identity and context : people and personal data

Kaliya

EduServe, Birmingham, UK November 6th 2012

Co-Founder, Co-Producer, Co-Facilitator, Internet Identity Workshop Founder, Executive Director, Personal Data Ecosystem Consortium

Internet Identity Workshop

Personal Data Ecosystem Consortium

What are the different contexts that you navigate in your life?

Roles?

Think about them write a list down on your paper.

Aspects of Self?

Persona 1

Persona 2

Context 1 Context 2

Persona 1

Persona 2

Context

Context 1 Context 2

Persona

CONTEXTS Professional Life

Student Life

Civic Life

Purchaser

Personal Life

Family Life

Activist/Political Life

Religious Life

Identity is socially constructed and contextual.

? Anonymous ?

?

? ? Per-Post Per-Session

Anonymous

? Anonymous

ü Verified ü ü ü

Verified

ü ü ü Documentation In Person

Verification Biometric Capture

? Anonymous

One Site Multi-Site

Self-Asserted Verified Socially Validated

ü Pseudonymous

? Anonymous

One Site Multi-Site

Self-Asserted Socially Validated

Verified ü

Pseudonymous

? Anonymous

One Site Multi-Site

Self-Asserted Socially Validated

Verified ü

Pseudonymous

? Anonymous

One Site Multi-Site

Self-Asserted Socially Validated

Verified ü

Pseudonymous

? ü

Verified Anonymous Attributes

Over 18 years Woman Voter

CA Congressional District 9

Ms.Sue Donna DOB = 1/21/1982 1823 6th Ave. Alameda, CA

? Anonymous

One Site Multi-Site

Self-Asserted Socially Validated

Verified ü

Pseudonymous

ü ü

Limited Liability Persona

Government Efforts

USA = NSITC & IDESG

We’ll see how it goes.

UK leveraging

OIX Framework Listing Service

? Anonymous

ü Verified ü ü ü

Verified

ü ü ü Documentation In Person

Verification Biometric Capture

? Anonymous

One Site Multi-Site

Self-Asserted Socially Validated

Verified ü

Pseudonymous

ü ü

Limited Liability Persona

Why Does this Matter?

Individuals move across contexts. http://cmykern.com/?p=1112

Contexts the Individual does not want linked (without their knowledge and consent).

Why James Chartrand Wears Women’s Underpants

http://www.copyblogger.com/james-chartrand-underpants/

Identity is socially constructed and contextual.

More data then ever.

Less control then ever.

Do Not Track

Yeah! Not

Personal Cloud

PersonalData

Analytics

INDIVIDUAL

DATA

ContextShared & PersonalDevices

Roles/Persone

What if we collected our own data in our own dossiers?

What kind of data your students/readers generate in their lives from what devices?

Group Brainstorm

Diagram is in the appendix of the latest WEF Rethinking Personal Data

Personal Cloud

PersonalData

Analytics

INDIVIDUAL

DATA

ContextShared & PersonalDevices

Roles/Persone

Peer to Peer

Personal Data Ecosystem Models

VRM

Personal Data Ecosystem Models

Infomediary Markets Personal Data Ecosystem Models

Data Aggregation Personal Data Ecosystem Models

Collaborative Filtering Personal Data Ecosystem Models

State secondary school

Exam Board

University Admissions Service (UCAS) Learner

record service

HE Stats Agency

Employer

SLC Student Loan Company

University(s)

National Pupil Db

o Complex data flows

o Low data quality

o Expensive to operate

o User not in control

o Privacy destroying

Current UK education architecture is ‘organisation-centric’

State secondary school

Exam Board

University Admissions Service (UCAS)

HE Stats Agency

Employer

SLC Student Loan Company

University(s)

National Pupil Db

o  Simpler

o  Cheaper (?)

o  Higher data quality

o  User in control of data flows

o  Privacy enhancing

Future architecture could be ‘student-centric’

Personal Data Ecosystem Models

Personal Data Ecosystem Models

Information Brokers compete to serve individuals

Service Provider Acquirers compete to serve organisations

eXtensible Circle of Trust -Visa-like body. Superset of UKAMF

supply of software and services

Characterising Authorities issue role certificates to SPs

Authentication Service Providers

Individuals

UK Based Companies developing Personal Cloud Services

Allfiled Solutions build white label personal data services for large organisations or individuals wishing to enter the space: •  Launched in 2007 •  Rich, deep personal

data architecture •  Fully ‘identity enabled’ •  Members of PDEC and

The Respect Network •  Several upcoming

launches in UK and beyond

Personal Data Ecosystem Consortium

Internet Identity Workshop

May 7-9 Mountain View

February Vienna

ID Unconference