against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 an application of...

91
!"#$%&'(") +,-. /012 3$,'%4$ 5'%4$5$. 4,"6%&7 088/92: 54 ;(&$5(- <,-<5-"%4$ =< $>% &%?,5&%"%4$# <=& $>% '%@&%% =< !"#$%& () *+,%-+% ,- .--(/"$,(- !"-"0%1%-$ A5&#$ #,;%&B5#=&7 '&C 5&C (&D>C ECFCFC+C G%."%4 3%D=4' #,;%&B5#=&7 '&C HC3C I='=.45$#.4( J=";(4. #,;%&B5#=&7 K&#C LC B(4 !-$%&%4 I,6-5#>54@ '($%7 11 $> =< +,-. /012 M45B%&#5$.7 N54'>=B%4 M45B%&#5$. =< O%D>4=-=@. A(D,-$.7 E4',#$&5(- N4@54%%&54@ P E44=B($5=4 3D5%4D%# K%;(&$"%4$7 E44=B($5=4) O%D>4=-=@.) N4$&%;&%4%,&#>5; (4' F(&Q%$54@ REONFS Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of open business model innovation to create and appropriate synergy in a sustainable business context 6. FC+C!C RF5D>5%-S B(4 !&'%44%

Upload: others

Post on 12-Mar-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* ************************

3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:***

*54*;(&$5(-*<,-<5-"%4$*=<*$>%*&%?,5&%"%4$#*<=&*$>%*'%@&%%*=<*

*!"#$%&'()'*+,%-+%'

,-'.--(/"$,(-'!"-"0%1%-$**

********

A5&#$*#,;%&B5#=&7* * '&C*5&C*(&D>C*ECFCFC+C*G%."%4*3%D=4'*#,;%&B5#=&7* * '&C*HC3C*I='=.45$#.4(*J=";(4.*#,;%&B5#=&7* K&#C*LC*B(4*!-$%&%4*I,6-5#>54@*'($%7* * 11$>*=<*+,-.*/012*M45B%&#5$.7* * * N54'>=B%4*M45B%&#5$.*=<*O%D>4=-=@.*A(D,-$.7* * * E4',#$&5(-*N4@54%%&54@*P*E44=B($5=4*3D5%4D%#*K%;(&$"%4$7* * * E44=B($5=4)*O%D>4=-=@.)*N4$&%;&%4%,&#>5;*(4'*F(&Q%$54@*

* * REONFS*

Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5

An application of open business model innovation to create and appropriate synergy

in a sustainable business context *

6.*FC+C!C*RF5D>5%-S*B(4*!&'%44%*

Page 2: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /*

***

!

!************

Page 3: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 2*

"#$%&!.2345666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'7*8.*9':;';.<=>4*6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'?*8.*9':;'9@A84*'66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'?*B6'.29>:3=C9.:2'6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'D*1C1*GN3N!GJT*UMN3OEVW*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*9*!"#$%&'%()$*#"$+#*%#*,)*-%..............................................................................................................................................%/*!"#$%0'%1"2*3"4"562*2%......................................................................................................................................................%7*!"#$%8'%9*2):4%;"2*%..........................................................................................................................................................%7*

1C/*JVWOGEXMOEVW*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*10*E6'*F24><F'.2':G42'A=*.24**'!:348*H'8.94>@9=>4'>4I.4J'6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'BB*/C1*VINW*EWWVY!OEVWCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*11*0.&.&%1<4;*=$+"5)>"$)<4%...............................................................................................................................................%&&*0.&.0%?4@<+4A%,*#2+2%<+$@<+4A%)44<,"$)<4%........................................................................................................%&&*0.&.8%BA,"4$":*2%"4A%A)2"A,"4$":*2%....................................................................................................................%&0*0.&.C%1<4;5+2)<4%..............................................................................................................................................................%&C*

/C/*XM3EWN33*FVKNZ*EWWVY!OEVW*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*1[*0.0.&%DE*%;<4;*=$%<F%@+2)4*22%G<A*52%....................................................................................................................%&H*0.0.0%DE*%;<4;*=$%<F%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%)44<,"$)<4%..............................................................................................%&I*0.0.8%J+2)4*22%G<A*5%F#"G*-<#K2%...........................................................................................................................%&I*0.0.C%DE*%=#<;*22%<F%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%)44<,"$)<4...............................................................................................%&L*0.0.H%M<5*%<F%$E*%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%)4%<=*4%)44<,"$)<4......................................................................................%&/*0.0.I%1<4;5+2)<4%..............................................................................................................................................................%&7*

/C2*3LWNG\L*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*/0*0.8.&%DE*%;<4;*=$%<F%264*#:6%.....................................................................................................................................%0N*0.8.0%O64*#:6%;#*"$)<4%..................................................................................................................................................%0I*0.8.8%DE*%A"#K%2)A*%<F%264*#:6%..................................................................................................................................%0/*0.8.C%1<4;5+2)<4%..............................................................................................................................................................%07*

/C]*OTNVGNOEJ!Z*AG!FN^VGH*!WK*OTNVGL_X!3NK*IGEWJEIZN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*/:*0.C.&%1+2$<G*#%264*#:)*2%............................................................................................................................................%8&*0.C.0%P=*#"$)<4"5%264*#:)*2%.......................................................................................................................................%8&*0.C.8%Q)4"4;)"5%264*#:)*2%.............................................................................................................................................%8&*0.C.C%R"4":*G*4$%264*#:)*2%.....................................................................................................................................%8&*0.C.H%S4<-5*A:*%G"4":*G*4$%264*#:)*2%............................................................................................................%80*0.C.I%Q)#G%264*#:6%..........................................................................................................................................................%80*

76'!49K:3:8:<F'66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'77*2C1*GN3N!GJT*KN3E\W*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*22*2C/*3L3ONF!OEJ*ZEONG!OMGN*GNYEN^*!WK*GNYEN^*3LWOTN3E37*OTNVGL_X!3NK*IGEWJEIZN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*2`*2C2*J!3N*!W!ZL3E37*IG!JOEJN_X!3NK*IGEWJEIZN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*2`*2C]*K!O!*JVZZNJOEVW*!WK*!W!ZL3E3*AVG*OTN*KN3E\W*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*28*2C[*Y!ZEKEOL*!WK*GNZE!XEZEOL*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*28*8.H.&%1<42$#+;$%,"5)A)$6%................................................................................................................................................%8/*8.H.0%?4$*#4"5%,"5)A)$6%...................................................................................................................................................%8/*8.H.8%TU$*#4"5%,"5)A)$6%..................................................................................................................................................%8/*8.H.C%M*5)"@)5)$6%................................................................................................................................................................%8/*

L6'*F24><F'.2':G42'A=*.24**'!:348*H'.2*.<K9*';>:!'G>@C9.C4'6666666666666666666666666666666666666'7M*]C1*OTN*J!3N*3OMKEN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*2:*]C/*!W!ZL3E3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*2:*

Page 4: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]*

]C2*IG!JOEJN_X!3NK*IGEWJEIZN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*]2*C.8.&%P=*#"$)<4"5%264*#:6...........................................................................................................................................%C8*C.8.0%R"4":*G*4$%264*#:6%........................................................................................................................................%C8*C.8.8%S4<-5*A:*%G"4":*G*4$%264*#:6%...............................................................................................................%C8*C.8.C%1+2$<G*#%264*#:6%................................................................................................................................................%C8*

]C]*JVFI!GE3VW*VA*KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*]]*?6'34*.<2'666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'L?*[C1*JZMX*Y!W*20*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*][*H.&.&%18N%!#<V*;$%J+#*"+%............................................................................................................................................%CH*H.&.0%18N%W*$-<#K%..........................................................................................................................................................%CI*H.&.8%18N%R*A)"%...............................................................................................................................................................%CI*

[C/*IGVXZNF*FN33*!WK*VX+NJOEYN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*]`*[C2*KN3E\W*GNUMEGNFNWO3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*]9*[C]*KN3E\W*3VZMOEVW*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*]:*H.C.&%R"==)4:%$E*%<=*4%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%F<#%264*#:6......................................................................................%C7*H.C.0%S*6%="#$4*#2%..........................................................................................................................................................%H0*H.C.8%S*6%#*2<+#;*2%"4A%";$),)$)*2%...........................................................................................................................%H0*H.C.C%1E"44*52X%;+2$<G*#%2*:G*4$2%Y%#*5"$)<42E)=2%......................................................................................%H8*H.C.H%Z"5+*%=#<=<2)$)<4%................................................................................................................................................%H8*H.C.I%M*,*4+*%2$#*"G2%"4A%;<2$%2$#+;$+#*%..........................................................................................................%H8*H.C.L%9*2):4%=#)4;)=5*2%#*F5*;$)4:%"55%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%;<G=<4*4$2%..........................................................%HC*

N6'3.*C=**.:2'@23'C:2C8=*.:2'6666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'??*`C1*AEWKEW\3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*[[*`C/*GNAZNJOEW\*VW*OTN*AEWKEW\3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*[`*`C2*JVWOGEXMOEVW3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*[8*`C]*F!W!\NGE!Z*EFIZEJ!OEVW3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*[9*`C[*ZEFEO!OEVW3*!WK*GNJVFFNWK!OEVW3*AVG*AMOMGN*GN3N!GJT*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*[9*

>4;4>42C4*'666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'NO*IMXZEJ!OEVW3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*̀ 0*VWZEWN*GN3VMGJN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*̀ ]*

@GG423.C4*'666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'N?*!IINWKEa*E* *XM3EWN33*FVKNZ*J!WY!3*XMEZKEW\*XZVJH3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*̀ [*!IINWKEa*EE* *NaINGEFNWO!OEVW)*NAANJOM!OEVW*!WK*ZN!KNG3TEI*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*̀ [*!IINWKEa*EEE* *3LWNG\L*OLIVZV\EN3*!WK*KNGEYNK*KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*̀ 8*!IINWKEa*EY* *3LWNG\L*XE!3N3*RX!3NK*VW*\VVZK*!WK*J!FIXNZZ)*1::9S*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*80*!IINWKEa*Y* *JEFV*ZV\EJ*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*81*!IINWKEa*YE* *ZEONG!OMGN*3N!GJT*3OG!ON\L*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*8/*!IINWKEa*YEE* *JVKEW\*3JTNFN*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*82*!IINWKEa*YEEE* *XM3EWN33*FVKNZ*J!WY!3*VA*J20*IGV+NJO*XMGN!MCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*8]*!IINWKEa*Ea* *KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3*!WK*XMEZKEW\*XZVJH3bI!G!FNONG3*!GG!W\NK*XL*3LWNG\L*OLIN*CC*8[*!IINWKEa*a* *XM3EWN33*FVKNZ*J!WY!3*J20*XM3EWN33*KNYNZVIFNWO*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*89*

!@2@<4!429'*=!!@>F666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'PO**=!!@>F'Q3=9CKR'66666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666666'PP*

Page 5: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [*

8.*9':;';.<=>4*''AE\MGN*1*_*XM3EWN33*FVKNZ*J!WY!3*C*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*18*AE\MGN*/*_*!KKNK*Y!ZMN*VA*VINW*XM3EWN33*FVKNZ3**CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*1:*AE\MGN*2*_*JGV33_XM3EWN33*3LWNG\EN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*/]*AE\MGN*]*_*OTNVGNOEJ!Z*AG!FN^VGH*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*20*AE\MGN*[*_*OTN*OTN3E3c3*KN3E\W*3JENWJN*!IIGV!JT*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*2]*AE\MGN*8*_*GNAZNJOEYN*JLJZNCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*2[*AE\MGN*9*_*3NGYEJN*VA*J20*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*][*AE\MGN*:* *VINW*XM3EWN33*FVKNZ*J!WY!3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*[1*AE\MGN*10*_*OTNVGNOEJ!Z*AG!FN^VGH*VA*OTE3*OTN3E3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*9/*AE\MGN*11*_*KN3E\W*3VZMOEVW*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*9]**8.*9':;'9@A84*'O!XZN*1*_*KEAANGNWO*AVGF3*VA*VINWWN33*C*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*1/*O!XZN*/*_*!KY!WO!\N3*!WK*KE3!KY!WO!\N3*VA*VINW*EWWVY!OEVW*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*1]*O!XZN*2*_*KNAEWEOEVW3*VA*XM3EWN33*FVKNZ3*!O*OTN*\NWNG!Z*ZNYNZ*C*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*1[*O!XZN*]*_*3LWNG\L*OLIVZV\EN3*!GG!W\NK*ING*LN!G*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*/1*O!XZN*[*_*KEAANGNWJN3*XNO^NNW*NAAEJENWJL_*!WK*\GV^OT*3LWNG\EN3*C*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*/[*O!XZN*`*_*3LWNG\L*OLIVZV\L*VA*OTE3*OTN3E3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*/`*O!XZN*8*_*KN3JGEIOEYN*YNG3M3*IGN3JGEIOEYN*GN3N!GJT*IGV\G!FFN3*C*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*22*O!XZN*9*_*EWONGYEN^NN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*28*O!XZN*:*_*J!3N*3OMKEN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*2:*O!XZN*10*_*VINW*EWWVY!OEVW*EWEOE!OEYN3*!WK*VMOJVFN3*JVKEW\*3JTNFN*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*]1*O!XZN*11*_*3LWNG\L*OLIVZV\EN3*!WK*IGEWJEIZN3*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*̀ 8*O!XZN*1/*_*JEFV*ZV\EJ*KNAEWNK*C*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*81*O!XZN*12*_*KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3*!WK*I!G!FNONG3* *JM3OVFNG*3LWNG\L*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*8[*O!XZN*1]*_*KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3*!WK*I!G!FNONG3* *VING!OEVW!Z*3LWNG\LCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*8[*O!XZN*1[*_*KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3*!WK*I!G!FNONG3* *AEW!WJE!Z*3LWNG\L*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*8`*O!XZN*1`*_*KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3*!WK*I!G!FNONG3*_*F!W!\NFNWO*3LWNG\L*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*8`*O!XZN*18*_*KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3*!WK*I!G!FNONG3*_*HWV^ZNK\N*F!W!\NFNWO*3LWNG\LCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*88*O!XZN*19*_*KN3E\W*IGEWJEIZN3*!WK*I!G!FNONG3*_*AEGF*3LWNG\L*CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC*88*

Page 6: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `*

Page 7: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 8*

'(!"#)*+$,-).+#!

#>=d#* $>%* 5";=&$(4D%* =<* 544=B($5=47* D=";(45%#* 4%%'* $=* 544=B($%* 54* $>%5&* #$&,@@-%* $=*#,&B5B%* (4'* #%(&D>* <=&* D=";%$5$5B%* ('B(4$(@%* RO5''* %$* (-C)* /00[e* I=&$%&)* 1:9[SC*F%(4d>5-%)* $>%*D=4'5$5=4#*$>%.*(&%* <(D54@*(&%* D>(4@54@*&(;5'-.*(4'*&('5D(--.*RX(-'d54*(4'*Y=4*T5;;%-)*/011SC*O>%*5";=&$(4D%*6%54@*%B5'%4$)*$>%*<5&#$*;(&$*=<*$>%*?,=$%*#>=d#*$>%* '5<<5D,-$.* =<* 544=B($54@* <=&* "=#$* <5&"#C* NB%4* <5&"#* ($=;* =<* $>%5&* 54',#$&5%#* <(5-* $=*544 *R1::8SC***G%D%4$*&%#%(&D>*=4*$>5#*'5-%""(*<=D,#%#*=4*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*<=*4%)44<,"$)<4X%(#*#>=d4*54*$>%* &%B5%d*=<*K(>-(4'%&* (4'*\(44* R/010SC* 3$(&$54@* ;=54$* <=&* $>5#* 5'%(* 5#* $>($* (* #54@-%*=&@(45f($5=4*D(44=$*544=B($%*54*5#=-($5=4C*N4@(@%"%4$*d5$>*'5<<%&%4$*$.;%#*=<*;(&$5%#*5#*4%D%##(&.*$=*>(B%*(DD%##*$=*4%d*5'%(#*=&*&%#=,&D%#*RK(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC*G%%'*%$*(-C*R/01/S*<54'*$>($*=;%44%##*$=*$>%#%*4%d*5'%(#*<&="*$>%*%4B5&=4"%4$*5";&=544=B($5B%* ;%&<=&"(4D%7*"=&%* (4'*"=&%* <5&"#* <54'* B(-,%* 6.* $(;;54@* 54$=* $>%* 5'%(#* =<*=;%4* 544=B($5=4C*J>%#6&=,@>* R/008S*;,$#* 5$*'5<<%&%4$-.*(4'*'%#D&56%#* $>($)* 54*=&'%&* $=*@%$* $>%*"=#$*=,$*=<*=;%4* 544=B($5=4)* D=";(45%#*"=#$*=;%4* $>%5&* @+2)4*22%G<A*52%$=*6%*"=&%* %<<%D$5B%* 54* D&%($54@* (#* d%--* (#* D(;$,&54@* B(-,%C* 3=)* (#* '%#D&56%'* 6.* G%%'* %$* (-C*R/01/S* (4'* 54* %B%4*"=&%* '%$(5-* 6.* J>%#6&=,@>* R/008S)* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* 5#* (*"%(4* $=*

%##*"='%-*RD<C*J>%#6&=,@>)*/008e*V#$%&d(-'%&*(4'*I5@4%,&*/010SC***!#*;=54$%'*=,$*6.*G%%'*%$*(-C* R/01/S)* $>%&%* 5#* (* $&('%_=<<*6%$d%%4*$>%*6%4%<5$#*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4* (4'* $>%* 6%4%<5$#* =<* 54$%&4(--.* @%4%&($%'* 544=B($5=4C* !--* ;(&$5%#* 54B=-B%'*#>=,-'* 6%4%<5$* <&="*=;%4* 544=B($5=4)* =$>%&d5#%* $>%* &5#Q#* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=4)* 4("%-.)*D==&'54($5=4* D=#$#)* &%"=B%'*6(&&5%&#* $=*4%d*D=";%$5$5=4*(4'* -=##*=<* 544=B($5=4* #Q5--#*RN4Q%-*%$*(-C)*/00:S*D=,-'*6%$$%&*6%*(B=5'%'C*O=*;,$*5$*'5<<%&%4$-.)*$>%*B(-,%*D(;$,&%'*(4'*D&%($%'*6.*<5&"#*=;%454@*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-*#>=,-'*4($,&(--.*6%*>5@>%&*$>(4*$>%*#,"*=<* $>%*B(-,%*6=$>*;(&$5%#* D=,-'*>(B%*D&%($%'* 54* 5#=-($5=4C* 3$* +=>4*(4'*T(&&5#=4* R1:::S*'%#D&56%* $>5#*;>%4="%4=4*=<* $d=* <5&"#*6%54@*"=&%*;&=<5$(6-%*=&* D=";%$5$5B%* $=@%$>%&*$>(4*$>%*(@@&%@($%*=<*$>%5&*;&=<5$(65-5$.*d>%4*$>%.*d= C***3=)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*#$&5B%*<=&*#.4%&@.*6.*=;%454@*,;*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-*(4'*D="654%*5$*d5$>*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-#*=<*=$>%&*<5&"#C*T=d%B%&)*d>%4*"(Q54@*$>%*$&(4#5$5=4*<&="*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-#*=<*$d=*<5&"#*$=d(&'#*(*4%d*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-)*<5&"#*",#$*<5@,&%*=,$*

G"4":)4:% $E*% *U)2$*4;*% <F% "% 4*-%RJ>%#6&=,@>)* /008)* ;C* /8SC*

!-$>=,@>*=B%&D="%)*#$5--)* -5Q%*'%#D&56%'*6.*$>%*#("%*(,$>=&* <=,&*.%(&#*%(&-5%&)*"=#$* 544=B($5=4#*<(5-C* NB%4* <=&* $>%* #,DD%##* D(#%#* J>%#6&=,@>* R/008S* '%#D&56%#)* $>%* g=,&4%.* $=d(&'#*#,DD%##<,-*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*(--*6%@(4*d5$>*(*#>=DQ*=&*D>(--%4@%*=<*$>%*#$($,#*?,=C*E4*(''5$5=4)*Z5D>$%4$(-%&*R/009S*"%4$5=4#*$>($*"(4.*<5&"#*%h;%&5%4D%*#%B%&%*D>(--%4@%#*54*"(4(@54@* $>%* %4$5&%* ;&=D%##* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=4)* d>5D>* 54D-,'%#* $>%* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-C*A=&*D=";(45%#*$>($*(&%*d5--54@*$=*=;%4*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#)*5$*5#*5";=&$(4$*$=*Q4=d*>=d*$=*'%(-*d5$>*$>%#%*D>(--%4@%#*(4'*>=d*$>%.*D(4*D&%($%*$>%*#.4%&@.*4%%'%'*$=*6%D="%*$>%*#"(--*@&=,;*=<*544=B($=&#*$>($*'=%#*4=$*<(5-)*4=&*'5%C**

Page 8: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 9*

'('!/%0%1*-2!3,%0).+#!!!#*#$($%')*54*$>%*B5%d*=<*$>%*=;%4*544=B($5=4*;(&('5@"*<5&"#*#>=,-'*=;%4*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-*54*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*(4'*D(;$,&%*B(-,%C*!-$>=,@>*"(4.*#D>=-(&#*'5#D,##*$>%*6%4%<5$#*=<*=;%4* 544=B($5=4)* <%d%&* <=D,#* $>%5&* &%#%(&D>*=4*=;%4* @+2)4*22%G<A*5%544=B($5=4%R#%%*J>%#6&=,@>)* /008SC* A,&$>%&"=&%)* (-$>=,@>* #D>=-(&#* "%4$5=4* $>%* 6%4%<5$#* =<* =;%4*544=B($5=4*(4'*#="%$5"%#*5";-5D5$-.*"%4$5=4*(*#,&;-,#*54*B(-,%*<=&*6=$>*;(&$5%#)*$=*$>%*6%#$*=<*".*Q4=d-%'@%*4=*#D>=-(&*>(B%*-54Q%'*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*%h;-5D5$-.*$=* $>%*'5<<%&%4$* $.;%#*=<* #.4%&@.*(;;%(&54@* 54* -5$%&($,&%C*!-$>=,@>*#="%*#D>=-(&#*>(B%*#$,'5%#* $>%* -54Q(@%#* 6%$d%%4* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* (4'* <5&"* B(-,%* R%C@C* \&5";%* (4'* 3=<Q()*/00:S)*-5$%&($,&%*=4*(D>5%B54@*<5&"*#.4%&@.*B5(*$>%*"%D>(45#"*=<*(4*<=*4%@+2)4*22%G<A*5*&%"(54#*(6#%4$)*=&*($* -%(#$*#D(&D%C*O>%&%<=&%)* $>5#* $>%#5#*d5--*'5B%* 54$=* $>5#* $=;5D* $=*#%%*>=d*#.4%&@.*D(4*6%*D&%($%'*<=&*$>=#%*<5&"#*=;%454@*,;*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#*R5C%C*>=d*D(4* $d=* <5&"#* D&%($%* (4'* D(;$,&%* >5@>%&* B(-,%#* $=@%$>%&* $>(4* $>%.* D=,-'* >(B%* '=4%*#%;(&($%-.SC*E4*'=54@*#=)*$>%*<=--=d54@*&%#%(&D>*?,%#$5=4*d5--*6%*(4#d%&%'7*

!

%54*$>5#*#$,'.*&%<%&#*$=*6=$>*#.4%&@5%#*-)$E)4)*(#*d%--*(#*@*$-**4*<5&"#)*#54D%* B(-,%* D&%($5=4* $>&=,@>*=;%4* 544=B($5=4* D(4* &%#,-$* <&="* $>%* @%4%&($5=4* =<* )4$*#_<5&"*#.4%&@5%#)*d>5D>* 54*"(4.*D(#%#*>(#* $>%*;=$%4$5(-* $=* #5",-$(4%=,#-.*,4-=DQ* )4$#"_<5&"* #.4%&@5%#* R3"5$#* %$* (-C)* /01/SC* O=* D(;$,&%* (--* B(-,%* @%4%&($%'* 6.* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)*$>5#*$>%#5#*d5--*<=D,#*=4*$>%*$=$(-*#,"*=<*B(-,%*@%4%&($%')*&%@(&'-%##*=<*$>%* <(D$* $>($* 5$* 5#* 54$%&_<5&"* #.4%&@.* =&* #5",-$(4%=,#-.* ,4-=DQ%'* 54$&(_<5&"* #.4%&@.C*!-$>=,@>*"(4.* $.;=-=@5%#* <=,4'* 54* -5$%&($,&%* '=* 4=$*"%4$5=4* $>%* '5#$54D$5=4* 54* 54$%&_*(4'* 54$&(_<5&"* #.4%&@.)* $>%* '5B5#5=4* D=,-'* >(B%* 6=$>* #D>=-(&-.* (4'* "(4(@%&5(-*5";-5D($5=4#C*O>%*'5#D,##5=4*#%##5=4*d5--*%-(6=&($%*=4*$>5#*$=;5DC**O=*(4#d%&*$>%*"(54*&%#%(&D>*?,%#$5=4)*$>5#*$>%#5#*d5--*D=4#5#$*=<*$>&%%*;(&$#7*(*-5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d* $=* '%&5B%* $>%=&._6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#)* $%4* D(#%_(4(-.#%#* $=* '%&5B%* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#*(4'*<54(--.*(*'%#5@4*D(#%*<=&*(;;-.54@*$>%*;&54D5;-%#*R5CDC*J-,6*B(4*20*XCYCSC*

41*)!'5!6.)%*1),*%!*%7.%8!O>%*<5&#$*;(&$*=<*$>%*$>%#5#*RD>(;$%&*/S*5#*(*&%<-%D$5=4*=<*$>%*D,&&%4$*#$($%*=<*-5$%&($,&%*=4*=;%4* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4* (4'* <5&"* #.4%&@.C* O>5#* ;(&$* d5--* (4#d%&* $d=* #,6_?,%#$5=4#)*4("%-.7**

"#$%&#'()*+,!-.!/01)!*(!+2',!$#(*,'((!3+4'5!*,,+61)*+,7!

O>5#*?,%#$5=4*%-(6=&($%#*=4*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4)*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*(4'*$>%*D&%($5=4*=<*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4C*F=&%*#;%D5<5D(--.)*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*(#*'%#D&56%'*6.*J>%#6&=,@>* R/008S*d5--*6%*%-(6=&($%'*,;=4)* #54D%* <5&"#*>(B%* $=*=;%4*(4'*D="654%*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#* 54*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*(4'*D(;$,&%*B(-,%C*Z5$%&($,&%*=4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*(4'*<=*4* 6,#54%##*"='%-#* D=";-%"%4$#* &($>%&* $>(4* #,6#$5$,$%#*%(D>*=$>%&)*#54D%* 54*=&'%&*$=*,4'%&#$(4'*>=d*$=*D(;$,&%*#.4%&@.*d5$>*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)* 5$* 5#*%##%4$5(-* $=*,4'%&#$(4'*>=d*$=*D(;$,&%*B(-,%*d5$>*6,#54%##*"='%-#C*

"#$%&#'()*+,!8.!/01)!4+'(!)0'!9+,9'2)!+:!(;,'<=;!*,!1!$#(*,'((!9+,)'>)!',)1*57!

Page 9: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* :*

O>5#*#,6_?,%#$5=4*D-(&5<5%#*$>%*D=4D%;$*(4'*D&%($5=4*=<*<5&"*#.4%&@.C*3.4%&@.)*(#*d%--*(#*B(-,%)*5#*(*&($>%&*(6#$&(D$*D=4D%;$C*O>%&%<=&%)*$>5#*;(&$*=<*$>%*$>%#5#*d5--*'%<54%*#.4%&@.)*'%B%-=;#* (* $.;=-=@.* <=--=d54@* <&="* -5$%&($,&%* (4'* '%#D&56%#* >=d* #.4%&@.* D(4* 6%*(D>5%B%'C*

41*)!95!:10%;1#1<=0%0!O>%* #%D=4'* ;(&$* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#* RD>(;$%&* ]S* d5--* <=D,#* =4* $%4* D(#%* #$,'5%#* 54* =&'%&* $=*(4#d%&*#,6_?,%#$5=4*2*6.*'%&5B54@*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#7*

"#$%&#'()*+,!?.!/01)!1<'!)0'!5'((+,(!5'1<,'4!:<+3!+2',!$#(*,'((!3+4'5!*,*)*1)*6'(!*,!2<19)*9'7!!

41*)!>5!?%0.@#!-10%!A=--=d54@* <&="* $>%* (4#d%&#* =4* #,6_?,%#$5=4#* 1* (4'* /)* (* D=4D%;$,(-* <&("%d=&Q* 5#*'%B%-=;%'* (4'* $>%=&%$5D(--.* @&=,4'%'* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* d5--* 6%* <=&",-($%'C* O=@%$>%&*d5$>* ;&(D$5D(--.* @&=,4'%'* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* R$>%* (4#d%&* =4* #,6_?,%#$5=4* 2S)* $>%#%*;&54D5;-%#*d5--*6%*,#%'*$=*'%#5@4*(*#=-,$5=4*RD>(;$%&*[S*<=&*(*#;%D5<5D*D(#%*=4*$>%*5##,%*=<*>=d*$=*%#$(6-5#>*#.4%&@5%#*B5(*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*54*(*;(&$5D,-(&*D=4$%h$)*54*$>5#*D(#%*54*(*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##*D=4$%h$C**

;%&<=&"(4D%)* $=d(&'#* $>%* &%D=4D5-5($5=4* =<* %D=4="5D)* #=D5(-* (4'* %4B5&=4"%4$(-*;%&<=&"(4D%* RN-Q54@$=4)*1::9SC*W=d('(.#)*"=&%*(4'*"=&%* <5&"#*;&=(D$5B%-.* 54$%@&($%*%4B5&=4"%4$(-* D=4#5'%&($5=4#* 54* $>%5&* 6,#54%##* #$&($%@5%#* R3>(&"(* (4'* T%4&5?,%#)*

E",*% )4,*2$*A% 2):4)F);"4$% #*2<+#;*2%"4A%*FF<#$2% )4% $E*%)4$*:#"$)<4%<F%2+2$")4"@)5)$6%)22+*2%)4$<%$E*)#%@+2)4*22%G<A*52%F)4A%)$%)4;#*"2)4:56%A)FF);+5$%$<%G"4":*%$E*%5*"#4)4:%"4A%;E"4:*%=#<;*22*2%4*;*22"#6%$<%$";K5*%$E*%;E"55*4:*(-C)*/011)*;C*:]/SC*V;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*D=,-'*;%&>(;#*>%-;*=B%&D="%*$>%#%*D>(--%4@%#)* #54D%* (DD%##* $=* Q4=d-%'@%* (4'* &%#=,&D%#* =<* =$>%&* ;(&$5%#* D=,-'* 4=$* =4-.*

)44<,"$),**;%&<=&"(4D%*RD<C*G%%'*%$*(-C)*/01/S)*6,$*(-#=*$>%*&%D=4D5-5($5=4*=<*$>%5&**;<4<G);)*2<;)"5*(4'**4,)#<4G*4$"5*;%&<=&"(4D%*RD<C*N-Q54@$=4)*1::9SC**A=--=d54@*<&="*$>5#)* $>%*'%#5@4* D(#%*D(4*6%* 54$&=',D%'7*J-,6*B(4*20*XCYC*R<&="*>%&%=4*

_%4B5&=4"%4$C*T(4'#_=4*#,#$(54(65-5$.*&

#%*D>(--%4@%#*$>($* <5&"#*<(D%)* 5#* $=*#$(&$*(*;&=g%D$*6,&%(,*$=*'%B%-=;*#,#$(54(6-%* #=-,$5=4#*$>($*D(4*6%*5";-%"%4$%'*54* C*E4*'=54@*#=)*J20*D&%($%#*<(B=,&(6-%*6,#54%##*"='%-#*(4'*4%d*=;;=&$,45$5%#*<=&*<5&"#1C*354D%*#,#$(54(65-5$.*5#*(*6&=('*$=;5D)*Q4=d-%'@%* 5#* '5#;%&#%'* (4'* 4=* #54@-%* =&@(45f($5=4* >(#* (--* 4%D%##(&.* Q4=d-%'@%* 54_>=,#%C* 3=)* J20* D-=#%-.* D=--(6=&($%#* d5$>* D,#$="%&#)* #,;;-5%&#)* =&* =$>%&* ;(&$5%#)* d>5-%*%h%D,$54@* $>%5&* ;&=g%D$#C* K,&54@* $>5#* D-=#%* D=--(6=&($5=4)* 5$* (;;%(&#* $=* $>%* ;&=g%D$*"(4(@%"%4$*$%("*$>($*#="%*=<*$>%*"=&%* B(-,%* <=&* 6=$>* <5&"#* $>(4* (4$5D5;($%'* d>%4* 6=$>* <5&"#* g=54* $>%5&* #$&%4@$>#* <=&*<,$,&%*(D$5B5$5%# 5$#*D,#$="%&#*D=,-'*D&%($%*(4'*D(;$,&%*"=&%*B(-,%*$>(4*$>%*54'5B5',(-*<5&"#*D=,-'*>(B%*(D>5%B%'*(-=4%)*<=&*%h(";-%*B5(*D="654%'*6,#54%##*D&%($5=4C*!-$>=,@>*;%&>(;#*4=$*54$%4$5=4(--.)*#="%$5"%#*J20*(4'*5$*D,#$="%&#* (&%* ($* $>%* 6%@54454@*=<* (4*=;%4* 544=B($5=4* ;&(D$5D%C*T=d%B%&)* $>5#* ;&=D%##*********************************************************1*3%%*>$$;7bbdddCD-,6B(420C4-b=B%&_=4#b*

Page 10: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 10*

6%54@* &%-($5B%-.* 4%d* $=* J20)* $>%* <5&"*>(#* .%$* $=* <5@,&%* =,$* >=d* $=* D&%($%* (4'* D(;$,&%*B(-,%* $>&=,@>* $>%#%* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* ;&(D$5D%#C* 3=)* $=* #;%(Q* d5$>* $>%* d=&'#* =<*V#$%&d(-'%&* (4'* I5@4%,&* R/010S)* J20* 5#* 54$%&%#$%'* $=* Q4=d* >=d* %h;-=5$54@* (4* =;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4*&%#,-$*54*$>%*D&%($5=4*(4'*(;;&=;&5($5=4*=<*#.4%&@..*%O>%* '%#5@4* D(#%* &%('5-.* <5$#* $>%* $=;5D* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#)* #54D%* J20* d(4$#* $=* Q4=d*>=d* $=*(D>5%B%* #.4%&@5%#* B5(* =;%4* 544=B($5=4C* !''5$5=4(--.)* $>%* D=4$%h$* =<* $>%* D(#%* #$,'.*RD&%($54@*B(-,%*$>&=,@>*5";-%"%4$54@*#,#$(54(65-5$.*54*6,#54%##*"='%-#S*5#*(*;&=6-%"*($*>(4'* <=&*"(4.* <5&"#* (4'* (* &%-%B(4$* $=;T,66(&')*/00:SC*O>%&%<=&%)*$>%*D>=5D%*<=&*$>%*'%#5@4*D(#%*(4'*$>%*(DD=";(4.54@*(4#d%&*$=* #,6_?,%#$5=4* ]* (&%* &%-%B(4$* <=&* (;;-.54@* '%#5@4* Q4=d-%'@%* 54* ;&(D$5D%)*#5",-$(4%=,#-.*D=4$&56,$54@*$=*6=$>*$>%*(4#d%&*$=*$>%*&%#%(&D>*?,%#$5=4*(4'*$=*#=-B54@*$>%*5##,%#*J20*>(#)*D=4D%&454@*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4C**

"#$%&#'()*+,!@.!A+B!91,!+2',!$#(*,'((!3+4'5!*,,+61)*+,'0'52!C?D!*,!9<'1)*,=!1,4!122<+2<*1)*,=!(;,'<=;7!

O>%* &%"(54'%&* =<* $>%* $>%#5#* 5#* #$&,D$,&%'* (#* <=--=d#C* J>(;$%&* /* %-(6=&($%#* =4* $>%*D=4D%;$#* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=4)* 6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4* (4'* #.4%&@.C* O>%#%* D=4D%;$#*(&%*D="654%'*54$=*(*D=4D%;$,(-*<&("%d=&Q*(4'*$>%=&._6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#*d5--*6%*'%&5B%'C*W%h$)*$>%*"%$>='=-=@.*5#*;&=B5'%')*<=--=d%'*6.*$>%*(4(-.#5#*=<*$%4*D(#%*#$,'5%#*$=*'%&5B%*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#C*O>%*'%#5@4*<=&*J20*6(#%'*=4*$>%*;&54D5;-%#*5#*@5B%4*54*D>(;$%&*[C*O>%*$>%#5#*%4'#*d5$>*(*'5#D,##5=4*=<*$>%*&%#,-$#*(4'*'5&%D$5=4#*<=&*<,$,&%*&%#%(&D>C*

'(9!:+#)*.A,).+#!O>5#*$>%#5#*>(#*",-$5;-%*;,&;=#%#C*O>%=&%$5D(--.)*5$*(5"#*($*D-=#54@*$>%*D,&&%4$-.*%h5#$54@*@(;* 6%$d%%4* '%#5&%'* #.4%&@.* <+$;<G*2* (4'* >=d* $=* #*"5)>** $>%"C*F=&%* #;%D5<5D(--.)* 5$*(5"#*($*D=4$&56,$54@*$=*$>%*;%&#;%D$5B%*=<*D>(4@%* 54*=&@(45f($5=4*$>%=&.*6.*'%#D&5654@*>=d*=&@(4 =4*(4'*D(;$,&54@*<=&*<5&"#C*O>5#*$>%#5#*(5"#*($*%h$%4'54@*$>%*-5$%&($,&%*=4*>=d*<5&"#*D(4*D&%($%*(4'* D(;$,&%* B(-,%* $>&=,@>* &%(-5f54@* #.4%&@5#$5D* =;;=&$,45$5%#* 6.* =;%454@* ,;* $>%5&*6=,4'(&5%#*$=*$>5&'*;(&$5%#C*G%(-5f54@*#.4%&@5%#*<&="*(4*<=*4*@+2)4*22%G<A*5*;%&#;%D$5B%*(''#* $>%* (#;%D$* =<* #.4%&@.* (D>5%B%"%4$* $=* 6,#54%##* "='%-* -5$%&($,&%* (4'* =;%4*544=B($5=4* -5$%&($,&%C* F(4.* #D>=-(&#* 54* $>%* <5%-'* =<* %D=4="5D#* (4'*"(4(@%"%4$* ;(5'*",D>*($$%4$5=4*$=*$>%*$=;5D*=<*#.4%&@.)*6,$*(*d%--_'%<54%'*$>%=&.*=<*#.4%&@.*(4'*54$%&_<5&"*4%$d=&Q#*>(#*.%$*$=*%"%&@%*R^%5)*/010SC*O>5#*$>%#5#*5#*(*D=4$&56,$5=4*$=*<5--*$>5#*@(;C*A,&$>%&"=&%)*(-$>=,@>*#D>=-(&#*54D&%(#54@-.*"%4$5=4*#,#$(54(65-5$.*(#*(*;=$%4$5(-*#=,&D%*=<* %D=4="5D* 6%4%<5$#* R\=$$<&5%')* /002S)* 54$%@&($54@* #,#$(54(65-5$.* 54* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-#*54*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*(*#,&;-,#*54*B(-,%*<=&*$d=*<5&"#*>(#*4=$*6%%4*<=D,#%'*=4*.%$C*N#;%D5(--.*4=d('(.#)*d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d5$>* 54#5@>$#* 54*=;;=&$,45$5%#*<=&*B(-,%*D&%($5=4*(4'*@,5'%-54%#*<=&*D(;$,&54@*$>5#*B(-,%)*%#;%D5(--.*54*$>%*D=4$%h$*=<*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##*545$5($5B%#C**

Page 11: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 11*

9(!B=#%*@=!.#!+C%#!A,0.#%00!D+$%<05!<.)%*1),*%!*%7.%8!

%

O>5#* D>(;$%&* '%#D&56%#* $>%* D,&&%4$* #$($%* =<* -5$%&($,&%* D=4D%&454@* =;%4* 544=B($5=4)*6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4* (4'* #.4%&@.* D&%($5=4C* O>5#* -5$%&($,&%*d5--* 6%* (4(-.#%'* (4'*D="654%'*54*=&'%&*$=*<54'*(4*(4#d%&*=4*#,6_?,%#$5=4#*1*P*/C%

9('!EC%#!.##+71).+#!!#*#(5')* #$(&$54@*;=54$* <=&*$>%* 5'%(*=<*=;%44%##* 5#* $>($*(*#54@-%* <5&"*D(44=$* 544=B($%* 54*5#=-($5=4C* O>5#* #$(&$54@* ;=54$* %";>(#5f%#* $>%* ; 6=,4'(&5%#)* #54D%*5'%(#)*&%#=,&D%#*(4'* 54'5B5',(-#* <-=d*54*(4'*=,$*(4*=&@(45f($5=4*RK(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC*O>%* <=--=d54@* ;(&$#*d5--* '5#D,##* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<*=;%44%##)* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* (4'*d>%$>%&* =&* 4=$* <5&"#* #>=,-'* >(B%* ;%&"%(6-%* 6=,4'(&5%#* R5C%C* d>($* D=,-'* 6%* $>%*R'5#S('B(4$(@%#*<=&*<5&"#*d>%4*(;;-.54@*=;%4*544=B($5=4*$=*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#SC*

9('('!:+#-%C),1<.F1).+#!V4%*=<*$>%*"=#$*D=""=4-.*,#%'*'%<545$5=4#*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4*5#*$>%*=4%*6.*J>%#6&=,@>*R/002S)* d>=* <5&#$* D=54%'* $>%* $%&"* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* RK(>-(4'%&* (4'* \(44)* /010SC*

"%="#"A):G%$E"$%"22+G*2%$E"$%"%F)#G%;"4%"4A%2E<+5A%+2*%*U$*#4"5%)A*"2%"2%-*55%"2%)4$*#4"5%)A*"2X%"4A%)4$*#4"5%"4A%*U$*#4"5%="$E2% $<% $E*% G"#K*$X% "2% F)#G2% 5<<K% $<% "A,"4;*% $E*)#% $*;E4<5<:6 $E*%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%i=<* (* <5&"j%+$)5)>*2%@<$E%*U$*#4"5%"4A%)4$*#4"5%)A*"2%$<%;#*"$*%,"5+*X%-E)5*%A*F)4)4:%)4$*#4"5%G*;E"4)2G2%$<%;5")G%2<G*%=<#$)<4%<F%$E"$%,"5+* C*E4*=&'%&*$=*,$5-5f%*6=$>*%h$%&4(-*(4'*54$%&&%-($5=4#>5;#*d5$>*%h$%&4(-*(D$=&#C*O=*'=*#=)*<5&"#*4%%'*D=";%$%4D5%#*54*(&%(#*&%-($%'*$=*

_'%B%-=;* 5'%(#* $>($* =&5@54($%* <&="* %h$%&4(-* &%#=,&D%#*RX&,#=45)* I&%4D5;%* (4'* I(B5$$)* /001SC* E4$%&4(-* D(;(65-5$5%#* (4'* %h$%&4(-* &%-($5=4#* (&%*$>%&%<=&%*D=";-%"%4$#*&($>%&*$>(4*#,6#$5$,$%#*RK(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC***354D%* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* 5#* (* &%-($5B%-.* 4%d* (4'* &5D>* D=4D%;$* &%#%(&D>%&#* ,#%* "(4.*'5<<%&%4$*'%<545$5=4#)*d>5D>*>54'%&#*$>%=&.*'%B%-=;"%4$*RT,5f54@>)*/011SC*E4*<(D$)*%B%4*J>%#6&=,@>*&%<54%'*>5#*'%<545$5=4*$=@%$>%&*d5$>*>5#*D=--%(@,%#*Y(4>(B%&6%Q%*(4'*^%#$*R/00`)*;C1S*(4'*#$($%'*$>($7*<F%K4<-5*A:*%$<%";;*5*#"$*%)4$*#4"5%)44<,"$)<4X%"4A%$<%*U="4A%$E*%G"#K*$2%F<#%*U$*#4"5%+2*%

O>5#* '%<545$5=4* >(#* 6%D="%* d%--* D5$%')* 6%D(,#%* =<* $>%*'5#$54D$5=4*54*$d=*;&=D%##%#*5$*D=4$(54#C*O>%*<5&#$*;&=D%##)*$>%*,#%*=<*;,&;=#5B%*54<-=d#*=<*Q4=d-%'@%* $=* (DD%-%&($%* 54$%&4(-* 544=B($5=4)* 5#* D(--%'* )4@<+4A% <=*4% )44<,"$)<4C* O>%*#%D=4'*;(&$)*,#54@*;,&;=#5B%*=,$<-=d#*=<*Q4=d-%'@%*$=*%h;(4'*$>%*"(&Q%$#*<=&*%h$%&4(-*,#%*=<*544=B($5=4)*5#*D(--%'*<+$@<+4A%<=*4%)44<,"$)<4*RT,5f54@>)*/011SC**

9('(9!"#A+,#$!7%*0,0!+,)A+,#$!.##+71).+#!E46=,4'* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* D=4#5#$#* =<* =;%454@* ,;* (4'* %#$(6-5#>54@* &%-($5=4#>5;#* d5$>*%h$%&4(-*=&@(45f($5=4#*54*=&'%&*$=*(DD%##*$>%5&* $%D>45D(-*(4'*#D5%4$5<5D*D=";%$%4D%#* <=&*

* E$* 5#* $E*% =#";$);*% <F% 5*,*#":)4:% $E*%A)2;<,*#)*2%<F% <$E*#2 * (4'* A&($$545)* /011)* ;C* 2[SC* Z5D>$%4$(-%&* R/011S*;,$#*5$*#-5@>$-.*'5<<%&%4$*6.*#$($54@*$>($*546=,4'*=;%4*544=B($5=4*54B=-B%#*=;%454@*,;*$>%*544=B($5=4*;&=D%##*$=*Q4=d-%'@%*%h;-=&($5=4*<&="*=,$#5'%*$>%*=&@(45f($5=4*$=*54#5'%*$>%*

="#$2'%$E* [ %\!"22F)*5AX%0NN0X%=.&HI].%

%

Page 12: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 1/*

=&@(45f($5=4)* d>%&%(#* %h$%&4(-* Q4=d-%'@%* %h;-=&($5=4* &%<%&#* $=* $>%* (D?,5#5$5=4* =<*Q4=d-%'@%*<&="*%h$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#C*J=4$&(&.)*<+$@<+4A*=;%4*544=B($5=4*5#*(4*54#5'%_=,$*;&=D%##* (4'* 54B=-B%#* =;%454@* ,;* $>%* 544=B($5=4* ;&=D%##* $=* Q4=d-%'@%* %h;-=5$($5=4*RZ5D>$%4$(-%&)*/011SC*3=)*%h$%&4(-*Q4=d-%'@%*%h;-=5$($5=4*&%<%&#*$=*D=""%&D5(-5f($5=4*=<*$%D>4=-=@5D(-*Q4=d-%'@%C*J>5(&=45)*J>5%#(*(4'*A&($$545* R/011)*;C*2[S* #%%* $>5#* (#* 54#5'%*=,$* #"$E*#%$E"4%#*56)4:%*4$)#*56%<4%)4$*#4"5%="$E2%$<%G"#K*$X% ;<G="4)*2% ;"4% 5<<K% F<#% *U$*#4"5% <#:"4)>"$)<42% -)$E% @+2)4*22% G<A*52% $E"$% "#*%@*$$*#%2+)$*A%$<%;<GG*#;)"5)>*%"%:),*4%$*;E4<5<:6&%-($5=4#>5;#*d5$>*%h$%&4(-*;(&$5%#*d5$>*$>%*=6g%D$5B%*$=*D=""%&D5(--.*%h;-=5$*544=B($5B%*=;;=&$,45$5%#*RJ>5(&=45)*J>5%#(*(4'*A&($$545)*/011SC***E4* (''5$5=4* $=* $>%* '5#$54D$5=4* 6%$d%%4* 546=,4'* (4'* =,$6=,4'* =;%4* 544=B($5=4)*K(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44*R/010S*(''*(*"=4%$(&.*(#;%D$e*=;%4*544=B($5=4*D(4*6%*;%D,45(&.*=&*4=4_;%D,45(&.C*O>5#*&%#,-$#*54*$d=*$.;%#*=<*546=,4'*(4'*$d=*$.;%#*=<*=,$6=,4'*=;%4*544=B($5=4C*O(6-%*1*#>=d#*$>%*&%#,-$#*=<*$>%#%*'5<<%&%4$*<=&"#*=<*=;%44%##7*9"ST%'B'U'3,))%&%-$')(&1#'()'(V%--%##'QS"#%W'(-'3"XT"-W%&'"-W'<"--Y'EOBOR'

' .-S(Z-W',--(/"$,(-' :Z$S(Z-W',--(/"$,(-'G%+Z-,"&[' !D?,5&54@* 3%--54@*2(-UV%+Z-,"&[' 3=,&D54@* G%B%(-54@**O>%* &%(#=4* <=&* $>5#*%h$&(*'5B5#5=4* 5#* $>%* <(D$* $>($* $>%*('B(4$(@%#*(4'*'5#('B(4$(@%#*=<*;%D,45(&.* (4'* 4=4_;%D,45(&.* 544=B($5=4* (&%* '5<<%&%4$C* O>%&%<=&%)* $>%* ('B(4$(@%#* (4'*'5#('B(4$(@%#*=<* $>%*'5<<%&%4$* <=&"#*=<*=;%44%##* (#*;&=;=#%'*6.*K(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44*R/010S*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*4%h$C*

9('(>!G$71#)1@%0!1#$!$.01$71#)1@%0!E4* $>%5&* &%B5%d)* K(>-(4'%&* (4'* \(44* R/010S* >(B%* 4=$5D%'* $>($* $>%* D,&&%4$* #$($%* =<*-5$%&($,&%*>(#*6%%4*5"6(-(4D%'*54*5$#*#$&=4@*<=D,#*=4*$>%*6%4%<5$#*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4C*O=*D&%($%* (*"=&%* 6(-(4D%'* =B%&B5%d*=<*=;%4* 544=B($5=4)* $>5#* $>%#5#*d5--*'5#D,##* 6=$>* $>%*('B(4$(@%#* RkS)* (#* d%--* (#* $>%* '5#('B(4$(@%#* R_S*6=&'%&#)*#$(&$54@*d5$>*K(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44 *<=,&*$.;%#*=<*=;%44%##*(#*;&=B5'%'*54*$(6-%*1)*<=--=d%'*6.*(*&%B5%d*=<*=$>%&*-5$%&($,&%*=4*=;%4*544=B($5=4C*

/%7%1<.#@!!Q\R*O>%*"(54*('B(4$(@%*=<*&%B%(-54@*5#*d>($*!--%4*R1:92S*D(--#*D=--%D$5B%*54B%4$5=4C*O>%*5'%(*5#*$>($*;($%4$#*4=*-=4@%&*;&=$%D$*4%d*5'%(#)*#=*D=";%$54@*<5&"#*D(4*,#%*%(D>* *54<=&"($5=4C* O>5#*d(.)* $>%* ;=##565-5$.* (&5#%#* $=* 6,5-'* ,;=4* %(D>* * d=&Q)* >%&%6.*#$5",-($54@* 54D&%"%4$(-* 544=B($5=4C* 3=)* <5&"#* >(B%* $>%* ;=##565-5$.* $=* #%-%D$5B%-.* &%B%(-*R;(&$*=<S*$>%5&*$%D>4=-=@5%#)*54*=&'%&*$=*%-5D5$*D=--(6=&($5=4C**QUR*O>%*'=d4#5'%*=<*&%B%(-54@*5#)*=6B5=,#-.)*$>%*'5<<5D,-$.*54*;"=$+#)4:%B(-,%)*&($>%&*$>(4*;#*"$)4:%5$C*J=";%$5$=&#*D(4*6%)*=&*6%D="%)*6%$$%&*;=#5$5=4%'*d5$>*D=";-%"%4$(&.*(##%$#*(4'b=&*<(D5-5$5%#*$=*"(Q%*,#%*=<*$>%*$%D>[email protected]*O>%&%<=&%)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*D(&%<,--.*#%-%D$*d>5D>* 54<=&"($5=4* $=* "(Q%* ;,6-5D(--.* (B(5-(6-%* (4'* d>5D>* 54<=&"($5=4* 5#* ,#%'* <=&*

C%*

B%<<.#@!Q\R* X.* D=""%&D5(-5f54@* 54B%4$5=4#)* B5(* #%--54@* =&* -5D%4#54@_=,$)* <5&"#* D(4* "=&%* <,--.*-%B%&(@%*$>%5&*54B%#$"%4$#*54*GPKC*J>%#6&=,@>*(4'*G=#%46-=="*R/00/S*&%<%&*$=*$>5#*(#*(* 6%4%<5$* d>%4* #;5--=B%&#* &%#,-$54@* <&="* GPK* <,4'54@* (&%* D=""%&D5(-5f%'* 6.* 4%d*6,#54%##*"='%-#C**

Page 13: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 12*

QUR'O>%*;&=6-%"*d5$>* #%--54@*=&* -5D%4#54@* >=d%B%&)* 5#* $>%* <(D$* $>($* (* <5&"*",#$* &%B%(-*#="%* =<* $>%* 54<=&"($5=4* 54* (4* ($$%";$* $=* -5D%4#%* =&* #%--* $>%* 544=B($5=4* $=* (* ;=$%4$5(-*D,#$="%&C* V<* D=,&#%)* 5$* 5#* ;=##56-%* $>($* $>%* D,#$="%&* 5#* =;;=&$,45#$5D* (4'* #$%(-#* $>%*544=B($5=4* d5$>=,$* ;(.54@* <=&* 5$C* O>5#* "(Q%#* 54B%4$=&#* &%-,D$(4$* $=* &%B%(-* $>%5&*544=B($5=4#C* !4=$>%&* '5#('B(4$(@%* 5#* $>($* $>%&%* (&%* #5@45<5D(4$* $&(4#(D$5=4#* D=#$#*54B=-B%'*54*$&(4#<%&&54@*544=B($5=4#*6%$d%%4*=&@(45f($5=4#C*E$*5#*>(&'*<=&*(*D=";(4.*$=*'%D5'%*d>%$>%&*=&*4=$*$>%#%*D=#$#*(&%*(DD%;$(6-%)*#54D%*(4$5D5;($54@*$>%*;=$%4$5(-*B(-,%*=<*(4*544=B($5=4*5#*$&=,6-%#="%*RJ>%#6&=,@>*(4'*G=#%46-==")*/00/SC*

B+,*-.#@!!Q\R* A5&"#* $>($*"(4(@%* $=* D&%($%* #.4%&@.*6%$d%%4* $>%5&*=d4*;&=D%##%#*(4'* %h$%&4(--.*(B(5-(6-%* 5'%(#*"(.*D&%($%*(4'*D(;$,&%*B(-,%* <&="* $>%* 5'%(#*=<*=,$#5'%&#*B5(* #=,&D54@)*#54D%*&%#=,&D%#*6%D="%*(B(5-(6-%*(4'*;($>#*$=*$>%*"(&Q%$*#>=&$%&C*O>5#*D(4*6%*&%(-5f%'*6.*$(Q54@*(4*(D$5B%*;(&$*54*$>%*%h$%&4(-*%4B5&=4"%4$*RK(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC*QUR'T=d%B%&)* $ _#;%4'* $==* ",D>* $5"%* -==Q54@* <=&* %h$%&4(-* #=,&D%#* =<* 544=B($5=4C* !#* (* &%#,-$)* $>%*544=B($5B%*;%&<=&"(4D%*=<*$>%#%*<5&"*'%D&%(#%#C*!-$>=,@>*$>%&%*"(.*6%*(4*545$5(-*%<<%D$*=<*=;%44%##)*<5&"#*$>($*=B%&_#%(&D>*D(4*D="%*$=*&%-.*$==*>%(B5-.*=4*%h$%&4(-*#=,&D%#*=<*544=B($5=4)*$>%&%6.*'%D&%(#54@*544=B($5B%*;%&<=&"(4D%*RK(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC**

! G-H,.*.#@!Q\R'O>%*('B(4$(@%#*=<* (D?,5&54@*(&%* <&%?,%4$-.*'%#D&56%'* 54* -5$%&($,&%*(4'* 54D-,'%*$>%*<=--=d54@7* $>%* $%D>4=-=@5D(-*Q4=d_>=d* $>($* 5#*"5##54@* 54*(* <5&"*D(4*6%*(D?,5&%')*GPK*D=#$#*D(4*6%*'%D&%(#%'*(4'*544=B($5=4#*D(4*6%*6&=,@>$*$=*$>%*"(&Q%$*<(#$%&C**QUR*Z%##*<&%?,%4$-.*"%4$5=4%')*>=d%B%&)*(&%*$>%*'=d4#5'%#*=<*(D?,5&54@C*^>%4*(D?,5&54@*Q4=d-%'@%*=&* 5'%(#)*d5$>54*$>%* <5&"*%h;%&$5#%* 5#*&%?,5&%'*$=*#%(&D>*(4'*%B(-,($%* $>%#%*%h$%&4(-* 5'%(#*RK(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC*NB%4*(<$%&*%B(-,($5=4*(4'*(D?,5#5$5=4)* 5$* 5#*5";=&$(4$* $=* Q4=d* >=d* $=* <(D5-5$($%* $>%* 54$6,#54%##*"='%-*RD<C*J>%#6&=,@>)*/008)*d>=*#$($%'*$>($*"(4(@54@*(*4%d*6,#54%##*"='%-*(-=4@#5'%*(4*%h5#$54@*=4%*D(4*6%*$&=,6-%#="%SC%

E)2%*!<.)%*1),*%!*%7.%80!^>%&%(#*K(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44*R/010S*#;%(Q*=<*('B(4$(@%#*(4'*'5#('B(4$(@%#)*T,5f54@>*R/011S*&%<%&#*$=*$>%*$&('%*=<<*=<*$>%#%*(#*$>%**FF*;$),*4*22*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4C*O>%*"=#$*5";=&$(4$*&%(#=4#*<=&*=;%4*544=B($5=4*>%*"%4$5=4#*(&%*-=d%&*544=B($5=4*D=#$#)*#>=&$%&*$5"%*$=*"(&Q%$*(4'*54D&%(#%'*#(-%#C*O>5#*"(.*-%('*$=*(*D>(54*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4*%<<%D$#*

$%D>4=-=@5D(-*;=#5$5=4*RW(@(=Q(*(4'*Hd=4)*/00`SC*E4*-54%*d5$>*$>5#*B5%d)*Y(4>(B%&6%Q%)*Y(4*'%&*Y&(4'%*(4'*J>%#6&=,@>*R/009S*'5#$54@,5#>*<=,&*$.;%#*=<*6%4%<5$#)*d>5D>*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*4%h$7**% &]%J*4*F)$2%F#<G%*"#56%)4,<5,*G*4$% %V#%4#%*'%B%-=;"%4$#*54*(*d5'%*&(4@%*=<*%h$%&4(--.*'%B%-=;%'*54B%4$5=4#)*<=&*%h(";-%*6.*;(&$5D5;($54@* 54*B%4$,&%* D(;5$(-* <,4'#C*O>5#*d(.)* <5&"#*@%$*"=&%* 54<=&"($5=4*(4'* -%(&4*(6=,$*;&=g%D$#*d5$>*,4D%&$(54*;(.=<<#C*O>%*"(54*('B(4$(@%* 5#* $>($* <5&"#* -%(&4*%(&-.*=4*(6=,$*4%d*;&=g%D$#)*d>%4*54B%#$"%4$#*(&%*#$5--*#"(--C*3=)*$>%*D=";(4.*D(4*#D(4*(*6&=('*&(4@%*=<*54$%&%#$54@*5'%(#)*;=##56-.*&%#,-$54@*54*"=&%*'5B%&#5<5%'*=;;=&$,45$5%#C**% 0]%9*5"6*A%F)4"4;)"5%;<GG)$G*4$% *^>%&%(#* 54* D-=#%'* 544=B($5=4#* <5&"#*>(B%* $=*#$(&$*(4*544=B($5=4*(4'*;,--*5$*$>&=,@>*$>%*544=B($5=4*<,44%-*RO5''*%$*(-C)*/00[e*G%5$f5@)*/011S)*=;%4*544=B($5=4*=<<%&#*"=&%*<-%h565-5$.*(6=,$*d>%4*$=*#$(&$*$>%*54$%&4(-*;=&$5=4*=<*

Page 14: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 1]*

$>%*544=B($5=4*;&=D%##C*K%-(.54@*54$%&4(-*544=B($5=4*(D$5B5$.*(--=d#*(*<5&"*$=*D=4#5'%&*(*6&=('%&*;=&$<=-5=*=<*%4$&.*=;$5=4#)*&%#,-$54@*54*'5<<%&%4$5($%'*544=B($5=4*#$&($%@5%#C**% 2S*DE*%*"#56%*U)$% %V;%4* 544=B($5=4* 5#*D>(&(D$%&5f%'*6.*$>%*;=##565-5$.* $>($* <5&"#*D(4*(-d(.#*-5D%4#%*=&*#%--*544=B($5=4#*$>($*(&%*4=$*;&="5#54@*%4=,@>*=&*'=*4=$*<5$*$>%5&*6,#54%##* "='%-C* O>5#* d(.)* 545$5($5B%#* D(4* 6%* ;,&#,%'* $>&=,@>* ",-$5;-%* <5&"#* d5$>*

("=,4$*=<*D(;5$(-*D=,-'*#$5--*&%#,-$*54*$>%*'%#5&%'*544=B($5=4*%h;-=&($5=4C*% C]%DE*%A*5"6*A%*U)$% *J=4$&(&.*$=*$>%*%(&-.*%h5$)*$>%&%*5#*(-#=*$>%*;=##565-5$.*=<*$>%*'%-(.%'*%h5$7*d>%4*D=&;=&($%*B%4$,&%#*(&%*D&%($%'*=,$#5'%*$>%*<5&")*$>%*<5&"*D(4*"=45$=&*$>%*'%B%-=;"%4$*d>5-%*'%-(.54@*$>%*%h5$*'%D5#5=4C*^>5-%*$>%*B%4$,&%*@&=d#)*$>%*<5&"*D(4*'%D5'%* d>%$>%&* $=* #;54* 54* $>%* B%4$,&%* =&* #%--* $>%* 544=B($5=4* $=* %h$%&4(-* D(;5$(-*

