artificial intelligence and sleep – the next...
Post on 07-Jul-2020
0 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
10/17/19
1
ArtificialIntelligenceandSleep–TheNextFrontier
NathanielF.Watson,MD,MScProfessorofNeurology
UniversityofWashington(UW)SchoolofMedicineDirector,HarborviewMedicalCenterSleepClinic
Co-director,UWMedicineSleepCenter@SleepDocWatson
FullDisclosure:NoRelation/NoCOI
≠
UniversityofWashingtonWatson
10/17/19
2
WhatIwilltellyou
• WhatisArtificialIntelligence(AI)?• SleepmedicineandAI• Readingtealeaves– howcan/willAItransformsleepmedicine?• WhatdoesAImeanforusmoregenerallyinmedicine/life?
• Howtofeelaboutit(butIWILLchallengeyoutothinkaboutit)
WhatIwon’ttellyou
InfiniteMonkeyTheorem
10/17/19
3
WhatdowemeanbyArtificialIntelligence?• ArtificialIntelligence• Abranchofcomputersciencedealingwiththesimulationofintelligentbehaviorincomputers
• Thecapabilityofamachinetoimitateintelligenthumanbehavior• MachineLearning• Theprocessbywhichacomputerisabletoimproveitsownperformance(asinanalyzingimagefiles)bycontinuouslyincorporatingnewdataintoanexistingstatisticalmodel
• ComputationalPhenotyping• Abiomedicalinformaticsmethodforidentifyingcertainpatientpopulations
MerriamWebster;https://www.coursera.org/lecture/computational-phenotyping/introduction-to-computational-phenotyping-s0GJ8
Waveforms = Trillions of data points
6
10/17/19
4
PSGandtheDynamicMultivariateHumanPhysiologicalState
• Eachofthe3.2billionDNAbasepairsinahumangenomecanbeencodedbytwobits– 800megabytesfortheentiregenome• SequenceofnucleotidescomprisingDNAisrelativelystatic…whileenvironmentwithineachcellishighlyvariable• Genomesequencedoesnotindicateexposuretotoxicwater,howbadlyinjuredinafall,howarecentsurgeryorchangeinmedicationaffectedhealth,etc.• Bysomeestimates,yourphysiologicalstateatanypointintimecontainsroughly1018 (amilliontrillion)timesmoreinformationthanresidesinyourgeneticcode
CourtesyofChrisFernandez
StatisticalAnalysisofIndividualVersusConsensusScoringAgreement
Fernandezetal.Acrossvalidationapproachtointer-scorerreliabilityassessment.SLEEP2018;41:A122-123.
10/17/19
5
Machine LearningAlgorithmforAutomatedScoringandAnalysisofPolysomnographyData
Allocca etal.Validationof‘Somnivore’,aMachineLearningAlgorithmforAutomatedScoringandAnalysisofPolysomnographyData.FrontiersinNeuroscience2019;13:1-18
DeepNeuralNetworkSleepScoring
Biswal etal.Expert-levelsleepscoringwithdeepneuralnetworks.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalInformaticsAssociation,25(12),2018,1643–1650
10/17/19
6
CanAIEstimateOSASeveritybyEEGAlone?
• Adultpatients(N=4,650)whocompletedanovernightPSGstudy• Allsignalswereexcludedfromanalysisexceptthe10/20EEGsensorarray• GlobalphenotypicfeatureswerederivedfromEEGstudysleeparchitectureandfragmentationprofiles• Localphenotypicfeatureswerederivedbyanalyzingbiomarkerpatternsandrespiratorycycle-relatedEEGchangesexhibitedintheEEGsignalsdirectly• AImethodsincludingBidirectional-LSTM,Deep-CNN,andacombinationofbothweretrained,optimized,andevaluatedtomodeltherelationshipbetweenglobalandlocalEEGphenotypesandOSAseverity• PerformanceforpredictingmoderateandsevereOSA(AHI≥15)wasevaluatedusingrandomized10-foldcross-validation
Fernandezetal.UsingnovelEEGphenotypesandAItoestimateOSAseverity.SLEEP2019;42:A375
Sleep-ArousalArchitectureEstimatedLow-RiskforOSA(AHI≤15)
10/17/19
7
Sleep-ArousalArchitectureEstimatedHigh-RiskOSA(AHI≥15)
PerformanceandStatisticalSignificanceofEEGbasedOSASeverityEstimation
https://towardsdatascience.com/precision-vs-recall-386cf9f89488
10/17/19
8
MachineLearningPredictsCPAPRxPressure± 2cmH2OCPAPStartingPressureComparison
PhysicianRxCPAPPressure
Machine
LearningPredicted
Th
erapeu
ticCPA
PPressure
Munafo etal.ComputationalphenotypinginCPAPtherapy:Usinginterpretablephysiology-basedmachinelearningmodelstopredicttherapeuticCPAPpressures.SLEEP2019;42:A217.
