aid for trade & nepal
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
1/36
Aid for Trade and Nepal
Issues and Way ForwardChandra Ghimire
Joint SecretaryMinistry of Commerce and SuppliesKathmandu, Nepal, 19 th Aug 2011
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
2/36
Talking Points Understanding of Aid for Trade (AfT) AfT flows in Nepal State-of-the Art of AfT in Nepal Issues in AfT Effectiveness Silver-lining with AfT in Nepal
Way forward in Nepalese Context The 4 principles for AfT Final TATWABODH
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
3/36
Methodology Applied and Limiatations
Review of the literature available around
My own observation constructed over last 2 years at
Ministry of Commerce & Supplies A bundle of frank speaking
Due to some limitations this also doesn't represent
the complete picture
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
4/36
The argument of Market Access Huge focus on market access (i.e. as of 31 July 2010, some 474 RTAs
notified to the GATT/WTO) - the underlying assumption was thatremoval of trade barriers leads to expanded trade ;
Generalized System of Preference (GSP) since 1968 provided to the LDCswith the same assumption;
Special and Differential Treatment (SDT) for LDCs in WTO and RTAs;
Despite the the LDCs share in global export
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
5/36
The missing link The issue of supply-side constraints was not addressed Following types of "Supply-Side Constraints" are prominent
in the context of Nepal: Availability of surplus to export (comparative plus competitive advantages); Lack of infrastructural and institutional prerequisites to competitively
supply international market; Relatively high costs of doing business;
Lowest level of Logistics Performance Index in South Asia;
5Constructed by CHANDRA GHIMIRE Aug 2010
Supply-side Capacity Vrs Market Access
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
6/36
To enable particularly LDCs to use trade effectively for growth,
development and poverty reduction & their developmentobjectives, including MDGs Goals;
To help particularly LDCs to build supply-side capacity andtrade-related infrastructure in order to access to markets;
To help facilitate & implement trade reform & liberalization;
To assist regional integration ;
To assist smooth integration into the world trading system;
To assist in implementation of trade agreements ;
6Constructed by CHANDRA GHIMIRE Aug 2010
Task Force Recommended
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
7/36
As Defined by the WTO Task Force 2006 on AfT
" Aid for trade is about assisting developingcountries to increase exports of goods and services , to integrate into the multilateral tradingsystem, and to benefit from liberalized trade and increased market access"
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
8/36
1. Trade-related infrastructuree.g., road, telecom, electricity
2. Building productive capacitye.g., agriculture, industry, fishery
3. Trade developmente.g., investment promotion, tradepromotion, business services
4. Trade-related adjustmente.g., retraining of workers,
compensation for retrenchedworkers
5. Trade policy and regulationse.g., training of officials and
stakeholders, designing policiesand comply with trade rules
6. Other arease.g., recipients other needs that are not
included above8Constructed by CHANDRA GHIMIRE Aug 2010
Task Force Recommended II
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
9/36
8 Guiding Principles as laid down by on Aid
Effectiveness & Country ownership; Aligning aid to national development strategies
Harmonization of donor procedures with country contexts ; Use of programme based aid modalities ; Mutual accountability; Managing for result ; Strengthening country ownership; Building inclusive partnership
But Task Force didnt recommend a stand -alone fund or facility, which
means the resources are provided bilaterally
9Constructed by CHANDRA GHIMIRE Aug 2010
Task Force Recommended III
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
10/36
LDCs lack basic infrastructures to take advantage of the marketaccess resulting from a successful Doha Round;
The Doha Ministerial Declaration (2001) made technicalassistance and capacity building a key component ;
In 2005, the Hong Kong Ministerial Conference paved way fortransforming IF into EIF & set up a new AfT mechanism
10Constructed by CHANDRA GHIMIRE Aug 2010
AfT and EIF under WTO
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
11/36
NEPAL AID-FOR TRADE FLOWSUSD in 000, 2009 constant prices (Source: WTO/OECD, 2011) Commitments Disbursements
Year 2002-05 Average 2006 2007 2008 2009 2006 2007 2008 2009
Trade policy andregulations andtrade relatedadjustment
84 0.05%
2982 1.41%
1344 0.51%
1423 0.75%
2366 8.08%
44 0.04%
859 0.73%
318 0.20%
494 0.28%
Economic
infrastructure
76347
44,81%
130689
61.93%
125165
48%
121622
64.3%
227173
77.7%
76992
68.7%
83341
71.23%
122533
79.29%
118959
68.54%
Building productivecapacity
93930 55.13%
77324 36.64%
134998 51,62%
65997 34.91%
62963 21.52%
35022 31.25%
32799 28.03%
31684 20.50%
54100 31.17%
Focus on tradedevelopment
3739 1.42%
12622 6.67%
32540 11,12%
1457 1.245%
4692 3.036%
11008 6.34%
Other trade relatedneeds/Tradeadjustment
Total AfT (Average
31.36%) 170361 30.51%
210995 44.35%
261507 36.63%
189042 29.87%
292501 31.38%
112058 27.64%
116999 26.75%
154534 29.73%
173553 26.075%
Total Sector
Allocable ODA
558356 475657 713801 632881 931971 405297 437267 519641 665590
NIL
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
12/36
AfT Flows in Nepal
Only 60% of the committed figure is disbursed
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
13/36
Distribution of AfT in Nepal
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
14/36
Who are the AfT donors of Nepal?
