minutes of the 27th meeting of the executive … · rishiraj singh memorial society, habibganj...
Post on 31-Jul-2020
1 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
1
MINUTES OF THE 27TH MEETING OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE OF BOARD OF
GOVERNORS OF CENTRAL COUNCIL OF HOMOEOPATHY HELD ON 06.06.2019 AT
NEW DELHI.
PRESENT
1. Dr. Anil Khurana - Chairman
2. Dr. Anil Kumari Malhotra - Member
Dr. Kumar Vivekanand - Secretary
Dr. D. Samba Murthy, Inspector and Shri Y.D. Vats, Asstt. Secretary (Admn.) were present to
assist the Secretary during the meeting.
Agenda item No. 1
Confirmation of the Minutes of the 26th meeting of the Executive Committee of Board of
Governors held on 27.05.2019 at New Delhi
The Executive Committee confirmed the Minutes of its 26th meeting held on 27.05.2019 at New Delhi as
circulated.
Agenda item No. 2
Action taken Report on the minutes of the 26th meeting of Executive Committee of Board of
Governors held on 27.05.2019 at New Delhi.
The Executive Committee noted the Action taken by the office of the Council on the Minutes of the 26th
meeting of Executive Committee of Board of Governors of Central Council of Homoeopathy held on
27.05.2019 at New Delhi.
Agenda item No. 3
Ministry’s O.M. No.X-18030/83/2019-CDN dated 23rd May, 2019 regarding Nomination for
Vayoshreshtha Samman – National Awards for Senior Citizens – 2019.
The Executive Committee considered Ministry’s letter dated 23.05.2019 regarding nomination for
National Awards for Senior Citizens-2019 and considering that last date is already over, therefore,
decided not to take any action for the time being.
Agenda item No. 4
Order dated 09.05.2019 of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi W.P. No.(C) No. 2829/2019 in respect of
Rishiraj Singh Memorial Society, Habibganj Station, Bhopal (M.P.) for Opening of New H.M.C. in
the name of Narayan Shree Homoeopathic Medical College, Hospital and Research Centre,
Indore(M.P.).
The Executive Committee took note of the Court Order and discussed the inspection report of Rishiraj
Singh Memorial Society’s Narayan Shree Homoeopathic Medical College, Hospital and Research
Centre, Indore (M.P.) in the light of order dated 09.05.2019 of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in W.P.
No.(C) No. 2829/2019 and decided to recommended for not issuing LOI for starting I-BHMS Course for
2
the session 2019-20 due to the gross deficiencies in Hospital as well as in the college, as reflected in the
report of inspection dated 09.11.2018. Deficiencies reflected in the report of inspection are as under:
1. Valid Consent of affiliation from university is not available.
2. Offer letter issued by the Rishiraj Singh Memorial Welfare Society to 15 teaching staff (05
Professors, 05 Readers and 05 Lecturers) but records of teaching faculty such as certificates of
qualification/experience not provided to verify their eligibility and thus suitability for
appointment.
3. Dr. Rajbala Dubey, Principal of the proposed college issued the offer letter to all teaching staffs
in January 2017, whereas she herself joined the college in September 2017 which creates doubts
about authenticity of the documents.
4. Functioning of attached Homoeopathic hospital is doubtful as IPD data for 10 months and OPD
data for eight months given instead of last calendar year. Further, Central OPD register is not
adequately maintained, Cases of IPD poorly recorded, Cases lack findings of general/systemic
examination, advice without investigations and record of findings. Temperature, Pulse,
Respiration (TPR) chart not maintained, No advice of diet given. A common register for USG
and X-Ray has been maintained which is not appropriate as also does not mention the reports of
the patient, which creates doubt about functionality of these departments. Central OPD register
mentions diagnosis and medicine which is unusual. OPD and IPD registers do not contain any
signature of visiting physicians. Average OPD per day as calculated from available data in the
annexure is 180 per day which does not meet the requirement of MSR, 2013.
5. Hospital staffs namely Dr. Arun Mishra, General Surgeon; Dr. Rakesh Parwar, RMO; Dr. Sanjay
Singh Solanki, Dispenser; Dr. Deepak Yadav, House Physician; Dr. Kavita Gadhwal, House
Physician; Mr. Abhishek Kuswaha, Lab. Technician etc. issued offer letter by Dr. Rajbala
Dubey, Principal in 2016 and 2017 much before joining of Principal herself which is not
acceptable. Further, the signature of hospital staffs are not matching with the signature at
attendance register and joining letter.
