1 hite study women in love: a cultural revolution in progress, 1987, shere hite 84% of women not...

1

Hite study Women in love: a cultural revolution

in progress, 1987, Shere Hite 84% of women not satisfied with their

relationships 70% of all women married >5 years

have extramarital affairs 95% of women report psychological

and physical harassment from their partners

2

Controversy Widely criticized by media –

“dubious,” “of limited value” Why?

Survey design (sampling methods, questionnaire) inadequate

Did not lead to a survey data set that supports inference to entire population of women in US

3

Hite’s survey design Sample

Addresses from broad range of special groups excludes many women in population sampling frame bias

Mailed questionnaires to 100K 4.5% returned low response rate (nonresponse bias)

Questionnaire 127 essay questions high respondent

burden, nonresponse bias (who completes?) Question wording vague (“in love” has many

different interpretations) measurement error Leading questions response bias

4

Survey processSURVEY DESIGN Define objectives & desired analyses Define target population Select sampling frame Choose sampling design, analysis

approach Choose data collection method

PREPARATION Create sampling frame Select sample Develop questions or measurements Construct questionnaire or other data

collection form Pre-test questionnaire & revise Train interviewers, data gatherers

COLLECT & PREPARE DATA

Collect data (interview, observe, self-administer)

Edit and code data Enter data (if paper) Edit data file

DATA ANALYSIS Exploratory data analysis Calculate estimates of

population characteristics Make inferences about

the population

5

Design for sample surveys Survey design involves selecting methods for all

phases of the survey process, including sampling and estimation

Sample design driven by Objectives Type of measurements to be taken (questions,

field observations) Operational constraints ($, time, people, materials)

Analysis approach driven by Objectives Sample design (like design of experiments) Data collected during the survey

6

Survey statistics Study population

Finite number of units 1.7 million people in Nebraska 18,567 students at UNL 3000 counties in the US 400 accounts being audited in a private

firm Finite # of values discrete distribution

7

Survey statistics - 2 Design

Very similar design structures

More explicit consideration of resource constraints and analysis objectives than in experimental design

Use stratification to obtain sufficient sample sizes for subpopulations

Use cluster sampling to reduce costs of collecting data

8

Survey statistics - 3 Design-based estimation (this class)

Focus on estimating descriptive parameters: means, proportions, totals

Less emphasis on regression, etc. Based on randomization theory

Other approaches exist Model-assisted (cover this a bit) Model-based (not covered)

9

Definitions Observation unit (OU)

Individual (student, animal, female), household, land area, business, commercial account

May have more than one OU (cluster sampling later in semester)

Target population Students at UNL, US households, farms, forests Impacts survey design and inferences that can be

made from survey Can be hard to define Political poll: are we interested in registered voters,

voters in last election, eligible voters?

10

Definitions - 2 Sample

Any method of selection (probability, quota, volunteer)

We will focus on ways of selecting a sample that use probability sampling

Sampling unit (SU) May not be the same as the OU Cluster sampling

OU = individual, SU = household OU = elementary student, SU = school

11

Definition - 3 Sampling frame

Want this to at least include the entire target population Some parts of frame may be outside the target population

Randomly selected telephone numbers include non-working numbers that do not correspond to households

Sampled population – set of all possible OUs that might have been chosen in a sample, or population from which sample is selected

Ideally very close to target population Does not include portions of target population that were

not sampled sampled but failed to respond

12

Telephone survey of likely voters (Fig 1.1, p. 4) OU

Target pop

SU

Frame

Sampled population = ?

13

National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) Ongoing survey to study crime rates

Interested in total number of US households that were victimized by crime last year

OU

Target population

Sampling frame

Sampled population

14

Pesticide survey Survey of nitrate and pesticide

contamination in US drinking water Target population

OU

Sampled population

15

What do we know about Hite’s study? OU Target population SU Sampling frame Sampled population

16

Selection bias Occurs when some part of the target

population is not in the sampled population May be due to ...

Sampling process Data collection process

Can induce bias in estimated population parameters Bias occurs when the omitted part of target

population is different from the sampled population with respect to the analysis variables

17

Types of selection bias (Things you should avoid)

Convenience, volunteer samples Take whomever is willing

Volunteer web surveys Call-in surveys from TV programs

Judgment, purposive, quota samples Select OUs without a probability mechanism Pick sample using your judgment to reflect the target

population composition Find a point on the land that “represents” a “typical”

soil condition Mall intercept surveys may have a quota scheme

May be useful for initial studies to probe a topic CANNOT make inferences about a population from such

studies

18

Types of selection bias - 2 (Things you should avoid)

Ad hoc substitution of observation unit If respondent not home, go to (unselected)

neighbor Characteristics of substitute are likely to

vary, may alter sample composition

19

Types of selection bias - 3 (Things you can partially control) Undercoverage – sampling frame omits portion

of target population Homeless in telephone survey of U.S. residents Unmapped waterways when sampling from USGS

topographic maps Remedies

Select / construct sampling frame carefully Cover as much of the target population as possible Better if portion not covered by frame is small, or if it

differs in a way that minimizes impact on inferences Once you have a frame, use probability sampling

Key to avoiding problems associated with convenience and purposive samples

20

Types of selection bias - 4(Things you can partially control)

Nonresponse during measurement process Refusals

Unit (refuse participation in survey) Item (refuse to answer a question)

