alternatives to ash storage ponds - pp1 doc
TRANSCRIPT
PRODUCT UPDATE
www.a-s-h.com
The information contained herein is solely for informational purposes and is not offered, nor should be construed, as a warranty or contractual obligation. Diamond Power International, Inc. reserves the right to make design or material changes without notice.
©2009 Diamond Power International, Inc.
All rights reserved. ASH-9760-0209-00
Allen-Sherman-Hoff · 185 Great Valley Parkway · Malvern, PA 19355 · Phone: (888) ASH-PARTS · Fax: (610) 648-8679
Hydrobin® and Hydro Ejector® are trademarks of Diamond Power International, Inc. MAC® is a trademark of Magaldi Salerno S.p.A. used under license by Diamond Power International, Inc.
Allen-Sherman-Hoff is a Diamond Power International, Inc. division located in Malvern, Pennsylvania. ISO 9001:2000 Certifiied
Diamond Power International, Inc. is a globally acknowledged market leader in all aspects of boiler cleaning and ash handling. For more than 100 years, DPII has consistently provided innovative technologies for power generation, pulp & paper and industrial boiler designs, proven to solve the most difficult plant challenges while delivering promised benefits. Diamond Power is headquartered in Lancaster, Ohio, U.S. with more than 80 field sales, service support, distribution and manufacturing locations worldwide. For more information, visit www.diamondpower.com.
For over a century: Trusted for experience. Preferred for performance.SM
Allen-Sherman-Hoff (A-S-H), a world leader in ash handling technology, regularly works with customers to reduce or eliminate the risks associated with ash ponds. Specializing in both fly ash and bottom ash removal systems, we are in a unique position to analyze and work with each customer’s existing system, propos-ing solutions to cost-effectively address current and anticipated needs.
This product update is designed to provide a brief overview of the technological advancements in fly ash and bottom ash handling technology that offer alternatives to ash storage ponds:
• Fly Ash Conversion (From Wet to Dry System)• Bottom Ash Conversion
- Hydrobin® Dewatering Bin Configuration- Submerged Chain Conveyor (SCC)- MAC™ Dry Bottom Ash Removal
Recent Ash Pond Failures have Gained Attention from Public, Legislators and Environmental Groups
ALTERNATIVES TO ASH STORAGE PONDS
NO ASH PONDS
LEGISLATIVE ACTION
Legislators are currently pushing for the following regulations in our industry:
• WetAshShallBeTreatedas“HazardousWaste”• NewPondsMustMeetStringentRegulatoryStandards• ExistingPondsExaminationRequiredwithin1Year• AllPondstobePeriodicallyInspectedbyGovernmentOfficialsforStructuralStability
• AnnualCostofInsurancetoAddressPondSpillRisk
Major Southern Utility Site:
•5.4 M Cu. Yards of Ash•RoadwayandRailwayCleanupwith
River Dredging•LawsuitsTotaling$165M•CleanupCost$1M/Day•EstimatedTotalCost$250M
Major Northeastern US Site:
•850,000 Cu. Yards of Ash•SpilledIntoRiver•7MonthCleanupEffortCosting$37M
Major Southern Utility Site:
•10,000 Gallons•ToxicMaterialsSpill(Arsenic,Cadmium)•CostsStillBeingCalculated
Traditional Wet System with Dewatering Bin
Submerged Chain Conveyor (SCC)
Dry Bottom Ash Conveyor
Water Use High Medium Zero
Environmental Risk Mitigation Low Medium High
Boiler Derating/Outage Risk Medium High Low