6. Hospital does not have functional pathology and bio chemistry labs as per required norms. The
college authority has simply submitted a MoU with allied pathology Lab, Indore for
Pathological, bio chemistry and radiology (X-ray and USG) in Hospital.
7. Facility of demonstration of Animal experimentation through Audio-Visual Aids not available in
department of Physiology.
8. Required No. of models not available in the Dept. of Pharmacy.
9. Required Charts not available in the Dept. of Organon.
3
Agenda item No. 5
Inspection of Existing Homoeopathic Medical College
Sl. No.
Name of the College Course(s) run/intake
capacity
Date of Inspection
Report Dispatched
on
Report received in
CCH on
Remarks
1. Kent Homoeopathic
Medical College and
Hospital At & P.O. Khilwat
(via-Bidupur Bazar)
Hajipur, District Vaishali
B.H.M.S.(50)
16.05.19 17.05.19 20.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 50 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course.
2. Nootan Homoeopathic
Medical College and
Hospital, Gat No.412,
Landgewadi, Tal.
Kavathemahankal, Dist.
Sangali.
B.H.M.S.(60)
16.5.19 17.5.19 20.5.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 60 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course and
continuation from 1st year to 2nd
year BHMS course.
3. Indira Gandhi Memorial
Homoeopathic Medical
College, 131, Prakash
Nagar, Dhar-454001
B.H.M.S.(100)
14.05.19 15.05.19 25.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 100 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course
subject to fulfilment of
conditions relating to IPD
functioning before
commencement of new session.
4. Dr. Hahnemann
Homoeopathy Medical
College & Research
Centre. Koneripatti,
Rasipuram, Namakkal
Dist-637408.
BHMS (100) 16.05.19 - 25.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 100 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course.
5. Atal Bihari Vajpayee
Homoeopathic Medical
College and Hospital, At-
Jalke (Bk.), Khadke,
Newasa, Dist.
Ahmednagar (M.S.)
B.H.M.S.(60)
15.05.19 16.05.19 20.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 60 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course and
continuation from 1st to 2nd
BHMS Course.
6. Vidya Vaibhav Siksham
Mandal, Dapoli,
Homoeopathic Medical
College and Hospital at
Apati, P.O. Talsure
Taluka, Dapoli, District-
Ratnagiri.
BHMS (50)
14.05.19 15.05.19 21.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 50 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course
7. Hamsa Homoeopathy
Medical College, Hospital
and Research Centre,
B.H.M.S (100)
14.05.19 - 21.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
4
Kasheersagar Village,
Mulugu Mandal, Medak
Distt
lack of fulltime higher faculty in
Practice of Medicine and
Repertory, no guest faculty and
other shortfall as per inspection
report. Deficiencies reflected in
the report of inspection are as
under:
27 FT teachers (11 Prof, 04
Readers and 12 Lecturers)
against 28, no GF against the
requirement of 12, no
Professor in Practice of
Medicine and no Reader in
Repertory.
Teachers of modern
Medicine Physician,
Ophthalmologist,
Pediatrician and Dentist are
available on MoU.
Mummified bodies not
available in dept. of
Anatomy.
Software 01 available against
the requirement of 05 in
dept. of Repertory.
8. Sendhwa Homoeopathic
Medical College &
Hospital, Dist. Barwani,
Sendhwa- 451666. MP
BHMS (100)
14.05.19 15.05.19 21.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 100 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course
subject to appointment of 04
Guest Faculties, 01 House
physician before
commencement of new session.
9. Birbhum Vivekanand
Homoeopathic Medical
College and Hospital, P.O.
Sainthia, Distt. Birbhum-
731234
BHMS (60)
14.5.19 15.05.19 21.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 60 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course.
10. Maa Kalawati
Homoeopathic Medical
College & Hospital,
Rajaulatu, Namkum,
Ranchi-834010
B.H.M.S.(100) 16.05.19 17.05.19 21.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
discrepancy in 06 fulltime
teaching staff who are also
shown as faculty in Mangla
Kamla Homoeopathic Medical
College. Deficiencies reflected in
the report of inspection are as
under:
Out of 29 teachers, only 20
5
teachers found in attendance register.
