0$/!'#12#1! - harvard–smithsonian center for astrophysics · smithsonian affiliations yccc -...

!!!!!

!!!!!

"#$%&!'()%$*+,-!%&.!'#/#*0$/!'#12#1!3$22(%+4.!5.)#*%!

!!!!

!!!!!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!3$62+%%.7!68!98,,!:($2!!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!;(,!'*#<=.*!>$1.$2!?11#<@!! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !!!;$,.!ABCD! !

2

!!E(6/.!#0!'#,%.,%1!!!F! F,%*#7$<%+#,!(,7!G4.*4+.H! ! ! ! D!!FF!! 3+%.!9.(7.*!E*(+,+,-!(,7!3$))#*%! ! ! I!!FFF!! J(*%+<+)(,%!5.1)#,1.1!! ! ! ! K!!FL!! "'''!F2)/.2.,%(%+#,!! ! ! ! CM!!L! 3$22(*8! ! ! ! ! ! CK!! ! !LF!! 5.<#22.,7(%+#,1! ! ! ! ! AA!!!

3

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

4

!"#$%%&'&()*#!&)*+#,-*.-&*/##

Round(s) Institution or Organization City/Town State

1 & 2 :+*%&)/(<.!#0!'#$,%*8!>$1+<!?//+(,<.! Bristol TN

1 & 2 '#//.-.!J(*=!?4+(%+#,!>$1.$2! College Park MD 1 '$/%$*.!(,7!\.*+%(-.!>$1.$2! Rock Hill SC 1 & 2 >+(2+!3<+.,<.!>$1.$2! Miami FL

1 & 2 >$1.$2!#0!?*%1!(,7!3<+.,<.1!! Daytona FL 1 >$1.$2!#0!]/+-&%! Seattle WA 1 J+,&.(7!F,1%+%$%.! Telluride CO

1 & 2 3%*(%.-+<!?+*!(,7!3)(<.!>$1.$2! Ashland NE 1 & 2 E.//$1!3<+.,<.!>$1.$2! Cartersville GA 1 & 2 ^3!3)(<.!(,7!5#<=.%!'.,%.*! Huntsville AL

1 & 2 _.1%.*,!'.,%.*!>$1.$2! Hemet CA 1 >$1.$2!#0!?*%1!(,7!3<+.,<.! Macon GA 1 & 2 3<+.,<.!'+%8!(%!^,+#,!3%(%+#,! Kansas City MO !!E&.*.!(*.!(!%#%(/!#0![RAX`!)(*%+<+)(,%1!+,!%&.!)*#-*(2!%#!7(%.@!G0!%&#1.R![`a!H.*.!0.2(/.@!!3).<+0+<!7(%(!#,!*(<+(/!(,7!.%&,+<!6(<=-*#$,7!H(1!,#%!(4(+/(6/.!0#*!2(,8!1+%.1@!!\#H.4.*R!(//!1+%.1!2(+,%(+,.7!(!<#22+%2.,%!%#!H#*=+,-!H+%&!/#HS+,<#2.!(,7!$,7.*S*.)*.1.,%.7!-*#$)1!H+%&+,!%&.+*!*.-+#,@!!!

Age range and total numbers Response

Total Response

Count

Elementary school age (children) 59 7 Middle school age (youth) 345 10 High school age (teens) 3,739 10 Parents/Caregivers 30 5 Teachers/educators 41 7 Senior citizens 8 3 Other adults 36 4

4,258 16 Total # Answered

E&.!-*.(%.1%!,$26.*!#0!)(*%+<+)(,%1!H(1!#0!&+-&!1<&##/!(-.@!!E&.!2(Y#*+%8!#0!%&#1.!&+-&!1<&##/!1%$7.,%1!H.*.!0*#2!%&.!^3!3)(<.!(,7!5#<=.%!'.,%.*@!!E&.!%#%(/!,$26.*!#0!)(*%+<+)(,%1!H+//!+,<*.(1.!(1!1+%.1!<#2)/.%.!%&.+*!5#$,7!A!J*#-*(21@!!!!;$1%!$,7.*!KBa!#0!%&.!1+%.1!*.)#*%.7!%&(%!%&.+*!(1%*#)&#%#-*()&8!7+1)/(81!*.(<&.7!DBB!%#!CBBB!).#)/.@!!!

5

!E&.!2(Y#*+%8!#0!(00+/+(%.!)*#-*(21!H.*.!&./7!+,!2$1.$21@!!F,!1#2.!<(1.1R!H&+/.!%&.!2$1.$2!H(1!%&.!)*+2(*8!1+%.R!1%(00!)(*%,.*.7!H+%&!1<&##/1R!<*.(%+,-!(!1&(*.7!.Q).*+.,<.@!!

Smithsonian Affi l iations YCCC - Microgrant Final Report

Where was your Youth Capture the Colorful Cosmos (YCCC) program held?

Answer Options Response

Percent Response

Count

museum or science center 73.3% 11 planetarium 0.0% 0 library 6.7% 1 school 13.3% 2 college/university 0.0% 0 community center 6.7% 1 Other (please specify) 4

answered question 15 skipped question 0

!!!9.,-%&!#0!3F!?00+/+(%.!J*#-*(21!

!J*#-*(21!4(*+.7!+,!/.,-%&!#0!<#,%(<%!&#$*1@!!_&+/.!%&.!2(Y#*+%8!#0!)*#-*(21!&(7![S`!<#,%(<%!&#$*1R!%&.*.!H(1!4(*+(6+/+%8!+,!%&.!7$*(%+#,!#0!)*#-*(2@!!3#2.!1+%.1!<#,7$<%.7!#,.!#*!%H#!H..=.,7!H#*=1&#)1!H&+/.!#%&.*1!1)*.(7!%&.+*!&#$*1!#4.*!(!).*+#7!#0!H..=1@!!!!!!!!

0.0% 5.9%

17.6%

41.2%

23.5%

11.8%

How long did this program last? Please estimate the total contact time, in hours, with participants.

less than 1 hour

1 to 2 hours

2 to 4 hours

4 to 8 hours

8 to 12 hours

More than 12 hours (please specify)

6

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bCX!&#$*!c%*(+,!%&.!%*(+,.*d!H#*=1&#)!1.*+.1!0#*!1+Q!E3P!1%(00!(,7!C!J*#Y.<%!'##*7+,(%#*@!!E&*..!#0!%&.!1+Q!1%(00!+2)/.2.,%.7!%&.!)*#-*(2@!!E&.!J*#Y.<%!'##*7+,(%#*!+2)/.2.,%.7!(!0#$*%&!)*#-*(2@!P$26.*!#0!1%$7.,%1!!!! AX!?-.!*(,-.!!! ! `!+,!-*(7.1![SX!!! ! ! CI!+,!-*(7.!M!'#,%(<%!&#$*1!e!4(*+(6/.R!6$%!/.11!%&(,!CM!!!

