agr october 2016 - march 2017 six-monthly update · pakistan's iscal architecture has...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE
AGR
from the British people
OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017
![Page 2: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Acronyms and Abbreviations
A&A AccountingandAuditingADB AsianDevelopmentBankBE BankexecutedBETF Bank-executedtrustfundCCICouncilofCommonInterestsDeM DebtManagementDMR DebtManagementReformsDMU DebtManagementUnitDPCO DebtPolicyCoordinationOf�iceEAD EconomicAffairsDivisionEE&C EnergyEf�iciencyandConservationEF ExternalFinanceES EnterpriseSurveyFBR FederalBoardofRevenueFCCL FiscalCommitmentandContingentLiabilitiesFD FinanceDivisionGDP GrossDomesticProductGoKP GovernmentofKhyberPakhtunkhwaGoP GovernmentofPakistanICT InformationandcommunicationtechnologyIFRS InternationalFinancialReportingStandardsISA InternationalStandardsonAuditingJPCL JamshoroPowerCompanyLimitedKP KhyberPakhtunkhwaKPIs KeyPerformanceIndicatorsMDTF-AGR Multi-DonorTrustFundforAcceleratingGrowthandReformsMIS ManagementInformationSystemMIS ManagementInformationSystemsMoF MinistryofFinance
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 20171
![Page 3: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
MTDS: MediumTermDebtManagementStrategyMWP MinistryofWaterandPowerNEECA NationalEnergyEf�iciencyandConservationAuthorityNEPRA NationalElectricPowerRegulatoryAuthorityPC PrivatizationCommissionPEECA PunjabEnergyEf�iciencyandConservationAgencyPEFMA PakistanElectricFansManufacturersAssociationPSE PublicSectorEnterprisePSEs PublicSectorEnterprisesRE Recipient-executedRETF Recipient-executedtrustfundRFO ResidualFurnaceOilROSC ReportonObservanceofStandardsandCodesSLIC StateLifeInsuranceCompanySN-DeMPA SubnationalDebtManagementPerformanceAssessmentSOE State-ownedenterpriseSOE state-ownedenterprisesSRO StatutoryRegulatoryOrderT&D Transmission&distributionTA TechnicalassistanceTF TrustfundUNCTAD UnitedNationsConferenceonTradeandDevelopmentVAT Value-addedtaxWBG WorldBankGroup
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 20172
![Page 4: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
OVERVIEW Multi Donor Trust Fund for Accelerating Growth and Reforms
Overthepastsixmonths,asetofconcretemilestoneshavebeenachievedbytheMultiDonorTrustfundforAcceleratingGrowth andReforms (MDTF-AGR) through technical assistance (TA) and continuous support to Federal and provincialinstitutions.WithregardtotheDebtManagementReforms,goodprogresswasmadeunderthePunjabDebtManagementSupport Program, revolving principally around supporting sound debtmanagement operations, capacity building, andstrengtheningdebtmanagementat theprovincial level. ARecipient-executedTrustFund(RETF)wasapproved for theMinistryofFinance(MoF)underwhichtheMinistrywouldbesupportedinthemonitoringandevaluationoftheMediumTermDebtManagementStrategy(MTDMS),improvingcoordinationamongdebtagenciesatfederallevel,managingrisksinthedebtportfolioandmonitoringandevaluationoftheMTDMS.
The EnergyReform component nowhas in place a practical programof support for strengthening and revision of theregulatoryframework,andtheoperationalizationof theGovernment'sreformvision intheoilandgassector. ProgramimplementationwithNationalElectricPowerRegulatoryAuthority(NEPRA)hasalsoprogressedwell,andanumberoftechnicalandregulatoryinitiativeshavebeensupported.However,therehasnotbeensigni�icantactivitywiththeMinistryofWaterandPower(MWP),norwiththePrivatizationCommission(PC),whichmirrorstheprogressintheworkprogramsoftheseagenciesandtheirevolvingpriorities.Giventhestallingoftheprivatizationprogram,focuswillhenceforthbeonthereformsneededwithinthepowersectorstate-ownedenterprises(SOEs).
Due to the slowdown in theprivatizationprocess, the formerSOEandPrivatization componenthashad to reorient itsactivitiestofocusmoreonprivatesectordevelopmentwithemphasisonenhancedcompetition,transparency,accountabilityandsectoralreformstoenhancethecompetitivenessoftheprivatesector.InadditiontoactivitiescompletedunderthePublicSectorEnterprises(PSE)RegulatoryandMonitoringFramework,PSECorporateGovernanceReforms,andPublicPrivatePartnership (PPP) Development, the Private Sector Development program is undertaking two new subtasks i.e. a Jobs
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 20173
![Page 5: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
diagnostic;andastudyontheEconomicempowermentofwomen.ThejobdiagnosticwillhelpdeterminetheaggregatetrendsinemploymentandproductivityandfactorsbehindGrossDomesticProduct(GDP)percapitaandlaborproductivitychanges,whilsttheEconomicEmpowermentofWomenstudywillbeusefulinunderstandingthedriversandinhibitorstowomenemploymentopportunitiesinPakistan.
Afteradvancingrapidlyoverthe�irst22monthsofitsoperations,theTaxPolicyandTaxAdministrationReformcomponentisnowatastrategicturningpoint.Detailedreformplanshavebeenpreparedfollowingaseriesofcomprehensivediagnostics.Goingforward,theemphasiswillnowbeonimplementingthekeypillarsoftherequiredreformsunderthecomponent.Atthefederallevel,plannedactivitieswillfocusonanumberoftasksintaxpolicy,ICTandaudit.Attheprovinciallevel,theteamwillcontinuetosupportpartnersinPunjabandSindhwithrevenuepolicyandadministrationreforms. TherecentlyapprovedRETFwillenabletheFederalRevenueBoard(FBR)toimplementpolicyinformeddecisionsindomesticrevenuemobilization,therebyimprovingproductionofannualcomprehensivetaxexpenditureanalysis;andforecastsofannualtaxrevenuesofFBRandprovincialgovernments.
TheMDTF-AGRreceivedanadditionalUS$4.48millioncoveringOctober2016toMarch2017.Thusfar,atotalofUS$20.5millionhasbeenreceived.TotaldisbursementsstandatUS$12million(59percent).TheTrustFund(TF)hascommittedUS$7.6millionandforecastexpendituresofUS$5.9millionfromApriltoSeptember2017,includingRETFactivities.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 20174
![Page 6: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Distribution of funds (US$ mn)
RETF (Debt Management)7%
RETF(Tax Reforms)22%
Tax Policy andTax Administration Reform35%
Energy SectorReform Support12%
SOE Reforms and Privatization10%
IFC Punjab Energy Efciency 4%Debt Management Support Program5%
0
Grant Amount USD
Disbursements USD
Tax Policy & Tax AdministrationReform
1,000,000
Disbursement and commitments against each child TF
Dept ManagementSupport Program
SOE Reforms and Privatization
Energy Sector Reform Support
IFC Punjab Energy EfciencyIFC SOE Reforms and PrivatizationProgram Management
Commitments USD
Forecast
7,586,08
5,752,94
325,253
1,800,00
1,050,00
702,114
76,805
150,000
2,270,00
1,904,30
190,436
1,200,00
338,438
258,699
5,319
50,000
2,650,00
2,123,61
402,781
800,000
814,967
814,966
-
800,000
472,158
246,038
100,000
IFC SOE Reforms & Privatization4%Program Management1%
US $2,000,000
3,000,000
4,000,000
5,000,000
6,000,000
7,000,000
8,000,000
RETF (Debt Management) RETF (Tax Reforms)
1,500,00
1,500,00
500,000
4,900,00
4,900,00
1,300,00
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 20175
![Page 7: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
TheDebtManagementReforms(DMR)componentoftheMDTF-AGRisaimedatstrengtheningdebtmanagementatthenationalandsub-nationallevels.Atthefederallevel,DMRisexpectedtohelptheGovernmentofPakistan(GOP)monitorandevaluate a debtmanagement strategy that contributes to �iscal anddebt sustainabilitywhileminimizing funding costs.Achievingthiswillrequirebuildingcapacityintheentitiesresponsiblefordifferentdebtmanagementfunctions.ThedesignofthefederalprogramisbasedontheGOP'srequesttostrengthenthreeinstitutions:theDebtPolicyCoordinationOf�ice(DPCO)MOF,theExternalFinance(EF)Wing(MOF)andtheEconomicAffairsDivision(EAD)asstandaloneentitiesresponsiblefordebtmanagement.Accordingly,thefederalcomponentofDMRisdesignedtoimprovedebtmanagementpracticesbyhelpingtheauthoritiesstrengthenthreekey functions: (i) themonitoring&evaluationofadebtmanagementstrategyandriskmanagementattheDPCO,(ii)externaldebtrecordingandreportingattheEADand(iii)fundinginexternalmarketsattheEF
Duration: December 2014- December 2018Program Development ObjectiveTo ensure that government debt management in Pakistan (both at the national and subnational levels) is on a sound policy and operational footing, so as to contribute to the wider objectives of sustaining macroeconomic stability and ensuring the efciency of the government's nancial management.
Overview
Debt Management Reforms
Execution Mode: Bank Executed (BE)
US$ 1,050,000Allocated Budget:
US$ 76,805 (7.3%)Outstanding Commitments:
US$ 702,114 (66.9%)Disbursement till April 15, 2017:
for the period from April-September 2017 Expenditure forecasts:
Bank Executed Trust Fund (BETF): US$ 150,000
RETF: US$ 500,000
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 20176
![Page 8: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Wing(MOF).TheseactivitieswillbecarriedoutthroughtwostandaloneRETFs,oneencompassingtheDPCOandExternalFinanceWing(MOF)andtheotherfortheEAD.However,�inalizingactivitiesunderthefederalcomponenthastakentime,givenitscomplexityandinvolvementofmultiplestakeholders.Pakistan's �iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th ConstitutionalAmendment.OnJuly12015,theNationalEconomicCouncildecidedtoallowtheprovincestoborrowinthedomesticmarket.Thischangehasheightenedtheneedtostrengthennotonlyfederalbutalsoprovincialdebtmanagementandthus,theDMRprogramalsoworksatthesubnationallevel-inSindhandPunjab.Thisaccountsforalmost75percentofPakistan'stotalsubnationaldebt.
