acts and regulations governing preservation of monuments …spa.ac.in/writereaddata/day2nma.pdf ·...

ACTS AND REGULATIONS

GOVERNING PRESERVATION OF

MONUMENTS & SITES

Himanshu Prabha Ray

Chairperson, National Monuments Authority

New Delhi

3650+ Monuments & Planned

Development

• 1904 – 1947: A majority of monuments and sites declared

protected.

• Legislation: Continuation of monument-centric colonial

legacy, rather than sustainable urban development.

• AMASRA 2010: shift from focus on monument to built

surroundings.

• Spatial Development Planning laws must recognize

conservation as a key component of development.

Participatory Spatial Planning

• “Immovable heritage (natural and manmade) is in

continuous danger of being dented and even being

obliterated. It therefore needs to be incorporated for

conservation through legalized mapping that is

transparent so that planned programmed development

through conservation strategies, techniques and tools can

take place within and around the legally identified heritage

structure, plot, precinct or site. Transparency typically

helps in garnering people’s participatory support”.

• Edgar F. Ribeiro, Legalized Mapping of Heritage of India: Can it be applied to

Goa? Indian World Heritage Sites in Context, NMA, 2014

Sanchi at the time of discovery

Sanchi after conservation

19th century ‘discovery’ of

‘monuments’ and beginnings

of legislation

Sarnath after

excavation and

conservation

Sarnath and the Archaeology of

Buddhism in India • 1835-6: Alexander Cunningham identified Sarnath 13

kilometres north-east of Varanasi based on accounts of

Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang who visited India in 7th century

AD.

• In 1856, the Government acquired the site at Sarnath

from an indigo planter by the name of Fergusson.

• 1900 that a guard was appointed to take charge of the

museum and the monastic complex.

• 1905: Ashokan Pillar and lion capital unearthed during

excavations.

Ancient Monuments Preservation Act

1904 • (1) “ancient monument” means any structure, erection or

monument, which is of historical, archaeological or artistic

interest, or any

• remains thereof, and includes—

• (a) the site of an ancient monument;

• (b) such portion of land adjoining the site of an ancient

monument as may be required for fencing or covering in

or otherwise preserving such monument; and

• (c) the means of access to and convenient inspection of

an ancient site.

Provisions of the Act

• Land may be acquired for protection of

monuments under Land Acquisition Act 1894.

• Declaration of protected status of monuments

through notification.

• Fixing of boundaries of the area.

• Restriction of mining, quarrying, blasting etc.

• Restriction on movement of antiquities.

Nationally Protected Monuments

• 1947: 2826 protected monuments.

• Protection of Sculptures, Carvings, Images, Bas-reliefs,

Inscriptions or like objects, which are not to be moved

from their present location.

• Declare areas with archaeological remains as protected

areas.

• 2014: more than 3650 ancient monuments and

archaeological sites and remains of national importance

(http://asi.nic.in/asi_monuments.asp).

Jain Tirthankara image in the

fields at Veerakudi, district

Pudukkottai, Tamilnadu –

notified in 1937

Declared as the

Nationally

Protected

Monument by

Archaeological

Survey of India

vide Notification

no. 2 / 3 / 75 - M,

dated 28.03.1985

under the name

“Monolithic Bas

Relief Image

Depicting Shiv at

Parel”.

1931: Sculpture (3.48 meter in

height, 1.95 in width) found in road

construction.

Sanghol – 40 kms from Chandigarh. Partially protected

archaeological site.

The mound at Sonkh near Mathura – excavations

unearthed a fortified settlement dated from 800 BC

onwards.

The Constitution of India

• 1. Entry 67 of the Union List - monuments declared by or

under law made by Parliament to be of national

importance.

• 2. Entry 12 of the State List - monuments other than those

declared to be of national importance.

• 3. Entry 40 of the Concurrent List - monuments other

than those declared by or under law made by

Parliament to be of national importance.

• 16. By incorporating Article 49 in the Directive Principles

of State Policy, the framers of the Constitution made it

obligatory for the State to protect every monument of

national importance.

The Constitution

49: It shall be the obligation

of the State to protect every

monument or place or object

of artistic or historical

interest, declared by or

under law made by

Parliament to be of national

importance, from spoliation,

disfigurement, destruction,

removal, disposal or export,

as the case may be.

History of the Acts & Legislation

• 1951: The Ancient and Historical Monuments and Archaeological

Sites and Remains (Declaration of National Importance) Act, 1951 (No

LXXI of 1951) was enacted.

• All the ancient and historical monuments and archaeological sites and

remains protected earlier under ‘The Ancient Monuments Preservation

Act, 1904' (Act No. VII of 1904) were re-declared as monuments and

archaeological sites of national importance under this Act.

• Four hundred and fifty monuments and sites of Part ‘B' States were

also added. Some more monuments and archaeological sites were

also declared as of national importance under Section 126 of the

States Reorganization Act, 1956.

ASI Notification 1992

• Notification prohibited new constructions within a 100m

radius of any ASI monument in the country.

