committee on gas - naruc

Summer Committee Meetings

Committee

On Gas

Transform the Energy Industry with New Gas-fueled Technologies

Innovative Detection Solutions

Energy - HVAC - Industrial - Safety

NARUC Gas PanelJuly 26, 2016

Presented by:

J. Scott Kleppe

President

Sensit Technologies

Product Development and CommercializationWhat does it take to deliver something new?

July 29, 2016ISO 9001:2008 certified company

Founded in 1980, Sensit Technologies serves the Natural

Gas, Propane, HVAC, and Fire Service markets in 40 countries

Sensit products are designed, manufactured, and serviced at

our factory in Valparaiso, Indiana USA

SENSIT Technologies brands include Sensit, Trak-It, Gas-Trac,

Smart Cal, Ultra-Trac

The Process:Customer

• Defined specifications

• Defined expectations

Business Case

• Customer

• Manufacturer

Develop

• Research/Development

• Testing

• Certifications

• Intellectual Property

Delivery

• Marketing Launch

• Product Launch

Customer Need:Locating underground pipe not locatable by traditional methods

Product Development Goals• Locate unmarked pipe

• Gas• Water• Sewer (cross bores)• Electric conduit/cable

• Locate pipes under soil, grass, concrete, asphalt, and other ground covers

• No utility access required

• Easy to operate

• Detect multiple pipes

July 29, 2016 6

Business Case Drivers

• State-of-the-art acoustic technology

• Accurately locate unmarked buried pipe

• Find plastic pipe with broken or missing trace wire

• Enhanced 3D pipe mapping

Research/Development

• Project launched in late 90’s

• Funded through GTI & OTD

• Significant utility support

• Licensed to SENSIT Technologies for commercialization in April, 2011 by GTI

• Market introduction in December, 2012

• Sensit investment $1.4M

July 29, 2016 8

Product Launch

• Promotional Materials

• Advertising

• Training of sales staff

• Training customer service

• Demo equipment

Legal Review

• Prior Art

• Patent Issuance

• Third party Certifications

• Other Liabilities

Results- finding pipes with no trace wire

July 29, 2016 11

New Mexico United Kingdom

APL at Beijing Gas

Beijing Gas used the Ultra-Trac APL to locate a leaking pipe in one of its busy downtown neighborhoods. The APL quickly and accurately located the unmarked pipe, allowing them to dramatically decrease the size of the excavation and improve the speed and efficiency of repairs.

Innovative Detection Solutions

Energy - HVAC - Industrial - Safety

Thank youfor the

opportunity

Committee

On Gas

Transforming the Energy

Industry with New Gas-

Fueled Technologies

Panel for NARUC’s Committee on Gas

Daphne D’Zurko, NYSEARCH/NGA

ddzurko@northeastgas.org

www.nysearch.org

NYSEARCH/NGA Technology

Development Program (20) regulated gas company members from around

North America; numerous R & D contractors

Voluntary RD & D program with expenditures that

range from $3.0 MM to $4.5 Million annually and

with program currently growing

On behalf of our members, NYSEARCH-

developed and tested technologies are licensed to

commercial partners

Several commercial products from NYSEARCH in

use in gas operations and engineering capacities

(Heath’s RMLD, Explorer/PipeTel Inspection

Platforms, etc)

