nsqip-p data driven improvement initiatives in pediatric ...web2.facs.org/download/anderson.pdf ·...
Post on 07-Mar-2018
216 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
NSQIP-P Data Driven Improvement Initiatives in Pediatric Surgery
Keith T. Oldham, MDProfessor and Chief
Division of Pediatric SurgeryMedical College of Wisconsin
Marie Z. UihleinChair and Surgeon-in-Chief
Clinical Vice President of SurgeryChildren’s Hospital of Wisconsin
ACS NSQIP National Conference Salt Lake City, Utah July 21 – 24, 2012
Yvonne (Bonnie ) Anderson, RN, MS, CPNPSurgical Clinical ReviewerNational Outcomes Center
Children's Hospital of Wisconsin
1
I have no relevant financial relationships with the manufacturer(s) or any commercial product(s) and/or
provider of commercial products or services discussed in this CME activity
I do not intend to discuss unapproved/investigative use of commercial product (s)/device (s)
in my presentation
.
Objective:
Explore potential for local institutional use of ACS-NSQIP-P data
2
Presentation Overview
Understand NSQIP-P data and reports, to enhance quality improvement initiatives
Review NSQIP-P occurrence (morbidity) data for trends and opportunities to further investigate improvement at the local and national level
Discuss impact of NSQIP-P Data on Patient Care
Collaboratives and future initiatives
3
Objectives
At the end of this session, participants will be able to assess NSQIP-P data reports for trends and perform further data analysis
At the end of this session, participants will be able to identify areas unique to their institutions to develop quality improvement initiatives
At the end of this session, participants will begin to develop plans to participate in collaboratives within the NSQIP-P
4
Quality/Outcomes in Pediatric Surgery Administrative efforts…process measures/cost
Federal & State governments Insurers Hospitals(CHCA,NACHRI, N.A.C.H) Joint Commission Industry, labor unions, others
Physician led efforts…medical, patient centered American College of Surgeons(NSQIP,COT) American Pediatric Surgical Association Specialty societies
5
‘91
2011 PediatricPhase 2 ends
6
ACS NSQIP-P
7
Background
In October of 2008, Phase 1 of the ACS NSQIP Pediatric was launched at four tertiary children’s hospitals
Yale New Haven Children’s Hospital
A.I. DuPont Hospital for Children
Children’s Hospital of Wisconsin
Children’s Hospital Colorado
8
Results Phase One Data October 2008 to December 2009, 7287 cases Demonstrated an overall mortality rate of 0.3% and a postoperative
occurrence rate of 3.9% Occurrence rates by site range from 3.1% to 5.6% Average sample 17.5% of children’s surgical population Audit Phase 1, data 1.9% disagreement (goal <5.0%) > 95% completeness of data at variable level 87% of patients had full 30-day follow-up Represented a variety of children’s surgery specialties Variability in outcomes was demonstrated across participating sites Supports the potential of the ACS NSQIP Pediatric to identify quality
improvement targets
9
10
ACS NSQIP Pediatric “Beta” phase of the program
One year of data collection completed on 12/31/2010 37,141 patient records from 30 institutions 1644 total CPT codes entered of which 456 accounted for 90%
of the cases
Pediatric Data 10/2008 to Present 106,490 patient records from 47 institutions• CPT codes limited July 2011 491 codes entered of which 160
accounted for for 90% of the cases• Piloting of ACS NSQIP Pediatric ENT Demonstration Project
April 2012 Total 42 CPT Codes
11
NSQIP-P The Process
Electronic DataOutcome Sciences
ACS Provides Sites with
Annual ReportsSupport
Performance Process
Improvement
Data to ACSRisk adjustment
Statistical analysis
SCR 30 dayData Collection
12
Background
• National Quality Forum• Institute of Medicine • Joint Commission• American Board of Surgery
13
Pediatric Databases/RegistryNational Pediatric Databases: 8,100,000 resultsPediatric Surgical Databases: 1,980,000 results
