02 legal and ethical aspect of medical emergencies - dr herkutanto sh, faclm
Post on 08-Apr-2018
220 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
1/50
LEGAL AND ETHICAL ASPECTLEGAL AND ETHICAL ASPECTOF MEDICAL EMERGENCIESOF MEDICAL EMERGENCIES
Dr.Herkutanto, SH, FACLM Dr.Herkutanto, SH, FACLM
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
2/50
HH erkutantoerkutanto Department of Forensic Medicine & Medicolegal Department of Forensic Medicine & Medicolegal
Faculty of Medicine University of IndonesiaFaculty of Medicine University of IndonesiaPh.D in Forensic MedicinePh.D in Forensic MedicineFellow of Australian College of Legal MedicineFellow of Australian College of Legal Medicine
Medical & Medicolegal QualificationsMedical & Medicolegal Qualifications
University of IndonesiaUniversity of Indonesia Faculty of Medicine Faculty of Medicine Monash University Monash University , Australia, Australia Faculty of Medicine Faculty of Medicine Netherland School of Public Health Netherland School of Public Health , The Netherland, The Netherland
Qualifications in Health LawQualifications in Health LawUniversity of IndonesiaUniversity of Indonesia Faculty of Law Faculty of Law
La Trobe University, Australia La Trobe University, Australia - - School of LawSchool of Law
International AssignmentsInternational Assignments Medicolegal ConsultantMedicolegal ConsultantWorld Health OrganizationWorld Health Organization 19891989United Nation Funds for Populations ActivitiesUnited Nation Funds for Populations Activities 1992, 19941992, 1994
John Hopkins University, 2003 John Hopkins University, 2003
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
3/50
OBJECTIVES
1) To understand Ethical and Legal
Aspect in a medical emergencies andits circumstances
2) To understand the scope of duties and
obligations in medical emergencies3) To understand consent in medical
emergencies
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
4/50
EMERGE NCY ( definition )
Any conditions that in the opinion of thepatient, his family, or whoever assumes theresponsibility of bringing the patient to thehospital requires immediate medicalattention . This condition continues until adetermination has been made by a
healthcare professionals that the patientslife or wellbeing is not threatened.
American Hospital Association
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
5/50
EMERGENCY PHASE
Pre Hospital HospitalPublic >> Medical PersonelGood Samaritan Doc P-P Relationship
voluntarism (- )pre-existing (- )
Public Good Private Good
All Aid in Emergency Phase FINISH
Avoid the loss of chance to survive
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
6/50
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
7/50
ROLE OF MEDICAL FIRSTROLE OF MEDICAL FIRSTRESPONDER RESPONDER
ACCESS TO THE VICTIMAND COMMUNICATIONSAFETY AND SECURITYASSISTING THE VICTIMSASSISTING OTHER MEDICAL EMEREGINCYPERSONNELSDATA PROTECTINGTRANSPORTATION
Access to communication facilities 118; 110; 113 Access to the victim and environment assessment
Access to security personnel Victim and self Personal
protection Assists the victim
according to thecompetence Reliability & Confidenti-ality medical informationVehicle & transportationroute
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
8/50
SCOPE OF ASSISTANCE
Knows the limit of competence
DO NO FURTHER HARM
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
9/50
LEGA L CONCERN LEGA L CONCERN IN MEDICA L EMERGENCIESIN MEDICA L EMERGENCIES
Is there any legal obligation in medical emergencycircumstances? Who are obliged? every person? Are there any limitation to act?
Are there any legal consequences for persons who helpsanother person in emergencies? Is there any protection for a person who is in good faith
voluntarily helps other people in medical emergencies?
Are there legal liability to the helpers?What about the costs of treatment? EMTALA ( E mergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act ) -
USA
COBRA ( Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act )
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
10/50
ETHICA L CONCERN ETHICA L CONCERN IN MEDICA L EMERGENCIESIN MEDICA L EMERGENCIES
Is there any basic moral principle in medical emergencycircumstances? What basic moral principle are? What ethical conduct for medical emrgencies
Are there any legal consequences for persons who helpsanother person in emergencies? Is there any protection for a person who is in good faith
voluntarily helps other people in medical emergencies?