Existing Sensors for Residential Methane

Detection leads to drive for new technology

A number of sensors available in the market

All are electrochemical sensors

Most are dual- or multi-sensors; programmable level for

detection threshold but typically set at 25% LEL

Price ranges from ~$30 to $90

Hard wired with battery back-up

Some are offered with wireless option

Bosch Methane

Wireless

Methane + COMethane + Propane

NYSEARCH/ANI MR Methane

Detector – why different

Physical sensor; not electrochemical

Designed and developed based on proven

micro-resonator technology

Specifications

Range: 0 – 100% CH4

Lower Detection Limit (LDL): 0.25%

Standard AC power; battery back-up

Rugged, reliable, accurate

Currently in pre-commercialization phase

Developed based on proven

micro-resonator technology

Two tuning forks; one in a

vacuum, one exposed to ambient

The viscosity of the gas that the

second tuning fork is exposed to

affects its natural frequency

This change allows us to identify the

gas it is exposed to and determine its

concentration

Physical sensor; not electrochemical

No false alarms when exposed to common

industrial and household chemicals

Chemicals tested Methane - Ethanol

Acetone - Ammonia

Paint thinner - Duster

Bleach - Detergent + bleach

Permanent glue - Hairspray

Furniture polish - Oven cleaner

Refresher - Bathroom cleaner

Spray deodorant

Stages of Testing

Lab testing of engineering prototypes

Lab testing of pre-commercial prototypes

Funders testing of pre-commercial prototypes

Prospective commercializer testing of pre-

commercial prototypes

UL testing of commercial prototype (on-going)

Pilot Testing (plans being

implemented)

Need for market acceptance

study?

Plans for Technology Transfer and

Commercialization Complete engineering analyses and independent

validations

Plan and implement pilot tests

Develop information and supporting materials for

manufacturers/members who are supporting

implement

Solicit prospective commercializers

Conduct testing and negotiations with serious bidders

Vision of Methane Detector Use in

Future Several jurisdictions supporting

potential mandates for residential

methane detection

NYSEARCH’s members/LDCs looking

to support reliable technology and to

help define standards for installation

UL Standard 1484 for residential

methane detection to be upgraded to

include standards for higher resolution

on threshold for alarm and for

standardization of labeling and usage

Committee

On Gas

A LORAX Innovation 25

Company

• Headquartered in Halifax Nova Scotia

• Incorporated in May 2010

• Engineering & Product Development

• Fluid control and management

• Current Markets

• Liquid fuels for commercial and

consumer applications in North

America

• Patented

• Certified

• In service

Project Definition

• Objective

• To develop an intelligent safety shutoff device that

will shut off the flow of gas in the event of line or

meter set damage or failure.

• Technology

• Must shut off the flow of gas when a leak threshold

is exceeded.

• Must permit small leaks below a specified threshold

• Must adapt to supply pressure changes.

• Must be mechanical – no electrics

• Implementation

• Ease of installation, service and monitoring

• Cost effective

Our Vision

Project Deliverables

• Full working prototype

• Full service line protection

• Mechanical monitoring (No Electricity)

• Easy to install and operate

• Configurable leak rate

• Pipe sizing concerns are eliminated

• Dynamically adapts to supply pressure changes

• Gas flow stops if system compromised

• Connections and Repairs – Ease of use

• Electrofusion preferred means of connection

System Prototype

Distribution Line

Service Line

Natural Gas Riser

Service Line Valve

Appliance

Connection

Regulator

Service Head

Adapter

Prototype Demonstration

Demonstration

Closing Remarks

• Testing will begin at GTI this fall

• Pilot tests will begin in the spring of

• Integration with other technologies to

begin early 2017

Committee

On Gas

Cybersecurity Collaborative

NARUC Gas Committee Panel

Transform the Energy Industry with New

Gas-fueled Technologies

July 26, 2016

GTI CONFIDENTIAL 3636

DHS S&T Department of

Homeland Security Science & Technology

• FUNDING = 50%

• TECHNICAL SUPPORT (ex. TTP Transition to Practice Program)

• ACCESS TO LABS & TESTING FACILITIES

SRI International• TECHNICAL EXPERTISE

• SME’S

OTD Operations Technology

Development NFP

• FUNDING = 50%

• MEMBER SUPPORT (10)

• PROJECT CHAMPIONS

GTI Gas Technology Institute

• PROGRAM ADMINISTRATION

• OUTREACH

• MEMBERS FORUM – TEAM SITE

CYBERSECURITY COLLABORATIVE

Objective – Address high priority cybersecurity technical issues through a multi-

year initiative of outreach and education, technology evaluation and transfer

Program

PROGRAM/PROJECT Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4

Passwords

Field Device Protocol

Device Mapping

Configuration of Devices

PNNL Test Bed

SCADA Monitoring

Detection/Correlation

Failure Scenario

Table Top Exercises

Sharing Existing/New,

Identifying Gaps - Agenda

Outreach

Best Practices

Tech to Manage Tech

2016 2017 2018

Program/Project Areas

>Detection/Correlation─ Security as part of new projects

─ Impossible to prevent

>Technology to Manage Technology (Passwords)

