aigner - master planning process - making your community...
TRANSCRIPT
June 2015
1
ANNUAL MEETINGJune (8) 9‐11, 2015Semiahmoo Resort, Blaine
The Master Planning Process Making your Community the
Best it Can Be
Torsten Hirche, President & CEO, PRCN
Paul Aigner, Vice President of Development, PRCN
DeAnne Clune, Corporate Marketing Director, PRCN
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
2
Agenda
I. PRCN Overview
II. Master Planning Overview, Process and Key Considerations
III. Progress Report and Next Steps
• Founded as Presbyterian Ministries, Inc. (PMI) by the Seattle Presbyterian Synod in 1956
• Built Park Shore in Madison Park in 1962• Purchased Exeter House in 1962• Severed direct legal ties with Presbyterian Church in 1996• Name change from PMI to PRCN in 2000• Opened Skyline in 2009• Affiliation with Fred Lind Manor in 2014• 4 campuses in the Seattle area now serving over 800
residents• PRCN providing third party development, management
and consulting services starting in late 2014• GSI Research joined PRCN family in 2015
ANNUAL MEETING
I. PRCN Overview
June 2015
3
ANNUAL MEETING
ANNUAL MEETING
• Type B CCRC in Madison Park
• Opened in 1963
• 15 floors on the shore of Lake Washington
• 113 IL, 30 AL, 28 SNF
June 2015
4
• Rental Community
• Building opened as the Exeter Hotel in 1926
• Community opened in 1963
• 10 floors
• 82 IL, 26 AL
ANNUAL MEETING
l
ANNUAL MEETING
• Type A Life Care CCRC
• Opened in 2009
• 26 Floors
• 199 IL
• 76 AL/MC
• 34 SNF
June 2015
5
ANNUAL MEETING
• Rental Community
• Opened in 1945 as Baptist Rest Home
• 1988 new 4 story building
• 82 IL/AL units
Operational Baseline
• Occupancy & Marketing: Vacancies, wait lists & pipeline challenges
• Aged and fatigued buildings: decades‐old infrastructure and exterior/interior
• Some existing contract options: consumer, financial challenges
• Product & amenities: lack of common amenities, undesirable unit mix, unit size, unit amenities
• Pricing challenges: Entrance Fees and/or Monthly Fees
• Operations: staffing, programs challenges
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
6
Financial Baseline
• PRCN portfolio: Key Performance Indicators lagging behind benchmarks in CARF‐CCAC (75th Percentile), State of Senior Housing (Upper Quartile):– Net Operating Margin: ranging from (5%)‐40%– Days Cash on Hand: ranging from 91‐220– Debt Service Coverage: ranging from 1.6‐3.9– Cash to Long‐term Debt: ranging from 5.41% to 36.67%
• Legal & Capital Structure with PRCN as single member parent:– Exeter House and ParkShore are operating divisions of PRCN:
existing debt of 15MM for group– Skyline separate LLC: existing debt of 112MM– FLM separate 501(c)3 : HUD loan of 3.5MM
ANNUAL MEETING
II. Master Planning Overview, Key Considerations and Process
June 2015
7
Why We Master Plan
• Address operational and financial challenges
• Changing consumer and demographics needs
• Holistic and comprehensive look at family of communities and how we can benefit each other
• Build a better and stronger senior living system
• Create platform for regional and national expansion of mission
• Build culture around innovation, customer focus and operational excellence
ANNUAL MEETING
What is Master Planning?
“Process of planning and implementation to improve a community through a long‐range plan that balances and harmonizes all elements of consumer preferences, competitive environment, operational and financials requirements in the context of vision and mission of the organization.”