(4'*J>%#6&=,@>)*/009)*;C/[]SC**

9('(I!:+#-<,0.+#!F=#$*-5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d#*=4*=;%4*544=B($5=4*(@&%%*=4*$>%*"(54*@*4*F)$27*#>=&$%&*$5"%*$=*"(&Q%$)* 54D&%(#%* 54* #(-%#*(4'* -=d%&* D=#$#C*O>%*'5<<%&%4D%#* -5%* 54* $>%*'5<<%&%4$*;=54$#*=<*B5%d* $(Q%4* 6.* $>%* (,$>=&#C* !-$>=,@>* 4=$* "%4$5=4%'* #;%D5<5D(--.)* 54* $>%* (&$5D-%* 6.*Y(4>(B%&6%Q%)*Y(4*'%&*Y&(4'%*(4'*J>%#6&=,@>*R/009S*=4%*D(4*#%%*$>%*(4(-=@.*$=*$>%*544=B($5=4*<,44%-*54*D-=#%'*544=B($5=4*R#%%*%C@C*O5''*%$*(-C)*/00[SC*O>%&%<=&%)*(--*6%4%<5$#*"%4$5=4%'*54B=-B%*$>%*(#;%D$*=<*$5"%7*$>%*6%4%<5$#*(&5#%*%5$>%&*<&="*$5"%*'%-(.#*=&*<&="*%(&-.* 54B=-B%"%4$)*&%#,-$54@* 54*#>=&$%&*$5"%*$=*"(&Q%$*(4'* -=d%&*D=#$#C*K(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44* R/010S)* =4* $>%5&* $,&4)* ;&%#%4$* (*"=&%* '%$(5-%'* =B%&B5%d* =<* $>%* ('B(4$(@%#)* 6,$*%B%4$,(--.*(@&%%*$>($*$>%*;"=$+#*A%B(-,%*-5%#*d5$>54*$>%*$>&%%*"=#$*<&%?,%4$-.*"%4$5=4%'*6%4%<5$#*=<*=;%4* 544=B($5=47*#>=&$%&*$5"%*$=*"(&Q%$)* 54D&%(#%* 54*#(-%#*(4'* -=d%&*D=#$#C*J=4#5'%&54@* $>%* A)2"A,"4$":*2* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=4)* K(>-(4'%&* (4'* \(44* R/010S* (&%*("=4@* $>%* <%d* d>=* '%#D&56%* $>%#%)* 6%D(,#%* $>%.* >(B%* 4=$5D%'* (4* 5"6(-(4D%'* B5%d*$=d(&'#* $>%* 6%4%<5$#* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=4C* O>%* '5#('B(4$(@%#* $>%.*"%4$5=4* (&%* <%(&* =<*D=";%$5$=&#*6%D="54@*6%$$%&*;=#5$5=4%')*#=*<5&"#*(&%*&%-,D$(4$*$=*&%B%(-*R;(&$*=<S*$>%5&*54<=&"($5=4C* A,&$>%&"=&%)* $&(4#(D$5=4* D=#$#)* &%?,5&%'* %h;%&$5#%* (4'* $>%* ;=##565-5$.* =<*

_ 44=B($5=4C****3=)* $>%* ;&%<%&&%'* =,$D="%* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* 5#* "=&%* =&* -%##* #5"5-(&)* >=d%B%&* 5$*

#* (4'* -%B%-#* =<* '%$(5-* $=* #%%* B5(* d>5D>* ;($>d(.#*$>%#%* 6%4%<5$#* D(4* 6%* &%(-5f%')* >%&%6.* $(Q54@* 54* "54'* $>($* %B%&.* ;($>d(.* (-#=* >(#* 5$*'=d4#5'%#C*A5&"#*#>=,-'*4=$*=B%&%#$5"($%*$>%*;=$%4$5(-*6%4%<5$#*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4)*6,$*#>=,-'* D(&%<,--.* D=4#5'%&*d>%$>%&*=&* 4=$* $>%*('B(4$(@%#* =,$d%5@>* $>%*'5#('B(4$(@%#7*$>%*;&=D%##* $>($*T,5f54@>* R/011S*D=54%'* $>%*%<<%D$5B%4%##*=<*=;%4* 544=B($5=4C*O(6-%*/*#,""(&5f%#*$>%*<54'54@#C*9"ST%'E'U'@W/"-$"0%#'"-W'W,#"W/"-$"0%#'()'(V%-',--(/"$,(-'

G$71#)1@%0! ?.01$71#)1@%0!!"#$%&$'%()&'%#')*$+&%' ,&*$'#-'.#)/&%(%#$0'1&.#)(23'1&%%&$'

/#0(%(#2&4'5#6&$'(22#7*%(#2'.#0%0' ,($)0'*$&'$&89.%*2%'%#'$&7&*8':/*$%'#-;'%"&($'

(2-#$)*%(#2'-#$'0&88(23'/9$/#0&0'<2.$&*0&4'0*8&0'' !(32(-(.*2%'%$*20*.%(#2'.#0%0'! =(0+'#-'#7&$>0&*$."(23'! ?@/&$%(0&'$&A9($&4'-#$'(2%&3$*%(#2'(2'%"&'

190(2&00')#4&8'

Page 15: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 1[*

9(9!J,0.#%00!D+$%<!.##+71).+#!X%<=&%*'5B54@*54$=*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*6,#54%##*"='%-* )44<,"$)<4)*(*$>=&=,@>*,4'%&#$(4'54@*=<* $>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*D=4D%;$* 5#*&%?,5&%'C*!<$%&*(--)*6%<=&%*(D>5%B54@* 544=B($5=4)*=<$%4*

e*\(&D5(*(4'*J(-(4$=4%)* /00/S)* $>%* #$($%* =<* * 6,#54%##*"='%-* >(#* $=* 6%* @&(#;%'C*T=d%B%&)*(#*l=$$)*!"5$*(4'*F(##(*R/010S*;=54$*=,$*54*$>%5&*d=&Q)*$>5#*5#*%(#5%&*#(5'*$>(4*'=4%C*O>%5&* &%B5%d*&%B%(-#* $>($* #D>=-(&#*'5#(@&%%*=4*(* #54@-%*'%<545$5=4*=<* $>%* D=4D%;$*(4'* -5$%&($,&%* 5#* '%B%-=;54@* -(&@%-.* 54* #5-=#C* 3$5--)* $>%5&* ;(;%&* 5#* (* &%D%4$)* 6&=('* (4'*",-$5<(D%$%'*&%B5%d*=<*6,#54%##*"='%-* -5$%&($,&%*(4'*d5--* $>%&%<=&%*6%*,#%'*(#*@,5'54@*;(;%&*54*(*#%(&D>*<=&*$>%*'%<545$5=4*$=*6%*,#%'*54*$>%*&%"(54'%&*=<*$>5#*$>%#5#C**

9(9('!K2%!-+#-%C)!+L!A,0.#%00!D+$%<0!O>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* D=4D%;$* >(#* @&=d4* %h;=4%4$5(--.* =B%&* $>%* -(#$* $d%4$.* .%(&#*R\>(f5(45* (4'*Y%4$&%#D()* /00[SC* O>%#%* <54'54@#* (&%* D=4#5#$%4$*d5$>* $>%* (##,";$5=4* =<*l=$$)*!"5$*(4'*F(##(*R/010S*$>($*E4$%&4%$*5#*=4%*=<*$>%*<(D$=&#*'&5B54@*$>%*54$%&%#$*54*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-C*E4D&%(#%'*(B(5-(65-5$.*=<*%-%D$&=45D*"%(4#*=<*D="",45D($5=4*>(#*D&%($%'*=;;=&$,45$5%#*<=&*=&@(45f($5=4#*$=*D>(4@%*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-)*(#*$>%5&*B(-,%*=<<%&54@#*6%D="%* (B(5-(6-%* $=* D,#$="%&#* (#* %_#%&B5D%#* R!4'%&##=4)* +=>(4%##=4* (4'* l'&(BQ=B5D)*/00:SC*O>5#*%4(6-%#*$>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*=<*4%d*d(.#*=<*'=54@*6,#54%##*RO5""%&#)*1::9S*(4'*4%d*"%D>(45#"#*<=&*D&%($54@*B(-,%*R!"5$*(4'*l=$$)*/001SC**O>%*'%<545$5=4*=<*(*6,#54%##*"='%-*>(#*6%%4*d5'%-.*(&@,%'*54*-5$%&($,&%C*!"5$*(4'*l=$$*

"% 262$*G% <F% ";$),)$)*2% $E"$%

=4-.* '%<54%* )*

'5B%&#5$.* =<* '%<545$5=4#)* $(6-%* 2* #>=d#* #="%* =<* $>%* <54'54@#* 6.* l=$$)* !"5$* (4'* F(##(*R/010SC* W=$%* $>($* $>%#%* <54'54@#* (&%* (--* '%<545$5=4#* =<* $>%* 6,#54%##*G<A*5* ($* (* @%4%&(-*-%B%-)*#=*5$*'=%#*4=$*;&=B5'%*(4.*54<=&"($5=4*(6=,$*$>%*=+#=<2**=<*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-C**9"ST%'7'U'3%),-,$,(-#'()'SZ#,-%##'1(W%T#'"$'$X%'0%-%&"T'T%/%T'QS"#%W'(-']($$Y'@1,$'"-W'!"##"Y'EOBOR'

! J,0.#%00!D+$%<!*%L%**%$!)+!10!1M#N5!! B+,*-%0!'(! B&0.$(/%(#2' C//8&3*%&':DEEE;'9(! =&/$&0&2%*%(#2' F#$$(0G'!."(24&"9%%&'H'C88&2':DEEI;'>(! C$."(%&.%9$&' J())&$0':KLLM;'I(! N#2.&/%9*8'%##8'#$')#4&8' O0%&$6*84&$':DEEP;'O(! F&%"#4' C-9*"'*24'J9..(':DEEK;'P(! !%$9.%9$*8'%&)/8*%&' C)(%'*24'Q#%%':DEEK;'*J=4D%&454@* $>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* =+#=<2*)* J(-B(D(4$%*6,#54%##*"='%-*#%&B%#*$d=*54$%&-54Q%'*;,&;=#%#7*$>%*<5&#$*5#*$=*;&=B5'%*#="%*#$(65-5$.*<=&*

<-%h56-%* %4=,@>* $=* (--=d* <=&* D>(4@%C* E4* '=5 $E*%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%2E<+5A%#*;<:4)>*X%*U=5<#*X% 2*)>*%"4A%*U=5<)$%,"5+"@5*%4*-%$*;E4<5<:6%"4A^<#%G"#K*$%<==<#$+4)$)*2% )4%$)G*RJ(-B(D(4$%*%$*(-C)*/011)*;C*12/9SC*!*#5"5-(&*'%<545$5=4*5#*$>($*=<*V#$%&d(-'%&*(4'*I5@4%,&*

"% @+2)4*22% G<A*5% A*2;#)@*2% $E*% #"$)<4"5*% <F% E<-% "4% <#:"4)>"$)<4% ;#*"$*2X%A*5),*#2%"4A%;"=$+#*2%,"5+*"='%-#)*$>%&%*#%%"#*$=*6%*#="%*(@&%%"%4$*=4*$>%*;,&;=#%*=<*6,#54%##*"='%-#)*4("%-.*$>%*(#;%D$*=<*B(-,%*D&%($5=4*(4'*D(;$,&%*(#*D(4*6%*#%%4*54*$>%*(&$5D-%*6.*l=$$)*!"5$*(4'*F(##(* R/010SC* E4* $>5#* (&$5D-%)* $>%* (,$>=&#* #%-%D$*"(4.* '%<545$5=4#* =<* 6,#54%##*"='%-#C*

Page 16: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 1`*

F=#$* =<* $>%#%* '%<545$5=4#* D=4$(54* $>%* D=4D%;$* = * <=&*%h(";-%* J>%#6&=,@>* (4'* G=#%46-=="* R/00/S)* +=>4#%4)* J>&5#$%4#%4* (4'* H(@%&"(44*R/009S*(4'*O%%D%*R/008SSC*A=&*$>%*#(Q%*=<*D=4#5#$%4D.)*$>5#*-5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d*d5--*<=--=d*$>%*"%4$5=4%'*'%<545$5=4*6.*V#$%&d(-'%&*(4'*I5@4%,&*R/010S)*#54D%*B(-,%*D&%($54@*(4'*D(;$,&54@*$,&4#*=,$*$=*6%*%##%4$5(-* <=&*(*6,#54%##*"='%-*(4'*D-=#%-.* <5$#* $>%*D=4D%;$*=<*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4C*A,&$>%&"=&%)*$>5#*'%<545$5=4*5#*d5'%-.*(DD%;$%'*(4'*,#%'*54*-5$%&($,&%C*O=*D=4D-,'%*$>5#*#%D$5=4D(4*D>(4@%*=B%&*$5"%*$=*D&%($%*<5$*d5$>*$>%*D>(4@54@*%4B5&=4"%4$C*O>%*(65-5$.*$=*D>(4@%*5#*;(&$*=<*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*)44<,"$)<4*D=4D%;$)*d>5D>*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*4%h$C*

9(9(9!K2%!-+#-%C)!+L!A,0.#%00!D+$%<!.##+71).+#!J(-B(D(4$%*%$*(-C*R/011S*'%#D&56%*<=,&*'5<<%&%4$*$.;%#*=<*6,#54%##*"='%-*D>(4@%C*O>%*<5&#$*$.;%*5#*@+2)4*22*G<A*5%;#*"$)<4)* 5C%C*@%$$54@*(*4%d* $*5#*$>%* $&(4#5$5=4* <&="* 5'%(* $=* B%4$,&%C* O>%* #%D=4'* D>(4@%* 5#* *U$*42)<4)* d>5D>* 5#* (''54@*(D$5B5$5%#*(4'b=&*%h;(4'54@*%h5#$54@*D=&%*;&=D%##%#C*O>%*4%h$*$.;%*=<*D>(4@%*5#*#*,)2)<4)*d>5D>* %4$(5-#* &%"=B54@* #="%$>54@* $>($* "='5<5%#* (4* %h5#$54@* 6,#54%##* "='%-* (4'*&%;-(D54@*5$*d5$>*(*4%d*;&=D%##C*3=)*$>%*%h5#$54@*d=&Q54@*;&=D%##%#*(&%*#,6g%D$*$=*D>(4@%C*A54(--.)* $>%* -(#$* $.;%* =<* D>(4@%* 5#* $*#G)4"$)<4)* 5C%C* (6(4'=454@* =&* &%"=B54@* ;&=D%##%#C*O%&"54($5=4*D(4*&%<%&*$=*D-=#54@*'=d4*(*6,#54%##*,45$*=&*%B%4*%4$5&%*D=";(4.C*!"5$*(4'*l=$$*R/010)*;C*[S*&%<%&*$=*$>%#%*;&=D%##%#*(#*'%#5@454@*(*4%d*R5C%C*D&%($5=4S)*=&*"='5<.54@*

5C%C* %h$%4#5=4)* &%B5#5=4* =&* $%&"54($5=4S)* (-#=* D(--%'*X,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*"(.*D=";-%"%4$*544=B($5=4#*54*

;&=',D$#*(4'*#%&B5D%#)*"%$>='#*=<*;&=',D$5=4)*'5#$&56,$5=4*=&*"(&Q%$54@)* (4'*"(&Q%$#*R!"5$*(4'*l=$$)*/010SC*!4*544=B($5B%*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4*%5$>%&*D&%($%*(*4%d*"(&Q%$*=&*(--=d*$>%*<5&"*$=*D&%($%*(4'*%h;-=5$*4%d*=;;=&$,45$5%#*54*%h5#$54@*"(&Q%$#C*F5$D>%--*(4'*J=-%#* R/002S* ;,$* 5$* '5<<%&%4$-.* 6.* ;&=;=#54@* $>($* 6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4#* 54B=-B%*

;&=B5'54@* ;&=',D$#* (4'* #%&B5D%#* $=* D,#$="%&#C* 35"5-(&-.)* +=>4#%4)* J>&5#$%4#%4* (4'*H(@%&"(44* R/009S* #$($%* $>($* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4#* 54B=-B%* D>(4B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4)*D,#$="%&#)*&%#=,&D%#)*&%B%4,%*"='%-)*D=#$*#$&,D$,&%)*&,-%#*(4'*4=&"#C***O>%* 54$%&%#$* 54*6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4* <&="*#D>=-(&#)*"(4(@%&#*(4'*%4$&%;&%4%,&#*>(#*#%B%&(-*&%(#=4#*R!"5$*(4'*l=$$)*/010SC*A5&#$)*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*&%;&%#%4$#*(4*=<$%4_=B%&-==Q%'*#=,&D%*=<*<,$,&%*B(-,%*<=&*$>%*6,#54%##C*3%D=4')*D=";%$5$=&#*<54'*5$*'5<<5D,-$* $=* 5"5$($%*(4'b=&* &%;-5D($%*(*6,#54%##*"='%-e* 5$* 5#* %(#5%&* $=* D=;.*(*;&=',D$*=&*;&=D%##C*O>%*$>5&'*(4'*<54(-*&%(#=4*5#*6(#%'*=4*$>%*;&%B5=,#*$d=e*#54D%*6,#54%##*"='%-*

%<<=&$* 54* $>5#* (&%(C* V#$%&d(-'%&* (4'* I5@4%,&* R/010S* <=D,#* =4*"(&Q%$#* &($>%&* $>(4* =4*D=";%$5$=&#*$=*#>=d*$>%*&%(#=4#*<=&*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=47*$>%.*"%4$5=4*#($5#<.54@*"(&Q%$*4%%'#)*6&54@54@*(*4%d*;&=',D$*=&*#%&B5D%*$=*$>%*"(&Q%$)*5";&=B54@*=&*'5#&,;$54@*(4*%h5#$54@*"(&Q%$*(4'*<54(--.)*D&%($54@*(4*%4$5&%-.*4%d*"(&Q%$*(#*"(54*'&5B%&#C*

9(9(>!J,0.#%00!D+$%<!L*1D%8+*Q0!T(B54@*'5#D,##%'*$>%*5";=&$(4D%*=<*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*(4'*$>%*<(D$*$>($*5$*6,5-'#*

H(@%&"(44)* /009S)* 5$* 5#* $5"%* $=* #%%* >=d* $>%#%* $%&"#* (&%* D=44%D$%'* $=* $>%* 6,#54%##*"='%-* (#* (* d>=-%C* O=* '=* #=)* $>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* <&("%d=&Q* 5#* 54$&=',D%'C* 354D%* $>%*'%<545$5=4* =<* $>%* 6,#54%##*"='%-* 5#* ('=;$%'* <&="*V#$%&d(-'%&* (4'*I5@4%,&* R/010S)* #=*d5--*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*<&("%d=&QC*O>5#*<&("%d=&Q*D=4#5#$#*=<*454%*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#*$>($*<=--=d* $>%* -=@5D*=<*>=d*(* D=";(4.* 54$%4'#* $=*"(Q%*"=4%.C*O>%#%*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#*(&%*

Page 17: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 18*

;+2$<G*#%2*:G*4$2X%,"5+*%=#<=<2)$)<4X%;E"44*52X%;+2$<G*#%#*5"$)<42E)=2X%#*,*4+*%2$#*"G2X%K*6%#*2<+#;*2X%K*6%";$),)$)*2X%K*6%="#$4*#2E)=%(4'%;<2$%2$#+;$+#**(4'*$=@%$>%&*D=";-%$%*$>%*6,#54%##* "='%-* D(4B(#C* F=#$* =<* $>%* 6,5-'54@* 6-=DQ#* #;%(Q* <=&* $>%"#%-B%#)* <=&*D=";-%$%4%##* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#)* $>%* '%<545$5=4* =<* %(D>* 6,5-'54@* 6-=DQ* D(4* 6%* <=,4'* 54*(;;%4'5h*EC*A5@,&%*1*5#*(*@&(;>5D(-*&%;&%#%4$($5=4*=<*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4B(#C*

!;,0Z&%'B'U'AZ#,-%##'1(W%T'+"-/"#'Q:#$%&^"TW%&'"-W'G,0-%Z&Y'EOBOR'

9(9(I!K2%!C*+-%00!+L!A,0.#%00!D+$%<!.##+71).+#!X,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4* &%;&%#%4$#* (4* =<$%4_=B%&-==Q%'* #=,&D%* =<* <,$,&%* B(-,%* <=&*$>%* 6,#54%##* R!"5$* (4'* l=$$)* /010SC* ^>5-%* D=";(45%#* "(.* >(B%* 54B%#$"%4$#* (4'*;&=D%##%#* <=&* %h;-=&54@* 4%d* 5'%(#* (4'* $%D>4=-=@5%#)* 6.* 5$#%-<* $>%#%* >(B%* 4=* #54@-%*=6g%D$5B%* B(-,%C*O>%*%D=4="5D*B(-,%* &%"(54#* -($%4$*,4$5-* 5$* 5#* D=""%&D5(-5f%'* 54* #="%*d(.*B5(*(*6,#54%##*"='%-*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC*NB%&.*<5&"*(DQ4=d-%'@%#*$>%*5";=&$(4D%*=<* B(-,%* D(;$,&54@)* 6.* %h;-=5$54@* $>%5&* D,&&%4$* 6,#54%##* "='%-#* 54* =&'%&* $=* #,&B5B%C*T=d%B%&)* $>%* #%(&D>* <=&* ;=$%4$5(-* 4*-* 6,#54%##* "='%-#* @*F<#** $>%* $5"%* D="%#* d>%4*%h$%&4(-*544=B($5=4*&%4'%&#*$>%5&*$&('5$5=4(-*=4%#*&%',4'(4$*>(#*=4-.*6%%4*&%D=@45f%'*6.*(*"54=&5$.*=<* <5&"#*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC*O>5#*#%%"#*;(&('=h5D(-e*=4*=4%*>(4'*<5&"#*#$&5B%* <=&* 544=B($5=4#*(4'*%h;-=5$* $>%5&*D,&&%4$*6,#54%##*"='%-#* $=*D(;$,&%*B(-,%* <&="*$>%#%* 544=B($5=4#)*d>5-%*=4*$>%*=$>%&*>(4'*$>%.*(&%*#,#D%;$56-%*$=* 544=B($%*$>%*-"6%=<*D(;$,&54@*$>5#*B(-,%C*!;;(&%4$-.)*$>%&%*(&%*#="%*=6#$(D-%#*$=*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4C*!"5$*(4'*l=$$*R/001S*&%D=@45f%*$>5#*6.*(&@,54@*<=&*$>%*%h5#$%4D%*=<*#5@45<5D(4$*6(&&5%&#*$=* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4C* O>%.* #$($%* $>($* 4=B%-$.)* -=DQ_54)* D=";-%"%4$(&5$.* (4'*%<<5D5%4D.* (&%* Q%.* (#;%D$#* =<* #,DD%##<,-* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4C* T=d%B%&)* $>%#%*(#;%D$#*"(.* D=4<-5D$*d5$>* $>%*"=&%* $&('5$5=4(-* D=4<5@,&($5=4* =<* <5&"* (##%$#* (4'*"5@>$*$>&%($%4*$>%*=4_@=54@*B(-,%*=<*$>%*D=";(4.*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC*O>5#*5#*$>%*;&=D%##*$>($*J>&5#$%4#%4*R1::8S*D(--#*'5#&,;$5B%*544=B($5=4e*$>%*4%d*6,#54%##*"='%-*d5--*'5#&,;$*$>%*D,&&%4$* 6,#54%##* "='%-* (4'* $>%&%6.* $>%* #=,&D%* =<* B(-,%* $=* $>%* <5&"C* 3=)* (-$>=,@>*"(4(@%&#* "5@>$* &%D=@45f%* (* ;&="5#54@* 6,#54%##* "='%-* $5"%-.)* 5$#* '%B%-=;"%4$* 5#*&%#5#$%'*',%*$=*5$#*D=4<-5D$*d5$>*$>%*;&%B(5-54@*6,#54%##*"='%-*R!"5$*(4'*l=$$)*/010SC***!-$>=,@>* $>%* %h;-(4($5=4* =<* '5#&,;$5B%* 544=B($5=4* #%%"#* ;-(,#56-%* (#* (* 6(&&5%&* $=*6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4)* 5$* 5#* 6(#%'* =4* $>%* (##,";$5=4* $>($* "(4(@%&#* &%D=@45f%*;&="5#54@* 6,#54%##* "='%-#)* %B%4* 54* '.4("5D* %4B5&=4"%4$#* d5$>* %B%&_D>(4@54@*D=4'5$5=4#C* J>%#6&=,@>* R/010S* &%g%D$#* $>5#* (##,";$5=4* (4'* (&@,%#* $>($* 5$* 5#* <(&* <&="*D-%(&* $=* "(4(@%&#* d>($* $>%* &5@>$ * 6,#54%##* "='%-* =,@>$* $=* 6%C* !#* (* &%#,-$)* 4=$* =4-.*=6#$&,D$5=4* <&="*"(4(@%&#*d>=*(&%*(<&(5'*=<* '5#&,;$54@* $>%5&* D,&&%4$*6,#54%##*"='%-*>54'%&#*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)*6,$*(-#=*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*D=4<,#5=4C*O>($*5#)*"(4(@%&#*

Page 18: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 19*

#*"='%-*54*D&%($54@*(4'*D(;$,&54@*B(-,%C***X.*>(B54@*%#$(6-5#>%'* $>%#%*6(&&5%&#)* $>%*?,%#$5=4*4=* -=4@%&* &%"(54#*-E6*"(4.* <5&"#*(&%* >%#5$(4$* $=* 544=B($%* $>%5&* 6,#54%##* "='%-#)* 6,$* &($>%&* 6%D="%#* E<-* $>%.* D(4*=B%&D="%*$>%*6(&&5%&#*$>%.*<(D%C*!DD=&'54@*$=*J>%#6&=,@>*R/010)*;C2[:S*$>%*(4#d%&*$=*$>5#*?,%#$5=4*-5%#*d5$>54*D=""5$"%4$*$=*%h;%&5"%4$($5=4)*5C%C*=#<@*% 4"2;*4$%G"#K*$2% -)$E% 4*-% =<$*4$)"5% ;<4F):+#"$)<42% <F% $E*% *5*G*4$2% <F% "% @+2)4*22%G<A*5%;"4%"55<-%"%F)#G%$<%5*"#4%"E*"A%<F%$E*%#*2$%<F%$E*%G"#K*$X%"4A%$<%@*:)4%$<%:*4*#"$*%

V4%* ;&="5#54@* (;;&=(D>* $=*%h;%&5"%4$($5=4* 5#* D=4#$&,D$54@* 6,#54%##* "='%-#* "(;#)* %C@C* $>%* <&("%d=&Q* =<*V#$%&d(-'%&*(4'*I5@4%,&*R/010SC*O>5#*"='%--54@*(;;&=(D>*;&=B5'%#*(*;&=_(D$5B%*d(.*$=*%h;%&5"%4$*d5$>*(-$%&4($5B%*6,#54%##*"='%-#)*#54D%*5$*%4(6-%#*<5&"#*$=*#5",-($%*B(&5=,#*;=##565-5$5%#*6%<=&%*(D$,(--.*D=""5$$54@*$=*#;%D5<5D*54B%#$"%4$#*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC***O>%* D=4#$&,D$5=4* =<* 6,#54%##* "='%-* "(;#* 5$#%-<* D(44=$* ;&="=$%* 6,#54%##* "='%-*544=B($5=4C* A=&* $>%* (D$,(-* $&(4#5$5=4* <&="* "(;#* $=* (-$%&4($5B%* 6,#54%##* "='%-#)*"(4(@%&#*4%%'*$=*('(;$*=&@(45f($5=4(-*;&=D%##%#C*X%#5'%#**U=*#)G*4$"$)<4)*J>%#6&=,@>*R/010S*"%4$5=4#* $d=* =$>%&* #%$#* =<* ;&=D%##%#* $=* '=* #=7%*FF*;$+"$)<4%(4'*<#:"4)>"$)<4"5%5*"A*#2E)=.%O>%#%*$>&%%*;&=D%##%#*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*54*"=&%*'%$(5-*54*(;;%4'5h*EEC**E4*D=4D-,#5=4)* $>%&%*(&%*#="%*;=d%&<,-*6(&&5%&#* $=*6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4)* 6,$* $>%*d(.* <=&d(&'* 5#* $=*('=;$*(4*%h;%&5"%4$(-* #$(4D%* $=d(&'#* 5$C*O>%* 54<=&"($5=4*@($>%&%'*#>=,-'*6%*&%<-%D$%'*54*'5#D=B%&.*'&5B%4*"='%-#*(4'*-%('%&#*",#$*6%*%";=d%&%'*$=*$(Q%*(D$5=4*6(#%'*=4*$>%#%*<54'54@#C*E4*#;5$%*=<*$>5#*%h;%&5"%4$(-*#$(4D%)*D=";(45%#*#$5--*<54'*5$* 54D&%(#54@-.* '5<<5D,-$* $=* g,#$5<.* R6,#54%##* "='%-S* 544=B($5=4#* ',%* $=* &5#54@*'%B%-=;"%4$*D=#$#*(4'*#>=&$%&*;&=',D$*-5<%*D.D-%#C*V4%*d(.*$=*=B%&D="%*$>5#*'5<<5D,-$.*5#*d>($* J>%#6&=,@>* R/008S* D(--#* $>%* ,#%* =<* <=*4* 6,#54%##*"='%-#)* 5C%C* D=";(45%#* #>=,-'*'%B%-=;*$>%*(65-5$.*$=*%h;%&5"%4$*d5$>*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#*$=*;(&$(Q%*"=&%*<,--.*54*$>%*6%4%<5$#* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=4C* O>%* &=-%* =<* $>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 54* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* 5#*'5#D,##%'*4%h$C*

9(9(O!/+<%!+L!)2%!A,0.#%00!D+$%<!.#!+C%#!.##+71).+#!I&%B5=,#-.)*D=";(45%#*'%<54%'*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-*=4*B(-,%*D&%($5=4*$>&=,@>*$>%*,#%*=<*54$%&4(-* &%#=,&D%#* =<* (* D=";(4.C* VB%&* $5"%* >=d%B%&)* <5&"#* 545$5($%'* $>%* ;&=D%##* =<*=;%454@* ,;* $>%* 6=,4'(&5%#* =<* $>%5&* 6,#54%##* "='%-)* (#* $>%.* 6%@(4* $=* (4(-.#%* $>%*D=4$&56,$5=4*=<*#,;;-5%&#)*D,#$="%&#*(4'*=$>%&*#$(Q%>=-'%&#*54*E4* '=54@* #=)* D=";(45%#* D=,-'* 54D-,'%* %h$%&4(-* &%#=,&D%#* (#* K*6% ;<G=<4*4$2% 54* $>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*R3(4',--5*(4'*J>%#6&=,@>)*/00:SC*A5&"#*#$(&$*$=*#>(&%*54$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*d5$>* (* $>5&'* ;(&$.* $=* D&%($%* B(-,%)* =&* B5D%* B%&#()* <5&"#* (&%* 6%@54454@* $=* 54D=&;=&($%*%h$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*54*$>%5&*=d4*6,#54%##*"='%-C*O>%#%*4%d*6,#54%##*"='%-#*>(B%*6%%4*'%<54%'*6.*J>%#6&=,@>*R/008S*(#*<=*4%@+2)4*22%G<A*52.%3=)*(4(-=@=,#*$=*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4)*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*#;%D5<5D(--.*<=D,#*=4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*

%*V;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*%4(6-%*(4*=&@(45f($5=4*$=*6%*"=&%*%<<%D$5B%*54*D&%($54@*(#*d%--*(#*D(;$,&54@*B(-,%C*Y(-,%*D&%($5=4*5#*%#$(6-5#>%'*6.*-%B%&(@54@*"=&%*5'%(#*6%D(,#%*=<*$>%5&*54D-,#5=4* =<* (* B(&5%$.* =<* %h$%&4(-* D=4D%;$C* Y(-,%* D(;$,&54@* 5#* %4>(4D%'* 6.* ,$5-5f54@* (*

=$>% 8e*Z5D>$%4$(-%&)*/011SC*A5@,&%*/)*('=;$%'*<&="*

Page 19: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 1:*

J>%#6&=,@>*R/008S)*B5#,(-5f%#*$>%*;&=D%##*=<*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*&%@(&'54@*$=*B(-,%*D&%($5=4*(4'*D(;$,&54@C*!#*D(4*6%*#%%4)* $>%*D=#$#_*(4'*$5"%*#(B54@#*D&%($%*B(-,%*$=*$>%*<5&"*6.* -%B%&(@54@*%h$%&4(-*'%B%-=;"%4$C*O>%* -5D%4#54@)* #;54=<<#*(4'*#(-%#* D(;$,&%* $>%*4%d-.*D&%($%'*&%B%4,%#)*(*#,&;-,#*D=";(&%'*$=*$>%*"(&Q%$*&%B%4,%#*<&="*%h;-=5$54@*$>%*D-=#%'*6,#54%##*"='%-C**

*;,0Z&%'E'U'@WW%W'/"TZ%'()'(V%-'SZ#,-%##'1(W%T#'QCX%#S&(Z0XY'EOODR'

J&%($54@*(4'*D(;$,&54@* $>5#* #,&;-,#* 54*B(-,%* &%?,5&%#*%<<%D$5B%*(4'*%<<5D5%4$* #>(&54@*=<*&%#=,&D%#C* 3(4',--5* (4'* J>%#6&=,@>* R/00:S* '%#D&56%* <(D$=&#* $>($* #,;;=&$* &%#=,&D%#*#>(&54@*6%$d%%4*$d=*=&*"=&%*;(&$5%#)*6=$>*<&="*$>%*#$(4';=54$*=<*$>%*<5&"*$>($*'%D5'%#*$=*#>(&%*5$#*&%#=,&D%#*d5$>*=$>%&#*R$>%*#%--%&S)*(4'*<&="*$>%*;=54$*=<*$>%*<5&"*$>($*'%D5'%#*$=* ,#%* $>5&'_;(&$.* &%#=,&D%#* 54* 5$#* 6,#54%##* "='%-* R$>%* 6,.%&SC* A&="* (* *;%&#;%D$5B%)* =4%* =<* $>%* "=#$* 5";=&$(4$* <(D$=&#* 5#* "@2<#=$),** ;"=";)$6C* !DD=&'54@* $=*3(4',--5* (4'* J>%#6&=,@>* R/00:S* $>%* #,DD%##* =<* (* D=";(4.* $>($* '%D5'%#* $=* ,#%* $>5&'_;(&$.*&%#=,&D%#*'%;%4'#*=4*5$#*(65-5$.* $=*5'%4$5<.*&%#=,&D%#*$>($*D&%($%*B(-,%)*54$%@&($%*$>%"* d5$>* 54$%&4(-* &%#=,&D%#* (4'* %h;-=5$* $>%"C* J=";(45%#* d5--* 6%* "=&%* -5Q%-.* $=*54$%@&($%* %h$%&4(-* &%#=,&D%#* D="54@* <&="* $&,#$<,-* (4'* D=""5$$%'* ;(&$4%&#)* d>=*

#* #$&($%@.C* A,&$>%&"=&%)* $>%* B(-,%*D=4$&56,$5=4* #>=,-'*4=$*6%*,4D%&$(54*(4'* 5$* #>=,-'*6%*;=##56-%* $=*"%(#,&%* 5$C*!4=$>%&*

_54B%4$%'_ *=&*WET*#.4'&="%)*&%#,-$54@*54*&%g%D$5=4*=<*%h$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*=&*Q4=d-%'@%*6.*(*<5&")*#5";-.*6%D(,#%*5$*5#*4=$*54B%4$%'*54$%&4(--.C*O=* =B%&D="%* $>%* WET_#.4'&="%)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* 6%* ("65'%h$&=,#e* #5",-$(4%=,#-.*%"6&(D54@*",-$5;-%*D=4$&('5D$=&.*%-%"%4$#)*5C%C*"(4(@%*$>%*D>(--%4@%*=<*5";-%"%4$54@*(*4%d*6,#54%##*"='%-*4%h$*$=*$>%*%h5#$54@*=4%*RO&5;#(#*(4'*\(B%$$5)*/000SC*A&="*(*;%&#;%D$5B%)* (* <5&"* 5#*d5--54@* $=* #>(&%*(* &%#=,&D%*d5$>*(* $>5&'*;(&$.*d>%4*%h;-=5$54@*(*&%#=,&D%* 54* $>5&'* ;(&$.* 6,#54%##* "='%-#* @%4%&($%#* "=&%* B(-,%* $>(4* D=4#$&(5454@* $>%*

<5&"#*",#$* '%D5'%* $>%* '%@&%%* $=*d>5D>* $>%.* (&%*d5--54@* $=* #>(&%* $>%5&* &%#=,&D%#C* O>%*-%B%-*=<*;(&$4%&*$&,#$*(4'*-%@(-*;&=$%D$5=4*(&%*<(D$=&#*$>($*D(4*>%-;*(*<5&"*54*'%$%&"5454@*$>%*'%@&%%*=<*54<=&"($5=4*#>(&54@C**

9(9(P!:+#-<,0.+#!O>5#* ;(&$* =<* $>%* $>%#5#* >(#* #.#$%"($5D(--.* (;;&=(D>%'* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)*#$(&$54@*d5$>*<54'54@*D=4#%4#,#*54*$>%*'%<545$5=4*=<*(*6,#54%##*"='%-C*!#* $,&4%'* =,$)*=4%* =<* $>%*"=#$*d5'%-.*,#%'* '%<545$5=4#* 5#* $>%* =4%* =<*V#$%&d(-'%&* (4'*

Page 20: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /0*

"%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%A*2;#)@*2%$E*%#"$)<4"5*% <F% E<-% "4% <#:"4)>"$)<4% ;#*"$*2X% A*5),*#2% "4A% ;"=$+#*2% ,"5+* C* J=4D%&454@*6,#54%##*"='%-* )44<,"$)<4X%J(-B(D(4$%* %$* (-C* R/011S* '%#D&56%* <=,&* ;&=D%##%#7* D&%($5=4)*%h$%4#5=4)*&%B5#5=4*(4'*$%&"54($5=4C* E";-%"%4$($5=4*=<* 6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4*D(4*6%*(D>5%B%'*B5(*%h;%&5"%4$($5=4)*%<<%D$,($5=4*=&*=&@(45f($5=4(-*-%('%&#>5;*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC* A54(--.)* $=* (4#d%&* $>%* <5&#$* #,6_ _E"$% )2% <=*4% @+2)4*22% G<A*5%)44<,"$)<4R/008SC*V;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4*&%<%&#*$=*$>%*,#%*=<*%h$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*(#*K*6%;<G=<4*4$2%54*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*R3(4',--5*(4'*J>%#6&=,@>)*/00:SC*A5&"#*#$(&$*$=*#>(&%*54$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*d5$>*(*$>5&'*;(&$.*$=*D&%($%*B(-,%)*=&*B5D%*B%&#()*<5&"#*(&%*6%@54454@*$=*54D=&;=&($%*%h$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*54*$>%5&*=d4*6,#54%##*"='%-*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/008SC***O(Q54@* 54$=*(DD=,4$* $>%* <(D$=&#* $>($* #,;;=&$* #>(&54@* &%#=,&D%#)*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*D(4* %B%4* -%('* $=* D==;%&($5=4*d5$>* D=";%$5$=&#* R3(4',--5* (4'*J>%#6&=,@>)*/00:SC* O>5#*D==;%&($5=4*D(4*6%*g,#$5<5%'*6.*$>%*4%%'*$=*=6$(54*#.4%&@5%#*6%$d%%4*&%#=,&D%#*RK(#*(4'*O%4@)*/000SC*3=)*=;%4* 544=B($5=4)*(4'*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*"=&%*#;%D5<5D(--.)*>(#*$>%*;=$%4$5(-* $=* D=4$&56,$%* $=* #.4%&@.*D&%($5=4*6%$d%%4* $d=*D=--(6=&($54@* <5&"#C*O>%*4%h$*;(&$*=<*$>5#*$>%#5#*d5--*%-(6=&($%*=4*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*#.4%&@.C*

9(>!B=#%*@=!O>5#* ;(&$* =<* $>%* $>%#5#* '%#D&56%#* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<* #.4%&@.* 54* '%$(5-* (4'* (5"#* ($* <54'54@*D=4#%4#,#*6%$d%%4*$>%*"(4.*$.;=-=@5%#*;&%#%4$*54*-5$%&($,&%C*E$*#$(&$#*d5$>*;&=B5'54@*(4*=B%&B5%d* =<* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@5%#* '5#D,##%'* 6.* &%#%(&D>%&#* =B%&* $>%* .%(&#C* W%h$)* $>%#%*$.;=-=@5%#*(&%*(4(-.#%'*$=*#%%*5<*D=4#%4#,#*6%$d%%4*$>%"*6(#%'*=4*$>%5&*'%<545$5=4#*D(4*6%* <=,4')* 54*=&'%&* $=* <=&",-($%*(* D=";&%>%4#5B%* $.;=-=@.*@&=,4'%'* 54* -5$%&($,&%* $>($*d5--* 6%* ,#%'* 54* $>%* &%"(54'%&* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#C* T%&%(<$%&)* $>%* D&%($5=4* =<* #.4%&@.* 5#*'5#D,##%')*<=--=d%'*6.*(4*(4(-.#5#*=<*$>%*;=##56-%*'5#('B(4$(@%#*<5&"#*"5@>$*%4D=,4$%&*d>5-%*D>(#54@*#.4%&@.C**

9(>('!K2%!-+#-%C)!+L!0=#%*@=!*"%(454@*g=54$*

d=&Q54@)*d=&Q54@* $=@%$>%&)* D=--(6=&($5=4* =&* D==;%&($5=4* R\==-'* (4'*J(";6%--)* 1::9SC*H54@* %$* (-C* R/00])* ;C199S* '%#D&56%* $E*%;<4;*=$%$E"$%$E*%2+G%<F%G*#:)4:%$-<%

* !-$>=,@>* $>5#*'%<545$5=4* 5<*B5%d%'*54*$>%* -5@>$*=<*"%&@54@*$d=*<5&"#)* $>%*'%<545$5=4)* (4'*%#;%D5(--.* $>%*D=-=,&<,-*d(.*=<*#(.54@*R5C%C*/k/m[S)*#;%(Q#*$=*$>%*5"(@54($5=4C*X&,4=&5*(4'*G=##5*R/000)*

$5$5%#)*d>=#%* g=54$* %<<=&$*;&=',D%#* ?,(4$5$($5B%-.* (4'* ?,(-5$($5B%-.* >5@>%&* %<<%D$#* $>(4* $>=#%* ;&=',D%'* 6.* $>%*

(4'*T(&&5#=4*R1:::S*(-#=*'%#D&56%*$>($*#.4%&@.*%h5#$#*d>%4*$>%*B(-,%*=<*$>%*D="654%'*%4$5$.* %hD%%'#* $>%* #,"* =<* B(-,%#* =<* $>%* $d=* <5&"#* 54* 5#=-($5=4C* A54(--.)* \==-'* (4'*J(";6%--* R1::9S* -==Q*($* $>%* D=4D%;$*=<* #.4%&@.*(#* $>%*(65-5$.*=<* $d=*=&*"=&%*,45$#*=&*<5&"#*$=*@%4%&($%*@&%($%&*B(-,%*d=&Q54@*$=@%$>%&*$>(4* $>%*#,"*=<*$>%5&*B(-,%#*D=,-'*6%*d>%4*d=&Q54@*(;(&$C***A=&*;&(D$5D(-*=&*"(4(@%&5(-*;,&;=#%#*>=d%B%&)*$>%#%*'%<545$5=4#*&%"(54*&($>%&*(6#$&(D$C*A,&$>%&"=&%)*$>%=&%$5D(--.*@&=,4'%'*$.;=-=@5%#*=<*6,#54%##*#.4%&@5%#*(&%*-(&@%-.*(6#%4$*54*-5$%&($,&%C*O>5#*5#*(-#=*(DQ4=d-%'@%'*6.*H4=--*R/009S)*d>=*D=4#5'%&#*"=#$*$.;=-=@5%#*(&65$&(&.* (4'* -(DQ54@* (4.* <=&"* =<* D-(##5<5D($5=4* D&5$%&5(* =&* $>%=&%$5D(-* @&=,4'54@C* E4*=&'%&* $=* D=4$&56,$%* $=* D-=#54@* $>5#* @(;)* $>5#* ;(&$* =<* $>%* $>%#5#* d5--* #$(&$* d5$>* (*

Page 21: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /1*

D=";&%>%4#5B%* -5#$* =<* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@5%#* '5#D,##%'* 6.* #%B%&(-* #D>=-(&#* (&&(4@%'* ;%&*.%(&*R$(6-%*]SC*!#*D(4*6%*#%%4)*$>%*B(&5=,#*#.4%&@.*<=&"#*(&%*#D($$%&%'*$>&=,@>=,$*"(4.*$.;=-=@5%#)*d>5D>* 5--,#$&($%#* $>%* -(DQ*=<* D=4#%4#,#*6%$d%%4* #D>=-(&#C*O>%#%* $.;=-=@5%#*d5--*6%*'%#D&56%'*54*'%$(5-*54*(4*($$%";$*$=*<54'*D=4#%4#,#*6%$d%%4*$>%"*(4'*;&=B5'%*(*$.;=-=@.*@&=,4'%'*54*-5$%&($,&%*$>($*D=B%&#*$>%*"(4.*$.;%#*=<*#.4%&@.*54*$(6-%*]C*9"ST%'L'U'*[-%&0['$[V(T(0,%#'"&&"-0%W'V%&'[%"&''

9[V%'()'*[-%&0['

@-#())'QBMN?R'

CX"$$%&_%%'QBMPNR'

J,-W'`'!"X"_"-'QBMPPR'

*+X^%,0%&''`'I%&['QEOO7R'

a"VT"-'`'2(&$(-'QEOONR'

G%&#"ZW'QEOO?R'

a-(TT'QEOOPR'

@Z#$,-'`'8%(-"&W'QEOOPR'

.-/%#$1%-$'' * * *;,-"-+,"T'' * * *C(#$'S"#%W' ' ' ' ' ' '>%/%-Z%'S"#%W'

' ' ' ' ' '*"T%#' * *C(TTZ#,/%' * *!"&b%$'V(^%&'' * *CZ#$(1%&' * *:V%&"$,-0'

:V%&"$,(-"T'

.-$%&-"T'

:V%&"$,/%' * *!"-"0%&,"T'' * * * *!"-"0%1%-$'

*$&"$%0,+' * * * *.--(/"$,/%'V&(),+,%-+['

* * * *

C(&V(&"$%'!"-"0%1%-$'8%"&-,-0'`'<&(^$X''a-(^T%W0%'!"-"0%1%-$'

* * * *

:&06'T%"&-,-0'

*3$(&$54@* d5$>* $>%* #%"54(-* d=&Q* =<* !4#=<<* R1:`[S)* d>=* '5<<%&%4$5($%#* 6%$d%%4* #(-%#*#.4%&@.)*=;%&($54@*#.4%&@.)*54B%#$"%4$*#.4%&@.*(4'*"(4(@%&5(-*#.4%&@.)*H4=--*R/009)*;C*

=#<=*#% A*F)4)$)<42X% ;5"22)F);"$)<4% ;#)$*#)"% <#%C* !-$>=,@>* !4#=<

@&=,4'54@)* 5$* '=%#* #%&B%* (#* $>%* 6(#5#* <=&* "(4.* =<* $>%* $.;=-=@5%#* '%B%-=;%'* =B%&* $>%*.%(&#)* (#*d5--* D="%* <=&d(&'* 54* $>5#* $>%#5#C* O>%* 2"5*2* #.4%&@.*!4#=<<* R1:`[S* '%#D&56%#)*=DD,&#* d>%4* '5<<%&%4$* ;&=',D$#* ,#%* D=""=4* '5#$&56,$5=4* D>(44%-#)* D=""=4* #(-%#*('"545#$&($5=4)* =&* D=""=4* d(&%>=,#54@C* P=*#"$)<4"5% #.4%&@.* 54D-,'%#* >5@>%&*,$5-5f($5=4* =<* <(D5-5$5%#* (4'* ;%&#=44%-)* #;&%('54@* =<* =B%&>%(')* ('B(4$(@%#* =<* D=""=4*-%(&454@* D,&B%#*(4'*#>(&%'*;,&D>(#54@C* ?4,*2$G*4$%264*#:6%5#* $>%* &%#,-$*=<* g=54$*,#%*=<*;-(4$)* D=""=4* &(d* "($%&5(-#* 54B%4$=&5%#)* $&(4#<%&* =<* GPK)* (4'* D=""=4* ,#%* =<*"(D>54%&.C* A54(--.)* G"4":*#)"5% 264*#:6% 5#* (D>5%B%'* d>%4* <5&"#* <(D%* #$&($%@5D)*=&@(45f($5=4(-*=&*=;%&($54@*;&=6-%"#)*d>5D>*(&%* #5"5-(&* $=*;&=6-%"#* $>($*"(4(@%"%4$*>(#*'%(-$*d5$>*54*$>%*;(#$C**Od=*'%D('%#*-($%&)*J>($$%&g%%*R1:9`S*'%B%-=;%'*(*$.;=-=@.)*54*d>5D>*>%*(&@,%#*<=&*$>%*

Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Michiel
Page 22: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* //*

D=--,#5B%)* =;%&($5=4(-* (4'* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@5%#C* J=--,#5B%* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* ;&5D%* &%-($%'*#.4%&@5%#*54B=-B54@*$>%*D-(##*=<*&%#=,&D%#*-%('54@*$=*"(&Q%$*;=d%&)*#5"5-(&*$=*$>%*#(-%#*#.4%&@.* =<* !4#=<<* R1:`[S* V;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@5%#* &%;&%#%4$* $>%* D-(##* =<* &%#=,&D%#* $>($*-%('* $=* ;&=',D$5=4b('"545#$&($5B%* %<<5D5%4D5%#)* d>%&%(#* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@5%#* &%;&%#%4$*$>%* D-(##* =<* &%#=,&D%#* $>($* -%('#* $=* &%',D$5=4* 54* D=#$#* =<* D(;5$(-C* O>%* =;%&($5=4(-* (4'*

`[S*=;%&($54@*(4'*54B%#$"%4$*#.4%&@5%#)*&%#;%D$5B%-.C***^54'* (4'* F(>(g(4* R1:99S* '%B%-=;%'* (* #5"5-(&* $.;=-=@.* (-"=#$* #5",-$(4%=,#-.* d5$>*J>($$%&g%%*R1:9`SC*O>%*$>5&'*$.;=-=@.*=<*$>5#*$>%#5#*'5<<%&%4$5($%#*6%$d%%4*<=,&*$.;%#*=<*#.4%&@.*D=4#5#$54@*=<*#%B%&(-* *

O"5*2% 264*#:6)* D=4#5#$54@* =<* D=""=4* '5#$&56,$5=4* D>(44%-#)* D=""=4* #(-%#*('"545#$&($5=4)*D=""=4*#(-%#*<=&D%*(4'*;&="=$5=4)*D=""=4*"(&Q%$*#%@"%4$#)*%$DC** P=*#"$)4:%O64*#:.7*D=4#5#$54@*=<*#>(&%'*<(D5-5$5%#*(4'*;%&#=44%-)*#>(&%'*=B%&>%(')*#>(&%'*;,&D>(#54@)*%$DC*** ?4,*2$G*4$%264*#:67*D=4#5#$54@*=<*g=54$*,#%*=<*;-(4$*(4'*%?,5;"%4$)*D=""=4*&(d*"($%&5(-*54B%4$=&5%#)*#>(&%'*GPK*(4'*%4@54%%&54@)*%$DC*** R"4":*G*4$%O64*#:67* D=4#5#$54@*=<* &5#Q* &%',D$5=4)* $>%*(65-5$.*$=*@%4%&($%*6%$$%&*#$&($%@5%#)*#>(&%'*&%#=,&D%#)*%$DC***!* 4=$(6-%* %hD%;$5=4* =4* $>%* D=""%4$* =<* H4=--* R/009S)* (-$>=,@>* 4=$*"%4$5=4%'* 54* >5#*#$,'.)* 5#* $>%* $.;=-=@.*=<*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4* R/00`S)*d>=*'%#D&56%* #.4%&@.* 54* $%&"#*=<*6,#54%##*+4)$*#.4%&@.)*&($>%&*$>(4*6,#54%##*G<A*5*#.4%&@.C*T=d%B%&)*-5Q%*$>%*54$%4$5=4*=<* (* 6,#54%##*"='%-)* $>%.*"%4$5=4* $>($* $>%* 54$%4$5=4* =<* $>%* 6,#54%##* ,45$* 5#* $=* D&%($%*;&=',D$#* (4'b=&* #%&B5D%#* $>($* =<<%&* (* ,45?,%* '5<<%&%4$5($%'*"5h* =<* 6%4%<5$#)* D(--%'* $>%*

R565')* ;C]SC* O>%5&* $.;=-=@.* 5#* 6(#%'* =4* (* #%$* =<* D&=##_6,#54%##* =6g%D$5B%#* 54$%4'%'* $=* D&%($%* B(-,%)* $>%* *4$*#=#)2*% ,"5+*% =#<=<2)$)<4.% O>%.*'%#D&56%*<=,&*$.;%#*=<*B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4#*(&=,4'*d>5D>*6,#54%##*,45$#*D=";%$%7**

J*2$%$<$"5%;<2$2% %6,#54%##* ,45$#* =<<%&* ;&=',D$#* (4'* #%&B5D%#* $>($* (&%* D=4#5#$%4$)*$5"%-.*(4'*>(B%*-=d*D=#$#C*

!#<A+;$%5*"A*#% %6,#54%##*,45$#*=<<%&*;&=',D$#*(4'*#%&B5D%#*$>($*%h;(4'*%h5#$54@*;%&<=&"(4D%*6=,4'(&5%#C*

1+2$<G*#% 2<5+$)<42% %6,#54%##* ,45$#%;&=B5'%* (* D,#$="5f%'*"5h* =<* ;&=',D$#* (4'*#%&B5D%#)*D="654%'*d5$>*Q4=d_ *

O62$*G%=5"$F<#G% %6,#54%##* ,45$#* ;&=B5'%* (* ;-($<=&"* $>($* 6%D="%#* $>%* 54',#$&.*#$(4'(&'*<=&*=<<%&54@*;&=',D$#*(4'*#%&B5D%C***V6B5=,#-.)*$>%&%*(&%*"(g=&*#5"5-(&5$5%#*d5$>*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*D-(##5<5D($5=4*=<*O&%(D.*(4'*^5%&#%"(* R1::2SC* O>%* $>&%%* $.;%#* =<* B(-,%* ;&=;=#5$5=4* R6%#$* $=$(-* D=#$#)* ;&=',D$*-%('%&*(4'*D,#$="%&* #=-,$5=4S*=<*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4* R/00`S*D(4*%(#5-.*6%* &%;-(D%'*6.*

-%('%&#>5;*(4'*D,#$="%&*54$5"(D.)*&%#;%D$5B%-.C*V4-.*$>%*-(#$*B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4)*$>%*#.#$%"*;-($<=&")*>(#*4=$*6%%4*'%#D&56%'*6.*O&%(D.*(4'*^5%&#%"(* R1::2SC*T=d%B%&)*=4%* D=,-'*(&@,%* $>($* $=*6%D="%*$>%* 4%d* 54',#$&.* #$(4'(&')* <5&"#* #>=,-'* '%-5B%&* B(-,%* 54*=4%* =<* $>%* $>&%%* =$>%&* B(-,%*

=5"$F<#G%5*"A*#2E)=%"4A%;<G=5*G*4$"#6%)44<,"$)<4%"#*%4<$%$E)4:2%$E"$%E"==*4%2=<4$"4*<+256%)4%"4%)4A+2$#6 ,%*6.*"(Q54@*5$*'5<<5D,-$*<=&*=$>%&#*$=* 5"5$($%* $>%5&* ;&=',D$#C* 3=)* #54D%* 6,#54%##* ,45$#* >(B%* #5"5-(&* ;,&;=#%#* (4'* B(-,%*

Page 23: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /2*

+4)$2*'%#D&56%'*6.*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4*R/00`S*D(4*6%*#%%4*(#*D=4@&,%4$*$=*#.4%&@5%#*(&5#54@*<&="*6,#54%##*G<A*5*(-5@4"%4$C*O>%*<=,&*<=&"#*=<*D=&;=&($%*#.4%&@.*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4*R/00`S*'%#D&56%*(&%7*** Q)4"4;)"5%O64*#:6% %54B=-B%#*5##,%#*(#*d>%&%*$=*54B%#$)*d>%&%*$=*>(&B%#$*(4'*>=d*$=* D&%($%*(4* 54B%#$=&*6&(4'C* E$* D&%($%#*B(-,%*6.* 5$#* (65-5$.* $=*(--=D($%* D(;5$(-* ("=4@* 5$#*

G<#*%*FF*;$),*%"4A%*FF);)*4$%$E"4%)F%*";E%"+$<4<G<+2%;<G="46%-*#*%"4%)4A*=*4A*4$%"4A%=+@5);%<-4*A%;<G="46 ** 1+2$<G*#%O64*#:6% %6.* %h;(4'54@* $>%* "(&Q%$* "%##(@%)* D=&;=&($5=4#* D(4* 6&54@*",-$5;-%*;&=',D$#*=<*#%B%&(-*6,#54%##*,45$#*$=*$>%*D,#$="%&)*$>%&%6.*54D&%(#54@*&%B%4,%*;%&* D,#$="%&* 6.* D&=##_#%--54@C* A,&$>%&"=&%)* ;=##56-%* #$(4'(&'5f($5=4* D=4$&56,$%#* $=* (*D=4#5#$%4$*D,#$="%&*%h;%&5%4D%)*d>5D>*&%54<=&D%#*(4'*%4>(4D%#*$>%*D=&;=&($%*6&(4'C*** ?4$*#4"5%O64*#:6* *-(&@%*<5&"#*>(B%*$>%*=;;=&$,45$.*$=*D&%($%*%D=4="5%#*=<*#D(-%)*d>5D>* %4>(4D%#* D=";%$5$5B%* ('B(4$(@%* (4'* #>(&%>=-'%&* B(-,%C* A5&"#* D(4* D&%($%* #D(-%*%D=4="5%#*6.*%h("5454@*D=""=4*;&=D%##%#*&%?,5&%'*6.*",-$5;-%*6,#54%##*,45$#C*** (*"#4)4:%"4A%`#<-$E%O64*&@.* *$>%*'%B%-=;"%4$*(4'*#>(&54@*=<*54$(4@56-%*(##%$#7*;%=;-%)* $%D>4=-=@.)* D,-$,&%* (4'* -%('%&#>5;C* O>%#%* (##%$#* ;&%#%4$* (4* =;;=&$,45$.* $=* 6%*"(4(@%'*54*#,D>*(*d(.*$>($*$>%.*D&%($%*#.4%&@.*(4'*#,#$(54%'*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%C**

D&%($5=4*6%$d%%4*GPK*'%;(&$"%4$#*54*<5&"#*#>=d*$>%*<=--=d54@*#.4%&@5%#7*O$#"$*:);%MY9%264*#:6e*$>%*%h$%4$*$=*d>5D>*D=--(6=&($5=4#*("=4@*GPK*,45$#*&%#,-$*

54*(4*54D&%(#%*54*$>%5&*;(&$5D5;($5=4*54*(*-(&@%&*4,"6%&*=<*D=";-%h*GPK*;&=g%D$#*R"4":*#)"5%"4A%P=*#"$)<4"5%264*#:67*$>%*%h$%4$*$=*d>5D>*$>%*%<<5D5%4D.*=<*$>%*GPK*

D=--(6=&($5B%-.*d5$>*=$>%&*,45$#C*S4<-5*A:*% G"4":*G*4$% 264*#:6* 5#* $>%* (65-5$.* =<* GPK* ,45$#* $=* >(&4%##* (4'*

-%B%&(@%* Q4=d-%'@%)* 5'%(#)* ;%=;-%)* $%D>4=-=@.)* (4'* =&@(45f($5=4(-* D=";%$%4D5%#* (4'*#.#$%"#*<=&*$>%*D&%($5=4*=<*4%d)*"=&%*#,DD%##<,-*544=B($5=4#*

?44<,"$),*%=#<F);)*4;6* 5#* $>%* (65-5$.* $=* '%B%-=;* (4'* %h;-=5$* 4%d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

Page 24: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /]*

*;,0Z&%'7'U'C&(##USZ#,-%##'#[-%&0,%#'Q"W(V$%W')&(1'a-(TTY'EOOPR'

O>%*"(&Q%$*;=d%&*#.4%&@5%#*(4'*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@5%#*=<*H4=--*R/009S*(&%*?,5$%*#5"5-(&*$=*$>%* D,#$="%&* (4'* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@5%#* ;&%B5=,#-.*"%4$5=4%'* (4'*d5--* $>%&%<=&%* 4=$* 6%*'5#D,##%'* 54* '%$(5-C* O>%* <=*#"$),** (4'* ;<#=<#"$**G"4":*G*4$* #.4%&@5%#* =4* $>%* =$>%&*>(4')*(&%*'5#$54D$5B%*(4'*d5--*$>%&%<=&%*6%*%-(6=&($%'*,;=4C**V;%&($5B%* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* '%&5B%'* <&="* =;%&($5B%* &%#=,&D%#* (4'* 54D&%(#%* *FF);)*4;6* (4'*=#<F)$"@5** :#<-$EC* O>%* &%#=,&D%#* &%<%&* $=* ;&=',D$* Q4=d-%'@%)* ;&=',D$* D=";=4%4$#)*;&=',D$5=4*;-(4$#)*%$DC*V;%&($5B%*#.4%&@5%#*(&%*D-(##5<5%'*54*R1S*%<<5D5%4D.*#.4%&@5%#*(4'*R/S*@&=d$>*#.4%&@5%#)*d>5D>*6=$>*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*4%h$C***R1S* N<<5D5%4D.* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* %<<5D5%4D.* ('B(4$(@%#* =<* <5&"#* <&="* #>(&54@* =;%&($5B%*&%#=,&D%#* 54* =&'%&* $=* &%',D%* D=#$#* RH4=--)* /009SC* O>%#%* ('B(4$(@%#)* (-#=* D(--%'*%D=4="5%#*=<*#D=;%X* -E*4%F<#%"55%<+$=+$2%$E*%;<2$%<F%V<)4$%=#<A+;$)<4%)2%5*22%$E"4%$E*%;<2$2% <F% =#<A+;)4:% *";E% <+$=+$% 2*="#"$*56 //]SC* ND=4="5%#* =<* #D=;%*@%4%&(--.*(&5#%*<&="*#>(&54@*=&*g=54$*,$5-5f($5=4*=<*&%#=,&D%#*<=&*;&=',D$5=4*R\5"%4=*(4'*^==)* 1:::S)* #54D%* $>5#* -%('#* $=* -=d%&* g=54$* ;&=',D$5=4* D=#$#* 6.* ;,$$54@* ,4'%&,$5-5f%'*&%#=,&D%#*$=*;&=',D$5B%*,#%*RI(4f(&*(4'*^5--5@)*1:91SC*X%#5'%#*$>%*;&=',D$5=4*;&=D%##)*#D=;%* %D=4="5%#* "(.* (-#=* =DD,&* 54* =$>%&* B(-,%* D>(54* (D$5B5$5%#)* #,D>* (#* GPK* RH4=--)*/009S* (4'* "(.* 54B=-B%* 54$(4@56-%* &%#=,&D%#* #,D>* (#* &%;,$($5=4* =&* 6%#$* ;&(D$5D%#*R3f,-(4#Q5)* 1::2SC* A5&"#* D(4* $&(4#<%&* "(4.* Q54'#* =<* &%#=,&D%#* $=* (D>5%B%* %<<5D5%4D.*#.4%&@5%#)*#=*5$*5#*B5&$,(--.*5";=##56-%*$=*;&=B5'%*(4*%h>(,#$5B%*-5#$*RH4=--)*/009SC**R/S* \&=d$>* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* ;&=<5$(6-%* @&=d$>* ('B(4$(@%#* <&="* R&%SD="65454@* (4'*$&(4#<%&&54@* D=";-%"%4$(&.* &%#=,&D%#* (D&=##* 6,#54%##* RH4=--)* /009SC* ^>%&%(#*%<<5D5%4D.*#.4%&@5%#*(&%*&%<-%D$%'*(#*;<2$%#*A+;$)<42)*@&=d$>*#.4%&@5%#*(&%*%h;&%##%'*6.*#*,*4+***4E"4;*G*4$2*=&* ,"5+"@5*%#*,*4+*%2+=*#3"AA)$),)$)*2 O>%.*%h5#$* 5<* $>%*$=$(-*&%B%4,%*<&="*,$5-5f54@*$>%*&%#=,&D%#*=<* $d=*<5&"#*$=@%$>%&*d5$>54*=4%*<5&"*%hD%%'#*$>%*D="654%'*&%B%4,%*<&="*,$5-5f54@*$>%* 54'5B5',(-*&%#=,&D%#* 54*'5<<%&%4$*<5&"#* RH4=--)* /009SC* J=4$&(&.* $=* %<<5D5%4D.* #.4%&@5%#* &%#,-$54@* <&="* #$($5D* &%#=,&D%*#>(&54@)* @&=d$>* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* 6(#%'* =4* '.4("5D* R&%SD="654($5=4#* =<* D=";-%"%4$(&.*&%#=,&D%#*(D&=##* <5&"#* $=* D(;$,&%*"(&Q%$*=;;=&$,45$5%#* RO(4&5B%&'5* (4'*Y%4Q($&("(4)*/00[e* N5#%4>(&'$* (4'* F(&$54)* /000SC* 3=)* @&=d$>* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* (D>5%B%'* $>&=,@>*D="65454@*&%#=,&D%#*R%C@C*;&=',D$*Q4=d-%'@%*=&*D,#$="%&*Q4=d-%'@%S*(D&=##*<5&"#*54$=*#=-,$5=4#*$=*;&=B5'%*,45?,%*D,#$="%&*B(-,%*RH4=--)*/009SC*

Page 25: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /[*

*O=* D-(&5<.* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<* =;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@5%#)* $(6-%* [* ;&=B5'%#* (* D=";(&5#=4* =<* $>%*'5<<%&%4D%#*6%$d%%4*%<<5D5%4D.*(4'*@&=d$>*#.4%&@5%#C*!-$>=,@>*'5<<%&%4$)*$>%#%*#.4%&@5%#*(&%*4=$*",$,(--.*%hD-,#5B%*(4'*<&%?,%4$-.*=DD,&*$=@%$>%&*RH4=--)*/009SC**9"ST%'?'U'3,))%&%-+%#'S%$^%%-'%)),+,%-+[U'"-W'0&(^$X'#[-%&0,%#'QS"#%W'(-'a-(TTY'EOOPR'

! EC%*1).7%!B=#%*@.%05!!""#$#%&$'()'&%*+#%,(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((-*./01()'&%*+#%,!