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
15/36
Aid for Trade Commitment for Nepal (2002-2009), constant 2008 US$ million
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
16/36
Nepal as Compared to Other Group of Countries
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
17/36
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
18/36
An Indicative List of Existing and Potential Trade-relatedProjects in Nepal
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
19/36
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
20/36
State-of-the Art of AfT in Nepal
Nepal has the policy and institutional ground works well-done Trade Policy 2009 and NTIS 2010
Nepal's NTIS is regarded as a best one
A 3 Three-tier institutional set up in effect, i.e. NSC, NIU, FP, TCs, DF
Least duplication in the AfT funded activities as NIU is there toavoid
NTIS 2010 is well articulated as the territory for AfT, thus the
practices seem to have been the "bottom-up" Over last few months, delegates from 2 countries visited Nepal
for learning out of it experiences
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
21/36
Framework for Analyzing the Issues in Nepal(As Pascal Lamy, 2011)
Resource mobilization
Trade mainstreaming
Ground level impact Result Showing
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
22/36
The quantum mobilized so far is below satisfactory
Global vrs Nepal Growth 36% vrs 42% increased (2002/05-2006/09)
0.07% out of the global AfT
< 2% of the AfT allocated to Asian countries
Nepal not in the list of top 10 recipient countries whereas so didemerging countries like India, Iraq, Indonesia, Vietnam,Bangladesh Ghana etc
No data base available depicting the AfT in Nepal i.e. from where
and where to??? Huge gap between commitment and disbursement
Compared 2006-2009 to 2002/2005, the gap increased as follows:
In non-AfT case from 102% to 98%
In AfT case from 98% to 59%
1st Issue: Resource mobilization
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
23/36
Absorptive capacity is blamed as 'poor No agency responsible specifically for AfT (In GoN apparatus and even within
MoCS)
Even MoCS is not fully aware of the AfT around i.e. what is where?
Resource mobilization AfT not mobilized as per DTIS in the past
So, projects beyond trade also funded with AfT, e.g. KTM-Sindhuali Highway
In Hardware vrs Software, DPs do love 'software
Passion in some DPs for the TA category higher than the ordinary AfT aid Running directly by donors outside the govt mechanism
Not recorded in GoNs Red Book
Use of foreign consultants unnecessarily
1st Issue: Resource Mobilization
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
24/36
Foreign Aid Policy silent on AfT mobilization Respect of Paris Declaration and Accra Plan of Action
Out of review as some AfTs are not reflected in Red
Book, i.e . EC-WTO Assistance Program Nepal has not yet seen any aid for trade adjustment
although the need is high
1st Issue: Resource mobilization
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
25/36
GoN gone to a significant extent, however, its DPs turn mainstreaming tradeinto their cooperation agenda
No good space for AfT in their CAS
Many DPs has no a dedicated strategy for AfT
Having poor understanding about AfT
Not all are aware of the principle of additionality
Peace and conflict and social sectors are the darlings of the DPs in Nepal
Trade is yet to be fully mainstreamed into sectoral policies, plans and annualprograms, e.g. agriculture, forest, industry etc, yet
Continuity of the trade as a priority sector Changing dynamics of trade sector and its sub-sectors
Private sector engagement yet not fully
Sustainability of the institutional set up erected as of now
2nd Issue: Trade Mainstreaming
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
26/36
3rd Issue: Ground level Impact There has been additionality in commitment but no additionality in
disbursement.
