does japan use the asian development bank to conceal its mercantilist foreign aid policy? daniel...
Post on 18-Dec-2015
214 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Does Japan Use the Asian Development Bank to Conceal
Its Mercantilist Foreign Aid policy?
Daniel James WatsonECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AND
INTERNATIONAL POLITICSINAF 100-14
-Brief History-Aid Policy-U.S. Influence
-Economic vs. Political-Robert Orr
-Why 1992?-Japan as top donor-Cold War ending-New ODA Charters
-Empirical Evidence-Small Donor Countries-Market Oriented
Japan’s Bilateral Aid Policy
•New ODA Charters• 1992 and 2003
•Focuses:• Environment-Energy Use per GDP• Peace- Armed Personnel• Democracy- Polity• Rich and Poor- Income Share
ODA Charters
Statistical Findings
• Significant for Single Variable• Better Correlations after 1992
• Not Robust
Current Economic Needs
• Waning Power• East Asian Financial Crisis• Remapping of the Region?– T.J. Pempel
• Stagnated Growth-Graph 1
Stagnated Growth:
Japanese Aid-Distributing Policy
• Several Ministries – Foreign Affairs– Finance– Trade and Industry
• Lack of clear goal• New coordination movements– Japanese International Cooperation Agency
• Changing Public Opinion– Orr vs. Woods
• International Influence (Rix)
Japan and the ADB• Influence– Voting shares– Key position
• Decreased Funding from Europe/U.S. – Table 1
Japan and the ADB- Influence– Voting shares– Key position
•Decreased Funding from Europe/U.S. – Table 1
•Increasing Relative Power of Japan– Ming Wan
•Empirical Analyses– Pre-1992 insignificance– Post-1992 significance– Robustness
The Asian Development Bank’s Policy
• Same as Japan?• Focuses:• Environment-Energy Use per GDP• Peace- Armed Personnel• Democracy- Polity• Rich and Poor- Income Share
• Thus far…Inconclusive
Conclusion• Japan’s Bilateral Policy– 1992-Charters– Evidence
• Current Economy and Politics– Motivation to continue– Ability to Change
• The ADB– Japanese Influence– Non-Responsive to New Japanese Policy
•Cover-Up?
top related