4*.D1*=!RLL%-)! <2.$&*0&4'&--(.(&2.R' <2.$&*0&4'$&7&29&0':+#-%C),1<.F1).+#! N#0%'091>*44(%(7(%(&0' =&7&29&'09/&$>*44(%(7(%(&0'4*.D1*=!S1<,%!?*.7%*! O/&$*%(#2*8'&--(.(&2.R' N90%#)&$'9%(8(%RG'(22#7*%(#2'/%1<.F1).+#!T%-21#.0D! J$*20-&$'#-'0()(8*$'$&0#9$.&0'*.$#00'

190(2&00&0'N#)1(2*%(#2'#-'.#)/8&)&2%*$R'$&0#9$.&0'*.$#00'190(2&00&0'

R&1DC<%0! !"*$&4'0*8&0'-#$.&G'.&2%$*8'/$#49.%(#2'/8*2%'

N$#00>190(2&00'0#89%(#20G'2&6'/$#49.%0'-$#)'.#)1(2&4'$&0#9$.&0'

'O>%'D=&;=&($%*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@5%#*=<*H4=--*R/009S'(&%*(*$.;%*=<*#.4%&@5%#*$>($*#$%"*<&="* -%B%&(@54@* D=&;=&($%* "(4(@%"%4$* D(;(65-5$5%#C* O>%#%* D(4* 6%* %4$&%;&%4%,&5(-*D(;(65-5$5%#)* D(;(65-5$5%#* 54*=&@(45f($5=4*'%#5@4*(4'*#,;%&5=&* #$&($%@5D* D(;(65-5$5%#* RT5--*(4'* +=4%#)* /008SC* \==-')* J(";6%--* (4'* !-%h(4'%&* R1::])* ;C`S* (@&%%* $>($* D=&;=&($%*"(4(@%"%4$*&%#=,&D%#*(&%*Q%.*$=*#,DD%##7* ?$%)2%$E*%iD=&;=&($%j%="#*4$%$E"$%A*;)A*2%-E"$%4*-%@+2)4*22*2%$<%2+==<#$X%-E"$%";a+)2)$)<42%$<%G"K*X%"4A%-E*$E*#%$<%F<#G%V<)4$%,*4$+#*2%"4A%"55)"4;*2.%?$%)2%$E*%="#*4$%$E"$%A*$*#G)4*2%$E*%2$#+;$+#*%<F%$E*%;<#=<#"$)<4X%A*F)4*2%$E*%@+A:*$)4:%"4A%;"=)$"5% *U=*4A)$+#*%=#<;*22*2X%"4A% 2*$2% $E*% $<4*% F<#% ;<#=<#"$*% ,"5+*2%"4A%"$$)$+A*2.% %DE*%="#*4$%)2%"$%$E*%E*"#$%<F%;<#=<#"$*%2$#"$*:6%A*;)2)<42.%P+#%"==#<";E%$<%;<#=<#"$*%2$#"$*:6%$E*#*F<#*%=5";*2%$E*%#<5*%<F% $E*%="#*4$% )4%;*4$*#% 3=)* D=&;=&($%*"(4(@%&#*#>=,-'*6%*(6-%*$=*@(54*(4*,4'%&#$(4'54@*=<*>=d*%(D>*#.4%&@.*545$5($5B%*#>=,-'*6%*5";-%"%4$%'*(4'*%h%D,$%')*$>%&%6.*<=&"54@*(*$.;%*=<*#.4%&@.*=4*5$#*=d4C***!-$>=,@>*H4=--*R/009S*(&@,%#*$=*<5--*$>%*@(;*54*-5$%&($,&%*D&%($%'*6.*(&65$&(&.*'%<545$5=4#*(4'*D-(##5<5D($5=4*D&5$%&5()*<=&*"=&%*$>(4*]0*.%(&#*#D>=-(&#*@%4%&(--.*>(B%*(@&%%'*,;=4*$>%*'5<<%&%4$* $.;%#*=<* #.4%&@.C*T=d%B%&)* $>%&%* 5#* (4=$>%&* &%#%(&D>* #$&%("* $>($*'5B5'%#*#.4%&@.*54*(*'5<<%&%4$*d(.)*4("%-.*%<<5D5%4D5%#*(4'*%4>(4D%"%4$#)*$=*D=B%&*<=&*6=$>*D=#$*#(B54@#* (4'* B(-,%* %4>(4D54@* #.4%&@5%#* Rl(>%%&* %$* (-C)* /012SC* A,&$>%&"=&%)* (*D="654($5=4* 6%$d%%4* 6=$>* &%#%(&D>* #$&%("#* D(4* 6%* <=,4')* %C@C* !,#$54* (4'* Z%=4(&'*R/009S* d>=* '%<54%* #.4%&@5%#* (#* D=#$_6(#%'* #.4%&@5%#)* &%B%4,%_6(#%'* #.4%&@5%#* (4'*=&@(45f($5=4(-* -%(&454@C* 3D>d%5@%&* (4'* Y%&.* R/002S* (''*"(&Q%$* ;=d%&* #.4%&@5%#* (4'*54$(4@56-%#* R<=&* 54#$(4D%* Q4=d-%'@%* #>(&54@S* $=* $>%* (-&%('.* "%4$5=4%'* D=#$_* (4'*&%B%4,%_ *@&=d$>*(4'*%<<5D5%4D.*#.4%&@5%#*(-#=*D=B%&#*$>%#%*D=#$_*(4'*&%B%4,%_6(#%'*#.4%&@5%#C***3=)* 5$* #>=d#* $>($*=B%&* <=,&*'%D('%#*=<*&%#%(&D>* &%#,-$%'* 54* #%B%&(-* D>(4@%#* 54*R1:`[S*'%<545$5=4#C*O>%*"=#$* 5";=&$(4$* D>(4@%* 5#* $>%*(''5$5=4*=<*=4%* $.;%*=<* #.4%&@.e*%"%&@54@*<&="*$>%*.%(&*/000*K4<-5*A:*%G"4":*G*4$%264*#:6%>(#*"('%*5$#*%4$&(4D%*54*#%B%&(-*$.;=-=@5%#*R54*$>%*d=&Q*=<*H(;-(4*P*W=&$=4)*/00`e*I%&#(,')*/00[*(4'*!,#$54*P*Z%=4(&')* /009SC* A=&* (* D=";-%$%* =B%&B5%d* =<* $>%* '5<<%&%4$* #.4%&@.* $.;%#* (4'* $>%5&*(4(-.#5#)* #%%* (;;%4'5h* EEEC* O>5#* (;;%4'5h* #>=d#* $>%* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@5%#* (&&(4@%'* 6.*(,$>=&)* <=--=d%'* 6.* $>%* '%<545$5=4#* =<* %(D>* #.4%&@.* $.;%C* O>%* "(4.* $.;=-=@5%#* (&%*D=";(&%'*$=*%(D>*=$>%&)*$=*#%%*5<*D=4#%4#,#*6%$d%%4*$>%*#D>=-(&-.*d=&Q#*D(4*6%*<=,4'C*!#* (* &%#,-$)* (--* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* &%',D%'* $=* =4%* =B%&(&D>54@* $.;=-=@.* D=4#5#$54@* =<* <5B%*'5<<%&%4$* #.4%&@.* <=&"#* $>($* $=@%$>%&* D=B%&* $>%* '%<545$5=4#* <=,4'* 54* $>%=&.C* O>5#*

Page 26: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /`*

$.;=-=@.*D(4*6%* <=,4'* 54*$(6-%*`*(4'* 5#*;&5"(&5-.*6(#%'*=4* $>%*#%"54(-*d=&Q*=<*!4#=<<*R1:`[S)* D=";-%$%'* 6.* (4* (4(-.#5#* =<* ]0* .%(&#* =<* &%#%(&D>* D(&&5%'* =,$* =4* $>%* $=;5D* =<*#.4%&@.C*9"ST%'N'U'*[-%&0['$[V(T(0['()'$X,#'$X%#,#'

B=#%*@=!K=C%! ?%0-*.C).+#!'(!U.#1#-.1<!0=#%*@=5! !R2&$3R' %"*%' 0%&)0' -$#)'#/&$*%(23' *' .*/(%*8')*$+&%' %"*%' (0')#$&' &--&.%(7&' *24'

&--(.(&2%'%"*2'(-'&*."'.#)/*2R'6&$&'*2'(24&/&24&2%'.#)/*2R':&S3S' T#(2%'90&'#-'(27&0%)&2%0;'

9(!T1#1@%D%#)!0=#%*@=5! !R2&$3R' %"*%' 0%&)0' -$#)' 8&7&$*3(23' &2%$&/$&2&9$(*8' .*/*1(8(%(&0G' .*/*1(8(%(&0' (2'#$3*2(U*%(#2'4&0(32'*24'09/&$(#$'0%$*%&3(.'8&*4&$0"(/'

>(!:,0)+D%*!0=#%*@=5! !R2&$3R' .$&*%&4' 1R' &@/*24(23' %"&' )*$+&%' )&00*3&' *24' 1$(23(23' )98%(/8&'/$#49.%0' %#' %"&' .90%#)&$G' %"&$&1R' (2.$&*0(23' $&7&29&' /&$' .90%#)&$' 7(*' .$#00>0&88(23S''

I(!EC%*1).+#1<!0=#%*@.%05! '!!1N'V$#6%"'0R2&$3RW! !R2&$3R' %"*%' 0%&)0' -$#)' :$&;.#)1(2(23' *24' %$*20-&$$(23' .#)/8&)&2%*$R'

#/&$*%(7&'$&0#9$.&0'*.$#00'190(2&00&0':$&7&29&'&2"*2.&)&2%0;'!!AN!?--(.(&2.R'0R2&$3RW! !R2&$3R'%"*%'0%&)0'-$#)'0"*$(23'#/&$*%(7&'$&0#9$.&0'(2'#$4&$'%#'$&49.&'.#0%0'

:&.#2#)(&0'#-'0.#/&;'O(!V#+8<%$@%!D1#1@%D%#)!0=#%*@=5!!

J"&' *1(8(%R' #-' *' -($)' %#' "*$2&00' *24' 8&7&$*3&' +2#68&43&G' (4&*0G' /&#/8&G'%&."2#8#3R' *24' #$3*2(U*%(#2*8' .#)/&%&2.&0' *24' 0R0%&)0' -#$' %"&' .$&*%(#2' #-'2&6G')#$&'09..&00-98'(22#7*%(#20S'

9(>(9!B=#%*@=!-*%1).+#!T(B54@*%#$(6-5#>%'*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*$.;%#*=<*#.4%&@.)*$>%*4%h$*-=@5D(-*#$%;*5#*$=*-==Q*($*$>%*;#*"$)<4* =<* #.4%&@.C* 3%B%&(-*;&%D=4'5$5=4#* <=&* $>%* D&%($5=4*=<* #.4%&@.*D(4*6%* <=,4'* 54*-5$%&($,&%C*O>5#*;(&$*=<*$>%*$>%#5#*;&=B5'%#*(4*=B%&B5%d*=<*$>%*<54'54@#C*O>%*;&%D=4'5$5=4#*"%4$5=4%'*&%;&%#%4$*<(D$=&#*$>($*(&%*<&%?,%4$-.*<=,4'*54*-5$%&($,&%C*G%=DD,&&54@*$>%"%#*54* -5$%&($,&%* =4* #.4%&@.* D&%($5=4* (&%* =&@(45f($5=4(-* -%('%&#>5;* (4'* $=;* "(4(@%"%4$*#,;;=&$)* $&,#$)*D-%(&*D="",45D($5=4*(4'*(6#=&;$5B%*D(;(D5$.* <=&* $&(4#<%&&54@*&%#=,&D%#*R%C@C*3(4',--5*(4'*J>%#6&=,@>)*/00:e*J>%#6&=,@>)*/008e*K(45%-*(4'*F%$D(-<)*/001e*H4=--)*/009SC**O>%* 5";=&$(4D%*=<* -%('%&#>5;*(4'* $=;_"(4(@%"%4$* #,;;=&$*>(#*6%%4*'%#D&56%'*d>5-%*<=D,#54@*=4*6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4C*!#* #(5')* -%('%&#*(&%*(D$5B%-.* 54B=-B%')* (4'*D(4*%4#,&%* D-%(&* D="",45D($5=4C* E4* (''5$5=4)* -%('%&#* D(4* 6%* 54#;5&54@* $=* %";-=.%%#)* 6.*@,5'54@* $>%5&* ($$%4$5=4* (4'* %4%&@.* $=d(&'#* $>%* &5@>$* '5&%D$5=4* RK(45%-* (4'* F%$D(-<)*/001SC* O=* <545#>* $>%* $=;5D* =4* -%('%&#>5;)* -%('%&#* D=,-'* 54B=-B%* $>%* &5@>$* ;%=;-%* 6.*6,5-'54@*(*#$&=4@*(4'*D=""5$$%'*$%("*(&=,4'*$>%*#.4%&@.*545$5($5B%*R!5Q%4*(4'*H%--%&)*/008SC**J="",45D($5=4* 5#* $>%*4%h$* <&%?,%4$-.*'%#D&56%'*;&%D=4'5$5=4* 54*-5$%&($,&%C*Z%d5#*%$*(-C*R/00`S*<54'*$>($*",-$5;-%*D="",45D($5=4*D>(44%-#*"(Q%*#,&%*(--*#%-%D$%'*#$(Q%>=-'%&#*&%D%5B%* $>%* 54<=&"($5=4* 4%D%##(&.* <=&* <=D,#54@* $>%5&* ($$%4$5=4* $=d(&'#* $>%* &5@>$*'5&%D$5=4C* E4* (''5$5=4)* 6,5-'54@* 54* <%%'6(DQ* #%&B%#* (#* (4* 54$%&B%4$5=4* $=* &%',D%*,4D%&$(54$.*("=4@#$*#$(<<*d>5D>*;&%B%4$#*'%D-5454@*;&=',D$5B5$.* R\(-;54*(4'*T%&4'=4)*/008SC*A54(--.)*W@,.%4*(4'*H-%54%&*R/002S*('B5#%*"(4(@%"%4$*$=*D="",45D($%*(*#$&=4@*#%$* =<* =&@(45f($5=4* d5'%* B(-,%#* (4'* 6%-5%<#* 54* =&'%&* $=* %4>(4D%* 54$%&&%-($5=4#>5;#*6%$d%%4* '%;(&$"%4$#* (4'* $>%* d5--54@4%##* $=* D==;%&($%* R$>%&%6.* &%',D54@* $>%* W=$*E4B%4$%'*T%&%*#.4'&="%*(4'*D&%($54@*$&,#$CSC**

Page 27: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /8*

!6#=&;$5B%* D(;(D5$.* >(#* 6%%4* '%<54%'* (#* $>%* (65-5$.* $=* 5'%4$5<.* &%#=,&D%#* $>($* D&%($%*B(-,%)* 54$%@&($%* $>%"* d5$>* 54$%&4(-* &%#=,&D%#* (4'* %h;-=5$* $>%"* R3(4',--5* (4'*J>%#6&=,@>)*/00:SC*3=)*$>5#*B(-,%*#>=,-'*6%*D&%($%'*6.*54$%@&($54@*%h$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*=&*Q4=d-%'@%)*D,&&%4$-.*4=$*;&%#%4$*d5$>54*$>%*<5&"C*E4*=$>%&*d=&'#)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*D="654%*D=";-%"%4$(&.* &%#=,&D%#* <=&* B(-,%* D&%($5=4C* E4* (--5(4D%* -5$%&($,&%)* $>%* ;&=D%##* =<*D&%($54@* D=";-%"%4$(&.* 6(-(4D%* =&* ",$,(-* 6%4%<5$#* *6%$d%%4*<5&"#C*!DD=&'54@*$=*K=,"(*%$*(-C*R/000S)*$>5 '%;%4'#*=<*#%B%&(-*'&5B%&#C*A5&#$)*D==;%&($5=4*5#*=4-.*('B5#(6-%*d>%4*;(&$4%&#*>(B%*(*#>(&%'*B5#5=4)*d>5D>*%4(6-%#* ;(&$4%&#* $=* #=-B%* 5##,%#* %<<%D$5B%-.C* 3=)* 54* $>%* D(#%* =<* =;%4* 6,#54%##* "='%-*544=B($5=4)*6=$>*;(&$4%&#*#>=,-'*>(B%*$>%*#("%*=6g%D$5B%#*(4'*#>=,-'*6%*D=""5$$%'*$=*$>%*545$5($5B%*6.*<=&*%h(";-%*"(Q54@*&%#=,&D%#*(B(5-(6-%C*!4=$>%&*'&5B%&*5#*$>%*<(D$*$>($*(*D==;%&($5=4* 5#* 5";=&$(4$* <=&*6=$>* <5&"#*(4'* $>($* $>%#%* <5&"#*(&%*%?,(--.*'%;%4'%4$*=4*%(D>*=$>%&*RK=,"(*%$*(-C)*/000SC*3=)*$>%*;(&$4%&#*#>=,-'*6%*(6-%*$=*$&,#$*%(D>*=$>%&)*#54D%*$>%.*'%;%4'*,;=4*%(D>*=$>%&* <=&*%h$%&4(-*Q4=d-%'@%*D,&&%4$-.*4=$*;&%#%4$*d5$>54*$>%*<5&"C*W%h$)* $>%* g=54$*(D$5B5$5%#* #>=,-'*>(B%*(''%'*B(-,%* <=&*6=$>* <5&"#* R5C%C* #.4%&@.S)* 54*=&'%&* $=* "(Q%* $>%* D=--(6=&($5=4* d=&Q* RK=,"(* %$* (-C)* /000SC* O>%* D="654($5=4* =<*D=";-%"%4$(&.*&%#=,&D%#*=&*Q4=d-%'@%*#>=,-'*<=&*%h(";-%*&%#,-$*54*-%B%&(@54@*54$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#* =&* Q4=d-%'@%* R54$&(_<5&"* #.4%&@5%#S* =&* D="654%'* B(-,%* D&%($5=4* R54$%&_<5&"*#.4%&@5%#SC* O=* D=";-%$%* $>5#* ;(&$)* O(4&5B%&'5* (4'* Y%4Q($&("(4* R/00[S* <54'* $>($*#.4%&@5%#*D(4*(&5#%*<&="*$>%*D=";-%"%4$(&5$.*=<*;&=',D$*Q4=d-%'@%*&%-($%'4%##*R=&*<5$S)*D,#$="%&* Q4=d-%'@%* &%-($%'4%##* (4'*"(4(@%&5(-* &%-($%'4%##C*^>%4* (--* $>&%%* #=,&D%#*(&%*D="654%')*$>%*;%&<=&"(4D%*=<*$>%*",-$5_6,#54%##*<5&"*D(4*6%*5";&=B%'C***H4=d54@*d>5D>*;&%D=4'5$5=4#*#>=,-'*6%*"%$*54*=&'%&*$=*(D>5%B%*#.4%&@.)*$>%*'%<545$5=4*=<* #.4%&@.* ;#*"$)<4%D(4* 6%* 6%$$%&* ,4'%&#$=='C*^,* (4'* J>=5* R/00])* ;C* 2/`S* #$($%* $>($*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4*%hD>(4@%* (4'* ;<G@)4"$)<4% <F% "55% K)4A2% <F% +2*F+5% #*2<+#;*2% -)$E% )$2% @+2)4*22% ="#$4*#2 *R%";>(#5#*(''%'SC*E4*$>%5&*&%#%(&D>)*^,*(4'*J>=5*R/00]S*;&=;=#%*<5B%*>.;=$>%#%#*6(#%'*=4* -5$%&($,&%* <54'54@#*(4'* $%#$%'* 54* $>%*J>54%#%*6,#54%##*"(&Q%$C*O>%*>.;=$>%#%#* $>($*(&%* #,;;=&$%'* -%('* $=* $>%* <54'54@#* $>($* $)*2% -)$E% F)4"4;)"5% )42$)$+$)<42* R5C%C* @=='*&%-($5=4#>5;#*d5$>*@=B%&4"%4$*=<<5D%#*(4'*<54(4D5(-*54#$5$,$5=4#S*(4'*#*=*"$)4:%@+2)4*22%$#"42";$)<42* R5C%C* -=4@_$%&"* =4_@=54@* 6,#54%##* 54$%&(D$5=4#* 6%$d%%4* $d=* %h5#$54@*6,#54%##*;(&$4%&#S*D=4$&56,$%*$=d(&'#*<5&"*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4C***3.4%&@.*D&%($5=4*5#*(##=D5($%'*d5$>*%5$>%&*#$&($%@5D*D>(4@%#)*=&*<54(4D5(-*'5B%&#5<5D($5=4*R3%$>)*1::0SC*3$&($%@5D*D>(4@%#*(&%*D>(4@%#*54*=;%&($54@*'%D5#5=4#C*M4'%&-.54@*%D=4="5D*#=,&D%#*R%C@C*"(&Q%$*;=d%&*=&*%D=4="5%#*=<*#D(-%S*"(Q%*#.4%&@.*",")5"@5*)*d>%&%(#*$>%**U=5<)$"$)<4* 54B=-B%#*(* D>(4@%* 54*=;%&($54@*'%D5#5=4#* R%C@C*;&=',D$5=4)*"(&Q%$54@)*GPK*'%D5#5=4#SC*A54(4D5(-*'5B%&#5<5D($5=4*5#*(##=D5($%'*d5$>*"=&%*#$(6-%*D(#>*<-=d#)*54D&%(#%'*-%B%-#*=<*-%B%&(@%*(4'*"=&%*;&=<5$(65-5$.*R!"5$*(4'*Z5B4($)*1:99SC*O>%*#$&($%@5D*D>(4@%#*(#*'%#D&56%'*6.*3%$>*R1::0S*(&%*#%%4*(#*(*#.4%&@5#$5D*"=$5B%*6.*!"5$*(4'*Z5B4($*R1:99SC*O>%.*'%#D&56%*$>($*#.4%&@.*%h5#$#*d>%4*54'5B5',(-*,45$#*=;%&($%*(#*(*#54@-%*=&@(45f($5=4C*ND=4="5%#* =<* #D(-%* 54* "(4,<(D$,&54@)* "(&Q%$54@)* GPK)* %$DC* "(.* 6%* &%(-5f%'* 6.*D=4#=-5'($54@* 54'5B5',(-* ,45$#* (4'* $>%&%6.* 54D&%(#54@* #.4%&@.C* A,&$>%&"=&%)* #.4%&@.*"(.*6%* D&%($%'* 5<*=;%&($5=4#*=<* 54'5B5',(-*,45$#* D=";-%"%4$*=4%*(4=$>%&)* &%#,-$54@* 54*6%4%<5$#* <&="*=<<%&54@*D=4#,"%&#*(*D=";-%$%* -54%*=<*;&=',D$#*R!"5$*(4'*Z5B4($)*1:99SC*V4* $>%* -=4@* &,4)*;&=<5$(65-5$.*=<* (* <5&"* 5#* D-=#%-.*(##=D5($%'*d5$>*@&=d$>* 54*;&=',D$5B%*

$E*%<==<#$+4)$6%$<%+2*%)$2%$"4:)@5*%"4A%)4$"4:)@5*%"22*$2%G<#*%*FF);)*4$56R3%$>)* 3=4@* (4'* I%$$5$)* /00/)* ;C* :/]SC* A,&$>%&"=&%)* $>%#%* (,$>=&#* #$($%* $>($* B(-,%*

Page 28: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /9*

D&%($5=4* 5#* &%(-5f%'* 6.* (##%$* #>(&54@* (4'* <54(4D5(-* '5B%&#5<5D($5=4)*d>5D>* 6,5-'#* =4* $>%*$>%=&.*=<*3%$>*R1::0SC**\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--*R1::9S*&%D=@45f%*$>($*$>%*@=(-#*(4'*D&%($5=4*=<*#.4%&@5%#*=<$%4*$%4'*$=* 6%* %h;&%##%'* 54* 6&=('* (4'* B(@,%* $;&=',D$# * $E*%F)#2$% "4A% G<2$% )G=<#$"4$% A)2;)=5)4*% )4% G"K)4:% 2<+4A% A*;)2)<42% <4% 264*#:6J(";6%--)* 1::9)* ;C128SC* O>%&%<=&%)* ;=-5D.* "(Q%&#* #>=,-'* '5#(@@&%@($%* $>%* #.4%&@.*;&=@&("e*#.#$%"($5D(--.*6&%(Q*$>%*D=4D%;$*'=d4*54$=*"%(454@<,-*D=";=4%4$#*$>($*D(4*6%*(''&%##%'*54'5B5',(--.C**'

O>%*(D$,(-*#.4%&@.*(D>5%B%'*D(4*$(Q%*=4%*=<*#5h*<=&"#*(DD=&'54@*$=*\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--*R1::9SC* !-$>=,@>* $>%.* (&@,%* $>($* $>%#%* <=&"#* (&%* (* $.;=-=@.* =<* #.4%&@.)* $>%.* >(B%*<=D,#%'*=4*";$)<42%RB%&6#S*&($>%&*$>(4*(*$.;%*=<*B(-,%C*X.*'=54@*#=)*$>%.*(&%*("=4@*$>%*<%d* #D>=-(&#*d>=* (D$,(--.* ;&=B5'%* @,5'%-54%#* <=&* (D>5%B54@* #.4%&@.* 6.* '5#(@@&%@($54@*$>%*#.4%&@.*D=4D%;$*(4'*;&=B5'54@*(DD=";(4.54@*(D$5=4#*$=*(D>5%B%*5$C*O>%*#5h*6,#54%##*#.4%&@5%#*\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--*R1::9S*'5#$54@,5#>*(&%7*** *

&.%OE"#*A%S4<-3b<-* *,45$#*=<$%4*6%4%<5$*<&="*#>(&54@*Q4=d-%'@%*=&*#Q5--#C*Y(-,%*D(4* 6%* D&%($%'* 6.* %h;=#54@* =4%* #%$* =<* ;%=;-%* $=* (4=$>%&*d>=* >(B%* '5<<%&%4$*d(.#* =<*'=54@* $>54@#C* F(4.* D=";(45%#* ;-(D%* %";>(#5#* =4* -%B%&(@54@* D=&%* D=";%$%4D5%#* (4'*#>(&54@*6%#$*;&(D$5D%#)*d>5D>*#>=d#*$>%*5";=&$(4D%*($$&56,$%'*$=*#>(&%'*Q4=d_>=dC*

0.% 1<<#A)4"$*A% O$#"$*:)*2% * 3="%$5"%#* 5$* d= =*(-5@4* $>%* #$&($%@5%#* =<* 5$#* 6,#54%##%#* d5$>* =$>%&#* Rd>5D>* 5#* 54* -54%* d5$>* $>%* #$&($%@.*(-5@4"%4$*=<*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4* R/00`S*$=* D&%($%* <=,&*'5<<%&%4$* $.;%#*=<* #.4%&@.SC*A=&*%h(";-%)*D==&'54($%'*&%#;=4#%*$=*#>(&%'*D=";%$5$=&#*"(.*6%*(*;=d%&<,-*d(.*$=*D=,4$%&*D=";%$5$5B%*$>&%($#C*T=d%B%&)*(-$>=,@>*D==&'54($%'*#$&($%@5%#*D(4*54*;&54D5;-%*6%*(*@=='*#=,&D%*=<*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4)*$>%.*(&%*$=,@>*$=*(D>5%B%)*#54D%*#$&5Q54@*$>%*6(-(4D%*6%$d%%4*D=&;=&($%*54$%&B%4$5=4*(4'*<5&"*(,$=4=".*5#*4=$*%(#.*R\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--)*1::9SC*

8.%OE"#*A%$"4:)@5*%#*2<+#;*2% *,45$#*=&*<5&"#*D(4*#="%$5"%#*#(B%*(*-=$*=<*"=4%.*6.*#>(&54@* (##%$#* (4'* &%#=,&D%#* R%C@C* B5(* #>(&%'* ,#%* =<*"(4,<(D$,&54@* <(D5-5$5%#* =&* GPKSC*O>5#*"(.*@(54*%D=4="5%#*=<*#D(-%*(4'*(B=5'*',;-5D($%'*%<<=&$C**

C.%Z*#$);"5%)4$*:#"$)<4% *&%<-%D$#*$>%*D==&'54($5=4*=<*<-=d#*=<*;&=',D$#*=&*#%&B5D%#*<&="*=4%*,45$*$=*(4=$>%&*(4'*D(4*&%',D%*54B%4$=&.*D=#$#*(4'*;&=',D$*'%B%-=;"%4$*$5"%C*A,&$>%&"=&%)*5$*D(4*54D&%(#%*D(;(D5$.*,$5-5f($5=4*(4'*5";&=B%*"(&Q%$*(DD%##C*

H.% !<<5*A% 4*:<$)"$)<4% =<-*#* * 6.* D="65454@* ;,&D>(#%#)* <5&"#* D(4* @(54* @&%($%&*-%B%&(@%*=B%&*#,;;-5%&#)*&%',D54@*D=#$#*=&*5";&=B54@*?,(-5$.*=<*$>%*@=='#*$>%.*6,.C**

I.%1<G@)4*A%@+2)4*22%;#*"$)<4% %$>%*D&%($5=4*=<*4%d*6,#54%##*D(4*6%*<(D5-5$($%'*6.*D="65454@*Q4=d_>=d*<&="*'5<<%&%4$*,45$#*=&*<5&"#C*A,&$>%&"=&%)*$>5#*D(4*6%*%#$(6-5#>%'*6.*<=&"54@*g=54$*B%4$,&%#*=&*(--5(4D%#C**

9(>(>!K2%!$1*Q!0.$%!+L!0=#%*@=!Z=@5D(--.)*"(4.* <5&"#* (4'*"(4(@%&#* ;,&#,%* $>%* D&%($5=4* =<* #.4%&@.)* #54D%* 5$*;&="5#%#*54D&%(#%'*B(-,%*$=*$>%*<5&"C*T=d%B%&)*5$*5#*D=4D%5B(6-%*$>($*$>%&%*5#*(*&%B%&#%*#5'%*=<*$>%*

(''&%##* #.4%&@5#$5D*=;;=&$,45$5%#* "%E*"5$E6%A<2*%<F%2;*=$);)2G%i$=j%A)2$)4:+)2E%#*"5%*O>%.*<54'*$>($*$>%*;,&#,5$*=<*#.4%&@.*=<$%4*'=%#*4=$*-5B%*,;*

Page 29: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* /:*

($$%4$5=4* <&="* D=&%* $(#Q#)* (4'* $>%&%6.* %hD-,'%#* 545$5($5B%#* $>($* "5@>$* @%4%&($%* &%(-*6%4%<5$#C* F=&%=B%&)* #="%$5"%#* $>%* #.4%&@.* ;&=@&("* 6(DQ<5&%#)* d5$>* ;=$%4$5(-* -=##* =<*6&(4'*B(-,%)* D,#$="%&* &%-($5=4#>5;#*=&*%";-=.%%*"=&(-%* R\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--)*1::9SC*3=)*d>5-%*=4*=4%*>(4'*#.4%&@.*>(#* $=*;=$%4$5(-* $=* ;#*"$** B(-,%)* 5$* $,&4#*=,$* $>($*"(4.*#.4%&@.* %<<=&$#* %4'* ,;* A*2$#<6)4:* B(-,%)* &($>%&* $>(4* D&%($54@* 5$C* \==-'* (4'* J(";%--*R1::9S* '%#D&56%* <=,&* 65(#%#* $>($* "(Q%* #.4%&@.* #%%"* "=&%* ($$&(D$5B%* (4'* %(#5-.*(D>5%B(6-%*$>(4*5$*$&,-.*5#C*O>%#%*65(#%#*(&%*#.4%&@.*65(#)*;(&%4$54@*65(#)*#Q5--#*65(#*(4'*$>%*,;#5'%*65(#C*K%#D&5;$5=4#*=<*$>%#%*65(#%#*D(4*6%*<=,4'*54*(;;%4'5h*EYC**

9(>(I!:+#-<,0.+#!O>5#*;(&$*=<* $>%#5#*($$%";$%'* $=* #.#$%"($5D(--.*"=B%* <&="*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-* D(4B(#)*B5(*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*$=d(&'#*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4C*!DD=&'54@*$=*J(-B(D(4$%*%$*(-C)*R/001S)* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4* D=4#5#$#* =<* D&%($5=4)* %h$%4#5=4)* &%B5#5=4* (4'*$%&"54($5=4C* J>%#6&=,@>* R/010S*"%4$5=4#* $>&%%* ;&=D%##%#* <=&* $>%* 5";-%"%4$($5=4* =<*$>%#%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4#)* 4("%-.* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4)* %<<%D$,($5=4* (4'*=&@(45f($5=4(-* -%(&454@C* O>%* 4%h$* #$%;)* "=B54@* <&="* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4* $=*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4)*>(#*4=$*6%%4*'%#D&56%'*54*-5$%&($,&%*%h;-5D5$-.)*(-$>=,@>*D="65454@*$>%*;&%D=4'5$5=4#*=<*#.4%&@.*d5$>*$>%*(D$5=4#*(#*'%#D&56%'*6.*\==-'*(4'*J("6%--*R1::9S*D(4*6%*,#%'* <=&* $>5#*;,&;=#%C*O>5#* D="654($5=4*%4$(5-#* $>($* <5&"#*4%%'* $=* D=";-.*d5$>* $>%*;&%D=4'5$5=4#)* 5C%C* <5&"#* #>=,-'* >(B%* >5@>* (6#=&;$5B%* D(;(D5$.* <=&* %<<5D5%4$* &%#=,&D%*#>(&54@)* #>=,-'* D="",45D($%* d5$>* (--* ;(&$4%&#* 54* =&'%&* $=* %4>(4D%* $&,#$* (4'* #>=,-'*#>=d*=&@(45f($5=4(-* -%('%&#>5;C* O>%* (D$5=4#*\==-'* (4'*J(";6%--* R1::9S*"%4$5=4* $>($*(D$,(--.* D(4* (D>5%B%* $>%* '%#5&%'* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* #>(&54@* =<* Q4=d_>=d)* D==&'54($54@*#$&($%@5%#)* #>(&54@* =<* $(4@56-%* &%#=,&D%#)* B%&$5D(-* 54$%@&($5=4* (4'* ;==-54@* 4%@=$5($5=4*;=d%&C*A=--=d54@*<&="*$>%*-5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d)*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*<=&"#*=<*#.4%&@.*$>($*D(4*6%*(D>5%B%'* (&%* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@.)* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.)* D,#$="%&* #.4%&@.)* Q4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.* (4'* =;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@.C* !-$>=,@>* $%";$54@* <=&* "(4(@%&#* $=*#$&5B%*<=&*#.4%&@.)*\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--*R1::9S*'%#D&56%*<=,&*65(#%#*$>($*#>=,-'*6%*$(Q%4*54$=* (DD=,4$* d>5-#$* #%%Q54@* <=&* 5$C* F%%$54@* $>%* ;&%D=4'5$5=4#* (4'* '5#(@@&%@($54@* $>%*#.4%&@.* ;&=@&("* #>=,-'* ;&%B%4$* "(4(@%&#* <&="* '%#;%&($%-.* -==Q54@* <=&* #.4%&@.)*$>%&%6.*Q%%;54@*54*"54'*$>($*$>5#*D(44=$*6%*#%%4*(#*(*;(4(D%(C*

9(I!K2%+*%).-1<!L*1D%8+*Q!1#$!)2%+*=;A10%$!C*.#-.C<%0!!O>%*<54'54@#*=<* $>%* -5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d*&%#,-$* 54*(* $>%=&%$5D(-* <&("%d=&Q*=<* <5@,&%*]C*O>%*<5@,&%* B5#,(-5f%#* $>%* D=4D-,#5=4*=<* $>%* -5$%&($,&%* &%B5%d)* #$(&$54@* <&="*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)*"=B54@*$=d(&'#*$>%*#.4%&@.*$.;=-=@.*'%B%-=;%'*54*$>5#*#$,'.C**A=--=d54@* <&="* $>5#* <&("%d=&Q* (4'* $>%* -5$%&($,&%* &%B5%d)* //* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* (&%*'%&5B%'C* !;;%4'5h* EEE* #>=d#* $>%* D=4#$&,D$5=4* =<* $>%* ;&54D5;-%#* R#%%* (-#=* D>(;$%&* 2)*"%$>='[email protected]*O>%*=,$D="%#*=<*$>%*;&54D5;-%#*(&%*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*<=&"#*=<*#.4%&@.*(#*,#%'*54*$>5#*$>%#5#*R$>%*$.;=-=@.*=<*Y(4*!&'%44%)*/012*54*(;;%4'5h*EEESC*O>%*54$%&B%4$5=4*(4'*"%D>(45#"#*$=*(D>5%B%*$>%#%*=,$D="%#*(&%*#.4$>%#5f%'*<&="*$>%*%(&-5%&*#D>=-(&-.*d=&QC*

$>($* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #>(&%* $>%5&* '5#$&56,$5=4)* ('"545#$&($5=4)* (4'*d(&%>=,#54@* D>(44%-#)*#54D%*#>(&54@*D(4*(D>5%B%*(*@&%($%&*B=-,"%*=<*(D$5B5$.*<=&*%(D>*;&=',D$*(4'*D=,-'*=6$(54*%D=4="5%#* =<* #D(-%* =&* %D=4="5%#* =<* #D=;%)* $>%&%6.* 54D&%(#54@* &%B%4,%* ;%&* D,#$="%&*

"%&* #.4%&@. )* $>%*'%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* (&%* '%&5B%'* $>5#* d(.)* &%#,-$54@* 54* $>%* $>&%%* ;&54D5;-%#* ;&=B5'%'* 54*D>(;$%&* /C]C1C* O>%* #("%* "%$>='* >(#* 6%%4* <=--=d%'* <=&* =;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@.)* <54(4D5(-*

Page 30: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 20*

#.4%&@.)* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.* (4'* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.)* &%#,-$54@* 54* 18*;&54D5;-%#C*O>%*[*&%"(5454@*;&54D5;-%#*D=,-'*4=$*6%*-54Q%'*$=*(4.*=<*$>%*#.4%&@.*$.;%#*=<*$>5#* $>%#5#)* #54D%* $>%* #D>=-(&#* $>($* "%4$5=4* $>%#%* #.4%&@5%#* '5#D,##* #.4%&@.* (#* (4*,"6&%--(*D=4D%;$*(4'*'=*4=$*#;%D5<5D(--.*-54Q*54$%&B%4$5=4#*$=*'5<<%&%4$*$.;%#*=<*#.4%&@.C*O>%&%<=&%)* ;&54D5;-%#* n19* $=* n//* >(B%* &%D%5B%'* $>%* =B%&(&D>54@* #,6_

**

*;,0Z&%'L'U'9X%(&%$,+"T')&"1%^(&b'

Page 31: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 21*

9(I('!:,0)+D%*!0=#%*@.%0!cB* * E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*D,#$="%&*#.4%&@.)* <5&"#*#>=,-'*#>(&%*$>%5&*'5#$&56,$5=4)*

('"545#$&($5=4*(4'*d(&%>=,#54@*D>(44%-#)*#54D%*#>(&54@*D(4*(D>5%B%*(*@&%($%&*B=-,"%*=<*(D$5B5$.* <=&* %(D>* ;&=',D$* (4'* D=,-'* =6$(54* %D=4="5%#* =<* #D(-%* =&* %D=4="5%#* =<* #D=;%)*$>%&%6.*54D&%(#54@*&%B%4,%*;%&*D,#$="%&*R6(#%'*=4*!4#=<<)*1:`[SC*

cE' *E4*=&'%&*$=*%#$(6-5#>*D,#$="%&*#.4%&@.)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*#>(&%*$>%5&*'5#$&56,$5=4*D>(44%-#* %4*"(&Q%$* #%@"%4$#)* #54D%* $>5#* D=,-'* 54D&%(#%* #(-%#* @&=d$>* 6.* -=d%&54@* $>%*D=#$#*=<*#(-%#*R6(#%'*=4*^54'*(4'*F(>(g(4)*1:99e*J>($$%&g%%)*1:9`e*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4)*/00`e*H4=--)*/009SC*

c7' * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* D,#$="%&* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #$&5B%* <=&*#$(4'(&'5f($5=4*=<*;&=D%##%#*(4'*=,$;,$*#54D%*$>5#*D=4$&56,$%#*$=*(*D=4#5#$%4$*D,#$="%&*%h;%&5%4D%)* d>5D>* &%54<=&D%#* (4'* %4>(4D%#* $>%* D=&;=&($%* 6&(4'* RH(;-(4* (4'* W=&$=4)*/00`SC*

9(I(9!EC%*1).+#1<!0=#%*@.%0!cL* *E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*=;%&($5=4(-*#.4%&@.)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*#>(&%*$>%5&*<(D5-5$5%#*(4'*

;%&#=44%-)* #54D%* #>(&54@* D(4*(D>5%B%* #$%%;%&* -%(&454@* D,&B%#*(4'*=6$(54*%D=4="5%#*=<*#D(-%*6.*54D&%(#54@*;&=<5$*<&="*=;%&($5=4#*6.*-=d%&54@*=;%&($54@*D=#$#*;%&*<5&"* R6(#%'*=4*!4#=<<)*1:`[e*^54'*(4'*F(>(g(4)*1:99e*J>($$%&g%%)*1:9`e*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4)*/00`SC*

c?* * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* =;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@5%#)* "(4(@%&#* #>=,-'* %h("54%*D=""=4*;&=D%##%#* <=&* %D=4="5%#* =<* #D(-%)* #54D%* $>5#* %4>(4D%#* D=";%$5$5B%* ('B(4$(@%*(4'*#>(&%>=-'%&*B(-,%*R6(#%'*=4*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4)*/00`S*

cN* * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* @&=d$>* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* D="654%*D=";-%"%4$(&.*&%#=,&D%#*(D&=##*<5&"#)*#54D%*$>5#*D=,-'*;&=B5'%*,45?,%*D,#$="%&*B(-,%*(4'*D(;$,&%*"(&Q%$*=;;=&$,45$5%#)*$>%&%6.*%4>(4D54@*&%B%4,%#*R6(#%'*=4*H4=--)*/009SC*

cD' * E4*=&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* %<<5D5%4D.* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #>(&%* &%#=,&D%#* 54*$>%*;&=',D$5=4*=<*",-$5;-%*=,$;,$#*(D&=##*<5&"#)*#54D%*$>5#*-%('#*$=*-=d%&*g=54$*D=#$#*6.*;,$$54@*,4'%&,$5-5f%'*&%#=,&D%#*$=*;&=',D$5B%*,#%*R6(#%'*=4*H4=--)*/009SC*

9(I(>!U.#1#-.1<!0=#%*@.%0!cP* * E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #>(&%* $>%5&* ;-(4$)* &(d*

"($%&5(-* 54B%4$=&5%#* (4'* "(D>54%&.)* #54D%* #>(&54@* D(4* (D>5%B%* (* @&%($%&* B=-,"%* =<*(D$5B5$.* (4'* D=,-'* =6$(54* %D=4="5%#* =<* #D(-%* =&* %D=4="5%#* =<* #D=;%* d5$>* -=d%&*54B%#$"%4$#*R6(#%'*=4*!4#=<<)*1:`[SC!

cM* * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #>(&%* $>%5&* ,#%* =<*%?,5;"%4$* (4'* GPK* <(D5-5$5%#)* #54D%* $>5#* -=d%&#* 54B%#$"%4$* D=#$#* (4'* 54D&%(#%#* $>%*&%$,&4*=4*54B%#$"%4$*R6(#%'*=4*^54'*(4'*F(>(g(4)*1:99SC**

cBO' * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* (--=D($%* D(;5$(-*("=4@*5$#*g=54$*#$&,D$,&%*#54D%*$>5#*D(;5$(-*"(&Q%$*5#*"=&%*%<<%D$5B%*(4'*%<<5D5%4$*$>(4*5<*%(D>* (,$=4="=,#* <5&"*d%&%* (4* 54'%;%4'%4$* =d4%'* <5&"* R6(#%'* =4* J>($$%&g%%)* 1:9`e*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4)*/00`e*H4=--)*/009S*

9(I(I!T1#1@%D%#)!0=#%*@.%0!cBB* * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #>(&%* $>%5&*

#$&($%@5D)* =&@(45f($5=4(-* =&* =;%&($54@* ;&=6-%"#)* #54D%* #>(&54@* D(4* (D>5%B%* <(#$%&*#=-,$5=4#*$=*#5"5-(&*;&=6-%"#*$>($*=$>%&*"(4(@%&#*>(B%*'%(-$*d5$>*54*$>%*;(#$*R6(#%'*=4*!4#=<<)*1:`[e*^54'*(4'*F(>(g(4)*1:99SC*

cBE* * E4*=&'%&*$=*%#$(6-5#>*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@.)* <5&"#*#>=,-'*#>(&%*&%#=,&D%#)*#54D%*$>5#*D=,-'*&%#,-$*54*$>%*(65-5$.*$=*@%4%&($%*6%$$%&*#$&($%@5%#*$>($*@&%($-.*(<<%D$*=$>%&*#.4%&@.*$.;%#*R6(#%'*=4*^54'*(4'*F(>(g(4)*1:99SC'

Page 32: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 2/*

cB7' * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* D==&'54($%*Q4=d-%'@%* <-=d#* (4'* "(&Q%$54@* (4'* $%D>4=-=@5D(-* %h;%&$5#%* ("=4@* <5&"#)* #54D%* $>5#*D=,-'*&%',D%*D=#$#*(4'* 5";&=B%* 544=B($5B%* 54$%&(D$5=4#*("=4@*'5#;%&#%'*<5&"#*R6(#%'*=4*I%&#(,')*/00[SC*

cBL* * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #$&,D$,&%* $>%*D=4$%h$* #=* $>($* ;&=D%',&%#* <=&* D=--(6=&($5=4* (4'* &%;=&$54@* (&%* D-%(&-.* '%<54%'* (4'*D="",45D($%')* #54D%* $>5#* "545"5f%#* D=4<-5D$#* (4'* "(Q%#* <5&"#* "=&%* D="<=&$(6-%*#>(&54@*Q4=d-%'@%)*&%#=,&D%#*(4'*;%&#=44%-*R6(#%'*=4*I%&#(,')*/00[SC*

cB?' *E4*=&'%&*$=*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@.)*D=&;=&($%*"(4(@%&#*#>=,-'*'5#(@@&%@($%*$>%* =6g%D$5B%#* =<* #.4%&@.* 545$5($5B%#)* #54D%* D-(&5<.54@* $>%* =6g%D$5B%#* D=4$&56,$%#* $=* $>%*%B(-,($5=4*=<* D=#$#*(4'*6%4%<5$#)* (4'* $=* $>%* D&%($5=4*=<* D=4D&%$%* 5";-%"%4$($5=4*;-(4#*R6(#%'*=4*H4=--)*/009e*K(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC*

9(I(O!V#+8<%$@%!D1#1@%D%#)!0=#%*@.%0!cBN' * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* #>=,-'*

-%B%&(@%* Q4=d-%'@%)* 5'%(#)* ;%=;-%)* $%D>4=-=@.* (4'* =&@(45f($5=4(-* D=";%$%4D%#)* #54D%*$>5#* D=,-'* D=4$&56,$%* $=* $>%* D&%($5=4* =<* 4%d)* "=&%* #,DD%##<,-* 544=B($5=4* R6(#%'* =4*I%&#(,')*/00[SC*

cBD' * E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'*'%B%-=;*(4'*#>(&%*54$(4@56-%*&%#=,&D%#)*#54D%*$>%#%*&%#=,&D%#*;&%#%4$*(4*=;;=&$,45$.*$=*D&%($%*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%*R6(#%'*=4*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4)*/00`SC*

9(I(P!U.*D!0=#%*@=!cBP' * E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%* <5&"* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* D="",45D($%* <&%?,%4$-.)*

#54D%* $>5#* 5";&=B%#* $>%* (65-5$.* $=* '%B%-=;* (4'* %h;-=5$* 4%d* (4'* #,DD%##<,-* 544=B($5=4#*?,5DQ-.*(4'*D=#$_%<<%D$5B%-.*R6(#%'*=4*I%&#(,')*/00[SC**

cBM* * E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%* <5&"* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* 54B%#$* 54* #$&=4@* $5%#* d5$>*@=B%&4"%4$* =<<5D%#* (4'* R<54(4D5(-S* 54#$5$,$5=4#)* #54D%* $>5#* ;&=B5'%#* (DD%##* $=* B(-,(6-%*54<=&"($5=4* (4'* 6%4%<5$#* $>($* D(4* ;,$* $>%* <5&"* 54* (* 6%$$%&* ;=#5$5=4* $=* D==;%&($%*"=&%*%<<5D5%4$-.*d5$>*5$#*6,#54%##*;(&$4%&#*R6(#%'*=4*^,*(4'*J>=5)*/00]SC*

cEO* *E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*<5&"*#.4%&@.)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*%4@(@%*54*-=4@*$%&")*=4_@=54@*54$%&(D$5=4#*d5$>*%(D>*=$>%&)*#54D%*$>5#*%4(6-%#*6=$>*<5&"#*$=*%#$(6-5#>*(4*%<<%D$5B%*d=&Q*&=,$54%*<=&*$>%*%hD>(4@%*=<*54<=&"($5=4*(4'*Q4=d-%'@%*R6(#%'*=4*^,*(4'*J>=5)*/00]SC**

cEB* *E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*<5&"*#.4%&@.)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*%4@(@%*d5$>*D=""5$$%'*(4'*

$>5#*d5--*54D&%(#%*$>%*(6#=&;$5B%*D(;(D5$.*=<*$>%*<5&"*#=*$>($*&%#=,&D%#*d5$>*(''%'*B(-,%*D(4* 6%* 5'%4$5<5%')* 54$%@&($%'*d5$>* 54$%&4(-* &%#=,&D%#* (4'* %h;-=5$%'* R6(#%'* =4* 3(4',--5*(4'*J>%#6&=,@>)*/00:SC*

cEE' *E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*<5&"*#.4%&@.)*<5&"#*",#$*=;%4*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#*$=*=$>%&*;(&$5%#)*#54D%*6.*D="65454@*=d4*;&=D%##%#*d5$>*%h$%&4(--.*(B(5-(6-%*5'%(#)*(B(5-(6-%*&%#=,&D%#*6%D="%*Q%.*D=";=4%4$#*54*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*(4'*;($>#*$=*"(&Q%$*6%D="%*#>=&$%&*R6(#%'*=4*K(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC**

Page 33: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 22*

>(!T%)2+$+<+@=!

%O>5#* #%D$5=4* %-(6=&($%#* =4* $>%* &%#%(&D>* "%$>='[email protected]* E4* $>5#* $>%#5#)* (* #D5%4D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*(;;&=(D>* 5#* ('=;$%')*6(#%'*=4*?,(-5$($5B%* &%#%(&D>C*O>%*4($,&%*=<* $>%* &%#%(&D>*?,%#$5=4* -%4'#* 5$#%-<* &%('5-.* <=&* #,D>* (4* (;;&=(D>)* #54D%* $>%* 4=$5=4* =<* '%#5@4* "(.*;<4$#)@+$*%$<%2<5,)4:%$E*%F+4A"G*4$"5%-*"K4*22%<F%<#:"4)>"$)<4%"4A%G"4":*G*4$%$E*<#6%% $E*% 2<3;"55*A% #*5*,"4;*3 RG=""%)* /002)* ;C* [[:SC*FDF(#$%&* R1::`S* #,@@%#$#* $>($* $>%* <5&#$* #$%;* 54* $>5#* (;;&=(D>* 5#* $=* '%&5B%* '%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#C* O>%* ;&54D5;-%#* d5--* 6%* (;;-5%'* $=* (* #;%D5<5D* D(#%* 54* =&'%&* $=* 5--,#$&($%* $>%*(;;-5D($5=4*(4'*;&=B5'%*<%%'6(DQ*=4*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#C*

>('!/%0%1*-2!$%0.@#!B;"A*G);% G"4":*G*4$% $E*<#6% E"2% "% 2*#)<+2% +$)5)>"$)<4% =#<@5*G;C/1:SC* !#* '5#D,##%')* $>5#* D%&$(54-.* >=-'#* <=&* (D('%"5D* -5$%&($,&%* =4* #.4%&@.* RF(&$54)*/00/SC* Y(4*!Q%4* R/00]S* (&@,%#* $>($* (D('%"5D*"(4(@%"%4$* -5$%&($,&%* #$(4'#* (* 6%$$%&*

;&%'5D$#)* '%#5@4* #D5%4D%* &($>%&* (5"#* ($* '%B%-=;54@* $%#$%'* (4'* @&=,4'%'* $%D>4=-=@5D(-*&,-%#* RY(4* !Q%4)* /00]SC* O(6-%* 8* #,""(&5f%#* $>%* '5<<%&%4D%#* 6%$d%%4* %h;-(4($=&.*

**9"ST%'D'U'3%#+&,V$,/%'/%&#Z#'V&%#+&,V$,/%'&%#%"&+X'V&(0&"11%#'QS"#%W'(-'I"-'@b%-Y'EOOLR'

:21*1-)%*.0).-! ?%0-*.C).+#;$*.7%#!*%0%1*-2!C*+@*1DD%0!

4*%0-*.C).+#;$*.7%#!*%0%1*-2!C*+@*1DD%0!

"#$%&'&(!)'*'+%,$! ?@/8*2*%#$R'0.(&2.&0' B&0(32'0.(&2.&0'-#./0! X$#18&)'-#.90&4' !#89%(#2'-#.90&4'12)%.'3!*404'*.5!6/40(%#&!

?@/8*2*%(#2' C8%&$2*%(7&'0#89%(#20'-#$'*'.8*00'#-'/$#18&)0'

12)%.'3!*404'*.5!)*#+/.(! N*90*8')#4&8Y'A9*2%(%*%(7&'8*6' J&0%&4'*24'3$#924&4'%&."2#8#3(.*8'$98&'7'(/*4!#8!*404'*.5!)*#+/.(!

C83#$(%")' Z&9$(0%(.'

