dyslexia: insights and current understandingsaimvaseptember2015.pbworks.com/w/file/fetch... ·...

Mary Murray Stowe, M.Ed.

TTAC at the College of William and Mary

And the Virginia Department of Education

mmstowe@wm.edu

(AIM VA November 2015 and AIM VA September 2015http://tinyurl.com/p5quddp )

( VCASE May 2015 http://tinyurl.com/n85ec97 )

http://ttacwm.blogs.wm.edu/dyslexia-insights-and-current-understandings/

Dyslexia: Insights and Current Understandings

Learn to Read Simulation

Adapted from the Northern CaliforniaBranch of IDA Simulation Kit

Reactions?

Aha’s?

Insights?

Learn to Spell Simulation

From the Northern CaliforniaBranch of IDA Simulation Kit

Guidance: IDA, VA Administrative Code, and OSERS

Dyslexia is a specific learning disability that is

neurobiological in origin. It is characterized by

difficulties with accurate and / or fluent word

recognition and by poor spelling and decoding

abilities.

Adopted by the IDA Board of Directors, Nov. 12, 2002. This definition is also used by the

National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD) and is in the

Virginia and Federal Regulations.

These difficulties typically result from a deficit in

the phonological component of language that is

often unexpected in relation to other cognitive

abilities and the provision of effective classroom

instruction. Secondary consequences may include

problems in reading comprehension and reduced

reading experience that can impede growth of

vocabulary and background knowledge.

Dyslexia within the Virginia Code: (1 of 2)

8VAC20-81-10. Definitions…

"Specific learning disability" means a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or in using language, spoken or written, that may manifest itself in the imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell or to do mathematical calculations, including conditions such as perceptual disabilities, brain injury, minimal brain dysfunction, dyslexia, and developmental aphasia.

From the Virginia Administrative Code: http://leg1.state.va.us/cgi-bin/legp504.exe?000+reg+8VAC20-81-10

(2 of 2) Dyslexia is distinguished from other learning disabilities due to its weakness occurring at the phonological level. Dyslexia is a specific learning disability that is neurobiological in origin. It is characterized by difficulties with accurate and/or fluent word recognition and by poor spelling and decoding abilities. These difficulties typically result from a deficit in the phonological component of language that is often unexpected in relation to other cognitive abilities and the provision of effective classroom instruction. Secondary consequences may include problems in reading comprehension and reduced reading experience that can impede growth of vocabulary and background knowledge.

(§ 22.1-213 of the Code of Virginia; 34 CFR 300.8(c)(10))

Guidance from OSERS

From the definition within the Virginia Administrative Code:

What are the key take aways from the definition?

neurobiological in origin

deficit in the phonological component of language

unexpected

Gabrieli, 2015

Cause or Consequence?

permission from the publisher.

Terminology Counts! Defining the “Phon” WordsExercise 1.1: Phonology Terms Graphic Organizer

Phonological

Processing

speech

perception

production

metalinguistic

awareness

syllable

onset-rime

phoneme

phonological

memory

retrieval

naming

phonics

graphemes

syllables

morphemes

Phonics is

phonological

processing

issue.

Moats, 2009

Possible symptoms of poor phonological working memory:

Not able to accomplish multiple steps

Forget all sounds in sound blending

Not able to identify discrete sounds within a word or segments of a word, phrase, or sentence

Loses track of the story

Cannot remember phone numbers

Cannot remember sounds within multisyllabic words Moats, 2009

“unexpected”

….unexpected in relation to other cognitive abilities and the provision of effective classroom instruction…

Students with phonological processing issues may not be dyslexic. The issue must be unexpected in relation to other skills. Requirements for the identification for SLD do not include and are not a result of intellectual challenges, a hearing issue, low SES, inadequate instruction, and so on….

Prevalence

Prevalence of a Specific Learning Disability:

SLD is the highest incidence of students receiving special education services (42% of the 5.7 million school-age children with all kinds of disabilities.

There are 2.4 million American publicschools students (approximately 5 % of the total public school enrollment)identified with SLD under IDEA.

