advance care directives: do they help or do they harm?...• median time for directive completion...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?
John Holmes, PhD Director of Ethics
PeaceHealth Oregon
![Page 2: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Disclosures and Thank You
• No Financial Interests to Disclose
• Not Intending to Give Medical or Legal Advice
![Page 3: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Outline of Today’s Talk
• Historical Cases
• Federal & State Responses to Cases
• Advance Directive Use Today
• Proposed Harms of ADs and Replies
• I will defend the robust use of ADs against various challenges.
![Page 4: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Why This Talk?
![Page 5: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
![Page 6: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Historical Context
• Quinlan Case
• Cruzan Case
![Page 7: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Quinlan Case
• April 1975, 21 y.o. found not breathing by friends.
• Admitted to St. Clare’s Hospital in New Jersey, put on a ventilator.
• In a coma; unconscious but her eyes would open and move disconjugately, her body moved randomly.
![Page 8: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Quinlan Case cont’d
• After several months, her parents decided she should be disconnected from the ventilator.
• Doctors said no: – AMA said withdrawal of treatment = euthanasia
– Fear of malpractice; deviation from normal standards of medical practice
• Parents filed suit to remove life support.
![Page 9: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Quinlan Case cont’d
• Initial lower court decision held: – respirator should not be disconnected,
– Karen’s parents testimony about her wishes were insufficient,
– a non-family guardian was needed for Karen.
![Page 10: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Quinlan Case cont’d
• New Jersey Supreme Court appeal overturned lower court decision based on the Constitutional implied right to privacy (liberty).
• Three main findings: – allowed Karen’s father to be her guardian
(Substituted Judgment), – gave Karen’s doctors immunity for discontinuing her
treatment, – suggested use of an ethics committee to help in future
cases.
![Page 11: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Quinlan Case Resolution
• Karen was weaned from the ventilator so she was ultimately able to breathe on her own.
• Decubitus ulcers had developed exposing her hip bones in places.
• Karen languished in a nursing home for 10 years until she developed pneumonia and her parents declined the use of antibiotics.
• She died on June 13, 1986.
![Page 12: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Cruzan Case
• Jan 1983, 24 y.o. thrown from her car, landed face down in a watery ditch. Anoxic brain injury. In a coma.
• Able to breathe on her own, but required feeding tube.
• After four years in a PVS parents decided to discontinue feeding tube.
![Page 13: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Cruzan Case cont’d
• Missouri Supreme Court held: – the State has an interest in preserving life,
– Nancy’s parents had not met the standard of “clear and convincing” evidence in making their argument to discontinue feedings.
![Page 14: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Cruzan Case cont’d
• In 1990, U.S. Supreme Court reviewed the Missouri Supreme Court decision. Three main holdings: – Competent individuals have a Constitutional liberty right
to decline treatment.
– Withdrawal of feeding tube did not differ in kind from withdrawals of other life sustaining treatment.
– States could pass a statute requiring “clear and convincing” evidence for determining what formerly competent patients would want done. (Substituted Judgment)
![Page 15: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Cruzan Case Resolution
• Nancy’s case was reheard in a lower court.
• More friends of Nancy came forward to testify that she would not want the feeding tube.
• Her feeding tube was legally removed on Dec 14, 1990, she died 8 days later.
![Page 16: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
![Page 17: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Patient Self Determination Act (1991)
• The right to facilitate health care decisions • The right to accept or refuse medical
treatment • The right to make an advance health care
directive (Expressed Wishes and Substituted Judgment)
• Intended to fulfill the clear and convincing requirement suggested by the Cruzan case finding.
![Page 18: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Case Type for PSDA
• Young, previously healthy individual struck by unexpected tragic event which requires individual to be maintained – in a compromised health state – with life support in order to remain alive.
![Page 19: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Advance Directive Defined
Broadly construed: Any measure authored or initiated by an individual that is intended to direct the health care of that individual when he or she is unable to do so. Instruction Directive (“living will”) Proxy Directive (“DPOAHC”) Not necessarily focused on limitations or refusals.