9/0(%8%.'(%#&! X$##-' !*%9$*%&4'&7(4&2.&'

*K%#5@4*#D5%4D%*D(4*6&5'@%*$>%*@(;*6%$d%%4*&% *=<*#.4%&@.*

Q4=d-%'@%*$>($*5#*6=$>*(D$5=4(6-%*(4'*=;%4*$=*B(-5'($5=4*RG=""%)*/002SC*Y(4*X,&@*%$*(-C*R/009S* #,@@%#$* $d=* d(.#* =<* (;;-.54@* $>%* D=&%* 5'%(* =<* 6&5'@54@* $>%* @(;* 6%$d%%4*

+2)4:%=#)4;)=5*2%:#<+4A*A%)4%#*2*"#;E%$<%;#*"$*%\).*.%;<4;*=$+"5]%2<5+$)<42%$<%@*%2+@2*a+*4$56%$#)*A%<+$%"4A%

RY(4*X,&@*%$*(-C)*/009)*;C*11`SC*!-$%&4($5B%-.)*%h;%&5"%4$($5=4*d5$>*4%d*#=-,$5=4#*D(4*(-#=*#%&B%*$=*'%&5B%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#C*E4*$>%5&*(&$5D-%)*Y(4*X,&@*%$* (-C* R/009S* #$&,D$,&%* $>%* ;&=D%##* =<* <=&",-($54@* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* 6.* #%;(&($%-.*'%B%-=;54@* ;&54D5;-%#* 6(#%'* =4* ;&(D$5D%* R;&(D$5D%_6(#%'* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#S* (4'*;&54D5;-%#* "%&%-.* 6(#%'* =4* &%#%(&D>* R&%#%(&D>_6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#SC* 3.4$>%#5#* =<* $>%#%*

%\OE*#5<;K%b<5G*2]%

%

Page 34: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 2]*

;&54D5;-%#* &%#,-$#* 54* (* <54(-* #%$* =<* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#)*d>5D>* '&(d#*=4* 6=$>*;&(D$5$5=4%&*Q4=d-%'@%*(4'*&%#%(&D>*Q4=d-%'@%C**O>%*"(#$%&*$>%#5#*d5--*('=;$* $>%*(;;&=(D>*=<*Y(4*X,&@*%$*(-C* R/009S)*d5$>*#="%*"54=&*D>(4@%#C*A5@,&%*[*#>=d#*$>%*'%#5@4*;&=D%##*(;;&=(D>*=<*$>%*$>%#5#C*!#*D(4*6%*#%%4)*6=$>*$>%=&._6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#*R@&=,4'%'*54*-5$%&($,&%S*(4'*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#*R'%&5B%'*<&="*10*D(#%*#$,'5%#S*(&%*,#%'*$=*'%B%-=;*(*#%$*=<*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#C*O>%#%*;&54D5;-%#*d5--*6%*(;;-5%'*$=*$>%*#;%D5<5D*D(#%*=<*J-,6*B(4*20)* <=--=d%'*6.*(*&%<-%D$5=4*=4*$>%*&%#,-$)*54*$>%*'5#D,##5=4*(4'*D=4D-,#5=4*#%D$5=4C*O>%*'5#D,##5=4*d5--*;&=B5'%*<%%'6(DQ*(4'*54#5@>$#*<=&*<,&$>%&*&%#%(&D>)*d>5D>*D=,-'*#$&%4@$>%4*$>%*'%B%-=;"%4$*=<*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*54*$>%*<,$,&%C**

*;,0Z&%'?'U'9X%'$X%#,#d#'W%#,0-'#+,%-+%'"VV&("+X'Q+X"V$%&'7R'

A=&*$>%*<5<$>*D>(;$%&)*$>%*'%#5@4*<=&*J20)*(*#%$*=<*'%#5@4*(D$5B5$5%#*>(#*$=*6%*;%&<=&"%')*d>5D>* $=@%$>%&* <=&"* $>%* &%@,-($5B%* D.D-%* (#* '%#D&56%'* 6.*Y(4* 3$&5%4* R1::8SC* A5@,&%* `*'5#;-(.#* $>%* &%@,-($5B%* D.D-%* R('=;$%'* <&="* Y(4* !Q%4* %$* (-C)* /008SC* O>%* '&5B%&* =<* $>%*&%@,-($5B%*D.D-%*5#*$>%*=#<@5*G%A*F)4)$)<4C*O>5#*'%<545$5=4*D=,-'*6%*(*;%&D%;$5=4*;&=6-%"*=&*=4-.*(*#.";$="*=<*(4*,4'%&-.54@*;&=6-%"C*O>%&%<=&%)* $>%* 545$5(-*;&=6-%"*#$($%"%4$*>(#*$=*6%*;,$* 54*$>%*=#<@5*G%G*22%RY(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C)*/008SC*O>%*"4"562)2%"4A%A)":4<2)2%5#*$>%*(4(-.$5D(-*;(&$*=<*$>%*;&=g%D$C*O>5#*#$%;*;&=',D%#*#;%D5<5D*Q4=d-%'@%*=4*$>%*D=4$%h$*(4'*4($,&%*=<* $>%*;&=6-%"C*K,&54@*$>%*=5"4%<F%";$)<4* $>%*#=-,$5=4#* <=&* $>%*;&=6-%"*(4'*(##=D5($%'*D>(4@%*;-(4*(&%*'%#5@4%'C*A=&*$>5#*#$%;)*Y(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C*R/008S*#,@@%#$*%5$>%&*

$>%* ,#%* =<* Q4=d-%'@%* <&="*'%#D&5;$5B%* &%#%(&D>* =&)* "=&%*;=d%&<,-)*$>%*,#%*=<*<5%-'_$%#$54@*(4'*@&=,4'%'* $%D>4=-=@.* &,-%#* =&*#=-,$5=4#* D=4D%;$#* R5C%C* '%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#SC*!#*#(5')*$>%*;&54D5;-%#*(&%*'%B%-=;%'* 6.* 6,#54%##* &%#%(&D>* =4*$>%* 6(#5#* =<* '%#5@4* #D5%4D%* &%#%(&D>C*O=@%$>%&* d5$>* $>%* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#)* $>%#%* $>%=&._6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#* <=&"* (* &(4@%* =<* #=-,$5=4*D=4D%;$#*$=*$>%*;&=6-%"C*A&="*$>%#%*#=-,$5=4#)* (4* (;;&=;&5($%* =4%* 5#*D>=#%4*RY(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C)*/008SC**

;,0Z&%'N'U'>%0ZT"$,/%'+[+T%'Q"W(V$%W')&(1'I"-'@b%-'%$'"T6Y'EOODR'

Page 35: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 2[*

O>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*d5--*<=--=d*$>%*<=&"*=<*JEFV*-=@5D*RK%4.%&*%$*(-C)*/009SC*JEFV_-=@5D*)F% 6<+%-"4$% $<% ";E)*,*% <+$;<G*% P% )4%

;<4$*U$%1X%$E*4%+2*%)4$*#,*4$)<4%$6=*% RK%4.%&*%$*(-C)*/009)*;C*2:[SC!O>%*5##,%*=<*D(,#(-5$.)*$>%*%h;-(4($5=4*$>&=,@>*d>5D>*"%D>(45#"*$>%*54$%&B%4$5=4*;&=',D%#*$>%*=,$D="%*54*$>%*

=<<%&54@* @%4%&(-* $%";-($%#* <=&* $>%* D&%($5=4* =<* #=-,$5=4#* <=&* (* ;(&$5D,-(&* D-(##* =<* <5%-'*;&=6-%"#*RK%4.%&*%$*(-C)*/009SC*!-$>=,@>*$>%*"%(454@*=<*$>%*-%$$%&#*=<*$>%*JEFV*(D&=4."*5#*D-%(&_D,$)*<=&*D=";-%$%4%##*=<*$>5#*#$,'.)*(;;%4'5h*Y*;&=B5'%#*$>%*'%<545$5=4#*(#*@5B%4*6.* K%4.%&* %$* (-C* R/009SC* K,&54@* $>%#%* )4$*#,*4$)<42% 54* $>%* &%@,-($5B%* D.D-%)% d=&Q*;&=D%##%#* (&%* D>(4@%'* =4* $>%* 6(#5#* =<* $>%* '%#5@4* (4'* D>(4@%* ;-(4C* T%&%(<$%&)* $>%*%B(-,($5=4* $(Q%#* ;-(D%)* $=* #%%* d>%$>%&* =&* 4=$* 54$%&B%454@* &%#,-$%'* 54* $>%* '%#5&%'*=,$D="%C* O>%* ('g,#$"%4$#* "('%)* &%#,-$* 54* D>(4@%#* 54* $>%* ;&=6-%"* "%##* (4'*(DD=";(4.54@* ;&=6-%"* '%<545$5=4)* d>5D>* D-=#%#* $>%* D.D-%* (4'* $>%* ;&=6-%"* '%<545$5=4*6%@54#*(@(54)*d>%4*4%D%##(&.*=&*'%#5&%'*RY(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C)*/008SC*!D$,(--.*(;;-.54@*$>%*;&54D5;-%#*$=*J20*d5--*6%*,#%'*$=*%4$%&*$>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*;>(#%*54*$>%*#*:+5"$),**D.D-%C*

$>%#5#)*#54D%*5";-%"%4$54@*$>%*'%#5@4*d5--*D=B%&*(*;%&5='*-=4@%&*$>(4*$>%*d&5$54@*=<*$>5#*"(#$%&*$>%#5#C***O>%*&%@,-($5B%*D.D-%*5#*;(&$*=<*(*65@@%&*#.#$%")*4("%-.*=<*$>%*&%<-%D$5B%*D.D-%*RY(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C)*/008SC*A5@,&%*8)*('=;$%'*<&="*H%&##%4#_Y(4*K&=4@%-%4*R/001S)*'5#;-(.#*$>%*%4$5&%*#.#$%"e* 4("%-.* $>%* &%<-%D$5B%* D.D-%* (4'* $>%* &%@,-($5B%* D.D-%* D(;$,&%'* d5$>54C* !#* $>%*4("%* #,@@%#$#)* $>%* &%<-%D$5B%* D.D-%* #*F5*;$2* ,;=4* $>%* ;&=6-%"* #=-B54@* ;&=D%##* 54* $>%*&%@,-($5B%* D.D-%C* \%4%&(--.)* $>%* =,$D="%#* (&%* D=";(&%'* $=* =$>%&* D(#%* #$,'5%#* (4'*-5$%&($,&%*54*=&'%&*$=*'%B%-=;*@%4%&(-*Q4=d-%'@%C*O>5#*@%4%&(-*Q4=d-%'@%)*54*$>%*<=&"*=<*'%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#)* D(4* 6%* (;;-5%'* $=* '%#5@4* #=-,$5=4#* <=&* 4%d* D(#%#* (4'* ;&=6-%"*#5$,($5=4#)*$>%&%6.*D=4$&56,$54@*$=*$>%*$>%=&.*'%B%-=;"%4$*(4'*D=";-%$54@*$>%*&%<-%D$5B%*D.D-%C*\5B%4* $>%* #5f%*=<* $>%*"(#$%&* $>%#5#*(4'* $>%* <(D$* $>($* $>%*NB(-,($5=4*;>(#%*=<* $>%*&%@,-($5B%* D.D-%* 5#*4=$* D=";-%$%')* $>%*(;;-5D($5=4*=<* $>%*;&54D5;-%#* 54*=$>%&* D(#%#* $>(4*J20*d5--*4=$*$(Q%*;-(D%)*#=*$>%*&%<-%D$5B%*D.D-%*d5--*4=$*6%*D=";-%$%'C***

*;,0Z&%'D'U'>%)T%+$,/%'+[+T%'Q"W(V$%W')&(1'a%&##%-#UI"-'3&(-0%T%-Y'EOOBR'

Page 36: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 2`*

O>%*<=--=d54@*;(&$*=<* $>5#*"%$>='=-=@.*d5--*%-(6=&($%*=4*$>%* -5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d*(4'*$>%*&%#%(&D>*#.4$>%#5#*,#%'*$=*D&%($%*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#C*W%h$)*$>%*(;;&=(D>*$=*$>%*'%#5@4*

*

>(9!B=0)%D1).-!<.)%*1),*%!*%7.%8!1#$!*%7.%8!0=#)2%0.05!)2%+*=;A10%$!C*.#-.C<%0!E4*=&'%&*$=*'%&5B%*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*<&="*-5$%&($,&%*(4'*$>%*D(#%*#$,'5%#)*(*-5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d* "%$>='* (4'* &%#%(&D>* #.4$>%#5#* >(#* 6%%4* '%B%-=;%'C* Z5$%&($,&%* D,&&%4$-.*(B(5-(6-%* =4* $>%* $=;5D* =<* #.4%&@.* (4'* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4* '=%#* 4=$* ;&=B5'%* (*&%('5-.*(B(5-(6-%*#=-,$5=4*$=*$>%*;&=6-%"*#$($%'*54*$>%*54$&=',D$5=4C*O=*@(54*54#5@>$*54$=*$>%* &%-%B(4$* (#;%D$#* =<* $>%* ;&=6-%"* (4'* $=* '%&5B%* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#)* $>%* -5$%&($,&%* 5#*&%B5%d%'*#.#$%"($5D(--.C*O>%*<5&#$*;(&$*=<*$>%*"(#$%&*$>%#5#)*$>%*-5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d)*<=&"#*$>%* 6(#5#* <=&* $>5#* ;&=D%##* 6.* &%<-%D$54@* =4* #.4%&@.* RD&%($5=4S)* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* (4'*6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4C*O>%* #%(&D>* #$&54@#*,#%')*?,(-5$.* D&5$%&5(*(4'*'($(6(#%#* <=&*$>%* &%B5%d* (&%* '%#D&56%'* 54* '%$(5-* 54* (;;%4'5h* YE/C* O=@%$>%&*d5$>* $>%* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4* =&5%4$%'* &%#%(&D>* #.4$>%#5#* '%#D&56%'* 4%h$* R6(#%'* =4* $>%* $%4* D(#%_#$,'5%#S)* (*<54(-*#%$*=<*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*5#*<=&",-($%'C**

>(>!:10%!1#1<=0.05!C*1-).-%;A10%$!C*.#-.C<%0!!#* "%4$5=4%')* $=* '%B%-=;* $E*<#6_6(#%'* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#)* (* -5$%&($,&%* &%B5%d* 5#*;%&<=&"%'C*E4*(''5$5=4)*$=*'%B%-=;*=#";$);*_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#)*$%4*D(#%*#$,'5%#*(&%*(4(-.#%'* $=* 54D-,'%* %";5&5D(-% %B5'%4D%* RG=""%* (4'* N4'%46,&@)* /00`SC* !* ,45?,%*#$&%4@$>* =<*,#54@* D(#%* #$,'5%#* 5#* $>%* (65-5$.* $=* '%(-*d5$>* (*d5'%* &(4@%*=<* '($(* #=,&D%#*RL54)* 1::]SC* J="65454@* ",-$5;-%* '($(* &%#=,&D%#* <=#$%&#* '($(* $&5(4@,-($5=4)* d>5D>*54D&%(#%#* $>%* ?,(-5$.* =<* $>%* '($()* 6.* %4>(4D54@* D=4#$&,D$* B(-5'5$.* $>&=,@>* ",-$5;-%*"%(#,&%"%4$#* =<* $>%* #("%* ;>%4="%4=4* RL54)* 1::]SC* 3%D$5=4* 2C]*

#=,&D%#* =<* %B5'%4D%* $>($* D(4* 6%* ,#%'* <=&* &%#%(&D>7* '=D,"%4$#)* (&D>5B(-* &%D=&'#)*54$%&B5%d#)* '5&%D$* =6#%&B($5=4#)* ;(&$5D5;(4$* =6#%&B($5=4#* (4'* ;>.#5D(-* (&$%<(D$#C* O>%*"(#$%&* $>%#5#* d5--* "(Q%* ,#%* =<* $>%* '=D,"%4$#* (4'* 54$%&B5%d#* <&="* $>%* NMGE3* XFVE*I&=g%D$*RXFVE)*/012SC***X.*,#54@*$>%*'($(*<&="*$>%*D(#%*#$,'5%#)*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*(&%*'%B%-=;%'C*^>%4*(4(-.#54@* $>%*'($()* <-%h565-5$.* 5#*4%D%##(&.* #54D%* 5$* D(44=$*6%*Q4=d4*6%<=&%>(4'*d>5D>*D=4D%;$#*(4'* $>%=&5%#*(&%*Q%.* %-%"%4$#* 54* $>%*'%B%-=;"%4$*=<* $>%* $>%=&.C*Od=*$%D>45?,%#* L54* R/00]S* #,@@%#$#* (#* (4(-.$5D(-* $%D>45?,%#* <=&* ?,(-5$($5B%* &%#%(&D>* (&%*;($$%&4* "($D>54@* (4'* %h;-(4($5=4C* I($$%&4* "($D>54@* (5"#* ($* D=";(&54@* %";5&5D(--.*6(#%'*;($$%&4#*d5$>*;&%'5D$%'*=4%#C*Nh;-(4($5=4*6,5-'54@*5#*(*<=&"*=<*;($$%&4*"($D>54@7*(4* 5$%&($5B%* ;&=D%##* $>($* 6%@54#* d5$>* $>%=&%$5D(-* #$($%"%4$#)* d>5D>* (&%* &%<54%'* 6.*D=";(&54@* '($(* <&="* $>%* D(#%* #$,'5%#* $=* $>%#%* #$($%"%4$#* ,4$5-* $>%* '($(* 4=* -=4@%&*#,@@%#$#* ('(;$5=4#C* O>%* ;&=D%##* 6%>54'* '%&5B54@* $>%* ;&54D5;-%#* 5#* =;%4* D='54@C* V;%4*D='54@*54B=-B%#*-(6%--54@)*d>5D>*5#)*#5";-.*#$($%')*;,$$54@*-(6%-#*=4*$>%*'($(C*!$*$>%*%(&-.*#$(@%*=<*'($(*(4(-.#5#)*$>%*-(6%-#*(&%*;&=B5#5=4(-*(4'*(4.*;5%D%*=<*'($(*"(.*>(B%*",-$5;-%*-(6%-#C* J-=#,&%* =4* <54(-* -(6%-#* d5--* $(Q%* ;-(D%* d>%4* #,6#$(4$5(-* D='54@* >(#* 6%%4*;%&<=&"%'*(4'*$>%*(4(-.#$*>(#*(*#$(6-%*B5%d*=<*d>($*5#*D%4$&(-*54*$>%*'($(*RI,4D>)*/00[SC*V;%4*D='54@*5#*4=$*(6=,$*6&54@54@*D=4D%;$#*$=*$>%*'($(e*5$*5#*,#%'*$=*@%4%&($%*-(6%-#*<=&*,#%*54*$>%=&.*6,5-'54@C***

********************************************************/*A=&*$>%*(4(-.#5#*=<*$>%*-5$%&($,&%*?,(-5$.)*;-%(#%*#%%*;(&$*E*=<*$>%*"(#$%&*$>%#5#*;&=g%D$7*$>%*-5$%&($,&%*#$,'.*

Page 37: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 28*

O>%* D='54@* ;&=D%##* #$(&$#* d5$>* (4(-.#54@* $>%* '=D,"%4$#* $=* D&%($%* (* -5#$* =<* =;%4*544=B($5=4*545$5($5B%#)*d>5D>*d%&%*'%<54%'*(#*(D$5=4*=&*%B%4$#*545$5($%'*6.*$>%*B%4$,&%*54*=&'%&*$=*D=--(6=&($%*d5$>*%h$%&4(-*;(&$5%#C*3%D=4')*<=&*%(D>*545$5($5B%)*$>%*&%#,-$*>(#*6%%4*'%#D&56%'C*O>%#%*&%#,-$#*d%&%*-(6%--%'*(DD=&'54@*$=*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*#.4%&@.*$.;%#*<=--=d54@*<&="*$>%*$>%=&%$5D(-* <&("%d=&Q)* $=*D>%DQ* <=&*#.4%&@.*(D>5%B%"%4$#* &%#,-$54@* <&="*$>%*545$5($5B%#C*A54(--.)*$>%*54$%&B%4$5=4*<&="*$>%*D(#%#*>(B%*6%%4*'%#D&56%'*(4'*$>%*(D$5=4#*>(B%* 6%%4* -(6%--%'* d5$>* 54$%&B%4$5=4#* $>($* "%%$* $>%* ;&%D=4'5$5=4#* '%&5B%'* <&="* $>%*-5$%&($,&%* &%B5%d7* O&,#$* (4'* J="",45D($5=4* ROJS)* !6#=&;$5B%* J(;(D5$.* <=&* #>(&54@*&%#=,&D%#*R!JS*(4'*V&@(45f($5=4(-*Z%('%&#>5;*#,;;=&$*RVZSC*J>(;$%&*]C/*d5--*%-(6=&($%*=4*$>5#*;&=D%##C**

>(I!?1)1!-+<<%-).+#!1#$!1#1<=0.0!L+*!)2%!$%0.@#!!<$%&* $>%* '($(* 4%D%##(&.* <=&* '%B%-=;54@* $>%* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* 5#* @($>%&%')* (* '%$(5-%'*#=-,$5=4* d5--* 6%* '%#5@4%'* <=&* (* #;%D5<5D* D(#%)* 4("%-.* J20C* O>%&%<=&%)* '($(* D=--%D$5=4*D=4D%&454@* $>%* '%#5@4* <=&* J20* 5#* 4%D%##(&.C* O>5#* D>(;$%&* d5--* &%<-%D$* =4* $>%* '($(*D=--%D$5=4* (4'* (4(-.#5#* <=&* $>%* #=-,$5=4* '%#5@4C* O>5#* '($(* D=4#5#$#* =<* $>&%%* =<* $>%* #5h*#=,&D%#* =<* %B5'%4D%* (#* ;&=;=#%'* 6.* L54* R1::]S7* A<;+G*4$2)* )4$*#,)*-2* (4'* A)#*;$%<@2*#,"$)<42C*O>%#%*#=,&D%#*D=4$&56,$%*$=*$>%*#$&%4@$>*=<* $>%*$(5-=&%'*#=-,$5=4*(4'*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*#>=&$-.7*%

9<;+G*4$2* * K=D,"%4$($5=4* 54B=-B%#* $>%* &%$&5%B(-* (4'* (4(-.#5#* =<* 54$%&4(-*'=D,"%4$(&.*'($(* <&="*;&%B5=,#-.* <545#>%'*;&=g%D$#* (4'*4%d#*6,--%$54#*=<*J20C* O>%#%*'=D,"%4$#* 54D-,'%* ;&%#%4$($5=4#)* =&@(45f($5=4(-* @,5'%-54%#)* ;&=D%##* '=D,"%4$($5=4#*(4'*6,#54%##*D(#%*&%;=&$#C*** ?4$*#,)*-2% * O>%* #%D=4'* "%$>='* =<* '($(* D=--%D$5=4* 5#* $>%* ,#%* =<* 54$%&B5%d#C*E4$%&B5%d#*d5--* 6%* >%-'*d5$>* $>%* =d4%&* =<* $>%* <5&"#)* $>%* ;%&#=4#* &%#;=4#56-%* <=&* %(D>*'5B5#5=4* (4'* %";-=.%%#C* O(6-%* 9* '5#;-(.#* $>%* -5#$* =<* 54$%&B5%d%%#C* X.* D=4',D$54@* $>%*54$%&B5%d#)*$>%*&%#%(&D>%&*@%$#*54B=-B%'*"=&%*'%%;-.*54*$>%*<5&"*(4'*$>%*'($(*D=--%D$%'*D(4*6%*,#%'*$=*'%#5@4*$>%*#=-,$5=4C***9"ST%'P'U'.-$%&/,%^%%#'

U.*DW+*@1#.F1).+#! "#)%*7.%8%%!:>X! [#&$('7*2'C8%&$&2':N?O;':[7C;':>X!4*+Y%-)!J,*%1,! N#8&%%&'7*2'4&$'F(22&':NF;':>X!T%$.1! F*$+'\&9)&$':F\;':>X!Z%)8+*Q! 5(24*'N*0%$(.9)':5N;'

%9)#*;$%<@2*#,"$)<42% %O>%* <54(-*"%$>='* =<* '($(* D=--%D$5=4* 5#* '5&%D$* =6#%&B($5=4C* K,&54@*$>5#*&%#%(&D>)*$>%*&%#%(&D>%&*#;%4'#*#,6#$(4$5(-*$5"%*=4_#5$%)*>%&%6.*@%$$54@*54B=-B%'*54*$>%*'(5-.*=;%&($5=4#*=<* $>%* <5&"C*O>5#*;&=B5'%#* $>%* &%#%(&D>%&*d5$>* $>%*=;;=&$,45$.* $=*D=--%D$* D=4$%h$,(-* 54<=&"($5=4* (4'* 5";&%##5=4#* 54* (''5$5=4* $=* $>%* 54$%&B5%d#* RH4=--)*/009SC**

>(O!S1<.$.)=!1#$!*%<.1A.<.)=!O>%*<=--=d54@*;(&$*=<*$>5#*&%#%(&D>*;&=;=#(-*d5--*-==Q*($*$>%*B(-5'5$.*(4'*&%-5(65-5$.*=<*$>%*'($()*$=*#%%*d>%$>%&*5$*5#*;=##56-%*$=*'%#5@4*@%4%&(-*Q4=d-%'@%*=4*$>%*$=;5D*=<*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4*B5(*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4C*O>5#*;(&$*d5--*#$(&$*d5$>*$>%*'5#D,##5=4*=<*$>%*B(-5'5$.C*

Page 38: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 29*

>(O('!:+#0)*,-)!71<.$.)=!J=4#$&,D$* B(-5'5$.* &%<%&#* $=* $>%* (;;&=;&5($%* (4'* (DD,&($%* "%(#,&%"%4$* =<* Q%.*D=4#$&,D$#)*5C%C*5$*&%<%&#*$=*$>%*%h$%4$*$=*d>5D>*(*&%#%(&D>*;&=D%',&%*-%('#*$=*(4*(DD,&($%*=6#%&B($5=4*=<*&%(-5$.*RL54)*1::]SC*O=*(##,&%*D=4#$&,D$*B(-5'5$.)*L54*R1::]S*#,@@%#$#*$>%*,#%* =<*",-$5;-%* #=,&D%#* =<* %B5'%4D%C* E4* $>5#* $>%#5#)* '5<<%&%4$* #=,&D%#* =<* '($(* (&%* ,#%')*&%#,-$54@* 54* ",-$5;-%* #=,&D%#* =<* %B5'%4D%* <=&* $>%* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#)* d>5D>* "545"5f%#*;%&D%;$5=4* 65(#* $>&=,@>* $&5(4@,-($5=4C* A,&$>%&"=&%)* L54* R1::]S* (&@,%#* <=&* (* D-=#%'*D>(54*=<*%B5'%4D%*<&="*'($(*$=*$>%*D=4#$&,D$#C*O>5#*"%(4#*$>($*$>%*&%#%(&D>%&*",#$*(5"*<=&*%#$(6-5#>54@*(*D-=#%'*D>(54*=<*%B5'%4D%*$>($*(--=d#*(4*%h$%&4(-*=6#%&B%&*$=*<=--=d*$>%*'%&5B($5=4*=<* $>%*%B5'%4D%* <&="*&%#%(&D>*?,%#$5=4*$=* <54(-*D=4D-,#5=4#C*O>5#* $>%#5#*d5--*,#%*54$%&B5%d*D5$($5=4#*(4'*D(#%*'%#D&5;$5=4#*$=*(##,&%*#,D>*(*D-=#%'*D>(54*=<*%B5'%4D%C*A54(--.)* L54* R1::]S* #$($%#* $>($* $>%* &%#,-$#* =<* $>%* #$,'.* #>=,-'* 6%* &%B5%d%'* 6.* Q%.*54<=&"(4$#)*d>=*'5#D,##*$>%*('%?,(D.*(4'*"%(454@<,-4%##*=<*$>%*&%#,-$#C*E4*$>5#*"(#$%&*$>%#5#)* $>%* &%#,-$#* d5--* 6%* '5#D,##%'* d5$>* $>%* "(4(@%&#* =<* J20)* #$(&$54@* d5$>* $>%*;&%-5"54(&.*&%#,-$#*(4'*%4'54@*d5$>*$>%*(D$,(-*5";-%"%4$($5=4*;-(4)*$=*#%%*d>%$>%&*$>%*'%#5@4*#=-,$5=4*"%%$#*$>%*'%#5@4*&%?,5&%"%4$#*(4'*5#*&%-%B(4$*<=&*$>%*D=4#$&,D$)*5C%C*<=&*$>%*D&%($5=4*=<*#.4%&@.C**

>(O(9!"#)%*#1<!71<.$.)=!354D%*$>%*"(#$%&*$>%#5#*(5"#*($*%#$(6-5#>54@*(*D(,#(-*&%-($5=4#>5;)*$>%*54$%&4(-*B(-5'5$.*=<*$>%*&%#%(&D>*#>=,-'*6%*$(Q%4*54$=*(DD=,4$C*E4$%&4(-*B(-5'5$.*&%<%&#*$=*$>%*B(-5'5$.*=<*$>%*D(,#(-* 54<%&%4D%#*"('%* 54* $>%* '5(@4=#5#* (4'* (4(-.#5#* =<* $>%* R6,#54%##S* ;&=6-%"* RL54)*1::]SC* O=* (''&%##* 54$%&4(-* B(-5'5$.)* L54* R1::]S* ;&=;=#%#* $>%* ,#%* =<* ;($$%&4_"($D>54@*-=@5D* RD>%DQ54@*(*;%&D%5B%'*#%?,%4D%*=<* %B%4$#* <=&* $>%*;&%#%4D%*=<* #="%*;($$%&4S*(4'*$5"%_#%&5%#*(4(-.#5#C*O>%#%*;=54$#*(&%*$(Q%4*54$=*(DD=,4$*d>5-%*d&5$54@*$>%*"(#$%&*$>%#5#)*#54D%*5$*5#*(*-=4@5$,'54(-*#$,'.*54*#%(&D>*<=&*#="%*;($$%&4C**

>(O(>!R&)%*#1<!71<.$.)=!Nh$%&4(-* B(-5'5$.* &%<%&#* $=* $>%* @%4%&(-5f(65-5$.*=<* $>%* &%#%(&D>* &%#,-$#* 6%.=4'* $>%* D(#%*#$,'5%#C*T=d*@%4%&(-5f(6-%*&%#,-$#*(&%)*'%;%4'#*=4*$>%*&%#%(&D>*(;;&=(D>*RL54)*1::]SC*354D%* $>%* &%<-%D$5B%* D.D-%*d5--* 4=$* 6%* D=";-%$%')* @%4%&(-5f(65-5$.* =<* '%$%&"54%'*'%#5@4*Q4=d-%'@%* d5--* 4=$* 6%* ;=##56-%C* T=d%B%&)* 5$* #>=,-'* 6%* ;=54$%'* =,$* $>($* $>%* '%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*D=,-'*D=4$&56,$%*$=*(*"=&%*>=-5#$5D*$>%=&.*RZ("4%Q)*1::[S)*4("%-.*$>%=&.*=4*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4*(4'*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4C*O>%*'%#5@4*<=&*J20*d5--*6%*,#%'*$=*#%%*d>%$>%&* $>%* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* @&=,4'%'* 54* -5$%&($,&%* (4'* $>%* D(#%* #$,'5%#* >(B%* $>%*'%#5&%'* %<<%D$C* O>%* &%<-%D$5=4* =<* $>%* $>%#5#* d5--* D=B%&* $>%* $=;5D* =<* %h$%&4(-* B(-5'5$.* 54*@&%($%&*'%$(5-C**

>(O(I!/%<.1A.<.)=!!G%-5(65-5$.*&%<%&#*$=*$>%*;=##565-5$.*$>($*#D>=-(&#*D(4*&%;-5D($%*$>%*&%#%(&D>*d5$>*$>%*#("%*<54'54@#* RL54)*1::]SC*O>%*,#%*=<* #%"5_#$&,D$,&%'* 54$%&B5%d#*(4'*'5&%D$*=6#%&B($5=4#* 54*$>%*'%#5@4*D(#%*"(Q%#*&%;&=',D$5=4*#="%d>($*'5<<5D,-$)*#54D%*5$*5#*6=,4'*$=*$>%*D=4$%h$*(4'* &%#;=4#%#* =<* $>%* 54$%&B5%d%%#C* T=d%B%&)* d=&Q54@* 54* (* #$&,D$,&%'* d(.* 6.*'=D,"%4$54@*$>%*&%#%(&D>*'%#5@4*(4'*&(d*'($(*#%$#*d5--*D=4$&56,$%*$=*>5@>%&*&%-5(65-5$.*=<*$>%*$>%#5#C*!#*d5$>*$>%*%h$%&4(-*B(-5'5$.)*$>%*&%<-%D$5=4*;(&$*=<*$>5#*$>%#5#*d5--*'5#D,##*$>%*&%-5(65-5$.*D=4D%&454@*$>5#*#$,'.*54*@&%($%&*'%$(5-C*

Page 39: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 2:*

I(!B=#%*@=!.#!+C%#!A,0.#%00!D+$%<05!.#0.@2)0!L*+D!C*1-).-%!

%E4* =&'%&* $=*@(54* 54#5@>$#* 54* #.4%&@.* D&%($5=4* 54* ;&(D$5D%)* $>5#* $>%#5#*d5--* '%&5B%* '%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#* <&="* D(#%* #$,'5%#* 54* (''5$5=4* $=* $>%* $>%=&._6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#C* O>%* $%4* D(#%*#$,'5%#* (&%* '&(d4* <&="* %#$(6-5#>%'* <5&"#* (4'* ;&=B5'%'* 6.* $>%* <5&#$* #,;%&B5#=&* =<* $>5#*$>%#5#C* O>%&%<=&%)* '($(* D=--%D$5=4* d5--* 4=$* 6%* '%#D&56%'* 54* '%$(5-2C* O>%* D(#%#* d5--* 6%*54$&=',D%'*#>=&$-.)*<=--=d%'*6.*$>%*D=4#$&,D$5=4*=<*$>%*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#C**

I('!K2%!-10%!0),$.%0!O>%* D(#%* #$,'5%#* (&%* '&(d4* <&="* $%4* %#$(6-5#>%'* <5&"#* 54* $>&%%* N,&=;%(4* &%@5=4#*RW(B(&&%)*3$,$$@(&$*(4'*N54'>=B%4S*(4'*(--*>(B%*5";-%"%4$%'*=;%4*544=B($5=4*;&(D$5D%#*54*$>%5&*6,#54%##*545$5($5B%#C*O>%*<5&"#*>(B%*'5<<%&%4$*#5f%#*(4'*(&%*<&="*'5<<%&%4$*#%D$=&#C**O(6-%*:)*('=;$%'*<&="*$>%*XFVE*I&=g%D$*RXFVE)*/012S*@5B%#*(4*=B%&B5%d*=<*$>%*$%4*D(#%*#$,'5%#C**9"ST%'M'U'C"#%'#$ZW,%#'QA!:.Y'EOB7R'

U.*D! B.F%!!M0;D;<N!

"#$,0)*=!

J+0-2! 5*$3&' ?23(2&&$(23'*24'&8&.%$#2(.0'T%-21#.:+[! F&4(9)' ?23(2&&$(23'*24'&8&.%$#2(.0'J+$%@10!E-2+1! !)*88' ,##4'J*,#0! !)*88' ?@"(1(%(#2'&23(2&&$(23'"#@%)%1D!R#%*@=! !)*88' X#6&$'/8*2%0>&A9(/)&2%'4&0(32'*24'4&7&8#/)&2%'UR"! F&4(9)' ?8&.%$#2')(.$#0.#/&0'V,@<%*;\+D1Q+! !)*88' X$(2%(23'*24'/*/&$'/$#.&00(23'U*%#+0!"*,]1! !)*88' \$*+&0'0R0%&)0'4&0(32'*24')*29-*.%9$(23'42.<.C0! 5*$3&' ?8&.%$#2(.0'S1#!^1#0%8.#Q%<! F&4(9)' ]*0%&'F*2*3&)&2%'o*F%D>(45J=*5#*(*;#%,'=4."*

I(9!G#1<=0.0!!O>5#*;(&$*=<* $>%#5#*;&=B5'%#*$>%*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#)*'%&5B%'*<&="*$>%*D(#%_#$,'.*(4(-.#%#C* O>%* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* (&%* '%&5B%'* B5(* =;%4* D='54@C* A=&* %(D>* D(#%* #$,'.)* $>%*=;%4*544=B($5=4*;&(D$5D%*54*$>%5&*6,#54%##*545$5($5B%#*>(#*6%%4*(4(-.#%')*54*=&'%&*$=*#%%*5<* $>%#%* 545$5($5B%#* >(B%* &%#,-$%'* 54* (* $.;%* =<* #.4%&@.* (#* '%#D&56%'* 54* $>%* -5$%&($,&%*#%D$5=4C* !#* $>%.* #$(4')* $>%* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* 545$5($5B%#* (&%* 4=$* ;(&$5D,-(&-.* ,#%<,-* <=&*

V+2$%"%a+"5)$"$),*%)4A);"$<#%<F%-E"$%E"==*4*A%)4%$E*%A*,*5<=G*4$%<F%"4%i=;%4j% RT,6%&*(4'*Y(4*'%*Y%4)*1::[)*;C*1`9SC*3=)*$>%* 4%h$* #$%;* 54* &%;&%#%4$54@* $>%* '($(* 5#* $=* D='%* $>%* 54D5'%4$#* 54$=* $>%=&%$5D(--.*"%(454@<,-*%B%4$#e*54*$>5#*D(#%*$>%*)4$*#,*4$)<42*;%&<=&"%'*6.*$>%*<5&"*$=*#$(&$*(4*=;%4*544=B($5=4* 545$5($5B%* d5$>* (* $>5&'* ;(&$.C* Nh(";-%#* (&%* #%%Q54@* 54$%&"%'5($%*=&@(45f($5=4#)* D==;%&($5=4* d5$>* %h$%&4(-* ;(&$4%&#* (4'* =;%454@* ,;* <(D5-5$5%#* <=&* =$>%&*;(&$5%#* $=*,#%* 54*=&'%&* $=* 54D&%(#%* $>%* D>(4D%#*=<* <&,5$<,-*;(&$4%&#>5;#C* E4*=&'%&* $=*6%*********************************************************2*O>%*'($(*D=--%D$5=4*(4'*'%$(5-#*=<*$>%*$%4*D(#%*#$,'5%#*>(#*6%%4*'%#D&56%'*54*'%$(5-*54*(;;%4'5h*E*=<*$>%*NMGE3*XFVE*I&=g%D$*RXFVE)*/012SC*A=&*"=&%*54<=&"($5=4*;-%(#%*D=4$(D$*$>%*(,$>=&*=<*$>5#*"(#$%&*$>%#5#C*

%\B5@*#$%T)42$*)4]%

%

Page 40: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]0*

-5#$%'* (#* (4* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4* <=&* #.4%&@.* D&%($5=4)* $>%* %B%4$#* >(B%* $=*54B=-B%*R($*-%(#$S*$d=*;(&$5%#)*(*D>(4@%*54*6,#54%##*"='%-*%-%"%4$R#S*(4'*$>%*54$%4$5=4*$=*(D>5%B%*(*#,&;-,#* 54*B(-,%*R5C%C*=;%4*544=B($5=4*;&(D$5D%#*'%#D&5654@*A*2)#*A* #.4%&@.*=,$D="%*(#*d%--*(#*(-&%('.*#*"5)2*A*#.4%&@.*=,$D="%#*d%&%*-5#$%'*(#*%B%4$#SC*O>%*$.;%#*=<* #.4%&@.* d%&%* D='%'* (DD=&'54@* $=* $>%* $.;=-=@.* (4'* '%<545$5=4#* '%B%-=;%'* 54* $>5#*$>%#5#)* (#* ;&=B5'%'* 54* $>%* $>%=&%$5D(-* <&("%d=&QC* O>5#* <5&#$* #$%;* &%#,-$54@* 54* $>%* %B%4$*D=4#$&,D$#*5#*;&=B5'%'*54*$>%*#%D=4'*D=-,"4*=<*$(6-%*10*=4*$>%*4%h$*;(@%#C*O>%*&%#,-$*=<*$>%*545$5($5B%*5#*;&=B5'%'*54*$>%*$>5&'*D=-,"4*(4'*D='54@*54$=*$>%*R'%#5&%'S*#.4%&@.*54*$>%*<=,&$>* D=-,"4*=<* $>%* $(6-%C* O>%* D='54@* #D>%"%*,#%'* <=&* D='54@* $>%* D=4#$&,D$#* D(4* 6%*<=,4'*54*(;;%4'5h*YEEC**E4*$>%*4%h$*#$%;)*$>%*D=4#$&,D$*%B%4$#*(&%*(4(-.#%'*$=*'5#D=B%&*d>5D>*54$%&B%4$5=4#*>(B%*6%%4* "('%)* (4'* >=d* $>%#%* 54$%&B%4$5=4#* &%(-5f%* $>%* '%#5&%'* =,$D="%#* R5C%C* $>%*"%D>(45#"#*6%>54'*$>%*54$%&B%4$5=4SC*O>%*54$%&B%4$5=4#*(&%*'%#D&56%'*(#*(D$5=4#*$(Q%4*=4* 6%>(-<* =<* $>%* B%4$,&%* 54* =&'%&* $=* (D>5%B%* $>%* R'%#5&%'S* #.4%&@.C* O>%* ,4'%&-.54@*"%D>(45#"#* $>($* "(Q%* $>%* 54$%&B%4$5=4* d=&Q* (&%* -(6%--%'* (DD=&'54@* $=* d>5D>*;&%D=4'5$5=4#* (&%* "%$* 6.* "(Q54@* $>%* 54$%&B%4$5=4)* (#* %h;-(54%'* 54* $>%* $>%=&%$5D(-*<&("%d=&QC*O=*&%D(;)*$>%#%*;&%D=4'5$5=4#*(&%*%4(6-54@*O&,#$*(4'*J="",45D($5=4*ROJS)*!6#=&;$5B%*J(;(D5$.*$=*#>(&%*(4'*,$5-5f%*&%#=,&D%#*R!JS*(4'*V&@(45f($5=4(-*Z%('%&#>5;*RVZSC*O(6-%*10*=4* $>%*4%h$*;(@%#* #>=d#* $>%* &%#,-$#*=<* $>%* D='54@*(4'*(4(-.#54@*=<* $>%*%B%4$#)*$>%*$.;%*=<*#.4%&@.*(D>5%B%'*=<*'%#5&%')*$>%*54$%&B%4$5=4*(4'*$>%*"%D>(45#"*$=*(D>5%B%* $>%* '%#5&%'* =,$D="%#C* O>%* G="(4* 4,"%&(-#* 6%$d%%4* 6&(DQ%$#* 54* $>%* $(6-%*D=&&%#;=4'*$=*$>%*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%*;&=B5'%'*(<$%&*$>%*$(6-%)*(&&(4@%'*;%&*#.4%&@.*$.;%C***'

Page 41: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]1*

9"ST%'BO'U':V%-',--(/"$,(-',-,$,"$,/%#'"-W'(Z$+(1%#'+(W,-0'#+X%1%'

U.*D! :+#0)*,-)!%7%#)05!+C%#!JT!.##+71).+#!2$13&+%(#&(45,#&%,,(6.7%8($.69.&%&0:(

/%0,<)!+L!+C%#!A,0.#%00!D+$%<!.##+71).+#!

K=C%!+L!B=#%*@=!$%0.*%$!

"#)%*7%#).+#!:^'/$*.%(.&'1*0&4'/$(2.(/8&;!;_/$&.#24(%(#2')&%`!!

J+0-2! <2%&$)&4(*%&' #$3*2(U*%(#20' 6&$&' 0#93"%' %#'0&*$."'-#$'&@%&$2*8'/*$%2&$0'%#'3*(2'*..&00'%#'.#)/8&)&2%*$R' %&."2#8#3(&0' *24' %#' 8##+' -#$'/#%&2%(*8' 0#89%(#20' %#' 0#87&' (2%&$2*8'4&7&8#/)&2%' /$#18&)0S' C2' &@%&20(7&' 8&3*8'-$*)&6#$+' "*0' 1&&2' 4&7&8#/&4G' 6(%"' %"&'/#%&2%(*8' %#' 1&' $&>90&4' (2' -9$%"&$' (2(%(*%(7&0':;%'(93*0&%*,;'(

J"&' 90&' #-' (2%&$)&4(*$(&0' %#'0.*2' %"&' &27($#2)&2%' #--&$0' *'A9(.+' #7&$7(&6' #-' *' .&$%*(2'$&0&*$."' -(&84' *24' /#%&2%(*8'%&."2#8#3R' /$#7(4&$0' -#$' 0%*$%>(23' .#88*1#$*%(#2' (2' #$4&$' %#'0*7&' %()&' *24' 0%$9.%9$&'/$#18&)0S' C' 8&3*8' -$*)&6#$+'

'

EC%*1).+#1<':&--(.(&2.(&0;''

H''T1#1@%D%#)':0#87&'/$#18&)0'6(%"'&@%&$2*8'+2#68&43&;''

B&7&8#/)&2%'#-'&@%&20(7&'8&3*8'-$*)&6#$+'':^'<;'>'_JN`''a0&'#-'(2%&$)&4(*$(&0'*24'.8&*$'.#))92(.*%(#2'':^'b<;'>'_JN`''

T%-21#.:+! <2' #$4&$' %#' *."(&7&' "(3"' 8&7&8' #-' (22#7*%(#2G'F&."*2(N#' *()0' %#' .##/&$*%&' 6(%"' &@%&$2*8'/*$%2&$0' 6(%"(2' /918(.8R' -924&4' $&0&*$."'/$#T&.%0':;%'(93*0&%*,;(

c#%' R&%' 4&%&$)(2&4G' 3#*8' %#'*."(&7&' "(3"&$' 8&7&80' #-'(22#7*%(#2'

V#+8<%$@%!T1#1@%D%#)':*."(&7&'"(3"&$'

8&7&80'#-'(22#7*%(#2;'

:^'<<<;'<2%$#49.%(#2'#-'*'.&2%$*8'2&%6#$+'*24'.##/&$*%(#2')*2*3&)&2%'4&/*$%)&2%'*24'.$&*%(#2'#-'*2'(2%&$-*.&'1&%6&&2'%"&'&@%&$2*8'$&0&*$."'6#$84'*24'(2%&$2*8'&@/&$%'6#$84S'_JN`'

T%-21#.:+! <2' #$4&$' %#' &2*18&' +2#68&43&' *00()(8*%(#2':1&R#24' %"&' .&2%$*8' 2&%6#$+;' *' 2&6'4&/*$%)&2%' 6*0' 0&%' 9/' %#' 4&7&8#/' .$#00>-92.%(#2*8' (2%&$-*.&0' *24' 0&.9$&' +2#68&43&'*00()(8*%(#2' :$.665&#$30#.&( *%"8%$0#&+( 59.&(388($.69.&%&0,;'

O9%.#)&0' #-' %"&' /*$%(.(/*%(#2'"*0' 1&&2' 90&4' -#$' %"&'4&7&8#/)&2%' #-' /$#49.%0d'0&$7(.&'.#2.&/%0'*24')*$+&%(23'*24'()*3&'/9$/#0&0'

V#+8<%$@%!D1#1@%D%#)!:*."(&7&'"(3"&$'

8&7&80'#-'(22#7*%(#2;'_!T1#1@%D%#)!:)*2*3&)&2%'(27#87&)&2%;'

:^' b<<;'B&7&8#/)&2%' #-' .$#00>-92.%(#2*8' (2%&$-*.&0'%#' 3&2&$*%&' .#))(%)&2%' *24' ()/8&)&2%*%(#2'4&.(0(#20' %"*%' *$&' 1$#*48R' 09//#$%&4G' %"&$&1R'#7&$.#)(23'%"&'c<Z'0R24$#)&'_JN`S''':^b;' !&2(#$' )*2*3&)&2%' (27#87&)&2%G' 0#'*00()(8*%(#2' .#984' #..9$' 7(*' %"&' "(&$*$."R' #-'*9%"#$(%R'_O5`'

J+$%@10!E-2+1!

\#4&3*0'O."#*' 0%*$%&4' (2' DEEe'6(%"' (%0' -($0%'/8*2%*%(#2' #-' #8(7&' %$&&0G' (2' .8#0&'.#88*1#$*%(#2'6(%"'C3$#)(88*G'*'/8*2%0'29$0&$R'2;%'(*%,.5*$%,<(;%'(93*0&%*,:(

c&6' 190(2&00' #//#$%92(%(&0' 1R'*..&00(23' +2#68&43&' *24'*.A9($(23' )*."(2&$R' %#3&%"&$'-#$' 1#%"' #8(7&>' *24' 6(2&'"*$7&0%(23'

V#+8<%$@%!D1#1@%D%#)!

:&@/&$()&2%*%(#2'*24'T#(2%'190(2&00'4&7&8#/)&2%;'

:<<;'F9%9*8'%$90%'(0'%"&'$&*0#2'6"R'%"(0'/*$%2&$0"(/'#--&$0' 09."' (2%&$&0%(23' 1&2&-(%0' -#$' 1#%"'/*$%2&$0S'_JN`'

J*,#0! ]#$+(23' %#3&%"&$' 6(%"' *' 4&0(32' *3&2.R' %#'0&.9$&' 4&0(32' *24' )*$+&%(23' .#)/&%&2.&0':=385%( 9*.9.,#0#.&<( $5,0.6%*( ,%+6%&0,<($13&&%8,:(

c&6'190(2&00')#4&8'%#'1$(23'8#6'.#0%'0%*24*$4(U&4')90&9)'&@"(1(%0'%#'%"&')*$+&%'*24'0&$7&'2&6'.90%#)&$0'0&3)&2%0'

:,0)+D%*!:&@/*24(23'%"&')*$+&%')&00*3&;'H'T1#1@%D%#)!:8&7&$*3(23'2&6'190(2&00')#4&8;'

:b<<<;' :CN;' !&*$."' -#$' -($)0' 6(%"' *' .#)/*%(18&'.98%9$&G'0(2.&'%"(0'8*R0'%"&'-#924*%(#2'-#$'.#88&.%(7&'1&"*7(#9$' ' :<b;' _O5`' \$(23' (2' 8&*4&$0' -$#)'#9%0(4&'6(%"' 0%$#23' .#))(%)&2%G' 0(2.&' %"&R' .*2' 1$(23' *'-$&0"' /&$0/&.%(7&' *24' *$&' 8&00' %(3"%' %#' &@(0%(23'190(2&00')#4&80S''

Page 42: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]/*

"#@%)%1D!R#%*@=!

]#$+(23' %#3&%"&$' 6(%"' 0&7&$*8' 92(7&$0(%R'/*$%2&$0' 6"&2' ()/8&)&2%(23' %"&' 2&6'190(2&00' )#4&8' 2;%'( 93*0&%*,1#9,<( =385%(9*.9.,#0#.&:(

c&6'190(2&00')#4&8'%#'1$(23')#$&'0%*24*$4(U&4'/$#49.%0'%#'%"&')*$+&%S'

:,0)+D%*':&@/*24(23'%"&')*$+&%')&00*3&;'

:b<<<;'_JN`',#$)'/*$%2&$0"(/0'*24')*(2%*(2'3##4'.#22&.%(#20'1R'(27&0%(23'(2'/*$%2&$0'6(%"'.#))#2'+2#68&43&'*24'8&*$2(23'0+(880G'0(2.&'%"(0'6*R'T#(2%'/$#T&.%0'.*2'1&'4&7&8#/&4'%"*%')*R'4&.$&*0&'.#0%0'*24'$(0+0S''

UR"! ]#$+(23'%#3&%"&$'6(%"'&@%&$2*8'/*$%2&$0'%"*%'/$#7(4&4' )*29-*.%9$(23' *24' 0#-%6*$&'.#)/&%&2.&0' (2' #$4&$' %#' /$#7(4&' *--#$4*18&'.#0%'&--&.%(7&'0#89%(#20':388( $.69.&%&0,>(&%/(45,#&%,,(6.7%8:'

C'2&6'190(2&00')#4&8'%#'.#))&$.(*8(0&'*'8#6'.#0%'0.*22(23'&8&.%$#2')(.$#0.#/&'

:,0)+D%*!:&@/*24(23'%"&')*$+&%')&00*3&;'

:f;'_CN`',?<'"*0'4&7&8#/&4'0)*88&$'190(2&00'%&*)0G'4(--&$&2%(*%&4'-$#)'%"&')*(20%$&*)'#$3*2(U*%(#2'%#'1&.#)&'g*)1(4&@%$#90g'1R'.#)1(2(23'2&6'*24'#84'190(2&00')#4&80'%#3&%"&$'*24'0#'$&0/#24'%#'&27($#2)&2%*8'."*23&'*24'2&6'#//#$%92(%(&0S',?<'"*0'90&4'.8(&2%0'%#'&@/&$()&2%'6(%"'%"&')(.$#0.#/&'*%'$&49.&4'.#0%0G'%#'-(2&>%92&'%"&'4&7(.&S''

V,@<%*;\+D1Q+!

]#$+(23' %#3&%"&$' 6(%"' *' 2&6' .90%#)&$'#/&$*%(23' (2' %"&' *9%#)#%(7&' (2490%$R' *0' .#>.$&*%#$'2;%'(93*0&%*,<(=385%(9*.9.,#0#.&:'

c&6'190(2&00')#4&8'%#'.#))&$.(*8(0&'*'2&6')*."(2&'%#'/$#49.&'6($&')&0"'-#$'%"&'*9%#)#%(7&'(2490%$R'

:,0)+D%*!:&@/*24(23'%"&')*$+&%')&00*3&;''

:b<<<;'_O5`'F#2(%#$'0%$*%&3(.'-(%W'"*7&'3#*80'6(%"'0()(8*$'8&7&8'#-'()/#$%*2.&'%"*%'*$&'2#2>.#2-8(.%(23S''

U*%#+0!"*,]1! ]#$+(23'%#3&%"&$'6(%"'*'%&."2#8#3(.*8'.&2%$&'%"*%'/$#7(4&4'%"&'%&0%'1&2."'%#'7&$(-R'/$#%#%R/&'/$#49.%0'(2'%"&'2&6'190(2&00')#4&8':388($.69.&%&0,>(&%/(45,#&%,,(6.7%8;'

!%$*%&3(.'.#88*1#$*%(#2'%#'4&7&8#/'2&6'190(2&00')#4&80'%#'#--&$'1$*+&'0R0%&)0'%#'%"&'6(24>/#6&$'0&.%#$'

T1#1@%D%#)':8&7&$*3(23'2&6'190(2&00')#4&8;'H':,0)+D%*':&@/*24(23'%"&')*$+&%')&00*3&;'

:b;'_O5`'F*2*3&)&2%'(27#87&)&2%'$&(2-#$.(23'#/&2')(24&4'*%%(%94&'$&098%(23'(2'.#))(%%&4'6#$+&$0'%"*%'&)1$*.&'#//#$%92(%(&0G''':f<<;'_CN`'F*/'%"&'190(2&00')#4&8'%#'#7&$.#)&'(2%&$/$&%*%(#2'4(--&$&2.&0'1&%6&&2'%"&'0%*+&"#84&$0'(27#87&4'(2'190(2&00')#4&8'(22#7*%(#2S'

42.<.C0! O/&2(23'9/'0&7&$*8'#-'(%0'.8&*2'$##)0'*24'$&8*%&4'$&0&*$."'0&$7(.&0'%#'#9%0(4&'/*$%(&0'(2'#$4&$'%#'(2.$&*0&'%"&'."*2.&0'#-'-$9(%-98'/*$%2&$0"(/0':=385%(9*.9.,#0#.&:(

5#6&$'#/&$*%(23'.#0%0'7(*'.90%#)&$0'90(23'%"&'.8&*2'$##)0G'(20(3"%0'(2'+2#68&43&'*24'(4&*0'-#$'2&6'190(2&00'4&7&8#/)&2%'

:,0)+D%*!!:&@/*24(23'%"&')*$+&%')&00*3&;'

:<f;'C//#(2%'.#))92(.*%(#2')*2*3&$G'.#249.%'0%*+&"#84&$'*2*8R0(0'%#'4&-(2&'7*89&'/$#/#0(%(#2S'_JN`'

S1#!^1#0%8.#Q%<!

!%*$%'.#88*1#$*%(#2'6(%"'/$#49.%'4&0(32&$0'*24'4&7&8#/&$0'*%')*29-*.%9$&$0'%#'1$(23'4&0(32'+2#68&43&'-$#)'%"&'/&$0/&.%(7&'#-'#/%()*8'$&.R.8(23':=385%(9*.9.,#0#.&:(

c&6'190(2&00'4&7&8#/)&2%':.#2098%*2.R'H'$&.R.8(23G'$*%"&$'%"*2'0#8&8R'6*0%&'.#88&.%(#2'*24'/$#.&00(23'

:,0)+D%*!:2&6'.#2098%(23'#--&$0'%#'.90%#)&$0;'

:f<;'!%*$%'.$#00>-92.%(#2*8'(2%&$2*8'&7&2%0':(2%&$2*8'.#))92(.*%(#2;'%#'(4&2%(-R'*24'.*%&3#$(0&'%&."2#8#3(.*8'+2#68&43&'.#)/&%&2.&0G'%#'%9$2'%"&0&'.#)/&%&2.&0'(2'7*89&'/$#/#0(%(#20S'_CN`'

Page 43: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]2*

I(>!4*1-).-%;A10%$!C*.#-.C<%0!A=--=d54@*<&="*$>%*(4(-.#5#)* $>%*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#*(&%*'%&5B%')*D($%@=&5#%'*;%&*#.4%&@.* $.;%C*O=@%$>%&)* $>%*;&54D5;-%#* <=&"* $>%*(4#d%&* $=* #,6_?,%#$5=4*])*6.* #>=d54@*d>($*-%##=4#*D(4*6%*-%(&4%'*<&="*;&(D$5D%C**

I(>('!EC%*1).+#1<!0=#%*@=!G&,-+,VT%' .' ' E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%* =;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* D=,-'' '%B%-=;* (* -%@(-*<&("%d=&Q)*#54D%*$>5#*6,5-'#*D=4<5'%4D%*d5$>*;(&$4%&#*$=*6%*#,&%*$>($*$>%.*D(4*&%(;*$>%*6%4%<5$#*=<*$>%*545$5($5B%*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*X=#D>SC*

I(>(9!T1#1@%D%#)!0=#%*@=!G&,-+,VT%' ...' ' E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%*"(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #$(&$* (* D%4$&(-*4%$d=&Q)* #54D%* $>5#* %4>(4D%#* D=--(6=&($5=4* d5$>* %h$%&4(-* ;(&$4%&#)* $=* (D>5%B%* >5@>%&*-%B%-*=<*R=;%4S*544=B($5=4*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*F%D>(45J=SC**'G&,-+,VT%' .I' ' E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%*"(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* D=,-'* 6&54@* 54* -%('%&#*<&="* =,$#5'%)* #54D%* $>%.* D(4* 6&54@* (* <&%#>* ;%&#;%D$5B%* (4'* (&%* -%##* $5@>$* $=* %h5#$54@*6,#54%##*"='%-#*(##5"5-($5=4* D=,-'*=DD,&*B5(* $>%*>5%&(&D>.*=<* (,$>=&5$.* R6(#%'*=4* $>%*D(#%#*=<*X&,4#e*F%D>(45J=S*'G&,-+,VT%'I' ' E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%*"(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.)* #%45=&*"(4(@%"%4$* #>=,-'* 6%*54B=-B%')* &%54<=&D54@* =;%4_"54'%'* ($$5$,'%* &%#,-$54@* 54* D=""5$$%'* d=&Q%&#* $>($*%"6&(D%*=;;=&$,45$5%#*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*A&%4=#*E&,p(SC*

I(>(>!V#+8<%$@%!D1#1@%D%#)!0=#%*@=!G&,-+,VT%'..' 'E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*Q4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@5%#)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*6,5-'*;(&$4%&#>5;#*6(#%'*=4*",$,(-*$&,#$)*#54D%*",$,(-*$&,#$*5#*5";=&$(4$*<=&*$>%*%hD>(4@%*=<*Q4=d-%'@%)*d>5D>*D=,-'*=<<%&*54$%&%#$54@*6%4%<5$#*<=&*6=$>*;(&$4%&#*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*X='%@(#*VD>=(SC**'G&,-+,VT%' I.' ' E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* #>=,-''D="",45D($%*D-%(&-.*$>%5&*=6g%D$5B%#*R%C@C*B5(*54$%&"%'5(&5%#S)*#54D%*D="",45D($5=4*D(4*>%-;* =B%&D="54@* $>%* Q4=d-%'@%* $&(4#<%&* 5##,%#)* &%#,-$54@* 54* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@5%#*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*X=#D>SC*'G&,-+,VT%'I..' 'E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*Q4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@5%#)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*#$(&$*D&=##_<,4D$5=4(-* 54$%&<(D%#)* #54D%* $>5#* @%4%&($%#* D=""5$"%4$* (4'* 5";-%"%4$($5=4*'%D5#5=4#*$>($*(&%*6&=('-.*#,;;=&$%')*$>%&%6.*=B%&D="54@*$>%*WET*#.4'&="%*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*F%D>(45J=SC**

I(>(I!:,0)+D%*!0=#%*@=!G&,-+,VT%'I...' 'E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*D,#$="%&*#.4%&@5%#)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*#%(&D>*<=&*;(&$4%&#*d5$>*(*D=";($56-%*D,-$,&%*R5C%C*;(&$4%&#*d5$>*D=""=4*Q4=d-%'@%*(4'*-%(&454@*#Q5--#*(4'*d5$>* #5"5-(&*@=(-#* $>($* (&%* 4=4_D=4<-5D$54@S* (4'* <=&"*;(&$4%&#>5;#* (4'*"(54$(54* @=='*D=44%D$5=4#* 6.* 54B%#$54@* 54* $>%#%* ;(&$4%&#)* #54D%* $>5#* d(.* g=54$* ;&=g%D$#* D(4* 6%*'%B%-=;%'* $>($* &%#,-$* 54* 4%d* 6,#54%##* 545$5($5B%#* (4'* "(.* '%D&%(#%* D=#$#* (4'* &5#Q#*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%#*=<*X&,4#)*E4@%$%("*N4%&@.*(4'*H,@-%&_^="(Q=SC**

Page 44: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]]*

G&,-+,VT%' .5' * E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%* D,#$="%&* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* (;;=54$* (*D="",45D($5=4* "(4(@%&* (4'* D=4',D$* #$(Q%>=-'%&* (4(-.#5#* $=* '%<54%* $>%* B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4*<=&*$>%*D,#$="%&*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*I>5-5;#SC*'G&,-+,VT%' 5' ' E4* =&'%&* $=* D&%($%* D,#$="%&* #.4%&@5%#)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* '%B%-=;* R#"(--%&S*6,#54%##* $%("#)* '5<<%&%4$5($%'* <&="* $>%* "(54#$&%("* =&@(45f($5=4* $=* 6%D="%*c("65'%h$&=,#c*6.*D="65454@*4%d*(4'*=-'*6,#54%##*"='%-#*$=@%$>%&*(4'*#=*&%#;=4'*$=*%4B5&=4"%4$(-*D>(4@%*(4'*4%d*=;;=&$,45$5%#*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*ANESC*'G&,-+,VT%'5.' *E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*D,#$="%&*#.4%&@5%#)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*#$(&$*D&=##_<,4D$5=4(-*54$%&4(-* %B%4$#* R$=* %4#,&%* 54$%&4(-* D="",45D($5=4S* $=* 5'%4$5<.* (4'* D($%@=&5#%*$%D>4=-=@5D(-*Q4=d-%'@%*D=";%$%4D%#)*$=*$,&4*$>%#%*D=";%$%4D%#*54*B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4#*Rd>5D>*D(4*6%* <=,4'*6.*D=4',D$54@*(*#$(Q%>=-'%&*(4(-.#5#*=&*%h;%&5"%4$($5=4S*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*Y(4*\(4#%d54Q%-SC**'G&,-+,VT%'5..' 'E4*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*D,#$="%&*#.4%&@5%#)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*'%B%-=;*(*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4B(#*$=*=B%&D="%*54$%&;&%$($5=4*'5<<%&%4D%#*6%$d%%4*$>%*#$(Q%>=-'%&#*54B=-B%'*54*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*R6(#%'*=4*$>%*D(#%*=<*A&%4=#*E&,p(SC**

I(I!:+DC1*.0+#!+L!$%0.@#!C*.#-.C<%0!^>%4* $>%* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#* (&%* D=";(&%'* $=* $>%* $>%=&._6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#)* $>%*"(54*'5<<%&%4D%*D(4*6%* #%%4* 54#$(4$-.)*4("%-.* $>%*(6#%4D%*=<*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#*D=4D%&454@*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@5%#C*!-$>=,@>*#="%*=<*$>%*<5&"#*54*$>%*D(#%#*#>(&%*54B%#$"%4$*D=#$#* R%C@C* 54B%#$"%4$#* =<* 6=$>* X='%@(#* VD>=(* (4'* !@&="5--(* 54* "(D>54%&.S)* $>%*R'%#5&%'S* #.4%&@.* $,&4#* =,$* $=* 6%* %5$>%&* =;%&($5=4(-* =&* D,#$="%&* #.4%&@.* R%C@C* g=54$-.*'%B%-=;"%4$* =<* =-5B%* =5-* $=* %h;(4'* * D,#$="%&* 6(#%SC* 3=)* d>5-%*$>%=&%$5D(--.*$>%*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@5%#*(&%*'%#D&56%'*54*$%&"#*=<*=;%&($54@*(*D(;5$(-*"(&Q%$*"=&%* %<<5D5%4$-.)* 54* ;&(D$5D%* 5$* $,&4#* =,$* $>($* #>(&54@* %?,5;"%4$* >(#* $>%* ;,&;=#%* =<*@&=d54@)* 6%D="54@* "=&%* %<<5D5%4$)* =&* #%&B54@* 4%d* D,#$="%&* #%@"%4$#C* O>5#* D(4* 6%*%h;-(54%'*6.*$>%*<(D$*$>($*"=#$*=<*$>%*#.4%&@.*%<<%D$#*&%#,-$54@*<&="*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@5%#*>(B%* $=* =DD,&* B5(* -=d%&54@* =;%&($5=4(-* D=#$#* =&* #%--54@* "=&%* =&* (''5$5=4(-*;&=',D$#b#%&B5D%*$=*D,#$="%&#*54*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*B(-,%*R5C%C*"(Q%*;&=<5$SC*O>5#*'=%#*4=$*"%(4* $>($* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@5%#* (&%* #,;%&<-,=,#* 54* $>%* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@.)* 6%D(,#%* $(h*6%4%<5$#* =&* (DD=,4$54@* 6%4%<5$#* D=,-'* 6%* <=&"#* =<* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@5%#* R"=#$-.* #%%4* 54*<54(4D%* (4'* (DD=,4$54@* -5$%&($,&%* =4* "%&@%&#* (4'* (D?,5#5$5=4#)* %C@C* $(h* ('B(4$(@%#* =<*,4,#%'* '%6$* D(;(D5$.* (#* '%#D&56%'* 6.* 3,'(&#(4("* %$* (-C)* 1::`SC* T=d%B%&)* $>%* D(#%*#$,'5%#* >(B%* 4=$* #>=d4* (4.* %h(";-%#* <=&* $>5#* $.;%* =<* #.4%&@.)* #=* 4=* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*D=4D%&454@*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@.*D=,-'*6%*'%&5B%'*<&="*$>%#%*D(#%#C**J=4D%&454@* $>%* =$>%&* #.4%&@.* $.;%#)* 4=* #$&5Q54@* '5<<%&%4D%#* (;;%(&* 54* $>%* #%$#* =<*;&54D5;-%#C*T=d%B%&)* $>%* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#* ;&=B5'%* -%##* (6#$&(D$* 54$%&B%4$5=4#)*#54D%*$>%#%*54$%&B%4$5=4#*(&%*%h%D,$%'*(D$5=4#*6.*<5&"#)*&($>%&*$>(4*'%#D&5;$5B%*(D$5=4#*

(4'* _6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#* ;&=B5'%* D=4D&%$%)* =&*;%&>(;#*5--,#$&($5B%)*54$%&B%4$5=4#*=<*$>%*$>%=&._6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#C*****

Page 45: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ][*

O(!?%0.@#!O>5#*#%D$5=4*'%#D&56%#*$>%*'%#5@4*#=-,$5=4*<=--=d54@*<&="*(;;-.54@*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#C*O>%* '%#5@4* D(#%* =<* $>%* $>%#5#* R5CDC* J-,6* B(4* 20S* d5--* 6%* 54$&=',D%')* <=--=d%'* 6.* $>%*;&=6-%"*"%##*R5C%C*$>%*D=4$%h$*54*d>5D>*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*(&%*(;;-5%'SC*T%&%(<$%&)*$>%*'%#5@4*&%?,5&%"%4$#*(&%*6&=,@>$* <=&d(&'C*O>%#%*&%?,5&%"%4$#*#>=,-'*6%*"%$* 54*=&'%&*

