doc guidebook
Post on 07-Aug-2018
214 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 1/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 2/669
This file contains all the comments received during the official review period (February 26 - April 1) for the draft revise
There are separate wor!sheets in this file#
- eneral comments# addresses comments that are generic and not specific for a certain chapter - eneral uidance comments# comments addressing eneral uidance chapters" $omments are sorted by chapter- %ectoral - te&tual comments# comments addressing the te&t in one of the technical chapters" $omments are sorted b- %ectoral - F comments# comments addressing emission factors in one of the tables in the technical chapters" $om
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 3/669
Comment
$omment relates to unc chapter (not in the drop menue)# *lease ma!e reference to the re+uirements in the ,,
The formulas do not appear uniform# in some cases the legend is missing"
,n copying te&t from the ,*$$ s. fre+uently inappropriate reference to / inventories remains" This must bechec!ed and corrected everywhere"
The references in Tables don0t have correspondence in reference list" ,t0s often impossible to understand where th
original emission factors are retrieved" The reference# uideboo! (26) or $*,* (23) are not acceptable.they wor! as 4$hinese nested bo&es4# substitute with original references5 Also the reference 4isschedi7!. 234 isnot a reference to the wor! where the user can found F and detailed e&planation of their derivation" Thereference spreme what means# the reference must be to a document where the methodology to derive Fs ise&plained"
The table 8"1 of the model chapter (cement as agreed in 9essau) is not implemented in many chapters (e"gtransport). it provides the necessary overview of where emissions are to be e&pected or not" *lease include asimilar table in all chapters"
,n the bo& 4ma7or changes since previous versions4 please remove the remar! on Tiers and the Thessaloni!imeeting" :n the other hand the comment in this bo& should be chapter specific. for e&le poit out if methods oemission factoes have been revised (which rarely is included). please add this information" This comment isgeneric to the entire guideboo!"
Figure and table numbering is not harmonised throughout the revised uideboo!. this must be ensured beforepublishing
verywhere where appropriate the new name of the uideboo! must be used (the name change will almostcertainly be approved)
The new uideboo! must clearly describe where emissions of / and *:*s are e&pected emitted (ir note&pected) (this is in line with the scope of the pro7ect)" The version sent out for review has many gaps in thisrespect" Furthermore improvements in information on / and *:*s are e&pected through support by ermany
and the 'etherlands. this information must be included in the ne&t version (prior to the TF,* meeting)The figures do not appear uniform" The e&planation for the blue arrows is missing from time to time (but e"g"$hapter 2"A"1" Figure 2-1 is :;) and in some cases heat (or fuel) are not denoted" %ee below
The draft uideboo! use a mi&ed terminology for substance vs (air) pollutants. please consult the uidelines andharmonise te&t everywhere
The uidelines use the term 4;ey category4 (agreed by TF,*). the < mus be consistent with this decisions (te&and decision trees) (in the current draft both terminologies are used. even within the same chapter. while !eysource is most fre+uently used)
:ne ob7ective of the pro7ect is to facilitate maintenance" 'evertheless. throughout the uidelines there is a lot ofrepetition of information" &les are definition of T$$$A and reference to the uidelines" *lease ensure thatsuch repetiton as far as possible is avoided"
The uideboo! is endorsed by the $onvention. conse+uently the term *arty is correct (and not %). and the <must be written this way (the current draft not alwyas is)" /owever a statement can be given to e&plain the role ofthe uideboo! under '$" The term 4country4 is neutral
The whole draft needs to undergo a proper =A>=$ by the consultantst. in the draft many references are missing.tables refereces are not correct. terminology (outline>numbering) is inappropriate>inconsistent and copy and pastemista!es ma!es part of the te&t meaningless
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 4/669
*ollutant subscripts eg '/8. %:& ':& etc" *lease standardise across all chapters
eferences- for three authors or more in the te&t use %urname et al (year)" *lease standardise across all chapters
%cientific improvements# ,n the agreement betweeen the $ommission and * in starting this pro7ect some toppriority scientific improvements were setteled" , have loo!ed into a couple of these# i) for solvent use some of theT2 emission factors given are 1? years old (the rest are more than 1) (e"f domestic solvent use. some solventchapters are updated). ii) fugitive emissions from fuel - parts updated - but not the very important chapter on fuel
(gasoline) distribution iii) waste (landfills and waste incineration) - landfill chapter is empty waste incinerationchapters have not been updated" All these are e&les of sectors where technology has been changing and it isli!ely that the provided information is outdated" /opefully the consultans can fill these gaps before the ne&t versiois sent for review"
,n some cases different technologies>abatment system are defined introducing Fs for each technology (fore&le for olume 2$) in some case new technologies>new products are introduced under abatment (fore&le for olume 8)" ,t0s better to produce alwaays Fs tables (non reductions) with technology>products andput them in section 8"8"2" , thin! the approach must be uni+ue5
$omment relates to unc chapter (not in the drop menue)" *lease cite the last draft uidelines (same comment tobe sec @ of this chapter)
eneral guidance# throughout the chapters 0!ey categories0 is interchangabley used with 0!ey sources0" A variety ocapitalisation is also used# ;ey %ource. !ey sources etc" *lease standardise across all chapters (it should be !ey
category in the '$ conte&t)The number of signicant digits provided throughout the different chapters vary greatly" "g" "1 (ead - esidential- <iomass - Fireplaces) and "12336@ (ead - esidential - %olid fuels - %toves)
A contact address would be e&termely helpful (in order to refer any +uestions to > to report additional evidence)"*robably. the &pert *anel chairs are most appropriate to be mentioned"
'umbering of tables and figures in general guidacne chapters needs standardising" %ometimes Fig 1. Fig 2 etc isused. other times Fig B"1. Fig B"8 is used where B is the section number - *lease standardise across all chapters
,n far too many instances. material copied and pasted from ,*$$ uidelines still contains inappropriate referenceto eg other sections or olumes of the ,**$ docs" *lease chec! and correct across all chapters
Terminology" ,n several general guidance chapters mention is made of reporting obligations for signatories (orsignatory *arties etc) to the various $onvention protocols" The obligations are actually only placed on *arties that
have ratified the protocols (i"e" a number of parties have signed but not ratifed protocols)" *lease correctterminlogy across all general guidance chapters
eneral guidance chapters# references to a *arty to the $onvention should have a capital *" ember %tatesshould also be capitalised" *lease standardise across all chapters
,n many places the 26 draft < cites the previous < for emission factors" ,t was agreed at the A meeting in9ublin that this only would be a last resort (7fr page 8 of the minutes)" This must be updated where the originalreferences are available in the current version of the < (in most cases it is)" Furthermore. the referencing to thecurrent version of the < is different in different chapters"
Chen all tables are e+uipped with a column providing the unit it is incomprehensible why this has not been utilisedto ensure more meaningful emission factors. e"g" 3 mg>D instead of "3 g>D"
eneral guidance# several times $AFE is used with accent on the . please correct to $AF" *lease standardiseacross all chapters%ome general guidance chapters use footnotes to provide reference details. while other references are included inthe reference list" ,f a reference list is included ina chapter avoid use of footnotes"
%tyles - not consistent across general guidance chapters i"e" sometimes evel one headings are A $A*%.sometimes %entence case. sometimes Title $ase" 'eeds to be standardised"
eference list provided in each chapter - should be alphabetical. in ascending date of publication and followingconsistent format i"e" authors (year) Title etc" *lease standardise across all chapters
The references need chec!ing in all general guidance chapters ( sector chapters)" ,n a number of casesreferences appear in the te&t but not in the reference list and vice versa
Abbrevaiations are not always e&plained" , recommend an e&planation in the general volume or separately in thevolume on each sector"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 5/669
'eed a consistent use of $TA*. TA* or TA* $onvention - all three are used interchangably" *leasestandardise across all chapters (to TA* $onventionG)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 6/669
Action taken Comments
Accepted
'oted 9one for as far as possible
Accepted 9one for most chapters
Accepted
Accepted 9one
Accepted
Accepted emains to be done" Chat is e&actly meantG
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted
Accepted Try to do this as much as possible
Accepted 9one
Accepted
Accepted 9one se country as much as possible to avoid this issue
Accepted 9one. at least to a large e&tent
Proposeddecision
Try to avoid this as much as possible" $hec! mainlythe chapters for these errors5
As agreed. we will ta!e Fs from (peer-reviewed)literature or at least publicly available references asmuch as we can" /owever. in +uite a number ofcases we don0t have anything better5
, assume it is meant to fill the 4'ot Applicable4 and4'ot stimated4 bo&es with all relevant pollutants"
evised in many cases"$omment about Tiers removed"
Chat is the e&act new nameG ,0m not sure" emainsto be done"
egends to be completed with every formula whereappropriate
The F tables will clearly display if emissions of eachpollutant are e&pected for this source category(according to reporting template)" All contributionsfrom ermany 'etherlands will be included in final
draft"ore e&planations added to thefigures where necessary
Ce0ll try to avoid unneccessary repetition. but must!eep in mind that the uideboo! is over 1@ pages
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 7/669
'oted
e7ected
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted $hec!ed
'oted
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9oneditorial 9one as much as possible
'oted
ditorial 9one
'oted
Accepted $hec!ed
Accepted $hec!ed
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted
%olvent use - All chapters e&cept domestic use (forthis one no new information available) have beensignificanly updated with input from the industry. ,therefore do not agree with this comment"
Fugitives chapter has been updated in consultationwith $:'$AC"Caste incineration - no other new emission factorsavailable"
This approach was presented already in 9essau(ay 2@) and approved for as far as , !now" 'otime to change it now"
$hec!ed. corrected where toomuch digits
6 digits too much. does not reflect the uncertainty ofthe numbers
emains to be done. but decision on this is neededbefore"
9one. B-& used where B issection number
eferencing to old uideboo! harmonised" Ce0ll referto original literature as much as possible"
Footnotes sometimes e&plain more than 7ust thereference"
To be discussed. one glossary might indeed be betterthan separate ones in each chapter
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 8/669
Accepted/armoniHed in chapters asmuch as possible
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 9/669
Volume
1 ,ntroduction 1
1 ,ntroduction 1
1 ,ntroduction 1
1 ,ntroduction 2 22 2 2I
1 ,ntroduction 2 ? 2 1
1 ,ntroduction 2 2 2 2
1 ,ntroduction 2 8@ 2 8?
1 ,ntroduction 2 8I 2 8I
1 ,ntroduction 2 1? 2 2I
1 ,ntroduction 2 12 2 18
1 ,ntroduction 2 8@ 2 8?1 ,ntroduction 2 8@
1 ,ntroduction 2 81
1 ,ntroduction 2 1J
1 ,ntroduction 2 2@
1 ,ntroduction 2 18
Chapter_ID
FromPage
ToPage
FromLine
ToLine
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 10/669
1 ,ntroduction 2 21 ,ntroduction 2 I
1 ,ntroduction 2 1J1 ,ntroduction 2 6
1 ,ntroduction 8 1? 2 1J
1 ,ntroduction 8 ? 8 1
1 ,ntroduction 8 8? 8 8J
1 ,ntroduction 8 26 8 86
1 ,ntroduction 8 2 8 31 ,ntroduction 8 12
1 ,ntroduction 8 1I
1 ,ntroduction 8 161 ,ntroduction 8 2@1 ,ntroduction 8 13
1 ,ntroduction 3 J I 2@
1 ,ntroduction 3 J 6 12
1 ,ntroduction 3 6
1 ,ntroduction 3 2@
1 ,ntroduction 3 6 @
1 ,ntroduction 3 I
1 ,ntroduction I 28 I 2@
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 11/669
1 ,ntroduction I 23 I 2@
1 ,ntroduction I 28 I 2@
1 ,ntroduction I 16 I 22
1 ,ntroduction I 16
1 ,ntroduction I 18
1 ,ntroduction I 221 ,ntroduction I 21 ,ntroduction I 2
1 ,ntroduction I 821 ,ntroduction I 82
1 ,ntroduction I 81 ,ntroduction I 23
1 ,ntroduction I 8@
1 ,ntroduction 6 I 6 6
1 ,ntroduction 6 18 161 ,ntroduction 6 I
1 ,ntroduction 6 23
1 ,ntroduction @ 1? @ 1?
1 ,ntroduction @ 3 @ 61 ,ntroduction @ 3 @ 11
1 ,ntroduction @ 1J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 12/669
1 ,ntroduction @ 2I
1 ,ntroduction @ 221 ,ntroduction @ 11
1 ,ntroduction ? 1J ? 21
1 ,ntroduction ? 8 ? J
1 ,ntroduction ? 88 J 11 ,ntroduction ? 111 ,ntroduction ? 121 ,ntroduction ? 86
1 ,ntroduction ? 1?
1 ,ntroduction ? 1I
1 ,ntroduction J 2 J 3
1 ,ntroduction J 8J 1 22
1 ,ntroduction J 1@ 8I
1 ,ntroduction J 8?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 13/669
1 ,ntroduction J 161 ,ntroduction J 1J
1 ,ntroduction 1 82
1 ,ntroduction 1 82
1 ,ntroduction 1 21 ,ntroduction 1 231 ,ntroduction 1 21 ,ntroduction 1 6
1 ,ntroduction 11 2I
1 ,ntroduction 11 8I
1 ,ntroduction 11 I
1 ,ntroduction 12 ? 12 J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 14/669
1 ,ntroduction 12 26 12 261 ,ntroduction 12 11
1 ,ntroduction 12 121 ,ntroduction 12 211 ,ntroduction 12 2I1 ,ntroduction 12 261 ,ntroduction 12 811 ,ntroduction 12 821 ,ntroduction 18 2? 18 2?1 ,ntroduction 18 2@ 18 2@1 ,ntroduction 18 1J 18 1J
1 ,ntroduction 18 3 18 21
1 ,ntroduction 18 2? 18 2J
1 ,ntroduction 18 2J
1 ,ntroduction 18 2@1 ,ntroduction 18 2@
1 ,ntroduction 13 16
1 ,ntroduction 13 11 ,ntroduction 1I 28 88
1 ,ntroduction 16 1?
1 ,ntroduction 16 1?
1 ,ntroduction 16 2@
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 15/669
1 ,ntroduction 1@ ? 1@ J
1 ,ntroduction 1? @ 1? ?
1 ,ntroduction 1? 2@ 1? 2?
1 ,ntroduction 1? 21 ,ntroduction 1? 8
1 ,ntroduction 1? 8?
1 ,ntroduction 1J 2
1 ,ntroduction 2 1 2 1
1 ,ntroduction 2 1 2 1
1 ,ntroduction 2 21
1 ,ntroduction 22 88
1 ,ntroduction 22
1 ,ntroduction 221 ,ntroduction 26
1 ,ntroduction 88 1 88 1
1 ,ntroduction
1 ,ntroduction
1 ,ntroduction
2 1 1
2 1 1
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 16/669
2 1
2 2 @
2 2 ?
2 8 1
2 8 I 8 6
2 8 @ 8 J
2 8 @ 8 ?
2 8 @ 8 J
2 8 @ 8 @
2 8 @ 8 J
2 8 12
2 8 2? 8 82
2 8 2J
2 8 2J
2 8 82
2 3 8
2 3 8
2 3 3
2 3 6
2 3 ?
2 3 ? 3 ?
2 3
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological
$hoiceethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological
$hoiceethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 17/669
2 3 6
2 I I
2 I I I I
2 I @
2 I ?
2 I ?
2 I 16
2 I 26
2 I 88 I 83
2 6 8
2 6 8 6 8
2 6 8 11 1
2 6 1
2 11 1
2 11 1
2 11 2
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological
$hoiceethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 18/669
2 12 I
2 12 1?
2 12 12
2 18 3 13 8@
2 18 3
2 18 16 18 1@
2 18 16 18 1@
2 18 16 18 1@
2 18 2 18 21
2 18 22
2 13 12
2 13 28
2 13 8? 1@ 8
2 1I 2I 1I 26
2 1? 12
2 1J @ 1J ?
2 1J 13 1J 13
2 1J 8? 1J 8?
2 2 6
2 2 @ 8
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological
$hoiceethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 19/669
2 2 @ 8
2 2 @ 8
2 2 @ 8
2 2 12
2 2 22
2 2 22
2 2 86
2 2 8
2 2 8
2 81 1
2 82 1
2 82 1
2 82 1
2 82 3
2 82 1I 88
2 82 1I
2 82 86
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 20/669
2 82 86
2 82 86
2 82 86
2 8I 2
2 8I 2
2 8I I 86 2
2 8I 6
2 86 32
2 8@
2 8@ 8@
8 1 11
8 2 18
8 2 2
8 8 13 8 2J
8 3 I
8 3 1@ 3 1@
8 @
8 ? I
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
ethodological$hoice
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 21/669
8 1 13
8 13 3 13 31
8 13 8I
8 1? 16
8 1J 1
8
8
3 1 1
3 2 1?
3 2 16
3 2 I
3 2 8
3 2 I
3 8 8I
3 8 1@
3 8 1I
3 3 6
3 I 6
3 6 82
3 @ 12
3 @ 11
3 @ J
3 @ 2
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
9ata $ollection,ssues
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time series
consistencyTime seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 22/669
3 @ 1
3 ? 12
3 J 18
3 J 1
3 1 1
3 1 23
3 1 11
3 11 2
3 11 J
3 11 3
3 12 1@
3 12 1@
3 12 1@
3 18 1
3 18 18
3 18 1I
3 13 ?
3 13 1?
3 13 1
3 16 1
3
3
3
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
Time seriesconsistency
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 23/669
3
I ncertainties 1 1
I ncertainties 2 2I ncertainties 2 8
I ncertainties 11 1
I ncertainties 13 1I ncertainties 13 11
I ncertainties 1@ 8I
I ncertainties 1J 2
I ncertainties 2 2
I ncertainties 21 83 21 8I
I ncertainties 21 8 21 81
I ncertainties 21 22
I ncertainties 21 13
I ncertainties 21 13
I ncertainties 22 81
I ncertainties 22 86
I ncertainties 28 86I ncertainties 23 1
Time seriesconsistency
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 24/669
6 1 2@
6 2 2 2 2
6 2 1J 2 1J
6 2 1J
6 8 @
6 8 23 8 23
6 8 2@ 8 2?
6 8 83
6 3 @ 3 1
6 3 ? 3 ?
6 3 11 3 12
6 6 3
,nventory
anagement,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventory
anagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 25/669
6 6 @ 6 @
6 6 2I
6 6 82 6 82
6 @ 2I @ 26
6 @ 8I
6 ? 1@
6 ? 1J ? 86
6 ? 81
6 J 8
6 1 18 1 18
6 11 6 11 6
6 11
6 11
6 12 J 12 13
6 12
6 18 16
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventory
anagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 26/669
6 1I 1?
6 16 26
6 16 2?
6 1? 1
6 1J 2 1J 21
6 1J 2 1J 2
6 2 J 2 J
6 21 8
6 21 @
6 21 2@ 21 2@
6 21 2@
6 21 81
6 21 8? 21 8?
6 21 8?
6 21
6 22 1
6 22 1
6 22 22
6 22 22
6 28 2
6 28 2
6
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventory
anagement,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
,nventory
anagement,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 27/669
6
6
@ 1 ?
@ 1 28
@ 1 22
@ 1 1
@ 1 1
@ 1 1
@ 1 1
@ 2 1? 2 1?
@ 2 88 8 81
@ 2 2I 2 2I
@ 2 I 2 2
@ 2 88 2 88
@ 8 23
@ 8 11 8 12
,nventoryanagement
,nventoryanagement
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patial
disaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 28/669
@ 8 2
@ 8 8I 8 8I
@ 8 8 8 81
@ 8 6
@ 3 16
@ 3 13
@ 3 @ 3 @@
@ I 22
@ I 2 I 2
@ 6 1I
@ 6 1J
@ 6 8 6 8
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 29/669
@ 6 2? 6 2?
@ ? 16
@ 1 12 1 12
@ 1 8 1 8
@ 11 22
@ 11 3
@ 18 18
@ 18 11 18 12
@ 13 1 13 3
@ 13 12
@ 1I 1@
@ 1I 1@
@ 1I 18
@ 1I 1@
@ 1I 1@
@ 1@ 1
@ 23 16
@ 2@ 1
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patial
disaggregation%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patial
disaggregation%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 30/669
@ 82 86
@ 82 86
@ 88 1
@ 8I 11
@ 8@
@ 8@ 2
? *ro7ections 1 1
? *ro7ections 1 1
? *ro7ections 1 1? *ro7ections 2 18
? *ro7ections 2 1I
? *ro7ections 2 2I? *ro7ections 2 26
? *ro7ections 2 @? *ro7ections 8 8? *ro7ections 8 1
? *ro7ections 8 1?
? *ro7ections 8 1
? *ro7ections 8 12
? *ro7ections 8
? *ro7ections 8 J 8 1@
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
%patialdisaggregation
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 31/669
? *ro7ections 8 16 1 16
? *ro7ections 8 1I 3 2
? *ro7ections 3 1
? *ro7ections 3 2
? *ro7ections 3 1 3 2? *ro7ections 3 1 3 12
? *ro7ections 3 11
? *ro7ections 3 28 3 26
? *ro7ections 3 3 3 1I
? *ro7ections 3 3 3 13? *ro7ections I 2
? *ro7ections I 1I? *ro7ections I 1?
? *ro7ections I J I 1
? *ro7ections I 1@ I 22
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 32/669
? *ro7ections I 3
? *ro7ections I 8 I 1
? *ro7ections I 12 I 16? *ro7ections 6 1
? *ro7ections 6? *ro7ections 6 @
? *ro7ections 6 8 6 18
? *ro7ections 6 1? *ro7ections @ 1@? *ro7ections @ 1J? *ro7ections @ 22? *ro7ections @ 1 @ 2? *ro7ections @ 3? *ro7ections @ 13
? *ro7ections @ 1J? *ro7ections @ 28? *ro7ections @ 88
? *ro7ections @ 2J? *ro7ections @ 1@
? *ro7ections @ ? ? 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 33/669
? *ro7ections ? 2J? *ro7ections ? 22? *ro7ections ? I
? *ro7ections ? 3? *ro7ections ? I? *ro7ections ? 22? *ro7ections ? 21
? *ro7ections ? 1?? *ro7ections J 2I J 2I? *ro7ections J 2I
? *ro7ections 1 23
? *ro7ections 1 3 1 11? *ro7ections 1 13? *ro7ections 1 2
? *ro7ections 1 18
? *ro7ections 1 8
? *ro7ections 1 13 1I? *ro7ections 1 1@? *ro7ections 1 1?? *ro7ections 1 1J
? *ro7ections 1 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 34/669
? *ro7ections 1 22
? *ro7ections 1 28
? *ro7ections 1 23? *ro7ections 1 2J
? *ro7ections 1 8I
? *ro7ections 1 8J 3? *ro7ections 11 1
? *ro7ections 11 31? *ro7ections 11 8?
? *ro7ections 11 1 11 8? *ro7ections 11 8?
? *ro7ections 11 1 2
? *ro7ections 11 8I 11 8@? *ro7ections 12 26? *ro7ections 18 1@
? *ro7ections 18 2 18 2
? *ro7ections 18 2 18 22? *ro7ections 18 1@? *ro7ections 18 1?? *ro7ections 18 2
? *ro7ections 18 21? *ro7ections 18 2 22
? *ro7ections 13 16? *ro7ections 13 81
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 35/669
? *ro7ections 13 82
? *ro7ections 1I ? 1I 16
? *ro7ections 1I I
? *ro7ections 16 @
? *ro7ections 16 ?
? *ro7ections 16 1@? *ro7ections 16 6
? *ro7ections 1? 1@
? *ro7ections
? *ro7ections
? *ro7ections
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 36/669
Comment Action taken
'oted Amended
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted 'ot sure what this is referring to
'oted Te&t amended
e7ected %elf evident
e7ected
Accepted trac! changed (page 2. lines 83-8J)
e7ected
'oted
AcceptedA0s T/' uropean""" ditorial
typo - change to to in" ditorial
Accepted
uidelines - first time of use properly define and reference ditorial
Accepted Te&t amended
Proposeddecision
*roper references should be given to $ legislation and$onvention etc mentioned in the te&t
, felt Appendi& $ fuels should be deleted from this chapter.as it is technical material being presented in a non-technical chapter" A table of fuels is repeated inethodological choice chapter - 7ust present this Fuelsinformation once (i"e" in the more technical ethodologicalchapter)
Appendi& A (pollutants) and Appendi& < (sectors) shouldbe deleted" ,nstead reference should be made to theuidelines which is the single source where thisinformation should be defined" Also helps future-proof thete&t and removes potential user confusion - e"g" alreadythere are inconsistences between the pollutant list withwhat is in the latest uidelines
These sentences should be deleted - not future proof (i"e"will be out of date in ne&t years version of the < already)
idiculous statement# there is a relationship between theresources allocated and the reliability of the emissioninventory
%ome 0scene setting0 is needed. to e&plain the importanceof emission inventories
%'A* is developed by TF,* not T$. in the past therewas a %'A*>':% committe in cooperation between Aand uropstat"
The current uideboo! credits theT$>A
'F was further developed in 26 and 2@ in revisingthe s. please correct
*lease also provide information on the improvementsmade to / and *:*s through the support by ermanyand the 'etherlands
The Tas! Force relies on. and isgrateful for. contribution from anumber of countriesK it would beinvidious to ac!nowledge allcontributions"
*lease specify that only Tier 1 and Tier 2 methods havebeen updated" any needs for updating Tier 8 methodshave been identified. but were outside the scope of thispro7ect"
The previous version referred only to%imple and 9etailed methods. thete&t has been revised"
%'A*J@ was developed by $,T*A or T$>Arespectively G
The current uideboo! credits theT$>A
%ignatories do not have reporting obligations - only partiesthat have ratified do (many *arties have signed but notratified protocols)" 'eeds rewording throughout chapter
Te&t amended to Lcountries thathave ratified $onvention *rotocols
$hange wording of 0updated where necessary0 i"e" not allneeded updates have been done by this pro7ect
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 37/669
typo - hereafter $A9 ditorial%uperscript the footnote reference 1 ditorial
Accepted Te&t amendedtypo - word uideboo! missing ditorial
Accepted
ditorial
'oted Te&t amended"
'oted
Accepted9elete 2? - not future proof ditorial
Accepted
ditorial9elete 0and actors0 - its 7argon ditorialparties should have capital * throuighout chapter ditorial
ditorial eplaced All
Accepted
Accepted
'oted Te&t amended
,nclude info what is the purpos of this section Accepted
e7ected
'oted
$onvention - first time of use please write out formal nameof $onvention. define abbreviation (see general comment)and properly reference
Appendi& A should be dleted" ,t0s already inconsistent withthe latest " se instead te&t such as 0for thosepollutants for which reporting is re+uired as defined in the* reporting guidelines
$orrect typos in these bullets - procedures. users to. levelsof
;yoto protocol and ,**$ uidelines should be properlyreferneced at their first time of use
*lease insert compliance chec!ing under the *rotocols ofthe $onvention and an e&plicit reference to *modelling activities (disopersion and integratedassessment)
$ompliance chec!ing is alreadyincluded" There is reference tosuitability for monitoring" * isnow referenced directly"
*lease delete te&t 4%uch a !nowledgeL4 under rest of thesentence. this does not belong here
missions data is no longer reported to '$%ecretariat (now to $,*)" eword
'$ - reference this and defien abbreviation which is laterused - '$9 etc
*lease use the e&act wording of the last version of theuidelines (consult the %ecretariat)" The term 4emberstates4 must ':T appear. but 4*arties4
*lease chec! - 9efintions of T$$$A elements here needto be identical to the defintions used in the latest draftuidelines
9efinitions are now based on the,*$$ 26 uidelines"
,nclude para on ecalculations - it is very important andshould be highlited
A 'ote has been added to theTransparency definition
consider to change 0this0 to 0relevant0 or 0appropriate0directive
%ection 8 $oncepts are introducedin lines @-J
consider to change 0$oncepts0 to 0lossary0 or channge thesystem of paras instead of alphabetic order group
sysetmetic ( it ta!es some time to undersatand whatsabout )
,ntorduction amended" '"<"eadersmight rightly e&pect a glossary to be
more comprehensive and 9efinitionsis e+ually confusing in this conte&t"
This paragraph states that the guideboo! covers allpollutants. however there are significant shortcomings withregard to /$< and *A/s" The *A/0s have for stationarycombustion been lumped together"
The comment is not relevant to thissection of the uideboo!"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 38/669
e7ected
Accepted Te&t amended where possible
Accepted eplaced All
Accepted eplaced All
ditorial
'oted*arties0 should be *arty0s ditorialtypo - 0in that helps0 is missing a word(s) ditorial Added 4it4
*lease chec! - use of signatory versus ratified for the $ ditorial*arty T: theL ditorial
ditorialreplace covers with 0designed to0 ditorial changed to 0is designed to cover0
'oted
ditorial
Acceptedreplace gas with pollutant Accepted
Accepted
Accepted Te&t amendment made
Accepted te&t removedTe&t should be under the %cope section 'oted Te&t amended - no longer relevant
e7ected
T': will as a side pro7ect add information on new *:*sfor consideration into future protocols (also resulting fromproduct use)" *lease update the te&t accordingly
The Tas! Force relies on. and isgrateful for. contribution from anumber of countriesK it would beinvidious to ac!nowledge allcontributions"
*lease see general remar! to use of the term 4substance4
vs 4air pollutant4,n accordance with TF,*s decision. the uidelines areusing the term 4!ey category4. please be consistent withthe uidelines
terminology - do not use !ey source" The agreed termunder '$ is !ey category" $orrect here andthroughoput all chapters (also. do not captilisise this term ifused in middle of a sentence)
delete 0actual nature and0 " eproting formats are thesame for all directives . countries 7ust do not need tocomplete columns if not ratified protocols
consider to use 0$AT*0 and 0'$90 inventory instead of
TA* and '$ (trough the whole report)
* prefer TA*. '$ 9irective
used
The * should have been properly refernecedbefore. so donMt need full refernece and weblin! here
*ropose to delet Appendi& < in which case reference tothe Appendi& here should be removed
delete sentence - this is reporting specific and is different
for eg '$" ,nstead use te&t 0 A national total isLeachpollutnat and categories as defined in the repsectivereporting re+uirements
Added 4and category as defined inthe repsective reportingre+uirements4
consider to add sentence li!e 0elevant information shellbe provided in ,,0
delete reference to * uidance - is outdated andreplaced by -*T uideance" ,n any case , didnlKt seeany reference>common approaches with to *>-*Tuidance in later chapters so perhaps should be deleted"
*lease also introduce abatement as it fre+uently used in
compiling air pollutant inventoriesTe&t appears partly repetition of a prev paragrap. pleasestreamline
*refrably introductory te&t should be user manual li!e andnot a novel" ,t is not easy to find in the te&t what the useryou loo!ing after" $onsider to highlit the 0!ey words0 andother options to structure the te&t
'ot practical. would introduce toogreat a change to the style of thedocument"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 39/669
e7ected
Accepted Footnote 2 added"typo - or ,% missing ditorial
ditorial
Accepted *aragraph deleted"
Accepted Te&t abridged*arties - capital * ditorialreword - secreatriate no longer receives data ditorialuidelines need to be properly referneced ditorial
ditorial
Accepted
'oted
ditorial
$onsider to reference also *% directive ditorial
ditorial
Chat !ind of !ey sources are you refering to. avaerage inurope or G $onsider e&planation as a foonoteG
;ey $atgories are now a defiedconcept in section 8"
,n the $hapter there is a Table 8-8 which provides therating definitions and typical error ranges used in theuideboo!"/owever. there are commonly used ratingdefinitions developed by the% *A" All of the emissionfactors in e"g" A*-32 are given an *A+uality rating" These
have been copied in previous versions of$orinair where*A F0s have been given":ther % institutes. eg A*, alsouse the same +uality codes"/owever. the *A +ualityrating definitions and those in Table 8-8are not the same.and this could cause confusion if the userof the uideboo!is not aware of this",t is proposed that a new paragraph isadded after line 22. page @.7ust before Table 8-8. asfollows#4,t should be noted that the definitions of emissionfactor +uality ratings given in Table 8-8 are not the sameas the definitionsused by the % *A" Chere emissionfactors developed by the % *A or other Americantechnical institutes are used. the % ratings A. < and $can be considered to be e+uivalent to the ratings A. < and$ in Table 8-8" /owever. % ratings 9 and can beconsidered to be e+uivalent to ratings $ and 9 in Table 8-8"The % *A has no e+uivalent to the $orinair rating as allemission factors developed by the *A are frommeasurement andnot from engineeering calculation"4
*lease change te&t to 4L report emission data to the$onvention to fulfil their obligations under the *rotocols"These protocols areL
4elevance4 has not previously been defined (page 3).and needs some more e&planation" The remaining te&t ofthe par appears redundant with previous te&t
To support more easy maintenance , propose not
repeating the information from the uidelines here" Thesame applies to following paragraphs (e"g '$ and'F$$$). the te&t should be made more general
The $onvention on long-rangeLand its abbreviationdoesn0t need defining in every new subsection"
use word pollutnats instead of species (species meanssoemthing else)
missions should be reported in the 'F format for yearB-2 by the 1Ith February each yearK that is not a realistic
propositionK between 1I and 8 of arch will be morerealistic
'o longer relevant - te&t has beenamended
emove bold formatiing for / legislation - this isnMtdone elsewhere
'o longer relevant - te&t has beenamended
9onMt have gapo between ' F$$$ - is not commonlydone
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 40/669
'oted'/8 not ammonia for consistency ditorial
Accepted Footnote removed"
Accepted
e7ectedlegislation. not aw Acceptedtypo in title ditorialthe the ditorial
typo - sources ditorial
e7ected
'oted
Accepted Te&t amended
There is no mention of the on-going review of the '$9 -the te&t should be updated to reflect this
'o action ta!en. wherever possiblethe mention of time refereced eventshas been avoided for ease of futureupdating"
footnote 2 - has variuos superfluous sub-footnotenumbering included - delete" These documents shouldalso be fully references in the refernece list of the chaptetr
replace should with may" ,t isnMt 7ustified to ma!e such aconclusion here
'o mention of upcoming review of the - - te&tshould be updated to mention this important aspect
'o action ta!en. wherever possiblethe mention of time relative eventshas been avoided for ease of futureupdating"
9etails of the enrty into force of the protocol should begiven
The ;iev protocol . while adopted in28. has yet to come intor force"'o action ta!en. wherever possiblethe mention of time relative eventshas been avoided for ease of futureupdating"
The international *T started at the conference in io deDaneiro in 1JJ2 where all countries were in the so-called
Agenda 21 advised to establish a *ollutant elease andTransfer system" :$9 too! the lead for supporting theseactivities in close cooperation with ',TA and '*chemicals" After a series of regional conferences it wasdecided to focus on more technical support using thee&periences from countries having already a moreestablished *T"
eference to to ',TA and '*chemicals introduced"
,n 2I the tas!force was merged with the ,:$ *Tcoordination group and is now called the *Tcoordination tas!force" seful products are sofar aresource centre built by nvironment $anada and recentlya *T portal (www"*T"net) providing lin!s withinternational and national *T activities and informationsources (also by nvironment $anada)" ,n 2? a the
following documents are e&pected# An overview of +ualitycontrol methods (Australie en %*A). methods forestimating emissions from small and medium siHedenterprises (Finland). and emissions from product use('ordic $ouncil)" Dapan is wor!ing on a paper called%haring and $omparing. ma!ing lin!s between emissionsand statistical data li!e national product or number ofinhabitants
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 41/669
'oted'ot polluting. but pollutant ditorial
Acceptedlater that year0 replace with october 2J Acceptedreplace 13 with 22 Accepteddelete final sentence Acceptedreplace signatories with *arties ditorialembership of the TF,* and the e&pert panelsL Accepted*lease delete 4should allow for maintenance and4. Accepted9elete 4e&pert4 ditorialChat is the 4verification4 panelG 'oted Te&t has been amended
Accepted 9ublin te&t inserted
delete# and will be sub7ect toL etc
'oted te&t removed
ditorial9elete 2? - not future proof ditorial
e7ected
Acceptedse numbering instead of bullets Accepted
Accepted eference to $,* included
$onsider to include headings * . TF,* (and $,*) e7ected
'oted
',TA is in 2? supporting Armenia. $h,le. cuador.*anama and Togo with some plans for further support iniddle America
,nformation not relevant totheuideboo!"
mention that -*T also goes beyond re+uirements ofthe protocol (more polls. strciter thresholds)
Added 4it goes beyond there+uirements of the protocol.
covering more pollutants with stricterthresholds4
The te&t deviates slightly from the panel T: agreed in9ublin. is any difference 7ustifiedG
%entence changed due to earliercomment
*lease consider shortening. e"g describing all TF,*meetings would re+uire an annual update of theintroduction"
reword - maintenance of the technical content of theuideboo! is the responsibility of the TF,* e&pert panels
ma!e bold all the $:,'A,BB so the user can see thedevelopment"From the te&t it is not clear what is thecurrent system" At the end of this section should be clearlydefind how is refered current system and include also infoon new e&tended 'F main sectors"
necessary - this is 0additionalinformation0" uidance on using theuideboo! - and the lin! between'F and %'A* is provided in boththe ,ntroduction and the section onhow to use the uideboo!
te&t not updated" 9elete refernece to T$>A" %tateagain here that TF,* is responsible for the technicalcontent and A for hosting
$onsider to ,nclude para e&plaining the role of the *$entre on mission inventories and *ro7ections ($,*)http#>>www"emep-emissions"at>ceip>
necessary - this is 0additional
information0"
chec! - * is not formed by a protocol , believe (ite&isted before the convention)" eplace formed with0funded via0
The 1J?3 *rotocol on ong-termFinancing of the $ooperative*rogramme for onitoring andvaluation of the ong-rangeTransmission of Air *ollutants inurope (*)K 32 *arties" nteredinto force 2? Danuary 1J??"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 42/669
Accepted
Accepted Te&t made more generic
Accepted
$apitalise ember %tates 'oted Add ;osovo to the list Accepted
%: report needs proper referencing 'oted
e7ected Appendicies removed
Accepted
e7ected Appendicies removed
e7ected Appendicies removed
e7ected Appendicies removed
e7ected Appendicies removed
e7ected Appendicies removed(b) add""" and emissions from $ultivation of ice e7ected Appendicies removed
e7ected Appendicies removed
e7ected Appendicies removed
e7ected Appendicies removed
e7ected Appendicies removed
Title of chapter and header is spelt wrong" ethodological5 ditorial $hanged title and headers
Accepted references have been revised
9T - 0develops the * emissions inventory basedon emission data from *arties0 - it doesn0t"
delete 'F$$$ and ;yoto and replace with '$ andTA* $onvention
roup %witHerland with ,celand etc and call FTA(uropean free Trade Area countries)
4ember %tates4 already removed infavour of 4*arties4
Te&t amended to ma!e it genericand. as elsewhere in the te&t.mention of dated information sub7etto regular review is avoided"
Appendi& 1 A *ollutants. The list of *:* does not matchwith list of the
,nclude in row 9io&ins# 4e&pressed as 4,nternational To&ic+uivalents4 ,-T=4
,nclude more clear definition of *2"I and *1 (possibly' 12831 standard NO 4real world4 *2"I and *1measurements always include larger particles)"
*lease add the additional *:*s proposed added to theprotocols (consult /ugo at T':)
consider to incclude column with aggregations used frogridding " %ee http#>>www"emep-emissions"at>fileadmin>inhalte>emep>doc>Anne&,,,PPAggregationPPgriddedPPdataPDan2?"doc
, suggest to include in Appendi& < 4%ectors by 'F code4correspon- ding %'A* code
*lease use the latest version. consulting ;atarina (<A-
) Qthere are some smaller differencesR
Table 4Fuel4# For all pollutants e&cept $:2 it doesn0 ma!emuch sense to divide %C into biomass and fossilfractions because emission factors will be available onlyfor total %C"
The claim that the guideboo! includes default emissionfactors for all sources and pollutants where applicable issimply not correct" The guideboo! should containguidance. but many pollutants from many sources arelisted as not estimated"
eneral# please also define natural vs anthropogenic
(included in national totals)*lease append a list of abbreviations (%'A*. TA*.TF,*""")
$hapter contains many cross references to other ,*$$olumes. ,*$$$ uidance sections" All need deleting orrewording
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 43/669
e7ected
typo - uncertainty ditorial
emovals not repoted under TA* convention Accepted removals removed"
$hange 4+uic! and dirty4 to 4simple4 ditorial
Accepted Te&t added
ive a proper reference for the 0present0 uideboo! ditorial
ditorial
Accepted Te&t 9eleted
ditorial
Accepted Te&t 9eleted
Chat does S refer toG $orrect Accepted Te&t 9eleted
'oted Te&t will be clarified
'oted Te&t will be clarified
$an sin!s be deleted in '$ conte&t
'oted Te&t will be clarified
e7ected
'oted Te&t will be clarified
'oted Te&t will be clarified
Accepted Figure will be reproduced
Accepted Te&t changed
Accepted Te&t changed
9ecison tree. please delete reference to sin!s Accepted Figure will be reproduced
The title of the chapter should be added 4and identificationof !ey categories4
Title is included already in theheading bo&"
,nsert te&t stating the +uality criteria of Tier 8 (sent byemail 2@"11"@)
Chat is meant by 4the present <4G *lease redraft to 4theprevious *>$orinair uideboo!L4
9elete these sentences - referencs to the 0present0(e&isting now) < are very confusing for future readersand will be irrelvant onve the updated version is published
To be more clear 4The present uideboo!4 should bereplaced with 4the 2@ *>$:,'A, uideboo!4"
,f this way of describing methods is !ept in the guideboo!the Tier wording has to be changed accordingly
The analysis is based on single pollutants. so this te&twould mean that the inventory compiler would loo! fordecision trees etc in sector chapters for categories and forpollutants"
olume < - incorrect ,**$ cross-reference - delete or
correct
%ection < - incorrect ,**$ cross-reference - delete orcorrect
,nventory anagement is not the proper name of thechapter
This an improved version of the,*$$ =A>=$ chapter with moredetailed guidance on inventorymanagement"
olume A incorrect ,**$ cross-reference - delete orcorrect
olume < - incorrect ,**$ cross-reference - delete or
correctFigure 1 does not print well and is unreadable - repaste inat higher +ualityG
/ inventory compiler reference - incorrect ,**$wording - delete or correct
*lease delete reference to 4greenhouse gas inventory4(comment applies throughout the chapter)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 44/669
e7ected
ood - captialise ditorial Te&t changed
ditorial Te&t changed
pollutant - , thin! !ey categories is meant ditorial
Anne& 1 - there is no Anne& 1" Appendi& AG ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
typo - particulate ditorial
Accepted Te&t changed
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
accepted
accepted
accepted
Add %ection before 2"3"8
eneral# The proposed !ey-category approach (singlehandling of each substance) will lead to the fact thatalmost all categories will be identified as !ey" ,n practicethis would re+uest whether the use of different (simple anddetailed) approaches for one given source category
depending from the substance or the general treatment ofthe entire inventory whit detailed approches" <oth waysproduce avoidable wor!"Ce propose to include a !ind of normation of the releasedemissons e"g" by using accidification potentials (or other4transferring4 parameters li!e for 'F$$$ the use ofC*-values)" This would streamline the results analysisdue to the inclusion of more than one substance in oneapproach"
,t was agreed in 9ublin in :ctoberthat a normation approach shouldnot be applied and each pollutantevaluated in its own right" Accifiyingpotentials would only address asubset of pollutants and would notresolve the issue for otherpollutantsL
, assume the proper reference here is not the 4goodpractice guidance4. please add the correct reference of the
26 uidelines
%ince no 4anne& 14 is available we guess this refers to4Appendi& A4
Approach 2 - add relevant chapter cross reference e"g"%ection 2"B"B
/ow to ta!e cross-correlations into account is not (neitherin the ,*$$ 26) described" An inclusion of a te&t as inthe ,*$$$ 26 p3"@ note 2 should be considered"
table 1 - put in an Appendi& - too long for the body of thete&t
9o once other changes made so notto lose page reference
arge table which does not include very helpfulinformation"
9o once other changes made so notto lose page reference
The b footnote should reflect the 'F codes" The cfootnote is irrelevant
*lease compare with latest 'F list and correct asappropriate" *lease chec! table font (appears mi&ed. alsoin the footnote)
9o once other changes made so notto lose page reference
Table footnote $- what does this mean in the <conte&tGGG Assessed 7ointly is relevant to /s onlyGG
9o once other changes made so notto lose page reference
Footnote to table - b - reference to ,**$ needs deleting orrewording ('FG)
9o once other changes made so notto lose page reference
$onsult with&pert*anel
don0t !now what is meant by thiscomment""
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 45/669
incorrect / inventory reference - delete or correct accepted Te&t ammended
accepted Te&t ammended
accepted Te&t ammended
accepted Te&t ammended
accepted Te&t ammended
accepted Te&t ammended
%uperscript footnote references I and 6 ditorial Te&t ammended
change footnote references to upper case ditorial Te&t ammended
e7ected
accepted te&t will be ammended
emovals relevantGG accepted te&t will be ammended
typo - dispersed ditorial te&t will be ammended
accepted te&t will be ammended
e7ected
incorrect ,*$$ referenceG - there is no Table 8"8 accepted te&t will be ammended
%!ip 4or removals have increased4" accepted te&t will be ammended
%!ip 4or decrease of removals in the future4" accepted te&t will be ammended
*lease ma!e a reference to the ,, accepted te&t will be ammended
accepted &le will be provided
accepted &le will be provided
This section must be adopted to air pollutant inventories# i)reference to sin!s must be removed from the te&t ii) thee+uantions should be substantially simplified when sin!s
are not considered (see the ,*$$ * 2) iii) changereference to / inventories to air pollutants
Footnote 8. there are no '$ emission reporting.please provide the proper reference
The chapter tal!s about reenhousegas inventories" For A*s we do not e&pect 4removals4 so that we can s!ipcalculation of absolute values"
,s sin!>removal anywhere relevant for 'F reporting (,t isnot for 9anish reporting)G ,f not. then change the te&taccordingly"
Are removals relevant to '$ inventory conte&t - if notdelete
%ince the analysis is to be carried out for each pollutant.the pollutant should be in the heading not as a column"
,t helps with the optional step 2 tohave the pollutant as a columnfeature"
Footnote 6 - incorrect / inventory reference - delete orcorrect" %in!s relevantGG
For A*s we do not e&pect 4removals4 so that we can s!ipcalculation of absolute values"
%ince the analysis is to be carried out for each pollutant.the pollutant should be in the heading not as a column"
,t helps with the optional step 2 tohave the pollutant as a columnfeature"
&les on the actual pollutants and 'F categoriesshould be wor!ed out
A +uarter of this chapter is dedicated to illustrate !eysource analysis. too many pagesG Chy showingcontributions of sources that are not !ey sourcesG ,s thechosen e&le relevantG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 46/669
e7ected
accepted te&t will be ammended
accepted te&t will be ammended
!ey categories in bold" 'o they0re notG
accepted &le will be provided
accepted &le will be provided
accepted &le will be provided
accepted &le will be provided
ditorial
Appendi& A is not mentioned in the te&t - it needs to be Accepted
'oted Te&t clarified
its not it0s ditorial
'oted
$orrect caption numbering ditorial
The e&le relates to / when $TA*>'$9reporting does not concerns /"
The e&les still illustrate theapproach ada+uately
The !ey sources are defined per pollutant in the newuideboo!. when the e&le illustrates an otherdefinition (!ey sources defined for the different / asC*)"
,t is confusing to display category codes within thee&le that are not consistent with the recommendedones (cf" table 1). as far as they relates to the new ,*$$categories. from ,*$$ 26 which are not yet appliedeven for 'F$$$ reporting yet"
tables needs to be put in Appendi& - is far too long forbody of the chapter
table 3 - $an we not 7ust have an e&le relevant for airpollutants instead of /sG
*lease provide an e&le for an air pollutant inventory
(one substance) rather than this e&le copied from the/ inventory guidance
$hapter 2"6 &les of !ey category analysis should bedeleted. if the reference is given in the spec" chapter in the,*$$$ . then it should be refer to that" :therwise ane&amle with the air pollutants should be given5
eneral# Ce propose a reference system instead of+uotation of all these detailed tables 3. I. 6. @. ? (ta!enfrom the 'F$$$ uidelines)"
$onsult with&pert*anel
eferences should be in correct order of date ie ,*$$2 before ,*$$ 26
,s the e&ercise meaningfull and is the results to be usedfor methodology demandsG
$onsult with&pert*anel
,t is now mentioned at the bottom ofsection 2"2
This is a mathematical e&ercise weighing all pollutantsidentically and weighing categories accordingly" (Chat ismeant by the te&t refering to the anne& (page I line @) thatit consolidate the pollutantG)
The e&le assumes JI treshold for !ey categories butthe !eysource chapter recommends ?"
issue clarified in te&t" There are
limited e&les for Air *ollutant;ey $ateogrit analysis""
,f the intention is that countries should perform a combinedran!ing of different pollutants it should be addressed in themain chapter and not only as an appendi&"
$onsult with&pert*anel
it was agreed to move it ot an anne&by the A and discussed in 9ublin"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 47/669
'oted
'oted
'oted will clarify
noted
typo ditorial
already have a Table 3 in the chapter - renumber ditorial
':& ditorial
will clarify
will clarify
4rror5 <oo!mar! not defined4 ditorial pdated contents table
!ey sources should be !ey categories ditorial Amended
Accepted * 2. lines 28 added
Accepted
Full stop missing ditorial Amended
*lease define % (or better rewrite) ditorial % updated to icrosoft
*lease provide reference to * measurement guidance Accepted
Accepted &les added
The method for combining the !ey category analysisdecribed in Appendi& A is not mentioned nor referenced inthe main chapter"
,t is now mentioned at the bottom ofsection 2"2
Chat is the result of the proposed combining procedure in Anne& 2G $ould this be used to minimise the overallnumber of !ey-categories in the sence of comment 1G"g" by inclusion of all results for the different substancesin these combination procedure" ,t would re+uest atreshold value to identify the 4overall-!ey-categories4"
That was the idea"" To minimise thenumber of !ey categories" ,t wasagreed to offer it as an option only""
*age 82 line 11 states that this combined ran!ing%/:9 be done. however the described approach isonly mentioned as a possible approach"
The individual ran!ing and scoring for the ran! placng canbee seen in the right columns"
Chy the definition of fuels is given in Appendi& <. it is alsogiven in $hapter 1 ,ntroduction Appendic $ FuelsGGG
$onsult with&pert*anel
Chat is this table doing hereG ,t is misplaced and alreadyincluded in the introduction" *lease correct
$onsult with&pert*anel
The same fuel table is already included in *art4,ntroduction4"
ention clearly in introduction that section draws heavilyon ,*$$ - eg as done for chapter time series consistency
,n adopting this to air pollutants. the focus must includeuroean sources. eg urostat and -*Ts>*Ts
Test amended to include specificmention of :%TAT and datareported under the *T
'ote added to Table 2"1 andreference included"
For some of the points the understanding is not very clear", suggest to include some typical e&les for each pointto increase the usiblity of this list also for 4measurementdummies4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 48/669
emove bullet point ditorial Amended
*roper references needed for $' standards e7ected
*roper reference needed for ' ,%:>,$L Accepted dited where necessary
ditorial Amended
delete final colon from the title ditorial Amended
Accepted Te&t added to *@ 2"1"1"
Accepted &planatory paragraph added"
ditorial Cill re-assign
'o such sections as 1"3 and 1"I" $hec! and correct ditorial reference corrected
1"8 should be 2" $hec!" ditorial reference corrected
typo - component an air pollutantL reword ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
'o such section - chec! and correct ditorial
typo - insert L0necessary0 to prepare""" ditorial
'o such section as I"2"8 - chec! and correct ditorial
ditorial
typo - to A**U different ditorial
e7ected
ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
$' standards are referred to as'
references should be put in ascending date order" seauthor (date) title format throughout (for boo!s as well asarticles)
eneral# guidance on use of *T data is missing andmust be added
eneral# reference to guidance for collection of spatialdata is missing
$hapter contains many cross references to other ,*$$olumes. ,*$$$ uidance sections" All need deleting orrewording
good practice guidance0 is ,*$$ 2" $larify wording -0good practice guidance of the ,*$$26 guidelines0 if thatis what is meant
evise 4is a central component an4 e"g" 4is a centralcomponent of an4
$apital for reporting" *rovide proper reference at firsttime of use
Footnote 2 - :verall rather than overlapG $hec! e+uationnumbering - there is no e+uation I"1" $orrect different fontsiHes within footnote
corrention made to the font and thee+uation number"
%ection numbering - use a 8 digit heading before a 3 digitheading (there is no 2"1"1)
Figure I"2 - correct figure numbering (the I has nomeaningG)
Figure I"1 - correct figure numbering (the I has nomeaningG)
Figure I"2 - correct figure numbering (the I has nomeaningG)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 49/669
ditorial
<o& numbering - remove I ditorial
+uation numbering emove I from I"2 ditorial
<o& numbering - remove 6 ditorial
ditorial
<o& numbering" section not %ection ditorial
se 8 digit heading numbering ditorial
Accepted note added
<o& numbering ditorial
<o& numbering ditorial
ditorial
Add table numbering ditorial
table numbering - no I ditorial
ditorial
table numbering - no I ditorial
table numbering - no I ditorial
ditorial
table numbering - no I
ditorial
references - arrange in ascending date order ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
Accepted
Figure I"1 - correct figure numbering (the I has nomeaningG)
Figure I"8 - correct figure numbering (the I has nomeaningG)
9efine AF: from figure caption (or delete as notrelevant to '$ inventories)
Add horiHontal lines to table to improve readibility - 8rdcolumn not aligned properly
olumes - incorrect / inventory reference - delete orcorrect
%ince the F:9 has a chapter on =A>=$ the refernce inthe parenteses should presumably be changed from the,*$$ to the F:9 chapter
olumes - incorrect / inventory reference - delete orcorrect
eneral# This chapter has been copied from ,*$$ ls.
and need to be properly review with the ob7ective ofchanging terminology and references to this manual"Furthermore. figure numbering needs to be changed
,f nowhere and for none of the pollutants sin!>removal isactual the te&t should be loo!ed through and revisedaccordingly
%ince 4base year4 might not be precise>uni+ue to the airpollutants the te&t should be loo!ed through>revised"
Foot note added to e&plain <aseUear"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 50/669
Accepted $hec!ed
Accepted
Accepted 9onencertainties chapter - paragraph not article Accepted $orrected
e7ected
Accepted 9onencertainties chapter - paragraph not article Accepted $orrected
Accepted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted 9eleted
Accepted
ncertainties chapter - eferences not in reference list Accepted
ncertainties chapter - eference not in reference list Accepted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
ncertainties chapter - eference not in reference list Accepted
ncertainties chapter - eference not in reference list Accepted
ncertainties chapter - eferences not in reference list Acceptedncertainties chapter - 9elete if Appendi& is empty Accepted 9one
eference to sections and tables does not match thesections and table headings"
ncertainties chapter - There are a number of referencesin the te&t not provided in the references list" $hec! andcorrect
eference sections (main te&t aswell as appendi&) chec!ed andcompleted
ncertainties chapter - incorrect reference draft
28GG pdate to 2? draft or the e&isting final 28
ncertainties chapter - Chy table 6"(1)G $orrectnumbering - 6 is not relevant
ncertainties chapter - incorrect reference draft 28GG pdate to 2? draft or the e&isting final 28
ncertainties chapter - Footnote 3" A number of referencesare provided with no details given in the reference list" Addto reference list or delete"
eference sections (main te&t aswell as appendi&) chec!ed andcompleted
ncertainties chapter - Fig 8"I" correct numbering - thereare no Figures 1-3
ncertainties chapter - AF: - define or preferabledelete - not relevant to '$ inventories
ncertainties chapter - Add references to reference list" And those in footnote 6
eference sections (main te&t aswell as appendi&) chec!ed andcompleted
eference sections (main te&t aswell as appendi&) chec!ed andcompleted
eference sections (main te&t aswell as appendi&) chec!ed and
completedncertainties chapter - Chat are approaches 1 and 2"these are not defined at all in the chapterG $orrect ordelete
ncertainties chapter - 'ot consistent" %ection 8"2"8 doesnot give details of Approaches 1 and 2
eference sections (main te&t aswell as appendi&) chec!ed andcompleted
eference sections (main te&t aswell as appendi&) chec!ed andcompleted
eference sections (main te&t aswell as appendi&) chec!ed andcompleted
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 51/669
'oted
4principles4 not principals Accepted $orrected
Accepted Te&t added
Accepted Te&t modified
Add referencing for ,*$$ documents Accepted
4e&pamnds4 -O 4e&pands4 Accepted
Accepted 9one
Accepted
*lease reference the 2? uidelines Accepted
Accepted 9one
:ne from the data providers would be facility operator Accepted 9one
* eporting guidelines - add proper reference Accepted 9one
According to me all the chapter is very clearK perhaps forbeing more practicable could be appreciated someoperating e&les related to the management inventoryreport (for e& some sheets related to the main phases(data re+uest>raw data>compilation>=AP=$)) suggesting a
way to include all info as introduced in paragraph 3"6
At this point or>and in the paragraph 2"2 could be betterdistinguished the difference between 4inventory manager4and 4inventory compiler4" As for the first one in page 2 line1J. it0d be specified that also the inventory compiler couldbe an individual or staff. one institution or more institutions",f the inventory manager is e&ternal to the inventory
compiler staff. the last one need generally a chiefinventory compiler staff" *robably in the case of smallgroup they can overlap" Anyway , suggest to point out.also ahead. that the inventory manager (or chief inventorycompiler staff if different) is responsible for the technicalstaff management (how to share resp. if for sectoral ortrasversal topics. how to attribute internal deadline. how tointroduce and guarantee that internal reports in thedifferents steps must be filled etc"). as financial budgetmanagement to guarantee hwPsw. data ac+uisitionavailability. inventory related e&ternal consultants etc"
Footnote 1 - *arty not party" $hec! $ signatory or ratifiedprotocols
eference however should be to the'F$$$ reporting uidelines here"
*lease harmonise with latest version of the draftuidelines (see also comment to the introduction)
These T$$$A criteria have different definitions to those inthe < ,ntroduction5 They should be consistent with theformal definitions in the latest version of the draftuidelines
$opied definitions from the draftguidelines
Added a reference to the still draft
2@ uidelines4,nventory compilers. virtual or real institutions.4 , suggestto substitute with 4,nventory compilers. one o moreinstitutions.4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 52/669
4detailed energy statistics4 , suggest to remove detailed Accepted 9one
9elete +uite string and replace with fi&ed Accepted 9one
4incventory4 -O4inventory4 Accepted 9one
delete 2nd part of sentence following Authority e7ected
I should be 6" eorder bullets once corrected Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted te&t updated
Accepted ,t is good practice to L
9elete bit. replace with rather Accepted 9one
4sectoral inventory4 ,0d suggest to remove sectoral Accepted 9one
Accepted
Table 1. please ma!e e&plicit reference to the ,, Accepted 9one
Figure 3# please change references to $F Accepted 9one
*lease update the te&t for air pollutant inventories e7ected
Accepted 9one
'o such bo&" $orrect or delete Accepted te&t removed
Ce believe that in a te&t bo& li!e thisone the suggestion to harmoniHewith the 'F$$$ is usefulK thelaguage is a bit wee!ened though"
%tyles - not consistent across chapter i"e" sometimes evelone headings are A $A*%. sometimes %entence case.sometimes Title $ase" 'eeds to be standardised"
A bit confusing the reference to year ' and 'V1 (line 22)and to year ' and 'V1 (line 86)" ,t coul be briefly e&tendedthe first sentence 4compiling an inventory is an annualprocess4 (line 1J) by mentionning that activities can
9elete should and replace with may" (,t0s not a re+uirementfor parties)
the figure is very interesting. only few comments" %omesymbols referred to documentation aren0t clear fore&le 4uni+ue reference4K , suggest to move down4e&plain large changes4 as it could be referred to all theprevious parameters comparison>balance" The legendshould be highlighted to be distinguished from the otherrectanglesK the figure is a bit compressed. there are somete&t characters with different dimensionsK4$F4 and 4'F4compare for the first time in the chapter. maybe can bereferred to general glossary or referred in the te&t
eplaced $F by 'F in twochec!s" ade figure a bit larger"&plain large changes is the first of adifferent !lind of chec!s" Thereforeorder not changed"
The / guidance here can providesupport for air pollution inventories
Table 1. there are no good practice guidance for airpollutant inventories. please change the terminolog
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 53/669
Accepted 9one
typo Accepted 9one
typo O Accepted 9one
replace will with may Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
e7ected *resent te&t is clear
partial te&t - delete Accepted 9one
e7ected
enthoven et al. 23 is not included in 4references4 e7ected ,t is included i nthe references
van elthoven et al for 8 or moe authors Accepted 9one
'A$* missing from reference list - include Accepted $ouldn0t find it. reference removed
,n -O An Accepted 9one
table - data provider# An institutionL Accepted 9one
e7ected 9o not understand this
missions reporting guidelines should be in reference list Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
e7ected
,n alidation L" 4is4 -O 4,s4 Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
,*$$ refereences need completeing Accepted 9one
e7ected ,s in data collection issues
9elete protocol provisions as this is confusing (not allprotocols reflect this)" ,nstead refer to the applicable te&t inthe uidelines
,0d suggest to move in the previous part (4institutional4 or4contact person4)
4institutional4 , suggest to change with or to add also4contact>reference person4
4technical4 ,0d suggest to change with software or archiveaspects
A,'% should be mentioned as a !ey source ofverification here (both activity data and emissions)
A,'% is to be fed by national
reported data. rather than the otherway around"
*lease discuss the role of * modellering data forverification purposes
=uality Assurance - %ection 6"I - no such section - deleteor correct
, suggest to enlarge the 4,nventory system4 definition. allthe institution involved in the emission inventoryplanning>compilation>dissemination etc""
,7n our view this is e&actly what ismeant
*eter vanL references should be ordered by surname not
first name" 9ate missing from reference details
*lease discuss the role of *T data in =A>=$ (e"gverification)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 54/669
Accepted %ee te&t bo&
e7ected 9o not understand this
ditorial
is A%: re+uired ditorial
Accepted eference moved to eference list
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
emove after !ey spatial data sources 4"4 ditorial
add para on %'A* ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
e7ected Terms left in" ,% added
typo - gross ditorial
Accepted te&t deleted
eneral# many *arties have integrated 'F$$$ andTA*>'$ inventories. but not all" The authors of thecurrent chapter seems to assume the former" This issue(institutional set-up) should be better e&plained. perhapseven in the introduction (see e"g figure I)
eneral# *lease define inventory compiler. under the
$onvention the responsibility lays with the 4designatedemission e&perts4
,nstead of referring to gothenburg. refer instead to theeporting uidelines as the driver for reporting"(technically various < decisions also implement spatialreporting and not 7ust the protocol - its easier 7ust to referto the )
eporting guidelines- use the reference list for referencing- not footnotes
styles - different chapter sections are in different fonts"
%tandardise throughout$hapter name might be changed to reflect reporting ofgridded data alsoG - 0%patially disgagregated emissionsmapping0G
$urrent heading is sufficient toinclude gridding"
$hapter could mention in introduction the basic wor! of thechpater was developed by A0s T$>A$$"
%ome areas of additional guidance are missing from thechapter (which the uideboo! consultants agreed tocomplete after ta!ing over responsibility from T$>A$$ forcompletion of the chapter") %pecifically. augmentedinformation on data sources and methods for mappingforest fires. biogenic :$ emissions. shipping and
aviation should be provided and included in the final draftof this chapter"
This guidance will be included in thefinal version"
, suggest to substitute here and after 4I&I !m grid4 wirh4I& I !m24
, suggest to add after 4their dispersion partners4 4andimpact area4
Among 4eneral Terms4 , suggest to !eep terms morerelated to spatial mapping. (such as 'T%. surroggate
etc". ,0d include 4,%4 definition) and remove those as4/94 and 494 for e&le"
9elete mention of associated proposed directives - its notat all clear which proposed directives are being tal!edabout here
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 55/669
ditorial
"" by an & and y coordinate4s"4 ditorial
Accepted te&t changed
%ay also when the protocol entered into force ditorial
Accepted te&t to be changed
Accepted te&t to be changed
Accepted 'ote added
Appendi& not Anne& 6 ditorial
Accepted te&t changed
typo identify toG ditorial
typo delete misses ditorial
Accepted te&t added
/9# /eavy 9uty ehicles are vehicles with a grossvehicle weight of W 8.I !g NNOOOO /eavy 9uty ehiclesare vehicles with a gross vehicle weight of O 8.I !g
,0d try to mention an e&le for each surrogate resolutionlevel>type and !eeping possibly the same order 4as landuse coverage pecentage by grid. vehicle flow by road lin!.employers number by industrial point. population byadministrative boundary
eferences for the various legislative acts should put inthe references. not in footnotes" 9elete footnote 3 givenearlier comment about the whole table should be deleted
this *% definition is very messy - mi&ing up -*T anduidelines aspects" ather directly refer to the uidelinesas the source where the definitions of *% for reportingunder the convetion and its protocols can be found"ention also that defintions of *% (sectors. thresholdsetc) can differ between different reporting mechanisms"9on0t provide details of the reporting thresholds andpollutants here - instead refer 7ust to the uidelines wherethese are defined" This will help avoid inconsistencies"ention of the -*T reporting thresholds and failitydefintions should be deleted as they confuses the issuetoo much here"
9efinition of *%# anything is written about th e stac!
height. which is also an important parameter for spatiolresolution and the * gridding"
, suggest to mention that also 4trasport emission can behandled sometimes as area soources. for e&le arcsthat are too numerous or information are not available tobe individually identified as line sources4"
Those cases they can be treated as area sourceas polygon or as area source as grid by the use ofdifferent surrogate variable (for e&le as percentage of
linear emission density or from fuel balance. as differencebetween total fuel and linear traffic fuel induced)
, suggest to invite compilers to the use when possibile ofthe spatial surrogate used for spatial mapping in previousyears to guarantee consistency
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 56/669
Accepted te&t added
delete and - T%G
Accepted te&t changed
Accepted te&t changed
'ot 3"2 - should be 3"8 $hec!" ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
Accepted te&t added
not Anne& ,,. it0s Appendi& ditorial
Accepted te&t added
Accepted
Appendi& not Anne& 6 ditorial
$omplete reference list for T,% ditorial
Apmosphere reference - <riggs not <rigg ditorial
Accepted te&t added
As the 4e&le 14 is a bit far from the referring te&t. ,suggest to include the corresponding page (e"g" &le1. 4pag J4)
*erhaps the emission total to be distributed is 4emission t4
instead of 4emission i&4, suggest to include in formula note ""to an 4(i)4 specificgeographic feature
styles - delete full stop from heading and all headings fromhere on
$hec! - does the latest $:,' provide 3I or moreGandcovers
Dust provide one generic lin! to A dataservice - specificlin!s become outdated
:%TAT has several useful agricultural datasets. e"g"
From the Farm %tructural %urvey
The $:*T refernece can be updated to latest v3manual available on the $:*T website
eference to uidelines should be updated to latest draft.not the Thessalini!i one (or final version when agreed)
There is no mention>consideration given in the chpater tothe gridded 'F 'F which parties are re+uired toreport spatial data in" This is a ma7or omission from thechapter and needs to be corrected" At least some shorte&planation needs to be given on how 'F emissions maybe aggregated to the 'F and reference made to thedraft uidelines where this is defined" ,deally pro&yvariables for each of the 'F sectors should also beprovided
$onsult with&pert*anel
'eed to ensure we respect theboundary between reporting andmethodological guidance"
,t should be noted in the te&t that updated information on gas connections etc may be available from urostat>,Aetc" This should be chec!ed before being stated
%ee previous comment - surrogates should also be givenfor 'F sectors. as this is the minium that some *artieswill be able to do
$onsult with&pert*anel
'eed to ensure we respect theboundary between reporting andmethodological guidance"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 57/669
'oted
'oted
Figure numbering inconsistent ditorial
Figure numbering inconsistent ditorial
Accepted will add
Figure numbering inconsistent ditorial
Accepted
ditorial $hanged all to ;ey $ategorieschange 4though4 to 4through4 ditorial
ditorial
ditorialdelete 4data4 ditorial
Accepteddelete 4to4 ditorial 9oesn0t really ma!e a differencechange 4and4 to 4or4 ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
Accepted Te&t added to paragraph"
/opefully this might enhance the accuracy andconsistency of the reported emission data" ,t would be nicealso to include a section describing this issue in theguideboo!"