TheachievementsoftheDMRcomponentincludeonsitemissions,offsitesupportandcontinuedengagementwithclientagencies.
Atthefederallevel,achievementshaveincludedsupportingMoF(DPCOandEFWing)insettinguptherecipient-executedtrustfundintermsof�iduciaryandprocurementrelatedactivities.ThegrantagreementofMoFRETFwassignedinthe�irstweekofJune2017andhasbeendeclaredeffective.
ThecomponenthasalsohelpedEADindesigningactivitiesunderthestandaloneRETFsetup.Moreover,thedraftagreementforProvisionofTechnicalAssistance(TA)withtheUnitedNationsConferenceonTradeandDevelopment(UNCTAD),whichistheproprietorofDMFAS,hasbeenclearedbyEAD.ThisprojectrevolvesaroundupgradingthecurrentversionoftheDMFASandtheassociatedcapacitybuilding.Giventheextensivebureaucraticrequirementsneededtokick-startRETFsfromtheclient'sside,thesettingupofthesewindowshasbeenunderprocessforawhile.
At the subnational level, considerable progress has been made on activities for the �irst year under the Punjab DebtManagementSupportProgram.Themainactivitiesrevolvearound(i)supportingsounddebtmanagementoperationsininternal organization, reporting and operational risk as far as PunjabDebtManagement Unit (DMU) is concerned, (ii)
Implementation Performance and Achievements as of March 2017
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 20177
![Page 9: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
comprehensivecapacitybuildingonconceptualunderpinningsrelevanttodebtmanagement,and(iii)strengtheningdebtmanagementoftheprovinceplanstotapmarketsinnearfuture.
Moreover,thesubnationalcomponenthascontinuouslygaugedtheprogressundertheSindhDebtManagementSupportProgram.TheDMRissupportingtheGovernmentofSindhindesigninganappropriatedebtmanagementstrategyandacomprehensiveTAisinplaceforthistask.
Workisunderprogressondesigningadebtcash�lowprojectiontoolforbothSindhandPunjab.Inthisregardandtoreinforceownership,DMUof�icialsfrombothgovernmentsattendedaninternshipinWashington,DCorganizedbyWBTreasuryinDecember2016.Thetool'spurposeistoallowforbetterrecordkeepingandreportingonthesubnationalfuturedebtservicepayments. Nonetheless, such a tool cannot replace a debtmanagement information system,with secure database andprocessingcapabilities.OffsitesupportwasalsoprovidedtotheGovernmentofSindhonthedesignofitsdomesticborrowingoptions.
Onthecapacitybuildingfront,threekeytrainingswereheldtostrengthensubnationaldebtmanagement:(i)SubnationalDebtManagementPerformanceAssessment(SN-DeMPA)methodologyorganizedinLahoreduring26to28October2016,(ii)DebtManagement(DeM)StrategyconductedinKarachiduring31Octoberto2November2016,and(iii)afollow-upDeMStrategyheldinIslamabadduring20to25February2017.ParticipantsfromallprovincialFinanceDepartments(FD)andPlanningandDevelopmentDepartments(includingFederallyAdministeredTribalAreas)and(selected)academicsattendedthe�irsttwoevents.Thethirdeventwasastepfurtherwithaselectgroupofof�icials(includingDMUstafffromPunjabandSindh)fromacrossprovinceswhowereassistedinusingtheMedium-TermDebtManagementStrategy(MTDS)AnalyticalToolbyde�iningandanalyzingvariousstrategiesbasedonfundingoptionsavailabletothem.
Theoverallprogramhasalsohelpedof�icialsfromallclientagenciestoparticipateinspecializedtraining,mostlyorganizedinternationally.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 20178
![Page 10: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Atthefederallevel,MoFwillbesupportedinexecutingtheRETF(June-September2017).Speci�ically,DPCOwillbesupportedinthemonitoringandevaluation(M&E)ofMTDS2015/16–18/19implementation,improvingcoordinationamongstalldebtagencieswithinthefederalarenaandmanagingrisksinherentinPakistan'sdebtportfolio.Inaddition,thissub-componentwillfacilitateEFWingininitiatingthecomprehensivecapacitybuildingprogramenvisagedundertheproject(July2017).Moreover,EADwillbesupportedininitiatingitsRETF(June-September2017).Thissub-componentwillalsostrivetoenableclientagencies'stafftoparticipateininternationalandlocalspecializedtraining(asandwhenrequired).
Atthesubnationallevel,theGovernmentsofPunjabandSindhwillcontinuetobesupportedincarryingoutactivitiesundertheirrespectivePrograms.Speci�ically,ongoingsupportwillbeprovidedin�inalizingthedebtcash�lowprojectiontoolaswellasindesigningadebtmanagementstrategyforSindh.Moreover,boththegovernmentswillbeassistedinpreparationforexecutingtheirdomesticdebtissuanceplan.
Theprogramalsoenvisagescontinuingknowledge-sharingevents(forallprovinces)suchasholdingamootinIslamabadondebtmanagementgovernancearrangementsatthesub-nationallevelinSeptember/October2017andenablingsubnationalgovernmentstafftoparticipateinlocalaswellasinternationaldebtmanagementtrainingandforums.
Planned Activities
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017WithintheNationalEconomicCouncil(NEC)limits1
1
9
![Page 11: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Energy Sector Reforms
Duration: December 2014- December 2018 Program Development ObjectiveTo support the Government of Pakistan's energy sector reforms program by strengthening the capacity of key institutions to design, implement, monitor and communicate the reform agenda.
Execution Mode: BE
US$ 2,650,000.00Allocated Budget:
US$ 402,780.94Outstanding Commitments:
US$ 123,609.57Available Balance:
Disbursement (for the period from October 2016-March 2017):
for the period from April-September 2017 Expenditure forecasts:
BETF: US$ 600,000 (disbursing existing commitments, plus US$200,000
in new commitments).
TheprimaryfocusoftheEnergyProgramhasbeenondeepeningtheengagementinthegassectortosupportacomprehensivemarket,structuralandregulatoryreforminthemid-streamanddownstreamaswellasaddressinglong-standingissuesintheupstreamoilandgassector. ThereformprocessisdrivenbytheMinistryofPetroleumandNaturalResources(MPNR)andinvolveskeysectorentities,includingtheDirectorateGeneralforPetroleumConcessions(DGPC)andOilandGasRegulatoryAuthority(OGRA).Apracticalprogramofsupportisnowinplacetosupportthestrengtheningandrevisionoftheregulatoryframework,andsupportingtheoperationalizationoftheGovernment'sreformvision.ProgramimplementationwithNEPRAhasprogressedwell,withanumberoftechnicalandregulatoryinitiativesbeingsupportedbytheProgram.Therehasbeennosigni�icantactivitywiththeMinistryofWaterandPower(MWP)andPCre�lectingtheprogressinthoseagencies'workprogramandevolvingpriorities.
Overview
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201710
![Page 12: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Implementation Performance and Achievements as of March 2017
Support toNEPRA: During the reportingperiod, international expert advisors engagedunder theProgram supportedNEPRAtariffdepartmentinareviewoftherateofreturnmethodology,andinthereviewofthemulti-yeartariffforK-Electric,withapendingchangeininvestor.Inaddition,theinternationalexpertsalsoprovidedinputstoNEPRAinitseffortstodevelopnewtransmissiontariffguidelines.
SupporttoNEPRA:TheinternationalexpertsprovidedfollowonsupporttoNEPRAinthereviewofatariffpetitionforaproposed 660 kV HVDC Transmission Line, including in the form of identi�ication of signi�icant cost and regulatoryimprovementsbasedoninternationalgoodpractice.
SupporttoMWP:Noactivitieswereinitiated.ThekeydevelopmentonthisfrontwastheprovisionofcommentsontheGovernment proposal related tomoving of independent regulatory agencies under administrative control of the lineministries.
SinceSeptember2016,thefollowingachievementsweremade:
PowerSectorReform
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017
Supportforgassectorreformimplementation:ThereformprocesshasbeenledbyMPNR,andwassupervisedbyahigh-levelforum,titledtheGasSectorLeadershipCommittee,comprisingoftheFederalMinisterforPetroleumandNaturalResourcesasthechairandtheprovincialenergyministersasmembers.TheReformProgramteamhasbeensupportingMPNRineffortstooperationalizethereformvision,implementtheagreedactionsinaconsultativemanner,bringingtogetherallkeysectorstakeholders.ToprovidetherequiredtechnicalinputsandadvisorysupporttotheTechnicalCommittees,LeadershipCommittee, and the key agencies, the Energy Program Management Team, with TAGR funding, engaged a series ofindependentinternationalexpertconsultants.TheresultingSectorReformSupportteamcurrentlycomprisesagassectorstructuretechnicaladvisor,agassectorregulatoryadvisor,agassectorpolicyconsultant,apolicyandlegalexpertanda
GasSectorReform
11
![Page 13: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
�inancialandtariffexpert.Todate,threemeetingsoftheGasSectorLeadershipCommitteeandmorethandozensofworkinggroupmeetingsdedicatedtospeci�ictechnicalissueshavebeenheld,inIslamabad,andremotely,withsupportfromTAGR.