*(4'*#$&($%@.C*V4D%*$>%*D=4$%h$)* $>%* ;&=6-%"* (4'* &%?,5&%"%4$#* >(B%* 6%%4* %#$(6-5#>%')* $>%* (D$,(-* #=-,$5=4* 5#*'%#5@4%'C*O>%*#=-,$5=4*d5--*6%*(4*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%*$>($*;&=B5'%#*J20*d5$>*'5&%D$5B%#*$=*(D>5%B%*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*Q54'#*=<*#.4%&@.C*O>%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%*d5--* 6%* '%#D&56%'* 54* @%4%&(-* $%&"#)* #=* $>($* J20* D(4* (;;-.* 5$* $=* ",-$5;-%* D(#%#* 54* $>%*<,$,&%C*T=d%B%&)*<=&*$>%*#(Q%*=<*D-(&5$.)*(4*5--,#$&($5B%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*545$5($5B%*5#*

<5&"* #.4%&@.C* O>5#* 545$5($5B%* >(#* #$(&$%'* &%D%4$-.)* <=--=d54@* $>%* '%#5@4* #=-,$5=4* =<* $>5#*$>%#5#C* M4<=&$,4($%-.)* $>%* 545$5($5B%* 5#* D,&&%4$-.* 54* ;&=@&%##)* #=* &%#,-$#* =4* $>%* '%#5@4*#=-,$5=4* D(44=$* 6%* ,#%'* <=&* <%%'6(DQ* =4* $>%* '%#5@4C* 3=)* $>%* 545$5($5B%* &%"(54#* 54* $>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*;>(#%*=<*$>%*&%<-%D$5B%*D.D-%*=<*Y(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C*R/008SC**

O('!:<,A!71#!>X!!J20* D=4#5#$#* =<* $>&%%* '5<<%&%4$* ,45$#)* 4("%-.* J20*I&=g%D$* X,&%(,)* J20*F%'5(* (4'*J20*W%$d=&QC* O>%* <=--=d54@* ;(&$#* d5--* '%#D&56%* $>%#%* ,45$#* 54* "=&%* '%$(5-C* !-$>=,@>* $>5#*$>%#5#*d5--* <=D,#* =4*=;%4* 544=B($5=4* <&="* $>%* ;%&#;%D$5B%* =<* J20*I&=g%D$* X,&%(,)* $>5#*D>(;$%&*d5--*(-#=*'5#D,##*J20*W%$d=&Q*(4'*J20*F%'5(*#>=&$-.*<=&*(*D=";-%$%*=B%&B5%d*=<*$>%*<5&"C*

O('('!:>X!4*+Y%-)!J,*%1,!E4*/00:)*D,&&%4$*JNV*L=%&5*B(4*!-$%&%4*>(#*<=,4'%'*J-,6*B(4*20*XCYC)*(*I&=g%D$*X,&%(,*$>($* (##5#$#* <5&"#* (4'* =&@(45f($5=4#* 54*"(Q54@* $>%5&* 6,#54%##* ;&=D%##%#* 6%D="%*"=&%*#,#$(54(6-%)*6.*<=D,##54@*=4*;&=D%##%#*D=4D%&454@*%4%&@.)*d($%&)*;(DQ(@54@*(4'*d(#$%)*(4'*"=65-5$.C*O>%*#%&B5D%#*J20*I&=g%D$*X,&%(,*;&=B5'%)*D=4#5#$*=<*$>&%%*'5<<%&%4$*;(&$#)*'5#;-(.%'*54*<5@,&%*9 ]

"=&%*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##*;&=D%##%#C*!<$%&*'%$%&"5454@*$>%*#$&($%@.)*$>%*6,#54%##*D(#%*D(4* 6%* '%B%-=;%')* 6(#%'* =4* =;$5"5f($5=4* (4'* 544=B($5=4* D=4D%&454@* $>%* <=,&* $>%"%#*R%4%&@.)*d($%&)*;(DQ(@54@*(4'*d(#$%)*(4'*"=65-5$.SC**

*;,0Z&%'P'U'*%&/,+%'()'C7O'Q"W(V$%W')&(1'^^^6+TZS/"-7O6-TR'

********************************************************]*O&(4#-($%'*<&="*K,$D> *

Page 46: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]`*

[ NB%&.*D=";(4.*'%;%4'#*=4*#,;;-5%&#)*6,.%&#* (4'* =$>%&* #$(Q%>=-'%&#C* H4=d-%'@%* #>(&54@* D=4D%&454@* #,#$(54(65-5$.* $>%"%#*&%#,-$#* 54* 544=B($5B%* 5'%(#* (4'* ;&="5#54@* 6,#54%##* "='%-#)* >%4D%* $>%* 5";=&$(4D%* =<*D==;%&($5=4* (4'* $>%* (4(-=@.* $=* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=4C* O>%* <54(-* #$%;* 54* $>%*

` * $>%* (D$,(-* 5";-%"%4$($5=4* =<* $>%* 6,#54%##* D(#%C* I(&$* =<* $>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4* 5#* $>%* <,4'54@*=<* $>%*;&=g%D$)* %5$>%&* 54$%&4(--.*=&* <,4'%'*6.* #,6#5'5%#)*d>%4*%-5@56-%C*O>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4B(#*=<*J20*I&=g%D$*X,&%(,*5#*;&=B5'%'*54*(;;%4'5h*YEEEC*

O('(9!:>X!Z%)8+*Q!3,#$(54(65-5$.* 5#* (* 6&=('* (4'* D=";-%h* D=4D%;$C* O=*"(Q%* #,&%* J20*I&=g%D$* X,&%(,* D(4*

D(;(65-5$5%#)* $>%*;&=g%D$*6,&%(,*"(Q%#*,#%*=<* (*4%$d=&Q* $=* D="654%*Q4=d-%'@%*=4* $>%*$=;5D*=<*#,#$(54(65-5$.C*O>%*4%$d=&Q*D=4#5#$#*=<*<5&"#*(4'*4=4_@=B%&4"%4$*=&@(45f($5=4#*$>($*;&=B5'%*(DD%##*$=*B(-,(6-%*Q4=d-%'@%*(4'*D=4$&56,$%*$=*6,#54%##*D(#%*'%B%-=;"%4$C**

O('(>!:>X!T%$.1!J20*F%'5(* 5#* (4* 54<=&"($5=4* D>(44%-* $>($* (5"#*($*"(Q54@* #,#$(54(65-5$.* (DD%##56-%* <=&*$>%*6,#54%##*%4B5&=4"%4$C*K(5-.)*$>%*d%6#5$%*'5#;-(.#*#%B%&(-*5";=&$(4$*4%d#*$=;5D#*=4*#,#$(54(6-%*R%4$&%;&%4%,&5(-S*5##,%#)*54*=&'%&*$=*54#;5&%*D=";(45%#C*J20*F%'5(*<54'#*5$#*=&5@54*($* $>%* <=,4'($5=4*=<*J20*I&=g%D$*X,&%(,C*W%d#*6,--%$54#*d%&%*;,6-5#>%'*=4* $>%*d%6#5$%* =<* J20* I&=g%D$* X,&%(,)* $=* 54#;5&%* (4'* 54<=&"* B5#5$=&#* =4* $>%* $=;5D* =<*#,#$(54(65-5$.C* 3$(&$54@* +,4%* /01/)* J20*F%'5(* D="",45D($%#* $>&=,@>* 5$#* =d4*d%6#5$%)*9++#>""G@*A#)VF25*,*4C45)* &($>%&* $>(4* B5(* $>%* D>(44%-#* =<* J20* I&=g%D$* X,&%(,C*K,,&f(("6%'&5g<#-%B%4C4-* 5#* (4*(,$=4="=,#*(4'* 54'%;%4'%4$*;(&$*=<*J-,6*B(4*20*XCYC*O>%* $%&"* J20* F%'5(* 54* $>5#* $>%#5#* &%<%&#* $=* $>%* D,&&%4$-.* ,#%'* (,$=4="=,#* d%6#5$%*(;(&$*<&="*J20*I&=g%D$*X,&%(,C**

O(9!4*+A<%D!D%00!1#$!+AY%-).7%0!<F%@+2)4*22%E"2%*U$*4A*A% F#<G%$E"$%<F% $E*%$#"A)$)<4"5%*;<4<G);%";$<#%$<%

@*)4:%"%=<5)$);"5%"4A%2<;)"5%";$<#&%#;=4#565-5$.* >(B%* D=4#%?,%4$-.* 6%D="%* (4* 54D&%(#54@-.* >5@>* ;&=<5-%* 5##,%* 54* "(4.*D=,4$&5%#* (4'* @-=6(-5f54@* 54',#$&5%#C* E4* (''5$5=4* $=* %D=4="5D* (##%##"%4$#) !%4B5&=4"%4$(-*(4'*#=D5(-*5";(D$*<&="*=;%&($5=4#*#>=,-'*(-#=*6%*54$%@&($%'*"=&%*D-=#%-.*54$=* D=&;=&($%* #$&($%@5D* '%D5#5=4_"(Q54@* RJ>&5#$"(44)* /00]SC* K.--5DQ* (4'* T=DQ%&$#*R/00/)*;C*121S*'%<54%*D=&;=&($%*#,#$(54(65-5$.*(#*)4A)#*;$% 2$"K*E<5A*#2% \2+;E% "2% 2E"#*E<5A*#2X% *G=5<6**2X% ;5)*4$2X% =#*22+#*% :#<+=2X%;<GG+4)$)*2% *$;.]X% -)$E<+$% ;<G=#<G)2)4:% )$2% "@)5)$6% $<% G**$% $E*% 4**A2% <F% F+$+#*%

O='(.)*"=#$*"(4(@%&#*>(B%*(DD%;$%'*D=&;=&($%*#,#$(54(65-5$.*(#*(*;&%D=4'5$5=4* <=&* '=54@* 6,#54%##C* O=d(&'#* $>5#* @=(-)* <5&"#* >(B%* $=*"(54$(54* (4'* @&=d*$>%5&*%D=4="5D)*#=D5(-*(4'*%4B5&=4"%4$(-*D(;5$(-*6(#%*RK.--5DQ*(4'*T=DQ%&$#)*/00/SC* E4*&%D%4$*.%(&#)*#D>=-(&#*>(B%*(&@,%'*$>($*5$*5#*;=##56-%*$=*(D>5%B%*d54_d54*#D%4(&5=#*,4'%&*d>5D>*(*<5&"*D(4*"(h5"5f%*&%$,&4#*d>5-%*"(Q54@*;&=@&%##*$=d(&'#*$>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*=<* #,#$(54(6-%* 6,#54%##* ;&(D$5D%#* RA=d-%&* (4'* T=;%)* /008SC* !* ;&=(D$5B%* D=&;=&($%*%4B5&=4"%4$(-* #$&($%@.* D(4* -%('* $=* $>%* '%B%-=;"%4$* =<* 5";=&$(4$* =&@(45f($5=4(-*D(;(65-5$5%#* $>($* D(4* 54D&%(#%* <5&"* D=";%$5$5B%4%##* RA=d-%&* (4'* T=;%)* /008SC* 3=)*

********************************************************[* *`* *

Page 47: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]8*

#,#$(54(6-%* '%#5@4* (4'* ;&(D$5D%#* 4=$* =4-.* '%D&%(#%* 4%@($5B%* 5";(D$#* =4* $>%*%4B5&=4"%4$)* 6,$* (-#=* D=,-'* ;&=B5'%* %D=4="5D* 6%4%<5$#)* ;&=',D$5B5$.* 6%4%<5$#)* (4'*%4>(4D%*;,6-5D*&%-($5=4#*R\=$$<&5%')*/002SC*3,#$(54(65-5$.*5";&=B%#*$>%*%D=4="5D*6=$$="*-54%* 6.* &%',D54@* =;%&($54@* D=#$#* (4'* =;$5"5f54@* -5<%_D.D-%* %D=4="5D* ;%&<=&"(4D%C*I&=',D$5B5$.* 6%4%<5$#* 54D-,'%* 5";&=B%'* ;%&<=&"(4D%* (4'* 54D&%(#%'* ;&=',D$5B5$.* (4'*#(-%#)*d>%&%(#*;,6-5D*&%-($5=4#*%4>(4D%"%4$#*54D-,'%*"(&Q%$54@*('B(4$(@%#*R\=$$<&5%')*/002SC**!-$>=,@>*"(4.* <5&"#*d5$>* ;==&* %4B5&=4"%4$(-* ;%&<=&"(4D%* #%--* $>%"#%-B%#* (#* 6%54@*@&%%4)*$>%*#=_ *^(4)*/011S)*(4'*"(4(@%&#*"(.*;&%<%&*#."6=-5D*(D$5=4#*$=*#,6#$(4$5B%*(D$5=4#*=4*%4B5&=4"%4$(-*5##,%#)*#54D%*#5@4(--54@*@&%%4*B(-,%#* 5#* %(#5%&* $>(4* 5";-%"%4$54@* $>%#%* B(-,%#* d5$>* (D$5=4#* R3,D>"(4)* 1::[S)* 5$* 5#*54D&%(#54@-.* 5";=&$(4$* <=&* <5&"#* $=* 6%D="%* "=&%* #,#$(54(6-%C* !-#=* 54* -5$%&($,&%)* $>%*&%-($5=4#>5;* 6%$d%%4* #,#$(54(65-5$.* (4'* ;%&<=&"(4D%* 5#* (4* %"%&@54@* <5%-'* =<* #$,'.C*T=d%B%&)* $>%* D,&&%4$* #$($%* =<* &%#%(&D>* =4* #,#$(54(65-5$.* 54* 6,#54%##* =<$%4* <=D,#%#* =4*>=d%$>%* D=4D%;$#* =<* #,#$(54(65-5$.* D=,-'%6%%)4$*#=#*$*A* 54* $>%* 6,#54%##_D=4$%h$)* &($>%&*$>(4* ;&%#D&5654@* >=d* #,#$(54(65-5$.* #>=,-'% 6%% )4$*:#"$*A% 54$=* 5$* R35-B5,#* P* W%'%#Q5)*/011SC***!#* D(4*6%*'%',D$%')* 5$*6%D="%#* 54D&%(#54@-.* 5";=##56-%* <=&*6=$>* <5&"#*(4'*#D>=-(&#* $=*(B=5'*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*#,#$(54(6-%*'%B%-=;"%4$C*T=d%B%&)*($*$>%*#("%*$5"%*5$*5#*D-%(&*$>($*

E"2%@**4%+2*A%$<%G*"4%A)FF*#*4$%$E)4:2%$<%A)FF*#*4$%=*<=5*%)4%RX%6654@$=4)* /001)* ;C2SC* !#* (* &%#,-$)* #,#$(54(6-%* '%B%-=;"%4$*

D=4#$5$,$%#*(*D>(--%4@%*$=*<5&"#)*#54D%*4%5$>%&*$>%*D=4D%;$)*4=&*$>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*=<*5$)*D(4* 6%* ;&=;%&-.* '%<54%'C* O=* =B%&D="%* $>%#%* D>(--%4@%#)* Y(4*H-%%<* (4'*G=="%* R/008S*(&@,%* <=&* D=--(6=&($5B%* 544=B($5=4* $>&=,@>* 4%$d=&Q#* (4'* ",-$5_(D$=&* <=&,"#C* O>%*D=4D%;$*6%54@*6&=(')*Q4=d-%'@%*=4*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*$=;5D#*5#*(-#=*d5'%#;&%('*(4'*&%?,5&%#*%h;%&$5#%*54*"(4.*<5%-'#C*

*J20*I&=g%D$* X,&%(,* &%D=@45f%#* $>%#%* D>(--%4@%#* <5&"#* (&%* <(D54@* (4'* >%-;#* $>%"*d5$>*5";-%"%4$54@* $>%5&*("65$5=4#*6.* $&(4#-($54@* $>%#%* 54$=* $>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#C*K%#;5$%*$>%*%h;%&$5#%*;&%#%4$*d5$>54*$>%*D=";(4.)*J20*(-#=*&%D=@45f%#*$>%*4%%'*<=&*4%$d=&Q54@*(4'*D=--(6=&($5B%*544=B($5=4*$=*'%B%-=;*(;;-5D(6-%*6,#54%##*D(#%#*R54*-54%*d5$>*Y(4*H-%%<*(4'*G=="%*R/008SSC*O>5#*5#*%h;&%##%'*d%--*6.*$>%*<=--=d54@*?,=$%*<&="*JNV*L=%&5*B(4*!-$%&%47%

%

O>5#*"%$>='*>(#*&%#,-$%'*54*",-$5;-%*#,DD%##<,-*(4'*#,#$(54(6-%*545$5($5B%#*=B%&*$>%*;(#$*.%(&#8C* T=d%B%&)* (#* D("%* <=&d(&'* ',&54@* $>%* 54$%&B5%d#)* $>%* #=-,$5=4#* J20* D,&&%4$-.*;&%#%4$#* $=* 5$#* D,#$="%&#)* "5@>$* >(B%* $>%* ;=$%4$5(-* $=* 6%* 54$&=',D%'* 54$=* (4* %4$5&%*"(&Q%$)* &($>%&* $>(4* #=-%-.* 6%54@* ,#%'* 6.* =4%* D,#$="%&C* !$* $>5#*"="%4$)* J20* ('B5#%#*D,#$="%&#* d5$>* $>%* 5";-%"%4$($5=4)* (<$%&* d>5D>* $>%* ;&=g%D$* 5#* <545#>%'C* T=d%B%&)*D="65454@* $>%* Q4=d-%'@%* (4'* %h;%&$5#%* =<* J20* d5$>* $>%* '(5-.* =;%&($5=4#* =<* 5$#*D,#$="%&#)* D=,-'* &%#,-$* 54* 544=B($5=4#* $>($* D=,-'* 6%* 5";-%"%4$%'* "(&Q%$_d5'%)*&%#,-$54@* 54* (* #,&;-,#* 54* B(-,%* <=&* 6=$>* D=";(45%#C* E4* =$>%&* d=&'#)* D=--(6=&($5=4*

********************************************************8*3%%*<=&*"=&%*54<=&"($5=47*>$$;7bbdddCD-,6B(420C4-b;=&$<=-5=b*

_*%A*#),*%<+#%5*:)$)G";6%F#<G%<+#%4*$-<#K.%W<%="#$6%E"2%"55%K4<-5*A:*%)4%$E*%"#*"%<F%2+2$")4"@)5)$6%)43E<+2*.%P+#%=#<V*;$%G"4":*#2%K4<-%F<#%*";E%V<@%-E);E%="#$)*2%$<%5)4K%"4A%E<-%$<%:+)A*%$E*G%$<%"%2+;;*22F+5%;<<=*#"$)<4 %

Page 48: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]9*

6%$d%%4*J20*(4'*5$#*D,#$="%&#*>(#*$>%*;=$%4$5(-*$=*&%#,-$*54*<5&"*#.4%&@.)*6,$*D,&&%4$-.*#$(@4($%#*(<$%&*$>%*;&=g%D$*5#*<545#>%'C*E4*(*#5$,($5=4*=<*D-=#%*D=--(6=&($5=4)*$>%*D>(--%4@%*<5&"#* <(D%*d>5-%* 5";-%"%4$54@* #,#$(54(65-5$.* 54* $>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-* D(4*6%*=B%&D="%*6.*,#54@*Q4=d-%'@%*(4'*%h;%&$5#%*=<*J20)*d>5-%*J20*=4* 5$#* $,&4*D=,-'*"(Q%*,#%*=<* $>%*'(5-.* =;%&($5=4#* =<* $>%* <5&"#* $=* %4$%&* 4%d* "(&Q%$#* d5$>* #,#$(54(6-%* 6,#54%##*544=B($5=4#C* O>%* ;=$%4$5(-* 6%4%<5$#* $>($* (&5#%* d=,-'* 6%* &%;,-#54@* @&%%4_d(#>54@)*%4#,&54@* &%D,&&54@* ;(."%4$#* <=&* 6=$>* <5&"#)* 5";-%"%4$54@* 544=B($5=4#* "(&Q%$_d5'%*(4'*5"(@%*6,5-'54@*<=&*6=$>*<5&"#C***3=)* (#* D("%* <=&d(&'* <&="* $>%* 54$%&B5%d#*d5$>* L=%&5* B(4* !-$%&%4* (4'* J=-%$$%* B(4* '%&*F544%)* J20* I&=g%D$* X,&%(,* (-&%('.* '%-5B%&#* $>%* =,$;,$* <=&* #,#$(54(6-%* 6,#54%##*544=B($5=4#)*6,$*-(DQ#*$>%*"%(4#*(4'*=;%&($5=4(-*&%#=,&D%#*$=*%4$%&*$>%*"(&Q%$*d5$>*$>5#*Q4=d-%'@%C*E$#*D,#$="%&#*=4*$>%*=$>%&*>(4')*&%D%5B%*$>%*#,#$(54(6-%*#=-,$5=4*$>%.*>(B%*(#Q%'*<=&)*6,$* -(DQ*$>%*Q4=d-%'@%*$=* 5";-%"%4$* 5$* 54* $>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-*d5$>=,$* $>%*Q4=d-%'@%*(4'*%h;%&$5#%*=<*J20C*O=@%$>%&)*J20*(4'*5$#*D,#$="%&#*D=,-'*D=--(6=&($%*(4'*=;%4*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#*54*=&'%&*$=*"(h5"5f%*$>%*;=$%4$5(-*=<*$>%*#=-,$5=4*(4'*D&%($%*"=&%* B(-,%* $=@%$>%&* $>%4* $>%* D="654%'* B(-,%* $>%.* D=,-'* >(B%* D&%($%'* (D$54@*54'%;%4'%4$-.* =<* %(D>* =$>%&C* O>%* ;&=6-%"* &%"(54#)* >=d%B%&)* >=d* =;%454@* $>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#*d=,-'*&%#,-$*54*<5&"*#.4%&@5%#C*O>%&%<=&%)*$>%*'%#5@4*#=-,$5=4*d5--*<=D,#*=4*$>5#*5##,%*6.*(4#d%&54@*#,6_?,%#$5=4*]7**

"#$%&#'()*+,!@.!A+B!91,!+2',!$#(*,'((!3+4'5!*,,+61)*+,'0'52!C?D!*,!9<'1)*,=!1,4!122<+2<*1)*,=!(;,'<=;7!

O(>!?%0.@#!*%H,.*%D%#)0!Y(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C*R/008S*;&=;=#%*$>($*$>%*'%#5@4*>(#*$=*<,-<5-*#%B%&(-*&%?,5&%"%4$#C*E<*$>%#%*&%?,5&%"%4$#* (&%* =B%&-==Q%')* 5$* -%('#* $=* g,#$5<5D($5=4* ;&=6-%"#* =<* $>%* #=-,$5=4C* O>%*&%?,5&%"%4$#*Y(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C*R/008S*;&=;=#%*(&%*<,4D$5=4(-*&%?,5&%"%4$#*R$>%*#=-,$5=4*#>=,-'* #=-B%* $>%* 5'%4$5<5%'* ;&=6-%"S)* ,#%&* &%?,5&%"%4$#* R#;%D5<5D* '%"(4'#* <&="* $>%*B5%d;=54$* =<* $>%* ,#%&#)* #=* $>($* $>%.* (&%* d5--54@* (4'* D(;(6-%* =<* 5";-%"%4$54@* $>%*#=-,$5=4S)* 6=,4'(&.* D=4'5$5=4#* R(;;%(&* 54* "(4.* <=&"#)* %C@C* 54* $>%* <=&"* =<* -(d#)*&%@,-($5=4#)* -5D.)* %$DCS* (4'* <54(--.)* '%#5@4* &%#$&5D$5=4#*R&%#$&5D$5=4#* $>($* #>=,-'* 6%* "%$* 54* =&'%&* $=* 5";-%"%4$* $>%* #=-,$5=4SC* K,&54@* $>%*54$%&B5%d#* (4'* $>%* 54$%&4(-* '5#D,##5=4#* >%-'* d>5-%* #;%4'54@* #,6#$(4$5(-* $5"%* =4* #5$%*R<5B%*"=4$>#S)*$>%*<=--=d54@*'%#5@4*&%?,5&%"%4$#*>(B%*6%%4*"%4$5=4%'7**'c2*#%#*a+)#*G*4$2'%

1C O>%*#=-,$5=4*#>=,-'*D=4$&56,$%*$=*&%D,&&54@*;(."%4$#*R%C@C*B5(*#%&B5D%#S)*54*=&'%&*$=* &%',D%* $>%* &5#Q* =<* -=d* D(#>* <-=d#)* (##=D5($%'* d5$>* %h%D,$54@* =4%_=<_(_Q54'*;&=g%D$#*<=&*<5&"#*R5C%C*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@.SC*

/C J20*d(4$#* $=* &%(D>*"=&%* D,#$="%&#*d5$>* $>%* #=-,$5=4* $>%.* >(B%* '%B%-=;%'* 6.*54$&=',D54@*5$*$=*$>%*"(&Q%$*R5C%C*D,#$="%&*#.4%&@.SC*

2C 354D%* #;%D5<5D*"(&Q%$*Q4=d-%'@%*(4'* &%#=,&D%#*(&%*4=$* &%('5-.*(B(5-(6-%*d5$>54*J20)* $>%&%* ",#$* 6%* (* #$&=4@* <=D,#* =4* =;%454@* 6=&'%&#* 54* =&'%&* $=* <=&"*;(&$4%&#>5;#*d5$>* ;(&$5%#* $>($* >(B%* $>%* &%#=,&D%#* (4'* Q4=d-%'@%* $=* #%&B%* $>%*"(&Q%$*R=;%&($5=4(-bQ4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@.SC*

%%%

Page 49: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ]:*

9*2):4%#*2$#);$)<42%4. 354D%*J20*5#*(*&%-($5B%-.*#"(--*<5&")*D,&&%4$-.*4=*6,#54%##*'%B%-=;"%4$*,45$*%h5#$#*

(4'*545$5($5B%#*#>=,-'*6%*$>%*&%#,-$*<&="*;&=g%D$#*%h%D,$%'*6.*J20*I&=g%D$*X,&%(,C 'Q+4;$)<4"5%#*a+)#*G*4$2%

[C O>%* #=-,$5=4#* #>=,-'* ;&=B5'%* (4* =B%&B5%d* =<* $>%* #.4%&@5%#* $.;%#* $>($* D(4* 6%*(D>5%B%'*B5(*D=--(6=&($5=4*d5$>*=$>%&*;(&$5%#*R<,4D$5=4(-*&%?,5&%"%4$SC*

`C O>%* #=-,$5=4* #>=,-'* ;&=B5'%* D-%(&*@,5'%-54%#* $>($* #>=d*>=d* $>%* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-*=<*J20*I&=g%D$*X,&%(,*D=,-'*&%#,-$*54*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*#.4%&@.*<=&"#C*

O(I!?%0.@#!0+<,).+#!!A=--=d54@*<&="*$>%*'%#5@4*&%?,5&%"%4$#*(4'*6=$>*;&(D$5D%_*(4'*$>%=&._6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#)*$>%* #=-,$5=4* D(4* 6%* '%#5@4%'C* O>%* '%#5@4* d5--* 6%* (4* =;%4* 6,#54%##* "='%-* $%";-($%)*<=d5$>*'5#D,##54@*$>%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%*$=*#%%*d>.*5$*5#*5";=&$(4$*$=*"(;*$>%*'%#5@4* #=-,$5=4* (4'* d5--* D=4$54,%* d5$>* ;&=B5'54@* $>%* #%;(&($%* 6,#54%##* "='%-*D=";=4%4$#*(4'*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*$>($*&%<-%D$*,;=4*$>%#%*D=";=4%4$#*R$>%*$>%=&._6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#*>(B%*!&(65D*4,"%&(-#*(4'*$>%*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#*(&%*;&%#%4$%'*d5$>* G="(4* 4,"%&(-#SC* O>%* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* $>($* D(44=$* 6%* ($$(D>%'* $=* =4%* =<* $>%*6,#54%##* "='%-* D=";=4%4$#)* 6,$* &%<-%D$* =4* "55* 6,#54%##* "='%-* D=";=4%4$#* d5--* 6%*'5#D,##%'* #%;(&($%-.* ($* $>%* %4'* =<* $>%* #=-,$5=4C* T=d%B%&)* (#* #$($%'* 6.* J>%#6&=,@>*R/010S)*"(;;54@*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*#=-%-.*D(44=$*;&="=$%*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)*(-#=* $>%* ;&=D%##%#* 4%%'* $=* 6%* ('(;$%')* %C@C* B5(* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4C* O>%&%<=&%)* (-#=* (4*5--,#$&($5B%*D(#%)*(4*545$5($5B%*54*$>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*;>(#%)*5#*;&=B5'%'*54*$>%*$%h$*6=h%#*(#*;(&$*=<*$>%*'%#5@4*#=-,$5=4*$=*D-(&5<.*#="%*=<*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#C*!;;%4'5h*Ea*#>=d#*$>%* (;;-5D($5=4* =<* $>%* ;&54D5;-%#* (4'* $>%* (4(-.#5#* $=* #%%* d>5D>* 6,#54%##* "='%-*D=";=4%4$#*$>%.*&%<-%D$*,;=4C*

O(I('!T1CC.#@!)2%!+C%#!A,0.#%00!D+$%<!L+*!0=#%*@=!A=--=d54@*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*00X%d%"4A%d??)* J20*#>=,-'* *6,#54%##*"='%-*d5$>* 4%d-.* '%B%-=;%'* 6,#54%##* "='%-#* d5$>* =$>%&* ;(&$5%#)* #54D%* 6.* D="65454@* =d4*;&=D%##%#*d5$>*%h$%&4(--.*(B(5-(6-%*5'%(#*(4'*&%#=,&D%#)*$>%#%*6%D="%*Q%.*D=";=4%4$#*54*$>%*4%d*6,#54%##*"='%-*(4'*;($>#*$=*"(&Q%$*6%D="%*#>=&$%&C*^>%4*=;%454@*,;* 5$#*6,#54%##*"='%-*$=*=$>%&*;(&$5%#)*J20*5#*&%D=""%4'%'*$=*"(;*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-)*#54D%*$>5#* %4#,&%#* $>($* 54$%&;&%$($5=4* '5<<%&%4D%#* d5$>* $>%* ;(&$4%&54@* <5&"* (&%* =B%&D="%*',&54@*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*;&=D%##C*E<*#=)*=;;=&$,45$5%#*54*$>%*"(&Q%$*(&5#54@*<&="* 5";-%"%4$54@* #,#$(54(6-%* 544=B($5=4#* D(4*6%* D(;$,&%'C* E4* (''5$5=4)*"(;;54@* $>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*D=,-'*;&=B5'%*'5&%D$5=4#*<=&*6=$>*<5&"#*d>%4*;(&$4%&54@*,;)*#=*$>($*$>%*4%d-.* <=&"%'* $%("* D(4* 6%D="%* ("65'%h$&=,#C* O>($* 5#)* "(;;54@* $>%* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-* D(4* >%-;* 6=$>* <5&"#* D="65454@* $>%* =-'* (4'* 4%d* 6,#54%##* "='%-#* 54* =&'%&* $=*D(;$,&%*=;;=&$,45$5%#*d>5-%*"(54$(5454@*$>%5&*D,&&%4$*RQ%.S*;&=D%##%#C***3=)*;(&$*=<*$>%*#=-,$5=4*>(#*<=D,#%'*=4*'%B%-=;54@*(4*<=*4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%*RD<C*V#$%&d(-'%&*(4'*I5@4%,&)*/010S*<=&*J20)*$=*#%%*>=d*%(D>*D=";=4%4$*D(4*D=4$&56,$%*$=*#.4%&@.* D&%($5=4* ($* (* @%4%&(-* -%B%-C* O>%* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-* D(4B(#* 5#* 6(#%'* =4* $>%*'%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* (4'* D(4* 6%* <=,4'* 54* <5@,&%* :C* !#* D(4* 6%* #%%4)* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#*D=4D%&454@*=;%&($5=4(-*#.4%&@5%#*&%<-%D$*"=#$-.*=4*Q%.*&%#=,&D%#)*Q%.*;(&$4%&#*(4'*Q%.*(D$5B5$5%#C* J,#$="%&* #.4%&@.* <=D,#%'* ;&54D5;-%#* 54B=-B%* ;&5"(&5-.* $>%*;&=;=#5$5=4)*D>(44%-#*(4'*D,#$="%&*#%@"%4$#C* A54(4D5(-*#.4%&@5%#*&%<-%D$*=4*$>%*D=#$*#$&,D$,&%*(4'*&%B%4,%*#$&%("#C*O>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*D=4D%&454@*$>%*$d=*&%"(5454@*

Page 50: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [0*

#.4%&@.* $.;%#)* "(4(@%"%4$* (4'* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@5%#)* <=D,#* =4* (--*6,#54%##*"='%-* D(4B(#* %-%"%4$#* (4'* $>%&%<=&%* D(44=$* 6%* B5#,(-5f%'* 54* <5@,&%* :C* !#* (*&%#,-$)* 4=$* (--* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* D(4* 6%* <=,4'* 54* $>%* $%";-($%)* #54D%* $>%#%* ;&54D5;-%#*&%<-%D$* =4* $>%* %4$5&%* D(4B(#* &($>%&* $>(4* =4* #="%* =<* $>%* 6,5-'54@* 6-=DQ#C* O=*"(Q%* $>%*'%#5@4* #=-,$5=4* "=&%* #;%D5<5D)* (* #%D=4')* 5--,#$&($5B%* =;%4* 6,#54%##* "='%-* D(4B(#* >(#*6%%4*'%B%-=;%'*<=&*(*#;%D5<5D*545$5($5B%*=<*J20)*(#*D(4*6%*#%%4*54*5--,#$&($5=4*6=h*1C**

<8890%$*%(#2'KW''O>5#*5--,#$&($5=4*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C*

** *

Page 51: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [1*

*;,0Z&%'M' ':V%-'AZ#,-%##'!(W%T'C"-/"#'QS"#%W'(-'S($X'V&"+$,+%'"-W'$X%(&[US"#%W'W%#,0-'V&,-+,VT%#R*'

**

A=&"7*Z=4@*$%&")*=4_@=54@*;(&$4%&#>5;#**^5$>7*J=""5$$%'*(4'*$&,#$%'*;(&$4%&#**^>=7*J=";-%"%4$*54$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#**Y5(7**J=";($56-%*D,-$,&%*(4'*<5$*

**X"2*A%<4%A*2):4%=#)4;)=5*2%&7X%0NX%0&X%?X%??X%???X%Z?%Y%Z???%%

Nh("54($5=4*=<*D=""=4*;&=D%##%#b(D$5B5$5%#*<=&*%D=4="5%#*=<*#D(-%*d5--*%4>(4D%*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%*(4'*D&%($%*#.4%&@.C**J"2*A%<4%=#)4;)=5*%H%Y%&&%*

J="654%*D=";-%"%4$(&.*&%#=,&D%#*R-%B%&(@%*Q4=d-%'@%)*5'%(#)*;%=;-%)*%$DCS*(D&=##*<5&"#*$=*;&=B5'%*,45?,%*D,#$="%&*B(-,%*(4'*D(;$,&%*"(&Q%$*=;;=&$,45$5%#C***3$(&$*D&=##_<,4D$5=4(-*%B%4$#*(4'*D=4',D$*#$(Q%>=-'%&*(4(-.#5#*$=*5'%4$5<.*(4'*D($%@=&5#%*Q4=d-%'@%*D=";%$%4D%#*(4'*$,&4*$>%#%*54$=*B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4#**J"2*A%<4%=#)4;)=5*%IX%Z???X%?d%Y%d?%

3>(&%*&%#=,&D%#*R%C@C*<(D5-5$5%#)*;%&#=44%-)*Q4=d-%'@%)*5'%(#)*%$DCS*<=&7*_*ND=4="5%#*=<*#D(-%*_*ND=4="5%#*=<*#D=;%**J"2*A%<4%CXHX%IXLX&0X&I%Y%&L%

3$&5B%*<=&*#$(4'(&'5f($5=4*#54D%*$>5#*D=4$&56,$%#*$=*(*D=4#5#$%4$*D,#$="%&*%h;%&5%4D%)*$>%&%6.*&%54<=&D54@*(4'*%4>(4D54@*$>%*D=&;=&($%*6&(4'C**J"2*A%<4%=#)4;)=5*%8%

E4D&%(#%*#(-%#*@&=d$>*B5(*#>(&54@*"(&Q%$*#%@"%4$#)*#54D%*$>5#*-=d%&#*D=#$#*=<*#(-%#*(4'*4%d*#%@"%4$#*D(4*6%*#%&B%'C***J"2*A%<4%=#)4;)=5*%0%

!--=D($%*D(;5$(-*("=4@*g=54$*#$&,D$,&%)*(4'*#>(&%*$>%*,#%*=<*%?,5;"%4$*$=*-=d%&*54B%#$"%4$*D=#$#)*$>%&%6.*54D&%(#54@*GVEC*

J"2*A%<4%=#)4;)=5*2%/X7%Y%&N%

K5#(@@&%@($%*#.4%&@.*=6g%D$5B%#*$=*%B(-,($%*D=#$#*(4'*6%4%<5$#*(4'*D&%($%*(4*5";-%"%4$($5=4*;-(4*d5$>*(--=D($%'*D(;5$(-*$=*(D>5%B%*'%#5&%'*#.4%&@.**

J"2*A%<4%=#)4;)=5*2%&N%Y%&H%

E4D&%(#%*#(-%#*@&=d$>*(4'*(D>5%B%*@&%($%&*B=-,"%#*=<*(D$5B5$.*B5(*#>(&54@*R'5#$&56,$5=4S*D>(44%-#C**J"2*A%<4%=#)4;)=5*2%&%Y%0%*

CZ#$(1%&'*[-%&0['

*

:V%&"$,(-"T'*[-%&0['

;,-"-+,"T'*[-%&0['

Page 52: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [/*

O(I(9!V%=!C1*)#%*0!$=* $>5&'* ;(&$5%#* 5#* 4=$*d5$>=,$* &5#QC*

O>%&%<=&%)*J20*#>=,-'*D(&%<,--.*#%-%D$*5$#*6,#54%##*;(&$4%&#*<=&*D=--(6=&($5=4C*A=--=d54@*<&="*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*&7X%0NX%0&X%?X%??X%???%Y%Z???*$>%&%*(&%*#%B%&(-*(#;%D$#*$>($*J20*#>=,-'*<=D,#*=4*d>%4*<=&"54@*=;%4*544=B($5=4*;(&$4%&#>5;#C***A5&#$)* J20* #>=,-'* <=D,#* =4* %#$(6-5#>54@* -=4@* $%&"* (4'* =4_@=54@* &%-($5=4#>5;#* d5$>*D=""5$$%'* (4'* $&,#$%'* ;(&$4%&#C* Z=4@_$%&"* D=--(6=&($5=4* %4(6-%#* 6=$>* <5&"#* $=*%#$(6-5#>*%<<%D$5B%*d=&Q*&=,$54%#* 54*$>%*%hD>(4@%*=<* 54<=&"($5=4C*!-$>=,@>*$&,#$*#%%"#*=6B5=,#*54*$>%*D=4$%h$*=<*;(&$4%&*#%-%D$5=4)*5$*&%"(54#*(4*5";=&$(4$*(#;%D$*=<*$>%*;(&$4%&*#%-%D$5=4*;&=D%##*(4'*#>=,-'*&%D%5B%*#5@45<5D(4$*($$%4$5=4*R%C@C*B5(* -%@(-* <&("%d=&Q#*$=*

*5#*$>%*<(D$*$>($*$>&=,@>*5$#*;&=g%D$#)*5$*>(#*d=&Q%'*=4*(* '5<<%&%4$* ;&=g%D$*d5$>* 5$#* D,#$="%&#* ;&5=&* $=* (* ;=$%4$5(-* #$(&$* =<* (4* =;%4* 544=B($5=4*545$5($5B%C* O>%&%<=&%)* J20* >(#* $>%* ;=##565-5$.* $=* #%%* d>5D>* ;(&$5%#* D(4* D=";-%"%4$*

O>5#*d5--*54D&%(#%*$>%*(6#=&;$5B%*D(;(D5$.*=<*J20*#=*$>($*&%#=,&D%#*d5$>*(''%'*B(-,%*D(4*6%*5'%4$5<5%'*(4'*54$%@&($%'*d5$>*54$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*54*=&'%&*$=*%h;-=5$*$>%"C*!*#%D=4'*6%4%<5$*<=&*J20*5#*$>%* ;=$%4$5(-* $>($* J20* W%$d=&Q* =<<%&#C* J20* W%$d=&Q* D=4#5#$#* =<* 6=$>* @=B%&4"%4$(-*54#$5$,$5=4#* (4'* <5&"#)* %(D>* d5$>* B(-,(6-%* 54<=&"($5=4* (4'* 6%4%<5$#* =4* #,#$(54(65-5$.*"($$%&#*$>($*D(4*>%-;*J20*(D>5%B%*>5@>%&*-%B%-#*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4C*

O(I(>!V%=!*%0+,*-%0!1#$!1-).7.).%0!A=--=d54@* <&="*;&54D5;-%*CX%HX%IX%LX%&0X%&I%Y%&L* $>%&%*(&%* #%B%&(-*Q%.* (D$5B5$5%#*(4'*Q%.*&%#=,&D%#*$>($*#>=,-'*6%*D="654%'*d>5-%*=;%454@*,;*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-C*A5&#$*=<*(--)* 54*=&'%&*$=*5";-%"%4$*(4*544=B($5=4*54$=*$>%*"(&Q%$)*J20*#>=,-'*<=D,#*=4*$>%*%?,5;"%4$*(4'* <(D5-5$5%#*4%D%##(&.* $=*=;%&($%* $>5#*"(&Q%$C*O>5#*d(.)* 545$5(-* 54B%#$"%4$*'%D&%(#%#)*$>%&%6.*54D&%(#54@*&%$,&4*=4*54B%#$"%4$C*A,&$>%&"=&%)*J20*#>=,-'*#$&5B%*<=&*%D=4="5%#*=<* #D=;%* (4'* %D=4="5%#* =<* #D(-%)* (#* <5h%'* D=#$#* (&%* #;&%('* =,$* =B%&*"=&%* =,$;,$* R%C@C*"=&%* ,45$#)* "=&%* D,#$="%&#)* %$DCS)* &%#,-$54@* 54* =;%&($5=4(-)* <54(4D5(-* (4'* D,#$="%&*#.4%&@.C* J="65454@* D=";-%"%4$(&.* &%#=,&D%#* =<* J20* (4'* 5$#* ;(&$4%&* D=,-'* ;&=B5'%*,45?,%*D,#$="%&*B(-,%*(4'*D(;$,&%*"(&Q%$*=;;=&$,45$5%#C**

!

<8890%$*%(#2'D' 'h&R'/*$%2&$0'O>5#*5--,#$&($5=4*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C*** *

<8890%$*%(#2'e 'h&R'$&0#9$.&0'H'*.%(7(%(&0'O>5#*5--,#$&($5=4*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C*

** *

Page 53: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [2*

O(I(I!:21##%<0`!-,0)+D%*!0%@D%#)0!_!*%<1).+#02.C0!!X(#%'*=4*;&54D5;-%*&X%0%Y%8* (4'*6,5-'54@*=4* $>%*Q%.* &%#=,&D%#*(4'*(D$5B5$5%#)*6=$>*J20*(4'* 5$#* ;(&$4%&* D=,-'* %h$%4'* 5$#* D,#$="%&* 6(#%)* #54D%* 4%d* "(&Q%$* #%@"%4$#* D(4* 6%*&%(D>%'* 6.* D="65454@* $>%* (B(5-(6-%* %h;%&$5#%* (4'* 4%$d=&Q* =<* 6=$>* <5&"#C* 3>(&54@* $>%*D>(44%-#*,#%'*6.*6=$>*<5&"#*$=*6&54@*$>%*B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4*$=*$>%*D,#$="%&)*(--=d#*6=$>*<5&"#* $=* &%(D>* 4%d* ;=$%4$5(-* D,#$="%&#* d5$>* #,#$(54(6-%* 6,#54%##* 544=B($5=4#C* J20*#>=,-'* <=D,#*=4*6&54@54@*#$(4'(&'5f%'*#%&B5D%*#=-,$5=4#* <=&*#,#$(54(65-5$.* 5##,%#*$=*$>%*D,#$="%&#)*#54D%*$>5#*D=4$&56,$%#*$=*(*D=4#5#$%4$*D,#$="%&*%h;%&5%4D%*(4'*D=,-'*&%('5-.*6%* 5";-%"%4$%'* 54* $>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* =<* ",-$5;-%* D,#$="%&#* 54* $>%* #("%* "(&Q%$*#%@"%4$)* $>%&%6.* D=4$&56,$54@* $=* &%D,&&54@* ;(."%4$#* &%#,-$54@* <=&"* $>%* '%-5B%&%'*#%&B5D%#C*

O(I(O!S1<,%!C*+C+0.).+#!!#*d5$>*(4.*<5&")*$>%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*=<*J20*#>=,-'*'%-5B%&*B(-,%*$=*5$#*D,#$="%&#C*E4* $>5#* D(#%)* $>%* B(-,%* ;&=;=#5$5=4* 5#* $>%* ;=##565-5$.* $=* D="654%* D=";-%"%4$(&.*&%#=,&D%#* R=&* $=* -%B%&(@%* Q4=d-%'@%)* 5'%(#)* ;%=;-%)* $%D>4=-=@.* (4'* =&@(45f($5=4(-*D=";%$%4D%#S* (D&=##* <5&"#* $=* ;&=B5'%* ,45?,%* D,#$="%&* B(-,%* (4'* D(;$,&%* "(&Q%$*=;;=&$,45$5%#C* E4* =&'%&* $=* #%%* d>($* $>%#%* =;;=&$,45$5%#* (&%)* J20* #>=,-'* #$(&$* D&=##_<,4D$5=4(-* %B%4$#* d5$>* ;=$%4$5(-* ;(&$4%&#* $=* 5'%4$5<.* (4'* D($%@=&5#%* Q4=d-%'@%*D=";%$%4D%#*(4'*$,&4*$>%#%* 54$=*B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4#C*A,&$>%&"=&%)* 54*=&'%&*$=*6%D="%*("65'%h$&=,#)* J20* #>=,-'* #$(&$* (* R#"(--S* 6,#54%##* $%(")* '5<<%&%4$5($%'* <&="* $>%*"(54*=&@(45f($5=4)*$=*<,&$>%&*'%B%-=;*$>%*545$5($5B%#*6(#%'*=4*$>%*Q4=d-%'@%*;&=',D%'*($*J20*

#5",-$(4%=,#-.)* $>%&%6.* &%"(5454@* <=D,#* =4* $>%* "(54* (D$5B5$.* R$>%* ;&=g%D$#S* (4'*#5",-$(4%=,#-.*4=$*;(##54@*6.*=4*%4B5&=4"%4$(-*D>(4@%#*(4'*4%d*=;;=&$,45$5%#*R6(#%'*=4*;&54D5;-%*IX%d???X%?d%"4A%d?SC*

O(I(P!/%7%#,%!0)*%1D0!1#$!-+0)!0)*,-),*%!X(#%'* =4* ;&54D5;-%#*/X%7X%&N%Y%&H)* J20* #>=,-'*'5#(@@&%@($%* $>%* =6g%D$5B%#* =<* (* #.4%&@.*545$5($5B%)*;&5=&*$=*#$(&$54@*$>%*;&=g%D$C*O>5#*d(.)* $>%*;=$%4$5(-*=<* $>%*#.4%&@.* 545$5($5B%*(4'*$>%*(DD=";(4.54@*D=#$#*6%D="%*D-%(&*$=*(--*#$(Q%>=-'%&#)*#=*$>%.*D(4*%#$5"($%*$>%5&*&%$,&4* =4* 54B%#$"%4$* (4'* Q4=d* >=d* D(;5$(-* <=&* $>%* 4%d* g=54$* #$&,D$,&%* #>=,-'* 6%*(--=D($%'C* O>5#* d(.)* 545$5($5B%#* 6(#%'* =4* #.4%&@.* 65(#%#* &%#,-$54@* 54* <(5-,&%#* D(4* 6%*;&%B%4$%'C*

<8890%$*%(#2'P>'N"*22&80G'.90%#)&$'0&3)&2%0'*24'$&8*%(#20"(/0'O>5#*5--,#$&($5=4*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C**

<8890%$*%(#2'I' 'b*89&'/$#/#0(%(#2'O>5#*5--,#$&($5=4*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C*

** *

Page 54: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* []*

O(I(a!?%0.@#!C*.#-.C<%0!*%L<%-).#@!1<<!A,0.#%00!D+$%<!-+DC+#%#)0!3=*<(&)*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*>(B%*6%%4*(;;-5%'*54*$>%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4B(#)*d>%4*(;;-5D(6-%C* T=d%B%&)* (#* D(4* 6%* #%%4)* $>%&%* (&%* #%B%&(-* ;&54D5;-%#* $>($* 4=$* >(B%* 6%%4*'5#D,##%'*.%$* 54*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4B(#)*#54D%*$>%.*'=*4=$* #;%D5<5D(--.*&%<-%D$*,;=4*=4%* =&* $d=* D=";=4%4$#)* 6,$* =4* $>%* %4$5&%* D(4B(#C* O>%#%* ;&54D5;-%#* <=D,#* =4* $>&%%*'5<<%&%4$*D=";=4%4$#*R#%%*(-#=*(;;%4'5h*EaS7*

1C J==&'54($%'*#$&($%@5%#7*(C I&54D5;-%*12*_*J==&'54($%*#$&($%@5%#*$=*5";&=B%*54$%&(D$5=4#*("=4@*<5&"#*6C I&54D5;-%*YEE* *#$(&$*D&=##_<,4D$5=4(-*54$%&<(D%#*$=*@%4%&($%*D=""5$"%4$*DC I&54D5;-%*a* * *

/C J="",45D($5=4**(C I&54D5;-%*19* *D="",45D($%*<&%?,%4$-.*6C I&54D5;-%*1]*_*3$&,D$,&%*D=4$%h$*<=&*D-%(&*D="",45D($5=4*

2C Z%('%&#>5;*#,;;=&$**(C I&54D5;-%*EY* *X&54@*54*-%('%&#*<&="*=,$#5'%*6C I&54D5;-%*Y* *3%45=&*"(4(@%"%4$*54B=-B%"%4$**

O>%#%*D=";=4%4$#*D(44=$*6%*"(;;%'*#%;(&($%-.*54$=*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*<&("%d=&Q*=<*V#$%&d(-'%&* (4'*I5@4%,&* R/010S)* (4'* $>%&%<=&%*d5--* 6%* '5#D,##%'* (;(&$* <&="* $>%* 454%*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#C*!#*d5--*6%* D-%(&)* D==&'54($54@*#$&($%@.)* -%('%&#>5;*(4'*D="",45D($5=4*(&%*54$%&$d54%'*D=4#$&,D$#*(4'*d5--*$>%&%<=&%*6%*'5#D,##%'*(4'*5--,#$&($%'*$=@%$>%&C**E4*=&'%&*$=*;&=<5$*"(h5"(--.*<&="*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)*J20*#>=,-'*#$&,D$,&%*$>%* D=4$%h$* <=&* D-%(&* (4'* <&%?,%4$* D="",45D($5=4* R%C@C* B5(* $>%* '%B%-=;"%4$* =<* (* -%@(-*<&("%d=&Q*=&*$=*#$(&$*D&=##_<,4D$5=4(-*54$%&<(D%#SC*O>5#*d(.)*D=4<-5D$#*d5--*6%*"545"5f%'*(4'* <5&"#* 6%D="%* "=&%* D="<=&$(6-%* 54* #>(&54@* Q4=d-%'@%C* T(B54@* "%%$54@#* =4* (*&%@,-(&*6(#5#*5";&=B%#*$>%*(65-5$.*$=*'%B%-=;*(4'*%h;-=5$*4%d*(4'*#,DD%##<,-*544=B($5=4#*?,5DQ-.)*(4'*d5--*>%-;*=B%&D="%*$>%*WET*#.4'&="%C*O=*'=*#=)*J20*#>=,-'*#>(&%*#$&($%@5D)*=&@(45f($5=4(-* =&* =;%&($54@* ;&=6-%"#* d5$>* "(4(@%&#* =<* 5$#* ;(&$4%&C* 3>(&54@* $>%#%*;&=6-%"#* D=,-'* &%#=-B%* $>%#%* ;&=6-%"#)* #54D%* "(4(@%&#* "(.* >(B%* '%(-$* d5$>* #5"5-(&*;&=6-%"#* 54* $>%* ;(#$C* O>%#%* -%('%&#* <&="* =$>%&* =&@(45f($5=4#* 6&54@* 54* (* <&%#>*;%&#;%D$5B%*(4'*&%54<=&D%*(4*=;%4_"54'%'*($$5$,'%C*

<8890%$*%(#2'i' '=&7&29&'0%$&*)0'*24'.#0%'0%$9.%9$&S'O>5#*5--,#$&($5=4*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C*'* **

** *

<8890%$*%(#2'jW'5&*4&$0"(/G'.##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'H'.#))92(.*%(#2'O>5#*5--,#$&($5=4*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C*

** *

Page 55: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [[*

P(!?.0-,00.+#!1#$!-+#-<,0.+#!O>5#* D>(;$%&* D=4#5#$#* =<* $>%* <54'54@#* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#* (4'* (4#d%&#* $>%* &%#%(&D>* ?,%#$5=4*(4'* #,6_?,%#$5=4#* ;=#%'* 54* $>%* 54$&=',D$5=4)* <=--=d%'* 6.* (* &%<-%D$5=4* =<* $>%* <54'54@#)*<=D,#54@*=4*$>%*#.4%&@.*$.;=-=@.)*$>%*;&54D5;-%#*(4'*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%C*W%h$)*$>%* D=4$&56,$5=4* (4'* "(4(@%&5(-* 5";-5D($5=4#* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#* (&%* '5#D,##%'C* A54(--.)*-5"5$($5=4#*d5--*6%*(''&%##%')*$=*#%%*>=d*$>%#%*D(4*6%*=B%&D="%*54*<,$,&%*#$,'5%#C*O>5#*$>%#5#*'=%#*4=$*;&%$%4'*$=*6%*%h>(,#$5B%)*#=*#$(&$54@*;=54$#* <=&* <,$,&%*&%#%(&D>*d5--*6%*@5B%4*($*$>%*%4'*=<*$>5#*#%D$5=4)*6(#%'*=4*$>%*<54'54@#*=<*$>5#*#$,'.C**

P('!U.#$.#@0!O>%*;,&;=#%* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#* >(#* 6%%4* $=* (4#d%&* $>%*"(54* &%#%(&D>* ?,%#$5=47* A+B!91,!+2',!$#(*,'((!3+4'5!*,,+61)*+,!0'52!:*<3(!'()1$5*(0!(;,'<=;7 %E4*=&'%&*$=*'=*#=)*<=,&*#,6_?,%#$5=4#* >(B%* 6%%4* ;=#%')* $>($* $=@%$>%&* <=&"* (4* (4#d%&* $=* $>5#* ?,%#$5=4C* O>%#%*#,6_?,%#$5=4#*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*<5&#$)*<=--=d%'*6.*(4*(4#d%&*$=*$>%*&%#%(&D>*?,%#$5=4C***O+@3a+*2$)<4%&'%_E"$%)2%<=*4%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%)44<,"$)<4e%3$(&$54@* ;=54$* <=&* $>5#* $>%#5#* >(#* 6%%4* $>%* 4=$5=4* =<* K(>-(4'%&* (4'* \(44* R/010S* $>($*4=d('(.#* (* #54@-%* <5&"* D(44=$* 544=B($%* 54* 5#=-($5=4)* 6,$* $>($* =;%44%##* $=* 4%d* 5'%(#*

<54'*B(-,%*6.*$(;;54@*54$=*$>%*5'%(#*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4*RG%%'*%$*(-C)*/01/SC*E4*-5$%&($,&%)*$>%* D=4D%;$*=<*=;%4* 544=B($5=4*(#*(* #=,&D%*=<*B(-,%*>(#* &%D%5B%'*#,6#$(4$5(-* ($$%4$5=4*<&="* #D>=-(&#* R%C@C* K(>-(4'%&* (4'* \(44)* /010e* T,5f54@>)* /011e* G%%'* %$* (-C)* /01/SC*T=d%B%&)*"(44%&#*$=*D(;$,&%*$>5#*D&%($%'*B(-,%*R=<$%4*&%<%&&%'*$=*6,#54%##*"='%-S)*>(#*&%D%5B%'*#D(4$*($$%4$5=4*R$>%*%hD%;$5=4*6%54@*J>%#6&=,@>)*/008SC*O>%&%<=&%)* $>5#* $>%#5#* >(#* <=D,#%'* =4* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<* <=*4% @+2)4*22%G<A*5% )44<,"$)<4C*A=--=d54@* <&="* -5$%&($,&%)* 5$* #>=d#* $>($* $>%* &=-%* =<* $>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 54* =;%4*544=B($5=4* 5#* 54D-,'54@* %h$%&4(-* &%#=,&D%#* (#* Q%.* D=";=4%4$#* 54* $>%* 6,#54%##*"='%-7*<5&"#*#$(&$* $=*#>(&%* 54$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#*$=*D&%($%*(4'*D(;$,&%*B(-,%*6.* -%B%&(@54@* 5'%(#*

#* =&* ;=#5$5=4* 4=$* =4-.**

*O+@3a+*2$)<4%0'%_E"$%)2%F)#G%264*#:6e%354D%*$>%*d=&Q*=<*!4#=<<*R1:`[S*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*#.4%&@.*>(#*&%D%5B%'*($$%4$5=4*<=&*(-"=#$*[0*.%(&#* <&="*6=$>* #D>=-(&#* RH4=--)*/009S*(4'*"(4(@%&#* R\==-'* (4'*J(";6%--*1::9SC*J=4#5'%&54@* $>5#* -=4@* ;%&5='* =<* 54$%&%#$)* $>%* "=&%* (#$=45#>54@* 5$* 6%D="%#* $>($* 4=*D=4#%4#,#*>(#*6%%4*<=,4'*54*$>%*$.;=-=@.*=<*#.4%&@.C*O>%&%<=&%)*$>5#*$>%#5#*>(#*<=D,#%'*=4*D=4',D$54@*(*&%B5%d*$=*<54'*D=4#%4#,#*54*$>%*"(4.*$.;=-=@5%#*D5&D,-($54@*54*-5$%&($,&%*6.*;=#54@*$>%*#%D=4'*#,6_?,%#$5=4C*A&="*=B%&*(*'=f%4*'%<545$5=4#*(4'*%5@>$*$.;=-=@5%#)*(4*=B%&(&D>54@*$.;=-=@.*>(#*6%%4*'%B%-=;%'C*!#*5$*$,&4#*=,$)*=B%&*$>%*.%(&#*$>%*#%"54(-*d=&Q*=<*!4#=<<*R1:`[S*>(#*6%%4*#,6g%D$*$=*#%B%&(-*D>(4@%#*54*'%<545$5=4#*(4'*=4%*"(g=&*D>(4@%e*4("%-.*(''54@*K4<-5*A:**G"4":*G*4$*#.4%&@.*$=*>5#*$.;[email protected]*O>5#*&%#,-$#*54*$>%*<=--=d54@*#.4%&@.*$.;%#*,#%'*54*$>5#*$>%#5#7*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@.)*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@.)*D,#$="%&* #.4%&@.)*=;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@.* RD=4#5#$54@*=<*@&=d$>*(4'*%<<5D5%4D.* #.4%&@5%#S*(4'*Q4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@5%#C*!#*D(4*6%*#%%4*54*$(6-%*]*R;C1[S)*(--*#D>=-(&#*>(B%*"%4$5=4%'* =;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@5%#)* d>5-%* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@5%#* >(B%* g,#$*

Page 56: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [`*

&%D%5B%'*($$%4$5=4*$>&=,@>=,$*(--*'%D%445()*(-$>=,@>*$>%*D="654($5=4*=<*(--*$>&%%*>(#*4=$**

*O+@3a+*2$)<4%8'%_E"$%"#*%$E*%5*22<42%5*"#4*A%F#<G%<=*4%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%)4)$)"$),*2%)4%=#";$);*e%%O>%* (4#d%&* $=* $>5#* #,6_?,%#$5=4% 5#* ;&=B5'%'* 54* $>%* <=&"* =<* 1/* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'* '%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#)*;&=B5'%'*=4*;(@%#*28_29C*O=@%$>%&*$>%*$>%=&._*(4'*;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*;&54D5;-%#)*;&=B5'%* (4* 54#$&,"%4$(-* $%";-($%* <=&* ;&(D$5$5=4%&#)* d>5D>* >(#* 6%%4* ,#%'* $=* '%#5@4* (*#=-,$5=4*<=&*J-,6*B(4*20)*54*=&'%&*$=*;&=B5'%*(4*(4#d%&*$=*#,6_?,%#$5=4*]7**O+@3a+*2$)<4% C'% b<-% ;"4% <=*4% @+2)4*22% G<A*5% )44<,"$)<4% E*5=% 18N% )4% ;#*"$)4:% "4A%"==#<=#)"$)4:%264*#:6e%O=*(4#d%&*$>5#*?,%#$5=4)*(4*<=*4%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%$*G=5"$*%6(#%'*=4*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#%>(#*6%%4*'%B%-=;%'*<=&*J20)*$=*#%%*>=d*$>%*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#*#>=,-'*6%*'%$(5-%'*54*=&'%&*$=*(D>5%B%*R=4%*=<S*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*#.4%&@.*<=&"#C*O>5#*d(.)*Q4=d-%'@%*;&=',D%'*<&="*J20*D(4*6%*$,&4%'*54$=*B(-,(6-%*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##*'%B%-=;"%4$*RQ4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@.S*6.*D=--(6=&($54@*d5$>*%h$%&4(-*;(&$4%&#)*$>%&%6.*4=$*=4-.*D&%($54@*(*#,&;-,#*54*%D=4="5D* 6%4%<5$#* R5C%C* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@.S* <=&* 6=$>* <5&"#)* 6,$* (-#=* '%D&%(#54@* 4%@($5B%*5";(D$*=4* $>%*%4B5&=4"%4$)* (D>5%B54@*;&=',D$5B5$.*6%4%<5$#* R=;%&($5=4(-* #.4%&@.S*(4'*%4>(4D54@* ;,6-5D* &%-($5=4#)* d>5D>* 54D-,'%* "(&Q%$54@* ('B(4$(@%#* $=* &%(D>* (4'* #%&B%*",-$5;-%*D,#$="%&*#%@"%4$#*RD,#$="%&*#.4%&@.S)*D<C*\=$$<&5%'*R/002SC***3=)* $>%* D=";&%>%4#5B%* $>%=&%$5D(-* @&=,4'54@* =<* $>%* ;&54D5;-%#)* -%('54@* <&="* 6,#54%##*"='%-* D&%($5=4* $=d(&'#* $>%* D&%($5=4* =<* '5<<%&%4$* #.4%&@.* $.;%#)* >(#* &%#,-$%'* 54* (*D=4D%;$,(-*<&("%d=&Q*$>($*#>=d#*>=d*#.4%&@.*D(4*6%*D&%($%'C**!4*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%*>(#*6%%4*'%B%-=;%'*$>($*#>=d#*d>5D>* <=&"#*=<* <5&"*#.4%&@.*D(4*6%*(D>5%B%'*6.*(;;-.54@*6=$>*$>%=&._*(4'*;&(D$5D%_*6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*$=*$>%*#;%D5<5D*6,#54%##*"='%-* D=";=4%4$#* =<* $>%* $%";-($%C* O>%* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#* >(B%* #>=d4* -%##*(6#$&(D$* (4'*"=&%* 5--,#$&($5B%* (;;-5D($5=4#* =<* $>%* 54$%&B%4$5=4#* '%#D&56%'* 54* $>%=&.C* !*D=";(&5#=4*=<*6=$>*$.;%#*=<*;&54D5;-%#*>(#*6%%4*@5B%4)*d>5D>*#>=d#*$>($*$>%*;&54D5;-%#*D=";-%"%4$*(4'*#$&%4@$>%4*%(D>*=$>%&)*d5$>*#="%*%hD%;$5=4#*$>($*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*54*$>%*4%h$*;(&$*=<*$>5#*$>%#5#C*

