as the crow flies reasoning and sense making using distance

“AS THE CROW

FLIES”

REASONING AND SENSE MAKING USING DISTANCE

““THE DISTANCE FORMULA IS OFTEN THE DISTANCE FORMULA IS OFTEN PRESENTED AS A ‘RULE’ TO MEMORIZE”PRESENTED AS A ‘RULE’ TO MEMORIZE”

PURPOSEPURPOSE

• To help students to develop an understanding of the meaning of the distance formula.

• A review of the distance formula.• To present a real-world problem using the

distance formula.• To encourage students to use reason to find a

solution.

TASK OVERVIEWTASK OVERVIEW

• Compute the distance between two locations in a city.

• City streets are laid out on an evenly spaced square grid.

• Define a coordinate system and think about how to compute the distance.

REASONING HABITS / PROCESS REASONING HABITS / PROCESS STANDARDSSTANDARDS

• Analyze a problem using relationships and structure

• Use connections across different representations

• Reflect on the solution

• Problem solving to build new knowledge.

• Understand how math ideas interconnect.

• Use representations to model and interpret physical, social, and mathematical data.

STANDARDS FOR MATHEMATICAL PRACTICESTANDARDS FOR MATHEMATICAL PRACTICE

2. Reason abstractly and quantitatively.4. Model with mathematics.7. Look for and make sense of structure.

STANDARDS FOR MATHEMATICAL CONTENTSTANDARDS FOR MATHEMATICAL CONTENT

5.G Graph points on the coordinate plane to solve real-

world and mathematical problems.

8.G.7 Apply the Pythagorean Theorem to determine

unknown side lengths in right triangles in real-

world math problems.

8.G.8 Apply the Pythagorean Theorem to find the distance

between two points in a coordinate system.

THE CLASSTHE CLASS

• 9th grade Transitional Algebra at LHS • 23 students in class, 12 boys, 11 girls• 21 students present for this lesson• 20% are repeating this class• Class grades: 84 high, 76 average, 66 low• Teacher said they work at “5th grade level”• Students were encouraged to work in pairs. Most did not.

TASK / PROBLEM LESSONTASK / PROBLEM LESSON

1. How many blocks would you have to drive to get from your house to your friend’s house? Draw a path that you would drive, and calculate the distance.

““BEFORE WE BEGIN…”BEFORE WE BEGIN…”

Presentation and discussion reveals that the studentsPresentation and discussion reveals that the students::

•Have worked with the Pythagorean Theorem this year, and in at least 3 earlier grades.•Have worked with the coordinate plane.•Understand the layout of a city grid.•Understand what the problem is asking them to find.•Require brief instruction to address misunderstandings regarding helicopter flight.

QUESTIONS 1-2: PRE-CLASS DISCUSSIONQUESTIONS 1-2: PRE-CLASS DISCUSSION

MisconceptionsMisconceptions::

• Students did not recognize that helicopter path was different from car path.

• Comments included travelling same path as car, but going faster.

• Some students recognized the flight path as on the diagonal, but:

• Explained the shorter time in relation to speed.

QUESTIONS 1-2: PRE-CLASS DISCUSSIONQUESTIONS 1-2: PRE-CLASS DISCUSSION

Misconceptions (cont)Misconceptions (cont)::

• Did not recognize the shape as a triangle, so did not connect the solution to the Pythagorean Theorem.

• Explained with confidence that there was no way to calculate an exact distance, because they couldn’t count the boxes accurately.

• They attempted to solve the problem using ratios, implying that they were trying to relate the task to a more recent lesson on similar triangles.

STUDENTSTUDENT EXAMPLE EXAMPLE

11

STUDENTSTUDENTEXAMPLEEXAMPLE

22

DISCUSSION OUTCOMESDISCUSSION OUTCOMES

1. Students were directed to observe the shape of the graph, eventually recognizing a triangle. No one noted the type of triangle.

2. When told it was a right triangle, students needed much directed talk to bring forth the Pythagorean Theorem.

3. Once the Pythagorean Theorem was in mind, the students worked the problem quickly, finding the value of “C.”

OBSERVATIONSOBSERVATIONS

Reasoning SkillsReasoning Skills

• Students did not connect prior skills and knowledge.• Did not recognize city grid as coordinate plane.• Did not recognize the shape as a right triangle.• Students could place appropriate points on the grid,

once directed, but could not build a viable model of the problem using mathematics.

OBSERVATIONSOBSERVATIONS

Sense Making: Students Struggled To Make SenseSense Making: Students Struggled To Make Sense

• Following the class discussion, students struggled to connect the answer, “C=11.7” to the distance of travel.

• Students could be successful in each individual skills, but struggled to make connections that led to problem-solving.

OBSERVATIONSOBSERVATIONS

Sense Making (cont)

•Students were unable to construct models for a follow-up question, #5, which may imply that they did not engage in sense making during the earlier task.•Some students chose to measure the hypotenuse in inches, and continued to believe the measurement was correct even after discussion of the Pythagorean Theorem.

STUDENT WORK: QUESTION 5STUDENT WORK: QUESTION 5

REFLECTIONSREFLECTIONS• Students in this class seem to view math as disjointed skills with no real-

world application.• Many of these students have a history of poor performance and poor

work habits in math and have developed a “why bother” attitude, which robs them of the ability to actively engage in problem solving.

• Some of the lower performing students showed strong potential to succeed using this method, as two students from the bottom half of the class attempted all 5 questions with success. It would be interesting to see how the students would respond to lower level tasks, building slowly toward more challenging current grade-level work.

• Students seemed to have a good toolbox of skills and knowledge, but may lack the confidence to use their tools appropriately and at the right times.

MORE SOLUTION ILLUSTRATIONS, Q #5MORE SOLUTION ILLUSTRATIONS, Q #5

The EndThe End““the crow has landed”the crow has landed”