Ce recommend. that a common harmoniHed ,% themeon coast line and territorial sea should be available for the
member countries reporting gridded emission data" This toavoid the use of themes with different resolution and levelof generaliHation"
* is e&tening area to the east . consider to provideinfo and add map with e&tended * area
, miss any reference to the various guidance material
developed for % compilation and reporting of /pro7ections under the wor!ing group of the $ climatechange committee" This at least should be referred to"
,ncluded footnote and reference inthe reference section"
Throughout chapter. references need chec!ing (te&t toreference list and vice versa)
Throughout chapter mi&ture of !ey sources. !ey categoriesand different capitalistaion is used - ;ey categories. ;ey$ategories etc" please standardise
4*ro7ections are usually much less certain than the historicinventory and re+uire""" 4
4uidance on tac!ling common problems associated with
gathering appropriate data onL4
9efinition of 4without measures4# what technology hasachieved to date. is confusing" specially comparing withterminology on p"8. l"16# without measures scenariosusually start from a convinient historic year"
modified te&t to remove reference totechnology
Footnote. line1- change 4and4 to 4or4" ine8. delete4resulting4
Footnote 1# ine 1 9elete 2nd 0and0" ine 8 9elete0resulting0 9elete 0resulting0
9elete 0present0 and replace by 0represent0 or 0derive from0or 0reflect0
Footnote# *olicies and easures and can be laws - delete4and4
Co scenario" 'o actual guidance on how this scenarioshould be developed i"e" are emissions to be pro7ectedfrom a base-year based on 9* for e&leG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 58/669
'oted
$hange 4with4 to 4where4 ditorial
$hange 4post the historic year4 to 4are4 ditorial
ditorialduplication of (b) on line 1 and subse+uent lettering ditorial
Accepted Te&t updated
'oted Te&t left unchanged"
'oted Te&t to be updated"
4targets. which has now been superceded"4 ditorial
change 4estimates4 to 4estimated4 ditorial4L based on a range of datasets. includingL4 ditorial
Accepted Te&t added to paragraph"
Accepted Te&t added to paragraph"
eneric te&t on determining cost-effectiveness is not veryhelpful" %ome guidance on how an costs can bedetermined would be useful"
$onsult with&pert*anel
%ome references will be includedwhere they are available"
Ce do not understand this definition" The starting year isonly 1JJI or 2G :r may be the latest year of historicinventoryG Ce thin! that this should be topic of discussion
in Tallinn on pro7ection e&pert panel"
The description has been e&tendedto include some proposed
methodology for calculation (seesomment in line 16 above"
Te&ted changed due to anothercomment
Te&ted changed due to anothercomment
Te&t nclear. , suggest 0Lscenarios can include theestimation of 4what would have happened4 if the measuresalready implemented since the historic year had not beenimplemented"0
(c) and (d) are a bit vague- it is not clear how they could
differ from the others" ,t might be helpfut to give e&lesof eachG
,t would be also good practice to clearly define themeasures that the C. Co and Ca scenarios refer"
The definitions used for Cith measures and with additionalmeasures should be fully in line with what is re+uired forfuture reporting under '$ and - (or in the draft* eporting uidelines or draft decisions if this isspecified there)" At present the defintions presented here
differ. and thus need to be harmonsied with thosespecified in the formal reporting re+uirements"
,n the definition for 4Cith easures4 an agreed date.beyond which policies and measures are not considered.should be mentioned" For e&le. legislation. policiesand measures in place by 81st of 9ecember of theprevious year will only be considered under the 4Citheasures4 scenario" *olicies implemented in the currentyear. when the pro7ection is being prepared should beincluded in the 4Cith Additional easures4 scenario"
$onsult with&pert*anel
,t depends how much detail you want to go into here but.the marginal cost curve in terms of a plot of total +uantityof pollution avoided against the marginal cost of reductionin euros>tonne. is often used"
Future assumptions could also be based on behaviouralchanges or structural changes in society"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 59/669
ditorial
Accepted Te&t added to paragraph"
Accepted Te&t added under 8"?Figure - can0t read the te&t on some sections of this Accepted ade more clear
AcceptedUou could give an e&le eg road traffic model Accepted te&t added
Accepted te&t clarified
Accepted pdated4An emission factorL4 ditorial
Add a comma after 4;ey %ource4 ditorialeffect ditorialformula is singularK plural is formulae or fomulas Accepted Te&t changedL""and involves ditorialevise sentence beginning at ( Accepted te&t changed
ditorialsector0s ditorialNAds should have upper case 9 ditorial
Accepted Te&t $hanged An emission factor ditorial
e7ected
mission pro7ection scenario should be compiled - eitherscenarios should be plural or the sentence should start4An emissionL4
There can also be regional considerations thatnecessitates that a measure is carried out despite the factthat it does not the biggest emission reduction for the
lowest cost" For e&le health considerations in urbanareas"
eneric te&t on the use of 4energy models4 to determinebasic growth factors" uidance on which models arerecommended would be useful"
Flow $hart# 9ecision 9iamond 2- The last sentence is 0orare current emission factors ade+uate0 to which ,answered yes and am then told in Tier 2 to use a futureemission factor" , thin! you have to be clearer on what+uestion you answer yes or no to
a!e te&t in the Tier 2 bo& read L""(or ada+uate current emissionfactors)
'ot clear what is the difference between Tier 8 and Tier 2"Tier 2 mentions ta!ing 4reasonable account4 of futureactivity changes" 'ot very specific"
'o caption" Figure poor +uality and unreadable whenprinted" *aste in higher +uality versionG
<e consistent in the use of 0emission factor0 and 0emission
rate0" ,nsert comma after %ource
The emission factor for a source using a specifictechnology or control in year n
*age @. formula 2 (row 26)# in the denominator is A9n.where in row 88 is A9n N A9sSFn" <ut on page ?. row 1.the formula for A9n is sum of A9t for tN1 to p" ,f we set theformula from page ? to formula 2. then the formula 2 willbe sum of the emission factors for tN1 to p" Ce thin!. thatin formula on page ? (row 1) should be correct A9tNsum of
A9t for tN1 to p (not A9n)"
Te&t definition of Adt changed toclarify that A9t is a sub source of
A9n
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 60/669
Accepted Te&t added4L so that a measureL4 ditorial4L methods. theL4 ditorial
Available - uppercase A ditorialcomma after methods ditorialits measures ditorialneed to be bro!en down Accepted Te&t added
Accepted 9efinition addedF9 is Flue as 9esulphurisationG ditorialF9# abbreviation is not e&plained ditorial
Accepted Te&t added than! you"
Accepted Te&t added to clarify"portray a picture consistent with ditorial $hanged with another commentLin from L ephrase ditorial
Accepted Te&t and reference added"
ditorial
ditorial4The energy related emissions should be chec!edL4 ditorialchange 4matched4 to 4match4 ditorial4L estimates" The overallL4 ditorial
ditorial
, thin! that it is worth stating in general terms that in somecomple& detailed sectors there can be an interractionbetween the emission factors assumed for pollutantcontrol technologies and the pro7ected activity data" For
e&le in electricity generation the underlying activitydata maybe future electricity demand" The energyconsumption of the power sector must be consistent withthe electricity demand and the efficiency of the future mi&of power stations" The control measures applied (eg F9.%$. carbon capture and storage) will affect the efficiencyof the power stations and hence fuel consumption" Thusthe assumed mi& of emission factors affects the fuelconsumption data" ,n such cases the assumed mi& ofabatement technologies is an input to the model whichpredicts energy consumption"
ither include a definition of %tratification here. or refer toit0s definition somewhere else
*ossible addition to list" $ompare pro7ected trends in data(emissions or activity) with historic trends- if there aresignificant differences then need to e&plain why" This is
based on a general observation that nationalemissions>activity data tend to change gradually (thoughnot always eg '2: emissions in chemical industry)
Ce need some te&t to e&plain what this figure means- alsoit loo!s as if the arrows are displaced
There is nothing in this section referring to best practiceused in historic compilation" ither include a reference toanother section of the uideboo!. or add the followingte&t#
&le of simplification - arrows need to be re-aligned in
diagram4,t is important to ensure that the resulting emissionpro7ections are consistent with the underlying input data"The following chec!sL4
4L inventory should be consistent with the energy balancefromL4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 61/669
4The transitionL4 Accepted Te&t modified"
4L pro7ection must be realistic" $hec! for L4 e7ected
'oted Te&t modified"4L are correct. and that revisions are transparent"4 ditorial
4L results and what were the sources of the difference"4 ditorial
e7ected te&t left the samesectors ditorial
Accepted &le Addedbased on measured ditorial
ditorial4L based on measuredL4 ditorial
4to assume that pro7ections are the same as those forL4 ditorial $hanged from another comment
Accepted %ome te&t added"'eed a heading 4mission factors4 Accepted %ome te&t added"pro7ected ditorial
ditorial
Accepted *aragraph movedtypo ditorialchange 4improve4 to 4improving4 ditorialchange 4are based4 to 4or based4 ditorial
4L employed to ma!e allL4 ditorialThis para is about sensitivities. should it be moved GG Accepted *aragraph moved
Accepted Te&t ammendedchange 4latst4 to 4latest4 ditorial
bullet replaced with moreappropriate te&t"
4L noted" ,f there is a large step change. then methodswill need to be modified"4
ore sensible to use domestic as the e&le for bothe"g"0s
&le# The emission limit value defined by the largecombustion plant directive (9irective 21>?>$) for newcoal plant is 2 mg>'m8 ':& as ':2 (X6:2)"
Applying an appropriate volume factor for coal of 863m8>D ('$) gives a pro7ected emission factor of @2"?g>D coal consumed" (eference for the volume factor israham. 9*. %alway . ay. *" %tac! as Flow ate
$alculation for missions eporting - Aguide to $urrent<est *ractice for the :perators of $oal Fired<oilers".*T>@>$322> ay 2@
'eeds re-wording eg" ""no surrogates available for sourcesectors. it is good practice to assume the pro7ected valueis the same as the latest historic yeear"
,ncluding the impact of non-technical measures is
mentioned" 'o guidance on how this +uite comple& tas!could be carried out"
mission pro7ections are always modelled 4and4 are basedonL"
$hanged by another comment to4or4 based
The paragraph is listed under the headline 4ncertainties4.however it seems to be referring to sensitivity. which isdescribed from line 26"
$hanged sentence to ma!e moresense. not in e&actly the waysuggested"
9efine $AT and provide proper reference in referencelist
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 62/669
Accepted te&t changed
Accepted te&t changed
ditorial
Accepted te&t changed
Accepted te&t changed
Accepted te&t changedThis isn0t a bullet point ditorial
, note that %ectoral :verview of ethods has been cut 'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted te&t added
'ot a good e&les because recent catalytst are notemitted higher '/8" $hoose something simple e"g"aviation
A Co scenario should not be listed as a necessaryactivity for compiling emissions pro7ections"
change 4be in accordance4 to 4have a methodology that is
consistent4
, thin! some more detail is re+uired ie some sort of listrefering to elements discussed in previous sections" eg"values and sources of activity data used. F factors used.emission factors. details of tiers. sector definitions. sectorstratification. assumptions made in deriving future Fs"
Again reference to =A>=$ activities referred to in te&t-chec!ing. energy balances. etc
*roperly define reference for current guideboo!*>TF,* (28) etc
, e&pect there are similar interractions in transport egpro7ected air !m and airccraft mi&K vehicle !m and vehiclemi&"
uidance for pro7ections is very generic" The 26uidance is more comprehensive
4The best practice principles for emission inventorycompilation also apply for pro7ections" Therefore theresulting pro7ections will need to be transparent. accurate.consistent. complete. and comparable"4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 63/669
Comments Additional note(s)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 64/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 65/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 66/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 67/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 68/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 69/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 70/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 71/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 72/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 73/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 74/669
':T# not all * members are members"
The uidance for *T is regime specific and notinformation of the same generic type as that in the te&t"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 75/669
Added 4of4
:verlap is meant as this describes the e+uation"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 76/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 77/669
6 is chapter number. this is the format for table>figurenumbering chosen"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 78/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 79/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 80/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 81/669
Dustin might li!e to chec!
eporting is A%: re+uired""
'eeds new guidelines referenceG
$an we change the chapter nameG
Aviation and 'ational 'avigation methods are alreadyinccluded
This is supposed to include relevant terms used for thechapter"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 82/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 83/669
Cill propose some te&t for thisL
%ee above Cill propose some te&t for thisL
ight want to chec! this is the best way - one of those lin!shas already been updated5
:! but the underlying purpose of the uideboo! is certainlyto assist with reporting (this is why for e&le it isstructured to 'F which is a reporting re+uirement. and nota methodological re+uirementL)" ,t is indeed strange thatthe chapter doesn0t mention 'F at all given this role ofthe <" %ome information>consideration of 'F needs tobe added"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 84/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 85/669
1JJI and 2 are possible starting years for a C:scenario" :ther years can be chosen"
easures will be different for different %" Ce can not beprescriptive about what measures belong where in the CCAs scenarios" The boundary for C is clearly definedin the C te&t inder items a- f"
9efinitions will be brought into line" /owever. as this is thelatest document in the evolution of our understanding there
may be some enhancements to the definitions in thisdocument over that of the eporting uidance"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 86/669
Te&t in diagram will be changed"
Te&t definition of Adt changed to clarify that A9t is a sub
source of A9n
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 87/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 88/669
more appropriate te&t provided
This e&le is good because it shows the lin!agesbetween different sectoral data for pro7ections"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 89/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 90/669
Chapter_Name NF_Code
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1 1 2J ?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1 6I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 2 2 2 21
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 I ? I 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 I 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 I 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 6 2 6 I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 6 J 12 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 6 11 nergy industries 1"A"1 6 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 6 23
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a @ ? @ 1I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a @ 1J
Chapter _ID
FromPage
ToPage
FromLine
ToLine
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 91/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a ? 2 ? 23
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a ? 2I J 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a J 82 J 88
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a J 821 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1 8@ 1 8@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1 8 11 ?1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1 21
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 11 @ 11 ?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 11 18 11 18
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 92/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 18 11 18 12
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 18 12 18 12
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 18 18 18 13
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 18 1? 18 21
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 18 121 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 18 18
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 18 18
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 13 1@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 13 2@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 13 2@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 1I 1I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 16 1@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 1J 23
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 93/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 1J 23
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 94/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 1J 8 2@ 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 21 21
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 22 22
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 28 28
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 28 28
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 2I 2I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 2I 3 2I I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 2I 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 26 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 26 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 2? 6 2? 6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 2J 11 2J 18
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 2J J 3 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 2J 26
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 2J 2?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8 1?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8 21
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8 2I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8 81 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 81 21 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 81 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 95/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 88 11 88 11
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 88 @1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 83 88
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 83 88
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 83 83
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8I I 8I I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8I I 8? 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8I I 8? 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8I I 8? 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 96/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8I I 8? 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8I I 8? 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8I 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 86 1 86 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8@ 1 8@ 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 97/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8@ 3 8@ 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8? 8 8? 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8? 8 8? 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8? 1 8? 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 98/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8? 8 8? 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8J 1 8J 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8J 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 8J 8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 3 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3 I 3 12
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"c 3 21 3 21
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"c 3 21 36 3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 99/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"c 3 21 36 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3 121 nergy industries 1"A"1 32 32
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"c 32 1I 32 1I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"c 38 28 38 28
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 33 1 33 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"c 33 1 33 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"c 33 8 33 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 100/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 36 1I 3@ 11 nergy industries 1"A"1"c 3? 3? 3? 86
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 I1 2 I2 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 I2 2 I8 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a I8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b I8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a I6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 IJ 2 IJ J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 101/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 IJ 2 IJ J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 61 28
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 68 I
1 nergy industries 1"A
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 102/669
1 nergy industries 1"A
1 nergy industries 1"A
1 nergy industries 1"A
1 nergy industries 1"A
1 nergy industries 1"A
1 nergy industries 1"A
1 nergy industries 1"A"1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 103/669
2 1"A"2 1 I2
2 1"A"2 2 18 2 13
2 1"A"2 8 1 8 2
2 1"A"2 8 1 8 2
2 1"A"2"c I 82 I 83
2 1"A"2 ? 81 ? 83
2 1"A"2 ? 2@ J 2@
2 1"A"2 12 2 12 2
2 1"A"2 12 I 12 I
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 104/669
2 1"A"2 12 3 12 3
2 1"A"2 12 3 12 3
2 1"A"2 18 2 18 2
2 1"A"2 18 I 18 I
2 1"A"2 18 1 18 1
2 1"A"2 18 1 18 1
2 1"A"2 18 3 18 3
2 1"A"2 18 1 18 2
2 1"A"2 18 3@
2 1"A"2 13 2 13 2
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 105/669
2 1"A"2 13 I 13 I
2 1"A"2 13 1 13 1
2 1"A"2 13 1 13 1
2 1"A"2 13 1 13 1
2 1"A"2 13 3 13 3
2 1"A"2 13 13 3? 3
2 1"A"2"a 1I 18 1I 18
2 1"A"2"a 1I 11 2 3
2 1"A"2 1I 3J
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 106/669
2 1"A"2 1I 1 11
2 1"A"2 16 16
2 1"A"2"a 16 8 16 8
2 1"A"2"a 16 6 16 6
2 1"A"2"a 1@ @ 1@ @
2 1"A"2"a 1@ 2 1@ 3
2 1"A"2"a 1@ 2 1@ 3
2 1"A"2"a 1@ I 1@ ?
2 1"A"2 1? 1?
2 1"A"2"a 1? 2 1? 2
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 107/669
2 1"A"2"a 1? 1 1? 2
2 1"A"2"a 1? 1 1? 2
2 1"A"2 1? 1J
2 1"A"2"a 1J 8 1J 8
2 1"A"2"a 1J 1 1J 8
2 1"A"2"a 1J 1 1J 8
2 1"A"2"a 1J 1 1J 8
2 1"A"2"b 2 2 2 3
2 1"A"2"b 2 2 2 3
2 1"A"2 2 26
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 108/669
2 1"A"2"b 2 1 2@ 8
2 1"A"2"b 21 1 21 8
2 1"A"2"b 22 1 22 8
2 1"A"2"b 22 1 22 8
2 1"A"2"b 22 1 22 8
2 1"A"2"b 22 1 22 8
2 1"A"2 22 2I
2 1"A"2"b 28 1 28 8
2 1"A"2"b 28 1 28 8
2 1"A"2"b 23 1 23 8
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 109/669
2 1"A"2"b 23 1 23 8
2 1"A"2 23 2@
2 1"A"2"b 2I 2 2I 3
2 1"A"2"b 2I 2 2I 3
2 1"A"2"b 2I 2 2I 3
2 1"A"2"b 26 1 26 8
2 1"A"2"b 2@ 1 2@ 8
2 1"A"2"d 2? 2 2? 3
2 1"A"2"d 2? 1 2J I
2 1"A"2"d 2J 8 2J I
2 1"A"2"d 2J 1 2J 2
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 110/669
2 1"A"2"d 2J 1 2J 2
2 1"A"2"d 2J 8 2J I
2 1"A"2 2J 3
2 1"A"2"f"i 8 1 8 1
2 1"A"2"f"i 8 8 8 I
2 1"A"2"f"i 8 2 81 3
2 1"A"2"f"i 8 2 81 3
2 1"A"2"f"i 81 2 81 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 81 2 81 8
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 111/669
2 1"A"2"f"i 82 1 8I 3
2 1"A"2"f"i 82 8 8I 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 82 8 8I 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 82 1 8I 3
2 1"A"2"f"i 88 8 88 I
2 1"A"2"f"i 88 8 88 I
2 1"A"2"f"i 83 1 83 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 83 1 83 8
2 1"A"2 8I 8I
2 1"A"2"f"i 8I 1 8I 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 8I 8
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 112/669
2 1"A"2"f"i 86 1 8J 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 86 1 8J 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 8@ 1 8@ 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 8@ 1 8@ 8
2 1"A"2 8@ 2
2 1"A"2"f"i 8? 2 8? 2
2 1"A"2"f"i 8? 2 8? 2
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 113/669
2 1"A"2"f"i 3 1 3 3
2 1"A"2"f"i 3 1 31 2
2 1"A"2"f"i 3 1 31 2
2 1"A"2"f"i 31 1 31 2
2 1"A"2"f"i 31 1 31 2
2 1"A"2"f"i 32 8 32 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 32 8 32 8
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 114/669
2 1"A"2"f"i 32 1 38 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 32 1 38 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 38 1 38 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 33 1 36 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 33 1 3? 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 3I 2 3I 2
2 1"A"2"f"i 3I 2 3I 2
2 1"A"2"f"i 36 1 36 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 36 1 36 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 3@ 8 3@ 8
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 115/669
2 1"A"2"f"i 3@ 8 3@ 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 3@ 1 3? 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 3@ 1 3? 8
2 1"A"2"f"i 3? 1 3? 8
2 1"A"2 I1 1 I1 1
2 1"A"2 I1 1 I2 1
2 1"A"2 I2 I2
2 1"A"2 I2 2 I2 3
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 116/669
2 1"A"2
2 1"A"2"a
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries and
construction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 117/669
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 118/669
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
2 1"A"2"f"i
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1 18 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2 I 2 I
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2 J 2 1@
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2 J 2 1@
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 8 13
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 3 @ 3 1@
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 3 1? 3 22
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 3 1J 3 22
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 3 83
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
anufacturing industries andconstruction (combustion)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 119/669
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a I
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 6 1 6 1
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a @ 12 @ 18
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a @ 2 @ 88 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a @ J @ 1
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a @
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a ? @ ? 18
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a J ? J J
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a J
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1 1
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 11
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 12 31 12 32
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 12 31
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 18 18 18 2?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 120/669
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 18 82 13 188 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 13 2J 13 82
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 13 1? 13 82
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 13 13 1@ 3
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1I 1 1I 2
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1I 1 1I 2
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1I
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1@ 1 1@ 3
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1@
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1? @ 1? 18
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1? 16 1? 1@
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 121/669
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1? 28 1? 23
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1? 1I 1? 23
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1? 2I 2 1
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1?
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1? 6
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 1? @
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2 1
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 122/669
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 21 22
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 22 8 22 J
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 22 12 28 ?8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 28
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2I 6 26 1
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2I 2J
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2I
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2I 38 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 26 I 26 6
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 26 @ 26 @
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 26 J 2@8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 26 11
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2@ @ 2J 6
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 2J 18 82 11
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 81 6 81 J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 123/669
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 83 16 83 1@
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 83
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 8I
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 86 2J 86 8
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 3 6
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a 32 38
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 124/669
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
8 $ivil aviation 1"A"8"a
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 1
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 1 8 2
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 8 8 1@3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 ? 8 J
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 18 8 133 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 1J 8 2?
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 28 8 2I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 125/669
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 1 8 11
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 8
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 I
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 @
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 1
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 1J3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 23 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 21
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 83 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 88
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8 8I
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 3 23 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 33 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 3 J
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 6 2J 6 83 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 6 @3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 6 8I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 126/669
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b @ 1 @ 2
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b @ 1 @ 13
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b @ I 1I ?
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b ? 13 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b ? 18 ? 18
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b ? 12 1I 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 127/669
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b ? 12 1I 8
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b ? 12 1I 83 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 11 2 11 23 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 12 2 12 23 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 18 2 18 23 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 1I 8 1I 83 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 1I 8
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 16 2J 81 13 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 16 81
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 16 2J
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 1@ J 81 2
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 23 26
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 81 8I
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8I J 8I 13 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8I 16 8I 16
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 128/669
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8I 16
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8I 2
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8I 1@
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8@ 3
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 8J ? 8J 1?
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 3 6 3 18
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 33 1 33 8
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b"iii I8 2I I3 833 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b I8 83 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b I8 ?
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b I8 12
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 129/669
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b II
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b I?
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b"iii 68 26 6I 2J
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 6@
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b @3
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b @6
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 1 I 1 @
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 1 @ 1 ?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 130/669
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 1
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 1@ ? 1@ 13
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b 11I 1 11?
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 131/669
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
3 oad transport (e&haust) 1"A"8"b
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 132/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 1 81
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 2 12 2 13
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 2 1J 2 2@
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 2 2I 2 2@
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 2 @
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 2 11
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 2
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 26 2 2@
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 133/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 2 8 I
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 @ 8 13
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 26 8 2@
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 3 8 3
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 8J 3 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 @
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 134/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 16
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 2?
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 2J
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 8
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 82
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 8 8I
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 3 ? 3 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 135/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 3 @
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 3 ?
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I I I 11
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I 3 I 18
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I 1 I 2
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I I I 6
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I 1 I 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I 1I I 1I
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I 1 I 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"<" I 8 2 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 136/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 6 ?
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 6 @
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 6 1@
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 6
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 6
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v @ ?
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v ? 18 J 83
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 137/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v ? J
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v ? 18
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v ? 18
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v ? 18
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v ?
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v J ? J J
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v J 12 J 18
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 138/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 1 12
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 12 J
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 18 1 18 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 18 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 13 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 1I 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 139/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 1I 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 1I 2
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 1I 22
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 16 18 16 13
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 16 @
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 16 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 140/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 1@ 1 1@ 1
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 1J 11
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 2 ? 2 J
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 2 2
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 21 8
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 21 @
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 22
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v 28 3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 141/669
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v
I oad transport. gasoline evaporation 1"A"8"b"v
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1
6 1"A"8"b"vi 2 1 2 1I
6 1"A"8"b"vi 2 28 2 2I
6 1"A"8"b"vi 2 1
6 1"A"8"b"vi 2 13
6 1"A"8"b"vi 2 1@
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre and
bra!e wear and road abrasionoad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 142/669
6 1"A"8"b"vi I 2
6 1"A"8"b"vi 6 8
6 1"A"8"b"vi @ 88
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1 J 12 1
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1 1
6 1"A"8"b"vi 11 1 12 1
6 1"A"8"b"vi 12 1 18 2@
6 1"A"8"b"vi 18 83
6 1"A"8"<", 13 6 2? I
6 1"A"8"b"vii 13
6 1"A"8"b"vii 13 18
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre and
bra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre and
bra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre and
bra!e wear and road abrasionoad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 143/669
6 1"A"8"b"vi 13
6 1"A"8"b"vi 13
6 1"A"8"b"vi 13 1I
6 1"A"8"b"vii 1I 16
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1I 21 16 2
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1I 21 16 2
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1I 12
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1I 1I
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1I 1J
6 1"A"8"b"vii 16 1?
6 1"A"8"b"vi 16 6
6 1"A"8"b"vi 16 2
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1@ 6 1@ ?
6 1"A"8"b"vii 1@ 28
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1@ 13
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre and
bra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre and
bra!e wear and road abrasionoad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 144/669
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1@ 13
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1@ 16
6 1"A"8"b"vi 1@ 22
6 1"A"8"b"vii 23
6 1"A"8"b"vii 2I
6 1"A"8"b"vii 26
6 1"A"8"b"vi 26 11
6 1"A"8"b"vi 26 1?
6 1"A"8"b"vi 2@ 3
6 1"A"8"b"vi 2? 1
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 145/669
6 1"A"8"b"vii 2J 18 2J 1?
6 1"A"8"b"vi 2J 2 2J 8
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8 8
6 1"A"8"b"vi 6 6
6 1"A"8"b"vii
6 1"A"8"b"vii
6 1"A"8"b"vii
6 1"A"8"b"vii
6 1"A"8"b"vii
6 1"A"8"b"vi
6 1"A"8"b"vi
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre and
bra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 146/669
6 1"A"8"b"vi@ ailways 1"A"8"c 3 16
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 6 1I 6 21
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 6 18 ? 1
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 6 J@ ailways 1"A"8"c 6 18
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 6 2
@ ailways 1"A"8"c @ 1? @ 23
@ ailways 1"A"8"c @ 2J @ 82@ ailways 1"A"8"c @ 2
@ ailways 1"A"8"c @ 1?
@ ailways 1"A"8"c ? 2 J 2
@ ailways 1"A"8"c ? J
@ ailways 1"A"8"c J@ ailways 1"A"8"c J
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 1 2J 1 2J
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 1 2J 1 2J
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 11 2 11 23
oad transport. automobile tyre andbra!e wear and road abrasion
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 147/669
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 11 2? 11 2?
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 11 2 11 23
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 11 2? 11 2?
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 11 2I 11 2?
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 11 3
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 12 2I 12 8@
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 12 2 12 2@ ailways 1"A"8"c 12 ? 12 ?
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 12 22 12 22
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 12 2 12 2@ ailways 1"A"8"c 12 ? 12 ?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 148/669
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 12 22 12 22
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 12 28 1I 18@ ailways 1"A"8"c 13 @@ ailways 1"A"8"c 1I @
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 16 1 16 1
@ ailways 1"A"8"c 16 1 16 1
@ ailways 1"A"8"c
@ ailways 1"A"8"c
? 1"A"8"d 8,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 149/669
? 1"A"8"d 3 82 3 32
? 1"A"8"d 3 82 3 32
? 1"A"8"d I 2 I 11
? 1"A"8"d I 1I I 1@
? 1"A"8"d I 1I I 1@
? 1"A"8"d I 23
? 1"A"8"d 6 2@ 6 1J
,nter(national) navigation. national
fishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 150/669
? 1"A"8"d @ 2 @ 2J
? 1"A"8"d 1 11
? 1"A"8"d 11 16 11 1?
? 1"A"8"d 11 16 11 1?
? 1"A"8"d 11 1?
? 1"A"8"d 11 1?
? 1"A"8"d 11 21
? 1"A"8"d 8I 6 8I 13
? 1"A"8"d 8I 6 8I 13
? 1"A"8"d 8I 1
? 1"A"8"d 8I 1
? 1"A"8"d 86
? 1"A"8"d 86
? 1"A"8"d 86
? 1"A"8"d 86
? 1"A"8"d 8@
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. national
fishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 151/669
? 1"A"8"d 8@
? 1"A"8"d 8?
? 1"A"8"d 8?
? 1"A"8"d 8J ?
? 1"A"8"d 8J 81
? 1"A"8"d 8J ?
? 1"A"8"d 8J 81
? 1"A"8"d 8J
? 1"A"8"d 3 1 3 8
? 1"A"8"d 3 23 3 2@
? 1"A"8"d 3 1 3 8
? 1"A"8"d 3 23 3 2@
? 1"A"8"d 3@ 3 3? 2
? 1"A"8"d 3@ 3 3? 2
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 152/669
? 1"A"8"d 3? 6 3? 11
? 1"A"8"d 3? 6 3? 11
? 1"A"8"d 3? 3J
? 1"A"8"d 3? 26
? 1"A"8"d 3J
? 1"A"8"d I 83 I1 2?
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 153/669
? 1"A"8"d I 83 I1 2?
? 1"A"8"d I8 1 I8 1
? 1"A"8"d I8 1 I8 1
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 154/669
? 1"A"8"d I8 1
? 1"A"8"d I8 1
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
,nter(national) navigation. national
fishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 155/669
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
,nter(national) navigation. national
fishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 156/669
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
? 1"A"8"d
J *ipeline compressors 1"A"8"e"i
,nter(national) navigation. national
fishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. national
fishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
,nter(national) navigation. nationalfishing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 157/669
1 %mall combustion 1"A"I 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 2 28 2 28
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 2 2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 8 1 8 12
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 8 1J 8 1J
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 8 22 18 11
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 8 18
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 158/669
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 3 @1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 I 86 I 86
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 6 16 6 3
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 6 3 6 3
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 @ I @ ?
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 @ 1? @ 2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 ? 88 ? 88
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 J 6 J ?
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 13 1I
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 16 1@ 16 88
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1? 1 1? 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 159/669
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1? 3 1? 6
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1? 11 1? 13
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1? @
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1J 1 1J 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1J 18 1J 18
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 1J 1 1J 1I
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1J 8@
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1J
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1J 13
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 1J 13
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 21 21
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 21 22
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 160/669
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 21 2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 22 22
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 22 22
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 22 1 28 2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 2I 2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 2@ 2@
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 2@ 1I 8@ 3
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 2? 23 2? 23
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 2? 23 2? 23
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 2J 1 2J 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 2J 1 8@ 2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 2J 1 8@ 2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 161/669
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8 1 8 2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 81 88
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 88 88
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 88 88
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 8I 8I
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8I 8I
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 8@ 8@
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"a"i 8@ 1 8@ 3
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8@ 8@
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 8? 1@ 8? 1?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 162/669
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 8J 18
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 3I 36
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 36 3?
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 3J 1 @1 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 @8 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 ?8 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 ?3 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 ?J 1 ?J 61 %mall combustion 1"A"3 J 1 JI 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3 J1 JI
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 163/669
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"a"i JI 1 JI J
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3
1 %mall combustion 1"A"31 %mall combustion 1"A"3
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i
1 %mall combustion 1"A"I
11 1"A"2"f"ii J 23 J 26
11 1"A"2"f"ii 18 1 18 18
11 1"A"2"f"ii 18 1I
11 1"A"2"f"ii 13
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 164/669
11 1"A"2"f"ii 1I
11 1"A"2"f"ii 16
11 1"A"2"f"ii 1@
11 1"A"2"f"ii 22 6 22 ?
11 1"A"2"f"ii 28 11
11 1"A"2"f"ii 28 18
11 1"A"2"f"ii 2? 81
11 1"A"2"f"ii 2? 81
11 1"A"2"f"ii 8@
11 1"A"2"f"ii 8@ I
11 1"A"2"f"ii 8? 16
11 1"A"2"f"ii 8J 1
11 1"A"2"f"ii 3 1@
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources and
machinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 165/669
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources and
machinery'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources and
machinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources and
machinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 166/669
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
11 1"A"2"f"ii
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a 2 6 2 6
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
'on-road mobile sources andmachinery
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 167/669
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a 2 6 2 ?
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a 2 6 2 6
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a 2 1@ 2 1@
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a @ 11 @ 11
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a J 3 J 3
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a J ? J ?
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a 1 8 1 8
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a 11 8 11 3
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a 11 3 11 3
12 $oal mining and handling 1"<"1"a
18 %olid fuel transformation 1"<"1"b J 13 J 13
13 :ther (please specify) 1"<"1"c 2 1 2 1
13 :ther (please specify) 1"<"1"c 2 1 2 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 168/669
1I 1"<"2"b 2 18 2 18
1I 1"<"2"a"i I @ I @
1I 1"<"2"a"i I J I J
1I 1"<"2"a"i I 26 6 2I
1I 1"<"2"b J 1I J 1@
1I 1"<"2"b 12 12 12 1@
1I 1"<"2"b 12 1I 12 1@
1I 1"<"2"a"i 13 6 13 6
1I 1"<"2"a"i 13 3 13 3
1I 1"<"2"a"i 1I 1 1I 8
1I 1"<"2"b 1I ? 1I J
1I 1"<"2"b 16 1 16 2
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 169/669
1I 1"<"2"b 1@ 23 2I 13
1I 1"<"2"a"i 1? 8 1? 23
1I 1"<"2"a"i 22 1 28 1?
1I 1"<"2"a"i 28 1J 23 8
1I 1"<"2"a"i 28 1J 23 8
1I 1"<"2"b 2@ 2?
1I 1"<"2"a"i
1I 1"<"2"b
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 2 ?
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 8 2
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 18 616 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 13 2 13 8
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 13 2
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 1I 21 1I 21
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 16 2
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 1@ 1? 1@ 1?
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oiland natural gas
&ploration production. transport of oil
and natural gas
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 170/669
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 1@ ? 1@ 1
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 1@ 2
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 1@ 2
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 1@ 2
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 1@ 2
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 1@ 2
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 2 1?
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 2 23
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 21 12
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 22 616 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 22 @
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 22 @
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 171/669
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 22 1I16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 22 1?16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 22 28
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 28 2 28 I16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 28 1
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 23
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 23
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 23
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 23
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 172/669
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 231@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 8 1
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 3 2@ 3 2@1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 3 2J
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 3 88
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v I 2
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v @ 1 @ 1
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v @ J1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v @ 2@
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v @ 881@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v ? @
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v ? 121@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v ? 1?1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v ? 211@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v ? 81@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v ? 8J1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v J 21@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v J 111@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v J 82
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 11 ? 12 121@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 11 1@
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 12 ?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 173/669
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 18 21
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 13 2
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 13 I
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1I 2
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1I I
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1I 6
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 16 I 1? 11
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 16 2
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 16 1
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1@ 2
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1@ 3
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1? 18 1J J
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1? I1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1? 161@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1? 21
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 174/669
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1? 21@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1J 2
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 1J 1J
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 2 6 2 1
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 2 1 2 1J
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 2 I
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 21 ? 21 J1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 21 1J1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 21 21
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 21 8
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 21 J1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 22 12 22 1J
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 22 1@
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 22 2I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 175/669
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 28 8
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 28 8
1@ 9istribution of oil products 1"<"2"a"v 28 8
1? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8 81 8 88
1? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 3 8 3 31? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 3 11 3 11
1? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi I 1 I 1
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 3 1@ 3 26
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 6 16 6 1@
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 176/669
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 6 1? 6 2
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c ? 13 ? 13
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c ? 11 J @1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c J 1 J @
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 1 13 1 1I
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 1 1J 1 21
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 1 2
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 11 81J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 12 2 12 21
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 177/669
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c
1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c
2 $ement production 2"A"1 1 1 1 1
2 $ement production 2"A"1 1 1?
2 $ement production 2"A"1 1 1?
2 $ement production 2"A"1 I 26 I 2@
2 $ement production 2"A"1 I 13 I 2I
2 $ement production 2"A"1 I 2I I 2I
2 $ement production 2"A"1 I 6
2 $ement production 2"A"1 I 2@ 6 I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 178/669
2 $ement production 2"A"1 J I J 1
2 $ement production 2"A"1 J 2 J 2
2 $ement production 2"A"1 J 2 12 8
2 $ement production 2"A"1 J 12
2 $ement production 2"A"1 J 12
2 $ement production 2"A"1 J 1
2 $ement production 2"A"1 J 1
2 $ement production 2"A"1 1 88 1 83
2 $ement production 2"A"1 1 16 1 16
2 $ement production 2"A"1 11 ? 11 J
2 $ement production 2"A"1 11 1 11 12
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 179/669
2 $ement production 2"A"1 18 132 $ement production 2"A"1 16 18
2 $ement production 2"A"1 16 1I
2 $ement production 2"A"1 1@ 1@
2 Total industrial processes 2
2 $ement production 2"A"1
2 $ement production 2"A"1
2 $ement production 2"A"1
2 $ement production 2"A"1
2 $ement production 2"A"1
2 $ement production 2"A"1
21 ime production 2"A"2 ? 2 ? 2
21 ime production 2"A"2 ? ?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 180/669
21 ime production 2"A"2 ? 1
21 ime production 2"A"2 J 2 18 8
22 imestone and dolomite use 2"A"8 1 3
22 imestone and dolomite use 2"A"8 2 21 2 22
22 imestone and dolomite use 2"A"8 2 J
22 imestone and dolomite use 2"A"8 8 1I
22 imestone and dolomite use 2"A"8 8 1J
22 imestone and dolomite use 2"A"8 8 22
22 imestone and dolomite use 2"A"8 8 23
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 1 6
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 2 1I 2 16
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 2 2I
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 3 2 3 2
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 3 3
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 3 1 3 228 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 I 2 I J
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 I 3 I I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 181/669
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 I @ I @
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I 1 1 1 1
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I 2 I 2 6
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I 2 1@
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I 8 11
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I I 1
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I 6 12 6 12
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I @ 2 @ 2
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I ? 3 ? 3
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I 11 2 11 2
23 Asphalt roofing 2"A"I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 182/669
2I oad paving with asphalt 2"A"6 1 1 1J 1J
2I oad paving with asphalt 2"A"6 3 2
2I oad paving with asphalt 2"A"6 @ 1I ? 8
2I oad paving with asphalt 2"A"6 18 8
26 2"A"@"a 1 I
2@ $onstruction and demolition 2"A"@"b 8 11 3 3
2@ $onstruction and demolition 2"A"@"b
2? 2"A"@"c 8 23
2? 2"A"@"c 3 1I
2? 2"A"@"c 6 16
2J 2"A"@"d 1 8@
2J 2"A"@"d 1 1 8@ 1
=uarrying and mining of mineralsother than coal
%torage. handling and transport ofmineral products
%torage. handling and transport ofmineral products
%torage. handling and transport ofmineral products
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 183/669
2J 2"A"@"d 8 82 8 83
2J 2"A"@"d 3 I 3 @
2J 2"A"@"d I 22 I 22
2J 2"A"@"d @ 8? @ 31
2J 2"A"@"d 11 1J
2J 2"A"@"d 12 81 12 83
2J 2"A"@"d 13 21 13 22
2J 2"A"@"d 1I 6 1I ?
2J 2"A"@"d 1? 3 1? ?
2J 2"A"@"d 2 16
2J 2"A"@"d 22 2 22 2
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*lease
specify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*lease
specify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 184/669
2J 2"A"@"d 22 2 8
2J 2"A"@"d 22 8
2J 2"A"@"d 23 2 23 2
2J 2"A"@"d 23 2I
2J 2"A"@"d 23 2 8 2
2J 2"A"@"d 2I 2I
2J 2"A"@"d 2@ 2@
2J 2"A"@"d 2@ 8
:ther mineral products (*lease
specify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 185/669
2J 2"A"@"d 2@ 8
2J 2"A"@"d 2@ 8
2J 2"A"@"d 81
2J 2"A"@"d 8I 1J
2J 2"A"@"d 86 8@
8 $hemical industry 2"< 2 J
8 $hemical industry 2"< 2 J
8 $hemical industry 2"< 2 J
8 $hemical industry 2"< 8
8 $hemical industry 2"< 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 I J I J
8 $hemical industry 2"<"2 6 1 6 1
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther mineral products (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 186/669
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a ? 1@ ? 1@8 $hemical industry 2"< J 88 J 83
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 18 16 18 16
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 18 16 18 1@
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 18 18 18 1I
8 $hemical industry 2"< 18 I 18 I
8 $hemical industry 2"< 18 J 18 I
8 $hemical industry 2"< 18 @ 18 11
8 $hemical industry 2"<"2 13 2 13 2
8 $hemical industry 2"<"8 13 J 13 J
8 $hemical industry 2"<"3 1I 1 1I 2
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I 1I 13 1I 1I
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 1I 13 1I
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 1@ 2I 1@ 2I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 187/669
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 1@ 28 1@ 2I
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 1@ 28 1@ 2I
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 1? 8 1? 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"2 1? @ 1? J
8 $hemical industry 2"<"2 1J 3 1J 6
8 $hemical industry 2"<"2 21 1 21 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"2 22 J 22 11
8 $hemical industry 2"<"8 22 12 28 2
8 $hemical industry 2"<"2 23 1 23 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 23 @
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 2I 1 2I 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 26 3 26 6
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 2? 1@ 2? 1@
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 188/669
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 2? 8 2? 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 8 8 8 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 8 1 81 88 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 81 18 81 18
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 81 6 81 J
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 88 1 88 8
8 $hemical industry 2"< 8I 8I
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 86 3 86 38 $hemical industry 2"< 8@ 8@
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 189/669
8 $hemical industry 2"< 8@ 18
8 $hemical industry 2"< 8? J
8 $hemical industry 2"< 8J 1 8J 1?
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 8J 1 88 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 32 1@ 38 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 190/669
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 32 16 1@
8 $hemical industry 2"< 38 1J 33 1I
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 38 2 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 33 13 16
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 3I 1 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 36 1 88 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 3? 8 3? J
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 3? J 3? J
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 3? 3 6
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 3? @ J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 191/669
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 3? 1
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 3J 21 23
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a I 6 I 6
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a I2 1 I2 1
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a I2 @
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a I8 2 I8 J
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a I8 1 8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a I8
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a I88 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a II 11 II 11
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a I@
8 $hemical industry 2"< I? I?
8 $hemical industry 2"< I? 6
8 $hemical industry 2"< IJ 1 IJ 1J8 $hemical industry 2"< 61 28
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 192/669
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 68 2 68 3
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 68 6 68 ?
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1 68 2
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 63 1J 63 21
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 6I 6 6I 6
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 6I 3
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 6I ?
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 66 22 28
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 66 2 21
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 6@ 8 3
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 6@ I @
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 6J 1 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 193/669
8 $hemical industry 2"< 16 @
8 $hemical industry 2"<"1
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 1 61
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8 2
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 3 2
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 I 21
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 6 28
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 11 J
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 11 81
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 11 8681 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 12 1@
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 18 3
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 18 1
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 13 11 1I J
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 16 3 1@ 2
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 1? J81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 21 6
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 22 1? 22 1?
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 22 22
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 22
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2I 11 2I 11
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 194/669
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2I 11 2I 11
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2I 2@
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2I J 2@ 6
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2I J 2@ 6
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 26 8 26 8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 26 8 26 8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 26 @ 26 @
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 26 @ 26 @
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 26 2@
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2@ 8 2@ 8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2@ 6 2@ 6
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2@ 6 2@ 6
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2@ 8 2@ 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 195/669
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2@ ? 8 8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2? 18 2? 18
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2? 2?
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2? 2?81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2? 12 2? 18
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 2? 8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 81 82
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 88 88
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 88 88
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 83 I 83 I
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 83 83
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 83 83
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 196/669
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8I 8 8I 8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8I 8I
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 86 86
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 86 86
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 86 8?
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8@ 8?
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8@ 8?
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 32 2? II 3
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 II I I6 16
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1
82 Ferroalloys production 2"$"2 1 6
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 197/669
82 Ferroalloys production 2"$"2 3 28 3 28
82 Ferroalloys production 2"$"2 3 22 3 28
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 2 2
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 1 1
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 1 1 1 2
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 1 2 18 I
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 1 18
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 1 18
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 12 8 12 3
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 12 8 12 3
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 12 8 12 3
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 12 13
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 198/669
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 18 8 18 3
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 18 8 18 3
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 13 13
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 13
88 Aluminium production 2"$"8 2 1 2 8
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 1 16
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 2 2
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 2 8 2 3
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 3 I
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a @ @
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a @ @
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 199/669
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a @ 13 @ 1I
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a @ 1I J 2
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a ? 1
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a J J
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a J 1 J 2
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 1 1
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 1 1 1 2
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 200/669
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 1 21
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 1 21
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 6 6
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 6 8 16 3
8I ead production 2"$"I"b ? ?
8I ead production 2"$"I"b ? 16
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 201/669
8I ead production 2"$"I"b ? 16
8I ead production 2"$"I"b J J
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 11 11
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 12 12
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 18 18
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 13 13
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 13 16
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 1I 1I
86 'ic!el production 2"$"I"c 1 ?
86 'ic!el production 2"$"I"c 2 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 202/669
86 'ic!el production 2"$"I"c 2 6 2 ?
86 'ic!el production 2"$"I"c 3 18 3 18
86 'ic!el production 2"$"I"c 3 3
86 'ic!el production 2"$"I"c 3 ? 3 J
86 'ic!el production 2"$"I"c ? ?
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 1 2
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 2 2
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 2 1 2 11
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 2 12 2 12
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d I I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 203/669
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d @ @
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d @ @ @ ?
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d ? 88 ? 83
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d J 2 J 2
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d J 12
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d J 1I
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 1 1
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 1 8 1 3
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 11 11
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 11 8 11 3
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 12 12
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 12 8 12 3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 204/669
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 18 18
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 18 8 18 3
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 13 8 13 3
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 1I 8 1I 3
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 16 16
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 16 1 16 2
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 1? 1@ 1? 1?
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 205/669
8? 2"$"I"e 1 ?
8? 2"$"I"e 3 3
8? 2"$"I"e @ @
8J 2"$"I"f 2 J 2 J
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 2 1I
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 2 @
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 I 163 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 @ 8@3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 18 @3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 18 @
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 16 2 16 2
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 16 2
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 1@ 8 1@ 8
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 1@ 1
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1 1? 8 1? 8
3 *ulp and paper 2"9"1
31 Food and drin! 2"9"2 11 2 12 2
31 Food and drin! 2"9"2 11 23
31 Food and drin! 2"9"2 16 @ 16 @
:ther metal production (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther metal production (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
:ther metal production (*leasespecify the sources included>e&cludedin the notes column to the right)
%torage. handling and transport ofmetal products (*lease specify thesources included>e&cluded in thenotes column to the right)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 206/669
31 Food and drin! 2"9"2 1@ 8 1@ 3
31 Food and drin! 2"9"2 1@ I 1@ @31 Food and drin! 2"9"2 1? 3 1? 3
31 Food and drin! 2"9"2 22 23
38 *roduction of *:*s 2" 1 8
38 *roduction of *:*s 2" 1 1 8 1638 *roduction of *:*s 2" 8 8
38 *roduction of *:*s 2"38 *roduction of *:*s 2"
33 $onsumption of *:*s and /s 2"F 1 1
33 $onsumption of *:*s and /s 2"F 6 6
36 *aint application 8"A 8 J 8 13
36 *aint application 8"A 8 13 8 1I
36 *aint application 8"A 8 2? 8 2?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 207/669
36 *aint application 8"A ? @ J 13
36 *aint application 8"A J 13 J 13
36 *aint application 8"A 1 2I 1 26
36 *aint application 8"A 1 2I 1 2636 *aint application 8"A 1 26 1 2636 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 236 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 236 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 236 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 236 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 236 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 236 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 2
36 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 236 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 236 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 2
36 *aint application 8"A 11 1 11 2
36 *aint application 8"A 11 1
36 *aint application 8"A 12 81 12 8@
36 *aint application 8"A 12 26 12 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 208/669
36 *aint application 8"A 12 2 12 2I
36 *aint application 8"A 12 1I 12 1J
36 *aint application 8"A 12 1I 12 1J
36 *aint application 8"A 12 16
36 *aint application 8"A 18 12 18 1I
36 *aint application 8"A 1I I 16 I
36 *aint application 8"A 16 22 16 28
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 209/669
36 *aint application 8"A 16 6 16 28
36 *aint application 8"A 16 22 1@ 3
36 *aint application 8"A 16 1@36 *aint application 8"A 16 22
36 *aint application 8"A 1@ 8 1@ @
36 *aint application 8"A 1@ 16 1? 82
36 *aint application 8"A 1@ 1
36 *aint application 8"A 1J 6 1J 1I
36 *aint application 8"A 1J 1J 1J 1J
36 *aint application 8"A 2 8 2 8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 210/669
36 *aint application 8"A 21 6 21 6
36 *aint application 8"A 22 8 22 8
36 *aint application 8"A 23 6 23 6
36 *aint application 8"A 2I @ 81 @
36 *aint application 8"A 2? 8 2? 8
36 *aint application 8"A 81 16
36 *aint application 8"A 82 21 82 8
36 *aint application 8"A 82 21 82 8
36 *aint application 8"A 83 1@ 83 83
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 211/669
36 *aint application 8"A 83 1@ 83 83
36 *aint application 8"A 83 1 83 @
36 *aint application 8"A 83 ? 83 16
36 *aint application 8
36 *aint application 8
36 *aint application 8
36 *aint application 8
36 *aint application 8"A
36 *aint application 8"A
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 212/669
36 *aint application 8"A
36 *aint application 8"A
3@ 9egreasing 8"<"1 @ ?
3@ 9egreasing 8"<
3@ 9egreasing 8"<"1
3@ 9egreasing 8"<"1
3? 9ry cleaning 8"<"2 ? 1@ ? 2J
3? 9ry cleaning 8"<"2
3J 8"$ 1 1$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 213/669
3J 8"$ 8 2 8 I
3J 8"$ 8 88 8 88
3J 8"$ 3 21 3 22
3J 8"$ I 26
3J 8"$ I 2@ 8@
3J 8"$ @ 22 ? 1
3J 8"$ @ 8
3J 8"$ @ 8
3J 8"$ ? 26 ? 88
3J 8"$ ? 26 ? 88
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture and
processing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture and
processing$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 214/669
3J 8"$ ? 22 ? 2I
3J 8"$ 11 11
3J 8"$ 12 22 12 2I
3J 8"$ 18 18
3J 8"$ 18 1I
3J 8"$ 18 2 J
3J 8"$ 13 1 13 11
3J 8"$ 13 11 13 11
3J 8"$ 13 2 13 3
3J 8"$ 13 18 1@ 3
3J 8"$ 13 11
3J 8"$ 1I 23
$hemical products. manufacture and
processing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 215/669
3J 8"$ 1@ 12
3J 8"$ 1? 1 1? 8
3J 8"$ 1? 11 1J 6
3J 8"$ 2 I
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
3J 8"$
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
$hemical products. manufacture andprocessing
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 216/669
I *rinting 8"9"1 I 22 6 26
I *rinting 8"9"1 @ 1
I *rinting 8"9"1 J @ J 1@
I *rinting 8"9"1 13 6 13 @
I *rinting 8"9"1 1? 28
I *rinting 8"9"1
I *rinting 8"9"1
I *rinting 8"9"1
I1 8"9"2 I 1 I 2
I1 8"9"2 I
I1 8"9"2 6 8 6 8
9omestic solvent use includingfungicides
9omestic solvent use includingfungicides
9omestic solvent use includingfungicides
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 217/669
I1 8"9"2 6 6 @ 6
I1 8"9"2 @ 12 @ 18
I1 8"9"2 1@ 1@ 1@ 22
I1 8"9"2
I2 :ther product use 8"9"8 3 22 3 22
I2 :ther product use 8"9"8 I 8J I 31
I2 :ther product use 8"9"8 1 1?
I2 :ther product use 8"9"8 11 1 11 J
I2 :ther product use 8"9"8 1@ 1 1@ 8
I2 :ther product use 8"9"8 1? 1 1? 2
I2 :ther product use 8"9"8I8 anure management 3"< 1 1 2 2
I8 anure management 3"< 1 1 2 2
I8 anure management 3"< 1 32
9omestic solvent use includingfungicides
9omestic solvent use includingfungicides
9omestic solvent use includingfungicides
9omestic solvent use includingfungicides
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 218/669
I8 anure management 3"< 1 IJ
I8 anure management 3"< 8 3 8 3
I8 anure management 3"< 8 6 8 6I8 anure management 3"< 8 1 8 13
I8 anure management 3"< 8 1 8 13
I8 anure management 3"< 8 3 8 I
I8 anure management 3"< 8 1 8 12
I8 anure management 3"< 8 21 8 2J
I8 anure management 3"< 8 2? 8 2?
I8 anure management 3"< 8 2 8 J
I8 anure management 3"< 8 18 8 13
I8 anure management 3"< 8 22 8 23I8 anure management 3"< 8 11 8 11
I8 anure management 3"< 8 1@ 8 1?
I8 anure management 3"< 8 11 8 11
I8 anure management 3"< 8 1J 8 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 219/669
I8 anure management 3"< 8 8 8 82
I8 anure management 3"< 8 1I 3 J
I8 anure management 3"< 8 1I 3 JI8 anure management 3"< 8 1?
I8 anure management 3"< 8 2J
I8 anure management 3"< 8 2@I8 anure management 3"< 8 2@
I8 anure management 3"< 3 1I 3 1I
I8 anure management 3"< 3 1 3 6
I8 anure management 3"< 3 1 3 I
I8 anure management 3"< 3 28 3 23
I8 anure management 3"< 3 11 @ 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3 11 @ 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3 J
I8 anure management 3"< 3 @
I8 anure management 3"< 3 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3 23
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 220/669
I8 anure management 3"< 3 1
I8 anure management 3"< 3 1I
I8 anure management 3"< I 11 I 26
I8 anure management 3"< I 1
I8 anure management 3"< I 22
I8 anure management 3"< I 26
I8 anure management 3"< I 2I8 anure management 3"< 6 @
I8 anure management 3"< 6 18
I8 anure management 3"< 6 2
I8 anure management 3"< 6 2I8 anure management 3"< 6 18
I8 anure management 3"< 6 18
I8 anure management 3"< @ I @ II8 anure management 3"< @ 2@ @ 2?
I8 anure management 3"< @ 3 @ 82
I8 anure management 3"< @ 3 @ 82
I8 anure management 3"< @ 26 @ 82
I8 anure management 3"< @ 2? @ 8I8 anure management 3"< @ 2 @ 2
I8 anure management 3"< @ 1 @ 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 221/669
I8 anure management 3"< @ 88 ? 2I8 anure management 3"< @ 1
I8 anure management 3"< @ 1
I8 anure management 3"< @ 8I
I8 anure management 3"< @ 1
I8 anure management 3"< @ 6
I8 anure management 3"< @ 2?
I8 anure management 3"< @ 3
I8 anure management 3"< ? 1 ? 1
I8 anure management 3"< ? 83 ? 83
I8 anure management 3"< ? 13 ? 16
I8 anure management 3"< ? 1@ ? 21
I8 anure management 3"< ? 22 ? 81I8 anure management 3"< ? 82 ? 82
I8 anure management 3"< ? 2I8 anure management 3"< ? 18
I8 anure management 3"< ? 2@
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 222/669
I8 anure management 3"< J 8 J 3
I8 anure management 3"< J 1 3
I8 anure management 3"< 1 1 1 2I8 anure management 3"< 1 8 1 8I8 anure management 3"< 1 8 1 8I8 anure management 3"< 1 8 1 8
I8 anure management 3"< 11 22 11 22
I8 anure management 3"< 11 26 11 26
I8 anure management 3"< 11 1? 11 82
I8 anure management 3"< 11 1? 11 82
I8 anure management 3"< 11 2? 11 2?
I8 anure management 3"< 11 8 11 I
I8 anure management 3"< 11 26 11 26
I8 anure management 3"< 11 1J 1? 12
I8 anure management 3"< 11 82
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 223/669
I8 anure management 3"< 11 1@
I8 anure management 3"< 11 26
I8 anure management 3"< 11 1I
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 12 @
I8 anure management 3"< 12 3 12 3
I8 anure management 3"< 12 3 12 3I8 anure management 3"< 12 2 12 8
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1I I
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 16 I
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 16 6
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 16 6
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 224/669
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 16 6
I8 anure management 3"< 12 6 16 6
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 16 6
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 2
I8 anure management 3"< 12 2 1@ 2
I8 anure management 3"< 12 1@
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 2
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 12 2 1@ 2
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 225/669
I8 anure management 3"< 12 1@
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 12 2 1@ 2
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I 1@ 2
I8 *oultry 3"<"J 12 I 81 2
I8 anure management 3"< 12 I
I8 anure management 3"< 12 II8 anure management 3"< 18 1 18 8
I8 anure management 3"< 13 @ 1I 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 226/669
I8 anure management 3"< 13 @ 16 1
I8 anure management 3"< 1I 8 1I I
I8 anure management 3"< 1I 8 1I I
I8 anure management 3"< 16 1 16 1
I8 anure management 3"< 16 1I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 16 1@ 16
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 16 1@ 16
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 1? 1@ 1?
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 16 1@ 16
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 227/669
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 6 1@ 6
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ @ 1@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 6 1@ 6
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ @ 1@ 16
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 8 1? 12
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 1J
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 8I8 anure management 3"< 1@ J
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 228/669
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 11
I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 13I8 anure management 3"< 1@ 3I8 anure management 3"< 1? 1 1? 1
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 3 1? 3I8 anure management 3"< 1? 2@ 1? 2?
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 13 1? 82
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 1 1? 11
I8 anure management 3"< 1? ? 1? 11
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 13 1? 1@
I8 anure management 3"< 1? ? 1? 11
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 8 1? 11
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 16 1? 16
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 23 1? 2I
I8 anure management 3"< 1? ? 1? 11
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 229/669
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 28 1? 28
I8 anure management 3"< 1? ? 1? ?
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 86 1J 2
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 13 23 11
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 13 23 11
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 8
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 83
I8 anure management 3"< 1? 16
I8 anure management 3"< 1J 1 1J 1
I8 anure management 3"< 1J 1I8 anure management 3"< 1J 8I
I8 anure management 3"< 2 ? 2 J
I8 anure management 3"< 2 1 2 1I8 anure management 3"< 2 1I 2 1I
I8 anure management 3"< 2 ? 2 J
I8 anure management 3"< 2 21 2 22
I8 anure management 3"< 2 28
I8 anure management 3"< 2 1?
I8 anure management 3"< 2 ?
I8 anure management 3"< 21 @ 21 @
I8 anure management 3"< 21 3 21 3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 230/669
I8 anure management 3"< 21 1 21 1I8 anure management 3"< 21 J 21 J
I8 anure management 3"< 21 18 21 18
I8 anure management 3"< 21 @ 21 @
I8 anure management 3"< 21 11 21 8
I8 anure management 3"< 21 I 21 1@
I8 anure management 3"< 21 I
I8 anure management 3"< 21 81I8 anure management 3"< 22 16 11 16
I8 anure management 3"< 22 16 22 1@I8 anure management 3"< 22 6 22 @I8 anure management 3"< 22 J 22 J
I8 anure management 3"< 22 22 22 22
I8 anure management 3"< 22 81
I8 anure management 3"< 22 22
I8 anure management 3"< 22 22
I8 anure management 3"< 22 8I8 anure management 3"< 22 JI8 anure management 3"< 22 16
I8 anure management 3"< 22 12
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 231/669
I8 anure management 3"< 28 88 28 83
I8 anure management 3"< 28 26
I8 anure management 3"< 28 1@
I8 anure management 3"< 23 3 23 I
I8 anure management 3"< 23 3 23 3
I8 anure management 3"< 23 3 23 11
I8 anure management 3"< 23 ? 23 JI8 anure management 3"< 23 @ 23 @
I8 anure management 3"< 23 16 2I 3
I8 anure management 3"< 23 18 81 1
I8 anure management 3"< 23 81
I8 anure management 3"< 23 16 81 2
I8 anure management 3"< 23 16 81 2
I8 anure management 3"< 23 12 81 2
I8 anure management 3"< 23 12 81 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 232/669
I8 anure management 3"< 23 16 81 2
I8 anure management 3"< 23 16 81 2
I8 anure management 3"< 23 1
I8 anure management 3"< 23 16
I8 anure management 3"< 23 16I8 anure management 3"< 23 @I8 anure management 3"< 2I 2 26 2
I8 anure management 3"< 26 8 26 8
I8 anure management 3"< 2@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 2@ 8I8 anure management 3"< 2J 1 2J I
I8 anure management 3"< 8 2 8 2
I8 anure management 3"< 8 8 8 I
I8 anure management 3"< 8 I 8 6
I8 *oultry 3"<"J 8 I 8 I
I8 *oultry 3"<"J 8 1 8 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 233/669
I8 anure management 3"< 8 1
I8 anure management 3"< 8 I
I8 anure management 3"< 81 11 81 11I8 anure management 3"< 81 1@ 81 1@
I8 anure management 3"< 81 8 81 8
I8 anure management 3"< 81 11 81 28
I8 anure management 3"< 81 11 81 11
I8 anure management 3"< 81 2I 81 2@
I8 anure management 3"< 81 28 81 28
I8 anure management 3"< 81 1@ 81 1@
I8 anure management 3"< 81 12 81 22
I8 anure management 3"< 81 28 81 2?
I8 anure management 3"< 81 2I 81 2@
I8 anure management 3"< 81 2I 81 2@
I8 anure management 3"< 81 11 81 22I8 anure management 3"< 81 12 81 22
I8 anure management 3"< 81 12 81 22
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 234/669
I8 anure management 3"< 81 28 81 2?
I8 anure management 3"< 81 I 81 6I8 anure management 3"< 81 12 81 1?
I8 anure management 3"< 81 11 1?
I8 anure management 3"< 81 23
I8 anure management 3"< 81 2@
I8 anure management 3"< 81 2I
I8 anure management 3"< 82 2 82 8I8 anure management 3"< 82 2I 82 2?
I8 anure management 3"< 82 1J 82 1J
I8 anure management 3"< 82 26 82 2@
I8 anure management 3"< 88 2J
I8 anure management 3"< 88 2J
I8 anure management 3"< 83 1 83 11
I8 anure management 3"< 83 28I8 anure management 3"< 8I 13
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 235/669
I8 anure management 3"< 86 16 86 1?
I8 anure management 3"< 86 16 86 21
I8 anure management 3"< 86 1J 86 21
I8 anure management 3"< 86 86 8J
I8 anure management 3"< 8JI8 anure management 3"< 3 2 3 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3 21 32 1
I8 anure management 3"< 3 1 32 1
I8 anure management 3"< 3 2 3I 13
I8 anure management 3"< 3 I@
I8 anure management 3"< 3 1 I@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 3 1 IJ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 31 1I 32 1
I8 anure management 3"< 31 J IJ 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 236/669
I8 anure management 3"< 31 J IJ 1
I8 anure management 3"< 31 2?
I8 anure management 3"< 32 26 32 2?