06 teachers namely, Dr. K. C. Choudhary, Dr. ANK Srivastava, Dr. Praful Kumar Singh, Dr. B. P. Dey, Dr. Dhananjaya Chatterjee and Dr. Sayan Dutta Ray found available in Mangla Kamla Homoeopathic Medical College, Siwan also.
Only 11 Guest Faculty available against the requirement of 12.
Required no. of Stretcher with Trolley, Oxygen cylinder, Diagnostic set (ENT) not available in Hospital.
Cataloguing of books not done in Central Library.
Mummified Bodies & Cadaver not available.
Specimens of Animal not available.
License for Alcohol/ Spirit is under process in dept. of Homoeopathic Pharmacy
11. Kisan Dnyanoday
Mandal’s homoeopathic
medical college, shirpur ,
Dhule
BHMS (75
seats)
15.5.19 17.5.19 22.5.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 75 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course.
12. Prabhat Education
Society’s P.D. Jain
Homoeopathic Medical
College, Behind State
Bank of Hyderabad, Vakil
Colony, Parbhani-431
401.
BHMS (100)
M.D.(Hom.)
Organon- 6
Materia
Medica-6
Repertory-6
15.05.19 16.05.19 22.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 100 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course
subject to improvement in OPD
functioning before
commencement of new session.
Also recommended for
admissions in M.D. (Hom.)
course in subjects of Organon of
Medicine with 04 seats and
Materia Medica & Repertory
with 03 seats in each.
13. Sri Sairam Homoeopathic
Medical College and
Research Centre,
(Sapthagiri Education
Trust), Sai Leo Nagar
Tambaram West Chennai-
600044
BHMS (50)
16.05.19 16.05.19 22.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 50 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course.
6
14. Sharadchandraji Pawar
Homoeopathic Medical
College and Hospital, At
Shiva Trust Campus,
Wadala-Mahadev Tq.
Shiriram Distt.
Ahmednagar
BHMS (100)
15.05.19 16.05.19 22.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 100 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course.
15. Shree Janta Homeopathic
Medical College and
Hospital Akola
BHMS (50)
15.05.19 16.05.19 - Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
lack of fulltime teachers,
Hospital Staff, Equipments and
doubtful OPD/IPD functioning.
The Executive Committee also
decided to recommend for
action under Section 19 of HCC
Act, 1973, i.e. for withdrawal of
qualification awarded by
Maharashtra University of
Health Sciences in respect of
the Students of Shri Janta
Homoeopathic Medical College,
Akola. Deficiencies reflected in
the report of inspection are as
under:
University affiliation is given
for continuation of 2-4th
BHMS not for 1st BHMS
admission.
Total 14 FT teachers and 04
GF available against the
requirement of 24 FT and 08
GF as per visitor.
Consultants of Modern
Medicine except
Gynaecologist all others are
not available.
Average IPD on calculation
16.7% and Average OPD 42.9
on calculation.
Superintendent room and
staff nurse room not
available, dispensary for IPD
and OPD common, Clinical
Laboratory for Hospital not
available, X ray available non
functional and USG not
available, O T available but
non functional, Surgeon
room not available,
7
Rehabilitation Unit, Hospital
kitchen Stores, Ambulance
not available in Hospital.
Required no. of Medical
Officers, RMO, Surgeon,
Radiologist, House physician,
X ray technician, Dresser, X
ray attendant, Nursing staff
in charge Nursing staff, Ward
boys/ Ayas, Store keeper,
Registration clerk, Yoga
expert, Physiotherapist,
dietician Secretarial staff
Accounts staff, Auxiliary staff
lab attendant, Dark room
attendant, hospital reception
staff and Pathologist not
available in hospital.
Sterilizer 01 against 02,
Artery forceps small and big
06 against 06 each in
Hospital equipment.
Lab attendants of Pharmacy
& Anatomy, Lab Technician
Pathology, Librarian and
Library asst, staff on watch
duty are not available in
college.
Reading room for students
capacity around 32,
Photocopy facility not
available and Librarian and
Library Asst. not appointed in
Central Library.
Diagrams and cadavers not
available in dept. of
Anatomy.
Separate Biochemistry lab
not available in dept. of
Physiology.