75 to 80% of special education students identified as LD have their basic deficits in language and reading (National Institutes of Health)http://ldaamerica.org/support/new-to-ld/

State of LD, 2014

Depending on the definition used, 5% to 10% (20%) of the population is considered to have dyslexia; however, because of the nature of the definitional issues…, an estimate of prevalence is specific to a particular sample and to the definition used in a study.

(Siegel, 2006)

Prevalence and DefinitionsEstimates range from 5 to 20%

The Shaywitz from Yale Center on Dyslexia and Creativity report 5 to 17%

Moats and Dakin, 2012 report 15 to 20% of population has

characteristics through an IDA Fact Sheet

Mayo Clinic through an Epidemiological (incidence of) Study,

Rochester, Minnesota reports 11%

Maryanne Wolf reports 10% during a 2015 Presentation in Fairfax Co.

Assessment

Study for Dyslexia Screener for Kindergartners: (Please read this study)

http://leg2.state.va.us/dls/h&sdocs.nsf/fc86c2b17a1cf388852570f9006f1299/cbf35e67f28c8b328525773f005a73e6/$FILE/SD4.pdf

The study results indicated that PALS was sufficient to identify a reading challenge. A rapid naming component (RAN) was suggested as a possible enhancement as well as a mid-year screening.

If you suspect a reading challenge from the PALS’ results, additional testing may be done to provide appropriate interventions.

If you suspect a disability from the results of the PALS screener, the student should be referred for evaluation.

Assessment for Four Purposes:

Evaluation of the effectiveness of a program

Screening to determine risk for reading difficulty and need for additional intervention

Progress monitoring to determine if adequate progress made or need more intervention to achieve grade level reading outcomes

Evaluate/diagnosis to help plan instruction by providing information about skills and instructional needs

(Moats, 2005)

What are we assessing?

• Family history

• General intellectual functioning

• Information on cognitive processing: language, memory, auditory processing, visual processing/visual motor integration, reasoning abilities and executive functioning

• Specific oral language skills related to reading and writing success

• Phonological processing

• Determine level of functioning in basic skill areas of reading, spelling, written language, and math

(NCLD, 2013 via Rosenberg 2015)

Typical Characteristics

Typical Characteristics by Grade

No two individuals with dyslexia are alike!

These variations can be considerable according to the:

• Severity of the problem

• Duration of the problem

• Responsiveness of the problem to instruction

• Relative difficulty a person has with related aspects of reading, spelling, writing, math, or language learning

• Co-existing conditions

• Co-existing strengthsMoats and Tolman, 2009

Slides were deleted for posting on the wiki as they a copyright protected.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2qX-afcGIwWhat could a dyslexic look like in the classroom?

Instruction

Literacy Timeline – How did you learn to read?Rozzelle and Scearce, 2009

Reading Instruction: Multisensory and Structured

Students with dyslexia and other reading challenges benefit from reading instruction that is structured, systematic, direct, sequential, cumulative, and multisensory. (Birsh, 2011; Moats and Dakin, 2008)

Multisensory Structured Language Instruction

E-Learning Series from TTAC WM

http://education.wm.edu/centers/ttac/resources/webinar/languageinstruction/index.php

What programs do you have available in your division to address this need? What teachers have received training in multisensory structured language approaches or programs to address this need?

http://www.winsorlearning.com/images/downloads/pdf/find-out-more/IDA-Matrix-of-Multisensory-Language-Programs.pdf

Examples of Multisensory Structured Language Instructional Approaches and Programming:

Orton Gillingham Approach SlingerlandAlphabetic Phonics Sonday SystemAssociation Method Sounds in SyllablesLanguage! Spalding MethodLexia – Herman Method Starting OverLindamood-Bell Wilson FundationsProject Read Wilson Reading

Teaching is done using all learning pathways in the brain (visual/auditory, kinesthetic-tactile) simultaneously in order to enhance memory and learning.

IMSLEC

What?: Multisensory

Why?: Multisensory

Information can be processed on a modality-specific basis [visual, auditory, kinesthetic etc.], but when they converge and the information is integrated in the brain stronger neural pathways are created.

Performance enhancement is greater for multisensory than unisensorystimuli.

