charged leptons as probes of the standard model j. michael roney university of victoria (b a b ar...
Post on 17-Jan-2016
218 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard ModelJ. Michael Roney
University of Victoria (BABAR Collaboration Member)
Lepton-Photon SymposiumDaegu, South Korea August 13-18, 2007
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
What Standard Model sectors can we probe with charged leptons and how useful is that probing?
• Appropriate questions, especially for the LEPTON-photon symposium…
• There are recent very high precision measurements at low energy of interest but nothing new for LP07 (see Sven Heinemeyer’s review from
Monday morning) the tension between data and SM persists in muon g-2 PRL 97, 030801(2006) Odom et al electron g-2: defines to 0.7ppb EDMs: continue to heavily constrain any physics beyond the SM
• Lets start with the basics where new results are in: Quantum Field Theory has CPT invariance built into it: translates into equal masses &
lifetimes for each particle and antiparticle … SM silent on particular masses, but foundations crumble if e.g. + and - have different
masses or lifetimes charged leptons are the only bare fermions allowing such probes
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
SM is silent on actual values of the masses and lifetimes
• Some are used to define the SM parameter space because of their high precision whereas the absolute values are required for less foundational probing… such as the assumption of charged current universality Present new results on
lifetime masses and CPT tests
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
Precision lifetime at PSI byMuLan Collaboration Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 032001 (2007)
• “Defines” GF : fundamental SM parameter
• GF
9ppm 0.0007ppm 23ppm
,...
2
2
2 5
3
182
1
19
( ,
2
)tF
W
F
H
G g
M
G m
r m m
weak int’n loop corrections e.g.
van Ritbergen & Stuart full 2-loop QEDcorrections (1999) allow determination ofGF from lifetime at 0.3ppm level
(Nucl.Phys.B564:343-390,2000)
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
(from D. Hertzog, Moriond’07)
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria6
(from D. Hertzog, Moriond’07)
(MuLan)
5 -2F
=2.197013(24) s (11ppm)
G 1.166372(6) 10 GeV (5ppm)
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria7
CPT test from lifetime Dominated by lifetime of s
(Bardin 94)
don’t expect much improvement on testing CPT
5
5
2.197 025(155) s - 2.197 013(24) s/ =
2.197019(21) s
0.5 71 10
PDG 2 8 10cf
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria8
CPT• what about Lifetime:
1st CPT on lifetime from BABAR (Lusiani, TAU04)
THIS TEST WOULD BENEFIT FROM HIGH
STATISTICS AS MANY SYSTEMATICS WOULD CANCEL
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria9
CPT Mass: BELLE published using 5.8x106 pair
events: in 414/fb of data PRL 99,011801(2007) (hep-ex/0608046)
2
2
4
1776.61 0.13 0.35MeV/c
0.05 0.23 0.14 MeV/c
2.8 10 @90%CL
m
m m
m mm
2
min 2( )( )
3
X beam X X XM M E E E P
X
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
0
CPT• Mass: future? A SuperB factory with ~100/ab would yield a
statistical error of 0.023MeV on the mass difference ~ 6 x smaller than 0.14MeV systematic error BELLE now quotes.(Reach 0.15MeV at 2.3/ab)
To fully exploit 100/ab, would need charge asymmetric momentum scales controlled at 10-5 level. VERY CHALLENGING DETECTOR SYSTEMATICS PROBLEM
Would get CPT test to 2x10-5 level of sensitivity and would be most sensitive CPT mass difference test after K0(10-18), proton and electron (10-8).