Maintenance High High Low
Operations High High Low
Typical Lead Time 10months 12months 12months
Outage to Install None Major Outage Major Outage
Initial Capital Cost $ $$ $$$
Life Cycle Cost $$$ $$$ PositiveROI
BOTTOM ASH TECHNOLOGY COMPARISON: Benefits and Cost Savings
Hydrobin® Dewatering Bins
Plant Makeup Water
Bottom Ash Hopper
HydroEjector®
Jet PumpClinker Grinder
Ash Hopper Drain Sump
HP Pumps LP Pumps
Seal Water Supply
Surge Tank
Sludge Pumps
Back to Hydrobin® Dewatering Bins
Settling Tank
Sludge Pumps Back to Hydrobin® Dewatering Bins
Slurry Pump
C. Chain & Flight Bars
B. Spray Cleaning Nozzles
A. Drive Unit
I. Overflow Trough
H. Lower Trough
D. Upper Trough
G. Idler Assemblies
F. Access Panels
E. Take-up Assembly
Technologies to Eliminate Ash Storage PondsFLY ASH CONVERSION
M
MM
F
M
MF
MF
M
M
FM
Hydrovactor®
Vacuum Producer
Vent
Water
Ash Disposal Pond
Fly Ash Vacuum Pumps
Ash Storage Silo
Airlock Valve
Collector & Filter
Equalizer Valve
Vent Filter
Pugmill Unloader
Hopper Aeration Blowers
SiloAerationBlowers
Dry DustUnloader
Air GravityConveyors
MaterialHandlingValve
Syle 2Cut-offGate
Precipitataor or Baghouse Hoppers
Precipitataor or Baghouse Hoppers
1-1 1-2 1-3 1-4
1-5 1-6 1-7 1-8
Wet System Overview
• Outdated Technology• ExtensiveWaterUsageandTreatment
Required for Operation• EnvironmentalRisks
o Slurry Piping Leakso Ash Pond Leakso Contamination of Fresh Water
Supplies
Benefits of Dry Conversion
• CompletelyEliminatesWaterUsageandFly Ash Storage Ponds
• MostSitescanRe-UseaLargePortionoftheExistingFlyAshEquipment
• VariousTypesofDryFlyAshSystemsareAvailable to Match Your Application
• PotentialforSALEofFlyAsh
Convert From Wet to Dry Fly Ash Handling Technology
BOTTOM ASH CONVERSION TO HYDROBIN® SYSTEM
BOTTOM ASH HANDLING USING SCC
Submerged Chain Conveyor (SCC) System
STATE-OF-THE-ART DRY BOTTOM ASH HANDLING
Advantages
• ZEROWaterUsage• LowestLifecycleCosts• HighestEnvironmentalRiskMitigation–
Completely Dry!• HighestReliability• LowestMaintenance/OperationCosts• ReducedUnburnedCarbonContentinAsh–ReturnedasHeattoBoiler
• Proven,AdvancedTechnologywithMoreThan120SystemsSoldWorldwide
• PotentialforSaleofBottomAsh(CrushedandMixedwithFlyAsh–OffsetsCapitalExpenditure)
• EliminatesNeedforBottomAshStoragePonds
Disadvantages
• Requires Major Outage for Conversion• HighestInitialCost
Today
MAC® Systems Sold 121
InstalledMW> 42,000
Crusher
MAC®Extractor
Hopper
Advantages
• Lower Water Consumption than Traditional Hydraulic System
• ModerateInitialCost• EliminatesNeedforBottomAshStorage
Ponds
Disadvantages
• Reliability is a Risk• RequiresFrontEndLoaderstoMoveAsh• WaterUsage
o EvaporationandCarryovero Ash Pile Runoff
• MaintenanceCostsRiseOverTimeasSystemAges(RebuildsRequired~3-5Yrs)
• RequiresMajorOutageforInstallation/Conversion
Advantages
• Conversion Does Not Require an Outage• LowestInitialCost• LocationFlexibility• ShortestLeadTime• CanUtilizeMuchofExistingSystem• EliminatesNeedforBottomAshStorage
Ponds
Disadvantages
• Utilizes Same Hydraulic Systemo High Maintenanceo High Power Consumption
• UsesLargeAmountsofWater• HighestLifecycleCosts/Maintenance
Cost• LowestEnvironmentalRiskMitigation
MAC® Dry Bottom Ash System
Traditional Bottom Ash Storage with Slurry Pumping
=ELIMINATESASHPONDS $=POSITIVERETURNS =CONSERVESWATER =LOWMAINTENTANCE
