is fresh blood better than old blood ?. 1667 – jean baptiste denis

Is Fresh Blood better than Old Blood ?

1667 – Jean Baptiste Denis

First successful human-human transfusion

Early 1800’s

Won the 1930 Nobel Peace Prize

Isolated the A, B, & O blood types.

Type AB blood was identified two years

later.

1900 – Karl Landsteiner

Recruit Transfuse blood 

Screen Donor Pretransfusion Testing

Collect & Prepare Monitor & evaluate

Infections/disease tests Medical Decision to transfuse 

Blood Safety

Transfusion Safety

Transfusion Safety in the Hospital Transfusion Sept 2003

P latelet Units T rans fus ed

273

167164

95

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

2004 2005 2006 2007

Uni

ts T

rans

fuse

d

Cost of Platelet Transfusions

$131,040

$45,600

$-

$20,000

$40,000

$60,000

$80,000

$100,000

$120,000

$140,000

2004 2005 2006 2007

$85,440 reduced cost

Red Blood Cells

Problems with stored pRBC’s

1. Reduced ability of Hgb to release bound oxygen at tissue level (2,3 DPG)

2,3 DPG levels become undetectable after two weeks of

storage. Levels are restored within 72 hours after transfusion

Does red blood cell storage affect clinical outcome? When in doubt, do the experiment. Transfusion Vol 49 July 2009

Problems with stored pRBC’s

1. Reduced ability of Hgb to release bound oxygen at tissue level (2,3 DPG).

2. Reduced RBC deformability = potential to block capillary beds

RBC squeezing through a capillary bed

Problems with stored pRBC’s

1. Reduced ability of Hgb to release bound oxygen at tissue level (2,3 DPG)..

2. Reduced RBC deformability = potential to block capillary beds

3. Storage lesion (age dependent defect) = potential to block capillary beds

More Is Known About the Risks of Blood Transfusion Than the

Benefits!

Problems with stored pRBC’s

1. Reduced ability of Hgb to release bound oxygen at tissue level (2,3 DPG)

2. Reduced RBC deformability = potential to block capillary beds

3. Storage lesion (age dependent defect) = potential to block capillary beds

4. Activation of recipients immune system

Transfusions & Infection

Each unit of blood increases the risk of a nosocomial infection by up to 50%!

Transfusion increases the risk of postoperative infections after cardiovascular surgery J Am Coll Surg 2006 Jan;202

An alternative scoring system to predict risk for surgical site infection complicaating coronary artery bypass graft surgery Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol 2007 Oct;

Transfusion of red cells is associated with increased incidence of bacterial infection after colorectal surgery; a prospective study Transfusion Feb 2003

Impact of allogenic packed red blood cell transfusion on nosocomial infection rates in the critically ill patient Crit Care Med 2002 Vol 30 #10

Transfusion Practice and Blood Stream Infections in Critically Ill Patients Chest 2005:127

Blood transfusions correlate with infections in trauma patients in a dose-dependant manner Am Surg 2002:68

838 ICU patients randomi

zed into one of the following strategies:

1.Restrictive (transfusion for Hgb < 7g/dl)

2.Liberal (transfusion for Hgb < 10 g/dl)

TRICC Trial Results

Complication Restrictive Incidence Liberal Incidence

All Cardiac morbidities 13.2% 21%

Myocardial Infarction 0.7% 2.9%

ARDS 7.7% 11.4%

Pulmonary Edema 5.3% 10.7%

30 day Mortality 18.7% 23.3%

A Multicenter, Randomized, Controlled Clinical Trial of Transfusion Requirements in Critical Care – Hebert et al New England Journal of Medicine 1999

Blood Transfusion MorbidityStudy of 12,000 CAB patients at Cleveland Clinic

Post-Op Complication Non-Transfused patients Transfused patients

New onset of renal failure requiring dialysis

0% 1.81%

Post-op ventilator support > 72 hours

.44% 9.14%

Serious post-op infection (includes sepsis and mediastinitis)

.24% 5.03%

Cardiac Morbidity(Includes Low Cardiac Index (< 1.8), high dose inotropic support > 4 hrs, post-op MI with IABP or VAD)

.05% 3.03%

Neurologic Morbidity .37% 2.41%

Morbidity and mortality risk associated with red blood cell and blood-component transfusion in isolated coronary artery bypass grafting – Koch, et al. ,Critical Care Medicine 2006

Blood Transfusion MorbidityStudy of 12,000 CAB patients at Cleveland Clinic

Morbidity and mortality risk associated with red blood cell and blood-component transfusion in isolated coronary artery bypass grafting – Koch, et al. ,Critical Care Medicine 2006

“Transfusion is the single factor most reliably associated with increased

postoperative morbid events. Each unit of red cells transfused is associated with incrementally increased risk for adverse

outcome.”

How low can we go?

First proposed in 1942 and based onstudies that defined “peak” oxygen

delivery in animals

10/30 Rule*

*Keep Hgb at 10gm and Hct at 30%

10/30 Rule*

*Keep Hgb at 10gm and Hct at 30%

How low can we go?

• In animal studies, ECG ST segment changes are observed once Hgb falls below 5 g/dL

• Both human and animal studies have demonstrated that Hgb’s < 3 g/dL are “maximally life-threatening.”

Time course and etiology of death in patients with severe anemia Transfusion Vol 49 July 2009

Is Fresh Blood better than Old Blood ?

