of shot.

    On most occasions, Id move thecamera until the frame looked interestingand the light looked good; I didnt everwant anything to look lit.But theres a

    night scene in the middle of the film whenit was pitch black in the middle of thejungle, and Id sworn to myself that thecamera was never going to leave the van [inwhich Sam and Kaulder cower while theirguides battle a creature]. We had a smokemachine and two HMIs, but one of theHMIs blew out straightaway. We alsogaffer-taped an LED light inside the van, asif it was the internal light.

    A particularly nerve-rattlingscene takes place in a boat on a river at

    night. The boats engine has stalled,and what looks like a giant fin startsmaking its way toward the characters.Was that scene shot day-for-night?

    Edwards: It was dusk-for-night, butit became night-for-night by the end of thescene!I wanted to be able to tell that thetorch lights were on, and if you do day-for-night on the water, it gives you a perfectreflection of the sky; I think day-for-nightworks best when you have no idea how

    bright the sky is. The only way we could doit was to wait for the sky to get darkenough, and as soon as the torch lookedbrighter than the rest of the environment,we went for it.

    Monsters opens with a green-hued night-vision sequence. How did

    you achieve the night-vision effect?Edwards: That was quite embar-rassing. That sequence was part of thepickup shoot, and we filmed it in one night.You dont really notice it in the film, buttheres a van flipped on its side nothingsays post-apocalypse like a car on its side! Ishot it with an inexpensive Sony night-visioncamera [HVR-A1E], and everyone was look-ing at me like, You paid thousands ofpounds for these cranes and trucks, andyoure filming with that thing?

    People tend to shoot those thingsproperly and then treat them in post to looklike bad footage, but I dont like that at all;theres something you cant fake about thelook. Ironically, I thought Id be making mylife a nightmare, having to put the creatureinto these night-vision shots, but it was theeasiest thing in the world. Its so grainy andblurry, you cant tell where the creaturesfeet connect with the ground and you canget away with murder.

    The credits list Adam Inglis as thedigital colorist. Where did you do the

    digital grade?Edwards: We did all of our grading

    and our Dolby 5.1 mix at Post Republic inBerlin. Adam did a brilliant grade. We wereboth surprised by how much we could getout of the blacks in the EX3 footage, andwe softened a lot of it to take the harshnessout of the shots.

    The perfect version of this filmwould be full of imperfections I wantedit to have all the crap that reality brings. Idsometimes completely abandon my plan

    while we were filming and just go withwhat felt right in the moment, hoping itwouldnt be a mistake in the edit.

    TECHNICAL SPECS

    2.35:1High-Definition VideoSony PMW-EX3, HVR-A1ENikon lensesDigital Intermediate

    Wynden andKaulder

    traverse thesite of a

    recent militarystrike againstthe creatures,

    a sequenceshot on

    location inTexas.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    31/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    32/104

    30 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    T

    he new film Secretariat, about the 1973 Triple Crownwinner, attempts to boldly go where no camera hasgone before: smack in the middle of a thundering pack

    of thoroughbred horses. We wanted to capture theexcitement of the race and were willing to do it in ways thatno one else had tried, says director Randall Wallace. We

    were skimming cameras an inch over the ground, so close tothe hooves that you can see the light reflected in the horse-shoes. The dirt is flying, and its all real.

    The cinematographer tasked with accomplishing thiswas Dean Semler, ASC, ACS, with whom Wallace hadpreviously collaborated on We Were Soldiers (ACFeb. 02).Semler has frequently worked with horses, most notably inDances With Wolves (ACMay 91), for which he won an

    An inexperienced stableowner gambles her familys

    fortune on a thoroughbredracehorse in Secretariat, shot byDean Semler, ASC, ACS.

    By Patricia Thomson

    |

    HorsePower

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    33/104

    www.theasc.com November 2010

    Academy Award. As he points out,though, thoroughbreds are differentbeasts. Theyre ultra-sensitive, andtheyre born to race.

    Secretariat re-creates all of thefamous horses astonishing accom-plishments, including his 31-length

    victory at the Belmont, a grueling raceknown as the graveyard of speed

    horses, but the films focus is on thelesser-known background story. Basedon William Nacks book Secretariat:The Making of a Champion , the filmfollows Peggy Chenery (Diane Lane)after she takes over her fathers horsefarm upon his death. Its a woman-against-the-odds story, as Chenerystruggles to succeed in the all-male

    world of thoroughbred racing. Withher stable deep in debt, she literallybets the farm on her horse, a risky

    gamble given that his bloodlineexcelled in speed, not distance. Incharting Secretariats rise, the filmcovers six races: his first;the first he

    won;a crucial one he lost;and theTriple Crown, comprising theKentucky Derby, the Preakness andthe Belmont Stakes. Filmed over 42days, Secretariatwas shot mostly onlocation in Kentucky and Louisiana,including at the tracks ChurchillU

    nitphotographybyJohnBramley,courtesyofDisneyEnterprises.