Are there legal liability to the helpers?What about the costs of treatment? EMTALA ( E mergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act ) -
USA
COBRA ( Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act )
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
11/50
MEDICAL PRACTICE ACT2004 ( Indonesia )
Article 5 1
(d) Medical practitioners shall have theobligation to provide humanitarianemergency medical assistance , except that they convince that
another competent person isavailable to provide such assistance , ..
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
12/50
GOOD SAMARITAN DOCTRINE
The principle that a person who is injured while
attempting to aid another in imminent danger and who the sues the one whose negligencecreated the danger , will not be charged withcontributory negligence unless the rescue
attempt is an unreasonable one or the rescuer acts unreasonably in performing the attemptedrescue
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
13/50
CONFIDENTIALITYMANDATORY-REPORTING
RIGHT TO P RIVACYDuty to medical secrec y
RE P ORT TO PU B LIC AGENCYP o lice
CHI LD AB USENo manda to r y ob liga t io n inI nd o nesia
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
14/50
SPECIFIC CIRCUMSTANCESSPECIFIC CIRCUMSTANCESIN MEDICAL EMERGENCIESIN MEDICAL EMERGENCIES
S HORT OB SE RVATION TIM E
SUDDE N & U N EXPEC T ED CL INI C A L MANIF ES TATION
HIGH MOBI L ITY OF H E A L THPE R S ONN EL
IN SU FFI C IE NT INFORMATION TO
ES TAB L IS H CL INI C A L J UD G E M E NT
HIGH RISK!!
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
15/50
LEGA L CONCERN IN EMERGENCY-TRA UM A
CONSENTREFUSAL OFTREATMENTCONFIDENTIALITYMANDATORY-REPORTING
INFORMED CONSENT
EMERGENCY DOCTRINE
GOOD SAMARITAN D.
PATIENTS COMPETENCY
ASSAULT & BATTERY
RIGHT TO PRIVACY
REPORT TO PUBLIC AGENCY
CHILD ABUSE
CHAIN OF CUSTODY
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
16/50
CONSENT TO TREATMENT
Every action must be consented by thecompetent patient or the next of kin(w hen the patient is incompetent )
Expressed ConsentImplied Consent the patient is unconscious
medical treatment is urgent no next of kin present
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
17/50
CONSENT IN MEDICAL EMERGENCY &CONSENT IN MEDICAL EMERGENCY &CONSENT COULDNOT BE OBTAINEDCONSENT COULDNOT BE OBTAINED
No ConsentNo ConsentNeededNeeded
Good FaithGood Faith
Patients BestPatients BestInterestInterest
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
18/50
CONFIDENTIALITYMANDATORY-REPORTING
RIGHT TO P RIVACYDuty to medical secrec y
RE P ORT TO PU B LIC AGENCYP o lice
CHI LD AB USENo manda to r y ob liga t io n inI nd o nesia
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
19/50
LEGA L CONCERN IN EMERGENCY-TRA UM A
NEGLIGENCE
DEATH / DNR
PATIENTSPROPERTY
MEDICAL
CERTIFICATION
LIABILITY
STANDARD OF CARE
ABANDONMENT
PATIENTS TRANSFERS
DEFINITION OF DEATH
DNR INDICATIONS
WITHHOLDING&WITHDRAWAL TREATMENT
UNCLAIMED DEATH BODIES
CHAIN OF CUSTODY
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
20/50
NEGLIGENCE
LIABI LITYSTANDARD OF CARE
ABANDON MENTP ATIENTS TRANSFERS
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
21/50
ABANDONMENT
Terminating an on-going emergencyassistance regardless the absence of a more competent health personnel
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
22/50
NEGLIGENCENEGLIGENCE
RecklessnessForeseeable
Preventable
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
23/50
DEATH / Do Not Resuscitate
DEFINITION OF DEATHC linicalB rain St em D ea th
DNR INDICATIONSTh e dea th h as b een declared
UNC LAI MED DEATH BODIES
S en t to th e ci ty m o rg u e
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
24/50
PATIENTS PROPERTY
CHAIN OF CUSTODY
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
25/50
MEDICAL CERTIFICATEMEDICAL CERTIFICATE
PURPOSE
LEGAL CONSEQUENCES
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
26/50
MEDICOLEGAL ASPECT OFMEDICOLEGAL ASPECT OFEMERGENCIESEMERGENCIES
According to Causes
TRAUMA
NON-TRAUMA
According to the Number of Victims
Individual Casualty
Mass Casualty
Criminal Act?