![Page 20: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Intended Ethical Benefit of ADs
• Respect individual autonomy (Expressed Wishes and Substituted Judgment) – Decisions made through an AD are intended to
have the same ethical standing as contemporaneous decisions.
• Clarify obligations of providers – Intended to help providers navigate between a
wide range of medical goals.
![Page 21: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Goals of Medicine
• Preserve Life
• Restore Function
• Reduce Suffering
• Manage Pain and Symptoms
• Prevent Disease
• Promote Health
• Maintain Health State
• Allow Natural Death
![Page 22: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Possible Harms of Not Having an AD
• Unwanted treatment
• Unnecessary treatment
• Conflict over medical futility
• Negative impact on others needing treatment
![Page 23: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Uniform Health Care Decisions Act (1993)
• Proposed rules for combining instruction directives with proxy directives into a single document.
![Page 24: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
CMS Conditions of Participation
“The patient has the right to formulate advance directives and to have hospital staff and practitioners who provide care in the hospital comply with these directives…”
42 CFR §482.13(b)(3)
![Page 25: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Oregon’s Advance Directive (1993)
• Legally codifies an individual’s right to designate a health care representative and give health care instructions.
• Particular content is specified, format may vary.
![Page 26: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Oregon Revised Statute 127
• Chapter 127 — Powers of Attorney; Advance Directives for Health Care; Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment Registry; Declarations for Mental Health Treatment; Death with Dignity
www.leg.state.or.us/ors/127.html
![Page 27: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Oregon’s Advance Directive
Two Main Parts:
• Part B = Appointment of Health Care Representative (Substituted Judgment)
• Part C = Health Care Instructions (Expressed Wishes)
![Page 28: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Part B
• Appoint a primary representative • Appoint an alternate representative • Place limits on rep decision-making (if applicable)
• Specifically consider whether to give
representative(s) decision-making ability regarding life support and tube feeding.
• Considered a durable power of attorney for health care.
![Page 29: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Part C
• Give health care instructions for life support and tube feeding in four conditions: – Close to Death, – Permanently Unconscious, – Advanced Progressive Illness, – Extraordinary Suffering.
• Three basic choices: Yes, No, Let Physician Decide.
• Room for additional instructions (if desired).
• Considered a living will.
![Page 30: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Life Support in Oregon
“…any medical procedure, pharmaceutical, medical device or medical intervention that maintains life by sustaining, restoring, or supplanting a vital function.” (ORS 127.505)
![Page 31: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Limitations on Rep’s Decision-making
• Convulsive treatment
• Psychosurgery
• Sterilization
• Abortion
• Withholding / withdrawing life support or tube feeding only if given this decisional ability or the principal is in one of the four conditions from Part C
![Page 32: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Oregon’s ANH Presumption
• If no advance directive, there is presumed consent for artificially administered nutrition and hydration (ANH) in the event someone is unable to take food orally and cannot/has not made medical decisions regarding ANH.
• Four conditions are exempt: – Terminal Condition (Close to Death) – Permanently Unconscious – Advanced Progressive Illness – State of Extraordinary Suffering
![Page 33: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Special Considerations in Oregon’s AD
• Designating a health care representative allows an individual to forgo ANH in circumstances beyond the four exempted conditions.
• Writing specific instructions allows an individual to limit (or possibly increase) treatment beyond the four default conditions on the AD.
![Page 34: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Oregon POLST (1991, 1995)
• Physician Orders for Life Sustaining Treatment
• Focuses on documenting individual wishes for specific medical interventions
• Intended to transfer from one care setting to another
![Page 35: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Oregon POLST Form
• Allows a physician (or PA or NP) to write medical orders which follow a patient: – Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation – Other Medical Interventions (mechanical vent,
other airway interventions, IV fluids, antibiotics, etc.)
– Artificially Administered Nutrition
• Appropriate for patients who are not expected to live longer than a year.
![Page 36: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Other Types of Directives?
