analyzing and visualizing correspondence ......thomson reuter‟s web of knowledge (wos) is a...
Post on 06-Aug-2020
0 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
ANALYZING AND VISUALIZING
CORRESPONDENCE NETWORKS FOR
BROWSABLE INTERFACES
Scott Weingart
Cyberinfrastructure for Network Science Center
Information Visualization Laboratory
Indiana Philosophy Ontology Project
School of Library and Information Science
Department of History and Philosophy of Science
Indiana University, Bloomington, IN
http://www.scottbot.net
Thanks to Katy Borner, The Sci2 Team, and Huygens ING.
Representing The Republic of Letters, 6/30/2011-7/1/2011
Huygens ING – Institute for Dutch History
The Hague, The Netherlands
10:50-12:20 on July 1, 2011
10:55-11:05 The Importance and Dangers of Visualization – Use & Theory
11:05-11:20 The Epistolarium – Networks, Topics & Tools
11:20-11:25 Computational Modeling
11:25-11:35 Move to other room
11:35-11:50 Sci2 Tool Basics
11:50-12:10 Sci2 Workflow Design: Padgett's Florentine Families - Prepare, load, analyze, and visualize family and business networks from 15th century Florence.
12:10-12:20 Q&A and Technical Assistance
Workshop Overview
2
10:55-11:05 The Importance and Dangers of Visualization – Use & Theory
11:05-11:20 The Epistolarium – Networks, Topics & Tools
11:20-11:25 Computational Modeling
11:25-11:35 Move to other room
11:35-11:50 Sci2 Tool Basics
11:50-12:10 Sci2 Workflow Design: Padgett's Florentine Families - Prepare, load, analyze, and visualize family and business networks from 15th century Florence.
12:10-12:20 Q&A and Technical Assistance
Workshop Overview
3
The Importance and Dangers of Visualization:
Use & Theory
4
Uses of Visualization
Solidifies objects of inquiry
Exploration
Discovery
Trend-spotting
Evidence
Audience Engagement
Engaging public / funding agencies
The Importance of Visualization
[Visualization] aim at more than making the invisible visible. [It aspires] to
all-at-once-ness, the condensation of laborious, step-by-step procedures
in to an immediate coup d’oeil… What was a painstaking process of
calculation and correlation—for example, in the construction of a table
of variables—becomes a flash of intuition. And all-at-once intuition is
traditionally the way that angels know, in contrast to the plodding
demonstrations of humans.
Descartes‟s craving for angelic all-at-once-ness emerged forcefully in his
mathematics…, compressing the steps of mathematical proof into a
single bright flare of insight: “I see the whole thing at once, by intuition.”
Lorraine Daston – On Scientific Observation
Warnings
[H]umanists have adopted many applications such as GIS mapping, graphs, and
charts for statistical display that were developed in other disciplines… such
graphical tools are a kind of intellectual Trojan horse…
Data pass themselves off as mere descriptions of a priori conditions. Rendering
observation (the act of creating a statistical, empirical, or subjective account or
image) as if it were the same as the phenomena observed collapses the critical distance
between the phenomenal world and its interpretation, undoing the basis of
interpretation on which humanistic knowledge production is based... we seem
ready and eager to suspend critical judgment in a rush to visualization.
Johanna Drucker – Humanities Approaches to Graphical Display
Warnings
Data format limits use, already an act of
interpretation.
Statistics is often misused (wield it very carefully).
Interpreting spatial distance as meaningful.
Always include a legend (this presentation breaks
that rule).
Accidental legitimization in eyes of public.
Character Networks in the 19th Century British Novel
-Graham Sack
I use computational methods to count the frequency and co-
occurrence of a generally ignored sub-class of common words,
namely, character names. Character names are often regarded as
noise and excluded from authorship and stylistics analysis
because they are not consistent across texts. This study makes
character names its main object of analysis because the
objective is quite different: rather than style or authorship, this
study attempts to make inferences about characterization and
social form, two areas about which computational analysis has
had comparatively little to say.
Character Networks in the 19th Century British Novel
-Graham Sack
Character
Networks
in the 19th
Century
British
Novel
-Graham
Sack
Word Co-Occurrences in European Fairytales
-Jorgensen & Weingart
10:55-11:05 The Importance and Dangers of Visualization – Use & Theory
11:05-11:20 The Epistolarium – Networks, Topics & Tools
11:20-11:25 Computational Modeling
11:25-11:35 Move to other room
11:35-11:50 Sci2 Tool Basics
11:50-12:10 Sci2 Workflow Design: Padgett's Florentine Families - Prepare, load, analyze, and visualize family and business networks from 15th century Florence.