7

FF!3+%.!9.(7.*!E*(+,+,-!(,7!3$))#*%!!!?,!#4.*(//!-#(/!0#*!"'''!+1!%&(%!1+%.!/.(7.*1!0+,7!%&.!"'''!)*#-*(2!(,7!(<<#2)(,8+,-!*.1#$*<.1!2.(,+,-0$/!(,7!*./.4(,%!%#!%&.!,..71!#0!1%(00!(,7!%&.+*!)*#-*(21!#4.*(//@!!G6Y.<%+4.1!0#*!1+%.S/.(7.*1!+,</$7.7f!

• F,<*.(1.7!+,%.*.1%R!(H(*.,.11!(,7!=,#H/.7-.!#0!(1%*#,#28!<#,%.,%!!• F,<*.(1.7!=,#H/.7-.!(,7!1=+//1!+,!&#H!%#!$1.!%.<&,#/#-8!%#!1$))#*%!)*#Y.<%S6(1.7!

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a!#0!%&.!)(*%+<+)(,%1!0./%!%&(%!%&.8!&(7!/.(*,.7!&#H!%#!$1.!%&.!%./.1<#).1!(,7!%&.!+2(-.!)*#<.11+,-!1#0%H(*.@!!V4.*8#,.!0./%!%&(%!%&.8!7..).,.7!%&.+*!$,7.*1%(,7+,-!#0!(1%*#)&#%#-*()&8R!(,7!%&(%!%&.8!H#$/7!$1.!+,0#*2(%+#,!#*!*.1#$*<.1!0*#2!%&.!H#*=1&#)!+,!%&.+*!#H,!)*#-*(21@!?77+%+#,(//8R!%&.8!H.*.!4.*8!.,%&$1+(1%+<!(6#$%!%&.!4(*+.%8!#0!(<%+4+%+.1!(,7!%&.!7.)%&!#0!<$**+<$/$2!%&(%!(<<#2)(,+.7!%&.!)*#Y.<%@!!!!3F!?00+/+(%.!1%(00!H.*.!+,%.*4+.H.7!0*#2!1+Q!1+%.1@!!E&.!<#22.,%1!0*#2!%&.1.!+,%.*4+.H1!1$))#*%.7!%&.!.,%&$1+(1%+<!1$*4.8!*.1)#,1.1!(6#$%!%&.!G,S/+,.!H#*=1&#)@!E&.!?00+/+(%.1!(/1#!())*.<+(%.7!&(4+,-!%&.!1.11+#,1!)#1%.7!#,S/+,.!(/%&#$-&!#,.!<#22.,%.7!%&(%!%&.8!7+7,U%!*.(/+T.!%&.!1.11+#,1!H.*.!%&.*.!$,%+/!Y$1%!6.0#*.!5#$,7!A!e!6$%!%&.,!$1.7!%&.2!*.-$/(*/8@!!!!E&.*.!H.*.!2(,8!)#1+%+4.!<#22.,%1!(6#$%!>##7/.@!!J.#)/.!%&#$-&%!+%!H(1!$1.0$/!0#*!1&(*+,-!+7.(1!(6#$%!H&(%!#%&.*!1+%.1!H.*.!<*.(%+,-!0#*!6#%&!%&.!)*#-*(2!(,7!%&.!0+,(/!.4.,%1@!G4.*!MMa!#0!%&.!1%(00!0*#2!%&.!3F!?00+/+(%.!3+%.1!<#22.,%.7!%&(%!%&.8!H.*.!4.*8!/+=./8!%#!<#,%+,$.!%#!$1.!%&.!>##7/.!1+%.!H+%&!%&.!*.2(+,+,-!*.1)#,7+,-!%&(%!+%!H(1!c1#2.H&(%!/+=./8d@!!F,!6#%&!1$*4.81!(,7!)&#,.!+,%.*4+.H1!1+%.S/.(7.*1!<#22.,%.7!&#H!2$<&!1$))#*%!%&.8!*.<.+4.7!0*#2!6#%&!%&.!3?G!(,7!3F!?00+/+(%+#,1!#00+<.1@!!3F!1+%.!/.(7.*1!+,!)(*%+<$/(*!*.)#*%.7!%&(%!%&.8!0#$,7!+%!.(18!%#!<#22$,+<(%.!H+%&!6#%&!#00+<.1@!!E.<&,+<(/!1$))#*%!H(1!)*#4+7.7!g$+<=/8!+,</$7+,-!%&.!$1.!#0!(!1.%!#0!/()%#)1!0#*!1+%.1!%&(%!,..7.7!<#2)$%.*1@!E&#1.!%&(%!$1.7!%&.!<#2)$%.*1!H.*.!4.*8!())*.<+(%+4.!%#!&(4.!%&.2!(**+4.!)*.S/#(7.7@!!!]#*!#%&.*!(72+,+1%*(%+4.!+11$.1R!1+%.!/.(7.*1!<#22.,%.7!%&(%!%&.8!())*.<+(%.7!%&.!1$))#*%!%&.8!*.<.+4.7!0*#2!%&.!3F!?00+/+(%+#,1!G00+<.@!!!!!!!

8

!F,!%&.!1$*4.81!0#//#H+,-!%&.!%*(+,+,-1!(%!6#%&!E3P!(,7!3F!?00+/+(%.!3+%.1!(!1.*+.1!#0!g$.1%+#,1!(1=.7!%&.!1+%.S/.(7.*1!%#!*.1)#,7!%#!%&.!0#//#H+,-!1%(%.2.,%1@!?!1(2)/+,-!#0!*.1)#,1.1!0*#2!#,.!#*!6#%&!-*#$)1!+1!)*#4+7.7!6./#H@!E&.!1%(%.2.,%1!$1.7!(!*(%+,-!1<(/.!#0!7!N+).289'4#:&+(9.**O!%#!;#N+).289'4#(9.**<@!!?4.*(-.!1<#*.1!(*.!+,</$7.7!6./#H@!E3P!PhX!3F!?00+/+(%.!PhK!!!03*#=>>>#?.29.(1#(8:#(+).28214#'*(.8&89#.*+2@.A*+#/*.*#(AA*++&B'*#(8:#.*'*-(8)#)2#14#8**:+C##3F!?00+/+(%.!?4.*(-.!1<#*.!h!M@#!"#&8A.*(+*:#14#2/8#(+).28214#A28)*8)#682/'*:9*##3F!?00+/+(%.!?4.*(-.!1<#*.h!X@XM@!!#EH#!<#22.,%1!(77.7!%&(%!%&.8!&(7!<#2.!%#!%&.!)*#-*(2!H+%&!(!1%*#,-!6(<=-*#$,7!+,!(1%*#,#28@!!!"#/&''#@+*#)3*#&8%2.1()&28#"#9(&8*:#&8#)3*#=>>>#28'&8*#).(&8&89#)2#&1?'*1*8)#(+).28214#'*(.8&89#(A)&-&)&*+#/&)3#42@)3#(@:&*8A*+C#E3P!?4.*(-.!1<#*.!h!M@M#!!"#%**'#12.*#A28%&:*8)#&8#14#(B&'&)4#)2#+@??2.)#42@)3#&8#2@)D2%D+A322'D)&1*#(+).28214#'*(.8&89C#E3P!?4.*(-.!1<#*.!h!M@A!3F!?00+/+(%.!?4.*(-.!3<#*.!h!X@`K#!'#22.,%!e!!"#$%&'%()$%*+,,$-(%.)/00$#,$-%+#%/-(1&#&23%($/.)+#,%+-%(&%.&##$.(%()$%-(45$#(-%6+()%