SupporttoMPNRindevelopinggassectorreformpolicystatement:Duringthereportingperiod,supportwasprovidedtoMPNRinthedevelopmentofapolicystatementthatformalizestheGovernment'svisionforgassectorreform.
SupporttoOGRAonkeyregulatoryactivities: Inthe lastsixmonths,signi�icantprogresshasbeenmadewithsupporttowardsthestrengtheningofthemid-anddownstreamgassectorregulatoryframework. DuringthereportingperiodimplementationoftheprogramoftechnicalsupporttotheOilandGasRegulatoryAuthority(OGRA),progresswasmadeunderseveralworkstreams(i)Thirdpartyaccesstonetworks,(ii)Tariffs,and(iii)Licensing.Technicalworkinggroups,ledbyOGRA,andwithparticipationfromsectoroperatingcompanies,madesubstantialprogressinrevisingthethirdpartyaccessrules,thelicensingframework(includingseparationoftransmission,distribution,andsalefunctions),anewtariffmethodology (which allows ring-fencing of RLNG costs, separation of transmission, distribution, and sale tariffs, andintroducesimprovementstotherateofreturnmethodologyforsettingtariffs),andend-consumertariffandsubsidypolicyforareformeddownstreamgassector(SeeTablebelow).Advanceddraftsofrelevantregulatorydocumentshavebeendeveloped by the OGRA-led working group support in a consultative manner with the participation of key sectorstakeholders,andwithcontinuingfacilitationandtechnicaladvisoryfromtheTAGR�inancedreformsupportteam.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017
SupporttoDGPC:Duringthereportingperiod,twointernationalexpertswereengagedtoreviewDGPCstructureandrulesofbusiness,andidentifyoptionsforincorporationofprovincialrepresentativesintoDGPCoperationsandprocesses.ThefocusofthetaskwastooutlinearangeofoptionsforincorporationofnewprovincialrepresentativesinDGPC'sdailyoperations,anddevelopmentofrulesofbusinessthatwouldfacilitatetheeventualindependenceofDGPC,andprovincialrepresentationinlinewiththe2012PetroleumPolicy.Inthisregard,adraftdiscussionnotefortheoperationalizationofare-organizedDGPCwithprovincialrepresentationhasbeensharedwithMPNR,DGPCandkeystakeholders.Thiswillbefollowedseparationofitsupstreamregulatoryfunctionsfrompolicyfunctionsandinstitutionalstrengthening.
12
![Page 14: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Implementation status of gas sector reforms
Document Status
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201713
![Page 15: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Planned Activities
Overthenextsixmonths,thefollowingactivitiesareplanned:
Support toNEPRA: Supportwill continueon transmission tariffmethodologyenhancementsandadvisory supportoncompetitionandmarketdevelopmentdirectionsisenvisaged.(BySeptember2017)
Supporttogassectorreformimplementation:Thetechnical,advisoryandimplementationsupportbeingprovidedthroughtheSectorReformSupportTeamwillcontinue,especiallyintermsofdirectsupporttoMPNRleadershiponmovingforwardin implementing thesectorreform;anddevelopingkey tenetsofa tariffandsubsidypolicy toensuresector �inancialsustainabilitygoingforward.(ThroughSeptember2017)
SupporttoOGRA:ImplementationofactivitiesintheagreedprogramofsupporttoOGRAwillcontinue,movinginparallelworkstreams:(i)Tariffsmethodology;(ii)Licensing;(iii)TPAandNetworkCode;(v)communicationsandoutreachonreform.(ThroughSeptember2017)
SupporttoDGPC:Thenextactivityisthebeginningofastudy,requestedbyMPNR,focusingonareviewofDGPCrolesandresponsibilities,andinstitutionalstructureforitsmediumtermdevelopmentintoastrongerandindependentupstreamregulatoryagency.(ThroughSeptember2017)
EnergyEf�iciency
SupporttoPunjabEnergyDepartment:TheoriginalactivitysupportedtheestablishmentandstrengtheningofthePunjabEnergyEf�iciencyandConservationAgency(PEECA)anditsinitialprogrammingisnearlycomplete,withalmostalltheallocatedfundsdisbursed. PunjabGovernmentrequestedfollowonsupportfortheinitialsetupofafanreplacementprogram,whichaimseventuallytoreplaceonemillionfanswithenergyef�icientunitsthatmeetthestandardsthathavebeensupportedundertheoriginalactivity. Thetaskteamrequestedanadditional$100,000torespondtothisrequest,whichwouldbecarriedoutwiththesupportoftheoriginalteamthatadvisedPEECA.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201714
![Page 16: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201715
![Page 17: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
IFC Support
Duration: December 2014- December 2018Program Development ObjectiveProvide transaction advisory to PC in order to attract the private sector in the efcient management and operations of one DISCO and a GENCO.
Execution Mode: Bank Executed
US$ 1.7 millionAllocated Budget:
$884,000Outstanding Commitments:
Disbursement: for the period from October – March 2017
for the period from November 2016-March 2017 Expenditure forecasts:
None given IFC's suspended mandate.
Giventhegovernment'sdecisiontostalltheprivatizationprogramespeciallywithinthepowersector,IFC'smandatesweresubsequentlyterminatedbythePC.However,thefocuswillbeonthereformsneededwithinthepowersectorSOEs.
Given the termination, IFChasdecommissioned theundisbursedamount (US$884k) to theparentTrustFund(TF) forreallocation.
Implementation Performance and Achievements as of March 2017
Overview
TheEnergyEf�iciency andConservation (EE&C)policy and regulatory framework is a recentphenomenon inPakistan,especiallyinPunjab.Thenationallevelframework(NationalEnergyEf�iciencyandConservationAuthority(NEECA)Act)wasapprovedinJuly2016.TheimplementationofnationalEE&Cpolicyandlegalframeworkisdelegatedtotheprovinces.With
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201716
![Page 18: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
WorldBankGroup(WBG)assistance,PunjabhastakentheleadondevelopingastrategicframeworkfortheEE&Cinitiativeinlinewiththerelatednationalobjectives.TheabsenceofthisframeworkinthepastwasamajorbarriertodriveasystemicchangeonEE&CcoveringbothEE&Crelatedstandardsandlabellingaswellasaddressingbehavioraltendenciesinenergyconsumption.Thelabelingschemehasjustbeenapproved(NEECAAct)andtheapplicationsforlabelsreceivedthroughourassistance.Intypicalcases,ittakesafewyearsforthisschemetotakeeffect,butthingsaremovingveryquicklyduetotheurgency toget these fansoutby this cooling season.Weareassisting theGovernmentAsianofPunjabdevelop the fanreplacementprogramwhichwillbe implementedby thegovernmentand theAsianDevelopmentBank (ADB)with thereplacementofabout1millionfansinpublicbuildings.Itisverydif�iculttoseeimpactsfromaStandards&Labellingprograminsuchashortperiodoftime.Duetoourapproachtoworkintheprovinceanddirectlywithmanufacturers,wemaybeabletoachieveimpactsinarelativelyshortperiodoftime.ThegovernmenthasalreadystartedadvertisinglabeledfansinPunjabandwewilldoanevaluation towards theendof theproject toseewhatresultshavebeenachieved.WBG isensuringclosecoordinationwithrelevantauthoritiestoovercomeimplementationchallengesinatimelymanner.
Implementation Performance and Achievements as of September 2016
Certi�icationof12PakistanEnergyLabelfans:NEECAhasplayedthemostsigni�icantroletowardsthisachievement.TheprojectfacilitatedlinksbetweenNEECA,PakistanElectricFansManufacturersAssociation(PEFMA)andthePunjabEnergyDepartment.
Baselinemarketresearchonfans:Thisisthe�irstmarketresearchonenergyef�icientPakistanEnergyLabelfansinPakistan.Themain�indingsweresharedinthesecondstakeholderworkshopandthefanmanufacturersespeciallyfoundthisveryusefultoincorporateintheirmarketingstrategies.
PunjabEnergyEf�iciencyandConservationAgency(PEECA)mediacampaigntolaunchPakistanEnergyLabels:PlayedadirectroletoconvincethePunjabgovernmenttoenhancetheirmediabudgetallocationfromamodestUSD50,000toasigni�icantUSD500,000.Helpedassessthe�ivegovernmentprequali�iedmediacompanies,andrankedthemaccordingtorequiredcompetencies.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201717
![Page 19: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
PromulgationoftheNEECAAct:Assistedinthecriticalroleofhelpinginterprettheimplicationsofthisnewlaw,especiallyforthePunjabprovince.TheprojectalsoassistedthePEECAutilizevariousprovisionsofthisfederallawtobuildtheirowncapacity.
PEFMAcollaborationwithNEECAandPEECA:Helpedconduct2StakeholderWorkshops,oneinGujratandtheotherinLahore.Theseweresuccessfulwiththeactiveparticipationofgovernmentandprivatesectorstakeholders.AsreportedbythePEFMAChairman,afterthesecondstakeholderworkshopthreeadditionalfanmanufacturershavecommittedtogettheirfanscerti�iedforthePakistanEnergyLabel.
Adoptionof250,000PakistanEnergyLabelfansforthePunjabSchoolsAsianDevelopmentBankproject:InteractedwiththeAsianDevelopmentBankprojectforsolarizationofschoolssinceAugust2016,andultimatelywasabletointegratethespeci�icationofPakistanEnergyLabelfansasaprocurementrequirement.
Designalargescale1millionfanprojectforconsiderationofdonorsandthePunjabGovernmentforeducationandhealthfacilities:Theprojectteamwasabletoconductactual�ieldsamplingofover600fansinstalledineducationandhealthfacilities.Trialreplacementrunsusingdifferentmethodsarebeingtested.