12:10-12:20 Q&A and Technical Assistance
Workshop Overview
13
The Epistolarium – Networks, Topics & Tools
14
Networks
Networks
Networks
Correspondence, Citation, and Co-Citation Networks show no less nor more information than is already available to the researcher, and is subject to the same biases.
These networks show that same information in a new light, and allows us to ask new sorts of questions, rethink our objects of inquiry, and systematize our methods of large scale analysis and comparison.
The Epistolarium
Simon Episcopiusin CEN network
The Epistolarium
Grotius corpusFrench letters
The Epistolarium
Topics
The Epistolarium
Chr. Huygens corpusLatin letters
The Epistolarium
Chr. Huygens corpusLatin letters
Topics
Topics
10:55-11:05 The Importance and Dangers of Visualization – Use & Theory
11:05-11:20 The Epistolarium – Networks, Topics & Tools
11:20-11:25 Computational Modeling
11:25-11:35 Move to other room
11:35-11:50 Sci2 Tool Basics
11:50-12:10 Sci2 Workflow Design: Padgett's Florentine Families - Prepare, load, analyze, and visualize family and business networks from 15th century Florence.
12:10-12:20 Q&A and Technical Assistance
Workshop Overview
26
Computational Modeling
27
CEN Statistics
Scholar 1
Idea 1
Scholar 2 Scholar 3
Idea 2
Quality = .8 Quality = .24
Age: 12, Lifespan: 50Quality of new ideas: .4 +/- .05
Age: 40, Lifespan: 85Quality of new ideas: .2 +/- .15
Age: 18, Lifespan: 80Quality of new ideas: .9 +/- .03
Strength: 3
Strength: 1
Strength: 4 Strength: 1
Modeling the Republic of Letters
or Mmmmm Spaghetti Dinner with Meatballs
10:55-11:05 The Importance and Dangers of Visualization – Use & Theory
11:05-11:20 The Epistolarium – Networks, Topics & Tools
11:20-11:25 Computational Modeling
11:25-11:35 Move to other room
11:35-11:50 Sci2 Tool Basics
11:50-12:10 Sci2 Workflow Design: Padgett's Florentine Families - Prepare, load, analyze, and visualize family and business networks from 15th century Florence.
12:10-12:20 Q&A and Technical Assistance
Workshop Overview
31
Sci2 Tool Basics
32
Just as the microscope empowered our naked eyes to see cells, microbes, and viruses thereby advancing the progress of biology and medicine or the telescope opened our minds to the immensity of the cosmos and has prepared mankind for the conquest of space, macroscopes promise to help us cope with another infinite: the infinitely complex. Macroscopes give us a „vision of the whole‟ and help us „synthesize‟. They let us detect patterns, trends, outliers, and access details in the landscape of science. Instead of making things larger or smaller, macroscopes let us observe what is at once too great, too slow, or too complex for our eyes.
Microscopes, Telescopes, and Macrocopes
Custom Tools for Different Scientific Communities
Information Visualization Cyberinfrastructure
http://iv.slis.indiana.edu
Network Workbench Tool + Community Wiki
http://nwb.slis.indiana.edu
Science of Science (Sci2) Tool and Portal
http://sci.slis.indiana.edu
Epidemics Cyberinfrastructure
http://epic.slis.indiana.edu/
180+ Algorithm Plugins and Branded GUIs
+
Core Architecture
Open Services Gateway Initiative (OSGi) Framework.
http://orgi.org
Cyberinfrastructure Shell (CIShell)
http://cishell.org
Macroscope Design
34
35
NWB Tool Interface Components
Console shows references to seminal works.
Workflows are recorded into a log file, and soon can be re-run for easy replication.
All algorithms are documented online; workflows are given in tutorials.