1$/0%0+'$%$74+82$#(%()/(%()$3%./#%4-$%/(%)&2$%/(%/#3%(+2$9%:)$%;+.1&"*-$1</(&13%($0$-.&8$-%/#5%

-&'(6/1$%1$/003%/55%/#%$=.+(+#,%$0$2$#(%(&%&41%($/.)+#,9>%!!!!"#'*(.8*:#32/#)2#@+*#28'&8*#(8:#A21?@)*.DB(+*:#.*+2@.A*+#)2#+@??2.)#42@)3#&8#?.2E*A)DB(+*:#(+).28214#'*(.8&89C#E3P!?4.*(-.!1<#*.!h!M@M!3+!?00+/+(%.!?4.*(-.!1<#*.!h!X@`K!#'#22.,%%!?%0$/1#$5%<$13%</04/*0$%-@+00-%6)$#%+(%.&2$-%(&%4-+#,%()$%;+.1&"*-$1</(&13%($0$-.&8$-%

/#5%-&'(6/1$9>%

!P#%.f!E&.*.!+1!1).<$/(%+#,!%&(%!#,.!*.1)#,7.*!0*#2!%&.!3F!?00+/+(%.!3+%.1!2+1*.(7!%&.!*(%+,-!1<(/.R!<#,1+1%.,%/8!*(%+,-!1%(%.2.,%1!(!cCd!+,1%.(7!#0!(!cId@!!F,!#%&.*!J#1%!_#*=1&#)!3$*4.8!g$.1%+#,1R!H&.*.!%&.!*(%+,-!1<(/.!H(1!*.4.*1.7R!%&.!*.1)#,1.1!H.*.!(//!+,!%&.!)#1+%+4.!*(,-.@!!F0!%&+1!H.*.!%&.!<(1.R!%&.!3F!?00+/+(%.!*.1)#,1.1!(6#4.!H#$/7!*.1$/%!+,!1+-,+0+<(,%/8!&+-&.*!(4.*(-.1@!

9

!FFF!J(*%+<+)(,%!5.1)#,1.1!!!G6Y.<%+4.1!0#*!1%$7.,%1!)(*%+<+)(%+,-!+,!"'''!+,</$7.7f!

• F,<*.(1.7!=,#H/.7-.!(,7!(H(*.,.11!#0!(1%*#,#28!<#,%.,%!!• F,<*.(1.7!)*#0+<+.,<8!H+%&!1<+.,%+0+<!)*(<%+<.!1=+//1!• :.%%.*!$,7.*1%(,7+,-!#0!%.<&,#/#-8!(1!(!%##/!0#*!7#+,-!1<+.,<.!• ^%+/+T(%+#,!#0!AC1%!'.,%$*8!/.(*,+,-!1=+//1!+,</$7+,-!<*.(%+4+%8R!<#//(6#*(%+#,R!

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g$.1%+#,1!)*#4+7.!(!*.4+.H!#0!%&.!*.1)#,1.1@!#(@!E3P!S!\#H!>$<&!E&.8!i,#H!Please rate how much you know about astronomy

Answer Options

A great deal

Quite a bit Some

A l i t t le Nothing

Rating Average

Response Count

Your astronomy knowledge - Pre 4 11 20 20 13 2.60 68*

Your astronomy knowledge - Post

9 18 7 3 0 3.89 37

j!MI!1%$7.,%1!(,7!C!1+%.!/.(7.*!)(*%+<+)(%.7!+,!%&.!)*.S%.1%@!G,/8!1%$7.,%1!%##=!%&.!)#1%S%.1%@!!3./0S*.)#*%.7!/.(*,+,-!0*#2!%&.!E3P!)(*%+<+)(,%1!1&#H1!(,!+,<*.(1.7!*(%+,-!0*#2!%&.!J*.!%#!J#1%!1$*4.81@!!E&.!(4.*(-.!*(%+,-!+,<*.(1.7!0*#2!A@MB!%#!D@`KR!H+%&!%&.!2(Y#*+%8!#0!1%$7.,%1!+,!%&.!J#1%!-*#$)!1./.<%+,-!c?!-*.(%!7.(/d!#*!k$+%.!(!6+%d!(1!%&.+*!/.4./!#0!=,#H/.7-.@!!!!

10

!6@!E&.!*.1$/%1!#,!&#H!2$<&!%&.!E3P!)(*%+<+)(,%1!=,.H!)*.!(,7!)#1%!(*.!0$*%&.*!1$))#*%.7!68!%&.!)*.!(,7!)#1%!*.1)#,1.1!0*#2!%&.!g$.1%+#,!(1=+,-!1%$7.,%1!%#!7.1<*+6.!&#H!(!%./.1<#).!H#*=1@!! ! ! PhM`!

!E&.!*.1)#,1.1!%#!%&.!)*.S%.1%!g$.1%+#,!7.2#,1%*(%.!(!4.*8!6(1+<!$,7.*1%(,7+,-!(,7!0(2+/+(*+%8!H+%&!%./.1<#).1@!X[a!#0!%&.!1%$7.,%1!7.1<*+6.7!%./.1<#).1!(1!.+%&.*!1#2.%&+,-!%&(%!/.%1!8#$!1..!6+-!#6Y.<%1R!#6Y.<%1!%&(%!(*.!0(*!(H(8!#*!(1!(!H(8!%#!#61.*4.!#6Y.<%1@!!G,/8!Ca!#0!%&.!1%$7.,%1!*.0.**.7!%#!/+-&%!(1!6.+,-!+2)#*%(,%@!!?,#%&.*!CMa!7+7!,#%!=,#H!&#H!%#!7.1<*+6.!%./.1<#).1@!! !

!?(%2/@$-%()+#,-%'/1%/6/3%$/-+$1%(&%-$$9%?#%-&2$%6/3-A%()$3%-$$2%.0&-$19>%

!B&4%0&&@%()1&4,)%+(%(&%-$$%()$%-@39%

!!! ! PhDM!

!F,!%&.!J#1%S%.1%!CIa!#0!%&.!1%$7.,%1!+,</$7.7!c/+-&%d!+,!%&.+*!.Q)/(,(%+#,R!(,7!(,!(77+%+#,(/!AXa!2.,%+#,.7!c2+**#*1d!(,7!c/.,1.1d@!!G,/8!`a!1(+7!%&.8!7+7!,#%!=,#H@!!!?!-*.(%.*!,$26.*!#0!1%$7.,%1!$1.7!2#*.!%.<&,+<(/!(,7!<#2)/.Q!4#<(6$/(*8!+,!%&.+*!*.1)#,1.1@!!! !C+1-(%()$%/8$1(41$%0$(-%()$%0$#-%,$(%()$%+2/,$9%D$=(%/%-)4(($1%0$(-%+#%0+,)(%/#5%.0&-$-9>%

!1$'0$.(-%&'%/%2+11+&1%(&%./8(41$%0+,)(%/#5%()$%+2/,$>%

!