6,000 patients – 20,000 units of blood

Compared “newer blood” (14 days or less of storage to “older blood” (>14 days of storage)

Duration of Red-Cell Storage and Complications after Cardiac Surgery The New England Journal of Medicine 2008

HIGHER RATES OF:

1. Mortality

2. Prolonged ventilation

3. Renal Failure

4. Sepsis

FDA Requirements

1.Hemolysis must be no greater than 1% at the end of storage, and

2.RBC recovery rates must be greater than 75% one day after transfusion

Does the storage duration of blood products affect outcomes in critically ill patients Spinella et al, Transfusion August 2011

Altered parameters in Stored RBC BiochemicalMetabolic

Biomechanical Oxidative

SNO-Hb ↓RBC Storage Lesions Tatsuro Yoshida PhD Presentation to AABB

Byproducts of Stored RBC’s

1.Released heme and iron from ruptured cells

2.Shed microvesicles

3.Loss of lipid and protein products from damaged RBC’s

4.Activated RBC adhesins

Properties of stored red blood cells: understanding immune and vascular reactivity Spinella et.al Transfusion 2011

FDA Requirements

Membrane fragments (lipids) shed from almost all cell types. They have been implicated in immune suppression.

Byproducts of Stored RBC’s

“All of these materials and activities are normal parts of the RBC life cycle, but they are concentrated in space and time by the RBC storage and transfusion process.”

Properties of stored red blood cells: understanding immune and vascular reactivity Spinella et.al Transfusion 2011

“TWO-INSULT” Model

Insult # 1 = Patient’s underlying inflammatory condition which “primes” the patient’s immune cells

Insult # 2 = Full-on inflammatory activation triggered by a potential second insult, such as an allogeneic blood transfusion

Properties of stored red blood cells: understanding immune and vascular reactivity Spinella et.al Transfusion 2011

Age of Blood Evaluation (ABLE) Trial

1.Canadian multicenter, randomized, controlled trial in the resuscitation of critically ill patients

2.Opened in 2008 – Anticipated end 20133.2,500 patients 4.Outcome measurements = 90 day mortality,

MODS, infections, length of stay,

Red Cell Storage Duration Study (RECESS)

1.NHLBI multicenter, randomized, controlled trial in cardiac surgery patients. Comparing blood stored <10 and >21 days.

2.Opened in 2010 – Anticipated end 20133.1,800 patients 4.Outcome measurements = 90 day mortality,

MODS, major cardiac events, ventilation time, renal function, liver function.

Age of Blood in Children in Pediatric Intensive Care Units (ABC - PICU)

1.Randomizing children to either a) blood less than 7 days old, or b) standard – issue RBC’s.

2.Opened in 2010 – Anticipated end 20133.1,500 patients 4.Outcome measurements = 28 day MODS, major

cardiac events, ventilation time, renal function, liver function.

So what do we do with all of this?

Byproducts of Stored RBC’s

1.Released heme and iron from ruptured cells

2.Shed microvesicles

3.Loss of lipid and protein products from damaged RBC’s

4.Activated RBC adhesins

Properties of stored red blood cells: understanding immune and vascular reactivity Spinella et.al Transfusion 2011

Transfusion. 2005 Aug;45(8):1295-301.Extracellular potassium concentrations in red blood cell suspensions after irradiation and washing.Weiskopf RB, Schnapp S, Rouine-Rapp K, Bostrom A, Toy P.

J Trauma. 2006 Apr;60(4):851-8.Pulmonary endothelial permeability is increased by fluid from packed red blood cell units but not by fluid from clinically-available washed units.Rao RS, Howard CA, Teague TK.

Transfus Apher Sci. 2008 Apr;38(2):141-7. Epub 2008 Mar 17.Stored packed red blood cells contain a procoagulant phospholipid reducible by leukodepletion filters and washing.Cardo LJ, Hmel P, Wilder D.

Transfus Med. 2007 Apr;17(2):89-95.Processing of stored packed red blood cells using autotransfusion devices decreases potassium and microaggregates: a prospective, randomized, single-blinded in vitro study.Westphal-Varghese B, Erren M, Westphal M, Van Aken H, Ertmer C, Lange M, Booke M.

Anesth Analg. 2002 Aug;95(2):324-5, table of contents.Intraoperative washing of long-stored packed red blood cells by using an autotransfusion device prevents hyperkalemia.Knichwitz G, Zahl M, Van Aken H, Semjonow A, Booke M.

ASAIO J. 2007 Nov-Dec;53(6):680-3.The effect of preprocessing stored red blood cells on neonates undergoing corrective cardiac surgery.Liu J, Ji B, Feng Z, Zhao J, Li C, Li B, Long C.

“Washing is associated with the loss of 10% to 20% of the red cells.” Blood Transfusion Therapy – A Physicians Handbook AABB 2005

1 Write a procedure

2. Get it signed by your doctors

3. Pick a QC marker

4. Measure (validate) what you are doing

5. Record your results.

REGULATORY ISSUES

So what does this mean?

So what does this mean?

1.Understand that transfusions may lead to worse outcomes.

So what does this mean?

1.Understand that transfusions may lead to worse outcomes.

2. It is reasonable to infer that older stored blood may lead to worse outcomes!

So what does this mean?

1.Understand that transfusions may lead to worse outcomes.

2. It is reasonable to infer that older stored blood may lead to worse outcomes!

3. Washing older stored blood may reduce morbidity.