P(9!/%L<%-).#@!+#!)2%!L.#$.#@0!O>5#* $>%#5#* >(#* '%B%-=;%'* (* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@.* (4'* >(#* -54Q%'* $>%#%* '5<<%&%4$* #.4%&@.*

"=#$*=<*$>%*'%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* D=4D%&454@* ;+2$<G*#% 264*#:6% <=D,#* =4* $>%* 6,5-'54@* 6-=DQ#* ;E"44*52)*;+2$<G*#% 2*:G*4$2X% ,"5+*% =#<=<2)$)<4% =&% ;+2$<G*#% #*5"$)<42E)=2* =<* $>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-*D(4B(#* =<* V#$%&d(-'%&* %4* I5@4%,&* R/010S.%O>5#* 5#* D=4#5#$%4$* d5$>* $>%* '%#D&5;$5=4* =<*D,#$="%&* #.4%&@.*,#%'* 54* $>5#* $>%#5#)*d>5D>* #$($%#* $>($* 54*=&'%&* $=* D&%($%*(4'*D(;$,&%*D,#$="%&* #.4%&@.)* $>%* "(&Q%$* "%##(@%* #>=,-'* 6%* %h;(4'%'* (4'* ",-$5;-%* ;&=',D$#*#>=,-'*6%*6&=,@>$*$=*$>%*D,#$="%&C*O>%*#%D=4'*$.;%*=<*#.4%&@.)*<=*#"$)<4"5*264*#:6)* 5#*'%<54%'*(#*#.4%&@.*$>($*#$%"#*<&="*#>(&54@*=&*&%D="65454@*=;%&($5B%*&%#=,&D%#C*O>5#*5#*(-#=*&%<-%D$%'*54*$>%*$%";-($%7*"=#$*=<*$>%*;&54D5;-%#*<=D,#*=4*#>(&54@*K*6%#*2<+#;*2*(4'*#%-%D$54@* K*6% ="#$4*#2* $=* D=--(6=&($%* d5$>)* 54* =&'%&* $=* (D>5%B%* %D=4="5%#* =<* #D(-%C*J=4D%&454@* F)4"4;)"5* 264*#:)*2)* $>%* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* &%<-%D$* =4* $>=#%* D=";=4%4$#*<=D,#54@* =4* &%B%4,%* (4'* D=#$#)* 4("%-.* ;<2$2%2$#+;$+#*%(4'% #*,*4+*%2$#*"G2.* T=d%B%&)*d>%4* D=";(&54@* $>%=&._6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#* $=* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#)* 5$* #>=d#* $>($*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@5%#*(&%* <&%?,%4$-.*'%#D&56%'* 54* -5$%&($,&%)*6,$* -%##*(;;(&%4$* 54*$>%*D(#%*

Page 57: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [8*

#$,'5%#C* I=$%4$5(-* &%(#=4#* <=&* $>5#* '5#D&%;(4D.* >(B%* 6%%4* "%4$5=4%'e* #>(&54@*54B%#$"%4$#* =<$%4* &%#,-$#* 54* =$>%&* $.;%#* =<* #.4%&@.)* &($>%&* $>(4* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@5%#C*A54(4D5(-*#.4%&@5%#*D=,-'*=DD,&* <=&*%h(";-%*54*$(h*6%4%<5$#)*6,$* <,$,&%*&%#%(&D>*#>=,-'*<=D,#* =4* %";5&5D(-* 6(#%'* %B5'%4D%* $=* B%&5<.* $>%#%* (##,";$5=4#* D=4D%&454@* <54(4D5(-*#.4%&@5%#C* R"4":*G*4$% 264*#:)*2* d%&%* '%<54%'* (#* -%B%&(@54@* %4$&%;&%4%,&5(-*D(;(65-5$5%#)*D(;(65-5$5%#*54*=&@(45f($5=4(-*'%#5@4*(4'*#,;%&5=&*#$&($%@5D*-%('%&#>5;C*O>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*<=,4'*54*$>5#*#$,'.*(&%*;(&$5(--.*54*(@&%%"%4$*d5$>*$>5#*'%<545$5=4)*#54D%*$>%.* &%<-%D$* =4* #%B%&(-* 6,5-'54@* 6-=DQ#* R4("%-.* K*6% ";$),)$)*2X% K*6% #*2<+#;*2% (4'% K*6%="#$4*#2]* 6,$* (-#=* =4* D==&'54($%'* #$&($%@5%#* (4'* -%('%&#>5;* #,;;=&$C* O>%#%* -(#$* $d=*D=";=4%4$#*(&%*4=$*&%<-%D$%'* 54*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-* $%";-($%)*6,$* <=--=d54@*<&="*6=$>*$>%* ;&54D5;-%#)* D==&'54($%'* #$&($%@5%#* (4'* -%('%&#>5;* #,;;=&$* (&%* 5";=&$(4$* <(D$=&#* 54*%#$(6-5#>54@* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@5%#C* A54(--.)* K4<-5*A:** G"4":*G*4$* 264*#:)*2* d%&%*'%<54%'* (#* >(&4%##54@* (4'* -%B%&(@54@* Q4=d-%'@%)* 5'%(#)* ;%=;-%* (4'* =&@(45f($5=4(-*D=";%$%4D%#* <=&* $>%*D&%($5=4*=<*4%d)*"=&%*#,DD%##<,-* 544=B($5=4#C*A=--=d54@*<&="*$>%*;&54D5;-%#* (--* 6,#54%##* "='%-* D=";=4%4$#* (&%* %##%4$5(-* 54* &%(-5f54@* Q4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.X%(4'* D&%($54@* $>5#* $.;%* =<* #.4%&@.* D(44=$* 6%* -54Q%'* $=* #%;(&($%*D=";=4%4$#*=<*$>%*$%";-($% *

P(>!:+#)*.A,).+#0!O>5#* $>%#5#*>(#* D=4$&56,$%'* $=* -5$%&($,&%* 54* $>&%%*d(.#C*A5&#$*=<* (--)* (* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@.*>(#*6%%4*'%B%-=;%'C*!-$>=,@>*#D>=-(&#*54*$>%*<5%-'*=<*%D=4="5D#*(4'*"(4(@%"%4$*;(5'*",D>* ($$%4$5=4* $=* $>%* $=;5D* =<* #.4%&@.)* (* d%--_'%<54%'* $>%=&.* =<* #.4%&@.* (4'* <5&"*4%$d=&Q#*>('*.%$*$=*%"%&@%*R^%5)*/010SC*O>5#* $>%#5#*D=4$&56,$%#*$=*D-=#54@*$>5#*@(;*6.*&%<-%D$54@*=4*<5B%*'%D('%#*=<*-5$%&($,&%*=4*#.4%&@.*54*=&'%&*$=*;&=B5'%*(*D=";&%>%4#5B%*$.;=-=@.* d5$>* (DD=";(4.54@* '%<545$5=4#C* O>5#* $.;=-=@.* D=4$&56,$%#* $=* "(4(@%"%4$*-5$%&($,&%* 6.* #>=d54@* $>($* D=4#%4#,#* D(4* 6%* <=,4'* 54* $>%*"(4.* $.;=-=@5%#* ;&%#%4$* 54*-5$%&($,&%C* O>%* $.;=-=@.* D=B%&#* "(4.* =<* $>%* '%<545$5=4#* <=,4')* $>%&%6.* "(Q54@* $>%*D=4D%;$*=<*#.4%&@.*-%##*(6#$&(D$C**O>%* #%D=4'* D=4$&56,$5=4* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#* >(#* 6%%4* -54Q54@* $>%* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@.* $=* $>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*=<*(* <5&"C*O>%&%6.*D=4$&56,$54@*$=*-5$%&($,&%*=4*R=;%4S*6,#54%##*"='%-*

=4* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* A=--=d54@* J>%#6&=,@>* R/008S)* $>%* $>%#5#* >(#* &%<-%D$%'* =4* =;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-%544=B($5=4*$=*#%%*>=d*;=$%4$5(-*B(-,%*#$%""54@*<&="*=;%4* 544=B($5=4*;&(D$5D%#* D(4* 6%* D&%($%'* (4'* D(;$,&%'C* F=&%* #;%D5<5D(--.)* $>%* '5<<%&%4$* #.4%&@.* $.;%#*>(B%*6%%4*-54Q%'*$=*$>%*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#*=<*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4B(#*=<*V#$%&d(-'%&*(4'*I5@4%,&* R/010SC* O>5#* d(.)* (4* =;%4* 6,#54%##* "='%-* $%";-($%* <=&* D&%($54@* (4'*(;;&=;&5($54@*#.4%&@.*>(#*6%%4*'%B%-=;%'C*O>5#*$%";-($%*#>=d#*d>5D>*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#*<5&"#* #>=,-'* <=D,#* =4* $=* D&%($%* $>%* '5<<%&%4$* #.4%&@.* $.;%#C* 3=)* 6.* '%#D&5654@* >=d*

D(;$,&54@* <=&* <5&"#)* $>%*$>%#5#*D=4$&56,$%#*$=*$>%*;%&#;%D$5B%*=<*D>(4@%* 54*=&@(45f($5=4*$>%=&.C**A54(--.)* (* #%$* =<* =B%&* 20* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* '%&5B%'* <&="* $>%=&.* (4'*;&(D$5D%* >(#* 6%%4*'%B%-=;%'*$>($*;&=B5'%#*@,5'%-54%#*=4*-54Q54@*$>%*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#*$=*$>%*#.4%&@.*$.;%#C**^>%4*D=";(&54@*6=$>*#%$#*=<*;&54D5;-%#)*5$*#>=d#*$>($*$>%#%*(&%*>5@>-.*D=";($56-%*(4'*D=";-%"%4$*%(D>*=$>%&)*d>5D>*#$&%4@$>%4#*$>%*<54(-*#%$*=<*;&54D5;-%#C*354D%*$>%*$>%=&._6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#* (&%* @&=,4'%'* 54*"=&%* @%4%&(-* $>%=&5%#)* $>%* (''5$5=4* =<* $>%* ;&(D$5D%_

Page 58: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [9*

6(#%'* ;&54D5;-%#* >(#* #>=d4* $=* 6%* 5--,#$&($5B%*(4'* D-(&5<.54@C* O>5#*d(.)* $>%* #$&%4@$>*=<*$>%=&.*5#*D="654%'*d5$>*;&(D$5D%)*$=*;&=B5'%*(*D=";&%>%4#5B%*<54(-*#%$*=<*;&54D5;-%#C*

P(I!T1#1@%*.1<!.DC<.-1).+#0!O>%*<54(-*'%#5@4*=<* $>5#* $>%#5#*>(#*6%%4* 5";-%"%4$%'* 54*=&'%&*$=*D=4$&56,$%*$=*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4*<=&*J20C*354D%*$>%*=;%4*544=B($5=4*545$5($5B%*5#*#$5--*54*;&=@&%##)*&%#,-$#*D(44=$*6%*(D>5%B%'*($* $>5#*"="%4$C*T=d%B%&)* $>5#* $>%#5#*>(#* #="%*5";=&$(4$* 5";-5D($5=4#* <=&*"(4(@%&5(-*;&(D$5D%)*54D-,'54@*$>%*<=--=d54@7**!#* #$($%'* 6.* \==-'* (4'* J(";6%--* R1::9)* ;C121S*

T=d%B%&)* $>%* D=4D%;$* 6%54@* (6#$&(D$* (4'*$&=,6-%#="%*$=*@&(#;)*Q4=d-%'@%*(4'*;&(D$5D%#*=4*$>%*(D$,(-*D&%($5=4*(4'*D(;$,&54@*=<*#.4%&@.*>(#*&%D%5B%'*#D(4$*($$%4$5=4C*!#*(*D=4#%?,%4D%*5$*$(Q%#*D=,&(@%*(4'*B5#5=4*$=*$&.*=,$* 4%d* 5'%(#)* %#;%D5(--.* ',&54@* $5"%#* =<* <54(4D5(-* '5<<5D,-$.C* !#* ;=54$%'* =,$* 6.*

G<A*5%G"6%4<$%@*%*"26X%@+$%)F%A)5):*4$56%=+#2+*AX%)$%=#<,)A*2%"%=<$*4$)"5%="$E-"6%$<%:#*"$*#%)44<,"$)<4% ";$),)$6% "4A% )4;#*"2*A% :#<-$E * (* <5&#$* #$%;* <=&* "(4(@%&#* 54*=B%&D="54@* $>5#* ;&=6-%")* #54D%* $>%* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* ;&=B5'%* D=4D&%$%* @,5'%-54%#* <=&*<5--54@* 54* $>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* D=";=4%4$#* '5-5@%4$-.)* $>%&%6.* >=;%<,--.* ;&=B5'54@* $>%*;=$%4$5(-*;($>d(.*$=*$>%*@&%($%&*544=B($5=4*(D$5B5$.*$>($*J>%#6&=,@>*R/008S*"%4$5=4#C*F(4(@%&#*D(4*D=4#,-$* $>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*$=*'%B%-=;*$(&@%$%'*#=-,$5=4#* <=&*(*#;%D5<5D*D=4$%h$*d>%4*=;%454@*,;*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-*54*=&'%&*$=*(D>5%B%*#.4%&@.C*

P(O!6.D.)1).+#0!1#$!*%-+DD%#$1).+#0!L+*!L,),*%!*%0%1*-2!O>%&%* (&%* #%B%&(-* -5"5$($5=4#* $>($* 5";(5&* $>%* <54'54@#* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#C* O>%#%* -5"5$($5=4#*d5--*6%*'5#D,##%'*4%h$)*(DD=";(45%'*6.*&%D=""%4'($5=4#*<=&*<,$,&%*&%#%(&D>C***A5&#$* =<* (--)* (#* #$($%'* 6.* FD\&($>* R/010S)* (* 4%d* 6,#54%##* "='%-* D(44=$* 6%* <,--.*(4$5D5;($%'* 54* ('B(4D%)* 6,$* ",#$* 6%* -%(&4%'* =B%&* $5"%C* E4* $>5#* B5%d)* $>%* D=4D%;$,(-*"='%-* 54* $>5#* $>%#5#* (;;&=(D>%#* $>%* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4* ;&=D%##* ;%&>(;#*$==* #5";-5#$5D7* (-$>=,@>* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4* (4'*'%#5@454@* (* #=-,$5=4* (''&%##%#* $>%* 5##,%*(;;&=;&5($%-.)*$>%*<54(-*#=-,$5=4*=<*$>5#*$>%#5#*5#*4=$*(*'.4("5D)*5$%&($5B%*;&=D%##)*d>5D>*5#*#,@@%#$%'*<=&*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*RO>="Q%)*/00/SC*3=)*54*(''5$5=4*$=*$>5#*#$,'.)*<,$,&%*&%#%(&D>*D=,-'*(''&%##*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4*B5(*%h;%&5"%4$54@*=&* %<<%D$,($5=4* =B%&* (* -=4@%&* ;%&5=')* $=* #%%* 5<* $>%&%* (&%* (4.* D>(4@%#* D=";(&%'* $=* $>%*#=-,$5=4*=<*$>5#*#$,'.C**W%h$)*$>%*D>=5D%*<=&*$>%*$%4*D(#%*#$,'5%#*>(#*#="%*-5"5$($5=4#C*!-$>=,@>*$>%*D(#%*#$,'5%#*#>=d* >=d* #.4%&@.* D(4* 6%* D&%($%'* 54* ;&(D$5D%* (4'* $>%* '%&5B%'* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#*D=&&%#;=4'* $=* $>%=&.)* $>%*4,"6%&*=<* D(#%#* 5#* &($>%&* -=dC*A,&$>%&"=&%)* $>%* D(#%#*>(B%*'5<<%&%4$* #5f%#)* 54D-,'54@*",-$5_4($5=4(-#)* d>5-%* $>%* <54(-* '%#5@4* >(#* 6%%4* (;;-5%'* $=* (*3FN*R5CDC*J20SC*A,$,&%*&%#%(&D>*#>=,-'*(''&%##*$>%#%*5##,%#*6.*'%#5@454@)*5";-%"%4$54@*(4'* %B(-,($54@* #=-,$5=4#* 6(#%'* =4* $>5#* $>%#5#)* <=&*",-$5;-%* D(#%* #$,'5%#* 54* '5B%&#5<5%'*#%$$54@#*(4'*=<*'5<<%&%4$*#5f%#C*O>5#*d(.)*'5<<%&%4D%#*54*#5f%*(4'*D=4$%h$*D(4*6%*=B%&D="%*6.*'%$(5-54@*$>%*'%#5@4)*d>5D>*D=,-'*#$&%4@$>%4*$>%*&=6,#$4%##*=<*$>%*'%#5@4C**O>5&')* (-$>=,@>* $>%* $.;=-=@.*=<* $>5#* #$,'.* 5#* D=";&%>%4#5B%)* [0* .%(&#* =<* -5$%&($,&%*=4*#.4%&@.* "(Q%* 5$* B5&$,(--.* 5";=##56-%* $=* D=B%&* (--* $.;=-=@5%#* ;&%#%4$* 54* -5$%&($,&%C*N#;%D5(--.*#54D%*$>%&%*5#*4=*D=4#%4#,#*=4*$>%*$%&"54=-=@.*(4'*'%<545$5=4*=<*$>%*D=4D%;$)*

*

Page 59: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* [:*

O>%&%* (&%*",-$5;-%* &%#%(&D>* #$&%("#* $>($* <=D,#* =4* $>%* $=;5D* =<* #.4%&@.C* A=&* %h(";-%)*"%&@%&#* (4'* (D?,5#5$5=4#* -5$%&($,&%*'5B%#* 54* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<* $d=* <5&"#* D="65454@* $>%5&*#$&%4@$>#* 54* =&'%&* $=* (D>5%B%* B(-,%C* T=d%B%&)* $>5#* $>%#5#* >(#* <=D,#%'* =4* #.4%&@.*6%$d%%4*D=--(6=&($54@*<5&"#)*#54D%*$>5#*(;;&=(D>%#*=;%4*544=B($5=4*;&(D$5D%#*"=#$-.C***A=,&$>)*d>%4*'%#D&5654@*<5&"*#.4%&@.)* $>%*'5B5#5=4*54*54$%&_*(4'*54$&(_<5&"*#.4%&@.*>(#*4=$* 6%%4* $(Q%4* 54$=* (DD=,4$)* #54D%* $>5#* '5#$54D$5=4* >(#* 4=$* 6%%4* "%4$5=4%'* 54* $>%*'5<<%&%4$* $.;=-=@5%#* ;&%#%4$* 54* -5$%&($,&%C* T=d%B%&)* &%D%4$* &%#%(&D>* >(#* #>=d4* $>($*54$%&_<5&"* #.4%&@.* =<$%4* &%#,-$#* 54* 54$&(_<5&"* #.4%&@5%#* (#* d%--* R3"5$#* %$* (-C)* /01/SC*A,$,&%*&%#%(&D>* #>=,-'* <=D,#*=4* $>5#* $=;5D*(4'* #>=,-'*"(Q%* $>%*'5#$54D$5=4* 54$=* 54$%&_*(4'*54$&(_<5&"*#.4%&@.)*$=*#%%*5<*(4.*'5<<%&%4D%#*54*$>%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%*D(4*6%*<=,4'C**A54(--.)* D=4D%&454@* $>%* "%$>='=-=@.)* $>%* D='54@* =<* $>%* NMGE3* D(#%#* <=&* $>%* ;&(D$5D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*>(#*6%%4*;%&<=&"%'*6.*=4-.*=4%*&%#%(&D>%&C*3=)*,4<=&$,4($%-.)*$>%&%*5#*4=*B(-5'($5=4*=<*$>%#%*&%#,-$#*(4'*$>%*<54'54@#*D=,-'*6%*#,6g%D$*$=*&%$&=#;%D$5B%*65(#C* E<* ",-$5;-%* &%#%(&D>%&#* >('* ;%&<=&"%'* $>%* D='54@)* $>%* &%#,-$#* d=,-'* 6%* "=&%*&%-5(6-%)*d>5D>*d=,-'* #$&%4@$>%4* $>5#* $>%#5#C* A,$,&%* &%#%(&D>*D=,-'*%(#5-.*(''&%##* $>5#*5##,%*6.*-%$$54@*",-$5;-%*&%#%(&D>%&#*;%&<=&"*$>%*=;%4*D='54@*;&=D%##C********

Page 60: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `0*

/%L%*%#-%0!

4,A<.-1).+#0!!<,(>)*!C)*P*O,DD5)*JC*ZC*R/001S*?4$*#4*$%@+2)4*22%G<A*52%"4A%2$#"$*:)*2'%D*U$%"4A%;"2*2C*FD\&(d_T5--7*W%d** L=&Q)*WL*

R"4":*G*4$%f+"#$*#56%C/R/S7** 20_2:*!--%4)*GCJC*R1:92S*J=--%D$5B%*54B%4$5=4C*g<+#4"5%<F%T;<4<G);%J*E",)<+#%"4A%P#:"4)>"$)<4*CR1S7*1 /]C*!"5$)*GC*P*Z5B4($)*+C*R1:99S*K5B%&#5<5D($5=4*#$&($%@5%#)*6,#54%##*D.D-%#*(4'*%D=4="5D*;%&<=&"(4D%C** O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%7R1S7*::_110*!"5$)*GC*P*l=$$)*JC*R/001S*Y(-,%*J&%($5=4*54*N_X,#54%##C*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%00R1S7*]:2_[/0*!"5$)*GC)*P*l=$$)*JC!R/010S*X,#54%##*F='%-*E44=B($5=47*J&%($54@*Y(-,%!54*O5"%#*=<**J>(4@%C*_<#K)4:!! !"=*#!_!3/LNX%?TOT!J+2)4*22!O;E<<5X!c4),*#2)$6!<F!W","##"7*0_1[*!4'%&##=4)*XC)*+=>(44%##=4)*IC*P*l'&(BQ=B5D)*+C*R/00:S*!-5@454@*@=(-#*(4'*#%&B5D%#*$>&=,@>*@=(-*(4'** 6,#54%##*"='%--54@C*?4F<#G"$)<4%O62$*G2%T3@+2)4*22%R"4":*G*4$*LR1S7*12]_1`:*!4#=<<)*ECTC*R1:`[S*1<#=<#"$*%2$#"$*:6'%B4%"4"56$);"5%"==#<";E%$<%@+2)4*22%=<5);6%F<#%%:#<-$E%"4A%*U="42)<4.%% FD\&(d_T5--7*W%d*L=&Q)*WL*!;;-%@($%)*ZCFC*R/000S*N_X,#54%##*"='%-#7*F(Q54@*#%4#%*=<*$>%*E4$%&4%$*6,#54%##*-(4'#D(;%) E4*K5DQ#=4)*\C** P*K%3(4D$5#)*\C*RN'#CS)*?4F<#G"$)<4%$*;E4<5<:6%"4A%$E*%F+$+#*%*4$*#=#)2*'%W*-%G<A*52%F<#%G"4":*#2'%% ]:_101C*N4@-%d=='*J-5<<#)*W+7*I&%4$5D%_T(--C*!&%B(-=)*+C!C)*J(#$%--=)*EC)*'%*J=--%)*3C)*Z%4##%4)*\C)*W%,"(44)*HC*P*l=--=)*FC*R/011S*E4$&=',D$5=4*$=*$>%*#;%D5(-** 5##,%7*54$%@&($54@*#,#$(54(65-5$.*54*6,#54%##*"='%-#C*g<+#4"5%<F%R"4":*G*4$%9*,*5<=G*4$%8NR10S7** :]1_:[]*!,#$54)*+C*P*Z%=4(&')*TC*R/009S*J(4*$>%*B5&$,=,#*"=,#%*(4'*$>%*d%(-$>.*%-%;>(4$*-5B%*>(;;5-.*%B%&*(<$%&q** 1"5)F<#4)"%R"4":*G*4$%M*,)*-%H&R1S7*88_10/*X(-'d54)*JC*P*Y=4*T5;;%-)*NC*R/011S*F='%--54@*(*;(&('5@"*#>5<$7*<&="*;&=',D%&*544=B($5=4*$=*,#%&*(4'** =;%4*D=--(6=&($5B%*544=B($5=4C*P#:"4)>"$)<4%O;)*4;*%00R`S7*12::_1]18*X(&4%.)*+C*R1::1SC*A5&"*&%#=,&D%#*(4'*#,#$(54%'*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%C*g<+#4"5%<F%R"4":*G*4$*&LR1S7** 1[1_1``**X%6654@$=4)*+C*R/001S*3,#$(54(6-%*'%B%-=;"%4$7*(*&%B5%d*=<*$>%*54$%&4($5=4(-*'%B%-=;"%4$)*6,#54%##*(4'** (DD=,4$54@*-5$%&($,&%C*B;;<+4$)4:%Q<#+G%0HR/S7*1/9_1[8*X&,4=&5)*\C*P*G=##5)*!C*R/000S*3.4%&@.*(4'*J=>%&%4D%*$>&=,@>*J=--%D$5B%*!D$5=47*3="%*E4#5@>$#*<&="*^54%** G=,$%#*54*O,#D(4.C*O<;)<5<:)"%M+#"5)2%CNR1S7*]0: ]/2*X&,#=45)*3C)*I&%4D5;%)*!C)*P*I(B5$$)*HC*R/001SC*H4=d-%'@%*#;%D5(-5f($5=4)*=&@(45f($5=4(-*D=,;-54@)*(4'*$>%** 6=,4'(&5%#*=<*$>%*<5&"7*d>.*'=*<5&"#*Q4=d*"=&%*$>(4*$>%.*"(Q%q*BAG)4)2$#"$),*%O;)*4;*%% f+"#$*#56%CIR1S7*[:8 `/1*X,4@%)*FC*R1:`8S*O;)*4$)F);%M*2*"#;E%??'%DE*%O*"#;E%F<#%D#+$EC*X%&-54)*T%5'%-6%&@)*W%d*L=&Q7*3;&54@%&C*J(-B(D(4$%)*3C)*H%#$54@)*IC*P*M->r5)*+C*R/011S*X,#54%##*"='%-*'.4("5D#*(4'*544=B($5=47*R&%S%#$(6-5#>54@*$>%** "5##54@*-54Q(@%#C*R"4":*G*4$%9*;)2)<4%C7R9S7*12/8_12]/*J>($$%&g%%)*3C*R1:9`S*O.;%#*=<*#.4%&@.*(4'*%D=4="5D*B(-,%7*$>%*5";(D$*=<*(D?,5#5$5=4#*=4*"%&@54@*(4'** &5B(-*<5&"#C*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%LR/S7*11:_12:*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/002S*P=*4%)44<,"$)<4'%$E*%4*-%)G=*#"$),*%F<#%;#*"$)4:%"4A%=#<F)$)4:%F#<G%$*;E4<5<:6.%% T(&B(&'*X,#54%##*3D>==-*I&%##7*X=#$=4)*F!C*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/008S*^>.*D=";(45%#*#>=,-'*>(B%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#C*O5<"4%R"4":*G*4$%M*,)*-%% C/R/S7*//_/9*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/010S*X,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=47*=;;=&$,45$5%#*(4'*6(&&5%&#C*(<4:%M"4:*%!5"44)4:%% C8R1S7*2[]_2`2%J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*P*G=#%46-=="*GC3C*R/00/S*O>%*&=-%*=<*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*54*D(;$,&54@*B(-,%*<&="** 544=B($5=4C*?4A+2$#)"5%"4A%1<#=<#"$*%1E"4:*%&&R2S7*[/:_[[[*J>%#6&=,@>)* TC)* Y(4>(B%&6%Q%)* ^C* P* ^%#$)* +C* R/00`S* P=*4% )44<,"$)<4'% #*2*"#;E)4:% "% 4*-% ="#"A):G.%% Vh<=&'*M45B%&#5$.*I&%##7*Z=4'=4)*N4@-(4'*J>5(&=45)*KC)*J>5%#()*YC*P*A&($$545)*AC*R/011S*O>%*=;%4*544=B($5=4*g=,&4%.7*>=d*<5&"#*'.4("5D(--.** 5";-%"%4$*$>%*%"%&@54@*544=B($5=4*"(4(@%"%4$*;(&('5@"C*D*;E4<,"$)<4%8&R1S7*2]_]2*

Page 61: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `1*

J>&5#$%4#%4)*JCFC*R1::8S* +2*%:#*"$%F)#G2%%$<%F")5.%T(&B(&'*X,#54%##*3D>==-*I&%##7*X=#$=4)*F!*

J>&5#$"(44)*IC*R/00]S*F,-$54($5=4(-*D=";(45%#*(4'*$>%*4($,&(-*%4B5&=4"%4$7*'%$%&"54(4$#*=<*@-=6(-** %4B5&=4"%4$(-*;=-5D.*#$(4'(&'5f($5=4C*B;"A*G6%<F*R"4":*G*4$*g<+#4"5*CLR[S7*8]8 8`0*K(>-(4'%&)*ZC*P*\(44)*KCFC*R/010S*T=d*=;%4*5#*=;%4*544=B($5=4q*M*2*"#;E%!<5);6%87R1S7*`::_80:*K(45%-)*OC*!C)F%$D(-<)*\C*3C*R/001SC*DE*%G"4":*G*4$%<F%=*<=5*%)4%G*#:*#2%"4A%";a+)2)$)<42E*U,=&,"*X==Q#7** ^%#$;=&$)*JO*K(#)*OCHC*P*O%4@)*XC*R/000S*!*&%#=,&D%*6(#%'*$>%=&.*=<*#$&($%@5D*(--5(4D%#C*g<+#4"5%<F%R"4":*G*4$%0IR1S7** 21_`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q*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5** 0&R1S7*110[_11/1*N-Q54@$=4*+C*R1::9S*1"44)@"52%-)$E%Q<#K2'%DE*%D#)=5*%J<$$<G%()4*%<F%0&2$%1*4$+#6%J+2)4*22C*W%d*3=D5%$.7** \(6&5=-(*E#-(4')*XJC**N4Q%-)*NC)*\(##"(44)*V*P*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/00:S*V;%4*GPK*(4'*=;%4*544=B($5=47*%h;-=&54@*$>%** ;>%4="%4=4C*MY9%R"4":*G*4$%87R1S7%211_21`*A=d-%&)*3C+C*P*T=;%)*JC*R/008S*E4D=&;=&($54@*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##*;&(D$5D%#*54$=*D=";(4.*#$&($%@.C** J+2)4*22%O$#"$*:6%"4A%$E*%T4,)#<4G*4$%&IR1S7*/`_29**\(-;54)*OC+C*P*T%&4'=4)*FC*R/000S*DE*%;<G=5*$*%:+)A*%$<%G*#:*#2%"4A%";a+)2)$)<42C*+=>4*^5-%.*P*3=4#)*E4DC7** W%d*L=&Q)*WL*\(&D5()*GC*P*J(-(4$=4%)*GC*R/00/S*!*D&5$5D(-*-==Q*($*$%D>4=-=@5D(-*544=B($5=4*$.;=-=@.*(4'*544=B($5B%4%##** $%&"[email protected]*(*-5$%&($,&%*&%B5%dC*g<+#4"5%<F%=#<A+;$%)44<,"$)<4%G"4":*G*4$%&7R/S7*10_2/*\(d%&)*!C*P*\,#,"(4=)*FC!C*R/00/S*!5"$F<#G%(*"A*#2E)='%E<-%?4$*5X%R);#<2<F$%"4A%1)2;<%A#),*%)4A+2$#6%% )44<,"$)<4.%T(&B(&'*X,#54%##*3D>==-*I&%##7*J("6&5'@%)*F!*\5"%4=)*+C*P*^==)*JCLC*R1:::S*F,-$5"(&Q%$*D=4$(D$)*%D=4="5%#*=<*#D=;%)*(4'*<5&"*;%&<=&"(4D%C*B;"A*G6%<F%% R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%C0R2S7*/2:_/[:*\>(f5(45)*!C*P*Y%4$&%#D()*FC+C*R/00[S*H%.d=&'#*(4'*D,-$,&(-*D>(4@%7*<&("%*(4(-.#5#*=<*6,#54%##*"='%-** ;,6-5D*$(-Q*1:8[_/000C*O<;)<5<:6%Q<#+G%0NR1S7*[/2_[[:*\==-')*FC*P*J(";6%--)*!C*R1::9S*K%#;%&($%-.*#%%Q54@*#.4%&@.C*b"#,"#A%J+2)4*22%M*,)*-'%1/:_1]2%\==-')*FC)*J(";6%--)*!C*P*!-%h(4'%&)*FC*R1::]S*1<#=<#"$*35*,*5%2$#"$*:6'%;#*"$)4:%,"5+*%)4%% $E*%G+5$)3@+2)4*22%;<G="46C*+=>4*^5-%.*P*3=4#)*E4DC7*W%d*L=&Q)*WL*\=$$<&5%')*KC*R/002S*O>%*K=--(&#*(4'*3%4#%*=<*@&%%4*6,5-'54@C*3$(4<=&'*M45B%&#5$.)*VD$=6%&*:$>*/002C**\&5";%)*JC*P*3=<Q()*^C*R/00:S*3%(&D>*;($$%&4#*(4'*(6#=&;$5B%*D(;(D5$.7*-=d*(4'*>5@>*$%D>4=-=@.*#%D$=&#*54** N,&=;%(4*D=,4$&5%#C*M*2*"#;E%!<5);6%8/R2S7*]:[_[0`C*T5--)*JC*P*+=4%#)*\C*R/008S*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$% %B4%)4$*:#"$*A%"==#<";EC*8$>*%'5$5=4C*T=,@>$=4*F5<<-54** J=";(4.7*X=#$=4)*F!*T,66(&')* \C* R/00:S* F%(#,&54@* =&@(45f($5=4(-* ;%&<=&"(4D%7* 6%.=4'* $>%* $&5;-%* 6=$$="* -54%C* J+2)4*22%% O$#"$*:6%"4A%$E*%T4,)#<4G*4$%&7R1S7*188_1:1*T,6%&)* IC* P* Y(4* '%* Y%4)* TC* R1::[S* (<4:)$+A)4"5% Q)*5A% M*2*"#;E% R*$E<A2% % O$+A6)4:% !#<;*22*2% <F%% P#:"4)>"$)<4"5%1E"4:*.%3(@%*I,6-5D($5=4#7*J(-5<=&45()*M3*T,5f54@>)*NCHCGCNC*R/011S*V;%4*544=B($5=47*#$($%*=<*$>%*(&$*(4'*<,$,&%*;%&#;%D$5B%#C*D*;E4<,"$)<4%8&R1S7/_* :*+=>4#%4)*FC^C)*J>&5#$%4#%4)*JCJC*P*H(@%&"(44)*TC*R/009S*G%54B%4$54@*.=,&*6,#54%##*"='%-C*b"#,"#A%% J+2)4*22%M*,)*-%/IR1/S7*[0_[:*H(;-(4)*GC*P*W=&$=4)*KC*R/00`S*B5):4G*4$'%c2)4:%$E*%J"5"4;*A%O;<#*;"#A%$<%1#*"$*%1<#=<#"$*%O64*#:)*2C** T(&B(&'*X,#54%##*3D>==-*I&%##7*J("6&5'@%)*F!*H%&##%4#* *Y(4*K&=4@%-%4)*EC*R/001S*O>%*5$%&($5B%*$>%=&._6,5-'54@*;&=D%##7*&($5=4(-%)*;&54D5;-%#*(4'** %B(-,($5=4C*R"4":*G*4$%9*;)2)<4%87R8S7*[02_[1/*H54@)*KCGC)*K(-$=4)*KCGC)*K(5-.)*JCFC*P*J=B54)*+CJC*R/00]S*F%$(_(4(-.#%#*=<*;=#$_(D?,5#5$5=4*;%&<=&"(4D%7** 54'5D($5=4#*=<*,45'%4$5<5%'*"='%&($=&#C*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%0HR1S7*198_/00*

Page 62: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `/*

H4=--)*3C*R/009S*1#<223@+2)4*22%264*#:)*2'%B%$6=<5<:6%<F%;#<223@+2)4*22%264*#:)*2%"4A%"%G)A3#"4:*%$E*<#6%<F%% ;<4$)4+<+2%:#<-$E%264*#:6%#*"5)>"$)<4C*^5%#6('%47*K%,$#D>%&*M45B%&#5$s$#_*Y%&-(@*RKMYS)*\(6-%&** N'5$5=4*^5##%4#D>(<$**Z("4%Q)*3C*R1::[S*f+"5)$"$),*%O<>)"5F<#2;E+4:)*2&'*%'5$5=4C)*^%54>%5"7*X%-$f)*I#.D>=-=@5%*Y%&-(@#*M45=4C*Z5)*WC*P*O=;;54%4)*!C*R/011S*J=&;=&($%*&%#;=4#565-5$.*(4'*#,#$(54(6-%*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%*54*<=&%#$_* 6(#%'*54',#$&.7*J=";-%"%4$(&.*=&*D=4<-5D$54@*@=(-#q*Q<#*2$%!<5);6%"4A%T;<4<G);2%&8R1S7*112_1/2%Z5D>$%4$(-%&)*MC*R/009SC*V;%4*544=B($5=4*54*;&(D$5D%7*!4*(4(-.#5#*=<*#$&($%@5D*(;;&=(D>%#*$=**$%D>4=-=@.** $&(4#(D$5=4#C*?TTT%D#"42";$)<42%<4%T4:)4**#)4:%R"4":*G*4$%HHR1S7*1]9 1[8*Z5D>$%4$(-%&)*MC*R/011S*V;%4*544=B($5=47*;(#$*&%#%(&D>)*D,&&%4$*'%6($%#)*(4'*<,$,&%*'5&%D$5=4#C*B;"A*G6%<F%% R"4":*G*4$%!*#2=*;$),*2%0H7*8[_:2*Z%d5#)*ZCHC)*3D>"5##%,&)*!C)*3$%;>%4#)*HC*P*^%5&)*HC*R/00`SC*!'B5D%*=4*J="",45D($54@*K,&54@** V&@(45f($5=4(-*J>(4@%C*g<+#4"5%<F%J+2)4*22%1<GG+4);"$)<4%C8R/S7*112_128*F(&$54)*+C*R/00/S*1#<223J+2)4*22%O64*#:)*2'%M*;<G@)4"$)<4X%G<A+5"#)$6X%"4A%$E*%G+5$)3%@+2)4*22%$*"GC** K5##%&$($5=4)*3$(4<=&'*M45B%&#5$.*FD\&($>)*GC\C*R/010S*X,#54%##*"='%-#7*(*'5#D=B%&.*'&5B%4*(;;&=(D>C*(<4:%M"4:*%!5"44)4:%C8R1S7*/]8_/`1*FDF(#$%&)*FCKC*R1::`S*DE*%)4$*55):*4;*%"A,"4$":*'%P#:"4)>)4:%F<#%;<G=5*U)$6C*X,$$%&d=&$>_*T%54%"(447** X=#$=4)*F!*F5$D>%-)*KC*P*J=-%#)*JC*R/002S*O>%*,-$5"($%*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%*=<*D=4$54,54@*6,#54%##*"='%-** 544=B($5=4C*g<+#4"5%<F%J+2)4*22%O$#"$*:6%0CR[S7*1[_/1*

*$=d(&'*(*,45<5%'** ;%&#;%D$5B%C*g<+#4"5%<F%J+2)4*22%M*2*"#;E%H/R1S7*8/`_2[C*W(@(=Q()*3C*P*Hd=4)*TCMC*R/00`S*O>%*54D5'%4D%*=<*D&=##_-5D%4#54@7*(*$>%=&.*(4'*4%d*%B5'%4D%*=4*$>%*<5&"** (4'*D=4$&(D$*-%B%-*'%$%&"54(4$#C*M*2*"#;E%!<5);6%8HR1S7*12]8 12`1*W@,.%4)*TC*P*H-%54%&)*XCTC*R/002S*O>%*%<<%D$5B%*"(4(@%"%4$*=<*"%&@%&#C*(*"A*#2E)=%Y%P#:"4)>"$)<4%% 9*,*5<=G*4$%g<+#4"5%0CR9S7*]]8_][]*V#$%&d(-'%&)*!C*R/00]S*DE*%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%<4$<5<:6 B%=#<=<2)$)<4%)4%"%A*2):4%2;)*4;*%"==#<";EC** K5##%&$($5=4*182)*M45B%&#5$.*=<*Z(,#(44%)*3d5$f%&-(4'C*V#$%&d(-'%&)*!C*P*I5@4%,&)*LC*R/010S*J+2)4*22%G<A*5%:*4*#"$)<4C*+=>4*^5-%.*P*3=4#)*E4D7*T=6=Q%4)*W%d** +%&#%.*I(4f(&)*+C*P*^5--5@)*GC*R1:91S*ND=4="5%#*=<*3D=;%C*BG*#);"4%T;<4<G);%M*,)*-*L&R/S7*/`9_/8/*I(##<5%-')*GC*R/00/S*E44=B($5=4*(4'*3.4%&@.*$>&=,@>*(*;(&(--%-*(D$5=4*-%(&454@*#$&,D$,&%C*DE*%(*"#4)4:%% P#:"4)>"$)<4%7R]S7*1[0_1[9*I%&#(,')*!C*R/00[S*N4>(4D54@*3.4%&@5#$5D*E44=B($5B%*J(;(65-5$.*54*F,-$54($5=4(-*J=&;=&($5=4#7*!4** N";5&5D(-*E4B%#$5@($5=4C*g<+#4"5%<F%!#<A+;$%?44<,"$)<4%R"4":*G*4$%//R1S7*]1/_]/:*I=&$%&)*FCNC*R1:9[S*1<G=*$)$),*%"A,"4$":*'%;#*"$)4:%"4A%2+2$")4)4:%2+=*#)<#%=*#F<#G"4;*.%A&%%*I&%##7*W%d** L=&Q)*WL*I,4D>)*HCAC*R/00[S%?4$#<A+;$)<4%$<%2<;)"5%#*2*"#;E'%f+"5)$"$),*%"4A%a+"4$)$"$),*%"==#<";E*2.*3(@%** I,6-5D($5=4#7*Z=4'=4)*N4@-(4'%G%%')*GC)*3$=&&,'_X(&4%#)*3C*P*+%##,;)*ZC*R/01/S*T=d*=;%4*544=B($5=4*(<<%D$#*$>%*'&5B%&#*=<*D=";%$5$5B%** ('B(4$(@%C*R"4":*G*4$%9*;)2)<4%HNR1S7*[9_82*G%5$f5@)*FC*R/011S*E#*.=,&*D=";(4.*D>==#54@*$>%*6%#$*544=B($5=4*5'%(#q*R?D%O5<"4%R"4":*G*4$%M*,)*-%% H0R]S7*]`_[/**G=""%)*!C\CZC*R/002S*F(Q54@*(*'5<<%&%4D%7*=&@(45f($5=4*(#*'%#5@4C*P#:"4)>"$)<4%O;)*4;**&CR[S7*[[9_[82C*G=""%*)*!C\CZC*P*N4'%46,&@)*\C*R/00`S*J=4#$&,D$5=4*;&54D5;-%#*(4'*'%#5@4*&,-%#*54*$>%*D(#%*=<*D5&D,-(&** '%#5@4C*P#:"4)>"$)<4%O;)*4;*%&LR/S7*/98_/:8*3(&(#B($>.)*3CKC*R/001S*J(,#($5=4*(4'*%<<%D$,($5=47*$=d(&'*(*$>%=&%$5D(-*#>5<$*<&="**%D=4="5D*54%B5$(65-5$.** $=*%4$&%;&%4%,&5(-*D=4$54@%4D.C*B;"A*G6%<F%R"4":*G*4$%M*,)*-%0IR/S7*/]2_/`2*3(4',--5)*AC*P*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/00:S*O>%*$d=*<(D%#*=<*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#C*33GW*d=&Q54@*;(;%&*#%&5%#*3D>d%5@%&)*KCFC*P*Y%&.)*IC*R/002S*J&%($54@*B(-,%*$&=,@>*"%&@%&*(4'*(D?,5#5$5=4*54$%@&($5=4C*BA,"4;*2%)4%% R*#:*#2%"4A%B;a+)2)$)<42%0R1S7*1_/`*3%$>)*!C*R1::0S*3=,&D%#*=<*B(-,%*D&%($5=4*54*(D?,5#5$5=4#7*(4*%";5&5D(-*54B%#$5@($5=4C*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%% g<+#4"5%&&R1S7*]21_]``*3%$>)* !C)* 3=4@)* HCIC* P* I%$$5$)* GC* R/00/S* Y(-,%* D&%($5=4* (4'* '%#$&,D$5=4* 54* D&=##_6=&'%&* (D?,5#5$5=4#7* (4** %";5&5D(-*(4(-.#5#*=<*<=&%5@4*(D?,5#5$5=4#*=<*MC3C*<5&"#C*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%08R1S7*:/1_* :]0*

Page 63: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `2*

3>(&"()*3C*P*T%4&5?,%#)*EC*R/00[S*3$(Q%>=-'%&*54<-,%4D%#*=4*#,#$(54(65-5$.*;&(D$5D%#*54*$>%*J(4('5(4*<=&%#$** ;&=',D$#*54',#$&.C*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%0IR1S7*1[:_/0[*35-B5,#)*!C+C*P*W%'%#Q5)*3C*R/011S*3,#$(54(65-5$.*54*E3*I&=g%D$#7*(*D(#%*#$,'.C*1<GG+4);"$)<42%<F%$E*%??RB%% &&R]S7*1_1/*3"5$#)* !C!C+C)* X%&%4'#)* +C+C)* G%."%4)* ECFCFC+C)* !4f=-()* IC)* X(.=4()* JC)* \(&D5()* OC)* 3D>,6%&$)* FC* P* 3$,&")* AC** R/01/SC*E4$%&;-(.*6%$d%%4*=;%4*544=B($5=4#*"=B%#*(4'*6,#54%##*"='%-*'.4("5D#C*E4*+C*X,$-%&*%$C** (-C* RN'CS)*!#<;**A)4:2%<F%DE*%MY9%R"4":*G*4$%1<4F*#*4;*X%0830H%R"6%0N&0X%`#*4<@5*X%Q#"4;*.* \==.%% &38C].*\&%4=6-%)*A&(4D%7*ND=-%*'%*F(4(@%"%4$C*3$*+=>4)*JCTC*P*T(&&5#=4)*+C3C*R1:::S*F(4,<(D$,&54@_6(#%'*&%-($%'4%##)*#.4%&@.)*(4'*D==&'54($5=4C*O$#"$*:);%% R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%0NR/S7*1/: 1][*3,D>"(4)*FCJC*R1::[S*F(4(@54@*-%@5$5"(D.7*3$&($%@5D*(4'*54#$5$,$5=4(-*(;;&=(D>%#C*B;"A*G6%<F%% R"4":*G*4$%M*,)*-%0NR2S)*[81 `10*3,'(&#(4(")*3C)*T=--)*IC*P*3(-("5)*!C*R1::`S*3>(&%>=-'%&*d%(-$>*@(54#*54*"%&@%&#7*%<<%D$*=<*#.4%&@.*(4'** =d4%&#>5;*D,-$,&%C*g<+#4"5%<F%J+2)4*22%Q)4"4;*%"4A%B;;<+4$)4:%08R[S7*`82_`:9*3f,-(4#Q5)*\C*R1::2S*E4$&(_<5&"*$&(4#<%&*=<*6%#$*;&(D$5D%)*(;;&=;&5($5B%*D(;(65-5$5%#)*(4'*=&@(45f($5=4(-** 6(&&5%&#*$=*(;;&=;&5($5=4C*B;"A*G6%<F%R"4":*G*4$%!#<;**A)4:2%&R1S7*]8_[2*O(4&5B%&'5)*P*Y%4Q($&("(4*R/00[S H4=d-%'@%*&%-($%'4%##*(4'*$>%*;%&<=&"(4D%*=<*$>%*",-$56,#54%##** <5&"C*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5*0IR/S7*:8_11:*O%%D%)*KC+C*R1:90S*ND=4="5%#*=<*#D=;%*(4'*$>%*#D=;%*=<*$>%*%4$%&;&5#%C*g<+#4"5%<F%T;<4<G);%J*E",)<#%"4A%% P#:"4)>"$)<4%&R1S7*//2_/]8%%O%%D%)*KC+C*R/008S*Nh;-5D($54@*'.4("5D*D(;(65-5$5%#7*$>%*4($,&%*(4'*"5D&=<=,4'($5=4#*=<*R#,#$(54(6-%S** %4$%&;&5#%*;%&<=&"(4D%C*O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%0/R1S7*121:_12[0*O>="Q%)*3C*R/00/S*TU=*#)G*4$"$)<4%R"$$*#2.%T(&B(&'*X,#54%##*3D>==-*I&%##7*J("6&5'@%)*F!*O5'')*+C)*X%##(4$)*+C*P*I(B5$$)*HC*R/00[S*R"4":)4:*?44<,"$)<4C*+=>4*^5-%.*P*3=4#*Z$'7*^%#$*3,##%h)*N4@-(4'*O5""%&#)*IC*R1::9S*X,#54%##*"='%-#*<=&*%-%D$&=45D*"(&Q%$#C*T5*;$#<4);%R"#K*$2%/R/S7*2_9*O&%(D.)*FC*P*^5%&#%"()*AC*R1::2S*J,#$="%&*54$5"(D.*(4'*=$>%&*B(-,%*'5#D5;-54%#C*b"#,"#A%J+2)4*22%M*,)*-X%% 78&NL'%92_:2*O&5;#(#)*FC*P*\(B%$$5)*\C*R/000S*J(;(65-5$5%#)*D=@45$5=4#*(4'*54%&$5(7*%B5'%4D%*<&="*'5@5$(-*5"(@54@C** O$#"$*:);%R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%0&R1S7*11]8_11`1*Y(4*!Q%4)*+C*NC*R/00]S*F(4(@%"%4$*&%#%(&D>*6(#%'*=4*$>%*;(&('5@"*=<*$>%*'%#5@4*#D5%4D%#7*$>%*?,%#$*<=&** <5%-'_$%#$%'*(4'*@&=,4'%'*$%D>4=-=@5D(-*&,-%#C*g<+#4"5%<F%R"4":*G*4$%O$+A)*2*C&R/S7*/1:_/]`C*Y(4*!Q%4)*+CNC)*X%&%4'#)*TC*P*Y(4*'%&*X5g)*TC*R/008S*!#<@5*G%2<5,)4:%)4%<#:"4)>"$)<42.%J("6&5'@%** M45B%&#5$.*I&%##7*J("6&5'@%)*F!*Y(4*X,&@)*NC)*G=""%)*!C\CZC)*\5-#54@)*YC!C*P*G%."%4)*ECFCFC+C*R/009S*J&%($54@*,45B%&#5$.*#;54_=<<#7*(** #D5%4D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;%&#;%D$5B%C*g<+#4"5%<F%!#<A+;$%?44<,"$)<4%R"4":*G*4$%0HR/S7*11]_1/9*Y(4>(B%&6%Q%)*^C)*Y(4*'%*Y&(4'%)*YC*P*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/009S*M4'%&#$(4'54@*$>%*('B(4$(@%#*=<*=;%4** 544=B($5=4*;&(D$5D%#*54*D=&;=&($%*B%4$,&54@*54*$%&"#*=<*&%(-*=;$5=4#C*1#*"$),)$6%"4A%?44<,"$)<4%% R"4":*G*4$%&LR]S7*/[1_/[9*Y(4*H-%%<)*+C!C\C*P*G=="%)*WC+C*R/008S*K%B%-=;54@*D(;(65-5$5%#*(4'*D=";%$%4D%*<=&*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##** "(4(@%"%4$*(#*544=B($5=47*(*&%#%(&D>*(@%4'(C*g<+#4"5%<F%15*"4*#%!#<A+;$)<4%&HR1S7*29_[1*Y(4*3$&5%4)*IC+C*R1::8S*O=d(&'#*(*"%$>='=-=@.*=<*;#.D>=-=@5D(-*;&(D$5D%C*DE*<#6%"4A%!26;E<5<:6%LR[S7*`92_800*^(-Q%&)*HC*P*^(4)*AC*R/011S*O>%*>(&"*=<*#."6=-5D*(D$5=4#*(4'*\&%%4_^(#>54@7*D=&;=&($%*(D$5=4#*(4'** D="",45D($5=4#*=4*%4B5&=4"%4$(-*;%&<=&"(4D%*(4'*$>%5&*<54(4D5(-*5";-5D($5=4#C*g<+#4"5%<F%% J+2)4*22%T$E);2%&N7R/S7*//8_/]/*^%5)*TC*R/010S*J==;%&($5=4*(4'*D=";%$5$5=4*=<*54$%&<5&"*4%$d=&Q*=&@(45f($5=4#7*$>%*<,4D$5=4*=<*#.4%&@5%#C** ?4$*#4"$)<4"5%1<4F*#*4;*%<4%T3J+2)4*22*2%"4A%T3`<,*#4G*4$%\0N&&]7*/22:_/2]/**^54')*LC*P*F(>(g(4)*YC*R1:99S*X,#54%##*3.4%&@.*'=%#*4=$*(-d(.#*;(.*=<<C*(<4:%M"4:*%!5"44)4:%0&\&]7*[:_``*^,)*^C*P*J>=5)*^CZC*R/00]S* 54*J>54%#%** X,#54%##*W%$d=&Q#7*!4*E4$%@&($5B%*!;;&=(D>C*B2)"%!";)F);%g<+#4"5%<F%R"4":*G*4$%0&R1S7*2/[ 2]2*L54)*GCHC*R1::]SC*1"2*%O$+A6%M*2*"#;E'%9*2):4%"4A%R*$E<A2C*3(@%*I,6-5D($5=4#7*Z=4'=4)*N4@-(4'**l(>%%&)*!C)*J(#$(p%&)*aC*P*3=,'%&)*KC*R/012S*3.4%&@.*#=,&D%#)*$(&@%$*(,$=4=".*(4'*54$%@&($5=4*54** (D?,5#5$5=4#C*g<+#4"5%<F%R"4":*G*4$%87R2S7*`0]_`2/**l=$$)*JC)*!"5$)*G)*P*F(##()*ZC*R/010S*O>%*6,#54%##*"='%-7*$>%=&%$5D(-*&==$#)*&%D%4$*'%B%-=;"%4$#*(4'*<,$,&%** &%#%(&D>C*_<#K)4:%!"=*#%_!3/I0X%?TOT!J+2)4*22!!O;E<<5X!c4),*#2)$6!<F!W","##"7*0_][*

Page 64: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `]*

E#<.#%!*%0+,*-%0!J20*R/01/S*J-,6*B(4*20*XCYC** dddCD-,6B(420C4-)*<5&#$*$5"%*(DD%##%'*K%D%"6%&*1/$>*/01/*T(&f54@CD="*R/01/S*E4$%&4($5=4(-*+=,&4(-*G(4Q54@*

dddC>(&f54@CD="bg?-C>$")*<5&#$*$5"%*(DD%##%'*K%D%"6%&*18$>**/01/**XFVE*R/012S*NMGE3*X,#54%##*F='%-#*<=&*V;%4*E44=B($5=4*RXFVES*I&=g%D$** >$$;7bb6"=5C%,&5#_;&=@&(""%C%,b;&=g%D$_54<=b%,&5#)*<5&#$*$5"%*(DD%##%'*!;&5-*/8$>*/012*VY!F*R/01/S*V;%46(&%*Y-(("#%*!<B(-#$=<<%4"(($#D>(;;5g** >$$;7bbdddC&5%"#$C6%b=B("bA%#$5B(-#bK%<(,-$C(#;_#m8C>$")*<5&#$*$5"%*(DD%##%'*!;&5-*`$>*/012*G%#;=4#*R/012S*G%#;=4#*=4-54%*<%#$5B(-*"=45$=&** >$$;7bbdddC&%#;=4#C4-b,;-=('#bA(D$#>%%$_A%#$5B(-#C;'<)*<5&#$*$5"%*(DD%##%'*!;&5-*/0$>*/012****

!*

!!

Page 65: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `[*

GCC%#$.-%0!