    Opposite: Thelegendary racehorseSecretariat widens hlead in a Triple Crowrace. This page, top:The championthoroughbred (farleft, at back of packwas known for hisslow starts andexciting finishes.Middle: Stable owne

    Penny Chenery (DiaLane, far right),sartoriallyextravagant trainerLucien Laurin (JohnMalkovich) andChenerys stalwartassistant, ElizabethHam (MargotMartindale), watchgroom Eddie Sweat(Nelsan Ellis) exercisSecretariat. Bottom:Dean Semler, ASC,ACS (right) lays outhis race plan for 2ndunit director ofphotography BradShield.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    34/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    35/104

    www.theasc.com November 2010

    knows what a difficult job it was forthe jockeys to maintain and match theexact positions that Secretariat and

    Sham [his primary rival] had in thereal event. The other jockeys had to benear accurate with their positions as

    well.If they got it right and we didnt,

    it would have been disastrous, so I putas many cameras as possible on each ofthose short bursts. Generally, there

    were one or two really long lensesfront-on, a couple of wider lenseshigher up, and one through somecrowds, where we might track along

    with them. The shots at the startinggate, where its wall-to-wall horses,

    were done on a long lens from down atthe end of the track. Its 400-500 yardsaway, maybe farther. Id give them asmuch depth as I could on the apertureto make it work. Its silly to limit themin a case like that. If it was full sun, Icould give them a 16 or 22 f-stop. The[Panavision] Genesis goes to 50 fps,and we shot most of the races at 48 fps

    in case Randy wanted to use somespeed later on. As it turned out, heskipped pretty much all of it back to24 fps because he liked the speed

    when he saw it cut. If slow motion wasrequired, we used the trusty Arri 435.

    This is the seventh feature

    youve shot with the Genesis, thoughwe understand you mixed in someother cameras as well. Why did youfeel the Genesis was right for thisproject?

    Semler:The Genesis gives me agreat look, and it also gives me a long

    Cheneryquicklydeveloped abond with hprize horse,who provedbe bothstrong-willeand stubbo

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    36/104

    34 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    recording time, which directors andactors seem to like. Also, I can go tohigh ISOs and shoot pretty low lightlevels. As cinematographers, we stillhave to maintain that craft of lightingsets, lighting people and creating

    moods, but the Genesis allows me tosometimes use smaller lights and, insome cases, available light. An integralpart of why I love it is EFilmsColorstream, which applies the look-up table that emulates the negativeand the print stock. Its not just agood-quality HD image; its actuallythe image Im going to be seeing

    onscreen. Im watching dailies, basi-cally.

    I rate the Genesis at 400 ASA,the same as I do with [Kodak Vision3500T] 5219. I normally shoot with a180-degree shutter with no Gain atall. If I need more light, Ill progres-sively use the shutter. First, Ill go to

    270 degrees, which gives me half astop. Going to 360 degrees puts me at800 ASA, and Ill use that as long as itdoesnt interfere with the movement ofthe character, like blurring the eyes orface; at 360 degrees, Im actuallyshooting at an equivalent to 124second, so theres more of a blur factor.In some cases, thats good, likepanning with a racehorse across afinish line. Next, Ill go to + 12 Gain,

    Horse Power

    Top: During a pre-race press conference, Chenery trades barbs with rival trainer Pancho Martin (NestorSerrano, far right), the owner of Secretariats main rival, Sham. Middle: A dynamic angle captures the

    excitement of a race from behind the rail. Bottom: Chenery celebrates a big win.

    Ive had the samecrew over the last

    six or sevenpictures, and weve

    got the Genesissystem down to

    a fine art.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    37/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    38/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    39/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    40/104

    38 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    painters pole that extended to about12 feet. First AC Tony Rivetti put aprotective filter on the front of thecamera, as well as a little nitrogen hoseto blow off dirt. Then they ran a cablefrom the camera to a regular analogmonitor on top of the post that Kris

    was holding, so he could see exactlywhat he was getting. The cameracouldnt pan or tilt; it was fixed to theend of the pole. From that monitor,three things happened. It wasconnected to two monitors in the

    cabin of the vehicle, a powerful pick-up truck driven by Freddie Hice.Freddie had a monitor to see wherethe camera was. [Second-unit directorof photography] Brad Shield also satin the front with another monitor. Inaddition, we had guys from a companycalled RF Film transmit wirelessimages from the Olycam to Randyand me we were off shooting withthe actors maybe 500 or 600 yardsaway. So we could monitor at all times

    what second unit was doing, or theycould play back for us. The system wasbrilliant. Brad Shield, a fellow Aussie,shot all of the Olycam material, as wellas a lot of the race coverage that wecouldnt fit into the main-unit sched-ule and, of course, the horses beautyshots.Brad is an old colleague whod

    just moved to Hollywood, as had A-camera/Steadicam operator MarkGoellnicht. With them, [B-camera