File, Preprocessing, Modeling, and Visualization Menus
36
Börner, Katy, Sanyal, Soma and Vespignani, Alessandro (2007). Network Science. In Blaise Cronin (Ed.),
ARIST, Information Today, Inc./American Society for Information Science and Technology, Medford, NJ,
Volume 41, Chapter 12, pp. 537-607.
http://ivl.slis.indiana.edu/km/pub/2007-borner-arist.pdf
Analysis Menu and Submenus
37
Börner, Katy, Sanyal, Soma and Vespignani, Alessandro (2007). Network Science. In Blaise Cronin (Ed.),
ARIST, Information Today, Inc./American Society for Information Science and Technology, Medford, NJ,
Volume 41, Chapter 12, pp. 537-607. http://ivl.slis.indiana.edu/km/pub/2007-borner-arist.pdf
Supported Data Formats
The NWB tool supports loading the following input file formats:
GraphML (*.xml or *.graphml)
XGMML (*.xml)
Pajek .NET (*.net) & Pajek .Matrix (*.mat)
NWB (*.nwb)
TreeML (*.xml)
Edge list (*.edge)
CSV (*.csv)
ISI (*.isi)
Scopus (*.scopus)
NSF (*.nsf)
Bibtex (*.bib)
Endnote (*.enw)
and the following network file output formats:
GraphML (*.xml or *.graphml)
Pajek .MAT (*.mat)
Pajek .NET (*.net)
NWB (*.nwb)
XGMML (*.xml)
CSV (*.csv)
Formats are documented at https://nwb.slis.indiana.edu/community/?n=DataFormats.HomePage. 38
File-types
Excel
Database
Text
CSV
Network Formats
Matrix
Adjacency List
Node & Edge List
Newton Oldenburg Flamsteed
Newton 0 13 38
Oldenburg 24 0 45
Flamsteed 62 7 0
Newton Oldenburg 13
Newton Flamsteed 38
Oldenburg Newton 24
Oldenburg Flamsteed 45
Flamsteed Newton 62
Flamsteed Oldenburg 7
Nodes
1 Newton
2 Oldenburg
3 Flamsteed
Edges
1 2 13
1 3 38
2 1 24
2 3 45
3 1 62
3 2 7
NWB Format
*Nodesid*int label*string totaldegree*int 16 “Merwede van Clootwyck, Matthys van der (1613-1664)” 1 36 “Perrault, Charles” 1 48 “Bonius, Johannes” 1 67 “Surenhusius Gzn., Gulielmus” 1 99 “Anguissola, Giacomo” 1 126 “Johann Moritz, von Nassau-Siegen (1604-1679)” 6 131 “Steenberge, J.B.” 1 133 “Vosberghen Jr., Caspar van” 1 151 “Bogerman, Johannes (1576-1637)” 25 *DirectedEdges source*int target*int weight*float eyear*int syear*int 16 36 1 1640 1650 16 126 5 1641 1649 36 48 2 1630 1633 48 16 4 1637 1644 48 67 10 1645 1648 48 36 2 1632 1638 67 133 7 1644 1648 67 131 3 1642 1643 99 67 9 1640 1645 126 16 3 1641 1646 131 133 5 1630 1638 131 99 1 1637 1639 133 36 4 1645 1648 133 48 8 1632 1636 151 48 6 1644 1647
42
Science of Science (Sci2) Tool
http://sci.slis.indiana.edu
Explicitly designed for SoS research and practice, well documented, easy to use.
Empowers many to run common studies while making it easy for exports to
perform novel research.
Advanced algorithms, effective visualizations, and many (standard) workflows.
Supports micro-level documentation and replication of studies.
Is open source—anybody can review and extend the code, or use it for
commercial purposes.
Sci2 Tool – “Open Code for S&T Assessment”
OSGi/CIShell powered tool with NWB plugins and
many new scientometrics and visualizations plugins.
Börner, Katy, Huang, Weixia (Bonnie), Linnemeier, Micah, Duhon, Russell Jackson, Phillips, Patrick, Ma, Nianli, Zoss, Angela, Guo, Hanning & Price, Mark. (2009). Rete-Netzwerk-Red: Analyzing and Visualizing Scholarly Networks Using the Scholarly Database and the Network Workbench Tool. Proceedings of ISSI 2009: 12th International Conference on Scientometrics and Informetrics, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, July 14-17 . Vol. 2, pp. 619-630.
Horizontal Time Graphs
Sci Maps GUESS Network Vis
Sci2 Tool
Geo Maps
Circular Hierarchy
See Sci2 Manual
Studying Four Major NetSci Researchers (ISI Data)
Thomson Reuter‟s Web of Knowledge (WoS) is a leading citation database cataloging
over 10,000 journals and over 120,000 conferences. Access it via the “Web of
Science” tab at http://www.isiknowledge.com (note: access to this database requires
a paid subscription). Along with Scopus, WoS provides some of the most
comprehensive datasets for scientometric analysis.