Models not available in Dept.
of Pathology.
Arrangements for student
visits not done in dept. of
Community medicine.
Availably of Homoeopathic
pharmacopeias not reported
and No student since last 04
years hence no educational
tour conducted in dept. of
8
Pharmacy.
02 software against 05 dept.
of Repertory.
16. Pt. Jawahar Lal Nehru
Memorial Institute of
Homoeopathic Medical
Sciences, Badnera Road,
Amravati-444605.
BHMS(70)
M.D.(Hom.)
Organon-3
Materia
Medica - 3
Repertory-3
16.05.19 17.5.19 22.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
deficiency of fulltime teachers in
PG departments. Deficiencies
reflected in the report of
inspection as under:
07 GF (Professor) available
against the requirement of
12 and no FT teachers
available for PG
departments.
Qualifications of 15 FT
teachers are with
DHMS/BHMS qualifications
out of which 01 reader and
03 Lecturers are appointed in
2013, 2014 & 2016. Rest all
are appointed before 2013.
Consultants of modern
medicine reported as not
provided separately.
Dispensary for OPD & IPD
not separate, X-ray and USG
available but not working,
Space for Operation Theatre
is reported as space available
with few equipments,
Rehabilitation unit of yoga
not available, Kitchen not
available and Ambulance
reported as old one not in
use in Hospital
Lab Attendant, Dark room
attendant & hospital
reception staff, Staff to
maintain hospital catering
not available, Account
section not separate in
Hospital staff.
Required no. of Iron beds,
Stretcher with trolley,
Backrest, Oxygen cylinder,
Diagnostic set (ENT) not
available in Hospital.
In the Central Library,
reading room capacity is for
9
20 students against the
requirement of 50-60,
Reading room for teaching
faculty is not separate and 01
Library assistant available
against the requirement of
02 in Central Library.
Auto Analyzer, clinical
thermometer (Digital),
Stethographs or
Pneumographs, Electronic
stopwatches, Films and
models, Facility for animal
experiment demonstration
with the help of audio-visual
aids not available in dept. of
Physiology.
Centre hot plate not
available.
Glassware, Stains and
chemical reagents for
Histopathology not available,
Colony counter not available
against the requirement of
01, Material for preparation
of media and stain not
available, Machine for
estimation of blood
sugar/serological test not
available against the
requirement of 01 in dept. of
Pathology.
Specimens and models not
available in dept. of Practice
of Medicine
Hydrometer, Filter Paestur
Chamber land not available
against the required
requirement in dept. of
Community Medicine.
Required Pestles and Motors,
Stopwatches, Pyknometer
not available in dept. of
Pharmacy.
Books on history of medicine
not available in Dept. of
Organon of Medicine.
Required Software not
available in the Dept. of
Repertory.
10
17. Gandhi Natha Rangaji
Homoeopathic Medical
College, 13, Budhawar
Peth, Jain Boarding
Campus, Balives, Solapur-
413 002.
BHMS (50) 14.05.19 15.05.19 22.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
lack of 05 fulltime teachers,
Guest faculty and other shortfall
in the department. Deficiencies
reflected in the report of
inspection are as under:
01 Guest Faculty in Professor
cadre against the
requirement of 08 and
qualification of 15 FT
teachers without PG degree,
out of which 05 (Lecturers)
appointed between 2014,
2016 and 2017.
USG reported as under MoU
– (MoU agreement expired in
January, 2019), no provision
of Rehabilitation Unit of Yoga
in Hospital.
Nursing Staff 01 available
against the requirement of
02, Dark room attendant and
hospital reception staff not
available in Hospital staff.
Stretcher with trolley and
Chair trolley with wheels is
not available against the
requirement of 04, Sterilizers
01 available against the
requirement of 02.
Artey forceps, small and big
06 available in against the
requirement of 12, Oxygen
cylinder with stand 03
available against the
requirement of 04,
Diagnostic set (ENT) 01
available against the
requirement of 04 Hospital
equipement.
Reading room for student is
for 36 student and Reading
room for teaching faculty is
for 06 in Central Library.
Auto Analyzer or Semi Auto
Aalyzer and colour
perception lantern (Edirdge
Green) not available against
11
requirement of 01,
Sphygmomanometer 20
available against the
requirement of 25, Balance
chemical/ordinary 01
available against the
requirement of 02,
Albuminometers 02 available
against the requirement 10
in dept. of Physiology.