Designalargescale9millionfanprojectforconsiderationbythedonorsandPunjabGovernment:Theprojecthasdevelopedanestimationofbene�itsofPeakLoadReduction,AnnualElectricalEnergySavings,AnnualCostReductionandAnnual Greenhouse Gas emissions reduction resulting from the successful implementation of this large scale fanreplacementproject.
Refrigerators/freezersarethenextpriorityapplianceforcerti�icationofPakistanEnergyLabelforthePunjabEnergyDepartment:RespondedtoarequestfromthePunjabEnergyDepartmenttohelpidentifyapriorityapplianceforPakistanEnergyLabel.AdetailedsessionwasheldwiththePEECA,andafterconsideringallpotentialappliances,thedomesticFridge/Freezerwasselectedasthemostappropriateappliance.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201718
![Page 20: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
BetweenApril–September2017,weintendtoundertakethefollowingactivities:
PrepareandpresenttheMillion+FanProjecttothePunjabEnergyDepartment(PED)AssistthePEDtopresenttheMillion+FanProjecttoprospectivedonorsConductactual�ieldtestingofinstalledfansinPunjabSchoolsConductactualtrialreplacementrunsoffansinPunjabhealthandeducationfacilities,about400fansAssistthePEDtodevelopamonitoringandevaluationmechanismfortheir20,000fanreplacementprojectConvincethePEDtoincludeintheprojectdesignandplanstheinstallationofabout250,000PakistanEnergyLabelfansinthe20,000schoolssolarisationprojectConvincethegovernmenttoconductafollowupmarketresearchafterthecommunicationscampaignAssistPEECAtoidentifythenextpriorityapplianceforcerti�icationofPakistanEnergyLabelAssistNEECAandPEECAtodevelopamatrixofpossiblenon-complianceslinkedtothePakistanEnergyLabel,referredtoasMonitoring,EvaluationandEnforcement
Planned Activities:
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201719
![Page 21: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Private Sector Development
Duration: December 2014- December 2018Program Development ObjectiveThe development objective of this activity is to support the GoP in designing and implementing a strategic framework for PSE reforms, including effective privatization. The overall goal is to reduce the Government's direct participation in product and factor markets within a number of sectors, while increasing private sector participation and fostering competition.
Execution Mode: BE
US$ 2.17 millionAllocated Budget:
US$ 190,436Outstanding Commitments:
US$ 482,881Disbursement: for the period from April – October 2016:
Expenditure forecasts: US$ 1.2 million is expected to be committed under the
various sub-tasks till October 2017.
Owingtotheslow-downintheprivatizationprocess,thetaskteamhasreorientedactivitiesunderthecomponenttofocusonprivatesectordevelopmentgroundedinenhancedcompetition,transparency,accountabilityandsectoralreformsgearedtowardsenhancingthecompetitivenessoftheprivatesector.Thisreorientationisalsore�lectedinthenameofthecomponentwhich has been changed from 'SOE Reforms and Privatization' to 'Private Sector Development'. The component'sreorientation,goingforward,willentailcloseengagementwithsectoralregulatorybodiesandtheprivatesectorinadditiontothegovernment.Thisstrategicshiftinthenatureofactivitieswillfacilitateacceleratedgrowththroughtheapplicationofacascade approach which promotes ef�icient and just use of the scarce public and concessional resources to crowd-incommercialcapitalandminimizethepublicdebtburden.
Overview
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201720
![Page 22: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Going forward, implementationof the respective subtaskswill be carriedout exclusively throughBETF, as insteadof acombinationofBETFandRETF.WhilethetaskteamhadintendedondeliveringtwoRETFsi.e.fortheImplementationandEconomicReformsUnit(IERU)andCompetitionCommissionofPakistan(CCP),processingdelayscoupledwiththeguidancereceivedduringthelaststeeringcommitteemeetinghaveledtothetaskteamdecidingagainstrecipientledimplementation.
Thekeydevelopmentoutcomesaretwo-fold:(i)the�iscaldrainonthegovernment'sscarceresourcesislikelytobereduced,and these resources can be redirected towards other socio-economic development goals; (ii) increased private sectorparticipationislikelytobringinprofessionalmanagement,investment,innovation,higherproductivity,andbetterservicedeliveryforconsumers.
Implementation Performance and Achievements as of March 2017
ThePrivateSectorDevelopmentpillarofMDTF-AGRisaprogrammaticTechnicalAssistance(TA)comprisedofthefollowingsevencomplementaryactivities(alsoreferredtoassubtasks).Theseactivitiesinclude:
1.PSERegulatoryandMonitoringFramework;2.PSECorporateGovernanceReforms;3.CapacitybuildingofthePC;4.PPPdevelopment;and5.TechnicalassistancetotheCCP;6.Jobsdiagnostic;and7.Economicempowermentofwomen
Thefollowingactivitieshavebeencompletedundertherespectivesub-taskssinceOctober2016:
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201721
![Page 23: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
PSERegulatoryandMonitoringFramework
Inlinewiththespeci�icsinthepreviousprogressreport,andgiventhecurrentstatusoftheprivatizationprogram,thePSERegulatory andMonitoring Framework subtask is nowgeared towards ensuring that the federal and subnational PSEsoperateef�icientlyandtransparentlywithclearaccountabilities.
TheCorporateFinanceUnitof theFinanceDepartment,GovernmentofPunjabhasbeensupportedover thepast sixmonths,includingsupporttotheunitindevelopingareportingformat,datarequirements,andadministrativeregulationsforprovincialPSEstoreporton�inancialperformanceandcompliancewiththeCorporateGovernanceRulesissuedbytheSECP.
Thissubtaskalsosupportedtwoconsultantsdevelopinga�inancialreportingsystemforPSEs.
PSECorporateGovernanceReforms
TheCorporateGovernanceAssessment forStateLife InsuranceCompany (SLIC)wascompleted.SLIC isaPSEand isPakistan'slargestinsurancecompanywithover5millionpolicyholders.TheCGassessmentreport's20recommendationsfocusonenhancingtheindependenceoftheBoardofDirectors,strengtheningtheBoardCommittees,limitingtheroleofthe Ministry of Commerce in day-to-day administration, empowering management, and improving the controlenvironment.Implementationoftheassessment'srecommendationswillservetoenhancetheef�icienciesofthecompanyandmayattractprivatesectorinvestmentandremoveentrybarriersinPakistan'sinsurancesector.
AReportonObservanceofStandardsandCodes(ROSC)onAuditingandAccountswascompletedforPakistan.Standardsand codes are benchmarks of good practices. TheROSC initiativewas launched in 1999 (byWBG and InternationalMonitoryFund)asaprominentcomponentofeffortstostrengthentheinternational�inancialarchitecture.Theinitiativeaims at promoting greater �inancial stability, both domestically and internationally, through the development,dissemination,adoption,andimplementationofinternationalstandardsandcodes.AspartoftheROSC,theAccountingandAuditing (A&A)modulecovers twogloballyacceptedstandards: the InternationalFinancialReportingStandards
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201722
![Page 24: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
(IFRS)andtheInternationalStandardsonAuditing(ISA).TheROSCalsolookedattheAuditingandAccountingpracticesofPSEsinPakistanandmademultiplerecommendationstoimprovetheaccountingpractices,fostergreateref�icienciesandenhancetransparency.
CapacityBuildingofPC
Thissubtaskhasbeendroppedfromthepillarowingtothecessationofthegovernment'sprivatizationprogram.Thetaskisbeingreplacedbyanewsubtasktitled'Cascade',detailsonwhicharegivenbelow.
PPPDevelopment
Activities under this subtask entailed support to the provinces and the federal government in the development of acomprehensiveframeworkforPPPs.
Balochistan:ADiagnosticonPPPReadinesswasdeliveredtotheGovernmentofBalochistan.
Sindh:TheSindhFiscalManagementFrameworkforPPPswasdeliveredbypreparingandhandingoverthereporttotheFinanceDepartment,GovernmentofSindh.WBGexpertsalsodeliveredatrainingtotheof�icialsofthePPPcellofSindhontheimplementationmodalitiesoftheframework.
KhyberPakhtunkhwa(KP):TheteampreparedanactionplanfortheGovernmentofKhyberPakhtunkhwa(GoKP)PPPcellinadditiontoprovidingcommentsontheKP'sPPPActandgivingtrainingtoof�icialsoftheGoKPsPPPcell.Thisactivitywasalsousedtodevelopinter-provincialdialogueandcoordinationbetweentheGoKPandGovernmentofSindhonPPPs.ThePPPteamofSindhhastrained5of�icialsfromKP'sPPPunit,PlanningandDevelopmentandTourismDepartmentsandtheprocesswillcontinue.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201723
![Page 25: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Federal:WBGsPPPexpertsreviewedthefederalPPPActandprovidedextensivecommentsonthegaps.TheremightbeanopportunitytotakesomethingoutofthisasaprioractionforthenextDPC.
AssistancetoCCP
ActivitiesunderthissubtaskoftheprivatesectordevelopmentpillarwereputonholdowingtoalackofclarityRETF.Basedontheclaritygiventothetaskteamintherecentlyheldsteeringcommitteemeeting,andthefeedbackfromCCP,mostoftheactivities initially proposed under the RETF will be undertaken, through the ongoing BETF. These activities includecompetitionassessments,advocacyworkshopsandreviewofregulations/guidelinesetc.
JobsDiagnostic
Theteamhasmadesigni�icantprogressonthefollowinganalyticalactivitiesaimedatdeliveringa'core'JobsDiagnosticanalysisbasedoneasilyaccessibledata:
Demographics and Structural Transformation and Jobs: This analysis examines aggregate trends in employment andproductivityandfactorsbehindGDPpercapitaandlaborproductivitychanges.