To find all publications by an author, search for the last name and the first initial
followed by an asterisk in the author field.
46
Data Acquisition from Web of Science
Download all papers by
Eugene Garfield
Stanley Wasserman
Alessandro Vespignani
Albert-László Barabási
from
Science Citation Index
Expanded (SCI-EXPANDED)
--1955-present
Social Sciences Citation Index
(SSCI)--1956-present
Arts & Humanities Citation
Index (A&HCI)--1975-present
47
Comparison of CountsNo books and other non-WoS publications are covered.
Age Total # Cites Total # Papers H-Index
Eugene Garfield 82 1,525 672 31
Stanley Wasserman 122 35 17
Alessandro Vespignani 42 451 101 33
Albert-László Barabási 40 2,218 126 47 (Dec 2007)
41 16,920 159 52 (Dec 2008)
48
Extract Co-Author Network
Load*yoursci2directory*/sampledata/scientometrics/isi/FourNetSciResearchers.isi’
using 'File > Load‘ and parameters
And file with 361 records
appears in Data Manager.
49
Extract Co-Author Network
(see section 5.1.4.2 on correcting duplicate/misspelled author names)
To extract the co-author network, select the ‘361 Unique ISI Records’ table and run
‘Data Preparation > Extract Co-Author Network’ using isi file format:
The result is an undirected but weighted network of co-authors in the Data Manager.
Run ‘Analysis > Network > Network Analysis Toolkit (NAT)’ to calculate basic
properties: the network has 247 nodes and 891 edges.
Use ‘Analysis > Network > Unweighted and Undirected > Node Degree’ to calculate the number
of neighbors for each node.
To view the complete network, select the ‘Extracted Co-Authorship Network’ and run
‘Visualization > Networks > GUESS’.
Network is loaded with random layout. In GUESS, run ‘Layout > GEM’ and „Layout
> Bin Pack‟ to improve layout.
50
Co-Author Network of all Four NetsSci Researchers
51
Co-Author Network of all Four NetsSci Researchers
52
Use the GUESS Graph Modifier to change
color and size coding.
Calculate node degrees in Sci2 Tool.
Use a graphic program to add legend.
Individual Co-Author Networks
(Read/map 4 files separately)
Eugene Garfield Stanley Wasserman
Alessandro Vespignani Albert-László Barabási53
Network Visualization:
Node Layout
54
Load and Clean ISI File was selected.
Loaded 361 records.
Removed 0 duplicate records.
Author names have been normalized.
361 records with unique ISI IDs are available
via Data Manager.
..........
Extract Co-Author Network was selected.
Input Parameters:
File Format: isi
..........
Network Analysis Toolkit (NAT) was selected.
Nodes: 247
Edges: 891
..........
GUESS was selected.
Network Visualization:
Color/Size Coding by Data Attribute Values
55
Network Visualization:
Giant Component
56
..........
Weak Component Clustering was selected.
Implementer(s): Russell Duhon
Integrator(s): Russell Duhon
Input Parameters:
Number of top clusters: 10
3 clusters found, generating graphs for the top 3 clusters.
..........
Network Visualization:
Color/Size Coding by Degree
57
..........
Node Degree was selected.
Documentation:
https://nwb.slis.indiana.edu/community/?n=AnalyzeData.No
deDegree
..........
Network Visualization:
Color/Size Coding by Betweeness Centrality
58
..........
Node Betweenness Centrality was selected.
Author(s): L. C. Freeman
Implementer(s): Santo Fortunato
Integrator(s): Santo Fortunato, Weixia Huang
Reference: Freeman, L. C. (1977). A set of measuring centrality
based on betweenness. Sociometry. 40:35-41.
Input Parameters:
Number of bins: 10
umber of bins: 10
..........
Network Visualization:
Reduced Network After Pathfinder Network Scaling
59
..........
MST-Pathfinder Network Scaling was selected.
Input Parameters:
Weight Attribute measures: SIMILARITY
Edge Weight Attribute: weight
..........
