internet measurement initiatives in the wisconsin advanced internet lab

Internet Measurement Initiatives in the Wisconsin Advanced Internet Lab

Paul Barford

Computer Science Department

University of Wisconsin – Madison

Spring, 2003

pb@cs.wisc.edu 2

Talk Objectives

• Motivate and describe Wisconsin Advanced Internet Lab (WAIL)– Internal lab environment– External lab environment

• Provide some detail on three current projects– Anomaly detection and characterization– Distributed intrusion monitoring– Understanding packet loss

pb@cs.wisc.edu 3

Motivation for New Tools• Any area of scientific research is limited by the tools

available for experimental study– “If your only tool is a hammer then everything looks

like a nail”• 2001 NRC report: “network research community is in

danger of ossification due to strictures of experimental systems”– Challenge: “Capturing a day in the life of the Internet”

• New experimental tools can open up areas of research that have not previously been accessible

pb@cs.wisc.edu 4

An Internet Instance Lab • A hands-on test environment designed to recreate

paths and conditions identical to those in the Internet from end-to-end-through-core– Requires large amount of routing and end host equipment

• Network and host equipment able to recreate (not emulate) a wide range of services, configurations and traffic conditions– Complete instrumentation of end-to-end paths

– Deployment of disruptive prototypes

pb@cs.wisc.edu 5

Key Challenges

• Design• Configurations and management• Traffic generation• Propagation delay• Validation

pb@cs.wisc.edu 6

The Wisconsin Advanced Internet Lab

• Our realization of an IIL• Developed over past 18 months by UW/Cisco team• Supported by $3.5M equipment grant from Cisco and

UW matching funds– Used to purchase over 75 pieces of networking equipment

• Phase 1 nearing completion => Abilene recreation• Other partners: EMC, Spirent, Intel, Fujitsu, Sun• Research initiatives in many areas…

pb@cs.wisc.edu 7

External Environment• Essential complement to internal environment• Existing infrastructure

– DOMINO systems (1 class A + 2 class B’s + Dshield)

– Surveyor + WAWM systems (~70 nodes)• New database and front end by summer ‘03

• Partnerships and other available systems– Condor/Grid Infrastructures

• Passive flow measurements– FlowScan data from UW, Internet2, others…

pb@cs.wisc.edu 8

Project 1: Detecting Anomalies in IP Flows

• Motivation: Anomaly detection remains difficult• Objective: Improve understanding of traffic anomalies• Approach: Multiresolution analysis of data set that

includes IP flow, SNMP and an anomaly catalog• Method: Integrated Measurement Analysis Platform for

Internet Traffic (IMAPIT)• Results: Identify anomaly characteristics using wavelets

and develop new method for exposing short-lived events

pb@cs.wisc.edu 9

Our Data Sets• Consider anomalies in IP flow and SNMP data

– Collected at UW border router (Juniper M10)– Archive of ~6 months worth of data (packets, bytes, flows)– Includes catalog of anomalies (after-the-fact analysis)

• Group observed anomalies into four categories– Network anomalies (41)

• Steep drop offs in service followed by quick return to normal behavior– Flash crowd anomalies (4)

• Steep increase in service followed by slow return to normal behavior– Attack anomalies (46)

• Steep increase in flows in one direction followed by quick return to normal behavior– Measurement anomalies (18)

• Short-lived anomalies which are not network anomalies or attacks

pb@cs.wisc.edu 10

Multiresolution Analysis• Wavelets provide a means for describing time series

data that considers both frequency and time– Powerful means for characterizing data with sharp spikes

and discontinuities

– Using wavelets can be quite tricky

• We use tools developed at UW which together make up IMAPIT– FlowScan software

– The IDR Framenet software

pb@cs.wisc.edu 11

Ambient IP Flow Traffic

pb@cs.wisc.edu 12

Flow Traffic During DoS Attacks

pb@cs.wisc.edu 13

Deviation Score for Three Anomalies

pb@cs.wisc.edu 14

Project 2: Coordinated Intrusion Detection

• Motivation: Intrusion detection is a moving target• Objective: Coordinate intrusion monitoring between

multiple sites around the Internet• Approach: Share data from firewalls, NIDS and tarpits

(on unused IP space)• Method: Distributed Overlay for Monitoring Internet

Outbreaks (DOMINO)• Results: Blacklists can be rapidly generated, false

positives can be substantially lowered, new outbreaks can be easily identified

pb@cs.wisc.edu 15

DOMINO: A new approach to DNIDS

• Partnership with dshield.org– 1600 firewall and NIDS logs

• Tarpits– Active monitor of unused IP space– 1 class A (this week), 2 class B’s

• A protocol for node participation, data sharing and alert clustering– Chord-based overlay network– Extension of Intrusion Detection Message Exchange

Format– Various clustering methods

pb@cs.wisc.edu 16

Marginal Utility of Adding Nodes

pb@cs.wisc.edu 17

SQL-Sapphire Analysis

pb@cs.wisc.edu 18

Project 3: Understanding Packet Loss

• Motivation: Many of the most basic aspects of packet loss are not understood– Where, when, how long, how often?

• Focus: Developing a comprehensive understanding of packet loss in the Internet

• Approach: Combine understanding of protocols and queue behavior to create a probe train which can accurately measure delay and loss.

• Implications: End-to-end tools for pin-pointing loss, better transport protocols, better network management for congestion

pb@cs.wisc.edu 19

Active versus Passive Loss Measures

• Hypothesis: Active measures of loss are correlated with passive measures of loss

• Assessment in Abilene– SNMP loss measures on all backbone routers– Active probes via Ping/Zing in Surveyor nodes at

10Hz, 20Hz and 100Hz– Tests in full mesh over one month period

pb@cs.wisc.edu 20

Result: Active <> Passive

pb@cs.wisc.edu 21

Summary

• Both internal lab building initiatives and external measurement initiatives in WAIL

• Internal facilities are intended to be open

• We are seeking partnerships in external measurement projects.– DOMINO in particular