I8 anure management 3"< 38 12 33 6I8 anure management 3"< 38 12
I8 anure management 3"< 33 8? 3I 18
I8 anure management 3"< 33 8@ 3I 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3I 1@ 3I 22I8 anure management 3"< 36 @ 36 @
I8 anure management 3"< 36 8
I8 anure management 3"< 36 J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 237/669
I8 anure management 3"< 3@ ?I8 anure management 3"< 3@ ?
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 2 3? 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 2 3? 3
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 8 3? 3
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 2 I 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 2 I 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 8 I 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 2
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 8
I8 anure management 3"< 3? 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 238/669
I8 anure management 3"< I1 18 I8 2
I8 anure management 3"< I1 18
I8 anure management 3"< I2 1? I2 1J
I8 anure management 3"< I2 1?
I8 anure management 3"< I2 ?
I8 anure management 3"< I8 1
I8 anure management 3"< I8 1
I8 anure management 3"< I8 1
I8 anure management 3"< I8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 239/669
I8 anure management 3"< I3 @ I@ 1
I8 anure management 3"< II 1 II 1
I8 anure management 3"< I@ 1
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 anure management 3"<
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 240/669
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 anure management 3"<
I8 9airy cattle 3"<"1"a
I8 'on-dairy cattle 3"<"1"b
I8 %heep 3"<"8
I8 oats 3"<"3
I8 /orses 3"<"6
I8 %wine 3"<"?
I8 *oultry 3"<"J
I8 aying hens 3"<"J"a
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 241/669
I8 <roilers 3"<"J"b
I8 Tur!eys 3"<"J"c
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 1 1 1 1I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 1 1?
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 1 28
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 2 1 2 18
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 2 J 2 12I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 2 1@ 2 1J
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 2 12 2 18
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 2 1@ 2 2
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 2I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 2 82
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 2 3
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 2 8I
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 8 2 8 2
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 8 1I 8 1II3 Agricultural soils 3"9 8 1 8 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 242/669
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 8 ? 8 1I
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 8 @ 8 1I
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 8 16 3 21
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 8 6 I 12I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 8 3 6 6I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 3 13 3 13I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 3 6 3 6
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 3 1 3 1
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 3 1J 3 1J
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 3 13 3 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 3 18 3 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 3 1I 3 21
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 3 12I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 3I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 3 83
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 243/669
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 3 1 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 1 6 1
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 ? 6 ?
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 J 6 1@
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 1 6 1I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 1 6 1
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 2 6 2
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13 6 16
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 244/669
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13 6 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13 6 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 18 6 18
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13 6 13
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 245/669
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13 6 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13 6 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13 6 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 1 @ 13I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 1J @ ?
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 18
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 246/669
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 J 18 ?
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 13 13 6
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 6 1 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 6 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 @ 2 @ 2
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 @ 11 @ 11I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 @ ? @ ?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 247/669
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 @ 18 13 @
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 @ 18 13 @
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 @ 28
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 13 J 13 1I
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 13 13 13 1II3 Agricultural soils 3"9 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 13
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 16 21 16 21
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 1@ I 1@ 6
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 1@ 2I 1@ 2@I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 1@ 2@ 1@ 2@
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 1@ 1? 1@ 21
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 1@ 86 1@ 8@
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9 1? 2? 1? 2?
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 1? J 1? J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 248/669
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 1? 81 28
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 1? 28
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1 21 21
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"1
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"2I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"2
I3 Agricultural soils 3"9"2
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 2 12
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 249/669
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 2 2 12II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 8 1I
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 3 18 3 1I
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 3 1 3 1
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 3 1I
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 3 1
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 3 1
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 3 @
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F I 16 ? 3
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F I 6
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F I ?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 250/669
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F I 3II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F I 13
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F I 1
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 6 ?
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 6 1
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 6 1
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F 6 1
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F J 12
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"F
II Field burning of agricultural wastes 3"FI6 Agriculture other 3" 1 1 1 1
I6 Agriculture other 3" 2 6 2 @
I6 Agriculture other 3"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 251/669
I6 Agriculture other 3"
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 1 3I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 1
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 2 3 2 3I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 2 13 2 13
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 2 13 2 13I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 2 8 2 8I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 2 3 2 3
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 2 8
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 2 8I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 2 2 3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 252/669
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 8 3 8 I
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 8 @ 8 @
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 8
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A 3 1? 3 1?
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A
I@ %olid waste disposal on land 6"A
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 1 6I? Caste-water handling 6"< 1 6
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 2 @ 2 ?
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 2 11 2 1J
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 2 1I 2 1J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 253/669
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 2 @ 2 ?
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 2 @ 2 ?
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 2 1I 8 6
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 3 28 3 28
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 3 28 3 28
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 3 16 3 1J
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 3 22 3 28
I? Caste-water handling 6"< 6 ?
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 254/669
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 255/669
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
I? Caste-water handling 6"<
IJ $linical waste incineration (d) 6"$"a 6 11
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 256/669
IJ $linical waste incineration (d) 6"$"a @ 18
IJ $linical waste incineration (d) 6"$"a @
IJ $linical waste incineration (d) 6"$"a J
IJ $linical waste incineration (d) 6"$"a 18 3 18 3IJ $linical waste incineration (d) 6"$"a 1I
IJ $linical waste incineration (d) 6"$"a 1@
IJ Caste incineration 6"$
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 1 1J
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 8 8
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b ? 16 ? 1?
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b J J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 257/669
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 11 8 11 8
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 11 11
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 12 12
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 1@ 1@
61 unicipal waste incineration (d) 6"$"c 8 8
61 unicipal waste incineration (d) 6"$"c 1 1
61 unicipal waste incineration (d) 6"$"c 1 161 unicipal waste incineration (d) 6"$"c 11 8 11 8
61 unicipal waste incineration (d) 6"$"c 18 22
61 unicipal waste incineration (d) 6"$"c 23 23
61 unicipal waste incineration (d) 6"$"c
61 unicipal waste incineration (d) 6"$"c62 $remation 6"$"d @ @
62 $remation 6"$"d
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 258/669
68 %mall scale waste burning 6"$"e 1 1?
68 %mall scale waste burning 6"$"e I 1I
68 %mall scale waste burning 6"$"e J J
63 :ther waste Z 6"9 1 J
63 :ther waste Z 6"9 2 2
63 :ther waste Z 6"9 I 6
63 :ther waste Z 6"9 I @
63 :ther waste Z 6"9 I @
63 :ther waste Z 6"9 I
63 :ther waste Z 6"9 6 1? @ 8
63 :ther waste Z 6"9
63 :ther waste Z 6"96@ Forest fires 11"< 1 18
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 259/669
Comment Action taken
e7ected 'one
'oted
Accepted /$< added to Table 1-1
e7ected
ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one2nd sentence# 4,A1b4 should read 41A1c4" ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one
'oted
'oted
Proposeddecision
The Fs are clearly inade+uate and was evidentlybeen reviewed by people with no or little
e&perience in emission inventory compilation
The document is wea! in discussing Flue gastreatment impacts on reducing emissions - it is notclear whether emission factors refer to abated orunabated emissions and which abatementtechnology is used" Also see $omment 1 on thissheet (only %o& and ':& abatement are discussedand no co-benefits)
odified te&t to includemore detail on *. someadditional detail onabatement added as anappendi&
Table 1-1 has no mention of /$< despite that
there is a reporting re+uirement for this substance"
missions from crac!ing and catalyst regenerationare includedin $hapter 1"<"2"a"iv" %uggestcombine last 2 sentences to read# 4*roductionprocesses such as thermal crac!ing and catalystregeneration as well as fugitive emissions arecovered in $hapter 1"<4
Te&t modified to clarifyscope"
Add 'F code to title to maintain consistency withtitle 2"1
,nsert 41"A"1"b4 into section 2"2 title as per that for2"1 for 1"A"1"a
This paragraph is unclear" Assumeable there
should be a reference to 1A1c"
, can agree in general about the semplification inmethodologies and in reference to <F but theprevious release of the chapter was reallyinteresting including a very good description of4combustion mechanism4. so 49on0t throw out thebaby with the bath water4K , propose to maintainthe old documentation in the new < for e&leas an Appendi&5
$onsult with&pert *anel
%ome additional te&tincluded (on * control)and selected informationincluded as an appendi&
,nsert 41"A"1"c4 into section 2"2 title as per that for2"1 for 1"A"1"a
write# 4Lhas typical combustion temperaturesLleading toL4
For these paragraphs to be of any use they needto be e&panded"
%ome slight modificationsbut readers needing detailshould consult <F
4""up to about 2 Cth""4 should read 4""fromabout 2 Cth"""4
Te&t modified to clarifyscope"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 260/669
'oted Te&t amended
'oted 'one
Accepted
'otedThe sentence 4can achieve4 is duplicate ditorial 9one
'otedwrite# 4Ltechnology""4 ditorial 9one
Accepted
'oted
'oted 'one
'ot only solid and li+uid fuels contains '. biomassshould be included in the parentheses"
'atural gas fuelled stationary engines should bementioned as a potential large emitter"
As usually in the te&t there are no data aboutpollutants concentration , propose to delete theparagraph 4ercury concentrations are reported tobe in the range of 2 - I [g>m8 for natural gas Qvander ost eldt. 1JJ2. mweltbundesamt.ermany. 1J?R4" Chy /g for natural gas and notother pollutants for other fuelsG
Te&t modified to removedata"
/g levels +uoted for natural gas are too highK owndata show a mean of about 1 ng>m\
mission factor removedfrom te&t. no newreferencable data from *but previous guideboo!factor adopted
The entire chapter on controls in this draft aree&cerpts from the e&isting guideboo!. however ithas been scaled bac! so that the usefulness hastotally vanished"
%ome additional te&tincluded (on * control)and selected informationincluded as an appendi&
,mpacts of control measures on %:& and ':& arediscussed. but there is no discussion of particulatecontrol and the co-benefit of these technologies onthe reduction of e"g" metals
%hort te&t added on *abatement
As usually in the te&t there are no data aboutpollutants concentration , propose to delete theparagraph 4 The ':& reduction efficiency can bebetween @ and J "4 :therwise efficiency mustbe reported for all technologies in an appropriateTable" This last option is most appropriate"
%ome efficiency data fromcurrent guideboo! chapteradded as an appendi&
The sentence 4,f detailed information is available.use it4 is generic. , propose 4if emissions datacoming from continuous stac!s measurement areavailable. use itK otherwise if information comingfrom periodic measurements are available use it incombination with other information4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 261/669
Accepted Te&t amended
Accepted Te&t amended
Accepted Te&t amended
'oted
Accepted Te&t amended$orrect 4sib-bituminous4 to 4sub-bituminous4 ditorial 9one
'oted 'one
Accepted
ditorial table fuels modified
Table 8-I# no /g emission factor for natural gas" 9iscuss with * @>I>?
Accepted
Accepted Factors provided
Accepted
The statement. that the default emission factorshave been derived from all available data andinformation. seems rather bold when the vastma7ority simply refers to the e&isting guideboo!"
9elete the sentence 4have been derived from allavailable data and information4
9o the term vegetable waste e+uals agriculturalwasteG
There is no clear definition of the assumption(power input. technology. abatement) of the Tier 1methodology" ,f. as stated. the factors are a simplemean , thin! this is not appropriate" Ce cannotevaluate the Fs without reference to a concept of4most used4 technology"
9iscussed with * @>I>?Ksome detail added ande&pansion of Tier 2 factors
9elete 4have been derived from all available dataand information4"
Ce feel *etroleum $o!e would be better classified
under 4hard coal4 rather than heavy fuel oil. as it isa solid fuel
Tables 8-8-8-J are not complete" mission factorsfor *A/ are shown without indication of speciesKemission factors for *$99>F are shown withreference to *A 1JJ? but there are a loturopean-based data on dio&ins emissionK no Ffor *$< and /$< for all fuels"
9iscussed with * @>I>?.*A/ now speciated.*$99>F *$< and /$<added where available"
,nconsistencies in the terminology used to describefuels in different tables
,t should be indicated in the tables what TFsystem (,-TF or C/:-TF) is used for dio&ins
furans
Cill change with new
tables$onsult with&pert *anel
Table 8-@- 8-J# no *$99>F emission factors forheavy fuel oil. other li+uid fuels and biomass" *A/emission factor for biomass should be chec!ed"
Factors reviewed andmodified as appropriate
tier 2 emission factors for stationary engines aremissing
Tables 8-11. 8-12. 8-18. 8-13. 8-16. 8-1@. 8-1J. 8-2# emission factors are shown with reference tothe uideboo! 26" <ut uideboo! 26 doesnot contain e&actly the same emission factorsKmaybe they were recalculated - this should beindicated" $ombustion emissions significantlydepend on boilers power. but Tier 2 tables do notaccount this"
Tables revised. source offactors should now beclearer
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 262/669
9iscussed with * @>I>?
Accepted
'oted
'oted 9iscussed with * @>I>?
'oted 9iscussed with * @>I>?
'oted
Accepted
'oted
'oted
Tables 8-11. 8-12. 8-18. 8-16. 8-1@. 8-1J. 8-2(Tier 2) and Tables 8-8 -8-3 (Tier 1) include sameemission factor for *$99>F with reference to *A1JJ? ] a lot of data available for *$99>F emissionfrom coal combustion in urope"
$onsult with&pert *anel
'o subdivision based on Ct of the plant arereported in Tier 2 methodology (the 4old4 <reported this subdivision5)K this subdivision can bemore relevant that the subdivision between drybottom and wet bottom reported in the new <
9iscussed with * @>I>?KsiHe split retained
'o subdivision based on technology of combustion(low ':& burner - staged air supply o overfire air)of the plant are reported in Tier 2 methodology (the4old4 < reported this subdivision5)K thissubdivision can be more relevant that thesubdivision between dry bottom and wet bottom
reported in the 4new4 <
9iscussed with * @>I>?.some te&t on abatementefficiency retained as anappendi& to maintain
information
'o complete subdivision based on configuration ofburner (wall or tangential) are reported in Tier 2methodology (the 4old4 < reported thissubdivision5)K this subdivision can be more relevantthat the subdivision between dry bottom and wetbottom reported in the 4new4 <
'o control system specification in Tier 2methodology (the 4old4 < reported thisinformation5)K
nclear ':& emission factors and undefinedreferences. for e&le for coal the F is too lowcompared with the methodology of 4old4 < seeTable 2I of the <11 chapter" For natural gas the Fis to high compared with the methodology of 4old4< see Table 23 of the <11 chapter controlsG
%ome factors modified bye&tension to Tier 2 tables
nclear %:& emission factors ( % in fuelG ashcontent in coalG) controlsG
Te&t now includescalculation from fuel %
nclear $:. $:. / emission factors. noreference with 4old4 <
%ome factors modified bye&tension to Tier 2 tables
* emission factors unacceptable for Tier 2" ,n% *A for e&le a 9ry bottom plant burning$oal with no control has F N 8J?.@ while thesame plant with baghouse has F N 8.I" 4'ew4 <($*,*) report F N 26" Chat is theassumption5 Chat is the control systemG /ow canbe used this emission factor in %weden and
AlbaniaG /ow can be used to evaluate futureemissionsG
Tier 2 factors are now asused in guideboo!supplements from 2I>6
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 263/669
'oted
'oted Tables revised"
'oted Tables revised
Accepted Tables revised
'oted Tables revised
'oted Tables revised
ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
Accepted eference included
Accepted Te&t amended
'oted 9iscuss with * @>I>?
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one9elete 4)4 after 44 ditorial 9one
Add 4Q$oncawe. 2@R4 after 4$oncawe4 Accepted 9one
$:'$%,:' the tables are unclear andunusable. the 4interpretation4 of the 4old4 < F isan unacceptable simplification
9iscussed with * @>I>?"ore of old guideboo!retained"
Table 8-18 (Tier 2)# * and / emission factorsare the same as in the Table 8-3 (Tier 1)"
Table 8-1I (Tier 2)# emission factors are the sameas in the Table 8-I (Tier 1)K no /g emission factor"
Table 8-1?# no *$99>F emission factors for woodand similar wood wastes"
Table 8-1@ (Cet <ottom <oilers) and the Table 8-12 (9ry bottom <oilers)# the same emission factorsfor all technologies - this is not correct"
Table 8-21# no *$99>F emission factors for woodand similar wood wastes"
This table 8-22 is an e&act duplicate of table 8-23in chapter 1A3. including the mista!e of having a
negative T%* emission factor"
Cill change with new
tables,n the 4'ot estimated4 list of Table 8-22. *A/0sshould be deleted
Cill change with newtables
,n the 4'ot estimated4 list of Table 8-28. %:&should be deleted
Cill change with newtables
,n the 4'ot estimated4 list of Table 8-23. * shouldbe deleted
Cill change with newtables
ven though this report is a draft version thereshould not be incomplete references to otherchapters. unless the intent is to purposely annoythe reader" This is a recurring problem severaltimes in this draft version"
The industry emission reporting guidance does notprovide anydetails of the technologies" 9elete 4andthe industry emissionreporting guidance Q$oncawe.2@R4"
$:'$%,:' the tables are unclear andunusable. the only complete wor! by $oncawe wasnot used
For guidance add 4-see $hapter 1<2c4 after4""""activities4
For guidance add 4-see $hapter 1<2a"iv4 after4""""units4
For guidance add 4-see $hapter 1<2a"iv4 after
4""""releases4For guidance add 4-see $hapter 1<2a"iv4 after4""""emissions4
$hange 4reduced4 to 4eliminated4 as '/8 is fullyconverted
For guidance add 4-see $hapter 1<2a"iv4 after4""""units4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 264/669
'oted
Accepted 9one Add 4in Appendi& <4 after 4"""comparison4 Accepted 9one
e7ected
Accepted 9one
'oted Te&t revised
Accepted
'oted
There is a specific paper by $oncawe (eport no"J>I 4Air pollutant emission estimation methodsfor * and *T reporting by refineries(revised)4) that the consultant don0t ta!e intoconsideration and use an undefined reference %*A (2)
Table has been revisitedand incorporates $oncaweand other sources
9elete 4grouped by ma7or fuel types4 as onlyrefinery gas F0s given"
Add new paragraph# 4$oncawe has published acompilation ofrecommended emission factors forreporting by refineries under the -*Tre+uirements Q$oncawe. 2@R" For combustionthe ma7ority of these factors are e+uivalent to aTier 2 approach"4
Application of thesefactors by refineryoperators is on a facilitybasis - inclusion of thisstatement may precludeacceptability of this data atTier 8
Following on from comment above. it is proposedthat the followingis added after 4combustion4 at the
end of line 83# 4units e"g" boilers and processheaters and 0furnaces0K4
There is a specific paper by $oncawe (eport no"J>I 4Air pollutant emission estimation methodsfor * and *T reporting by refineries(revised)4) that the consultant don0t ta!e intoconsideration and use an undefined reference %*A (2)
Tables# - F for %:&# *roviding a fi&ed F for %:&does not permitthe benefits of the reduction in fuelsulphur content by refineriesto be captured ininventories" ember %tate authorities can obtainthe mass and average sulphur content of fuelsused in refineries. soa simple algorithm should beprovided in Tier 2 instead of fi&ed F"
Te&t modified. wheremember %tates havefacility specifc data theyshould incorporate in theirinventories" Tier 2 couldbe refinery-specific but thisis still an aggregatedactivity level"
Tables# - there should be consistency in thenumber of significantfigures used for emissionfactors" Two significant figures should beused forTier 2" ,n Table 3-8 some F0s are given with veryhigh accuracy (e"g" %:& N 83J"J) whereas otherse"g" heavy metals arerounded to only onesignificant figure"
Cill change with newtables
Tables# - calculation of upper and lower JIconfidence limits" The calculation of limits in theseTables do not appear to follow the guidance in thecross-cutting $hapter on uncertainities" Fore&le. an F with $orinair code $ would haveJI limits of1 of the F value (range I to2 - 1 ta!en as default)" Chere $oncawehas made comments on F0s the upper and lowerlimit values have been calculated according tothese guidelines"
limits revised in updatedtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 265/669
'oted
'oted Te&t clarified
'oted 'one
'oted
'oted
Table# F references - there are a number ofreferences to 4uideboo! (26)4 and 4uideboo!(26). % *A (2)4" $oncawe stronglyconsiders that an F derived in some manner(e"g"by ta!ing geometric mean) of upper and lower
limit values of a range.as +uoted in the uideboo!.should ':T be used where a publishedF isavailable from a well established source (e"g" A*-32) whichhas been computed from a large numberof measurements" %uch a mean value has morescientific basis than one derived from valuesateither end of spread for which the distribution isun!nown" That techni+ue is accepted as beingvalid only where an F derivedfrom a number ofmeasurements made in the same way isnotavailable"
'one. but revision ofemission factor tables hasbeen done
Table Titles# Tables 3-8 through 3-@ all refer solelyto 4heaters4" Thereare other combustion units inrefineries e"g" $: boilers. fired waste heat boilers.etc" and heaters are often called 0processfurnaces0(see. e"g. te&t in section 3"1"2) althoughthere is no contact betweenthe fuel and processmaterial",t is proposed. therefore. to help clarifywhat the F0s are for. the term4/eater4 in the titlesof the Tables is changed to 4$ombustion nit4"
Add new paragraph for clarity# 4All the Tier 2emission factorsprovided in Tables 3-8 to 3-? arefor unabated emissions" To estimate emissionswhere abatement systems are installed.informationon abatement system efficiencies isavailable in the efinery <FQ,**$<. 28R4"(/owever. see comment on p 8J. line 8)
There is a specific paper by $oncawe (eport no"J>I 4Air pollutant emission estimation methodsfor * and *T reporting by refineries(revised)4) that the consultant don0t ta!e intoconsideration and use an undefined reference %*A (2)
%ee earlier note on$oncawe report
There is a specific paper by $oncawe (eport no"J>I 4Air pollutant emission estimation methodsfor * and *T reporting by refineries(revised)4) that the consultant don0t ta!e intoconsideration and use an undefined reference %*A (2)
%ee earlier note on$oncawe report
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 266/669
'oted
e7ected
'oted
'oted
There is a specific paper by $oncawe (eport no"J>I 4Air pollutant emission estimation methodsfor * and *T reporting by refineries(revised)4) that the consultant don0t ta!e intoconsideration and use an undefined reference %*A (2)
%ee earlier note on$oncawe report
$omment on table 3-?#- the emission of ':$ is dependent on the fuelgas composition- in the %A :$s (that means non methane > non
ethane hydrocarbons) are regulated and ':T'/$ (non methane /ydro carbons)- the $* <F document 26 mentions onlyformaldehyde as hydrocarbon- $:'9AT,:'# the figues on ':$ intable 3-? should be ta!en out and a generalcomment on the fuel dependancy relating to thisemmitent has to be put in the table" :therwise thefigures will lead to big misunderstandings"
Ce accept that theemission is dependent onfuel composition butcombustion and lubricantsare also relevant" Ce alsoaccept that %*A :$figure also e&cludesethane however. in theabsence of other data. itprovides a reasonablevalue for nm:$" An
alternative would be toapply the the %*A T:$figure" At least onemember state applies anemission limit forformaldehyde butinventory is about totalnm:$ not individualcomponents"
The value for ':B in the table 3-? (1 g>D) isabout 12 mg>'m8 (at 1I :2)" This is about 82mg>'m8 at I :2" This is far away from theindustry recommendation that has been given inthe $* <F" There it was recommended tointroduce 1J mg>'m8 at 1I :2 for lean burn% gas engines" This is about 16 g>D"
$:'9AT,:'#- correct the value according to industryrecommendation"- Furthermore introduce a span for the ':& value"- A value for gas engine that are operated in thegas-diesel-mode is missing" This value has also to
be integrated"
The guideboo! is not
reflecting <AT"
There is a specific paper by $oncawe (eport no"J>I 4Air pollutant emission estimation methodsfor * and *T reporting by refineries(revised)4) that the consultant don0t ta!e intoconsideration and use an undefined reference %*A (2)
%ee earlier note on$oncawe report
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 267/669
'oted
'oted
'oted 9one where possible
'oted 9iscussed with * @>I>?
'oted
ditorial
'oted
There is a specific paper by $oncawe (eport no"J>I 4Air pollutant emission estimation methodsfor * and *T reporting by refineries(revised)4) that the consultant don0t ta!e intoconsideration and use an undefined reference %*A (2)
%ee earlier note on$oncawe report
Crong 'F. it0s no clear what table refer5 ,t0s crudeoil combustionG ChereG ,n a process furnaceG
Table 3-J appears to belong to 'F 1A1c (asshown in table 4code4bo&"
Cill change with newtables
All the Tier 2 emission factors are for unabatedemissions" ,t wouldbe useful to provide a table ofabatement system efficiencies (c"f"tables in1"<"2"a"v and 1"<"2"a"iv) after the Tier 2 F tables"
%ubchapter I 1A1c anufacture of solid fuels# thetitle and content are not harmoniHedK only co!e
manufacture is described"
This section may be misleading" ,f a refinery hasused the $oncaweguidance Q$oncawe. 2@R. thenthe data do not re+uire a =A>=$ chec! as the F0sused would be from well recognised and acceptedsources such as *A A*-32" ,f facility *T dataare e&trapolated to derive national inventories.there is the danger of serious errors as both the* and -*T reporting schemesincludethresholds" ,t is proposed that the second and thirdsentences are switched. te&t e&tended and the restdeleted#Thus# 4efinery installations are ma7orfacilities and emission data forindividual plantsmay be available. but possibly for only alimitednumber of pollutants. through a *T oranother national emission reporting scheme"Chen the +uality of such data is assured by a welldeveloped =A>=$ system. it is good practice touse such data"uidance on estimating refineryemissions has been publishedby the industrysector Q$oncawe. 2@R4
Tect amended to partlyreflect comment"
The heading for this chapter misses the secondpart 4:ther energy industries4
/ave put in those from oldguideboo! *:*s chapter
$:'$%,:' the tables are unclear andunusable
/ave put in those from oldguideboo! *:*s chapter
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 268/669
9one where possible
e7ectedFigure I-1# error in the title" ditorial 9one
ditorial Figure title amended
'oted 9iscussed with * @>I>?
'oted Tables revised
9one
'oted 9iscussed with * @>I>?
This chapter is very thin" nder 4Techni+ues4 onlyco!e manufacture is mentioned" The e&istingguideboo! does not have a separate chapter onneither 1A1b nor 1A1c. this would have been ane&cellent time to improve that aspect. alas nothinghas been done"
$onsult with&pert *anel
,t is proposed that there is an additional paragraphon ':& estimation using facility data" 4':&formation is very comple&. anddepends on anumber of parameters e"g" hydrogen and moisturecontents. pre-heat temperature. burner intensity.etc" Amethodology to calculate ':& emissions hasbeen published (in the:il and as Dournal) andprovided in $oncawe. 2@ as the recommendedmethod for refineries to use for emission reporting"Chere facility data are available. this detailedmethodology should beused to obtain more
accurate ':& estimates than the fi&ed valueemission factor provided in the Tier 2 approach"4
The chapter already refersthe reader to $oncaweguidance for Tier 8"
Additional reference or
highlighting of specificpollutants is not necessary"
The decision tree is obviously similar to the one forpetroleum refining. however the figure te&t shouldreflect the correct chapter"
There is no clear definition of the assumption(power input. technology. abatement) of the Tier 1methodology" ,f as stated the factors are a simplemean , thin! this is not appropriate" Ce cannotevaluate the Fs without reference to a concept of4most used4 technology"
,n the tables I-8. I-3 not estimate selenium and/eavy metals" ,t is not correct. because /includes %e"The same problem for *A/ as forother combustion (only summary F. not bypollutants)
There is no clear definition of the assumption(power input. technology. abatement) of the Tier 1methodology" ,f as stated the factors are a simplemean , thin! this is not appropriate" Ce cannotevaluated the Fs without reference to a conceptof 4most used4 technology" :nly very poor list of
pollutants ta!e into account" G :ther li+uid fuelG
$onsult with
&pert *anel
There is no clear definition of the assumption(power input. technology. abatement) of the Tier 1methodology" ,f as stated the factors are a simplemean , thin! this is not appropriate" Ce cannotevaluated the Fs without reference to a conceptof 4most used4 technology" :nly very poor list ofpollutants ta!e into account" G
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 269/669
'oted Appendi& < not Appendi& 2 ditorial 9one
Accepted evised
Accepted
pdate the reference to the $T,$ guide ditorial evised
ditorial
Accepted note added to tables
'oted 'one
ery useful table. however there is no need toseparate emissions from T and gas engines last"The order of the pollutants is also strange. %:2.':& T%* would be the logical order"
T and engines moved.no other comments onpollutant order so notchanged
This glossary should either be e&panded or
removed" %ome listings in the glossary do notappear previously in the te&t"
$onsidering the number of times 4uideboo!(26)4 is referenced in the te&t it is +uite anaccomplishment to have it e&cluded from the list ofreferences"
eferences amended -uideboo! 26 generallyreplaced by original ref"
eference list# There are references given in theF tables of 4%*A (1JJ?)4. 4% *A (2)4and 4% *A (28)4" There areonly two % *Areferences in the eference ist. and one of these
is for 1J?@" The other is undated" The eferenceist needs toreflect the references in the te&t andtables"
eferences will berationalised
'eed to define the calculations assumptionsused to convert emission concentrations into Fand ma!e sure that they are consistent with
Appendi& $
The ':& values from the othenburg *rotocol arelisted in table <3"These values should be ta!en out as there os a
political decision to review the othenburg*rotocol" Furthermore these values (for dieselengines) are far beyond <AT"%ee also#http#>>www"euromot"org>download>news>positions>stationaryPengines>'$P$TA*PA<$PAnalysisP?38"pdf
http#>>www"euromot"org>download>news>positions>stationaryPengines>,**$<P<FPeuromotPcommentPmayP2"pdf
,n these position papers emission limit values arerecommended" Ce propose to overta!e those
emission limit values in table <3"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 270/669
'oted
'oted
e7ected
Accepted Tables revised
The given <F ':B value for new and e&istingstationary gas engines in the table <3 is too low"$orrect span should be 2-1J mg>'m8" *leasecompare the emission table of the eneral
nvironmental /ealth and %afety (/%) uidelinesof the Corld <an!" Corld <an! has implementedemission limit values that are depending on theengine type. the used fuel. the positioon of theengine etc" Ce support this strategy as it refers ondifferent emission limit values that are dependingof different surrounding operation factors" Thesefactors are also depending on the infrastructurearound the engine (water. reagents. fuel +uality.etc")"
*lease compare page @ of the document under thefollowing lin!#
http#>>www"ifc"org>ifce&t>enviro"nsf>Attachments<yTitle>guiP/%uidelines2@Peneral/%>^F,>FinalV-VeneralV/%Vuidelines"pdf
Ce recommend to distinguish the emission limitvalues for different engine types"
The range indicated in the
comment reflects industryview of <ATK the table isintended to summarise themain <F As andcannot reflect allcomments>notes to theTable"
An :2 concentration of 21 instead of 2.Jseems more commonK e"g" 21 is used in theinformative appendi& of ' 131?1
%ome sources use 21 (fore&le standardisation ofemission concentrations inthe Caste ,ncineration9irective which. as withthe $*9. includesre+uirements on $%uncertainty and hence wasa driver for '131?1).%*A ethod 1J andothers use 2"J forcorrections and someothers apply valuesbetween these figures (fore&le 2"JI or 2"J6)"9ifference is minor"
convert % *A method 1J in %, units or replace itby the ,A correlations
units are dscm>D or. drym8>D
, could not find any /$< emission factors for coaland wood combustion or other relevant sources"%eehttp#>>reports"eea"europa"eu>*$:,'A,I>en>%ourcesPofP/$<Pemissions"pdf"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 271/669
'oted eferences revised
'oted
Accepted Tables revised
Accepted Tables revised
'oted Tables revised
'oted Tables revised
'oted Tables revised
Accepted Additional te&t added
'oted Table included
'oted
'oted
any F-references are of !ind 4(uideboo!26)4" , suggest to refer to original referencesfrom the uideboo! 26"
The units in the emission factor tables should bechanged depending on pollutant" ain pollutants
and particles could be !ept in g>D. while metalscould be listed in mg>D. *A/ in mi!rogram>D ormg>D and dio&in and other *:*0s in ng>D"
'oted and some factorshave been modified
,n the chapters concerning stationary combustionthere are only given a default emission factor for*A/" <ut for reporting purposes individualemission factors are needed for the 3 different*A/0s"
,n the e&isting guideboo! information on the 3different *A/0s is available" A combined *A/emission factor is somewhat useless consideringthe reporting re+uirements"
There are a general lac! of /$< emission factorsin this chapter" ,t seems that only under wasteincineration is an emission factor for /$<provided"
The e&isting guideboo! has a specific chapter on/$<. (and *$<). it would be appropiate if the datain these e&isting chapters were included ande&panded in this revised guideboo!"
A lot of the emission factors references touideboo! 26 does not seem to correspondcorrectly"
"g" ':& emission factor for 9<< residual oil listedin table 8-13 as 8 g>D" ,n the e&istingguideboo! the ':& emission factor for residual oilvaries between 1I and 2J6 g>D
ma!e clear that mission factors refer to netcalorific values
The emission factors for the stationary gasenginestotaly missing"
'o mention of stationary engines in the ethodschapter5
,f the authors could not be bothered to writesomething new. they could at least have copied all
the te&t from the e&isting guideboo!"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 272/669
Accepted
'oted %ome modification to te&t
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
'oted 'one
'oted Te&t now includes /$<
'oted
'oted
eneral comments# chapter includes large numberof very different processes so will be difficult forusageK there is no indication where to getinformation for estimation of emission from
combustion using proposed methodology (i"e" whatfuel and how much it was used for production of acertain ferrous or non-ferrous metal)" ,n this caseapplicability of it will be low" There are a lot oftables in the chapter which are not applicable. fore&le. emissions from natural gas combustionin lead or copper production" Assumption that all':&. %:2. $:. ':$ emissions are from fuelcombustion will lead to significant difficulties inemission inventory and to miss of sources"
Tier 1 factors will remainheat input but Tier 2 will berevised to be based onproduction which shouldma!e chapter more useful
For fuel use in conventional boilers. furnace.engine or other device emission information isreferred to $hapters 1A1 and 1A3"
,n table 1-1 under iron and steel one is refered tochapter 1A1 with regard to stationary engines thismust be a mista!e since no guidance on stationaryengines is provided in this chapter"
'one - combustionchapters now include astationary engine table
, assume the correct chapter for guidance onmobile sources in industry would be chapter 1A3:ther obile and not 1A2"
Amended reference to1A2fii
Chere. if any. should be accounted ':& emissionsfrom catalytic o&idation of ammonia in nitric acidproductionG Are you provided for this source of':& emissions in $hapters 1A2 or 2<G
Although ':& arises formo&idation of ammoniaemissions are assigned tothe process
%:& emissions in this 'F category are calculatedonly from %:& emissions from the fuel combustedG
Again there are no mention of /$< despite thereporting re+uirement for this substance"
,t0s not clear where the Fs come from5 *articularlywhen uideboo! (26) is +uoted it0s not true thatFs are present in this form in original reference5 ,felaboration was performed on original data thesemust be e&plained. otherwise the table isunacceptable
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
,t0s not clear where the Fs come from5 *articularlywhen uideboo! (26) is +uoted it0s not true thatFs are present in this form in original reference5 ,felaboration was performed on original data thesemust be e&plained. otherwise the table isunacceptable
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 273/669
Accepted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
,ncluded
'oted
There is any reference about what specific fuelsare covered under fuel type named 49erivedFuels4 in this $hapter" Are these specific fuelsthose mentioned in $hapter 1A1. Table 8-2G
Ues. table included from1A1
The JI confidence interval for T%* in Table 8-2is -1. while for *1 and *2.I the interval is
"1-1" ,s lower value for T%* correctG
Cill change with new
tables
,t0s not clear where the Fs come from5 *articularlywhen uideboo! (26) is +uoted it0s not true thatFs are present in this form in original reference5 ,felaboration was performed on original data thesemust be e&plained. otherwise the table isunacceptable
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
,t0s not clear where the Fs come from5 *articularlywhen uideboo! (26) is +uoted it0s not true thatFs are present in this form in original reference5 ,felaboration was performed on original data thesemust be e&plained. otherwise the table is
unacceptable
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended to
clarifyThe JI confidence interval for *1 in Table 8-2is -2. while for T%* and *2.I the interval is"2-2" ,s lower value for *1 correctG
Cill change with newtables
Table 8-8# Chy 9io&ins and Furans emissionfactors for natural gas have not been estimatedGChen using Tier 2 method there is an emissionfactor of 2 ,-T= ng>D for all activities in this 'Fcategory 1A2 with the e&ception of cement andlime production activities (%'A* codes 8811 and8812)
Factors now in at Tier 1 -refer to process emissions
,n Table 8-3 (Tier 1 approach). there is no emission
factor estimated for dio&ins and furans when usingheavy fuel oil"
'ow referenced tocombustion chapters
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-18
$onsult with&pert *anel
Tables 8-18. 8-16. 8-1J. 8-26. 8-8. 8-83. 8-86. 8-8?. 8-31. 8-38# F for /g and *b in column alueare shown as . but in column ower ] not "
Cill change with newtables
,t0s not clear where the Fs come from5 *articularlywhen uideboo! (26) is +uoted it0s not true thatFs are present in this form in original reference5 ,felaboration was performed on original data thesemust be e&plained. otherwise the table isunacceptable
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 274/669
'oted
'oted
There is no mention to heavy metals in Table 8-I"
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
,t0s not clear where the Fs come from5 *articularlywhen uideboo! (26) is +uoted it0s not true thatFs are present in this form in original reference5 ,felaboration was performed on original data thesemust be e&plained. otherwise the table isunacceptable
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
There is any reference about what specific fuelsare covered under fuel type named 4:ther i+uidFuels4 in this $hapter" Are these specific fuelsthose mentioned in $hapter 1A1. Table 8-2G
Ues. table included from1A1
Cill change with newtables
,n Table 8-I. 9io&ins and Furans emission factorshave not been estimated for :ther i+uid Fuels"/owever. when using Tier 2 approach there is anemission factor of I ,-T= ng>D independently ofwhat is the %'A* activity considered"
Cill change with newtables
Chich fuels are considered under the fuel type4<iomass4G
For combustion these areas listed in 1A1 - table nowincluded in te&t
,n general terms it is have not been clarifiedwhether the proposed emission factors correspondto the emissions originated from only the fuelscombusted or they also correspond to totalemissions originated from the fuels combustedplus those originated from the materials in thecontact furnaces" $arificatin of this pont isparticularly relevant for the activities in the 1A2'F category. as many of its installations are
contact furnaces"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned to
the process chapters
:nly a un!nown elaboration on very old <values" 'C ,'F:AT,:' F: ,**$ <F9:'0T TA;' ,'T: A$$:'T" Chy only $o!e:ven as when old < contains Fs also for blastfurnace gas and natural gasG %pecific fuelconsumptions in D>g of product %T <*:T95
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
<last furnace cowpers (%'A* 828)# missionfactors proposed only covers co!e oven gascombustion (table 8-@). but there are noinformation available related to other fuels
(specially blast furnace gas. but also * ornatural gas)"
9iscussed with *. tables
have been amended toclarify
F in tables (Tier 2) for T%*. / and *$99>F arethe similar for same fuel and different processes.for instance. F in Tables 8-?. 8-1I. 8-2@. 8-2?. 8-82. 8-3 (fuel is co!e or hard coal)" The samesituation ] for as. i+uid fuels" /ow this wssprovedG ,s it necessary to duplicate tablesG
Tables revised followingdiscussion with *
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 275/669
'oted
'oted Tables have been revised
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
ditorial 9one
'oted
The production processes described in theguideboo! are generic. focussed on applicabilityfor various individual processes" This approachdoes not ta!e into account the more comple&reality of intertwined processes such as ,ron and%teel anufacture" This is especially true for the
use of mi&ed process gases"
Ues but the level of activitydetail defines the basis offactors suitable for use at
Tier 1 and 2Table 8-? Tier 2# it is shown that / emissionfactors are from the uideboo! (26)" <ut in theTable ?"2c of the uideboo! (26) there are nosuch emission factors"
Fs old and not validated" * Fs for 1"A"2 and2"$"1# as you subdivide combustion and notcombustion * emissions5 se <F Fs5
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
Fs old and not validated" * Fs for 1"A"2 and2"$"1# as you subdivide combustion and notcombustion * emissions5 se <F Fs5
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
Fs old and not validated" * Fs for 1"A"2 and
2"$"1# as you subdivide combustion and notcombustion * emissions5 se <F Fs5
9iscussed with *. tables
have been amended toclarify
The %'A* code in table 8-1 (882). and theliteral for Technologies>*ractices item (eheatingFurnaces) does not match with the heading of thetable" Chich activity is referred to in this tableG
Cill change with newtables
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-1
evised F tables shouldbe clearer
For eheating Furnaces (%'A* 882) there areonly emission factors for co!e oven gas" Chat0sthe matter with the other fuels used in this activityG,n uideboo! 26 there is a wide list of fuels usedin this furnaces"
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
Table 8-12 (Tier 2)# error in the title of the tableK notcoincide with the content (eheating furnaces)K Ffor *$99>F are shown with reference to theuideboo! 26. but in the uideboo! 26 thereare no such emission factors"
The title refers to 4ray ,ron Foundries4 but thetechnology in the table refers to 4eheatingFurnaces4" /owever e&isting < Fs old and notvalidated" * Fs for 1"A"2 and 2"$"1# as yousubdivide combustion and not combustion *emissions5 se <F Fs5
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 276/669
'oted %ee earlier comment
'oted Table headings modified
'oted
Accepted
'oted
'oted %ee earlier comment
The %'A* code in table 8-12 (882). and theliteral for Technologies>*ractices item (eheatingFurnaces) does not match with the heading of thetable" Chich activity is referred to in this tableGmission factors in this table are the same asthose proposed in Table 8-1"
Cill change with newtables
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-12
Tables 8-12 - 8-18 Tier 2# it is !nown that gray ironin foundries is produced using co!e so how F fornatural gas and other li+uid fuels were obtainedand where they can be appliedG
Chy 4:ther i+uid Fuels4G Chy these Fs G %<F Fs5
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
,n the e&isting guideboo! default values are
provided in g>tonne li+uid steel. which perhaps is abetter unit for these type of default emissionfactors"
Tables have been modifiedto allow use of productionactivity data at Tier 2
The /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-18 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with newtables
The *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-18 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
Table 8-13# For *rimary and %econdary *b>Yn>$uproduction using 'atural as. it is very surprisingthat there are no heavy metals emissions(indicated as not applicable). ta!ing into acccountthat these are processes with contact and the rawmaterials obviously content the corresponding/eavy etals"
/eavy metals nowassigned to processemission
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-13
The same F for *. /. *$99>F and *A/ areshown in the Tables 8-13 (*b>$u>Yn *roduction).8-1@ (%econdary Aluminium *roduction) and 8-2(Alumina>g>'i *roduction)K though technologies
are different"
Cill change with new
tables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 277/669
'oted
'oted
'oted ounding issue corrected
Table 8-16# same comment as for Table 8-1I" 'oted
'oted
All the chapter 48"8"2"2 $ombustion in 1A2b ] 1'on-ferrous metal4 it0s unclear because , don0tunderstand if ta!e into account the differentcondition of combustion in roasting and as it0spossible to subdivide emissions from fuel and frommaterials in such a case (see 'A*,,'AU $:'T)" ,f it0s possible it0snecessary to develop specific emission factors notto copy 4old4 F that derive from anotherapproach"
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
,n Table 8-1I. emission factors for /eavy etals.9io&ins and Furans and *A/ for *rimary *b. Ynand $u *roduction using co!e are the same as inany other activity in this 1A2 'F category" ,n theparticular case of /eavy etals. it seems thatemission factors only refers to emissionsoriginated from the fuel combusted and there is no
relation to the raw materials used"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned to
the process chaptersTable 8-16 also contains mysterious 44 values"i!ewise with table 8-1J. table 8-26. table 8-8.table 8-83. table 8-86. table 8-8?. table 8-31 andtable 8-38"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned to
the process chaptersThe /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-16 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with newtables
The *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-16 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
The same F for *. /. *$99>F and *A/ areshown in the Tables 8-16 (*b>$u>Yn *roduction)and 8-1J (%econdary Aluminium *roduction)Kthough technologies are different"
Cill change with newtables
%'A* code in table 8-1@ should be 881 (not
88)
Cill change with new
tables,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-1@
%'A* code in table 8-1? should be 881 (not88)
Cill change with newtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 278/669
'oted
Accepted
'oted %ee earlier comment
'oted
'oted
,n Table 8-1?. *1 and *2"I emission factorsfor heavy fuel oil seem to be interchanged (*2"Ivalues are higher than *1)
Cill change with newtables
The same F for *. / and *A/ are shown inthe Tables 8-1? (%econdary Aluminium *roduction)and 8-21 (Alumina>g>'i *roduction)K thoughtechnologies are different" There are errors of Ffor *1 and *2"I in both tables"
Cill change with newtables
%'A* code in table 8-1J should be 881 (not88)
Cill change with newtables
The /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-1J is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with newtables
The *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-1J is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-2
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n Table 8-21. *1 and *2"I emission factorsfor heavy fuel oil seem to be interchanged (*2"Ivalues are higher than *1)
evised F tables shouldbe clearer
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-22
All the chapter $ombustion in 1A2d ] *ulp and 1paper production is not necessary (emissions arecounted in 1"A"1 as boilers)
<oiler plant emissions canuse factors from 5A1 (or1A3) butthey are not a 1A1activity
*articles and metals in table 8-23 are indicated asincluded elsewhere" Chere would that beG
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n Table 8-28 the JI confidence interval for 'i is"2-"" Chat is the upper bound of thisintervalG
Cill change with newtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 279/669
'oted
'oted
ditorial 9one
'oted %ee earlier comment
'oted
'oted
mission factors for dio&ins and furans and *A/for wood are the same as for hard coal (or co!e) inother activities" Are this emission factors correctGCe could not find in uideboo! 26 thisreference for %'A* activity 8821"
Cill change with newtables
,n Table 8-23. particulates and heavy metalsemission factors for blac! li+uor combustion havethe label 4,4" Chere have these emission factorsbeen includedG
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
Chat does 4,4 for emission factors mean G Chereincluded G
,ncluded elsewhere butthese references havebeen removed (notestimated)
rroneous paragraph numeration 8"8"3 and not
8"8"8"1,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-2I
*laster# all the te&t it0s unclear because , don0tunderstand if ta!e into account the differentcondition of combustion in !iln and as it0s possibleto subdivide emissions from fuel and frommaterials in such a case (see 'A*,,'AU $:'T)" ,f it0s possible it0snecessary to develop specific emission factors not
to copy 4old4 F that derive from another approach(combustion V process)"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balance
of emissions assigned tothe process chapters
For *laster Furnaces there are only emissionfactors proposed for natural gas and other li+uidfuels" Chich emission factors should be used forother fuels li!e hard coal. heavy fuel oil. petroleumco!e. wood. """G
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
The /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-26 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for this
pollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with new
tablesThe *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-26 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 280/669
'oted
ditorial 'one
e7ected
'oted %ee earlier comment
'oted
$ement# all the te&t it0s unclear because , don0tunderstand if ta!e into account the differentcondition of combustion in !iln and as it0s possibleto subdivide emissions from fuel and frommaterials in such a case (see 'A*,,'AU $:'T)" ,f it0s possible it0s
necessary to develop specific emission factors notto copy 4old4 F that derive from another approach(combustion V process)"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only
':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
ive precise reference to F rather thanuideboo! (26)
Cill change with newtables
The table design with one fuel per table do not givea general view of F - all fuels per process in onetable
For $ement *roduction. there are no emissionfactors proposed for petroleum co!e. heavy fueloil. wood and wood wastes" *etroleum co!e is themain fuel used in this activity"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-2J
,n Table 8-2J. 9io&ins and Furans emission factorshas not been estimated for 'ataural as"/owever. whe using Tier 2 approach there is anemission factor of 2 ,-T= ng>D independently of
the %'A* activity considered"
Cill change with new
tablesThe /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-8 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with newtables
The *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-8 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
Table 8-81 Tier 2# no emission factors for *$99>Fwhich are high for waste combustion"
Caste combustion factorsnow removed asinappropriate in thischapter
The fuel indicated in Table 8-81 (/ard coal) is
wrong" ,n accordance with the heading it should be4,ndustrial waste4
Cill change with newtables
Table 8-81# Fuel# eplace 4/ard coal4 with4,ndustrial waste4
Cill change with newtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 281/669
'oted
'oted
'oted %ee earlier comment
'oted
'oted
ime# all the te&t it0s unclear because , don0tunderstand if ta!e into account the differentcondition of combustion in !iln and as it0s possibleto subdivide emissions from fuel and frommaterials in such a case (see 'A*,,'AU $:'T)" ,f it0s possible it0s
necessary to develop specific emission factors notto copy 4old4 F that derive from another approach(combustion V process)"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only
':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
'ot all fuels used in lime production are covered inthe 9raft" There are no emission factors for co!e.petroleum co!e. heavy fuel oil or biomass fuels"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is said
that 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-88
,n Table 8-88. 9io&ins and Furans emission factorshas not been estimated for 'ataural as"/owever. whe using Tier 2 approach there is anemission factor of 2 ,-T= ng>D independently ofthe %'A* activity considered"
'* factor adopted atTier 1. Tier 2 factors will bein process chapters
':B-F for ime !ilns seems to be very high sincethe needed temperatures are much lower than forcement !ilns" The different !iln types have verydifferent levels on ':B emissions" (seehttp#>>www"umweltbundesamt"at>fileadmin>site>publi!ationen>*12?"pdf. page 11)
Tham!you for providingdata. this is good detail on
state of the art><AT but ison a restricted pool ofplant" 9ata from the draftrevised $* <F doesn0tprovide fuel-based Fs butindicates a very widerange of emissions andthe factors provided in theguideboo! are within therange of 0inferred0 factorsfrom the <F data"
The /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-83 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for this
pollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with new
tablesThe *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-83 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 282/669
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
'oted %ee earlier comment
,n Table 8-86. the fuel is described as 4:ther i+uid
Fuels4. but probably it is about gas oil" ,s thisassumption correctG
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balance
of emissions assigned tothe process chapters
Asphalt# all the te&t it0s unclear because , don0tunderstand if ta!e into account the differentcondition of combustion in !iln and as it0s possibleto subdivide emissions from fuel and frommaterials in such a case (see 'A*,,'AU $:'T)" ,f it0s possible it0snecessary to develop specific emission factors notto copy 4old4 F that derive from another approach(combustion V process)" * from process where isinsertedG
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n accordance with uideboo! 26. chapter<8818. 49uring the production of asphalt concreteconsiderable amounts of fine particles can begenerated4"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n Table 8-8@ (gas natural combustion in asphaltplants). the emission factor for ':$ isindicated as estimated elsewhere (,)"'evertheless. in Table 8-86 (combustion of otherli+uid fuels) an emission factor of 11"? g>D ismentioned"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-8@
The /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-8? is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with newtables
The *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-8? is
g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 283/669
'oted
'oted %ee earlier comment
'oted
'oted
'oted %ee earlier comment
lass# all the te&t it0s unclear because , don0tunderstand if ta!e into account the differentcondition of combustion in !iln and as it0s possibleto subdivide emissions from fuel and frommaterials in such a case (see 'A*,,'AU $:'T)" ,f it0s possible it0snecessary to develop specific emission factors notto copy 4old4 F that derive from another approach(combustion V process)" * from process where isinsertedG etals emissions very important for thesector where are insertedG
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
For lass *roduction. the %'A* code indicated is88" ,t is suposed that %'A* codes involved are8813. 881I. 8816 and 881@"
Cill change with newtables
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-8J
The fuels considered are /ard $oal. :ther i+uidFuels and 'atural as" 'o reference is made toother fuels li!e heavy fuel oil. petroleum co!e orbiomass (wood and wood wastes)"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
<ric!s and Tiles# all the te&t it0s unclear because ,don0t understand if ta!e into account the differentcondition of combustion in !iln and as it0s possible
to subdivide emissions from fuel and frommaterials in such a case (see 'A*,,'AU $:'T)" ,f it0s possible it0snecessary to develop specific emission factors notto copy 4old4 F that derive from another approach(combustion V process)" * from process where isinsertedG
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
The /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-31 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with newtables
The *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-31 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
There is no emission factor for ':$ in Table 8-32
Cill change with newtables
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-32
The /g emission factor proposed in Table 8-38 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "1-"1
Cill change with newtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 284/669
'oted
'oted %ee earlier comment
Accepted
Accepted 9one
eferences include only 2 sources" 'oted evised
'oted evised
The *b emission factor proposed in Table 8-38 is g>D. while the JI confidence interval for thispollutant is "8-"2
Cill change with newtables
The fuels considered are :ther i+uid Fuels and'atural as" 'o reference is made to other fuelsli!e /eavy Fuel :il"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
Chich %'A* codes are referred to in Tables 8-32and 8-38G
Cill change with newtables
,n $hapter 1A1. page J. lines 81 to 88. it is saidthat 4for natural gas only emissions of mercury arerelevant """4" /owever no emission factors for /gare indicated in Table 8-33
,n 4lossary4 section the * are included into4aseous fuels4. while in $hapter 1A1. Table 8-2.the * are considered as 4:ther li+uid fuels4
$hanged changed to li+uidfuels
This glossary should either be e&panded orremoved" %ome listings in the glossary do notappear previously in the te&t"
A lot of references in the te&t do not appear in thelist of references. e"g" $*,* 23. $,T*A2@. uideboo! 26. $,T*A 'A 2@. %
*A 1JJ?. % *A 2. % *A 28 etc"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 285/669
Accepted
'oted
'oted
evaporate in the drying process" The 4new4uideboo! don0t ta!e into account these last andreport Fs for combustion that can be differentfrom F in 1"A"1" Then we have a lot of similarcases for e&le $ombustion in Food ,ndustry.echanic ,ndustry. ecc" Chat emissions factorsGCe need a specific subsection"'e&t we have old %'A* 82 and 88 group andrelated new chapters" , thin! in these chaptersmust be inserted only emissions come fromprocesses in which special condition or the contactbetween fuel and materials produces differentcombustion characteristics and different Fs#essentially process furnaces" For theseapplications. all the e&isting documentation (andfor e&le <F of the ,**$ directive) reportsFs in g pollutants>!g product" Also statistical dataare available for production and not for energyconsumption of single product (for e&le areavailable sinter production and fuel consumption iniron steel industry but not fuel consumption in
sinter plant)" ,f the fuel approach is mandatorythen# 1" ,t0s necessary to develop specific emissionfactors. only from fuel. not to copy 4old4 F thatderive from another approach (e&le % *Aapproach. that ta!e into account the overallprocess 2" %pecific fuel consumptions in D>g ofproduct %T < *:T9" ,'F:AT,:'B,%T% A'9 $A' < T,9 ,' ,**$<F 9:$'T"
9iscussed with *. tableshave been amended toclarify
The table contains some odd values. , assumethis is due to the haste with which this documentappears to have been drafted"
Cill change with newtables
$:'$%,:'# The chapter is unacceptable5 Allthe documentation from <F ignored also datasent to consultant from * leader5 All therecommendation in * and from industry about noseparation between combustion and processesignored" All the recommendation of use of productapproach ignored"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n addition to this. industrial waste fuels cover awide variety of materials. as specified in page 6.lines 8I and 86. with different characteristics andcomposition. so it is not clear if the emissionfactors proposed should be applied to all industrial
waste fuels"
Caste factors now
removedoreover. there are no emission factors proposedfor heavy metals. dio&ins and furans and *A/. andemissions for these pollutants are relevant whenusing industrial waste fuels"
$onsult with&pert *anel
Caste factors nowremoved
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 286/669
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
Additionally. emission factors for %:&. ':&.
':$ and $: are the same as for hard coal" Are these emission factors correctG
$onsult with&pert *anel
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balance
of emissions assigned tothe process chapters
,n addition. the reference for emission factors isuideboo! (26). but the corresponding chapterfor %'A* 8818 only provides emission factorsfor particles" This comment is also valid foremission factors related to gas naturalconsumption in Table 8-8@"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
/owever. emission factors for particles in Tables 8-86 and 8-8@ seems to concern only fuelconsumption"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
Ta!ing into account that this is a process with
contact. these particles emission factors areprobably underestimated"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balance
of emissions assigned tothe process chapters
Chat is the difference between both tablesGChere is the ':$ emission factor for naturalgas combustion indicatedG
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
There are only two !ind of fuels considered# :theri+uid Fuels and 'atural as" 'o reference ismade to other fuels li!e heavy fuel oil"
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 287/669
'oted
'oted
'oted Te&t amended to clarify
'otedeaning of T:-cycles 1G 'oted 'eeds correcting
'oted
'oted
'oted has been emphasised
'oted has been emphasised
Accepted Cill e&pand e&planation
Accepted Cill e&pand e&planation
Accepted
,n addition. emission factors for :ther i+uid Fuels
should be splitted for each fuel considered in thiscategory (gas oil. *. """)
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balance
of emissions assigned tothe process chapters
Chich emissions (combustion and>or process) areconsidered in the emission factors proposedG ,nchapter 2"A"@"d. emission factors for heavy metalsand particulates are propposed (in terms of massof pollutant per unit of production).
Following discussion with*. Tier 1 is defaultcombustion only. Tier 2 isgenerally only':&>%:B>$: with balanceof emissions assigned tothe process chapters
and it is not clear if there is a ris! of doublecounting when applying both emission factors"
Chat are the ma7or changes since earlierversionsG
Cill outline the mainchanges
9efault methodology has been developped by,$A: concerning A* cf" 4Airport Air =ualityuidance anual4 ,$A:. April 2@" That could beadded within the <. as far as the fuel used is theaircraft !eroHene"
/as been considered andwords added under4Au&illary poweroperations4 on p3 of %:9
Cithin the 2@ *>$:,'A, uideboo!.general information on A* and fuel dumping areprovided that may be interesting to !eep"
/as been incorporatedwhere appropriate
,t must be emphasiHed. that military aviation is
classified as 'F code 1AI (other) according toagreed * nomenclature"
*lease distinguish between sources of emissionsbelong under this 'F and other (e"g paintingbelongs to another 'F and should not beignored)
This should be e&plained in much more details.and a table should be provided giving a thoroughoverview of today0s situation
%ome elaboration on the grouping of 'Fcategories for each reporting re+uirement would beuseful here"
There is a lot of emission data for turboprops also"9ata for the most commonly engine fitted tospecific aircraft
updated aviation emissionfactors have beendiscussed with C(&pert *anel member)and incorporated asappropriate
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 288/669
Accepted
Accepted has been emphasised
AcceptedChat 9irective do you refer toG Accepted Cill e&pand e&planation
Accepted
has been modified
Accepted will reword
'oted will reword
'oted will reword
'oted
Table 2"1. this table needs update as it is ten yearsold. and new aircraft must be included
updated aviation emissionfactors have beendiscussed with C(&pert *anel member)and incorporated asappropriate
ilitary is reporting under a different 'F. while it0smethodology is described here
This paragraph was not included in the outlineagreed in 9essau" Furthermore if it is to beincluded it must be updated with new numbersfrom more recent references" %ame with table 2"8and 2"3" (the same comment applies to otherchapters including a similar paragraph)
$onsult with&pert *anel
D oodwin consulted withe&pert panel member(C)
Table 2"2# There is more recent legislation for ':&"*lease refer to the
updated the aviationemission regulations havebeen included"
Table 2"2" ,sn0t there more up to date informationavailableG
updated the aviationemission regulations havebeen included"
These tables 2-8 and 2-3. sould be completed withtables relating to internationals emissions" 'ote #international T: emissions are part of national'$9 emissions. and important issues ofemission trends for aviation concern internationalaviation" For international aviation emissions. e"g"international>domestic ratios could be displayed"
$onsult with&pert *anel
D oodwin consulted withe&pert panel member(C)
The 9ecision tree needs improving" %urely the first
2 diamond shaped white bo&es are needed to usea tier 8 method"
$onsult with&pert *anel
The decision tree is more less impossible tounderstand" *lease use the old decision tree as abasis for the Tier e&planations"
$onsult with&pert *anel
Table 8-1 is a complete mess. and is basicallywrong5
$onsult with&pert *anel
Footnoe I. must be changed. it is copied from,*$$ (26) and does not ma!e sense in thisconte&t
*lease state where military aviation emissions
should be reported"Chat do you mean by 4not reported here4" ilitaryaviation is a part of 'F 1AIb along with othermilitary mobile activities"
This te&t is incomprehensible" Further. it is not inline with the emission reporting uidelines (fore&le multilateral operations are ':T e&cludedfrom emission totals under TA*)
Te&t ta!en verbatim from,*$$ 26. need toconsult with e&pert panel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 289/669
'oted has been modifiedThis is not possible to understand5 'oted has been modified
'oted has been modified
'oted has been modified
'oted has been modified
'oted
'oted has been modified
'oted
This methodological description is not improvingthe old 4simple method4 described in section 3-2 of<?I1-18" ,t is assuming that inventory compiliers!now how to estimate emissions wothoutdescribing the process"
%ome duplication of information with section 8"2"8 Activity data"
$an the default emission factors (table8-8 fordomestic T:) also be used non-,F fligthsdomestic T:G ,t is not specified whether thedefaults are for ,F>F" Ce have an amount ofT: for F flights (small aircrafts li!e *A2?.$1I2.L) and not the amount of flight hours for F. andwonder if we can use table 8-8. 8-? and 8-J for it"
$onsult with&pert *anel
,n table 8-8 (Tier 1 9efault Fuel use in T:).second 'F source (domestic T:) has as fuel #
7et !erosine" ,s the value also valid for 7et gasoline aviation gasoline fuel useG :r must there a valuebe added for further use with tables 8-? and 8-JG
,s there no reference to these fuel consumptionFs in Table 8-8" Also what is meant by !g>tonnefuel in 'F 1"a"8"a"i(ii)" %hould it not be !g>T:G
,nformation on />*:*s are missing" *lease citethe origin (source) of emission factors from the*-$. emission factors must be tracable(comment applies to many chapters)" Furthermore
Tier 1 emission factors must be updated. a lot hasbeen changed since these Tier 1 emission factorswere derived
Fs have been includedwhere available
,0m not sure that a reference to an F should be4$alc from Tier 24 in Tables 8-? and 8-J" This couldbe described better"
Aviation gasoline is added substantial amounts oflead. please provide information
Fs have been includedwhere available
9ata available and necessary to apply Tier 2method sould be specified" 0The algorithmsparagraph 8"8"1 is not detailed enough" %omecomponents of such step by step algorithms is
given but in F paragraph 8"8"2" A global overviewof the algoritms is missing"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified in
consultation with e&pertpanel member C
The Tier 2 method should promote using fuel soldstatistics # separately domestic and internationalfuel sold when available" ,f these separate fuel soldstatistics are not available. then estimation methodcould be used to split domestic and internationalfuel consumption. as presented in step 1"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 290/669
'oted
Chere does the data in this table originate fromG 'oted has been modified
*lease provide some method description for Tier 2" 'oted
'oted
'oted
ditorial
,t is strange to recommand to use Tier 8 F withina Tier 2 method" Furthermore. in case of using Tier2 method. data on cruise distances per aircraffttype are generally not available for using Tier 8 F(distance dependant)"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
The lin! of theses lines with paragraph 8"8"8 Activity data is not clear"
has been modified in
consultation with e&pertpanel member C
$an emissions factors for airplane types that aredisappeared referred to older versions of theguideboo! still be used from older versions (fore&le $oncorde in 1JJ6 guidelines)G
$onsult with&pert *anel
Fs used have beendiscussed with e&pertpanel member. C
The Tier 2 method is completely wrong5 Thismethod cannot use mission distance based factorsfor cruise - this relates to Tier 85
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
,n the last part of the bo&. reference to the F9< ismade. however there is no F9< for air pollutants5
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
Footnote ?. this assumption should be revieweddue to more recent !nowledge
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
Table 8-11# ,t is not acceptable to use the emissionfactors for T: provided by the ,*$$ 26guidelines
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
table 8-11# Footnote (8) does not appear belowKthere (2) apperas twice" - *lease change the 2nd(2) into (8)"
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 291/669
Accepted
'oted
'oted will clarifyTable 8"13" %ourceG 'oted will reference
'oted
'oted
'oted will continue to be
'otedThe sentence is diffucult to understand" 'oted will clarify
Chere is the table 8"1 G 'oted
'oted,t is both turbo fan and turbo prop engines" 'oted should be altered
'oted
Accepted
*lease chec! if this table has been updated withmore recent aircraft and ma!e corrections asappropriate
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
This paragraph should be more detailed. especiallythe lin! with the steps displayed in 8"8"2"
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
Chy is military described here in section 8"8"IG ,nwith the Tier 2 methodG There is no mention ofmilitary under the Tier 8 method"
Chat is the minimum flown distance for anairplane to reach cruise levelG Table 8-1I starts at12I nm" ,t means dat below 12I nm. an airplane isnot cruising yet (in normal average conditions)G
These data are ta!enverbatim from earlierversions of the guideboo!- refer to e&pert panel
,n general the method choice and descriptionshould preceed the F tables" %ection 8"3"2 onTier 8 Fs is on page 2I whilst section 8"3"8"1 on
Tier 8A method is on page 2J" This ma!es thechapter very difficult to read"
/ave re-organised Ftables
*lease e&plain where the remainer Tier 8 emissionfactors can be found (currently they are availableas a spreadhseet download)
There are no cruise emission factors published onthe ,$A: website"
These data are ta!enverbatim from earlierversions of the guideboo!- refer to e&pert panel
/ave as!ed author ofprevious guideboo!
This is not possible to follow. what has it to do withengine independent emission factorsG And whereis Appendi& 1G
should be aircraft type - Appendi& 1 is unaltered
For non-,F flights. we still use emission factorsfrom *A. A*-32 volume ,, (1J?I)" $an they still beusedG Chy are they not included as referencedefault emission factors (instead of calculatingnothing) G
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
These method descriptions in sections 8"3"8"1 to8"3"8"8 should be on page 23 before the F tables"
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
The note provides considerations on energybalance for domestic aviation" %imilarconsiderations on energy balance for internationalaviation sould be also included (ta!ing into accountthat in case of international aviation. half ofinternational fuel consumption should becompared to fuel sold in the country forinternational flights)"
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 292/669
These are very old data. please update Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted Cill include 9escription
'oted
'oted
'oted will clarify
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
,$A: website"
in the Tables 8-3 and 8-I is preferable"
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
This section 3"3 has nothing to do with consistenttime series and recalculation5 ,t is simply copy andpaste from the old chapter section 8"6
4*ro7ections4# ven the title has been changed tofit the misplaced content"
has been modified in
consultation with e&pertpanel member C
This information (including the tables) appearsoutdatet" Chat is for e&le 4current level4 inTable 3-1G *lease update or rewrite
has been discussed withe&pert panel member C
,t is indeed suprising that there is no specific issuehere given the comple&ity of reporting this category(e"g" differences betwee 'F$$$. TA* and'$ reporting). memo items etc" (same remar! tonavigation>shipping chapter)
Chat other sourcesG ,t is essential to e&plainwhere the data comes from
'ot changed - ta!enverbatim from previous
version of the guidboo!"efer to e&pert panel
Chat is the difference between Anne& < and Table8-11G Are both neededG
has been discussed withe&pert panel member C
A large number of references in this chapter arenot found in the reference list" (including ,*$$(26) which the method is based on5)
*lease also include Tier 2 cruise emission factors(else the method will not wor!)