June 2015
8
Master Planning Key Considerations
15
• Experienced Project Lead• Team of Experts• External/Internal Drivers• Product Life Cycle• Structured Master Planning Process• Involve all Stakeholders
ANNUAL MEETING
Project Lead
16
Paul Aigner – Project Manager & Facilitator • Architectural background• Owners Rep/Project Management firm specializing
in Senior Housing• Over 20 years development and master planning
experience• SVP with Covenant Solutions, development arm of
Covenant Retirement Communities• Strong West Coast and Seattle experience• Heads up new community development
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
9
Team of Experts
17
• Comprehensive Selection Process• Team:
• Architect ‐ Perkins Eastman/Sage• Market Research – GSI Research• Financial Analyst – PRCN/Covenant• Physical Plant Assessment – ACG• PRCN Executive Team
ANNUAL MEETING
Mission
Deferred Capital Needs
Resident Expectations
Contract Types/EFCompetition
Market/New Consumer
Construction CostsHousing Values
Economic Environment
Levels of Care
Existing Debt
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
10
Product Life Cycle
Introduction Growth Maturity Decline
Pro
duct
Sal
es
Structured Master Planning Process
• Three step process• Session I – Project Information• Session II – Project Analysis• Session III – Project ConsensusNotes: Each campus will take about 6 months to complete MP Goal is to complete MP for all our campuses in 2015
calendar year Implementation of MP will be based on the financial
analysis, debt structuring and project prioritization
20ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
11
Structured Master Planning Process
Session I – Project InformationPreparation and Homework required:o History and Culture ‐ campuso SWOT – campus o Marketing Overview – campus: review all units, square
footages, occupancies, vacancy durationo Market Research – competition, # of age income
qualified, penetration rates o Physical Plant Assessmento Entitlement and Zoningo Resident Satisfaction Surveyso Financial Dashboard – Determine Debt Capacity
21ANNUAL MEETING
Structured Master Planning Process
Session II– Project Analysis
• Develop possible repositioning scenariosProgram‐ including new business linesProduct‐ renovation or expansion
• Refine scenarios with a potential phasing plan
• Develop Conceptual Financial Model (CFM) to determine potential ROI, DSCR and DCOH
22ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
12
Structured Master Planning Process
Session III – Project Consensus
• Review/refine assumptions of agreed upon scenarios with validated cost estimates
• Prioritize projects with timelines
• Create 10‐year financial model
• Strategic Finance Plan
• Plan Implementation
23ANNUAL MEETING
Involve all Stakeholders
24ANNUAL MEETING
• Involved throughout Master Planning process/sessions :• PRCN Executive Team• Community Executive Director• Department Directors• Resident Representatives • Board Members
• Communications Plan for larger scale communication after consensus is reached• All team members• All residents
June 2015
13
Progress Report and Next Steps
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
14
Session I Highlights – Market Research
• Overlap of PRCN Communities
• 43% of Park Shore Residents are from within three miles
• Another 11% from 3‐5 Miles
• One‐third of residents are from the immediate zip codes: 98112 and 98105
• PRCN and Seattle markets generally have significant outside fill –
• Park Shore: 28% from out‐of‐state
27ANNUAL MEETING
Madison Park NeighborhoodUpscale Residential, Walkable
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
15
Lake Location and Views
ANNUAL MEETING
Session I Highlights – Market Research
Growth is in the Younger AgesSEATTLE ZIP CODES ONLY
Households: % Change 2014‐2019
• Age 65‐7439% increase
• Age 75+ 11% increase
50,443
76,118
103,112
42,344 36,573
43,628
16,615 21,228 20,685
0
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
120,000
Y 2000 Y 2014 Y 2019
65‐74
75‐84
30ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
16
Session I Highlights – Market Research
Competition
73 Existing Communities (Including the East Side)
• 13 CCRCs or Look‐Alikes
• 6,490 Independent units – 94%– Less than half have kitchens
• 495 Congregate units – 93%
• 1,193 Assisted Living units –92%
• 609 Memory Care units – 89%
31ANNUAL MEETING
Session I Highlights – Market Research
Competition
• Most new product is Assisted Living with Memory Care
• New or expanded CCRCs in surrounding areas
• Multiple “branded” assisted living providers offering multiple communities within the Seattle market:
– Aegis– ERA– Emeritus/Brookdale– Merrill Gardens
32ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
17
Session I Highlights – Market Research
33ANNUAL MEETING
• Seattle Is highly penetrated with inventory especially higher priced product
• Majority of inventory is older and probably serving medium priced market
• Market and penetration differences between Seattle and East Side
Session I Highlights – Market Research
SUMMARY1. Growth is in the younger
segments
2. City growth of young in technology sector
3. Significant growth in non‐age restricted high rise towers with large number of units
4. Lower ages correlated with high income points
34ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
18
Park Shores Session I ‐ SWOT
STRENGTHS
• Location
• Lake
• Views
• Established CCRC
• Madison Park neighborhood highly walkable
WEAKNESSES• 50+ year old Building• Landlocked. No room for expansion?
