all tax cases

Upload: franky-time-minalang

Post on 07-Apr-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    1/322

    .;,549.,,.723,,9,,943,/23897,9;0,00.943,7020/,,!5530.43899:943.,80/089,34908

    O O $$%O %$#$O %#O &$%

    %%

    422884307;8:0

    $#

    ,.98

    %0!5530$:,789,900;0452039425,3!$

    554390/:03.,898,039:070.0;0/,.422884341

    ,3/9,81742907.42288439,995,/47,307841

    '!3574547943,1008

    90#010/,099074157490894770

    9,990.,20//0/:.943,8574507

    47/3,770,843,-04730.088,70503

    88:0890#.4770.9

    #:3

    49,08,709010-44/41

    .40.90/94:9:330.088,73/7,3.0

    2:89.4397-:9088,703907:333

    147985,798050.90/94708543/390

    -0301983903/0/942574;090;084

    ,3/2,907,;,:08%882-49.70,

    ,3/84://850900774304:8349439

    0,.943-948039080,9415407

    3904907,3/8:..40.

    9,,8,3,7-97,7308830,90

    9801

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    2/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    3/322

    ,:947994.40.99,0885,7,24:39

    88:0890,5574;,4190.4:792,3/,947706:702039390.40.943

    419,08

    #:3

    49003147.02039419,,8,3/.40.943419,08,7041

    5,7,24:3925479,3.0147908:8903,3.0414;0732039%,08,7090

    10-44/41904;0732039,3/84:/-0.40.90/94:9:330.088,7

    3/7,3.040;078:..40.94384:/-02,/03,..47/,3.09

    ,,8,3,7-97,7308830,9090;0770,8431474;073203998019

    89070147030.088,79470.43.090,55,7039.431.9339070894190

    ,:947908,3/909,5,078849,99070,5:75480419,,943.8

    90574249434190.4224344/2,-0,.0;0/

    07/3,3/#,7.48,88,0/90/0.84341904:7941

    550,8/0.,7390/01.03.3.4209,,8808820398,3/

    089,909,,8808820398:54390089,90,3/574507908418

    ,901,907/0859090503/03.4190574-,90574.00/3841

    904190,90!708/0393904907,3/90#

    ,7:0/9,990$9,908,:94799

    9,0885,7,24:39

    !09943071:7907,7:089,990

    .,8086:08943390,905708/0

    80;07,574507908-4970,,3/

    ;,:0418089,90,3/90.4380

    3.,5,-0410,.950.:3,7/090

    708543/0398,88088203941900

    419049.08410;,3/8,0,7

    4557088;00543984:99050

    ;,8048,3/

    4;0732039946:0894390430

    !708/039370,,3/507843,574

    4:98/090!55308!099430

    0907905745079080;0/:54

    41089,909,08:54390/0.0/03

    3;4;0/3908,/.,808503/3

    3/00/90.4:798,9,488,894

    700;,3994902,9907,988:0%

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    4/322

    /0.0/039,8503/3.,8083;4;3499030,9/408

    349,110.99003147.02039419,,88088203984;0790

    5745079083/:-9,-3.:/0/38089,90

    88:0890.4390394341,7.48.4770.9

    0/4%0,5574;,4190.4:7989933574-,9047,8,

    80990203997-:3,4;0790/0.0,80/8089,908349,

    2,3/,947706:702039390.40.94341089,909,08

    %07083493390%,4/0,3/390507930397020/,

    ,89,925089030.08894190574-,9047089,90

    809902039.4:798,5574;,419089,908.,2147089,90

    9,08-01470908,20.,3-003147.0/,3/.40.90/

    %003147.02039419,,8,3/90.40.943419,08,7041

    5,7,24:3925479,3.0147908:8903,3.0414;0732039

    %,08,709010-44/414;0732039,3/84:/-0.40.90/

    94:9:330.088,73/7,3.040;078:..40.943

    84:/-02,/03,..47/,3.09,,8,3,7-97,73088

    30,909008903.0414;07

    983499005,79203941:89.0

    9,80/94/090723090,24:39419

    089,90-:990:70,:4139073,#0

    ,3/,8808820398,705708:20/.47

    9,5,07,890/:941574;349

    41,3770:,79083905071472,3

    ,880882039349-0/89:7-0/

    0892,9088572,1,.0;,/,3/,

    ,;0-003,77;0/,9,7-97,747.,

    8:54390.425,335,799484

    0774304:8,:7094570803957441

    :89190:/.,,1172,3.0418,/

    50994307,834954390/4:94308

    0247,3/:24190$50.,:/9%

    6:089430/,880882039.-0,7

    509943078,99,.4390,8808820

    2574-,-0,3/:3.438.43,-0,2

    207070947..,33498:5590-,8

    90,88088203982,/0

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    5/322

    47034;8!48,/,8

    !

    ,.98

    %42,8,30/0/3,2-4,3,0,;3,.

    574;/0/,243490789,9905745079;0394,990030

    -04394243,19070,78,1907%42,8/0,943806:03990

    #,880880/3079,3.09,,,38990089,90470349097:89004190

    089,905,/90,88088203984357490890.43903/0/9,9903079,3.09,

    84:/,;0-003,19070,78

    88:0890.439039432079474:8

    #:3

    49043-0301943.909,5,07803990/89,9

    /07;0/1742900342039419057;00841;33,347,30/

    84.09089,-80/,3/8,10:,7/0/-90/0;4943419,0894905:-.

    5:75480%04;0732039574280/349394905078439,0/-043/

    ,92,-0,39.5,90/1742,/23897,

    44/

    %,08,70088039,147900

    4-,943945,9,087089349:54390

    57490.943,1147/0/9490.903-90

    4124301479908:554794190089,90

    4-0.947708895,2039419,08840-

    .,3-054390/4:9,8,7831742909,

    !033;8#

    #::89

    ,.98

    !03347547,943,8

    ,550,8.,11720/90/0.843419

    50945,980.809,,-95

    ,8503/3.,28147;,935:9.70/94

    .84:/-02,/0.425038,904780

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    6/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    7/322

    34234;848.48490$:570204:79/0.,70/,913,,3/

    00.:9479047/074190.4:79411789389,3.041090147905,203941

    089,90,3/3079,3.09,08.,708,3/503,908,24:39394

    -90089,904190,90,907$.499!30050994314700.:943

    10/-9018.,40;07,8/030/-90407.4:7990.4:790/

    9,99000.:9438:3:8910/,8904;0732039980183/0-90/9490

    089,90147,3/47/070/90,24:39413079,3.09,08-0/0/:.90/

    1742904;073203983/0-90/30889490089,90

    88:08,39070-00,.425038,943

    #:3

    08%01,.99,990.4:79,;3:78/.9434190089,90,/

    14:3/9,990.,24190089,90,,389904;0732039,8-003

    ,557457,90/147905:75480-,.47708543/3,#8489,9

    -4990.,241904;07320391473079,3.09,08,3/90.,24190

    39089,90147807;.0870,7/0/,;0,70,/-0.4204;07/:0,3/

    /02,3/,-0,80,81:6:/,90/425038,943907014709,0

    5,.0-4507,94341,3,..47/,3.0990574;843841,79.0

    ,3/4190.;.4/0,3/-49/0-98,70093:80/9490,24:39

    !;8/:

    $#

    ,.98

    %0!5530,7308803,

    -:83088:3/07,08,9;017,3.80

    905,2039419,0839089703941

    :89.0!,8/0907230/34994,;0

    70897,943100883.0%0,3/%

    706:70/,9,002590399083.:/3

    70897,9431008!57490890/

    88:07024947;0.070897,943100

    #:3

    985488-0147,30,.9439

    .03801008,3/.,708440/94,8,

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    8/322

    20,384170:,943%02430.40.90/:3/079024947;0.0,8

    3493903/0/147900503/9:708419024947;0.0411.0-:9,..7:094

    901:3/814790.43897:.943,3/2,3903,3.041905:-.74,/88970098

    ,3/-7/088901008,70349.40.90/14770:,9475:75480,8,3

    3./039949003147.020394170:,943,4;07334507,9434124947

    ;0.08435:-.,8-:994574;/070;03:09.90

    4;0732039894.43897:.9,3/2,39,35:-.,81470;074308

    :8090,709,0834920701008

    :9;87,309,

    #

    ,.98

    ,907:9,8:7/.,,/23897,947419039089,90089,9041

    394340/082,84:99470.4;07908:2415,/-90

    089,90,89,08174290.422884307:3/0780.943'4190

    .422430,9,.9908:,7,/:892039,.90,00/9,98:.9,8

    :3.43899:943,,8980;0/14790,/,3/8:5547941908:,73/:897

    0.:8;0.83845343349,5:-.5:75480

    88:08909,08;,/

    #:3

    08%09,80;0/970

    20,381479070,-9,943,3/89,-

    8,572,7,3007.804154.0540

    540788:,7574/:.9438430419

    ,3/9,9985742494357490.943,3/,

    0307,01,70%008,9:7014:3/9

    903/:89784:/-089,-0/,3/57

    -03019890701742-070,/:890/,243

    90,//0/897,341903.70,8039,9

    #4,809,;8%

    #57

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    9/322

    ,.98

    %0#4,8-749078430/,7.:9:7,,3/89,949,,70,41

    0.9,70899003/419080.43/47/,790903,39057088

    907/0870945:7.,80174290-749078905,7.0807090,.9:,

    4..:547985,79904;07320393.43843,3.0990.43899:943,

    2,3/,9094,.6:70-,3/0/089,90,3/,5547943902,243,3/088

    903,3985078:,/0/90-749078945,799907,3/4/3840;07

    904;0732039//349,;0901:3/894.4;07905:7.,8057.084#4,8

    ,40/901,7207894-:90,3/147908,2057.0-:9-389,2039

    $:-806:03990#/02,3/0/9,990-749078945,70,089,90/0,078

    9,147908,041908,/,3/

    88:070509943078,-0

    #:3

    490.439039434190##4,8,84:/-0.438/070/,

    70,089,90/0,07-0.,:80903,0/3908034170,089,90,894:9

    2079%08,041901,72,8349433.43843,3.09-:93

    4-0/03.09490706:089,3/5:78:,39949054.41904;073203994

    ,4.,90,3/89490,3/0889890/:941904;0732039945,90

    ,700/.425038,943,190795078:,/0/

    ,3/948:-806:0398:-/;/0902,2

    90728,3/57.08

    !,8.:,;8$0.709,741!:-.47

    $#

    ,.98

    !0994307800894/0.,70#

    /0.,7390/43,943-$03::09,,

    902,557457,93.905

    .43897:.9434174,/82574;39057;

    9,9908,/,,8349147,5:-.5:

    88:08#:3.43899:943,

    #:3

    08#8,33;,/2

    5742494341,57;,90039075780,89-0

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    10/322

    3/;/:,%0574;8439,990,3/9070,1907-0/43,90/9490

    4;0732039,8349.:7090/010.9%07:089,91905:-.,/;,39,0

    47-03019820703./039,35742494341,5,79.:,70390757808:.

    /010.98,703/0790,3;,/3904907,3/1,983./039,

    8905742494341,57;,90039075780909,,8,-0/0020/147,

    5:-.5:75480

    820N,;87-48

    $#

    ,.98

    !0994307800894,;0$0.5,7,7,541!,8

    ,203/0/-/0.,70/:3.43899:943,147-03:3/:0,3/3;,/

    /00,9434108,9;05407949030770:,9474,7/&3/0790

    ,88,0/,90#8;0390,:94799425480,//943,,24:398

    43509740:2574/:.98,3/9425480,//943,,24:39894,:203990

    7084:7.0841901:3/0,7:09,9902430.40.90/5:78:,3994!

    2:89-0970,90/,8,850.,1:3/349,8,97:89,..4:3947,97:891:3/

    ,3/9,91,850.,9,8.40.90/147,850.,5:7548098,-0970,90/

    ,8,850.,1:3/94-0:80/43147905:754803/.,90/

    88:089070:3/:0/00,9434108

    #:3

    4147,;,//00,943415

    /00,939054072:89-04250

    54.94-000.:90/-90/00,90

    .,708:11.039/090723,9047/0

    2:89.4314720901:3/82,-0

    03,.90/390007.80419054.054

    8:-0.9949070;0,3/,..4:39341

    990.43899:943,/08.7594341,8

    ,8.4;8!#

    #,

    ,.98

    !#,8.70,90/-;79

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    11/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    12/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    13/322

    4:/349.4314729490%,7002039

    88:0,890.439039432079474:8

    #:3

    4084;07039,897,/943,-003/0020/,-84:90,3/

    ,03.425,883390/42089.0;09840;078:-0.99470897.9438

    ,3/29,9438;4:39,7,700/94-90!5530805708847

    250/,8,202-0741901,23,9438&36:08943,-90

    .43899:943//34903;843072995084:9434190.4:397174290

    7089419047/

    903070393,9:70%70,908294770897.990,-84:903088

    4184;07039907;4:39,7,.93,94382,8:7703/078420,850.98

    4190789,90540730.,3014770,907-0301987,390/-,/07;0/

    1742,.43;03943475,.9

    422884307;8

    $#

    ,.98

    7984;0780,8,7,8.475

    47547,943803,0/339073,943,

    9,8344,/379814797,11.

    2,39,30/,0307,8,08,039390!

    1478039.098.4;0735,8

    ,880880//01.03.3.4209,08,,3

    88:08,-0945,9,08

    #:3

    08%084:7.0413.4208

    574/:.08903.420479084:7.041

    174290!55308988:11.0399,9

    ,.9;9.423174290!55308%

    70;03:094-09,,-092:89.43899:90

    98.,80908,0419.09889084:7.0

    415,20398890!55308

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    14/322

    %,3;80#48,74

    $#

    ,.98

    !09943078.,03090.43899:943,941#4790

    82510/3.4209,,9438.020$%:3/07798,3/,3/

    %0$%.439,30/.,3083909,8.0/:08,3//1107039

    970,92039390574108843,8.509943078,88,,8:3.43899:943,

    147-0384,9;0419006:,57490.943.,:80390.43899:943

    88:0890.439039432079474:8

    #:3

    4:314729419,,9430903/070/.43.0594106:,

    57490.9432070706:709,9,8:-0.98474-0.98419,,94382,7

    89:,90/,7094-0970,90/,0-4957;008,3/,-908&314729

    /40834941103/.,881.,943,843,897089438:-89,39,/893.94389

    8072,3094905:754804190,98349290/94089343,3/

    2:89,5506:,94,202-07841908,20.,88

    %008,9;0390398943.