Medicolegal
Certification
IdentificationR ights of victims
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
27/50
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
28/50
DISCUSSION
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
29/50
ISSUES TO BE EXPLORED
Dont know his/her limitation of competenceNegligenceDifferent opinion amongst the helpersPatients consent
Refuse of treatment by the patientEtc, etc
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
30/50
DISCUSSION PROCEDURES
1. What kinds of conflicts that possible to bearisen when a MFR helps a victim?
2. Play the role of two parties in conflict3. Identify potential problems
4. Develop options to solve the problems
5. What is the theoretical background?
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
31/50
POTENTIAL CONFLICT.
.
POSSIBLE SOLUTION
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
32/50
POTENTIAL CONFLICTPasien tidak mau ditolong , tidak mau di RJ P, Keluarganyaminta agar dilakukan tindakan (bertentangan dengankemauan pasien) , & butuh RJ P, tidak ditolong , pasienmeninggal. Keluarga menuntut.
.
POSSIBLE SOLUTION
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
33/50
S ikap dokter (merespon permintaan pasien):analisis kondisi mental pasien(sehat:turuti pasien)
S ikap dokter (merespon keluarga ygminta RJ P):menjelaskan kpdkeluarga , menunjukkan surat
pernyataan sikap pasienDN R adalah advance directive , sejauh alasan dpt diterima , dokter menuruti kehendak pasien
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
34/50
Dokter punya kewajiban utk menolong sesamaDokter tetap melakukan RJ Pmeskipun permintaan pasien menolak RJ P. Krn RJ P life-saving. Lebih baik dituntut krn melakukan perbuatan yg
baik.
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
35/50
Advance directive:dokter harusmemastikan bhw pasien benar-benar memahami keadaan dirinya.Dr.amal:tetap mengikuti keinginan
pasien krn hak otonomi pasien
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
36/50
R espon keluarga:marah krn next of kin minta RJ P tapi dokter tdk mengabulkan permintaan keluarga.
pasien hrs dinilai apakah dpt menilaihak2nya sendiri
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
37/50
Dokter hrs menjelaskan krn pasien belum tentu dpt mengerti kondisinyayg sebenar2nya.
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
38/50
POTENTIAL CONFLICTDi tengah jalan ,dokter bertemu seseorang yg tertembak.Dokter menelpon ambulans ,tetapi datangnya lama. Klinik terdekat fasilitasnya tidak lengkap. Jadi ,menungguambulans atau menolong di klinik (kemungkinan tertolongkecil)
.
POSSIBLE SOLUTION
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
39/50
Dr.anton:ditolong dulu di klinik danmeminta ambulans menjemput diklinik
Adakah dilema moralnya?Apa yg terbaik utk korban? (asas
beneficence ,non-maleficence)
Mana yg lbh mencelakakan pasien?Mana yg lbh menolong pasien?
B enefit/ R isk ratio?
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
40/50
POTENTIAL CONFLICTDitengah jalan bertemu wanita bercadar (tdk boleh kontak fisik dg lawan jenis) yg saat itu mengalami serangan
jantung. S edangkan dokter penolong laki-laki.
.
POSSIBLE SOLUTION
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
41/50
Mencari orang lain (perempuan) utk memeriksa korban
S ebagai pasien ,saya terima penolongapabila juga perempuanDlm agama diijinkan utk menolongmeskipun lawan jenis.
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
42/50
POTENTIAL CONFLICT.
.