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
*lease refer also to general commentssummarised in the separate word file 49; eviewof guideboo! chapters for mobile sources"doc4
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
ven more important. a lot of references ande&planations how data are obtained. are missing"
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
All military mobile activities (aviation. land basedand sailing activities) are classified as 1AIb(e+uivalent to %'A* code ?1) according to*"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
data are available from the current guideboo!. both
for T: and cruise distance classes
$onsult with
&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pert
panel member C
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 293/669
Accepted $orrected
'oted
'oted $orrected<adly written" 'oted $orrected
*oorly phrased" 'oted<adly written. and difficult to follow" 'oted $hanged
Chat is section 3G The sentence gives no meaning 'oted %orted
*lease use the simple method description directlyfrom the old guideboo!"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
These T: factors are not supported by newcruise emf related to distances. as in the currentguideboo! version"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
oreover. loo!ing into the ,*$$ guidelines theT: factors are very poorly documented"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
,f we use the ,*$$ data. we loose the consistencywith cruise factors per distance class. and forspecies li!e ':&. ':$ and $:
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
cruise factors heavily depend on the actualaircraft>engine combination" ,n some countries.detailed city-pair inventories
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
are made each year using distances betweenairports. and for these countries such new data
gives less meaning"
$onsult with
&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pert
panel member C%o. the strong recommendation is to maintain the4old4 T: (and cruise) emf in order not to introduceerrors into the inventories"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
The data come from specific simulations made byaircraft emission e&perts"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
and the approach used to obtain the data that ispresented in the guideboo!"
$onsult with&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pertpanel member C
The schematic diagram (Figure 3"1) in the chapter<?I1 in the uideboo! should be retained in the
new chapter"
$onsult with
&pert *anel
has been modified inconsultation with e&pert
panel member CTitle of chapter should include a reference tobuses. ie /9s and buses instead of 4heavy-dutytruc!s4"
Chat is the difference between 0:verview0 and0eneral description0G
eneral 9escription is partof the :verview"
These paragraphs are rather badly written. andcould be improved"
e7ected because thisphrase was ta!en verbatim
from e&isting guideboo!.see <@1-1 in pdf version
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 294/669
$: is not an :Hone *recursor e7ected
Accepted $orrected
'oted $orrected
'oted $orrected
'otedChere is this referenceG 'oted $orrected%hould read 0three-tier0" 'oted $orrected
The section 2"1 title is not helpful" 'otedChat is meant by 0positively ignite0G 'oted $orrected
'oted $orrected
Figure 2-1 is poor" Chat purpose does it serveG e7ectedFigure 2-1 gives no information" 'oted $orrectedThis reference is wrong" ditorial %orted
Accepted %ortedChere is Table 2-1G ditorial %ortedChere is the Tables 3-@ to 3-2JG ditorial %orted
The A include $: intheir definition of :Hone*recursorhttp#>>glossary"eea"europa"eu>Alossary>:>oHoneP precursor
9elete 0mobile0" $hange 0transportation0 to0transport0 (throughout)"$hange 0vehicles0 to0vehicle0"
Chy 0on-road0G The whole chapter refers to roadvehicles"
missions from e&haust aftertreatmentG This isnonsense"
$hange to 0The most important pollutants fromroad vehicles are coveredL0"
$onsult with&pert *anel
e7ected because thisphrase was ta!en verbatimfrom e&isting guideboo!.see <@1-1 in pdf version
Chat is the relationship to $:*TG ,f it has beenupdated five times why are we now at $:*T 3G
The e&isting guideboo!says it is the Ith update.see <@1-2 in pdf version"These lines merely reflectthese words - no changemade"
Cill clarify align withtransport terminology
Chich processG :ne of the combustion
processesG Figure 2-1 does not show combustionprocesses"
used to conceptualise theboundaries of roadtransport emissions. and isan approach adoptedthroughout the uideboo!"
,t is written that for Tier 1 uses fuel as activityindicator with average fuel specific emission
factors" <ut then in the table 8-2-8"Jf are g>D
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 295/669
ditorial $orrected
ditorial $orrected
Accepted %orted
Accepted %ortedunits for $d and *b in table 8-2 are missing" Accepted $orrected
Figure 8-1 should read 49ecision tree for roadtransport4 not 4aviation4" , also wonder about thediamond 4,s this a !ey sourceG4" oad transport isalways a !ey-source" There should be added the
following statement in p"6 where the figure isintroduced# 4oad transport is a !ey-source in allcountries" Therefore. the Tier 1 method should onlybe used in the absence of any more detailedinformation than fuel statistics" ,n parallel. in such acase. the country needs to ma!e every effort tocollect the detailed statistics re+uired to use ahigher Tier method. preferrably Tier 8"4
+" 1 needs to change to read i.7.! where ! willrefer to fuel (gas. diesel. *. ')" Therefore. F$7should change to F$7.! and fi.7 should change tofi.7.!"
the formula (1) multiply F Qg>!gfuelR for F$ (fuelconsumption Q!g fuel but in the table the emissionfactor for Tier 1 approach are e&pressed in termsof g>D" There should be one common standardand , suggest that !g of fuel ma!es more sense
The emission factors are wrong. due to errors inthe calculations"
Tables 8"2 to 8"J present emission factors in g>D"First. the methodology in p"@ is in g>!g" %econd.the values are wrong (they should be _I timeshigher)" , understand the editors try to beconsistent with ,*$$" :n the other hand. urostatdata report all values in tonnes that can be readilyconverted to !g. without !nowing the energycontent of fuel" ,n addition. methodologies Tier 2and Tier 8 calculate total fuel consumption in !g sowhy having Tier 1 in DG Third. emission values ing>!g fuel are widespread and are published inscientific literature so the reader can comparethem to the uideboo! values" All models ($opert.
Artemis. even eritV in the 'etherlands) use fuelmass values" /eavy metals and sulfur are allreported per mass of fuel" The user of any
methodology needs now to convert them to D5 ,!now of no source that reports emission in g>De&cept for /s" <ut even in the 26 ,*$$uidelines. '2: and $/3 emission factors for %and urope are in mg>!m" ,n summary. , find thee&pression g>D aw!ward and not practical and ,strongly reccomend this to be changed bac! tog>!g fuel"
$onsult with&pert *anel
%orted - after discussionswith &pert *anel we havereverted bac! toe&pressing emissionfactors in units of g>tonnefuel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 296/669
Accepted
units for $d and *b in table 8-I are missing" Accepted %ortedunit for $d in table 8-6 are missing" Accepted %ortedunit for $d in table 8-@ are missing" Accepted %ortedunits for $d and *b in table 8-J are missing" Accepted %ortedtable 8-J# unit for $d and *b missing Accepted %orted
ditorial $orrectedChere is Table 3-6G ditorial %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted $orrected
'oted
Acceptedwhere is section 3"8"8G ditorial %orted
Tables 8"2 to 8"J also include emissions of %:&and heavy metals and ma!e reference to Tables 3-BBB" First. as the draft chapter stands now. thesetables are A"BBB and not 3"BBB. but please also
chec! my comment below related to the structureof the chapter" %econd. why should we provide adefault %:& emission factor (e+uivalent to 3 ppm% in fuel) when % content of fuel is !nown in eachcountryG 'one of the countries (e&cept <ulgaria)that are going to use a Tier 1 methodology haveaverage sulfur of 3 ppm5555 , reccomend weintroduce the very simple methodology (two rows)given in section A"6"J as part of Tier 1 as well" Thisis all it ta!es to have the correct estimation of %:&"
eferencing to tables willbe corrected" Alsocomment will beaddressed to include afle&ible % content variablewith a default if none is!nown"
Tables 8-2 to 8-J include 9efault Fs Tier1" Theunit used is g>D. instead og g>!g of fuel used" ,tmay be worth including both Fs by U and !g inthe final guideboo! and a description of thecalculation from one to the other"" Also , thin! thereference AT 2? needs to be clarified (e&actlya reference to which reportG)
$onsult with&pert *anel
%orted - after discussionswith &pert *anel we havereverted bac! toe&pressing emissionfactors in units of g>tonnefuel
All these Tables 8-11 to 8-8? contain Fs for Tier 2"Chat is the reference for these FsG
Tier 2 method gives Fs by technology. howeverthese technologies are not provided until the
Appendi& to this F:9"
Tables 8-11 to 8"8? contain the statement 4gramsof international to&ic e+uivalent4 for 9,:B and novalues" There are such values in Table A"11"
For heavy duty truc!s. so many siHe classe andtechnology combinations are missing in terms ofTier 2 emission factors"
$onsult with&pert *anel
$hanged - commentadded regarding what touse for 4missing4 siHe>technology combinations"
Table 8-8J is a good summary" , do not understandwhy this is only specific to F$ and what are theuses it intents to cover"
$orrected ,t0s use hasbeen clarified in the te&t"
4<y applying a trial-and-error-approach"""4 Thissentence is meaningless5
e7ected because thisphrase was ta!en verbatimfrom e&isting guideboo!.see <@1-8@ in pdf version
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 297/669
There is no discussion in section 3"8"85 ditorial %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted
Accepted Cill be refered to""
eferences are not oldG Accepted
Accepted
Acceptedeference to Table 3-1 is wrong" ditorial %ortedThere is no Table 2-1 in the chapter ditorial %orted
$: is not an :Hone *recursor e7ected
,t is a very wrong decision to let Tier 8 bedescribed in an Anne&" Tier 8 is what manycountries use now"
,t is very important that this Tier 8 method has aproper description and overview in the actualchapter as does the Tier 1 2 methods" Thismethod is the most used method by inventorycompiliers and should not be discussed in an
Appendi&"
The te&t in %ection 3"3 has nothing to do withconsistent time series and recalculation5 ,t is 7ustcopy and paste of %ection 18 4Temporaldisaggregation criteria4 from the old chapter"
/eading changed to reflectte&t provided - now nosection on 4developing aconsistent time series4 -'eed to decide on thee&tent of te&t neded onthis
The problem of 4tan! tourism4 it is not mentioned"
,f it is relevant. fuel balance. as e&plained here.could not be applied"
e7ected because thisphrase was ta!en verbatimfrom e&isting guideboo!.see <@1-31 in pdf version
This !ind of table could be very useful" Chy don0tput information on the other pollutantsG
Chere available data willbe included" These datawere ta!en verbatim fromTable 1-8 of previousguideboo!" Analogous
data for other pollutantswas not provided"
Cill be the emission factors for buses $'included into the $:*T ,G
$:*T 3 is a softwaretool outside the scope ofthis uideboo! revision"This +uestion will beforwarded to the team at
Artistotle niversity"
The A include $: intheir definition of :Hone*recursorhttp#>>glossary"eea"europa"eu>Alossary>:>oHoneP precursor
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 298/669
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted %ee above
ditorial %orted
ditorial
ditorial
%ection A"2 is not part of the Tier 8 methodologyand it is o! to remain as an Anne&" /owever. inother chapters (e"g" non-e&haust * emissions.evaporation) the sections referring to thecontribution of the sector to total emissions areprovided as introductory sections beforepresenting the Tier 1 methodology" %o. please beconsistent between chapters. where you want thissection to be presented (anne& or introduction)"
%ection A"8 should be part of Tier 1 methodologybecause it 7ust provides definitions of the vehicleclasses considered" %ection A"3 should be part ofTier 2 methodology because Tier 2 already usesthe emission standards classification"
etodology does not estimate in which categoryshould be included tracotrs with registrationnumber (vehicles)" These can not drive onmotorway"
e7ected for this versionbecause this phrase wasta!en verbatim frome&isting guideboo! -comment will be passed to
AT"
Table A"@ now offers no new information andneeds to be erased"
e7ected because theguidance we havereceived is that thee&isting detailedmethodology te&t shouldnot be changed much atall"
,ndeed the current section A"6 should follow as the
ne&t section. after A"1
$hec! format of Figure A"2" The te&t on the left-most bo&es should be vertical and not horiHontal"
The sentence is not coherent with the table A"I8"The sentence must be 4/owever. some additionalreductions need to be applied for vehicletechnologies post-uro 3 (Fi7). which are given inTable A" I84
e7ected for this versionbecause this phrase wasta!en verbatim frome&isting guideboo! -comment will be passed to
AT"
,n the e+uation (2@) replace e/:TKi.uro1 bye/:TKi.uro3 to be coherent with table A"I8 andfi7 factors
e7ected for this versionbecause this phrase wasta!en verbatim frome&isting guideboo! -comment will be passed to
AT"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 299/669
ditorial
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted %orted
The 4ehotKi.uro 14 value in e+" 2@ should bereplaced with 4ehotKi.uro 34" the 4ecold>ehot`i.uro14 value should remain intact"
e7ected for this versionbecause this phrase wasta!en verbatim frome&isting guideboo! -comment will be passed to
AT"
,t is not possible to distinguish between mopeds 2and 3 stro!esG
$onsult with&pert *anel
e7ected for this versionbecause this phrase wasta!en verbatim frome&isting guideboo! -comment will be passed to
AT"
table A"@@. A"@?. A"@J. A"? e A"?1 it is not possibleto define the emission factors in term of emissionlegislationG
$onsult with&pert *anel
e7ected for this versionbecause this phrase wasta!en verbatim frome&isting guideboo! -comment will be passed to
AT"
*lease refer also to general commentssummarised in the separate word file 49; eviewof guideboo! chapters for mobile sources"doc4
$omments have beenconsidered"
p to uro ,# The vehicle categories @.I-12 13-2 26-82 tons are missing"
%ee also comment 2?3 -$hanged - commentadded regarding what touse for 4missing4 siHe>technology combinations"
For newer technologies# The vehicle categories@.I-2 26-82 tons are missing"
%ee also comment 2?3 -$hanged - commentadded regarding what touse for 4missing4 siHe>technology combinations"
,n general the Anne&. who is supposed to treat Tier8. also repeats the data used for the old simplemethod"
The old chapter discusses how to treat emissioninventories in relation to dispersion models"
$onsult with&pert *anel
/eading changed to reflectte&t provided - now nosection on 4developing aconsistent time series4 -'eed to decide on the
e&tent of te&t neded onthis
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 300/669
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted
Accepted %orted
T/ T, 8 T/:9::U %T ':T <,'T:9$9 A% A' A''B <T A% %$T,:'8"3. A% :,,'AU F:%'" ':C T/C/: $/A*T ,% A %%5 A %$T,:'%
,' $/A*T 3 9,%$%% ,%%% :F T, 8T/:9::U (T/U A A $:*U :F T/*,:% %,:' :F T/ ,9<::;)
A'9 T, 8 ,% :'U ,'T:9$9 ,' T/ A''B" :%T F'$% F T: T/T, 8 T/:9 A'9 T/ T, 8 ,%,'T:9$9 AFT T/ F'$% A% A'
A''B5 ,T ,% *:,'T%% T: A; A 9TA,9,C A% T/ $/A*T ,% %: <A9UC,TT' A'9 %T$T9 T/AT ,% A;%': %'%"
The chapter ma!es a lot of references to sectionsand tables 3"&" These do not e&ist because Tier 8has been anne&ed" These need not be changedwhen the editors correct the chapter per myreccomendation above" /owever. there are manyerronous references to tables and figures as thedraft version stands now"
,n all Tier tables for the road transport notapplicable would be *:*sAnne& ,
$onsult with&pert *anel
The general description and overview couldperhaps include tables 1"1 and 1"2 from theuideboo! <@1-8"
There is no reference to classification of vehiclessuch as in the uideboo! table 8"1 <@1-@ andTable 8"6 <@1-16" All of this information isrelevant regardless of which Tier approach is usedby inventory compiliers and should be included inthe chapter overview or description"
Accepted - cross referenceincluded
eneral comment" This chapter needs ma7orrestructuring" All vehicle classifications. legislation(as described in <@1-18 to <@1-16) should beincluded in the te&t of the chapter before
discussion of the different Tier method (1.2 and 8)",mprovements are also needed in referencing Ftables and if changes are made to F units theseshould be e&plained clearly" Also there is no bul!$% Fs based on the 22 wor! which could beuseful for a Tier 1 method" There is no discussionof the contribution road transport ma!es to totalnational emissions"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 301/669
ditorial %orted
This paragraph could read a little better" noted evised
Accepted
Accepted
&plain what carbon canisters are" Accepted
Accepted evised
Accepted
%ubsections 6"1 and 6"2 should occur in the sameorder as the title of %ection 6" ,n addition. the level8 sections in the report are missing from the tableof contents"
This paragraph is poorly constructed and not wellphrased" /ow do breathing losses relate to diurnalemissions. hot soa! losses and running lossesG9o we need to use both 0losses0 and 0emissions0GDust use 0emissions0"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%ection 8"1" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
The last sentence of the para ought to be the first" Again" /ow do 0breathing losses0 relate to thesources mentioned" y understanding is that this
is a part of the process which leads to diurnalemissions"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%ection 8"1" Cill pass
comment on to &pert*anel
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) page1" Cill pass comment onto &pert *anel
*rocess description0 is not a good title in my view",t is too vague" , also thin! that it more or less
repeats title 2. and would therefore delete it"
$onsult with
&pert *anel
$ould be made moretransport specific"/owever. might detractfrom a common guideboo!
style"Figure 2-1 is poor" ,t could show the differentevaporative sources much more clearly (i"e" pictureof vehicle. with diurnal losses. hot soa! losses andrunning losses e&plained)"
aybe worth adding that some studies haveidentified 0resting emissions0 as a separateevaporative source" These result from diffusion.permeation. seepage and minor li+uid lea!s. anddo not need an increase in fuel temperature tooccur" /ere. , assume that these are already
included in the hot-soa! and diurnal calculationsG
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%ection 8"1"8" Cill passcomment on to &pert
*anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 302/669
Accepted
ditorial
Accepted
ditorial
ditorial
ditorial
*oorly written" %hould begin 09iurnal losses areL0"$an , offer something li!e this OO The increase inambient temperature which occurs during thedaylight hours results in the thermal e&pansion of
the fuel and vapour in the petrol tan!" Cithout anevaporation control system. some of the increasedvolume of fuel vapour is vented to the atmosphere"
At night. when the temperature drops. the vapourcontracts and fresh air is drawn into the petrol tan!through the vent" This lowers the concentration ofhydrocarbons in the vapour space above the li+uidpetrol. which subse+uently leads to additionalevaporation" The overall mechanism is also !nownas tan! breathingM"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%ection 8"1"1" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
Again. the wording could be better" Aren0t runninglosses are defined as something li!e 0theevaporative emissions which occur whilst a vehicleis being driven0G There is always vapour in the fueltan!" Are we tal!ing about additional vapourG%urely there is an increase in the fuel temperaturefor all vehicle types (e"g" heat from engine ande&haust)G
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%ection 8"1"2" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
9oes this para refer to vehicle refuelling. fueldelivery. or both" ,t shoul dbe clearer" /ere. it says0petrol stations0" ,0m not sure whether 0gasolinestations0 even e&ists in % nglish"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%ection 8"1"8" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
,n the line 3 we can read# 4Cithout an emissioncontrol system. some of the increasing volume offuel vapor is vented to atmosphere4
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) te&t insection 2"2"1" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
$hange to 0Lat the same level" /owever. the test
procedure for evaporative emissions increased inseverity0"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) te&t insection 8"8" Cill pass
comment on to &pert*anel
,n general. would prefer the ; nglish 0petrol0 tothe % nglish 0gasoline0" *lease use the term 0fueltan!0 instead of 0gasoline tan!0"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 303/669
ditorial
Accepted
$/2"1 is not a unit" Tan! breathing again" ditorial
&plain 0%/90" Accepted
Accepted
$hange to 0/ot-soa! emissions occur when L0"0/ot-soa!0 should be hyphenated when used
immediately before 0emissions0"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%ection 8"1"8" Cill passcomment on to &pert
*anel
Chat is the meaning of the %ection 2"8 title" ,t isvery vague"
$onsult with&pert *anel
'ot changed because thiswas the heading used inthe uideboo! version<@6(2@) /eading 8"2"Cill pass comment on to&pert *anel
The first sentence is unclear" Chat does it meanGThe distinction between :$s and ':$s alsoneeds to be better e&plained"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) te&t in
section 8"2" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) te&t insection 8"2" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
Again. the %ection heading (2"3) needs to be moreinformative"
$onsult with&pert *anel
'ot changed because thiswas the heading used inthe uideboo! version<@6(2@) /eading 8"8"Cill pass comment on to&pert *anel
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) te&t insection 8"8" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
Table 2-1# ,n %pain. the percentage contribution ofthe evaporative emissions to the total emissionsfrom road transport in year 26 was not J. itwas 82"@
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) Table2-1" Cill pass commenton to &pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 304/669
&plain what T: is" Accepted
Accepted
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
The activity rate for lime production Accepted %orted
'oted %orted
Accepted
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted $orrected
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) te&tiimmediately above Table2-1" Cill pass comment
on to &pert *anel
%ome e&planation of this Table would be useful"For e&le. why are evaporative emissionsproportionally higher in colder countries than inhotter countriesG
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@) page1" Cill pass comment onto &pert *anel
This is very poor" ,t does not even relate to roadtransport" The terms below the e+uation do notmatch those in the e+uation. and no units aregiven"
Chat a mess5# This is not the Tier 1 approach for
evaporation" Uou use words li!e 4small combustioninstallations4 and 4lime production4"
,n the decision tree from figure 8"1 the te&t in thefirst and second rhomboidal bo&es is the same
Chat is the sense in this chapter of 4The Tier 1approach for process emissions from smallcombustion installations """5
Ce can read# Aproduction N the activity rate forthe lime production5
Ce thin! it should say 4fuel consumption4 not 4fuelsales4K 4fuel sales4 could be a good pro&y for 4fuel
consumption4 but ,t is not the same
Tiers classification" $omments are summariHed inseparate Cord document
9ecision tree" This is rather poor" The first two0decisions0 contain the same +uestion" ,n the third0decision0. how is a 0!ey source0 definedG ,f evap" ,sidentified as a !ey source then data collection isrecommended" /owever. the user is then directedto Tier 2" Chy not Tier 8. as the re+uirements forTier 8 appear to be fulfilledG" The Figure title
appears twice"
9ecision tree revisedmar!edly to reflect thedifferent tiers. and activity
data. re+uired for eachThe decision tree is wrong# ,f the answer is 4'o4right after start. then you are lead to the same+uestion one more time"
%ection 8"2"1 is copied from lime production anddoes not refer to evaporation
Figure 8-1 has two identical diamonds for Tier 8and Tier 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 305/669
'oted %orted
'oted %orted
'oted %orted
%orted
%orted
Accepted Amended
Accepted
,t is +uestionable if the data in Tables 8-1 to 8-Iare sound" ,t is recommended to let the originaldata suppliers ma!e such aggregated figures"
, would imagine that data on fuel sales and data onvehicle licensing statistics are !ept by differentorganisations"
Chay 0default0" $an these be changed by theuserG
The Tier 1 method proposes evaporation factors inthe form g>!g fuel consumed" This was neveragreed in the Transport *anel so it has to bediscussed" The Tier 1 method proposed by thetransport panel only re+uired the total number ofcars and truc!s operating on gasoline. atemperature range relevant for the countryconcerned and the 9* value of the fuel" All thisis information that e&ists in each country" The
problem now with Tier 1 is that there is notemperature effect and. therefore. evaporationemissions in !raine will be e+ual to emissions in
Algeria5 Chatever the method we agree. atemperature correction needs to be introduced forthe emission factor" Ambient temperature is notdifficult to find in any country5
$onsult with&pert *anel
The Tier 2 method proposes evaporation factors inthe form g>!g fuel consumed" This was neverdiscussed in the Transport *anel" The editorsshould have at least consulted with the transport
panel if they wanted to change something fromwhat was agreed" ,n fact the Tier 2 methodproposed is totally anachronistic and is clearly ascientific degradation of the uideboo!" Thesimple methodology that was proposed in theprevious uideboo! is still the original methoddeveloped by the $:,'A, 1J?I wor!ing groupand most member states wor! with it" , stronglyreccomend that the simple method of the previousguideboo! is used as a Tier 2"
$onsult with&pert *anel
Tables 8-2 to 8-I" &plain 09*0" The names ofchemicals do not ta!e capital letters" %hould be0polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons0" %ome of cell
contents are cut off
The use of the words 0hot0. 0warm0 and Kcold0 in theterms of the e+uations is confusing" These need tobe e&plained"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%impler methodology" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 306/669
Accepted %orted
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted %orted
Accepted
, would imagine that data on fuel sales and data onvehicle licensing statistics are !ept by differentorganisations"
, assume that what we want to calculate is the totalnational emission" For this. you need to sum overall vehicle categories ('7)" This needs to beincorporated into the e+uation"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)+uation 1" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
For consistency with /% and . why are diurnalemissions not referred to as 090G
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)+uation 1" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
,t is not entirely clear what a vehicle catgory (070)actually is" ,s it a uro standardG y first thoughtwas that it related to the descriptions in Tables 8-6and 8-@. but the problem would then be not havingthe activity data for these categories" aybe this iswhy you include Table 8-11. but , don0t thin! that itis stated e&plicity" The lin!s between Tables 8-6>8-@and 8-11 should be stated e&plicitly"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%impler methodology" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
The Tier 8 method proposed is a collation of thesimple and detailed methodology of the 0old0uideboo! with a mi&-up of the emission factors"
As it stands now. the whole chapter is a mess andit is impossible to review point by point" %imply put.the Tier 8 te&t provided ma!es no sense"
$old and warm soa!>running emissions" Accordingto +uations (2) and (8). these only appear toapply to vehicles with a carburettor" These areli!ely to be pre-uro 1 and uncontrolled (i"e" nocanister)" %o why are there lots of emission factorsfor controlled vehicles in Table 8-6G This shoul dbee&plained"
$onsult with&pert *anel
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%impler methodology" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
*etrol cars are separated according to whether
they have fuel in7ection or a carburettor. and hencethe parameter 0c0 (the fraction of vehicles e+ippedwith a carburettor) needs to be defined" , assumethat this is 7ust for pre-uro 1 vehicles (andpossibly uro 1)" <earing in mind the re+uirementto combine Tables 8-6 and 8-11. statistics on thefractions by uro standard should be given tousers"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%impler methodology" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 307/669
Accepted eordered and clarified
Accepted
Are these values for a particular countryG 'oted
Accepted
Accepted %orted
,s the vaopur pressure re+uiredG ,t appears that it
isnMt used"
$onsult with
&pert *anel
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%impler methodology" Cillpass comment on to
&pert *anelThe reference to the Table which contains par!ingduration distributions (and the Table itself) appearstoo early in the $hapter" At this point it is not clearto the reader what this means and why it isre+uired"
Ce don0t understand the matri& presented in thetable 8-1" From this data. if we compute. fore&le. the probabilty of the event of not to bepar!ed some time between 1am and 2am hourswe obtain "J@2. this means that the J ofvehicles are on road at 2am5 Cithout doubt. this isnot representative of the %panish pattern" %o.either the numbers from the matri& are wrong. orthere is another type of error about the meaning ofthe matri& as it is e&plained in the guideboo! te&t"
$omment noted - the dataand e&planations providedare ta!en verbatim fromTable 6-8 of the previousuideboo! version<@6(2@)" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
'ot !now - the data areta!en verbatim from Table6-8 of the previousuideboo! version<@6(2@)" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
&plain 0cats0" Again. at this point it is not clear whyfuel tan! volume would be re+uired"
$omment noted - the dataand e&planations providedare ta!en verbatim fromTable 6-8 of the previousuideboo! version<@6(2@)" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
At this point , am completely lost" This loo!s li!e
the start of a more comple& 0Tier 30 approach" Ane&planation of this structure is re+uired" Aresections 8"3"I to 8"3"12 ad7ustments to theemissions which have already been calculated tothis pointG Furthermore. much of the te&t in thesesections repeats the earlier te&t"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 308/669
Accepted
Accepted
/ow is %ection 8"3"6 usedG &plain" Accepted
Accepted
/ow is %ection 8"3"@ usedG &plain" Accepted
Accepted
/ow are the temperatures calculated in %ection8"3"I usedG
earranged. but notchanged because this wasta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)9etailed methodology"
Cill pass comment on to&pert *anel
Table 8-12" %urely the values in the first columnshould start at 1# and end at 23# (or #)G'eed to e&plain that there are 23 intervals in eachrow because "I hour steps are used over a 12-hour period"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)9etailed methodology"Cill pass comment on to&pert *anel
earranged. but notchanged because this wasta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)9etailed methodology"Cill pass comment on to&pert *anel
From personal communication from iorgosellios ($:*T team) it appears that thenumbers in formulae for parameters a and b areincorrect and they should be replaced by thefollowing figures# a N -11 -"1ISvp V"6ISTKbN"11I-"1ISvp V"1STK please chec! it
with iorgos ellios
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)9etailed methodology"Cill pass comment on to
&pert *anel
earranged. but notchanged because this wasta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)9etailed methodology"Cill pass comment on to&pert *anel
/ow is %ection 8"3"? usedG Chat is 0permeationand lea!age0G ,s this a new sourceG &plain"
earranged. but notchanged because this was
ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)9etailed methodology"Cill pass comment on to&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 309/669
Accepted
9elete this %ection" Accepted
ditorial
There is no section 8"8"8" Accepted %orted
Accepted
Accepted
%ection 3"I. which Tier does it refer toG 'oted
The reference for $:*T 3 is incorrect" Accepted
The formula in this line has not mathematicalmeaning. it is not a mathematical formula" Thesum over the continuous variable T has notmeaning" Chat is that you want to sayG# sum ofthe formula over the different hours (/1 to /2)
considering constant the temperature of each hour.or integral of the formula from T1 to T2G The twothings are the same only if the temperature dataare discrete (temperature averaged for each hour).but if we apply a continuous function to thema&imum and minimum daily temperatures toappro&imate the hourly variation. the two things aredistinct
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)9etailed methodology"Cill pass comment on to&pert *anel
'ot deleted. because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)9etailed methodology.
%ection ?"12" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
$hange to 0ight fuel components tend to be morevolatile than heavy ones0"
'ot changed because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)%ection J. p<@6-1I" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
%ome of the topics in $hapter 3 (e"g" gridding.reporting) do not appear to be data +uality issues"
'o change made - thesewere the headingsprovided in the templatefrom T':" $onsult withT':>&pert panelregarding their retention
9oes this comment apply to all %ections 3"1 to 3"8.or 7ust 3"8G ,f not. something should be written for%ections 3"1 and 3"2
, believe it does. hencephrase added
'ot sure - ta!en verbatimfrom Table 1-1 ofprevious uideboo!version <@6(2@)" 'eedto refer +uestion toauthors> &pert *anel
Ta!en verbatim from%ection13 of previousuideboo! version<@6(2@)" 'eed to refercomment to authors>&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 310/669
noted
noted %orted
noted %orted
'oted %orted
'oted %orted
noted %orted
'oted
%ome references are needed in this paragraph" Accepted eferences included
e7ected
'oted Altered
$hange 0proportion0 to 0contribution0" ditorial Altered
*lease refer also to general commentssummarised in the separate word file 49; eviewof guideboo! chapters for mobile sources"doc4
The Tier 8 method is now a mi& of the simple anddetailed method from the old chapterG
This is a very serious mista!e by the consultants todevelop such a new method. without discussingwith the data suppliers"
Chy do we need to have 8 Tier methodologiesG ,sit mandatory to have 8 Tiers in the uideboo!GTier 1 now ma!es no sense5 Again this was neveragreed with the Transport panel" oreover. themethodlogies are again a mess#Chy is Table 8-8part of the Tier 1 since there is no vehicledistinction to Tier 1G Tier 2 has a correction forspeed but the emission factors are independent ofspeed5
Acording the formulae specified in the documentfor vehicles without control systems it seems theright could be replace 4some4 by 4all4
Ce have computed the probabilty as follows# theprobability of to be par!ed between /-1 to / hoursis the sum from t2N/ to t2N/V11 of sum off(t2.tpar!) from tpar!N2(t2-/)V1 to t2N23 . beingunderstood that# /V& N (/V&) mod 23 and f(t2.tpar!) is the element of matri& at row t2. columntpar!"
There appears to be a problem with the 'F code
for these sources" *art A of %ector 1 is0$ombustion0" Tyre wear. bra!e wear and roadsurface wear are not combustion processes"
This is an inherent
problem with thenomenclature for this sub-sector"
Figure 2-1 is poor and is not helpful" $ould bemuch more graphic" Chy 0flow diagram0G
used to conceptualise theboundaries of roadtransport emissions. and isan approach adoptedthroughout the uideboo!"
0This sector0" Chich sectorG The three sources. the
two 'F codesG AbrasionG
*rocess description0 is not a good title in my view",t is too vague" , also thin! that it repeats title 2.and would therefore delete it"
$onsult with&pert *anel
$ould be made moretransport specific"/owever. might detractfrom a common guideboo!style"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 311/669
'oted
e7ected
'oted
Are there any more recent dataG 'oted
A discussion of the Tables would be useful" Accepted
%ome of these data should be updated" e7ected
%urely Tier 2 or Tier 8G Accepted Altered
'oted %orted
Accepted Altered
%orted
9isc bra!es are increasingly used in heavy-dutyvehicles"
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)%ection 8"2" Cill pass
comment on to &pert*anel
%ection 2"2 title could be more helpful" Chate&actly does it refer toG
$onsult with&pert *anel
$ould be made moretransport specific"/owever. might detractfrom a common guideboo!style"
Chat is the meaning of the %ection 2"8 title" ,t isvery vague"
A discussion on emissionsources"
,t is not possible ma!ing an update of the emission
estimateG
'ot with the same level ofcompleteness" Chenreporting improves there
will be"'ot with the same level ofcompleteness" Chenreporting improves therewill be"
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)%ection 8"2" Cill passcomment on to &pert
*anel
'umbers are suitable forindicative purposes" Alsonot changed in thisrevision because this wasta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)%ection 2" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
Tiers classification" $omments are summariHed inseparate Cord document
The decision tree only e&plains *1" <utconvention needs are T%* and *2"I also"
The Tier 1 algorithm resolution is per vehicleclasse" <ut the Tier 1 factors are averaged for allvehicles"
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 312/669
Accepted Altered
Figure 8-1" Chere does Tier 8 fit inG Accepted %orted
Accepted
%orted
Accepted Altered
Accepted Altered
eference codes to be updated" Accepted will be updated
etrics other than *1 are included" Accepted Altered
Accepted Altered
%orted
'oted
Accepted
Chere are the values for fs.i and %s()G %orted
%orted
Altered
Figure 8-1" *1 is not a 0species0 it is a prticlesiHe metric"
The sum over all vehicle categories should beformally introduced into the e+uation"
':T9 - not changed in
this revision because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)+uation 1" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
Tables 8-1 to 8-8. is averages only" ,t is considereda wrong decision not to give data per vehicleclasse" Also. T%* and *2"I emission factors areneeded"
$onsult with&pert *anel
Tables 8-1 and 8-2" The units are clearer as g !m-1 vehicle-1" %ubscripts re+uired for *1 and
*2"I"Tables 8-1 and 8-2" The names of chemicals donot ta!e capital letters" %hould be 0polycyclicaromatic hydrocarbons0" %ome of cell contents arecut off
This method seems unnecessarily crude" Cheredo these percentages come fromG
The Tier 2 algorithm claims speed dependency"
/owever. no speed dependency is given in theTable 8-3 to 8-1I emission factors"
$onsult with&pert *anel
Table 8-8" Font too large in Table" Chat are theunitsG
Table superceded bychanged Tables 8-1 and 8-2
Again. summation over all vehicle categories
re+uired"
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)+uation 1" Cill passcomment on to &pert
*anel$onsult with&pert *anel
Chere is the speed dependencyG mission factortables for T%* and *2"I are missing"
$onsult with&pert *anel
,s the detailed methodology Tier 2G This is notclear"
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 313/669
%orted
Accepted %orted
etrics other than T%* are included" Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
Accepted %orted
%orted
This could be more helpful" Chy is this the caseG 'oted %orted
&plain choice of *A/s" Chich protocolG Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
This is all badly e&plained" Chat is this section(8"8"2) aboutG Chere is the speed dependenceG$hec! that the Table titles match the contents"
$onsult with&pert *anel
etrics other than T%* are included" This is allbadly e&plained" Chat is this section (8"8"2)aboutG
,n Tier 8 (Table 8-16). the particulate fractions forother siHes than *1 are listed for tyre wear" <utthese fractions should be available from thebeginning to support also Tier 1 and 2 calculations"
,n Tier 8 (Table 8-1@). the particulate fractions forother siHes than *1 are listed for bra!e wear"<ut these fractions should be available from thebeginning to support also Tier 1 and 2 calculations"
The Tier 8 methodology for road surface wear ismissing"
$onsult with&pert *anel
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thiswas ta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)%ection J" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
%hould be Table 8-1J" 'ot all the substances listedare elements - some of them are ions"
%orted regarding tablereferenced - *hrase49ifferent elements4 notchanged because this wasta!en verbatim fromprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)%ection J" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
Table 8-1J needs to be improved" As stated above.some of the 0elements0 are actually ions" Thenomenclature is not consistent (eg" g2V but%:3--" %ubscripts and superscripts are re+uired forthe ions" The term 0elemental speciation0 is usedincorrectly" The word 0bra!e0 is spelt incorrectly"Chat is the meaning of blan! cellsG
':T9 - not changed in
this revision because thistable is ta!en verbatimfrom Table 18 of theprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 314/669
Accepted Title changed
Chy is there no te&t under 3"1 and 3"2G Accepted /eadings deleted
noted
Chat is 0method 80G ditorial %orted
'oted
%orted
%orted
%orted
Chy have / and *:*s not been includedG noted
Accepted
The te&t in %ection 3"3 has nothing to do withconsistent time series and recalculation5 ,t is moreor less the same te&t as %ection 18 4Temporaldisaggregation criteria4 from the old chapter"
Are the Fs really for asphaltG This is ratherspecific"
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thisis ta!en verbatim from%ection 11 of the previousuideboo! version<@@(28)" Cill passcomment on to &pert*anel
%ee
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf. page 31-33
&pert panel to be madeaware of these data"
,t is a mista!e to ma!e such averages. since thenumber of vehicles per classe is !nown from theroad transport e&haust inventory"
$onsult with&pert *anel
,n Tier 8. the e&pressions for heavy duty load anda&les (tyre wear). heavy duty load (bra!e wear).and speed (all vehicle classes) are present"
$onsult with&pert *anel
/owever. the speed corrections was to be used inTier 2"
$onsult with&pert *anel
The old chapter briefly discusses how to treatemission inventories in relation to dispersionmodels"
$onsult with&pert *anel
,nformation from oldchapter is included. hencenothing has been lost"
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thisis ta!en verbatim from theprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
missions other then * %eehttp#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf. page 8J-31
':T9 - not changed inthis revision because thisis ta!en verbatim from theprevious uideboo!version <@@(28)" Cillpass comment on to&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 315/669
AcceptedChat 9irective do you refer toG Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9oneChat is the reference for %:2G Accepted 9one
'oted 9one
Chat is 4/4G 'oted 9one
'oted 9one*"JIGG ditorial 9one
factor 0/0 in e+uation is not specified 'oted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one A table for line haul locomotives is missing Accepted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
*lease refer also to general commentssummarised in the separate word file 49; eviewof guideboo! chapters for mobile sources"doc4
relevant information will beincluded whereappropriate and timepermits"
This is 7ust messy !ey words. not fit for a
documentation reportChat is the source of the Fs in tables 8-1. 8-2and 8-8 in this F:9G Also. how is Tier 1 Fsappro& 2 times greater than Tier 2 FsG
There must be errors somewhere in the emissionfactor tablesK ,t is not possible with suchdifferences between Tier 1 and Tier 25
efers reader to T chapter. but then on followingpage. refers reader to the off-road section - whichis correct or are both relevantG
Table shows fs in g>D of fuel - where do hourscome into thisGG
same data in tables 8-2 and 8-8 whereas table forline haul locomotives is missing
Table 8-2 and Table 8-8 are the same e&cept forthe technology name5 They are titled Tier 2 and thene&t line says Tier 15
eneral comment - where are the fs for line haul
locomotivesG
4(e"g". B-T,% ($hiffi. Fiorello. %chrooten. 9elieger (2?)K A,,L4
4(e"g". B-T,% ($hiffi. Fiorello. %chrooten. 9elieger (2?)K A,,L4
The B-T,% railways inventory contains timeseries 1J?-2I and pro7ections (up to 28) forlocomotives and railcars specific activity data(passenger>freight train !m and gross hauled tonne!m) as well as for energy consumption andemission factors" *lease. send us a re+uest tohave a view on the preliminary data (a password isneeded) - the pro7ect will be concluded by the 8 of
April 2?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 316/669
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
The emission factors are still missing" 'oted 9one
'oted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9oneplease add 4B-T,% 2?4 Accepted 9one
'oted 9one
Accepted 9oneplease add 4B-T,% 2?4 Accepted 9one
*lease +uote the B-T,% pro7ect. founded bythe DD-,*T% of %eville and carried aout by TTand ,T:. and provide the weblin! to users in thesame page http#>>www"e&-tremis"eu> - B-T,%combines statistics from different sources and
calculate emission factors for specific engine typesfor each of the 2@ countries (e&cluding altaand $yprus that have no railways)
The B-T,% railways inventory contains timeseries 1J?-2I and pro7ections (up to 28) forlocomotives and railcars specific activity data(passenger>freight train !m and gross hauled tonne!m) as well as for energy consumption andemission factors"
*lease +uote the B-T,% pro7ect. founded by
the DD-,*T% of %eville and carried aout by TTand ,T:. and provide the weblin! to users in thasame page http#>>www"e&-tremis"eu> - B-T,%combines statistics from different sources andcalculate emission factors for specific engine typesfor each of the 2@ countries (e&cluding altaand $yprus that have no railways)
Chat units are the emissions shown in. in the%*A tableG
*aragraph not clear" For e&le. 4bio-diesel canbe used in all diesel engines with slight or nomodification4 - is this true for 1 biodieselG Aretrains currently running on <2 - <IG
please refer to 4gross hauled tonne !ilometre(hT;)4
according to egulation J1>28. from thebeginning of 28 all railway underta!ings (notonly the 4principal4) shall report their traffic data tourostat" oreover. train movements (national.
international and transit train !m) are reportedconsidering only the distance covered on thenational territory of the reporting country" <y usingoperating data. double counting problem may beavoided" ,n B-T,% some technical notes todata sources will be made available tocompilers>users"
please refer to 4gross hauled tonne !ilometre(hT;)4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 317/669
'oted 9one
Accepted 9oneemisison factors for additivesGG 'oted 9oneThe number of the chapter is missing Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
'oted done
according to egulation J1>28. from thebeginning of 28 all railway underta!ings (notonly the 4principal4) shall report their traffic data tourostat" oreover. train movements (national.international and transit train !m) are reportedconsidering only the distance covered on the
national territory of the reporting country" <y usingoperating data. double counting problem may beavoided"
This is 7ust copy and paste from the ,*$$ 26guidelines"
*lease add the reference 4B-T,% pro7ect -ailways ,nventory" For information see thewebsite http#>>www"e&-tremis"eu> and Final eport#$hiffi. Fiorello. %chrooten. 9e lieger. B-T,%.&ploring non-road Transport missions in urope.
D$-,*T% (2?)4
*lease add the reference 4B-T,% pro7ect -ailways ,nventory" For information see thewebsite http#>>www"e&-tremis"eu> and Final eport#$hiffi. Fiorello. %chrooten. 9e lieger. B-T,%.&ploring non-road Transport missions in urope.D$-,*T% (2?)4
eneral comment - chapter refers to diesel andsometimes to gas oil - use one or the otherperhaps as otherwise confusingL
*lease refer also to general comments
summarised in the separate word file 49; eviewof guideboo! chapters for mobile sources"doc4
Table 2"1. please harmonise with ,*$$ 26uidelines
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 318/669
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
$an0t access website
$an0t access website
'oted 9one
please update
the distinction beteween domestic (coastal) andinternational shipping in terms of 4activity4 is not sodifficoult to e&trapolate" Activity data in arecollected and provided to urostat by all memberstates according to the aritime %tatistics 9irective($ouncil 9irective J6>63>$)" ,n the urostat'ewcronos aritime 9atabase it is possible to find+uarterly statistics both for passengers and goods(collections marPpaP+mPdetl andmarPgoP+mPdetl) spiltted by direction (inw. outw).partner entity and type of cargo" These collecionsrefers fo main ports only (but J of the totaltraffic)" ,t is possible to consider the total traffic(marPpaPaa and magPgoPaa) of passenger andgoods of all ports by direction and use it for addingthe missing +uota to detailed collections"eferences and methodologies for doing it are in
B-T,% (2?)"
the distinction beteween domestic (coastal) andinternational shipping in terms of 4activity4 is not sodifficoult to e&trapolate" Activity data in arecollected and provided to urostat by all memberstates according to the aritime %tatistics 9irective($ouncil 9irective J6>63>$)" ,n the urostat'ewcronos maritime database it is possible to find+uarterly statistics both for passengers and goods(collections marPpaP+mPdetl and
marPgoP+mPdetl) spiltted by direction (inw. outw).partner entity and type of cargo" These collecionsrefers fo main ports only (but ?>J of the totaltraffic)" ,t is possible to consider the total traffic(marPpaPaa and magPgoPaa) of passenger andgoods of all ports by direction and use it for addingthe missing +uota to detailed collections"eferences and methodologies for doing it are inB-T,% (2?)"
*lease delete. this is not possible to understand>isincorrect>refers to ember %tates (not *arties)
$onsult with&pert *anel
, disagree with thecomment
Also the B-T,% methodology gives an
allocation of emissions according to the type oftraffic
$onsult with&pert *anel
Also the B-T,% methodology gives anallocation of emissions according to the type oftraffic
$onsult with&pert *anel
Footnote# , can0t find the reference for the ntecreports anywhere in the chapter"
*lease remove or update (this was not in theoriginal outline agreed by TF,*>is outdated)
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 319/669
'oted
Accepted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted done
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted $an0t access website
'oted $an0t access website
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
Chat is the origin of this tableG 'oted uideboo! 26
Table 8-2@# %ourceG 'oted uideboo! 26
Table 8-2@# %ourceG 'oted uideboo! 26
Chere does the data in Table 8-2@ come fromG 'oted uideboo! 26
'oted 9one
Chat does the terms in brac!et Q R meanG /as thiste&t been updated in accordance with latest ,:regulationsG
Table 8"1 and 8"2. please provide originalreferences for emission factors (not *-$)(same with the subse+uent tables)
urostat collection of vessel traffic (+uarterly data.main ports. number and gross tonnage of vessels.by type and siHe of vessels and inwards direction -marPtfP+m) provides country statistics for @ groupsof ship types and 22 T siHe classes" eferencesare in B-T,% (2?)" *lease. +uote thewebsite" ,n case. re+uest us a tecnical note on thisissue
urostat collection of vessel traffic (+uarterly data.main ports. number and gross tonnage of vessels.by type and siHe of vessels and inwards direction -marPtfP+m) provides country statistics for @ groups
of ship types and 22 T siHe classes" eferencesare in B-T,% (2?)" *lease. +uote thewebsite"
'ot only ':& emissions are engine specific. butalso * emissions (see % protocols)"
'ot only ':& emissions are engine specific. butalso * emissions (see % protocols)"
The calculation formula gives no meaning" ,nsteadof (fuel sold. engine type) it should
$onsult with&pert *anel
fuel instead of mass#which unit of measureG 7or tonnesG
B-T,% provides a similar tables or additionalparameters in the website (i"e" differentiated
conversion factors or weighted F)B-T,% provides a similar tables or additionalparameters in the website (i"e" differentiatedconversion factors or weighted F)
Activity data has to be segmented per activity type(different F for hotelling. manoeuvring andcruising in T,2)"
Activity data has to be segmented per activity type(different F for hotelling. manoeuvring andcruising in T,2)"
ntec 22G , can0t find this reference in thechapter
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 320/669
All table references are wrong 'oted 9one
Chere does the data in Table 8-2J come fromG 'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
*lease chec! the table references 'oted 9one
also on the B-T,% website $an0t access website
$an0t access website
also on the B-T,% website $an0t access website
$an0t access website
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
Table 8-2J# *lease include the units in the tablete&t
Chy is the T,8 methodology not very well suitedto show annual trends in emissionsG
The F - only cruise based now - should be aweighted average F of cruising. manoeuvring andhotelling"
Chy is the T,8 methodology not very well suitedto show annual trends in emissionsG
The F - only cruise based now - should be aweighted average F of cruising. manoeuvring andhotelling"
$onsult with&pert *anel
we may add such tables on B-T,%" 9o youthin! this may solve problems to compilers or helpthemG
$onsult with&pert *anel
$onsult with&pert *anel
we may add such tables on B-T,%" 9o youthin! this may solve many problems to compilersG
$onsult with&pert *anel
, thin! we should have to +uote the relevantfacilities provided by the urostat 'ewcronosdatabase" %ee the comment 11" Ce haveassembled some technical notes for wor!ing withurostat data and produce>derive ship movements"*lease. re+uest us these notes if you thin! that aparagraph should be added here"
, thin! we should have to +uote the relevantfacilities provided by the urostat 'ewcronosdatabase" %ee the comment 11" Ce haveassembled some technical notes for wor!ing withurostat data and produce>derive ship movements"
*lese. re+uest us these notes if you thin! that aparagraph should be added here"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 321/669
Accepted done
Accepted done
Accepted 9one
Accepted done
$onsider for Tier 8
The most comprehensive and detailed source ofinformation for Ferry. o-o. /% craft and cruiseships is the %hip*a& database (please visitwww"shippa&"se for more infos and in particular thewebpage http#>>www"shippa&"se>page>page"aspG
idN13)" , thin! that the 4Thomas $oo!L4 source isnot a good reference"
The most comprehensive and detailed source ofinformation for Ferry. o-o. /% craft and cruiseships is the %hip*a& database (please visitwww"shippa&"se for more infos and in particularhttp#>>www"shippa&"se>page>page"aspGidN13)" ,thin! that the 4Thomas $oo!L4 source is not agood reference"
This par seems to have been copied from the 26sK it mentioned the 26 s and ma!esreference to multilateral operations. this is not in
line with the TA* reporting uidelines" *leaserevise
Ce have built a distance table (mainly forinternational traffic) from>to each maritime coastalareas ($As) of countries to>from $As.all editerranean and <altic third countries and to18 overseas areas. namely <lac! %ea. Arabianulf. ed %ea. ,ndian %ub $ontinent. Australasia.Far ast - $hina Dapan. %outh ast Africa.Cest Africa. % Atlantic $anada - reat a!es.$entral America ] $aribbean. %outh America ]
Atlantic. % $anada ] *acific. %outh America -*acific" 9o you thin! this table proveded on thewebste could help compilersG The table refers toone sole reference port per country
$onsult with&pert *anel
This section 3"3 has nothing to do with consistenttime series and recalculation5 ,t is simply copy andpaste from the old chapter section 8"I4*ro7ections4"
B-T,% performed an analysis on historicaldata (1J?-2I) and gives on a country basis
activity data (tonne-miles and ship-milesmovements by type of ship>engine and by :9).emission factors and total emissions" The F aredifferentiated according to the characteristics of thevisiting fleet calling at seaports of each country"*lease. inform us and re+uest our interim report orthe outline of the final report of B-T,%"
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 322/669
$onsider for Tier 8
$onsider for Tier 8
Accepted 9one
B-T,% performed an analysis on historicaldata (1J?-2I) and gives on a country basisactivity data (tonne-miles and ship-milesmovements by type of ship>engine and by :9).emission factors and total emissions" The F aredifferentiated according to the characteristics of thevisiting fleet calling at seaports of each country"*lease. inform us and re+uest our interim report orthe outline of the final report of B-T,%"
$onsult with&pert *anel
eplace the column $onsumption at full power(tonne>day) as a function of gross tonnage (T)with the following values# $ N 12.@23V.12ST -1.1I1-?ST2V3.63?3-13ST8$ N @.21J3V.1IST-J.1??I-JST2V2.6?8-13ST8$ N -2.262V.3JST-1.631-@ST2V1.@8J3-12ST8$ N .J1JV.8?ST-6.1I6I-?ST2V6.@J1@-18ST8$ N 6.8I1V.18STV1.6?I2-@ST2-6.26J1-12ST8V I.6JJ-1@ST3$ N I.21IJV.83ST-8.8@8-?ST2V2.62-18ST8$ N -J.@8IV.3?6ST-3.668-6ST2V1.8J11-1ST8$ N -2.262V.3JST-1.631-@ST2V1.@8J3-12ST8$ N "326?2 V "1ST
$ N 1.?I@V.2IJST-1.2@J-IST2V1.6?2?-JST8$ N 1.2@33V.62ST-6.368-@ST2VI.I1J8-11ST8$ N 1.2@33V.62ST-6.368-@ST2VI.I1J8-11ST8$ N ?.2JJV.1?ST-3.3J?-?ST2V3.?J81-13ST8 % A''B *A* F: 9TA,%
$onsult with&pert *anel
Add the reference# 4TroHHi $". accaro " (26).ethodologies for estimating air pollutantemissions from ships# a 26 update. nvironment Transport. 2th ,nternational %cientific%ymposium(including 1Ith conference Transport and Air*ollution). eims. France # 12-13 Dune 26
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 323/669
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted
$onsider for Tier 8
*lease insert the B-T,% reference orwebsite# B-T,% pro7ect - aritme ,nventory -for information see the website http#>>www"e&-tremis"eu> and Final eport# $hiffi. Fiorello.%chrooten. 9e lieger. B-T,%. &ploringnon-road Transport missions in urope. D$-
,*T% (2?)"
*lease insert the B-T,% reference orwebsite# B-T,% pro7ect - aritme ,nventory -for information see the website http#>>www"e&-tremis"eu> and Final eport# $hiffi. Fiorello.%chrooten. 9e lieger. B-T,%. &ploringnon-road Transport missions in urope. D$-,*T% (2?)"
,t0s impossible to verify fs without clear referenceabout source of data" 'o correspondence betweenTable and references5
T,12 are bun!er fuel based methodologies.T,8 is an activity based methodology" Forinstance for <elgium. there is a difference of afactor 8I between a bun!er fuel and an activitybased methodology (,nventory and forecasting ofmaritime emissions in the <elgian sea territory. anactivity-based emission model. Atmosphericnvironment. olume 32. ,ssue 3. February 2?.*ages 66@-6@6. iesbeth %chrooten. ,na 9elieger. uc ,nt *anis. ;arel %tyns and udi Torfs)",t is possible to ma!e a T,12 activity basedmethodology (transforming :%TAT statistics
into activities) on findings in &-T,% - B-T,% pro7ect - aritme ,nventory - forinformation see the website http#>>www"e&-tremis"eu> and Final eport# $hiffi. Fiorello.%chrooten. 9e lieger. B-T,%. &ploringnon-road Transport missions in urope. D$-,*T% (2?)"
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 324/669
$onsider for Tier 8
$onsider for Tier 8
The emission factors used are aggregatedemission factors from 'T$" The T,8methodology can be made even moredesaggregated by using even more desaggregatedemission factors from % (A. T':-*. ,YA.A,'. $-9elft. /as!oning. missieregistratie en
]onitoring %cheepvaart. 9. 'ovember 28)"The 'T$ emission factors are predefined for$ ?I and 2. as for % you can use yourcountry specific $ and create your own countryspecific emission factor" A comparison of bothsources would be usefull" The % protocols arein 9utch. but you can find relevant documentationin nglish in the :*%A report(http#>>www"belspo"be>belspo>home>publ>pubPostc>>rapp38Pen"pdf) and the &-T,% pro7ect
(see comment above for lin!)"
$onsult with
&pert *anel
T,12 are bun!er fuel based methodologies.T,8 is an activity based methodology" Forinstance for <elgium. there is a difference of afactor 8I between a bun!er fuel and an activitybased methodology (,nventory and forecasting ofmaritime emissions in the <elgian sea territory. anactivity-based emission model. Atmosphericnvironment. olume 32. ,ssue 3. February 2?.*ages 66@-6@6. iesbeth %chrooten. ,na 9elieger. uc ,nt *anis. ;arel %tyns and udi Torfs)"
,t is possible to ma!e a T,12 activity basedmethodology (transforming :%TAT statisticsinto activities) on findings in &-T,% - B-T,% pro7ect - aritme ,nventory - forinformation see the website http#>>www"e&-tremis"eu> and Final eport# $hiffi. Fiorello.%chrooten. 9e lieger. B-T,%. &ploringnon-road Transport missions in urope. D$-,*T% (2?)"
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 325/669
$onsider for Tier 8
'oted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
'oted 9one
Accepted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
then we are not able to ma!e the calculations5 'oted 9one
Accepted
The emission factors used are aggregatedemission factors from 'T$" The T,8methodology can be made even moredesaggregated by using even more desaggregatedemission factors from % (A. T':-*. ,YA.A,'. $-9elft. /as!oning. missieregistratie en
]onitoring %cheepvaart. 9. 'ovember 28)"The 'T$ emission factors are predefined for$ ?I and 2. as for % you can use yourcountry specific $ and create your own countryspecific emission factor" A comparison of bothsources would be usefull" The % protocols arein 9utch. but you can find relevant documentationin nglish in the :*%A report(http#>>www"belspo"be>belspo>home>publ>pubPostc>>rapp38Pen"pdf) and the &-T,% pro7ect
(see comment above for lin!)"
$onsult with
&pert *anel
*lease refer also to general commentssummarised in the separate word file 49; eviewof guideboo! chapters for mobile sources"doc4
,t is very confusing to read this chapter" *racticallyall the references to tables in the te&t
are wrong. and some tables are even missing" Alsoreferences are given to an important sources ofinformation (ntec study)
which we can0t find in the list of reference" And
even more important. the chapter doesn0t print the crusial information from ntec",nventory ma!ers are as!ed to loo! them upthemselves"
<ecause so much remains to be done in thischapter. the reviewers are wasting a lot of time"
be (fuel sold. fuel type. engine type). in order tohave the same resolution as for F"
Chen this basis is correct. you can ma!esummations afterwards"
, suggest to include a description of typicaldevices. e"g"# modified ollsoyce airplaneturbines with cap" of about 8 C . fed by naturalgas" %omeone even have low-'o& technologies"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 326/669
Cill amend tables (
Accepted Te&t modified
'oted /$< included
Accepted
'oted 'one
'oted
'oted 'one
There is no reference either in the Tier 1 or 2tables for the 'F 1AIa",t would be correct. if Ffor this 'F not available (or the same asfor other'F in this chapter). it would be specified in thete&t"
,n table 1-1 (and furtheron) the term 0non-residential heating0 is introduced" This term ishighly confusing. and re+uires change" *leaseavoid (throughout the te&t) as much as possiblethis !ind of negative definition" /ere use4commercial>institutional heating4 instead" Also theterm 4other4 should be avoided and may only beused when e&plicitely defined as 'F term"
Fishing is not covered in the small combustionchapter and should therefore be removed from thelist of activities covered" Again there is no mentionof /$< in table 1-1"
%ubdividing this sector needs to be done in aconsistent manner. in order not to confuse areader" The list as presented now is an ambiguousmi&ture of 'F attributions (but note my commentQ1R above) and techni+ues ($/*)
Te&t modified to aligntechnologies more with'F
The only pathway of interest (emissions fromcombustion) is not described in Fig" 2-1
,n conse+uence to comment Q2R. subsections within
the section 2"2 should be consistent to the sub-division first introduced in *age 8>line 1-12"Furthermore. levels of sub-types are not clear orconsistent (e&le below. comment Q6R)" Finally.techni+ues and sub-types need to match emissionfactors presented" ,"e". differentiating between0open fireplaces0 and 0partly closed fireplaces0 isonly useful when also emission factors are beingpresented (This e&le being chosen here forsimplicity. but the point is applicable throughout)" Anational e&pert should be able to find the type ofinstallation operative in his>her country accordingto the description in the list of techni+ues. and thenloo! up an appropriate emission factor" ,deally. foreach type of appliance an own set of emissionfactors is presented by fuel" :f course this will notalways be possible - but in the current te&t there isalmost no such connection"
Te&t modified to align moreclosely with 'F. tier 1factors are on fuel basis sono technology relevanceKTier 2 has moredisaggregation but not afull split as this would beunmanageable but thereare more appliance-specific details in Appendi&
%trong chapter on techni+ues ($hapter 2"2)" :newould wish that all chapters were on this high level"/owever the subchapter on $/* should bee&panded"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 327/669
e7ectede&plain 0autonomy0 - or use different term Accepted odified
Accepted Te&t modified to clarify
Accepted Te&t modified to address
Accepted Te&t included
Accepted 9one
Accepted Te&t modified
'oted
'oted Te&t modified
Accepted Te&t order modified
e7ected
figure 2-1# wrong title (Lcontribution fromrailwaysL)
$omment for wrongchapter - have ta!en intoaccount in 1A8
%tove types can not be differentiated by thedescription presented" This is widely the case forthe whole list of stove types" $riteria used to formsubcategories are very ambiguous (from fuel type -0pellet0 to appication 0coo!ing0 and further toabatement 0catalytic0)
Finish stove0 and 0ussian stove0 may not bee&pressions that are very helpful to describe stovetypes outside particular countries which applythese terms" ,t is o"!" to use those as a support.but one should not e&pect this is sufficiente&planation
Authors may wish to refer to the fact that - whilethere e&ist stoves predominantly constructed forspecific fuels - there are also multi-fuel stoves"These stoves are popular in some countries asthey are able to burn waste - a considerableemission problem
A very simple statement would help an e&pert tounderstand which type his installation belongs to#4<oilers are devices which heat water4
Automatic feeder systems are also available forwood logs" The advantage of automatic systems isthat they minimiHe handling errors(primary>secondary air. constant combustiontemeratures. L)
$ondensing boilers may achieve efficiencies evenabove 1 - this is basically their feat" For ane&pert using this guideboo!. one could ma!e itesier to identify such an installation# 4condensingboilers re+uire a chimney resistant to the li+uidcondensate4"
Accepted but detail notneeded here"
Chen the potential for large dio&in emission ismentioned it would only be natural to also addressthe possible formation of other *:*s notably /$<"
*rimary measures can be presented in a moresystematic way# modifed fuels > modified heater >
modified combuation
Figure 8-1 does not contain any informationspecific for small combustion - why is it here thenG
,t is a generic decision treebut the elements arerelevant to smallcombustion plant
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 328/669
Accepted
Accepted 9one
'oted
e7ected
'oted
'oted
Accepted
'oted
Accepted Tables revised
'oted Tables revised
Accepted
Accepted
, strongly disagree# if we limit a country0scontribution to Tier 1 already at this stage. weshould forget about the whole effort" Applyingdefault emission factors to ,A (and similar)statistics can be done much more reliably in acentraliHed manner. and in fact has been done
already (see A,'% model)
Te&t modified slightly butTier 2>1 may be the mostappropriate with (unli!esome other sectors) Tier 8only being achievableusing the model or hybrid
approach "
,n row 11 - A fuel consumption. but in the row 13 - A production -activity rate for the lime production
,t would be better if these tables 8-1 to 8-12refering to Tier 1 were listed in order from 1a3a.1a3b and 1a3c etc" Also what siHe boilers to theseFs relate to 2-I C or W2 CG
%ee comment Q1R above# avoid 0other0. instead use0medium>light li+uid fuels0
<ased on 'A*F fuelclassifications
/ere and elsewhere# ,f the range presented for
emission factors e&tends over two orders ofmagnitude. reporting has very little meaning
The selected fuel groupings for residential andnon-residential combustion seems less than ideal"<iomass should be divided into wood and straw"
At Tier 1 we have broughttogether by main fuelclassifications
$ommon comment for Tier 1 and Tier 2 tables#emission factors are shown with reference touideboo! 26" <ut most of emission factors donot coincide with the factors in the uideboo!26" specially large differences are for %:&. $:.':$. *$99>F. *A/" 'o emission factors for
indicator *A/ while uideboo! 26 includesthem"
evised F tables shouldbe clearer
,t would be possible to include corresponding%'A* codes in the allTier 1 and 2 tables
Table format is fi&ed toreflect 'F but %'A* alsoprovided
,n table 8-2 (and all other Tier 1-2 tables) the total*A/ emission factor is resulted. but according tore+uirements of reporting uideline it is necessaryto report separately on four substances
,n the table 8-2 (and all other Tier 1-2 tables) fromrow 4'ot estimate4 would be deleted 4*:*s4 and
into row 4'ot applicable4 include Anne& , *:*s (byeach substance)"
Table 8-I# error in *b and /g emission factor (incolumn alue are shown as . but in column ower
] not )"ounding>significant figureissue
%everal values listed as 44 in table 8-I and 8-6"ac! of /$< emission factor as well as detailed*A/ emission factors are a problem"
Cill change with newtables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 329/669
Accepted
'oted
'oted Te&t modified
'oted
'oted
'oted Addressed where possible"
Accepted
,n the table substitute 4%olid fuel4 with 4$oal fuel4 'oted
Accepted
'oted
'oted
,n the table 8-I. row fuel name - 4:ther i+uidFuels4" ,t is not clear - other. e&cepting residualfuel oil. or 4other oil4 (according to fuel defini
,nclude summary table offuel classes
Table 8-6# error in *b emission factor (in columnalue are shown as . but in column ower ] not)"
Cill change with newtables
The dio&in emission seems to refer to the emissionfactor for advanced fireplaces in the e&istingguideboo!" A general tier 1 emission factor shouldprobably be somewhat higher"
Cill change with newtables
,n table 8-6. upper estimate for %e is below therecommended valueK in tab" 8-@. several metalse&hibit an upper estimate of 00
Cill change with newtables
,n table 8-I the fuel name is 4/eavy Fuel :il4" According to fuel definition in the new reportingguideline it must be 4esidual Fuel :il4,n othercombustion chapters the same"
,t seems odd that all particles from biomass
combustion in the non-residential sector isassumed to be *2"I"
Cill change with newtables
Again Tier 2. Tanles 8-13 to 8-26 seem to start withresidential (1a3a) and then move onto :thersectors (1a3a and 1a3c)" Also there is noinformation about thermal siHe of combustion planthere"
Table 8-18 amendedslightly. note that 'F hasno siHe distinction
in table 8-18 and subse+uent tables# provideemission factors to instllations as they have beendescribed in section 2"2 - see comment Q3R
solid0 fuel is first mentioned here - put this way itwould comprise also biomassK use 0coal0 (as in theprevious part of this chapter) or 0solid fossil fuels0
Te&t amended to include1A1a fuel types
%ee earlier note on fuelclassification - don0t wantto preclude co!e and othersolid fuels
The tables contain a very large number ofemission factors +uoted as uideboo! (26) butwith different values" ,t0s impossible to presentsimilar tables 5 %ome e&les are reported inFPcomments"
Cill change with newtables
$:'$%,:'# A T/ TA<% %T <,%9
The e&isting guideboo! list a dio&in emission factorof ? ng>D for standard fireplaces and 8 foradvanced fireplaces" Therefore the emission factorof 8I ng>D with reference to the e&istingguideboo! seems wrong"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 330/669
Accepted
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted Table included
Accepted Te&t deleted
,n table 8-16 the F for $: is "1 g>DG %urelythis is a mista!e" ,n the ne&t table 8-1@ $: has anF of 1g>D. or 1. greater"
Cill change with newtables
Tables 8-1@. 8-1?. 8-2# heavy metals emissionfactors should be rounded"
Cill change with newtables
Table 8-2# errors in F for *2"I (in column
alue are shown as . but in column ower ] not)"
Cill change with newtables
The dual reference system is confusing" ither thereference is the e&isisting guideboo! or it is$,T*A" %everal of the listed emission factorsdoes not correspond to the values in the e&istingguideboo!s values for stoves li+uid fuels"
Cill change with newtables
Table 8-28# errors in F for *1 and *2"I (incolumn alue are shown as . but in column ower
] not )K F for T%* should be chec!ed"Cill change with newtables
ost values in table 8-22 refers to the e&istingguideboo!. however several of the listed emissionfactors do not correspond to the emission factorsprovided for wood burning boilers in the e&istingguideboo!"