Workers and Jobs:This analysisprovides themostup-to-date informationon the supply sideof the labormarket inPakistan.Itlooksatkeylabormarketoutcomesfordifferentpopulationgroups(byage,gender,education,etc.)acrossprovincesandtrendsovertime.Itdescribesthekeycharacteristicsoftheworkingagepopulationwithafocusonyouthandfemaleworkers.Theanalysisalsodelvesintothedeterminantsoflaborforceparticipation,unemployment,employmenttype,andearnings.
FirmsandJobs:ThisanalysiscontainsdetailedtrendsinemploymentbysectorincludingbyprovinceandbygenderusingLaborForceSurveydata.Italsolooksintothecharacteristicsofformalsector�irmsandemploymentinthemanufacturingsector in Punjab using the Census of Manufacturing Industries (2005 and 2011), analyzes and benchmarks labor
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201724
![Page 26: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
productivity and TFP, and discusses the relationship between productivity and employment. Finally, it presents keyconstraints �irms face based on theEnterprise Survey (ES) analysis by province and sector. The team isworkingoncorroboratingtheanalysisbasedonCMIwiththeESdata.
TheteamhasdraftPowerPointsofallanalysisandisworkingonareport,summarizingthekey�indings,whichwillbereadybyendMay/earlyJune.
EconomicEmpowermentofWomen
In order to develop a roadmap to increasewomen empowerment (employment) by eliminating constraints towomenparticipationineconomicactivities,thefollowingactivitywascarriedoutunderthissubtask:
A"CorporateSurveyforUnderstandingDriversofWomenEmploymentinPakistan'wasundertakentounderstandthedriversandinhibitorstowomenemploymentopportunitiesinPakistan.Throughdetailedinterviewsheldwithregisteredprivate �irms, labor contractors and focus group sessionswithwomen employees, the survey report documents thechallengesandgoodcorporatepracticesinPakistan, includingthecontributionsthatwomenmaketothesocietyandorganizations.Thesurveyaimstoenhanceawarenesstogovernmentandthebusinesssectoraboutchallengestowomenemploymentandproviderecommendationsonhowthechallengescanbeaddressed.
Planned Activities
PSERegulatoryandMonitoringFramework
Thefollowingactivitieswillbeundertakenoverthenextsixmonths:
ContinuedsupporttothePunjabFinanceDepartmenttoestimatethecontingentliabilitiesarisingfromtheSOEportfolio.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201725
![Page 27: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
SupportwillbeprovidedtotheFinanceDepartmenttoestablishamonitoringsystemtooverseethecomplianceofitsPSCswiththeSECPrules.
SupporttoIERUtopublishthenextSOEPerformanceReport.
PSECorporateGovernanceReforms
TheROSConCorporateGovernancewillbecommenced.TheobjectivesofthisROSCareto:
BenchmarkPakistan's corporategovernance frameworkandcompanypracticesagainst theG20/OECDPrinciples forCorporateGovernance.
AssistPakistanindevelopingandimplementingacountryactionplanforimprovinginstitutionalcapacitytostrengthenthecorporategovernanceframework.
Raiseawarenessofgoodcorporategovernancepracticesamongpublicandprivatesectorstakeholders.
ThisROSCwillincludeacomponentonSOE'sandwillreviewthepublicsectorsperformanceincomplyingwiththePSECorporateGovernanceAct(2013).
Cascade(previouslyCapacityBuildingofPC)
Thecascadeapproachwillbeadoptedtofurtherbolsterthedevelopmentobjectiveofthepillar.Theapproachwillfacilitatethecreationofmarketsandaddressconstraints toprivatesectordevelopment through themobilizationof commercial�inancing.Cascadingwillexpandtheoptionsavailabletoclientsfor�inancinganddeliveringondevelopmentgoals.Itwill
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201726
![Page 28: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
promoteef�icientandjustuseofthescarcepublicandconcessionalresourcestocrowd-incommercialcapitalandminimizethepublicdebtburden.
Cascadingwillfurtherthedevelopmentobjectivebyidentifyingactivitieswhichcannotbesponsoredthroughcommercialcapitalduetomarketfailures.Insuchcases,thissubtaskwillbeutilizedtoidentifyreformsnecessarytoaddresssuchfailures.
TheWBGiswellpositionedtoplayaroleincrowding-inprivateinvestment,especiallyForeignDirectInvestmentthroughinvestmentpolicy,legalandregulatoryreformssuchas:
Federallevelreformstopromotenewinvestmentandtradediversi�ication;
Province-speci�icinvestmentclimatereformswithaparticularfocusoninvestmentpoliciesandinvestmentpromotionstrategies;
Regulatoryreformsforeaseofdoingbusinessforlocalandforeign�irmswhichrequireabigpushtowardsincreasingthetransparency, consistencyandpredictability in complianceandenforcementmatters.Regulatorydelivery inPakistanneedstogoonlineusingelectronicsingle-windowsolutions;
Modernization of sectoral policies, laws and regulation to encourage investment into untapped yet promisingopportunitiessuchasintheagribusiness,auto,lightengineering,constructionmaterials,andhomeappliances;and
Pricecontrolsandcompetitionreformstopromoteforeignanddomesticinvestment.
Reformsinitiatedthroughthissubtaskwillhelptoreduceriskstoprivateinvestment,andwillcontributetoopeningupopportunitiesforpublic-privatepartnerships,especiallyforaddressingurbanandindustrialinfrastructuregaps.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201727
![Page 29: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
PPPDevelopment
Thefollowingactivitieswillbecarriedoutunderthissubtaskinthecoming6-12months:
ContinuedsupporttoSindh.Thissupport,amongstotherareas,willleadtothedevelopmentofStandardOperatingProceduresformanagingPPPFiscalCommitmentandContingentLiabilities(FCCL);ii)buildingcapacityofthePPPsectornodesinProjectSelectionmethodologyandFCCLmatters,andiii)initiatethescopingofguaranteeproductsforthePPPprojectsinSindh.
ContinuedengagementwithKP.ThiswillincludecapacitybuildingandassessmentandshortlistingofthePPPpipeline.ThisengagementwillserveasabridgeandwilleventuallycomplementtheupcomingengagementwiththegovernmentonTourismandPeshawar-TorkhamEconomicCorridorprojects.
Thissubtaskwillalsocontribute to thepipeline InfrastructureFinancing lendingoperationof theWBG.ThepipelineoperationwillhaveaPPPcomponentatthefederallevelwhichisexpectedtobeimplementedthroughthePPPAuthorityandProjectDevelopmentFund.
AssistancetoCCP
TheteamwillbeundertakingmostoftheactivitiesinitiallyproposedtobeundertakenthroughtheRETFundertheon-goingBETF.Thefollowingactivitiesaregoingtobecarriedoutunderthissubtaskoverthenext6months:
Reviewofthenewadoptedmergerregulations.Thisreviewwillimprovetheef�iciencyoftheprocessofmergerreview,includingthecostsavingsassociatedwithmergerreviewfortheCCPandprivatesector.
Designofguidelinesfortheeconomicanalysisofmergers(includingnon-horizontalmergers).ThiswillimprovetheinteractionbetweenthemergingpartiesandtheCCPoutsidethemergerhearingprocess,adjustthetimeallocatedto
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201728
![Page 30: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
mergerreviewaccordingtothecomplexityofthecase,andsupportthesoundeconomicanalysisofmergers.
Guidelines on steps for exemptions authorization. This activity will improve the ef�iciency for exemptionauthorizations,reducecasebacklog,shiftresourcestotheanalysisofmostharmfulanti-competitivepractices
Designingguidelinesformarketinquiries.ThisactivitywillimprovetheeffectivenessofCCPmarketinquiriesthroughthereviewofguidelinesforthecollectionandexaminationofmarketinformation
Draftingguidelinesonpro-competitivedesignoftenders.Thisactivitywillminimizerisksofbidriggingduringthepublicprocurementprocess.TheactivitywillentailclosecoordinationbothwiththeCCPandthePublicProcurementRegulatoryAuthority.
CompetitionAssessmentonTelecomSector.Thetaskteamhascommissionedacompetitionassessmentonthetelecomsector;the�irstdraftofthereportwillbesharedwiththeCCPbyOctober2017.TheobjectiveofthisassignmentistopromoteaframeworkthatwillallowtheCompetitionCommissionofPakistantounderstandmarket-relatedcompetitionconstraintsandidentifypro-activelycompetitionpolicyreformstogetherwiththesectoralregulator.Thisassignmentwillbeguidedbymethodologiestoidentifyregulatorybarrierstocompetition,suchastheMarketsandCompetitionPolicyToolkit(MCPAT).
EconomicEmpowermentofWomen
TheabovementionedcorporatesurveywhichwasundertakentounderstandthedriversofemploymentofwomeninPakistanwillserveasthefoundationforadditionalsectorspeci�icanalysesunderthissubtask.Theseanalyses,tentatively,willcoverselect sectors, includinghighvalue services, retail and apparel. The analyseswill entail a deeperdive into the sectoraldynamicsandpoliciesthatgoverntheparticipationofwomenintheidenti�iedsectors.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201729
![Page 31: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
JobsDiagnostic
Thefollowingactivitiesareplannedforthenext6months:
Constraintstofemalelaborforceparticipationandaccesstobetterjobs.Theteamwillexpandontheexistinganalysistobetterelaborateonsuchdimensionsashomebasedwork,highwagedifferentialsinthemanufacturingsectors,andrelationshipbetween femaleemployment,household laborsupply,andpoverty (incollaborationwithPovertyGP).Aqualitativeanalysisisbeingundertakentobetterunderstandfemalebarriersandconstraintstoaccesstojobs(next12months).
Household enterprises. The team will �inalize analysis of informal employment and productivity of householdenterpriseswhichemployalargeshareoftheemployed.