Multisensory Integration in the Brain, 2015

Paul J. Laurienti, M.D., Ph.D. Department of Radiology, ANSIR, Advanced Neuroscience Imaging Research, Wake Forest University

Judith Willis, in Research-Based Strategies to Ignite Student Learning, suggests that the more sensory areas used in learning a task, the stronger the neural connections, the associations for learning, memory and fluency.

Simultaneous and alternative deployment of visual, auditory, kinesthetic, and tactile sensory modalities that supports the connection of oral

language with visual language symbols Birsh, 2010

Multisensory approach promotes active

engagement to enhance learning.

Farrell and Sherman, 2011

The structure of the language instructionprovides the power. Farrell and Sherman, 2011

Instruction must be:direct,

systematic,and

sequential.

Henry 2008

What do we mean by the structure of the English language?

Phases of Word Reading Development (Ehri’s Model, 1996)(How reading and spelling develop… Cain, 2011 and Moats, 2010)

Pre-alphabetic context dependent; incidental visual cues

Early Alphabetic (Partial alphabetic)

initial letter, salient consonants; letter name knowledge,partial phoneme awareness

Later Alphabetic (Full alphabetic)

recognition of chunks, grapheme-phoneme connections,more elaborated phoneme awareness

Consolidated Alphabetic

sequential decoding and fluent analogizing to larger units; phoneme, syllable, morpheme and speech-print connections; phoneme and morpheme awareness

http://sopriswest.http.internapcdn.net/sopriswest_vitalstream_com/Elearning/LETRS/LETRS_Mod5Chp2/html/ehri_s_model_of_word_recognition.html

Multisensory Language Instruction Pilot ProgramSuperintendent’s Memo of April 17, 2015http://doe.virginia.gov/administrators/superintendents_memos/2015/093-15.shtml

Classroom Educator (CE) Orton Gillingham Approach instruction was provided to teachers in Virginia this summer with follow up throughout the 2015 – 2016 school year through the TTACs across the commonwealth and the CE Certification process.

•http://ortonacademy.org/academy-of-orton-gillingham-video.php

The Orton-Gillingham instructional approach is a direct, systematic approach to teaching language structure for reading remediation. It

is designed to address the needs of struggling readers who have difficulty with reading, spelling, and writing including those with a

specific learning disability such as dyslexia.

Let’s examine several aspects of Orton-Gillingham approach to instruction; this

approach is modeled in other intensive intervention reading programs as discussed previously, but can be used in the general

education classroom as well.

The Orton-Gillingham Approach follows seven (7) tenets when providing instruction:

MultisensoryDirect & Explicit Language BasedStructured, Sequential & Cumulative Diagnostic/Prescriptive Cognitive

Emotionally Sound cycle)

Scarborough (2001) htt

Orton-GillinghamLesson Plan

Phonemic Awareness ActivitySymbol to Sound (salmon/white cards)Alphabet Sound to Symbol (yellow

cards)Review Words for ReadingReview Words for Spelling (SOS Dictation)New Words for ReadingNew Words for SpellingHandwritingOral Reading

Multisensory LessonPlan (Birsh, 2011)

Alphabet Knowledge and Phonemic Awareness

Reading DecksSpelling DeckMultisensory Introduction of Letter or

ConceptReading Practice for Accuracy and

FluencySpellingHandwritingComprehension and Listening

StrategiesOral Language Practice and Composition

Irregular Words 15%Categories – 10%Learned Words – 5%

Basic Patterns of Language Structure

Basic Phonetic Patterns85%

Lund and Cheatum, 2004

Structural analysis Moats, 2015

Instructional Component Approximate Time

VA 2011 English Standards of Learning

Alphabet Knowledge and Phonemic AwarenessAlphabet Knowledge – students touch and name the letters of the alphabet in sequence as warm-up; students can match plastic uppercase letter to a grid of alphabet letters on a mat (FCRR, Activity P.003, Alphabet Arc)Phonemic Awareness – ask students if these words rhyme, examples – pill/hill, tip/hip, yes/my, run/sun, mice/nice, now/nap.