• Old and tired exterior and interior
• Vacancy ‐ $8M in lost EF• Loss of Monthly Fees $750K/YR
• Parking
35ANNUAL MEETING
Park Shores Session I – SWOT
OPPORTUNITIES• Wellness Programs/Fitness
• Purchase Land, Buildings for expansion
• More Dining Options
• Change Contract Services
• Memory Support
• Lake Access
• Attract a younger senior
THREATS• Competition
• Building Age
• Age of Resident Population ‐ 88
• Not enough SNF & AL/MC for Future Needs
• Not Enough Amenities to Attract Future Residents
36ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
19
Session I– Physical Plant
Seismic Report• Building has stood the test of
time ‐ over 50 years with no significant damage
• Will maintain building life safety performance similar in magnitude to past events
Physical Plant• 12 year capital expenditure and
Reserve Cost Estimate $5.3M total with cost escalation
37ANNUAL MEETING
Zoning
38ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
20
Zoning
39ANNUAL MEETING
Considerations for Repositioning Park Shore
• Addressing Wish List for younger seniors and changing market • Add Parking• Improve “Curb Appeal”• Increase amenity spaces for Health and Wellness• Increase Choice of Dining Venues• Create Larger Residences• Customize Residential Finishes• Improve Interiors Throughout• Connect with the Waterfront
40ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
21
IL Apartment Design
• Bigger Apartments –51% were under 600 SF
• More 2 BR• Add Kitchens to apartments
• W/D in Apartment• Full Wi‐fi• Customize Apartment
9th floor (typical)
41ANNUAL MEETING
DINING
89
42ANNUAL MEETING
Ideal Floor Layout
June 2015
22
Wellness / Fitness / Spa
ANNUAL MEETING
Chapel Floor Pool Alternative
44ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
23
ANNUAL MEETING
15th Floor Penthouse Utilization
• Provide New Options for Resident Dining
46ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
24
ANNUAL MEETING
Session I Highlights ‐ SWOT
STRENGTHS• Newer high‐end CCRC with
outstanding views
• Great location close to many medical services and hospitals and close to all downtown attractions
• Younger CCRC – average age 78
WEAKNESSES
• Parking
• Low ratio of IL to HC units
48ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
25
Session I Highlights ‐ SWOT
OPPORTUNITIES
• Adjacent Property• Re‐purpose and add
additional common amenities
THREATS
• Downtown Competitors
• Interior finishes will need to be on a replacement schedule
49ANNUAL MEETING
Session I Highlights – Physical Plant
Physical Plant• 12 year capital expenditure and
reserve cost estimate• $1.8M total with cost escalation
50ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
26
51
FIRST HILL URBAN CENTER VILLAGE
HR ZONE HIGH RISE
• Residential Use is permitted• Congregate Residences are
permitted
• Base FAR = 8 • All Multi‐family Structures &
enclosed amenity areas are exempt from FAR
• Base Height Limit = 160 ft• Maximum Height Limit = 240
or 300 ft
Zoning and Entitlement Review
ANNUAL MEETING
52
Zoning and Entitlement Review
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
27
53
Zoning and Entitlement Review
ANNUAL MEETING
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
28
Session I Highlights ‐ SWOT
STRENGTHS• Great Downtown Location
• Great location close to many medical services and hospitals and close to all downtown attractions
• Building has “old world charm”• Seattle Landmark• Development Potential
WEAKNESS• Old Building = Old Infrastructure
• Old apartment design
• Lack of quality amenities spaces
• Deferred Maintenance
• Land Locked
• No MC
55ANNUAL MEETING
Session I Highlights ‐ SWOT
OPPORTUNITIES
• Valuable land• Partnership potential• Monthly rental vs EF
THREATS
• Age of Building• Poor Infrastructure• Apartment explosion in downtown – driving rents south
• Potential Public Outcry if Building was ever Demolished
56ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
29
Session I– Physical Plant
Seismic Report• Building has stood the test of
time ‐ over 50 years with no significant damage
• Will maintain building life safety performance similar in magnitude to past events
Physical Plant• 12 year capital expenditure and
Reserve Cost Estimate• $9.5M total with cost escalation• Big ticket items:
• Replace steam system‐ $1.5M
57ANNUAL MEETING
Zoning / Entitlement Review
FIRST HILL URBAN CENTER VILLAGE
HR ZONE HIGH RISE
• Residential Use is permitted• Congregate Residences are
permitted
• Base FAR = 8 • All Multi-family Structures &
enclosed amenity areas are exempt from FAR
• Base Height Limit = 160 ft• Maximum Height Limit = 240 or
300 ft
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
30
HR ZONE HIGH RISE
• Base Height Limit = 160 ft
• Maximum Height Limit = 240 or 300 ft
ANNUAL MEETING
ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
31
• Kick off Master Planning in July with Session I
• Key considerations will be:
– Market Demand
– Levels of Care
– Financial Feasibility
– Operations
– Location and services
61ANNUAL MEETING
Global PRCN Master Planning Key Considerations:
• Evaluate operational synergies between our 4 Communities
• Avoid Direct Competition with one Another
• Explore Operational Efficiencies
• Integrate into PRCN Strategic Plan
62ANNUAL MEETING
June 2015
32
Next Steps
• Complete Master Planning sessions for each community and create final plan
• Complete master plan budget and financial, operational models
• Finalize financing options and strategies
• Implementation of master plan (phased)
• Continued communication with all stakeholders throughout the process
Conclusion
• Master Planning is essential to long‐term success of your community
• It is a long‐term strategic process requiring support by a team of experts
• It sets the operational, financial and cultural tone for the future of your organization
• Master planning involves all stakeholders and is a collaborative effort
June 2015
33
ANNUAL MEETING
QUESTIONS?