GCC%#$.&!"! !J,0.#%00!D+$%<!-1#710!A,.<$.#@!A<+-Q0!!\J"2*A%<4%P2$*#-"5A*#%"4A%!):4*+#X%0N&N]%%1+2$<G*#%2*:G*4$2* *'%<54%*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*@&=,;#*=<*;%=;-%*=&*=&@(45f($5=4#*(4*%4$%&;&5#%*(5"#* $=* &%(D>* (4'* #%&B%C* O>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* #>=,-'* 6%* D(&%<,--.* '%#5@4%'* (&=,4'* (*

#,&B5B%*<=&*-=4@C** Z"5+*% !#<=<2)$)<4% * '%#D&56%#* $>%* 6,4'-%* =<* ;&=',D$#* (4'* #%&B5D%#* $>($* D&%($%*B(-,%* <=&*(* #;%D5<5D* D,#$="%&* #%@"%4$C* E4*=$>%&*d=&'#)* 5$* 5#* $>%* &%(#=4*d>.*D,#$="%&#*$,&4* $=* =4%* D=";(4.* =B%&* (4=$>%&C* O>%* B(-,%* ;&=;=#5$5=4* >(#* $=* %5$>%&* #($5#<.* (*

* ** 1E"44*52% *'%#D&56%*>=d*(*D=";(4.*D="",45D($%#*d5$>*(4'*&%(D>%#*5$#*D,#$="%&*#%@"%4$#* $=* '%-5B%&* $>%* B(-,%* ;&=;=#5$5=4C* E$* 5#* $>%* 54$%&<(D%* d5$>* $>%* D,#$="%&* (4'*$>%&%<=&%*;-(.#*(4*5";=&$(4$*&=-%*54*$>%*D,#$="%&*%h;%&5%4D%C** 1+2$<G*#% #*5"$)<42E)=2% * '%#D&56%#* $>%* $.;%#* =<* &%-($5=4#>5;#* (* D=";(4.*%#$(6-5#>%#*d5$>*#;%D5<5D*D,#$="%&*#%@"%4$#C*O>%#%*&%-($5=4#>5;#*&(4@%*<&="*(,$="($%'*(##5#$(4D%*$=*;%&#=4(-*(##5#$(4D%*$=*D=_D&%($5=4*d5$>*$>%*D,#$="%&C** M*,*4+*%2$#*"G2% * &%;&%#%4$*$>%*D(#>*(*D=";(4.*@%4%&($%#* <&="*%(D>*D,#$="%&*#%@"%4$C*!*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4*54B=-B%*$d=*'5<<%&%4$*$.;%#*=<*&%B%4,%*#$&%("#)*4("%-.*$&(4#(D$5=4* &%B%4,%* #$&%("#* R&%#,-$54@* <&="* =4%_$5"%* D,#$="%&* ;(."%4$#S* (4'*&%D,&&54@*&%B%4,%*#$&%("#*R&%#,-$54@*<&="*=4_@=54@*;(."%4$#SC** S*6%#*2<+#;*2* *'%#D&56%*$>%*"=#$*5";=&$(4$*(##%$#*&%?,5&%'*$=*"(Q%*(*6,#54%##*"='%-* d=&QC* O>%#%* &%#=,&D%#* D(4* 6%* ;>.#5D(-)* <54(4D5(-)* 54$%--%D$,(-)* =&* >,"(4C* H%.*&%#=,&D%#*D(4*6%*=d4%'*6.*$>%*D=";(4.)*(D?,5&%'*<&="*Q%.*;(&$4%&#*=&*-%(#%'C* *

S*6*";$),)$)*2% *'%#D&56%*$>%*"=#$* 5";=&$(4$* $>54@#*(*D=";(4.*",#$*'=*$=*"(Q%*5$#* 6,#54%##* "='%-* d=&QC* O>%#%* (D$5B5$5%#* (&%* &%?,5&%'* $=* D&%($%* (4'* =<<%&* $>%* B(-,%*;&=;=#5$5=4C*** S*6%="#$4*#2E)=* *'%#D&56%#*$>%*4%$d=&Q*=<*#,;;-5%&#*(4'*;(&$4%&#*$>($*"(Q%*$>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*d=&QC*N#;%D5(--.*54*$>%*D=4$%h$*=<*=;%4*R6,#54%##*"='%-S*544=B($5=4)*Q%.*;(&$4%&#>5;#*>(B%*$>%*;=$%4$5(-*$=*6%D="%*(4*5";=&$(4$*#=,&D%*=<*B(-,%*D&%($5=4)*#54D%*;(&$4%&54@* ,;*d5$>* D,#$="%&#)* #,;;-5%&#)* =&* %B%4* D=";%$5$=&#* ;&=B5'%#* (DD%##* $=* 4%d*54<=&"($5=4*(4'*&%#=,&D%#*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/008SC*** 1<2$%2$#+;$+#*% %'%#D&56%#*(--* D=#$#* 54D,&&%'* $=*=;%&($%*(* 6,#54%##*"='%-C*O>%#%*(&%*$>%*D=#$#*($$(D>%'*$=*$>%*B(-,%*D&%($5=4*6.*$>%*=$>%&*%5@>$*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#C*

GCC%#$.&!""! !R&C%*.D%#)1).+#`!%LL%-),1).+#!1#$!<%1$%*02.C!%TU=*#)G*4$"$)<4* * O>="Q%* R/00/S* >(#*d&5$$%4* (* ,#%<,-* ;(;%&* =4* ;&54D5;-%#* <=&*

%<<%D$5B%* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4C* !-$>=,@>* >5#* D=4D%;$#* (&%* <=D,#%'* =4* 4%d* ;&=',D$* (4'*;&=D%##* 544=B($5=4)* $>%.* (;;-.* %?,(--.* $=* 6,#54%##* "='%-#C* !4* 5";=&$(4$* ;&54D5;-%*D=4D%&4#*$>%* <5'%-5$.*=<* $>%*%h;%&5"%4$)*d>5D>* 5#* $>%*%h$%4$* $=*d>5D>*$>%*%h;%&5"%4$(-*D=4'5$5=4#*(&%*&%;&%#%4$($5B%*<=&*$>%*-(&@%&*"(&Q%$*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC*T5@>%#$*<5'%-5$.*5#* (D>5%B%'*6.* $&.54@*=,$* (4*(-$%&4($5B%*6,#54%##*"='%-*=4*&%(-* D,#$="%&#*;(.54@* &%(-*"=4%.* 54* &%(-* %D=4="5D* $&(4#(D$5=4#C* O>%&%* (&%* #="%* 5";=&$(4$* ;(&("%$%&#* <=&* $>5#*$.;%*=<*;&=D%##7*$>%*D=#$#*=<*D=4',D$54@*$>%*$%#$*R'5&%D$*D=#$#*(#*d%--*(#*D=#$*=<*<(5-,&%S)*$5"%*&%?,5&%'*$=*=6$(54* <%%'6(DQ*(4'*$>%*("=,4$*=<* 54<=&"($5=4* -%(&4%'*<&="*$>%*$%#$*

Page 66: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* ``*

RO>="Q%)* /00/SC* O>%* <(5-,&%#* O>="Q%* R/00/S* "%4$5=4#* #>=,-'* 4=$* 6%* D=4<,#%'* d5$>*"5#$(Q%#*"('%C*A(5-,&%#*(&%*(*4($,&(-*=,$D="%*=<*$>%*%h;%&5"%4$($5=4*;&=D%##*(4'*D(4*;&=B5'%* ,#%<,-* 54<=&"($5=4C*F5#$(Q%#* =4* $>%* =$>%&* >(4')* (&%* %h;%&5"%4$#* $>($* (&%* $==*;==&-.* '%#5@4%'* $=* .5%-'* (4.* 4%d* -%(&454@C* 3=* D=";(45%#* #>=,-'* #$&5B%* $=* '%B%-=;*;&=D%##%#*$>($*;&=B5'%*>5@>* <5'%-5$.*(#*?,5DQ-.*(4'*D>%(;-.*(#*;=##56-%C*O>%*@=(-*=<* $>%*%h;%&5"%4$#* 5#* $=*@(54*(DD,",-($5B%* -%(&454@)* %B%4* <&="* <(5-,&%#)* 6%<=&%*'5#D=B%&54@* (*B5(6-%*(-$%&4($5B%*6,#54%##*"='%-*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC* E4* -54%*d5$>*J>%#6&=,@>*R/010S*(4'* O>="Q%* R/00/S)* FD\&($>* R/010S* (&@,%#* $>($* #$&($%@5%#* (5"54@* $=* '5#D=B%&* (4'*%h;-=5$* 4%d* "='%-#* ",#$* %4@(@%* 54* #5@45<5D(4$* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4* (4'* -%(&454@C* O>5#*(;;&=(D>* 5#* D(--%'* A)2;<,*#6%A#),*4)* &($>%&* $>(4* $>%* D=4B%4$5=4(-* (4(-.$5D(-* (;;&=(D>C*O>%&%* (&%* #="%* ,4'%&-.54@* D=4#$&,D$#* 54* #,;;=&$* <=&* $>%* '5#D=B%&.* '&5B%4* (;;&=(D>C*A5&#$)* 5$*#>5<$#* $>%* <=D,#* <&="*(4* 54$%&4(-*;%&#;%D$5B%*R<=D,#54@*=4*D=&%*D=";%$%4D%#*=<*$>%* <5&"S* $=* (* "=&%* D,#$="%&_D%4$&5D* B5%d7* <=D,#54@* =4)* (4'* ('(;$54@* $=)* D>(4@54@*D,#$="%&* B(-,%#C* 3%D=4')* 6,#54%##*"='%-#* D(44=$* 6%* <,--.* (4$5D5;($%'* 54* ('B(4D%)* 6,$*",#$* 6%* -%(&4%'* =B%&* $5"%C* O>5#* %";>(#5f%#* $>%* D%4$&(-5$.* =<* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4* 54* $>%*'5#D=B%&.* (4'* '%B%-=;"%4$* =<* 4%d* 6,#54%##* "='%-#C* A54(--.)* $>%&%* 5#* (* #>5<$* <&="*#,#$(54(6-%* $=d(&'#* (* "=&%* $%";=&(&.* D=";%$5$5B%* ('B(4$(@%C* M4'%&* D>(4@54@*D=4'5$5=4#)* <5&"#*#%%Q* $=* (D>5%B%*(* $%";=&(&.*('B(4$(@%*,4$5-* D=";%$5$5=4*>(#* D(,@>$*,;)*=&* $>%*"(&Q%$*>(#*D>(4@%'C*!$* $>5#*;=54$)* <5&"#*#$(&$* $>%*>,4$* <=&*(*4%d*('B(4$(@%*RFD\&($>)*/010SC**

TFF*;$+"$)<4* *$>%*#%D=4'*#%$*=<*;&=D%##%#*"%4$5=4%'*6.*J>%#6&=,@>*R/010S*5#*$>%*D=4D%;$* $>($* 3(&(#B($>.* R/001S* D(--#* %<<%D$,($5=4)* (* $%&"* =;;=#5$%* =<* D(,#($5=4C* E4*%<<%D$,($5=4*;&=D%##%#*(D$=&#*'=*4=$*#$,'.*$>%*"(&Q%$*#=*",D>*(#**4";$%5$*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*

$"K*%"%="#$);+5"#%*FF*;$%"2%:),*4%"4A%F<;+2%<4%2*5*;$)4:%i%<<%D$,($5=4* ;&=D%##%#j% % <F% G*"42% "2%

:),*4%"4A%F<;+2%<4%2*5*;$)4:%@*$-**4%=<22)@5*%*FF*;$2%$E"$%;"4%@*%;#*"$*A%-)$E%$E"$%2*$%<F%R3(&(#B($>.)* /001)* ;C/][SC* N<<%D$,($5=4* (##,"%#* (* '.4("5D* '%D5#5=4*

%4B5&=4"%4$* 54B=-B54@* ",-$5;-%* 54$%&(D$54@* '%D5#5=4* "(Q%&#* (4'* 5#* 6(#%'* =4* <=,&*;&54D5;-%#C*A5&#$)*%<<%D$,($5=4*;&%'%$%&"54%#*>=d*",D>*-=##*5#*(<<=&'(6-%*(4'*<=D,#%#*=4*%h;%&5"%4$54@*d5$>*(#*"(4.*#$&($%@5%#*(#*;=##56-%*d5$>*$>%*@5B%4*-5"5$%'*"%(4#C*3%D=4')*%<<%D$,($5=4* %";>(#5f%#* #$&($%@5D* (--5(4D%#* &($>%&* $>(4* D=";%$5$5B%* (4(-.#%#C* O>5&')*%<<%D$,($5=4*d=,-'*6%*6%$$%&* <=&*%h;-=5$54@*D=4$54@%4D5%#*$>($*(&=#%*,4%h;%D$%'-.*=B%&*$5"%)*&($>%&*$>(4*%h;-=5$54@*;&%_%h5#$54@*Q4=d-%'@%C*A54(--.)*%<<%D$,($5=4*<=D,#%#*=4*$>%*D=4$&=--(6-%* (#;%D$#* =<* (4* ,4;&%'5D$(6-%* <,$,&%* &($>%&* $>(4* $&.54@* $=* ;&%'5D$* (4*,4D%&$(54* =4%* R3(&(#B($>.)* /001SC* N#;%D5(--.* 5";=&$(4$* 54* $>%* D=4$%h$* =<* =;%4*544=B($5=4*(4'*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)*$>%#%*;&54D5;-%#*$(Q%*54$=*(DD=,4$*D>(4@54@*D5&D,"#$(4D%#* (4'* ,4;&%'5D$(6-%* <,$,&%#C* O>5#* ;&=B5'%#* <5&"#* d5$>* (* #$(&$54@* ;=54$)*4("%-.*$>%5&*=d4*54$%--%D$,(-)*>,"(4*(4'*#=D5(-*D(;5$(-C*A&="*>%&%=4)*4%d*54<=&"($5=4*d5--* 6%D="%* (B(5-(6-%* $>($* D(4* @,5'%* $>%* <5&"* $>&=,@>* $>%* ,4;&%'5D$(6-%* <,$,&%*R3(&(#B($>.)*/001SC**

P#:"4)>"$)<4"5% 5*"A*#2E)=* * $>%* <54(-* ;&=D%##* $>($* 5#* B5$(-* <=&* D>(4@54@* $>%*6,#54%##*"='%-*5#*-%('54@*$>%*D>(4@%*54*$>%*=&@(45f($5=4)*d>5D>*6(#5D(--.*"%(4#*d>=*5#*&%#;=4#56-%* <=&* $>%* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4* RJ>%#6&=,@>)* /010SC* H4=d54@* d>%4* $=* #>5<$*&%#=,&D%#*<&="*$>%*<=&"%&*$=*$>%*-($$%&*6,#54%##*"='%-*5#*4=$*(4*%(#.*$(#Q*(4'*;=##56-.*D="%#*d5$>*D(&%%&*D=4#%?,%4D%#*<=&*$>%*&%#;=4#56-%*=4%#*54B=-B%'C*V&@(45f($5=4#*",#$*(''&%##* $>%#%* -%('%&#>5;* 5##,%#* $=* %4#,&%* %<<%D$5B%* @=B%&4(4D%* =<* 6,#54%##* "='%-*%h;%&5"%4$($5=4*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC**

Page 67: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `8*

*

GCC%#$.&!"""! !B=#%*@=!)=C+<+@.%0!1#$!$%*.7%$!$%0.@#!C*.#-.C<%0!9"ST%'BB'U'*[-%&0['$[V(T(0,%#'"-W'V&,-+,VT%#'

K=C+<+@=! ! ! ! ! !G,)2+*! b%1*! B=#%*@=! ?%0-*.C).+#! B=#%*@=!)=C+<+@=!S1#!

G*$%##%!M9X'>N!?%0.@#! C*.#-.C<%! L*+D! <.)%*1),*%! M)2%! #,DA%*0! McN! -+**%0C+#$! )+! )2%! $%0.@#!C*.#-.C<%0`!0)*,-),*%$!)+!0=#%*@=!)=C%`!.#!-21C)%*!9(I!

G#0+LL! KLiI' !*8&0'!R2&$3R' O..9$' 6"&2' 4(--&$&2%' /$#49.%0' 90&'.#))#2'4(0%$(19%(#2'."*22&80G'.#))#2'0*8&0' *4)(2(0%$*%(#2G' #$' .#))#2'6*$&"#90(23S'

J,#$="%&*#.4%&@.' ^K' <2' #$4&$' %#' .$&*%&' .90%#)&$' 0R2&$3RG' -($)0' 0"#984' 0"*$&' %"&($' 4(0%$(19%(#2G'*4)(2(0%$*%(#2' *24'6*$&"#90(23' ."*22&80G' 0(2.&' 0"*$(23' .*2' *."(&7&' *' 3$&*%&$'7#89)&' #-' *.%(7(%R' -#$' &*."' /$#49.%' *24' .#984' #1%*(2' &.#2#)(&0' #-' 0.*8&' #$'&.#2#)(&0'#-'0.#/&G'%"&$&1R'(2.$&*0(23'$&7&29&'/&$'.90%#)&$'

! ' O/&$*%(23'!R2&$3R'

<2.894&'"(3"&$'9%(8(U*%(#2'#-'-*.(8(%(&0'*24'/&$0#22&8G' 0/$&*4(23' #-' #7&$"&*4G'*47*2%*3&0'#-'.#))#2'8&*$2(23'.9$7&0G'*24'8*$3&>8#%'/9$."*0(23S'

V;%&($5=4(-*#.4%&@.' ^P'<2'#$4&$'%#'.$&*%&'#/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3RG'-($)0'0"#984'0"*$&'%"&($'-*.(8(%(&0'*24'/&$0#22&8G' 0(2.&' 0"*$(23' .*2' *."(&7&' 0%&&/&$' 8&*$2(23' .9$7&0' *24' #1%*(2'&.#2#)(&0'#-' 0.*8&'1R' (2.$&*0(23'/$#-(%' -$#)'#/&$*%(#20'1R' 8#6&$(23'#/&$*%(23'.#0%0'/&$'-($)S'

! ' <27&0%)&2%'!R2&$3R'

J"&'$&098%'#-'T#(2%'90&'#-'/8*2%G'.#))#2'$*6' )*%&$(*80' (27&2%#$(&0G' %$*20-&$' #-'=HB' -$#)' #2&' /$#49.%' %#' *2#%"&$G'.#))#2'%##8(23'*24')*."(2&$RS''

,(2*2.(*8'0R2&$3R' ^M' <2' #$4&$' %#' .$&*%&' -(2*2.(*8' 0R2&$3RG' -($)0' 0"#984' 0"*$&' %"&($' /8*2%G' $*6')*%&$(*8'(27&2%#$(&0'*24')*."(2&$RG'0(2.&'0"*$(23'.*2'*."(&7&'*'3$&*%&$'7#89)&'#-' *.%(7(%R' *24' .#984' #1%*(2' &.#2#)(&0' #-' 0.*8&' #$' &.#2#)(&0' #-' 0.#/&' 6(%"'8#6&$'(27&0%)&2%0'

'! ' F*2*3&$(*8'

!R2&$3R'F*2*3&$(*8' 0R2&$3R' (0' /#00(18&' 6"&2' *'2&6' 190(2&00' 7&2%9$&' -*.&0' 0%$*%&3(.G'#$3*2(U*%(#2*8' #$' #/&$*%(23' /$#18&)0G'6"(."' *$&' 0()(8*$' %#' /$#18&)0' %"*%' %"&')*2*3&)&2%'"*0'4&*8%'6(%"'(2'%"&'/*0%S'

F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' ^KK'<2'#$4&$'%#'.$&*%&')*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3RG'-($)0'0"#984'0"*$&'%"&($'0%$*%&3(.G'#$3*2(U*%(#2*8'#$'#/&$*%(23'/$#18&)0G'0(2.&'0"*$(23'.*2'*."(&7&'-*0%&$'0#89%(#20'%#'0()(8*$'/$#18&)0'%"*%'#%"&$')*2*3&$0'"*7&'4&*8%'6(%"'(2'%"&'/*0%S'

\.#$!1#$!T121Y1#!

KLMM' <27&0%)&2%'!R2&$3R'

k#(2%'90&'#-'&A9(/)&2%G'0"*$&4'=HB'*24'&23(2&&$(23'

,(2*2.(*8'0R2&$3R' ^L' <2' #$4&$' %#' &0%*18(0"' -(2*2.(*8' 0R2&$3RG' -($)0' 0"#984' 0"*$&' %"&($' 90&' #-'&A9(/)&2%'*24'=HB'-*.(8(%(&0G'0(2.&'%"(0' 8#6&$0'(27&0%)&2%'.#0%0'*24'(2.$&*0&0'%"&'$&%9$2'#2'(27&0%)&2%S'

! ' !*8&0'!R2&$3R' N#))#2' 4(0%$(19%(#2' ."*22&80G'.#))#2')*$+&%'0&3)&2%0'

N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' ^D'<2'#$4&$'%#'&0%*18(0"'.90%#)&$'0R2&$3RG' -($)0'0"#984'0"*$&'%"&($'4(0%$(19%(#2'."*22&80' &2' )*$+&%' 0&3)&2%0G' 0(2.&' %"(0' .#984' (2.$&*0&' 0*8&0' 3$#6%"' 1R'8#6&$(23'%"&'.#0%0'#-'0*8&0'

! ' O/&$*%(23'!R2&$3R'

!"*$&4' -*.(8(%(&0' *24' /&$0#22&8G' 0"*$&4'#7&$"&*4G'0"*$&4'/9$."*0(23'

O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' !()(8*$'%#'#/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R'#-'C20#--':KLiI;'!()(8*$'%#'/$(2.(/8&'^P'

!! '' F*2*3&)&2%'!R2&$3R'

=(0+' $&49.%(#2G'0"*$&4' $&0#9$.&0G' *1(8(%R'%#'3&2&$*%&'1&%%&$'0%$*%&3(&0'

F(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@.' ^KD' <2' #$4&$' %#'&0%*18(0"')*2*3&)&2%' 0R2&$3RG' -($)0' 0"#984' 0"*$&' $&0#9$.&0G'0(2.&' %"(0' .#984' $&098%' (2' %"&' *1(8(%R' %#' 3&2&$*%&' 1&%%&$' 0%$*%&3(&0' %"*%' 3$&*%8R'*--&.%'#%"&$'0R2&$3R'%R/&0S'

Page 68: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `9*

:21))%*Y%%! KLMi' ,(2*2.(*8'!R2&$3R'

<2%&$2*8' .*/(%*8' )*2*3&)&2%W' .$&*%&'0R2&$3R' %"$#93"' &--&.%(7&' )*2*3&)&2%'#-'(2%&$2*8'.*/(%*8'*24'8*1#9$')*$+&%0'

A54(4D5(-*#.4%&@.* n10* E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* <54(4D5(-* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* (--=D($%* D(;5$(-*("=4@* 5$#* g=54$* #$&,D$,&%* #54D%* $>5#* D(;5$(-* "(&Q%$* 5#* "=&%* %<<%D$5B%* (4'*%<<5D5%4$*$>(4*5<*%(D>*(,$=4="=,#*<5&"*d%&%*(4*54'%;%4'%4$*=d4%'*<5&"*

! ' N#8890(7&'!R2&$3R'

N8*00' #-' 0.*$.&' $&0#9$.&0' 8&*4(23' %#')*$+&%'0&3)&2%'/#6&$'

J,#$="%&*#.4%&@.** !()(8*$'%#'.90%#)&$'0R2&$3R'#-'](24'*24'F*"*T*2':KLMM;G''!()(8*$'%#'/$(2.(/8&'^D*

! ' O/&$*%(#2*8'!R2&$3R'

' V;%&($5=4(-*#.4%&@.* 35"5-(&*$=*=;%&($5=4(-*#.4%&@.*=<*!4#=<*R1:`[Se*^54'*(4'*F(>(g(4*R1:99S*35"5-(&*$=*;&54D5;-%*n]*

4%*01,$! DEEI' !%$*%&3(.'!R2&$3R'

J"&' &@%&2%' %#' 6"(."' .#88*1#$*%(#20'$&098%' (2' *2' (2.$&*0&' (2' %"&($'/*$%(.(/*%(#2' (2' *' 8*$3&$' 29)1&$' #-'.#)/8&@'#$'9/0%$&*)'/$#T&.%0'

F(4(@%&5(-*#.4%&@.' ^Ke' <2' #$4&$' %#' &0%*18(0"' )*2*3&$(*8' 0R2&$3RG' -($)0' 0"#984' .##$4(2*%&'+2#68&43&'-8#60'*24')*$+&%(23'*24'%&."2#8#3(.*8'&@/&$%(0&'*)#23'-($)0G'0(2.&'%"(0' .#984' $&49.&' .#0%0' *24' ()/$#7&' (22#7*%(7&' (2%&$*.%(#20' *)#23' 4(0/&$0&4'-($)0S'

! ' F*2*3&$(*8'*24'O/&$*%(#2*8'!R2&$3R'

J"&'&@%&2%'%#'6"(."'%"&'&--(.(&2.R'#-'%"&'92(% ' )*2*3&$(*8' *24' #/&$*%(#2*8'$&0#9$.&0' *$&' &2"*2.&4' *0' *'.#20&A9&2.&' #-'6#$+(23' .#88*1#$*%(7&8R'6(%"'#%"&$'92(%0S'

F(4(@%&5(-*#.4%&@.' ^KP'<2'#$4&$'%#'&0%*18(0"')*2*3&$(*8'0R2&$3RG'-($)0'0"#984'0%$9.%9$&'%"&'.#2%&@%'6"&$&' %"&' /$#.&49$&0' -#$' .#88*1#$*%(#2' *24' $&/#$%(23'*$&' .8&*$8R' 4&-(2&4' *24'.#))92(.*%&4G' 0(2.&' %"(0' )(2()(U&0' .#2-8(.%0' *24' )*+&0' -($)0' )#$&'.#)-#$%*18&'0"*$(23'+2#68&43&G'$&0#9$.&0'*24'/&$0#22&8S''

! ' h2#68&43&'F*2*3&)&2%'!R2&$3R'

J"&' *1(8(%R' %#' "*$2&00' *24' 8&7&$*3&'+2#68&43&G' (4&*0G' /&#/8&G' %&."2#8#3RG'*24' #$3*2(U*%(#2*8' .#)/&%&2.(&0' *24'0R0%&)0' -#$' %"&' .$&*%(#2' #-' 2&6G')#$&'09..&00-98'(22#7*%(#20'

H4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@5%#'

^Ki' <2' #$4&$' %#' &0%*18(0"' +2#68&43&' )*2*3&)&2%' 0R2&$3RG' -($)0' 0"#984'8&7&$*3&'+2#68&43&G'(4&*0G'/&#/8&G'%&."2#8#3R'*24'#$3*2(U*%(#2*8'.#)/&%&2.&0G'0(2.&'%"(0'.#984'.#2%$(19%&'%#'%"&'.$&*%(#2'#-'2&6G')#$&'09..&00-98'(22#7*%(#2'

!! '' <22#7*%(7&'X$#-(.(&2.R'

J"&' *1(8(%R' %#' 4&7&8#/' *24' &@/8#(%' 2&6'*24' 09..&00-98' (22#7*%(#20' A9(.+8R' *24'.#0%>&--&.%(7&8R' 1R' -$&A9&2%'.#))92(.*%(#2'

A5&"*#.4%&@.' ^KM' <2' #$4&$' %#' &0%*18(0"' -($)' 0R2&$3RG' -($)0' 0"#984' .#))92(.*%&' -$&A9&2%8RG'0(2.&' %"(0' ()/$#7&0' %"&' *1(8(%R' %#' 4&7&8#/' *24' &@/8#(%' 2&6' *24' 09..&00-98'(22#7*%(#20'A9(.+8R'*24'.#0%>&--&.%(7&8R'

V1C<1#!1#$!Z+*)+#!

DEEi' ,(2*2.(*8'!R2&$3R'

KS' <2%&$2*8' .*/(%*8' )*2*3&)&2%W' .$&*%&'0R2&$3R' %"$#93"' &--&.%(7&' )*2*3&)&2%'#-'(2%&$2*8'.*/(%*8'*24'8*1#9$')*$+&%0'

A54(4D5(-*#.4%&@.* 35"5-(&*$=*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@.*=<*J>($$%&g%%*R1:9`S*35"5-(&*$=*;&54D5;-%*n10*

! ' N90%#)&$'!R2&$3R'

KS' N$#00>0&88(23W' .$&*%&' 7*89&' 1R' .$#00>0&88(23' *' 1$#*4' $*23&' #-' /$#49.%0' *24'0&$7(.&0'-$#)'0&7&$*8'190(2&00'92(%0'

N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' !()(8*$'%#'.90%#)&$'0R2&$3R'#-'C20#--G'KLiIY'](24'*24'F*"*T*2':KLMM;'!()(8*$'%#'/$(2.(/8&'^D'

! ' ' DS' N#))#2'7*89&' /$#/#0(%(#2W' .$&*%&' *'.#20(0%&2%' 19R(23' &@/&$(&2.&G'.#2-#$)(23' %#' .#$/#$*%&' 0%*24*$40' 7(*'0%*24*$4(U*%(#2'

N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R* n2* E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* D,#$="%&* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* #$&5B%* <=&*#$(4'(&'5f($5=4*#54D%*$>5#*D=4$&56,$%#*$=*(*D=4#5#$%4$*D,#$="%&*%h;%&5%4D%)*d>5D>*&%54<=&D%#*(4'*%4>(4D%#*$>%*D=&;=&($%*6&(4'*

! ' <2%&$2*8'!R2&$3R'

KS' !"*$&4' 0&$7(.&0W' .$&*%&'&.#2#)(&0'#-'0.*8&' 1R' 0"*$(23' %"&' 0R0%&)0G' -*.(8(%(&0'*24'/&$0#2*8'09//#$%'

V;%&($5=4(-*#.4%&@.* n[*E4*=&'%&*$=*%#$(6-5#>*=;%&($5=4(-*#.4%&@.)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*%h("54%*D=""=4*;&=D%##%#*<=&*%D=4="5%#*=<*#D(-%)*#54D%*$>5#*%4>(4D%#*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%*(4'*#>(&%>=-'%&*B(-,%*

Page 69: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* `:*

! ' ' DS'b*89&>."*(2' (2%&3$*%(#2W' .$&*%&' 7*89&'1R' (2%&3$*%(23' .#2%(39#90' /$#.&00&0' (2'%"&'(2490%$R'7*89&'."*(2'

O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' !()(8*$' %#' #/&$*%(#2*8' 0R2&$3R' #-' C20#--' :KLiI;Y' ](24' *24' F*"*T*2' :KLMM;Y'N"*%%&$T&&G'KLMi'!()(8*$'%#'/$(2.(/8&'^P'

!! '' 5&*$2(23'*24'V$#6%"'!R2&$3R'

<2%*23(18&' *00&%0W' 0"*$&' .#)/&%&2.R' (2'%"&'4&7&8#/)&2%'#-'"9)*2G'(2-#$)*%(#2'*24'#$3*2(U*%(#2*8'.*/(%*8'

h2#68&43&')*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R*

n18* E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'*'%B%-=;* (4'* #>(&%* 54$(4@56-%* &%#=,&D%#)* #54D%* $>%#%* &%#=,&D%#* ;&%#%4$* (4*=;;=&$,45$.*$=*D&%($%*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%C*

V#+<<! DEEM' ,(2*2.(*8'!R2&$3R'

!()(8*$'%#'h*/8*2'*24'c#$%#2':DEEi;' ,(2*2.(*8'0R2&$3R' 35"5-(&*$=*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@.*=<*J>($$%&g%%*R1:9`Se*H(;-(4*(4'*W=&$=4*R/00`S*35"5-(&*$=*;&54D5;-%*n10'

! ' F*$+&%'X#6&$'!R2&$3(&0'

!()(8*$'%#'h*/8*2'*24'c#$%#2':DEEi;' N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' !()(8*$' %#' .90%#)&$' 0R2&$3R' #-'](24' *24'F*"*T*2' :KLMM;Y' h*/8*2' *24'c#$%#2':DEEi;S'!()(8*$'%#'/$(2.(/8&'^D'

! ' O/&$*%(7&'!R2&$3(&0'>'3$#6%"'

<2.$&*0&4' $&7&29&0G' .#)1(2*%(#2' #-'.#)/8&)&2%*$R' $&0#9$.&0' *.$#00'190(2&00&0'

O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' '3$#6%"'0R2&$3R*

n`* E4* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* @&=d$>* #.4%&@.)* <5&"#* #>=,-'* D="654%*D=";-%"%4$(&.* &%#=,&D%#* (D&=##* <5&"#)* #54D%* $>5#* D=,-'* ;&=B5'%* ,45?,%*D,#$="%&*B(-,%*(4'*D(;$,&%*"(&Q%$*=;;=&$,45$5%#C*

! ' O/&$*%(7&'0R2&$3(&0'>'&--(.(&2.R'

O/&$*%(#2*8' &--(.(&2.RG' .#0%' 091>*44(%(7(%(&0'

O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' '&--(.(&2.R'0R2&$3R*

n8*E4*=&'%&*$=*%#$(6-5#>*%<<5D5%4D.*#.4%&@.)*<5&"#*#>=,-'*#>(&%*&%#=,&D%#*54*$>%* ;&=',D$5=4* =<*",-$5;-%* =,$;,$#* (D&=##* <5&"#)* #54D%* $>5#* -%('#* $=* -=d%&*g=54$*D=#$#*6.*;,$$54@*,4'%&,$5-5f%'*&%#=,&D%#*$=*;&=',D$5B%*,#%C*

! ' N#$/#$*%&'F*2*3&)&2%'!R2&$3(&0'

?2%$&/$&2&9$(*8' .*/*1(8(%(&0G' 09/&$(#$'0%$*%&3(.'.*/*1(8(%(&0''

F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' ^KI'<2'#$4&$'%#')*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3RG'.#$/#$*%&')*2*3&$0'0"#984'4(0*33$&3*%&'%"&'#1T&.%(7&0'#-'0R2&$3R'(2(%(*%(7&0G'0(2.&'.8*$(-R(23'%"&'#1T&.%(7&0'.#2%$(19%&0'%#'%"&' &7*89*%(#2' #-' .#0%0' *24' 1&2&-(%0G' *24' %#' %"&' .$&*%(#2' #-' .#2.$&%&'()/8&)&2%*%(#2'/8*20S'

\,!1#$!:2+.!!

DEEP' c#'%R/#8#3R'/$#7(4&4G'3&2&$*8'0R2&$3(&0S'

' A5&"*#.4%&@.' ^KL'<2'#$4&$'%#'&0%*18(0"' -($)'0R2&$3(&0G' -($)0'0"#984' (27&0%' (2'0%$#23'%(&0'6(%"'3#7&$2)&2%' #--(.&0' *24' :-(2*2.(*8;' (20%(%9%(#20G' 0(2.&' %"(0' /$#7(4&0' *..&00' %#'7*89*18&' (2-#$)*%(#2'*24'1&2&-(%0'%"*%'.*2'/9%' %"&' -($)' (2'*'1&%%&$'/#0(%(#2' %#'.##/&$*%&')#$&'&--(.(&2%8R'6(%"'(%0'190(2&00'/*$%2&$0S'

! ' c#'%R/#8#3R'/$#7(4&4G'3&2&$*8'0R2&$3(&0'

' ,($)'0R2&$3R' ^DE'<2'#$4&$'%#'&0%*18(0"' -($)'0R2&$3(&0G' -($)0'0"#984'&23*3&' (2'8#23'%&$)G'#2>3#(23' 190(2&00' (2%&$*.%(#20' 6(%"' &*."' #%"&$G' 0(2.&' %"(0' &2*18&0' 1#%"' -($)0' %#'&0%*18(0"' *2' &--&.%(7&' 6#$+' $#9%(2&' -#$' %"&' &@."*23&' #-' (2-#$)*%(#2' *24'+2#68&43&S'

B1#$,<<!_!:2%0A*+,@2!

DEEL' c#'%R/#8#3R' ' ,($)'0R2&$3R' ^DK' <2' #$4&$' %#' &0%*18(0"' -($)'0R2&$3(&0G' -($)0' 0"#984' &23*3&'6(%"' .#))(%%&4'

0%$*%&3RG' 0(2.&' %"(0' 6(88' (2.$&*0&' %"&' *10#$/%(7&' .*/*.(%R' #-' %"&' -($)' 0#' %"*%'$&0#9$.&0'6(%"'*44&4'7*89&'.*2'1&'(4&2%(-(&4G'(2%&3$*%&4'6(%"'(2%&$2*8'$&0#9$.&0'*24'&@/8#(%&4'

?12<1#$%*!_!^1##!

DEKE' c#'%R/#8#3R' ' ,($)'0R2&$3R' <2'#$4&$'%#'.$&*%&'-($)'0R2&$3RG'-($)0')90%'#/&2'%"&($'190(2&00')#4&80'%#'#%"&$'/*$%(&0G' 0(2.&' 1R' .#)1(2(23' #62' /$#.&00&0' 6(%"' &@%&$2*88R' *7*(8*18&' (4&*0G'*7*(8*18&'$&0#9$.&0'1&.#)&'+&R'.#)/#2&2%0'(2'%"&'190(2&00')#4&8'*24'/*%"0'%#')*$+&%'1&.#)&'0"#$%&$'

Page 70: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 80*

GCC%#$.&!"S! !B=#%*@=!A.10%0!MA10%$!+#!^++<$!1#$!:1DCA%<<`!'ddeN!*&.% O64*#:6% @)"2* * $>5#* 65(#* &%<%&#* $=* $>%* =B%&%#$5"($5=4* =<* #.4%&@.* (4'* $>%*,4'%&%#$5"($5=4*=<*D=#$#*54B=-B%'C*O>%#%*%#$5"($5=4#*&5#%*<&="*$>%*<%%-54@*=<*%h%D,$5B%#*d5$>54*<5&"#*$>($*$>%.*<+:E$%$=*6%*D&%($54@*#.4%&@.C*E4*$>%5&*#%(&D>*<=&*#.4%&@.)*;%&>(;#*

#.4%&@.*6%D="%#*$=;*;&5=&5$.*(4'*'5#$&(D$#*($$%4$5=4*<&="*D=&%*$(#Q#C**0.% !"#*4$)4:% @)"2% * $>5#* 65(#* &%<%&#* $=* (* 6%-5%<* $>($* #.4%&@.* D(4* =4-.* 6%* D&%($%'* 6.*

,45$#*$=*D==;%&($%)*%B%4*5<*$>%*,45$#*(&%*>%#5$(4$*<=&*@=='*&%(#=4#C*O>%*;(&%4$*D=4D-,'%#*_54B%4$%'_

.*T=d%B%&)*(#*\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--*;=54$*=,$)*$>5#*(##,";$5=4*5#*d&=4@C*X,#54%##*,45$#*"(4(@%&#*>(B%*%B%&.*&%(#=4*$=*<=&@%*-54Q#*d5$>*=$>%&*,45$#*$=*"(Q%*$>%5&*=d4* ,45$*"=&%* #,DD%##<,-C* E4* <(D$)* $>%.* &%@,-(&-.* $%("* ,;* d5$>* =,$#5'%* =&@(45f($5=4e*#,;;-5%&#)*D,#$="%&#)*g=54$*B%4$,&%#)*(4'*%B%4*'5&%D$*D=";%$5$=&#*5<*5$*5#*54*$>%5&*54$%&%#$C*E4'%%')* \==-'* (4'* J544=B($5=4*(4'*#%%*54*$>5#*B(-,(6-%*=;;=&$,45$5%#*(#*6,#54%##*,45$#*$%("*,;*$=*6%D="%*"=&%* #,DD%##<,-C*T=d%B%&)* $>5#* (&$5D-%* 5#*d&5$$%4* <5B%*.%(&#*%(&-5%&*(4'* $>%&%<=&%*'=%#*4=$*54D-,'%*$>%*$%&"54=-=@.*(#*54$&=',D%'*6.*J>%#6&=,@>*R/002SC***8.% OK)552% @)"2* * <&%?,%4$-.* (DD=";(4.54@* $>%* ;(&%4$54@* 65(#)* $>%* #Q5--#* 65(#* 5#* $>%*(##,";$5=4*$>($*d>($%B%&*Q4=d_>=d*5#*&%?,5&%'*$=*(D>5%B%*#.4%&@.)*5#*(B(5-(6-%*d5$>54*$>%*<5&"C*I(&%4$#*$>($*<=&D%*D==;%&($5=4*6%$d%%4*,45$#)*(##,"%*(--*#Q5--#*(4'*Q4=d-%'@%*(&%* (B(5-(6-%* d5$>54* $>%* <5&"C* !* -(DQ* =<* $>%* &5@>$* #Q5--#* D(4* <($(--.* ,4'%&"54%* $>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*=<* (4.*#.4%&@.* 545$5($5B%C*F=&%=B%&)* -%(&454@*4%d*#Q5--#* 5#*4=$* %(#.C* E<*

)$%G"6%@*%@2+;;*22F+556% )G=5*G*4$*A

_5$_ **C.%c=2)A*%@)"2% %#.4%&@5%#*=<$%4*D="%*d5$>*,4<=&%#%%4*D=4#%?,%4D%#)*%5$>%&*6%4%<5D5(-*=&*

>(&'*=4*$>%*;=$%4$5(-*6%4%<5$#*=<*#.4%&@.)*$>($*$>%.*=B%&-==Q*$>%*'=d4#5'%C**

Page 71: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 81*

GCC%#$.&!S! !:"TE!<[email protected]!9"ST%'BE'U'C.!:'T(0,+'W%),-%W'QS"#%W'(-'3%-[%&'%$'"T6Y'EOOPY'V6'7MDR'

! :+DC+#%#)! R&C<1#1).+#!:! N#2%&@%'

3$0.*,( 0130( #&"85%&$%(4%13=#.5*38( $13&+%?( @1%'( #&$857%( "%305*%,( ,5$1( 3,( 3+%<( %A9%*#%&$%<($.69%0%&$'<( .*+3&#B30#.&38( 9.8#0#$,( 3&7( 9./%*<( 01%( &305*%( ."( 01%( 0%$1&#$38( ,',0%6<(.*+3&#B30#.&38( ,034#8#0'<( 5&$%*03#&0'( 3&7( ,',0%6( #&0%*7%9%&7%&$#%,?( C&0%*=%&0#.&,( 3*%(38/3',( %64%77%7( #&( 3( ,.$#38( ,',0%6(3&7<( 3,( &.0%7( 4'( D3/,.&(3&7( @#88%'( 2EFFG:<( /#88( 4%(3""%$0%7(4'(30( 8%3,0(".5*($.&0%A0538( 83'%*,>( 01%( #&7#=#7538<( 01%( #&0%*9%*,.&38( *%830#.&,1#9,<(

(

"!! <2%&$7&2%(#2'8%37%*,1#9( ,0'8%<( 983&&#&+( 3&7( $.&0*.8( ,',0%6,<( 0*3#&#&+<( 9%*".*63&$%(63&3+%6%&0?( C0( #,(#69.*03&0(0.(&.0%(0130(#0(#,(&%$%,,3*'(0.(%A36#&%(&.0(H5,0(01%(&305*%(."(01%(#&0%*=%&0#.&(450(38,.(1./(#0(#,(#698%6%&0%7?(I5*01%*6.*%<(#&0%*=%&0#.&,($3**'(/#01(01%6(1'9.01%,%,<(/1#$1(

( /#88( 8%37( 0.( 1#+1%*(/.*;%*((

T! F&."*2(0)'%69./%*6%&0( .""%*,( %698.'%%,( 01%( 6%3&,( 0.( $.&0*#450%( 0.( ,.6%( 3$0#=#0'( 4%'.&7( 01%#*(&.*638(03,;,(.*(.50,#7%(01%#*(&.*638(,91%*%(."(#&0%*%,0<(/1#$1(01%&(9*.690,(93*0#$#930#.&(3&7( *%,9.&,#4#8#0'<( .""%*#&+( 01%( 9.0%&0#38( ."( 8.&+J0%*6( 4%&%"#0,( 0.( 01%6( 3&7K.*( 0.( 01%#*(

(

E! O9%.#)&' *.=%6%&0<((

*

Page 72: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 8/*

GCC%#$.&!S"! !6.)%*1),*%!0%1*-2!0)*1)%@=!O>5#* (;;%4'5h* '%#D&56%#* $>%* ,#%'* #%(&D>* #$&($%@.* ,#%'* $=* <54'* (* ;,&;=#5B%* #(";-%* =<*(D('%"5D* -5$%&($,&%* $>($* 5#* &%-%B(4$* <=&* $>%*'%#D&5;$5=4*=<* $>%* D=4D%;$#*(4'*(4#d%&54@*$>%*&%#%(&D>*?,%#$5=4*;=#%'C*3%B%&(-*#%(&D>*#$&54@#*>(#*6%%4*,#%'*$=* <54'*$>%*&%-%B(4$*

*#%(&D>* #$&54@#* (&%* %4$%&%'* 54* #%B%&(-* (D('%"5D* &%#%(&D>* %4@54%#* R\==@-%* 3D>=-(&)*!XEb54<=&")* 3D5%4D%K5&%D$)* ^5-%.* (4'* +3OVGS* ',&54@* $>%* d&5$54@* =<* $>%* $>%#5#*

* >(#*6%%4*%#$(6-5#>%'*6.*&%('54@*5$#*$5$-%*(4'*(6#$&(D$C*^>%4*$>%*D=4$%4$*=<*$>%*(&$5D-%*-==Q%'*;&="5#54@*=&*%B%4*'5&%D$-.*&%-%B(4$)*$>%*(&$5D-%*d(#*#D(44%'*=&*&%(')*&%#;%D$5B%-.C*^>5-%*&%('54@*(&$5D-%#)*$>%*#D=;%*%h;(4'%'*d5$>*&%-%B(4$*&%<%&%4D%#*<=,4'*54*D(4*$>,#*6%*,#%'*54*$>5#*$>%#5#)*d5$>=,$*6%54@*<=,4'*B5(*,#54@*$>%*#%(&D>*#$&54@#C*^>5-%*;%&<=&"54@*$>%*-5$%&($,&%*&%B5%d)*4%d*#%(&D>*#$&54@#*d%&%*'%B%-=;%')*#54D%*<=&$,4($%-.)*4%d* 54#5@>$#* >(B%* 6%%4* @(54%'* ',&54@* $>%* d&5$54@* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#C* 3=)* $>%* ;&=D%##* =<*d&5$54@* $>%* $>%#5#* D(4* 6%* #%%4* (#* (4* 5$%&($5B%* ;&=D%##* "=&%* $>(4* (* -54%(&* ;&=D%##*D=4#5#$54@* =<* (* -5$%&($,&%* #%(&D>* (4'* (* #,""(&.* ;&%#%4$%'* =<* $>%* <54'54@#C* !* <54(-*&%"(&Q*=4*$>%*#%(&D>*#$&($%@.*5#*$>%*<(D$*$>($*4=$*(--*-5$%&($,&%*5#*<=,4'*,#54@*$>5#*#%(&D>*#$&($%@.e* #="%* (&$5D-%#* (&%* ;&=B5'%'* 6.* $>%* #,;%&B5#=&* =<* $>5#* #$,'.)* =&* <=,4'* B5(* $>%*Q4=d-%'@%* 6(#%* =<* $>%* EONF_@&=,;* RE44=B($5=4)* O%D>4=-=@.)* N4$&%;&%4%,&#>5;* (4'*F(&Q%$54@S* =<* $>%* E4',#$&5(-* N4@54%%&54@* (4'* E44=B($5=4* 3D5%4D%#* <(D,-$.* ($* $>%*N54'>=B%4*M45B%&#5$.*=<*O%D>[email protected]**O>%*-5$%&($,&%*,#%'*54*$>5#*$>%#5#*>(#*6%%4*%B(-,($%'*(DD=&'54@*$=*$>&%%*D&5$%&5(7**

D)G*2%;)$*A* *O>%*(&$5D-%*#>=,-'*6%*D5$%'*54*-5$%&($,&%*('%?,($%-.C*E<*(4*(&$5D-%*5#*D5$%'*"(4.* $5"%#)* 6,$* '=%#* 4=$* "%%$* $>%* 4%h$* D&5$%&5()* $>%* (&$5D-%* 5#* #$5--* D=4#5'%&%'* =<* (4*(;;&=;&5($%*#$(4'(&')*#54D%*5$*5#*&%D=@45f%'*6.*;%%&#*54*$>%*<5%-'*(#*(4*5";=&$(4$*(&$5D-%*d5$>*&%-%B(4$*$>%=&.*$=*D5$%C*

O<+#;** *V<*D=,&#%)*$>%*=-'%&*$>%*(&$5D-%*5#)*$>%*>5@>%&*$>%*D>(4D%#*=<*D5$($5=4*6%D="%C*O=*(B=5'*'%#%-%D$54@*&%D%4$*(&$5D-%#*=<*>5@>*?,(-5$.*#=-%-.*=4*(*-=d*4,"6%&*=<*D5$($5=4#)*$>%*#%D=4'*D&5$%&5(* *#=,&D%*=<*;,6-5D($5=4* *5#*$(Q%4*54$=*(DD=,4$C*!--*#=,&D%#*#>=,-'*6%*#D>=-(&-.* g=,&4(-#* (4'* #>=,-'* (;;%(&* 54* $>%* ]8$>* T(&f54@* +=,&4(-* U,(-5$.* Z5#$*RT(&f54@CD=")*/01/SC*O>5#*-5#$*5#*;,6-5#>%'*$=*$(&@%$*;(;%&#*($*g=,&4(-#*=<*(4*(;;&=;&5($%*#$(4'(&'C*F=&%*;&%D5#%-.)*$>%*-5#$*5#*(*D=--%D$5=4*=<*",-$5;-%*d=&-'d5'%*g=,&4(-*&(4Q54@#C*A&="*$>5#*-5#$)*$>%*$d=*"=#$*&%D%4$*&(4Q54@#*R6=$>*/01/S*>(B%*6%%4*,#%'C*V-'%&*&(4Q54@#*D=,-'*6%*=,$_'($%')*#54D%*$>%*?,(-5$.*=<*g=,&4(-#*D=,-'*>(B%*5";&=B%'*=&*'%D&%(#%'*=B%&*$>%* .%(&#C* O>%&%<=&%)* $>%* (&$5D-%#* ,#%'* 54* $>5#* -5$%&($,&%* &%B5%d* #>=,-'* (;;%(&* =4* $>%*g=,&4(-*&(4Q54@#*=<*%5$>%&*$>%*J&(4<5%-'*M45B%&#5$.*3D>==-*=<*F(4(@%"%4$*RJ&(S*=&* $>%*N&(#",#* G%#%(&D>* E4#$5$,$%* =<* F(4(@%"%4$* +=,&4(-#* Z5#$54@* RN+ZSC* V<* D=,&#%)* (--*&(4Q54@#* D=,-'* >(B%* 6%%4* $(Q%4* 54$=* (DD=,4$C* T=d%B%&)* $>5#* d=,-'* -56%&(-5f%* $>%*%B(-,($5=4*D&5$%&5(*(4'*;=##56-.*d=,-'*'%D&%(#%*$>%*?,(-5$.*=<*$>%*-5$%&($,&%*#$,'.C*!+#=<2** * $>%*(&$5D-%*#>=,-'*'%B%-=;*$>%=&.)*D=4#5#$*=<*(*&%B5%d*=&*D=4',D$#*%";5&5D(-*54B%#$5@($5=4***M#%'*(&$5D-%#*#>=,-'*"%%$*%5$>%&*(*D="654($5=4*=<*D&5$%&5(*1*P*2*=&*/*P*2*<=&*$>%*(6=B%_"%4$5=4%'* &%(#=4#C* !--* (&$5D-%#* <=,4'* $>&=,@>* #4=d6(--54@)* (&%* D=4#5'%&%'* =<* (4*(;;&=;&5($%* ?,(-5$.* #54D%* $>%#%* (&%* "%4$5=4%'* 54* (4* (&$5D-%* $>($* "%$* $>%* 54D-,#5=4*D&5$%&5(C*

Page 73: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 82*

GCC%#$.&!S""! !:+$.#@!0-2%D%!

!

Page 74: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 8]*

GCC%#$.&!S"""! !J,0.#%00!D+$%<!-1#710!+L!:>X!4*+Y%-)!J,*%1,!O>5#*(;;%4'5h*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C***

Page 75: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 8[*

GCC%#$.&!"f! !?%0.@#!4*.#-.C<%0!1#$!A,.<$.#@!A<+-Q0WC1*1D%)%*0!1**1#@%$!A=!0=#%*@=!)=C%!9"ST%'B7'U'3%#,0-'V&,-+,VT%#'"-W'V"&"1%$%&#' 'CZ#$(1%&'#[-%&0['

?%0.@#!4*.#-.C<%0!!

JT!-+DC+#%#)WC1*1D%)%*!M%&C<1#1).+#W$%L.#.).+#N!!

B=#%*@=!-*%1).+#!!M^++<$!1#$!:1DCA%<<`!'ddeN!

B=#%*@=!-*%1)%$! J10%$!+#!!

c'! L13&&%8,':4&0.$(1&'"#6'7*89&'/$#/#0(%(#2'(0'4&8(7&$&4;' !"*$&4'$&0#9$.&0' N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' C20#--':KLiI;'c9! L13&&%8,(3&7($5,0.6%*(,%+6%&0,(

:-#$'6"#)'%#'.$&*%&'*24'4&8(7&$'7*89&;'!"*$&4'$&0#9$.&0d'!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6'

N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' ](24'H'F*"*T*2':KLMM;G'N"*%%&$T&&':KLMi;G''h*/8*2'*24'c#$%#2':DEEi;'H'h2#88G'DEEM'

c>! M385%(9*.9.,#0#.&':.$&*%&'*'.#20(0%&2%'19R(23'&@/&$(&2.&'.#2-#$)(23'.#$/#$*%&'0%*24*$40;'

N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2''

N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' h*/8*2'*24'c#$%#2':DEEi;'

S"""! N%'(93*0&%*,1#90G'=385%(9*.9.,#0#.&<':/*$%2&$0'%"*%')*+&'%"&'190(2&00')#4&8'6#$+Y'(S&S'%"&R'-(%'%"&'.98%9$&;'

N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0' N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' \$920G'<23&%&*)'?2&$3R'H'h938&$>]#)*+#'

"f! M385%(9*.9.,#0#.&':/$#49.%0'#$'0&$7(.&'%"*%'.$&*%&'7*89&'-#$'.90%#)&$')90%'1&'4&-(2&4'1R'*2*8R0(0'#-'1#%"'-($)0;'

N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2' N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' X"(8(/0'

f! O88($.69.&%&0,':-#.90'#2'*)1(4&@%&$(%RW'.#)1(2&'#84'*24'2&6'190(2&00')#4&8G'.#20(0%(23'#-'*88'.#)/#2&2%0;'

N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0d'.#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2'

N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' ,?<'

f"! M385%(9*.9.,#0#.&':/$#49.%0'#$'0&$7(.&'%"*%'.$&*%&'7*89&'-#$'.90%#)&$')90%'1&'4&-(2&4'1R'*2*8R0(0'#-'1#%"'-($)0;'

N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0d'.#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2'

N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' b*2'V*20&6(2+&8'

f""! O88($.69.&%&0,':#7&$.#)&'(2%&$/$&%*%(#2'4(--&$&2.&0'1R')*//(23'%"&'190(2&00')#4&8'.#)/#2&2%0'(2'*'.*27*0;'

N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0d'.#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2'

N90%#)&$'0R2&$3R' ,$&2#0'<$92*'

9"ST%'BL'U'3%#,0-'V&,-+,VT%#'"-W'V"&"1%$%&#' ':V%&"$,(-"T'#[-%&0['

?%0.@#!C*.#-.C<%0!!

JT!:+DC+#%#)WC1*1D%)%*!M%&C<1#1).+#W$%L.#.).+#N!

B=#%*@=!-*%1).+#!!M^++<$!1#$!:1DCA%<<`!'ddeN!

B=#%*@=!:*%1)%$! J10%$!+#!!

I! N%'(*%,.5*$%,':/"R0(.*8G'-(2*2.(*8G'(2%&88&.%9*8'#$'"9)*2'*00&%0'$&A9($&4;'

!"*$&4':%*23(18&;'$&0#9$.&0' O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' C20#--':KLiI;G'](24'H'F*"*T*2':KLMM;G'N"*%%&$T&&':KLMi;'h*/8*24'H'c#$%#2:DEEi;'

O! N%'(*%,.5*$%,<(;%'(3$0#=#0#%,':*00&%0d*.%(7(%(&0'$&A9($&4;' N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'!"*$&4':%*23(18&;'$&0#9$.&0'

O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' h*/8*2'*24'c#$%#2':DEEi;'

P! N%'(*%,.5*$%,<(=385%(9*.9.,#0#.&(:.#)1(2*%(#2'#-'*00&%0'$&A9($&4'%#'.$&*%&'7*89&'-#$'%"&'.90%#)&$;'

!"*$&4':%*23(18&;'$&0#9$.&0'N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2'

O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' h2#88':DEEM;'

a! N%'(*%,.5*$%,(:*00&%0'$&A9($&4;' !"*$&4':%*23(18&;'$&0#9$.&0' O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' h2#88':DEEM;'"! N%'(93*0&%*,(:-($)0'0"#984'4&7&8#/'*'8&3*8'-$*)&6#$+'%#'

19(84'.#2-(4&2.&'1&%6&&2'/*$%2&$0;'N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2' O/&$*%(#2*8'0R2&$3R' \#0."'

**

Page 76: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 8`*

9"ST%'B?'U'3%#,0-'V&,-+,VT%#'"-W'V"&"1%$%&#' ';,-"-+,"T'#[-%&0['

?%0.@#!C*.#-.C<%0!!

JT!-+DC+#%#)W!C1*1D%)%*!M%&C<1#1).+#W$%L.#.).+#N!

B=#%*@=!-*%1).+#!M^++<$!1#$!:1DCA%<<`!'ddeN!

B=#%*@=!-*%1)%$! J10%$!+#!!

e! L.,0(,0*5$05*%':8#6&$(23'(27&0%)&2%0'.#0%0'(2.9$$&4'(2'#/&$*%(23'%"&'\F'1R'0"*$(23'/8*2%'*24'&A9(/)&2%;'

!"*$&4':%*23(18&;'$&0#9$.&0'N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'

,(2*2.(*8'0R2&$3R' C20#--':KLiI;'

d! L.,0(,0*5$05*%':8#6&$(23'(27&0%)&2%0'.#0%0'(2.9$$&4'(2'#/&$*%(23'%"&'\F'1R'0"*$(23'/8*2%'*24'&A9(/)&2%;'

!"*$&4':%*23(18&;'$&0#9$.&0'N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'

,(2*2.(*8'0R2&$3R' ](24'*24'F*"*T*2':KLMM;G'h*/8*2'*24'c#$%#2':DEEi;'

'X! P%=%&5%(,0*%36,G'.#0%'0%$9.%9$&':*88#.*%&'.*/(%*8'%#3&%"&$'%#'&209$&'$&7&29&'0%$&*)0'*24'8#6&$'.#0%0;'

N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0G'/##8&4'2&3#%(*%(#2'/#6&$'

,(2*2.(*8'0R2&$3R' N"*%%&$T&&':KLMi;G'h*/8*2'*24'c#$%#2':DEEi;G'h2#88':DEEM;'

!9"ST%'BN'U'3%#,0-'V&,-+,VT%#'"-W'V"&"1%$%&#'U'!"-"0%1%-$'#[-%&0['

?%0.@#!!4*.#-.C<%0!!

JT!-+DC+#%#)W!C1*1D%)%*!M%&C<1#1).+#W$%L.#.).+#N!

B=#%*@=!-*%1).+#!M^++<$!1#$!:1DCA%<<`!'ddeN!

B=#%*@=!-*%1)%$! J10%$!+#!!

''! N%'(3$0#=#0#%,'4#2&'1R'1#%"'-($)0;'

!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6' F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' C20#--':KLiI;'

'9! N%'(*%,.5*$%,':/"R0(.*8G'-(2*2.(*8G'(2%&88&.%9*8'#$'"9)*2'*00&%0'$&A9($&4'%#'3&2&$*%&'0%$*%&3(&0;'

!"*$&4':%*23(18&;'$&0#9$.&0'N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'

F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' ](24'*24'F*"*T*2':KLMM;'

'>! L..*7#&30%7(,0*30%+#%,':.##$4(2*%&'+2#68&43&'-8#60;' N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6'

F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' X&$0*94':DEEI;'

'I! L..*7#&30%7(,0*30%+#%,(:0%$9.%9$&4'.#2%&@%;' N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0' F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' X&$0*94':DEEI;''O! P%=%&5%(,0*%36,(:4(0*33$&3*%&'%"&'#1T&.%(7&0'(2'#$4&$'

%#'&7*89*%&'()/8&)&2%*%(#2'*24'$&7&29&'0%$&*)0;'N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0G'N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2'

F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' h2#88':DEEM;G'B*"8*24&$'*24'V*22':DEKE;'

"S!! O88($.69.&%&0,>(Q%37%*,1#9(,599.*0(:-$&0"'/&$0/&.%(7&'%"*%'(0'8&00'%(3"%'%#'&@(0%(23'190(2&00')#4&8;'

N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2' F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' \$920G'F&."*2(N#''

S! O88($.69.&%&0,>(Q%37%*,1#9(,599.*0(:-$&0"'/&$0/&.%(7&'*24'#/&2')(24&4'.98%9$&'0%()98*%&4;'

N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2' F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R' ,$&2#0'<$92*'

S"! N%'(93*0&%*,(:%#'.8&*$8R'.#))92(.*%&'#1T&.%(7&0'%#'#7&$.#)&'+2#68&43&'%$*20-&$'(009&0;(

!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6'N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'

h2#68&43&')*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R'

\#0."'

'

**

Page 77: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 88*

9"ST%'BD'U'3%#,0-'V&,-+,VT%#'"-W'V"&"1%$%&#'U'a-(^T%W0%'1"-"0%1%-$'#[-%&0['

?%0.@#!!C*.#-.C<%0!!

JT!-+DC+#%#)W!C1*1D%)%*!M%&C<1#1).+#W$%L.#.).+#N!

B=#%*@=!-*%1).+#!M^++<$!1#$!:1DCA%<<`!'ddeN!

B=#%*@=!-*%1)%$! J10%$!+#!!

'P! N%'(*%,.5*$%,':8&7&$*3&'+2#68&43&G'(4&*0G'/&#/8&G'%&."2#8#3R'*24'#$3*2(U*%(#2*8'.#)/&%&2.&0;'

!"*$&4':%*23(18&;'$&0#9$.&0'!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6'

h2#68&43&')*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R'

X&$0*94':DEEI;'

'a! N%'(*%,.5*$%,':4&7&8#/'*24'0"*$&'(2%*23(18&'$&0#9$.&0;' !"*$&4'+2#6>"#6' h2#68&43&')*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R'

h*/8*24'*24'c#$%#2':DEEi;'

""! N%'(93*0&%*,K(;%'(*%,.5*$%,KMDK$5,0.6%*(,%+6%&0,(:/*$%2&$0'%"*%')*+&'%"&'190(2&00')#4&8'6#$+Y'(S&S'%"*%'.*2'1&'%$90%&4;'

N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2' h2#68&43&')*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R'

\#4&3*0'O."#*'

"""!! N%'(93*0&%*,(:0%*$%'.&2%$*8'2&%6#$+'%"*%'.#984')*+&'%"&'#/&2'190(2&00')#4&8'6#$+'*24'*."(&7&'"(3"&$'8&7&80'#-'(22#7*%(#2;'(

N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'X##8&4'2&3#%(*%(#2'/#6&$'

h2#68&43&'F*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R'

F&."*2(N#'

S""! O88($.69.&%&0,(01*.5+1($.665&#$30#.&':0%*$%'.$#00>-92.%(#2*8'(2%&$-*.&0'%#'#7&$.#)&'c<Z'0R24$#)&;(

!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6'N##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0'

h2#68&43&')*2*3&)&2%'0R2&$3R'

F&."*2(N#'

9"ST%'BP'U'3%#,0-'V&,-+,VT%#'"-W'V"&"1%$%&#'U';,&1'#[-%&0['

?%0.@#!!C*.#-.C<%0!!

JT!-+DC+#%#)WC1*1D%)%*!M%&C<1#1).+#W$%L.#.).+#N!

B=#%*@=!-*%1).+#!M^++<$!1#$!:1DCA%<<`!'ddeN!

B=#%*@=!-*%1)%$! J10%$!+#!!

'e! L.665&#$30#.&(:()/$#7&0'%"&'*1(8(%R'%#'4&7&8#/'*24'&@/8#(%'2&6'*24'09..&00-98'(22#7*%(#20;!

