irm - a comparative analysis of three methods integrated resource management

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

A tool to inform sustainable city planning

Cole Roberts, PE, LEED AP

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | February 4, 2010

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Outline

Arup

IRMApproach

IRM Tool

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Arup

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

global | integrated | employee-owned | multidisciplinary

Arup Background

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Principal Fields of Activity

Building Engineering

Sustainability & GHG Consulting

LEED Consulting

Civil Engineering

Energy & Resources Engineering

Integrated Resource Planning

Infrastructure

Transportation Planning

Information Technology

Smart Grid & Information Architecture

Acoustics / Vibration Consulting

Advanced Technology

Risk Assessment

Environmental Consulting

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

the integration process and the interdependence of

all the professions involved, the creative nature of

planning and engineering, the value of innovation

and the social purpose of design.

Total Planning = Sustainability

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Collaborations

• Clinton Climate Positive Projects

• C40 Memorandum of Understanding

• World Economic Forum

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Arup

IRMApproach

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Urban Metabolism

“Organic” model for thinking about material and energy flows in cities dates to 1965 (Wolman, A.)(1965). The metabolism of cities. Scientific American, 179-190.

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Land Use

ScheduleSocial

Water

Waste waterPassenger

Transport

Agricultural

production

(External

Area)

Biomass / Biofuel

production

(External Area)

Consumption

(Food,

goods, etc)

Freight

movement

(Logistics)

Waste

management

Energy

Tonnes of

goods moved

Tonnes of

waste

moved

Energy recovery

from tonnes /

composition

waste

incineration(?)

Employment:

Recycling(??)

Employment generated

(external): Agricultural

production

Employment generated

(external): Biomass

production

(a) Supply

of housing

Passenger

Transport

distance

(based on

density)

Freight

transport

distance (based

on density)

Additional

Land Area for

Food

production

(a) Employment

demand

(b) Social infrastructure

demandReduction in

potable demand

through rainwater

harvest

POPULATION

Per capita

energy

demand excl.

transport /

logistics

Potable water

demand

Non-potable

water demand

(treated

wastewater)

Reduction

in potable

water

demand

through

recycling

Production of

sewage

effluent

Energy

demand

by type

Travel

demand

Demand for

consumables

(food, etc)

Additional

Land Area for

Biomass

production

Energy for freight

movement

Fuel source –

energy

supply

Fuel source – energy

supply (rice husk)

Reduction in

energy demand

through embedded

renewables

Generation of

biogas

Waste

output

Wind

Turbines

Energy

from Wind

Land area

required for

turbines

Urban Metabolism

Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

WATERENERGY

TRANSPORT

CARBON

SOCIETY

ECONOMY

MATERIALWASTE

LANDSCAPE

WEATHER

HUMAN

COMFORT

RATING

SYSTEMS

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Beyond VMT in Land Use

In One Project:

VMT related GHG reductions: 46%

Building energy related GHG reductions: 54% (i.e. greater than

the VMT related emissions reductions).

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Beyond VMT in Land Use

In One Project:

VMT related GHG reductions: 46%

Building energy related GHG reductions: 54% (i.e. greater than

the VMT related emissions reductions).

…and this did not include further benefits from embodied GHG

in the improved water and waste systems (often better in infill

locations) or the protected bio-mass sequestered in

undeveloped alternative sites such as prime ag land and

watersheds.

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Acknowledge

problems

“We’re wasting

resources. Our

reputation is at risk.”

Ad hoc attention to

sustainability issues.

Progress towards best practice sustainability

Trajectory

No

attention

“Just get the

job done”

Design

principles

“We design individual

strategies, each with

sustainability

elements.”

Management

process

“We use integrated,

holistic design to

optimise

sustainability”

Normal practice Best practice

Early Adopter Market Leader Global LeaderLegal Compliance

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Rational & Complete

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Significance and Control

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Quantitative Support – IRM: Modeling

A holistic quantitative model for

improved understanding of urban

systems and the impact of planning

decisions

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

waste material

s

watertransportationenergy carbonland use

Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

Energy

consumption

CO2

emissions

(indirect,

direct,

mobile)

Waste

generated

& diverted

Co

mp

os

itio

nG

en

era

tio

n

Lan

d u

se

dem

an

d

Em

issio

n r

ate

s

Em

issio

n f

acto

rs,

trip

le

ng

th, %

Wa

ter

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

rate

s

De

sig

n lif

e, m

ate

ria

l

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

Su

pp

ly

Embodied

Carbon in

Materials

VMTs

compare baseline

and design across

multiple indicators

compare baseline

with design

compare

alternatives

compare with comparable

everyday items (e.g. waste

generation measured in # of

garbage bins)

