mhealth to revolutionize information retrieval in …...mhealth to revolutionize information...

mHealth to Revolutionize Information Retrieval in Low and Middle Income Countries

Introduction and Proposed Solutions Using Botswana as Reference Point

Ryan Littman-Quinn Director of Mobile Health Informatics Botswana-UPenn Partnership (BUP)

MedInfo 2013 August 22, 2013 Copenhagen, Denmark

Ryan Littman-Quinn, Anthony A. Luberti, Carrie Kovarik

•  Partnership between University of Pennsylvania, Botswana Ministry of Health, and University of Botswana (UB)

•  Health Informatics Capacity Building Program

o  Curriculum development o  Workshops o  National conference o  mHealth (advisors and research partners)

§  Telemedicine using mobile phones §  mLearning with UB School of Medicine §  mHealth Innovation Competition §  9+ Others

Agenda

•  Information Retrieval (IR) in Low and Middle Income Countries (LMICs)

•  Mobile Tech Revolution and mHealth in LMICs •  Botswana Background •  mHealth Solution #1: USSD for Treatment Guidelines •  mHealth Solution #2: Smart Devices for all types of IR

content •  Conclusion

IR and LMICs •  Information Retrieval in digital era

•  Digital IR helps medical professionals to avoid medical errors and provide care in a more effective, efficient manner

•  IR challenges unique to LMICs o  Analog health records, data, resources o  Growing Digital Divide

•  Access to technology •  Power outages •  Weak/unreliable Internet

•  “Leap Frog” Technology...

Mobile Technology Revolution

% of world's population covered by mobile signal:

2003: 61% 2009: 90%

… high-speed mobile internet signal (>3G):

2017: 85%

ITU Statistics, 2009. Available online at http:// www.itu.int/en/pages/default.aspxThe World in 2010: ICT Facts and Figures, Published October 1, 2010

Ericsson Mobility Report 2013. Available online at http://www.ericsson.com/ericsson-mobility-report

% of mobile devices owned by citizens in developing countries:

2000: 25% of 700 million 2009: 75% of 4 BILLION 2011: 76% of 6 BILLION

The World in 2010: ICT Facts and Figures, Published October 1, 2010.

Early Promise of mHealth in LMICs

Proliferation of mHealth initiatives... •  Education and awareness •  Diagnostic and treatment support* •  Communication and training for

healthcare workers* •  Helpline •  Disease and epidemic outbreak tracking •  Remote monitoring •  Remote data collection

Botswana Background

•  Challenging landline IT infrastructure and high mobile tech penetration

•  Ranks 2nd in HIV prevalence and 4th in TB prevalence in the world

•  Severe shortage of healthcare workers

•  Need for standardization of care

CIA World Factbook, 2011. Available online at https:/ /www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/ geos/bc.html

mHealth Solution #1: USSD for Treatment Guidelines

•  Treatment Guidelines o  Secondary knowledge-based scientific research o  Integral resource for providing and standardizing

care, and measuring quality •  Pneumonia is the second-leading cause of death for

HIV patients •  Pneumonia Treatment Guideline implementation

o  limited to one-time lectures and provisions of hard copies of the guidelines

o  Guidelines are locked in rooms in health facilities and rarely referenced by clinicians

•  USSD: Unstructured Supplementary Service Data o  Constant connection with a database o  182 character limit o  90 second limit o  Free for user

•  Available on ALL mobile phones

mHealth Solution #1: USSD for Treatment Guidelines

mHealth Solution #1: USSD for Treatment Guidelines

•  Advantages o  Available on all mobile phones o  Free for user o  Quick, simple, easy

•  Disadvantages o  IR content limitations

§  182 characters §  90 seconds §  No multimedia

mHeath Solution #2: Smart Devices for all IR content

University of Botswana School of Medicine mLearning Initiative

Based on a fundamental theorem....

mLearning Fundamental Theorem

If easily provides:

●  Access to University Library Resources ●  Access to International Research ●  Local Treatment Guidelines ●  Drug and Dosage References ●  Ability to communicate with peers and mentors ●  Countless more medical knowledge resources...

mLearning Fundamental Theorem

Then...

IF...

AND...

THEN...

mLearning Fundamental Theorem

University of Botswana School of Medicine (UBSOM) University of Botswana Library

ManGoes Mobile

Orange Botswana

mLearning Partners

mLearning Project Growth

Year

Users

Locations

2010 7 Gaborone

2011 28 Gabs, Maun, Mahalapye

2012 36* Gabs, Maun, Mahalapye

2012-13 170* Gabs, Maun, Mahalapye, Lobatse

2013 235* Gabs, Maun, Mahalapye, Lobatse

* 7" Android Tablets

Pilot User Testimonials "These phones are like lifelines for us” •  Family Medicine Resident in

Mahalapye

“The internet supply in Maun is very dry... it can go for weeks without working... to have that substitute of information at hand... at all times, is very welcome.” •  Family Medicine Resident in

Maun

mLearning Tablet Setup

mLearning Tablet Trainings

mLearning Tablet Trainings

Conclusion

•  Tip of iceberg for mHealth and IR •  Customization and local ownership and drive

are key to sustainability •  Information - not technology - is at the

heart of a successful Health Informatics solution

Acknowledgements

•  Botswana-UPenn Partnership •  CDC Botswana / PEPFAR •  Orange Botswana •  Botswana Ministry of Health •  University of Botswana •  Nextel Botswana •  ManGoes Mobile

Thanks!

ryanlq@botswana-upenn.co.bw