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
1
New preliminary mass from KEDR Collaboration at the VEPP-4M Collider in Novosibirsk (hep-ex/0611046)
0.29 20
0.25 20.23
.26177
1776.80 0.15
6.99 MeV/c (PDG06, BES dominated)
MeV/c (KEDR preliminary)
m
m
using e,,,K,– vs - e -pair events
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
2
The mass is needed for probes of charged current universality involving the but …to probe the SM in and e- universality further requires higher precision measurements of BR(eand BR( and improved lifetime measurements
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
3
Charged Current Lepton universality • Charged current universality: tau decays
e
Branching ratios: (+ Lifetime, mass):
g g1.0000 0.0020
( ) 17.82 0.05 % [0.3%] PDG'07 Avera
1.0004 0g g
ges( ) 17.33 0.05 % [0.3%]
BR e
BR
.0022
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
4
Lepton universality in Kaon Decays New results from KLOE at Frascati’s DANE phi factory for LP07
KR ( ) / ( )K e K
can have deviations from SM frome.g. multi-Higgs effects inducing aneffective pseudoscalar interaction upto the few % level in K decays(A. Masiero, P. Paradisi, R. Petronzio, PRD74 (2006) 011701)
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
5
KLOE Universality results• Using 1.7fb-1 at the
• Compare RK to a SM calculation (M. Finkemeier, PLB 387 (1996) 391) which includes internal brem photons (IB) and ignores contributions from structure-dependent direct photon emission (DE). Requires care!
IB IB+DE
K e
6499 10 events
~8000 events
K
K e
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
6
KLOE Universality results
2 22
2 2 2 2
1 1
: efficiencies
C: corrections to MC efficiencies
: Fraction of IB component accepted (via
TRG TRKK KTRKKe
K TRG TRK IBPID PIDK Ke Ke KeMC MC
MC
IB
NR C
N C
MC
5K
SM 5K
SMK K
R 2.55 0.05 0.05 10
R = 2.472 0.001 10
RATIO: R /R
MC
1.032 0.0 9
)
2
cf
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
7
Probing the CKM Matrix with leptons• CKM Unitarity implies:
• strange decays of provides an additional way of probing |Vus | with a technique having uncorrelated experimental and theoretical errors
+ +
3
2 2
u
2
0.97377 0.00027
from 0 0 nuclear decay and neutron decay
= 4.40 0.34 10
from e.g. inclusive B X (numerically negligible role)
Unitar
1
ity 0.22 0. 75
ud
ub
ud us ub
us
V V V
V
V
V
0012
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
8
Strange and non-Strange -Decays
1= e
ee
Br hadrons B BR
BBr e
Strangenon,Strange, RRR
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria1
9
Extracting |Vus|The weighted spectral functions may be written as:
When one takes the flavour breaking difference:
the D=0 terms cancel leaving D 2. So:
19
02
0 0
0 0
0
( )
( ( ) ) ( )
where ( ) must be calculated and (
Note: because D=0 >>D 2 contribution, eve
) me
n a large relative
uncertainty o
asur
n ( )
e
yi
d
wus
us w wud ud OPE
w wO
wOP
PE i
E
j
R s
R
VR s V R s
R s R s
s
uselds a small uncertainty on V
0
,, 0
0
( ) ( ) ( )
s
ijwij
dRR s ds w s ij ud or us
ds
, 0 , 00 2 2
( ) ( )( )
| | | |
w ww ud us
ud us
R s R sR s
V V
2 2 2 2(0) ( ) ( ), 0
2
( ) 3 1w kl kl D kl Dij EW ud us ud ud us us
D
R s S V V V V
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
0
BABAR Branching Ratio for -K-0(uses 230/fb)
(2.267±0.008)%
NData 78,112±280
NBkg 38,247±159
-+
arXiv:0707.2922 [hep-ex]
submitted PRD-RC
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
1
#pair(351/fb)
310M
~6%
NSignal 53110
Purity 79%
arXiv:0706.223 [hep-ex] submitted to PLB
not in average
0
0 0
( ) 0.404 0.002 0.013 %
( ) 2 ( )
= 0.808 0.004 0.026 %
PDG 07 = 0.90 0.04 %
S
S
B K
B K B K
BELLE:BR, Mass & Width: - KS-
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
2
BELLE: BR -K-,-K-0(K*-); --0
-K-
-K-0
--0
#signal 1387 270 5959
BR
(1.620.10)x10-4
(1.610.050.09)x10-4
(1.650.160.10) x10-4
(4.71.10.4)x10-5
(1.390.030.07)x10-3
preliminary: decays with
arXiv:0708.0733 [hep-ex]
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
3
BELLE (preliminary) Use -K-0sample to get- K*-) through the K*-(892)K-0modeusing BR(K*-(892)K-0
-K*- BELLE~1.9 lower than
PDG 07(CLEO)
BR (1.130.19 0.07)x10-4
(2.900.800.42)x10-4