─ Password management/control

─ Auditable

─ Coordination between IT/OT

─ Authentication

>SCADA Monitoring─ Real information – data integrity

─ Content – experience based judgment

─ Holistic monitoring – gradual/catastrophic change

─ Threat, risk, impact, performance – updated over time

Best Practices

>Cloud Management

>Coordination Between Physical and Cybersecurity

>Data – Work Toward One Set

>Dispatch Environment

>Event Correlation

>Interdependency/Cascading Threats

>Odorizer Overload

>SCADA

>Supply Chain Integrity

>Training

Contact Information

>Jim Marean - Senior Program Manager─ 312/320-9407

─ James.marean@gastechnology.org

Committee

On Gas

ARPA-E’s MONITOR Program

Technology to Quantify

Methane Emissions

Nate Gorence

Technology-to-Market Advisor

The ARPA-E Mission

Reduce Imports

Reduce Emissions

Improve Efficiency

Catalyze and support

the development of

transformational, high-

impact energy

technologies

Ensure America’s

‣ Economic Security

‣ Energy Security

‣ Technological Lead

Creating New Learning Curves

Methane: A Growing Global Challenge

45Source: WMO Greenhouse Gas Bulletin (Sept. 2014), Rhodium Group, Untapped Potential (April 2015)

Atmospheric methane concentrations have increased about 10% since the mid-1980s and global

emissions are expected to grow an additional 20% by 2030

Global oil and gas methane emissions

under three production scenarios, 100-year GWPStart of the natural

gas boom

Atmospheric Methane Concentrations (1985-Present)

The U.S. Natural Gas System

1,000,000

well sites

500,000

separators100,000

field compressors

300,000

miles pipeline

transmission

compressor stations

processing plants

69,000,000

More Refined Emissions Data

0 20 40 60 80 100 120

Production

Processing

Transmission and Storage

Distribution

MMTCO2e

Comparison Between Current and Previous EPA Estimates of Methane Emissions from NG Systems, in 2013

New Previous

Source: EPA GHG Inventory (2016)

Today’s Methane Sensing Solutions

Ability to

Locate Leaks

Ability to

Quantify

MONITOR’s Methane Detection Solutions

Ability to

Locate Leaks

Ability to

Quantify

SCFH✓

MONITOR Metrics & Targets

1 ton per year (6 standard cubic feet per hour)Sensitivity

$3,000 per site per year (for basic functionality)Economical Cost

90% methane leakage reduction with a 90% confidence levelActionable

Information

Able to estimate mass flow rate within 20% margin of errorQuantification

Able to estimate location within 1 meterLeak Location

No more than 1 per yearFalse Positives

Transmits results wirelessly to remote receiverCommunications

Methane selectivity, speciation capability, thermogenic/biogenic

differentiation, continuous measurement, enhanced stability

Enhanced

Functionality

‣ Nascent technologies that may be too

early in the development process for

incorporation into a complete system

‣ Could significantly contribute to

meeting system-level objectives

‣ Primarily envisioned as advances in

detector technology or data analytics

‣ Systems that include:

1) Methane emission sensing

2) Leak rate characterization and

data analytics

3) Provisions for data quality control

4) Digital communication

5) Enhanced functionality

Complete & Partial Solutions to Detection

Complete measurement systems: 6 projects

Partial measurement systems: 5 projects

Bozeman, MT

Palo Alto, CA

Yorktown Heights, NY

Andover, MA

Houston, TX

Redwood City, CA

Jessup, MD Lincoln, NE

Niskayuna, NY

Boulder, CODurham, NC

ENABLINGFIXED MOBILE

The Portfolio: Four Approaches

POINT SENSORS

Image courtesy of Cuadrilla Resources

LONG DISTANCE

IMAGER

AERIAL

ENABLINGFIXED MOBILE

Portfolio:

Five Point Sensing Technologies

POINT SENSOR

AWARD AMOUNT: $2.4 million

PROJECT PARTNERS: Los Alamos

National Laboratory, Rice University

Miniature, High Accuracy Tunable Laser

Spectrometer for CH4/C2H6 Leak Detection

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Enables ppb/s sensitivity via simple and

robust direct absorption spectroscopy

‣ Discriminates biogenic vs. thermogenic

emissions

‣ 1/15th the size and power of existing in-

situ laser sensors

‣ 100x+ more sensitive/accurate than

legacy FID/NDIR

‣ Compatible with other industry

applications that require high accuracy,

real-time analyses (e.g. process control,

CEMS, environmental/GHG monitoring)