    Horse Power

    Top: Secretariat(in second place)

    closes the gap onSham. Middle:

    Director RandallWallace tests a

    low angle fromthe back of a

    truck. Bottom: Aremote arm

    captures a photofinish. Upper

    right: Wallacechats with actorOtto Thorwath,

    who plays jockeyRon Turcotte.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    41/104

    operator] Richard Merryman and me,there were four Aussies. They called usthe Gumleaf Mafia!

    What were your lenses?Semler: We had a full set of

    Primos, including the 10mm;

    Panavision Lightweight zoom lenses[17.5-34mm T2.8 and 27-68mmT2.8] for Steadicam and handheldwork; and Panavision 11:1 [24-275mm], 4:1 [17.5-75mm T2.3] and3:1 [135-420mm T2.8] zoom lenses.

    The 3:1 Hubble would generally playon my veteran B-camera team,Richard Merryman and his focuspuller, Fred McLane. Richard and I goback toMad Max 2: TheRoad Warrior

    he was the focus puller and I oper-ated. Hes a master at telling a story

    with a long lens rather than just grab-bing bits. Richard and Fred are aformidable duo in the long-lensdepartment, whether theyre wide-open indoors or, in this case, shootinghorses traveling at 35 mph comingstraight toward the camera from 440

    yards to 20 yards and decidingwhether to focus on the horses head

    or the jockeys head. Tricky stuff.We also hid a little camera on

    the inside of the track. This wasusually the Arri 435 with a wide-anglelens, like a 14mm, sitting on a sandbagright on the edge of the inside rail, sothe horses hooves missed it by a fewfeet as they thundered by. These are allbonus shots, and we stole a lot ofthem, but theyre in the movie. I coulddo that both ways: point the camera

    one way for this run, then pan itaround and have them going awayfrom us for the next run.

    Youd take as many stabs at it asyou could, knowing that this was reallythe master when we were including

    the background. Tom Sanders, who Ialso worked with on We Were Soldiersand Apocalypto, is a brilliant and veryhands-on production designer. Heturned one track, Evangeline Downs

    in Louisiana, into four different race-tracks. Hed change the infield, andthe visual-effects team would use CGIto fix the background.

    What were your visual refer-ences?

    Semler:Obviously, we looked atSeabiscuit [ACAug. 03]. Thats abeautiful-looking picture; JohnSchwartzman [ASC] did a fabulous

    job. That movie required actors on

    www.sylvania.com/entertainment

    2

    010OSRAMSYLVANIA

    OSRAMandKREIOSareregistered

    trademarksofOSRAMGmbHPhotoCredit:ImageSource/GettyImages

    KREIOS LED lighting shows true color.OSRAM KREIOS lighting solutions render true color and skin tones on

    film and videoexactly how the eye sees them. And with precise color

    temperature matching, OSRAM KREIOS LEDs seamlessly integrate with

    existing traditional lighting. The fact that you cant tell them apart is

    what sets them apart. For more information on OSRAM KREIOS LED

    lighting system solutions, please email [email protected]

    or call 1-888-677-2627.

    You cant riskactors lives

    doing coverageat speed.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    42/104

    horses, whereas Randy cast real jock-eys for all the riding in our picture. You

    cant risk actors lives doing coverage atspeed. They can sit on the horses and

    walk around the paddock, but racingis taboo. Thats for the real jockeys.Because we used jockeys, I didnt haveto hide anybody. Randy cast this

    young guy, Otto [Thorwarth], as RonTurcotte, Secretariats main jockey.

    Otto was an extraordinary rider, buthe also turned out to be a fantasticactor. Imagine, the poor bugger iscovered in mud, sitting next to JohnMalkovich [who plays Secretariatstrainer, Lucien Laurin] and getting

    yelled at by Diane Lane for losing arace. Hed never acted before, but he

    was right between these two veteranactors, and he got right into the part.

    Did mixing the Genesis,Olympus and Phantom materialcreate any problems in post?

    Semler: No. There are so manygreat tools now that help you blenddifferent material. If you sat down andreally analyzed Secretariat, youd seedifferences, but in the context of ahorserace, you get away with it.