!"#"$#

$#$%# &#

'#('#!'#%'#

)*+,-./# 0)12/32# 4*+56# 70896#:80;#

0652/#

G*+A.&B*#H2/#(#0*'*+A2?*#I2.6+#D#F.*#

5@1B*.+#&8##F*.A*8)#

(<#$&# $=#

(<#

># %#

'#<#$'#$<#('#(<#"'#

G*+A.&B*#H2/#(#0*'*+A2?*#I2.6+#D#F2+)#5@1B*.+#&8#F*.A*8)#

11

<@!E3P!J#1%!S!_&(%!E&.8!9.(*,.7!!_&.,!E3P!1%$7.,%1!H.*.!(1=.7!H&(%!%&.8!/.(*,.7!0*#2!%&.!)*#-*(2R!`[a!#0!%&.!*.1)#,1.1!H.*.!<#22.,%1!(6#$%!(+).28214!#*!)*A382'294@!!!?2#,-!%&.!(+).28214!<#22.,%1R!%&.!4(*+.%8!#0!1%$7.,%!*.1)#,1.1!+,7+<(%.!%&.!*(,-.!#0!).*1#,(/!.Q)/#*(%+#,!#0!1)(<.R!(,7!%&.+*!+,7+4+7$(/!<#,,.<%+#,!H+%&!)(*%+<$/(*!)+.<.1!#0!%&.!<#12#1@!!

c%&(%!1%(*1!<(,!(/1#!6.!1$,1!#0!7+00.*.,%!1#/(*!181%.21d!!

cE&(%!(//!%&.!)/(,.%1!(*.!7+00.*.,%d!!

cF!/.(*,.7!(6#$%!%&.!,.6$/(d!!

c&#H!(!6/(<=!&#/.!+1!2(7.!(,7!%&(%!+%!+1!7(*=!2(%%.*d!!!

E&.!)*A382'294!*.1)#,1.1!+,</$7.7!<#22.,%1!(6#$%!$,7.*1%(,7+,-!%./.1<#).1R!/.(*,+,-!&#H!%#!$1.!%&.!>+<*#G61.*4(%#*8!(,7!<#2)$%.*1@!!]#*!2(,8!1%$7.,%1!%&.*.!()).(*1!%#!6.!(!-(+,!+,!(6+/+%8!%#!$1.!%&.!%.<&,#/#-8!+,!%&.!)*#-*(2@!!!

!(&%#&%)&6%(&%6&1@%/%($0$-.&8$>%

%

!?%0$/1#$5%()$%5+''$1$#.$%*$(6$$#%(6&%5+''$1$#(%($0$-.&8$-%1$'1/.(&1%/#5%1$'0$.(&1999>%

%

!E&6%(&%.)/#,$%/#%+2/,$%.&0&1%/#5%-+F$>%

!!EH#!*.1)#,1.1!H.*.!1).<+0+<!*.0/.<%+#,1!#,!H#*=+,-!1%8/.@!!E&.!)*#-*(2!())(*.,%/8!)*#4+7.7!%&.1.!1%$7.,%1!%&.!#))#*%$,+%8!%#!/.(*,!2#*.!(6#$%!&#H!%&.8!)*.0.*!%#!H#*=@!

!!+%6&1@%*$(($1%/0&#$>%

%

!?G<$%0$/1#$5%/#5%5+-.&<$1$5%(&%.&224#+./($%/#5%6&1@%/-%/%($/2%(&%'+#+-)%6)/(%3&41%5&+#,>%

!!! !

12

!_&+/.!%&.*.!H(1!.4+7.,<.!#0!/.(*,+,-!H+%&+,!%&.!E3P!)(*%+<+)(,%1R!+,!#%&.*!1$*4.8!g$.1%+#,1!%&.!)*.S)#1%!*.1)#,1.1!H.*.!0/(%@!]#*!.Q(2)/.R!H&.,!E3P!1%$7.,%1!H.*.!(1=.7!&#H!+,%.*.1%.7!%&.8!H.*.!+,!/.(*,+,-!(6#$%!(1%*#,#28R!%&.!(4.*(-.!*.1)#,1.!H.,%!7#H,!1/+-&%/8!0*#2!)*.!%#!)#1%!ND@XD!%#!D@[CO@!!E&.*.!H.*.!1+2+/(*!*.1)#,1.1!+,!g$.1%+#,1!<#,<.*,+,-!&#H!<#20#*%(6/.!1%$7.,%1!H#$/7!6.!+,!%(/=+,-!(6#$%!%&.+*!(1%*#,#28!H#*=!H+%&!0*+.,71!(,7!0(2+/8@!!!_&.,!(1=.7!H&(%!)(*%!#0!%&.!)*#-*(2!%&.8!.,Y#8.7!/.(1%!DDa!1(+7!c,#%&+,-d@!!E&+1!-*#$)!0./%!%&(%!.4.*8%&+,-!H.,%!H.//!0#*!%&.2@!

cP#%&+,-R!.4.*8%&+,-!H(1!(H.1#2./8!(2(T+,-@d!#_+%&+,!%&.!*.2(+,+,-!MMa!%&.*.!H(1!(!*(,-.!#0!<#22.,%1!(6#$%!#%&.*!+11$.1!%&(%!0./%!7+00+<$/%R!<&(//.,-+,-R!#*!6#*+,-@!!E&.1.!+,</$7.7!H#*=+,-!+,!(!-*#$)R!<*.(%+,-!%&.!7+1)/(81R!-#+,-!%#!4+1+%!%&.!#61.*4(%#*8!(,7!H#*=+,-!#,!%&.!+2(-.1@!!]#*!2(,8!#0!%&.!1%$7.,%1R!%&+1!)*#-*(2!H(1!,#%!(!0*..!<&#+<.@!!E&.8!H.*.!*.<*$+%.7R!#*!%&.8!1+-,.7!$)!,#%!*.(/+T+,-!%&.!.Q%.,%!#0!%&.!<#22+%2.,%@!!E&.*.!+1!1).<$/(%+#,!%&(%!%&.!/(<=!#0!0*..!<&#+<.!+,!<&##1+,-!%#!)(*%+<+)(%.!+2)(<%.7!%&.+*!*.1)#,1.!%#!%&.!.Q).*+.,<.@!# #

13

!"#$%%&'&()*#!&)*+#F(.)&A&?(8)+#J(*%+<+)(,%1!0*#2!%&.!3F!?00+/+(%.!3+%.1!<#2)/.%.7!(!)#1%S%.1%!0#//#H+,-!<#2)/.%+#,!#0!%&.!)*#-*(2@!!(@!_&(%!%&.8!/.(*,.7!! ! PhK`!

!! ! !E&.!2(Y#*+%8!#0!<#22.,%1!0#<$1.7!#,!%&.!+2(-.!)*#<.11+,-!1#0%H(*.@!!F%!+1!())(*.,%!%&(%!)(*%+<+)(,%1!H.*.!+,%.*.1%.7!+,!/.(*,+,-!&#H!%#!$1.!0+/%.*1R!<*.(%+,-!<#/#*1!(,7!2(=+,-!<&(,-.1!%#!%&.+*!)&#%#-*()&1@!!!