La

nd

tak

e D

en

sit

y

Un

its

Water

consumption/

wastewater

generation

detect “hotspots”

of resource

consumption

across the plan

The IRM Model

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

waste material

s

watertransportationenergy carbonland use

Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

Energy

consumption

CO2

emissions

(indirect,

direct,

mobile)

Waste

generated

& diverted

Co

mp

os

itio

nG

en

era

tio

n

Lan

d u

se

dem

an

d

Em

issio

n r

ate

s

Em

issio

n f

acto

rs,

trip

le

ng

th, %

Wa

ter

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

rate

s

De

sig

n lif

e, m

ate

ria

l

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

Su

pp

ly

Embodied

Carbon in

Materials

VMTs

compare baseline

and design across

multiple indicators

compare baseline

with design

compare

alternatives

compare with comparable

everyday items (e.g. waste

generation measured in # of

garbage bins)

La

nd

tak

e D

en

sit

y

Un

its

Water

consumption/

wastewater

generation

detect “hotspots”

of resource

consumption

across the plan

The IRM Model

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

waste material

s

watertransportationenergy carbonland use

Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

Energy

consumption

CO2

emissions

(indirect,

direct,

mobile)

Waste

generated

& diverted

Co

mp

os

itio

nG

en

era

tio

n

Lan

d u

se

dem

an

d

Em

issio

n r

ate

s

Em

issio

n f

acto

rs,

trip

le

ng

th, %

Wa

ter

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

rate

s

De

sig

n lif

e, m

ate

ria

l

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

Su

pp

ly

Embodied

Carbon in

Materials

VMTs

compare baseline

and design across

multiple indicators

compare baseline

with design

compare

alternatives

compare with comparable

everyday items (e.g. waste

generation measured in # of

garbage bins)

La

nd

tak

e D

en

sit

y

Un

its

Water

consumption/

wastewater

generation

detect “hotspots”

of resource

consumption

across the plan

The IRM Model

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

waste material

s

watertransportationenergy carbonland use

Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

Energy

consumption

CO2

emissions

(indirect,

direct,

mobile)

Waste

generated

& diverted

Co

mp

os

itio

nG

en

era

tio

n

Lan

d u

se

dem

an

d

Em

issio

n r

ate

s

Em

issio

n f

acto

rs,

trip

le

ng

th, %

Wa

ter

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

rate

s

De

sig

n lif

e, m

ate

ria

l

co

nsu

mp

tio

n

Su

pp

ly

Embodied

Carbon in

Materials

VMTs

compare baseline

and design across

multiple indicators

compare baseline

with design

compare

alternatives

compare with comparable

everyday items (e.g. waste

generation measured in # of

garbage bins)

La

nd

tak

e D

en

sit

y

Un

its

Water

consumption/

wastewater

generation

detect “hotspots”

of resource

consumption

across the plan

The IRM Model

Optimized and Informed Planning

- Plan evolution

- Performance

optimization

IRM

modelDevelop

strategies

Refine

strategies

IRM

model

Optimize

Strategies

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

GIS Integration

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Greenhouse Gases and Emissions

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Arup

IRMApproach

IRM Tool

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Projects

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Concord Naval Weapon Station

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Concord Naval Weapon Station

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Concord Naval Weapon Station

Transportation

Economics

• Financial Feasibility

Nevada Institution

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Nevada Institution

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Nevada Institution

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Nevada Institution

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Nevada Institution

Long Island 2035 Sustainability Plan

• Evaluation of “alternative futures” for a

region of 3 million people

• Analysis of existing and future:

• Land use patterns

• Resource consumption

• Government regulations

• Practices and policies

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUPSlide 58

Summary

Quantitative and integrated approach to sustainable

development and design

Outputs for Scope 1, 2 and 3 Carbon emissions classified by

WRI protocol

Outputs for density, waste, energy, water & wastewater

Provides output in non-technical language (marketability)

“How many worlds will an urban future need?”

Arup Drivers of Change Cards, Urbanization Set, 2008

Spatially-linked Integrated Resource Management (IRM)

New Partners for Smart Growth 2010 | Seattle, WA | January 2010 | © ARUP

Acknowledgements

Engin Ayaz, Aidan Hughes, Jake Levitas for co-authoring the presentation

Adam Friedberg, Andrew Egleton, Damien McCloud, Jessen Page, Mark Shorett, Sarah

Gillhespy, and numerous other Arup consultants, designers, engineers and planners for

their contribution to the development of the IRM approach and its use on various projects.

All material © of