Cill change with newtables
Table 8-26# value F and JI confidence intervalare the same for T%*. As. $d. $r. /g. *b"
Cill change with newtables
$: seems to be to high for a diesel engine (li+uidfired) in table 8-26" ,n the tables 8-23 and 8-2Iturbines running on gas and oil are included" ,n
these two table als gas engines should beintroduced so that the ':& values are comparablebetween different prime mover technologies"
%ee also#http#>>www"euromot"org>download>news>positions>stationaryPengines>FuturePstationaryPenginePemissionPlegislationP'ov3"pdf
http#>>www"euromot"org>download>news>positions>stationaryPengines>,**$<P<FPeuromotPcommentPmayP2"pdf
Chy is there no default emission factors given for
natural gas fired reciprocating engines" ,t wouldseem that a large part of the fuel use for sttionaryengines would be natural gas"
%uggest to do it the other way round - datareported to the 'F$$$ will have no focus onwood consumption and thus will li!ely provideunreliable numbers" ,nstead# esults on woodconsumption provided here should be made use offor the 'F$$$ submission also"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 331/669
'oted
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
ditorial ef modified
ditorial ef corrected
ditorial
'otedThe title of the tables are not visible" ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one
The Tier 8 method needs more elaboration" %houldinventory compiliers use the technology based Fsin Appendi& A or notG These Fs tables should notbe placed in an Appendi& if they are part of the Tier8 methodology"
The choice ofmethodology is up to thecountry. the significance ofthe source and theresources available"
This glossary should either be e&panded or
removed"%ome sources listed as references in the chapterare missing from the list of references. e"g"$,T*A 2@. ustavsson et al" 1JJ8. $*,*23. 9T, 2I. uideboo! 26"
, suggest to indicate if emissions factors are basedon field measurements (real conditions) orstationary conditions which e"g" is the case for(<T) 1JJJ to <T (2I)" Additionally ,t would beuseful to !now how many ovens>boilers have beenmeasured and if the emission factors are
representative for e"g" a specific technology whichis typical for a country or region"
Ce have no additional
data - these are asprovided in <216
<T (2I>2)/yperlin! does not point to a specificdocument#http#>>www"blt"bmlf"gv"at>menu>inde&Pe"htm"
*lease correct reference to 4sterreichischemissionsinventur fr %tauSbS4 and4mweSlStbundesamt4
Appendi& < dos not add much additionalinformation to appendi& $ of $hapter 1A1 (they arewidely identically)" , suggest to 7ust add a table with
typical reference :2 concentrations and the 29iagrams and add a reference to chapter 1A1"
Agree but they areseparate chapters. not
sure we can split out theappendi&"
eference :2 concentration of wood is often 18", suggest to add a line for this to the diagrams"
'ot changed. there aremany reference :2 levelseg @. 1 or 11 nationalpreferences apply" '88(boilers W8!C) is 1
The tables are unreadable as they are partly offthe page"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 332/669
'oted
'oted Final chec!ing needed
'oted
'oted
'ot relevant to 1A3tion in the new reporting guideline) $omment corrupted G
'one
'oted 9one
Accepted 9one
Chat is the number of this directiveG 'oted 9one
e7ected 9one
missions that are related to different engine typesare missing e"g" %par! ,gnition engine (gas mode)"Ce recommend to refer on page 12 of thefollowing document#
http#>>www"ymparisto"fi>download"aspGcontentidN8@?lanNfi
Furthemore the French limits for 9ual Fuelstationary engines are missing" These should beadded"
:ther details# , rec!on a final proofreading will beperformed to ta!e care of a number of editingissues (incomplete sentences. abbreviationspresented but not e&plained in Tab 3-3. citations($,T*A 2@). and similar)
ac! of line numbering of the chapter on small
combustion will result in fewer line numberreferrals"
As reference is made to $hapter 1A3. should weunderstand that industrial engines are the samethan engines in $ommercial. ,nstitutional andesidential sectorsG 9oes it matter the power ofthe engineG
%mall $/* for publicpower uses the sametechnology as non-residential $/*" asturbines can often belarger than I Cth butengines are generallysmaller (usually a lotsmaller)"
Ta!ing into account that raw materials have alsosulphur content. where are the net %:& emissionsestimated for cement and lime productionG# eitherin 1"A"2"f or in 'F categories 2"A"1 and 2"A"2G
For instance the emission factors for $:. %:2.T%* etc"
9on0t see where this isreferred to
Chat are the total net %:& emissions. ta!ing intoaccount the three components# gross %:& fromfuel. gross %:& from raw materials and %:&captured by raw materialsG
This is wrong and confusing" The %'A* group
?1 contains military activities (and differentfuel types). please refer to error 1d"
Uou must show tables for each ' directiveand e&plain what they contain"
Chere is there a precise definition of e+uipmentlevel and e+uipment typeG This must behighlighted"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 333/669
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
$hapterK 'on road mobile sources and machinery 'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
Tables for 1A2fii (industry machinery) and 1A3a ii($ommercial>,nstitutional# obile) emission factorsare missing"
,t is necessary to e&plain. that only agriculture andforestry machinery are behind the figures"
Table 8-8# The categorisation of recreational craftis wrong" These types of vessels must be included
This sentence gives no meaning" A lot of dieselfuel is being used by stationary engine. and toassume all
The * fuel type is also present" ,n fact. you mayconsider to use the term fuel>engine type"
*lease be aware that recreational craft and militaryvehicles must be treated differently
Table 8-18 to 8-16# The figures in this table relatesonly to recreational craft" Tables 8-18 (diesel) and8-1I (3-stro!e gasoline) concerns the emission
level prior to the directive 28>33 emissionstandards"
Uou have forgotten two tables for 2-stro!e gasolineboats. relating to emission levels before directive28>33. and for directive 28>33 emission levels"
%till missing is three emission factor tables fordiesel fuelled e+uipment in the 'F sector 1A3aii
This section is essential for inventory ma!ers inorder to allocate fuel into emission layers. but itgives no guidance at all"
A study from 1JJ8 is not recently made" 'othinghas been done to update this part of the te&t"
%ince there is still no updates in this part. , reallyhave no opinion"
This table is full of errors" *lease use the tablesdirectly from the old guideboo!"
*lease refer also to general commentssummarised in the separate word file 49; eview
of guideboo! chapters for mobile sources"doc4There are many serious mista!es in this chapter"%ome of them relates to 1) errors in 'F codecategorisation
and 2) errors in computed emission factors whentransferring from g>tonnes of fuel to g>D"
rror 1a)# The data that is stated for 1AIb (:ther)in the new chapter has nothing to do with militaryactivities5
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 334/669
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
These data. submitted by orten Cinther are validfor boats. and hence represent recreational craft"The %'A* code for recreational craft is ?8.
which is specificly mentioned in the old guideboo!"Following the $TA* transfer procedure between
%'A* and 'F codes.recreational craft are further classified as part of'avigation 1A8d (agreed by all member states)"
,f we want recreational craft to be included in thischapter. it is necessary to include the code 1A8d ii('ational 'avigation) in the table on *age 1"
rror 1b) ,n the * 9raft 2@ guidelines forestimating and reporting guidelines the 'Fcategory 1A3a ii ($ommercial>,nstitutional# obile)now appears"
This category must be included in the table on
*age 1"rror 1c)# The category 1A3c iii(Agriculture>Forestry>Fishing# 'ational Fishing istreated in the 'avigation chapter"
/ence this code should be deleted from the tableon *age 1"
rror 1d)# ilitary mobile activities are 'Fgrouped as 1AIb (other). and contains aviation.land based and sailing activities"
,f you want to present emf for military in thischapter you must produce completely new figures.
or perhaps repeat the data from the old guideboo!"rror 2)# A calculation error has been made in allthe emission factor tables. when transferring fromg>tonnes to g>D"
,n the spreadsheets provided by orten Cinther.g>D related emf are calculated" *lease use thesefactors instead"
%erious omission# the information on testprocedures from the old chapter must be included(and updated) in the new chapter
,t is no help for inventory ma!ers to have suchvague description
The Tier 1 figures in the Tables 8-2 to 8-? are allwrong" *lease use the factors from ortenCinther. directly"
Fishing vessels are treated in the 'avigationchapter"
in the sector 1A8d ('avigation)" This follows thecorrect transfer between %'A* (?8)
and the 'F (1A8d) category" ,n the currentversion of the guideboo!. %'A* ?8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 335/669
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
'oted 9one
ditorial 9one
is clearly described as inland waterways.containing also the activities by recreational craft"
,t is a very big mista!e not to follow thenomenclature agreed by the inventory community"
,f you want to present emf for military you mustproduce completely new figures. or perhaps repeatthe data from the old guideboo!"
fuel being used in ' would introduce aserious error in the inventories"
Tables# ,nventory ma!ers must have theinformation of which sales year relates to whichemission layers"
Tables# Tier 2 emission factors prior to stage , mustbe split into three technology levels (W1J?1. 1J?1-1JJ. 1JJ1-stage ,) instead of applying oneaverage"
The differences between layers are too big toignore" Uou must use the data provided by ortenCinther"
Tables 8-13 (diesel) and 8-16 (3-stro!e gasoline)concerns the emission level corresponding with thedirective 28>33 emission standards"
,t has nothing to do with military e+uipment5 Uouare mi&ing up all definitions"
,n addition. the Table 8-13 to 8-16 captions includethe 'F category 1A3c# *lease stress that it is therecreational craft part of 'avigation we are dealingwith here"
These data , calculated for you also. as a part ofour agreement"
1) Uou must provide some !ind of information. forinstance -values. which distributes fuelconsumption as a function of engine age for each'F code"
%uch distribution functions can be derived from theCinther 'ielsen database"
2) Uou must also provide information of whichsales year relates to which emission layers"
Uou can find these data in the relevant directives.
or alternatively derive aggregated sales yearinformation from the Cinther 'ielsen database"
8) Finally. you must provide information of averageengine life times for the different 'F codes" Thiscan be derived from the Cinther 'ielsendatabase"
$hange as 4The e&traction and treatment of coalresult mainly in emissions of methane"4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 336/669
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
ditorial 9one
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted 9one
,n the te&t the reference is Tsibuls!i not Tisbuls!i" ditorial 9one
Accepted Added to references
'oted
Are you sure *$< N 2 g (it0s not mgG) Accepted
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
9elete the sentence 4This sector was estimated toaccount for 22 of the total national $/3emissions in the ; in 1JJ1 (ilham. 1JJ3)"4 ,t0san old data not relevant for the <"
$hange as /owever. also ':$. * and $:2are emitted
$hange 4methane emission4 with 4firedamprelease4
9elete from not applicable# 4T%*. *1K *2"IK*bK $dK /gK AsK $rK $uK 'iK %eK YnK4 *ut in 'otestimated## 4T%*. *1K *2"IK *bK $dK /gK AsK$rK $uK 'iK %eK YnK4
9elete from not applicable# 4T%*. *1K *2"IK*bK $dK /gK AsK $rK $uK 'iK %eK YnK4 *ut in 'otestimated## 4T%*. *1K *2"IK *bK $dK /gK AsK$rK $uK 'iK %eK YnK4
9elete from not applicable# 4T%*. *1K *2"IK*bK $dK /gK AsK $rK $uK 'iK %eK YnK4 *ut in 'ot
estimated## 4T%*. *1K *2"IK *bK $dK /gK AsK$rK $uK 'iK %eK YnK4
,nsert after the title# 4A Tier 8 methodology foremission factors estimate for open dust sources atcoal mines can be found in % *A A*32 in$hapter 11"J Cestern %urface $oal ining (%*A. 1JJ?)4
,nsert the reference# % *A. 1JJ? A* 32.$ompilation of Air *ollutant mission Factors.olume 1# %tationary *oint and Area %ources. Fifth
dition. olume ,. $hapter 11"J Cestern %urface$oal ining. 1JJ?
There are no guidance of storage of solid fuel"%hould particle emission from coal storage beestimated and if so there should be a defaultemission factor made available"
F removed. notapplicable here
Add the sentence 4,n this category can be included$oal /andling And %torage" For this A Tier 8methodology for emission factors estimate can befound in % *A A*32 in $hapter 18"2"3
Aggregate /andling And %torage *iles (% *A.26)4
,nsert the reference# % *A. 26 A* 32.$ompilation of Air *ollutant mission Factors.olume 1# %tationary *oint and Area %ources. Fifthdition. olume ,. $hapter 18"2"3 Aggregate/andling And %torage *iles. 26
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 337/669
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted %entence added
Accepted %entence added
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
Chy is venting included in this chapterG ,t shouldbe placed in the chapter 1<2c 'T,' andflaring"
delete 4or li+uefied gas4# it0s included insubse+uent 2"1"? paragraph
insert a comment about 4oil pumps4 and indicatewhere mission from these are computed.particularly when pumps are fuelled by oil (as inthe case of ships pumping of oil at maritimeterminal4
insert a paragraph about 4gas compressor station4and indicate where mission from these arecomputed
The references are very old" The newest one ismore than 2 years old" ,t should be discussedwhether the data are still valid"
, can only agree with the inserted comment. thatbetter data should be available" This issue should
however had been solved prior to releasing a firstorder draft"
, am unable to reproduce the resulting emissionfactor in table 8-2 based on the current values inthe e&isting guideboo!" The comment states thatthe geometric mean from distribution has beenadded based on table ?"1@ in the e&istingguideboo!"
ery strange sentence since the inserted commentcontradicts the meaning of the sentence"
$omment removedK iswrong
insert a Tier 2 evaluation for I61*ipelines andI68 9istribution networ!sK , thin! it0s a priority
The values in the e&isting guideboo! varies greatlyfrom "J1 to 8"2. therefore 7ust ta!ing a geometricmean of all values listed without an accompanyinge&planation does not seem appropriate"
The values in the e&isting guideboo! varies greatlyfrom "1 to 8"1. therefore 7ust ta!ing a geometricmean of all values listed without an accompanyinge&planation does not seem appropriate"
The values in the e&isting guideboo! varies greatlyfrom "J to 8"1. therefore 7ust ta!ing a geometricmean of all values listed without an accompanyinge&planation does not seem appropriate" The valueof 8"1 stems from omania and seems li!e anoutlier
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 338/669
Accepted
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
rase Table 8-28 as must be included in 1"<"2"a"v e7ected
Accepted 9one
A couple of the references are not used in the te&t" Accepted
olume title correctly# 1"<"2"a"i. 1"<"2"b" 'oted
'oted
Accepted 9one
Accepted Figure updated
Accepted 9onereplace 4unit units4 with 4unit4 ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted pdated to "3
e7ected
As mentioned this chapter is directly copy>pastefrom the e&isting guideboo!" A lot of data concernsventing. this information should be moved to thecorrect chapter"
, would suggested to move factors for venting to1"<"2"c"
delete all the point 8"3"2"I :il loading and transportmust be included in 1"<"2"a"v
$larify Table 8-23 (in the te&t erroneous indicatedas Table ?"1?)# must be included in 1"<"2"a"v andreview the te&t conse+uently
$hec!edK some referencesremoved
$onsidering the values in that table covers only
distribution the emission factor seems low"
9elete 4*assant. 1JJ84 This reference is no longergiven and the*A reference is wholly ade+uate"
Figure 2-1# The notation of /eat and its emission ismissing from the chart" %ee 2nd comment above"
,n Table 8-2. %ection 4Abatement Technologies4the use of thephrase 4*rimary cyclone"""""""4 maybe misleading" To avoid confusion. it isrecommended that the abatement technologyisdescribed as 4$yclone systems installed
internally within the regenerator4"
Title of Table 8-8 re+uires amendment as itcurrently reads 4"""""""reforming unit units4" 9eletethe word 4unit4"
change 48"8"2"@ 9iffuse emissions4 with 48"8"2"@asoline storage" For depots of gasoline inrefinery refer to Tier84
,n Table 8-6. the pper $onfidence imit loo!sincorrect" The samepollutant and F are given inthe Tier 1 Table 8-1. with an upperlimit of "3instead of "6 given in this Table"
replace 4This section provides Tier 8 informationfor refineries"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 339/669
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one
eferences should be (% *A. 1JJI. $'. 2?) Accepted 9one
eference should be 4% *A (1JJI)4 Accepted 9oneeference should be 4$' (2?)4 Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
*roposed changed te&t to clarify where thecyclones are installed#4The basic catalytic crac!ingregenerator design normally incorporates. insidethe regenerator vessel. cyclone systems toseparate the catalyst particles from thehydrocarbon vapours"Additional cyclones systemsand>or electrostatic precipitators maybe installede&ternal to the regenerator to abate further theparticulate emissions4"
,n Table 8-@. the reference for 4partial burn with $:boiler4 is wrong" This is not given in $:'$AC8>@" The o&idation value of JJ"Iis given in the$ommission 9ecision of 2J-1-3 on /0s- see:D 'o" IJ. 26"2"23 (comment later re p23)
,n Table 8-@. the reference for 4full burnregeneration4 is wrong" This is not given in$:'$AC 8>@" The o&idation value of JJ"Iisgiven in the $ommission 9ecision of 2J-1-3 on/0s- see :D 'o" IJ. 26"2"23 (commentlater re p23)
,n Table 8-@. the reference for 4additional cyclonestages4 is wrong" This is not given in $:'$AC8>@" A reference to the efinery<F should begiven i"e" 4uropean $ommission (28)4
,n Table 8-@. the reference for 4electrostaticprecipitators4 is wrong" This is not given in$:'$AC 8>@" A reference to the efinery<F
should be given i"e" 4uropean $ommission(28)4
,n Table 8-@. to clarify where the 4Additionalcyclone stages4 arelocated. it is recommended tochange this to 4Additional cyclonestages installede&ternal to the regenerator4
%hould this e+uation be numbered i"e" be e+uation4(J)4G
%hould this e+uation be numbered i"e" be e+uation4(1)4G
Add new paragraph# 4A recent development is theuse of hand-held optical imaging devices to detectlea!ing components permitting surveys to beunderta!en more +uic!ly (pperson et al". 2@)"4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 340/669
Accepted 9oneeference should be 4% *A (1JJI)4 Accepted 9oneeference should be 4% *A (1JJI)4 Accepted 9one
Accepted 9oneeference should be 4% *A (1JJI)4 Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
There are issues on double counting which arehighlighted on page 1.lines J to 1@" %uggest repeathere"
$urrent te&t in this paragraph should be deletedand replaced# eason# optical remote sensingtechni+ues can only measure emissions over avery short time period e"g" a few hours" missionsfrom refinery sources generally vary widely withtime. e"g" floating roof tan! emissions are highlydependent on wind speed" ,t is not valid. therefore.to e&trapolate these short term measurements tocalculate refinery annual emission inventoriesasthis would result in significant errors" ,t isproposed that the ,t is proposed that the following
te&t is inserted in its place#4emote sensing usingoptical gas imaging may be used to identify.fore&le. if any e&ternal floating roof storage tan!sare operating outside of the performance boundsfor which emission factors are valid. permittingfocussed maintenanceto ensure that factors canthen be used for these sources forinventorypurposes"4
eference *A 1JJ8 is incorrect" ,t should be#4nited %tatesnvironmental *rotection Agency(% *A) 1JJI" *rotocol for+uipment ea!mission stimates" *A-3I8>-JI-1@" :fficeof
Air =uality *lanning and %tandards. esearchTriangle *ar!.'orth $arolina4
eference $' (2I) should be updated as this%tandard is now published as ' 1I336. 2?"
The reference % *A 1JJ3 is not referred to inthe chapter" ,t should be removed from the list"
,f the proposed te&t addition above (p 22. line @) isaccepted. thenthere is the need for a newreference# 4pperson. 9 et al" 49erivationof newemission factors for +uantification of massemissions whenusing optical gas imaging for
detecting lea!s4" Dournal of the Air andCasteanagement Association (DACA). ol" I@. ,ssue'o" J.%eptember 2@4"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 341/669
Accepted 9one'o F for %'A* I32 'oted
'oted
e7ected9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one
9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one
Accepted 9one
ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one$hange 4reportedly4 to 4reported4" ditorial 9one
Accepted9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one
Accepted
A new reference is re+uired for Table 8-@ (seecomments above)" This is# 4uropean$ommission (23). 4$ommission decisionof 2JDanuary 23 establishing guidelines for themonitoring andreporting of greenhouse gasemissions pursuant to 9irective28>?@>$ of the
uropean *arliament and of the $ouncil(23>1I6>$)" :fficial Dournal of the uropean$ommunities 'o" IJ. 26"2"234
The figure is nice" A similar one should be providedfor marine terminals or include marine terminals inthe present figure 2"1
Add the reference# A*AT (2@) AgenHiaegionale per la *roteHione Ambientale dellaToscana. onitoraggio delle aree geotermiche"apporto Finale. Anno 26. 'ovembre 2@
*ropose change 4There are two ma7or sources """4to 4There are three sources """"4" easons#following the statement are listed three sources. ofwhich only one (standing storage emissions)issignificant"
eplace 4into a cargo tan! truc!4 with 4into a cargotan! truc! or ship4
Add 4occur when4 at start of this line to follow onfrom line ?"
eference should be 4uropean $ommission.
264 not 4,**$<. 2I4
%hould be 4uropean $ommission. 264 not4,**$<. 2I4
A - gasoline production statistic (p" 11. row ?)" :n
the p"12. row 12 - amount of gasoline sold shouldbe used as activity statistics
9escriptions harmoniHedK
gasoline sold is relevantactivity here
ive a definition of oil product" Chat productshave to be includedG gasoline. gas oil. fuel oil.aviation gasoline. distillate oil L"G
9escription made moreclear
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 342/669
Accepted $orrect here
Accepted 9one
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
ditorial 9one
Add 4is4 between 4"""""pressure4 and 4the vapour """4 ditorial 9oneTable title should be 8-12 ditorial 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one
Chat is throughput # crude oil G %omething elseG9efine please" *rovide also some default valuesfor average vapour pressures for the differentproducts from crude oil to naphtha. gasoline. gasoilL
$onsult with&pert *anel
asoline considered here.has been added to te&t
Chat is throughput # crude oil G %omething elseG9efine please" *rovide also some default valuesfor average vapour pressures for the differentproducts from crude oil to naphtha. gasoline. gasoilL
$onsult with&pert *anel
asoline considered here.has been added to te&t
Chat is throughput # crude oil G %omething elseG9efine please" *rovide also some default valuesfor average vapour pressures for the differentproducts from crude oil to naphtha. gasoline. gasoilL
$onsult with&pert *anel
asoline considered here.has been added to te&t
Chat is throughput # crude oil G %omething elseG9efine please" *rovide also some default valuesfor average vapour pressures for the different
products from crude oil to naphtha. gasoline. gasoilL
$onsult with&pert *anel
asoline considered here.has been added to te&t
Chat is throughput # crude oil G %omething elseG9efine please" *rovide also some default valuesfor average vapour pressures for the differentproducts from crude oil to naphtha. gasoline. gasoilL
$onsult with&pert *anel
asoline considered here.has been added to te&t
,n the table 8-6 %'A* II1 or I31 (marineterminalsG)
references should not be guide boo! 26 but$:'$AC 2@
Chat is throughput # crude oil G %omething elseG9efine please" *rovide also some default valuesfor average vapour pressures for the differentproducts from crude oil to naphtha. gasoline. gasoilL
$onsult with&pert *anel
asoline considered here.has been added to te&t
Chat is throughput in service station stations.gasoline and gas oilG *rovide default vapourpressures or e&plain how to get them
eference made to %*A description
Chat is throughput in service station stations.gasoline and gas oilG *rovide default vapourpressures or e&plain how to get them
eference made to %*A description
Chat is throughput in service station stations.gasoline and gas oilG *rovide default vapour
pressures or e&plain how to get them
eference made to %
*A descriptioneplace 4previously contained gasoline4 with4previously contained crude oil. gasoline or otherhighly volatile products4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 343/669
Accepted 9oneChy it is not throughput but gasolineG 'oted
'oted
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted 9one9irective number is J3>68>$. not 68>J3>$ ditorial 9one%hould be Table 8-18 ditorial 9one
Accepted 9one
ditorial 9one*ropose move to %ection 3"2 Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
ditorial 9one
Chat is throughput in service station stations.gasoline and gas oilG *rovide default vapourpressures or e&plain how to get them
the efficiency of J? is too optimistic in real lifethe efficiency is lower" J to JI would be more
reasonable"$oncawe considered the methodology asobsolete5 eplace all with the sentence 4Fordepots of gasoline in refinery refer to Tier84
This e&planation comes too late" /owever not onlygasoline is volatile" Aviation gasoline. 'aphtha.crude oil are stored and displaced" They have tobe considered" as oil could be considered ifnecessary in countries with high temperature"
The efficiency of J is too optimistic" Fromstudies carried out in France the efficiency for astation with an active system wor!ing correctly is? " Uou have also to consider that due to poormaintenance. most active systems become lessefficient and some of them are out of service" ,fyou do not have statistics on the of activesystems wor!ing correctly. an average efficiencyta!ing into account the systems out of service canbe 6" The T, document (see the T,web site) describes this situation" This situation iscommon in urope" ermany and %witHerlandhave recently implemented the use of selfcontrolled active systems (the e+uipment ofe&isting stations should be finalised in ermanythis year and 1 of service stations are alreadye+uipped in %witHerland")" :nly with such systems.the efficiency can rise up to J "
$omment ta!en intoaccountK some te&t on thisadded and reference toT, made
9elete 4For e&le. it will use a !nowledge ofe+uipment components fitted in the refinery toprovide estimates of process fugitive emissions"4as this e&le is not relevant to this 'F"
The te&t currently in 3"I seems more appropriatehere than in 3"I
$hange 4For storage """4 to 4For e&le. forstorage """4
Add 4refinery4 before 4storage4 to clarify what is in313"
Add 4terminals and 4 between 4mar!eting4 and4depots4 to ensureall facilities are captured"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 344/669
ditorial 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
e7ected
Accepted 9one9elete5 e7ected
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
lossary# %tage , $ontrols - 4terminals (dispatchstations)4 should be replaced by 4refinery dispatchstations4"
lossary# True apour *ressure - suggest add4%ee section 8"8"2"14at the end of the definition asthe formula to calculate T* is giventhere"
lossary# apour 9estruction nit (9)" 9eletethis definition. as9s are not described in thete&t as not permitted in "
4 with # 4For storage tan! emissions $oncawereport suggests the use of the latest edition of A*,documents for Floating oof Tan!s (A*,.28).and ertical Fi&ed oof Tan!s (A*,. 22)" For
Aboveground /oriHontal Tan!s. $oncawe reportsuggests to use the latest edition of "%" *Amethodology ("%"*A. 1JJI)" 'ote that this
reference normally contains the latest version ofpreviously +uoted A*, methodologies" An emissioncalculation software is available from the % *Avia their website. http#>>www"epa"gov. or on a $9-:("%"*A. 2I)" This $9 also contains the*A publication ("%"*A. 1JJI) and A*,documents (A*, 22K 28)"4
replace 4ost emission factors are ta!en from theuide to eothermal nergy and the nvironment(eothermal nergy Association. 2@). availablevia http#>>www"geo-energy"org>publications>reports>nvironmental2uide"pdf"4 with 4mission factors results frommeasurement performed by the environmentalprotection agency of Toscana region. ,taly (A*AT.26)" The region is the main urope producer ofthis !ind of energy"
9ue to differences in chemical composition ofgeothermal fluid. site dependent emission factorsobtained by sampling is suggested"
Added to te&t as apreferable option
%ince the authors. 7udging by the insertedcomment. do not !now. what is meant. , will ta!e acrac! at solving the mystery" y best bet is that
line 1J-2 and line 21-22 should also be part of thebulletpoints. then it all ma!es sense55
Than!s5 'ow it ma!esmore sense"
,s there a particular resaon why the emission factorare e&preesed in g>%m8. or is it 7ust because thatis the units used in the e&isting guideboo!G g>'m8og g>D could be used"
All updated to g>'m8 forharmoniHation"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 345/669
'oted
e7ected'o need to repeat a completely identical table" e7ected
Accepted %entence removed
Accepted Fi&ed
Accepted Fi&ed
Accepted Fi&edChy no glossary for this chapterG 'oted
9espite all the mentions of venting. this table isabout flaring not venting" 9ata stems from thee&isting guideboo!. where the +uality is $ and not9 as mentioned in the inserted comment"
$onsult with&pert *anel
Table heading updated"=uality rating updated.therefore uncertaintyrange updated as well"
,f the factors only are applicable for 'orway. therelevance of having them in the guideboo! would
seem miniscule"
replace 4For the types of storage tan!s used tostore volatile li+uids at refineries. emissionestimation methodologies are provided by the %*A (*A. 26)" These methodologies re+uireinformation on the tan! contents. siHe. shell colour.floating roof fitting types and number. etc". on atan!-by-tan! basis" mission calculation softwareutiliHing the algorithms in the % *A publication is
available on the *A website http#>>www"epa"gov.or on a $9-: (*A. 2I)" 4 with 4For storagetan! emissions $oncawe report suggests the useof the latest edition of A*, documents for Floatingoof Tan!s (A*,.28). and ertical Fi&ed oofTan!s (A*,. 22)" For Aboveground /oriHontalTan!s. $oncawe report suggests to use the latestedition of "%" *A methodology ("%"*A. 1JJI)"'ote that this reference normally contains thelatest version of previously +uoted A*,methodologies" An emission calculation software isavailable from the % *A via their website.http#>>www"epa"gov. or on a $9-:("%"*A.2I)" This $9 also contains the *A publication
("%"*A. 1JJI) and A*, documents (A*, 22K28)"4
The sentence about uncertainty ma!es no sense"'o +uality codes are provided in this chapter. socomparison with the uncertainties chapter is ratherdifficult"
*1 should be removed from the table andplaced under 'A or '"
,n the 4'ot Applicable4 list for Table 8-I. *1 isgiven" /owever.this is also shown in the Table as4'4" %hould it be listed.therefore. in the 4'ot
stimated4 listG
,n Table 8-I. the following pollutants should bedeleted from the4'ot Applicable4 list as F0s areprovided# *1. *b. $d. /g. As. $r" $u. 'i and Yn"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 346/669
Accepted
'oted
Accepted 9one
'oted
Accepted Two new tables introduced
'oted
'oted
Accepted %tatement corrected
'oted
'oted
An emission factor of is clearly not acceptable.either there is an emission factor or the pollutantshould be listed as not applicable"
All Fs that are e+ual toHero removed. moved to'A or ' according toreporting template
The $: and ':$ emission factors are a factor1 lower from the reference chosen compared to
the other references in the e&isting guideboo!" Atleast a note e&plaining the comparatively lowvalues should be offered"
rase 8811 $ement (is included in <1 nergy)and erase (decarbonising) from 3612
$hapter contains scarce information necessary foremission inventory from cement production" Thereare I short tables with only * emission factors"$hapter should be supplemented and updated"
*roposals# two Tier 2 tables applicable for $$Acountries were suggested for the uideboo!# for
wet and dry cement production with averagedlevels of abatement"
4This chapter only considers emission ofparticulate matter from cement plants. which ismainly the * from pre- and aftertreatment4" ,f thisis the case. where can we find the emission factorsof the pre- and aftertreatment processesG
For many of the pollutants listed in the mentionedlines the <F states that a significant contributioncomes from the materials processed"
,n this statement. the ammonia appears as animportant pollutant to be considered in the cementproduction but. in the rest of the document. theammonia does not appear and in the tables istreated li!e 4 not applicable 4"
%ubchapter 2"8 missions contains long list ofpollutants emitted during cement productions andprocesses are described but Tier 1 and Tier 2Tables 8-1-8-8 gives only particulate emissionfactors"
The te&t concerning emissions of %:B originating
from fuels or raw material can be misunderstood"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 347/669
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
'oted
e7ected
'oted
4and the algorithm in e+uation (8) reduces to#4 ditorial
'oted
'oted
rase 4For Tier 1 the emissions of ':&. $:.':$. %:&. heavy metals and *:*s can beassumed to be mainly due to the combustion ofthe solid and waste fuels and will be included inthe emission factors used for chapter 1"A"2"f"i" Toavoid double counting estimates should be madein the chapter 1"A"2"f"i" ,n the Tier 1 approach theywill. as far as they originate from the chemicalcomposition of the raw meal. be reported as 'otstimated"4
ove <(a)*. <(b)F. <(!)F. $:. 9,:B. /$<. ,ndeno.':$. ':B. %:&. from 'ot estimated to 'otapplicable
rase Tier 2 (is a copy of Tier 1) because itgenerates confusion
Tables 8-1-8-8# these tables include only 8emission factors each which are the same" Tier 2tables for wet and dry processes include the samefactors for different cement production processesand same with Tier 1 ] this is not true andcontradicts to Tier 2 approach determination"ewor!ing of F tables is necessary"
Tables 8-1-8-8# there are no emission factors forheavy metalsK it is shown that they are accountedin 1"A"2" <ut it is !nown that heavy metals areemitted with particles" %o it assumed that cement
particulate do not contains heavy metalsG And it isassumed that only particulate is abated whileheavy metals are emitted unabatedG
Table 8"1# F seem to be too high. if +uarry ise&cluded as presented in Figure 2-1
'o need to present the same default F in threetables# 8-1. 8-2 and 8-8
4The Tier 1 emission factors have been used in theTier 2 approach as well4" This sentences amountsto say that there is no Tier 2 approach for the wet!iln process5
+uation numbering
corrected4The feeding of dry material into the !iln willhowever typically result in higher emissions of dustas compared to the wet !iln process4"
4 ""the Tier 2 emission factors for the dry !ilnprocess in Table 8-8 are the same as the Tier 1default emission factors presented in Table 8-14"This sentences amounts to say that there is no Tier2 approach for the dry !iln process5
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 348/669
'oted9elete 4from4 ditorial
Accepted
'oted
Accepted
Chere is the e+uation (8) in the documentG Accepted
'oted
'oted
Accepted '/8 in ' instead of 'A
'oted
'oted
Accepted
9escriptions of algorithms occupy 2 pages whileonly 8 factors availableK what is the usefulness ofthese algorithmsG
Table 3-1# /ow does this table correspond totables 8-2@ - 8-81 (1A2)G *resent thecorrespondance between the different units
%implest correspondanceincluded plus a reference
to the <F if moredetailed information isre+uested
eferences contain only 3 sources including 2<Fs# it is too short"
The indication ,"" for the pollutants present also in$ombustion activities is ambiguousK it0s not clear ifthere are part of process emissions evaluated incombustion or if there are combustion emissions
,ndication removed fromall chaptersK now in '
+uation numberingcorrected
Ce consider that this is a very serious drawbac!for process emission estimation in this sector (!eysource for many pollutants as heavy metals fromthe very !ilned raw materials (whose emissionfactors do not appear at all))
for many of the pollutants listed in the mentionedlines the <F states that a significant contributioncomes from the materials processed"
,t is considered that the ammonia in not animportant pollutant to be considered in the cementproductionG
Ce consider that this is a very serious drawbac!for process emission estimation in this sector (!eysource for many pollutants as heavy metals fromthe very !ilned raw materials (whose emissionfactors do not appear at all))
%o the +uestion arises# where are you allocatingthese emissions and what are the correspondingemission factors. if their emissions have not beencomputed in the combustion activity (1"A"2"f"i). andthere is not information on them in this processactvityG
The proposed F are very high compared with
<F use T%* from <F and estimate fractionof *1 and *2.I
eplaced with <Ffactors
,t is assumed that heavy metals are mainly due tofuel combustion so they are accounted in 1"A"2"f"i"%o it supposed that lime particulate do not containsheavy metalsG And abatement affects particulateand not affects heavy metalsG
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 349/669
'oted
Accepted 9one
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted Added to chapter
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
ditorial 9one
ditorial 9one
ound the Fs value" Ammonia lower value N .6 Accepted 9one
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected9elete# no clear. no necessary e7ected
Accepted 9one
Table 8"1# F seem to be too high. if +uarry ise&cluded as presented in Figure 2-1
9elete# Fs very oldK substitute with controlled > nocontrolled T%* from <F and estimate fraction of*1 and *2.I
$hapter contains mainly headings. algorithms and
table without emission factors" ,t should besupplemented"
%ome headings removedto ma!e more readable
'evertheless a decision tree is possible# Forermany we have the +uestion clarified whetherinformation from sectors limestone used areavailable" Cith 4Ues4 li!e in ermany allcalculations are made in sectorspecific chapters.so 2"A"8 shows only 4,4" Cith 4'o4 an estimationunder 2"A"8 is necessary" ,n ermany we havemade for verification a limestone balance with thefull set of production and use and so identified
gaps. which were closed in different sectors"
9ecision tree and somete&t on this issue added to
chapter ,t is not mentioned that heating emission is ta!eninto consideration in 1"A"2"c"
%ee comments to german limestone balancebefore"
%ee comments to german limestone balancebefore"
%ee comments to german limestone balancebefore"
%ee comments to german limestone balancebefore"
11 subchapters of the chapter consist only of
heading and comment# 'o specific issues" aybeit will be better not to show this chapter at thisstage at allG
%ome of the multipleheadings removed
$orrect the mentioned <F and write 4L isavailable in the <F 4arge volume inorganicchemicals - solids and others (uropean$ommission. 2@)
$orrect the word 4<oudart reaction4 into4<oudouard reaction4
Table 8-1# emission factors are with 6 digits after
point ] it is too much"table 8-1# the emission for '/8 given in the <Fis "6-1"I (,$-%A:. chapter 2"8"8"I)
The <F documents don0t present emission limitvalues. but <AT-associated emission levels (<AT-
As) - delete the sentence 4This section providesemission limit values (s) as defined in the<F document4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 350/669
Accepted
'oted
Accepted $orrected to 8"$
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted
Accepted $orrected
$an0t find the cieted value for '/8 in the <F -cite correct or delete value"
rror - value should nothave appeared here"emoved"
,nterpretation is correct as Asphalt oofingaterials
4"""with the e&ception of asphalt blowing. which is
inventoried separately under 'F source category1"A"2"f"i4"
Figure 2-1# The notation for /eat or Fuel and itsemission are missing"
Table 1-8# ostly the production data are includedin +uadrat m" , would recommend the inclusion offactor-information from this. as well"
9ecision tree is proper for production only.emissions of application seem to be relevant are inermany calculated too" The decision tree has torefer to the complete number of application ofroofing materials"
The proposed Fs from old < are obsolete# thereare a new % *A chapter in A*32
The proposed Fs from old < are obsolete# thereare a new % *A chapter in A*32
The proposed Fs from old < are obsolete# thereare a new % *A chapter in A*32
The reference is obsolete new one is "%"nvironmental *rotection Agency ("%" *A).1JJI" 11"2 Asphalt oofing $ompilation of Air*ollutant mission Factors# %tationary *oint and
Area %ources" A*-32. Fifth dition" :ffice of Air=uality *lanning and %tandards. esearchTriangle *ar!. 'orth $arolina"
:ld reference replaced bynew one
This statement is not correct because asphaltblowing should be in 'F source category 8"$"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 351/669
Accepted Added to figure"
ditorial $orrected
Accepted 9one
'oted
ditorial $orrected
Table 8-1 and 8-2 are e&changed e7ected
A production -activity rate for the lime production ditorial $orrected
ditorial $orrected
ditorial $orrected
'oted
'oted
The chapter is wrong5 The content can beappropriate for activity 8818 Asphalt $oncrete*lants (that was e&pired from new <). but F andreference are old. a new A*32 chapter wasproduced" The chapter following my interpretationrefers to asphalt application on road5 and concern:$ emissions (see % *A A*32 chapter 3"I)"
$onsult with&pert *anel
%ome information from8818 used as well"There appears to beoverlap between the two
chapters in the previousuideboo! and also the*A reference given in thiscomment"y best guess is that boththe i& Asphalt plants andthe asphalt application onroad should be ta!en intoaccount" $hapter hastherefore not beensubse+uently updated"
Figure 2-2# /eat and its emission are missing fromthe chart"
/ere seems a mi&-up to be# reference to cementand lime are not useful"
The emissions factor indicates a mass rate ofabout 2. what is not usually. please see underFPcomments"
$hapter consists of mainly headings" ,t includesone table with 8 * emission factors (for all miningprocesses) which seem underestimated" ist ofeferences includes one source"
A - not lime production (page 8. row 11). but floorarea of the building construsted (page 3. row 8 orp"8 row 21)
A - the activity rate for the storage. handling andtransport
,n lossary table - A production -activity rate forthe lime productionThe right definition as on thepage 3. row 1I
This chapter includes 6 sources. I connected withglass production# Flat lass. $ontainer lass.lass Cool. :ther lass. lass (decarboniHing)"Chy they were not included in a separate chapterlass production li!e imestone and 9olomiteta!ing into account contribution into heavy metalsemissionG
*lease. ma!e sure to use the most up-to-datesources for technical information and emissionfactors
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 352/669
'oted
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Accepted
'oted
Accepted
'oted
'oted
'oted
ditorial $orrected
:$ emissions see *A A*32 'oted
According to a not yet published research pro7ecton emission factors of the german glass andmineral wool industry. 8I cullet is used in the flatglass production
*lease. provide updated information on preheating
or remove the word currently in line @ since thesource is 11 years old5
please. provide the source to table 2-2"Furthermore. 9, 2I@? on the emission control inglass wor!s provides more detailed information onthe energy demand of carious glass types andfurnaces
*lease. provide updated information on soda limeglass manufacturing via electric heating or removethe word currently in line 8J since the source is 11years old5
Te&t updated for as far asnew information availableKold information removed
About ? pages of the chapter are devoted toreduction measures for ':& and %:2K this is notbalanced with other chapters especially ta!ing intoconsideration that gases are not accounted in2"A"@"d chapter"
*lease. update the information on fuel staging inermany
:bvious outdatedinformation removed. noupdated informationavailable
*lease. update the information on ow-':& inermany
:bvious outdatedinformation removed. noupdated informationavailable
*lease. update the information on :&yfuel-usingfurnaces" ,n western urope T-glass is notproduced anymore and could therefore be deletedfrom the listing e&pect for the case that theproducing plants in eastern urope are using:&yfuel"
:bvious outdatedinformation removed. noupdated informationavailable
*lease. update the information on %$" There isno T-glass production ermany anymore"Therefore. remove the listing in line I
:bvious outdatedinformation removed. noupdated informationavailable
A production -activity rate for the lime production.
not correctedwould be glass production (page 22.row 2 or I)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 353/669
Accepted All corrected
'oted
'oted
'oted
e7ected
'oted
'oted
Tables 8-11-8-12# errors (not lime production)" ditorial $orrected
,n all tables *A/ by substance included into row4not estimate4and to row 4not applicable4 as *A/,twould be more correct if Tier tables in all chaptershave been madein identical format (se+uence ofrows)#'F%'A* (ifapplicable)Fuel*ollutantsTechnologies (for Tier 2-
8)egion (for Tier 2-8)Abatement technologies (forTier 2-8)''A
The heavy metal F refer to the uideboo! (26)- some in general and some to Doc!el (21)"/owever. for lead crystal glass the general F isused instead of F for special glass (e"g" leadcrystal)G
/ Fs removed wherenot applicable
Tables 8-2 to 8-1 contain emission factors whichseem to be too high (by appro&imately factor 1and more) according to the preliminary final reportof a research pro7ect on emission factors of theerman glass und mineral f ibre industry" Thereport is e&pected to be published in ay 2?"%ome e&les are listed in the F-commentsspread sheet" They refer to the year 2I and sumup energy- and production-related emissions"
Tables 8-2. 8-8 (Tier 2)# * and / F for Flatglass and $ontainer glass are the same# this is nottrue because technologies are different"
Tables 8-2 to 8-1 contain emission factors forwhich the reference year is not mentioned" *lease.add this information" Furthermore. to our
!nowledge it is very common to use the metalclasses , to ,,," Therefore. they should be used inthe handboo! as well"
,t is stated that /eavy metal emission factors fromthe Tier 1 table for this source category are addedto the table in order to fill the gap ]methodologically this is not good because asdeclared Tier 2 is more sophisticated approachwhich provide more accurate estimatesK generallyTier 1 tables should originate from Tier 2"
Table 8-I# heavy metals emission factors are thesame as in Tier 1 Table 8-1 while T%* F isdifferent"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 354/669
'oted
Accepted
ditorial $orrected
ditorial $orrected
isschedi7! (23) is missing in the eferences ditorial Added
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
spelling mista!e# correct 4gassified4 into 4gasified4 ditorial processed
Accepted processed
%ubchapter 8"8"2"I includes I tables (8-6 ] 8-1)with the same / F for different types of glass"This is not true# every type of glass has differentcontent of / thus emissions will be differentKdifferentiation is especially important for leadcrystal glass"
Tables 8-6 ] 8-1# uideboo! 26 as referencedin these tables does not contain such emissionfactors"
All chec!ed" Fs removedwhere not applicable"
,n the tables 8-11. 12 (glass production) the 'Fcode is 2"A"2 - lime production. would be 2"A"@"d
lossary. A production - the A for the limeproductionGG
The %'A* for the organic chemical industry isabsolutely not adapted and not representative ofall productions of chemicals substances" The list ofproducts from %'A* 3I1 to 3I26 is notsufficient" The problem is also li!ed to the fact thatproducts accounted under different %'A* code.are produced by the same process (ethylene andpropylene are the best e&le)
The problem of carrying our emission inventoriesfor the organic chemical industry is related to thedecrease in the availability in statistics" ost of theproduction of products considered in the %'A* arenot available in current national statistics"
the first %'A* 3I1 and 3I2 represent thesame process. the steam crac!er" %ee thedescription in the T, document as e&le"
$onsult with&pert *anel
%'A* 3I2I and %'A* 3I26 should note&ist" There are redundant with %'A* 686 ifthis one becomes speciality organic chemicalindustry
%'A* 3622 should also related to the specialityorganic chemistry
Figure 2-3# *lease correct 4Adsorption4 into4Absorption4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 355/669
footnote I is not e&isting below ditorial not foundcorrect reference to the <F is missing Accepted processed
e7ected
ditorial processed ,$ AAF
ditorial processed
ditorial processed
ditorial not found
ditorial processed
Accepted *rocessed
e7ected
e7ected procesed
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
Ammonia Tier1# , don0t found correspondence with+uoted <F values
table 8-1. column 4reference4# what does $ A$Fmean# define reference (*robably you mean the
<F 4arge olume ,norganic $hemicals - Ammonia. Acids and Fertilisers4 (,$ - AAF)9ecember 26G)
the paragraph mentions only two primary sourcesof pollutants. but in the table 8-1 below you findthree pollutants
spelling mista!e# correct 4Tier 2 ort Tier 84 into4Tier 2 or Tier 84
put in a space between 4tier 14 and 4 emissionfactors4
write 4Tier4 always in the same spelling# either witha capital (see line 1 to I on the same page) or in
lower cases"
'itric Acid Tier1# ,t0s better to use <F averagevalue# 1"
Adipic Acid Tier 1#Chy no values when can befound in % *A A*3IG
table 8-3# the upper and lower value can not befound in the refered <F" Table @"1 of ,$ %A:shows the emission factors for different abatementtechnology you refer to as tier 2 (s" table 8-16)
table 8-I# delete table 8-I. because of to manyvery different production processes in 2 < I
Table 8-IK delete this tableK it is impossible tocreate a emission factor for the whole chemicalindustry
Ammonia Tier2# se ,**$ <F value andintroduce also Tables for controlled process from,**$ <F
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 356/669
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
e7ected
Accepted *rocessed
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
e7ected
ditorial processed
Accepted prcocessed
'oted
Accepted processed
Ammonium 'itrate Fs from % *A A*3I Accepted processed
table 8-6# the conventional as well as advancedprocesses are not abatement technologies. butprocess technologies - e&pand the te&t in line 2.column 6 with the te&t from line ?. column 2 anddelete the te&t in ine ?. column 2
table 8-6# the reference of the values given here is
the guideboo! 26 - but there are no datas5 Thereference for ':& ($:G) seems to be ,$ AAF.table 2"@G 9efine the reference of the data
Ammonia Tier2# ,ntroduce also Tables forcontrolled process from ,**$ <F
'itric Acid# erase table 8-?. for unspecified processuse Tier 1
table 8-1# please define why the value is belowthe range
table 8-18# only the value of I refers to Frenchand erman plants. the range of 1-1 refersto % plants - define how to use value and range(why is the range lower than the valueG)
table 8-1I# referring to the guideboo! 26 thedata for the e&tended absorption does also applyfor medium and high pressure processes - add inline 6>column 2 medium and high pressureprocesses
Adipic Acid Tier 2#Chy no emission when valuescan be found in % *A A*3IG
table 8-1?# line 6. column 2# change 4withusage4
into 4with usage 4
the %'A* classification 388 belongs to thegroup of metallproduction and not to the chemicalprocesses - 2<Ia doesn0t include either thesilicium production nor synthetic amorphes silicaand silicates - please chec! this issue"
,n the last line you write. that T%* has not beenestimated - but in line 11 you have a value for T%*- please chec!
table 8-21# line J says that decomposition plantsare included - but table 8-22 is covering the
decomposition plants" $hange 4,ncluding4 into e"g"4without 9ecomposition plants4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 357/669
Accepted *rocessed
'*; fertiliser# '/8 old $orinair F e7ected *rocessed
'otedrea# *. *1. *2.I from % *A A*3I Accepted processed
'oted
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
$hlorine production# se <F values Accepted processedTable 8-86# emission factor for $d is missed" 'oted
Ammonium %ulphate# '/8 value from old $orinairreferences. $: from conomopoulos. J8. *from *A
There are not emission factors for '*; fertilisers
production"
,n this lines the dimension unites for T%* and '/8are in the range of !g>t. but while using the samenumerical value you have in table 8-2? thedimension unit g>t" *lease chec! thedimensions>values"
table 8-2J# The <F ,$-%A: is cited incorrect(s" also &cel sheet 4FP$omments4" , alsocouldn0t find in the <F emission values for*1 and *2.I" *lease cite accurately"
$hlorine production" Table 8-88 Tier 2# /gemission is shown as ' ] it need to be estimatedta!ing into account contribution of $hlorineproduction by this method into mercury emissions"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 358/669
Accepted
'oted
Accepted processed
Accepted accepted*olyethylene# use <F values 'oted
'aphtha is not the uni+ue feedstoc! in urope forsteam crac!ing"
Added note on otherfeedstoc!s
The list of products provided is not complete"*lease provide all possible products to avoiddouble counting by not specialists"
,n France in 2I the emission is different as thevolumes produced are different" The emissionfactors provided for ethylene and propylene are thecorrect one to represent the emissions of thesteam crac!ers if we are able to allocate theemissions of the steam crac!er in all the differenttypes of products manufactured by this process" ,nthe 'etherlands ethylene and propylene representonly 3J of the total products coming from thesteam crac!ers" Chat are the other productsG Addan e&planation to consider them in %'A* 3I2@ ifthe product is not considered in an other item ofthe %'A*" ,f you do not recommend to proceed asabove. the emissions of the steam crac!ers are notcorrectly estimated
Table 8-8@K <F :$# range from .8 to 6 !g>t
ethen and not .3 to 1 in table 8-8@"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 359/669
e7ected
Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
'oted*olystyrene. Crong reference# data from <F 'oted
'oted
e7ected
Accepted processed
Table 8-31K <F *olymers# range (9*) .@ to1.1 !g>t for new plants and 1.1 to 2.1 !g>t fore&isting plants and not 2 to 8 !g>t
The T, document on chemical industrypresents emissions from the suspension *$process developed with the industry organisation"The emission factors could be used"
processed. accepted for':$. T%* F0sunmodified
Table 8-32K <F *olymers# range (/9*) .8 to.I !g>t for new plants and .I to 1.? !g>t fore&isting plants and not 1 to 8 !g>t"
Table 8-38K <F *olymers# range 1? to 3I g>t %-*$ and not 1? to 1
Table 8-33K <F *olymers# range 1 to I g> t-*$ and not 1? to 1
Table 8-3IK in <F *olymers the emission factorfor ** is in the range of /9* (see above)
*olystyrene. Crong :$ F# correct <F value82
Table 8-3?K <AT for /,*% is about ?I g>t (<F*olymers)
Table 8-3J# <F *olymers# range (*%) .3I to.@ !g>t
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 360/669
e7ected
Accepted processed
'oted
'oted
Accepted processed
Accepted *rocessed
Accepted processed
Table 8-I6# The reference is wrong (<F :$) Accepted processed
Table 8-I@# the reference is wrong (<F :$) Accepted processedthylbenHene# F from <F G Accepted *rocessed
Table 8-61K *lease add :$ as reference e7ected
'oted
'oted'ot clear 'oted
Table 8-3@K <AT for **% is about ?I g>t (<F*olymers)
Table 8-I# <F *olymers# range (-%<) .1@to .8@ !g >t
%tyrene <utadiene ubber very lower :$ from<F (1@-I3)
thylene o&ide# wrong reference and incompletedata
<F :$# in the case of tratment by o&idationthe emissions are considered to be Hero
Formaldehyde# the reference was wrong <F butnot polymers
Table 8-II#<F :$ reportet emissions of
about .11 or 8 to I !g>t" The reference <F*olymers is wrong"
made a reference to the<F instead
Table 8-68# F for *:*s pesticides production isshown Hero" ,t is written that emissions of all thedifferent pesticides are assumed to be negliblecompared to product" <ut $hapter 2" *roduction of *:*s contain Fs for all *:*spesticides (1 !g>g product)"
$onsult with&pert *anel
As said before the %'A* 3I2@ has to becompleted to give e&les" ,n France ase&le. all chemical production which can not beclassified in the previous %'A* are put under this%'A* 4other4 and their emissions represent alarge amount of total emissions of the organicchemical industry (8 at least)
,s this chapter usefulG 'othing is given to try toestimate the amount of organic chemical productsstored per t of production" There are no statisticson the +uantity of organic chemicals stored" A wayto estimate them should be useful"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 361/669
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
Accepted processed
'oted
e7ected
e7ected
<AT emission factor for -%<# .1@ to .8@ !g>t Accepted processed
Accepted processed
table 3-1# the <AT-associated emission valuereferred to the <F ,$-AAF is not for '/8 butfor ':& - write 4':&4 instead of '/8K pleasedefine also the reference (,$-AAF)
table 3-2# the <AT-associated emission valuereferred to the <F ,$-AAF is not for '/8 but
for ':& - write 4':&4 instead of '/8
title of the table# the F given apply not only forconventional reforming processes. but also forreduced primary reforming - add reduced primaryreforming processes (,$-AAF. table 2"18)
table 3-3# instead of 4%:24 write 4%:& as %:24 (s"reference and te&t above)
tab" 3-6 (/eading)# table 3-6 refers to the sulfateprocess and not the chloride process - correctheading into 4sulfate process4
The given <AT value for %:2 is not only for drying
but for the total emission level to air (s" ,$-%A:.$hapter 8"I"1. 'o" 13)" Therefore add the data totable 3-I
The given <AT value for %:2 is not only for dryingbut for the total emission level to air (s" ,$-%A:.$hapter 8"I"2. 'o" 1?)" Therefore add the data totable 3-6
<AT emission factor for %-*$# 1? to 3I g>t and -*$# 1 to I g>t
<AT emission factor for 9*# .@ to 1.1 !g>t fornew plants and 1.1 to 2.1 !g>t for e&isting plants K<AT emission factor for /9*# .8 to .I !g>t fornew plants and .I to 1.? !g>t for e&isting plants
<AT emission factor for **%# ?I g>tK /,*%# ?I g>t
and *%# .3I to .@ !g>t
eferences# *lease add# ,**$ <F *olymers -,**$ eference 9ocument on <est AvailableTechni+ues - *olymers. :ctober 26
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 362/669
'oted
'oted
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
Figure 2-8# &planation for the blue arrow missing Accepted
Figure 2-3# &planation missing for the blue arrow Accepted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
ditorial $orrectedTypo in the middle of the line" $orrectly# agents" ditorial $orrected
Accepted $hec!ed and corrected
ditorial $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
ditorial $orrected'o legend provided for formuila" %ee row 1" Accepted egend added
e7ected $orrected
'oted
tab 8-1 'F %ource cat" %hould be 2"$"1 not 2"A"1 ditorial $orrected
%ubdivide %inter from pellets as in ,**$ <F Accepted
&cept in some country where the industry is notpresent. the chemical industry is often a largeemitter of pollutants
all tables# use units consistently (g. t. ton# e"g" intable 8-1 you use !g>t. in table 8-2 you use g>g. intable 8-I you use !g>ton
$onsult with&pert *anel
$hapter describes all processes in ferrous metalsindustry thus very complicated and difficult forusage"
Figure 2-1# 'otatin for blast furnace gas missing",nstead of coal in7ection , recommend co!e ornatural gas in7ection"
Figure 2-2# The 4metallurgical co!e4in the top leftarrow is incorrect" $orrectly# 4$o!ing coal"4
ore info provided incaption
ore info provided incaption
4"""au&iliary reducing agent4 should be amendedwith 4and as a fuelL4
4,t leavesL4 should be replaced with# 4,t and otherfuels leavesL4
etter missing at the beginning of the line"$orrectly# Top of the L
$ontradictions# /ere 1"J is mentioned. but onpage @>1? it says# 4L be reduced less than 14
,n section 2"2"3" the order# <:F. :/F. AF. while inthe others it is# :/F. </F. AF" The letter is
preferred"The agent for reheating is not mentioned in thedescription. e"g" co!e oven gas"
The heavy metal content of furnace gas is notmentioned" Table 8-13 (8>18) does include it"
4L sulfurdio&ideL4 should be written as sulfurdio&id"
As there are iron steel installations that haveonly some plant (for e&le no co!e productionor no sinter and so on) it0s not possible to have a
set of overall emission factorsK please use also forTier 1 the subdivision used for Tier 2"
Table 8-1# emission factor for chromium isoverestimated"
*ellets added as separateTier 2 using Fs from<F
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 363/669
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted Fs added
Accepted
%ubdivide %inter from pellets as in ,**$ <F Accepted
e7ected
%ubdivide %inter from pellets as in ,**$ <F Accepted
e7ected
Accepted $orrections in units made
e7ected
e7ected
%ubdivide %inter from pellets as in ,**$ <F Accepted
%ubdivide %inter from pellets as in ,**$ <F Accepted
$onvert the data in g>!g sinter using appropriatechange factor to compare with 4state of the art4Fs
%ubchapter 8"8"2"1# for sinter production it appearsthat effect of different systems of control ontoheavy metals is different depending on metal and
for some of them more advanced system leads toincrease of emissions"
spreme factors chec!ed"
%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
Chy are the Fs of T%*. *1 and *2"I notestimated in the tables 8"8. 8"3. 8"I and 8"6 G
,n table 8"2 the F of *b is .I g>g sinter product.while the Fs in the tables 8"8.8"3 and 8"I arehigher" ,s that correct G
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
*ellets added as separateTier 2 using Fs from<F
$onvert the data in g>!g sinter using appropriate
change factor to compare with 4state of the art4Fs
*ellets added as separateTier 2 using Fs from<F
$onvert the data in g>!g sinter using appropriatechange factor to compare with 4state of the art4Fs
Tables 8-8-8-6# because Table 8-2 is also namedTier 2 these tables might be considered as Tier 8"
<ut they includes only heavy metals and *:*s ]no *K error in units (should be sinterM instead ofpig ironMK should be [g T=>gM instead of [g>g)K %'A* code is shown as 881 while inTable 8-1 as 32J. e&cept 881" Tables arenot harmoniHed with Tables 8-1 and 8-2# thus inthe Table 8-8 ($ontrolled by wF9) ] emissionfactors for $r. 'i. *b and *$99>F more high thanin the Table 8-2 while for *$< ] lower 2 timesKdio&ins are the same in all tables"
$onvert the data in g>!g sinter using appropriatechange factor to compare with 4state of the art4Fs
$onvert the data in g>!g sinter using appropriatechange factor to compare with 4state of the art4Fs
*ellets added as separateTier 2 using Fs from<F
*ellets added as separateTier 2 using Fs from<F
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 364/669
Accepted Tables removed
Accepted
'oted
Accepted $orrectednit *1 and *2"I not correct Accepted $orrected
Accepted
'oted
Accepted Table corrected
Accepted Tables included
Accepted
'oted
'oted
rase Table 8-? and Table 8-J# are in contrast withTable 8-@
* emission factors are very high if compared with<F data (a factor 1)5 <F F must be ta!eninto account"
Factors replaced with<F values"
/eavy metals emission factors in the Table 8-@ are
generally underestimated especially for $d. *b.Yn. but for $r they are overestimated (ta!ing intoaccount properties of metals)"
Table 8-@# there are errors in unit for *1 and*2"I"
Table 8-@ provides F for pig iron production. forthe whole process starting from the charging of theblast furnace to the tapping of pig iron" Table 8-?and Table 8-J provide F for the charging andtapping individually" <ut emission factors in thesetables are not harmoniHed"
Tables 8-? and 8-Jremoved because theygenerate confusion andare not complete andrather old anyway
rror in units in Tables 8-1-8-18 for *$99>F ]should be [g T=>gK tables do not contain *emission factorsK emission factors were ta!en from%* without analysis of applicabilityK theyloo! very low and probably contain systematicerror in units"
* Fs added"%* data chec!edfor errors"
Table 8-13# table should be revised# it is shownthat the table is for ncontrolled conditions but *emission factors are too low and lower than /emission factorsK / emission factors are partially
from uideboo! 26. and partially ] from$*,* so overall table is heterogeneous andnot reliableK error in units ] should be steelM"
*roposals#Tier 2 emission factors table issuggested applicable for $$A countries fortypical levels of dust abatement (JI-J6)"
<asic :&ygen Furnace# ':& and $: occurs fromo&idation process (see <F for description ofprocess and Fs)# T/% ,%%,:' %T <,'$99 A% T/U A ':T 4$:<%T,:'4,%%,:'% (': F :'U :BU')
':& and $: Fs added totable
Table 8-1I# / emission factors loo!underestimated"
,t is shown that ost emission factors are ta!enfrom the <F document for <est AvailableTechnologies in the ,ron and %teel ,ndustry(uropean $ommission. 21) but this reduceapplicability of emission factors"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 365/669
e7ected
Accepted nit corrected"
Accepted
Accepted Tables included
Tables 8-1] 8-21# error in units ] should be steelM" Accepted $orrected
Accepted
Accepted Tables included
Accepted
Accepted ,nserted as separate Tier 2
'oted
Accepted
'oted
lectric Furnace %teel *lant# ':& and $: occursonly in small portion due to adding of coal in scrabas input to electric furnace (see <F fordescription of process and Fs)# , T/,'; A%:T/% ,%%,:' %T < ,'$99. T/U
A :'U ,' ,,T9 =A'T,TU
4$:<%T,:'4 ,%%,:'%Table 8-16# error in units for benHo(a)pyrene" T%*emission factor is underestimated"
Table 8-1?# emission factor for lead is higher thanin the Table 8-1I (typical conditions)"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
*roposals# tier 2 emission factors table aresuggested applicable for $$A countries fortypical levels of dust abatement (J@"I)"
Tables 8-1J-8-21# error in unit ] should be steelMKunits for *$99>F should be chec!ed" /eavymetals emission factors among tables were notharmoniHed# thus F for lectric Arc Furnaces withbag filter (Table 8-2) are higher than with %*(Table 8-1J)"
*$99>F emission factorcorrected" spremefactors chec!ed. but someinconsistencies remain"
*roposals# tier 2 emission factors table issuggested applicable for $$A countries fortypical levels of dust abatement (bag filter. aboutJJ)
, propose to erase all this old materials# it0s notT,8
All this old informationremoved
8"3"2"I olling mills" This activity must be in Tier 2with <F Fs
,tMs not clear why some pollutants are in 41"<"2",ndustrial *rocesses4 section and not in 41"<"1"nergy4 section while are combustion related" Fore&le in sinter plant the F for sinter plant inTable 8"2 is fuel related as e&plained in +uotedreference (4The combustion process is nothomogenous and is incomplete. resulting insignificant +uantities of polycyclic aromatic
hydrocarbons (*A/s) being produced"4)",n the Tables erase the row relative to ':&. $:.':$ and %:& and put these pollutants in thebo& 4'ot applicable4 in conformity with otherchapters
/armoniHed witheporting Template
$hapter consists mainly of headings" ,t includesone table with one emission factor# this is notenough for inventory of emissions from this sector"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 366/669
Ferroalloys production# use * Fs from <F Accepted
Accepted
,n the list of main pollutants *A/ are not included" Accepted
'oted
Accepted
Accepted Added to tables
'oted
'oted
Accepted
Accepted Added
Accepted
'oted $orrected
The notation !eys given in Table 8-1 for Total *A/(') do not correspond to the notation !eys givenfor the *A/s included in *A/-3 ('A)"
/armoniHed witheporting Template
/armoniHed witheporting Template
Table 8-1# no F for dio&ins>furansK no F for *A/e&cept benso(a)pyrene"
The notation !eys given in Table 8-1 for Total *A/(') do not correspond to the notation !eys givenfor the *A/s included in *A/-3 ('A)"
/armoniHed witheporting Template
%:&. ':& and :$ comes from process and arenot evaluated elsewhere" ,nsert F here from ,**$<F" %ee <F for details of the processemissions description"
Tables 8-1. 8-2. 8-8# benHo(a)pyrene F are thesame for Tier 1 and Tier 2 for both technologies ofprimary aluminium production# this is not so"
Tables 8-1. 8-2 and 8-8 include $: emission factor
while other gases are estimated in the chapter1"A"2
The F given for benHo(a)pyrene is not valid forthe *re<a!e-process"
F removed. other Fs('etherlands contributionfor *:*s) used instead
,n the <F-document %:2 and ':&emissionfactors (from sulfur and nitrogen in theanodes) are given" These emission factors mightbe useful for estimating emissions using higherTier than Tier 1"
The notation !eys given in Table 8-2 for Total *A/
(') do not correspond to the notation !eys givenfor the *A/s included in *A/-3 ('A)"
/armoniHed witheporting Template
Tables 8-2. 8-8 and 8-3# * emission factorsshown the same for primary (both technologies)and secondary aluminium production" This is notso"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 367/669
Accepted
Accepted Added
'oted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted Tables included
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
The notation !eys given in Table 8-8 for Total *A/(') do not correspond to the notation !eys givenfor the *A/s included in *A/-3 ('A)"
/armoniHed witheporting Template
,n the <F-document %:2 and ':&emissionfactors (from sulfur and nitrogen in the
anodes) are given" These emission factors mightbe useful for estimating emissions using higherTier than Tier 1"
Table 8-3# no F for dio&ins>furans (important forsecondary aluminium)K no F for *A/"
tab 8-3 'F %ource cat" %hould be 2"$"8 not 2"$"1also in tab 8-8
The legend for Table 3-8 refers to emission factorsfor primary aluminium production" ,n row four in thetable it says 4%econdary aluminium"""""4
*roposals# tier 2 emission factor tables aresuggested for primary (limited control andadvanced control) and secondary copperproduction in $$A based upon average valuesof unabated dust emissions. emission controllevels and content of metals in dust"
,t is shown that emissions from secondary copperproduction are considered in the $hapter 1"A"2"b"<ut Table 8-8 proposes F for secondary copperproduction. Tier 1 (Table 8-1) emission factors arefor all copper"
%entence removed. notapplicable here5
4The emissions from the production of secondarycopper are due to energy use only and thereforetreated in the combustion chapter 1"A"2"b4"
%entence removed. notapplicable here5
,n the sector 2"8 missions %:2 emission aremainly considered in spite of the fact that gaseousemissions are not estimated in this chapterKscarce information about * emission"
%ubchapter 8"2"2# methods of estimation of Tier 1emission factors are not described and in generalcommon table for primary and secondary copperloo!s artificial"
Table 8-1# error in unit (aluminium is shown)Kemission factors for heavy metals seemunderestimated especially for *bK no emissionfactor for YnK no emission factor for copper whilecopper production is the main source of copperemissionK emission factor for *$99>F loo!soverestimated"
nit corrected" $u Fadded"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 368/669
Accepted $orrected
e7ected
'oted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
%ame comment for tables 8-2 and 8-8" 'oted
Accepted /armoniHed
'oted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted /armoniHed
Accepted /armoniHed
Accepted $orrected
The emission factors are e&pressed in terms ofmass of pollutant per mass of aluminiumproduced" *lease ta!e into account that the activityconsidered is copper production"
%:&. ':& and :$ comes from process and arenot evaluated elsewhere" ,nsert F here from ,**$
<F" %ee <F for details of the processemissions description"
$hapter not contains technologically specificemission factors as necessary# only tables forprimary and secondary copper with the sameerrors (see comment to the table 8-1)"
Table 8-2# error in title# not Tier 1. but it is Tier 2Krror in unit (aluminium is shown)K no F for Ynand $u"
The title of the table 8-2 refers to Tier 1 when it
should be Tier 2"Table 8-8# error in unit (not aluminiumM)K no F forYn and $u"
nit corrected" F for $uadded. for Yn noinformation available"
Carning# the emission factor value considered for*b matches with one of the JI confidenceinterval value. is this correctG
The JI confidence interval for $r in Table 8-1 is-. but the emission factor proposed is 16 g>galuminium"
The title of the table 8"8 refers to Tier 1 when itshould be Tier 2"
,n Table 8-1. emission factors for As. $d. $r. /g. 'iand *b do not coincide with the values thatappears in the indicated reference (%*)"
The *%T. *1 and *2"I emissions factors thatappears in Table 8-2 for Tier 2 are the same thatappears in Table 8-1 for Tier 1"
The JI confidence interval for $r in Table 8-2 is-. but the emission factor proposed is 21 g>galuminium"
,n Table 8-8. emission factors for As. $d. 'i and *b
do not match with the values that appears in theindicated reference (%*)"
,n Table 8-2. emission factors for As. $d. $r. 'iand *b do not match with the values that appearsin the indicated reference (%*)"
9io&ins and furans are indicated as not estimatedbut there is an emission factor proposed in Table8-1"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 369/669
'oted
Accepted $orrected
'oted
Accepted $u F added
Accepted $orrected
'oted
Accepted $orrected
'oted
e7ected
'oted
e7ected
,n Table 8-1. for %:&. ':&. ':$ and $:.emissions are indicated as estimated elsewhere"Chere are these emissions estimatedG ,n the caseof %:&. are not process emissions (other thanthose related to the fuel consumption) that should
be computed in this $hapter 2$IaG
This statement does not match with the presenceof the table 8-8. which presents emissions factorsfor secondary copper production"
%ame comment for subse+uent tables in this$hapter"
,n addition. as a big surprise. there is no $uemission factor for the very copper production.although there are emission factors for other heavymetals"
*$< is indicated as not applicable but there is an
emission factor proposed in the Table 8-1"eneral comment# chapter should be substantiallyrewor!ed" 'ecessity and methods of aggregationof primary and secondary lead production shouldbe discussed"
$hapter should be edited# 0ime production0 (*"I).0$ement production0 (*"I). 4$ement industry4 (*"3).0*roduction of cement0 (*"6). 0Yinc production0 (*"2).0$opper plants4 (*"1?) et" al" are not consideredhere"
Table 8-1# / emission factors areunderestimatedK no F for HincK principals of Tier 1
F calculation should be discussed"%:& and ':& comes from process and are notevaluated elsewhere" ,nsert F here from ,**$<F" %ee <F for details of the processemissions description"
Table 8-2# there are no differences with Tier 1 tablefor *. but large differences for /"
Tier 2 Tables 8-2 ] 8-1# emission factors in thetables were not harmoniHed. i"e relations betweendust and / were not accounted (/ emissionfactors canMt be higher than *K abatement affects* similar way as most /" Applicability of
proposed emission factors is limited because nogeographical indications are given for technologiesdistribution"
Te&t in section added to
ma!e it more clear that *factors are generic. notspecific for the technology
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 370/669
Accepted Tables included
Accepted
'oted
Table 8-6# the same comment as for Table 8-I" 'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
*roposals# two Tier 2 emission factors for primarylead tables were prepared applicable for $$A#first ] for low level of abatement (about J?) andsecond ] for high level (OJJ)":ne emissionfactors table was prepared for secondary leadproduction (abatement WJJ)"
Table 8-8# not understandable# if it is a <AT tablewhy F for / are higher than in the Table 8-2(Typical abatement)K lead emission factor is higherthan for T%*"
All %* factorschec!ed again for errors
Table 8-I# F for T%* is the same as in the Table8-8 (<AT). but for / emission factors aresignificantly lower than in Table 8-8" ead emissionfactor is underestimated"
Te&t in section added toma!e it more clear that *factors are generic. notspecific for the technology
Te&t in section added to
ma!e it more clear that *factors are generic. notspecific for the technology
Table 8-@ (secondary lead)# * F is the same asin the Table 8-2 (primary lead) and in the Table 8-1(Tier 1)" * emission factors are underestimated"*$< and *$99>F emission factors ] errors inunits"
Te&t in section added toma!e it more clear that *factors are generic. notspecific for the technology
Table 8-?# / emission factors are higher for <AT
than for typical abatement (Table 8-@)"
Te&t in section added toma!e it more clear that *factors are generic. not
specific for the technology
Tables 8-? - 8-1# * emission factors are thesame for different technologies but / emissionfactors are different" 9ependence of / emissionfactors from abatement is not understandable"
Te&t in section added toma!e it more clear that *factors are generic. notspecific for the technology
Table 8-J# / emission factors are higher for %*than for typical abatement (Table 8-@)"
Te&t in section added toma!e it more clear that *factors are generic. notspecific for the technology
*roposals# chapter should be significantlysupplemented and rewor!ed" Tier 2 region-specificand technology-specific tables are necessary"
,t is shown that only primary Hinc emissions areconsidered but emission factors also for secondaryare included in the tables 8-I-8-?"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 371/669
Accepted %entence removed
e7ected
'oted
Accepted
'oted
Accepted $$A tables included"
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
,t is written. that missions from nic!el productionare not significant. since the contribution to thetotal national emissions is thought to beinsignificant. i"e" less than 1 of the nationalemissions of any pollutantM" ,t is not right# inussian Federation according to rough estimates
about 1 mln" tons of %:2 are emitted annuallyfrom nic!el production ] about 2 of nationaltotal"
%:&. $:. :$ and ':& comes from process andare not evaluated elsewhere" ,nsert %:& and $:F here from ,**$ <F" %ee <F for details ofthe process emissions description"
%:& included in thischapter
Table 8-1 (Tier 1) should be updated# it includesonly 2 emission factors# for T%* and 'i" Thesefactors if considered *-wide areunderestimated" 9uring nic!el production otherheavy metals are emitted"
,t is written. that 0missions of %:&. ':&. ':$and $: are due to the combustion activities andsubse+uently treated in source category 1"A"2"b0 "This is not so# in nic!el production from sulphidicore %:2 emission is not due to combustionactivities so should be treated in 2"$"I"c chapter"
%:& included in thischapter
eferences include only one source (,**$ <F)- it is not enough"
*roposals# chapter need to be substantionally
rewor!ed" Two Tier 2 emission factors Tables forprimary Hinc production by electrochemicaltechnology were prepared applicable for $$A#first ] for low level of abatement (about J) andsecond ] for high level (OJJ)" lectrochemicaltechnology is dominant in the $$A countriesHinc industry (more than J of total primary Hinc)"
,t is shown. that the most important pollutantsemitted from these processes are heavy metals(particularly Hinc) ] but there are no emissionfactors for Hinc in the Tables 8-1 ] 8-?"