Health Care Cost and Utilization Project (AHRQ) Kids Inpatient Database (KID) Pediatric Health Information System (PHIS) National Database of Nursing Quality Indicators (NDNQI) National Healthcare Safety Network (NHSN) National Research Center (NRC) ORYX Joint Commission NACHRI (National Association Of Children's Hospitals and
of the Related Institutions) NACH National Association of Children's Hospital CHCA (Children's Health Corporation of America)• Case Mix Comparative Data Mix• Quality Measurement System (PQMS)• Quality Transformation Network• Children's Hospital Neonatal Consortium
Trauma – TRISS methodology, Pennsylvania trauma database, NTDB(ACS)
Cardiac Surgery – STS database, others National Cardiovascular Data Registry (NCDR)
• Pediatric Cadiomyopathy• Pediatric Perioperative Cardiac Arrest (POCA)• Prospective Assessment after Pediatric cardiac Ablation
Transplantation – UNOS Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients (SRTR)
Vermont Oxford Network
VPS
(SPS ) Solutions for Patient Safety
Improve Care Now
Congenital Diaphragmatic Hernia Study Group Registry
Cystic Fibrosis Pediatric Inflammatory Bowel Disease Database Stroke in Infants and Children
Children Oncology Group• Intercontinental Registry for the Treatment of Choriod
Plexus Tumors• International Adrenocortic Tumor Registry Blastoma• Pediatric CML Registry
Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis Multicenter Registry in Sickle Cell Disease Patients United States Immunodeficiency Network (USIDNET)
14
Improving Outcomes Requires Measurement
82%of hospitals decreased complications*
66%of hospitals decreased mortality*
250-500fewer complications per hospital per year*
*Hall BL, et al. “Does Surgical Quality Improve in the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program?” Ann Surg. 2009; 250:363-376
Quality: ACS NSQIP - Pediatrics
16
Provide reliable and actionable data about a site’s performance
Analyze and interpret results Identify quality improvement opportunities:
• Proactive versus Reactive• Re-engineer workflow – clinical processes of care• Foster and improve internal education• Identify and develop clinical performance
improvement initiatives• Share best practices• Benchmark performance against peers• Conduct research• Re-engineer or eliminate retrospective clinical
databases historically used for quality assurance for The Joint Commission reporting
Pediatric NSQIPPrimary Role – Act on the Data
Assess NSQIP-P DataFocus on:
Occurrences with the highest frequency
Services with the highest occurrences
Specific populations with the highest occurrences
Patients with the highest occurrences
Procedures with the highest occurrences
Every Occurrence is a Patient and a family
18
CHW ALL Services Surgical Cases All Services Surgical Cases Comparison HospitalsTotal Cases 1542 37,158Mortality within 30 Days of Surgery 8 (0.5%) 97 (0.3%)
Post Operative Occurrence Rate 6.7% 8.4%Total of Cases with Post‐Op Occurrences 103 3105
Transfusion Intraop/Postop (72h of surgery start time
70 (4.5%) 1682 (4.5%)
Unplanned Intubation 12 (0.8%) 160 (0.4%)Superficial Incisional SSI 12 (0.8%) 449 (1.2%)Urinary Tract Infections 7 (0.5%) 266 (0.7%)Postoperative Systemic Sepsis 5 (0.3%) 223 (0.6%)Wound Disruption 5 (0.3%) 252 (0.7%)Deep Incisional SSI 3 (0.2%) 122 (0.3%)Venous Thrombosis Requiring Therapy 3 (0.2%) 41 (0.1%)Seizure 3 (0.2%) 85 (0.2%)Central‐Line Associated Blood Stream Infection
2 (0.1%) 51 (0.1%)
IVH Grade 1 2 (0.1%) 8 (0.0%)Pneumonia 1 (0.1%) 189 (0.5%)Cardiac Arrest Requiring CPR 1 (0.1%) 46 (0.1%)Organ/Space SSI 1 (0.1%) 189 (0.5%)Nerve Injury 1 (0.0%) 43 (0.1%)Pulmonary Embolism 0 (0.0%) 4 (0.0%)Acute Renal Failure 0 (0.0%) 24 (0.1%)Progressive Renal Insufficiency 0 (0.0%) 19 (0.1%)Coma> 24 hours 0 (0.0%) 3 (0.0%)Cerebral Vascular Accident (CVA) Stroke of Intracranial Hemorrhage