    8890294,7/8908.0/:0/,5574,.

    ,3/2,39,39057080394-,970,9203

    .,881.,943830907,7-97,73473,

    fIf

    fn9fIf

    ff

    ,nf

    %ffffff

    -n

    %@;ffnf

    f-n

    ff9f

    fff

    nfnf

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    15/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    16/322

    nfff

    fffffffff

    ff%,nfn

    nnffffn

    ffnfnnf

    n%-ffnf

    fn

    nffnff#

    fnfffnnf

    nffffnffnn

    f%f;f

    fJffffn

    ffnnff

    ffffffff

    fnnfnff

    ffnffnnf

    @nnnf

    nffnnff

    ff

    ,ffnff

    nnf

    nfn,f

    fn9fffnf

    nf

    f9

    f,ff-

    ,fffnfnf

    nn

    f,ff

    9fnf

    %n

    9ff

    9fn

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    17/322

    ,ffn@f,ff

    fffnnf

    nfn-

    nf,ffnfnf

    fnffffnf

    ffnfn

    fnnn

    ff

    f9nff

    fffnf

    fn@fff

    nffnn

    fnnnfff

    nffffnf

    nnffn9f

    ffnnnf

    fff

    f

    @n

    ff

    nnn

    nfnf

    nfnf

    fnf

    nfnf

    ffn

    ffn f

    ff

    @nffn

    n

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    18/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    19/322

    903899:943,8,5:-..,79%0002594331,;4:7415745079:80/

    0.:8;0147.,79,-0470/:.,943,5:754808349290/945745079

    ,.9:,3/85038,-090701470-:90903/8941,.908.,70

    3./039,94,3/70,843,-30.088,714790,..42582039418,/

    5:754808:.,8390.,80414859,8,8.4414797,333:7808,

    3:78084205745079:80/94574;/04:831,.908147390738

    708/039/4.94788:5073903/0398,3/4907202-07841904859,89,11

    ,3/70.70,943,1,.90814789:/0393:7808390738,3/708/039893

    905:7;0419043899:943$9,9073084859,8,.,79,-0

    3899:9430025917429,,943

    $43,7%,,943

    !,28809;8%

    #0.

    ,.98

    !0994307,.98,83;0820392,3,0741

    2,3,0203990.3.,807;.08,3/9

    !!94/90,24:394106:

    70:,94335710/97

    4/39,!099430710/147701:3/1

    /030/9050994314770;00/

    .70/9413.4209,5,/,.47547,9432

    2,7390.47708543/3-44398,

    88:0

    09074734950994307803990/94,

    #:3

    39,3.4209,985,/30.08841

    2,-0701:3/0/574;/0/9,9,9,5,

    30.,334909,9,701:3/,3/,9,.

    0.088943.4209,085,/,:70948

    880882039#09:73#/40834920,

    147,701:3/

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    20/322

    #06:739,990%#4390#41908:..00/30,7-057080390/94

    90#3706:0893,9,701:3/,834-,883,,3/:7857:/03.0

    %0%,4/0080,4890701:3/419,08949,5,079,9.,289

    3793930,78,19075,203941909,08%0.3.,908,3/

    0,8284:/349-028:80/-904;0732039940052430349

    -0433949,3/9070-037.0/9801,9900503804198,,-/3

    .9038

    $,2,,3;8$0.41,-47,3/8890283.

    #:30

    !:34

    ,.98

    $,2,,3:34350994307,7089070/:34310/,509943147

    .0791.,94300.943!7;,90708543/0/6:089430/9089,9:84150994307

    ,8439074:3/41,.41574419,998.4397,.941,11,9439

    &&,8-0038:-2990/94#$,2,,3,;0770/9,9,8,3

    3/0503/039,3//:7089070/:3439,8,90798,3/57;00894

    ,.9,8,705708039,9;04198202-078147905:7548041.40.93

    -,7,33902540780/,7-907/82880/905099430,30

    &,8,40/94.43/:.9.0791.,94300.943,3/0;039:,

    3049,90/,!7;,90708543/0391

    88:0

    0907473490,507843,94190:

    089,-80/.4:/-08:-0.994.4,907,

    #:3

    !09943078,33/0503/0397089070/

    509943147.0791.,94300.94343984

    574;098,11,9439&&

    509943,8,33/0503/039:343

    !099430780,843,-,550,0/9:898

    .0791.,94300.943..47/39070

    .,80,99092090,8039070/-

    %07084:/-0344-89,.0949079

    .0791.,94300.943,990574507920

    057,94341901041,.07910/

    ,70020398:-2990//:7390503/03.

    &%&!;8%7,,34

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    21/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    22/322

    %0:3;078,3899:943415099430794090798-749078,3/889078

    9490039703079,3.041909089,947708:983949,,-74,9390

    -0.,:80903:1.,943418:.3899:94341:3;078,07894:9,3

    49079089,2039,7/8548943390,24:39894,/0.,7,9439,9

    3493,87990340,.08,3//0;8008,;3-003574;/0/390

    904057450794190/0.0,80/,8-003019-:3;078,99094

    50994307,3/8-749078,3/889078

    !$'$#%

    #.94-07

    ,3.,.4

    %$

    !09943078-4:9945,7.0841,3/,3/,349075,7.08901443

    0,7%05,7.0807084/3090490707084/3

    #0,35741981742908,050994307810/.,59,,38

    9,40;0790070,880880/9/

    9,08

    $$&

    09074734950994307814720/,3:3

    ,880880/9.47547,903.4209,

    #&

    90.4397,.9415,793078594472

    .4397-:9024303/:8974757450799

    41/;/3574198,24390280;08%

    509943078039070/394,3,700203994

    ,3/9,9903903/94/;/0574198,2

    5:7.,80/5,7.0841,3/,3/-0.,20.

    418039049807084,90/.,808%

    9490-:8308897,38,.9438147905:75

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    23/322

    %08,7341709:738140834939801089,-8,5,7930785090747

    3499050784388,7390703,;0,43947.42243794739070893

    905745079%0702:89-0,.0,7390399414725,79307859008903.0

    41,:7/.,507843,9/11070391742903/;/:,5,793078,3/90

    1700/42410,.5,799497,3810747,88390405745079

    $#'$

    #4;02-07

    #0,,/4

    %$

    $,7/,3000.:90/574288473490839

    411,:70945,.40/4-74:9,3,.

    2430$,7/,30,00/9,9,5,793078

    -:9#%70;0780/:54/370,8439,9

    90..4:/903;,79020,33

    .43.:/0/9,9!3;4;0/0702070

    8,/5,7930785,3/:50/90.,29

    03.05,740;/03.0,8,4,-094

    7057080390/4,3.4397,.9

    $$&

    0907473495,79307850890/03

    #&

    ;0310;/03.049079,3!2,-0

    .43;00/9070-89900;/03.083

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    24/322

    0890/-090039057;,905,7908%01,.99,90,/70.0;0/4190

    309574198/408349.43.:8;0089,-89,90,8,5,7930741

    .40/,79.005.9574;/089,99070.05941,507843

    41,8,7041905741984190-:830888572,1,.00;/03.09,908,

    5,79307390-:83088348:.310703.08,-0/7,318:.574198

    07070.0;0/35,2039,8,0841,3025400

    %#%'%###%##$'$

    #

    #:30

    ,75447,08

    %$

    3900,790,557457,90/!!41#,8

    5747,220/1:3/9,557457,90/,805,7,90,24:3941!41#:3/07

    90.,881.,94341:35747,220/1:3/90,9907,24:3994-0700,80/

    43:54394..:7703.04190.43/943889,90/390

    $$&

    090747349906:089430/574;843;4,9090.43899:943,3:3.943

    9,990:898,70414.,4;073203983903,943,9,084190#

    8,-0,:942,9.,700,80/

    #&

    79.0$0.943419043899:9435

    8,70,8/0907230/-,3903,94

    ,:942,9.,700,80/949020

    :898,7084:/-0700,80/94902,8

    700,80503/3,30;039.4397,;030/9

    #$%'$

    #57

    0

    %$

    !,3911,550,398,14703343894.

    .47547,943,3/390.4:780419823

    48505479438974:4:990.4:397,

    !5530/,0.98%0941,3,

    90-:83088410307,207.,3/0,3/

    50729,3/.03801008

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    25/322

    $$&

    090747349,550,39103,0/3-:83088,8,704:8.47547,943

    ,3/9:8-02,/0945,1008479,08

    #&

    92,-097:09,99057.041--08,3/5,25098,8,-9079,3

    90,.9:,.48941908,20-:998.4:/34920,39,9,550,398

    03,0/3-:8308814757419479870,8430-00;09,99047/3,3.0

    706:73902945,1008479,084:/25,7981700007.804198

    704:81700/4297:/897-:943415,25098

    #'$#%$'#$$#$

    #57

    3,3.00.407707,

    %$

    798;0780,87,88,7984;0732039430/.47547,943

    03,0/339073,943,,730-:83088,3/8,202-074190390730

    7%7,385479884.,943,3/9:894507,908,797,385479,943807;.0,3/

    80897,385479,9439.0984;079074:90841904907,730202-078

    74294,/34,3/379814797,11.5:754808390

    !55308-:92,39,30/,0307,8,

    ,7308,87085438-0147803

    ,3/.,748%0#,880880//01.03.

    $$&

    0907473499070;03:0/07;0/-

    !553081479897,385479,943.43899

    ,3/,..47/39,,-0

    #&

    %084:7.041,33.4208905745079

    903.420479084:7.0413.42094

    !55308988:11.0399,9903.42

    90!553080703908,0419.0

    3.420%09.0980.,30/,3/80

    2,/0070390!5530.:7703.%

    890!55308%014410,957

    !5530907794703439057490.9

    4;07320393.438/07,943418:.57

    8,7090-:7/03418:554793904;07

    !038:7089,939073,943,,73

    !553084:7.08%09,4374

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    26/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    27/322

    .30110.9:,7,3900/9028,105,88,0,974:4:9025,7

    /,2,08390,24:3941,8080,,7/0/

    $$&

    09074734990,,7/1470025,7/,2,08,890,-,88

    #&

    %0,,7/410025,7/,2,0884:/-0023,90/3:38,,.;8

    0,7,$#9,88,/

    98349034:948,9,9,30,25084:/-02,/047.4770.9;0

    20,8:708-002540/147905:-.44/0850.,3,../039.,808

    0705:-..,77078,703;4;0/%0.,:8,9;03003.038:..,808

    8507843,94900254008,.9:,3.,704190;0.08,3/9890

    484:/-02,/0945,983/41/,2,08-,410,25047

    .4770.943:3088-90/0243897,9;09407,3.047,5574;,419043078

    9090280;08.,3-00/,91,:9,3/9071,:984190.,7,.907

    /08.7-0/3,79.04190;4/0

    390.,80,9-,790708348439,9$#$,.90/3,,3943

    472,0;40392,330779;4/0

    %$$$$#&'$$$

    &

    #:30

    '0,8.47

    %$

    030;4,/00-:8,343894.34357

    20/.,,798-:/3,8.43897:.90/,3

    .0791.,943.,881390-:/3,8.

    ,880880/90-:/39,2,709;,:

    ,880880/;,:041!5,990,

    .8.:7703925480/4357;

    .,20/9,990-:/38:80/,8.42

    9458.,38,3/9:8.,8810/,8.42

    .43903/0/9,990-:/38:80/,.9:

    4859,,3/84:/,;0,3,880882039

    $$&

    0907473499030-:/38,-

    #&

    04/9,99030-:/38,3390

    349-0,880880/,8.42207.,03,

    1:/05,792039,0/,3/-006:550/

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    28/322

    948:55479.07910/20/.,850.,89,3/4907.0380/58.,38%0

    1,.99,990,704/3411.08,805,7,90-:/3/4083499,0,,

    9008803.0,3/3,9:7041907807;.08;8,;8904;07,4507,9434190

    4859,,3/94985,90398

    &3/07904.,4;07320394/0$0.,3/8-:/38,3/4907

    2574;020398907043,.9:,/70.9,3/0.:8;0:80/1474859,8

    .:9:7,478.0391.5:754808,3/9480430/,3/:80/-4.,,907

    /897.988,-0.,8810/,8850.,

    884.,94341:8942874078;8,3,

    #,

    3,3.