MachineLearningBasedPAPComplianceAssessment:
• Snoringtime• Heartrate• Longestapnea• ESSscore• PercenttimeunderSpO2 of85%• Numberofapneas/hour
RandomForestAnalysis:5-yearAllCauseMortality• 1,541interpretablephysiologicalandclinicalfeaturescomputationallyderivedfromtheSHHSdataset(N=5,803)• 435clinicalobservationalvariables(e.g.,smoking,bloodpressure,cholesterol)
• 1,170PSGvariables(e.g.,sleeparchitecture,AHI,SpO2 trends)• Compumedics P-seriestypeIIPSG• Machinelearningmodelsweretrained,optimized,andevaluated:OrdinaryLeastSquares,RandomForest,DeepMLP,KernelSVM,NaïveBayes,KNN,GaussianProcess,QDA,LASSO,LogisticRegression,AdaBoost
Fernandezetal.ComputationalphenotypinginPSG:Usinginterpretablephysiology-basedmachinelearningmodelstopredicthealthoutcomes.SLEEP2017;40:A26.
10/17/19
9
PredictiveUtilityRanking
TableofTop-30PSGvariableandclinicalobservationfeaturesrankedbyGiniImportance:
PSG-only,Obs-only,andCombinedRandomForestAnalysis
10/17/19
10
ComputationalPhenotypingModelComparison
Fernandezetal.ComputationalphenotypinginPSG:Usinginterpretablephysiology-basedmachinelearningmodelstopredicthealthoutcomes.SLEEP2017;40:A26.
Zinchuketal.Phenotypesinobstructivesleepapnea:Adefinition,examplesandevolutionofapproaches.SleepMedicineReviews35(2017)113-123
10/17/19
11
Can“BrainAge”BePredictedbytheEEG?
• Brainage(BA)servesasapotentialagingbiomarkerwherethevariationofBAbetweenindividualsofthesamechronologicalagemaycarryimportantinformationabouttheriskofcognitiveimpairment,neurologicalorpsychiatricdisease,ordeath• Alzheimer’sdisease,schizophrenia,epilepsy,traumaticbraininjury,bipolardisorder,majordepression,cognitiveimpairment,diabetesmellitus,andHIV,areassociatedwithexcessBA(onMRI)• MachinelearningmodeldevelopedtopredictBAbasedon2largesleepEEGdatasets:theMassachusettsGeneralHospital(MGH)sleeplabdataset(N=2,532;ages18-80);andtheSleepHeartHealthStudy(SHHS,N=1,974;ages40-80).
Sunetal.BrainagefromEEGofsleep.NeurobiologyofAging2019;74:112-120
Sunetal.BrainagefromEEGofsleep.NeurobiologyofAging2019;74:112-120
10/17/19
12
Sunetal.BrainagefromEEGofsleep.NeurobiologyofAging2019;74:112-120
Sunetal.BrainagefromEEGofsleep.NeurobiologyofAging2019;74:112-120
10/17/19
13
TimetoThinkAboutit
•Whatdoesitmean:• Forsleepmedicine?• Formedicineingeneral?• Forusasmembersofsociety?
ProtecttheSleepMedicineStatusQuo
EmbracetheFuture
10/17/19
14
• Genotype - thegeneticconstitutionofanindividualorganism• Phenotype - thesetofobservablecharacteristicsofanindividualresultingfromtheinteractionofitsgenotypewiththeenvironment• Geneticdeterminism- thebeliefthathumanbehavioriscontrolledbyanindividual's genes orsomecomponentoftheirphysiology,generallyattheexpenseoftheroleoftheenvironment,whetherinembryonicdevelopmentorinlearning• Thequantifiedself- refersbothtothe culturalphenomenonofself-trackingwithtechnologyandtoacommunityofusersandmakersofself-trackingtoolswhoshareaninterestin“self-knowledgethroughnumbers.”• Phenotypedeterminism- ???
ComparisonofAccuracyofCSTsVersusPSG
Sleep Wake Light Deep REMSleepScore 88% 66% 58% 62% 57%FitbitCharge 2
96% 61% 81% 49% 74%
Ōura Ring 96% 48% 65% 51% 61%Beddit N/A 42% 56% 37% N/A
DeZambottietal.ChronobiologyInternational2018;35(4):465-476Tuominen etal.JClinSleepMed.2019;15(3):483–487Zaffaronietal.EngineeringinMedicineandBiology2019,Berlin,Germany,July23-27deZambottietal.Behav SleepMed20181–15.doi:10.1080/15402002.2017.1300587
10/17/19
15
BacktotheFuture?
https://www.nuance.com/healthcare/ambient-clinical-intelligence;https://www.engineering.com/DesignerEdge/DesignerEdgeArticles/ArticleID/17664/A-Healthy-Future-for-Artificial-Intelligence-in-Healthcare.aspx
Accessed10/5/2019
10/17/19
16
WhatItoldyou
• DefinedAI,machinelearning,andcomputationalphenotyping• AIandsleepstudyscoring• EEGandOSAseverityestimation(diagnosis?)• AIandPAPRxaccuracy• Computationalphenotypingand5-yearsurvivalwithPSG/clinicalvariables• “BrainAge”andAI• Consumersleeptechnologyaccuracycomparison• AIandimplicationsforthefutureofhealthcare
top related