!?%0$/1#$5%/*&4(%+2/,$%81&.$--+#,%/#5%)&6%(&%4-$%'+0($1-9>%

!+%0$/1#$5%)&6%(&%2/#+840/($%8)&(&,1/8)->%

!?%0$/1#$5%)&6%/-(1&#&2$1%4-$%+2/,$%81&.$--+#,%(&%5+-80/3%5+''$1$#(%()+#,-%+#%&41%-&0/1%-3-($2>%

!!!9.(*,+,-!(6#$%!%./.1<#).1!(,7!%&.!>+<*#G61.*4(%#*8!H(1!%&.!1.<#,7!2#1%S2.,%+#,.7!%#)+<!@!

!H$/1#+#,%(&%4-$%()$%6$*-+($%(&%(/@$%8)&(&->%

!(&%-$$%()+#,-%()1&4,)%()$%($0$-.&8$9%?(%6/-%6&#5$1'40A%?G5%#$<$1%5&#$%()/(%*$'&1$>%

!!!!!!!!!

<=#

(!#&# $'#

'#$'#('#"'#!'#<'#%'#

!21*)3&89#=2@#J*(.8*:#2.#G&+A2-*.*:#

5@1B*.+#&8#F*.A*8)#

14

!!6@!_&(%!3F!?00+/+(%.!3+%.1!.,Y#8.7!!! PhK`!

!! !!F%!+1!,#%!1$*)*+1+,-!%&(%!*.1)#,1.1!%#!H&(%!)(*%+<+)(,%1!2#1%!.,Y#8.7!)(*(//./1!%&.!*.1)#,1.1!%#!H&(%!%&.8!/.(*,.7!#*!7+1<#4.*.7@!!3%$7.,%1!.,Y#8.7!%&.!#))#*%$,+%8!%#!<*.(%.!%&.+*!#H,!+2(-.1R!%#!$1.!%&.+*!+2(-+,(%+#,!H&+/.!1%+//!<#,,.<%+,-!%&.+*!H#*=!%#!1#2.%&+,-!4.*8!*.(/@!!!!

%

!?%1$/003%$#I&3$5%0$/1#+#,%)&6%(&%5+,+(/003%81&.$--%()$%+2/,$-%'1&2%()$%J1+F&#/%($0$-.&8$->%

%

!?%0&<$5%$5+(+#,%()$%8)&(&-9%+(%,1$6%23%+2/,+#/(+&#%/#5%2/5$%2$%6/#(%(&%5&%2&1$%6+()%+(>9%

%

!?%2&-(%$#I&3$5%1$.$+<+#,%()$%+2/,$-%*/.@9%?(%6/-%-&%$=.+(+#,%(&%-$$%6)/(%()$%($0$-.&8$-%)/5%

./8(41$5K>%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

$$# $"#!#

"'#"%#

$# "#'#<#$'#$<#('#(<#"'#"<#!'#

I3()#F(.)#2%#)3*#F.29.(1#G&:#=2@#K8E24#L2+)M#5@1B*.+#&8#F*.A*8)#

15

%

<@!\#H!3F!?00+/+(%.!3+%.1!H#$/7!+2)*#4.!%&.!J*#-*(2!!E&.!%#)!A!*.1)#,1.1!%#!%&+1!g$.1%+#,!H.*.!c)#1+%+4.d!(,7!c2#*.!%+2.d@!!_&(%!)(*%+<+)(,%1!H(,%.7!2#*.!%+2.!0#*!4(*+.7!0*#2!/.,-%&!#0!)*#-*(2!%#!2#*.!%+2.!+,!%&.!/(6!(,7!2#*.!%+2.!H+%&!%&.!<#2)$%.*1@!!E&.!7.1+*.!0#*!2#*.!%+2.!+1!+,!#0!+%1./0!(,!+,7+<(%#*!#0!+,%.*.1%!+,!%&.!)*#-*(2@!!E&.!<#22.,%1!+,!%&.!#%&.*!<(%.-#*+.1!H.*.!#0!(!<#,1%*$<%+4.!,(%$*.@!!E&.*.!H(1!#,/8!#,.!1).<+0+<(//8!,.-(%+4.!<#22.,%R!H&+<&!H(1!(6#$%!(!)(*%+<$/(*!)*.1.,%.*U1!(00.<%@!!! ! PhIB!

!! !!

!2&1$%(+2$%+#%()$%0/*%6+()%()$%.&284($1->%

%

%!:/@$%/#5%81+#(%&4(%2&1$%8)&(&->%

%

!?%()+#@%+(%6&405%*$%<$13%)$08'40%(&%*$,+#%()$%'+0($1%-$--+&#%*3%81&I$.(+#,%/%.&0&1'40%+2/,$%&#%()$%

-.1$$#%/#5%84(%LA%MA%N%'+0($1-%+#%()$%0+,)(%8/()%(&%(/0@%/*&4(%()$%1$-40(+#,%$''$.(>%

%

!"''$1%+(%/,/+#%O%+(G-%,1$/(K>%

%

!?%6&405%)/<$%2$#(&1-%0+@$%/.(4/0%/-(1&#&2$1-%($/.)%4-9>%

% %

(%#("#

$=#$$#

$=#

"# $# $#'#<#$'#$<#('#(<#"'# !"#$%&'(%$()**(+%(+,'(-$%.$/"(

01"2'$3(45(-'$6'5+(

16

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g$.1%+#,1!#,!(!1<(/.!#0!7#N-*.4#8*9()&-*#&1?(A)<!%#!;#N-*.4#?2+&)&-*#&1?(A)<C#E&.!<#22.,%1!6./#H!)*#4+7.!(!*(,-.!#0!*.1)#,1.1!(,7!+,1+-&%!0*#2!%&.!1+%.1@!!H2/#/2@':#42@#.()*#)3*#&1?(A)#2%#&1?'*1*8)&89#=>>>#28#=,OP#,PQ$5"R$0",5M#$-*.(9*#!A2.*#S#TCU#!!:)$%BPPP%81&,1/2%+-%/%'4#%/#5%.1$/(+<$%6/3%(&%+#(1&54.$%/-(1&#&239%P&#-+5$1+#,%()/(%()$%

80/#$(/1+42%+-#Q(%2&*+0$%/#5%-.)&&0%'4#5-%/1$%51+$5%48%'&1%'+$05%(1+8-%()+-%6/-%/%,1$/(%'+(%'&1%&41%

24-$429%?(%/00&6$5%4-%(&%2/@$%/%0/-(+#,%+28/.(%&#%-(45$#(-%/(%B&1@%;+550$%R.)&&0%/#5%,/<$%4-%/%

'&4#5/(+&#%'&1%+#(1&54.+#,%/-(1&#&23%/-%&4(1$/.)9>%

%

!J-%/%5+1$.(%1$-40(%&'%+280$2$#(+#,%()$%81&,1/2%6$%)/<$%/01$/53%*$,4#%5+-.4--+&#-%6+()%E&6/15%

E4,)$-%E+,)%R.)&&0%(&%5$<$0&8%/%2&1$%+#($#-$%/-(1&#&23%81&,1/2%'&1%#$=(%3$/19>%

%

!:)+-%+-%/%@$3%$=/280$%&'%)&6%-(453%&'%()$%#/(41/0%-.+$#.$-%/1$%$#)/#.$5%4-+#,%5+,+(/0%2$5+/%