Computer with accessories
not available against the
requirement of 01 in dept. of
Pathology.
Pill tiles not available, Glass
apparatus for filtration with
vacuum 01 available against
the requirement of 02,
Alcoholmeter 01 available
against the requirement of
05, Chemical Balance 06
available against the
requirement of 10, Models
are not available,
Alcohol/Spirit procuring not
available and Species planted
not available in herbal
garden in dept. of Pharmacy.
18. Om Charitable Chikitsa
Samiti’s K.S.
Homoeopathic Medical
College, Village, Piproli,
Chirwai Naka, Lashkar,
Gwalior-474001.
BHMS-60
21.05.19 21.05.19 23.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 60 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course.
19. Shri Ramnath Singh
Homoeopathic Medical
College & Hospital,
Gormi, Bhind, MP
BHMS (85) 21.05.19 22.05.19 24.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due
to withdrawal of NOC by the
Government of Madhya Pradesh
vide letter no. 1-34/2015/1/59
dated 31.05.2019. Deficiencies
reflected in the report of
inspection are as under:
In the list of teaching faculty
given Dr DS Tomar is
mentioned as Reader, Gynae
& Obs but as per
appointment letter he is
shown as GF in MM and Dr
Sunil Viswkarma, is
12
mentioned as Prof Pathology
but as per appointment
letter he is GF Professor in
Anatomy.
As per annexure X ray and
USG is under MoU in
Hospital.
Mummified body, Cadaver
not available and College not
covered under Anatomy Act
in dept. of Anatomy.
Availability of license for
procuring alcohol/ spirit not
reported in dept. of
Pharmacy.
20. Sophia Homoeopathic
Medical College (Swastik
Educational & Social
Welfare Society’s), Mahal
Gaon, Opp. R.I. Training
Institute, City Centre,
Gwalior.
B.H.M.S.(100) 21.05.19 22.05.19 24.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due
to lack of documents related to
eligibility of fulltime teachers.
Deficiencies reflected in the
report of inspection as under:
Attendance register and
Acquittance Roll of teaching
faculty, non teaching,
supporting staff and hospital
staff not provided and 13 FT
teaching staff are not
possessing MD qualification.
Ward boys/Ayas 08 available
against the requirement of
09, Lab attendant not
available in Hospital staff.
Required no. of Stretcher
with trolley, Artery Forceps,
Oxygen cylinder and
Diagnostic set (ENT) not
available in the Hospital.
Pathology lab attendant not
available in Non teaching
staff.
Reading room capacity for
student is 35 in Central
Library.
College applied for Cadavers
and Mummified body not
available in dept. of
Anatomy.
Colony counter is not
13
available in dept. of
Pathology.
License for Procuring
Alcohol/Spirit cannot be
ascertained (valid up to
20.08.2018) in dept. of
Homoeopathic Pharmacy.
21. Swami Pranavanand
Homoeopathic Medical
College and Hospital,
Near Police Line Road,
Chhatarpur (M.P.)-
471001
BHMS (50)
21.05.19 22.05.19 27.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 50 seats in
existing UG (I-BHMS) course
subject to removal of
deficiencies in departments
before commencement of new
session.
22. Muzaffarpur
Homoeopathic Medical
College, Raghu Nath
Pandey Nagar, MIC Bela,
Muzaffarpur- 842005
BHMS (50)
21.05.19 22.05.19 27.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
lack of documents for fulltime
teachers in respect of non
availability of annexure.
Deficiencies reflected in the
report of inspection are as
under:
24 FT teachers with
DHMS/BHMS qualification
but DoA not provided, Only
teaching experience is
mentioned of more than 06
years except one Lecturer
(BHMS) with less than one
year and No Annexure of
attendance provided.
List of 40 members with no
cadre demarcation and
among them 12 members
unsigned in acquaintance
roll.
X-ray, ECG and USG reported
as available for
demonstration for teaching
purpose in hospital.
Required Iron beds not
available in hospital.
Mummified body reported as
available in charts, Model in
dept. of Anatomy.
14
23. B.N.M. Homoeopathic
Medical Hospital,
Saharsa-852 201.