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
4
BABAR Branching Ratios for -h-h-h+
Particle Identification (PID) Efficiency Matrix
Candidates Decay Modes (MC Truth)
--+ K--+ K--K+ K-K-K+
--+ 97.40% 22.49% 4.73% 1.02%
K--+ 1.42% 74.87% 16.43 6.38%
K--K+ 0.01% 0.49% 59.63% 25.54%
K-K-K+ 0.26% 50.87%
Characteristic Efficiency (excluding PID)
2.8% 3.1% 3.5% 3.9%
)NN(MN
)NN(NM
)MC(Bkgi
Datai
iij
1Sigj
)MC(Bkgi
Datai
Sigj
jij
L2
NBr
Sigj
ji=Channels Selectedj=Decay Mode
arXiv:0707.2981 [hep-ex] Submitted PRL
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
5
BABAR Branching Ratios for -h-h-h+
--
+
K--K+
K--+
K-K-K+
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
6
Some Updates to |Vus| from
UPDATED
-K-0arXiv:0707.2922 [hep-ex]-K--+arXiv:0707.2981 [hep-ex]
-K0-arXiv:0706.2231 [hep-ex]
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
7
Some Updates to |Vus| from
UPDATED
-K-0arXiv:0707.2922 [hep-ex]-K--+arXiv:0707.2981 [hep-ex]
-K0-arXiv:0706.2231 [hep-ex]
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
8
About the tension…• Comment 1: B-factory experimental program to
measure all strange decays of the in progress: many modes still to be measured by BABAR and BELLE, |Vus| analysis assumed modes not yet measured are negligibly small…
• Comment 2:Theory errors for R00 require some care (Maltman & Wolfe hep-ph/0603215): poor convergence properties of the integrated D=2 OPE series for R00
argues for better behaved weighted spectral functions – even so, difference is not diminished using ALEPH spectral functions re-scaled with B-factory BRs even with better behaved weighted SF
• Comment 3: The updated |Vus| analysis doesn’t yet include the new -K-,-K-0(K*-) results from Belle… these lower values will increase the tension further
• very active area for both experimentalists and theorists
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria2
9
Lepton Flavour Violation:A bit of history…the importance of being earnest in seeing nothing
1947: muon established as lepton, excited electron ruled out by absence ofe
1958: G. Feinberg: “leptonic GIM” argument establishes two neutrino types:
Early weak theory: BR(e)~10-4 expected but BR(e)<10-5
1950’s: first -Ne-N conversion experiments Ee=m-Binding Energy~105MeV
and eee searches
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
0
History of e-muon LFV SearchesB(μeγ) < 1.2x10-11 (MEGA/LAMPF) Brooks et al PRL 83 1521 (1999)
μTieTi < 4x10-12
MEG
‘MECO’(?)
hadronic decays
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
1
SNO, SuperK, K2K: all see neutrino mixing implying massive neutrinos
We even have parts of the mixing matrix … experiments, such as T2K, preparing to measure So the SM extended to include massive neutrinos predicts LFV in the charged lepton sector as well:
well below any conceivable experimental sensitivity…
OPPORTUNITY: CHARGED LFV IS UNAMBIGUOUS SIGNAL OF NEW PHYSICS
Pham EPJ C 8 (1999) 513
2314
22 1
( ) ln 10kk k
k
mBR l l U U
m
222 5423
232
2 -3 2(for max. mixing and =3 10 eV )23
e.g.Lee & Shrock, PRD 16,144(1977)
3( ) sin 2 ( ) 10
128
Similarly for and
w
m
mBR BR
m
e e
By beginning of 21st Century: Lepton Flavour Violation established!
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
2
Many SM extensions predict observable Charged LFV• If see-saw mechanism responsible for
small mass, natural to get large Charged LFV
• Heavy Neutrinos• Supersymmetry• …
e.g.SO(10) inspired model with SUSYimbedded in GUTCalibbi et al PRD 74(2006)
univ. gaugino mass
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
3
e
(requires ~107 /sec)
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
4
The present status of the MEG experiment (T. Mori)
Drift Chambers:
Installed and ready at the beam line; cosmic ray test soon
Liquid Xenon Gamma-Ray Detector:
All phototubes installed inside the cryostat; final preparations to start operation toward the end of August
Timing Counters:
Final assembly in Italy; Installation planned at the end of August
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
5
The whole MEG detector will be ready in September 2007
Plan to start an engineering run with muons after calibration runs in October.