($.)#&0&,39%:)$%(&&0-%81&.41$5%6+()%()$%81&,1/2%'4#5+#,%)/<$%$=8/#5$5%&41%./8/*+0+(+$-%/#5%/1$%

$#)/#.+#,%&()$1%81&,1/2-%6$%/1$%/*0$%(&%&''$19>%

%

!?(%,&(%&41%#/2$%&4(%+#(&%()$%.&224#+(3%+#(&%/%8&-+(+<$%6/39>%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

%

17

%

H2/#/2@':#42@#.()*#)3*#&1?(A)#2%#&1?'*1*8)&89#)3*#=>>>#F.29.(1#28#=,OP#F$P0">"F$50!M#$-*.(9*#.*+?28+*#&+#TCU;#!!R(45$#(-%+#%()+-%81&,1/2%0$/1#$5%74+($%/%*+(%/*&4(%/-(1&#&23%/#5%)&6%+(%1$0/($-%(&%()$+1%

$<$135/3%0+<$-9%:)$3%6$1$%$28&6$1$5%()1&4,)%()+-%81&,1/2%()1&4,)%4-$%&'%.&284($1-A%-$0$.(+#,%

()$+1%&6#%+2/,$-A%.&#(1&00+#,%($0$-.&8$-A%/#5%4(+0+F+#,%()$%-&'(6/1$%81&<+5$59%?%./#%,4/1/#($$%

()+-%+-%/%81&,1/2%()$3%6&#G(%-&&#%'&1,$(9>%

%

!J-%?%2$#(+&#$5A%3&4#,%8$&80$%)/<$%#&6%1$,+-($1$5%(&%1$(41#%(&%&41%:$$#%:$.)%P$#($1%&#%/%

1$,40/1%*/-+-A%/'($1%8/1(+.+8/(+#,%+#%&41%BPPP%81&I$.(9%%:)$3%6+00%*$%/*0$%(&%5$-+,#%/#5%.1$/($%()$+1%

&6#%240(+2$5+/%81&I$.(-A%,$(%(4(&1+#,%/#5%)/<$%/%80/.$%(&%.&#(+#4$%6)/(%()$3%-(/1($59>%%

%

!R&2$%-(45$#(-%$=81$--$5%-4.)%+#($1$-(%+#%()$%;+.1&"*-$1</(&13%()/(%()$3%6/#($5%(&%.&#(+#4$%

4-+#,%+(%'1&2%)&2$%/#5%8&-(+#,%()$+1%6&1@%&#%-&.+/0%2$5+/9%J55+(+&#/003A%-(45$#(-%/1$%-&%81&45%

()/(%()$+1%6&1@%/#5%()$+1%#/2$-%/1$%48%&#%/%;4-$42%$=)+*+(%/#5%6$1$%/2/F$5%/(%()$%'/.(%()/(%

()$3%6$1$%/*0$%(&%4-$%()$%!1$/0%()+#,>%6+()%()$%;+.1&"*-$1</(&13%($0$-.&8$-9>%

%

!:)+-%/.(+<+(3%/00&6-%&41%-(45$#(-%(&%*$(($1%4#5$1-(/#5%)&6%DJRJ%.&28+0$-%/#5%81&.$--$-%+2/,$-%

'1&2%E4**0$%/#5%,+<$-%()$2%/%*$(($1%4#5$1-(/#5+#,%&'%5$$8%-8/.$%/#5%2$--+$1%&*I$.(-9>%

%

As mentioned above, sharing information across sites helped site-leaders consider new possibilities for program development. ! !:)$%($0$.&#%6/-%4-$'40%S?%6/-%+#($1$-($5%()/(%-&%2/#3%5+5%+(%/-%/%-422$1%./289%%T$%5&#Q(%)/<$%

()/(%'/.+0+(3%*4(%.&405%5&%/O&#$%5/3%&'%&4(1$/.)%(&%()$%./28-9%S%?%6&#5$1%+'%+(%.&405%*$%-$(%48%/-%/%

6&1@-(/(+&#%(&%5&%-+280$%.)/00$#,$-9%U-(/''$5V” !G%&.*!1+%.1!%(/=.7!(6#$%!)/(,1!%#!<#,%+,$.!%&.!H#*=!#,!%&.+*!#H,!(0%.*!%&.!)*#Y.<%!.,71@!G,.!1+%.!+1!<*.(%+,-!(!)/(,.%(*+$2!1&#H!%&(%!H+//!+,<#*)#*(%.!./.2.,%1!0*#2!"'''@!!?,#%&.*!1+%.!H+//!6.!%*(+,+,-!%&.!1%(00!H&#!H#*=!H+%&!%..,1!+,!%&.+*!E..,!E.<&!'.,%.*!%#!$1.!%&.!>+<*#G:1.*4(%#*8@!!E.(<&.*1!)/(,!%#!<#,%+,$.!$1+,-!%&.!<$**+<$/$2!+,!%&.+*!</(11*##21@!Additionally, %&.*.!H.*.!2(,8!<#22.,%1!%&(%!%&.!)*#-*(2!H(1!4.*8!.(18!%#!+2)/.2.,%!(,7!%&(%!%&.8!H#$/7!/+=.!%#!)(*%+<+)(%.!(-(+,!+,!(,#%&.*!"'''S/+=.!.4.,%!+0!%&.!#))#*%$,+%8!(*#1.@!!!!!!!!!!!!!

18

When asked in what types of programs would they use the YCCC resources and MicroObservatory both the TSN and the SI Affiliates had a variety of responses. E&.1.!*.1)#,1.1!(-(+,!&+-&/+-&%!%&.!0/.Q+6+/+%8!#0!%&.!"'''!%#!(7()%!%#!(!*(,-.!#0!%.(<&+,-!(,7!/.(*,+,-!1+%$(%+#,1@!!E3P!PhX!

! !!3F!?00+/+(%.!3+%.1!PhK!

!!'#22.,%1!0*#2!%&.!c#%&.*d!<(%.-#*8!+,</$7.!<&(*%.*!1<&##/R!0/##*!(<%+4+%+.1!+,!%&.!2$1.$2!(,7!8.(*S*#$,7!3)(<.!'(2)1@!E&.*.!H.*.!,#!1+%.1!%&(%!*.1)#,7.7!%&(%!%&.8!H#$/7!,#%!$1.!%&.!>+<*#G61.*4(%#*8!+,!%&.+*!)*#-*(21@!!!! !!