    %$

    %0:3.5,4,7/41,3,5,880/47/3,3.04.254808

    ,57450799,9,989390540741909:3/079870;80/.,7907

    %047/3,3.0,85,880/-90:3.5,4,7/:3/0790,:9479

    .4310770/-80.94341#

    $$&

    0907473499047/3,3.03173084390:314729419,08,8

    47/,30/-9043899:943

    #&

    %07/3,3.00,.98909,:543,2

    ,3,,3//408349/893:8-09003

    9,3/4307089070/3,349075,.0

    ;0.014770%0/893.9438254

    3903/894-:7/039909,43948

    570903809,9907/3,3.006:,,55

    147,902547,75:75480

    '$#

    #57$#

    :90770

    %$

    !09943078,7070970/:89.084190$:5

    4,70.:7703970.0;35038438:3

    !708/039,7.4888:0/,/0.700

    .,:9470/90,/:89203941905

    411.078,3/03890/202-0784190

    -,7.48.574;/0/14790,:942

    411.078,3/03890/203,87089470/

    349#,87089470/974:

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    29/322

    ,;09074331472,9439,9906:089430/574;84383

    070,3,990259944;07.420070,707;0943!708/0396:34

    88:0/90;09434.,030/398509943

    99:7384:99,9!.7050,0/#30;07-0.,20,;,/,

    ,-8039985:-.,9439:89070,834,914489,9#,8

    8930110.9,3/,88:5071:4:8-0.,:809970/947089470

    -030198.07030;079,03,,;,/%0;09441//

    349,84574/:.0,30110.9

    $$&

    09074734990;0944190!708/03941.079,3574;843839041

    70,9394905,20394190,/:890/50384384170970/:89.08

    8.43899:943,47;,/

    #&

    %0;094419080850.1.574;843839089,39,24:3994/.9,93

    9490:/.,749981:3/884:/-0:90/.8.0,7705:3,3994

    18.,,:94342!:78:,3994.43899:943,2,3/,9090:/.,72:89

    0341700/42390/854894341901:3/8,4.,90/949390

    ,557457,9438,

    3,7:2039.8008947024;0850.,57;008;03-,94

    147207:89.08439074:3/9,9907084:/-0347,3941/893.9

    57;00847570107039,970,920399470970/:89.08347089080

    574;8438419043899:943,3/30110.9,889,9908043899:943,

    574;843843850.,57490.943814790

    %050994387,390/,3/906:08943

    41,70/0.,70/;,/,3/8:-

    #$'$#

    #57$#

    !,7,8

    %$

    !0994307,7043078415,7.0841,3/

    03,.90/574-931474300,7,33.70

    :398,3/8,/.9,84/8,40/00.92

    4190:8:,5074/410,809,880884

    5099430785745079-,80/43908.0/

    -90$0.709,7413,3.0%070;84

    7,908,3/509943078,;0770/9,99070,

    70,90.00/0/90,33:,3.420/07

    $$&

    0907473493.420,5574,.8902

    ,880882039,3/34990.425,7,-08,0

    #&

    3489709.41902,3,943.,390

    -!-006:,90/9902,709;,

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    30/322

    90.,80,9-,73490;031,.9478/090723,394190,880880/;,:0418:-0.9

    574507908:3/0790.425,7,-08,08,5574,.07057080390/-

    708543/0393,20

    %,9908,02:89705708039,-43,1/0,72803997,38,.943-09003

    ,38007,3/,3-:07

    %057450792:89-0.425,7,-05745079

    8,0307,7:09070070349,078849,99070.,3-03470,843,-0

    -,8814790.43.:8439,99080574507908,70.425,7,-0

    %,08,7010-44/414;073203940;078:..40.94384:/-0

    2,/03,..47/,3.0990,,3/9070147030.088,79470.43.0

    .431.93390708984190,:947908849,99070,5:75480419,,943

    57424943419001,7041.4224344/.,3-0,.0;0/

    '#%

    #:30$#

    !,70/08

    %$

    89,9041,.44/9/43,90/!53.,8947#:90390

    !,78!708941'.947,84,890570/0.08847415099430789,90

    10/907/43478199,-:950994307843574908970,7/3/430089,

    .,239,9,88088203941199,,,38990,94.:7.8,,389

    90,9,90390/43,943,82,

    $$&

    0907473495099430784:/-0,-

    /439,90/

    #&

    199,8349,57450799,-:9,30

    5745079-,41193907;;4890

    :80/0.:8;0147704:85:754808

    4143899:9430025917429,,943

    84:/349-0390757090/9420,30025

    9070-0334.0,75489;047057088

    1,;4741509943079000259430703

    &%#'$"&%

    #:30

    3,3.,04

    ,.98

    %0:3.039078,.,79,-03899:94

    .43899:9438%00020398.438/

    3899:943,709089,9:0.70,939003

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    31/322

    .43899:943,3/-,82094/841,/23897,9433,9:7041,.9:,47

    50714720/.,7,.9074190807;.08703/070/3/0139030884190

    -0301.,708,3/90:804..:5,943415745079088,03573.50,

    .,79,-03899:943/4034948098.,7,.907,88:.,3/980025943

    14729,08825-0.,:809/07;083.42017425,35,9039847

    70.0;088:-8/0817424;0732039,3/34243038:708949057;,90

    -03019419050784382,3,3474507,93903899:943

    88:0

    0907473499070,5745079084190:3.03907,7000259174270,

    57450799,08

    #:3

    !,794%4805479438419870,57450799,9,700,80/9457;,90

    039908,70349002591742,.9:,/70.9,3/0.:8;0:80/147

    .,79,-05:75480&3/07!90:3.03907/408349034,3

    57450799,002594357;0081479870,574507908,80,890

    -:/3.43897:.90/907043

    %057450799,0025943:3/07$0.79'419057450799,08

    43%8574;843,825,390/-$0.-41#.

    574;/089,9347/0794-003990/9490002594390:3.039072:89

    -0,-094574;09,998,.,79,-03899:943,3/9870,574507908,70

    ,.9:,/70.9,3/0.:8;0:80/147.,79,-05:75480..47/3

    9054794384..:50/-904859,:80/147985,90398,70002591742

    70,57450799,08094800,80/94

    17428:.9,08

    &%'$#%

    #0.02-07

    #008

    %$

    ,907:9:/.,/23897,947419

    84:99470.4;07908:241!5

    ,039,98:.9,8:3.43899:943,

    41908:,73/:8970.:8;0.

    5:75480

    $$&

    0907473499,8;,/38:554793

    #&

    %0.4:797:0/9,9909,8;,/,89

    574;/0/14738572,7,30

    8,70,984:7.0413.42014790.4:39

    ,-4707803.09,8.425090391479

    01,70/02,3/0/9,9908:,73/:897

    390/010/419854.0540790

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    32/322

    90/897-:94341-03019890701742-070,/:890/,24398.425430398

    9403,-09947088990,//0/897,341903.70,8039,089,99,/94

    8:89,3

    $$##'$%#!

    #:30

    .:3,

    %$

    %88,50994314770;0:3/07#:041#:08414:79800390

    3:1.,94341/0.8437,393708543/0398.,21479,06:,9490

    ,24:3941909,990903/0/9480347.90384390,99078

    5:7.,8085:78:,3994$03479038.9#08543/039/0/:.90/90949,

    ,24:3941!517429874883.420147909,,-00,7

    070-708543/039//3495,9,1479,90,77054793,30948841

    !5398.47547,903.4209,3.,239,990

    !584:/-0,550/,8,9,.70/9708543/039.,20/147701:3/

    390,24:3941!5

    $$&

    09074734990/8.4:397,390/-90708543/039946:,10/

    80347.90382,-0.,20/,89,.70/947,8/0/:.94317427488

    8,08

    #&

    %,.70/9805.9574;/0/1473

    ;0394$0347.90388,9,.70/93

    4190089,-82039.43.0730/%09,

    98.98,147241:89.425038,943

    0774304:8470,,880880/,3/.4

    5,203941,39,,-98,570.43

    -0301917429,.70/9%0.70/92,-

    07090708349,,-947070

    488147905074/909,.70/9.,3-0

    3099,,-00,7

    !$%!#%'$%%#

    #57

    2507,

    %$

    %054894.!7010.98,.47547,943

    :3/0790!5530,8,3/9708

    ,850.,,880882039,,389574507908

    3.:/39480419054894.!7010.9

    ,3/8007,088902%054894.!70

    84:/-01700419,-0341704:8

    $$&

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    33/322

    09074734954894.!7010.9,8,704:80399800259174290

    5,20394190850.,,880882039

    #&

    850.,,8808820398349,9,,3/3090790/0.70034790

    43899:943002595099430717425,2039418,/850.,,880882039

    94:998-74,/20,339,3.:/08-490307,9,08,3/850.,

    ,8808820390990708,70.430//893.9438808820398.43130/94

    4.,25489438:5435745079147905,20394190.489415:-.

    2574;020398398220/,90;.39,3/0;0/9850.,-03019894

    905745079,880880/!0994307080,8574;039,99057450793

    6:089438:80/0.:8;0147704:85:754808-:99,99,550,7890

    8,208-03:80/944907343704:85:754808%:8509943078

    706:70/945,90850.,,880882039

    !'$&

    #::89

    :90770

    %$

    !803,0/3,797,385479,943-:83088:3/07,08,9;017,3.80

    0703980025917429,5,2039!,8349-0035,324947

    ;0.070897,94383.0%0,3/#0897,943422884307

    706:70/,9,002590399083.:/3!945,24947;0.0

    70897,9431008

    $$&

    09074734970897,9431008,8942

    !8002590/

    #&

    %,08,7014770;03:0070,81008,700

    ,3/3850.943,3/,701479,970,843

    30.088,794.4;0790.4894190807;.

    904-0.94190.,70,3/349903,2

    8,9,47,100%02430.40.90/:3

    3903/0/147900503/9:7084190'

    90.43897:.943,3/2,3903,3.0415:-

    81008,70349.40.90/14770:,947

    03147.020394170:,94384;07339

    5:-.,8-:994574;/070;03:0

    .43897:.9,3/2,39,35:-.,8

    ;079,-09,0834920701008!8

    0.059147905074/-09003:30

    002594339017,3.80,87050,0/

    %!!!$'$

    #

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    34/322

    ,;/0

    %$

    38039,0990794,90/70.93994702994!$98

    .40.9434190,//943,9,43509740:2,:9470/:3/07!,3/

    503/38:.70299,3.0,4198.,28174290!$8,-00/3

    ,-0,3.0!0994307706:0890/147900,7700,804198

    702-:7802039.0791.,908174290!$.4;073.,2899011.0

    4130711,78/030/908,20

    $$&

    09074134950994307.,3,;,41907994411809,3,24:399,99

    2,-0706:70/:3/0790,9470299490!$,,389,3,24:399,9

    92,70.0;0-,41702-:7802039

    #&

    98,80990/7:09,9,9,5,072,3494118099,08/:0174290.,28

    9,902,,;0,,389904;0732039%,08.,3349-0908:-0.941

    .425038,943-0.,:80904;0732039,3/9,5,07,703492:9:,

    /0-9478,3/.70/9478410,.4907,3/,.,21479,0883498:.,/0-9

    /02,3/.4397,.947:/2039,88,40/94-0809411

    %04.425,3082070,.90/,8,0398147904;0732039390,99078

    .40.94383.09,08,705,880/:3949003/:807890.438:235:-.

    '$#%$

    #:30

    ,-7,/47

    %$

    34234;848.48490$:57020

    9047/074190407.4:79147905,2

    .,708,3/503,908,24:39394!5

    ,90,907!7.0%05099430714700

    -90407.4:79%0.4:790/9,99

    4;073203983/0-90/9490089,90147

    ,24:39413079,3.09,08.,3-0/0/:

    3/0-90/30889490089,90

    $$&

    090741349,9,,3/,/0-92,-0

    #&

    %0.4:79,;3:78/.943419089,

    89,90,,389904;0732039,8-003

    ,70,/-003,557457,90/-,.4770854

    4;07320391473079,3.09,08,3/9

    703/070/,;0,70,/-0.4204;07/:0

    6:/,90/425038,9439,085,.0-

    093:80/9490.43.:77039,24:39

    799400.:9090:/20391479,08,

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    35/322

    ,907!7.0

    #'$&%'$#%#

    $#:

    0.,34

    %$

    %0!708/03988:0/,3.25480/,.748890-4,7/3.:/3

    .7:/04,3/49074574/:.98,//943,/:9,/;,4702%0%,711

    42288430/5:-.0,738438,/,3/8:-2990/,7054799490

    !708/039147.438/07,943,3/,557457,90,.943%0!708/0394390

    4907,3/88:0/,3.0;0/,850.,/:941!50790741

    254790/.7:/04,3/!50790741254790/4574/:.98

    $$&

    09074134990!708/0392,88:0,3.89,39,24:3994

    03,.93,-3903,9:704170;03:00307,9320,8:708

    #&

    %04:798,/9,9,94:9003,.9203941,557457,94370;03:0,3/

    9,711-889390574;3.0419008,9;09/4083491449,9

    36:08943,88:23902,-0.,7,.9070/,870;03:020,8:70,70

    574-90/9490!708/0399,9902:89-003,.90/3890,/-437088

    $0.9434179.0'419043899:943574;/08

    %04370882,-,,:94709

    4907/:90847254898

    %0700;,3943708843,89,9:90890

    !55308,3/$0.9438,3/9

    ,7507,94384228843%0,2

    $0,!,3,3-,3

    !49.,,02074,7047

    723,,3%4770.,254

    ,-47,$0.$,3.40$,3,,

    0,9.8070/2,3,

    07.,390,:33$,39,,3,$0

    #020/,,0$,3,,3$0!,

    %,,943,070/2,3,

    ;,$0,-743%4770.,25

    $0!,3,3-,3070/2,3,!4890/

    4228843

    ,9.4220398%,,943

    !#%$$$$

    $%%%%&

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    36/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    37/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    38/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    39/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    40/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    41/322

    :78/.943

    0,790701470708543/039:/0,/34:78/.943949,0.43,3.0

    4190509943,3/88:0906:089430/%#

    98,-,8.573.509,99040.94741:89428,80.:8;0

    :78/.9434;0780:70,3/147109:70574.00/3841/:9,-044/8

    89:/4:8,3/.438.0394:8:/0.,30,8-0.43;078,3998:.,3

    002039,77:0

    %#$%%!%%#

    %!#'$%'#%

    %!##!#%;8%%&

    #457

    ,.98!#90509943078,4;073203940/,3/.439740/

    .47547,943.70,90/:3/07422430,9.9989,80/94:3/079,0

    90/0;045203941/7400.97.0307,9438415407,3/90574/:.943

    4100.97.917423:.0,7049072,,3/490784:7.08,80,890

    97,38288434100.97.540743,3,943/0-,88

    472,30,7834!#80800.97.54079490708/039

    ,-,3,9:,3954893,74883.42041!3

    !:78:,3994$0.417/3,3.0490708543/039,880880/90

    50994307,17,3.809,,24:39394!