    Horse Power

    Chenery and her extended family celebrate Secretariats ultimate triumph: winning the Triple Crown.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    43/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    44/104

    42 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    Olivier Assayas Carlos, which premiered out of competi-tion to great acclaim at this years Cannes Film Festival,is an epic portrait of the famous terrorist known asCarlos the Jackal (a.k.a. Ilich Ramrez Snchez), who

    was born in Venezuela in 1949 and is currently behind bars inFrance, serving a life sentence for three murders. ProducerDaniel Leconte, who initiated the production, says he wasdrawn to the subject because he believes that terrorism is thebig topic of my generation. He observes, Carlos was theBin Laden of his time.

    In order to increase their financing options, the film-

    makers decided to create Carlosin two versions, a 2-hourcut for theatrical release and a 5-hour cut for televisionbroadcast and home-video release. (The latter was screenedat Cannes.) In the United States, the longer cut recently airedon the Sundance Channel and has been theatrically releasedby IFC Films in select major cities, and the shorter cut isavailable on demand and is playing theatrically in smallermarkets.

    Carlosis an epic in every sense of the word. The three-episode story takes place over 20 years in a dozen countries,

    with dialogue in French, English, Arabic, Spanish, German,

    TheWorlds Most

    Wanted Man

    Carlos, shot byYorick Le Saux andDenis Lenoir, ASC,

    AFC, offers a portraitof infamous terrorist

    Carlos the Jackal.

    By Benjamin B

    |

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    45/104

    www.theasc.com November 2010

    Hungarian, Russian and Japanese. Thefilm starts as the Venezuelan-bornmigr (played by Edgar Ramrez)begins his career as a terrorist with aPalestinian terrorist group that is seek-ing a European agent. The first episode

    encompasses Carlos first assassinationattempt (the target is a British business-man), a series of explosions in Londonand France, a bungled airport attack,and the murder of three members ofFrances counterintelligence service in aLeft Bank apartment. The secondepisode begins with Carlos most spec-tacular operation, in December 1975:taking 11 OPEC ministers and theiraides hostage, flying them to variouspoints in the Middle East, and then

    ultimately releasing them in exchangefor millions of dollars. Now a celebrity,Carlos offers his services to Syria, withthe complicity of the Soviet Union andthe East German and Hungariangovernments. In the final episode,Carlos takes up residence in Budapest

    with his German wife, MagdalenaKopp (Nora von Waldsttten), andprovides his murderous services to thehighest bidder. When the Berlin WallC

    arlosphotosbyJean-ClaudeMoineau,courtesyofRaphaelCohenandFilmEnStock.

    FramegrabsbyBenjaminB,courtesyofthefilmmakers.

    Opposite:Ambitiousterrorist Carlosthe Jackal (EdgRamrez)deplanes aftertaking hostageduring hisinfamous OPECoperation. Thispage, top: Carloand his croniestransport theOPEC hostagesto the airport.Middle: The

    radical shows hmeans businesBottom:Casualties arestrewn throughan airport aftean attack.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    46/104

    44 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    falls in 1989, Carlos seeks refuge inSyria, and then finally in Sudan, wherehe is kidnapped by French authorities.

    Assayas, whose recent creditsinclude Summer Hours, Boarding Gateand Clean, was obsessed with the verac-ity and authenticity of every detail inCarlos. Executive producer Raphael

    Cohen reports that the director wantedeach character to be played by someoneof that nationality, speaking in his orher own language with the correctaccent. We had 96 shooting days with135 locations in nine countries, addsCohen.

    Carlosis not a political film, but

    it is a film about politics, says Assayas.The movie does, indeed, succeed inrevealing the complex web of terroristnetworks involving Palestine, Iraq, Iran,

    Syria, Libya, the Soviet Union, EastGermany and Hungary. (We learn, forexample, that Carlos OPEC operation

    was financed and supported by SaddamHussein and Moammar Gadhafi.)

    Yet the film is above all a fiction-alized portrait of a terrorist. Assayasobserves, Its not difficult to position

    yourself morally with respect to Carlos its pretty black and white! But weget to understand him, what driveshim, and he becomes a rich, complex,

    conflicted individual. We can followhim the same way that we follow TonyMontana when were watching Scarfaceor Don Corleone in The Godfather .Carlosis much closer to a Mafia moviethan a political movie.

    For scheduling reasons, Assayasworked with two cinematographers.He did a lengthy preparation with

    Yorick Le Saux, who then filmed untilhe had to depart for the birth of his

    The Worlds Most Wanted Man

    Right: Nada(Julia Hummer),a loose cannon

    on the terroristsOPEC team,

    takes things toofar. Below: A

    handheld cameracaptures some

    over-the-shoulder action.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    47/104

    www.theasc.com November 2010

    daughter. At that point, Denis Lenoir,ASC, AFC, stepped in for the secondhalf of the shooting schedule. Bothcinematographers had worked with

    Assayas before; Lenoir had shot sevenprevious features for the director(including Demonlover; ACSept. 03),

    and Le Saux was the second-unit direc-tor of photography on two of thosefilms, as well as the director of photog-raphy on Boarding Gate.