80.0%

20.0%

100.0%

0.0% 0.0% 0.0%

20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0%

100.0% 120.0%

Afte

r S

choo

l P

rogr

ams

Fam

ily P

rogr

am/

Wor

ksho

p

Sum

mer

/Sch

ool

vaca

tion

Cam

ps

Oth

er (

plea

se

spec

ify b

elow

)

I do

not p

lan

to

use

Mic

roO

bser

vato

ry

in m

y pr

ogra

ms

In what type(s) of programs would you use YCCC resources and MicroObservatory? (check all that apply)

55.6% 55.6%

77.8%

44.4% 44.4% 33.3%

0.0% 0.0%

20.0%

40.0%

60.0%

80.0%

100.0%

Fam

ily P

rogr

am/

Wor

ksho

p

Sch

ool

Pro

gram

s

Sum

mer

Cam

p

Pro

gram

for

the

Gen

eral

Pub

lic

Afte

r S

choo

l P

rogr

ams

Oth

er (

plea

se

spec

ify b

elow

)

I do

not p

lan

to

use

Mic

roO

bser

vato

ry

in m

y

In what type(s) of programs would you use MicroObservatory? (check all that apply)

19

!L!3$22(*8!!F,!*.4+.H+,-!%&.!*.1)#,1.1!0*#2!%&.!)(*%+<+)(,%1!(,7!%&.!1+%.!/.(7.*1!+%!+1!.4+7.,%!%&(%!%&.!7.0+,.7!#6Y.<%+4.1!0#*!"'''!&(4.!6..,!(<&+.4.7@!!?<*#11!%&.!*(,-.!#0!1+%.1!%&.*.!H(1!<#,1+7.*(6/.!4(*+(6+/+%8!+,!%&.!1+T.!#0!%&.!)*#-*(2R!%&.!%(*-.%!($7+.,<.R!<#,%(<%!&#$*1!(,7!%&.!=+,7!#0!1.%%+,-!$%+/+T.7@!!".%R!%&.!<#*.!./.2.,%1!#0!%&.!)*#-*(2!H.*.!1$<<.110$//8!+2)/.2.,%.7@!E&.!1%*.,-%&!#0!%&.!)*#-*(2!+,</$7.7!%&.!0/.Q+6+/+%8!#0!7.1+-,R!%&.!1%*.,-%&!#0!%&.!<#//(6#*(%+4.!#*-(,+T(%+#,R!(,7!%&.!<#,%.,%!#0!%&.!)*#-*(2@!!F%!+1!H#*%&!.Q(2+,+,-!%&.1.!./.2.,%1!%&(%!/.7!%#!%&.!1$<<.11!#0!%&.!"'''R!(/#,-!H+%&!<&(//.,-.1!%&(%!(*#1.!+,!%&.!+2)/.2.,%(%+#,!(1!0$%$*.!)*#-*(21!(*.!<#,1+7.*.7@!!K'*1*8)+#2%#!@AA*++#E&.!0#//#H+,-!(*.!%&.!./.2.,%1!%&(%!<#,%*+6$%.7!%#!%&.!1$<<.110$/!+2)/.2.,%(%+#,!#0!%&.!"'''f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g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g$+%.!(1!1%*#,-!+,!(1%*#,#28!#*!3EV>R!%&.!(77+%+#,!#0!%&.!(1%*#)&#%#-*()&8!.4.,%!)*#4+7.7!(,#%&.*!.,%*8!)#+,%!0#*!)(*%+<+)(%+#,@!F,!0(<%R!%&+1!<#$/7!6.!<#,1+7.*.7!(!3EV?>S6(1.7!)*#Y.<%@!!?!,$26.*!#0!1+%.1!<#22.,%.7!%&(%!(/%&#$-&!%&.8!H.*.!).*1#,(//8!,#%!%*(+,.7!+,!(1%*#,#28R!%&.8!7+7!=,#H!&#H!%#!$1.!%&.!+2(-.!)*#<.11+,-!1#0%H(*.@!!G0%.,!%&.1.!1%(00!)(*%,.*.7!H+%&!)/(,.%(*+$2!1%(00!%#!)*#4+7.!(//!,..7.7!.Q).*%+1.@!!!!

20

!<@!E.<&,#/#-8!!E&.!>+<*#SG61.*4(%#*8!(,7!%&.!+2(-.!)*#<.11+,-!1#0%H(*.!&./).7!1+%.1!(<&+.4.!(,7!.Q)(,7!%&.+*!%.<&,#/#-8!-#(/1!H&+/.!<*.(%+,-!(H(*.,.11!(2#,-!%&.+*!($7+.,<.1!(6#$%!%&.!(4(+/(6+/+%8!#0!%&.!>+<*#SG61.*4(%#*8@!!:#%&!1%(00!(,7!)(*%+<+)(,%1!H.*.!4.*8!1$*)*+1.7!%#!/.(*,!%&(%!%&.!1#0%H(*.!+1!0*..!%#!.4.*8#,.@!!_+%&!%&.!-#(/!#0!%(*-.%+,-!$,7.*S*.)*.1.,%.7!(,7!/#HS+,<#2.!)(*%+<+)(,%1R!%&+1!)*#-*(2!<*.(%.7!(,!.,%*8!)#+,%!(,7!/#,-S%.*2!(<<.11!%#!%&.!%.<&,#/#-8!6.8#,7!%&.!<#2)/.%+#,!#0!%&.!"''''@!!!!7@!]/.Q+6+/+%8!(,7!?7()%(6+/+%8!#0!)*#-*(2!!_+%&!%&.!)*#1<*+6.7!./.2.,%1!+,!"'''U1!7.1+-,R!1+%.1!H.*.!(6/.!%#!(7()%!%&.!)*#-*(2!%#!0+%!%&.+*!1).<+0+<!,..71!(,7!.,4+*#,2.,%1@!!E&+1!2.(,%!%&(%!H&+/.!1#2.!1+%.1!<*.(%.7!(0%.*S1<&##/!)*#-*(21!0#*!2+77/.!1<&##/!1%$7.,%1!#*!)(*%,.*.7!H+%&!1<&##/1!0#*!+,S</(11!1.%%+,-1R!#%&.*1!&(7!H..=.,7!H#*=1&#)1!0#*!0(2+/+.1R!H&+/.!1%+//!#%&.*!1+%.1!<#,7$<%.7!H..=S/#,-!1<+.,<.!<(2)1@!!?77+%+#,(//8R!%&.!<()(<+%8!(%!1+%.1!4(*+.7!<#,1+7.*(6/8!1#!%&(%!H&+/.!1#2.!1+%.1!H#*=.7!H+%&!&$,7*.71!#0!)(*%+<+)(,%1R!#%&.*1!H#*=.7!H+%&!-*#$)1!+,!%&.!#*7.*!#0!CB1@!!E&+1!0/.Q+6+/+%8!2.(,%!%&(%!1+%.1!<#$/7!*.(//8!<*.(%.!(!)*#-*(2!%&(%!6.1%!1$+%.7!%&.2!H&+/.!1%+//!$%+/+T+,-!(//!%&.!1$))#*%R!*.1#$*<.1!(,7!-$+7(,<.!0*#2!%&.!<#//(6#*(%+#,@!!E&.!(6+/+%8!%#!%(/=!H+%&!1%(00!(<*#11!1+%.1!(//#H.7!)*#-*(2!1%(00!#))#*%$,+%+.1!0#*!7.1<*+6+,-!(,7!1&(*+,-!1$<<.110$/!2#7./1R!(,#%&.*!H(8!%#!.Q%.,7!%&.!*.(<&!#0!%&.!H#*=@!!?!,$26.*!#0!1+%.1!<#22.,%.7!#,!H(81!%&(%!%&.8!H(,%!%#!<&(,-.!%&.+*!0#*2(%1!6(1.7!#,!%&.1.!<#,4.*1(%+#,1@!!.@!]$,7+,-!J*#4+7+,-!0$,7+,-!2(7.!%&.!#))#*%$,+%8!(//!%&.!2#*.!7.1+*(6/.@!!?/%&#$-&!%&.!0$,7+,-!7+7!,#%!1$))#*%!%&.!.,%+*.!)*#-*(2!+%!()).(*.7!%#!6.!.,#$-&!%#!2(=.!%&.!(77+%+#,!#0!%&+1!,.H!6#78!#0!H#*=!)#11+6/.@!!?,7R!H+%&!%&.!0*..!(<<.11!%#!%&.!%.<&,#/#-8R!+%!()).(*1!%&(%!1+%.1!H+//!<#,%+,$.!%#!0+,7!H(81!%#!.26.7!./.2.,%1!#0!%&.!"'''!+,%#!%&.+*!0$%$*.!)*#-*(21@!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