Yn Fs added to eachtable
4This chapter only discusses primary Hincproduction" %econdary Hinc production causes only
emissions from combustion activities and istherefore treated in chapter 1"A"2"b4"
%entence removed. notapplicable here5
4The most important pollutants emitted from theseprocesses are heavy metals (particularly Hinc)4"
Yn Fs added to eachtable
%ubchapter 2"3 $ontrols# no description ofabatement systems"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 372/669
'oted nit errors corrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Table 8-1 (Tier 1)# heavy metals emission factorsare significantly underestimatedK no F for $uK noF for Yn which is the main pollutant from HincproductionK F for *$< and *$99>F are dubious"rror in unit for *$99>F"
*$< is indicated as not applicable but there is an
emission factor proposed in the Table 8-1"
,t is written that This section provides technologyspecific emission factors for the two techni+ues Lthe electrochemical process and the thermalsmelting process but below there are nodescriptions of these technologies and no emissionfactors"
%entence removed. nospecific Fs for theseprocesses available5
,n Table 8-2. why are used the emission factors forTier 1 from %* li!e emission factors for Tier2G
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
Tables 8-2. 8-I# * emission factors for primary(Table 8-2) and secondary (Table 8-I) Hinc are thesame while technologies are different"
Tables 8-2-8-? Tier 2# tables were not harmoniHedwith Tier 1 table and with each otherK * emissionlevels do not correspond / emissions andsometimes lower than / emission factorsK noHinc emission factors"
Yn Fs added to eachtable
Table 8-8 (<AT technologies table)# emissionfactors for $d and *b are higher than for typicalabatementK emission factor for $r appeared notincluded in Table 8-2"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
,n Table 8-8. JI confidence interval values for$d. $r. /g and *b do not match with the valuesthat appears in the indicated reference(%*)"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
Table 8-3# * emission factors are the same as inthe Table 8-8 but / emission factors are lower 3orders of magnitude"
,n Table 8-3. JI confidence interval values for$d. $r. /g and *b do not match with the valuesthat appears in the indicated reference(%*)"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
Table 8-I# * emission factors are the same as forprimary Hinc which is not trueK / emission factorsare underestimatedK no Yn emission factor"
Yn Fs added to eachtable
,n Table 8-I. JI confidence interval values for As. $d. /g and *b do not match with the valuesthat appears in the indicated reference(%*)"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 373/669
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted
'oted
'oted
Table 8-6# <AT technology. but / emissionfactors compared with typical abatement (Table 8-I) are 2-8 order of magnitude higher. * ] thesame. *$< and *$99>F ] lower"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
,n Table 8-6. emission factors for As. $d. /g and
*b do not match with the values that appears inthe indicated reference (%*)"
spreme factors chec!ed"
%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
,n Table 8-@. JI confidence interval values for As. $d. $r. /g and *b do not match with thevalues that appears in the indicated reference(%*)"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
,n Table 8-?. JI confidence interval values for As. $d. $r. /g and *b do not match with thevalues that appears in the indicated reference(%*)"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
Table 8-J# abatement efficiencies for modern plant
is shown lower than for conventional installations"rror# not ead productionM but Yinc productionM"
The information that is showed in Table 8-J is forlead production. not for Hinc production"
,t is written that Tier 2 tables were compiled usingcountry data from Table 8-1" <ut data in Tier 2tables do not correspond to the data in the Table 8-1" ,t is not clear enough how Tier 2 tables wereobtained and for what countries data was used"egion-specific emission factors are necessary"
'ew Fs inserted from%*. they are nowused in all Tier 2"
,n Table 8-1. for %:&. ':&. ':$ and $:.emissions are indicated as estimated elsewhere"Chere are these emissions estimatedG %amecomment for subse+uent tables in this $hapter"
9io&ins and furans are indicated as not estimatedbut there is an emission factor proposed in Table8-1"
,n Table 8-1. emission factors for As. /g and *b donot match with the values that appears in theindicated reference (%*)"
spreme factors chec!ed"%ome inconsistenciesremain however"
This statement does not match with the presenceof the Tables 8-I. 8-6. 8-@ and 8-?. which presentsemissions factors for secondary Hinc production"
This statement does not match with the rest of thecapitule because there is no Yn emission factor"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 374/669
'oted rror corrected
Accepted $orrected
eferences include only one source" 'oted
transport of 4cement4 is not correct Accepted $orrected
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
'otedT/ should be written as the" Accepted $orrectedusing annual national total cement productionG ditorial $orrected
A - national total cement productionGGG ditorial $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted 9one
Accepted $orrected
'oted
'oted
Accepted
Accepted $orrected
$hapter consists of ? pages and one table Tier 1emission factors for source category 2"$"I"c 'ic!elproduction (probably error) with one emissionfactor (for T%*)" This is not enough for emissionestimation from :ther metals production" $haptershould be supplemented"
Table 8-1# the title and content of the table are notharmoniHed"
,nstead of 4LhardwoodL4 , recommend wood orcellulose-bearing materials
,nstead of 4LwoodL4 , would recommend 4woodor other cellulose-bearing materialsL4
,t is not described where ensillary fuel used inrecovery furnace (e"g" oil) should be ta!en intoconsideration" %ee also page @. lines I-6"
;raft process# the values for ':$ and %:B arewrongly copied from <F
Table 8-2. for T%*. *1. *2.I unit is !g>g coalproducedG
Acid sulphite process # the values for * arewrongly copied from <F
Table 8-1# , would recommend 4air dried pulp4instead of 4dried pulp4"
'eutral sulphite semi-chemical process# wrongreference (see the te&t)
%everal polutants are given in the F-tables to be'A" From %wedish e&periences there areemissions of metals. '/8 and also some *A/-3and dio&ins from the process (;raft and acid
sulphite) why the notation should be '"
eporting template nowused to automatically fill
'A and ' bo&es"Tables 8-@. 8-?. 8-J# !g> alcohol# whatconcentration of alcoholG
,t is unclear when Table @-J and when Table 2?-82should be used"
%ome descriptive te&tadded in beginning of Tier2 section
$a!es. biscuits and brea!fast cereals# wrong copyF from old <# verify
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 375/669
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrectedreplace !g>g meat etc with !g>g product Accepted 9one
'oted
'oted
'otedThere are no any references" 'oted
'otedCho is the e&pert for e&pert 7udgement 'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
,t0s not clear where leather finishing is included
Accepted
,n table 8-1J instead of %'A* 36I must be%'A* 362@ (meat"")
,n table 8-2 instead of %'A* 36I must be%'A* 362I (sugar)
Tables 8-2? to 8-22# !g>hl alcohol# what
concentration of alcoholG
$hapter should be significantly supplementedta!ing into consideration importance of *:*sproduction for total *:*s emission" 'ow it consistsof 8 pages and one table with similar emissionfactors for all *:*s which are not grounded"$hapter should also include production of *:*s-containing products li!e *$< transformers.capacitors. dyers etc" which is important forretrospective emission assessment"
Chat confidence can we give to this chapterG ery
poor at first view" This chapter has to be wor!edmore deeply" Chat is the definition of productsused in the table 8"1"
9ue to increase pressure on ember states forproviding emission inventories for *:*. the +ualityof this chapter is too low"
$hapter is based upon chapter lectricale+uipment with *$< from the uideboo! 26which was reduced" $hapter need to be
significantly supplemented and rewor!ed (maybewith division into a few chapters) to show overallpicture of consumption of *:*s and heavy metals"
Table 8-1# table should be revised - it is notreliable. for instance it shows emission factors 1!g>ton from consumption of heavy metals li!e $ror 'i which is not understandable"
This section is not very clear" Chat do you to say G04*harmaceutical products manufacturing (%'A*686)4 does not correspond to 4application ofcoatings during the manufacture of a number ofother industrial products4
*harmaceutical productsmanufacturing removedfrom this list
$onsult with&pert *anel
substitute 4for architectural or furnitureapplications4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 376/669
'oted
Accepted
Accepted pdated
Accepted directive 23>32>$ ((9ecopaint directive4) Accepted 9irective addedthird column 1th row# 1I Acceptedthird column second row# @I Acceptedthird column third row# 3 Acceptedthird column fifth row# 3 Acceptedthird column si&th row# @I Acceptedthird column seventh row# 3I Acceptedthird column ?th row# 1I Accepted
third column Jth row# 3 Acceptedfourth column 1th row# 18 Acceptedfourth column Jth row# 8 Accepted
Accepted alues corrected
Accepted alues corrected
Accepted 9irective mentioned
Accepted Te&t added
,n the discussion of emissions there is noindication what happens with :$0s emitted fromcleaning e+uipemtn. brushes. guns. rollers. etc"9ilution is also mentioned marginally but it mightbe +uite important" ,t certainly should be clear ifthis is included or not" ,n case of emission factorslater shown from the model the model developersshould be as!ed if the factors include thesecomponents or refer only to solvent in paint"
, would suggest to apply an uniform emissionfactor of JI for open applications instead of1
These products are covered by the *roduct9irective 23>32>$ on the limitation of emissionsof volatile organic compounds due to the use oforganic solvents in certain paints and varnishesLChen T, document was done. the directive
was not yet implemented"The results of this are the %olvent missions9irective (1JJJ>18>$) and the *roduct 9irective(23>32>$)" This latter regulation will beL"
pdated" 9ecopaintdirective added to te&t"
%ome of the values table 2-2 are not correct" Theright ones are in Anne& ,, < of the 9ecopaintdirective (23>32>$)
:$ content limit values in table 2"2 have to bemodified according to the *roduct 9irectivementioned above
ention the %olvents missions 9irective1JJJ>18>$ for this sector
%olvent 9irective 1JJJ>18>$ mentions that#4coating activities which cannot be applied undercontained conditions (as shipbuilding. aircraftpainting) may be e&empted from emission limitvalues # the reduction scheme is then to be used.unless it is demonstrated that this option is nottechnically and economically feasible" ,n this case.the operator must demonstrate to the satisfactionof the competent authority that the <AT is beingused"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 377/669
Accepted 9irective mentioned
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
Accepted 9irective mentioned
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
Accepted 9irective mentioned
Accepted
'oted
ention the %olvents missions 9irective1JJJ>18>$ for this sector
$ar repairing is regulated under the *roduct9irective 23>32>$ and was removed from the%olvent emissions 9irective 1JJJ>18>$
*lease +uote the regulations of the 9ecopaint
directive for $ar repairing (23>32>$. Anne& ,,<)"
:$ contents in paints used for car repairing areregulated by the *roduct 9irective 23>32>$ #only 1 phase which came into force in 2@ (seetable of :$ content in the 9irective)
ention the %olvents missions 9irective1JJJ>18>$ for this sector
,n the e+uation the activity rate refers to theapplication of paint while later in line 18 on page1I it says that national production data are used" ,thin! this is wrong. in time of multinationalconsortia producing vertain paints in few locationsand distributing them to many countries we cannotrely on production figures. not too mention stoc!schangins from year to year and e&ports outsideurope or imports" , thin! one needs to refer her tothe paint use and industrial associations need tobe consulted for this data" They do e&ist and areavailable for most countries. for the others onewouldhave to ma!e assessment based on percapita use of paint or something li!e that which ,thin! would still give better result than production
figures"
Te&t adapted. discussionshould be about paint
used%hould emission factor be distinguished accordingto the year # 1JJ. 2 and 21 (afterimplementation of the 9irective) # if yes. data areavailable from $*" $,T*A has this type ofinformation"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 378/669
'oted
Accepted
Accepted $orrected9ecorative paints (618 V 613) e7ected
'oted
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
'oted
'oted
e7ected
e7ected
, would go for even more caution when suggestingas a default value a 2 average uropennumber" , thin! it could be better to refer todeveloped and developing coutnries and try to
develop two factors at least" Ce need toremember that there are very often historical orcultural differences. say how and from whatmaterials the houses are built. e"g" if onecompares %candinavia and editerraneancountries. the construction materials are sodifferent that the standard typical paint applicationsmust be different" , feel these things should bementioned" This type of information will be usefulalso for the Tier 1 approach" All that in spite of thatfact that , do agree that the JI conf"int doescover that largely"
,n the tables 8-1 to 8-8 the development of the Tier1 emission factors must be further e&plained"
9escription on how Tier 1
has been derived hasbeen updated
L" ember %tates to bring decorative or vehiclerefinishing paint products L""
%pecific F for 1JJ. 2 and 21 are availablefrom $* and have been used in A,'%
Again the issue of production versus use" *leasema!e sure this is consitent. while for cars. coatedarea. etc. it is o! for decorative paint is not the rightappraoch"
The sector 4industrial coating applications4 is verywide # %'A* codes should be precised
9onMt refer to abatement documents that preceedthe *roduct 9irective 23>32>$ from April 23"The actual abatement regulations in -2@ shouldbe from that publication onwards" The T, andA,'%>A,'% nomenclature used here is notapplicable for 9$:"
The sentence 4products containing I wt-solvent4 is not compatible with F replace with4products containing 2I wt- solvent4 or correctF
The sentence 4products containing I wt-solvent4 is not compatible with F replace with4products containing 2I wt- solvent4 or correctF
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 379/669
Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
Accepted $orrected
Accepted Added to the <AT section
Accepted
'oted
The F in not applicableK where we can found thedata m2 coated" The F in this form can be usefulto estimate the new paint technology penetrationbut non the emissions" F %T be e&pressed as
g>t of paint or g>t product" $onsideration abouttransfer efficiency of paint on ob7ect can be usefulto estimate future paint consumption but not foremission inventory" ventually maintain g>m2 foremissions but define default value for m2>t assurface painted for tonnes of products" This defaultvalues can be e&tracted from original F source"
ersion calculated in termsof g>!g paint applied"$onversion factormentioned in te&t"
The F is wrong55 The value is referred to g>m25 And for this is valid the previous comment# wherewe can found the data m2 coated" The F in thisform can be useful to estimate the new painttechnology penetration but non the emissions" Fmust be e&pressed as g>t of paint" $onsiderationabout transfer efficiency of paint on ob7ect can beuseful to estimate future paint consumption but notfor emission inventory"
$onsult with&pert *anel
rror corrected" F shouldbe g>m2 indeed
There is an emission factor of 2 !g>g foreather Finishing from <F that must be ta!eninto account5
$onsult with&pert *anel
, don0t thin! these are always 4abatement4. newtechnology>new products are often considered" ,t0sbetter produce Fs tables (non reductions) withtechnology>products and put them in section 8"8"2as in others chapters of <" , thin! the approach
must be uni+ue5The table is not applicable" At statistical level is not!nown the m2 of wood painted" Ce need Fs fortonne of paint"
For wire. area is not the relevant activity which isthe mass of wire coated
The <AT reference is only applicable to the decoproducts applied in a factory (installation)" Thema7ority of the volume in 9$:. however. is goinginto profeesional use (painters) and do-it-yourself"For that ma7ority (_@I) there is no accepted <AT"
$oating of agricultural and construction e+uipment#this falls in the industrial coating application (notthe decorative coating application)
oved to ,ndustrial coatingapplication
, thin! in this chapter should be describedmethodologies to ensure time consistency andrecalcualtion and not methodologies to generatetemporally resolved emission data sets
Te&t removedK doesindeed not belong here
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 380/669
Accepted
'oted
e7ected
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted F added
Chat is the meaning of time seriesG , believed thatit is about emission s changing from year to yearand so here the issues of changing emissionsfactors owing to technological change andlegislation might be touched upon" As is it is a verydifernt story" erify"
Te&t removedK doesindeed not belong here
,t probably does not belong here as , thin! woodpreservation is a separate chapter and is not partof coating" %uggest ot simply delete"
emovedK belongs inwood preservation chapter
$oating of plastic parts is defined separately in the<F# it should be added somewhere and theplace is in the industrial coating"
For all source categories# 'ational import. e&portand production statictics for single chemicals canbe used as activity data" sed amounts can bedifferentiated into activities and facilities"
mission factors can be applied for use of single
chemicals in products and>or activities"Cith respect to harmoniHation to 9irective1JJJ>18>$. which is e"g" employed in performingemission pro7ections# ,n many technologies asolvent consumption is warranted at facility level"cont" below
continued from above. This re+uires !nowledge onTier 8 level. which may not be avaliable" Theguideline could suggest how to differentiate a totaluse amount of solvent on a facility level"
FU,# 'orway is adopting a different approach toestimating emissions from the use of solventcontaining products than the ones described in theuideboo!" i!e in the %wedish inventory. volumedata from the national *roduct egister on thesolvents themselves is used" mission factors arespecific for combinations of product types andindustrial sectors" The 2? uideboo! does notprovide us with information that can be used in theemission model directly" /owever. the informationprovided may help to correctly allocate emissionfigures (pertaining to the combinations of product
type and industrial sectors) into the differentsource categories and help us to improve ouremission factors" ore information on the new'orwegian model on ':$ emissions from theuse of solvent containing products can be providedon demand"
': Fs for paint application# boat building (%'A*6 1 6) - ,mportant in some countries. there isan F from <F5
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 381/669
Accepted
'oted
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
Accepted
': Fs for lectronic components manufacturing 'oted
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted 'umber placed in te&t
'oted
ore information is re+uired in relation to theemission factors from T," A specific referenceis re+uired to the bac!ground documentation in theA,'% model so that emission factor values canbe e&amined for applicability to nationalcircumstance" The emission factors are not clear in
terms of their derivation" The units differ betweensources" A common emission factor unit would behelpful"
9escription on how Tier 1has been derived has
been updated. referenceto A,'% fordocumentation
A very important refernce is missing , thin!" ,t is49$:*A,'T - %tudy on the *otential foreducing missions of olatile :rganic$ompounds (:$) 9ue To The se :f 9ecorative*aints and arnishes for *rofessional and 'on-professional se4. $ 9 nvironment Tender1>T>J??3. Dune 2" , believe it is availablefrom the $ommission web site" This wouldbe very
valuable for the section on decorative paints. evenif it was certainly used by T, group"
entioned in the te&t as
an interesting bac!grounddocument
$leaning products to be considered are onlyorganic solvents" This has to be precised" anyproducts used for degreasing do not produce':$
ore information is re+uired in relation to theemission factors from T," A specific referenceis re+uired to the bac!ground documentation in theA,'% model so that emission factor values can
be e&amined for applicability to nationalcircumstance" The referecence to T, for thissector is to a document published in 2I and not28 as indicated" ,n respect of dry cleaning isuggest reverting to the old simple methodologyapproach rather than an emission factor based on!g of garment cleaned"
eference correctedK oldmethodology put bac! butonly as a 4reference4methdology. industry hasinsisted on removinginformation because it wasoutdated5
The old < emission factors for units in operationcan be useful as Tier 1 meth and must bemaintained in the new <
, thin! in this chapter should be describedmethodologies to ensure time consistency andrecalcualtion and not methodologies to generatetemporally resolved emission data sets
Te&t removedK doesindeed not belong here
,n the 4old4 uideboo! is present an F in!g>inhabitant year that can be useful for countrieswith no other information" Transfer the F in new< please"
,n this $hapter 681 (*olyester processing)should be also considered
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 382/669
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
Accepted
'oted
'oted
Accepted =uote fi&ed
&planations coming from T, to be cited Accepted =uote fi&ed
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
Accepted
Accepted
,t is not correct to say that all these activities areinsignificant" According to characteristic of theindustry and member states. several of theseactivities are significant"
,n the e&panded polystyrene. pentane is the mostoften blowing agent used" ,n e&truded polystyreneother types of chemicals are used" ,n polyurethane$F$ were used but presently other types ofblowing agents are used" ,n polyurethane. thetypes of blowing agents used depend on the finaluse of the foam" <utane. pentane can be used asmany substitutes of $F$ such as /F$ and /$F$"%ome polyurethane foams can be e&pandeddirectly with $:2 resulting from a reaction betweenpolyols and water"
,nformation added tochapter
The description is a little bit too old " A description
of the present situation would be necessary"
The title of the paragraph does not correspond tothe %'A* 686 definition (manufacturing ofpharmaceutical product) Ce agree and support thee&tension of the scope of %'A* 686" Thespeciality organic chemical industry aims atproducing different types of chemical productsincluding pharmaceutical products but not only"
the description comes from the T, documentwhich is not +uoted"
For e&panded polystyrene. pentane is e&clusivelyused"
F11. F12 are forbidden today and cannot be usedanymore" ive the names of the present blowingagents"
The reduction techni+ues available for polystyreneand polyurethane are different" ,t would be usefulto distinguish the two applications" For polystyrene.low pentane content e&pandable polystyrene canbe used (3"I to I ) but 7ust for some specific
application" missions can be captured andtreated by o&idation"
,nformation added tochapter
Add on techni+ues can be used" Applicationse&ists in several countries" :&idation techni+uesare the most often used techni+ues but wastegases containing pentane can be also destroyed ina boiler"
,nformation added tochapter
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 383/669
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
ive the list of products to be considered" Accepted
the title is not the correct one ditorial $orrected
e7ected
This chapter is outdated 'oted
ditorial $orrected
'oted
Accepted
'oted
'oted
The $ 9irective has been implemented but manymember states have their own regulation goingfurther the $ directive" *olyurethane foamprocessing. *olystyrene foam processing. asphaltblowing. the non pharmaceutical part of thespeciality chemical industry are not covered by this
directive"
%mall list of productsadded. but is not complete
/ere is a strong mista!e" The suspension processis a process to produce the *$ from $monomers" ,n this chapter only *$ processinghas to be considered" All the paragraph has to beremoved if no data are available for *$processing"
$onsult with&pert *anel
The confidence interval should correspond tosomething li!e II to 6I g > !g"
,n Table 8-6 is meant pharmaceutical productsmanufacturing
An emission factors of I !g>ton of product (fromtwo factory in ,taly) can also be proposed
the title of the table if not the correct one" Forrubber it is possible to distinguish tyre productionand other rubber processing" For tyre the T,default emission factor is 1g> !g rubber
processed" This emission factor is larger for otherapplication" The ? proposed if perhapsunderestimated"
Title updatedK rubberproduction now alsoincludes tyre production
,n the %'A* $ode should be only considered4Asphalt blowing 4 a special asphalt productionprocess and not the application of asphalt" Theemissionsfactors are very outdated and verylarge555 The asphalt application is considered under361 and %'A* 3611
$onsult with&pert *anel
The definition of solvent used is the same as thedefinition used by the $ directive JJ>18" ,tcorresponds to new solvents or bought solvents V
solvents recycled" ,t has to be reminded that in the$ directive fugitive emissions are e&pressed in compared to solvent used" "
,nformation added tochapter
The definition of asphalt should be provided" 9oesit included only the hydrocarbons or hydrocarbonsV all additives and ingredient used (stonesL)G
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 384/669
Accepted Te&t updated accordingly
Accepted $orrected
'oted
the title is the correct one ditorial $orrected
'oted
Accepted F added
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
'oted
'oted
'oted
ive the list of products to be considered" ,n factthey are at east paints. varnishes. glues. in!s" ,nfact this emission factor comes from T, whichprovides the emission factors for solvent borneproducts. water based products which can be used
by e&perts if they have the !nowledge on theshare of each type of products"
nder 6813 should not be considered Tyremanufacturing" This is considered under rubberprocessing" nder 6813 is considered themanufacturing of solvent containing products
This description is the same for all the specialityfine chemical industry" ower rates of emissionscan be achieved in the newest plants" ,n e&istingones also" $hec! if we stay with a definition ofpharmaceutical products or use the specialitychemical industryG
': F (and ': TA<55) for 6818 eatherTanning
An emission factor for 6811 Adhesive Tapeanufacturing is present in <F
': F (and ': TA<55) for 6812 Te&tileFinishing
% *A insert a lot of other fiber manufacturingactivities that must be evaluated# ryanoin. acetate.acrylic. nylon. etc"
': F (and ': TA<55) for 681 *olyester
*rocessing there are data from *A A* 32"%T< ,'%T955
$onsult with&pert *anel
ost of this information can be founded by directuses of plant data"
ore information is re+uired in relation to theemission factors from T," A specific referenceis re+uired to the bac!ground documentation in theA,'% model so that emission factor values canbe e&amined for applicability to nationalcircumstance" mission factors for each sub sectorcould be presented in one table"
in! to A,'% websiteprovided wherebac!ground info can befound
<ut this process has to be considered in chapter2<
There is a good description of the suspensionprocess in T,
,n polyurethane foam manufacturing a large part of:$ emissions is due to the use of solvents forcleaning moulds and blowing instruments"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 385/669
Accepted :ther processes added
Accepted $orrected
e7ected
ditorial
ditorial
e7ected
'oted
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
This section only concerns heatset web offset.being only one of the three groups of printingporcesses addressed in the previous section" Thisshould be clearly mentioned" The other twoprocesses should also be adressed"
newspapers are not printed in rotogravure" ention
magaHines. brochures. and catalogues
This section is dangerous and absolutely useless"The two halves of the industry (i"e" a) everything todo with publications and b) everything to do withpac!aging) are completely independent of eachotherK different techni+ues. different mar!ets.different import and e&port positions. differentsolvents etc etc" ,t is wrong to put them in thesame boat" This section must be deleted" ,t is as ofvehicle refinishing (i"e" painting) and solventconsumption in shipbuilding (i"e" also painting) are
ta!en together"
, table 8"? the line 0technoclogy>process0reads0heatset offset0" This should be publication gravure"
4audits4 could be replaced by 4solventmanagement plan4
, don0t thin! these are always 4abatement4. oftennew technology>new products are considered" ,t0sbetter produce Fs tables (non reductions) withtechnology>products and put them in section 8"8"2as in others chapters of <" , thin! the approachmust be uni+ue5
,n general. 2 other processes could be added#sheet fed and coldset offset" F and abetmentefficiencies have been defined by *" erspoor forthe revision of A,'%" $,T*A has also data onthese emissions"
%uggest using the previous simple methodlogyapproach and presenting emission factors in onetable"
Figure 8-1 seems to be copied into severaldocuments but it is not always appropriate" This issuch case where including T, 8 on chart is notof relevance"
9ecision tree andcorresponding te&tupdated
Figure 8"1. decision tree is not correct# the facilitylevel for domesticsector not available and no Tier 8for this 'F"
9ecision tree andcorresponding te&tupdated
Tier 1 default emission factors is incoherent withTier 2 as F (Tier 1) W % (Fs(Tier2)) anddifferent from old one" $hange Tier1 or removeTier 2
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 386/669
Accepted
Accepted Added
Accepted
Accepted Added
ditorial
Accepted %ection headings renamed
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
ditorial
'otedadd all subsections to the table of contents ditorial 9one
ditorial
Accepted
Althogh the two approaches presented in thealgorithm are principally applicable here. theformulation (obioviously copied in severalchapters) is not appropriatre. specifically tal!inghere about industry is not what this sector ise&actly about. it is use of products and their
characteristics (formulationNsolvent content) andthen shares in total use are of interest" *leaseadapt accordingly"
9escription updatedaccording to comments
cooling li+uid (ethylene glycol) may also contributeto emissions
This must be a missunderstanding" Chat are these0add on 0 measures that couldbe applied here. alittle incinerator in the bathroom to burn the :$sfrom the hairspray usedG Apologies for trying to befunny #-)
$orrectedK abatementindeed not applicable assuch
An important and very useful reference is missingand certainbly it could be used for improvement ofthe chapter - <,*:. 22" 4%creening study toidentify reductions in :$ emissions due to therestrictions in the :$ content of products4 -Finalreport for the uropean $ommission"
should read 42"1"2"8 :rganic solvent bornepreservatives4
Chy is 4adhesive tape4 the uni+ue sectordescribed in ,ndustrial application of adhesives"any other type of application are e&isting"
$ould it be possible to define which sectors areconsidered in ,'9P:%
eference to A,'%added for documentation
Chen it is said that 8 sectors have the sameactivity units (g product used). it is not totallye&act as we have g of glue. g of seed and gof othersL how do you deal with thesedifferencesG ive e&les"
Chy is 4use of shoes4 a source of ':$G Themanufacture of shoes is a source of ':$. butthe 4use of shoes4 is a source of *555
pdate# must bemanufacturing of shoes.not use of shoes" ovedto chapter 8"$ as well
The title should be Cood preservation and not Fat.edible and non edible oil e&traction
,n this $hapter is not considered (forgotten) glass
and mineral wool enduction
sometimes (e"g" p 1?. l 88) there is only onesubsection 8"8"1. but no 8"8"2K subsections need atleast two chapters
'ot sure about this. , don0tsee the need. but can'icola discuss with Tinus
+uations and legends# inconsistent notation. notin line with ,*A$
'icola. this was mentionedearlier so probably doneby now
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 387/669
Accepted
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one:verview too short. gives too little information Accepted :verview e&panded
Accepted :verview e&panded
Accepted 9one
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted 9one
Accepted
e7ected
Acceptedadd# for -2@ Accepted 9one
e7ected
Accepted 9one
e7ected
The chapter is difficult to read" ,t is not a reallywhole ist a summary previous chapters"Title shouldbe e&panded to livestoc! husbandry and manure"'obody would search for * emissions in manuremanagement" The structure is not suitable foragriculture" * is not really integrated and is
added only"
The structure has beenrevised and hopefully isnow much more
accessiblemaybe it would be useful to say that '2:emissions. even if part of the ' mass-flowemission cycle. are not considered here because/
it must be specified that the emissions fromgraHing animals have to be calculated but not (GG)reported under chapter 3<" ,n the general schemeof the chapters it appear they are under 39
&pand overview to give more bac!ground
informationTo avoid misunderstanding it should be pointedout. that the emission from grassing animals has tobe reported in 'F category 392c
Table 1-1 shows that ':& emission from theagricultural sector contribute by 1"? of total ':&"This indicate the important of develop a Tier 1methodology" ,s is possible to recommend a Tier 1approach based on the reference of the data givenin table 1-1G
%imple Tier 1 approachnow included
There is no mention of '/8 being produced fromurine e&cept for the comment in brac!ets on line
28" ,t woul read better for the non-ag e&pert if asentince on '/8 from urine and faeces began theparagraph
'o longer relevant as wehave revised thesesections
4a small percentage of this ' (is in the form of)urea or '/3VLLLL4
%uggest re-wording the overview" Appears as ifsome te&t was deleted and as a conse+uence itsstructure does not read well
:verview revised ande&panded
%uggest moving this comment to the bottom of thepage as a footnote
Footnotes are irritating tothe reader
The reference Darvis etal doesn0t cover pigs" Forpigs @ of ' is in urine and J of urine-' N
urea-'"
eference for pigs now
included
add '2: and $/3 to the emissions created frommanure
'o longer relevant due tore-structure of chapter
There is no abbreviation e&pansion for T%*" Thisconcerns the whole te&t" , suggest to add theglossary of all abbreviations in chapter 3<
4in particular (the) handling of manuresasLLLLL4
'o longer relevant due tore-structure of chapter
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 388/669
Accepted 9one
*rocess description is too short Accepted
Accepted An e&le of 4movements activities4G Accepted That te&t now deleted
e7ected
Accepted 9oneThe reference N an Faassen and an 9i7! Accepted 9one
%entence incorrect Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted 9one
Accepted /ave done
Accepted /ave done
Appendi& A2"2"8 GG e7ected
e7ected
9elete activity e7ected
on animalG e7ected
roenestein. $"" and /"" van Faassen. 1JJ6"olatiliHation of ammonia. nitrous o&ide and nitrico&ide in deep-litter systems for fattening pigs"Dournal of Agricultural ngineering esearch 6I#26J-2@3
*rocess descriptions now
e&panded
*rovide more information about processes (pute&tended description in an appendi&)
ore information providedon processes and clearlylin!ed with supplementarydata in Appendi&
,t is correct that only a small percent of faeces is'/3V. but the sentence needs furtherdevelopment. because most manure is managedin a combination of urine and faces (both slurryand solid waste)" The sentence need to clarify thatthe TA' content i in solid based stable systemscontains large amounts of TA' (8-I)" %o the'/8 emission is not 4sufficient small4"
This section is dealing with0fresh0 ' e&creta. socomment not releveant.but revision of chapter nowgives more e&planatoryte&t"
please change an Fassen and an 9y!e into anFaassen and an 9i7!
This entire section hasbeen revised
ist obvious that * belonges not to manuremangement
There is now a separatesection for *
9ust mainly origins from poultry and pig farms"9ust from poultry houses is mainly caused byfeathers and manure. dust in pig houses mainlycomes from feed. s!in particles. faeces andbedding (Aarnin! llen. 2@. seewww"dustconf"com)
'icola. can you pleaselocate the reference andinsert
4 e"g" at pasture or on yards. and (in) animal(housing)LL4
eplace with te&t from original final draft. whichwas structured according to pollutant
eplace with te&t from original final draft. whichwas structured according to pollutant
,ncomprehensible
commentepace 4',:$ inventory is furthercomplicatedLL"4 with 4stimates of ':$emissions are further complicatedLLL"4
That sentence has beendeleted
%ection has been re-written
%ection has been re-written
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 389/669
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted $hange made
e7ectedFigure 2-1 appears twice Accepted 9one
Authors not cited in chapter I Accepted eference now given
e7ected
e7ected9ammgen and /utchings is not in eferences Accepted eference now included
Accepted eference now included
e7ectedreferenceG Accepted eference added
Accepted /ave done
Accepted /ave done
'oted
e7ectedthe number of Figure 2-1 is double Accepted 9one
Accepted
9elete 4The4 from 4The significant emissions of*LL""4
'o longer relevant due tore-structure of chapter
4The types of feed consumed will have a ma7oraffect (on) emissions4
'o longer relevant due tore-structure of chapter
:rder of items does not seem logical. better followorder of figure 2-1
'o longer relevant due tore-structure of chapter
TA' needs proper e&planation first. unless TA' isintroduced earlierG Also mention A'
&planation now give.including A'
Add after building# and the storage system" , thin!it shoud be included here instead of in line 26
This section re-written toinclude original te&t
9elete -the storage system- and add -ventilationsystem-" The latter is very important in determiningair velocity and thus emission of ammonia
4the height and density of (the) canopy of the cropor grassland4
'o longer relevant due tore-structure of chapter
eneral# 9istuinguish between indoor and outdoorstorage li!e you did on the previous page insumming up important elements" 9istuinguishing isvery important because reduction strategies forindoor storage are totally different from outdoorstorage" ,ndoor storage is a component of thehousing system"
The figure is to illustratethe principals"
eneral# , assume the symbols for variables arescientifically correct. but it is also very confusing. ,got lost" *lease find better solution
The figure has notconfused other reviewers
$an0t find 49mmgen and /utchings. 2@) at thereference-list
the treatment of manure (i"e"# aeration. separation.composting) is not cited here neither considered inthe following
These are not ma7orsources and not e&plicitlyaccounted for in themethodology
eplace with te&t from original final draft. whichwas structured according to pollutant
eplace with te&t from original final draft. whichwas structured according to pollutant
A good idea to clarified that the ':$ is related
to the methane in manure"
:dour (of pigs) can be characterised by 2 maincomponents (putting those compounds togethercreates artificial odour)" The formulation used inthese lines suggest something else" *lease chec!"
9o not agree with thecomment. we already statethat most of the emissionis from 2 compounds
There are two figure 2"1" %ome e&planation isneeded for this figure in page @"
%ame comment as 16 and1J above
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 390/669
AcceptedFigure should be shown in 2"1 before Accepted ,f the figure remains
e7ected ay delete the figure
e7ected
e7ected
Accepted Te&t now amended
Accepted %entence clarified
eplace 4&creta4 with 4e&creta4 e7ected
Accepted 9one
Accepted $omment deleted
e7ected
%ee remar! I Accepted
e7ected2"3"3 written 2 times ditorial 9one
e7ectedadd after '# and>or TA' Accepted TA' inserted
ditorial 9one
This chapter only covers '/8" *lease e&pand onother compounds or incorporate in 2"3"1 (whichthen should become 2"8"1)
Ce have revised thissection
Figure 2-1K should consider to show a figure basedon different compounds instead of production
states"
,t is not possible 4reducing the rate oftransformation of TA' to '/34" This is incorrect"'/3 is part of TA'" ,t is possible to change thedistribution between '/8 and '/3 by altering p/"
'/3 is part of TA'. but notall of it
,f animal feed is silage. '/8 can emit" ,f not ta!eninto account as losses. please note so
replace -mainly from feed- with not only frome&creta. but also from feed. animal s!in. flees orplumage and bedding
between brac!ets# two third of the total" :f whatG
Total ':$G'o longer relevant due tore-structure of chapter
better to say also that the measures to reduceemissions are listed and e&plained in Appendi& A8
why manure drying via conveyor belts wouldreduce * emissionsG
list measures to reduce '/8 emissions (e"g"reduction of air contact. lowering of the p/ value)instead of manure management stages where '/8emissions can be reduced
'ot the purpose of theuideboo! to give detailedappraisal of abatementtechni+ues
Ce have revised thissection
'ot all '/8-emission-reducing techni+ues inhousing systems reduce odour emission (ol. "and '"C"" :gin! (23)" The effect of twoammonia emission reducing pig housing systemson odour emission" 2nd ,CA $onference on :dour :$s# easurement. egulation and $ontrolTechni+ues. %ingapore" *ublished in# Cater%cience and Technology. 23. issue 3. p"88I-83)
Ce do not state that alltechni+ues to reduce '/8emissions reduce odour"Ce state that techni+ueswith reduce either or odourcan reduce ':$"/ave changed 0can0 to0may0
$leaning the air with air scrubbers is also anabatement option (optional as <AT)
%cubbers are nowmentioned elsewhere
9elete 4way4 from 4The latter is the most effectiveway4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 391/669
Accepted
e7ected
Acceptedbefore this line insert a heading# Ammonia ditorial 9one%ection title 0Ammonia0 is missing ditorial 9one%ection title 0Ammonia0 is missing ditorial 9one
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted Te&t restored
Accepted Te&t restored
Accepted
Accepted Tier 1 approach added
ditorial
e7ected
Accepted %entence added
,n the e&pert roup of Ammonia Abatement('$) air scrubbers are considered to becategory 1 abatement options" %ome informationon effectivity in# else. "C" and '" C" " :gin!(2I)" Air %crubbing Techni+ues for Ammonia and:dor eduction at ivestoc! :perations# eview of:n-Farm esearch in the 'etherlands"Transactions of the A%A" ol" 3?(6)# 288-2818" Te&t amended to report air
scrubbers as category 1
the abatement means are theoretical but notapplicable or state of art
Ce do not suggestotherwise
9ecision tree# as! first if it is a !ey source and thenthe other +uestions (tier 8 available. %distribution available. etc")
'icola. can you pleaseamend
The dafault emission factors include emissionsfrom graHing animalsG (better to specify)
Ce now state the Fincludes graHing forruminants
, thin! it will be easier for the user to wor! with onedocument instead of loo!ing forinformation>e&planation in ,*$$ (26)
Ce provide all theinformation needed. thereference to ,*$$ is toenable access to moredetail"
estore te&t from original draft but removing thediscussion of emission factors
estore te&t from original draft but removing thediscussion of emission factors
,t could be useful to add the e&act reference to,*$$ 26" &le" , suppose it is refered to$hapter 1 section 1"2
The chapter is already inthe reference list. and wehave added the section tothe reference
eneral remar!# ': emissions from manuremangement are not presented (only an estimate issaid to be presented in the section on ammoniaemissions for losses during storage (step 1 page22 with reference to an Appendi& Table I"J whichcannot be foundK it seems to be the Table on p I@)"/owever. no ': emf is presented for manureapplication to soilGG
Average Annual *opulation or as ,*$$26 Annual Average *opulationG
/as already been ta!enout - discuss with D
,s it re+uired to distinguish between time in stableand time on grass in Tier 1G , assume that the Tier1 F for '/8 given in Table 8-1 to 8-1I onlyincludes the emission in stableG F for ':$and * - is it for 86I days in stableG
,t is stated in the te&t theF includes graHingemissions based onaverage graHing periods
$ould supply with a sentence li!e 4'o Tier 1approach is available for emission of ':&4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 392/669
Appendi& A8"1"3GG e7ected
Accepted
ditorial 9one
'oted
'oted This is 39
Accepted,nconsistent citation of references" ditorial /as already changed
'oted
9ammgen et al 2? is not in eferences Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
,ncomprehensiblecomment
A lot of misunderstanding and miscommunicationcan be caused by the definition of the activity data"9efinition of AA* is not in agreement with p" 3 lines
28-26" , do not thin! it is appropriate to deal withthis matter only with referring to ,*$$ 26 forfuller e&planation"
AA* now definedconsistently
9elete 4in tables4 from 4'etherlands. 9enmar! andermany in tablesL"4
*1 and *2"I are higher for FU (straw based)than for li+uid systems" *lease ma!e adifferentiation
%pecify in the te&t which regions is applicable theF
eferences used to proposing new Fs are notpublished and not available yet" The 'ational
,nventory eport of a single country can beconsidered a scientific referenceG
*ublished references now
provided for the Fs fromeach national inventory
*1 F values presented seem to be not in linewith values used by the 'etherlands for severalanimal categories" /owever. since the basis for thepm1 emf is rather unclear it is very hard to ma!ea good comparison" %ee below +uestions oncategories included and on the time spend in themeadow# ,t is unclear where the calves and piglets are
included" g for cattle it is unclear whether dairycattle only includes female adult dairy cows or alsoyoung (dairy) cattleG And what animal numbersshould be used if dairy cattle is a mi&ed categoryG%ince calves have a much lower emission factortheir emission will be overestimated if thepresented emf for other cattle should be used" Thesame remar! can be made for swine# in whatcategory should the piglets (weaners) be includedG(specifie! place in the te!st# page 12. line I topage 18. line 8 and page 13. line @ to page 1I. lineI)
The te&t will be correctedto 9ammgen 2@ - 'icola
,n table 8-1 to 8-13 concerning the *2"I emissionreferees to 49mmgen et al". 2?4 - this referenceis not on the reference list"
The te&t will be correctedto 9ammgen 2@ - 'icola
,n table 8-1 to 8-1I *ropose one table for eachcompounds - then it is more easy to compare theemission levels for all livestoc! categories"
Ce have restored suchtables to the te&t
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 393/669
Accepted
ditorial
ditorial
, would prefer fewer tables in the te&t Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted Te&t changed
Accepted Te&t changed
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
ditorial
The emission factors for ':$ and * aregiven in incorrect units (!g '/85)" This is valid forall tables" <oth 4a-14 and 4per AA*4 is used" Thesame nomenclation should be used all over. eg"either 4a-14 or 4per annum4
'icola. can you pleasema!e these corrections inthe tables
the unit has to be differentiated by pollutants (notalways !g'/8 a-1 per AA*)
Cill change with new
tables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
eneral remar!# ,ncorrect units used in Tables formost pollutants e&cept '/8 (all units aree&pressed as !g '/8)
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
$oncise summary tablesnow provided
emove tables to an appendi& (correcting the Fsfor * where appropriate) and replace the te&t andtables from the original draft. adding more
information about Fs
/ave replaced te&t andtables from original draft"/ave not yet placedtemplate tables into
Appendi& as we need to
agree this with T':Tables are confusing and should be presented in acondensed form"
$oncise summary tablesnow provided
the eidy et al. 2@ reference is insufficient. itdoes not contain the specified '/8 emissionfactors" *lease give more references
,t is not appropriate toinsert large numbers ofreferences in the te&t. thefull list is now given in the
Appendi&"
*lease indicate in the te&t that all animal manure issurface applied
*lease indicate in the te&t that all manure storagesare open
the tables are not the best. previous solution hadbeen better
Agree. but we need toagree with T':
The detailed tables provided even thoughnumerous are user friendly and allow the user tobe able to calculate upper and lower estimates ofemissions for each gas" ,t may be possible toincluded all the info in one large table however. itmay become too cluttered and diificult to use"There appears to be some discrepancies with thelivestoc! categories used in 3< and 39" %uggest acloser loo! at the discriptions in the emission factor
database especially for cattle sub-categories"
This is not the view of thegreat ma7ority ofrespondents. and for thefinal version we proposehaving the detailed tables
in the Appendi&emove tables to an appendi& (correcting the Fsfor * where appropriate) and replace the te&t andtables from the original draft. adding moreinformation about Fs
/ave done this" 'icola.can you please see to Fcorrections
, am afraid the units for ':$. *1.*2.I arenot +uite clear for me - for all these parameters is4!g '/8 per AA*4correctG This concerns tables8"1 to 8"1I
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 394/669
Tables# eferences inconsistent with $hapter I ditorial
ditorial
Accepted 9one
e7ected
Accepted ore references given
Accepted
$hec! units of Table 8-1 ditorialsame comment as for dairy cattle 'oted
'oted
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
change units for ':$. *1. *2"I from '/8into appropiate units
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
&plain abbreviation 4AA*4 (e&planation comes inthe ne&t section. but should be given when AA* isused for the first time)
Chy are the last two rows relevantG The sameremar!s goes for every table 8-"
$an0t change the tabletemplate
The reference publication eidy et al. 2@ ismentioned as basis for the values presented in theuidelines 2? draft for tier 1 '/8 emf (on pages12 till 1@ in Tables 8-1 till 8-1I) and for tier 2 '/8(on pages 23 till 81 in Tables 8-16 till 8-8)"
/owever. it only provides some (not all. yardvalues are not included) tier 2 data for dairy cowsand fattening pigs" ,t is unclear what is the basisfor the tier 1 emf for all animal categories (not evenfor dairy cattle and fattening pigs the chosendefaults are presented in eidy et al. 2@)" Also isit unclear what is the basis for the tier 2 emf forother animal categories than dairy cows andfattening pigs and for the tier 2 Uard emf for dairycows and fattening pigs",t is recommended to ma!e clear what the basis isfor all chosen emf (to provide information on thepublications where these data originate from)"(specifie! place in the te!st# page 12. line I to
page 1@. line 2 and page 23. line 16 to page 81.line 2)
Table 8"1 and all other" JI confidence interval isoften the same and should prefrenctially be givenas V-&&" specially to avoid upper emissionlevels above 1"
'icola. can you please seeto this
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
* is higher for FU then for li+uid systemsfattening pigs
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 395/669
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
e7ected 'ot for Tier 1$leaning period# the unit (in day) is lac!ing Accepted nit inserted
Accepted 9efinition inserted
n-places# add usually occupied Accepted 9efinition e&panded
Accepted average0 inserted
*1 F values presented seem to be not in linewith values used by the 'etherlands for severalanimal categories" /owever. since the basis for thepm1 emf is rather unclear it is very hard to ma!ea good comparison" %ee below +uestions on
categories included and on the time spend in themeadow# *m1 F values in Tables are not always clearlybased on table A8-I in appendi&# eg eg forfattening pigs. sows and laying hens in Table A8-I2 different values are presented for 2 differenthousing types. while in Table 8-? en 8-J (page 13and 1I) only one (meanG) value is presented forthe different systems"
please lower *2"I because these figures arenow higher then *1
* is higher for FU then for li+uid systems forsows
For *1 (Table 8-12) emf are provided for allmanure management systems" %ince there are bigdifferences in the two manure managementsystems cages and perchery) it is recommended toprovide emf for the two management systems"
The distinction betweencages and perchery is inthe new table
please differentiate within poultry for solid(bedding) and li+uid systems
better to add in the table also a definition of n-round N average number of production cycles peryear
mpty period# , prefer to add 4average4 durationduring the yearL"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 396/669
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
ditorial 9one
e7ected
Accepted
e7ected4present on a particular day (will)LLL""4 ditorial 9one
ditorial
The lin! to FA: *roduction Uearboo! is#http#>>faostat"fao"org>nder item atest news FA: %tatisticalUearboo!s 2I>26 (issue 1 and issue 2) are
available",ssue 1#http#>>www"fao"org>statistics>yearboo!>volP1P1>inde&"asp and ,ssue 2#http#>>www"fao"org>statistics>yearboo!>volP1P2>inde&"asp(ivestoc! numbers are available from ,ssue 1.Table AJ)"
*lease note that the yearboo! is updated on anannual basis" *roviding the http#>>faostat"fao"org> is probably the best"(Dust a thought regarding section 8"2"8 Activity9ata (line 3-6)L if a country do not carry out
annual surveys on animal numbers how would%TAT or FA: get these numbersG)
eferences included"Than!s to the reviewer
$hec! definition with earlier e&planations on p 3(line 28-26) and p" 11 (line 26)
Te&t amended to beconsistent
%ometimes the two sources of activity datainformation do not match" :%TAT informationfor european countries is updated every year andhave definitive data available" FA:%TAT importantsource. but nowadays data available only till 23year" *robably the best is to encourage at firstnational statistics and after other sources"
/ave amended wordingslightly to reflect thecomment
%ame comment# define is using Average Annualpopulation or annual average population
Are there no activity data on storage andspreading to be mentioned hereG
'o. statement made thatdefault based on surfaceapplication and openstores
The formula should be elaborated further" For mostanimal types AA* is given in the national statistis"For animals having a life cycleO 1year. the cencusin most countries thus ta!es into account emptyplaces" The formula is therefore more a correction
formula for amimals haveing a life cycle W1year"The same is valid for the subse+uent formulas"
This section has been re-written to ma!e clearer
, prefer to have the methodology to estimateanimal number>acivity data before themethodology for F
The T': chapter structuredoes not allow this
(A)nnual agricultural cenus (data) can supply (thisinformation)
%entence changed withother comments
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 397/669
4seasonal production cycle(s). LL4 e7ected
ditorial 9oneTable 8-1 (to Table 8-1I) ditorial 9oneafter the word 4rounds4 specify per year Accepted 9one
Third method seems second method e7ecteddefault data for ' e&cretion# whereG Accepted eference to table given
e7ected
Accepted
e7ected
'o information on application re+uiredG e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
rammar was alreadycorrect
4is seaonal or because the (housing) is beingcleaned4
'o. there are threemethods
The basis for a Tier 2 approach is mentioned inline 13-16" ,n these calculations itMs not e&actlyclear if a brea!down of the different livestoc!categories (cattle. pigs etc") into sub-categories(e"g" sows. piglets etc") is ta!en into account"/owever from sections 8"8"1 Algorithm V 8"8"2Technology %pecific mission Factors it appearsthat different livestoc! sub-categories are ta!eninto account" *erhaps the introduction of section
8"8 could be a bit clearer on this"
Te&t has been substantiallyrevised so comment nolonger relevant (%tep 1
onward)
For * emission is mentioned that 4For graHinganimalsL the graHing season and the daily graHingtime is needed4 <T at page J.@ is written that *emission from 4cattle. pigs ectL" are considered tobe negligible during graHing4GG
The time spent graHing isneeded in order toaccurately estimate thetime spent in the buildingwhere most emissionsta!e place" This is nowmade clear"
%uggest deleting the heading * and begin theparagraphs as follows# 4 ,n the case of *.information is re+uiredLLLLL"4
The guideboo! templatere+uires clear sub-headings
Te&t amended in responseto previous comment tostate that default based onsurface application andopen stores
activity data listed under the heading * are notonly re+uired for * emission estimates but for theother gases as well
Ues. to confirm specificre+uirements for *
emphasis only on livestoc! numbersK much moreactivity data are needed for an accurate inventoryKgive those more room in the chapter
Ues. but this is for Tier 1.the need for activity dataemphasised in Tiers 2 and8
information on manure treatment is needed.please add this to the list
anure treatment is not ama7or factor in nationalemissions
formulate stronger e"g 4Tier 2 is $:'994instead of 4proposed4
Te&t has changed and thepassage referred toremoved"
Chy is * mentioned separately. this infromationis also needed for other componentsG
Ues. to confirm specificre+uirements for *
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 398/669
section 2"1"1 where is itG ditorial
4*4 - misprint G 'oted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
%ee comment to page 1@ line 1J" Accepted
Accepted 9one
Accepted
*/ N p/ Accepted
Acceptedafter ' e&cretion# add # and TA' or A' Accepted done
Accepted 'icola is dealing with this
Accepted $hanged to m' e&cretedafter mil! add 4eggs or offspring4 Accepted 9one
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted changed to 0!g a-1 '0
Table 8-1 does not e&ist in that form ditorial
e7ected
Accepted
$hanged with earliercomment
'ot sure about this - Dplease could you ta!e aloo!
,n which way are soil */ includedGG - is this shown
in figure 2-1 (process scheme)G
eference to soil p/
deletedemove this Tier 2 description and replace withthe te&t from the original draft (i"e" Cith moree&planation and without the formating errors)
The original te&t has beenre-inserted. with someimprovements
emove this Tier 2 description and replace withthe te&t from the original draft (i"e" Cith moree&planation and without the formating errors)
9uplicate of row 18aboveG
This section has been re-written to ma!e clearer
This chapter heading can be left out" ,nstaeademphasiHe that Tier 2 is 7ust ammonia (althoughalready mentioned in line 82)"
4the types of stores in which (manure) is!eptLLL""4
$hanged with earliercomment
$hanged with earliercomment
, do not understand why you mention soil */G ;eyvariables are not shown in Figure 2-1
eference to soil p/deleted
Table 8-1. section 8"8"1 and also many times in thefollowing# the ref is wrong or lac!ing
me&creted is not a self-e&plaining symbol for totalnitrogen e&creted. it seems total matter e&creted. itwould be better to use m'e&creted. by analogy
with mTA'
,t seems to me. references to Tables 8-1 and*aragraph 8"8"1 are wrong
'icola. can you chec!table references once wefinish the te&t
, would prefer to find ,*$$ e+uations1"82.1"88right in the uideboo!.