    Lenoir recalls that one of thejokes on the set was that the only differ-ence between the two cinematogra-phers lighting was that Yorick will puta bright practical light in the back-ground behind Carlos. In reality, it isimpossible to distinguish whichsequences were lit and shot by Lenoir

    or Le Saux. Each cinematographer shotabout half the footage, and each did hisown operating. Such stylistic unity, saysLenoir, proves that cinematography ismade by the director.

    Carloswas shot in 2-perf Super35mm with Kodak negative. Le Sauxexplains that he and Assayas chose toshoot film because we wanted to work

    very fast and light very little, and wehad to shoot sunny day exteriors in all

    these different countries. Digital isgood when can you control the light,but you cant work rock n roll in digi-tal. Although the filmmakers consid-ered Super 16mm, they opted for35mm in part because the AatonPenelope camera had just come out,providing an ideal handheld tool. Inaddition, 2-perf was perfectly suited tothe 2.40:1 frame they wanted to

    compose, and the magazines run longerthan 16mm mags, a plus in light of

    Assayas penchant for long takes.A Panaflex Platinum served as

    the B camera for some action sequencesand intense dialogue sequences, like therestaurant dinner with Carlos and hisfirst wife, Juana Acosta, early in thefilm. The camera gear package,provided by Panavision Alga Techno in

    Left: Carlosenjoys somefemale

    companionshipduring a breakfrom hisoperations.Below: Theterroristchallenges oneof his mostefficientoperatives,BrigitteKuhlmann(KatharinaSchttler), toprove hermarksmanship.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    48/104

    Paris, also included Panavision Primolenses. Much of the movie was shot

    with a 27mm prime, according to LeSaux. Assayas, who is generally knownfor using long focal lengths, notes, I

    decided to go two lenses wider thanusual so we could see the Seventies.

    The main film stock was KodakVision3 500T 5219, which the cine-matographers rated at ISO 400. (Day

    exteriors in Lebanon were shot onslower Vision2negatives, 100T 5212and 200T 5217.) During prep, Le Sauxdefined a look for Carloswith a set ofrules that he and Lenoir subsequentlyfelt free to break upon occasion. I set

    up a framework, and then I did ordidnt apply it depending on the set orthe feeling I had about the space, saysLe Saux. I wanted to shoot pretty

    wide open, around T2.8; I wanted tosoften the image somewhat with filters;and I didnt hesitate to change colortemperatures, burning the highlights togive the feeling of heat and sun in theMiddle East and keeping Paris darker,sadder.

    Le Saux used two Tiffen diffu-sion filters, White Pro-Mist andSoft/FX, throughout the shoot. He

    would often add NDs to get to an openstop. The idea was to work with littledepth of field, using the filters to softenthe image and lower the contrast. Heexplains, With the Soft/FX, we brokethe contrast, the sharpness and hard-ness of 5219. The White Pro-Mist

    works as a kind of screen throughwhich you have to project yourself toget into the story and the period; ithelped give a patina to the image. The

    White Pro-Mist also added a halo tolight sources, and Le Saux thereforechose a lighter degree of filtration

    when shooting towards a window orwith a longer focal length. But, henotes, there were moments when I feltI should go all out, without any rules.

    Le Saux also softened the imagewith smoke, which was motivated bycigarettes and cigars, gunfire, and evenbathroom vapors. Smoke is a bitch!he says with a laugh. Everyone hated

    me for it, and even I got sick of it, butOlivier agreed that it was right.

    Carlos is full of varying colortemperatures. In the Middle East, LeSaux and Lenoir often used a Tiffen

    Antique Suede filter to create a distinc-tive ochre hue. This was often coupled

    with an 85 to get an even warmerimage. (The coloring scheme washeightened in the digital grade atDigimage by colorist Isabelle Julien.

    46 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    Frame grabs show various stages of the OPEC operation:Carlos and his team heading to the job (top); holding hostages (middle); and changing planes while

    transporting the hostages from Austria to North Africa (bottom).

    The Worlds Most Wanted Man

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    49/104

    www.theasc.com November 2010

    Both cinematographers participated inthe grading sessions.) All these rulesare very precise at the outset, but once

    you start shooting, you throw yourselfinto the film and do what you do, saysLe Saux. I stay free so I can respond to

    the set the production designer deliversand the details of the scene.Both Lenoir and Le Saux kept

    their lighting to a minimum. Lenoirsshort lighting list for the Lebaneseportion of the shoot speaks volumes,and seems more appropriate for anambitious short than an epic feature:the HMIs were two 6Ks, one 2.5/4K,one 1.2K Cinepar, and four Jokers(three 400-watt and one 200-watt);and the Kino Flos comprised pairs of 4'4-Banks, 2-Banks and 1-Banks, as wellas two 2' units (4-Bank and 2-Bank), a12-volt single kit and two Mini Flos.