21

!>3(''*89*+#?!,$26.*!#0!<&(//.,-.1!H.*.!*.)#*%.7!0*#2!7+00.*.,%!<#,1%+%$.,%1!+,!%&.!)*#-*(2@!l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g$+*.7!H(1!$,.Q).<%.7@!!E&.!3?G!#00+<.!(/1#!<#22.,%.7!%&(%!%&.!1$))#*%!0#*!%&.!)*#-*(2!%##=!2#*.!%+2.!%&(,!(,%+<+)(%.7@!!E&.*.!H(1!<#,<.*,!%&(%!%&.!0$,7+,-!H(1!,#%!(7.g$(%.!%#!<#4.*!%&.!&#$*1!,..7.7!%#!1$))#*%!(//!%&.!1+%.1@!!:#%&!%&.!3+!?00+/+(%+#,1!G00+<.!(,7!%&.!3?G!1%(00!0./%!%&(%!0#*!0$%$*.!)*#-*(21!%&.!%+2.!*.g$+*.2.,%1!0#*!7.4./#)2.,%!(,7!+2)/.2.,%(%+#,!H#$/7!,..7!%#!6.!*.<(/<$/(%.7@!!6@!E&.!3#0%H(*.!!E&.*.!H.*.!1.4.*(/!<#22.,%1!(6#$%!)*#6/.21!H+%&!%&.!>+<*#G61.*4(%#*8@!!E&.1.!/(*-./8!*.4#/4.7!(*#$,7!+11$.1!#0!/#1+,-!(//!%&.!+2(-.1!+0!%&.!<#2)$%.*1!H.*.!,#%!1&$%!7#H,!+,!(!)(*%+<$/(*!#*7.*!e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

! !!!!!

22

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c8.1d!H&.,!0+*1%!())*#(<&.7@!'#,%+,$+,-!%#!/.(*,!(6#$%!%&.!,..71!(,7!/#-+1%+<1!#0!%&.!1+%.1!+1!=.8!%#!1%*.(2/+,+,-!%&.!,..7.7!%+2.!1).,%!%#!1$))#*%!%&.!1+%.1!%&*#$-&#$%!(,8!0$%$*.!)*#-*(21@!!!!6@!'#,%+,$.!%#!5.0+,.!3#0%H(*.!E&.*.!H.*.!*./(%+4./8!0.H!1#0%H(*.!)*#6/.21!<#,1+7.*+,-!%&.!.Q%.,1+4.!,(%$*.!#0!%&.!1#0%H(*.!(,7!%&.!H+7.!*(,-.!#0!<()(6+/+%+.1!0*#2!1+%.!%#!1+%.@!\#H.4.*R!+%!H#$/7!6.!H#*%&H&+/.!%#!%(=.!,#%.!#0!1#2.!#0!%&.!*.).(%.7!)*#6/.21@!!]*#2!%&.!>+<*#SG61.*4(%#*8!%&+1!()).(*1!%#!6.!2#1%/8!(,!+11$.!H+%&!1&$%%+,-!7#H,!%&.!)*#-*(2!(,7!/#1+,-!%&.!+2(-.1@!!E&.*.!H.*.!0.H.*!<#,1+1%.,%!)*#6/.21!H+%&!%&.!+2(-+,-!1#0%H(*.!e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k$.1%+#,1!%#!<#,1+7.*!0#*!+,<*.(1+,-!1$<<.11!#0!)*#-*(2!+2)/.2.,%(%+#,!6.-+,!H+%&f!!_&(%!H.*.!%&.!6(**+.*1!%#!+2)/.2.,%+,-!%&.!"'''!)*#-*(2m!!VQ(2+,+,-!%&(%!g$.1%+#,!0$*%&.*f!

• _#$/7!(!1&#*%.*R!1+2)/.*!)*#-*(2!7.1+-,!6.!(!6.%%.*!)/(<.!%#!6.-+,m!!E&.*.!(*.!2(,8!.Q(2)/.1!0*#2!%&.!?00+/+(%.!3+%.1!%&(%!<#$/7!6.!$1.7@!

• _(1!%&.!<#,%.,%!#4.*H&./2+,-!#*!<#,0$1+,-m!N3#2.!E*(+,.*1!H.*.!<#,0$1.7!(6#$%!%&.!7+00.*.,<.!6.%H..,!(1%*#,#28!(,7!(1%*#/#-8!e!%&+1!+1!$1.0$/!+,0#*2(%+#,!(,7!)*#4+7.1!(!-##7!1%(*%+,-!)#+,%O!

• _.*.!%&.*.!(,8!<$/%$*(/!6(**+.*1!%&(%!2(7.!+%!$,<#20#*%(6/.!0#*!E*(+,.*1!%#!1..=!%&.!=+,7!#0!1$))#*%!?00+/+(%.1!<#20#*%(6/8!$1.7m!!!

?!7.6*+.0+,-!H+%&!E*(+,.*1!.+%&.*!(1!(!-*#$)!#*!+,7+4+7$(//8!H#$/7!6.!$1.0$/!%#!$,7.*1%(,7!%&.!+11$.1!2#*.!0$//8@!!!!!!!

23

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g$.1%+#,1!0#*!0$%$*.!<#//(6#*(%+#,1@!!E&.*.!(*.!(!4(*+.%8!#0!H(81!%#!7#!%&+1!+,</$7+,-f!!

• 3./.<%!(!,(%+#,(/!<#,0.*.,<.!2(,8!(00+/+(%.1!(*.!(/*.(78!)/(,,+,-!%#!(%%.,7!(,7!<*.(%.!(!2..%S$)!

• J/(,!(!0#//#HS$)!%./.<#2!• '*.(%.!(!1%..*+,-!<#22+%%..!#0!)(*%+<+)(%+,-!"'''!1+%.1!e!%&+1!H#$/7!6.!)(*%+<$/(*/8!

$1.0$/!0#*!(,8!0$%$*.!(1%*#,#28S6(1.7!<#//(6#*(%+#,1R!6$%!2+-&%!*.g$+*.!0$,7+,-@!!

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