adult museum visitors' learning identities
DESCRIPTION
Final presentation of my thesis to AARE conference 2006TRANSCRIPT
1
Visitors and learners:
Adult museum visitors’ learning identities
Lynda Kelly, University of Technology, Sydney
2Lynda Kelly, UTS
Research questions
What are the interrelationships between adult museum visitors’ views of learning and their learning experiences at a museum? Relationships between learning, education
and entertainment How does a visit to a museum exhibition
interact with an adult visitors’ learning identity? How does the roles played during a visit
influence learning identity?
3Lynda Kelly, UTS
The challenges we face …
Conceptual shift for museums … education to learning responding to learners & communities lifelong learning & educational leisure demonstrate outcomes/performance
Visitors’ learning agendas Confusion between learning & education Dumbing down & entertainment “Thematise” learning
4Lynda Kelly, UTS
Stage One: Individual•Pilot studies (n=7)•In-depth interviews (n=8)•Questionnaire (n=100)•Telephone survey (n=300)
Literature Review: Identity and Learning•General learning theories•Theories influencing museum learning•How word “learning” has been researched•General definitions of identity•Identity and museums•How identity has been researched in museums
Stage Two: Sociocultural•Five families; five couples:
•Pre & post-visit interviews•Observations•Conversation analysis
5Lynda Kelly, UTS
Literature findings Learning is
an essential part of being human linked to identity & sense of self about change
Education is imposed, formal, prescriptive … negative!
Identity is how a person sees themselves & how others see them changing shaped by social context & community membership past, present & future
6Lynda Kelly, UTS
Museums as places for ‘identity work’ (Rounds, 2006, p.133-150)
‘… the processes through which we construct, maintain, and adapt our sense of personal identity, and persuade other people to believe in that identity’
Focus on what people are doing about their identity
7Lynda Kelly, UTS
Learning identity
How an individual’s see themselves as a learner;
within a sociocultural context; including future views of self as a learner;
and the role learning plays across a person’s
life.
PLACE•school•museums, galleries, cultural institutions•libraries•Internet•environment/nature•life
MUSEUMLEARNING
PROCESS•“doing something”:
•gathering•choosing•understanding•applying•linking•discovering•assimilating•acquiring•expanding•exploring•increasing•reminiscing•explaining•accumulating•questioning•thinking•hands-on
•facts & ideas•objects & tools•short & long-term•cognitive & physical•surface & deep
PURPOSE•motivation•interests•enjoyment•change•choice
PEOPLE•family•friends, colleagues•work peers•community•professionals:
•museum staff•teachers
PERSON•prior knowledge•experience•role•gender•cultural background•lived history•personal interest•personal change•meaning making•seeing in different way
9Lynda Kelly, UTS
PERSON•Expanding your knowledge, a new aspect on life (Interview #11)
•Finding your place in the world. Engaging with the world in a way to discover more about it and make sense of things. That’s the big picture (Interview #40)
•Being able to put pieces of information together [to] draw conclusions (Interview #71)
•New things that add to your body of knowledge (Interview #78)
10Lynda Kelly, UTS
PEOPLE
… sometimes we’d bounce off something of interest to ourselves, then we’d look at it a bit more, wander off. Then we’d come together a few times to have a look at things. … I also learned a bit more about my friends. I didn’t know they had an interest in [tattoos] either, and you sort of learn more of what they’re about as well. (Interview Transcript 3.4, 24/02/01)
11Lynda Kelly, UTS
PROCESS
•Opening the mind to new experience (Interview #4)
•Acquiring new knowledge and applying that (Interview #5)
•Expanding your knowledge about an area by a variety of means (Interview #11)
•An understanding of how things work (Interview #42)
12Lynda Kelly, UTS
PURPOSE
Obviously [learning is] something that’s not boring, something that’s not passive, so it’s more of an active thing … Something where you choose to be involved, that you’re interested in doing. (Interview Transcript 3.1, 22/11/00)
13Lynda Kelly, UTS
PLACE 1
Libraries Museums, galleries, other cultural
institutions University, school, formal education Internet Holiday destinations, the environment
14Lynda Kelly, UTS
PLACE 2
Eddie. Look at the seahorses.Cath. Like the one in the salt water.Bree. They’re just so cute and they swim along…Eddie. I’d hate to be bitten by these fish, look at
the teeth!Cath. But they don’t normally attack. … When we
go to Port Stephens next week we should go and find the white seahorses. Wouldn’t that be mad if we see one and we go, that’s a white seahorse. The guy’s going to just look at us [and go] how do you know that!