    41901472078748870.059814790

    !0994307480.,59,894.,88:-8

    !55304;0732039701:80/945,9

    708543/039,834,:947994254809,

    ,84.43903/9,9,8,3435741947,3

    5,203941,14728419,08.,708/

    $0.41#,8,203/0/

    %0708543/03910/,.40.9438:93

    /02,3/39,9509943075,90,88088

    4190,24:39419,,3/2439

    509943078002594317424.,9,08

    #4.,4;07320394/0%

    /8288390.,803,550,904:

    4190#%,3/47/070/905099430794

    ,880882039

    88:08890!#0.:/0/1

    9,825-0.,:8098894.8,704

    4;0732039,3/98.,7907.,7,.9070

    890!#800259431742

    574;843841904.,4;07320394

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    42/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    43/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    44/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    45/322

    4:7941%,550,8,3/%9490#%%06:089430/#,3/

    #,70,.9:,7:3847453438419042288430725020393

    90%,4/043909,,-94190!,38458

    &3/07#3.970,93904:7941%,550,88:.7:3841

    904228843074139073,#0;03:0,70,550,,-0949,9.4:79

    $0.:78/.943%04:7941%,550,88,007.800.:8;0

    ,550,90:78/.9439470;0-,550,,80703574;/0/

    0.843841904228843074139073,#0;03:03.,8083;4;3

    /85:90/,8808820398701:3/84139073,70;03:09,081008474907

    .,708503,90825480/370,9439070944749072,99078,783:3/07

    90,943,#0;03:04/0474907,8475,7941,,/2389070/-90

    :70,:4139073,#0;03:0

    9,7020/0880.943484:/3899:90,550,39,.,808

    $$#%##'&;8$%#

    #%%%#

    #4:

    ,.983987084:943/,90/4;02-0790$:570204:79/030/

    90!09943147#0;04307947,78:-2990/-9042288430741

    39073,#0;03:0147343.425,3.0

    ;071.,94305.93$0.#:041

    ,3/1:79072470-0.,:8090,550,,

    0307,03902494314770.438/0

    080/030/5099430710/90389

    908:55480//8.705,3.-09003905

    430,3/9,94:/706:70905,79.5

    0307,,3/50793039574;84384190

    ,40,411.0784190:70,:4139

    .43/:.9:/.,,.9433-0,14190

    %,#01472.941

    88:070900,411.074190#,

    574.00/38,8/893:80/1742.42

    905,79.5,9434190$4.9470307,

    0/%03899:94347.42203.0

    ,3/.723,,.9438,3/574.00/38,7

    .8,-0.43/:.90/0,411.0

    #0;03:083493/85:903,550,17

    2,99074179$0.4190%,#014

    4;079:7339043089,-80/574.0/

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    46/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    47/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    48/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    49/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    50/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    51/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    52/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    53/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    54/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    55/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    56/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    57/322

    93088082:89-0:3/074,9,3/70/:.0/94793390147241

    80,7.36:089438,3/,38078,8349.4250/9703/07390

    80,7.,77,393;,/43806:039900;/03.0800/5:78:,3994

    0,80,7.,77,39.,3349-0:80/30;/03.0,,389,550,393

    ,..47/,3.09$0.94379.0419043899:943

    $%'#%!#$%%"&$##$%

    %&%##%

    !!'$#$!#

    #4,3:,7

    ,.98!7;,90.425,3,39,-09039074,83974/:.0/94,..:80/

    7853,-07-071703/8%0,..:80/94/0390749,90.4:/

    0507,.6:709030.088,75,5078,3/13/07,4-,-74,/039074

    3974/:.0/90,..:80/94#,::7,34%0,..:80/411070/:7,34,4-

    ,88507843,/7;07390&$:7,34,3/0390745,/90,..:80/,3/

    ,80/14770.059-:990,..:80/8,/9,99,834930.088,783.090

    0,;0940907

    0,300390743974/:.0/90,..:80/94%0783,3,,3/411070/,

    4-,-74,/%070,190790,..:80/3897:.90/90970057;,90

    .425,3,398039074:7,34,3/3,9420092,990,754794390

    ,700//,9040;0790,..:80/1,0/

    :7,34.,3.0/:54390,..:80/,990

    03:7,34970/94894590,..:80/1

    -74:9-49:7,34,3/90,..:80/94

    411070/30;/03.0,.0791.,9017429

    349.0380/47,:9470/9470.7:947

    ,..:80//030/70.0;3243017425

    ,/0103804117,20:5,3/0947943,,

    88:080907473499097,.4:79

    ,..:80/,770890/94:9,77,39

    09074734990.4:79,.6:70/:7

    ,..:80/

    0/9,550,789,9,..:80/,550,3

    940907990.425,3,39:7,343

    -:9-0.,:804190.42249439,9038:

    99054.089,943:7,34,3/9049

    89,9020398.,73,550,3990

    09079070,8,3,.9:,,7708947

    ,550,39.422990/,8,.9:,.422

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    58/322

    ,34110380,;0-003703/070/2449

    550,39//349,00,3770:,793,24943946:,8-01470

    039073850,,3/890701470/0020/94,;0,;0/,36:0894341

    9097,.4:798:78/.9434;078507843

    $$#$$$

    !!'$%&%&

    #4$05902-07

    ,.98$407314720/9054.09,9%:/9:/4:/.420-,.930

    894.8412,7:,3,!4.02038,94203,90/174290-:8053

    0,.4907.,77,.,7943-4430419021990/90/08.7594341%:/9:/

    %0,5574,.0/9094,3/%:/9://030/9,90.,770/,3/7:8%0

    ,990745030/90-4-030,9/70/1807094-:3/084307,550/3

    ,5,89.-,,3/,3490733085,5078!4.0203,80/%:/9:/94:37,5

    905,.,08,3/.439,30/,980020/949054.0,82,7:,3,0,;08

    %094//3497088990,77089,70/90,54880884341

    574-90//7:89050,/0/349:9,3/39075480/90/0103809,9

    9007017,20/:5%097,.4:79.43;.90/902990.720.,70/

    ,3/803903.0/902948:110790503,94170.:843507509:,

    88:009074734980,7.08,3/80:

    4-9,30/

    0/%07:089,9,80,7.,3/80:

    9,:/.,,77,394907808:.

    70,843,-0939020,334190.4

    0;/03.080.:70/9070--03,/2

    3,3574.00/3.059990144

    41,,77,39,77,3908880,7.3./

    0;/03.035,3;0$0,7.41,2

    ,77,3908880,7.:8942880,7.

    020703..7.:289,3.08

    %04389,3/37:0398:78/.9

    .4388903.89,9,70,-031472,94

    ,77,39088,7708903.090902880

    -0034-9,30/3;4,9434190,..:80

    :370,843,-080,7.08,3/80:708

    '%#$#

    %'$!%%

    %'$!%%$

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    59/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    60/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    61/322

    5,79.:,7$0.943,3/$0.94341#:0$0.94341#:0

    $0.94341#:0,3/,349077:03841,7,890574;/0147/70.9

    ,550,8174290#043,%7,4:7989490$:570204:793.,808070

    90503,925480/8/0,970.:843507509:,47102578432039,8

    0,8907084:9434190$:570204:7903-,3./,90/$05902-07

    339073,#:084190$:570204:793.,80882,73;4;3

    90/0,9503,9,7094-0/0020/24/10/,..47/3

    4$

    #%$%%

    #'$#&$#!#

    %'#%!%$$

    #$&%

    .93439070.42203/,9434190422990043#0;8434190#:08

    414:798:-2993147984:798.438/07,943,3/,5574;,90

    !745480/203/203989490#0;80/#:0841723,!74.0/:7094

    4;0730,9!03,9,808904:79#084;0/94!!#'908,20

    %0,203/20398,9,00110.943.94-07144398

    5:-.,9433,3085,507410307,.7.:,943349,9079,3$05902-07

    $05902-07

    ********************************

    #&$%'##'

    %!%$$

    #:0$0.9438,3/,3/#:0

    #0;80/#:0841723,!74.0/:70,

    #&

    $0.4,550,9,03,%0,550

    904:7941550,83.,808/0./0/-

    007.804198473,:78/.9438,

    90.4:79.703/070/90:/20394

    807;3,.45907041:54390,/;0780

    -%0,550,94904:7941550,8

    %7,4:79390007.804198,550,

    14770;0:3/07#:0

    .%0,550,3.,808070-90503

    4:79870.:843507509:,1025784

    25480/14741103808.422990/4390

    4:941908,204..:7703.09,9,;078

    .90503,941/0,970.:84350

    25480/8,-0-349.041,550,94

    95,7,7,5,4198#:0

    /4349.041,550,830.088,73.

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    62/322

    25480/90/0,9503,9%04:7941550,88,,:942,9.,70;0

    90:/2039,8574;/0/3$0.9434198#:0,

    #&

    $0.!4079470.0;00;/03.0%04:7941550,88,,;090

    54079497.,808,3/.43/:.90,73870.0;00;/03.0,3/5071472,

    ,.9830.088,7947084;0901,.9:,88:087,80/3.,8081,39398

    473,,3/,550,90:78/.9433.:/3905407947,39,3/.43/:.9

    3097,8471:7907574.00/38%7,8470,733904:7941550,8

    2:89-0.4393:4:8,3/2:89-0.425090/93970024398:3088

    0903/0/-9001:89.0,

    $0.0791.,94347,550,41.,809490$:570204:79,

    030;07904:7941550,813/89,990503,941/0,984:/-0

    25480/90.4:798,703/07:/2039-:97017,317422,3,30397

    41:/2039,3/14799.079190.,80,3/00;,90980397070.47/94

    90$:570204:7914770;0

    -07090:/2039,84254808,08807503,914741103808

    .422990/43908,204..,84347.,74804:941908,204..:7703.0

    9,9,;07809490247080;0704110380147.90503,9825480/

    ,3/90,..:80/,550,890,550,8,-03.:/0/390.,80.07910/

    14770;09490$:570204:79

    .3.,808070904:7941550,825480870.:843507509:,10

    257843203947,08807503,998,

    254838:.503,9%0:/20392

    4:79-349.041,550,10990

    '

    $&%'$%

    B#%

    #4,3:,7

    ,.989/23897,947#4/0,

    5099430734.0,$:903.4990

    /843089,3/28.43/:.93411.0%

    7,;4,302540041909880884

    5705,7,94341905,7441.,8:,025

    5,745705,70/-07:543904

    11.01470,$07;.0888:0/,7084:

    50994307:94128.43/:.93411.0

    ,5503.0/940,5,203941

    70,7/89490.,7041/84308990

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    63/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    64/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    65/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    66/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    67/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    68/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    69/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    70/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    71/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    72/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    73/322

    ,.983,7.-:830882,30,3/07$,/,N,03994$:9,3

    :/,7,9997004907203942009,.079,3,.,5,,$43,3,,8

    422,3/07,2-,/,%0,77;0/39024733,3/070,-0949,94

    ,.,5,,.43.0733904/3:0989,95:754790/-0384/-90

    ,9907%0-:8308897,38,.943,854895430/,3/.4393:0/390

    ,19073443/:09490/0,941,.,5,,870,9;0,3/9,90,8945.

    8-74907349,-,949

    %03,9,74:3/!,8900,/0/9490,,.,5,,47/070/

    90/7;07948945$://03,720/203,550,70/0,3/07,3/8

    9700.425,343807047/070/9444:94190;0.09007090/:5

    ,3/-3/14/0/,.,5,,,3/%0//070,8490/,3/-3/14/0/-:9

    34932470,8/430949020,3/07/03910/,90,-/:.9478

    3.:/390-74907841,.,5,,

    %014:7;.9280709,03949024:39,3/04:93,:3/,3,4%0

    /3,55078/02,3/0/!17420,3/078101478700,80

    -:990,24:39,870/:.0/9490;0243%0;.928070903

    97,3810770/17424305,.094,34907%02,/00,3/07790,0990794

    81014787,3842:94380;07,4..,8438,5078433,20/

    ,,3,328014:/790940,3/07810%0944907

    ;.9282,3,0/9408.,50-:90,3/07,8700,80/,19075,203941

    7,3842%097,.4:79.43;.90/,.,5,,,3/8.425,34384190

    .72041/3,553147#,38429$

    88:009079830.088,79,99070

    .72041/3,553

    0/49830.088,79,990708,.

    41/3,5534790.72094-0.42

    /02,3/37,38422:89-02,/0983

    5,2039417,3842-0.,:80,990,

    905:7548041/02,3/37,384239

    389,3.080390/3,55078/02,3/0

    24:39,3/04:90700,3/07,8

    810,8307945,7,3842419

    2801749024700990789481,2

    0,3/071907,3842,83495,/

    $%%#&$%#!%$

    #'$%!!