Ce should avoid simplyrepeating ,*$$ te&t
The source of the stepwise approach should becited"
The derivation of theapproach is given insection 8"2"2"1
Treatment of units# 4!g ' a-14 means !ilogramnewton per year5
'eed to sort out the tablesin these steps
in ,*$$ organic matter is defined as olatile%olids# wy not to use the same hereG
The sentence referred tohas been superceded
it is not clear how do you use &faeces and &urine# ,suppose &urine is not the same as &slurry and &faeces is not the same as &FU" %o it is not clearhow to translate &faeces and &urine in mTA'K
This section has been re-written to ma!e clearer
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 399/669
Acceptedmfaeces# definitionG Accepted 9efined
Accepted %ame symbols now used
e7ected
Chere is table 8-8G ditorial
chec! subscripts ditorial
And how should we calculate &('faeces)G Accepted
e7ectedany references for the value of fminG Accepted eference inserted
e7ectedmbedding don0t appear in the formulasL e7ected ,t appears in + 28any references for the value of fimmG Accepted eference inserted
Chere are Tables 8-8 and I"JG ditorial
e7ected
e7ected
Appendi& Table I"JGG e7ected
Appendi& Table I"8GG e7ected9o you have a refence for "6?G Accepted eference inserted9o you have a refence for "1G Accepted eference inserted
mm (storage.org) or mm (storage. ')G Accepted
proportion of total e&creta or proportion of total ' ine&cretaG (is the assumption that 'itrogen split inthe same way as mass into faeces and urineG)
This section has been re-written to ma!e clearer
use the same symbols in the te&t and in theformulas# mTA'Pslurry is mbuildPslurry.TA'G tc"
, would prefer to see ,*$$ e+uations1"23 right inthe uideboo!
eference to e+uation nolonger made
'eed to sort out the tablesin these steps
D - there is now a missinge+uation - would you li!eme to renumber theseG
This section amended toma!e clearer
, would prefer step @ to be graHing" This manure isnot in storage
To ma!e step @ graHingwould interrupt these+uence from e&cretionthrough housing to storageand then to application"
at this point of the calculation &FU is theproportion (without bedding5) of manure e&creted.handled as FU" , believe it woul be better specifythat the proportion is in mass (!g>!g) and that it
doesn0t ta!e into account the bedding materialL
/ave chec!ed formulaeand they do account for
bedding
'eed to sort out the tablesin these steps
Table 8-8 shows Tier 1 emission factor for :ther$attle on slurry which give no relevans in the te&tdescribtion"
'icola. when re-draftingcomplete please chec!accuracy of references toTables
Table 8-8 shows Tier 1 emission factor for :ther$attle on slurry which give no relevans in the te&t
describtion"
'icola. when re-draftingcomplete please chec!accuracy of references to
Tables,ncomprehensiblecomment
,ncomprehensiblecomment
mm storage '. correctionmade
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 400/669
4 it does (however) re+uire much moreLLL"4 ditorial 9one
e7ected
e7ected
the active a&cel file is necessary55 Accepted
9oes Appendi& < e&istG e7ected
9o there e&ist an Appendi& <G e7ected
e7ectedCher is Figure 1-1G ditorial 9one
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
same remar! regarding the terrible table Accepted
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
Table 8-8 shows Tier 1 emission factor for :ther$attle on slurry which give no relevans in the te&tdescribtion"
'icola. when re-draftingcomplete please chec!accuracy of references toTables
Could a formula not normally be written as# ;g
'/8-' a-1 GG
'ot according to one of
the other reviewers,t was supplied for thereview5
,t was supplied for thereview5
,t was supplied for thereview5
The ammonia emission report unit in 'F is '/8and not '/8-'
Chich is what we havewritten5G
As the F is a percentage of TA'. there is noreason to differentiate in F yard and for graHing
between dairy cows and other cattle
The evidence we haveindicates that there is a
reason
emove tables to an appendi& and replace the te&tand tables from the original draft. adding moreinformation about Fs
/ave replaced te&t andtables from original draft"/ave not yet placedtemplate tables into
Appendi& as we need toagree this with T':
Tables are confusing and should be presented in acondensed form"
$oncise summary tablesnow provided
The concise tables havebeen restored and we
propose the templatetables go to the Appendi&
To many tables - all data could relativly simple berepresented in one or two tables without missingimportant information"
/ave replaced te&t andtables from original draft"/ave not yet placedtemplate tables into
Appendi& as we need toagree this with T':
:nly emission factors for dairy cows and othercows are included" mission factors for other cattlesub-categories are re+uired here" %ee comment 13for further issues"
The uideboo! only needsto cover the 'F codes"
%ection 8"3. Tier 8 statesthat 0if data are available.emission calculations maybe made for a greaternumber of livestoc!categories than listedunder Tier 20"
emove tables to an appendi& and replace the te&tand tables from the original draft. adding moreinformation about Fs
/ave re-inserted te&t andconcise tables
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 401/669
Accepted
ditorial
e7ected
e7ected
ditorialFigure 1-1 not presented in the document ditorial 9onesame comment as for dairy cattle e7ected And the same riposte
not 4:ther cows4 but 4other cattle4 ditorial
e7ected %ource of F now given
e7ected %ource of F givenThere is no F for outdoor sowsG Accepted F added using ; data
e7ected
e7ected
Table 8-2J - no data for 4other poultry4GG ditorial
(Table 8-2J :ther poultry) no figures are included" Accepted $orrected
e7ected
The chosen tier 2 default emf '/8 in the Tables 8-16 till 8-8 on pages 23 till 81 seem to be anaverage of the figures presented in the appendicespage 3? till I (Table A8-1 a till d)" /owever thereare some deviations# Uard emf are not available inthe appendi& Tables and a figure of "1I ispresented for broilers (one value only for the'etherlands). while in Table 8-2? a value of 1@ ispresented" Chat0s the basis for this figureG
Further footnotes nowadded to new summarytables
$hec! proper width of cells" Chy are last two rowsrelevantG
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
'ow it is '/8-' conversion despite the formulaconsists of 4storage. '/84" ,t should be changedin all formuals to 4storage. '/8-'4"
This e+uation no longer inchapter
All tables has the unit as TA'" ,t shouldpreferentially be 4 of TA'4 and no JI upperlimit
above 1
Ce thin! the meaning is
clear
All tables could be written more easily" To muchunnessary data
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
the F for yard is e&tremely high and note&plainable. so please ad7ust to I8
the F for graHing is too high. so please change
into 1
,s the manure of the laying hens consideredalways as solid manure and not slurryG
Ce do not thin! there isenough evidence todiscriminate
broilers and other poultry are mostly !ept on solidmanure systems. so here no need for F li+uidsystems
, cannot see that we havean F for broiler slurry (G)
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
(Table 8-2@) emf are provided for all manuremanagement systems" /owever. since thesefigures are based on the Appendi& tables it turnsout that only solid manure is included" %ince li+uidmanure systems (cages) still e&ist and since theiremf are different from solid manure systems. alsoli+uid manure management emf should beprovided"
'ot enough evidence todifferentiate
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 402/669
e7ected
$hec! alues and confidence interval in table Accepted
e7ectedadd a reference to Appendi& A8 Accepted 9one
e7ected
Accepted Te&t now amended
Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
after 4storage4 add 4and after field application4 Accepted
Accepted /ave done
Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
Accepted 9oneeinsert sections for the different polluntants" Accepted /ave done
add abatement measures from the house Accepted
please ma!e a differentiation into solid (bedding)and li+uid"
'ot enough evidence todifferentiate
'icola. can you please seeto this
8"8"8 Abatement# why not $ontrols as in section
2"3G Abatments seems more appropriate to end-of-pipe techni+uesL
This section is specific tothe incorporation of
abatement techni+ues inthe calculation
As it seems to me. table 1"1J of ,*$$ chapter 19efault ' e&cretion data is necessary to beincluded in the uideboo!
All inventory ma!ers surelyhave ,*$$ available aswell (and can loo! thedefault values up)
As it seems to me. paragraphs 8"8"8 and 8"8"3 arenot complited
'o techni+ue to reduce emissions in livestoc!
housesG ,n the ,F <F there is a long list of<ATs for animal houses""
The section now ma!esreference to housing
techni+ues in '$ and<F docs
The F for inside storage and outside storagediffer. mainly due to differences in temperature"oreover by removing the manure +uic!er tooutside. is an abatement techni+ue" As , do nothave the data from eidy et al. , cannot chec! thepresented F" ,f necessary , will be helpful toelaborate this in more detail"
, dont0t understand why this section is here and not
within 8"2"8
The intention was to putinformation on activity dataspecific to the Tier with
that Tier And manure applicationinserted
einsert sections for the different polluntants"emove second paragraph (not valid for allabatement measures (eg optimised feeding)
efer to ,*$$ data on manure managementsystems
Table in Appendi& givescross reference to ,*$$definitions
i!ely the choosen approach is that most of theanimal manure does not stay for a long time insidethe animal house and is stored outside"
Fair commenr. but te&talready covers this
This reviewer has the opinion that a lot ofuropean animal production systems store theirmanure inside the animal house
$ontradicts previouscomment
eferer to Appendi!s A - chapter A"8"1 for furtherinformation
eader referred to Appendi& and otherdocuments
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 403/669
Accepted done
, cannot find these notes in the TablesG Acceptedchec! subscripts ditorial 9one
Abatement deals with ammonia only e7ected
e7ected Formula no longer used
Accepted Te&t amended
Accepted *aragraph re-worded
Acceptedentioned an e&le of double counting" Accepted &le now given
Accepted $hanged as suggested
Accepted &le now given
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
also in ol and :gin! 23 (see also remar! 22) e7ected 'o need for action%(T.%) GG e7ected These terms are defined
not only housing activity data are relevante. butstorage and spreading as wellK please add these
The concise tables havethe footnotes
<ecause there is only aTier 2 method forammonia
,s the formula correctG The value calculated is myview an implied emission factor and not an F forabated techonlogy" 'Pabatement is not defined"
see remar! 18 about differentiation of inside andoutside storage
missions are not solely governed by fouled area"$hange formulationG
There is no restriction on the form of Tier 8.
provided it can supply estimates that are moreaccurate than Tie 2"
/ave re-worded to ma!ethis point"
%ame comment# for european countries the bestcross chec! is to be done with :%TATinformation" FA:%TAT statistics at this moment arenot updated"
*robably an e&le of 4manure managementsub-categories within the livestoc! categories4could be useful" :therwise. define it in Figue 8"1 orat page 1? line 2@ where this term is used"
There is also a figure for overall uncertainty in the'etherlands. using a Tier 8 approach" The 9utchuncertainty is 1@ (T':. 23)
=uoted uncertainty now
included. 'icola. can youplease find the fullreference
T':. 23" ncertainty assessment of ':&. %:2and '/8 emissions in the 'etherlands. T': report 23>1. T':. Apeldoorn
=uoted uncertainty nowincluded
,n the te&t is mentioned 4$onse+uently. there arelarge uncertainties associated with the default Ffor this source4" <t no ':& defalut value isrecommended - not even for Tier1 methodology"
Te&t reworded to refer toemission estimates. notspecific F
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 404/669
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
'otedno overview for ammoniaG Accepted 'ow added
'oted
, miss some further describtion for '/8 and ':& Accepted 'ow added
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
e7ected
'oted
Accepted /ave done
it is not clear from the previous methodology thatthe emissions from graHing animals have to bereported under 39" /ow could you do it in the caseof tier1 methodologyG ,f , understood it correctly. itis necessary to highligh somewhere else that you
ma!e the calculation under chapter 3< and toreport the results under chapter 39
This has now been made
clearer at the beginning ofthe chapter
why are these sentences reported under 4e&ternalreviewG
The statement has beendeleted
/as this been copied directly from the ,*$$guidelinesG ,t contradicts the statement p8. l 1 - Jwhere all '/8 emissions are reported undermanure management and not under soils"
The statement has beendeleted
All references should be available on the internetat A homepage
'icola. can you chec! thiswith T':
van Fassen etc should read# an Faassen. /""
and an 9i7!. /" 1J?@" anure etc ,n# /"" an dereer. "D" nwin. T"A" an 9i7! and "$" nni! etc
eference seems to havebeen removed
* definitions are not target orientatet",ts ami&ture of differnt defin" ,st to separate why in thepast other defin" Are used and which will be usedin the future" The relevant difference incomparision with gases should be e&plained",tsnice to see my figure(A1-1)but no +uotingG
Amount of science in the uideboo! is 7ust right.
but it is better to place it in one place. it isunimportant where -in the main body te&t or inappendi&
The revision now gives a
more coherent balancebetween chapter and
Appendi&
the Appendi& is toolong"The author could notdecide wether he gives information(scientific(in thebody or the appendi&"
The Appendi& is nowshorter
eneral# Chy is this information in the appendi&and other information in te&t" Chen is itbac!ground information and when notG $hoice isnot clear and seems arbitrarely" *lease e&plainprotocol or change the way information ispresented without shattering"
Ce have restored much ofthe e&planatory te&t to themain chapter and nowthin! the division betweente&t and Appendi& iscoherent"
The appendices are misplaced and should beincluded at the end of the agriculture chapter (i"e"after 3) in future drafts"
,t ma!es more sense tohave the Appendicescloser to the main te&t
A clear guideboo! definition of 4,nhalable dust4 and4espirable dust4 are needed"
9iscuss with D - put intothe chapters
Appendices will re+uire revision. since somematerial will be moved from the current appendicesbac! into the body of the te&t
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 405/669
Accepted
$aption# 4aerodynamic4 instead of 4airodynamic4 'oted
e7ected
e7ected4measured4 instead of 4made4 ditorial 9one
'oted
Accepted
e7ectedlandspreading instead of spreading Accepted done
Accepted eference now given
Accepted %entence e&panded
Appendices will re+uire revision. when commentsabove have been ta!en into account
Appendices have beenrevised
D - is this correctG ,s thisyour graph to changeG
This paragraph appears to be misplaced" %uggestre-wording
*anel $hairs are happywith te&t
why the information here are related only tograHingG
<ecause this is the Appendi& where weinclude specific additionalinformation
For cattle housing system values on pm1 F arelower for litter (Nsolid manureNFU) compared toslurry" This is in contradiction with the te&t on page33 line 8? (section *). which says that it ise&pected to find higher pm1 emissions from littercompared to slurry" This was also found comparingnglish dairy cows with litter to erman dairy cowsin cubicles (slurry)"9irectly below this alinea (page 3I line ?) this isonce more contradicted by the remar! that cubiclehouses (slurry based) give higher pm1 emissionscompared to litter based systems (depending onseveral factors)" This is in line with the presentedpm1 emf" /owever. no reference is presentedhere" Chere are the default pm1 valuespresented based on thenG,t is recommended to rewrite this te&t to present aclear line of reasoning"
,n a deep litter system * emissions can bereduced by I because the dust is incorporatedinto the bed and held there because of moist"
Activity of animals will not have an effect anymore#$,-wor!ing group 'o 18 4$limatiHationnvironmental $ontrol in Animal /ousing4" 1JJ3"
Aerial environment inanimal housing" $oncentrations in and emissionsfrom farm buildings" $,-rapport eport %eries'o"J3"1. $AF. roupement de ennes.ennes $ede&. France. 116 pp"#
/ave incorporatedcomment" 'icola. couldyou as! T': for the fullreference to $, 18.authors etc. it seems tohave got cut off in cell /3?
Chy this sentence is here and not at page 36under educe emissions during and afterlandspreadingG
<ecause this is where wediscuss management
please give the source of table A2"1. &pert roupon Ammonia Abatement
4missions following (the) spreading (of)manuresL""4
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 406/669
Accepted eference now given Asteri& and 4a>4 not e&plained Accepted 'ow e&plained
Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
Accepted 'ow added
Accepted
Accepted All countries now full te&t
Accepted
'umbers in heading not e&plained e7ected 'umbers now deleted
Accepted ade clear it is TA'
please give the source of table A2"2. &pert roupon Ammonia Abatement
it has to be specified which values are e&pressedas TA' or total '
TA'. Table headingcorrected
Table A8-1 Chere is the note e&plenationG
eferenceG
The notes are redundant
and have been deletedThe notes in the table (1.2.8 in the first row of thetable) are not e&plained
The notes are redundantand have been deleted
Table A8-1 There is no te&t ontroducing the table",n which way can this table be usedG
For '/8 as far as dairy cows and fattening pigsare considered. the figures presented in theappendices should be the same as thosepresented in the publication of eidy et al. 2@" ,n
general this seems to be the case" /owever. thereare some deviations" %ome e&les#
in Appendi& Table A8-1 b storage a figure of1J"2 is presented for dairy cows in the'etherlands. while in the eidy et al. 2@publication a value of 16"8 is presented (for bothmodels)" ,s the value of 1J"2 wrong or is it basedon another publicationG
in Appendi& Table A8-1 graHing for the'etherlands and the ; a figure of 18"8 and @"@ ispresented for dairy cows respectively. while in theeidy et al. 2@ publication a figure of 18"6 and1" is presented" in Appendi& Table A8-1 housing for the ; afigure of 88"2 is presented for fattening pigs. whilein the eidy et al. 2@ publication a figure of ispresented"Ce recommend to present and provide allreferences used"
eferences for eachnational ,nventory nowgiven in the Appendi&
se full te&t or abbreviations of countries. not both('etherlands N ' and not 'l)
the title of table A8"1 is misleading with repect tothe F. or it is of TA' either of total 'available" aybe an additional column is desirable"*lease give also the corresponding references
/eading clarified.references given
Are the emission factors e&pressed as TA' ortotal ' available"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 407/669
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
/yphenation 4Fattening pigs4 e7ected
For *1# ,t seems from table A8-I that the F for dairycattle are valid for dairy cattle with a weight of I!g" %o if there is information on the mean weight of
cattle categories a recalculation could be made"/owever. Table A8-8 and A8-I are not in line witheachother# according to Table A8-8 calves have aweight from I-1 !g. while in Table A8-I theyhave a weight of 1I!g" <eef cattle is notmentioned in Table A8-8" %ince young cattle in thisTable has a weight between 3I and 6I theycannot be compared with the beef cattle in Table
A8-I (weight of 8I !g)" ,t is unclear what transfer factor should be used"For young cattle it says in Table A8-8 "6 till 1"2K sofor the lower weight of 3I !g the lower transferfactor of "6 should be used" <ut in Table A8-I forbeef cattle with a weight of 8I !g a conversionfactor of "@ is used5 For cattle it is unclear whether in the F pm1presented the time spend in the meadow is ta!eninto accountG ,f it is. how has this been done" Andif it hasn0t how should this be doneG
The tables are nowconsistent in their use oflivestoc! weights
please change the liveweight for calves into I to8 !g
calf weight now I-1I.transfer factors scaledaccordingly
Transformation factors for poultry don0t ma!e
senseG
These factors aree&plained in the te&tabove" The uncertaintyand need for more wor!
are ac!nowledgedthis reviewer does not agree with the conversionfactor of 1" for poultry" Ta!ay et al. 1JJ? givesinformation over the conversion factors even forpoultry"
4%eedorf and /artung. unpubliched4 - cant findthis reference on the reference list"
the conversion factor for fattening pigs is here "16and in table A8"8 "12" *lease change it into "12
A lot of F values for *2"I are physicallyimpossible" 9 is measured as *I" and shouldtherefore be higher then *2"I" %o. please lowerthe *2"I values for dairy cattle. beef cattle.calves and weaners
as a conse+uence of the remar! on conversionfactor of 1". the *1 and *2"I values forlaying hens and broilers should be lower
'ot hyphenated anywhereelse
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 408/669
e7ected
Accepted 9one
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
Chat are information in Table A8-@. Table A8-J.Table A8 and Tbales on page I@ used forGG
To provide supplementaryinformation
*assive composting# for the ,*$$ e+uivalentseems more appropriate 4$omposting - passivewindrow4
Chat is reference for the values in this tableG As aeneral comment , want to add that literaturereferences are sometimes given. but not always"
Table heading now givenand referred to in te&t"
, suggest to consider including all ,*$$ referencesright in the te&t
,t should be considered to move some of the morescientific description in appendi& to the main te&t""g" e&plaining why the ':$ emission is animportant environmental issue"
/ave restored much of thete&t to the main chapter
,t is nessary to e&plain much more in detail the
difference between Tier 1 and Tier 2 in theemission factors because they are sofundamentally different" ,s '/8 in Tier 1 convertedto '/8 from '/8-'G %pend much more space one&plaining the emission factors in Tier 2 and thedifference between slurry and solid" &plain why'/8-' is used in Tier 2 compared to Tier 1"
The restoration of te&t nowgives more e&planation
,t is a big confusion between '/8-' and '/8"%ometimes is '/8 reported and sometimes is'/8-' reported" *lease clarify"
There is no confusion. Tier2 calculations have to beas '. but reporting has tobe '/8-'
The chapter on manure management is not verywell written" There is a strong need for clearreferences. a better e&planation of the comple&system with ' and ammonia" ,t loo!s li!e that thereshould be no dublicate between this guideboo!and the ,*$$ 26/owever. for clarification therecould be some tables on 'e& for typical animaltypes" %tabletype distribution from the A,'%dataset etc" to give more information on the basicsituation in many countries" And reduce thenumber of tables because they are reallyunessesary in many cases"
uch of the original te&thas been restored toimprove clarity
eneral comment" 'ational agriculture inventoryconsistency ($TA*-'F$$$)# ,s this new$:,'A, update methodology (Tier2) for manuremanagement compatible with the ,*$$ 26G
eneral# eference to Appendi& A (see Appendi& A) is not conse+uently done loo!ing atcorresponding chapters in the appendi&. pleasechec!" Also chec! table numbers
These cross referenceshave been corrected"'icola. when finished canyou double-chec!"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 409/669
nits for * are wrong not !g '/8 ditorial
ditorial
eneral# , miss Table with notations ditorial
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
eneral# eferences to tables and figures in thete&t are not correct. please chec!"
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
Cill change with newtables (what are we doingabout tablesG5
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate theemission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment" ,tis no more than astatement not appearing tore+uire an answer"
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate the
emission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment" ,tis no more than astatement not appearing to
re+uire an answer"
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate theemission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment" ,tis no more than astatement not appearing tore+uire an answer"
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate theemission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment" ,tis no more than astatement not appearing tore+uire an answer"
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate theemission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment" ,tis no more than astatement not appearing tore+uire an answer"
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate theemission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment" ,tis no more than astatement not appearing tore+uire an answer"
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate the
emission values
9on0t understand what is
meant by the comment" Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate theemission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 410/669
e7ected
e7ected
'F8 3"9"1 is not agricultural soils" ,t should be 3"9 Accepted 9one,nconsistent citation of references" Accepted 9one
e7ected
Accepted
e7ectedditorial comment not removed Accepted 9one
'oted
Accepted
,n the overview harvesting is missing Accepted /arvest mentioned in 2"1"3this appendi& is missing Accepted
missions occur from both soil and crops5 e7ected
Accepted
'oted
Add more detail about processes e7ectedadd also in the heading# for -2@ Accepted 9one
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate theemission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment" ,tis no more than astatement not appearing tore+uire an answer"
Accordning to the reporting purposes Tier 1 andTier 2 methodologies will be used" For comparisionneeds it will be necessary to recalculate theemission values
9on0t understand what ismeant by the comment" ,tis no more than astatement not appearing tore+uire an answer"
%ame remar!s in generall as given for 3"<" , amnot happy with th *
,n the absence of concretesuggestions forimprovement""
%pecify where have to be reported emissions fromgraHing animals" ,t is not clear if they have to be
calculated and reported under 3< or calculatedunder 3< but reported under 39" The same formanure application
Te&t inserted to e&plainand cross-reference
'F 39 and $F 39 codes do not include thesame source categories# Application of manure tosoil and production of animal manure in themeadow is not included in 'F 39 while it isincluded in $F 39"
$lear e&planation given inte&t
*ersistent :rganic *ollutants - what could this e"g"includeG
,n the overview emission from legumes is
mentioend" ,n the te&t separat '/8 emission fromlegumes are only included in Tier 8 approach - isthat correctG
F for legumes nowrestored
Te&t already includescrops
eference to the chapter where they are dealt withis missing"
the *1 emissions reported in the table N arein contrast with the sentence page 28 line 88"9oes the value N in the table mean that theemissions are not estimatedG
/ave changed data using
updated webdabemissions sent by AnneCagner" ':$emissions are now at 3of total so is in contrast towhat it said in the previousparagraph"
The detail is found in thete&t below
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 411/669
'oted 9one
Accepted
Accepted
Acceptede&plain the variables Accepted 'ow done
A paragraph on ': emissions is missing Accepted 'ow insertedappendi& 3. where is itG 'oted ,ncluded in this version
and soils0 should be added to title Accepted
The appendices have disappeared5 Accepted
'oted ,ncluded in this version
Accepted 'ow deleted
Accepted yes"
Acceptednothing found about *m Accepted Te&t restored$A' not e&plained Accepted ,t is now
9elete process diagram - deal with processess bypollutant not source
ood figure to give an overview. but maybe moreuseful to describe the different emission sourcesbased on each substance"
arlier te&t now restoredas appropriate
The mission section should be e&panded andstructured according to pollutant not source",nclude some of the omitted te&t from earlier drafts
arlier te&t now restoredas appropriate
'eeds much more scientific bac!groundinformation on emission of ':. ':$ and *"
arlier te&t now restoredas appropriate
'o longer relevant sectionhas changed"
*ossibly no longer
relevantG A paragraph on * emissions from soil cultivationis missing
%uggest removing the sentence 4The effects of fsfrom grasslandLL4
'/8 emission from growing crops are mentionedin section 2"2"8" Are this '/8 emission short afterapllication of fertiliser included in therecommended Tier 2 emission factorsG
This reviewer does not understand why a doubleF for grassland is needed in comparison witharable land" There are also arguments that the Ffor arable land is higher due to for instance theabsence of a canopy" *lease give moree&planation"
ore e&planation nowgiven in te&t
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 412/669
'oted
e7ected
Tier 1 method for unfertilised legumes is missing Accepted
e7ected 'ot Tier 1
Accepted Te&t amendedThe 8 in '/8 should be subscripted Accepted 9one
Accepted
e7ected
'ew Yealand in which losses from urea applied tograssland and arable land were compared" Thepaper of /arrison and Cebb (21) is a reviewpaper" /owever. they only refer to the paper of ander Ceerden and Darvis (1JJ@)" Thus. thedifference in the emission factor betweengrassland and arable land is based on only study"
<y contrast. in a review <ouwman et al" (22) of13? research papers it was concluded that themean '/8 emission from grassland is 2 lowerthan for upland crops (the balanced medianshowed almost no difference)" This paper was notused for the guideboo!"Thus. there is no firm scientific basis to usedifferent emission factors for grasslands andarable land" The grassland area in urope is highand therefore the underpinning of higher emissionfactors for grassland must be scientifically sound"oreover. from a theoretical point of view (i"e" theeffect of crop on wind speed and thereby on '/8emission) it may be e&pected that there are arablecropping systems with lower emissions (i"e" when' fertiliHer is applied to high crops or when 'fertiliHer is incorporated) and higher emissions (i"e"when ' fertiliHer is applied to the bare soil 7ust afterplanting or seeding)"
why the fs of the different fertiliHers which wherereported in the old $:,'A, handboo! are notused hereG The consumption of the differentfertiliHers is normally available at a national level.so a better estimate is possible
Tier 1 agreed with *anel$hairs
The F for legumes now inthe te&t
9eafault values in the body of the te&t and detailedtables according to the needs as an appendi&"
According to FA consumption for 26>. urea isthe third most used. after $A' and A'
se chemical notation not words (e"g" forammonia)
%ection has been re-written but instances ofwords rather than chemicalnotation
The unit for ':$ is defined as !g ':$>!g
crop - is it !g harvest cropGG The e+uation (page 6.line @-?) is mentioned use of crop area (haGG)
eference now made to
the Appendi& where moreinformation is provided"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 413/669
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
e7ected
A default emf of 2"I@ !g ': per !g fertiliHer-'applied is presented (reference %teinbrecher et al.2?)" ,t seems the wrong unit is used here" ,f2"I@ is meant (N 2I"@ g>!g fertiliHer ') it is not
clear how this could be in line with the value of "@ ':-' (e+uals "J ':>!g fertiliHer N J g ':>!gfertiliHer) presented by %tehfest and <ouwman(26) and until now also presented in theuideboo!"The value of "@ is the fertiliHer induced emf. but inthe former uideboo! also for cultures withoutdirect fertiliHer (but with crop residues and indirectemissions as a conse+uence of ammonia-'deposition and '-leaching from fertiliHer use) thisvalue is recommended to be used"
Chy is this value presented with 2 decimal placesKthis seems unrealistic concerning the high
uncertainty for ': measurements"
'icola.please change in
template to 2"6eneral remar! on '/8# Appendices A1-A3 arenot included. so information on assumptions is notavailable"
Appendices are now in thechapter
ore specific on '/8 (Table 8-1) Tier 1 values are no longer
presented for other fertiliHer types than urea" Forcountries where urea is not commonly used asfertiliHer and where not enough data are availableto use the tier 2 method also tier 1 emf for the
different types of fertiliHer should be available" ,nthe former guideboo! also tier 1 emf werepresented for other fertiliHer types (pJ table 3"1 ofthe uideboo!)" ,t is recommended present tier 1emf for the different types of fertiliHer" This couldbe the former emission factors or new tier 1 emfderived for different fertiliHer types from the tier 2values"
,n the past the urea emf was "1I '/8-'(e+uals "1? '/8 per !g fertiliHer ' applied)"<ased on the current proposed tier 2 method forurea emf the mean value would be "28 (mean oflowest and highest values for all regions and forgrass and arable land# ("11 V "8I)>2)" For region< it should be " 21 (("13 V "2?)>2)# Chat0s thebasis for "22G
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 414/669
'oted
Accepted
e7ected
'oted'o e+uation for Tier 2 methodologyG Accepted +uation now restored
'oted done
:n basis of table 8-1 in the proposed uidelines itis unclear whether the proposed *1 emissionfactor should only be applied to arable land or alsoto grassland (at the presentation in 9ublin also hayma!ing was mentionedK this seems to refer tograssland) and whether the application of fertiliHer
and pesticide use is included" ,t is recommendedto ma!e this clear"The basis for the presented T%*. pm1 and pm2.Iemf (Table 8-1) should be the reference publicationd /oe! and /inH (2@)" /owever. this basiscannot be found there#
'o basis at all presented for T%* and pm2.Iemf
For pm1 emf the basis is unclear" From Table8 in the eference publication it seems that forpm1 the highest value (eg 3"I6 !g pm1>ha foroat with no reduction applied of for redeposition ofpm1 on the field) is pic!ed to be used as a defaultfor pm1 (3"I in Table 8-1)" /owever. this is not
clearly e&plained and some +uestions rise if this isthe case#-Chy is the average value of "2I (for soilcultivation) in eference Table 8 (and discussed inthe te&t on page 1?) not in line with the figures onsoil cultivation presented in Table 2G /ere evenwith wet soil conditions the total pm1 emf for soilcultivation is I.2 !g>ha" That0s a factor 2 higher5-Chy is no correction term applied for rapid nearsource depositionG-Chy are the harvesting emf in Table 8 lower(between 2" and 8"3 !g pm1>ha) compared tothe values presented in the te&t on p 1? (lowestvalue 8"8K highest 6"J)"
-Chat0s the basis for the values for cleaning anddrying in Table 8
The reference publication (vd /oe! /inH. 2@)mentioned is not easily attainableK , had toapproach one of the authors to get it" :n basis ofthe reference it seems hay ma!ing is not included"FertiliHer use seems to be included. but it is notclear" *esticide use is not included" ,t isrecommended to ma!e the references available"
A revision of the guideboo! should include thenewest !nowledge and lead to more accurateinventory" , was surprised that the '/8 Tier1methodology is simpler than given in the oldguideboo! and the emission factor is only basedon use of urea"
+uations and legends# inconsistent notation. notin line with ,*A$
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 415/669
e7ected
'oted
Accepted
'oted
limiting fertiliHer to urea only is a step bac!wards Accepted 'ew Tier 1 F developed
Acceptednit for particulates should be !g ha-1 a-1" Accepted 9one
Accepted
e7ectedTier 2 e+uation is missing Accepted 9one
,n tables 8-1 to 8-13 emission factors for '/8 arepresented for the different fertiliHer types" ,tsuggested that these emission factors are allderived from /arrison Cebb (21) and an derCeerden and Darvis (1JJ@)" /owever. the+uantification of the effects of temperature and p/on the emission factors is not found in thesepapers",n the review paper of <ouwman et al" (22)effects of crop type. fertiliHer type. applicationmode. ' application rate. temperature. p/. andother soil properties on '/8 emission arestatistically assessed" This paper maybe avaluable source for the guideboo!"eference# <ouwman et al" (22) stimation ofglobal '/8 volatiliHation loss from syntheticfertiliHers and animal manure applied to arablelands and grasslands" lobal <iogeochemical
$ycles 16"*lease indicate clearly in the te&t that the '/8emission N 1@>13 S F"
The ': emission is 2"I@ !g ': per !g fertiliHer 'applied" This means that more ' is lost than the 'input by the fertiliHer" This is +uite impossiblebecause about I of the ' fertiliHer is ta!en upby the crop
The F should be g>!g -'icola. can you pleaseamend in the templatetable"
,t is necessary to e&plain in the te&t how the F forT%*. *1 and *2"I are derived" ,f necessarythe reviewer will assist"
, do not agree with the use of the urea F as thedefault F" The previous approach in the simpemethodology in the old uideboo! should bemaintained" ven though the use of urea accordingto world fertiliser consumption statistics is currentlyappro& I of total ' consumed. it does notwarrant its use as the default" any counties useurea only in the spring when weather conditionsare wet and cold and therefore emissions are low"sing urea as a default in such circumstances
would lead to a gross over estimation of emissionlevels"
at which depth the soil temperature has to bemeasuredG
Te&t amended to ma!eclear it is air temperature
ore e&planation on how to use and apply newproposed F is needed as done also in tier2 3<"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 416/669
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
e7ected
Acceptedabatement without note with * concern Accepted Te&t restored
Activity without concern of *. area treated. yields e7ected
section 2"1"1 where is itG Accepted
e7ected
e7ectedsoil ' content# where is it usedG Accepted 'ow deleted
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Tier 2 emissions should be calculated using theactual spring temperature" eplace e+uatoin andthe original compact version of e+uationparameters" &le emission factor tables couldbe put into an appendi&
:riginal compact tablenow restored
,t is a bit confusing with so many tables showingthe emission factor for Tier 2 - mineral fertiliser" ,s itpossible to reduce the number of tablesG ,nsteadof a table for each fertiliser type. it could be chosento show a table from each temperature region A. <or $ (t O18 $. TN6-18 $ or t W 6 $)"
Tables are confusing and should be presented in acondensed form"
$oncise tables have beenrestored"
$ontrolling emissions has already been covered onp 3 and I
Ues. but this e&plains howaccount may be ta!en incalculating emissions
sing A' instead of urea may reduce The ':emission" 9efinition of A'GG
Abbreviation now definedat first point of mention
Te&t changed. no longerrelevant
This section has beenadded
The sentence on e&pert 7udgement is not related toconsisten time series. maybe more to ncertainty
,n this specific case e&pert 7udgement may be neededfor a consistent time series
,t is not necessary a specific chapter 3"I"1. put thesentence under line 21
This is the agreed format
for each uideboo!chapter
,s the mentioned uncertainty range (V-I) for allsubstances e&ept from ':$G The uncertaintyrange for ': and * emission is properly muchhigherG
To e&plain the differences between the defaultvalue and tha national value. a robust bacgroundinformation and documentation for the defaultvalue is needed" :therwise you do not support and
promote the meber states to use national values"
9on0t understand the point
that is being madeis the temperature. which is necessary for tier 2.the air or the soil temperatureG
Air temperature nowspecified in the te&t
,FA - please write the name of the organisation(maybe in chapter I 4lossary4)" Are data from thisorganisation available for all member states forfreeGG
'ow given in full in thereference list
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 417/669
Accepted
$itation inconsistent (e"g" 4and4) Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted 'ot Tier 1
Accepted
'oted
'oted 'ot Tier 1'o guidelines availableG e7ected 'o page reference given
e7ected 'o page reference given
,nconsistent citation of references" Accepted
The reference list include a lot of references whichis not mentioned in the main te&t" , prosume thislist include the references from the appendices5
The references have nowbeen sorted following thevarious revisions of thete&t"
$itations were consistentin that two authors used
4and4 and more than oneauthor was bloggs et al
For ': the reference %tehfest and <ouwman(26) is included in the references (howevermisspelled as %tefest and <owman). but notmentioned in the te&t"
%pelling in reference listcorrected and relevant te&trestored
issing Appendi& A5 There are lin!s to this acouple of places" ,tMs hard to 7udge references toactivity data when the appendi& is missing"
9eafault values in the body of the te&t and detailedtables according to the needs as an appendi&"
<y reading of the draft , really missed theappendices - especially because the main te&tdoes not content many references or scientifice&planations" At my point of view more specificscientific description and e&planation is needed inthe main chapter" ,t is very important to !now thescientific documentation for the default value"Theguideboo! should not only be useful to calculatethe emission inventory.but also a guideline to findmore scientific information to chec! the conditionsare comparable with the conditions in the member
states and to encourage member states tocontinue the wor! to develop more accurateinventory with national data"
That each answer ma& can be 2II characters isvery frustrating
9eafault values in the body of the te&t and detailedtables according to the needs as an appendi&"
,t is rather strange to find an 'F 392 here(animal production) since this source is notincluded in 'F39 but in 'F3<
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 418/669
'oted A is not defined Accepted 9one
Accepted
F for '/8 missing from table Accepted
A source published in 1JJ1 is inade+uate" Accepted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
Accepted
To my !nowledge is there no -regulation on agr"waste burning. only national legislation" Thisshould be verfied" The te&t indicate that it is veryeasy to burn agr" crop residues and waste in9enmar!" This is not the case" <urning of plant
residue has been prohibited i 9enmar! since 1JJand may only ta!es place in connection withcontinuos cultivation of seed grass"
Ce !now. the ob7ect was
to point out that undersome circumstancesburning may ta!e place
$ouldnMt the lin! to FA: *roduction Uearboo!(FA:. 1JJ1) be updatedG
Ues. up-to-date referencegiven
D - should there be any fsfor '/8 in this chapterG
Ues. up-to-date referencegiven
Table 8-1" There should not be different units in atable. ie"!g> !g dry matter and !g> tonne" ,t will giveerrors in the reporting
The comment specificallyrefers to agriculturalactivity data. so referenceto forest fires is irrelevant
Table 8-1" There are errors in the data" enerallycontains crop residues (straw) .8 ' or e+v" to1"2 ':& after burning if all ' is emitted as ':&"Tier 1 indicates that 23 is ':& or that at lot ofinert '2 is conveted to ':&"
<ecause they are notneeded for the calculation
,f default '>$ ratios are given in the ,*$$guidelines why aren0t they included in table 8"2
which have the same originGTier 2 does not appear to provide the basis ofbetter estimates than Tier 1" emove Tier 2
9efault data is not ta!en from ,*$$ 26 but from,*$$ * 2
D - have changed this intrac! changes. is this thecorrect referenceG
The source data is ta!en from ,*$$ guideboo!.* 2 and not from ,*$$ 26" $rop>cropresidues has been changed very much from *2 to ,*$$ 26" %ee Table 11"2 i the new
guidelines for data" * 2 is not appropriatefor uropean conditions"The authors of these'$$-guidelines should read %trehler and%ttHle" The paper is about utilisable biomass andnot field burning and based primarily on conditionsin the praerie in the %"The figure should be usedvith caution especially under uropean conditionswhere there is other crop>crop residue ratios due tohigh fertilisation rates"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 419/669
'otedChere is nitrogen mentionedG 'oted
%ouce in not in the table Accepted
'oted
ditorial
ditorial
Table 8"2 is dublicated e7ected
'oted
'oted
Accepted,ncorrect %'A* Accepted
'oted
'oted
Three years average should not be used if wewant to model the emissions in short time spans"%hould then forest fires be averaged over threeyears tooG Averaging is not in line with the new,*$$ guidelines
Tables should be combined" :mit superfluousinformation"
The value is app" the same as for Tier 1. but now itis in g>D not in !g>!g dry matter" %ee my commentpage 3 line 1"
$hanged bac! to !g>!g drymatter
Three different nits are used for the same source(wheat straw)" This is also true for the other tables
$hanged bac! to !g>!g drymatter
, can0t see what thisperson is tal!ing about
Chy should Tier 8 be aggregated at a sub-nationalscale to fine grid scale if the data>model issuperior" ,t is a direct copy from ,*$$$ 26 andmaybe not valid for '$ conditions"
The chapter was based onthe information available
eneral# The chapter gives an impression of lac!of agricultural !nowledge and is more or less acopy and paste of the ,*$$ guidelines
'o. , sourced the datafrom 26
The mentioned cases in the te&t are seldom. and itis very difficult to burn rotten straw. so theimportance is very limited"
y mista!e. in convertingfrom . these F are all&1 too big" $an youplease reduce
This statement is indeed very surpising given thatmany pesticices are considered as *:*s (whereagriculture use is the only source)" *lease properlye&plain *:*s in the conte&t of this chapter
'F category include %'A* 16 4se ofpesticides and limestone4 - but in the te&t4overview4 is mentioned that this sector ia a 4catchall4 for the agricultural sector" %o this 'F categorycovers more than %'A* 16" ,n the 9anishinventory this sector covers sewage sludge. whichare used as fertiliser and applied on agricultural
soils"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 420/669
'oted
'otedThe chapter is incomplete" 'oted
Accepted 9oneadd 4. '/84 after 4$:4 Accepted 9one
Accepted 9onesubstitute 4very minor4 with 4minor4 Accepted 9oneadd 4. '/84 after 4$:4 Accepted 9one
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrectedtoo less e&planation. only reference to / 'oted
For use of pesticides no method is provided" 'ewmethods are available in the 'etherlands and the which could be refered to# 'ie (22). indenet all (26). and inden et all (2?K in
preperation)
'ie 9% de (eds). 22missie-evaluatie D*- 2K Achtergronden enbere!eningen van emissies vangewasbeschermingsmiddelenQ missions of plant protection products to theenvironment" valuation of the policy goals of theong-term $rop *rotection *lan R, apport @16613
inden AA van der. <eelen * van. <erg A vanden. <oer de. aag 9D van der. roenwold D.
/ui7smans DF. ;alf 9F. ;ool %A de. ;rui7ne .er!elbach $. %noo de. i7ftigschild A'.i7ver . Cal AD van dervaluatie duurHame gewasbescherming 26#milieuQidterm evaluation of the plant protection policy ofthe 'etherlandsK environment R, rapport 6@161
,n preperatationinden AA van der. roenwold D. ;rui7ne .utti! . er!elbach $9utch nvironmental ,ndicator for plant protectionproducts. version 2
,nput. calculation and aggregation procedures, eport 6@62>2?
$hapter should be supplemented# now in containsheadings. one table without F. one literaturesource"
Add# 4Also * emissions from waste handling aregenerated but no estimate of emission factors isavailable"4
Add# 4Also * emissions from waste handling aregenerated but no estimate of emission factors is
available"4
An incomplete and une&plained algorithm is givenfor emissions from pulp and paper onlyG
why process emissions from pulp and paper in thisconnection G
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 421/669
Accepted 9one
Accepted 9one
'oted
Accepted Added to references
Accepted
'oted
The chapter is incomplete" %ee e&les below 'oted
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
substitute 4missions are considered to benegligible in most cases"4 Cith 4%mall +uantity of':$ and nitrate compounds are emitted" For':$ % *A evaluate that J?.@ of landfillgas is methane and 1.8 other :$s such asperchloroethylene. pentane buthane. etc" (*A.
1JJ)" Also * emissions from waste handling aregenerated but no estimate of emission factors isavailable"4
change position of '/8. T%*. *1 and *2.I in4not estimated4 section
no emission factors estimated or applicable" 'oteven for ':$ and $: """, miss some support"
':$ estimated nowfrom ; inventory
% *A (1JJ). Air missions %pecies anual.olume ,K olatile :rganic $ompounds %peciesprofiles. %econd dition. *A-3I2-J-1a.nited %tates nvironmental *rotection Agency.
:ffice of Air =uality *lanning and %tandards.Danuary 1JJ
An estimate of ':$ emissions from landfillswas made using an emission factor of "1 t':$> t methane produced which is e+uivalentto I"6Ig ':$> m8 landfill gas (; inventory.23)"
F used as Tier 1 defaultF
F should be defined depending on the !ind ofwaste deposited
$hapter should be supplemented# now it contains2 tables. including one table with one emissionfactor (for '/8) and list of eferences with 2sources"
$onsult with&pert *anel
$hapter discussed inmeeting with $, &pert*anel eader" atrinesmoved to Tier 2" Tier 1 Ffor ':$ estimatedfrom one of the suggestedpapers"
An aspect of importance not described in thischapter is the importance of industrial effluents tothe sewer system and i"e"contribution to thecentralised CCT*s and i"e" ':$ emissions"
':$ from CCT*mentioned
':$ emissions may occur during sewagecollection and are very dependent upon treatment
processes at different stages at the CCT*s (seerefs row28-8I))
%ome te&t about this issuehas been added
The chapter states that it focusses on biologicaltreatment plants. however. the te&t deals in nodetail with biological processes anddephosphoriHation is a chemical process
Te&t ta!en from former<K adapted to fit better inrevised chapter
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 422/669
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
Accepted
'oted
The chapter states that 0':$ and '/8 is ofminor and only of local importance0 as compared tolandfills where these emission are referred to as0emitted in smal +uantities0"
From the ,nventory of "%" reenhouse asmissions. however. it may be observed that theemission of ':$ from wastwater treatmentprocesses are a factor two of the estimatedemisions from landfillsK ranging from I@ to 6? g>yrin 1JJ and 21"
,nformation on ':$addedK see othercomments
The te&t on latrines(http#>>reports"eea"europa"eu>*$:,'A,3>en><J1@vs2"1"pdf) are overpresented compared tosection 2"1 considering the relevance of the twoactivities
change position of '/8. and ':$ in 4notestimated4 section
rase '/8 F and related information and changeposition of '/8 and ':$ in 4not estimated4section
9one following discussions
with $, *" A Tier 1 for':$ has also beenderived
, don0t thin! the similarity of latrines with animalswas correct and then latrines are not e+ual to4waste water treatment plants4" %ubstitute 4Thedefault emission factor for ammonia from wastewater handling is provided in Table 8-1" ,t is e+ualto the estimated emission factor for ammonia fromlatrines. which has been determined from thesimilarity between latrines and open storage ofanimal manure in lagoons or ponds (uideboo!.26)"4 with 4Also '/8 and ':$ emissionsfrom waste water handling are generated but noestimate of emission factors is available"4
9one following discussionswith $, *" A Tier 1 for':$ has also beenderived
Air emissions of *:*s as well as ':$s. $:and ammonia are occurring eventhough maybe atinsignificant levels. still not very well investigated"/owever some scientific studies do adress suchemissions"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
&les from the scientific literature documentingsuch emissions of aromatic and halogenatedcompounds from urban CCT*s are %ree et al.
2
%ome info added tochapterK see earlier
comments
:s!ouie.A";". ordi. 9"T". ranato. T"$" and;ollia. " (2?)" *lant-specific correlations topredict the total :$ emissions from wastewatertreatment plants"Atmospheric nvironment. ,n*ress. $orrected *roof. Available online 18February 2?"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 423/669
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
<aillod. $". $rittenden. D"$". ihelic. ". ogers.T"'". rady. $"*"". 1JJ" $ritical evaluation of thestate of technologies for predicting the transportand fate of to&ic compounds in wastewaterfacilities" C*$F research Foundation *ro7ect J-1"
$AAA" "%" *A. 1JJ"
%ome info added tochapterK see earlier
comments$orsi. "". $ard. T"". 1JJ1" stimation of :$emissions using the <aste model" nvironmental*rogress 1 (3). 2J"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
9obbs. "A". Cang. ". ovind. ". 1J?J" %orptionof to&ic organic compounds on wastewater solids#correlation with fundamental properties"nvironmental %cience and Technology 28 (J).1J2"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
aster et al"" :dor and air emissions control usingbiotechnology for both collection and wastewatertreatment systems" $hemical ngineering Dournal.
olume 118. ,ssues 2-8. 2 :ctober 2I. *agesJ8-13
%ome info added to
chapterK see earliercomments
scalasa et al" Time and space patterns of volatileorganic compounds in a sewage treatmentplant"Cater esearch 8@ (28) 8J18-8J2
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
,n urban areas. :$ emissions from CCT*s maybe a significant fraction of the total hydrocarbonemissions
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
whereas the corresponding ':$ emissionsfrom whole Austria were reported as I (2I t
yr) of the total anthropogenic ':$ emissions"
%ome info added tochapterK see earlier
comments
more focus should be given to rban wastewatertreatment plants and separate industrialwastewater treatment plants"(see references ascommnt to list of reference below. page 6 line ?)
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
According to the ,**$ guidelines such releasesinto the domestic sewer system should be includedin the 0Caste water treatment inresidential>commercial sectors0"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
Air emissions of ':$ prevails in pre-treatmentand primary clarifiers. whereas biodegradation andsorption compete in aerobic biological reactors"""
Air emission prevails in secondary clarifiers (e"g"scalas et al" 28. Cater esearch 8@. 8J18]8J2)"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 424/669
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted $orrected
ost plants have highly techological developedprimary. secodary and tertiary treatment processesincluding mechanical. chemical. biologicalanaerocic and aerobic processes and emissionmay occur at several stages of treatment"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
eference for inspiration# *" Tata. D" Citherspoonand $" ue-/ing. ditors. :$ missions fromCastewater Treatment *lants# $haracteriHation.$ontrol and $ompliance. ewis *ublishers. <ocaaton. %A (28) ,%<' 1-I66@6-?2-J. p" 31I
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
<:9 characterisation . which is the main sourcefor ':$ emission. is totally missing in analogyto the missing precess descriptions which arepotential for ':$ emissions as well as *:*s"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
eference for statements in row 26 to 2?# Atasoyet al" (23)"The estimation of ':$ emissionsfrom an urban-scale wastewater treatment plant"Cater esearch.olume 8?. 826I-82@3
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
latrines are not relevant at all for many uropeancountries
'/$ or non-methane :$ may occur forcontrolled as well as uncontrolled aerationprocesses"
%ree. ". <auer. /". Fuerhac!er. ". llinger. ".%chmidt. /" and *u&baum. /" (2)"
/ydrocarbons missions From Aunicipalwastewater Treatment *ilot *lant ,nienna" Cater. Air. %oil *olution. 123. 1@@-1?6
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
%chmid. /". <auer. /". llinger. ". Fuerhac!er.". %ree. " and *u&baum. /" (21)" missionsof ':. T:$. $:2. and aerosols from a pilot-scale wastewater treatment plant with intermittentaeration Atmospheric nvironment. 8I. 16J@-1@2"
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
Cua. <"-Y". Fenga. T"-Y". %reea.". $hiuc. ;"-/"and oa. D"-" (26)" %ampling and analysis ofvolatile organics emitted from wastewater
treatment plant and drain system of an industrialscience par!" Analytica $himica Acta . I@6. 1-111
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
For e&le. ':$ contribution from CCT*s inienna. as an urban area. was estimated to bearound @"I of the total anthropogenic ':$emissions L
%ome info added tochapterK see earliercomments
lossary. A production - the A for the limeproductionG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 425/669
Acceptedrror of table 8-J Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
Figure 2-1# scheme is too simplified" e7ected
Accepted 9one
Tables 8-1] 8-6# /$< and *$< emission factorsare the same (in spite of the abatement)K ':&. $:and %:& F are not harmoniHed. as well as T%*"For e&le# T%* F in the Table 8-1 (Tier 1) isthe same with F in the tables 8-3. 8-I and 8-6
(Tier 2. different abatement. including <AT)"
$onsult with
&pert *anel
9ifferences in abatementKliterature references arenot complete" This causesdifferences" /ow else to
deal with thisGGG
Table 8-1" According to the '* Tool!it *$99>FF value of .I2I mg for the high controle+uipment efficiency
$onsult with&pert *anel
Table 8-2" *$$9>F F is 3 mg ,-T=>g waste"There is no contrudictions in values of these twotablesG
$onsult with&pert *anel
Abetment factors are derived from *A notcontrolled>controlled Fs" These abetments cannotbe used for Table 8-6 Fs. related to <ATtechnologies " Also dio&ins abatement table is notpresent in the te&t and is related to unabated Fdifferent from Table 8-6 one" *lease introduceunabated Fs or all the pollutants or erase theentire chapter5
$orrectedK abatementfactors only applicable to*A factors in Tables 8-2and 8-85
Table 3-1" ,t is correct *$99>F emission factor unit- mg>'m8G
Are emissions from flared landfil gas (the part ofthe gas not used for energy purposes) missingG'orway reports these emissions under 6$
$onsult with&pert *anel
,ndustrial waste is e&tremely heterogenous groupwith very different levels of emissions from theircombustion" <ut in the chapter industrial wasteconsidered without differentiation even at Tier 2level" $hapter should be supplemented"
$onsult with&pert *anel
'o new info available.therefore addition of moreTier 2 methods could notbe done" ,ssue has beendiscussed with $, *"
$hange 4uch of the information on pollutantemissions has been reported as emissionconcentrations rather than emission factors" Thesehave been converted using a specific flue gasvolume of I m8 at 11 :2 per tonne of waste"4 with 4mission factors for heavy metals are
assumed to be the same as for clinical wasteincineration"4
Table 8-1# F for T%* and * seem very lowK Ffor *b. /g and Yn are higher than F for T%*"
$onsult with&pert *anel
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 426/669
'oted
Table 3-1# *$99>F emission factor ] error in units" Accepted $orrected
Figure 2-1# scheme is too simplified" e7ected
e7ected
': TA< G e7ected
Table 3-1# *$99>F emission factor ] error in units" Accepted $orrected
'oted
Table 8-1# emission factors need to be updated 'oted
Accepted
9ata are from Table ?"2"2 of old < and areassumed to be the same as for clinical wasteincineration se the same Fs of Tier 1 in Table8"1 eplace the chapter with 4Technology specificemission factors are not available for this sourcecategory" 4
$onsult with&pert *anel
Table 8-2 (ncontrolled)# *$99>F. /$<. *$< and*A/ emission factors are the same as in the Table8-1 (Tier 1 ] typical situation) but T%* and /emission factors are more high" F for *$99>F ]need to be updated ('* $hemicals%tandartiHed Tool!it. 2I might be for instanceused)"
$onsult with&pert *anel
Table 8-8# T%* and * emission factors seem tobe overestimated"
Tables 8-1. 8-2 should be updated. for instanceF for *$99>F from the '* $hemicals%tandartiHed Tool!it (2I)"
Tables 8-1 (Tier 1) and 8-2 (Tier 2) were notharmoniHed# F for *$99>F. /$<. *$< and *A/compounds are the same while F for T%* and/ are more high in Tier 2" ,f Tier 2 factors are thesame as Tier 1 what are the reasons to include inthe chapter choice of methods procedureG
$onsult with&pert *anel
Tables 8-3 ] 8-16 which are shown as Tier 8 tablescan be hardly considered as Tier 8# they are out-ofdate (main reference - *A 1JJI) and do notprovide emission factors for complete list ofinstallations and types of wastes"
$onsult with&pert *anel
There are still only default emission factors forpriority metals" 'o emission factors for othermetals are included"
Caste incineration could potentionally be a largeemission source of the other metals thereforeguidance on these metals should be included"
$onsult with&pert *anel
,t should be possible to provide some roughguidance on the particle siHe distribution. so that*1 and *2"I can be estimated"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 427/669
'oted
Accepted $orrected
Accepted $orrected
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
e7ected
Accepted 9one
'oted
'oted'o emission factors for *. / and *:*s" 'oted
$hapter should be supplemented# it include only:pen burning of agricultural wastes. while othertypes of open burning are also important source ofemission especially *:*s"
in! to more detailedmethods of A*32 inserted
Tables 8-1] 8-1# error in unit for *1" mission
factors for *$99>F need to be updated"Table 8-3# title of the table do not coincide with thecontent (:rchard crops ] in the titleK eaf <urning
] in the table)"
$hapter should be supplemented# now there are 3tables with one F for '/8" 'o references"
Figure 2-1# *rocess scheme consists of one bo&and three arrows and do not provide anyinformation about the processes"
$onsult with&pert *anel
Table 8-1 (Tier 1) and Table 8-8 include the same'/8 F for compost production"
Table 8-2 (Tier 1) and Table 8-3 (Tier 2) include the
same '/8 F for sludge spreading"lots of F seem to be missing. for e&" ':$ ortotal *A/
original references should be named (notuideboo! 26)
9ata are the same as Tier 1" eplace the chapterwith 4Technology specific emission factors are notavailable for this source category" 4
Are emissions from car and house fires missingG%ee FP$omments
Are emissions from tobacco missingG %ee
FP$omments
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 428/669
Comments
,nlude /$< and other *:*s
$overed by ne&t comment
The contractors and indeed many of the individuals inthe pro7ect team have many years e&perience insupport of inventories and combustion emissions" ,fthis is an unsupported comment it is neither
constructive nor factual"
The factors represent a wide range of technologies.for most pollutants there will be varying degrees ofabatement and in some instances the factors couldrepresent unabated emission" ,n terms of an emissioninventory the !ey issue is whether they can representa national emission" At Tier 1 and Tier 2 inclusion offactors for specific abatement technologies isachievable but would re+uire many tables and isconsidered inappropriate"
'ote that 1<2a"iv covers fugitive releases fromrefining. venting and flaring from oil-refining are 1<2c d respectively"
Te&t and indeed emission factors from the previouschapter could be included as an appendi& butincluding the whole chapter is not appropriate" Cherethe e&pert panel feels that more te&t would be helpfulthen , propose to as! them to determine what shouldbe included (as an appendi&)"
, accept that more detail can be provided but it isintended as general information only - we can go intodetail but there is information elsewhere such as the$* <F"
Firetube boilers more typically at siHes lower than 2Cth"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 429/669
te&t in prentheses modified to state 0mainly relevant tosolid and li+uid fuels0" aseous fuels can containnitrogen compounds but natural gas contains nitrogenas '2 other nitrogen compounds are only present attrace levels (compared to biomass. coal and fuel oil)"
%ome emission factors are high but whether they are alarge emitter depends on overall technology mi&" Thissection is about formation of 'o& in general ratherthan for different technologies)"
As ta!en from the previous guideboo!" *lease notecommentary elsewhere on mercury in gas"
The te&t was in the original guideboo! but may havebeen contrary to the guideboo! F which was omittedin compilation" uideboo! factor has been restored"
uch of the detail in the current chapter is not relevantto someone preparing a national inventory" The <Fprovides relevant data"
As stated in the introduction to 8"8 details are in the<F" ,nclusion of %:2. ':B but not * is notconsistent but it reflects the original guideboo! where* controls were considered. as commented. withheavy metals controls"
Abatement efficiencies are indicative only - efficienciesare dependent on a range of factors and emissionreductions. particulary for retrofit applications. are veryvariable"
eneric te&t. note that it is not 7ust about emissiondataK more detailed approaches may also need toaddress fuel use"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 430/669
uropean *$99>F data G
uideboo! factor missed. also data in Ap-32"
Ues. 0all0 is unli!ely and there will always be new datato consider"
Ues. 0all0 is unli!ely and there will always be new datato consider"
The technology used will differ for each country andwill change over time" A representative factor for allusers is not achievable. these factors provide a first orsecond level estimating tool for the sector"
Ues. 0all0 is unli!ely and there will always be new datato consider"
'ote this also applies to 0other li+uid fuels0 which
includes refinery gas - these are 'A*Fclassifications"
An oversight. technology identified but failed to includetable
Ce accept that combustion emissions can depend oncombustion unit siHe but. there has to be a degree ofsimplification otherwise the number of tables becomesunmanageable"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 431/669
As!ed for uropean-based data"
9ry and wet bottom boiler classifications are as usedin current guideboo! but it is recognised that these arenot the only technology distinctions
Abatement efficiencies are dependent on a range offactors and reductions. particulary for retrofit
applications are very variable"
These dsitinctions are not in current guideboo! but arein A*-32 and are reasonable distinctions for unabatedplant (with downfiring as a potential additionaltechnology)" /owever. these technologies are lessrelevant for new and abated plant"
The factors do not represent a specific level ofemission control. where countries have !nowledge ofabatement levels then this !nowledge should be usedto develop appropriate country-specific emissionfactors"
%ome inconsistencies - incorrect mapping of somefactors in database G
%ome inconsistencies - incorrect mapping of somefactors in database G
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 432/669
%ee previous comment
,t was not the intent
/ave ta!en out this table
,s this correctG
Chere Tier 2 and Tier 1 defaults are the same then wedon0t have data to provide a Tier 2 factor and haveincluded Tier 1
Chere there no data to provide a Tier 2 factor. wehave included Tier 1 data
The wor! by $oncawe is referenced and tables havebeen revisited to incorporate relevant data
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 433/669
see other comments on $oncawe data
,s this right - perhaps one for Dustin>Tinus
'ote that $oncawe references are generally to%*A
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 434/669
see other related comments
see other related comments
The terminology used is not ideal but combustion unitwould not be appropriate either (it could be used todescribe engines. gas turbines. conceivably flares)"%uggest process furnace may be more appropriate"
,n general this is correct but there are significantranges which indicate that some abatement measuresare present"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 435/669
see other related comments
see other related comments
Ce accept that the emission is dependent on fuelcomposition but combustion and lubricants are alsorelevant" Ce also accept that %*A :$ figure alsoe&cludes ethane however. in the absence of otherdata. it provides a reasonable value for nm:$" Analternative would be to apply the the %*A T:$figure" At least one member state applies an emissionlimit for formaldehyde but inventory is about totalnm:$ not individual components"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 436/669
see other related comments
'ot sure what table this refers to but tables revised
Title modified but. we have no data for other activities
The completeness or othewise of facility emissionreporting is a !ey issue but is not uni+ue to refineries"Further guidance is provided in cross-cutting chapters"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 437/669
%ee row I@
see above
$an the e&pert panel provide any further input on co!emanufacture outside iron steel plant or othermanufactured solid fuel processes
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 438/669
$alculated with reference to %*A ethod 1J
Add a footnote G
, thin! this may be a timing issue. F:9 may have beencompleted shortly before document finalised
Chere the references are for A*32. the dates refer tothe chapter dates rather than the current edition"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 439/669
9one
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 440/669
%ee earlier notes re engines
'ot at Tier 1 but is needed at Tier 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 441/669
'ot clear what this comment is about
2<
Ues (for combustion)
%ee 188
'ote that emission is not generally associated withcombustion processes in 1A2 and may be assigned tothe process emission
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 442/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 443/669
Chere we have broadly similar fuels we have providedthe same emission factors rather than provide nofactors
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 444/669
see above
see above
Actually table revised
%ee 16J
Ues. this is correct but the Tier 1 and Tier 2 defaultfactors are for application to a wide range oftechnologies with aggregated activity data" Thecompe&ity of individual furnace fuel mi& is more
consistent with a Tier 8 approach"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 445/669
These are assigned through 'F 2 emission guidance
%ee earlier
The table titles were incorrect. these factors are forheating>reheating
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 446/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 447/669
Ues. this would be impossible"
missions should not be included in 1A1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 448/669
se tier 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 449/669
/owever note that for cement the Tier 2 tables willinclude all emissions e&cept *
'ot possible according to editorial re+uirements"/owever such data can be found in <F documents
*etco!e is a fuel but by no means the ma7or fuel in allcountries
,n general *$99>F emissions are not increased byuse of waste in cement !ilns (if applying <AT)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 450/669
,n the absence of facility-specific data or specific fuelsthen use Tier 1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 451/669
Ues. other li+uid fuel includes gas oil
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 452/669
metals should be assigned to process"
At Tier 1 we have brought together by main fuelclassifications
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 453/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 454/669
Te&t and tables now modified to reflect discussion with* leader
%uggest applying same factors as for coal in cement!ilns
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 455/669
see above
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 456/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 457/669
update
include especially the last suggestion
re7ected
could be improved
There are some errors# e"g" we should divideemissions by T: and $ruise not by ta!e off andlandingK it could be improved
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 458/669
,n my view default F should refer only to ,F flight
see the comment above (row 8?)
see the comment above (row 8?)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 459/669
see the comment above (row 8?)
, agree with the comment" ,n Tier 2 it is not sufficientclear how to estimate cruise emissions (domestic andinternational)# the suggested methodology could bereported with a complete e&le (ta!ing in accountan average domestic and international distance for
the country)",n my view data needed for the Tier 2 aren of flight by type of aircraft and bydomestic>internationalK total fuel consumption (ifpossible domestic and international separately)Kaverage national distances for domestic andinternational flights" %o the first step should be toestimate T: fuel consumption for domestic andinternational. and cruise fc for domestic on the basis oftables 8"11. 8"12 and 8"1I" ,nternational cruise fuelconsumption should be calculated anyway bydifference with the total F$ in the energy balance"%tep 8 probably is the first step. step 3 the second oneand step 1 and step 2 are a results of the method" ,n
my !nowledge no countries have information n fuelconsumption distinguished by domestic andinternationalK also Tier 8 methodologies. as *agodamodel by :$:'T:. estimated the fuelconsumption on the basis of the distance of the flightsbecause F$ on single trip are not collected because ofconfidentiality"
, disagree with the comment in generalK if the ,*$$26 guidelines report new emission factors beforenot available in my view they should be used
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 460/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 461/669
,t is correct. emission from military mobile. includingaviation. are reported in 1AI< with e&ception for thosereferring to multilateral operation that shoul bereported in memo items
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 462/669
,t could be useful to describe the Tier 2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 463/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 464/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 465/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 466/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 467/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 468/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 469/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 470/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 471/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 472/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 473/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 474/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 475/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 476/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 477/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 478/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 479/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 480/669
9one
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 481/669
+uation is correct as it is
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 482/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 483/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 484/669
will clarify
will clarify
will chec! and clarify units need correcting
will chec! and clarify units need correctingwill clarify
Cill be clarified
will correct
will correct
will correct
'eed to add Fs where appropriate'eed to add Fs where appropriate
will chec! and clarify units need correcting and lin!ing
to F tables"will chec! and clarify units need correcting and lin!ingto F tables"
will chec! and clarify units need correcting and lin!ingto F tables"
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 485/669
nits will be added"
Cill clarify
Cill clarifyCill add
Cill clarifyCill clarify
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 486/669
Cill clarifyCill add
Cill add
Cill add
Cill clarify
Cill review
Cill update
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
Cill be redrafted to fit with uideboo! and referencemade to ,*$$ 26
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 487/669
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill incorporate where appropriate
$an0t find any later data on ship fleet ma!e up"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 488/669
clarified
Cill include originals
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
'eed clarifying
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill clarify reference
Cill clarify reference
Cill clarify reference
Cill clarify reference
Cill include reference
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 489/669
Cill clarify reference
Cill clarify reference
Cill clarify reference
Cill clarify
Cill clarify
Cill clarify
Cill clarify
Cill clarify reference
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 490/669
Cill revise
Cill revise
Cill revise
Cill incorporate where appropriate
will be deleted
Cill incorporate where appropriate
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 491/669
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 492/669
Cill incorporate
Cill incorporate
Cill clarify reference
Cill incorporate where appropriate
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 493/669
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Cill incorporate where appropriate
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 494/669
Cill incorporate where appropriate
Tables will be revised and clarified
eferences will be added
will incorporate
Cill be clarified
Cill be clarified
Cill be clarified
Cill be clarified
Cill incorporate where appropriate to the tiermethodology or reference given to detailed datasets"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 495/669
As applied to 1A3a>c
9iagram is generic
%ome removal of detail. no additional $/* detail
Agreed at :verview and Table 1-1. subse+uent usemodified to align with 'F terminology
Accepted but. tried to retain much of the original te&t(<216) as it has only recently been revised" Thetechnologies are not all 'F sector specific"
'ot sure these comments are being held together that, can follow the references made"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 496/669
/$< emissions very uncertain
These technology descriptions are largely ta!en fromthe e&isting chapter
accepted however waterheaters are also deviceswhich heat water 5 u* ecodesign ots 1 and 2 aredistinguishable on this basis"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 497/669
Tier 1 is based on fuel not technology
several coments here. tables reviewed
The factors for some of these activities are highlyuncertain. this is partly due to the movement away
from technology to fuel categories but also reflectsvariability in source data"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 498/669
%ome more obvious splitting included"
Additional data in appendi&
many tables have been revisedj
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 499/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 500/669
To be improved
To be revised
Ciniwarter reference
$an we do as a &-reference
The factors were in the appendi& of <216 of the26>@ guideboo!" ,f they can help a countryelaborate the emissions better and the country hasresources to do this. then why not use them G
The <T test reports are type-approval tests for use in Austria and other countries"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 501/669
<AT figures G
GG
1A2 G
will clarify
Cill include summary table of limits
will clarify
These are described in 2"2"
This is a fair point but we have tried to avoid applyingdifferent siHes as the number of tables will becomeunmanageable for the guidance"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 502/669
Table labelling is miss leading and will be corrected"
Cill be clarified in a footnote
will clarify
will clarify
Cill add
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill elaborate
Cill update
Table will be revised
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 503/669
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 504/669
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
Cill update
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 505/669
Ce0ll follow the reporting template on this issue"
Ce0ll follow the reporting template on this issue"
Ce0ll follow the reporting template on this issue"
elates to Tier 8 methodology comment
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 506/669
Ce don0t have any information for thisL consult with*
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 507/669
'ot true" as distribution must be in this chapter"
'ot sure what is meant here"
'ot sure what is meant here"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 508/669
For full reference see later comment
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 509/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 510/669
%till to do if there is time
, suppose this comment is applicable to chapter1"<"2"a"vi" eference added thereinK not here since itis not referred to
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 511/669
These values could indeed be useful for theuideboo!. but we don0t have them and cannot findeasily"
These values could indeed be useful for theuideboo!. but we don0t have them and cannot findeasily"
These values could indeed be useful for theuideboo!. but we don0t have them and cannot findeasily"
These values could indeed be useful for the
uideboo!. but we don0t have them and cannot findeasily"
These values could indeed be useful for theuideboo!. but we don0t have them and cannot findeasily"
'ot sure" Cere listed under II1 in formeruideboo!