Sustainability aspect is still blurring
The impact is subject to rigorous examination
Even the Paris and Accra based criteria for evaluatingeffectiveness may not necessarily reflect the true ground levelimpact
One regression analysis shows, + impact of AfT on exportperformance. 1% increase in AfT is associated with exportsgrowth by 0.224 %
Nepal's case is taken as too early to evaluate the impact
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
27/36
Sustainability Aspect of AfT in Nepal
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
28/36
Silver Lining with Nepalese AfT
Nepal being a LDC has a great advantage Some unique comparative advantages it has Policy and institutional set up ready for take off Private sector eager to have support for capacity
building Trade mainstreaming to a certain extent
undertaken DPs has a great interest as the country is a post-
conflict ridden one
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
29/36
Way Forward in the Nepalese Context Accept MoCS as the lead role in AfT mobilization
By recognizing it in the Rule of GON's Business Allocation
By keeping MoCS in loop prior to accepting any AfT from DPs
By maintaining a sound database at MoCS
By broadening the country ownership of AfT beyond MoCS and MoF
Strengthen the NIU established at MoCS Improving HR planning
Minimizing staff turnover rate
Building the capacity of HRs for designing projects and resource absorption
Fully activate NSC, TCs, etc Mainstream NTIS 2010 and Trade Policy into sectoral policy, strategy and
annual programs
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
30/36
Way Forward in the Nepalese Context 2 Optimize the donor group established for trade & development
Benefit from the principle of 'additionality'
Mainstream of NTIS 2010 and Trade Policy into sectoral policy,strategy and annual programs
Engage private sector as an active actor especially in formulationand implementation of Tier 2 projects By exploring avenues for public-private partnership
By developing jointly bankable projects
Keep at top the agenda of aid effectiveness as per the Paris andAccra elements, i.e. ownership, alignment, harmonization, results, mutualaccountability, predictability, country systems, conditionality, and untying
Revise Foreign Aid Policy to incorporate AfT
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
31/36
Promote South-South cooperation, i.e. India, China,Kuwait, Saudi Fund and OPEC Fund
Run with the idea of regional integration in the SouthAsia (linking Nepal to India, Bangladesh and Bhutan) whileshifting from software to hardware
Secure a greater quantum of the AfT Get the political economy right: the feasibility of
reforms Where possible, link AfT with think-tanks and
national academic institutions to have close oversighton the changing/emerging dynamics of trade sector
Way Forward in the Nepalese Context 3
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
32/36
Focus on the awareness and coordination capacity of private sectors, FNCCI, CNI, CoCand civil society for AfT
Make DPs eager in trade by:
including trade in their country assistance strategy (CAS)
providing dedicated AfT through TTF/Trade SWAp
stopping conditionalities on the sourcing of equipments and HRs
allowing local institutions and experts, as far as possible
when hiring international expert unavoidable, station them inside GoN agencies
increase the use of financial management and procurement system of GoN
effectively ban direct implementation of projects by bypassing government mechanism and byrunning PIU (parallel implementation unit)
building the capacity/expertise of local institutions, e.g. emphasis on ToT rather than just training
Provide AfT in grant form as far as possible
Focus on the absorptive capacity to narrow the gap between the commitment anddisbursement
Enhance the understanding and capacity of the GON's bureaucrats dealing with AfT
Way Forward in the Nepalese Context 4
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
33/36
Get all AfT assisted programs in Red Book in order to bringinto review
Unpack the NTIS by creating a 'project bank'
Seek aid for trade related adjustment, where negativeconsequences of trade liberalization
Get private sector developing AfT project proposals in PPPmode
Get think tank institutions and private sector conductingresearch & studies for informed inputs to the GoN
Make investment in HRD from private sector so as to mobilizea greater AfT
Way Forward in the Nepalese Context 5
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
34/36
1. Additionality: Developing countries need aid for trade and such aid must not come at the expense of aid for development;
2. Predictability: It is easy to be taken in with promises of bilateral aid, and make seeminglyinnocuous commitments in bilateral agreements;
3. Country ownership: Development cannot beimposed, it can only be facilitated."
34Constructed by CHANDRA GHIMIRE Aug 2010
4 Principles by Stiglitz and Charlton on AfT
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
35/36
4. Coherence: Trade liberalization must becarefully managed as part of comprehensivedevelopment strategies
Private sector: In productive capacity & publicsector in infrastructure
Loans vs Grants: "Many have rallied to the idea of dropping the debt. I say let's rally to the idea of
stopping the debt
35Constructed by CHANDRA GHIMIRE Aug 2010
4 Principles by Stiglitz and Charlton on AfT
-
7/30/2019 Aid for Trade & Nepal
36/36
TATWABODH
Should we really go for 'Trade Trust Fund'/TradeSWAp ?
If YES the answer what should we do??? Formulation of different operation modalities, e.g. financial, institutional, project
management etc. Motivation to trade related DPs buy-in the idea
What else to make it very NEPALESE, wellfunctioning and result oriented???