0 (0.0%) 46 (0.1%)
Intraventricular Hemorrhage (IVH) gradeGrade 2 0 (0.0%) 3 (0.0%)Grade 3 0 (0.0%) 1 (0.0%)Grade 4 0 (0.0%) 1 (0.0%)Unknown /Specific grade not documented 0 (0.0%) 5 (0.0%)
Graft/Prosthesis/Flap Failure 0 (0.0%) 21 (0.1%)Sepsis 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%)
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Unplanned Intubations Number of Unplanned Intubations
• Surgical Services with most occurrence's of unplanned intubations• Population with most occurrences of Unplanned Intubations
Neonatal Population at Risk • Morbidity (Occurrences) are low in the pediatric surgical populations our highest
number of occurrence were unplanned intubations in the neonatal population• Neonates, defintion changes, with preoperative NSQIP-p risks factors which may
include congenital cardiac disease, congenital malformations, ASA PS class 3-5,Extensive or physiologically-destabilizing surgeries
The need to address the severity grading of occurrences • Not all unplanned intubations are clinically regarded as equal• For example: an unplanned intubation for a cardiac arrest compared to patient
who self extubates
With the low event rate in children • The need to utilize national data to assess if other institutions are seeing the
same occurrence of unplanned intubations To assess the patients who experience unplanned intubations To validate that unplanned intubations are seen in the neonatal surgical
population
Decision to collect all data on the unplanned intubations in the NICU
26
Unplanned Intubations An Occurrence Equals a Patient and Family
First Steps in developing a plan to address the issue of unplanned intubations Utilize the NSQIP-P data to understand the problem exists Involve your Surgeon Champion Find the right people to address the concern
• Surgeons• NICU director• Anesthesia• Nursing Staff• Fellows and Residents• Nurse Practitioner and PA’s• Respiratory Therapists
Administration
Case by case analysis to validate the problem and the specific populations Neonatal Patients
Bring the issue to the attention of the NICU Director Do a root cause analysis
• Type of surgery• Length of surgery• Anesthesia given
Assess the preoperative risk factors of patients• Utilizing NSQIP-P variables
Assess post operative risk factors• Weaning protocol for patients• Pain control• Narcotic use• Infection
27
Total Counts and Percentages of NSQIP-P Morbidity (occurrences) by Surgical Service: October 7, 2008 –December 31, 2010
Morbidity (Occurrences)Pediatric Surgery
Pediatric Neurosurgery
Pediatric Orthopedic
SurgeryPediatric Urology Plastics
Pediatric Otolaryngology Orthopedics Total
Unplanned Intubation 24 5 1 1 1 2 0 34
Superficial Incision SSI
Postoperative Systemic Sepsis
Urinary Tract Infection
Deep Incision SSI
Central-Line Associated Bloodstream Infection
Organ/Space SSI
Pneumonia
Wound Disruption
Seizure
Venous Thrombosis requiring Therapy
Grade 1
Nerve Injury
Progressive Renal Insufficiency
Acute Renal Failure
Cardiac Arrest Requiring CPR
Cerebral Vascular Accident (CVA)/Stroke or Intracranial Hemorrhage
Graft/Prosthesis/Flap Failure
Unknown/Specific grade not documented
Total Morbidity (Occurrences) 28
Total Counts of NSQIP-P Morbidity (occurrences) by Surgical Service: January 1, 2010–December 31, 2010
Morbidity (Occurrences)Pediatric Surgery
Pediatric Orthopedic
Surgery PlasticsPediatric
Neurosurgery Pediatric Urology Pediatric Otolaryngology Total
Transfusion
Unplanned Intubation 9 0 0 2 1 0 12
Unplanned Intubation Neonates 7 0 0 0 1 0 8
Superficial Incision SSI
Postoperative Systemic Sepsis
Wound Disruption
Urinary Tract Infection
Deep Incision SSI
IVH
Central-Line Associated Bloodstream Infection
Venous Thrombosis requiring Therapy
Pneumonia
Acute Renal Failure
Cardiac Arrest Requiring CPR
Seizure
Organ/Space SSI
Nerve Injury
Progressive Renal Insufficiency