15Lynda Kelly, UTS
Differences Varied responses to word learning General language differed
learning = active education = process
Choice Education delivers learning Entertainment described differently:
fleeting, short-term, good time uses all senses feelings & emotions
EDUCATION
LEARNING
ENTERTAINMENT
MUSEUMS
17Lynda Kelly, UTS
Learning is
Lifelong & lifewide Fluid
changes with the context Adaptive Active Shared & solitary Meaning making An integral part of identity
18Lynda Kelly, UTS
Learning identity changed
learning more than thought they would (F1) being surprised that they talked a great deal
more than usual (F2) discovering a range of new animals related to
ones they already knew about (F5) changing from a “top-level reader-learner” to
becoming absorbed and reading all the texts (F5) being surprised at what they discovered about
nature, realising if Museum didn’t have these things we would never know about them (C4)
19Lynda Kelly, UTS
Learning identity did not change: exhibition matched it
C3: taking what we know and making connections
from what is in that to the exhibition read and process
20Lynda Kelly, UTS
Learning identity did not change: reinforced how not like to learn
F3: Immersive learner forced to use browsing
strategies F4:
Not engaging enough for the whole family C1:
Not enough challenge Didn’t engage them emotionally
C2: Not enough deep layers of information
21Lynda Kelly, UTS
THREE ROLES PLAYED
Visit manager Museum expert Learning-facilitator
22Lynda Kelly, UTS
Visit manager
Liz. Let’s look down the back; check if there’s anything down there we need to see.
Liz. Shall we go and have a look back there? We might find something that you like Paul.
Museum expert
Rox. How do they catch them, Mum? I wonder what they put them in a bottle for?Mary. So you can see them, ‘cos the backs are white, so you can see them better.
Tara. Eoww, disgusting! Look at the little bugs … with a needle through them.Liz. Well that’s just to hold them in place.
Art. That’s from India again.Dot. I know, I wonder where they find them. Just walking along?Art. I don’t know, probably dug up from somewhere. Caves, mines, it doesn’t say.
24Lynda Kelly, UTS
Learner-facilitator
Kay. Come and look at this. What is that? Where’s that from Zeke?Zeke. Bali.Kay. Yes, good boy.Zeke. I knew that.Kay. How did you know that?Zeke. Because it has all these on it “Javanese and Balinese” [reading from text] in the second line. I’ll tell you why I knew it was Balinese, because I saw those little gold things in Bali.
Rick. Hey Kate look at these ones, how’s that for a shell?
Kate. That’s an unusual one.Toni. That’s beautiful.Kate. Were shells alive, are shells alive?Rick. They’ve got things inside them.Toni. Molluscs in them.Kate. But are the actual shells alive?Toni. No.Rick. They’re a shell.Toni. I think the shell is the shell of the mollusc that
originally lived in them, like a snail.Kate. So they’re part of something?Toni. They’re part of something that was, yes.
SHARING LEARNING
LINKING TO PRIOR, PRESENT & FUTURE LIFE EXPERIENCES
Kate. Are they stick insects?Toni. Some of them are. That’s at the end of
Lord Howe Island, Ball’s Pyramid.Kate. Did we sail past that?Toni. We didn’t sail past that but we flew
nearby. You could see it from the top of the mountain Daddy climbed. Look at the
frogs. Look at the size of those. Not like our piddly little ones.
Kate. Like that small one? [points]Toni. Ours would be like that.
PLACE•access huge range of places in learning•relaxed physical environment•make links
PROCESS•collections & objects •layered information•personal stories•critical thinking•questions & answers
PURPOSE•People visit to learn, to be educated and to be entertained•in an exciting & stimulating environment•that is enjoyable for them & all group members
PEOPLE•sharing•conversations•roles•application•parents
PERSON•visitors & learners•fluidity•multiple roles•gender•front-end evaluation•application•meaning making
Implications
28Lynda Kelly, UTS
Museums shape identities
Through access to objects & information visitors see reflections of themselves & their culture that encourage: new connections; meaning-making; and changes to how they see themselves as
learners …• their learning identities.