    #457

    ,.98!0994307/,7/3705708039

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    74/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    75/322

    6:,770808:89,30/.439:8438-7:808,3/:25843/11070395,79841

    07-4/

    3::8972,3/4,8/733030,,/24380/2

    34994/4840,,8903-,30/4390,-72,3/4%030

    5:80/,3/.0/0,43900198/04107-4/..,:80/07941,

    439074:3/;03,80,,8,70,/3574897,9072,3/4

    .4393:0/94-0,907:55:3.3074390/11070395,7984107-4/

    0,90310/94904:80410,47,-:972,3/47,3,190707,3/

    07/0/07-,.949074:800,10,,3949074:3/,3/48907

    .438.4:83088%097,.4:79.43;.90/72,3/4415,77./0

    88:009079097,.4:79.4770.9.43;.90/90,..:80/

    0/089097,.4:79.4770.9.43.:/0/9,9903:7088:89,30/-

    0,9,9.,:80/07/0,907090.43806:03.04190,550,398

    /0-07,90,3/3903943,,.98

    %0.720415,77./08/0130/-79.04190#0;80/!03,4/0

    9:8350784348,81,9072490747./0907

    092,9047092,9047,3418,8.03/,39847/08.03/,398478

    854:808,-0:9415,77./0,3/8,-05:380/-90503,941

    70.:843507509:,94/0,9

    %057480.:94382,3/,90/94574;0901443088039,0020398,

    50784380/90/0.0,80/80

    /0.0,80/8901,9072490747./

    ,092,904907,8.03/,39474907/08

    90,..:80/%05708.7-0/503,9147

    /0,9%0000203935,77./041,

    70,94385-0900390,..:80/,3/9

    .0791.,90

    $%%&%##!#%

    %

    !!%!!!$'$

    #457

    ,.98$42092039030,74/#

    ,550,3903,230990.42243

    948.44,3/,9.904:809,-4:9

    80318#.008,,550,398,7

    ,550,39/7,0/0794,7/8907442

    ,1907344341,7.#.001

    ,9907,80/90730-479470547990

    .43;.90/90,550,39:94194.4

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    76/322

    88:009079208,3088039,0020394189,9:9477,50

    0/49208349,3088039,0020394189,9:9477,50331472,943

    8;,/,843,89/893.989,90890002039841904110380,3/90,.98

    47428843.43899:9;0907041%00,.9/,904190.422884341,

    .7208349,3088039,002039417,50%:83,57480.:943417,5090

    2,907,1,.947.7.:289,3.094-0.438/070/8904..:7703.0417,50349

    909204198.4228843

    9834930.088,79489,9090570.8092003904110380,8.422990/

    0.059039208,2,907,370/03941904110380389,9:9477,50

    9208349,3088039,002039,9825479,3989031472,943

    ,0089,990;.928,2347:3/0790;00,7841,0,3/90,..:80/

    ,/.,73,340/041070;03134147.047392/,943,8:80/47

    80,8349490780/057;0/4170,843

    $%%&%##!#%%$%$$%

    %

    !!%!!!$'$

    ,.98#03,/4,,97..0/7;0703994,.41100845942009

    #4330$,3.0,3/98$,3.0/8.4

    $%070,190700,4,/,,77;0/%

    804:/3472,0,;007/7:89470

    ,;0,845,330/94#489,$:54

    ,0.:80/280143905709099,9

    /0,0/2801,3/905,3,83492

    /0,%0,;0,700/945:78:0990

    ,,1742907200935,.090309

    4;07907,/49,9,10088-4/41#4

    88:0090747349,002039841,#

    94.43899:90,503,941/0,9

    0/%0$7:0/9,9,900020398

    ,324:7/47507843,5745079-043

    ;403.0,,38947392/,9434150784

    .43899:90874--07,3/90.4250.7

    03-70,8434743904..,8434174

    0020398,;08,981,.947-003843

    %%#$#

    %!%$$

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    77/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    78/322

    ;3940907,8:8-,3/,3/10

    $420920347034,8-,709030,784/,8,9073

    17044/990,550,390;381,7209007030,73,

    :,;,970090,550,398://03-40/0743908942,.4703489

    .438.4:83088$0,/07.4908038040:5$0,/,9077-0

    0,/,.0,3/1095,3307;,3,$0,84,/,-7:803902//0

    5479434107790%0,550,39,730/34994900724907,-4:99

    49078004:/07

    %080:,,88,:980707050,90/80;07,92088480/0./0/949007

    88907,3/0;039:,0724907%097,.4:7914:3/90,..:80/:941

    90.7207,50,3/803903.0/294/0,9

    88:009074734990,..:80/8:94190.720.,70/

    0/0890,..:80/8:94190.720.,70/4790,..:80/94

    0/:941.438:22,90/7,509057480.:9432:89574;0-043/

    70,843,-0/4:-99,99070,/-003.,73,340/04190;.92-

    90,..:80/90,..:80/,.0;0890,.9974:147.047392/,943

    :54390;.92-0.,:8090,99078/057;0/4170,84347490780

    :3.438.4:8,73,340/04190;.92-90,..:80/2,-0574;0/

    0907-/70.90;/03.047-.7.:289,39,0;/03.09,97,50,/-003

    .422990/,3/9,990,..:80/8905075097,94790704113/341:9

    4190,..:80/1477,502,-0-,80/84

    8:.90892432009890908941.70/-

    1706:039:3,;,,-037,50.,80883

    .43;.9434190,..:80/14790.720

    42,389,9089,980,8-0037,50/8

    30.088,794847,50//9,05,.0

    2:89-08.7:930/9097020.,:94

    1,43984320798

    %0.70/-9414703,3/90574-,

    -0,88,0/825-0.,:8007,/2884

    847992094380798503839407;,

    0397418503839490,-,41905:

    08034:3841,7,890.438:22

    .43.0730/90-70;9419209,990,

    ;.928;,3,841345,79.:,72547

    !4890/-&,7507,9438422

    %%

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    79/322

    $$#%##'&;8&

    !#%%!,3/%%!!$

    #40.02-07

    %$;79:041,/0.84341904:7941%,550,8703/070/43

    :30,824/10/43,550,-90$:570204:79430-7:,7

    904228843074139073,#0;03:0,847/070/94701:3/9490

    0-:!479,3/02039425,390,24:3941!7057080393

    4;075,2039841,/;,47029,0843.02039574/:.0/,3/84/-9,1907

    .94-07

    3,7.1443/03,4124943814770.438/07,94310/

    --499050994307,3/9057;,90708543/03990,990724;0/147,79

    4100.:9439403147.0908,/:/2039

    %024943,8455480/-9050994307439074:3/9,99057;,90

    708543/039,/,34:989,3/38,089,,-994.90:/2039/0-9

    ,/,70,/-003.70/90/31,.99,88970880/9070,889,-,,3.0

    4343908,089,08390,24:3941!5:8

    8:7.,70

    357904:7941%,5

    9,990,00/8,089,,-94190

    6:089430/,3/90701470.4:/349-080

    $$&

    09074734990:/2039/0-9.,3-

    708543/03988,089,,-990,990

    #&

    %0,7:20399,990,880882039.,334

    89-03.4390890/4808894190:7

    9010-44/41904;0732039190

    54895430/-8256:089433907;

    4:/73/94,,9,3/,4;073203

    %0%,4/0574;/08$0.3:3

    .40.943419,4.4:798,,;0,

    70897,390.40.94341,33,943,3

    25480/-984/0

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    80/322

    940894:98,39,9983:3.9438,;,,-0349430390

    ,8808820398,70,/-036:089430/3,.4:7941:89.0-:92470841

    ,8390389,39.,8090.,0309490,880882039889,3/434390

    ,/23897,9;00;0%0708,90247070,84394,55907:0070

    -0.,:809,550,789,90;03,1907.70/934190701:3/,,389909,

    /01.03.,-,,3.04124709,3!243889/:017429057;,90

    708543/039

    $$#%##'&;8&,3/%

    %%!!$

    #40-7:,7

    %$%0!5530$:,789,900;0452039425,3,/0,707

    ,554390/:0,898,039,:94739948098,3/1,.94708,3/4

    2,3:1,.9:73574.088!:78:,39948:.,:9479-0794:0;,7,7

    /:,7/4:0;,7,8,-0:0;,7,/9,70,3/!,-4$,3.0

    470/147901472,9434190'009,-03;089203947547,943

    3/:.349075078438943;08939&92,90,1907983.47547,943

    ,70974:905742494341908,/50784389830.47547,943

    5:7.,80/90!$57450790847988,0:070.0;0/,8,039,

    .422884341!,3/9,8174298.42288439,990!

    57424943,10080705,/949

    %050994307.43903/89,990.,20/

    574507/8,40/-0.,:809,8349,

    -:83088050380%04:7941%,55

    70039:090/9,9908,

    5,/-9057;,90708543/039147,.9:,

    ,839014724157424943,1008

    $$&

    0907473499040.9474139073,

    !/0/:.943.,20/-57;,

    -:8308805038083983.4209,709:

    #&

    %0$:570204:79,70089907085

    57424943,1008,83490.088;0%0

    90949,.4228843%8,8,70,843

    ,8905,0084//57,.9.,0;07

    '009,-03;089203947547,9439

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    81/322

    $:,789,90574507908

    988,/9,99,08,70,905,147.;,94384.0994:99,08

    904;07320394:/-05,7,0/147,.4190249;0540794,.9;,90

    ,3/4507,90903.0/08590903,9:7,70:.9,3.0948:7703/075,7941

    4308,7/0,730/3.42094909,3,:9479080;0750784348,-0

    942:89.4397-:9088,703907:33341904;0732039

    $;8&!#%%

    #4,3:,7

    %$3:3090:3.5,4,7/419094144

    03,.90/7/3,3.0480708415:78:,399490574;843841

    #05:-..94343,8904.,:94342.9706:73,3

    507843172,884.,94347.47547,943945,,8,089,414141

    9080357.041,324947;0.0,3/574-939070897,9434190

    8,0419024947;0.03904947'0.0811.0419094144

    :3088909,,8-0035,/

    4/084,803,0/390-:8308841-:3,3/803

    80.43/,3/24947;0.08390941448430419480,110.90/-

    9003,.92039419047/3,3.0,3/-0

    ,;3-0035,880/30.0884190,:9

    2:3.5,-4,7/010/43:30

    :/20399904:7941789389,3.

    47/3,3.0-0/0.,70/;4/,-394

    %0.4:79,6:4703/070//0.84343

    5,79419047/3,3.0.706:70890

    5,,8,089,41414190803

    907041.706:708905,2039419

    9070897,94341908,03904947

    705:3,3994$0.94341#05:-.

    ,550,0/

    $$&

    0907473499047/3,3.036:0894

    547943.706:708905,2039419

    9070897,94341908,03904947

    #&

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    82/322

    %094144,890,:9479,3/540794,5574;09047/3,3.03

    6:0894314792070254808,507.039,09,43908,041,80.43/,3/

    24947;0.09,92,-0.,770/4:99390.9-,3507843172

    ,884.,94347.47547,94343347/0,39942,.42093

    90:78/.943

    %0706:702039419047/3,3.0.,3349-0.438/070/,9,3909

    ;00/-90.4:79,6:4147908,2082070,.407.;020,8:7094

    2,09003147.020394190.439025,90/8,089,24700110.9;00

    80990/890573.509,99,08,7025480/147908:554794190

    4;07320393709:73147900307,,/;,39,0,3/57490.943.90

    4;0732039,1147/8949,5,078,3/9075745079%,08,709010-44/

    41904;0732039

    $$%&$%##$;8&!

    #

    #4,

    %$%0884.,94341:89428740783..8.425480/41

    ,-74078,3/5:-.807;.04507,94784124947

    ;0.08390941,3,.,030

    9074:3/9,9090;08,84.

    .03809,.8-043/9054074

    ,3,8,/47/3,3.041103/8,,3

    9,,943,3/9.43899:908/4:-09,

    %0708543/0398.43903/439075,799

    254808,57450799,.8939

    25480:3/0798#0;80/,7907$0.9

    ,3/9,9909,36:08943/408349;4

    9,,943347/4089.43899:90/4:-09,

    $$&

    0907473499047/3,3.083:,3/

    #&

    %047/3,3.0317308907:04190:

    4:743899:9434909,99047/3,3.

    ;0.084507,939390941,

    -09003,24947;0.014770,3/43

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    83/322

    0907/4089/893:8-09003,24947;0.07089070/390941

    ,3,,3/4307089070/3,349075,.0-:94..,843,.420894

    ,3,,3/:808988970098,3/5:-.,8%88,3306:,9.

    013/39047/3,3.0,3/.703/0789411038;0949043899:943

    $$$%#$%#;$$#

    %##'&

    #48:

    %$3%,804884$9,3/,7/,890733.884

    /0/:.90/17429874883.420147,85,79419847/3,7,3/

    30.088,7-:83088050380890,24:399,/85039147/73,3/

    0547,9434198509740:2.43.088438%8.,2,8/8,40/-90

    4228843074139073,#0;03:0#439074:3/9,9900503808

    84:/-0.,59,0/,3/29-079903411,8,4884303,/7

    4084:/708:988490310/,3,203/0/709:730709,80/14790

    701:3/41!-70,8434198,-,3/432039,8/74084180;07,

    419840884.,20/,847/3,7,3/30.088,70503808390

    8,20709:73,890,24:3941!70570803932,7310089

    ,/5,/94900397,,343985741970299,3.0894980470,/

    411.0

    3::8990#7,390/,9,

    /8,4390.,20//0/:.9431479

    9,9902,7310085,/94900397,

    47,40/,8/0/:.9-0-:830880503

    884,550,0/94904:7941%,550

    2,7310089,/0,7075,/.43903/3

    /0/:.9-0174274883.4200907,8,

    -:8308805038040;078848,550

    $$&

    090747349902,731008,709

    090747349902,731008,703

    0503808

    #&

    49,80;0/94574;/070;03:

    90574.00/841902,73100,70,55

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    84/322

    39073,943,70807;08%02,73100,825480/-90$9,90390

    007.80419854.05407,3/349905407419,,943

    47/3,7,3050380-0.438/070/30.088,707090

    0503/9:708,557457,90,3/051:390/0;045203941909,5,078

    -:830889847/3,7039.4334908,5,2039.83472,3

    70,9439490-:8308841909,5,07,3/908:774:3/3.7.:289,3.08

    $3.0902,73100836:089430703.:770/1479070299,3.0411:3/8

    9488480,/11.03047.8,805,7,90,3//893.93.420

    9,5,07174290-7,3.390!5530814798/8548,,-74,/9.,3

    30;07-08,/907014709,9902,731008070,557457,90,3/051:3

    90/0;0452039418848-:83088390!553080.:8;047070

    3.:770/1475:7548085745079490.43/:.94190,11,78418848-7,3.3

    90!553080.:8;047147905:754804170,3,574194741

    2323,488390!553080.:8;0

    !##$$''!%#!#%;"&

    %

    #457

    %$30.02-0790

    7/3,3.04490780343,

    $0.943418,/47/3,3.0574;/089,

    5:-.2,70988,8:-29243994

    4189,4/07884390,24:394189

    89,4/07,3/8,5,4190

    909,88:507;843100

    3:!747088;00;0452

    4307,3/4507,94741,5:-.2,709

    $45530390710/,!09943147!7

    3:3.943,,389":04394390

    .03809,25480/-90,-4;02039

    3.420.":04392,34925

    574-90/-#05:-..94,

    4.,:94342.9

    3983807":0439974:90

    ,:94799403,.9906:089430/47/3,3

    748870.059825480/907038349,9,

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    85/322

    %0407.4:797:0/9,9906:089430/25489438349,9,433.420

    -:97,907,57;009,47.0380100.4.,4;073203980

    ":0439,700254070/9425480,3/.40.9

    $$&

    0907909,25480/-":043943748870.05984189,7039,88

    574507.,7,.9070/,85,79,341903,9:7041,33.4209,

    #&

    4%09,25480/390.43974;0790/47/3,3.0.43899:908349,9,43

    3.420349,.93.4209,,8/893:80/1742903,943,3.420

    9,25480/-90,943,39073,#0;03:04/0939020,3341

    $0.94341904.,:94342.9-:97,907,.03809,47100147

    9070:,9434190-:830883.!747088;0803,0/098

    97:09,990,24:3925480/-906:089430/47/3,3.082,-0

    .438/070/3/09072330907900,.943870,43014770;03:047

    574-9433890,/414304170:,943:3/079054.054079

    30;0790088-05708:20/94-070,843,-0

    !!!#$;

    #4::89

    %$%0!55307308!