5 minutes K.7, K.11, 1.5, 1.6, 1.11, 1.12, 2.5

Reading Rope : Word Recognition Strands

Alphabet Knowledge

Alphabet Activity P.003http://www.fcrr.org/Curriculum/pdf/GK-1/P_Final_Part1.pdf

NAlphabet Archttp://youtu.be/PJPs_Sx4eG0

Alphabetic Knowledge

takefakebake

bakerskatebrake/break

streak/skaterkaratebasketbreakfast

Making Big Words – Cunningham and Hall

makemaker rake

Phonemic Awareness

/k/ /a/ /t/

By sounds (phonemic awareness)

Segment by phonemes:

Said a book-reading parrot named Hooey,“The words in this book are all phooey.When you say them, your lipswill make slips and back flipsand your tongue may end up in Saint Looey!”

Dr. Seuss, 1979

Phonemic Awareness: http://youtu.be/sbp3kl14R1c

Phonological/Phonemic Awareness Development Continuum

Word Comparison Easy

Sentence Segmentation

Syllable Segmentation/Blending

Onset-Rime Segmentation/Blending

Blending/Segmenting Individual Phonemes

Phoneme Deletion/Manipulation

Gibbs 2012

Beginning Lesson Plan: Instructional Component

Approximate Time

Reading Decks (http://neuhaus.org/decks/ ) Show letter cards (FCRR, Activity P.002, Letter Cards) for quick drill for student to name.Give key words and sounds: I, t, p, n, s, a, l, d, f, h, g, o (can use Ron Yosimoto’s Primary Card Deck in file - Basic)Use irregular word deck (http://neuhaus.org/decks/ ): said, the, of, on. High Frequency Words might be used as well (FCRR, Part Five Activity Packet)

3 minutes Reading Decks – Standards listed above and

Phonemic Awareness –K.4, 1.4, 2.4

Irregular Word Deck and High Frequency Word Deck –1.6

Reading Rope: Word Recognition Strands

Reading Deck Cards

Letter Naming Deck

Letter Naming

Keyword and Sound Deck

Keyword and Sound Card

de - port - ment

de port ment

Affix and root can be created for morphology reading decks.

Approximate Time

Spelling Deck/DictationExample: Using a spelling deck (cards bearing letters and sounds introduced for reading), Procedure: - dictate sounds to student,the student: a) repeats the

sound(s), b) says the letter name(s), and c) writes them on a board or paper: short /i/, /t/, /p/, /n/, /s/, short /a/, /l/, /d/, /f/, /h/, /g/, /o/ and so on.

5 minutes Standards appropriate to the example: Phonemic Awareness –Standards Listed Above

Or the Standards applicable to the concept being assessed through the Dictation.

Teacher says: /k/

Students says: /k/ (sound), c, k, and final ck (letters)

Student writes: c, k, and final ck

This activity can be expanded to includediagraphs, diphthongs, or word parts. The most frequently used spelling will be targetedfirst.

S.O.SSimultaneous Oral Spelling

Teacher pronounces word (or phoneme)Student repeats word (or phoneme)Student isolates sounds (often using finger spelling)Student spells word (or phoneme) aloudStudent writes, naming each letter as he/she forms it or making

the sound of each phoneme Student reads word (or phoneme) aloud

Some teachers pronounce the word, use it in a sentence, and repeat the word before the student repeats and spells the word Often, when the student has completed word dictation, the instructor will have him/her read the entire list of words aloud.

Let’s practice together!

Approximate Time

Multisensory Introduction of Letter or ConceptExample: Provide multisensory introduction of digraph ng using guided discovery of sound, letters, key words, and mouth position.Discovery words might be: sing, sang, sting, ding.Reinforce with sky writing, handwriting, reading the sound, and spelling the sound.Possible concepts to introduce might be the syllable types, spelling patterns, and spelling

generalizations.

5 minutes Standards appropriate to the example: K.7, K.11, 1.5, 1.6, 1.11, 1.12, 2.5

Trace, Copy, Cover, Eyes Averted Procedure

• Trace the letter three times (verbalizing while writing)

• Copy the letter three times (verbalizing while writing)

• Write the letter three times without a written prompt (verbalizing while writing)

• Write the letter three times with eyes averted or closed (verbalizing while writing; circle the best one)

Syllables Types to Introduce:

Closed Syllables with Spelling Patterns – VC, CVC, CCVC, CVCC, CCVCC

Vowel-Consonant-EOpen SyllablesR-controlled SyllablesConsonant-le SyllablesVowel Team Syllables

Spelling Generalizations, and so on……

If students are able to recognize and read closed syllables, they will be able to read almost 50% of running text.