Expect to start taking some physics data toward the end of the year
STATUS
of
MEG
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
6
Focus on Lepton Flavour Violation in decays
• lepton-mass dependent couplings • parameter space in some models touch current limits • different sensitivity to 2-body & 3-body decays – which mode will be discovered first is unknown (e.g. some mSUGRA+Seesaw
(PRD66) has parameters having : = 1.5:1.0:8.4) • Well motivated searches: complementary to potential LHC
discoveries: Limits (or discovery!) will better constrain theories
LFV expected in many SM-extensions lll
SM + mixingLee, Shrock, PRD 16 (1977) 1444Cheng, Li, PRD 45 (1980) 1908
Pham EPJ C8 (1999) 513
10-54 – 10-40
10-14
SUSY HiggsDedes, Ellis, Raidal, PLB 549 (2002) 159
Brignole, Rossi, PLB 566 (2003) 51710-10 10-7
SM + heavy Maj R
Cvetic, Dib, Kim, Kim , PRD66 (2002) 034008 10-9 10-10
Non-universal Z’ Yue, Zhang, Liu, PLB 547 (2002) 252 10-9 10-8
SUSY SO(10)Masiero, Vempati, Vives, NPB 649 (2003) 189
Fukuyama, Kikuchi, Okada, PRD 68 (2003) 03301210-8 10-10
mSUGRA + Seesaw
Ellis, Gomez, Leontaris, Lola, Nanopoulos, EPJ C14 (2002) 319
Ellis, Hisano, Raidal, Shimizu, PRD 66 (2002) 11501310-7 10-9
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
7
General approach in Search for LFV @ e+e- colliders
SM decay(1- or 3- prong)
(1 or 2 )
CM frame
Signal decayLFV: no pmiss
Lab frame
• e+e- +- clean environment+- back-to-back (CM frame), jet-likeeasy BB bkgd rej through event shape variables
• Event easily divided in 2 hemispheres in CM: signal and tag decay• Signal (LFV) decay is neutrinoless: no missing momentum• Tag (SM) tau decay: 1- or 3- prong (+ 1 or 2 )
(depending on signal and dominant non bkgd)
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
8
Signal: no neutrinos powerful mass and beam energy informationmass: mm
Babar uses beam energy constrained mass & vertex at μ point of closest approach to beamspot in x,y(MEC)~9MeV(cf no mass or vertex constraint ~24MeV)
Beam Energy:E = E -Ebeam ~ 0
(E)~50MeV
signal region typically defined as 2 box or ellipse
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria3
9
-
mode
Belle BaBar
Br, 10-8 Lum. fb-
1 Br, 10-8 Lum. fb-1
<4.5 535 <6.8 232
e- <12 535 <11 232
e+ <2.4 535 <5.6 376
e+e- <2.8 535 <8.0 376
<3.4 535 <5.3 376
e- <4.3 535 <3.7 376
+ee <2.1 535 <5.8 376
e-ee <3.6 535 <4.3 376
Summary of γ,
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
0
BaBar
New Babar (prelim) & Belle (prelim) results on
Signal Mode
e-e+e- μ-e+e- e-
μ+e-e-
e+
Dominant Background
uds
Bhabhaeeee
ee
uds
optimize event selections for each signal mode separately accounting for different background compositions
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
1
New prelim Belle result on
Belle update to 535fb-1increase in lumi by 6.1 fold
Efficiency:6.0-12.5%<Bkgnd>:0.01-0.40 eventsTotal <Bkgnd>=0.590.31evNobs=0 events
90%CL limits:BR()<(2.0-4.1)x10-8
5-7 fold improvement overprevious limit
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
2
New prelim BABAR results on BABAR update to 376fb-1
for LP07 increase in lumi by 4.3 fold
•Background PDFshapes fromMC or controlsamples•PDFs summedand fit to datain sidebands•<Bkgd> fromintegral of PDFover signal box
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
3
New prelim Babar results on
Efficiency:5.5-12.4%<Bkgnd>:0.3-1.3 events; total=4.20.8 eventsTotal Nobs=6 events
90%CL limits:BR()<(3.7-8.0)x10-8
2-5 fold lower limits over previous Babar results
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
4
New Belle results on V0 using 543fb-1
Efficiency:2.5-4.0%<Bkgnd>:0.0-0.2 eventsTotal <Bkgnd>=0.780.29evNobs=3 events
90%CL limits:BR(V0)<(6.1-18)x10-8
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
5
NEW ’hep-ex/0610067 PRL 98.061803 (2007)BaBar
expected background/channel ~ 0.1-0.3Total expected background=3.1, Observed=2
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
6
Some intepretations within benchmark models
compilation by S. Banerjee (Tau06,hep-ex/0702017)
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
7
LFV in tau decays: How far we can go?It depends on “irresidual background”
levels… not currently a limiting factor
: future sensitivity will be affected by e+e- tag irreducible background. When that limit hit, sensitivity will scale as 1/sqrt(Lumi) . For ~75/ab as with SuperB might expect O(10-9) level
, hh’: sensitivity not likely limited by irreducible backgrounds so might expect sensitivity to scale as 1/Lumi .For SuperB might expect O(10-10) level
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
8
Summary• Charged leptons are probing many sectors
of the SM CPT CC Universality LFV CKM unitarity with |Vus| - watch this space EDM g-2 – possible hint of something beyond SM?