Stock-takeofgovernmentprograms.Theteamwillcompletethestock-takingtoidentifyspeci�icareaswheretheWBGcanfocusitsinterventionsintheshorttomediumtermtomaximizeimpactsonjobs.
JobspotentialofICTsector.Theteamwill�inalizeashortnoteestimatingthejobspotentialofICTanddiscussingpoliciestomaximizetheeconomicandsocialimpactofICT.
The abovementioned analyticalwork, coupledwith additional analytical reports,will by the endof next FY lead to thepreparationofanupdated/expandedJobsDiagnosticreportoraseriesofcomplementaryanalyticalandpolicynotes(tobedecided),includingrecommendationsforaJobsStrategytoaddressthejobschallengesidenti�ied.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201730
![Page 32: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Tax Policy and Tax Administration Reform
Duration: December 2014- December 2018Program Development ObjectiveIncreased tax collection by at least 2 percentage points of GDP (from 2013/14) and by no less than the average ination rate.
Execution Mode: Bank Executed (BE)
US $7,586,087Allocated Budget as of April 12, 2017:
US $6,078,198Actual + Commitments:
US $1,507,889Available Budget:
US $1,760,028Disbursement: from October 2016 – March 2017:
Expenditure forecasts: April 2017 - September 2017:
The taxation component of the Trust Fund advanced rapidlywith strong client demand during the �irst 22months ofoperations,howeveritisnowatastrategicturningpoint.Aseriesofcomprehensivediagnosticssetsoutdetailedplansforthereformsplannedovertheimplementationperiod.TheWorldBankhassharedwithFederal(FBR)andprovincialauthoritiesinSindhandPunjabkeydeliverablesincludinganICTstrategy,changemanagementprograms,implementationplans,taxauditstrategy,trackandtraceprojectdocument,processmappingandbusinessprocessreengineering,tonameafew.TheWorldBankisnowplacingmoreemphasisonmonitoringtheimplementationofthekeypillarsintheTaxComponent.Theworkprogramisexpectedtoendin2018andthusgoingforward,thechallengeistosustainthereformagendaandsuccessfullyimplementthevariousreforminitiatives.
Overview
BETF: US $1,800,000
RETF: US $4,900,000
Total: US $6,700,000
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201731
![Page 33: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
AdvisoryCommitteeActivities
1. An Advisory Committee comprising representatives from the DFID, the IMF, and the World Bank guidesimplementationof the tax componentof theTAGR.ThisCommitteeprovides strategic adviceandquality controlofimplementationreports.TheAdvisoryCommitteemeetsvirtually,reviewingelectroniccopiesoftheimplementationreportandrelatedannexes,andprovidestechnicalrecommendationsandadvicetotheteamontheworkprogram.InFebruary,therewasameetingoftheACinIslamabadwheretheWBmadeapresentationonprogressmadeinimplementingthetaxpillarofTAGR.Inthismeeting,itwasdiscussedtoputinplaceanewresultsframeworkforthetaxpillarwhilemaintainingthePDO.AnewresultsframeworkhasbeensharedwithFBRtoreceiveitsinputs.
Implementation Performance and Achievements as of April 2017
Strongclientdemanddroverapidimplementationinthe22monthsofTAGRoperations,ledbyaseriesofdiagnosticreports.ApreliminaryfunctionalreviewofFBRfedintotheworkplanandstrategyforsubsequentactivities.Followingthefunctionalreview,Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)were drafted tomeasure ongoing FBRperformance andwere subsequentlyintegratedintoFBR'sapplications.AcostedITstrategicplanwasdevelopedandapprovedbyFBRinDecember2016.AprocessmappingofkeytaxfunctionswasdevelopedandtheassociatedrecommendationsintegratedintotheoverallITreformplan.Onaudit,mentoring,training,andstudytourswereintensi�iedandworkisunderwaytointroducerisk-basedaudit frameworksat the federalandprovincial levels. InPunjab,anassessmentof the ICT infrastructure for thePunjabRevenueAuthoritywasconducted.Also,draftsofanalyticalstudies(onGeneralSalesTax,UrbanImmoveablePropertytax,transactiontaxes,AgricultureIncomeTaxandprofessionaltax)wereproduced.InSindh,theWorldBankcompletedtheICTassessmentofSRBinMarch2017thatincludedaremediationplanwithactions,andearlier,inDecember2016,submittedadraftpropertytaxstudy.AsummaryoftheseactivitiesispresentedinTable1below:
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201732
![Page 34: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Table 1: Summary of FY 2015-17 Activities (as of April 2017)
TaxPolicy–Buildinganalyticalcapacitytoimprovethequalityofthetaxsystemandinformthebudgetprocesswithrealisticrevenuetargets.
Federal Board of Revenue
TaxPolicySupportedbyTAGRResearch
Duringthepreviousreportingperiod,signi�icantanalyticalworkwascompletedtoinformpolicymakers.Astudyoncapitalgainstaxrevealedthatsystematicundervaluationandexemptionsoncapitalgainsonpropertiesheldfortwoyearsledtosigni�icanttaxlosses.
Toaddresstheseproblems,theMinistryofFinanceandtheFBRdesignednewpolicymeasurestoestablishanimprovedvaluationmodelandtoextendtheholdingtimerequiredforpropertytaxexemption.Duringthereportingperiod,thesecapital gains provisions were included in the 2016-17 budget. Implementation of the new measures is currentlyunderway.
Theabove-mentionedRETFincludessupporttotheestablishmentofataxintelligence/marketintelligenceunitwhichisexpected toproduceanalyticalworkonrevenue forecasting, taxexpenditure, and taxcompliancegap.TheWBwillsupportthisinitiativebyreplicatingsimilarworkthatisbeingconductedinPunjab.
TaxAdministration–Strengtheningcoretaxadminoperationstoimprovecontrol&facilitatecompliance
KPIsandManagementInformationSystem(MIS)
Asacontinuationofthefunctionalreviewcompletedduringthepreviousreportingperiod,asetofpreliminarystrategic-levelKPIstomeasurecriticalsuccessfactorsandtoevaluateperformancewereidenti�iedanddevelopedandanMISto
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201733
![Page 35: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
monitorthem. TheMISwasdeliveredanddiscussedinSeptember2016andsoonafterinstalledanddeployedinFBRserverswiththeassistanceofPRALpersonnel.Moreover,theBankprovidedalistofrecommendationsincludingtheset-upofasmallteamwithinFBRtomanagetheKPItask,thelaunchofapilotprocesswithasetofstrategicindicators,andtheimitationofthepilot.
InDecember2016,theFBRdecidedtointegratetheKPIstoolintotheirownapplications,developinganewintegratedmodule using the provided KPIs model. Screening sessions were coordinated to share some key details and newrecommendationswereprovided.
ProcessMappingoftaxfunctions
Aprocessmappingexercisecoveringkeytaxfunctionswascompletedwiththeaimofassessingtheexistingbaselineandidentifyingrecommendationstosimplifyproceduresandimproveproductivityineacharea.ThisiscriticalpriortotheimplementationofnewICTsystems.Toreviewtheprocedures,theteamheldmeetingswithauthoritiesandtechnicalstaffatFBRHeadquarters,PRALandwithRTOIslamabad.Theprocessmappingcoversthefollowingfunctions:TaxpayerRegistration,BroadeningtheTaxBase,ReturnProcessing,Stop-FilingControl,PaymentProcessing,Withholdingtaxcontrol, Refund processing, Tax Arrears, VAT Refund, and Audit. Recommendations were evaluated according tocomplexityandimpacttoprioritizeanddeducequick-wins.TherecommendationsweresummarizedandcommunicatedtoFBR,whichinearly2017integratedtheprocessmappingrecommendationsintoitsoverallITActionPlan.
TaxAudit
ThetrainingprogramstartedinNovember2015.Fiveworkshops–onbasicaudittechniques-werecompletedbyJune2016,andfourworkshopsconductedbetweenOctober2016andJanuary2017.Anewthree-dayworkshoponcomputerassistedaudittechniqueswasheldinMarch2017.TAGRseekstoestablishapermanentstructurefortaxaudittrainingwithastrongfocusonforensicaudittechniques.Additionally,TAGRhasprovidedmentoringoftaxauditorsonforensicauditandsupportedthereviewoftaxauditregulations,developmentofariskassessmentframeworkfortaxauditwingandtheelaborationoftaxauditpolicies.ThementoringactivitycoveredRTOsandLTUsacrossthecountry(Islamabad,
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201734
![Page 36: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Rawalpindi, Lahore, and Karachi). The activity resumed in October 2016with a �irstmission covering the LTU inIslamabad.SubsequentmentoringmissionswereconductedinNovemberandDecember2016,andinFebruaryandMarch2017.TwomoremissionsareplannedforApril(LTU),andMay(RTO)2017.49LTUcasesand61RTOcaseswereselectedbasedonspeci�iccriteria(high-sector, importantsector,etc.)andcompletedunderthesupervisionofBankexperts.Initialresultsisrecordedtodate.Forinstance,intheLTUs,17caseswere�inalizedgeneratinganadditionalrevenueofapproximately4.3billionRps.Similarly,22caseswere�inalizedattheRTOsgeneratinganadditional404millionRpsandanextra1.7billionidenti�iedaspotentialrevenues.
To complement the training and thementoring, onestudy tour covering audit techniques, risk-based frameworks,computer-assistedsolutions,andoperations,wasconductedbetweenApril3and7,2017.Fourteenof�icersfromFBR(andonefromPunjabRevenueAuthority)visitedLebanonwheretheywerehostedbytheLebanesetaxAdministration.The tourwas interactive, an eye opener, and a great learning experience for the participants. Another study tour,specializedinrisk-basedframeworks,isplannedforMay28-June2,2017whereaboutsevenmiddleandtopmanagementof�icerswillvisittheAustralianTaxAdministration.