• A validly executed advance directive from another state “may be given effect in accordance with its provisions, subject to the laws of this state.” (ORS 127.515)
![Page 37: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Advance Directive Use Today
![Page 38: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Prevalence of Advance Directives
• 88% of hospice patients have an AD
• 65% of nursing home residents have an AD
• 37% of the general public have an AD – (other studies range from 18-36%)
Jones et al., Use of Advance Directives in Long-term Care Populations, 54 NCHS Data Brief 1 (2011), available at www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db54.htm
![Page 39: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Factors Associated with AD Completion
• Older Age
• Greater Disease Burden
• White
• Higher Socioeconomic Status
• Long-standing Relationship with PCP
• Whether PCP has a Directive
• Patients with Cancer
Advance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Report to Congress. DHHS. August 2008.
![Page 40: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Effectiveness of ADs
• Study involving 3746 individuals over 60 years of age who died between 2000-2006 showed that patients who had completed an AD received care that was strongly associated with their wishes.
– Reduced hospitalizations
– Less likely to receive all care possible
– More likely to receive limited care
– More likely to receive comfort care
• Median time for directive completion was 19-20 months prior to death.
Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes of Surrogate Decision Making before Death, NEJM 362:12 (2010).
![Page 41: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Effectiveness of POLST
• Study involving 1711 individuals over 65 living in nursing homes in Oregon, Washington, and Virginia showed: – Those with a POLST were more likely to have
comprehensive life support orders in their chart,
– Those with a POLST were 50% less likely to receive unwanted life support than those without a POLST.
Hickman et al., A Comparison of Methods to Communicate Treatment Preferences in Nursing Facilities, JAGS 58:7 (2010).
![Page 42: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
POLST Admission Project at SHRB
![Page 43: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (2010)
• Originally included ability for physicians to receive Medicare reimbursement for advance care planning discussions with patients every five years.
• Rescinded after fear of “death panels” took root.
![Page 44: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
![Page 45: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Benefits and Harms of ADs
![Page 46: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Intended Ethical Benefits of ADs
• Respect individual autonomy (Expressed Wishes and Substituted Judgment) – Decisions made through an AD are intended to
have the same ethical standing as contemporaneous decisions.
• Clarify obligations of providers – Intended to help providers navigate between a
wide range of medical goals.
![Page 47: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Challenges to ADs
1. ADs don’t respect autonomy in practice.
2. ADs can’t respect autonomy in principle.
3. ADs rarely apply.
4. Ignoring ADs produces more benefit.
![Page 48: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
Challenge #1: ADs Don’t Respect Autonomy in Practice
ADs often fail a basic requirement of informed consent = having sufficient knowledge.
– individuals who fill out ADs lack sufficient knowledge about future disease state in order to make an informed choice. (Opacity Problem)
Hence, ADs often harm individuals because individuals are lulled into a false sense of self control which may or may not exist.
![Page 49: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Response to #1
• Seems to misunderstand the nature of deliberation. – The difference in knowledge between informed
consent for treatment and filling out an AD is a matter of degree as opposed to type.
– Opacity is a problem of degree for all types of decision-making.
![Page 50: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
Challenge #2: ADs Can’t Respect Autonomy in Principle
ADs in principle fail a basic requirement of informed consent = voluntary deliberation.
– Individuals who fill out ADs lack the future ability to deliberate over options.
– Tantamount to “indentured servitude” since the future patient is involuntarily bound to a contract.
Hence, ADs harm individuals because individuals are lulled into a false belief that self control can be achieved by an AD.
![Page 51: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
Responses to #2
• Comparing Proxies to “Masters” seems dis-analogous. – Proxies use substituted judgment to deliberate. – “Masters” use their own judgment. – Third parties are obligated to help preserve this
distinction (without being coercive).
• Would implicate many other future looking decisions which depend on others…
![Page 52: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Challenge #3: ADs Rarely Apply
Version A: Often irrelevant to the treatment plan since patients are rarely in one of the four conditions.
Version B: New treatments exist since time when AD was completed.
Hence, ADs fail to give provider clear guidance (and patients are subsequently harmed by false sense of self control)
![Page 53: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Responses to 3A and 3B
• Don’t put the cart before the horse…define the goal of medicine. – ADs need to be identified and integrated at
beginning of care plan.
– If proxy states patient would never want to live in long term nursing home, how does offering a trach or tube feeding help meet the goals of medicine?