(Moats 2009)

A sequence for syllable instruction is present within the Virginia Standards of Learning Curriculum Frameworks in Grades One and Two.

Vowel Consonant E: http://youtu.be/TB0KGwTLkhc

Rabbit Rule (VCCV)

Examples:

rabbit, napkin, clutter, basket, litter, sudden

Animal Shapes for SyllableDivision Rules

Approximate Time

Reading Practice For Accuracy And FluencyExample: Students prepare and read orally closed-syllable words: hint, stand, tint, slop, split, spat, spin, snap, nips, plant. Dad lifts the sand in a tin pan. (Can use FCRR – Part Seven Activity Packet Syllable Patterns and Morpheme Patterns)Use this portion of the lesson for the syllable type studying, and combine with spelling patterns (Keystone - Lund and Cheatum, 2004).

5 – 10 minutes

Standardsappropriate to the example:

1.4, 1.6, 2.4, 2.5, 3.3

Reading Rope: Decoding/Spelling and Phonological Awareness Strands

Approximate Time

Spelling Example: Give warm up, with review of sounds to be spelled: short /i/, /t/, /s/, /a/, /l/, /f/, /h/.Review the Floss Rule (can use Ron Yosimoto’s worksheets found in Rules and Generalizations within file –Rules and Generalizations) and spell these words: sniff, tiff, staff, till, hill, spill.

5 – 10 minutes

Standards appropriate to the example: K.1, K.5, K.12 (spell phonetically), 1.1, 1.6, 1.12, 1.13,2.5, 2.13, 3.3. 3.4, 3.10, 4.8, 5.8

S.O.SSimultaneous Oral Spelling

Teacher pronounces word (or phoneme)Student repeats word (or phoneme)Student isolates sounds (often using finger spelling)Student spells word (or phoneme) aloudStudent writes, naming each letter or making the sound of each

phoneme in the word as he/she forms it Student reads word (or phoneme) aloud

Some teachers pronounce the word, use it in a sentence, and repeat the word before the student repeats and spells the word Often, when the student has completed word dictation, the instructor will have him/her read the entire list of words aloud.

Approximate Time

HandwritingExamples: 1) Students practice writing d on folded newsprint paper or regular paper. Students trace the letter three times while listening to guided stroke description: “Curve under, over, stop, back around, up, down, release.” Student make three copies, saying the letter name each time. 2) Students will incorporate this section within other sections of the lesson plan.

5 – 10 minutes

Standards appropriate to the example:

K.11, 3.8

Supports Reading Rope Strands

Cursive Writing is part of all multisensory approaches and

methods.

Cursive writing allows students to engage in the procedures and learning with movement.

Cursive writing has been said to assist with blending (Birsh, 2005 and 2011).

Cursive eliminates or lessens reversals.

Cursive promotes writing (handwriting) fluency (Birsh, 2005 and 2011).

Approximate Time

Comprehension and Listening StrategiesExample: Read “The Tortoise and the Hare” to students.Have the students retell the fable with graphic organizer for stories (simple story map).

10 minutes Standards appropriate to the example:

K.9, K.10, 1.9, 1.10 , .1, 2.8, 2.9, 3.5, 3.6, 4.5, 4.6, 5.5, 5.6

Reading Rope: Language Comprehension Strand

Decodable Text: http://youtu.be/EmI2jexBSK0

Retelling Strip Oliver 2011

(Adapted from Moreau/Fidrych 1994)

and other retellingdevices…

K.8, 1.1b, 1.9, 2.8 and so on….

Intermediate Lesson Plan: Instructional Component

Approximate Time

Extended Reading and Writing Goal is accuracy, fluency, and

comprehension. Students read from connected decodable text with controlled vocabulary that is geared to the students’ levels.

Students write sentences using vocabulary they are reading and spelling.

10 minutes 3.5, 3.6. 4.5, 4.6, 5.5, 5.6, 6.5, 6.6, 7.5, 7.6, 8.5, 8.6

Reading Rope: Language Comprehension Strand

The strategies for comprehending…..