    97,385479,943-:83088:3/07,08,9;

    9817,3.80!8002591742905,

    $420920340;07,3/%7,3

    0;,900;,9088:0/,70:,9435:

    490780343,890,3/,3/

    706:73,9,00259039908,243

    70897,9431008

    08590!85749089,94380;,90701

    ;0.08:308890,24:39825480/:3

    !9:85,/:3/07574908970897,94

    5,3:3/075749089!974:.4:3

    94,3/%7,385479,943422

    /02,3/3,701:3/4190,24:3985,/

    03.0!10/,.425,39,,389

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    86/322

    ,7-430,7-430

    %097,.4:79/82880/!8.425,39!,550,0/94904:7941

    550,8.39:73.07910/90.,809490$:570204:79

    $$&

    09074734924947;0.070897,9431008,70.438/070/,89,08

    #&

    081905:754808572,770;03:047170;03:08,90,894304190

    70,,3/8:-89,39,5:754808903900,.9438574507.,0/,9,

    $:.890.,804124947;0.070897,9431008%024947;0.0

    70897,9431008,70,.9:,9,083903/0/147,//943,70;03:084190

    4;07320390;031430119470884190,24:39.40.90/8809,8/0147

    904507,9305038084190,03.,/2389073905747,2

    '$;&%$!

    #44;02-07

    %$30-7:,790:

    7/3,3.04%08,/.947/3

    ,3,,4739434'0,8'

    $0.94341908,/.947/3,3.0574

    9403,0475,79.5,903,3548943

    03:207,90/9070309075072,3039

    80.:73,3025420395072917429

    5072910041!0.0595078438025

    2884384114703.4:39708473909

    -4990!55304;0732039,3/,3

    473390770850.9;04:804/8

    .4370,943880.947/03423,943

    3/

    :43%8,!,44%8,!,44

    ,50994399041,3,94/0.

    3:,3/;4/147-03/8.723,947,

    :31472939,,943%097,.4:79/0

    3:,3/;4/'0,810/905708039

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    87/322

    $$&

    09074734997/3,3.048,9,4770;03:020,8:70

    #&

    08%0.439039439,997/3,3.048349,5:709,47

    70;03:020,8:70-0.,:8098573.5,5:75480870:,94733,9:70,834

    207909897:09,99017895,79.706:7089,990,038,

    80.:70,30254203950729174290,473;4;0890007.8041

    /8.70943,3/:/2039390574.0883,3/,5574;,47/8,5574;,41

    ,55.,943814702542039507298,3/90701470870:,9473.,7,.907

    9080.43/5,79.706:708905,203941!,802540081008

    34970:,947-:9,70;03:020,8:70%0708344.47:891.,9433

    0,.93!1742,0384,;0-003.0,70/1470254203998

    4-;4:89,9905:75480419047/3,3.08947,802430:3/0790:80

    4170:,943

    !B#%$!$;8

    %%

    #4:30

    %$!099430710/,3,.943390

    ,3,9908:241!,

    408,0,3/709,8,08416:471479

    949080.43/6:,7907413.

    ,3/

    %,-,.,07,8,.943147701:3/8-,80/4

    986:478,08984:/5,90.0380

    9,08,3/83.09,70,/5,/90.03

    5,/-9,24:39394908:241!

    47/3,3.088,34;075,20392,/0-2

    %09.43903/89,9147905072988

    5,90.038010085708.7-0/-7/3

    9,0825480/-7/3,3.0848

    $$&

    090747349909,0825480/,70;,

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    88/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    89/322

    #&

    &3/075,7,7,5,80.#98.0,79,990941,8,3

    2,430;,3/.40.99,081470307,,3/850.,5:7548083

    ,..47/,3.0947,8574;/0/-,3490747/890.941,8,3

    ,83497,390/,-,3095407419,,943%0:80419057,803

    ,..47/,3.09,.34:74534320,38908,20,8

    574;/0/-,.0,7/8.48089008,9;039039942990

    9,3540741909

    9,8-0030/9,99054079470:,90,8,3007.804154.05407

    /4083493.:/09054079425480100814770;03:05:754808550,39

    .9843.439039439,9906:089430/47/3,3.0,803,.90/390

    007.8041985407419,,9432,0894-;4:89,990100825480/,70

    349207070:,947

    $B;8$##$09,

    #4,7.

    %$.94-07!708/03907/3,3/,7.4888:0/!

    .70,93,$50.,..4:393900307,:3//083,90/,890!7.0

    $9,-,943:3/!$%0!$

    .425,308147.4893.70,8083.7:/04

    708:9317420.,307,90,/:892039

    2,70957.0841.7:/04$:-806:039

    97:89,-9,..4:39!708/03947,

    05,3/39074:3/8147702-:78

    .489:3/0770.4;073.:770/,8,708:9

    41509740:2574/:.98

    %050994307,7:083907,,9,990

    !,8,203/0/2:89-0970,90/

    97:89,..4:3947,97:891:3/,3/9,9

    850.1.5:754809070;03:00307,90/

    850.,1:3/94-0:80/43147905:75

    94,349074;07320394-0.9;0!099

    850.,1:3/.4388984124308.40.90

    $9,908:.,24:398-0439490$9,90

    9490850.,5:754804-0.9;0147.

    $$&

    090747349901:3/8.40.90/:3/0

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    90/322

    5407419,,943

    #&

    %00;8572,7390007.80419054.054074190$9,900

    901:3/8.40.90/2,-07010770/94,89,0890,700,.90/390

    007.80419054.054074190$9,90

    ,9509943074:/889013418420/013906:,399,9;0

    70897.94347,850.1.294342:.949,%04:798.90/94

    98706:702039-905099430743905702809,9,983;4;0/070

    8905407419,,943-:9,8,70,//8.:880/98834990.,80,9

    80703;4;0/8349842:.905407419,,943,854.05407

    94:90574;843,:947390#9425480,//943,,24:398

    .4:/-0.43897:0/947010794905407419,,9439.,3349-04;07440/

    9,9904;077/3.438/07,94389403,-090/00,9094,.99

    050/03.3.,7734:9904-0.9;084190,.,7002-7,.0/-

    9054.054074190$9,90

    94:/80029,9174290,-4;06:490/7:390509943147574-943

    84:/1,

    #!&%!!!$

    $&

    %$$!

    #48,3/

    %$439,550,-97008:,7.03

    /0.84341904:7941789389,3.04

    850.,,8808820398:3/07$0.94341

    %0,550,39890888825949001

    418:,7,:9470/94-0.40.90/:3/

    850.,,88088203988:.90574.00/

    90850.1.5:75480147.90,8808

    ,880882039-03,0;:54357450795

    5745079,,389.980;0//07;

    2574;0203998349,9,20,8:7039

    4;0732039

    $$&

    890254894341850.,,880882039,

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    91/322

    #&

    %04:79/0020/9700;,3994/8.:88984/33:9;7,309,47

    398:9.,80422430,9.9490780343,890$:,7

    /:892039.9,.40.94382,/09070:3/078,,..7:094,850.,

    1:3/390!5530%70,8:794-0343,890$:,7/:892039,3/

    $9,-,943:3/,3/8,-05,/4:943147,347,41901443

    5:7548084794,99,3,347,419014434-0.9;08,82,-0

    574;/0/-,3,884190.9,3/5,79.:,7$0.94384

    9,9909,80;0/9,70:,9475:7548094574;/020,3814790

    70,-9,943,3/89,-,9434190970,9030/8:,73/:89734907

    47/890,.98572,7,3007.80419054.05407

    390,:94794190,-4;0.,8090304/9,990850.,

    ,880882039,9-,72,-0.438/070/,882,7,890,-4;09,989,9

    900;14790!8:3:3/8349842:.,3007.804190540741

    9,,94334790254894341,850.,,880882039-:990007.804190

    54.05407147900307,01,70419003970.4:3979890701470,3

    007.8041,84;07035407.3457;,90.9032,,1:70889

    '%#$;8%&!%

    '%#$!#'#

    #4$05902-07

    %$

    %8.,80.,83946:0894390;,/9

    4190:3.5,941'.947,80748

    %0/85:90/47/3,3.025480/.0380

    ,3/8:,770130708%0.,308070

    3.70,83907,90841.03809,08,3/

    907,90841.03809,08,80,8907

    ,33:,4:95:9.,5,.9

    4790574/:.943415,3911'.947,8

    .0397,,3/988:,77013074.,90/3

    9390809028

    !,391110/8:9-0494,8147:/2

    80708413:,3/;4/%05,39

    /8.723,94783.0983084:95,39

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    92/322

    8:,7.0397,,3/,8:,77013079390:78/.94341/0103/,39

    2:3.5,9

    %097,.4:79703/070/98:/2039/0.,739,99047/3,3.03

    6:0894370107894.03809,08471008495,3911,3//0103/,39/70.9

    ,550,0/9490$:570204:79

    $$&

    ,87/3,3.0480708415,880/-/0103/,3982:3.5,

    .4:3.,8,70:,94703,.9203947,8,70;03:020,8:70

    #&

    %0570803925489432:89-0970,90/,8,0;14770;03:05:754808

    6:.,3.0,990-,24:39412,2:2,33:,9,8091479390

    47/3,3.0!1478:,7.0397,8,3/!1478:,7

    7013070870,/.43;3.04309,9909,870,,70;03:09,3/

    903070,/39047/3,3.03493.4:/,82:.,83/.,90

    9,9909,25480/8207014754.03850.9438:507;84347

    70:,943;03905:754808:892039430/013/34,77,3934.

    94;04:7,880399490;09,99047/3,3.036:089438840147

    70:,9475:75480!,389020,33

    7,832430%48,4907808942

    %#&%;8%#

    #40.02-07

    %$%8.,80,839,90/390

    ../039,949089900,941909,0

    4490780343,890$:,7

    !,3911,907:980089470.4;0717

    #0;03:0908:241!5,/-

    4190.914790.7450,78

    9,8:3.43899:943,,3/;4/-030

    8:,73/:8970.:8;0.35,

    5:75480147.,9,2,-0.43899:

    -003/82880/-904:794178938

    .,80/70.99490$:570204:79

    $$&

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    93/322

    8909,574;/0/1473422430,9.94,5:70007.804190

    9,35407

    #&

    3,884190.9,3/5,79.:,74180.943849,9909,8

    0;0/9,70:,9475:7548094574;/020,381479070,-9,943,3/

    89,-,9434190970,9030/8:,73/:8973490747/890,.98

    572,7,3007.80419054.05407

    %057490.943,3/5742494341908:,73/:8978,2,9907415:-.

    .43.073914489,99008,9:702,/09072309370,843,-0

    -4:3/8,9830.088,71479857490.943,3/050/0391479857424943

    14-0.9;0,3/2094/8,70,0.43899:943,;,/3470,84388003

    9089,902,3490;9,08947,801:3/814790757480.:943,3/

    ,99,32039%,,9432,-02,/0902502039419089,90854.0

    5407

    #!&%!!!$7057080390/-90

    !#$%$$'#%

    !;8%,3/#$%

    ,3

    $789;843

    #40.02-07

    %$%0!88:0/,3/2502

    1700047/078,3/574;843,9,04;078

    ,88098,3/57450790870,47507843,

    24390574507908806:089070/-9

    390&390/4.43:9!,39078,3&

    ,00/430243.4.43:91,720789

    3;0892039:3/.425,308.425

    /:,7/44:,3.473,3:,7

    13,0.8433:13,3/80993,8/

    $,3/,3-,,3.190/90806:0897

    $$&

    70904.43:90;:3/87,80/974

    54078

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    94/322

    #&

    3/00/.4.43:90;1:3/85,79,041903,9:70419,08.30307,

    ,7003147.0/574547943,.4397-:943817425078438,3/574507908

    0,.90/-90$9,90-;79:0419884;07039147908:5547941

    4;0732039,3/147,5:-.300/8

    ,80/4398/013943,9,,8970000203983,20,98,3

    03147.0/574547943,.4397-:94317425078438,3/574507908-98

    25480/-90$9,90-;79:0419884;07039,3/.980;0/14790

    8:5547941904;0732039

    %,,9438/4303492070947,8070;03:08948:55479904;0732039

    -:9,8494574;/020,381479070,-9,943,3/9089,-,94341,

    970,9030/3/:897.884,110.90/95:-.3907089,894-093

    9054.054074190$9,90

    $!$&;8%$#%#!&

    #$&%$%

    #40.02-07

    %$3::8950994307

    ,.943147/0.,7,947700193:3.

    .9403990/3.9557457

    ,5574;0/43:30.439,30/

    (41!14790.43897:.9

    ,3/2574;0203941!,8100/0774,/

    5,88,0,3/,5574;,418,/.990,1

    3493-:95740.90/,3/5,330/8:-/

    939039434$:-/;8438

    5740.90/100/0774,/8/4349.4330.9,

    25479,39570280894902,3,

    #08543/039824;0/94/8288905099

    ,/340,.,5,.9948:0,3/9,9

    ,.943

    $$&

    $4:/,557457,943:835:-.1:3/8

    #&

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    95/322

    %079419008,9:7094,557457,901:3/88.4770,9;099879

    949,,3/:3/07.43899:943,574;8438,,3899,,9430.059147

    5:-.5:754808,3/574-9390.40.94341,9,1474305:75480,3/

    90/0;494390704194,349075:7548034,557457,9434189,901:3/8.,3

    -02,/014749079,3147,5:-.5:75480

    %090894190.43899:943,941,89,9:90706:7390:80415:-.1:3/8

    809079089,9:908/0830/945742490905:-.3907089,8455480/

    94901:7907,3.04190,/;,39,0413/;/:,8,94:0,.,/;,39,0

    943/;/:,8293./039,807;0905:-.