Hydrobin® Dewatering Bins
Plant Makeup Water
Bottom Ash Hopper
HydroEjector®
Jet PumpClinker Grinder
Ash Hopper Drain Sump
HP Pumps LP Pumps
Seal Water Supply
Surge Tank
Sludge Pumps
Back to Hydrobin® Dewatering Bins
Settling Tank
Sludge Pumps Back to Hydrobin® Dewatering Bins
Slurry Pump
C. Chain & Flight Bars
B. Spray Cleaning Nozzles
A. Drive Unit
I. Overflow Trough
H. Lower Trough
D. Upper Trough
G. Idler Assemblies
F. Access Panels
E. Take-up Assembly
Technologies to Eliminate Ash Storage PondsFLY ASH CONVERSION
M
MM
F
M
MF
MF
M
M
FM
Hydrovactor®
Vacuum Producer
Vent
Water
Ash Disposal Pond
Fly Ash Vacuum Pumps
Ash Storage Silo
Airlock Valve
Collector & Filter
Equalizer Valve
Vent Filter
Pugmill Unloader
Hopper Aeration Blowers
SiloAerationBlowers
Dry DustUnloader
Air GravityConveyors
MaterialHandlingValve
Syle 2Cut-offGate
Precipitataor or Baghouse Hoppers
Precipitataor or Baghouse Hoppers
1-1 1-2 1-3 1-4
1-5 1-6 1-7 1-8
Wet System Overview
• Outdated Technology• ExtensiveWaterUsageandTreatment
Required for Operation• EnvironmentalRisks
o Slurry Piping Leakso Ash Pond Leakso Contamination of Fresh Water
Supplies
Benefits of Dry Conversion
• CompletelyEliminatesWaterUsageandFly Ash Storage Ponds
• MostSitescanRe-UseaLargePortionoftheExistingFlyAshEquipment
• VariousTypesofDryFlyAshSystemsareAvailable to Match Your Application
• PotentialforSALEofFlyAsh
Convert From Wet to Dry Fly Ash Handling Technology
BOTTOM ASH CONVERSION TO HYDROBIN® SYSTEM
BOTTOM ASH HANDLING USING SCC
Submerged Chain Conveyor (SCC) System
STATE-OF-THE-ART DRY BOTTOM ASH HANDLING
Advantages
• ZEROWaterUsage• LowestLifecycleCosts• HighestEnvironmentalRiskMitigation–
Completely Dry!• HighestReliability• LowestMaintenance/OperationCosts• ReducedUnburnedCarbonContentinAsh–ReturnedasHeattoBoiler
• Proven,AdvancedTechnologywithMoreThan120SystemsSoldWorldwide
• PotentialforSaleofBottomAsh(CrushedandMixedwithFlyAsh–OffsetsCapitalExpenditure)
• EliminatesNeedforBottomAshStoragePonds
Disadvantages
• Requires Major Outage for Conversion• HighestInitialCost
Today
MAC® Systems Sold 121
InstalledMW> 42,000
Crusher
MAC®Extractor
Hopper
Advantages
• Lower Water Consumption than Traditional Hydraulic System
• ModerateInitialCost• EliminatesNeedforBottomAshStorage
Ponds
Disadvantages
• Reliability is a Risk• RequiresFrontEndLoaderstoMoveAsh• WaterUsage
o EvaporationandCarryovero Ash Pile Runoff
• MaintenanceCostsRiseOverTimeasSystemAges(RebuildsRequired~3-5Yrs)
• RequiresMajorOutageforInstallation/Conversion
Advantages
• Conversion Does Not Require an Outage• LowestInitialCost• LocationFlexibility• ShortestLeadTime• CanUtilizeMuchofExistingSystem• EliminatesNeedforBottomAshStorage
Ponds
Disadvantages
• Utilizes Same Hydraulic Systemo High Maintenanceo High Power Consumption
• UsesLargeAmountsofWater• HighestLifecycleCosts/Maintenance
Cost• LowestEnvironmentalRiskMitigation
MAC® Dry Bottom Ash System
Traditional Bottom Ash Storage with Slurry Pumping
=ELIMINATESASHPONDS $=POSITIVERETURNS =CONSERVESWATER =LOWMAINTENTANCE
PRODUCT UPDATE
www.a-s-h.com
The information contained herein is solely for informational purposes and is not offered, nor should be construed, as a warranty or contractual obligation. Diamond Power International, Inc. reserves the right to make design or material changes without notice.
