future technologies for storage networks v0.3 - post · • networking • proxy caching •...

Future technologies for storage networks

Shravan PargalDirector, Compellent Consulting

2

Agenda• Storage applications• Application requirements• Available technology solutions• Who is winning today?• What will determine the winning storage

technology of tomorrow?

And, NO object storage in this talk!

3

Storage applications• Data base applications

• What are they used for in a business?

• Email• Is it critical to a business?

• File and print sharing• Document archiving• “Backup”

Audience question – what % of storage today is email storage?

4

Application categories• Business processing:

• Enterprise resource planning (ERP)

• Customer relationship management (CRM)

• Online transaction processing (OLTP)

• Batch • Decision support:

• Data warehousing/data mart

• Data analysis/data mining

• Collaborative: • Email • Workgroup

• Application development • IT infrastructure:

• File and print • Networking • Proxy caching • Security • Systems management

• Web infrastructure: • Web serving • Streaming media

• Technical -Scientific/engineering (compute only)

Source IDC: 2002

5

Storage market

Source IDC: 2002

Technical3%

Other3%

Business Processing

25%

IT Infrastructure

24%

Decision support

19%

Application development

10%

Collaborative10%

Web Infrastructure

6%

Application requirements

7

Application requirements…

• Focus of Databases• What is the end user application?

• Order entry• Data mining• OLTP

• All require efficient block I/O• Benchmarked using transactions per

second

Requirements depend on the type of data in the database and the method of

access.

8

…More requirements• Latency

• How long are you willing to wait at the ATM machine?

• Availability• What happens if the ATM is unable to connect to

its database?• What happens if a patient’s allergy record is

unavailable during surgery?

• Scalability• How much storage do you have today, and how

much will it be in 3 or 6 months?• Does the existing storage solution scale?

9

FinallyDoes the user or administrator of the

application know the answer to the following:

• What is the data throughput required? • MB/s

• How important are transactions per second metrics? • Input/Outputs per second

Storage architectureoptions

11

Architecture Options• Networked Storage – NAS and SAN

• NAS• Very flexible on front end protocol options (FC, iSCSI, InfiniBand

available today)• Currently only FC on the backend

• SAN• FC• IP

» iSCSI» iFCP» FCIP

• InfiniBand

• Direct attached storage• SCSI• ATA

12

Technology Options• Storage Virtualization

• In-band• Out-of-band

• Why is this interesting?• Why is it difficult to do?• What are the problems with storage

virtualization?

13

Network Attached Storage (NAS)

NAS Filer

Application Server

Clients

EthernetLAN

Storage Server

14

Storage Area Network (SAN)

Servers StorageClients

Fibre ChannelSAN

Win 2K

Unix

Novell

Tape

Disk

Disk

EthernetLAN

Disk

15

iSCSI, iFCP and FCIP Protocol Stacks

IP IP IP

TCP TCP

New Serial SCSI FCP FC-4

TCP

FC Lower Layers

FCP FC-4

iSCSI iFCP FCIP

Standard SCSI Command Set

Operating System

Applications

Copyright © 2001, Storage Networking Industry Association

16

Direct attached drives (DAS)

IDE or SCSI

Internal disk drive(s)

Useful link: http://www.pcmech.com/hdindex.htm

17

Who is winning today• Direct Attached Storage - 66.4 % of all

installed storage in 2001

• Network Attached Storage – 7.4 % of all installed storage in 2001

• Storage Area Networks – 26.1 % of all installed storage in 2001

Source IDC: 2002

18

Installed Storage Revenue

19

Installed Storage Data

20

Storage Consolidation

LAN

NTServers

Tape Drive

RAID

Tape Drive

RAID

Tape Drive

RAID

NTServers

RAID(Email)

TapeLibrary

Mission-Critical RAID(Oracle, ERP DB)

SAN

Switch Switch

SwitchSwitch

21

Interconnect Technologies

Knowing that the strengths of a technology don’t guarantee its success, here are some nice technologies …

22

Fibre Channel• Low Latency• Immunity from congestion• In-order delivery• Guaranteed delivery• 2 Gigabit per second pipe• Dominant server to storage connection

What percentage of the 2 Gb/s bandwidth is used?

23

IP• TCP provides in-order delivery• Most ethernet switches can now provide

some level of immunity from congestion –particularly in a LAN environment

• Higher layer protocols provide delivery guarantees

• 1 Gigabit per second bandwidth• Dominant client to server connection

What percentage of the bandwidth is used?

24

Reality check for IP Storage• Fibre Channel

• Will not disappear any time soon• Market will continue to grow and expand

• IP will provide a way to connect FC islands• Today with FCIP, iFCP and iSCSI

• iSCSI is slowly maturing• Plug Fests to test standard compliance• Final specification just completed - February 2003

iSCSI provides end-to-end native IP Storage

25

Future Network

Servers StorageClients

SAN

Win 2K

Unix

Novell

Tape

Disk

Disk

LAN

Disk

Single management domain

There is a convergence of network and data administration functions

Trumps

27

Hidden agendas• Who is backing the technology?

• FC – FC switch and adapter incumbents• Brocade, EMC, Emulex, QLogic, HDS, IBM,

Sun, HP• iFCP – Nishan and others• FCIP – Cisco, Brocade and others• iSCSI – Cisco, IBM, EMC and others

Fibre Channel incumbents stand to lose as new IP based technologies gain acceptance

The new players need IP based technologies to enter the storage space

28

Tomorrow’s winners

• What is going to decide who the winners are?• Open systems compliant• Resilient• Flexible deployment options• Affordable as the solution scales• Enables server consolidation

29

Conclusions• Better

• More features – what is the baseline feature-set requirement?

• Faster• More IOPs - Not more MB/s

• Cheaper• Commodity pricing – like ethernet

• Easy to use – Simplify!

The best technologies don’t always triumph over other contenders – remember VHS v.s.

Betamax

30

Questions?

Shravan Pargal

Director, Compellent ConsultingCompellent Technologies Inc.

Shravan.Pargal@compellent.com612-850-5351

www.compellent.com