BHMS (50) 21.05.19 23.05.19 27.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
deficiency in various
departments, Hospital
functioning and ineligibility of
Principal as per MSR and other
shortfalls as per Inspection
Report. Deficiencies reflected in
the report of inspection as
under:
04 GF available against 08,
Principal is with BHMS
qualification DoA as Lecturer
in 2012, as Reader in 2016,
as Professor in 2019, as
Principal in 01.04.2019.
36 staff Biometric
attendance available with no
cadre demarcation and total
37 teachers list available in
acquaintance roll.
No IPD or OPD annexure of 1
year enclosed for
verification, SMO room,
dressing room available but
combined, Dispensary for
OPD and IPD reported as
combined, Doctor duty room
and nursing station under
construction, Preparation
room, Post op recovery
room, space for sterilized
linen, labor room, surgeon
room and Nursing staff room
not available.
Yoga unit, hospital kitchen
and ambulance not available
and Store room reported as
combined in Hospital.
House physician 02 available
against the requirement of
05, Dispenser 01 available
against the requirement of
02, Nursing staff 02 available
against the requirement of
07, Ward boys 05 available
against the requirement of
07 and Hospital catering not
available in Hospital staff.
15
Artery forceps small and big
18 available against the
requirement of 24, Dressing
drums 02 available against
the requirement of 03 and
ENT Diagnostic sets 01
available against the
requirement of 03 in Hospital
equipment.
Reading room for students
and teaching faculty with
capacity reported as
combined with library but
not quantified and Two
name and qualification of
library assistant available
though visitor reported 04
library assistant in non-
teaching& supportive staff in
Central Library.
Mummified bodies and
cadaver not available and
College not covered under
anatomy act in dept. of
Anatomy.
ECG not available against the
requirement of 01,
Colorimeter 01 available
against the requirement of
02, Educational CD, Films and
Audio-visual aids not
available, Facility for Animal
experiments demonstration
with the help of Audio-visual
aids not reported and
Biochemistry lab not
established separately in
dept. of Physiology.
Computer with accessories
not available against the
requirement of 01and
Models not available in dept.
of Pathology.
Filter Pasteur chamber land
not available against the
requirement of 01,
Information on display on
Biostatistics, Research
Methodology not available,
Refrigerator not available
16
against the requirement of
01, Visit of students to water
purification plant, milk
pasteurization plant and
industries not available and
Village adoption not
reported in dept. of
Community of Medicine.
Specimens not available in
Dept. of Gynecology
Macerator 02 available
against the requirement of
05, Models, Specimens of
vegetable, animal, chemical
not available, Alcohol vehicle
not available.
License for procuring alcohol
and homoeopathic
pharmacopeias not available,
Educational Tour not
conducted in dept. of
Pharmacy.
Charts, Charts on history of
Medicine and books on
history of medicine not
available in dept. of Ogranon
of Medicine.
No. of Software not available
against the requirement of
05 in dept. of Repertory.
24. Bhargva Homoeopathic
Medical College,
Vidyagram, At & Post-
Dahemi, Ta-Borsad, Dist.
Anand-388560, Gujarat
BHMS (100)
21.05.19 21.05.19 28.05.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 100 seats in
existing UG (BHMS) course
subject to availability of USG
facility in hospital and
rectification of various
deficiencies of departments
before the commencement of
new session.
25. Disha Shikshan-V-Vikas
Kendra‘s E.B. Gadkari
Homoeopathic Medical
College, 1830/A/B,
Kadgaon Road, Opposite
Govt. Rest House,
Gadhinglaj, Dist.
Kolhapur-416
BHMS (50)
21.05.19 22.05.19 27.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
deficiency in Hospital
Functioning and discrepancy in
attendance, acquaintance and
teaching staff list. Deficiencies
reflected in the report of
inspection are as under:
17
No Fulltime higher faculty for
Anatomy.
Signature of 01 Teaching
staff Dr. R.P. Desouza is
missing in the attendance
register for the month of
March and April, 2019 also in
acquaintance roll.
20 teachers are not
possessing MD qualification.
Ophthalmologist,
Paediatrician not available in
dept. of
Teachers/Consultants of
Modern Medicine.
Provision for Superintendent
Room, Surgeon room not
available, Operation theatre,
Preparation Room, Post
operative recovery room,
Labor room and space for
sterilized linen is reported
non functional.