N#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2'!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6'

,($)'0R2&$3R' X&$0*94':DEEI;'

'd! N%'(93*0&%*,(:(27&0%'(2'0%$#23'%(&0'6(%"'7*89*18&'+2#68&43&'%"*%'.*2')*+&'%"&'190(2&00')#4&8'6#$+;'

!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6' ,($)'0R2&$3R' ]9'*24'N"#(':DEEP;'

9X! N%'(93*0&%*,(:8#23'%&$)G'#2>3#(23'(2%&$*.%(#20'&2*18&'1#%"'-($)0'%#'&0%*18(0"'*2'&--&.%(7&'6#$+'$#9%(2&'-#$'%"&'&@."*23&'#-'(2-#$)*%(#2'*24'+2#68&43&;'

!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6' ,($)'0R2&$3R' ]9'*24'N"#(':DEEP;'

9'! N%'(93*0&%*,':&23*3&)&2%'6(%"'.#))(%%&4'*24'%$90%&4'/*$%2&$0G'6"#'.#)/8&)&2%'(2%&$2*8'$&0#9$.&0'*24'-(%'

*24'6(88')*+&'%"&'190(2&00')#4&8'6#$+;(

!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6' ,($)'0R2&$3R' !*24988('*24'N"&01$#93"':DEEL;'

99! O88($.69.&%&0,(:#/&2(23'9/'%"&'190(2&00')#4&8'(27#87&0'*88'190(2&00')#4&8'.#)/#2&2%0;'

!"*$&4'+2#6>"#6G'.##$4(2*%&4'0%$*%&3(&0G'0"*$&4'%*23(18&'$&0#9$.&0G'/##8&4'2&3#%(*%(#2'/#6&$'H'.#)1(2&4'190(2&00'.$&*%(#2'

,($)'0R2&$3R' B*"8*24&$'*24'V*22':DEKE;'

Page 78: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 89*

*

GCC%#$.&!f! !J,0.#%00!T+$%<!:1#710!:>X!J,0.#%00!?%7%<+CD%#)!*O>5#*(;;%4'5h*>(#*6%%4*&%"=B%'*6%D(,#%*5$*D=4$(54%'*D=4<5'%4$5(-*54<=&"($5=4C*

Page 79: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 8:*

G^G"ZBK!TGKgRTGK":B5!gE\!9!h!9!:GZ!R3iG6!O!*G#!1CC<.-1).+#!+L!+C%#!A,0.#%00!D+$%<!.##+71).+#!)+!-*%1)%!1#$!1CC*+C*.1)%!0=#%*@=!.#!1!0,0)1.#1A<%!A,0.#%00!-+#)%&)!**"##+71).+#!T1#1@%D%#)!9X'9;9X'>!C9%"#$W'FSkSC'7*2'C$4&22&''!^*1$,1).+#!C*+@*1D5!!Jad&'!."##8'#-'<2490%$(*8'?23(2&&$(23'!&$(&0'F*0%&$'J"&0&0'<22#7*%(#2'F*2*3&)&2%'!^*1$,1).+#!-+DD.))%%5!B$S'<$S'C$."'<SFSFSk'=&R)&2''B$S'hS!S'X#4#R2(%0R2*'B$0S'[S'7*2'C8%&$&2'!?1)%!+L!@*1$,1).+#5!KK>Ej>DEKe'!GJBK/G:K'@1%(&.0#.&(0130(3(,#&+8%("#*6($3&&.0(#&&.=30%(#&(#,.830#.&(,%*=%,(3,(,03*0#&+(9.#&0(".*(01%(.9%&(#&&.=30#.&( 93*37#+6( #&0*.75$%7( 4'( L1%,4*.5+1( 2RSST:?( C&( .*7%*( 0.( #69*.=%( #&&.=30#=%(9%*".*63&$%( 3&7( 01%*%4'( $*%30%( =385%<( "#*6,( 13=%( 0.( %&+3+%( /#01( .01%*( 93*0#%,( 0.( +3#&(3$$%,,( 0.( &%/( #7%3,( .*( *%,.5*$%,( 2U3183&7%*( 3&7( -3&&<( RSES:?( @1%( =385%( $*%30%7( 3&7($3905*%7(4'("#*6,(.9%&#&+(59(01%#*(45,#&%,,(6.7%8(,1.587(&305*388'(4%(1#+1%*(013&(01%(,56(."(01%(=385%(4.01(93*0#%,($.587(13=%($*%30%7(#&(#,.830#.&?()0(V.1&(3&7(W3**#,.&(2EFFF:(7%,$*#4%(01#,(91%&.6%&.&(3,( ?(@1#,(63,0%*(01%,#,(7#=%,( #&0.(01#,(630%*#38( #&(.*7%*(0.(7%*#=%(4.01(01%.*'J(3&7(9*3$0#$%J43,%7(7%,#+&(9*#&$#98%,( ".*(01%($*%30#.&(."(,'&%*+'(01*.5+1(.9%&(45,#&%,,(6.7%8(#&&.=30#.&?(@1%,%(9*#&$#98%,(3*%(3998#%7(#&(3(,5,03#&348%(45,#&%,,($.&0%A0<(0.(,%%(1./(0/.("#*6,($.8834.*30#&+($.587($*%30%(,5,03#&348%(#&&.=30#.&,(0130(7%8#=%*(6.*%(=385%(0.( 01%,%( "#*6,( 013&( 01%( $.64#&%7( %"".*0( ."( 01%#*( /.*;( /.587( 13=%( 4%%&( /1%&( /.*;#&+(#&7#=#75388'?(O,(3(*%,580<(3&(.9%&(45,#&%,,(6.7%8(0%69830%(0.($*%30%(".5*(0'9%,(."(,'&%*+'(13,(4%%&(7%=%8.9%7(3&7(#698%6%&0%7(#&(3(,5,03#&348%(45,#&%,,($.&0%A0?(!V%=8+*$0W'O/&2'<22#7*%(#2G'\90(2&00'F#4&8'<22#7*%(#2G'O/&2'\90(2&00'F#4&8'N*27*0G',($)'!R2&$3RG'B&0(32'X$(2.(/8&0G'!90%*(2*18&'\90(2&00'?27($#2)&2%S''

Page 80: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 90*

"ZK/E?i:K"EZ!O>%*4=$5=4*$>($*(*#54@-%*<5&"*D(44=$*544=B($%*54*5#=-($5=4*#%&B%#*(#*#$(&$54@*;=54$*<=&*$>%*=;%4* 544=B($5=4* ;(&('5@"* 54$&=',D%'* 6.* J>%#6&=,@>* R/002SC* E4* =&'%&* $=* 5";&=B%*544=B($5B%*;%&<=&"(4D%)*<5&"#*>(B%*$=*%4@(@%*d5$>*=$>%&*;(&$5%#*$=*@(54*(DD%##*$=*4%d*5'%(#*=&*&%#=,&D%#*RK(>-(4'%&*(4'*\(44)*/010SC*3=)*=;%4%544=B($5=4*5#*(*"%(4*$=*D&%($%*(4'* D(;$,&%* B(- % "='%-%RV#$%&d(-'%&* (4'* I5@4%,&)* /010S.%A=--=d54@* <&="* $>5#)* J>%#6&=,@>* R/008S* #$($%#* $>($*<5&"#*>(B%*$=*=;%4*$>%5&*@+2)4*22*G<A*52%$=*=$>%&*;(&$5%#*54*=&'%&*$=*5";&=B%*544=B($5B%*;%&<=&"(4D%)*&($>%&*$>(4*&%-.54@*($*54$%&4(--.*@%4%&($54@*544=B($5=4*#=-%-.C*T=d%B%&)*(#*;=54$%'*=,$*6.*G%%'*%$*(-C*R/01/S)*$>%&%*5#*(*$&('%_=<<*6%$d%%4*$>%*6%4%<5$#*(4'*&5#Q#*=<*=;%4* 544=B($5=47* (--* ;(&$5%#* 54B=-B%'* #>=,-'* 6%4%<5$* <&="* =;%4* 544=B($5=4)* =$>%&d5#%*<5&"#*D=,-'*6%$$%&*<=D,#*=4*54$%&4(--.*@%4%&($54@*544=B($5=4)*$>%&%6.*(B=5'54@*(4.*&5#Q#*

C*E4*=$>%&*d=&'#)*$>%*B(-,%*D(;$,&%'*(4'*D&%($%'*6.* <5&"#*=;%454@*,;*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-* #>=,-'*4($,&(--.*6%*>5@>%&* $>(4* $>%*#,"* =<* $>%* B(-,%* 6=$>* ;(&$5%#* D=,-'* >(B%* D&%($%'* 54* 5#=-($5=4C* 3$* +=>4* (4'* T(&&5#=4*R1:::S*'%#D&56%*$>5#*;>%4="%4=4*(#* %

/RBRG/:g!3iRBK"EZ!!-$>=,@>*#=,4'54@*;&="5#54@* <=&*6=$>*"(4(@%&#*(4'*#D>=-(&#)* $>%&%*(&%*$d=*;&%"5#%#*$>($*"(.*#%%"*$=*#$&5Q%*d5$>*#.4%&@.*(D>5%B%"%4$*B5(*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4C*O>%*<5&#$*;&%"5#%*#$%"#*<&="*J>%#6&=,@>*R/008S)*d>=*#$($%#*$>($*$>%*g=,&4%.*$=d(&'#*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*5#*D>(--%4@54@C*O>%*#%D=4'*;&%"5#%)*<=--=d54@*\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--*R1::9S)*#$($%#*$>($*(-$>=,@>*#.4%&@.*>(#*$>%*;=$%4$5(-* $=*D&%($%*B(-,%)* 5$* $,&4#*=,$* $>($*"(4.* #.4%&@.* %<<=&$#* %4'* ,;* A*2$#<6)4:% B(-,%* &($>%&* $>(4* D&%($54@* 5$C* 3=)* (-$>=,@>*'%#5&%'*6.*"(4(@%&#*(4'*&%D%5B54@*54D&%(#%'*($$%4$5=4*<&="*#D>=-(&#)*D&%($54@*#.4%&@.*RB5(* =;%4* 6,#54%##* "='%-#S* #$5--* >(#* 5$#* &=,@>* %'@%#C* A=&* <5&"#* d5--54@* $=* =;%4* $>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-#* 54* $>%5&*'%#5&%* <=&* #.4%&@.)* 5$* 5#* 5";=&$(4$* $=*@(54* 54#5@>$#* 54*'%(-54@*d5$>* $>%#%* D>(--%4@%#C* O>5#* $>%#5#* D=4$&56,$%#* $=* @(5454@* $>%#%* 54#5@>$#* 6.* ;=#54@* (4'*(4#d%&54@*$>%*<=--=d54@*&%#%(&D>*?,%#$5=47*

!

F(4.* #D>=-(&#* 54* $>%* <5%-'* =<* %D=4="5D#* (4'*"(4(@%"%4$* >(B%* ;(5'* ($$%4$5=4* $=* $>%*$=;5D*=<*#.4%&@.)*6,$*(*d%--_'%<54%'*$>%=&.*=<*#.4%&@.*(4'*54$%&_<5&"*4%$d=&Q#*>(#*.%$*$=*%"%&@%*R^%5)*/010SC*O>5#*$>%#5#*d5--*D=4$&56,$%*$=*$>%*D-=#,&%*=<*$>5#*@(;)*6.*'%B%-=;54@*(* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@.* @&=,4'%'* 54* -5$%&($,&%)* d>5D>* D(4* 6%* -54Q%'* $=* (4* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-* $%";-($%)* $=* #%%* >=d* =;%4* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4* D=,-'* &%#,-$* 54* <5&"*#.4%&@5%#C*K%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*6(#%'*=4*6=$>*$>%=&.*(4'*;&(D$5D%*(&%*'%B%-=;%'*54*=&'%&*$=*#>=d*>=d*$>%#%*'5<<%&%4$*$.;%#*=<*#.4%&@.*D(4*6%*(D>5%B%'C**

BbZR/^b!"Z!E4RZ!JiB"ZRBB!TE?R6B5!6"KR/GKi/R!/RS"R\!!* -5$%&($,&%* &%B5%d* >(#* 6%%4* D=4',D$%')* &%B%(-54@* R&%D%4$S* &%#%(&D>* =4* $>%* $=;5D#* =<*=;%4*544=B($5=4)*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*(4'*#.4%&@.C**

E4RZ!"ZZESGK"EZ!G%B5%d54@* $>%* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* ;(&('5@"* >(#* #$(&$%'* d5$>* <54'54@* (* d5'%-.* (DD%;$%'*

Page 81: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 91*

544=B($5=4* 5#j* $E*% +2*% <F% =+#=<2),*% )4F5<-2% "4A% <+$F5<-2% <F% K4<-5*A:*% $<% ";;*5*#"$*%)4$*#4"5%)44<,"$)<4X%"4A%$<%*U="4A%$E*%G" *RJ>%#6&=,@>)* Y(4>(B%&6%Q%* (4'*^%#$)* /00`)* ;C1SC* A=--=d54@* <&="* $>5#* '%<545$5=4)* $>%*R'5#S('B(4$(@%#*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4*(&%*'5#D,##%'C*3D>=-(&#*#%%"*$=*>(B%*(4*5"6(-(4D%'*<=D,#*=4*$>%*('B(4$(@%#*=<*=;%4*544=B($5=4)*$>%&%6.*4%@-%D$54@*5$#*'=d4#5'%C*O>%*"(54*('B(4$(@%#* #D>=-(&#* (@&%%* ,;=4* (&%* 2E<#$*#%$)G*%$<%G"#K*$X% 5<-*#%)44<,"$)<4%;<2$2%(4'%)4;#*"2*A% 2"5*2C* K(>-(4'%&* (4'* \(44* R/010S* (&%* ("=4@* $>%* <%d* d>=* '%#D&56%* $>%*A)2"A,"4$":*2* =<* =;%4* 544=B($5=47* <%(&* =<* D=";%$5$=&#* 6%D="54@* 6%$$%&* ;=#5$5=4%')*54D&%(#54@*$&(4#(D$5=4*D=#$#)*-(DQ*=<*(6#=&;$5B%*D(;(D5$.*(4'*$>%*;=##565-5$.*=<*&%-.54@*$==*>%(B5-.*=4*%h$%&4(-*&%#=,&D%#C*

JiB"ZRBB!TE?R6!"ZZESGK"EZ!W%h$)* 54*=&'%&* $=* #%%*>=d*(;;-.54@*=;%4* 544=B($5=4* D(4* D&%($%*(4'*D(;$,&%*B(-,%)* $>%*D=4D%;$* =<* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4* 5#* '5#D,##%'C* O>%* 6,#54%##* "='%-* D(4B(#* =<*V#$%&d(-'%&*(4'*I5@4%,&*R/010S*#%&B%#*(#*$>%*6(#5#*<=&*$>%*$>%=&%$5D(-*<&("%d=&QC*O>%.*R565')* ;C* ]S* #$($%* $>($* (* 6,#54%##*"='%-* %E<-%"4%<#:"4)>"$)<4%

J=4D%&454@* 6,#54%##* "='%-* )44<,"$)<4)* !"5$* (4'*

262$*G %##*"='%-*544=B($5=4)*"=#$*5";=&$(4$-.*$>%*<(D$*$>($*"(4(@%&#*>(B%*'5<<5D,-$5%#*54*&%D=@45f54@*(*;&="5#54@*6,#54%##*"='%-* $5"%-.* =&* $>($* 5$#* '%B%-=;"%4$* 5#* &%#5#$%'* ',%* $=* D=4<-5D$#* d5$>* $>%* ;&%B(5-54@*6,#54%##*"='%-*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010SC*O>="Q%*R/00/S*(&@,%#*$>($*$>%*d(.*<=&d(&'*5#*$=*('=;$* (4* %h;%&5"%4$(-* #$(4D%* $=d(&'#* 5$7* D=";(45%#* #>=,-'* '%B%-=;* $>%* (65-5$.* $=*%h;%&5"%4$* d5$>* $>%5&* 6,#54%##* "='%-#* $=* ;(&$(Q%* "=&%* <,--.* 54* $>%* 6%4%<5$#* =<* =;%4*544=B($5=4)* D=54%'* 6.* J>%#6&=,@>* R/008S* (#* <=*4%@+2)4*22%G<A*52C* 3=)* =;%4* 6,#54%##*

6,#54%##*"='%-* 54*=&'%&*$=*D&%($%*(4'*D(;$,&%*B(-,%*R3(4',--5*(4'*J>%#6&=,@>)*/00:SC*O=*#%%*>=d*D=--(6=&($54@*<5&"#*D(4*D(;$,&%*(*2+#=5+2%54*B(-,%)*$>%*$>%#5#*D=4$54,%#*d5$>*%-(6=&($54@*=4*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*#.4%&@.C**

BbZR/^b!!3.4%&@.* 5#*(D>5%B%'*d>%4*$>%*B(-,%*=<*(*D="654%'*%4$5$.*%hD%%'#*$>%*#,"*=<*B(-,%#*=<*$>%* <5&"#* 54* 5#=-($5=4* R3$* +=>4* (4'* T(&&5#=4)* 1:::SC* T=d%B%&)* $>5#* '%<545$5=4* &%"(54#*&($>%&* (6#$&(D$* RD<C* H4=--)* /009SC*O>%&%<=&%)* (* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@.* @&=,4'%'* 54* -5$%&($,&%*>(#* 6%%4* '%B%-=;%'* D=4#5#$54@* =<* F)4"4;)"5)* G"4":*G*4$)* ;+2$<G*#)* <=*#"$)<4"5* (4'*K4<-5*A:**G"4":*G*4$* #.4%&@.C* N(D>* #.4%&@.* $.;%* >(#* 6%%4* '%<54%'* 6.* #.4$>%#5f54@*;&%B5=,#* -5$%&($,&%C* A=&* $>%* ;#*"$)<4* =<* #.4%&@.*^,* (4'* J>=5* R/00]S* #$($%* $>($* <5&"#*#>=,-'* %hD>(4@%* (4'* D="654%* &%#=,&D%#* d5$>* 6,#54%##* ;(&$4%&#* $=* 6%D="%* "=&%*D=";%$5$5B%*(4'*%<<5D5%4$C%X(#%'*=4*\==-'*(4'*J(";6%--*R1::9S)*#5h*;&=D%##%#*$=*(D>5%B%*#.4%&@.* (&%* <=&",-($%'7* #>(&54@* Q4=d_>=d)* D==&'54($54@* #$&($%@5%#)* #>(&54@* $(4@56-%*&%#=,&D%#)* B%&$5D(-* 54$%@&($5=4* (4'* ;==-54@* 4%@=$5($5=4* ;=d%&C* !-$>=,@>* $%";$54@* <=&*"(4(@%&#*$=*#$&5B%*<=&*#.4%&@.)*<=,&*;=$%4$5(-*65(#%#*#>=,-'*6%*$(Q%4*54$=*(DD=,4$*d>5-#$*#%%Q54@*5$7*$>%*#.4%&@.*65(#)*$>%*;(&%4$54@*65(#)*$>%*#Q5--#*65(#*(4'*$>%*,;#5'%*65(#*R565'SC**

KgRE/RK":G6!U/GTR\E/V!!O>%#%* <54'54@#* >(B%* &%#,-$%'* 54* (* $>%=&%$5D(-* <&("%d=&Q* (4'* //* $>%=&._6(#%'* '%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#* $>($* #>=d*d>5D>* 54$%&B%4$5=4#* #>=,-'* $(Q%* ;-(D%* 54* =&'%&* $=* %#$(6-5#>* <5&"*#.4%&@.*R#%%*<5@,&%*10SC**

Page 82: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 9/*

*;,0Z&%'BO'U'9X%(&%$,+"T')&"1%^(&b'()'$X,#'$X%#,#'

TRKgE?E6E^b!O>5#*$>%#5#*('=;$#*(*#D5%4D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*(;;&=(D>)*6(#%'*=4*?,(-5$($5B%*&%#%(&D>C*O>%*4($,&%* =<* $>%* &%#%(&D>* ?,%#$5=4* -%4'#* 5$#%-<* &%('5-.* <=&* #,D>* (4* (;;&=(D>)* #54D%* 5$*

#* =<* #.4%&@.*C*F=&%*#;%D5<5D(--.)*$>5#*$>%#5#*

<=--=d#*$>%*&%<-%D$5B%*D.D-%*=<*Y(4*!Q%4*%$*(-C*R/008S)*d>5D>*%4$(5-#*'%#5@454@*(*#=-,$5=4*<=&*(*#;%D5<5D*D(#%*6(#%'*=4*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*54*=&'%&*$=*@%4%&($%*'%#5@4*Q4=d-%'@%C*O=*'%&5B%* $>%* <54(-* #%$* =<* ;&54D5;-%#)* $>%* (;;&=(D>* =<* Y(4* X,&@* %$* (-C* R/009S* 5#* <=--=d%')*d>5D>* D=4$(54#* '%#5@454@* (* <54(-* #%$* =<* ;&54D5;-%#* 6.* D="65454@* ;&54D5;-%#* 6(#%'* =4*;&(D$5D%*R6.*(4(-.#54@*$%4*D(#%*#$,'5%#*,#54@*=;%4*D='54@S*(4'*;&54D5;-%#*"%&%-.*6(#%'*=4* &%#%(&D>C* 3=)* $>%* <54(-* #%$* =<* ;&54D5;-%#* '&(d#* =4* 6=$>* ;&(D$5$5=4%&_* (4'* &%#%(&D>*Q4=d-%'@%C* O>%* ;&54D5;-%#* <=--=d* $>%* JEFV* -=@5D* =<*K%4.%&* %$* (-C* R/009)*;C2:[S7* )F%6<+%-"4$% $<% ";E)*,*% <+$;<G*% P% )4% ;<4$*U$% 1X% $E*4% +2*% )4$*#,*4$)<4% $6=*% ?.* O>%* %h;-(4($5=4*$>&=,@>*d>5D>*F%D>(45#"*$>%*54$%&B%4$5=4*;&=',D%#*$>%*=,$D="%*5#*&%;&%#%4$%'*6.*$>%*

*RJ20SC*O>%*'($(*D=--%D$%'*<=&*$>%*'%$(5-%'*'%#5@4*#=-,$5=4*<=&*J20*>(#*6%%4*@($>%&%'*6.*D=4',D$54@*54$%&B5%d#*(4'*B5(*'5&%D$*=6#%&B($5=4#*',&54@*$>%*$5"%*#;%4$*=4_#5$%C*

?RB"^Z!O>%* D%4$&(-* &=-%* =<* $>%* 6,#54%##* %4B5&=4"%4$* >(#* %h$%4'%'* <&="* 6%54@* (* $&('5$5=4(-*%D=4="5D* (D$=&)* $=d(&'#* 6%54@* (* ;=-5$5D(-* (4'* #=D5(-* (D$=&* RZ5* (4'* O=;;54%4)* /011SC*

Page 83: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 92*

A=d-%&* (4'*T=;%* R/008S* (&@,%* $>($* 5$* 5#* ;=##56-%* $=* (D>5%B%*d54_d54* #D%4(&5=#* ,4'%&*d>5D>*(*<5&"*D(4*"(h5"5f%*&%$,&4#*d>5-%*"(Q54@*;&=@&%##*$=d(&'#*$>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*=<*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##*;&(D$5D%C*3=)*#,#$(54(6-%*'%#5@4*(4'*;&(D$5D%#*4=$*=4-.*'%D&%(#%*4%@($5B%* 5";(D$* =4* $>%* %4B5&=4"%4$)* 6,$* (-#=* D=,-'* ;&=B5'%* 6%4%<5$#* $=* $>%* <5&"*R\=$$<&5%')* /002S)*"(Q54@* 5$* 54D&%(#54@-.* 5";=##56-%* <=&* <5&"#* $=* (B=5'* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<*#,#$(54(6-%* '%B%-=;"%4$* RK.--5DQ* (4'* T=DQ%&$#)* /00/SC* T=d%B%&)* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<*

E"2% @**4% +2*A% $<% G*"4% A)FF*#*4$% $E)4:2% $<% A)FF*#*4$% =*<=5*% )4% A)FF*#*4$%* RX%6654@$=4)* /002)* ;C1SC* !#* (* &%#,-$)* #,#$(54(6-%* '%B%-=;"%4$* D=4#$5$,$%#* (*

D>(--%4@%* <=&* <5&"#)*#54D%*4%5$>%&*$>%*D=4D%;$)*4=&*$>%* 5";-%"%4$($5=4*D(4*6%*;&=;%&-.*@&(#;%'C* O=* =B%&D="%* $>%#%* D>(--%4@%#)* Y(4* H-%%<* (4'* G=="%* R/008S* (&@,%* <=&*D=--(6=&($5B%*544=B($5=4*$>&=,@>*4%$d=&Q#*(4'*",-$5_(D$=&*<=&,"#C**E4* $>5#* D=4$%h$)* J20* >%-;#* <5&"#* =B%&D="%* $>%#%* D>(--%4@%#* 6.* $&(4#-($54@* $>%5&*("65$5=4#* 54$=* $>%5&* 6,#54%##* "='%-#C* T=d%B%&)* (#* #$($%'* 6.* \=$$<&5%'* R/002S)* $>%*#=-,$5=4#*$>($*J20*;&%#%4$#*$=*5$#*D,#$="%&#*"5@>$*>(B%*"=&%*;=$%4$5(-*B(-,%*$>(4*#=-%-.*6%54@*;&%#%4$%'*$=*$>%*D,#$="%&*5";(D$C*F="%4$(&5-.)*J20*('B5#%#*D,#$="%&#*(4'*>%-;#*d5$>*$>%*5";-%"%4$($5=4*=<*$>%*#=-,$5=4* )*(<$%&*d>5D>*$>%*;&=g%D$*5#*<545#>%'C*T=d%B%&)*54* B5%d*=<* $>%* =;%4* 544=B($5=4* ;(&('5@")* D="65454@* Q4=d-%'@%* (4'* %h;%&$5#%* =<* J20*d5$>*'(5-.*=;%&($5=4#*=<*5$#*D,#$="%&#*D=,-'*&%#,-$*54*544=B($5=4#*$>&=,@>*D=--(6=&($5=4)*&%#,-$54@* 54* (* #,&;-,#* =<* B(-,%* <=&* 6=$>* D=";(45%#C* E4* =$>%&* d=&'#)* D=--(6=&($5=4*6%$d%%4*J20*(4'*5$#*D,#$="%&#*>(#*$>%*;=$%4$5(-*$=*&%#,-$*54*<5&"*#.4%&@.)*6,$*#$(@4($%#*($* $>5#* "="%4$* (<$%&* $>%* ;&=g%D$* 5#* <545#>%'C* E4* (* #5$,($5=4* =<* D-=#%* D=--(6=&($5=4)* $>%*D>(--%4@%*$>($*<5&"#*<(D%*d>5-%*5";-%"%4$54@*#,#$(54(65-5$.*54*$>%5&*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(4*6%*=B%&D="%*6.*,#54@*Q4=d-%'@%*(4'*%h;%&$5#%*=<*J20)*d>5-%*J20*=4*5$#*$,&4*D=,-'*"(Q%*,#%*=<*$>%*&%#=,&D%#*=&*'(5-.*=;%&($5=4#*=<*$>%*<5&"#*'%B%-=;*(4'*5";-%"%4$*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##* 544=B($5=4#C* O>%* ;=$%4$5(-* 6%4%<5$#* <=&* 6=$>* <5&"#* $>($* D=,-'* (&5#%*d=,-'* 6%*&%;,-#54@* @&%%4_d(#>54@)* %4#,&54@* &%D,&&54@* ;(."%4$#* <=&* 6=$>* <5&"#)* 5";-%"%4$54@*544=B($5=4#*"(&Q%$_d5'%*(4'*5"(@%*6,5-'54@C***!* #=-,$5=4* <=&* $>5#* ;&=6-%"*>(#* 6%%4* '%#5@4%')* 54* $>%* <=&"*=<* (4* <=*4%@+2)4*22%G<A*5%$*G=5"$*%6(#%'*=4*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#)*$=*#%%*>=d*$>%*6,5-'54@*6-=DQ#*=<*$>%*$%";-($%*#>=,-'*6%*'%$(5-%'*54*=&'%&*$=*(D>5%B%*R=4%*=<S*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*#.4%&@.*<=&"#C*O>%*@%4%&5D*$%";-($%* >(#* 6%%4* D=4$%h$,(-5f%'* <=&* $>%* #5$,($5=4* =<* J20C* O>5#*d(.)* Q4=d-%'@%* <&="*J20* D(4* 6%* $,&4%'* 54$=* B(-,(6-%* #,#$(54(6-%* 6,#54%##* '%B%-=;"%4$* RQ4=d-%'@%*"(4(@%"%4$*#.4%&@.S*6.*D=--(6=&($54@*d5$>*%h$%&4(-*;(&$4%&#)*$>%&%6.*4=$*=4-.*D&%($54@*(*#,&;-,#*54*%D=4="5D*6%4%<5$#*R5C%C*<54(4D5(-*#.4%&@.S*<=&*6=$>*<5&"#)*6,$*(-#=*'%D&%(#54@*4%@($5B%* 5";(D$* =4* $>%* %4B5&=4"%4$)* (D>5%B54@* ;&=',D$5B5$.* 6%4%<5$#* R=;%&($5=4(-*#.4%&@.S*(4'*%4>(4D54@*;,6-5D*&%-($5=4#)*d>5D>*54D-,'%*"(&Q%$54@*('B(4$(@%#*$=*&%(D>*(4'*#%&B%*",-$5;-%*D,#$="%&*#%@"%4$#*RD,#$="%&*#.4%&@.S)*D<C*\=$$<&5%'*R/002SC*A5@,&%*11*=4*$>%*4%h$*;(@%*#>=d#*$>%*@%4%&5D*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%)*d5$>*$>%*'5<<%&%4$*#.4%&@.* $.;%#C* F(4(@%"%4$* (4'* Q4=d-%'@%* "(4(@%"%4$* #.4%&@5%#* &%<-%D$* =4* (--*6,#54%##*"='%-*D=";=4%4$#*(4'*$>%&%<=&%*$>%#%*#.4%&@5%#*>(B%*4=$*6%%4*B5#,(-5f%'* 54*$>%*<5@,&%C*O>%*$(5-=&%'*#=-,$5=4*$=*$>%*#5$,($5=4*=<*J20*5#*'%#D&56%'*54*$>%*$>%#5#C**

Page 84: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 9]*

*;,0Z&%'BB'U'3%#,0-'#(TZ$,(-'

?"B:iBB"EZ!GZ?!:EZ:6iB"EZ!O>5#*$>%#5#*D=4$&56,$%#*$=*-5$%&($,&%*54*#%B%&(-*d(.#C*A5&#$)*(#*;=54$%'*=,$*6.*^%5*R/010S)*(* d%--_'%<54%'* $>%=&.* =<* #.4%&@.* (4'* <5&"* 4%$d=&Q#* >('* .%$* $=* %"%&@%C* O>5#* $>%#5#*D=4$&56,$%#*$=*D-=#54@*$>5#*@(;*6.*&%<-%D$54@*=4*<5B%*'%D('%#*=<* -5$%&($,&%*=4*#.4%&@.* 54*=&'%&* $=* ;&=B5'%* (* D=";&%>%4#5B%* #.4%&@.* $.;=-=@.* d5$>* (DD=";(4.54@* '%<545$5=4#C*NB%4* "=&%* 5";=&$(4$)* $>5#* $>%#5#* (5"%'* ($* D-=#54@* $>%* @(;* 6%$d%%4* '%#5&%'* #.4%&@.*=,$D="%#*(4'*>=d*$=*(D>5%B%*$>%"*6.*D="65454@*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#*$=*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<* <5&"* #.4%&@.C* !#* (* &%#,-$)* 5$* #>=d#* >=d* #.4%&@.* D(4* 6%* D&%($%'* (4'* D(;$,&%'* 6.*'%B%-=;54@* (4* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-* $%";-($%)* 6(#%'* =4* $>%*d=&Q* =<* V#$%&d(-'%&* (4'*I5@4%,&* R/010SC* A,&$>%&"=&%)* (* #%$* =<* =B%&* 20* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* >(#* 6%%4* '%B%-=;%')*6,5-'54@* =4* 6=$>* $>%=&.* (4'* ;&(D$5D%C* O>%* #%$* =<* ;&54D5;-%#* #>=d#* >=d* $>%* '5<<%&%4$*#.4%&@.*$.;%#*D(4*6%*(D>5%B%'C***A=&*"(4(@%&5(-*;,&;=#%#)* $>5#* $>%#5#* 5#* (* <5&#$* #$%;* <=&*;&(D$5$5=4%&#* 54*=B%&D="54@* $>%*;&=6-%"#* $>%.* <(D%* d>%4* =;%454@* ,;* $>%5&* 6,#54%##* "='%-)* 6.* ;&=B5'54@* D=4D&%$%*@,5'%-54%#* <=&* <5--54@* 54* $>%*6,#54%##*"='%-* D=";=4%4$#)* $>%&%6.*;&=B5'54@*(*;=$%4$5(-*;($>d(.* $=* @&%($%&* 544=B($5=4* (D$5B5$.C*R/002S* 4=$5=4* $>($* D=";(45%#* ",#$* 544=B($%* $=* #,&B5B%* (4'* $>%* <(D$* $>($* =;%4*544=B($5=4* >(#* 6%%4* #>=d4* $=* ;&=B5'%* =;;=&$,45$5%#)* 6,$* #5",-$(4%=,#-.* D(4* 6%*D>(--%4@54@*<=&*"(4.*<5&"#*RJ>%#6&=,@>)*/010S)*$>%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%*(4'*$>%*(DD=";(4.54@*$>%*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*D=,-'*6%*(*B(-,(6-%*$==-*<=&*<5&"#*d>%4*=;%454@*,;*$>%5&*6=&'%&#*54*(4*($$%";$*$=*%4>(4D%*544=B($5B%*;%&<=&"(4D%C*

6"T"KGK"EZB!GZ?!UiKi/R!/RBRG/:g!!#*d5$>*(4.*&%#%(&D>)*$>5#*&%#%(&D>*>(#*6%%4*#,6g%D$*$=*#="%*-5"5$($5=4#C* A5&#$*=<*(--)*(#*#$($%'*6.*FD\&($>*R/010S)*(*4%d*6,#54%##*"='%-*D(44=$*6%*<,--.*(4$5D5;($%'*54*('B(4D%)*6,$*",#$* 6%* -%(&4%'* =B%&* $5"%C* E4* $>5#* B5%d)* $>%* $>%=&%$5D(-* <&("%d=&Q* =<* $>5#* $>%#5#*(;;&=(D>%#* $>%* =;%4* 6,#54%##* "='%-* 544=B($5=4* ;&=D%##* ;%&>(;#* $==* #5";-5#$5D)* 6.*#$($54@* $>($* #.4%&@.* D=,-'* 6%* (* '5&%D$* &%#,-$*=<* D>(4@%#* 54* 6,#54%##*"='%-C* E4*;&(D$5D%)* $>5#* ;&=D%##*d5--* $(Q%* $5"%* (4'*"5@>$* 54B=-B%* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4* $=* -%(&4* <&="*

Page 85: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 9[*

"5#$(Q%#*"('%* (4'* $=* <54'* =,$*d>5D>* 6,#54%##*"='%-* 5#* (;;&=;&5($%* <=&* D&%($54@* (4'*(;;&=;&5($54@* #.4%&@.C* 3=)* (-$>=,@>* $>5#* $>%#5#* ;&=B5'%#* D-%(&* (4'* ,#%<,-* -54Q(@%#*6%$d%%4* =;%4* 6,#54%##*"='%-* 544=B($5=4* (4'* #.4%&@.)* <,$,&%* &%#%(&D>* D=,-'* (''&%##*$>%*D=4D%;$*=<*#.4%&@.*D&%($5=4*B5(*%h;%&5"%4$($5=4)*54*(''5$5=4*$=*$>5#*#$,'.C*E4*'=54@*#=)* $>%* '.4("5D* (4'* 5$%&($5B%* ;&=D%##* =<* %h;%&5"%4$($5=4)* d>5D>* 5#* #,@@%#$%'* <=&*6,#54%##*"='%-*544=B($5=4*RO>="Q%)*/00/S)*D(4*6%*"(;;%'*(4'*(;;-5%'*$=*(*D(#%*'%#5@4*=B%&*(*-=4@%&*;%&5='*=<*$5"%)*$=*#%%*5<*$>%&%*(&%*(4.*D>(4@%#*D=";(&%'*$=*$>%*<54'54@#*=<*$>5#*#$,'.C**W%h$)* $>%*D>=5D%* <=&* $>%*$%4*D(#%*#$,'5%#*=4*d>5D>*$>%*;&(D$5D%*6(#%'*'%#5@4*;&54D5;-%#*(&%* 6(#%')* >(#* #="%* -5"5$($5=4#C* !-$>=,@>* $>%* D(#%* #$,'5%#* #>=d* >=d* #.4%&@.* D(4* 6%*D&%($%'*54*;&(D$5D%*(4'*$>%*'%&5B%'*;&54D5;-%#*D=&&%#;=4'*$=*$>%=&.)*$>%*4,"6%&*=<*D(#%#*5#* &($>%&* -=dC* A,&$>%&"=&%)* $>%* D(#%#* >(B%* '5<<%&%4$* #5f%#)* 54D-,'54@* ",-$5_4($5=4(-#)*d>5-%*$>%*<54(-*'%#5@4*>(#*6%%4*(;;-5%'*$=*(*&%-($5B%-.*#"(--*<5&"*54*(*#;%D5<5D*D=4$%h$*R5CDC*J20SC* A,$,&%* &%#%(&D>* #>=,-'* (''&%##* $>%#%* 5##,%#* 6.* '%#5@454@)* 5";-%"%4$54@* (4'*%B(-,($54@* $>%* ;&(D$5D%* 6(#%'* '%#5@4* ;&54D5;-%#* (4'* $>%* $%";-($%* <=&* ",-$5;-%* D(#%*#$,'5%#* 54* '5B%&#5<5%'* D=4$%h$#* (4'* =<*'5<<%&%4$* #5f%#C* O>5#*d(.)* '5<<%&%4D%#* 54* #5f%* (4'*D=4$%h$*D(4*6%*=B%&D="%*6.*'%$(5-54@*$>%*'%#5@4)*d>5D>*D=,-'*#$&%4@$>%4*$>%*&=6,#$4%##*=<*$>%*'%#5@4C**O>5&')* (-$>=,@>* $>%* $.;=-=@.*=<* $>5#* #$,'.* 5#* D=";&%>%4#5B%)* [0* .%(&#* =<* -5$%&($,&%*=4*#.4%&@.*"(Q%#*5$*B5&$,(--.*5";=##56-%*$=*D=B%&*(--*$.;=-=@5%#*;&%#%4$*54*-5$%&($,&%C*K&5B%4*6.*$>%*<(D$*$>($*$>%&%*5#*4=*D=4#%4#,#*=4*$>%*$%&"54=-=@.*(4'*'%<545$5=4*=<*$>%*D=4D%;$)*"(4.*#.4=4."#*=&*D=4D%;$#*&%-($%'*$=*

!-$>=,@>* $>5#* $>%#5#* >(#* D=B%&%'* (* -(&@%* ;(&$* =<* $>%#%*$>%=&5%#)*$>%&%*&%"(54*#="%*&%#%(&D>*#$&%("#*$>($*<=D,#*=4*$>%*$=;5D*=<*#.4%&@.*$>($*>(#*4=$* &%D%5B%'* D=";&%>%4#5B%* ($$%4$5=4* 54* $>5#* #$,'.C* A=&* %h(";-%)* "%&@%&#* (4'*(D?,5#5$5=4#* -5$%&($,&%* '5B%#* 54* $>%* D=4D%;$* =<* $d=* <5&"#* D="65454@* $>%5&* #$&%4@$>#* 54*=&'%&* $=* (D>5%B%* B(-,%C* T=d%B%&)* $>5#* $>%#5#* >(#* <=D,#%'* =4* #.4%&@.* 6%$d%%4*D=--(6=&($54@*<5&"#*&($>%&*$>(4*"%&@54@*=&*(D?,5&54@*<5&"#)*#54D%*$>5#*(;;&=(D>%#*=;%4*544=B($5=4*;&(D$5D%#*"=#$*'5&%D$-.C*A,$,&%*&%#%(&D>*D=,-'*(;;-.*$>%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-*$%";-($%*54*$>%*D=4$%h$*=<*"%&@%&#*(4'*(D?,5#5$5=4#)*$=*#%%*5<*$>%*$%";-($%*D(4*6%*,#%'*54*'5<<%&%4$*#%$$54@#*=&*D=,-'*6%*%h$%4'%'*$=*B(-,%*D&%($5=4*(4'*(;;&=;&5($5=4*54*'5<<%&%4$*<=&"#*=<*g=54$*#$&,D$,&%#)*=$>%&*$>(4*=;%4*544=B($5=4*;&(D$5D%#C*

Page 86: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 9`*

/RUR/RZ:RB!!"5$)*GC)*P*l=$$)*JC!R/010S*X,#54%##*F='%-*E44=B($5=47*J&%($54@*Y(-,%!54*O5"%#*=<**J>(4@%C*_<#K)4:!! !"=*#!_!3/LNX%?TOT!J+2)4*22!O;E<<5X!c4),*#2)$6!<F!W","##"7*0_1[*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/002S*P=*4%)44<,"$)<4'%$E*%4*-%)G=*#"$),*%F<#%;#*"$)4:%"4A%=#<F)$)4:%F#<G%$*;E4<5<:6.%% T(&B(&'*X,#54%##*3D>==-*I&%##7*X=#$=4)*F!C*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/008S*^>.*D=";(45%#*#>=,-'*>(B%*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#C*O5<"4%R"4":*G*4$%M*,)*-%% C/R/S7*//_/9*J>%#6&=,@>)* TC)* Y(4>(B%&6%Q%)* ^C* P* ^%#$)* +C* R/00`S* P=*4% )44<,"$)<4'% #*2*"#;E)4:% "% 4*-% ="#"A):G.%% Vh<=&'*M45B%&#5$.*I&%##7*Z=4'=4)*N4@-(4'*K%4.%&)*KC)*O&(4<5%-')*KC)*P*Y(4*!Q%4*+CNC*R/009S*K%B%-=;54@*'%#5@4*;&=;=#5$5=4#*$>&=,@>*&%#%(&D>** #.4$>%#5#C*P#:"4)>"$)<4%O$+A)*2%07R2S7*2:2_]12*A=d-%&)*3C+C*P*T=;%)*JC*R/008S*E4D=&;=&($54@*#,#$(54(6-%*6,#54%##*;&(D$5D%#*54$=*D=";(4.*#$&($%@.C** J+2)4*22%O$#"$*:6%"4A%$E*%T4,)#<4G*4$%&IR1S7*/`_29**\==-')*FC*P*J(";6%--)*!C*R1::9S*K%#;%&($%-.*#%%Q54@*#.4%&@.C*b"#,"#A%J+2)4*22%M*,)*-'%1/:_1]2%K(>-(4'%&)*ZC*P*\(44)*KCFC*R/010S*T=d*=;%4*5#*=;%4*544=B($5=4q*M*2*"#;E%!<5);6%87R1S7*`::_80:*H4=--)*3C*R/009S*1#<223@+2)4*22%264*#:)*2'%B%$6=<5<:6%<F%;#<223@+2)4*22%264*#:)*2%"4A%"%G)A3#"4:*%$E*<#6%<F%% ;<4$)4+<+2%:#<-$E%264*#:6%#*"5)>"$)<4C*^5%#6('%47*K%,$#D>%&*M45B%&#5$s$#_*Y%&-(@*RKMYS)*\(6-%&** N'5$5=4*^5##%4#D>(<$**Z5)*WC*P*O=;;54%4)*!C*R/011S*J=&;=&($%*&%#;=4#565-5$.*(4'*#,#$(54(6-%*D=";%$5$5B%*('B(4$(@%*54*<=&%#$_* 6(#%'*54',#$&.7*J=";-%"%4$(&.*=&*D=4<-5D$54@*@=(-#q*Q<#*2$%!<5);6%"4A%T;<4<G);2%&8R1S7*112_1/2%V#$%&d(-'%&)*!C*P*I5@4%,&)*LC*R/010S*J+2)4*22%G<A*5%:*4*#"$)<4C*+=>4*^5-%.*P*3=4#)*E4D7*T=6=Q%4)*W%d** +%&#%.*G%%')*GC)*3$=&&,'_X(&4%#)*3C*P*+%##,;)*ZC*R/01/S*T=d*=;%4*544=B($5=4*(<<%D$#*$>%*'&5B%&#*=<*D=";%$5$5B%** ('B(4$(@%C*R"4":*G*4$%9*;)2)<4%HNR1S7*[9_82*G=""%)*!C\CZC*R/002S*F(Q54@*(*'5<<%&%4D%7*=&@(45f($5=4*(#*'%#5@4C*P#:"4)>"$)<4%O;)*4;**&CR[S7*[[9_[82C*3(4',--5)*AC*P*J>%#6&=,@>)*TC*R/00:S*O>%*$d=*<(D%#*=<*=;%4*6,#54%##*"='%-#C*33GW*d=&Q54@*;(;%&*#%&5%#*3$*+=>4)*JCTC*P*T(&&5#=4)*+C3C*R1:::S*F(4,<(D$,&54@_6(#%'*&%-($%'4%##)*#.4%&@.)*(4'*D==&'54($5=4C*O$#"$*:);%% R"4":*G*4$%g<+#4"5%0NR/S7*1/: 1][*Y(4*X,&@)*NC)*G=""%)*!C\CZC)*\5-#54@)*YC!C*P*G%."%4)*ECFCFC+C*R/009S*J&%($54@*,45B%&#5$.*#;54_=<<#7*(** #D5%4D%_6(#%'*'%#5@4*;%&#;%D$5B%C*g<+#4"5%<F%!#<A+;$%?44<,"$)<4%R"4":*G*4$%0HR/S7*11]_1/9*^%5)*TC*R/010S*J==;%&($5=4*(4'*D=";%$5$5=4*=<*54$%&<5&"*4%$d=&Q*=&@(45f($5=4#7*$>%*<,4D$5=4*=<*#.4%&@5%#C** ?4$*#4"$)<4"5%1<4F*#*4;*%<4%T3J+2)4*22*2%"4A%T3`<,*#4G*4$%\0N&&]7*/22:_/2]/**^,)*^C*P*J>=5)*^CZC*R/00]S** X,#54%##*W%$d=&Q#7*!4*E4$%@&($5B%*!;;&=(D>C*B2)"%!";)F);%g<+#4"5%<F%R"4":*G*4$%0&R1S7*2/[ 2]2***

*********

**/008* */011**** W($,,&d%$%4#D>(;*%4*E44=B($5%*F(4(@%"%4$)*M$&%D>$*/011* */01/** * I&%_F(#$%&*E44=B($5=4*F(4(@%"%4$)*N54'>=B%4*/011* */012** * E44=B($5=4*F(4(@%"%4$)*N54'>=B%4*/012* *I&%#%4$* I&=g%D$*F(4(@%&*($*J-,6*B(4*20*XCYC)*!"#$%&'("**

@=9K:>H'!.CK.48'I@2'@>34224'K,&54@* >5#* "(#$%&* E44=B($5=4* F(4(@%"%4$* ($* N54'>=B%4*O%D>45D(-*M45B%&#5$.)*$>%*(,$>=&*D>=#%*$=*d&5$%*>5#*$>%#5#*($*J-,6*B(4*20*XCYC)*(*;&=g%D$*6,&%(,*<=D,#54@*=4*#,#$(54(65-5$.*54*$>%*6,#54%##*%4B5&=4"%4$*54*(*'%#5&%*$=*D="654%*$>%*$=;5D*=<*#,#$(54(65-5$.*$=*(4*54D&%(#%*54*B(-,%*<=&*<5&"#C*E4*$>%*4%(&*<,$,&%)*d>5-%*d=&Q54@*(#*(*;&=g%D$*"(4(@%&*<=&*J-,6*B(4*20)*>%*>=;%#*$=*$,&4*$>%*Q4=d-%'@%*;&=',D%'*54*$>5#*$>%#5#*54$=*;&(D$5D%C**

Page 87: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 98*

?1#Q8++*$!Y==&*,*-5@$*>%$*&%#,-$(($*B(4*B5g<*"((4'%4*d%&QC*Y5g<*"((4'%4*'5%*B==&65g*f5g4*@%B-=@%4C*K%*Q%,f%*="*"5g4*$>%#5#*$%*#D>&5gB%4*6544%4*%%4*6%'&5g<)*54*'5$*@%B(-*J-,6*B(4*20)*5#*%%4*Q%,f%* @%d%%#$* d((&((4* 5Q* B%%-* ;-%f5%&* >%6* 6%-%%<'C* W((#$* >%$* Q,44%4* $=%;(##%4* B(4*$>%=&5%t4*54*%%4*;&(Q$5gQ*#5$,($5%)*>%%<$*'%*(<#$,'%%&#$(@%*"5g*-%,Q%*>%&544%&54@%4)*B%%-*%&B(&54@* %4* 6=B%4* B%&d(D>$54@* B%%-* $((&$* %4* D>(";(@4%* @%6&(D>$C*F5g4* %%&#$%*d==&'*B(4*'(4Q*@(($*'((&="*,5$*4((&*J=-%$$%)*F(&Q*%4*"%$*4("%*L=%&5)*'5%*B(4(<*"54,,$*uu4*>%%<$*"%%@%'(D>$*%4*@%f=D>$*4((&*"=@%-5gQ%*(<#$,'%%&&5D>$54@%4C*EQ*Q5gQ*%&*4((&*,5$*="*6544%4*'5$*6%'&5g<*((4*'%*#-(@*$%*@((4v**K((&4((#$* d5-* 5Q* B5(* '%f%* d%@* "5g4* '(4Q* 6%$,5@%4* ((4* "5g4* 6%@%-%5'%&#* 6544%4* '%*O%D>45#D>%*M45B%&#5$%5$*N54'>=B%4C*!--%&%%&#$*E#(6%--%*G%."%4*B==&*'%*<5g4%*6%@%-%5'54@*@%',&%4'%* '%f%* (<#$,'%%&;%&5='%C* K%* B==&$@(4@#@%#;&%QQ%4*d%&'%4*"%%#$(-* 54@%-%5'*'==&*%%4*@%f%--5@*;&(($g%)*"((&*(-$5g'*@%B=-@'*'==&*4,$$5@%*<%%'6(DQe*uu4*B(4*'%*&%'%4%4*d((&'==&*"5g4*(<#$,'%&%4*#4%-*'==&-=;%4*Q=4*d=&'%4C*V=Q*>%$*54*D=4$(D$*6&%4@%4*"%$*'%* >%%&* 3D>(%<%&)* d((&'==&* 5Q* Q=4* '%%-4%"%4* ((4* >%$* HNW^EX* ;&=g%D$* %4* 4((&* >%$*

"5g4* $d%%'%* 6%@%-%5'%&)* H#%45(* I='=.45$#.4()* >(&$%-5gQ* '(4Q%4* B==&* >((&* <%%'6(DQC*V4'(4Q#*>%$*<%5$*'($*'%f%*D=4$(D$*"="%4$%4*"54'%&*<&%?,%4$*d(&%4)*>%66%4*'%f%*d%-*54f5D>$*B%&#D>(<$* 54*%%4*((4$(-*;,4$%4*'5%*B==&*B%&6%$%&54@*B($6((&*d(&%4)*>%$@%%4*'%*Qd(-5$%5$*B(4*'%f%*$>%#5#*f%Q%&*$%4*@=%'%*5#*@%Q="%4C***O=$*#-=$*d5-*5Q*"5g4*<("5-5%*%4*B&5%4'%4*6%'(4Q%4C*^%--5D>$*45%$*'5&%D$*B==&*4,$$5@%*54;,$)*"((&*B==&(-*B==&*'%*@%f%--5@%*%4*-%,Q%*"="%4$%4*B(4*>%$*(<@%-=;%4*>(-<*g((&*(-#*5Q*45%$*"5g4*$>%#5#*((4*>%$*#D>&5gB%4*d(#C***Y%%-*;-%f5%&*"%$*>%$*-%f%4*B(4*'%f%*$>%#5#C***F5D>5%-*B(4*!&'%44%***M$&%D>$)*/012**

Page 88: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 99*

BiTTG/b!M?iK:gN!!"Z6R"?"Z^''B&' %&$)'#/&2' (22#7*%(&' (0' 3&1*0&&$4' #/'"&%' (4&&'4*%' 1&4$(T7&2'2(&%' 8*23&$'*88&&2'+922&2'(22#7&$&2G')**$' 0*)&26&$+(2307&$1*24&2')&%' *24&$&' 1&4$(T7&2' **2' 4(&2&2' %&' 3**2' #)'%#&3*23' %&' +$(T3&2' %#%' 2(&96&' (4&&l2' &2' )(44&8&2' :B*"8*24&$' &2' V*22G' DEKE;S' <2' 4(%'/&$0/&.%(&-' (0'#/&2' (22#7*%(&'&&2')*2(&$'#)'6**$4&'4&'.$&l$&2'&2'7*0%'%&' 8&33&2G'6*%' (2'&00&2%(&'4&'-92.%(&'(0'7*2'&&2'190(2&00')#4&8':O0%&$6*84&$'&2'X(32&9$G'DEKE;S'N"&01$#93"':DEEj;' 1#$499$%' "(&$#/' 7##$%G' 2*)&8(T+' 4##$' %&' 0%&88&2' 4*%' 1&4$(T7&2' "92' 45,#&%,,( 6.7%8()#&%&2' #/0%&88&2' **2' *24&$&' 1&4$(T7&2' #)' "92' (22#7*%(&7&' /$&0%*%(&0' %&' 7&$1&%&$&2S'\&4$(T7&2' )#&%&2' &."%&$' 7*2' %&' 7#$&2' (20."*%%&2' #-' 4&' 7##$4&8&2' 7*2' #/&2' (22#7*%(&'

3&/**$4'3**2S'C88&'1&%$#++&2'1&4$(T7&2')#&%&2'490'/$#-(%&$&2'7*2'#/&2' (22#7*%(&G'*24&$0'+922&2'U&'U(."'1&%&$'$(."%&2'#/'"&%' (2%&$2'3&2&$&$&2'7*2'(22#7*%(&S'F&%'*24&$&'6##$4&2G'4&'6**$4&'4(&'1&4$(T7&2'3&2&$&&$%'4##$'#/&20%&88(23'7*2'"92'190(2&00')#4&8')#&%'3$#%&$'U(T2' 4*2' 4&' 0#)' 7*2' 4&' 6**$4&' 4(&' 1&(4&' /*$%(T&2' 3&m0#8&&$4' U#94&2' "&11&2' +922&2'$&*8(0&$&2S'B(%'-&2 ''Z#&6&8' 0R2&$3(&' $&*8(0*%(&' 4##$' )(44&8' 7*2' #/&2' 190(2&00' )#4&8' (22#7*%(&' 7##$' U#6&8')*2*3&$0'*80'#24&$U#&+&$0'&&2'7&&81&8#7&24'#24&$6&$/'7#$)%G')#&%'&$'$&+&2(23'3&"#94&2'6#$4&2' )&%' "&%' -&(%' 4*%' #/&2' 190(2&00' )#4&8' (22#7*%(&' 3&&2' 3&)*++&8(T+' %$*T&.%' (0':N"&01$#93"G'DEEj;S'B**$2**0%'18(T+%'4*%'4&' (20/*22(23'#)'0R2&$3(&'%&'$&*8(0&$&2G'#24*2+0'*88&' /#%&2%(&' 4(&' "&%' 1(&4%G' 7*+&$' 6**$4&' =%*&#%0#+7( 4*2' "&%' 6**$4&' .98%=%*0' :V##84' &2'N*)/1&88G' KLLM;S' B90G' #24*2+0' T*$&28*23&' **24*."%' 7##$' "&%' .#2.&/%G' (0' "&%' .$&l$&2' 7*2'0R2&$3(&':7(*'#/&2'190(2&00')#4&8'(22#7*%(&;'2#3'0%&&40'#)3&7&2'4##$'&2+&8&'#2#/3&8#0%&'7$**30%9++&2S'b##$'1&4$(T7&2'4(&'"92'190(2&00')#4&8'6(88&2'#/0%&88&2'**2'*24&$&'1&4$(T7&2'#)' U#' 0R2&$3(&' %&' .$&l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eEG'&&2'/$#T&.%'19$&*9'4*%'U(."'$(."%'#/'4&'7&$499$U*)(23'7*2'1&4$(T-0/$#.&00&2'#)'#/'4&U&')*2(&$'0*)&2')&%'*24&$&'1&4$(T7&2'499$U*)&'(22#7*%(&0'(2'4&')*$+%'%&'U&%%&2S''!BbZR/^"R!"Z!E4RZ!JiB"ZRBB!TE?R66RZ5!6"KR/GKii/!EZ?R/jERV!B&U&'%"&0(0'1&3(2%')&%'&&2'8(%&$*%99$'#24&$U#&+G'#)'(2U(."%'%&'+$(T3&2'(2'4&'1&3$(//&2'#/&2'(22#7*%(&G' 190(2&00' )#4&8' (22#7*%(&' &2' 0R2&$3(&G' &2' "#&' 4&U&' 1&3$(//&2' )&%' &8+**$'0*)&2"*23&2S'''

Page 89: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* 9:*

E4RZ'"ZZESGK"R''O)' (2U(."%' %&' 7&$+$(T3&2' (2' "&%' .#2.&/%' #/&2' (22#7*83&)&&2'**27**$4&'4&-(2(%(&'7*2'"&%'1&3$(/S'B&'4&-(2(%(&'3&1$9(+%'(2'4&U&'%"&0(0'(0'*80'7#83%W'n_#/&2' (22#7*%(&' (0`' "&%' 3&1$9(+' 7*2' 4#&83&$(."%&' (2>' &2' 9(%0%$##)' 7*2' +&22(0' #)' (2%&$2&'(22#7*%(&' %&' 7&$02&88&2' &2' #)' )*$+%&2' 9(%' %&' +922&2' 1$&(4&2' 7##$' &@%&$2' 3&1$9(+' 7*2'(22#7*%(&G' $&0/&.%(&7&8(T+n' :N"&01$#93"G' b*2"*7&$1&+&' &2' ]&0%G' DEEiG' 18US' K;S' c**$'**28&(4(23' 7*2' 4&U&' 4&-(2(%(&' U(T2' 4&' 7##$>' &2' 2*4&8&2' 7*2' #/&2' (22#7*%(&' 1&+&+&2S']&%&20."*//&$0' 8(T+&2'&&2'#2&7&26(."%(3&'2*4$9+'#/'4&'7##$4&8&2'7*2'#/&2' (22#7*%(&' %&'"&11&2G'6**$4##$' 4&'+&&$U(T4&'&$7*2'#24&$1&8(."%'6#$4%S'B&'1&8*23$(T+0%&'7##$4&8&2' U(T2W'"&%'02&88&$'#/'4&')*$+&%'+922&2'1$&23&2'7*2'(22#7*%(&0G'8*3&$&'+#0%&2'7*2'(22#7*%(&'&2'&&2'"#3&$&'#)U&%S'B*"8*24&$'&2'V*22':DEKE;'U(T2'oo2'7*2'4&'6&(2(3&2'4(&'4&'2*4&8&2'7*2'#/&2'(22#7*%(&'1&0."$(T7&2W'*230%'7##$'.#2.9$$&2%&2'4(&'1&%&$'3&/#0(%(#2&&$4'6#$4&2G'7&$"##34&'%$*20*.%(&+#0%&2G' &&2' 3&1$&+' **2' *10#$/%(&.*/*.(%&(%' &2' &&2' )#3&8(T+' /$#18&&)' #)' %&'*-"*2+&8(T+'%&'6#$4&2'7*2'&@%&$2&')(44&8&2S''A=*.24**'!:348'.22:[email protected]'O)'%&'U(&2'"#&'"&%'%#&/*00&2'7*2'#/&2'(22#7*%(&'0R2&$3(&'+*2'.$&l$&2'&2'7*0%8&33&2G'6#$4%'"&%' .#2.&/%' 7*2' 190(2&00' )#4&8' (22#7*%(&' 1&0/$#+&2S' B&' 190(2&00' )#4&8' .*27*0' 7*2'O0%&$6*84&$' &2' X(32&9$' :DEKE;G' 4(&' 0%&88&2' 4*%' &&2' 190(2&00' )#4&8' 4&' 3$#243&4*."%&'7*0%8&3%'7*2'"#&'&&2'#$3*2(0*%(&'6**$4&'.$&l&$%'&2'8&7&$%G'4(&2%'"(&$7##$'*80'1*0(0S'\90(2&00')#4&8' (22#7*%(&' (0' 7#83&20' C)(%' &2' Q#%%' :DEKEG' /SI;' n"&%' #2%6&$/&2' 7*2' 2(&96&G' #-' "&%'6(TU(3&2' 7*2' 1&0%**24&' *.%(7(%&(%&2' 7*2' &&2' #24&$2&)(23nS' ?$' U(T2' &."%&$' &&2' **2%*8'1*$$(p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l$&2'&2'7*0%'%&'8&33&2':!*24988('&2'N"&01$#93"G'DEEL;S''!BbZR/^"R!!R2&$3(&'6#$4%' 1&$&(+%'6*22&&$' 4&'6**$4&' 7*2' &&2' 2(&96&'#24&$2&)(23' 4&' 0#)' 7*2' 4&'6**$4&2'7*2'4&'#24&$2&)(23&2'*-U#24&$8(T+'#7&$0."$(T4%':!%'k#"2'&2'Z*$$(0#2G'KLLL;S'B&U&'4&-(2(%(&'18(T-%'&."%&$'2#3*8'*10%$*.%':h2#88G'DEEM;S'B**$#)'(0'(2'4&U&'%"&0(0'&&2'#/'8(%&$*%99$'3&1*0&&$4&' %R/#8#3(&' #2%6(++&84' 4(&' 1&0%**%' 9(%' -(2*2.(l8&G' )*2*3&)&2%G' .90%#)&$G'#/&$*%(#2&8&' &2' +&22(0)*2*3&)&2%' 0R2&$3(&S' ?8+' 0R2&$3(&' %R/&' (0' 3&4&-(2(&&$4' 4##$' "&%'0R2%"&%(0&$&2'7*2'8(%&$*%99$S'Q&0'/$#.&00&2'#)'0R2&$3(&'%&'$&*8(0&$&2'U(T2'3&-#$)98&&$4W'"&%'4&8&2'7*2'+&22(0G'"&%'4&8&2'7*2')(44&8&2G'0%$*%&3(&'.#q$4(2*%(&'7&$%(.*8&' (2%&3$*%(&'&2'"&%'0*)&21$&23&2'7*2'4&'#24&$"*24&8(230/#0(%(&':!*24988('&2'N"&01$#93"G'DEEL;'!KgRE/RK"B:g!VG?R/!!B&U&' 1&7(24(23&2' U(T2' 0*)&23&7#&34' %#%' &&2' %"&#$&%(0."' +*4&$' ' :*-1&&84(23' K;' &2' DD'#2%6&$/' /$(2.(/&0G' 4(&' 8*%&2' U(&2' 6&8+&' (2%&$7&2%(&0' /8**%0' U#94&2' )#&%&2' 7(24&2' #)'0R2&$3(&'%&'$&*8(0&$&2S''

Page 90: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* :0*

*@)S%%TW,-0'B'U'9X%(&%$,#+X'b"W%&!

TRKgE?E6E^"R!>1*0&4'

**23&U(&2' 4&U&' **2/*+' 1(T4$**3%' **2' "&%' #7&$1$933&2' 7*2' "&%' 3*%' 4*%' #2%0%**%' 4##$' 4&'*10%$*.%&' 0R2&$3(&' 4&-(2(%(&0' 7*2' #24&$U#&+&$0' &2' 4&' U#&+%#."%' 7*2' )*2*3&$0' #)' "&%' %&'$&*8(0&$&2' :=#))&G' DEEe;S' b##$' "&%' #2%6(++&8&2' 7*2' 4&' 0&%' #2%6&$/' /$(2.(/&0' 6#$4%' 4&'**2/*+' 7*2' b*2' \9$3' &%' *8S' :DEEM;' 3&7#834G' 4(&' 0%&88&2' 4*%' U#6&8' /$(2.(/&0' 3&1*0&&$4' #/'%"&#$(&G'*80'/$(2.(/&0'3&1*0&&$4'#/'/$*+%(T+' :(2'4(%'3&7*8'4##$'"&%'*2*8R0&$&2'7*2'%(&2'.*0&'0%94(&0' 4##$' )(44&8' 7*2' #/&2' .#4(23;' (2' 4&' 9(%&(24&8(T+&' 0&%' /$(2.(/&0' U#94&2' )#&%&2'

> 5#0;.6,0(X(6(8%'1&$&(+&2'(2'$.&0%A0(L<(3&1$9(+'4*2'#&0%*=%&0#%'NS'Z&%'#24&$8(33&24&')&."*2(0)&'4*%'4&'9(%+#)0%'$&*8(0&&$%'6#$4%'7&$+8**$4'4##$'4&'gFg'(2'"&%'N<FO'*.$#2(&)S'B&U&'/$(2.(/&0'U988&2'6#$4&2' %#&3&/*0%' #/' &&2' 0/&.(-(&+' 1&4$(T-W' N891' 7*2' eE' :NeE;S' B&' 3&3&7&20' 7##$' "&%'3&4&%*(88&&$4&' #2%6&$/' 7##$' NeE' U(T2' 7&$U*)&84' 4##$' "&%' "#94&2' 7*2' (2%&$7(&60' &2' 7(*'4($&.%&'#10&$7*%(&0'3&49$&24&'4&'%(T4'4##$3&1$*."%'1(22&2'"&%'1&4$(T-S''?RB"^Z!B&' $#8' 7*2'1&4$(T7&2' (0' 7&$0."#7&2'7*2'&&2' %$*4(%(#2&&8'&.#2#)(0."' 0/&8&$'2**$'&&2')&&$'/#8(%(&+&'&2'0#.(*8&'0/&8&$' :5('&2'J#//(2&2G'DEKK;S',#68&$'&2'Z#/&':DEEj;'1&*$39)&2%&$&2'4*%'"&%')#3&8(T+'(0'7##$'1&4$(T7&2'#)'6(2> &$%(T4'#/%()*8(0&$&2' 7*2' 6(20%' o2' 7##$%3*23' %&' 1#&+&2' (2' 4&' ()/8&)&2%*%(&' 7*2' 499$U*)&'(22#7*%(&0S' NeE' "&8/%' 1&4$(T7&2' (2' 4&U&' U#&+%#."%G' 4##$' "92' *)1(%(&0' %&' 7&$%*8&2' (2'499$U*)&' 190(2&00' )#4&88&2S' Z&%' 18(T+%' &."%&$G' 4*%' 4&U&' 499$U*)&' (2(%(*%(&7&2' )&&$'/#%&2%(&'"&11&2'*80'4&'+&22(0'7*2'NeE'7&$&2(34'6#$4%')&%'4&'#/&$*%(#2&8&'+$*."%'7*2'"92'

Page 91: Against mathematics: how 2+2 can equal 5 An application of ......!"#$%&'(")*+,-.*/012* * 3$,'%4$*5'%4$5$.*4,"6%&7*088/92:* * * * 54*;(&$5(-*

* :1*

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l8&' 0R2&$3(&;G' )**$' ##+' &&2'499$U*)&$&' 1&4$(T-07#&$(23' 6#$4%' 3&$&*8(0&&$4G' /$#49.%(7(%&(%07##$4&8&2' ' 6#$4&2' 1&$&(+%':#/&$*%(#2&8&' 0R2&$3(&;' &2' 7&$0."(88&24&' +8*2%0&3)&2%&2' +922&2' 6#$4&2' **23&0/$#+&2':.90%#)&$'0R2&$3(&;S'C-1&&84(23'D'3&&-%'4&'%&)/8*%&G'4&'1(T1&"#$&24&'%R/&2'0R2&$3(&'&2'4&'#2%6&$//$(2.(/&0'6&&$S'

*@)S%%TW,-0'E'U'3%#,0-'

?"B:iBB"R!RZ!:EZ:6i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b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