AdetailedauditdiagnosticwasdraftedandsubmittedinDecember2016.ThereportbuildsontheFBRfunctionalreview and the processmapping exercise with the objective of identifying performance gaps, key challenges, andcorrective measures. The diagnostic examines the institutional and legal frameworks, operations, and the overallcomplianceriskmanagementframework.
TohelpFBRmovetowardsarisk-basedauditframework,aroadmapandastrategyguidingdocumentwerealsoproducedandsharedwithFBR,respectivelyinFebruaryandApril2017.Theroadmapoutlinesthekeystepsrequired,theowner,andtheexpectedtimeframe.The�irststepistodeveloparisk-basedstrategy,andassuch,aguidingdocumentwasdevelopedtoguideFBRinoutliningthestrategy.Thedocumentcoverswhatthestrategyentails–fromvisionandmissiontoobjectivesandassociatedmeasures–andoutlinesthekeyparametersandquestionsFBRneedstoconsiderwhiledraftingitsstrategy.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201735
![Page 37: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
ICTSystems–Automationtofacilitatecompliance,improveaccesstoinformation,supportef�icientprocessingoftaxpayer�ilingsandincreaseaccountability.
BuildingonacomprehensiveITstrategicplan,theTAGRconductedafunctionalreviewoftheIRISsystemwhichistheintegratedrevenuesystemthatissupportingFBRbusinessesprocesses.ThereviewwascarriedoutinSeptemberandOctober2016andkey�indingsandrecommendationscommunicatedtoFBR.KeyrecommendationswithregardstoIRISwereprovidedandstaggeredoverathree-yeartimeframe.ThelistofrecommendationsforthecomingyearincludesthecreationofanArchitecturetaskforce,theimplementationofaqualityassurancereviewandanoperationalfeedbackmechanism,thecompletionofthefunctionalityoftaxarrearsmanagementfortheincometaxsystem.
AttheendofNovember2016,discussionsessionswerecoordinatedtoreceivecommentsonthefunctionalreviewoftheIRISsystem.Themeetingsfocusedontheresponsibilitiesofanewarchitectureworkforce,theprocessforimplementingaqualityassurancereviewandanoperationalfeedbackmechanism,andthevisionofcompletingnewfunctionalitiesforsystems.
InJanuaryandFebruary2017,aseriesofvisitswereorganizedtoreviewprogressmadebytheITWingoftheFBRwithrespect to theActionPlanoriginallydeveloped in threephases (including theprogressofPRAL).The statusof theimplementationoftheoriginalActionPlan(132actions)wasreviewedand24(18%)wereconsideredaseitherdoneorobsolete,34(26%)areinprogressandactivelybeingworkedonbytheFBRorPRALand74(56%)arestillpending.TheFBRapprovedanICTStrategicPlaninlateDecemberof2016andaconsolidatedlistofactionsfromtheActionPlanandtheStrategicPlanwaspreparedbytheWorldBankteam.Inaddition, inclosecollaborationwiththeFRBChiefInformationTechnology,anupdateddocumentwasprepared,called“ImplementationplanfortheStrategicPlan”asanamendment to the current strategic plan that details how it will be implemented (including some processmapping/reengineeringactions).
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201736
![Page 38: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Punjab Province
Bene�iciaryinstitutions: FinanceDepartment,PunjabRevenueAuthority(PRA),BoardofRevenue(BoR),andExciseandTaxationDepartment(ETD).
FinanceDepartment(TaxReformsUnit(TRU): Regularmentoringandon-the-jobtraininginrevenueanalysishasbeen provided to TRU staff. TheUnit has produced quarterly, bi-annual, and annual revenue reports. TRU is alsoproviding support in budget making, revenuemobilization committeemeetings, and for high-level discussions onrevenuemeasureswithfederalandotherprovincialgovernments.
In-depthstudiesonselectedtaxesandnon-taxes(forPRA,BoRandETD):The�irstdraftsofanalyticalstudiesonGeneralSalesTax,UrbanImmoveablePropertytax,transactiontaxes,AgricultureIncomeTaxandprofessionaltaxhavebeensharedwiththeauthoritiesforcomments.Theobjectiveofthesestudiesistoanalyzepotentialinthesetaxes,andsuggestnecessarypolicyandadministrationreformstoachievethatpotential. ThesestudieswillbecompletedbytheendofFY2017.Also,areviewofselectednon-taxrevenuesourcesandminortaxesisbeingconducted.Theseandotheranalyticalstudieswillinformtherevenuemobilizationstrategyandroadmap/implementationplanoftheprovincethatwasdevelopedwiththesupportoftheWorldBank.
PRA:StrengtheningAdministration-AfunctionalreviewofthePRAwascompletedin2016,assessingthestrengthsandweaknessesofthePRAtoguideinterventionsoverthemediumtolongterm.Ahumanresourcesmanual,auditmanual,andtaxlitigationmanualwerealsodeveloped.
ICT - The ICT assessment of PRAhas been completed that includes a remediation planwith actions that PRA canundertaketoaddressrelatedchallenges.Overfouryears,theplancallsforauni�iedcurrentaccount,theroll-outofacasemanagementsystem,theestablishmentofariskmanagementsystem,andtheimplementationofatrainingandHRdevelopmentplanforIT.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201737
![Page 39: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
DuringJanuaryandFebruary2017thestatusofthe implementationoftherecommendations(presentedintheICTAssessmentreport)wasreviewed.Thefollowingwerethemain�indingsofthereview:(i)therehasbeennoprogresswithrespecttotheoriginalactionplanrecommendedonOctoberof2016,and(ii)thecontractualrelationshipwithPRALhasnotimprovedandtherearestillfundamentaldifferencesbetweenPRAandPRALastotheexpectedservicelevelstobeprovided.HencetheWorldBankteam,incoordinationwithITDirector,preparedtheoutlineofastrategicplananddocumentedtheITVisionthatwastransmittedtotheteambythedifferentPRAMembersinterviews.
Audit-TrainingsintaxauditmethodsandtechniqueswereprovidedinAugustandSeptember2015and2016.InOctober2016,theauditpolicydocumentandtheauditmanualsforauditorsandauditmanagerswere�inalized.Inaddition,theBankprovidedadviceonatrainingprogramandonarisk-basedsystemtoselecttaxpayersforaudit.ThedeliverablesincludedamendmentstothePunjabSalesTaxonServiceActanditsRules(2012),aproposalforatrainingplanonVATAudit,andadiscussiondocumentonrisk-basedauditselection.
BoRandETD:AninternationalpropertytaxworkshopwasconductedtogatherideasonreformstopropertytaxinApril/May2016inLahore.Differentinternationalgoodpracticesinpropertytaxweresharedduringtheworkshop.AninternationalvisitwasorganizedforETDof�icialstostudyUK'spropertytaxsystems(BradfordandBelfast)inFebruary2017.Aworkshopwas also conductedwith theof�icials ofBoR inMarch2017 todiscussAIT reforms and relatedchallenges.Thediscussioninformedtheanalysisunderthemainstudy.
Otherareas:SupportwasalsoprovidedinorganizingPunjabTaxDayeventsonApril10,2017,bysharingconceptnoteforkeyawarenessraisingactivities,andparticipationof internationalexpertaspanelist/discussant. Inaddition, incollaborationwithIFCteam,provincialleveldiscussionsessionswereheldinApril2016(nextoneplannedforJuly2017)onreformstoimproveDoingBusiness-PayingTaxesindicator.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201738
![Page 40: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
Sindh Province
Bene�iciaryInstitutions:FinanceDepartment,SindhRevenueBoard(SRB),BoardofRevenue(BoR),andExciseandTaxationDepartment(ETD).
FinanceDepartment:BuildinganalyticalCapacity–TheBankteamhelddiscussionswiththeBureauofStatisticsandFinanceDepartmentinprovidingsupporttodeveloptheircapacityinestimatingprovincialmacroeconomicindicators,andconductingrevenueanalysis(forecasting,potentialanalysis,expenditureandgapanalysisetc.)–formoreinformeddecisionmaking.RelatedsupportwillbeprovidedaftertheestablishmentoftheTaxReformUnitinFY17.
SRB:Capacitybuilding–Aninternationalworkshopwasconductedonsubnationaltaxationwithparticipationfromotherprovincesaswell.ItmainlyfocusedonGSTandpropertytaxes.Also,internationalvisitswerearrangedtostudysalestaxadministrationofIndiaandpropertytaxadministrationofUK(BradfordandBelfast,February2017).Moreover,trainingshavebeenprovidedtostaffinbasicauditskillsandtechniquesin2015and2016.
ICTStrategy–InMarch2017,theWorldBankcompletedtheICTassessmentofSRBthatincludedaremediationplanwithactionsthatSRBcanundertaketoaddressurgentchallenges.Theareaswithopportunitiestobeimprovedare:StrategicThinking,ITGovernance,ProcessManagement,SoftwareEngineering,HRdevelopmentandtraining.
HRassessmentandaudit–Arisk-basedauditmodelhasbeenfordeveloped,whichisbeingadaptedforSRB.Thiswillbecomplimentedbytrainingonarisk-basedsystemtoselecttaxpayersforaudit. Further,theHRassessmentofSRBisbeingconducted,whichwillhelpinformitsHRstrategy,HRmanualandtrainingplan.
BoRandETD:Propertytaxstudy–The�irstdraftofthestudywassubmittedinDecember2016.Thestudyhighlightsthekeyproblemsofunderassessment,anincompletevaluationroll,andlackofautomation,andmakesrecommendationsforimprovementinthelaw,valuationandtheadministrationoftax.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201739
![Page 41: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
AgriculturalIncomeTax–TheBankteamhasinitiatedthedatacollectionforestimatingthepotentialforAITinSindhandrelatedreforms.Theteamdiscussedthescopeofworkwithauthoritiesandconducted�ieldvisitsduringJanuary2017.