• Controlled development within the regulated area of

the monument, which was fixed at 200m.

• Reconstruction allowed in prohibited area.

AMASR Act 2010

• November 2011: Establishment of National Monuments

Authority.

• Redefinition of 100 metres as prohibited and 100 to 300

metres as regulated area around the monument.

• Categorization of monuments into 8 categories.

• Framing of heritage bye laws for each of the centrally

protected monuments.

Categorization of

monuments.

Mapping & detailed

site plans.

No construction in

prohibited area.

Construction in

regulated area in

accordance with heritage

bye laws/ Development

Control Regulations.

Archaeological

assessment for large

projects essential.

Supreme Court Judgement January 16,

2012 • To measure the prohibited (100m) and regulated area

(200m) for a centrally protected monument from the base

of its boundary wall and not the monument structure.

• Renovation of any building existing in the prohibited area

before June 16, 1992 near monuments only meant repair

and not razing them and putting up new ones.

• Permission in exceptional cases for undertaking

construction in public interest in the vicinity of protected

monuments.

• http://www.legalindia.in/construction-near-monuments-in-

public-interest-only-supreme-court/

Se Cathedral and Church of St. Xavier, Goa

AMASRA 2010 & Categorization

• 4A (1) - The Central Government shall prescribe

categories in respect of ancient monuments and

archaeological sites and remains declared as of

national importance…. Notified by MoC on 23rd

August 2011.

• 4A (2) - The Central Government shall, on the

recommendation of the Authority classify all the

ancient monuments or archaeological sites and

remains declared as of national importance….

• Functions & Powers of the Authority:

• 20-I (d) – to suggest measures for implementation of

the provisions of this Act.

Categories notified by MoC

• Category I: World Heritage Cultural sites

• Category II: Tentative List of World Heritage Committee

• Category III: Sites identified for inclusion in Tentative List

Category IV: Ticketed Monuments

• Category V: Sites with adequate flow of visitors identified

for levying tickets

• Category VI: Living Monuments

• Category VII: Other Monuments in Urban/Semi Urban

limits.

• Category VIII: Others - Heritage Zones; Archaeological

Parks.

Centrally Protected Monuments in Delhi Numbers

NMA Category I & II - World Heritage Sites and those on Tentative List 37

NMA Category III – Monuments and Sites identified for inclusion in

Tentative List

18

NMA Category IV - Ticketed Monuments

10

NMA Category V – Monuments and Sites with adequate flow of visitors

– could be made ticketed

1

NMA Category VI – living monuments

8

NMA Category VII - In densely populated urban area

41

NMA Category VIII – Others

48 (Heritage Zone)

7 (Arch Park)

Total 160 + 14 (missing/

de-notified)

World Heritage/ Tentative WH Sites in

Delhi • World Heritage Sites:

• 1993: Qutb Minar and its Monuments.

• 1993: Humayun’s Tomb: 29 monuments notified

between 1913 and 2005.

• 2007: Red Fort Complex, Delhi: Comprehensive

Conservation Management Plan required.

• Tentative WH Sites:

• Shahjahanabad & Lutyen’s Delhi: 20

monuments.

• Badshahi Marg: 4 monuments

Challenges

Monuments have lost

their context both with

other structures and the

landscape.

Artificial definitions of

space

Vehicular traffic and

pollution and

encroachments

Sher Shah’s gate and

Khairul Manazil

mosque

Living Monuments

Meghesvar temple,

Bhubaneshwar

Mosque at Sarkhej

Heritage Zones identified by DDA

Walled City of Delhi, Shahjahanabad

Nizamuddin and Humayun’s Tomb Complex

Mehrauli area & Qutub Complex

Lutyen’s Delhi

Vijay Mandal – Begumpur – Lal Gumbad

Chirag Delhi

Additions in NMA List:

Lodi Gardens – Safdarjung Tomb

Deer Park – Green Park

Archaeological Parks identified by DDA

Mehrauli Archaeological Park

Tughlaqabad Archaeological Park

Sultan Garhi Archaeological Park

Additions in NMA List:

Purana Qila Archaeological Park

Northern Ridge Archaeological Park

Unresolved Issues

• Heritage Zones identified by DDA: boundaries yet to be

demarcated.

• Archaeological Parks: defined as excavated

archaeological sites that have been preserved in a park

setting and open to the public.

• CAG Report on WH sites: 3.2 - ASI did not distinguish and

categorize any monument as prospective WH site;

• Chapter 3, p. 39 of the CAG Report (18 of 2013): 'The

Ministry stated (May 2013) that ACWHM was in the process

of updating the tentative list and was also ensuring that

management systems were in place before the dossiers

were sent to WHC'.

Issues for discussion • Categories I to III: rules applicable to World Heritage

sites.

•

• Categories IV to VII: As prescribed in Master Plans and

local building bye laws.

•

• Category VIII: Heritage Zones and Archaeological Parks

as per Development Control Regulations.

• Single Window Clearance: Real Estate (Regulation

and Development) Bill, 2013