• Look forward to more precision data from MEG, MuLan, Babar, Belle, KEDR, BES, KLOE
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria4
9
Additional Slides
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
050
, where or us
ij
ij
e
Br hadronsR ij ud
Br e
Strange and non-strange Hadronic Width
May be written in terms of the spectral density function
or in terms of the 2 point correlator function
2 2
22 (1) (0)2 2 2
0
2( ) 12 1 1 ( ) ( )
m
ij EW ij ij ij
s s dsR s S V s s
m m m
2 2
2 (1) (0)2 2 2
0
2( ) 12 1 1 ( ) ( )
m
ij EW ij ij ij
s s dsR s S V s s
m m m
Extracting |Vus| from -Spectral Function
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
1
Extracting |Vus|
51
0
0
)()(2
1)()(
)(~)(
2
s
s ssS thth
dssswi
dssswdsqs
ss
0
,, 2 2
0
1k ls
ijklij
dRs sR ds
m m ds
A set of ‘spectral moments’ has been used in the FESR as the particular weight functions w
For (k,l)=(0,0), R00 is obtained from the BR of strange decays
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
2
Some Updates to |Vus| from
from S. Banerjee (Kaon07)
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
3
Belle result on summer ’06 result submitted to PLB
2 projection
signaldata
blinded region
Unbinned Extended Maximum Likelihood fit
94 events in 535 fb-1
within 2 ellipse, eff=5.1%
s(90% CL) = 2.0 events Br<4.5x10-8 at 90%C.L
3.63.2
6.0
( )
1
4.8
UEML fit to data in 2 ellipse
#signal events, 3.9
# background e
NOTE: P(s<-3.9)
vents, b 13.9
=25%10;
( )!
s b N
i ii
eL
N
s bB
s
SN
0705.0650[hep-ex] submitted to PRB
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
4
Belle result on esummer ’06 result submitted to PLB
2 projection
20 events within 5 in 535 fb-1
within 2 ellipse, eff=3%
UEML fit in 2 ellipse # signal events = -0.14 (P(n<-0.14)=48%)
# background evts=5.14
s(90% CL) = 3.34 events
Br<1.2x10-7 at 90%C.L
Unbinned Extended Maximum Likelihood fit0705.0650[hep-ex] submitted to PRB
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
5
Summary of l, l0, l, l’, lK0S
L (fb-1)
L (fb-1)
90% CLUL (10-7)
90% CLUL (10-7)
LumUL
Red
Blue
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
6
Summary of lhh’L (fb-1)90% CL
UL (10-7)
L (fb-1)90% CLUL (10-7)
Red
Blue
Charged Leptons as Probes of the Standard Model J.M.Roney, Victoria5
7
Current exp UL’s vs BSM scenarios
Excluded
BaBar (L=232 fb-1)Belle (L=535 fb-1)preliminary
SUSY SO(10) + seesawMasiero et al. – NJP 6 (2004) 202
23
22 4
( ) tanlij
j iF SUSY
BR l lG m
top related