    $B;8#$

    #4,7.

    %$.94-07!708/03907/3,3/,7.4888:0/!

    .70,93,$50.,..4:393900307,:3//083,90/,890!7.0

    $9,-,943:3/!$%0!$,8/0830/94702-:7804

    .425,308147.4893.70,8083.7:/04,3/254790/509740:2574/:.98

    708:9317420.,307,90,/:8920398,3/17423.70,80839047/

    2,70957.0841.7:/04$:-806:03990!$,870.,8810/394,

    97:89,-9,..4:39!708/03947,

    05,3/39074:3/8147702-:78

    .489:3/0770.4;073.:770/,8,708:9

    41509740:2574/:.98

    %050994307,7:083907,,9,990

    !,8,203/0/2:89-0970,90/

    97:89,..4:3947,97:891:3/,3/9,9

    850.1.5:754809070;03:00307,90/

    850.,1:3/94-0:80/43147905:75

    94,349074;07320394-0.9;0!099

    850.,1:3/.4388984124308.40.90

    $9,908:.,24:398-0439490$9,90

    9490850.,5:754804-0.9;0147.

    $$&

    490540787,390/9490#:3/0

    909,,94354074190$9,90

    #&

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    96/322

    %0!$,8089,-80/147905:75480412323901706:039

    57.0.,308-74:9,-4:9-0.,307,90,/:892039,3/47.,3083

    47/2,70957.0841.7:/04,3/254790/509740:2574/:.980

    901:3/8.40.90/2,-07010770/94,89,0890,700,.90/390

    007.80419054.054074190$9,90

    !!$%%!%!!!$

    ;8&!%%&

    #40-7:,7

    %$30-7:,75,3911.42203.0/,.425,39800394

    /0.,70$0.94341#4.,:94342.9:3.43899:943,,8

    ,3:3/:0/00,943419,35407,3/94/0.,707/3,3.048,3/

    88:0/-90:3.5,941%,3,:,3090,83:,3/;4/

    :3.5,7/3,3.040;08,3/.40.9817428419/738574/:.078

    ,3/2,3:1,.9:707843089003941,.039,;41470;07-4990418419

    /73.470/3904907,3/:3.5,7/3,3.040;08,3/

    .40.98438419/738574/:.0/472,3:1,.9:70/93909077947,

    :78/.94341902:3.5,9,9,41430.039,;4!430,.,43

    41;4:20.,5,.9%09,25480/3-497/3,3.0848,3/8

    /03423,90/,82:3.5,574/:.943

    $$&$

    8$0.94341#,3:3/:0/

    47/3,3.048,3/.43899:

    507.039,047850.1.9,08

    #&

    %05407419,,94385:70

    949000.:9;047:/.,/05,7920394

    :54390904741805,7,9434154078

    /408349,55942:3.5,.47547,943

    /00,90/944.,4;07320398370850

    %0:3.5,941%,3,:,3/8

    3.70,8090;4:20.4390398410,.-4

    83.09,825480/430;07-4990.47

    :3.5,7/3,3.04,803,.90

    :3.5,7/3,3.04390895

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    97/322

    9,990:3.5,%70,8:707,803147.3:3.5,7/3,3.04

    4303.09070,834.,8041/4:-09,,943

    $$%$$%;8%

    #4:

    %$!0994307$4.,$0.:79$89021474507,9435:754808

    2,39,38,1;089470-:/33,.44/94..:5314:75,7.0841

    ,3/$,/,3/8,3/-:/38070,880880/1479,,943!09943071,0/

    945,9070,99,08147900,78,3/43806:03990

    941,.44/0;0/:5438,/,3/8,3/-:/38,3//0.,70/902

    1471090/3981,;4:73574908950994307749090.92,47974:90

    .9970,8:707800370.438/07,9434190147109:70574.00/34390

    74:3/9,998,4;0732039430/,3/.439740/.47547,943,3/,8

    8:.84:/-00025917425,20394170,089,909,084,.943,8

    40;079,03%070,19075099430710/,3,.9433.4:7914790

    3:1.,9434190.4:79574.00/38%0.4:797:0/9,99057450790841

    50994307,70349002591742905,20394170,57450799,-0.,:80

    9080,70349430419000259438:3/07$0.9434190,790741

    ,.44/9,3/90708344907,574;/3147980025943

    $$&

    $4:/908:-0.95745079082,39,30

    5,20394170,57450799,

    #&

    $0907,4;0732039430/,3/

    507147234;0732039,475745709,7

    4190,790741,.44/9/408349

    ,9840;073574;/31479000259

    ,3/-:/38430/-90422430

    03.0039008,9:70002590/,

    4;073203917425,2039418,/9,08

    .42570038;0,55.,943418:.2,3

    57450798/0;490/944;0732039,475

    :7907!,8,203/0/90$4.,

    00259390$$$17425,203941,3

    94980025943

    $$#';8&

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    98/322

    #457

    %$!0994307$0,,3/$07;.03.47547,90/,3207.,3

    39073,943,8553.425,3.0380/-90$0.:7908,3/.,30

    422884394/4-:83088390!55308039070/394,.4397,.99

    90&390/$9,9084;07320399497,38547929,74:804/44/8,3/

    0110.9841&$29,750784330,8830/9490$:-.,;,,80$0,

    ,3/5,/98.47708543/3.47547,903.4209,147909,,-00,7

    ,9907,90413,..47/,3.09$0.943,4190,943,

    39073,#0;03:04/0370,9439479.04190#!&$%,%70,9

    $:-806:039$0,,3/10/,.,2147701:3/,039,9909,089

    5,/0702,/03289,0-0.,:80:3/0790#!&$9,7,80

    700203998002591742905,2039419,08

    $$&

    408903.4209,950994307/07;0/1742807;.08397,385479390

    4:804/44/8,3/0110.9841&$29,7507843301,93909,

    0025943574;/0/390#!&$9,7,8087002039

    #&

    ,87,393002594317429,

    ,,389909,5,07,3/-07,31,;4

    97,38547947852039414:804/44/

    5078433083493.:/0/3909072.4

    ,3//0103804190-,8080907.4:/

    90&$4;0732039-0390757090/,8/

    80.:794190!5530907794708

    $$#%##

    %#!#%

    #4,3:,7

    %$3579,8438

    47547,943039070/394,4,3,3/$,

    47547,9431475:75480841905740.90

    .,5,.94190147207823083%40/4

    98:-8,700/940903/,4,3949

    &390/$9,908.:7703.

    98:-8,90.45507.43.0397,9085

    0,7898:-89070,1907,550/147

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    99/322

    41,5,32-,31475:75480841984-,943:3/078,/.4397,.998

    4,3,55.,943,8,5574;0/43,39006:;,0398:241

    3&390/$9,908.:7703.,990903570;,30.,30

    7,90

    !:78:,399490.4397,.9-090039,8,3/98:-839070895,20398

    0702,/0-901472079490,9907949,3!147900,78

    ,3/%0.47708543/39,907043390,24:3941!

    ,890/5:78:,3994$0.943-,3/$0.943-

    4190,943,39073,#0;03:04/0,8,203/0/-!708/039,

    0.7004,3//:702990/94904;0732039

    $$&

    0907473499039070893.4201742904,380903/0/949,8-

    98:-880.:/-0174274883.4209,,9435:78:,3994$0.943

    41909,.4/0,3/9070147000259174294/39,

    #&

    %0.4:797:0/39030,9;02-,3,/349394/49908,041

    90.45507.43.0397,90883.0,9,998:-889,90/3984,3

    ,55.,943990147207,89,990

    :80/,8,4,394,3/3.438/07,94314

    17429,8$:.,3334.:4:889,90203

    3903/0/147347.4:/90,.43899:

    .43.:84383/:-9,-0%$&$

    840.70/94741%$90147207-03

    :543.425094341984,3.4397,.99

    9880990/,7:0398:78/.9439,

    ,70.43897:0/897.9882:78,,3899

    909,35407%,,9438907:0,3

    89%#!$%

    #4$05902-07

    %$%08931,397!489.,3

    ,..47/,3.097270:,9438,3/9

    .4:7804198/:,:9470/-:8308897

    2,35:7.,80841;,74:8,3//;0780

    207.,3/801742;,74:8207.,3983

    .40.90/,8,089,4141907

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    100/322

    174290207.,398484/8,/.4224/9089490.,301472,

    5749089,84/0/-90.,30

    $$&

    09074734990509943078002591742908,089,25480/,,389

    988:55078

    #&

    %0.4:797:0/39030,9;0%,08,;0-003.40.90/1742207.,398

    42,/08,089472!489.,30883.0.9$0.943

    $2,79,08,705,/-9480480207.,3/809490!5530

    4;0732039,3/-94804/4-:83088990&$72,3/,;3

    90!55308070390207.,39840110.90/908,089490!489

    .,30,7090430845,/909,,3/9890411.07884/078,3/

    .;,30254008,3/9071,2084,70-030190/-905489

    0.,309442909,8:92,908190/

    372!489.,30,94:,3,03.9390&$72.,3349

    80.:70002594317429,,943147207.,39842,08,089490!489

    .,30

    $$#%##

    #!#%

    #40.02-07

    %$#08543/039,7:-0347547,

    /:7089070/9403,03-:830883

    4;02-07509943074228843

    0990741,:9479940,23090-448

    411.041#08543/03947547,943

    390.4:78041900,23,94350994

    :3/0.,70/3.420174294.4397,.

    70;03:00,2307870.42203/0/,3,88

    -7,3.5741970299,3.0,3/.4397,.947

    #08543/0396:089430/98,880882039

    147250994307,880883708543/03980;

    $05902-07708543/03910/9

    4:7941%,550,8

    ,70743::890.:9;0

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    101/322

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    102/322

    708:9419097,38,.94390422884307703/070/#0,,3,-0147

    3.4209,3908:241!#0,,3.,20/9,90,800259,890

    97,38,.9434..:770/3,77,80.,80.43903/88,-,80

    4:98/090!55308

    $$&

    09074734950994307#0,,3,8.4;070/-909,0025943

    #&

    %0.4:797:0/39030,9;0%0!55308,8,33/0503/039,3/

    84;0703.4:397007.80898,:94794;079803970/42,3389,90

    2,40;07-98.43803905708847250/8:-2994,70897.94341

    9884;070379892,,4,349075407945,79.5,90390

    007.8041:78/.943,794;07.079,3547943841989077947/43

    849-3420,3814489,98:.,70,8-0.4202570880/9,3,03

    .,7,.907%0,70,8709,390789,9:8,83,9;084,77,808

    93!55309077947,:78/.943949,,3/9:8#0,,3,8,-0

    147903.4209,,7831742908,0418,:9424-03,7%0,

    /4083494491,;4:7439,00259438,3/9,9044:/80094

    -09:857;00/2:89:8919-47/89445,394-0289,03,3/944

    .,9047.,94-028390757090/#0,,3

    %&;8%!!$

    #4,3:,7

    %$437088990,5574;,41

    03990/3.9..007,9390

    394907!74/:.9;0&80870,939

    0;0452039:947914798!:75480

    907!:754808$0.943907041.70

    $50.,.4342.430,3/7,390/90

    #,24888:0/0.:9;07/074

    ,3//:93.039;08%0!708/03988:0

    850.1390,70,93.909,

    4507,9;0%0509943078.,030/-0

    41147,00/-03;4,9;

    90,8%84:797010770/902,9907

    !74.,2,9434,888:0/-!70

    0,.920908,3/-4:3/84190$:-.$5

    5:78:,3994$0.94341##08

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    103/322

    8:-89,39,/110703.0-0900390574;843841,3/$0.94341

    #3-4990$0.:70/70,8570.80,3/0/0130/,890

    ,3/84..:50/-90$:-.,;,,80,3/98.439:4:809038438,8

    02-7,.0/.4;070/,3//0130/-909,7,8087002039

    -0900390!55308,3/90&390/$9,90841207.,,8,203/0/

    $$&

    0907473490.:9;07/074;4,9089006:,57490.943

    .,:80419043899:943

    #&

    4%04:7914:3/70,,3/8:-89,39;0/893.9438-0900390

    .7.:289,3.084-9,3338/0,3/94804:98/090$:-.,;,,80

    9070-:8913,;,/,3/70,843,-0.,881.,943%01:3/,2039,

    794106:,57490.9434190,88349,-84:90-:988:-0.994

    70,843,-0.,881.,94319074:538,70.,7,.9070/-8:-89,39,

    /893.94389,92,070,/110703.08430.,882,-0970,90/,3/

    70:,90//11070391742,34907%0.,881.,9432:89,84-0072,30

    94905:754804190,,3/2:89,5594,9480-043394908,20

    .,88

    !!$%#%'

    #4.94-07

    %$#05:-..948094:9

    ,..007,909084:3/,3/-,,3.0/.43;0

    :808419014720729,7-,8089.70,

    0;0452039:94799,84.70,90/

    700!47943097,390/90$:-.$

    ,:94799490!708/03994.70,90974:

    9490.43.:7703.041904.,4;0732

    $50.,.4342.4308390,70,8.4

    0247,3/:2417002039,3/8.74

    8,47/%:390,3/8,47

    7002039%0$,3:3,3!,3:38

    0.:/0,90-,7,3,85,7947949,

    17429070,.47.4;07,041,35,34

    8,3:3,3,/4590/,3/8:-2990/,

    41,2543,%:390,3/

    700.90/4724/10/904907574548,8

    ,2543,,$,8,.43/94357

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    104/322

    %08,3:3,3706:0890/90,479447/0790/090723,94341

    70,99,08.2,-0.40.90/174270,57450790841,2543,

    9,83903/0/94390039:/0908,3:3,33/090723398

    548943430907,2543,-0/0.,70/,$9-034190;0

    9,98:./0.,7,9434:/0025990.,2585745079,3/900.4342.