    This modest package was rounded outwith some small tungsten units: two 2KBlondes, four 1K Redheads, twoSource Four Lekos, four 500-wattFresnels, and two 150-watt Fresnels.Other fixtures were added throughoutthe shoot as needed for special situa-tions; these included an occasional18K, as well as dozens of industrialfluorescents and household bulbs.

    Carlos begins in bed, with aPalestinian agent waking up beside hisgirlfriend in Paris minutes before dyingin a car bomb on the street outside. LeSaux created a simple, moody ambiencefor the scene: the dark bedroom has asplash of sunlight from the window asthe man rises and moves about. Thepenumbra is punctuated by the red haloof the mans lighter as he lights his ciga-rette. The sunlight was provided by an18K HMI. We couldnt get the permit

    to set up a tower outside the window,and I was happy about that, recalls LeSaux. So the 18K was in an apartmenton the other side of the street very faraway, and I was only getting crumbsfrom it. Le Saux didnt want the light-ing to be too harsh for the woman, sohe put a Kino Flo inside the room forfill and bounced a Joker 800 on theceiling. The dark image was madegentler still by the combination of the

    Soft/FXand White Pro-Mist filters,which also added a halo to the flame ofthe mans cigarette lighter. I almostalways used the Soft/FX and WhitePro-Mist together, and I would vary the

    gradation of one or the other depend-ing on faces, the contrast or the light,notes Le Saux.

    Early in the first episode, we seeCarlos sitting naked in a bathroom; he

    From top: Sunlight provided by an 18K helps to illuminate the opening scene; an Antique Suedefilter, often coupled with an 85, lends Middle East scenes a distinctive ochre hue; the narcissistic Carlos

    examines himself in a mirror.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    50/104

    then walks into the adjoining bedroomand peers at himself in a mirror. Hisfull-frontal nudity is unexpected andsignals, says Assayas, that were notgoing to shy away from anything as wetell this story. The scene is meant to be

    shocking, and it establishes that we willbe going into areas that you dontexpect. Were going to tell the story ofCarlos, but we are going to take liber-ties. The director adds, Every witnesshas written about Carlos relationship

    with his body; it was complex, narcissis-tic and uneasy.

    The backlit shot of Carlosadmiring himself in the mirror is lumi-

    nous and hazy with smoke. Le Sauxrecalls, There were Kinos everywhere,above the windows and to the left ofEdgar fitted with Lee 250 diffusiongels. Its all about the balance of theshadows, he says. You see somethingthere, but its still dark. There was nooutside lighting, as the location was onthe sixth floor. You have to know when

    its worth it to bring out the heavyartillery and when it isnt, says thecinematographer.

    One of the films most suspense-ful moments takes place in an apart-ment of Paris Rue Toullier, whereCarlos is partying with friends whenFrench counterintelligence agentsknock on the door. A fellow member ofCarlos group has been captured andhas led the police to the apartment. The

    48 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    The Worlds Most Wanted Man

    You have toknow when its

    worth it to bringout the heavyartillery and

    when it isnt.

    From top:Magdalena

    Kopp (Nora vonWaldsttten),who became

    one of theterrorists

    wives, seducesCarlos in a

    Beirut hotelroom; Carlos

    gives arevealing

    interview; ashis world falls

    apart, Carlosargues with

    Magdalena justprior to their

    breakup; inAlgeria, the

    terrorist savorshis OPEC

    triumph afternegotiating the

    release of thehostages.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    51/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    52/104

    50 November 2010 American Cinematographer

    The Worlds Most Wanted Manconversation with the police is casual,and one of the inspectors even acceptsa whiskey. The camera follows Carlosinto the bathroom, where he prepareshis gun. When his traitorous compa-triot identifies him, Carlos leaps into

    action, killing the three agents and thetraitor. He is now a true killer.Le Saux created the scenes

    warm lighting with several hot practi-cals. An open kitchen area is lit veryhot, with fluorescents above. A barebulb near the door adds drama to theentrances and exits. Le Saux confides,I sweated on this one! The apartment

    was very small, so I used only smallsources. I changed lightbulbs andcreated rhythms in the set; it was theonly way to make it live. He even laida lamp on the ground to avoid a blackhole, and used newspapers as reflec-tors. Coats were hung on a light standto disguise it.