Not reachable Can’t locate sampled person due to outdated contact info

Incompetent Too ill to complete survey, mentally/physically disabled

Remedies Use multiple and persistent methods to find / reach OU

Variety of address sources (web, change-of-address) Multiple attempts to call at different times of week / day

Use rigorous methods encourage OU to participate Refusal conversion techniques, incentives, rapport (see

later)

21

1936 Literary Digest survey

Predicted correctly presidential election outcome 1912-1932

1932: Predicted Roosevelt w/ 56%, got 58% in election Used “commercial sampling methods” used to

market books Telephone books, club rosters, city directories,

registered voter lists, mail-order lists, auto registrations Mailed out 10 million questionnaires, received 2.3

million 1936

Predicted Roosevelt loss (41% to Landon’s 55%) Roosevelt won, 61% to 37%

22

What happened? Undercoverage in sampling frame

Heavy reliance on auto and phone lists Those w/ cars and/or phones voted in favor or

Roosevelt, but not to the extent that those without cars and phones did

Low response rate Those responding preferred Landon relative

to those who didin’t Many Roosevelt supporters didn’t remember

receiving survey Large sample is no guarantee of accuracy

23

Selection bias nearly always exists

Want sample and resulting survey data to be “representative” of the target population

Good survey design and proper implementation of protocols are key to minimizing selection bias

Methods should be described in documentation and published articles

Enable user/reader to make judgments about the nature of selection bias and its effects on the interpretation of results

Useful to explicitly define the sampled population to reflect selection bias that has occurred in the survey process

Likely voters with telephones who could be reached and were willing and able to respond to the survey

24

Measurement bias Ideally, want accurate responses to

questions or measurements of phenomena Measurement bias occurs when

measurement process produces observations on an OU that differ from the true value for the OU in a systematic manner Calibration error in scale adds 5 kg to weight

for each person in a health survey Bird surveys record species heard or sighted in

0.5 km radius during a 10 min period Fail to present a valid option in a response list

25

Measurement bias in people

Respondent may provide false information More likely with sensitive subject matter Socially acceptable behavior (drug use) Desire to influence outcome of survey to

reap benefit (ag yields) Memory

Recall bias – distant memory more prone to error Telescoping – recall events that occurred before

reference period

26

Measurement bias in people - 2

Impact of interviewer Respondent reactions

Caucasians provide different answers to white and black interviewers, vice versa

Interviewer interaction with respondent

Misreading questions Poor rapport

27

Measurement bias in people - 3

Impact of questionnaire Respondent fails to understand question

May not understand terms, be confused by question, not hear correctly

Variation in interpretation of of words or phrases

Even simple questions may not be explicitly clear Do you own a car?

Is “you” singular or plural? Is a van or truck included in the concept of a car?

Question order Context effects – previous question impacts answer Poorly organized questionnaire can make it difficult

for respondent to understand questions

28

Questionnaire design Clearly and specifically define study objectives

Specific topics and questions for study Identify target (sub)populations and contextual

variables for analysis (e.g., demographics) Evaluate proposed questions as to whether

they clearly support objectives and analysis methods

Pre-test the survey instrument (=questionnaire) On respondents from the target population Large-scale surveys may rely on intensive study

NCVS: alternative recall periods, question wording

29

Writing questions Use clear, simple, precise language Focus on one well-defined item in a

question Avoid referring to multiple concepts in a single

question Divide lengthy questions into a contextual

statement plus a simple question Specify a time frame, area, or other form of

scope Define critical terms

State question neutrally Avoid leading questions that might induce bias

30

Writing questions - 2 Response formats

Use mutually-exclusive categories in closed-ended questions

Reduce post-hoc coding by minimizing use of open-ended questions

Organization Group questions to improve ability of

respondent to follow content and understand questions

Put key questions first while the respondent is fresh (but start easy)

31

Impact of measurement bias

Measurement bias via data collection procedures Individual observation level

Bias at the observation level impacts estimates in two ways Systematic bias over OUs in sample in same

direction results in a biased estimate of a population characteristic

Measurement error often results in increased variance in estimates (with or without bias) as well

32

Nonsampling Errors (Lessler & Kalsbeek, 1992)

Assume: probability sample Frame error

Mismatch between sampled population & target population

Nonresponse error Unable to obtain data from observation units Whole observation unit or single response item

Measurement error Inadequacies in the process of obtaining

measurements from observation units

33

Survey error model

Total Survey

Error

= +

Measurement errorNonresponse errorFrame error

Due to the sampling process (i.e., we observe only part of population)

Assessed via bias and variance

34

Sampling Error Sample survey

Collecting data from a sample – a subset of the population – to make inference about the whole population

We never observe the whole population estimate for any one sample is unlikely to perfectly match the population parameter

Example Proportion of undergraduates in Fall 2000 that are males

= 44.6% Select a sample of 100 undergrads estimate = 46.2% Select a sample of 100 undergrads estimate is 41.9% Etc.

35

Why sample? Widely accepted that sample surveys of

large populations will lead to more precise estimates than a census of the population Sampling error vanishes, but measurement error

is typically much higher US example

Number of occupied housing units (N) = 105,480,101 Federal statistical survey sample size (n) = 50,000

May not be a need to select a sample with small populations (e.g., web or mail surveys) Membership of organizations Employees in a business