    ,.9;99070317424.,473,943,9,,943%08,3:3,35,880/,

    7084:94380039088:,3.0-!708/039#,24841,5708/039,

    574.,2,943/0.,73,3,70,410.9,7084190.,25,8,$

    !708/039#,24888:0/!74.,2,9434.089,-80/,$43

    ,54794341,2543,

    $$&

    0907!74.,2,94348.43899:943,

    #&

    0907,39410.4342.3.039;082,-0088039,9490.70,943,3/

    8:..08841$8170097,/04308,3/900907,39907041949043

    ,$.,3349-08:89,30/%03.039;08:3/07#4,70

    0.:8;0439490$:-.$03.090090384341908,209490

    43,$13/8348:55479907030907/408908,207,3941

    57;008949043,$13/8:5

    :3/07$0.94341!74.,2,9434

    -014709088:,3.04190574.,2,943

    47025479,39903,9:7041248941

    0025943989008,9:70:3088

    .43899:9439,9,81:540794002

    41574507917429,,943985407940

    949,%0.,030/7,39419,002

    43899:943825489439,9,,7,

    90.43.:7703.041,2,47941,902

    &%##$$$

    #4:

    %$#05:-..94,803

    -,,3.0/.43;078434190,7,3/$:

    09038438394,9073,9;0574/:.9;0:8

    4308347/07945742490900.4342.

    :4335,79.:,7,3/90.4:3973

    0.:9;07/074./0.,70/

    ,55.,-03.039;087,390/9490$:-

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    105/322

    430:3/07#05:-..94%0$8,,;0,90,55.,-0

    3.039;08390$:-.$50.,.4342.,3/700!479430:3/07#

    %0$,3430.4;07390,77,805745078,,;0

    ,903;08920393.039;08090$$:-430.4;07390708941

    90$8,,;0290/3.039;08%01:3.039;08390,7$

    ,3430,3/90290/3.039;08390,7$$:-4308,-0

    /0907230/-905,880/4,7/#084:9434

    ,43909,,3//:917008,0,9709,41.438:20744/8254790/;,

    ,7147.438:259434:98/090$%0!708/03988:0/4

    ,71390%,,3/:97003.039;09390$:-.$50.,

    .4342.430!:78:,3994#4,888:0/:7907

    ,71390%,,3/:9700!7;009390$:-.$50.,

    .4342.,3/700!479430

    $$&

    0907473490.:9;07/074$0.943410.:9;07/07

    4,3/$0.943414,7/

    #084:9434,703:,3/;4/

    #&

    %04:7913/89,99080993:5418:

    .,7090434308/:,:9470/

    /:917008890939054.0

    .949,990$:-.$50.,

    /0;0450/394,8018:89,333/:897

    3;0892039.03970940307,90025420

    430,3/94,997,.9,3/5742490574/:.9

    70907,9089,99080.43/803903.08415

    7/074,439,,3//:9

    3/;/:,80;033,290/,24:3917

    ,703:,3/;4/147-03.4397,794$

    $,/$0.943.0,7574;/089,9

    17429090779474190$:-.$50.,

    90!553090779478,-08:-0.99

    90:89428,3/%,7114/0,3/4907

    !55308

    !#'#;8#

    #4::89

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    106/322

    %$3901,.04198.07947,7,3/2,3/,2:85099439.0,7

    ,550,789,990,.9:,94341708543/039:/0073,3/40192:.94-0

    /0870/%070,8,/03,41,2494394/8288,3,.943147/0.,7,947

    7001-#42,3,94.84541,3:0//0874:841-03002590/

    1742,70,089,909,1440/-,8:22,7:/20397,3938:.

    002594394:90;030,73908/041509943079,890

    8:-2884341.4:3809,9,3,.943147/0.,7,94770014:/-0574507

    43-01470,-70,.47;4,94341,389,9:9000.:9;047/0747

    70:,9434704;079070-03,9,,8808820392,/0-90!74;3.,

    8808847439057450790841708543/039509943071,0/940,:8990

    ,/23897,9;07020/08,;,,-0:3/07!4-01470138:..4:79

    ,.943#08543/039:/0,00/9,990708346:089439,99070,

    57450790884:994-09,0/-90!74;3.041-7,,705745079084190

    708543/039#42,3,94.84541,3:0/3.%0;07309

    803903.0,88:20/90;0754399,80/030.,9047.,89,90/

    0809070834/85:909,9905745079083.:/3907574.0/:70

    ,70,.9:,/70.9,3/0.:8;0:80/-90#42,3,94.84541

    ,3:0/3.147704:847.,79,-05:754808472903%0

    5745077020/4190509943078,550,,3/34998850.,.;,.943

    $$&

    0907473499057450790841708543/

    -00025917429,,943

    #&

    #08543/039:/04:/349,;00770/

    .425,70/90574;843841905708039

    90,790743909,00259434

    2574;020398%0708,2,70//110

    02090708.:7.08,3/5,7843,08

    ,,3/8-:/38,3/2574;020398:

    .,79,-0470/:.,943,5:7548088,

    570803943899:943,//0/.,79,-03

    .02090708,3/706:70/9,91479000

    2574;0203989084:/34943-0

    /70.9:80/147704:847.,79,-

    47/0//1107039%0.,3084:/3

    394.438/07,943

    %%;8$#%#

    #4.94-07

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    107/322

    %$4943807010/800370.438/07,9434190$:570204:79

    /0.843/8288390509943814790/0.,7,94341:3.43899:943,941

    #4490780343,8905,3/0/',:0//0/%,,

    %024943841.9070,703,,;0-00310/-9080;07,

    50994307839080.,808

    $$&$

    090747349#4//349473,900.:8;0390

    4:8041#05708039,9;08,8706:70/-79'$0.419043899:943

    090747349#48;4,9;041570881700/42,3/704:8

    1700/42:3/0779$0.8,3/419043899:943

    09074734990708;4,94341907:0439,,943:3/0779'

    $0.419043899:943

    09074734990708,325,72039414-,94341.4397,.98:3/07

    79$0.419043899:943

    09074734990708;4,9434190/:0574.088.,:80:3/0779

    $0.419043899:943

    #&

    079'$0.574;/089,9,

    -8-8,:94733.70,8041905:

    ,3/57;,90-82:89473,900.:8

    #05708039,9;089,84,//8-:990$

    ,203/20398390007.80419854

    0397030-,8,8:-899:9020,8:70

    $3.090,7,390/9057088,57;

    57;00,392094:941103809490

    .03809,98349,9,4390007.80

    .43899:943,799825480/4390

    44/84757450790847908,0470.,3

    5745079085:7014770;03:05:754808

    834994-:7/0390007.80419879

    3.4209,478:-0.99940307,70:

    :3/079043899:943

    %043899:943/40834970,574

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    108/322

    .090'%,70707088;0

    ,99825574;/0889,94370888,0;4;0,5747088;088902

    419,,943

    4397,.982:89-0:3/078944/,8,;3-0032,/037010703.09490

    5488-0007.804190791:,:947941904;0732039,3/34

    4-,94341.4397,.9.,30903/9490/010,9419,9,:9479

    390,00/;4,94341/:0574.088,7/85949,5,078,4308349

    ,3,/06:,90:891.,943147,/:/.,93,-897,.988:0890780

    ,/:/.,9434:/-034/1107039174290;341,/;847453439,9

    /40834970,809900,88:080,7094/9,9984:7/:9:3/0779

    '$0.94/0./0030;07,.,282,/09,99070,8-003,

    7,;0,-:8041/8.70943,24:39394,.470.08841:78/.9434390

    5,7941,3-7,3.473897:2039,941904;0732039%8/:9.,3

    43,7801,3,.9:,.,8047.43974;0788-01470:8

    :74!,7989;8729,

    #4$05902-07

    %$01470#49440110

    !,798909,10/,509943147574

    6:08943390.43899:943,941$0.9

    ,203/3$0.9438,3/70

    #0;03:04/0#$0.9432548

    574507908$0.943254808,'

    $0.943254808,'%438,04

    574507908%0806:089430/574;8438

    ,:947390!708/039:54370.422

    3,3.0947,8090'%7,90940

    850.10/.43/9438,;0-0038,9810/

    :3.43899:943,

    $$&$

    09074734990708,;4,94341

    43899:943

    09074734990708:3/:0/00,9

    4179.0'$0.419043899:9

    09074734990708,;4,94341

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    109/322

    57490.943:3/0779.0$0.419043899:943

    #&

    $3.090708346:089439,99070;03:0-0.:8;0473,90/3

    904:8041#05708039,9;0890$03,90,8,.939398.43899:943,

    5407943974/:.0,203/2039894904:80-0393.:/0/

    574;84383$03,904,203/3.47547,903.4209,08

    507.039,0,3/0.80,3/17,3.809,08

    %070834:3/:0/00,9434108,9;05407-:9434190

    /8.70943,8949000.:94341,,%88.43899:943,507288-0

    437088/408349,-/.,90981:3.943847:3/:/00,905407039

    /08.7-08,94-2:89-0/43042:89/49,3/,98908.45041

    8,:947934:7.42500.43429,981706:0399043,3

    .9008,9;0574.088.,34147,7/

    %054074190$9,90942,070,843,-0,3/3,9:7,.,881.,9438147

    905:754808419,,943,843-003089,-80/0907970,9089490

    8:-0.9419,,943903/415745079907,90894-00;0/4790

    ,24:39894-07,80/902094/841,880882039;,:,943,3/.40.943

    90$9,9085407803990/945708:2594341;,/98,7:090

    :/.,73493907107098:.54

    :370,843,-03088/8.723,94347,7-

    $$#%$$%

    ;8!#%%$

    #44;02-07

    %$!09943078,287039,8

    /42089..47547,94303,0/390-:

    7039,%050994307,0089,9574

    0247,3/:27.:,743:30

    #:3.457,,8.,8810/,8,

    -4190,943,39073,#0;03:0

    '%,9,89,0841574/:.94347/897

    !099430784:9943:1#0;03:00

    034390.40.943-708543/03970;0

    %,'%43908,041.457,-202

    90.,881.,943,/900110.941/03

    570;4:80340/03.457,,8.,8

    574/:.9:3/07$0.-4190#

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    110/322

    $$&

    090790708;4,9434106:,57490.943.,:80-0.,:800.4.43:9

    1,72078,3/.457,574/:.078,700025997,/078,3//0,078,70349

    ,94:-4980.457,398473,89,90

    #&

    %0708,2,907,478:-89,39,/110703.0-09003.4.43:91,72078,3/

    .457,574/:.0784390430,3/,3/.457,97,/078,3//0,0784390

    4907%0147207574/:.0,3/80.457,90,9907207080.457,%0

    43899:943/408349147-/90/1107039,970,920394150784388443,8

    90708,70,843,-0-,88147.,8813902/1107039

    $$#%##'&;8%

    !!$

    #4::89

    %$

    479:30%4-,..447547,943479

    2,3:1,.9:7041/1107039-7,3/841.

    11.088:0/9490.47547,943805,7

    70897,9434;07,254345

    39,5489434190#,894.,88

    470,814703-7,3/883.090

    70.947,8-04339414703.42

    %4-,..4.,30/903,20841450

    !702:24709070-7024;39

    -7,3/.,9047

    #4,803,.90/,3/-0.,2

    ,203/0/$0.943.4190#

    03,.92039,3/94/,8-014709

    0247,3/:27.:,74#

    ,709908$:-0.994.80%,,8

    %4-,..4706:0890/147,70;070.43

    %0706:089,8/030/43:

    :90#,880880/479:30%

    /01.03.,24:39394!

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    111/322

    3::89479:30%4-,..410/,50994314770;09

    90%%0%:50/9054894341479:30%4-,..4,3/

    ,/:/0/#4,8/010.9;0

    $$&

    09074734990708,;4,9434190/:0574.08841,

    #&

    70,/341#5,79.:,7.438/07390.7.:289,3.08

    :3/07.9,8-00388:0/.43;3.08:89,990.7.:,7.,3349-0

    ;00/825,8,.4770.9;020,8:70472070,8.43897:3$0.943

    .4190#,8,203/0/-:9,831,.9,3/2489

    25479,39-0032,/0347/07945,.0450::7!702:2

    470,3/,25439390.,881.,943414.,

    2,3:1,.9:70/.,709908-0,7314703-7,3/8,3/949070-,;0

    902.4;070/-#

    384/4390#34982539075

    :3/07986:,808,9;0,:9479%

    706:702039841349.0410,73,3

    -0039033470/%04:798.43;

    #,81,03847941,;,/

    88:,3.0

    $$#%##

    %#!#

    #4::89

    %$%0708543/0399,5,073

    4507,908,300.97.54075,39807;3

    3,03,3/32,0!,3,83,35:

    7,390/9-90770850.9;02:3.5,

    ,3/41:30,3/:7085

    17,3.808574;/089,98,/7,39008,

    4-9,30/97:9857;0034;02-

    #0;03:0#,880880/,,389,3//02

  • 8/6/2019 All Tax Cases

    112/322

    90949,,24:3941!7057080393/01.03.17,3.809,08,3/

    8:7.,708147900,7894,5539017,3.809,7,9041

    43748870.05981742,7.940.02-07,85708.7-0/

    3$0.9434190,943,39073,#0;03:04/03890,/4190407

    7,908,8574;/0/3902:3.5,17,3.808!03/3900,734190

    8,/.,808#05:-..9#4,85,880/43:30

    7,393949057;,90708543/039,08,9;017,3.80147904507,94341

    9000.97.90,9,3/5407889023908,202:3.5,90841

    !,3,83,3$0.943907041574;/089,93.438/07,9434190

    17,3.80,3/798070-7,390/907,39008,5,3949039073,

    #0;03:0411.0410,.:3.5,93.988:55300.97..:77039

    94905:-.:3/079817,3.80,9,06:,9494507.039:241907488

    70.0598174200.97..:7703984/478:550/:3/079817,3.80%0

    509943078:-2989,9908,/,8:3.43899:943,3841,7,89574;/08

    147905,2039-9057;,90708543/03941,17,3.809,414198

    748870.0598049079,5,07882,789:,90/0708:-0.99490

    17,3.809,25480/3$0.9434190%,4/09070-

    /8.723,947,3/;4,9;041907:043:314729