Network Visualization:
Circular Hierarchy Visualization
60
Select Co-Author Network and run Blondel Community detection:
With parameter values
Network Visualization:
Circular Hierarchy Visualization
61
Visualize resulting file using ‘Visualization > Networks > Circular Hierarchy’
with parameter values
Network Visualization:
Circular Hierarchy Visualization
62
Node labels, e.g.,
author names.
Network structure
using edge bundling.
Color coded cluster
hierarchy according to
Blondel community
detection algorithm.
Note:
Header/footer info, legend, and more meaningful color coding are under development.
Nodes that are interlinked/clustered
are spatially close to minimize the
number of edge crossings.
Paper-Citation Network Layout
To extract the paper-citation network, select the ‘361 Unique ISI Records’ table and run
‘Data Preparation > Text Files > Extract Paper Citation Network.‘
The result is a unweighted, directed network of papers linked by citations, named
Extracted paper-citation network in the Data Manager.
Run NAT to calculate that the network has 5,342 nodes and 9,612 edges. There are
15 weakly connected components. (0 isolates)
Run ‘Analysis > Networks > Unweighted and Directed > Weak Component Clustering’ with
parameters
to identify top-10 largest components. The largest (giant) component has 5,151 nodes.
To view the complete network, select the network and run ‘Visualization > GUESS’.
63
64
10:55-11:05 The Importance and Dangers of Visualization – Use & Theory
11:05-11:20 The Epistolarium – Networks, Topics & Tools
11:20-11:25 Computational Modeling
11:25-11:35 Move to other room
11:35-11:50 Sci2 Tool Basics
11:50-12:10 Sci2 Workflow Design: Padgett's Florentine Families - Prepare, load, analyze, and visualize family and business networks from 15th century Florence.
12:10-12:20 Q&A and Technical Assistance
Workshop Overview
65
Workflow Design:
Padgett’s Florentine Families
66
Padgett's Florentine Families - Compute Basic
Network Properties & View in GUESS
Load *yoursci2directory*/sampledata/socialscience/florentine.nwb
Run ‘Analysis > Network Analysis Toolkit (NAT)’ to get basic properties.This graph claims to be undirected.
Nodes: 16
Isolated nodes: 1
Node attributes present: label, wealth, totalities, priorates
Edges: 27
No self loops were discovered.
No parallel edges were discovered.
Edge attributes:
Nonnumeric attributes:
Example value
marriag...T
busines...F
Average degree: 3.375
There are 2 weakly connected components. (1 isolates)
The largest connected component consists of 15 nodes.
Did not calculate strong connectedness because this graph was not directed.
Density (disregarding weights): 0.225
Optional: Run „Analysis > Unweighted & Undirected > Node Betweenness Centrality‟ with default parameters.
Select network and run ‘Visualization > GUESS’ to open GUESS with file loaded.
Apply „Layout > GEM‟.
Open NWB File67
68
Pan:
“grab” the background by holding left-click and moving your mouse.
Zoom:
Using scroll wheel, press the “+” and “-” buttons in the upper-left hand corner, or right-click and move the mouse left or right. Center graph by selecting „View -> Center‟.
Select to select/move single nodes. Hold down „Shift‟ to select multiple.
Right click to modify Color, etc.
69
Graph Modifier:
Select “all nodes” in the Object drop-down menu and click „Show Label‟ button.
Select „Resize Linear > Nodes >
totalities‟ drop-down menu, then
type “5” and “20” into the From”
and To” Value box separately.
Then select „Do Resize Linear‟.
Select „Colorize>
Nodes>totalities‟, then select
white and enter (204,0,51) in the
pop-up color boxes on in the
“From” and “To” buttons.
Select “Format Node Labels”,
replace default text {originallabel}
with your own label in the pop-up
box „Enter a formatting string for
node labels.‟
70
Interpreter:
Uses Jython a combination of Java and Python.
Try
colorize(wealth, white, red)
resizeLinear(sitebetweenness, 5, 25)
71
10:55-11:05 The Importance and Dangers of Visualization – Use & Theory
11:05-11:20 The Epistolarium – Networks, Topics & Tools
11:20-11:25 Computational Modeling
11:25-11:35 Move to other room
11:35-11:50 Sci2 Tool Basics
11:50-12:10 Sci2 Workflow Design: Padgett's Florentine Families - Prepare, load, analyze, and visualize family and business networks from 15th century Florence.
12:10-12:20 Q&A and Technical Assistance
Workshop Overview
72
top related