e463 research methodology lec ii
Post on 07-Apr-2018
225 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 1/28
Chapter 1: Human Inquiry and Science
E463 Research Methodology
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 2/28
Contents
y Introduction
y Looking for Reality
y The Foundations of Social Sciencey Some Dialectics of Social Research
y The Ethics of Social Research
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 3/28
Introduction
What is Science?
- Science is a method of inquiry
- A way of Knowing things about the world around us.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 4/28
Introductiony This course is about knowing things- not so much what we know as
how we know.
y How do we know things?
y
The basis of most knowledge is agreement.y We know most things through tradition and some things from
´experts.µ
y There are other ways of Knowing things.
y Through Direct Experience- through observations.
y When our experience conflicts with what everyone else knows,though, there is a good chance we·ll surrender our experience infavor of the agreement. (ex. FriedWorms)
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 5/28
Looking for Realityy How can you know what is real?
y Science offers an approach to both agreement reality andexperienced reality.
y Scientists have certain criteria that must be met before theywill accept the reality of something they have notexperienced personally.
y In general, a scientific assertion must have both logical andempirical support. It must make sense, and it must not
contradict observation.y So scientists accept an agreement reality BUT they have
standards for doing so.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 6/28
Ordinary Human Inquiryy We generally realize that future circumstances are somehow
caused or conditioned by present ones.
y People learn that such patterns of cause and effect areprobabilistic in nature. That is , the effects occur more often
when the causes occur than when the causes are absent- butnot always.
y In looking at ordinary human inquiry we need to distinguish between prediction and understanding. Often we can make a
prediction without understanding. And often, even if we donot understand why, we are willing to act on the basis of ademonstrated predictive ability.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 7/28
Sources of Agreed upon Knowledge
y Tradition
y Authority
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 8/28
Errors in Inquiry and some Solutions
y Inaccurate Observations
y Overgeneralization
y Selective Observationy Illogical Reasoning
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 9/28
What·s really real?
y The Premodern View
y The Modern View
y The Postmodern View
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 10/28
The Foundations of Social Science
y The two pillars of science are logic and observation.
y That is, a scientific understanding of the world must both
make sense and correspond to what we observe.
y Both elements are essential to science and relate to the three
major aspects of social scientific enterprise: theory, data
collection, and data analysis.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 11/28
The Foundations of Social Science
y scientific theory deals with the logical aspect of science,
y whereas data collection deals with the observational aspect.
y Data analysis looks for patterns in observations and, where
appropriate, compares what is logically expected with what isactually observed.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 12/28
Theory, Not Philosophy or Belief
y Today, social theory has to do with what is, not with what
should be.
y Although modern social researchers may mix them from
time to time, as scientists they focus on how things actuallyare and why.
y This means that scientific theory³and, more broadly,
science itself³cannot settle debates about values. (example:
Capitalism vs. Socialism)
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 13/28
Theory, Not Philosophy or Belief
y Social science, then, can help us know only what is and why.
y We can use it to determine what ought to be only when
people agree on the criteria for deciding what outcomes are
better others³an agreement that seldom occurs.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 14/28
Social Regularities
y Social research aims to find patterns of regularity in social
life.
y Despite many examples, however, social affairs do exhibit a
high degree of regularity that can be revealed by research andexplained by theory.
y The tremendous number of formal norms in society create a
considerable degree of regularity.
y
Three objections are sometimes raised in regard to suchsocial regularities.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 15/28
Social Regularities
y First, some of the regularities may seem trivial.
y Second, contradictory cases may be cited,y And third, it may be argued that the people involved in the
regularity could upset the whole thing if they wanted to.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 16/28
The Charge of Triviality
y Stouffer and his study on soldier·s morale inWWII.
y Documenting the obvious is a valuable function of any
science, physical or social.
y
Charles Darwin coined the phrase f ool's ex perimen t todescribe much of his own research³ research in which he
tested things that everyone else 'already knew."
y As Darwin understood, all too often, the obvious turns out
to be wrong; thus, apparent triviality is not a legitimateobjection to any scientific endeavor.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 17/28
W hat about Exceptions?