Processes/Strategies: Connecting (SOLs K.9 to …… )Questioning (SOLs K.9 to …… )Predicting (SOLs K.9 to …..)Imaging (Visualizing) (SOLs 4.5g to ……)Inferring (SOLs 4.5h to …… )Determining importance (SOLs 2.8 to ….. )Synthesizing (SOLs 10.5g to ……. )

These skills begin early in the SOLs then build and combine through the 12th grade.

Hall, 2011

Approximate Time

Oral Language Practice and CompositionExample: Introduce vocabulary: boasted, plodding, patient.Have students find and discuss meanings for the descriptive words from the story. Use words in sentences, and enter words in the vocabulary section of their language notebook.

10 minutes Standards appropriate to the example:

K.8, 1.2, 1.7, 1.8, 1.11, 2.2, 2.6, 2.7, 3.1, 3.2, 3.4, 4.2, 4.4, 4.7, 5.4

Reading Rope: Word Recognition andLanguage Comprehension Strands

Nagy (2007) proposed that teaching morphological awareness and decoding in school may be the way to narrow the achievement gap for children whose families differ in education and income levels, as well as ethnic or racial backgrounds.

http://neuhaus.org/readingteachersnetwork/The Reading Teacher Network from Neuhaus in Texas

http://learningabledkids.com/reading/proven_reading_programs.htmLearning Abled Kids – Orton Gillingham Reading Programs

http://www.fcrr.org/for-educators/sca.aspFlorida Center for Reading Research – Student Center Activities

Teaching Tips for All Educators:

Give prompts and clues when students have phonological memory, retrieval, and naming problems….

• Write down key words, cues, and phrases;

• Use visual prompts and graphic organizers;

• Pose a “choice” question;

• Give the first sounds if you know the word for which the student is searching;

• Ask students to repeat words orally; and

• Review and summarize often (check for understanding).

Moats, 2009

Supplementary Aids/Services, and Testing Accommodations :

• Audio text/read aloud or audio version

• Note-taking assistance or record information provided for note-taking

• Provide visual cues and graphic organizers

• Extra time

• Systematic, explicit, instruction in reading

OSEP Ideas That Work -

https://www.osepideasthatwork.org/toolkit/accommodations_manual_b.asp

Understood.org –

https://www.understood.org/en/school-learning/partnering-with-childs-school/instructional-strategies/at-a-glance-classroom-accommodations-for-dyslexia

Assistive Technology

AIM VA -http://doe.virginia.gov/administrators/superintendents_memos/2015/004-15.shtml

Jamie Martin - http://www.atdyslexia.com/assistive-technology/

Dyslexia Help at University of Michigan-http://dyslexiahelp.umich.edu/tools/software-assistive-technology

LD Guidance Document from VDOE -http://www.doe.virginia.gov/special_ed/disabilities/learning_disability/learning_disabilities_guidelines.pdf, page 6

Organizations Involved with Dyslexia and Improved Reading for All Students:

Decoding Dyslexia Virginia

International Dyslexia Association

The Virginia Branch of the International Dyslexia Association

Yale Center for Dyslexia and Creativity

The Dyslexia Foundation

Society of Scientific Studies of Reading

dyslexia: insights and current understandingsaimvaseptember2015.pbworks.com/w/file/fetch... ·...

Documents

neurobiological basis of

the neurobiological alterations of ptsd

the neurobiological underpinnings of addiction

dyslexia parent workshop - richard clarke first school ·...

leadership behaviours - a neurobiological perspective

dyslexia: the details!...nov 08, 2016 · dyslexia is...

considerations for english learners with specific learning...

acceptance accommodation and attitude · 1/23/2019 ·...

neurobiological mechanisms of cannabinoid addiction

neurobiological basis of - pacfold€¦ · web viewalthough...

273 neurobiological roots thinking 00

dyslexia. dyslexia video rm rm

2 neurobiological basis of psychology

neurobiological foundations of an attribute model of...

dyslexia: insights and current...

assessment for reading difficulties and dyslexia · 4...

dyslexia: insights and current...

neurobiological bases of behavior

with dyslexia · living with dyslexia information for...

neurobiological basis of psychology