mechanical strength testing of irradiated htr graphite grades m.c.r. heijna, j.a. vreeling nrg,...

Mechanical strength testing of irradiated

HTR graphite gradesM.C.R. Heijna, J.A. Vreeling

NRG, Petten

The Netherlands

INGSM-14

18 September 2013

Seattle

2

Outline

• Introduction– HTR graphite– INNOGRAPH irradiation programme

• Tensile strength from diametric compression– Why?– How?

• Results– Movies!– Trends for coke, grain size, production process

• Conclusions

3

HTR Graphite• Two types of (V)HTR:

• pebble bed• prismatic block

• Graphite as moderator• Structural material

Images from Wikipedia

4

INNOGRAPH programme

European Commission Framework Programmes:• Retain (V)HTR knowledge• Screen properties of modern graphite grades

5

INNOGRAPH programme

INNOGRAPH-1A: 750°C, 5-10 dpa

6

INNOGRAPH programme

INNOGRAPH-1B: 750°C, 10-25 dpaINNOGRAPH-2A: 950°C, 4-8 dpaINNOGRAPH-2B: 950°C, 8-15 dpa

7

INNOGRAPH programme

INNOGRAPH-1B: 750°C, 10-25 dpaINNOGRAPH-2A: 950°C, 4-8 dpaINNOGRAPH-2B: 950°C, 8-15 dpa

8

INNOGRAPH programme

INNOGRAPH-1C: 750°C, 1-2 dpaIrradiation will be concluded this month

INNOGRAPH design

• Selected irradiated samples from “1A”and “2A” were further irradiated in “1B” and “2B”

• INNOGRAPH-1B and -2B have been assembled in the NRG hot-cells

10

INNOGRAPH design• Each experiment contains 24 thermocouples and

9 dosimeter sets

• Temperature controlled by gas mixture

• Temperature control within ±30°C

• In the order of 180-220 samples per experiment

• Sample geometry:

• 6 mm high, 8 mm diameter

• Flat side with sample coding

• Samples in inert environment

11

Graphite grades

Manufacturer Grade Coke Process

IG-110 petroleum iso-moulding

IG-430 pitch iso-mouldingNBG-10 pitch extrusionNBG-17 pitch vibro-mouldingNBG-18 pitch vibro-mouldingNBG-25 petroleum iso-moulding

PCEA petroleum extrusionPCIB petroleum iso-mouldingPPEA pitch extrusionLPEB Needle extrusionLPIB Needle iso-moulding

GrafTech

Toyo Tanso

SGL

Major grades for this programme

12

Irradiation in HFR, Petten

• Tank-in-pool type MTR• 40 MW thermal• Operated by NRG

13

Post Irradiation Examination

Data on 800 graphite samples• Dimensional change• Density• Young’s modulus• Coefficient of Thermal Expansion• Thermal conductivity• Electrical resistivity

sample recovery

measurements

data set

14

Test matrix strength measurements

• Irradiation temperature 750°C

• Fine grains and coarse grains

• Pet & pitch coke• Various production

processes• Different levels of dpa’s /

volume change

• Sample selection limited by:

• Reloaded samples• Microscopy samples

15

Diametric compression

16

Why diametric compression?

Typical tensile test geometry INNOGRAPH geometry

17

Tensile strength from diametric compression

S.P. Timoshenko, J.N. Goodier, “Theory of elasticity”, 1970H. Awaji, J. Soc. Mat. Sci. Jap. 27 (1987)C. Berre et al., unpublished

Tensile strength < Compressive strength

18

Tensile strength from diametric compression

z = unique direction

19

Experiment! Coarse grain graphite

20

Experiment! Fine grain graphite

21

Strength vs dpa; Grain size

22

Strength vs dpa; Grain size

DV/V0

Scanning Electron Microscopy

23

Fine grain, 0 dpaGrade C

Coarse grain, 0 dpaGrade A

Fine grain, 13.4 dpaGrade C

Coarse grain, 12.8 dpaGrade A

24

Strength vs dpa; Coke

25

Strength vs dpa; Process

26

Conclusions

• Successful irradiation and PIE campaign concluded by demolishing samples

• Tensile strength vs. dpa trends derived from diametric compression

• At turn-around, strength doubles– Regardless of grain size, coke, production process

• Fine grained graphite stronger than coarse grained– Regardless of irradiation

• Coke and process have negligible effect on tensile strength

27

Conclusions

• Successful irradiation and PIE campaign concluded by demolishing samples

• Tensile strength vs. dpa trends derived from diametric compression

• At turn-around, strength doubles– Regardless of grain size, coke, production process

• Fine grained graphite stronger than coarse grained– Regardless of irradiation

• Coke and process have negligible effect on tensile strength

Thank you for your attention!