These values could indeed be useful for theuideboo!. but we don0t have them and cannot findeasily"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 512/669
A reference for thisLG
This chapter has been drafted in close cooperationwith $oncawe"
&planation is not too late - this is the section foractivity data"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 513/669
9on0t !now what this is applicable to
ChyG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 514/669
Tier 1 Tier 2 must be as complete as possible
$annot find te&t at indicated location" Furthermore.this te&t has been added by $oncawe themselves"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 515/669
Chat table is this comment aboutG
,n this chapter5 Chat is the +uestion hereG
Ce thin! that this is probably not the ma7ority" Andsince we cannot split we chose to report these in thecombustion chapter
mission e&pected in reporting template from sourcecategory 1"A"2"f"i. therefore emission factor in thatchapter (either factor itself or a 'ot stimated)" Cill becorrected in final draft
* is in process chapter (2"A"1). emission factors ofall other pollutants are in 1"A"2" 9escription describescomplete cement production process. since we wantto be complete in this respect"
9on0t !now what is meant by 4misunderstood4" ,n
which wayG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 516/669
Tier 2 Fs from $$A now inserted
$$A data now inserted as Tier 2
'o idea why this should be removed" , don0t see anyreason to do so"
'ot stimated > 'ot Applicable are filled using thereporting template" There is ':& and %:& fromprocess. but it has not been estimated here andincluded in the combustion %:& in chapter 1"A"2"f"i"
Ce thin! most /s from cement are from the fuelsrather than the raw meal and therefore they are
accounted for in 1A2" verything is emitted togetherfrom the !iln (process combustion). but we have toma!e a split somewhere"
'eeded for electronic emission factor database. Fsnot the same anymore in Final 9raft
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 517/669
,ndication ,"" will not be presented anymore in thefinal draft
*robably also a significant contribution is from thefuels" The +uestion is which one is the mostsignificant. since a split is not possible" Ce thin! thema7ority is from combustion"
Ammonia emissions treated in combustion chapter1A2fi (according to reporting template)K should not bea 'A
These are accounted for in the combustion chapter. asindicated" %ee chapter 1"A"2"
Ce anticipate that dust is mainly from the processesand /s are mainly from the fuel combustion" $ouldbe updated. but only if /s are in ma7ority from theprocess (which we do not thin! is true)"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 518/669
$hapter mainly important for /s. as indicated
rror made when copying value - will be correctedChyG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 519/669
To be added
ust be chapter 8"$. not 1"A"2"f"i (, thin! this is also
the point made in the comment. although ,0m notsureG)
ood suggestion. unfortunately , could not easily finda conversion factor"
9ecision tree updated to include product use besidesproduction" 9on0t !now what else to change"
9ates bac! to 1JJI while old uideboo! uses 1JJ3" All Fs the same. so , thin! this is not newer"
9ates bac! to 1JJI while old uideboo! uses 1JJ3" All Fs the same. so , thin! this is not newer"
9ates bac! to 1JJI while old uideboo! uses 1JJ3" All Fs the same. so , thin! this is not newer"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 520/669
This issue has been identified as a problem from thebeginning of the pro7ect" 'eeds to be discussed. ,thin!5
Table 8-2 does not e&ist" $omment not applicablehere"
Ce have to stic! to the 'F structure. which does notidentify glass as a separate source category"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 521/669
%ource N &pert 7udgement
Ce don0t have any better information" ,f provided. wewould li!e to include this"
Ce don0t have any better information" ,f provided. wewould li!e to include this"
Ce don0t have any better information" ,f provided. wewould li!e to include this"
Ce don0t have any better information" ,f provided. wewould li!e to include this"
':$ Fs from combustion and treated in chapter1"A"2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 522/669
All consistent tables will be produced for the final draft
True. but no figures available to +uantify this
Could be a nice report to use in a ne&t version. butsince not published yet it will be difficult to incorporatethis now" any emission factors have been revisedfollowing other comments however"
,0m not sure what is meant# %ince all references havea year. , thin! the person commenting refers to whichyear the Fs are valid for" :ur Tier 2 Fs do in
principle not have a reference year. because they aretechnology-based"Ce don0t use a class ,-,,, for /s in the uideboo!"
True. but if these more accurate Fs are not availablethey cannot be used"
*robably this is indeed not correct. but unfortunatlycomplete information is not available from literature"Ce have to deal with what we have"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 523/669
no suggestion for
%'A* 3622 is &plosives manufacturing
$omplete information is not available from literature"Ce have to deal with what we have"
%entence needs to be added to the preceding sectionsaying that all tables have been made complete byadding Tier 1 Fs where Tier 2 Fs for that specifictechnology were not available
The 3I1 and 3I2 were separate chapters inold guideboo!. but indeed referring tot the samenaftacrac!ing process - this is mentioned in the te&talso "" =uestion on the e&pert panel to combine theboth %'A*% to one paragraphG
686 is on pharmaceutical products. action as!edfrom tas! force on %'A*
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 524/669
%uggested is <AT associated emission levels"
<F ,$ AAF 2@# The tail gas compositiondepends on the applied process conditions" Table 8"8gives an overview of tail gas properties "" sed 2 -3 'm8 > ton and 2 - 3 mg>'m8 "" esults in62 - 18"2 g > ton - uideboo! values# 1" withlower upper I and 1I
Adipic acid production is relevant for emissions ofgreenhouse gasses ('2:). but not consideredsignificant or a !ey source for other air emissionsincluded in the protocols"
The source is indeed Table @"1 in <F ,$ %A:4mission sources and data on typical dust emissionsfrom the Austrian plant at different process stages 4- because we need a Tier 1 we made a aggregated Ffrom the different pprocess stages
The uideboo! has to give Tier 1 F0s for all 'F0sLincluding this one" This table therefore includes Tier 1emission factors for the 'F :ther chemical industry.generated with urostat and * data ] shoud beused with care. and is a very rough estimate5 ""
The uideboo! has to give Tier 1 F0s for all 'F0sLincluding this one" This table therefore includes Tier 1emission factors for the 'F :ther chemical industry.generated with urostat and * data ] shoud beused with care. and is a very rough estimate5 ""
There is already a separate <AT reference in thechapter on <AT for Ammonia
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 525/669
%'A* paragraph on %ilicium production removed
the both processes. steam reforming and partialo&idation are controlled processes
This seems a left over from the former version of theuideboo! "" Cill be corrected. we now assume alower value of 2
This seems a left over from the former version of theuideboo! "" Cill be correctedit is actually the other way round. I refers to %plantswe will use a value in the range for the uropeanplants - I
see comment on T, 1 F comment "" 'ot a !eysource
T%* and '/8# compiled new F0s from the differentunit operations listed in *A32. considering also newdevelopments in ta!ing upper and lower limits
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 526/669
please provide us with a suitable F
'ote#sed the *A A*32 (1JJ6) reference instead . samevalues old chapter <338 guideboo! states# A specificmethodology for these activities has not beenprepared because the contribution to total nationalemissions is thought to be currently insignificant. i"e"less than 1 of national emissions of any pollutant(26)reference to# $: from conomopoulos -O not clear5
old chapter <338 guideboo! states# A specificmethodology for these activities has not beenprepared because the contribution to total nationalemissions is thought to be currently insignificant. i"e"less than 1 of national emissions of any pollutant(26)
Ce received a T, 1 F from %* - chlorine-Tier 1 (not in F:9) we will use
mercury cell# compiled an F from the currentemission levels cell room ventilation "1@ - 1"J8.proces e&haust "1 - 1" g . $austic soda after thedecomposer# "J - "I and storage# 2"6 -O 8# (1 to6). these correspond with the %* value. whichis included in the revision
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 527/669
Chere to find this listG
<F :$# %uitablefeedstoc!s for olefins production range from lightgases (e"g" ethane and *s) to the refinery
li+uid products (naphtha. gas-oil)" /eavier feedstoc!sgenerally give a higher proportion of coproducts(propylene. butadiene. benHene) and need larger >more comple& plants" A large proportion of uropeMspropylene demand (and all of the butadiene demand)can besatisfied by the steam crac!ing of naphtha and gas-oil"The balance of propylene demand isessentially supplied from e&traction of propylene fromrefinery Fluidised $atalytic $rac!er offgasand imports" There is one *9/ (propanedehydrogenation) plant in urope. but it is onlyeconomic when propane prices are low" A similarprocess for butadiene production (by the
dehydrogenation of n-butane) is also available but isnot used in urope where there is generallya surplus of butadiene from steam crac!ing"
$orrect. use the F0s from the <F. Table @"Isummarises the principle pollutants and their sources.together with the range of emission levels met in mosturopean crac!ers"
liminated the other table for proylene "" Ce do note&pect however that the F of "6 underestimates theemissions "" ost uropean plants are having loweremissions
,nformation from the <F :$ were thylene is an
illustrative process
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 528/669
%uggested is <AT associated emission andconsumption levels" $urrent emissions are#<F *olymers. Table 8"J# mission and consumptiondata of 9* plants#9* uropean Average (benchmar! 1JJJ average)23 g>t:$ to air emissions in grams per tonne of product(g>t)" :$ includes all hydrocarbon and other organiccompounds including fugitive emissions " Ce willinclude this information in the <AT chapter
%uggested is <AT associated emission andconsumption levels" $urrent emissions are#
<F *olymers. Table 8"11# mission andconsumption data of /9* plants/9* uropean Average (benchmar! 1JJJ average)28 g>t:$ to air emissions in grams per tonne of product(g>t)" :$ includes all hydrocarbon and other organiccompounds including fugitive emissions" Ce willinclude this information in the <AT chapter
%uggested is <AT associated emission levels" There isalso an split view on <AT which resuts in higher <ATvalues" Ce will include this information in the <ATchapter
%uggested is <AT associated emission levels" There is
also an split view on <AT which resuts in higher <ATvalues" Ce will include this information in the <ATchapter
<F states that ?Ig>t is only for the topIfacilities ""uropean average is 12 g>t "" F willtherefore not be adapted. reference will be made to
the <F (Table 3"12# mission and consumptiondata per tonne of product of /,*% plants) in stead ofuideboo! 26
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 529/669
what information to use thenG
<F states that ?Ig>t is only for the topIfacilities ""uropean average is 12 g>t "" F willtherefore not be adapted. reference will be made tothe <F (Table 3"1# mission and consumptiondata per tonne of product from **% plants) in steadof uideboo! 26
" For more information see also the <F documenton arge olume :rganic $hemicals where theproduction of acrylonitrile is described as one of theillustrative processes
These should indeed be consistent "" *ropose to adaptthe approach on neglible emissions with productioncomparde to product use
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 530/669
pla!!en in e&cel
%uggested is <AT associated emission andconsumption levels" $urrent emissions are#
<F *olymers. Table 8"J# mission and consumptiondata of 9* plants#9* uropean Average (benchmar! 1JJJ average)23 g>t:$ to air emissions in grams per tonne of product(g>t)" :$ includes all hydrocarbon and other organiccompounds including fugitive emissions " Ce willinclude this information in the <AT chapter
<F states that ?Ig>t is only for the topIfacilities ""uropean average is 12 g>t "" F willtherefore not be adapted. reference will be made tothe <F (Table 3"1# mission and consumptiondata per tonne of product from **% plants) in stead
of uideboo! 26new table in <AT chapter. referring to table Table @"8#mission and consumption data from %< plants(per tonne of product)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 531/669
what units are most suitableG
%entence on this to be added
%entence on this to be added
A Tier 1 is re+uired for every 'F" ,t may be usefulhowever to stress in the te&t that the Tier 1 can only be
used for an ,ntegrated ,ron and %teel facility with allthe subfacilities on site"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 532/669
$omment not understoodK suggested to list all Fs ing>!g or in another unitG
$omment not understoodK suggested to list all Fs ing>!g or in another unitG
$omment not understoodK suggested to list all Fs ing>!g or in another unitG
Tier system here a bit different# iron>steel industryseperated in 8# sinter>pellets. pig iron and steel for Tier2" 9ifferent technologies identified within each ofthese" *roblem with inconsistent values appearsbecause of different references" Try to avoid this asmuch as possible. but will not be completeunavoidable5
$omment not understoodK suggested to list all Fs ing>!g or in another unitG
$omment not understoodK suggested to list all Fs ing>!g or in another unitG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 533/669
ChyG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 534/669
%* data to be chec!ed
%* data to be chec!ed
a7ority is still combustion. , suppose" %ince we havealways put ':&>%:&>$:>etc" in combustion whencombustion and process must be separated. , thin! it0s
better to !eep this approach here as well"
%plit has been agreed with &pert *anel" %ome of thepollutants are process- and combustion-related andit0s not possible to split" A choice must be made where
to allocate these emissions. which has been done"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 535/669
'ot anymore
nfortunately <F does not provide generic factorsfor Tier 1. only for different ferroalloys andsubprocesses within the ferroalloy production"Furthermore. the overview in the <F is notcomplete" Therefore difficult to use in the uideboo!and not included"
Also not included in Tier 2 because of non-completeness. but references made"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 536/669
'F does not distinguish *rimary>%econdary. so atTier 1 level we cannot separate them
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 537/669
*rimary and secondary copper production are process
with contact. therefore we should treat these similarlyto cement and lime production"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 538/669
%hould be in combustion cahpter 1"A"2"f"i"
%ame as for copper production# process with contact
$omment is true. but not too much can be done at thisstage" Fs from different references have beencombined and this causes inconsistencies (mostobvious between * and /s)" /owever we cannot
7ust simply scale down the * with /. that is toosimple" , thin! however that this is an issue that needsfurther discussion in the future"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 539/669
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes this
problem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$omment refers to wrong chapter" $orrection made inHinc chapter (2"$"I"d)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 540/669
%ame as for copper production# process with contact
'o more data available5
oo! at this issue (same as in copper>lead)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 541/669
$/$; %* 9ATA
$hec! for Yn FK other comments noted
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
$ombining information from different references andcompleting Tier 2 tables with typical Fs causes thisproblem" There is no simple way to solve this however"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 542/669
%hould be in combustion cahpter 1"A"2"f"i"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 543/669
'o info on this available"
Fuel combustion in 1A2 as indicated multiple times inchapter
Ce use the reporting template as the master to chec!
whether emission are e&pected or not"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 544/669
'o info on this available"
$hapter needs to be discussed" Chere to collect allthis informationG,f no information is found. , suggest to move allrelevant pollutants to ' and delete the emissionfactors. since they0re all wrong5
$hapter needs to be discussed" Chere to collect all
this informationG,f no new information is found. , propose to delete allobviously wrong Fs and move to '
, do not !now where this should be allocated. discusswith *
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 545/669
$hec! this and add some te&t to ma!e this clear"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 546/669
ention this somewhere in the descriptionG These canbe considered technology-specific in a way
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 547/669
:nly 'F is considered here. not %'A*
alues correct according to T,
alues correct according to T,
%hould be paint used. not paint produced" pdatenecessary5
Chat to use if T, and>or A,'% data cannot beusedG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 548/669
9iscuss with *. conversion factor difficult to find
Cill be added" %hould this be in chapter 8"AG
$hec! if default value is available in T, documentto recalculate in terms of mass of paint
Ce have considered this. but then we get hugenumbers of tables (O1) which will ma!e the
document practically non-readable
Table does not provide Fs. only abatementefficiencies" Tier 2 Fs will be revised (g>!g paint)"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 549/669
*erhaps we can add some wording on this in Tier 8
*erhaps we can add some wording on this in Tier 8
This is not in &ecutive %ummary of <F document(where the other te&t is ta!en from)" $annot find"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 550/669
$annot be Tier 1 since the old factors are technologyspecificK these new factors have been derived incontact with industrial representatives
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 551/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 552/669
ust be chec!ed. what is meant hereG
%ource needs discussion with *
This is too vague" eference needed for changingnumbers"
/ow to deal with thisG 9iffers significantly from presentvalue and unreferenced. so left out"
%ource needs discussion" Chat is meant hereG Fsindeed seem too high. but no other informationavailable5G
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 553/669
F to be added to chapter
*ublished in 1J?2. outdatedG
$annot find proper Fs in A*32
9on0t !now what te&t this comment is applicable to
9on0t !now what te&t this comment is applicable to
9on0t !now what te&t this comment is applicable to
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 554/669
*rinting is one 'F. therefore a Tier 1 F is necessary
Table structure cannot be changed at this stage
This has been considered. but would generate manytables with all 7ust one F and therefore e&pand thedocument +uite heavily"
*roblem is that references are different" /ow to solvethisG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 555/669
*roduct masses can be added to obtain some !ind ofgeneric F
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 556/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 557/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 558/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 559/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 560/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 561/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 562/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 563/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 564/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 565/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 566/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 567/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 568/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 569/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 570/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 571/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 572/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 573/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 574/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 575/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 576/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 577/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 578/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 579/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 580/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 581/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 582/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 583/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 584/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 585/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 586/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 587/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 588/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 589/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 590/669
missions mentioned in the te&t should be in the tableas well (as ' in this case since no numbers areavailable)
'o idea what the point is hereK we would be happyeven with a Tier 15
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 591/669
This solution loo!s +uite o! to me
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 592/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 593/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 594/669
ust be ng ,-T=>'m8
/ow to define differentiation and where to find FsG
Chat more can be saidG ,t0s 7ust burning of wasteL
Tier 1 represents averaged factors. Tier 2 tables arebasically uncontrolled factors (reduction efficiency tobe applied when abatement is in place)" 9iscuss ifalso Tier 1 should be unabated"
This is the uncontrolled one" ,n Tier 2. abatementefficiencies should be applied when in operation. whilein Tier 1 there is an 4averaged4 factor (alreadyaccounting for an average abatement)
A sentence will be added to ma!e clear that theabatement efficiencies are to be applied to the %*A factors onlyK the type 1>2>8 factors already havetheir abatement in there
To be discussedK , don0t !now how to ta!e this intoaccount
*roblem# T%* from <F while / Fs from former< (values are much older and therefore higher)":bviously / Fs should be updated. but where tofind FsG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 595/669
9iscuss with &pert *anel5
ust be ng ,-T=>'m8
Chat more can be saidG ,t0s 7ust burning of wasteL
$omment not understood
$onsult *# should we remove this or leave it inG
ust be ng ,-T=>'m8
9iscuss if factors are availableK where to find
'o indication given on where to find this information"
This again raises the +uestion how to deal with Tier 2in this chapter
F for *$99>F from '* already usedK if moreupdates necessary then please specify which ones toupdate and where to find Fs5
&tra information in Tier 2 available is only theunabated-abated FsK Tier 2 uses unabated factorswhere available (you can use abatement efficiencieswhere applicable) while Tier 1 ma!es a best estimatewhen no better info is available
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 596/669
nit will be corrected"
Table to be corrected
There is no original reference for this factor
,f Fs are provided. we are happy to include them5
emove schemeG ,t does not provide information.because a variety of process may occur within thissource category" eft in for now"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 597/669
Chapter_Name NF_Code Pollutant
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 %:& 83J"J 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 ':$ 1 2"8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 As "12I "3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 $d "2I "121 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 $r "62I "1I1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 $u "2I "121 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 /g "2I 1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 'i "?@I 1"8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 *b "82I "361 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 Yn "2I "3J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-13 *1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-1I %:& "2I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-1I $: 1I 8J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-1I ':$ 1 2"6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-1I *1 "2 "?J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-1I T%* "2 "?J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 8-1I *2"I "2 "?J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 <3 ':& @I 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 <3 ':& 3
Chapter _ID
Ta!leNum!er
PresentValue
ProposedValue
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 598/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1 <3 ':& 16
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 %:& 83J"J 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 $: 8 1I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 ':$ 1 "?3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 $d "1 "121 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 $r "1 "1I1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 $u "1 "12
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 *b "I "36
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 Yn "I "3J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 *1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 %:& 8 21 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 ':$ 1"8 "6I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 As "2 "1?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 $d "1 "13
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 $r "1 "13
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 $u "8 "2@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 /g "1 "13
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 'i "1 "13
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 *b "3 "31
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 Yn "2 "1?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 *1 2 8"2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 599/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-I %:& 2 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-I $: 8I 16
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-I ':$ 1"? 1"I1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-I As "8 "81 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-I $d "1 "11 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-I $r "J "J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 %:& 1 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 $: @I 8J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 ':$ 2 2"6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 As "8 "83
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 $d "1 "@1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 $r "8 "2@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 $u "2 "22
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 /g "1 J-I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 'i "3 "86
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 *b "2 "1?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-6 *1 "?J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-@ %:& 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-@ $: 3 8J
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 600/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-@ ':$ 8"1 2"6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-@ *1 "J "?J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-@ T%* 1"1 "?J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-@ *2"I "3 "?J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-? ':& 1 3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-? %:& 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-? $: 3 2@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-? ':$ 8"1 I6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-? *1 "J "8@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-? T%* 1"1 "8@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-? *2"I "3 "8@1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-2 Arsenic "1 "831 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-2 $admium "1 "@11 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-2 $hromium "2 "2@31 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-2 ercury "1 J-I1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-2 'ic!el "86 "86
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-2 ead "1? "1@J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 Arsenic "3 8"J?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 $admium "1 1"2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 $hromium "1 13"?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 ercury
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 'ic!el 1 18
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-8 ead "I 3"I6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 Arsenic "2 1"?1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 $admium "1 1"86
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 $hromium "1 1"86
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 ercury "1 1"86
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 601/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 'ic!el "1 1"86
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-3 ead "3 3"@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& Arsenic 8"J?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& $admium 1"2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& $hromium 13"?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& ercury
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& 'ic!el 18
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& ead 3"I6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& Arsenic
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& $admium 2"I2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& $hromium 6"26
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& ercury @"81
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& 'ic!el @J"8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& ead 18"6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& Arsenic "838
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& $admium "@12
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& $hromium 2"@3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& ercury "?6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& 'ic!el 8"6
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 602/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"b 3-& ead 1"@J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8"28 $: 1 1"I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8"28 ':$ "2 "1J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8"28 *1 1 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8"28 $d "2 "22
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8"28 'i "I "I3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 9io&ins
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 T%* 3 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 *1 8 1I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 *2"I 1 I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 ':$ 8 "3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 603/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 9io&ins
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 T%* 6 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 *1 8 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 *2"I 2 @
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 ':$ 8 "3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-I *1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-I ':$ 8 "I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-6 T%*
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ %:& 8I 2I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ Arsenic "1 "2
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 604/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ $admium "1 "2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ $hromium "8 "?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ ercury "? "8
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ 'ic!el "@ "2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ ':$ 8 "6
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-? *1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-11 9io&ins
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-11 9io&ins
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-11 T%* 3 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-11 *1 8 1I
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 605/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-11 *2"I 1 I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-11 ':$ 8 "3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-12 T%* 6 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-12 *1 8 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-12 *2"I 2 @
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-12 9io&ins
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-12 ':$ 8 "3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-18 T%* 6 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-18 *1 8 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-18 *2"I 2 @
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 606/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-18 T%* 6 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-18 *1 8 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-18 *2"I 2 @
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-18 9io&ins
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-18 ':$ 8 "3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-16 T%* 3 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-16 *1 8 1I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-16 *2"I 1 I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-16 9io&ins
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-16 ':$ 8 "3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 607/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1@ T%* 6 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1@ *1 8 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1@ *2"I 2 @
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1@ 9io&ins
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1@ ':$ 8 "3
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1J T%* 3 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1J *1 8 1I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1J *2"I 1 I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-1J 9io&ins
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 608/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-2 T%* 6 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-2 *1 8 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-2 *2"I 2 @
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-2 9io&ins1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-22 T%* -"?
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-22 %:& "2I
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-22 ':$ 1"6 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-22 *1 "2 "J11 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-22 T%* "2 "J11 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-22 *2"I "2 "J1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-28 %:& 13"2 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-28 *b "6 "68
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-23 *1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-23 %:& "I 2
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-23 $: 1 8J
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-23 ':$ 2"I 1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-23 *1 2 "J1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 609/669
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-23 T%* 8 "J11 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-23 *2"I 1 "J1
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-2I T%*
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 Arsenic "3 "I21 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 $admium "2 "J81 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 $hromium "8 "8@11 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 ercury "2 "82J1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 'ic!el "I "J161 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-8 ead "? "28881 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 Arsenic "3 "1@81 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 $admium "2 "1I8@1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 $hromium "2?1 "8@11 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 ercury "8 "12I1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 'ic!el "I "IJJ1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-3 ead "? "I8I@
1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ Arsenic "1 1"113@1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ $admium "1 1"I?J3I1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ $hromium "8 28"11J81 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ ercury "? "18IJ61 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ 'ic!el "@ 28"11J81 nergy industries 1"A"1"a 8-@ ead "2I 3"883?@1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a &-& /g() "I1 nergy industries 1"A"1"a &-& /g(,,) "31 nergy industries 1"A"1"a &-& /g(p) "1
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J As "? 8"?
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J $d 2"6 3"@8
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J $r 12"3 28"?2I
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J 'i 88"6 2J"?I
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 610/669
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J *b 1@ 1@6"26
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J As 1 6@"I
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J $d 18"28? 22"8@@?
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J $r 66J"283 281"JJ
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J 'i 368"133 826"I1I
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-1J *b 8126"8 6@1"?1
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-I T%* "J6 "62J
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-I *1 "63 "J81
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-I *2.I "8I "I
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-@ T%* "31 "83J2?
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-@ *1 "2@ "2@J3
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 611/669
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-@ *2.I "1I "13
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-J T%* "11 "J@
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-J *1 "@8 "@J?
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-J *2.I "8J "33
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-11 T%* "3? "32@8
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-11 *1 "82 "8@62
6 1"A"8"b"vi 8-11 *2.I "1@ "1J81 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-I Arsenic "8 1"??J11 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-I $admium "1 1@"11131 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-I $hromium "2 23?"?J81 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-I ercury 1"2IJ1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-I 'ic!el "1 23?"?J81 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-I ead 36"66@31 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-6 Arsenic "I "1@1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-6 $admium "1 "1@
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-6 $hromium "2 "18881 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-6 ercury "I "J6@1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-6 'ic!el "2 "1@1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b 8-6 ead "J@1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-I ercury "11 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-I ead 1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-6 ead 3
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyre
and bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
oad transport. automobile tyreand bra!e wear
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 612/669
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-13 T%* II 8I
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-13 *1 I8 88
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-13 *2.I I81 88
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-13 $opper "1J "2
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-13 ercury "@ "1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-13 $hromium "1 "1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-13 ':$ ? 6
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-1I %:B "@
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-1I 2 1"I1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-1I T%* "2 "I1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-1I *1 "2 "I1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-1I *2.I "2 "I
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-16 ':B 12 I
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-16 $: 82 1
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-16 %:B "1 6
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-16 /1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-2 *2"I 11 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i 8-23 T%* -"? "?1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i &-& /g() "I1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i &-& /g(,,) "8
1 %mall combustion 1"A"3"b"i &-& /g(p) "2
18 %olid fuel transformation 1"<"1"b 8-1 *1 1
18 %olid fuel transformation 1"<"1"b 8-1 *2.I J
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 8-6 ':$ "2 "2
9io&ins andFurans
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 613/669
16 efining > storage 1"<"2"a"iv 8-@ *1 "? "6
1? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8-1 ':B
1? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8-1 %:B 161? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8-1 '/8 8 211? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8-1 *%T 1? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8-1 *1
1? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8-1 *2.I 1? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8-1 /g "2 "331? eothermal energy e&traction 1"<"2"a"vi 8-1 As "2I1J enting and flaring 1"<"2"c 8-8 ':& 3 8"@
2 $ement production 2"A"1 &-& /g() "?
2 $ement production 2"A"1 &-& /g(,,) "1I
2 $ement production 2"A"1 &-& /g(p) "I
28 %oda ash production and use 2"A"3 tab" 8-1 '/8 "8?@8 1
2I oad paving with asphalt 2"A"6 'o" 8-6 ':$ 2 8
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 %:& 1J
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 Arsenic "12 "?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 614/669
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 $admium "1I "6?
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 $hromium 2"3 "?
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 $opper "6 "@
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 ercury "I "8
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 'ic!el 1"J "@3
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 ead 12 "3
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 %elenium 1? "1I
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d 8-2 Yinc 11 "866
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d Table 8-2 *2"I 82 1"?
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d Table 8-2 *1 86 1J"6
2J :ther mineral products 2"A"@"d Table 8-2 %e 1? 1"86
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 8-& Arsenic
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 8-& $admium
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 8-& $hromium
8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a 8-& 'ic!el8 $hemical industry 2"<"I"a &-& /g(p)
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-2 ead "I 8"I38?
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 615/669
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-2 Arsenic "2 "1@?J
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-2 $admium "J "8J3
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-2 $hromium "2 2"8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-2 'ic!el "J "?J3@
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-2 ercury "I "1?8?
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $admium "21@66
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $hromium 2"8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ercury "IIJ
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& 'ic!el "@2II8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ead 2"611J1
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& Arsenic "36J
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $admium "66@?
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $hromium 2"8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ercury "18@
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& 'ic!el "188I6
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ead 3"6J1
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& 'ic!el 1
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 &-& /g() "@
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 &-& /g(,,) "8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ercury "1381 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 &-& /g(p)
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& Arsenic
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& Arsenic "13I1
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $hromium 2"8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 616/669
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ead 8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& 'ic!el
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ead "6
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& Arsenic
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $admium "11
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $hromium
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ercury
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& 'ic!el "IJJ
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ead "886
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& Arsenic 8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $admium "?
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $hromium 2"8
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& ercury
81 ,ron and steel production 2"$"1 8-& $admium
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-1 Arsenic 8J 8?"@682
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-1 $admium 12 11"3?66
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-1 $hromium 16 16"186
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-1 ercury "28 "288I
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-1 'ic!el 13 13"38J
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-2 $admium 1I 13"II81
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-1 ead 16 1IJ"I66
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 617/669
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-2 $hromium 21 21"8I1I
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-2 ercury "81 "8118
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-2 'ic!el 1J 1J"211
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-2 ead 1@ 1@3"68@
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-& Arsenic 1"8@228
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-& $admium 2"2?@I
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-& $hromium
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-& ercury
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-& 'ic!el "12I@J
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-& ead 113"8I2
83 $opper production 2"$"I"a 8-2 Arsenic I1 I1"226?
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-& ercury
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-& 'ic!el
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-& ead 32I"J26
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-& $admium 1"11I8
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-& Arsenic 8"3I13@
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-& $hromium8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-1 Arsenic "?J "?@31@8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-1 $admium "88 "82I688I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-1 $hromium 8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-1 ercury "@ "6J3@8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-1 'ic!el 8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-1 ead 12 11I"J8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 618/669
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-2 Arsenic "1I "1I@
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-2 $admium "6@ "6@
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-2 $hromium
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-2 ercury "J8 "J2I32
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-2 'ic!el
8I ead production 2"$"I"b 8-2 ead 18 12"I621
8I ead production 2"$"I"b &-& /g() "?3
8I ead production 2"$"I"b &-& /g(,,) "1
8I ead production 2"$"I"b &-& /g(p) "6
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-2 'ic!el 8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-1 Arsenic "12 "11JI68@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-1 $admium 2"I 2"I881J8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-1 $hromium 8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-1 ercury 8"? 8"@?I@?
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-1 'ic!el 8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-1 ead 13 13"?36
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-2 Arsenic
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-2 $admium 2"3 2"381??
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-2 ercury I I"3II6
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-2 ead 1@ 1@"282
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-& Arsenic "3@?26
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-& $admium 2"?8@12
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-& $hromium
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-& ercury "63I
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-& 'ic!el
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 619/669
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-& ead I"26?JI
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d 8-2 $hromium
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d &-& /g() "?
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d &-& /g(,,) "1I
8@ Yinc production 2"$"I"d &-& /g(p) "I
36 *aint application 8"A"8 8-8 ':$ 2 8?
36 *aint application 8"A"2 8-2 ':$ 3 266
36 *aint application 8"A"1 8-1 ':$ 1I ?
36 *aint application 8"A new $: 12I
3@ 9egreasing 8"<"1 new $: @3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 620/669
I2 :ther product use 8"9"8 new $: I"I
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ ':$
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ %:2 "2
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ $: "3
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ *aricles "13
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ &-& /g(p) "2
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ $/3 "8@
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ '2: "1I
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ /
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ &-& /g() "2
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ &-& /g(,,) "6
IJ $linical waste incineration 6"$ 'o& "1@
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 8-1 $admium 8 "11I?
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 8-1 $hromium "8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 621/669
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 8-1 ercury 8I "?66I
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 8-1 'ic!el I6 "18I33
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 8-1 ead "1 1"2I@66
6 ,ndustrial waste incineration (d) 6"$"b 8-1 Arsenic "I "163I
63 :ther waste 6"9
63 :ther waste 6"9 tobacco
houseand carefires
T%*. / anddio&in
':&. ':$.$:. T%*.*A/./ anddio&in
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 622/669
e"erence
1J"J 2 Accepted
1"? 2"? 'oted
"2 "? 'oted
"6 "23 Accepted"I "3I A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9) e7ected"3 "86 A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9) e7ected
A*, *ublication 83? (not detected) e7ected"88 8"1 A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9) e7ected
"28 "J2 e7ected"16 "1I A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9) e7ected
'oted
Accepted
28 II Accepted
1"8 I"2 Accepted
"I8 1"8 Accepted
"I8 1"8 Accepted
"I8 1"8 Accepted
'oted
'oted
Lo#erLimit
$pperLimit
Proposeddecision
$hemistry. assuming all sulphurconverted (values to be multiplied with
% N wt % in fuel)% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-8(rated A)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-11(rated $)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-11(rated $)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-11
(rated $)
% *A A*-32 provides algorithmrelating * to sulphur content
*age ?. line 1@ of this chapter statessulphur in natural gas is negligible" ,fthis proposal is not accepted. then thealgorithm 2S% should be used - seeabove"
% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-1(rated <)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-2
(rated $)% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-2(rated <)
A*-32 (as above) states that all * W1 micron
A*-32 (as above) states that all * W1 micron
%ee#http#>>www"ifc"org>ifce&t>enviro"nsf>Attachments<yTitle>guiP/%uidelines2@Peneral/%>^F,>FinalV-VeneralV/%Vuidelines"pdf
For dual fuel engines operated withgas. overta!e Corld <an! proposal.see eneral /% uidelines#http#>>www"ifc"org>ifce&t>enviro"nsf>Attachments<yTitle>guiP/%uidelines2@Peneral/%>^F,>FinalV-VeneralV/%Vuidelines"pdf
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 623/669
'oted
1J"J 2 'oted
12 1? 'oted
"6@ 1 'oted
"6 "23 'oted"I "3I A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9) 'oted"3 "86 A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9) 'oted
"28 "J2 'oted
"16 "1I A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9) 'oted
'oted
1J"J 2 'oted"I2 "@? -*T 'oted
"6 "I3 Accepted
"@ "32 'oted
"@ "32 Accepted
"J "?1 'oted
"@ "32 'oted
"@ "32 'oted
"13 "12 'oted
"6 "I3 'oted
1 J"6 'oted
For gas diesel engines. see#http#>>www"ifc"org>ifce&t>enviro"nsf>Attachments<yTitle>guiP/%uidelines2@Peneral/%>^F,>FinalV-VeneralV/%Vuidelines"pdf
$hemistry. assuming all sulphur
converted (values to be multiplied with% N wt % in fuel)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated A)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-8(rated A)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-11(rated $)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-11(rated $)
% *A A*-32 provides algorithmrelating * to sulphur content
$hemistry. assuming all sulphurconverted (values to be multiplied with% N wt % in fuel)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)K K present value rounded upto one significant figure
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)K present value rounded up to
one significant figure% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)K present value rounded up to
one significant figure% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
% *A A*-32 $h 1"8. Table 1"8-1(rated 9)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 624/669
1J"J 2 'oted
? 82 Accepted
"3J 3"3 'oted2-I "6 uideboo!. 26 gives units as g>TD AcceptedI-6 "2 uideboo!. 26 gives units as g>TD 'otedI-I "1? uideboo!. 26 gives units as g>TD 'oted
1J"J 2 'oted
28 II 'oted
1"8 I"2 'oted
"11 "1 'oted
"23 "21 'oted
"13 "I3 'oted
"11 "33 'oted
3-I "1@ 'oted
"1? "@2 'oted
"J "86 'oted
"I8 1"8 'oted
'oted
28 II 'oted
$hemistry. assuming all sulphurconverted (values to be multiplied with% N wt % in fuel)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"I. Table 1"I-1(rated 9)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"I. Table 1"I-1
(rated 9)
$hemistry. assuming all sulphurconverted (values to be multiplied with% N wt % in fuel)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-1(rated <)K Assuming refinery gase+uivalent to natural gas
% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-2(rated $)K Assuming refinery gas
e+uivalent to natural gas A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9)K presentvalue rounded up to one significantfigure
A*, *ublication 83? (rated 9)K presentvalue rounded up to one significantfigure
A*, *ublication 83? (rated $)K presentvalue rounded up to one significantfigure
A*, *ublication 83? (rated c)K presentvalue rounded up to one significant
figure A*, *ublication 83? (rated $)K presentvalue rounded up to one significantfigure
A*, *ublication 83? (rated $)K presentvalue rounded up to one significantfigure
A*, *ublication 83? (rated $)K presentvalue rounded up to one significantfigure
% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-2(rated <)K assuming refinery gas
e+uivalent to natural gas*age ?. line 1@ of this chapter statessulphur in natural gas is negligible" ,fthis proposal is not accepted. then thealgorithm 2S% should be used - seeabove"
% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-1(rated <)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 625/669
1"8 I"2 'oted
"I8 1"8 'oted
"I8 1"8 'oted
"I8 1"8 'oted
23 I6 'oted
'oted
16 8? 'oted
2? 11 'oted
"11 "11 'oted
"11 "11 'oted
"11 "11 'oted"2 "I %*-Table 2I 'oted"I "1 %*-Table 2I 'oted
"1 "3 %*-Table 2I 'oted"I "1I %*-Table 2I 'oted
"2 "6 %*-Table 2I 'oted
"12 "21 %*-Table 2I 'oted
2 6 'oted
"? 1"I 'oted
1 2 'oted
Accepted
I 1I Accepted
8 @ 'oted
1"I 2"I 'oted
1 1"? Accepted
1 1"? Accepted
1 1"? Accepted
% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-2(rated $)
% *A A*-32 $h 1"3. Table 1"3-2(rated <)
A*-32 (as above) states that all * W1 micron
A*-32 (as above) states that all * W1 micron
% *A A*-32 $h 8"2. Table 8"2-2(rated <)
*age ?. line 1@ of this chapter statessulphur in natural gas is negligible" ,fthis proposal is not accepted. then thealgorithm 2S% should be used - seeabove"
% *A A*-32 $h 8"2. Table 8"2-2(rated <)
% *A A*-32 $h 8"2. Table 8"2-2
(rated $)% *A A*-32 $h 8"2. Table 8"2-2(rated 9)
A*-32 (as above) states that all * W1 micron
A*-32 (as above) states that all * W1 micron
%*-Table 23 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-Table 23 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-Table 23 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-Table 23 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2) (not in F:9)
%*-Table 23 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-Table 23 (called in the
F:9 under Tier 2)%*-Table 28 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-Table 28 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-Table 28 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-Table 28 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 626/669
1 1"? 'oted
8 6 'oted
2 6 Accepted
"? 1"I 'oted
1 2 'oted
'oted
I 1I 'oted
8 @ 'oted
'oted
1 I 'oted
8 J 'oted
3 1 'oted
I 1 'oted
1 2 'oted
"2 "I 'oted
"I 1"2 'oted
1"I 3 'oted
"I "1I 'oted
2 I 'oted
%*-Table 28 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-Table 28 (called in theF:9 under Tier 2)
%*-gas turbines-destillate oil-table 26 (not in F:9)
%*-gas turbines-destillate oil-table 26 (not in F:9)
%*-gas turbines-destillate oil-table 26 (not in F:9)
%*-gas turbines-destillate oil-table 26 (not in F:9)
%*-gas turbines-destillate oil-table 26 (not in F:9)
%*-gas turbines-destillate oil-table 26 (not in F:9)
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2@ (not in
F:9)%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2@ (not inF:9)
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2@ (not inF:9)
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2@ (not inF:9)
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2@ (not in
F:9)%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2@ (not inF:9)
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2? (not inF:9)
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2? (not inF:9)
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2? (not in
F:9)%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2? (not inF:9)
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2? (not inF:9)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 627/669
1 8 'oted
"@ 8 'oted
"1 "6 'oted
"I 3 'oted
"1 "33 'oted
"2I "11 'oted
'oted
'oted
2 'oted
'oted
'oted
Accepted
%*-gas turbines-natural gasand refinery fuel gas-table 2? (not inF:9)
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-1(rated $)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
*resent value rounded up to onesignificant figure
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-2a(rated $)
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-I(rated $)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-I(rated $)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
F are much too high being based on1JJ? dataK according to ownmeasurements on power plants thema7ority of dio&ins>furans are notdetectableK we suggest to use the$T,$ data of 6-1
As the $T,$ data are basedon more actual measurements theranges of the F should be e&tendedto include the $T,$ FK theyshould also include the F calculatedin appendi& <
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is oftenbelow instrument detection limits"%uggest using $T,$ valueof "3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 628/669
Accepted
2 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
"2 Accepted
Accepted
"1 Accepted
Accepted
"1 Accepted
F are much too high being based on1JJ? dataK according to ownmeasurements on power plants thema7ority of dio&ins>furans are notdetectableK we suggest to use the$T,$ data of 6-1
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
ecalculated from proposed T%* F
factor
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is oftenbelow instrument detection limits"%uggest using $T,$ valueof "3
ower JI confidence limit value for*1 is lower than that of *2"I -suggest that they should be the same
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is oftenbelow instrument detection limits"%uggest using $T,$ valueof "I
ower JI confidence limit value forT%* is lower than that of *1 -suggest that they should be the same
imit for sulphur in fuel oil is 1 - thise+uates to an emission of around 2Ig>D
F given appears to be for a 1"Isulphur fuel - as fuel sulphur hasdecreased so has the heavy metalcontent" %uggest using the$T,$ value of "2 g>D
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 629/669
"1 Accepted
"I Accepted
"2 Accepted
"1 Accepted
Accepted
"1 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
2 Accepted
Accepted
F given appears to be for a 1"Isulphur fuel - as fuel sulphur hasdecreased so has the heavy metalcontent" %uggest using the$T,$ value of "2 g>D
F given appears to be for a 1"Isulphur fuel - as fuel sulphur hasdecreased so has the heavy metalcontent" %uggest using the$T,$ value of "? g>D
F given appears to be for a 1"Isulphur fuel - as fuel sulphur hasdecreased so has the heavy metalcontent" %uggest using the$T,$ value of "8 g>D
F given appears to be for a 1"Isulphur fuel - as fuel sulphur hasdecreased so has the heavy metal
content" %uggest using the$T,$ value of "2 g>D
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is oftenbelow instrument detection limits"%uggest using $T,$ valueof "6
ower JI confidence limit value for*1 is lower than that of *2"I -suggest that they should be the same
F are much too high being based on1JJ? dataK according to ownmeasurements on power plants thema7ority of dio&ins>furans are notdetectableK we suggest to use the$T,$ data of 6-1
,t should be stated which TF factorsare used (,-TF or C/:-TF)G
The proposed F seems too high -
under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 630/669
Accepted
Accepted
2 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
2 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is oftenbelow instrument detection limits"
%uggest using $T,$ valueof "3
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* F
factor ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
F are much too high being based on1JJ? dataK according to ownmeasurements on power plants thema7ority of dio&ins>furans are notdetectableK we suggest to use the$T,$ data of 6-1
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is often
below instrument detection limits"%uggest using $T,$ valueof "3
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 631/669
2 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
2 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
F are much too high being based on1JJ? dataK according to ownmeasurements on power plants thema7ority of dio&ins>furans are notdetectableK we suggest to use the
$T,$ data of 6-11
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is oftenbelow instrument detection limits"%uggest using $T,$ valueof "3
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
F are much too high being based on1JJ? dataK according to ownmeasurements on power plants thema7ority of dio&ins>furans are not
detectableK we suggest to use the$T,$ data of 6-1
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is oftenbelow instrument detection limits"%uggest using $T,$ valueof "3
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 632/669
2 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
2 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
F are much too high being based on1JJ? dataK according to ownmeasurements on power plants thema7ority of dio&ins>furans are notdetectableK we suggest to use the
$T,$ data of 6-1
F seems very high - ':$emission generally related tocombustion conditions and is oftenbelow instrument detection limits"%uggest using $T,$ valueof "3
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
F are probably too high being basedon 1JJ? dataK we have not measuredthese on fluidised bed plants but the
values are li!ely to be similar to thosefrom *F plants so we suggest usingthe $T,$ data of 6-1
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 633/669
2 'oted
'oted
'oted
'otednegative valueG 'oted
'oted
"I 2 'oted
"3I 1"? 'oted"3I 1"? Assuming all * W 1 micron 'oted"3I 1"? Assuming all * W 1 micron 'oted
1J"J 2 'oted
"8 "18 'oted
"1 'oted
1J"J 2 'oted
8 3@ 'oted
"I 2 'oted
"3I 1"? 'oted
The proposed F seems too high -under the $*9 plant OIC(thermal) have an of Img>'m8 (1@"I g>D). so the suggestedvalue would seem more appropriate"
According to our data. the lower JIconfidence intervals for T%* are toohigh" Ce recommend
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
ecalculated from proposed T%* Ffactor
F are probably too high being basedon 1JJ? dataK we have not measuredthese on fluidised bed plants but thevalues are li!ely to be similar to those
from *F plants so we suggest usingthe $T,$ data of 6-1
*age ?. line 1@ of this chapter statessulphur in natural gas is negligible"
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-2a(rated $)
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-2a(rated $)
$hemistry. assuming all sulphurconverted (values to be multiplied with% N wt % in fuel)
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-I(rated $)K present value rounded up toone significant figure
ower JI confidence limit value for*1 is lower than that of *2"I -suggest that they should be the same
$hemistry. assuming all sulphurconverted (values to be multiplied with
% N wt % in fuel)% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-1(rated A)K assumed refinery gase+uivalent to natural gas
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-2a(rated $)K assuming refinery gase+uivalent to natural gas
% *A A*-32 $h 8"1. Table 8"1-2a(rated $)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 634/669
"3I 1"? Assuming all * W 1 micron 'oted"3I 1"? Assuming all * W 1 micron 'oted
"1 'oted
"8I "@ %* 'oted"3@ "13 %* 'oted"2132 "32?I %* 'oted"28I "3@ %* 'oted"I?8 "13I? %* 'oted"1@I "8I %* 'oted
"38J "21J6 %* 'oted"38J "268I %* 'oted"@@J "8?J@ %* 'oted"62 "2I %* 'oted"21J6 "181@3 %* 'oted"1@I@ "1I8J %* 'oted
"@223? 1"333J6 %* 'oted"@223? 2"??JJ1 %* 'oted16"I18? 88"2@6 %* 'oted"J63 "862I@ %* 'oted@"223@J 38"83?@ %* 'oted2"16@33 6"I281 %* 'oted
"3 "6 %* 'oted"8 "I %* 'oted
"I "2 %* 'oted
1"6 6 'oted
1"3 J 'oted
2 61 'oted
2"3 68 'oted
ower JI confidence limit value forT%* is lower than that of *1 -suggest that they should be the same
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.
%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 635/669
6"8 6@ 'oted
1 18 'oted
1"I I@ 'oted
113"J8@I ?I 'oted
? 66 'oted
12 2 'oted
"1@ "12 'oted
"2II "1? 'oted
"13 "J6 'oted
"83 "@6? 'oted
"2@2 "6133 'oted
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.
%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
/7orten!rans et al" 2@. e&!ll et al"2I. Carner et al" 22. Cesterlund21. egret *agotto 1JJJ.%techmann 1JJ8. /ildemann et al"1JJ1. /einrichs 1JJ8
T': 21. <CA 1JJ2. ebbe et al"1JJ@. $A< 1JJ8. arben et al" 1JJ6.<aumann 1JJ@. egret and *agotto1JJJ. !ewille et al" 21
T': 21. <CA 1JJ2. ebbe et al"1JJ@. $A< 1JJ8. arben et al" 1JJ6.<aumann 1JJ@. egret and *agotto1JJJ. !ewille et al" 21
T': 21. <CA 1JJ2. ebbe et al"1JJ@. $A< 1JJ8. arben et al" 1JJ6.<aumann 1JJ@. egret and *agotto1JJJ. !ewille et al" 21
T': 21. <CA 1JJ2. ebbe et al"1JJ@. $A< 1JJ8. arben et al" 1JJ6.<aumann 1JJ@. egret and *agotto1JJJ. !ewille et al" 21
T': 21. <CA 1JJ2. ebbe et al"1JJ@. $A< 1JJ8. arben et al" 1JJ6.<aumann 1JJ@. egret and *agotto1JJJ. !ewille et al" 21
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 636/669
"13 "8@ 'oted
"1@J "2 'oted
"1I? "1@61 'oted
"? "?J1 'oted
"83@ "J 'oted
"86 "@J23 'oted
"1II "3J 'oted@"@@@J1 1I"III? %* 'oted@"@@@J1 81"1116 %* 'oted1@@"@?1 8II"I61 %* 'oted"?3 8"21I? %* 'oted
@@"@@J1 366"6@3 %* 'oted28"888@ @"12 %* 'oted"11 "2? %* 'oted"11 "2? %* 'oted
"??J "2222 %* 'oted"II6 "166@ %* 'oted"11 "2? %* 'oted"I6 "16@ %* 'oted
"8 "1 uideboo! 26" unit mg>D 'oted'oted
uideboo! 26. unit mg>D 'oted
T': 21. <CA 1JJ2. ebbe et al"1JJ@. $A< 1JJ8. arben et al" 1JJ6.<aumann 1JJ@. egret and *agotto1JJJ. !ewille et al" 21
arg et al" 2. egret*agotto1JJJ. Carner et al" 22. auterberg-
Culff 1JJ?. Dohansson et al" 1JJ?.Cesterlund 21. <uwal 21. T':21
arg et al" 2. egret*agotto1JJJ. Carner et al" 22. auterberg-Culff 1JJ?. Dohansson et al" 1JJ?.Cesterlund 21. <uwal 21. T':21
arg et al" 2. egret*agotto1JJJ. Carner et al" 22. auterberg-Culff 1JJ?. Dohansson et al" 1JJ?.Cesterlund 21. <uwal 21. T':
21arg et al" 2. egret*agotto1JJJ. Carner et al" 22. auterberg-Culff 1JJ?. Dohansson et al" 1JJ?.Cesterlund 21. <uwal 21. T':21
arg et al" 2. egret*agotto1JJJ. Carner et al" 22. auterberg-Culff 1JJ?. Dohansson et al" 1JJ?.Cesterlund 21. <uwal 21. T':21
arg et al" 2. egret*agotto1JJJ. Carner et al" 22. auterberg-Culff 1JJ?. Dohansson et al" 1JJ?.Cesterlund 21. <uwal 21. T':21
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 637/669
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
'oted
'otedF of old < has less uncertainty 'otedF of old < has less uncertainty 'otedF of old < has less uncertainty 'oted
'oted
'oted
'oted
'oteduideboo! 26. unit g>D 'oted
Accepted"3 "6 %* 'oted"2 "3 %* 'oted
"1 "8 %* 'oted
3I 1? Accepted
3 16 Accepted
"1 "3 Accepted
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 < orwrong reference
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 < orwrong reference
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 <SSS *roposed value O *1 one
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 <or wrong reference
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 < orwrong reference
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 < orwrong reference
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 < orwrong reference
, C %*A; A<:T 4'ATA4A% FN. if we spea! of other gases(i"e" *) then mut be declared
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 < orwrong reference
,t0s inaudite that consultant it0s not ableto copy 4old4 in 4new4 fs
,t0s inaudite that consultant it0s not ableto copy 4old4 in 4new4 fs
,t0s inaudite that consultant it0s not ableto copy 4old4 in 4new4 fs
: ,' $:*U F: 4:94 < orwrong reference
estimated fraction of * by % *Adata
estimated fraction of * by % *Adata
pper limit as per Table 8-1 of this'F
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 638/669
"8 "J Accepted
A*AT. 2@ Accepted
Accepted? J A*AT. 2@ Accepted
A*AT. 2@ Accepted A*AT. 2@ Accepted
A*AT. 2@ Accepted"26 1"8 A*AT. 2@ Accepted"2 "3I A*AT. 2@ Accepted
uideboo! 26 Accepted
"@ "J %* e7ected
"1 "2 %* e7ected
"1 "1 %* e7ected
"6 1"I Accepted
Accepted
186 21@ Accepted
"1? Accepted
efinery <F provides a range ofabatementefficiencies for cyclonesbetween 8 and J*ropose lowerlimit set to <F value"*roposedefault efficiency is ta!en at mid range
A*AT. 2@ 'ote that the proposedvalue is wrong5 The reference +uotedsay# 4Chile geothermal plants do notemit sulfur dio&ide directly. oncehydrogen sulfide is released as a gasinto the atmosphere. it spreads intothe air and eventually changes into
<F 4arge olume ,norganic$hemicals - %olids and :ther ,ndustry(,$ - %A:) :ctober 26. chapter2"8"8"I). unit !g>ton
used F of german ',. referenced on9, 22?8 Aufbereitungsanlagen fr
Asphaltmischgut
Average of measurements coming
from members of the federation (onlyflat glass)
Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (onlyflat glass). lower limit N belowdetection limit
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 639/669
"2I Accepted
"1 "18 Accepted
"11 Accepted
"8J Accepted
"I3 "J@ Accepted
"28 "6? Accepted
"2 "3 Accepted
"18 "I6 Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted%*-$hlor al!ali production Accepted
1"@?J33 I"86?81 Accepted
Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (onlyflat glass). lower limit N belowdetection limit
Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (only
flat glass) Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (onlyflat glass). lower limit N belowdetection limit
Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (onlyflat glass). lower limit N belowdetection limit
Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (onlyflat glass)
Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (onlyflat glass)
Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (onlyflat glass)
Average of measurements comingfrom members of the federation (onlyflat glass)
unpublished report on emission factorsof the erman glas and mineral fibre
industry for the year 2I
unpublished report on emission factorsof the erman glas and mineral fibreindustry for the year 2I
unpublished report on emission factorsof the erman glas and mineral fibreindustry for the year 2I
%* - chlorine-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - chlorine-Tier 1 (not in
F:9)%* - chlorine-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - chlorine-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%*-(called in the F:9 underTier 2)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 640/669
"?JI "26?3 Accepted
"1@J "I8@ Accepted
1"1I 8"3I Accepted
"I86? "161I Accepted
"122I "86@6 Accepted
"13I11 "2J21 Accepted
1"1I 8"3I Accepted
"8@J3 "I6J1 Accepted
"21@66 1"??8 Accepted
1"??8 3"8I81? Accepted
"26@18 "I8326 Accepted
"I838 "?13 Accepted
1"I8888 8"666@ Accepted
"6J "26 Accepted
"66@? "66@?2 Accepted
2"6@12? 6"6@?1J Accepted
? 1I Accepted
"6 "? %* e7ected
"2 "3 %* e7ected
@-I "21 Accepted%* e7ected
Accepted
"@26 "21@@ e7ected
1"1I 8"3I Accepted
%*-(called in the F:9 underTier 2)
%*-(called in the F:9 underTier 2)
%*-(called in the F:9 underTier 2)
%*-(called in the F:9 underTier 2)
%*-(called in the F:9 underTier 2)
%* - lectric arc -Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - lectric arc -Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - lectric arc -Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - lectric arc -Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - lectric arc -Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - <asic o&ygen-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - <asic o&ygen-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - <asic o&ygen-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - <asic o&ygen-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - <asic o&ygen-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - <asic o&ygen-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - open hearth furnace-Tier1 (not in F:9)
%* -pig iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* -pig iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - lectric arc -Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* -pig iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 641/669
2 I Accepted
e7ected
"8 "J1 Accepted
e7ected
J-I "1I Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
"3? "@1J Accepted
"1? "32 Accepted
2 I Accepted
"I 1"I Accepted
1"I8888 8"?8888 Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
26"88?I I2"JI@ Accepted
J"1@@8 1?"6@2 Accepted
1"J1?3 21"?86@ Accepted
"1II@ "8?J1 Accepted
?"@3613 21"?@2I Accepted
11"632I 28"2?3J Accepted
11"618 2@I"3@2 Accepted
%* - open hearth furnace-Tier1 (not in F:9)
%* -pig iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* -pig iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - cast iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - cast iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - cast iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - cast iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - cast iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - cast iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - open hearth furnace-Tier1 (not in F:9)
%* - open hearth furnace-Tier1 (not in F:9)
%* - open hearth furnace-Tier1 (not in F:9)
%* - open hearth furnace-Tier1 (not in F:9)
%* -pig iron-Tier 1 (not inF:9)
%* - primary copper-Tier 1The unit (g>g) aluminium should be
corrected in g>g copper %* - primary copper-Tier 1The unit (g>g) aluminium should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - primary copper-Tier 1The unit (g>g) aluminium should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - primary copper-Tier 1The unit (g>g) aluminium should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - primary copper-Tier 1The unit (g>g) aluminium should be
corrected in g>g copper %* - primary copper-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2) - Theunit (g>g aluminium) should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - primary copper-Tier 1The unit (g>g) aluminium should becorrected in g>g copper
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 642/669
13"II@? 2J"11I6 Accepted
"2@I "I1?J Accepted
11"632I 2J"162 Accepted
116"32I 2J1"62 Accepted
"I@1@6 2"I?83 Accepted
1"138I2 3"I@3J Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
"I@1? "1@1I8 Accepted
I@"1@62 22?"@I Accepted
83"J2@3 6J"?I3? Accepted
e7ected
e7ected
136"?@1 I?@"3?I Accepted
"@8386 2"J8@32 Accepted
2"28@ I"133J Accepted
e7ected"II?8 1"82 %* - primary lead-Tier 1 Accepted
"2212? "?J@8 %* - primary lead-Tier 1 Accepted%* - primary lead-Tier 1 e7ected
"III2I "?82?? %* - primary lead-Tier 1 Accepted%* - primary lead-Tier 1 e7ected
32"JJ?? 1IJ"388 %* - primary lead-Tier 1 Accepted
%* - primary copper-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2) - Theunit (g>g aluminium) should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - primary copper-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2) - The
unit (g>g aluminium) should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - primary copper-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2) - Theunit (g>g aluminium) should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - primary copper-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2) - Theunit (g>g aluminium) should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - secondary copper-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary copper-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary copper-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary copper-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary copper-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary copper-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - primary copper-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2) - The
unit (g>g aluminium) should becorrected in g>g copper
%* - secondary lead-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary lead-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary lead-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary lead-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary lead-Tier 1(not in F:9)
%* - secondary lead-Tier 1(not in F:9)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 643/669
"1I "21 Accepted
"I2I "1I Accepted
e7ected
"@383 1"11I1 Accepted
e7ected
?"8@3@2 16"@3J3 Accepted
"@ "J %*-primary lead e7ected
"I "1I %*-primary lead e7ected
"1 "1I %*-primary lead e7ected
e7ected"6? "1?28J %* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 Accepted
1"183?@ 8"J81I2 %* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 Accepted%* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 e7ected
1"I133@ 6"I@J %* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 Accepted
%* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 e7ected3"3I?38 2@"I618 %* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 Accepted
e7ected
"J@2@I 8"?J11 Accepted
2"1?22 ?"@2?J Accepted
3"?68@6 83"368 Accepted
"2381? "@2JII Accepted
1"62121 3"I83 Accepted
Accepted
"828 "J6? Accepted
Accepted
%* - primary lead-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary lead-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary lead-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary lead-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary lead-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary lead-Tier 1(called in the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 (calledin the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 (calledin the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 (calledin the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 (calledin the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 (calledin the F:9 under Tier 2)
%* - secondary Hinc-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - secondary Hinc-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - secondary Hinc-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - secondary Hinc-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - secondary Hinc-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 644/669
8"23238 ?"16@ Accepted
Accepted
"@ "J %*-Hinc e7ected
"1 "2 %*-Hinc e7ected
"1 "1 %*-Hinc e7ected
I 1J
66 I8
6 2
Accepted
Accepted
%* - secondary Hinc-Tier 1 (notin F:9)
%* - primary Hinc-Tier 1 (calledin the F:9 under Tier 2)
The mission factor is specific for
ermanyK eference# D" Thelo!e"':$-missionen aus derksemittelanwendung undkglich!eiten Hu ihrer inderung"Fort-schritt-<erichte 9, eihe 1I 'r"2I2" 9sseldorf# 9,-erlag.(9issertation). 2I
$onsult with&pert *anel
The mission factor is specific forermanyK eference# D" Thelo!e"':$-missionen aus derksemittelanwendung undkglich!eiten Hu ihrer inderung"Fort-schritt-<erichte 9, eihe 1I 'r"
2I2" 9sseldorf# 9,-erlag.(9issertation). 2I
$onsult with&pert *anel
The mission factor is specific forermanyK eference# D" Thelo!e"':$-missionen aus derksemittelanwendung undkglich!eiten Hu ihrer inderung"Fort-schritt-<erichte 9, eihe 1I 'r"2I2" 9sseldorf# 9,-erlag.(9issertation). 2I
$onsult with&pert *anel
g>m2 uropean $ommission (26d).,ntegrated *ollution *revention and$ontrol (,**$). eference 9ocumenton <est Available Techni+ues (<F)for the %urface Treatment of etalsand *lastics. August 26
electronic components !g>t wafer $arloTroHHi (*rivate $ommunication. 2?)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 645/669
Accepted
e7ected
Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
"1 "8 %* e7ected
e7ected
e7ected
Accepted
"1 "8 %* e7ected
"I "@ %* e7ected
Accepted
"3?8@ "13I11 %* Accepted
%* e7ected
g>m2 6811 Adhesive Tapeanufacturing (<F)
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 11. tabel @"2.unit N !g>ton
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 11. tabel @"2.unit N !g>ton
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 11. tabel @"2.unit N !g>ton
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 11. tabel @"2.unit N !g>ton
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 11. tabel @"2.unit N !g>ton
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 11. tabel @"2.unit N !g>ton
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 11. tabel @"2
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 11. tabel @"2.unit N !g>ton
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 646/669
"682 "11?1@ %* e7ected
"3?8@ "1J83J %* Accepted
"3?8@1 1"J83?6 %* Accepted
"J6@ "1J8I %* Accepted
Accepted
Accepted
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf. page 112
http#>>www"ssb"no>emner>1>3>1>rappPemissions>rappP2@8?Pen>rappP2@8?Pen"pdf page 112
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 647/669
Action taken Comments
eplaced with A*32 fs
eplaced with A*32 fs
eplaced with A*32 fseplaced with A*32 fseplaced with A*32 fseplaced with A*32 fseplaced with A*32 fs
eplaced with A*32 fseplaced with A*32 fs
obert - please can you loo! into this
obert - please can you loo! into this
9one
9one
9one
9one
9one
'eed to address %ulphur emissions - willreplace with % N wt% in fuel and defaultF using default sulphur content (made
e&plicit in te&t)
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 648/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 649/669
,-TF
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 650/669
%ee first comment
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 651/669
%ee first comment
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 652/669
%ee first comment
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 653/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 654/669
%ee first comment
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 655/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 656/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 657/669
%ee first comment
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 658/669
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 659/669
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 660/669
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 661/669
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done at
later stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
'ot included at this stage" $ould be done atlater stage"
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 662/669
9one
9one
9one
9one
9one
9one
9one
pdated
pdated
pdated
:ld0 uideboo! references will all beupdated and referenced to original source
:ld0 uideboo! references will all beupdated and referenced to original source
:ld0 uideboo! references will all beupdated and referenced to original source
:ld0 uideboo! references will all beupdated and referenced to original source
:ld0 uideboo! references will all beupdated and referenced to original source
:ld0 uideboo! references will all beupdated and referenced to original source
:ld0 uideboo! references will all beupdated and referenced to original source
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 663/669
pdated
alue N . so not ta!en into account
pdatedpdatedalue N . so not ta!en into accountalue N . so not ta!en into account
alue N . so not ta!en into accountpdatedpdatedpdated
JI confidence interval estimated
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 664/669
JI confidence interval estimated
JI confidence interval estimated
accepted %* list only F0s for mercury
accepted %* list only F0s for mercury
accepted %* list only F0s for mercury
accepted %* list only F0s for mercuryaccepted
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 665/669
alue N
'o value
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 666/669
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 667/669
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 668/669
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'o value
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this can
be included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
8/20/2019 Doc Guidebook
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/doc-guidebook 669/669
Added to chapter and database
Added to chapter and database , suppose ':$ is meant ($:G)
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this can
be included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
'ot included yet" ,s not one of thepollutants in the protocol" *erhaps this canbe included in separate (not Tier 1>2 tables)somewhere in the te&tG
'ot included for now" A,'% weightedaverage over all countries seems moreappropriate as Tier 1
%hould we use this as the Tier 1G :r theweighted average of A,'% as we havenowG
'ot included for now" A,'% weighted
average over all countries seems moreappropriate as Tier 1
%hould we use this as the Tier 1G :r the
weighted average of A,'% as we havenowG
'ot included for now" A,'% weightedaverage over all countries seems moreappropriate as Tier 1
%hould we use this as the Tier 1G :r theweighted average of A,'% as we havenowG
, suppose ':$ is meant ($:G)F is for boat building
top related