    The problem, says Le Saux, wasto avoid overlighting the actors whomight step too close to a source.Everything had to be measured, amatter of nuances. He explains thatthe bathroom lighting, a 400-watt

    Joker gelled with 12 CTO on the ceil-ing, was meant to contrast with the

    lower, warmer living room. The scenewas shot with a 50mm at the begin-ning, giving way to a 27mm before thegunplay begins.

    For Lenoir, Carlosbrought backmemories of his previous collabora-tions with Assayas, which included thedirectors first four features. All my

    years with Olivier were extremelyformative for me because hes a chal-lenging director, says Lenoir.Lighting for his films is more difficult

    because you have to cover 180, 270 oreven 360 degrees. So you have tocompromise; you have to light from theceiling or find ways to not light at all.

    Lenoir cites some examples inCarlos.The large OPEC room wherethe hostages are kept was a shoe boxlit with industrial fluorescents on theceiling, allowing the camera to movefreely. After that, its a matter ofsavoir-faireas to how to keep the actors from

    Top: Denis Lenoir,ASC, AFC grabs ashot with Aatons

    2-perf Penelope

    camera. Middle:Yorick Le Saux(left) watches a

    scene with directorOlivier Assayas.

    Bottom: Lenoir andLe Saux listen in as

    Assayas discussesthe OPEC sequence

    with actors.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    53/104

    being badly lit with that overheadsource, says the cinematographer. Itsmore a matter of redirecting, subtract-ing and diffusing the lighting, workingthe contrast to use what was given to usto our advantage. In the hallways, I

    took the liberty of turning off somefluorescents because we decided theycould have been broken by thegunfire. With a laugh, he adds, Thecamerawork and performances areinteresting in this sequence, but thelighting is not!

    No movie lights were used onthe plane carrying Carlos, his fellow

    terrorists and the OPEC hostages,continues Lenoir. If you start lightingone shot, you have to light the others,he notes. Lenoir requested that thecockpit face west and tapped thenatural light seeping in from thetarmac of the Beirut airport for thedaytime scenes. The camera washandheld there was no room for adolly, he notes. For the night

    sequences, he used the vintage planespracticals.

    Lenoir occasionally used HMIsoutside windows, for example, in thescenes where Carlos is reprimanded byhis Palestinian boss. For a memorable,elegantly lit scene in which MagdalenaKopp seduces Carlos in a bright hotelroom, Lenoir simply bounced Jokers toreduce the contrast and put up a diffu-sion frame to soften the light coming

    from the window on Carlos futurewife.

    Lenoir stresses the importance ofgiving the director more time in a hecticschedule. For any given location, Idecided what lighting would be quick

    to set up but also pleasing to the eye,while still being respectful of the periodatmosphere and the drama of the scene.I light with a big brush; I dont likedetail work, which is probably why I

    dont do commercials. I am impatientwith myself on the set. Thats probablywhy Im fast.

    Although the lighting in Carloscreates a stylish yet realistic period look

    with a minimum of tools, Lenoir points

    out that it is often the camerawork thatreally sets the filmmaking apart. Carloshas a distinctive, dynamic mise en scnethat keeps the actors moving wheneverpossible. The camera, whether hand-

    Carlos has adistinctive, dynamicmise en scne thatkeeps the actorsmoving whenever

    possible.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    54/104

    held or on a dolly, is moving also,giving a rhythm to the action: sweep-ing across the room or going fromcharacter to character with a uniquefluidity. Lenoir adds, This is why Ihave so much admiration for Olivier.His approach is actually modest insome ways, but at the same time,I find

    it extremely powerful and efficient.Almost every scene in Carloswas

    shot with a series of plan squences, theFrench term for a single continuousshot. The idea is to end up with atleast two shots, perhaps three or four,each of which lasts for the duration ofthe scene and is visually interesting

    because of the cameras and actorsmovements, explains Lenoir. Thisapproach allows for performances, andit feels more organic and real than stan-dard coverage.

    The first time we did this, in theearly Nineties, we were following oneactor from the beginning to the end of

    The Worlds Most Wanted Man

    2

    Left: Lenoir captures an emotional moment. Right: Members of Carlos team stand guard at a terrorist camp.

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    55/104

    the scene, and then we followed theother actor, continues Lenoir. Butsoon we developed something moreinteresting that wasnt tied to one actor:

    we started on one actor and thenmoved to the other actor when they

    crossed paths, and eventually to a thirdactor, all in the same shot. You can,ofcourse,cross the line,but then youcross it twice and you respect themoment you cross the line on thesecond shot. That way,you can cut tothe other shot at any moment, sincethe eyelines are always respected the180 rule. Another idea was to includethe inserts in the shot. So,for example,

    we might go down from the actors faceto what hes holding and then back tohis face, instead of cutting.

    Le Saux recalls a great exampleof a one-shot scene, when Carlos isoutside the French embassy that hasbeen taken over by Japanese terrorists,and watches as a wounded police-

    woman is brought out on a stretcher.