01 Nursing Staff against the
requirement of 03, Hospital
Reception staff not available
in dept. of Hospital Staff
In attendance Register
designation of non teaching
staff not mentioned, 16 non
teaching staff is on the
attendance register and 15
non teaching staff for the
month of March and April
2019.
42 Hospital staff is on the
attendance register for the
month of March, 2019 but in
Acquittance roll 27 hospital
staff is mentioned for the
months of February, March
and April, 2019.
Capacity for students reading
room is reported as 40 in
dept. of Central Library.
Required Stretcher with
trolley and Oxygen Cylinder
with stand, Diagnostic set
(ENT) not available in
hospital.
18
No facilities for Audio-Visual
Aids for demonstration
Animal experiments, 08
Glucometer available only
against requirement of 10,
Hot air oven 14”x14”x14”
(electric) not working,
Colorimeter (photo electric)
01 available against
requirement of 02 (Not
working), Centrifuge,
medium speed, electric not
functional and Centre hot
plate not available in dept. of
Physiology and Biochemistry.
Hot air oven (50OC) 01
available but not working,
Centrifuge Machine electric
(Rotofix) 01 not working, 01
working against the
requirement of 02, Chemical
Reagents for Histopathology
not available, Autoclave
Electric 02 available, 01 not
working against the
requirement of 02, Material
for preparation of media not
available and Total no. of
Models are not available in
the dept. of Pathology and
Microbiology.
Glass apparatus for filtration
with vacuum, Thin layer
Chromatography Apparatus,
Distillation Apparatus (Glass)
not available, 03Hydrometer,
01 Lactometer and 03
Macerator available against
the requirement of 05, 01
Pyknometer (Specific Gravity
Bottle) available against the
requirement of 02, Hot Air
Oven not functional, No. of
specimens Chemical not
available and Herbal Garden-
Species planted, Plants on
pots and Irrigation facility
not available in the dept. of
Homoeopathic Pharmacy.
19
26. Sh. H. N. Shukla
Homoeopathic Medical
College & Hospital, Nr.
Lalpari Lake, Bh.
Marketing Yard,
Amargadh-Bhichri, Rajkot
(by Shree Mahatama
Gandhi Education Trust,
Rajkot, Gujarat)-360005.
B.H.M.S.(100)
12.04.19 13.04.19 16.04.19 Recommended for allowing
admissions in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 with the
intake capacity of 60 seats only
in existing UG (BHMS) course
due to ineligibility of 07 teachers
who are without PG
qualifications and joined in 2018
onwards.
27. Mangla Kamla
Homoeopathic Medical
College & Hospital, Prof.
Vishnu Kumar Marg,
Srinagar, Siwan-841226.
B.H.M.S. (50)
30.04.19 01.05.19 06.05.19 Not recommended for allowing
admission in I-BHMS Course for
the session 2019-20 due to
discrepancy in fulltime teaching
staffs who are also shown as
faculty in Maa kalawati
Homoeopathic Medical College,
Jharkhand. Deficiencies reflected
in the report of inspection are as
under:
06 teachers namely, Dr. K. C. Choudhary, Dr. ANK Srivastava, Dr. Praful Kumar Singh, Dr. B. P. Dey, Dr. Dhananjaya Chatterjee and Dr. Sayan Dutta Ray found available in Maa Kalawati Homoeopathic Medical College, Jharkhand
Stretcher with trolley 01
against the requirement of
06, Oxygen cylinder with
stand 01 available against
the requirement of 06 and
Diagnostic Set (ENT) 01
available against the
requirement of 06 in hospital
equipment.
Cadaver not available but has
been applied for in dept. of
Anatomy.
ESR 02 available against the
requirement of 04 in dept. of
Pathology.
No Educational Tour has
been conducted during the
last year in dept. of
Pharmacy.
20
Agenda Item No.6.1
Request of National Homoeopathy Research Institute in Mental Health, Kottayam for inspection
by CCH for continuation of course for the academic year 2019-20 – Extension of affiliation by
Kerala University of Health Sciences, Thrissur, Kerala reg.
The Executive Committee deferred the matter for time being.
Agenda Item No.6.2
A letter dated 04.06.2019 of Ministry of AYUSH regarding Tentative Counseling Schedule for
admission to the ASU & H UG courses for the academic year 2019-20.