Stamptax–TheToRsforastudyonreformingtheStampTaxhavebeen�inalized,coveringarangeofadministrationmeasuresrelatedtobusinessprocesses,includingIT,onlineapplication,anddocumentmanagement.Thestudyispartofplanfornext�iscalyear.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201740
![Page 42: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Project Outcomes – As of April 2017
2. In its22monthsof implementation, signi�icantprogress towards the results frameworkoutcomeshasbeenachieved.Taxcollectiontargetsaregrowinginlinewiththe�inaloutcomeobjective,althoughfurthergainsarelikelytorequiremoredif�icultadministrativeimprovementsgoingforward.Thecontextandassumptionsprovidedintheconceptnoteforthisprojectremainvalid,andthedesigncontinuestoberelevanttothechallengesfacingauthorities.Progresshasbeenmadeagainstallintermediateoutcomes,assummarizedinTable2.
Table 2: Progress towards Results Framework Indicators
Final Outcome Increasedtaxcollectionbyatleast2percentagepointsofGDP(from2013/14)andnolessthantheaverageannualin�lationrate.
Ontrack.Baseline2013-14:10.5%ofGDP.Projectionfor2016-17:12.9%ofGDP.
Intermediate Outcomes
EliminationofSROsgrantingconcessionarytaxexemptions.
Achieved.LegislationwaspassedpermanentlylimitingtheissuanceofSROs.
Taxexpenditurereducedbyatleast0.5%ofGDP.
Achieved.Thegovernmenthaseliminatedtaxconcessionsandexemptionsamountingtoabout0.9percentofGDPsince2014.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017IMF12thReviewundertheExtendedArrangement,Table6b.2
2
Progress as of April 2017
41
![Page 43: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Increaseinnumberofactivetaxpayersbynolessthan5%perannum.
Notachieved.
2013-14Registeredtaxpayers: 3,660,441Taxreturns�iled: 1,078,124Taxpayments: 2,423,618,455,983
2014-15Registeredtaxpayers: 3,801,918Tax�ilings: 1,103,888Taxpayments: 2,639,346,712,995
Activetaxpayersroseby2.3%.Revenuesroseby8.9%.
Annualballot-basedauditsupfrom0%to15%
Indicatoradjusted.TheTAGRissupportingtheshiftfromballot-basedauditstorisk-basedaudit–aninternationalgoodpractice.TheDPCtargetis40risk-basedauditsoflargetaxpayers.In2017,riskparameterswereintroducedbyFBRandcasesselectedaccordingly.Afullrisk-basedmodelisinthedesignstage
IncreasedintegrationofFBRITsoftware.
Ontrack.TheFBRhasanICTStrategicPlanapprovedandalltheactionswillbemonitoredfollowingthe“ImplementationplanfortheStrategicPlan”thatdetailshowitwillbeimplemented.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201742
![Page 44: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Project Outlook – Year 2
3. While the 22 months of implementation indicates encouraging progress, the project continues to faceimplementation risks, particularly client staff turnover. The Federal and Provincial Boards of Revenue continue toexperienceahighturnoverrateofseniormanagement.Forinstance,twoFBRChairmanassumedof�iceduringthisreportingperiod,andkeyFBRcounterparts(MemberITandMemberAudit)wereeitherreplacedorretiredbetweenMarchandApril2017.Thisturnovercomplicatestheimplementationofworkplansagreedwithpreviousleaders,andrequiresadditionaltechnicalassistanceengagementstoreviewandadjustplansaccordingly.TheturnoverisprovingtobeanobstacleformovingtoamediumtermrevenuestrategyforFBR.
4.Progressachievedoverthepastyearisencouraging,however,sustainingthismomentumcontinuestocallfortimely investmentof resourcesandcontinuedengagementwith taxauthorities.Technicalassistancehas inherentlimitations;itcanprovidetechnicaladvice,deepanalysisofcorebusinessareas,andguidancebasedoninternationalgoodpractices.However,successdependsontheownershipandcommitmentofauthoritiestoimplementreforms.Theincreasesinrevenueachievedthroughpolicyactionprovideencouragingmomentum.Tosustainthiseffort,considerationshouldbegiventoexploreinstrumentstoinformcurrentinvestmentneedsintermsofadministrativecapacityinICTandHumanResources.
Planned Activities
5.Atthefederallevel,plannedactivitieswillfocusonanumberoftasksintaxpolicy,ICTandaudit.Belowisalistofactivitiesplannedfortheupcomingperiod.Missionsaresubjecttocon�irmationwiththeclientandmaybeadjusted.TheWBwillalsosupporttheimplementationofthetaxintelligence/marketintelligenceunitincludedintheRETFthroughadviceonrevenueanalysisandtaxcompliancegapestimates.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201743
![Page 45: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
Audit
April2017:MentoringofLTUsinKarachi,Lahore,Islamabad(lastvisitthiscycle)May2017:MentoringofRTOsinKarachi,Lahore,Islamabad,andRawalpindi(lastvisitthiscycle)May–June2017:StudyTourtoAustraliaonrisk-basedauditframeworkSeptember/October2017:SecondStudytouronbasicaudittechniquesSeptember/October2017:Resumptionofnewmentoringmissions(newcases)andpossibleresumptionofCAATtrainingworkshops
6.Attheprovinciallevel,theteamwillcontinuetosupportpartnersinPunjabandSindhwithrevenuepolicyandadministrationreforms.Theseactivitiesareplannedtotakeplacethroughoutthenextreportingperiod(anduntilFY18).Plannedactivitiesinclude:
April2017:ConsolidationoftheImplementationplanfortheStrategicPlanwithFBR/PRAL.Apr-May2017:DiscussionandfeedbackonICTassessmentwithSRBMay2017:MonitoringandworkshopswithFBR/PRALJune2017:Monitoringandworkshops-FBR/PRALJune2017:HRassessmentinSRBJuly2017:Monitoringandworkshops-FBR/PRALAugust2017:Monitoringandworkshops-FBR/PRALJun-Jul2017:SupportonICTStrategy–SRB
ICT
FinanceDepartment(TaxReformsUnit;TRU)
Analyticalwork:Reviewofminorornuisance taxesandnon-tax revenues (completing the report); reviewof currentrevenuemonitoringandreportingmechanismtosuggestimprovements;andassessmentoftaxburden(fromtaxpayerperspective).
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201744
![Page 46: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Developconceptnotefor�ieldexperimentationtohelpimprovevoluntarycompliance. Allthesestudieswillinform(andhelpupdate)themedium-termroadmapforrevenuemobilization.
Capacitybuilding:trainingonrevenueanalysisandforecastingtechniquesforTRUandallprovincialrevenuebodies;andrelevantint'lstudytours.
Taxpayers'awareness:supportconductingPunjabTaxDayeventsonApril10th.
PunjabRevenueAuthority(PRA)
Audit:Support in adapting the risk-basedauditmodel forPRAandproviding trainingson risk-based system to selecttaxpayersforaudit(includingdeskaudit).
Surveys: Provide technical guidance on methodology for designing surveys (tax base assessment survey and citizensatisfactionsurvey).
Taxlitigation:Developingcase-studiesbasedtrainingprogramontaxlitigationandproviderelatedtrainings.
Otherareas:DevelopingstrategyforPRA,includingde�iningKPIsandM&Eframework
ExciseandTaxationdepartment(ETD)
Nationalworkshoponinter-provincialcoordinationonMotorVehicleTaxStudytoanalyzepotentialinmotorvehicletaxandrelatedreforms
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201745
![Page 47: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
BusinessprocessmappingofETD
HRassessmenttoinformHRstrategyanddeveloptrainingprogram
BoardofRevenue(BOR)
Functionalreviewoftheorganizationforitsmodernization(incl.strategic,HRandITassessments)
SupportdevelopmentofHRmanualsandtrainingplans
Sindh
FinanceDepartment(TaxReformsUnit;TRU)
Revenueanalysis:conductingstudiesonGST,transactiontaxes,motorvehicletax,non-taxrevenuesandminortaxes–toinformrelatedreforms.Duringtheongoing�iscalyear,theteamwillcompletethestudyonAgricultureincometax.
Capacitybuilding:AftertheestablishmentofTRU,on-the-jobmentoringandtrainingwillbeprovidedonrevenueanalysis(forecasting,potential,expenditure,andgapanalysis–combinedwithPunjab).Studytourswillbeorganized,togetherwithPunjab.
The assessment of tax burden, and concept note for �ield experimentation to improve voluntary compliance will bedevelopedincollaborationwiththeTRU.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201746
![Page 48: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
SindhRevenueBoard(SRB)andExciseandTaxationDepartment(ETD)
Audit:Support inadapting the risk-basedauditmodel forPRAandproviding trainingsonrisk-basedsystemtoselecttaxpayersforaudit(includingdeskaudit).
HRassessment:completetheHRassessmenttoinformHRstrategyandmanual,anddevelop(orupdate)trainingplan.
Supportindesigningthesurveyforprofessionstax(ETD)
DoingBusiness–PayingTaxes(forLahoreandKarachi):Conductnational-levelworkshopwithallstakeholderstodiscussstrategiestoimprovePakistan'srankingonPayingTaxesindicator.
MDTF-AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 201747
![Page 49: AGR OCTOBER 2016 - MARCH 2017 SIX-MONTHLY UPDATE · Pakistan's iscal architecture has undergone a fundamental change with the introduction of the 18th Constitutional Amendment. On](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022040706/5e05160c60d24150393e5176/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
MDTF-AGR Secretariat Serena Business Complex Sector G-5/1. Khayaban-e-SuhrawardyIslamabad,
AGR
www.mdt fagr.org