advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

24
ADVANCED CFD MODELING ELECTRONICS COOLING DESIGN OPTIONS FOR AIR MANAGEMENT Don Blanchet 3B Associates 02/01/2016

Upload: don-blanchet

Post on 14-Apr-2017

408 views

Category:

Engineering


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

ADVANCED CFD

MODELING

ELECTR

ONICS COOLING DESI

GN OPTIONS F

OR AIR MANAGEMENT

Don Blanchet3B Associates02/01/2016

Page 2: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

MODEL – VME CARD HIGH POWER PMC STUDY

Processor (s)Heat sink

Air flow

30 watts

Total board Power = 130 watts

OptionalHeat spreader/

StiffenerPMC position #2

PMC position #1

Page 3: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

DUAL PMC CONFIGURATION WITH BASELINE HEAT SINK

Page 4: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

DETAIL – HIGH DENSITY MEMORY DAUGHTER CARD

FPGA

Memoryassembly

Page 5: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

BASELINE ALUMINUM HEAT SINK DESIGN

Page 6: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

ALUMINUM HEAT SINK DESIGN – BOTTOM VIEW

Page 7: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

ENHANCED HEAT SINK DESIGN - COPPER

Page 8: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

ENHANCED HEAT SINK DESIGN COPPER – BOTTOM VIEW

Page 9: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

DETAIL OF – PWB REMOVED – WITH HEAT SINK

FPGAFPGA

Baseline Heat sink

Page 10: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

MECHANICAL DESIGN HEAT PIPE IMPLEMENTATION

Heatspreaders

Heat Pipes

ProcessorHeat sink

Page 11: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

HEAT PIPE ENHANCED DESIGN

Main ProcessorHeat sink

Heat Pipes integrated with mainProcessor heat sink

FPGA

Page 12: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

HEAT PIPE ENHANCED DESIGN – PMC PWB REMOVED

FPGA

Heat Pipes

Page 13: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

HEAT PIPE ENHANCED DESIGN – PMC PWB REMOVED

FPGA

FPGA

Spreader

Page 14: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

RESULTS – WITH BASELINE ALUMINUM HEAT SINK

Tj =85 C40 C

ProcessorsTj =78 C

Air flow

Page 15: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

RESULTS – WITH BASELINE ALUMINUM HEAT SINK – MEMORY ARRAY

ProcessorsTj =78 C40 C

Page 16: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

RESULTS – WITH ENHANCED COPPER HEAT SINK

40 CTj =80 C

Page 17: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

RESULTS – WITH HEAT PIPES & SPREADER

Tj =78 C

40 C

Page 18: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

RESULTS – BASELINE HEAT SINK DUAL PMC CONFIGURATION

40 CTj =85 C Tj =112 C Processors

Tj =92 C

Page 19: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

RESULTS – BASELINE HEAT SINK DUAL HIGH POWER PMC CONFIGURATION

40 CTj =90 C Tj =117 C Processors

Tj =93 C

Page 20: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

RESULTS – BASELINE HEAT SINK DUAL PMC CONFIGURATION MAX POWER = 22W PER PMC

40 CTj =78 C Tj =98 C

Page 21: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

ENHANCED COPPER HEAT SINK DESIGN

Page 22: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

BASELINE VS. ENHANCED HEAT SINK

Page 23: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

BASELINE ALUMINUM VS. ENHANCED COPPER @ 25W EACH

Slot module air flow 20CFM 40C @ 10K feet

Tj =108 Tj =95

Page 24: Advanced cfd electronics cooling analyis

CFD TOOL – ORIGIN U.K.The tool used has been customized for electronics cooling

applications over 20+ years.

Unfortunately it is lease only and VERY expensive $$$$$$$.

Looking forward to cloud rental options being more economical. ??