POSSIBLE SOLUTION
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
43/50
POTENTIAL CONFLICT.
.
POSSIBLE SOLUTION
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
44/50
KEMUNGKINAN KONFLIK
1. Menolak pengobatan (belakangan ) setelah pengobatan dilakkan dalam keadaan tidak sadar
2. Menolak pengobatan karena masalah kultural3. Menolak pengobatan meninggal , orang lain
menuduh penolong tidak bersedia melakukan pertolongan
4. Penolong dijadikan saksi dan direpotkan:1. Konflik antara penolong dengan pihak lain yang
berkepentingan untuk menyelesaikan perkara tersebut(keadaan hukum)5. Multiple korban , tidak semua bisa ditolong
sekaligus. Korban merasa ditelantarkan dandinomorduakan.
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
45/50
KEMUNGKINAN KONFLIK
1. Menolak pengobatan meninggal , oranglain menuduh penolong tidak bersediamelakukan pertolongan
2. Akses ke korban terhalang , konflik denganmasyarakat ketika akan melakukan akseskepada korban
3. Masalah ekonomi. Pasien tidak punya biaya.Konflik dengan tenaga kesehatan.
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
46/50
KEMUNGKINAN KONFLIK
1. Ada 2 orang korban . S alah satu satu penjahat. Fasilitas saat itu hanyamenungkinkan untuk menolong satu orangsaja. S iapakah yang harus ditolong?
2. Tenaga medis dalam situasi pertempuran /konflik. Apakah tenaga medis itu dianggap
netral , ataukah memang bertugas menolongsalah satu pihak saja?
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
47/50
KEMUNGKINAN KONFLIK
1. Korban yang mati secara klinis. Apkaahakan dilakukan resusitasi? Pertimbangan:
1. B ila dilakukan resusitasi , korban akanmengalami sequele (cacat)
2. B ila tidak ditolong , keluarga marah
2. Penolong dituduh lalai melakukan tindakan
pertolongan sehingga menyebabkankematian.
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
48/50
1. Menolong pernafasan buatanterhadap jenis kelamin lain,ada hambatan agama. Bilamencari orang lain, tidak sempat, korban meninggal.
2. Dokter salah diagnosis, denganakibat salah terapi.
3. Korban massal, petugas terlalu
letih, tak mampu menolonglagi
4. Dalam keadaan perang, kitadikejar lawan, padahal adayang perlu ditolong
1. Hambatan kultural.Dalam situasi tersebut ,
jangan membayangkandengan pikiran non-medis. Membedakanlaki2 & perempuan..?
2. Tanggung guggat.S tandard Op Precedurevs S tandar Profesi ..?
3. Di R S : unacceptable4. Tenaga medis:
combatant & non-combatant
KEMUNGKINAN KONFLIK
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
49/50
5. Seorangtua menyeberang, tiba2 jatuh dan tak sadar ditengah jalan. Ada penyeberang lain ygmengaku sebagai mhs ked /tenaga medis tanpa
memperlihatkan jati diri. Yangdilakukan dianggap salah,haruskah kita menegur?
6. Korban tabrak lari. Apakahmenolong, dengan segalakonsekuensinya?
7. Anak menderita leukemiamyeblast akut, perlu transfusidarah. Padahal ia menganut
sekte yg tidak boleh dilakukan
1. Bekerjasama!! Bilatidak yakin dgtindakan org lain,komunikasi dg baik.
KEMUNGKINAN KONFLIK
-
8/6/2019 02 Legal and Ethical Aspect of Medical Emergencies - Dr Herkutanto SH, FACLM
50/50
8 . Ada 2 pasien di I G D , datang berbarengan. Penolongkekurangan tenaga , pada halkeduanya dalam keadaan
darurat.9. Tabrak lari malam hari. Ketikaakan menolong , ternyata kitamempunyai keperluanmendadak yang lain (keadaan
gawat).10. Dr. PTT ke daerah , hanya ada 1R S . Terjadi konflik sosial. Dr.mendapat ancaman agar tidak menolong kelompok lainnya.
KEMUNGKINAN KONFLIK
top related