The Executive Committee considered the matter and agreed to inform State Govt. immediately.
Agenda Item No.6.3
1. Order dated 27.05.2019 of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in W.P. No.(C) No. 5279/2019 & CM
Appl. 23402/2019 in respect of Faculty of Homoeopathic Medical Sciences, SGT University,
Gurgaon, Haryana.
The Executive Committee discussed the inspection report of Faculty of Homoeopathic Medical Sciences,
SGT University, Gurgaon, Haryana in the light of order dated 27.05.2019 of Hon’ble High Court of
Delhi in W.P. No.(C) No. 5279/2019 & CM Appl. 23402/2019 and decided to recommended for not
issuing LOI for starting I-BHMS Course for the session 2019-20 due to fulltime teaching faculty,
doubtful hospital functioning, Hospital staffs as well as deficiencies in the college, as reflected in the
report of inspection dated 31.05.2019. Deficiencies reflected in the report of inspection are as under:
1. College authority has provided a list of 10 teachers on consent basis but their records of
certificates of qualification, experience are either not legible or not provided to verify their
eligibility and thus suitability for appointment. Further, 01 higher faculty each is not available in
the Dept. of Organon & Materia Medica which does not meet the requirement of MSR, 2013.
2. Details of OPD, IPD for last calendar year not provided. Authority has simply provided a list of
number of patients without any details which could not be verified. Columns of verifications
specified for the visitors are blank. Attendance register, acqittance roll for hospital staffs, Non
teaching Staff and administrative staffs are not available to verify the same. No documents
pertaining to hospital functioning is available. Hence, functioning of attached Homoeopathic
hospital is doubtful.
3. Facility of demonstration of Animal experimentation through Audio-Visual Aids not available in
department of Physiology.
4. Required No. of models, specimens, chemical specimen not available in the Dept. of Pharmacy.
5. Required Charts not available in the Dept. of Organon.
6. Specimens for identification not available in Dept. of Materia Medica.
7. Consent of affiliation of the University does not have approval of UGC for running courses in
Homoeopathy.
8. Proposed college did not provide copy of amended Memorandum of Association duly registered
with State Govt.
9. Undertakings regarding Performance Bank Guarantee, establishment of course on the said land
and not admitting any student in BHMS Course without permission are not furnished.
21
2. Inspection u/s 12A of HCC Act, 1973 for starting New PG Course in Homoeopathy.
Sl.
No.
Name of the
College
Purpose Date of
Inspection
Report
Dispatched
on
Report
received in
CCH on
Remarks
1. National Medical
College of
Homoeo. Science
(Vamanraothape
Homoeopathic
Medical
College), New
Nagar Road,
Sangamner, Dt.
Ahmednagar
For issue of
LoP to start
new M.D.
(Hom.)
course in
the Dept. of
Repertory,
Pediatrics
and
Psychiatry
with 03
seats in
each.
27.03.2019
29.03.219 03.04.2019 The Executive
Committee decided to
recommend for
issuance of Letter of
Permission for starting
new M.D. (Hom.)
course in the Dept. of
Repertory, Pediatrics
and Psychiatry with 03
seats in each subject
from the session
2019-20 based on the
available inspection
report dated
27.03.2019.
2. White Memorial
Homoeopathic
Medical College,
Attoor,
Veeyanoor-629
177.Dist.
Kanyakumari,
TN
For issue of
LoP to start
new M.D.
(Hom.) in
Repertory,
Materia
Medica,
Organon of
Medicine,
Practice of
Medicine &
Pediatrics
with 05
seats in
each.
24.04.2019
25.04.2019 29.04.2019 The Executive
Committee decided to
recommend for
issuance of Letter of
Permission for starting
new M.D. (Hom.)
course in the Dept. of
Repertory, Materia
Medica, Organon of
Medicine & Practice
of Medicine with 04
seats in each subject
and Pediatrics with 05
seats from the session
2019-20 based on the
available inspection
report dated
24.04.2019
The Executive Committee directed the office to complete the actions on the decisions in these minutes
immediately, keeping in view of urgency of the matters.
Meeting ended with the vote of thanks to the Chair.
Sd/-
(Dr. Kumar Vivekanand)
Attested Secretary
Sd/-
(Dr. Anil Khurana)
Member, BOG
top related