![Page 54: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
Responses to 3A and 3B Continued
• POLST can address issues of AD application. – Focus on specific interventions as opposed to
general medical conditions.
• Reflective, thoughtful conversation with proxy
about whether new treatments align with patient goals is appropriate. (Substituted Judgment)
![Page 55: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
Challenge #4: Ignoring AD Provides Important Benefit
Current treatment provides important benefit for present interests of patient (and forgoing such benefit would be harmful).
– Patient’s current interest in receiving beneficial treatment should outweigh prior interests expressed in an AD.
– Radical variant: Current incapacitated patient is a different person from the one who completed the AD, so AD does not apply!
Dresser, R. Advance Directives, self determination, and personal identity. In Hackler, R. et al. Advance Directives in Medicine. Praeger: New York. 1989.
![Page 56: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
Typical Case
• Patient with advanced dementia who completed an advance directive a few years ago…should tube feeding commence?
• Prior Wishes vs. Present Welfare Problem
![Page 57: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Responses to #4
• Distinguish between critical interests and experiential interests. – Critical interests = derived from “self-chosen
values and goals that give overarching meaning to people’s lives, regardless of what sorts of experiences result from fulfilling them.”
– Experiential interests = derived from “carrying out certain activities just for the experience of doing so.”
Dworkin, R. Life’s Dominion. Knopf: New York. 1993.
![Page 58: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
Possible Benefits of Medical Interventions
• Medical (Physiological) • Psychological • Economic • Spiritual • Aesthetic • Legal • Familial • Social • Cultural
Adapted from Veatch, R. The Basics of Bioethics, (2nd Ed.), Prentice Hall: New York. 2003.
![Page 59: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
Qualitative vs. Quantitative Benefit
• Quantitative Benefit = measurable in terms of labs, physiological processes, numerical data, etc.
• Qualitative Benefit = measurable in terms of patient goals, quality of life, experiential moments, etc.
![Page 60: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Patient Wishes vs. Best Interest
• The ethical and legal presumption is that Patient Wishes (as expressed in an AD) take priority over Best Interest.
• Ignoring an AD based on Best Interest is an uphill endeavor…
![Page 61: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Best Interest Defined
• Decisions based on Best-Interest must: – Maximize long term benefits, minimize short term
burdens,
– Meet a minimum threshold of acceptable care (as understood by reasonable person standard)
– Align with other moral and legal duties to the individual.
Kopelman L. The Best Interest Standard for Incompetent or Incapacitated Persons of All Ages, JLME 58:7 (2007).
![Page 62: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
Other Important Considerations
• Consider date of AD completion.
• Following an AD ought not require inhumane treatment.
• Reflect on the meaning of “patient advocacy.” • Consider thoughts of all available family members
and friends.
![Page 63: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
Difficult Balance of Advance Care Planning
• Plan early enough so that enough distance exists, but not so late that fear of death (and death panels) is overwhelming.
![Page 64: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
A Patient Perceived Harm of Advance Care Planning
• “Physician/provider is attempting to ration health care to my detriment.”
– Is the directive being used from framework of
Expressed Wishes/Substituted Judgment or is it being used from framework of Best Interest?
![Page 65: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
Trust in Advance Care Planning
• Trust is a four-part relation…
• Patient W trusts Person X to do Action Y in Circumstance Z.
• “While seeing the physician in the hospital for the first time (Z), the patient (W) trusts the physician (X) to complete a POLST in a manner that reflects the patient’s sense of benefit and doesn’t attempt to ration health care (Y).”
![Page 66: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
Thank You
![Page 67: Advance Care Directives: Do They Help or Do They Harm?...• Median time for directive completion was 19- 20 months prior to death. Silveira et al., Advance Directives and Outcomes](https://reader036.vdocument.in/reader036/viewer/2022062403/60fa3567920f1a1e215da218/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
Other References
• Cohen, C. Philosophical Challenges to the Use of Advance Directives, in Kushf ,G. et al. Handbook of Bioethics. Kluwer: Netherlands. 2004.
• The Limited Wisdom of Advance Directives, in Taking Care: Ethical Care Giving in Our Aging Society. President’s Council on Bioethics. 2005.