PROJECT PARTNERS: Colorado State

University, Gener8

Laser Spectroscopic Point Sensor

for Methane Leak Detection

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Performance of state of the art cavity-

based point sensors at reduced cost

‣ High sensitivity, selectivity, and stability

measurements with low maintenance

‣ Closed path instrument is weather-proof,

high-performance, and low power

consumption

‣ Suitable for continuous or intermittent

stationary and mobile applications

‣ Advanced spectral models and high

instrument stability allow unattended

operation

‣ Advanced manufacturing and novel

design/alignment enable cost reductions

PROJECT PARTNERS: Princeton

University, Harvard University,

Southwestern Energy

On-Chip Optical Sensors and Distributed

Mesh Networks for Methane Leak Detection

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Developing novel, low cost, on-chip

optical sensors with high methane

selectivity

‣ Distributed and modular system with

self-organizing network of low-power

‣ State of the art silicon photonics

technology for on-chip TDLAS

‣ Allows for selectivity to molecule of

choice

‣ Orders of magnitude lower cost

($250/sensor target)

‣ Low power consumption (<1 Watt)

‣ Cloud-based analytics for source

detection and localization

PROJECT PARTNERS: NASA Ames

Research Center, BP, Xerox Corporation

Printed Carbon Nanotube Sensors

for Methane Leak Detection

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Developing a mesh network of ultra-low-

cost printed sensor arrays that can

detect multiple gases

‣ Uses scalable low-cost, additive printing

methods to print chemical sensor arrays

based on modified carbon nanotubes

‣ Sensor elements with different

responses to methane, ethane, propane

and other wellhead gases

‣ Total system costs under $350 per site

per year

‣ Multiple sensors reduces false positives

‣ Sub-ppm sensitivity with leak localization

within 1 m

Coded Aperture Miniature Mass

Spectrometer for Methane Sensing

PROJECT PARTNERS: RTI International

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Miniaturizing a mass spectrometer

utilizing microfabrication and aperture

coding

‣ High selectivity measurements at short

detection times for methane as well as

VOCs (such as benzene, C2-C7)

‣ Capable of thermogenic vs. biogenic

differentiation

‣ Developing advanced search/location

algorithms for optimum sampling

FIXED MOBILE

Portfolio:

Two Long Distance Technologies

LONG DISTANCE

ENABLING

PROJECT PARTNERS: NIST, NOAA

Frequency Comb-based

Methane Sensing

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ High sensitivity (ppb-m) kilometer-scale

path length measurements with

specificity of FTIR

‣ Ability to monitor 100s of sites from a

central location

‣ Simplifying design to reduce the cost of

dual comb spectroscopy

‣ Multispecies sensing includes CH4, CH4,

H2O, propane, and ethane

‣ Coupled to large eddy dispersion

modeling to provide localization

Frequency Comb-based

Methane Sensing

PROJECT PARTNERS: Virginia Tech

Microstructured Optical Fiber

for Methane Sensing

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Fiber optic sensor is broadly applicable

throughout the oil and gas industry,

particularly for large-scale infrastructure

(such as transmission lines)

‣ Photonic crystal fiber design will

minimize optical losses while permitting

ambient gas to enter hollow core

posts containing porous

hollow core fiber

remote interrogator

buried fiber

FIXED MOBILE

Portfolio:

Two Aerial Technologies

AERIAL

ENABLING

PROJECT PARTNERS: Heath Consultants,

Thorlabs, Princeton University,

University of Houston, Cascodium

UAV-based Laser Spectroscopy

for Methane Leak Measurement

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Continuous leak monitoring with leak

quantification and real-time alarm

notification

‣ Two modes of operation: continuous

perimeter monitoring and search mode

to pinpoint leak location

‣ Speciation of methane and ethane

differentiates thermogenic vs. biogenic

emission

‣ Improved production processes reduce

costs of mid-IR Interband Cascade Laser

(ICL) sources

Mobile LiDAR Sensors for

Methane Leak Detection

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Simultaneous, rapid, and precise 3D

topography and methane gas sensing on

fixed or mobile platform

‣ Capable of covering a broad range: a

frequency-swept laser beam is

transmitted to a topographical target 1-

300 m from the sensor

‣ Produces detailed situational awareness

reports derived from overlaid methane

concentration, 3D topography, and RGB

picture data

‣ Potentially able to achieve a minimum

leak rate detection of 1 gram per minute

‣ Estimated between ~$1,400-2,200 per

well per year

FIXED MOBILE

Portfolio:

One Imaging Camera Technology

IMAGER

ENABLING

Portable Imaging Spectrometer for

Methane Leak Detection

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Miniaturization of Rebellion’s Gas Cloud

Imager (GCI), a long-wave infrared

imaging spectrometer

‣ Camera will be lightweight and portable

– the size of a Red Bull can - and

capable of being incorporated into

personal protective equipment

‣ Data processing uses cloud-based

computing architecture that streams

results to mobile device

FIXED MOBILE ENABLING

Portfolio:

One Enabling Technology

69Image courtesy of Cuadrilla Resources

PROJECT PARTNERS: Thorlabs Quantum

Electronics, Praevium Research, Rice

University

Tunable Mid-infrared Laser

for Methane Sensing

PROJECT HIGHLIGHTS

‣ Innovative, low-cost mid-IR laser with

VCSEL architecture

‣ Integrated micro-electro-mechanical

system (MEMS) mirror enables a wide

tuning range

‣ Approximately 40x reduction in laser

cost, applicable across a wide array of

sensors and applications

Control

CSU: Methane Emissions Test Facility

EXAMPLE SITE LAYOUT –

DESIGN IS IN PROGRES

source(s)

Gas tank bundle (CH4 and other

hydrocarbons) and mass flow controller

Typical well pad

equipment (tanks,

separators, etc.)

*1x3 size ratio is approximate

Not all objects are drawn to scale

The MONITOR Timeline: ARPA-E & Beyond

Window for

field testing

YEAR 3YEAR 2YEAR 1

2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

*Subject to change

Engagement and Partnerships

‣ Engagement with:

– All sectors of oil and gas industry

– Environmental community

– Regulatory community (EPA, BLM, PHMSA, NARUC and several states)

• “The BLM also seeks to account for advances in continuous emissions monitoring

technology, and also for other advances in leak detection technologies, which

may result from ongoing technology development efforts such as the DOE

ARPA–E MONITOR program.”

‣ Partnerships:

– Comprised of state, federal, industrial & environmental leaders

– Commissioned to create technical/regulatory guidelines to produce a

comparative methodology to evaluate state-of-the-art methane detection

technologies vs traditional technologies (OGI and Method 21)

Policy Needs

Main goal: Avoid technology lock-in; move towards quantification

‣ MONITOR technologies will enable:

– Quantification, continuous monitoring, wireless communication—at low-cost and with high sensitivity

– Result: leak prioritization, non-arbitrary measurement intervals or concentration thresholds, and decreased personnel costs

‣ Policy needs:

– Inclusion of a technology onboarding mechanism—i.e. an explicit lookback to ensure that yesterday’s technologies aren’t “locked in”

‣ Policy should move towards:

– Mass flow thresholds and continuous monitoring

www.arpa-e.energy.gov

Nathaniel.Gorence@hq.doe.gov

committee on gas - naruc

Documents

state activity report - american gas association activity...

naruc summer committee meetings committee on water agenda...

naruc: revenue recognition

aceee 2011 state energy efficiency scorecard presented to...

executive summary - naruc

larry mansueti, doe stacy angel, epa naruc winter committee...

washington, dc - naruc

distribution grid code - naruc

natural gas update: eia naruc winter meeting barbara...

annual meeting 2019 - naruc

regulatory accounting - naruc

turkish electricity market - naruc

naruc cybersecurity manual

naruc natural gas committee new york city july 17, 2007...

gas transmission system - naruc

electricity committee - naruc

naruc water committee feb 2013 mcr

technologies for the future david c. carroll president and...

committee on water - naruc

rate case processing - naruc