©2009 Diamond Power International, Inc.
All rights reserved. ASH-9760-0209-00
Allen-Sherman-Hoff · 185 Great Valley Parkway · Malvern, PA 19355 · Phone: (888) ASH-PARTS · Fax: (610) 648-8679
Hydrobin® and Hydro Ejector® are trademarks of Diamond Power International, Inc. MAC® is a trademark of Magaldi Salerno S.p.A. used under license by Diamond Power International, Inc.
Allen-Sherman-Hoff is a Diamond Power International, Inc. division located in Malvern, Pennsylvania. ISO 9001:2000 Certifiied
Diamond Power International, Inc. is a globally acknowledged market leader in all aspects of boiler cleaning and ash handling. For more than 100 years, DPII has consistently provided innovative technologies for power generation, pulp & paper and industrial boiler designs, proven to solve the most difficult plant challenges while delivering promised benefits. Diamond Power is headquartered in Lancaster, Ohio, U.S. with more than 80 field sales, service support, distribution and manufacturing locations worldwide. For more information, visit www.diamondpower.com.
For over a century: Trusted for experience. Preferred for performance.SM
Allen-Sherman-Hoff (A-S-H), a world leader in ash handling technology, regularly works with customers to reduce or eliminate the risks associated with ash ponds. Specializing in both fly ash and bottom ash removal systems, we are in a unique position to analyze and work with each customer’s existing system, propos-ing solutions to cost-effectively address current and anticipated needs.
This product update is designed to provide a brief overview of the technological advancements in fly ash and bottom ash handling technology that offer alternatives to ash storage ponds:
• Fly Ash Conversion (From Wet to Dry System)• Bottom Ash Conversion
- Hydrobin® Dewatering Bin Configuration- Submerged Chain Conveyor (SCC)- MAC™ Dry Bottom Ash Removal
Recent Ash Pond Failures have Gained Attention from Public, Legislators and Environmental Groups
ALTERNATIVES TO ASH STORAGE PONDS
NO ASH PONDS
LEGISLATIVE ACTION
Legislators are currently pushing for the following regulations in our industry:
• WetAshShallBeTreatedas“HazardousWaste”• NewPondsMustMeetStringentRegulatoryStandards• ExistingPondsExaminationRequiredwithin1Year• AllPondstobePeriodicallyInspectedbyGovernmentOfficialsforStructuralStability
• AnnualCostofInsurancetoAddressPondSpillRisk
Major Southern Utility Site:
•5.4 M Cu. Yards of Ash•RoadwayandRailwayCleanupwith
River Dredging•LawsuitsTotaling$165M•CleanupCost$1M/Day•EstimatedTotalCost$250M
Major Northeastern US Site:
•850,000 Cu. Yards of Ash•SpilledIntoRiver•7MonthCleanupEffortCosting$37M
Major Southern Utility Site:
•10,000 Gallons•ToxicMaterialsSpill(Arsenic,Cadmium)•CostsStillBeingCalculated
Traditional Wet System with Dewatering Bin
Submerged Chain Conveyor (SCC)
Dry Bottom Ash Conveyor
Water Use High Medium Zero
Environmental Risk Mitigation Low Medium High
Boiler Derating/Outage Risk Medium High Low
Maintenance High High Low
Operations High High Low
Typical Lead Time 10months 12months 12months
Outage to Install None Major Outage Major Outage
Initial Capital Cost $ $$ $$$
Life Cycle Cost $$$ $$$ PositiveROI
BOTTOM ASH TECHNOLOGY COMPARISON: Benefits and Cost Savings