y The objection that there are always exceptions to any social
regularity does not mean that the regularity itself is unreal
or unimportant.
y
The pattern still exists. Social regularities, in other words,are probabilistic patterns, and they are no less real simply
because some cases don't fit the general pattern.
y The social scientist makes a probabilistic prediction-³that
women overall arc likely to earn less than men. Once a
pattern like this is observed, the social scientist has grounds
for asking why it exists.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 18/28
People Could Interfere
y The objection that observed social regularities could be upset
through the conscious will of the actors is not a serious
challenge to social science, even though there does not seem
to be a parallel situation in the physical sciences.
y Although disturbances may occur like; (examples)
y But these things do not happen often enough to seriously
threaten the observation of social regularities.
y
Social regularities, then, do exist, and social scientists candetect them and observe their effects.When these
regularities change over time, social scientists can observe
and explain those changes.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 19/28
A ggregates, Not Individuals
y The regularities of social life that social scientists study
generally reflect the collective behavior of many individuals.
y Although social scientists often study motivations that affect
individuals, the individual as such is seldom the subject of social science.
y Instead, social scientists create theories about the nature of
group, rather than individual, life.
y
Similarly, the objects of their research are typicallyaggregates, or collections, rather than individuals.
y Consider the birthrate, for example.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 20/28
A ggregates, Not IndividualsTABLE 1-1 Birthrates,United States: 1980-1999
Year Birth Rate Year Birth Rate
1980 16.0 1S.8 15.9 15.6 15.6
15.8 15.6 15.7 16.0 16.41987 15.7
1981 15.8 1988 16.0
1982 15.9 1989 16.4
1983 15.6 1990 16.6
1984 15.6 1991 16.3
1985 15.8 1992 15.9
1986 15.6 1993 15.5
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 21/28
A ggregates, Not Individuals
y It becomes obvious that the relative consistency of the U.S.
birthrate over time is not a function of human biology. The
answer, rather, lies in the realm of social structure and
culture.
y Social scientific theories, then, typically deal with aggregated,
not individual, behavior.
y Their purpose is to explain why aggregate patterns of
behavior are so regular even when the individuals
participating in them may change over time.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 22/28
A ggregates, Not Individuals
y It could be said that social scientists don't even seek to
explain people. They try to understand the systems in which
people operate, the systems that explain why people do what
they do. The elements in such a system are not people but
variables.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 23/28
A Variable Language
y Variables: Logical groupings of attributes. The variable
gender is made up of the attributes mal e and f emal e.
y Social researchers are interested in understanding the system
of variables that causes a particular attitude to be strong inone instance and weak in another.
y Social research, then, involves the study of variables and their
relationships.
y
Social theories are written in a language oi variables, andpeople get involved only as the "carriers" of those variables.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 24/28
A Variable Language
y Variables, in turn, have what social researchers call attributes
or values. Attributes are characteristics or qualities that
describe an object³in this case, a person.
y
Examples include f emal e, Asian,al ienated, conserv ative, dishonest,
intell i gent,and f armer.
y Anything you might say to describe yourself or someone else
involves an attribute.
y
Variables, on the other hand, are logical groupings of attributes. Thus, for example, mal e and f emal e are attributes,
and sex or gender is the variable composed of those two
attributes.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 25/28
A Variable Language
y The relationship between attributes and variables lies at the
heart of both description and explanation in science.
y For example, we might describe a college class in terms of
the variable gender
by reporting the observed frequencies of the attributes mal e and f emal e.
y Sometimes the meanings of the concepts that lie behind
social science concepts are immediately dear.
y
Other times they aren't
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 26/28
A Variable Language
y The relationship between attributes and variables is more
complicated in the case of explanation and gets to the heart
of the variable language of scientific theory.
y Here we will discuss a simple example:
The relationship between Education and Prejudice.
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 27/28
A Variable Language
8/6/2019 E463 Research Methodology Lec II
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/e463-research-methodology-lec-ii 28/28
top related