    The camera starts on Carlos, thenfollows an ambulance driver as he

    whizzes by, revealing the entrance ofthe building; a moment later,thestretcher is brought out, then Carlos

    walks back into frame and we follow

    him as he walks off. Assayas remembersthat he designed the shot on the spot atthe end of a long day, and that the shot

    was accomplished in 30 minutes. Its amiracle! he says, laughing.

    Assayas emphasizes that he doesnot believe in storyboarding or shotlist-ing during prep. Rather, he designs allhis shots on the day of the shoot. I domy homework, but I dont plan. I thinkmovies are living organisms; theydevelop gradually, and you have to be insync with that growth, which dependson the actors and whatever they havebuilt themselves from scene to scene,on your locations, and on your crew. Amovie has its own life.

    PANTHER GmbHRaiffeisenallee 3 | 82041 Munich | GermanyT +49.89.613 90001 | F +49.89.61 31 00 [email protected] | www.panther.tv

    www.panther.tv

    The Panther DollyA new dolly generation

    After over 25 years of experience in designing and manufacturing elec-

    tromechanic dollies, Panther is introducing a new generation of camera

    dollies on the market.

    Lowest column dolly worldwide(lowest start position)

    Equipped with the new High-Low Turnstile Unique 3 column system

    Camera movements from a sitting to a standing person are possi-ble without any conversion of the dolly.

    Realise low camera positions without any conversion.A new period of working time efficiency and effectivity with acamera dolly has begun.

    Learn more about the Panther Tristar dolly by visting our

    webside at www.panther.tv

    PANTHER Dollies & Cranes LLC7358 Radford Ave. | North Hollywood, CA 91605T +818-764-1234 [email protected]

    rehg

    oD

    .

    lo

    reneg

    ofsarey5er 2ver otAf

    s, Plieldoanichomectr

    etarkon the mslieldo

    umn dollcolLowestporstowest(l

    Equipped with the new umn systemcolUnique 3

    ementsva moamerConcyanithoute wlb

    urinactanufg and migninse in dexperiencef

    ation ofenerg a new ginoducintrsanther is, P

    .et

    worldwidedollposition)

    urnstileTHigh-Lowhe newumn system

    son arg perandinto a sg tittinom a sfrements.lylthe doion ofservon

    ecg elurin -

    aamercof

    isse poson ar -

    rristT

    options:Steering

    HbmGREHTNAPreG|hcinuM10428|3eellanesieffiaR01316.98.94+F|10009136.98.94+T

    vtr.ehtnap.www|vtr.ehtnap@tcatnoc

    ynamr000

    a

    oncyanithoute wlb

    a poamerw cse loalieRorkwA new period ofbesahlyla doamerc

    aboutLearn more

    tawebside www

    rC&seilloDREHTNAPoN|.evAdrofdaR8537catnoc4231-46-7818+T

    sur.ehtnap.www

    C

    .lylservon

    ion.servoncyanithoutwsitionsa powityectivand effiencyg time efficinork

    ngube .

    ourvistingbyr dollristanther Tthe P

    .panther.tvwww

    LLsena50619AC,doowylloHhtro

    sur.ehtnap@tc

    ith aw

    our

    5

    TECHNICAL SPECS

    2.40:1

    2-perf Super 35mm

    Aaton Penelope;

    Panaflex PlatinumPanavision lenses

    Kodak Vision3 500T 5219;Vision2 100T 5212, 200T 5217

    Digital Intermediate

    Printed on Kodak Vision 2383

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    56/104

  • 7/29/2019 AC noi 2010

    57/104

    www.theasc.com November 2010

    George Lonegan (Matt Damon), a SanFranciscan with paranormal abilities

    who can commune with the dead bytouching their loved ones.

    To tell this tale, Eastwood and hiscollaborators, including longtime cine-matographer Tom Stern, ASC, AFC,

    took advantage of the latest tools andtechnology, employing extensive visualeffects and making significant use of thedigital-intermediate process. The direc-tor had previously explored digital posttechniques on Flags of Our Fathers (AC,Nov. 06), Letters from Iwo Jima (AC,March 07), Changeling and Invictus(AC, Nov. 08), but Hereafter ups theante right from its opening scenes inHawaii, where a terrifying tsunamicauses Marie to experience what Stern

    describes as the dream vacation all goneto hell.

    To realize this sequence, and tovisually distinguish the films threestorylines, Eastwood and Stern spentconsiderable time in a Technicolor DIsuite with colorist Jill Bogdanowicz,digitally painting the movie. This is a

    very unexpected film from Clint, main-tainsproducer Rob Lorenz, Eastwoodspartner at their production company,

    Malpaso. Its a departure he decided