Cerebral Vascular Accident (CVA)/Stroke or Intracranial Hemorrhage
Coma > 24 Hours
Graft/Prosthesis/Flap Failure
Pulmonary Embolism
Total Morbidity (Occurrences)29
Total Counts of NSQIP-P Morbidity (occurrences) by Surgical Service: January 1, 2011–December 31, 2011
Morbidity (Occurrences)Pediatric Surgery
Pediatric Orthopedic
Surgery PlasticsPediatric
Neurosurgery Pediatric Urology Pediatric Otolaryngology Total
Transfusion
Unplanned Intubation 6 0 0 2 0 0 8
Unplanned Intubation Neonates 2 0 0 1 0 0 3
Superficial Incision SSI
Postoperative Systemic Sepsis
Wound Disruption
Urinary Tract Infection
Deep Incision SSI
IVH
Central-Line Associated Bloodstream Infection
Venous Thrombosis requiring Therapy
Pneumonia
Acute Renal Failure
Cardiac Arrest Requiring CPR
Seizure
Organ/Space SSI
Nerve Injury
Progressive Renal Insufficiency
Cerebral Vascular Accident (CVA)/Stroke or Intracranial Hemorrhage
Coma > 24 Hours
Graft/Prosthesis/Flap Failure
Pulmonary Embolism
Total Morbidity (Occurrences)30
Unplanned Intubations - ALL
31
Unplanned Intubations – Neonatal
32
Unplanned Intubations Next StepsVision/Next Steps Assessment of the Data: on Unplanned Intubations Data reported to the NICU director and potential
improvements were identified Goal to change PracticeKey Requirements Neonatal team committed to collecting further data Data will be collected and reported with continued reporting
of ACS NSQIP data Discussion of unplanned intubation at weekly M&M Movement toward understanding and analyzing trends of
occurrences vs. singular events Identify quality improvement opportunities and
interventions
Benchmark Performance 33
34
35
NSQIP ROI CALCULATORhttp://site.acsnsqip.org/about/business-case/roi-calculator/
Complication $ Cost Per Case
Averted Events
QI Revenue
Ventilator >48 hrs 27,654 X 17 = $470,118
UTI 12,828 X 12 = $153,936
Pulmonary Embolism
16,644 X 0=
$ 0
Cardiac Arrest 15,079 X 4 = $60,316
Pneumonia 22,097 X 24 = $530,328
Unplanned Intubation
21,025 X 7=
$147,175
Deep SSI 20,012 X 15 = $300,180
$1,662,05336
Potential Cost Savings if U.S. Hospitals Adopt ACS NSQIP
Reducing preventable complications improves care and reduces costs: Reduction in complications: 250-500* Average cost per complication: $11,626 Average savings per hospital: $2,906,500 - $5,813,000 Potential yearly savings across 4,500 hospitals: $13 - $26
billion Estimated total savings over a decade**: $130 - $260
billion
*Per hospital/per year; Hall BL, et al. “Does Surgical Quality Improve in the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program?” Ann Surg. 2009; 250:363-376**Length of time used for health reform calculations
Potential for ACS NSQIP-P ROI CALCULATOR for Pediatrics
Complication $ Cost Per Case
Averted Events
QI Revenue
Unplanned Intubation
Cost X Event = Potential Cost Savings
Pneumonia $ X = $
SSI $ X = $
UTI $ X = $
Postoperative Systemic Sepsis
$ X = $
Deep SSI $ X=
$
Wound Disruption & X = $
$
Cost Savings Pediatrics
Number of complications Cost of complication: $ Potential savings per hospital: $ Examples of real NSQIP-P hospitals
• Hospital X reduced SSIs over 2 years for savings of $• Hospital X reduce Unplanned intubation over 2 years
saving of $• Hospital X reduced LOS for annual savings of $
39
Anesthesia Initiative
Data reported to Anesthesia
Concern about reliability of ASA classifications
Further breakdown of NSQIP-P Data
ASA data by CPT and ICD-9 codes provided
Discussed ASA class with other anesthesia staff
Discussed ASA class with surgeons during cases
Next step to collect additional data
40
ASA-Adjusted Mortality Rate
Average ASA PS class: 2.3; mortality trend decreasing (as patient severity trend increasing)
48H mortality 30D mortality
0.00
2.00
4.0
06.00
8Ad
just
ed R
ate
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011Year
ASA-Adjusted Mortality Rates
Definition: Number of patients who died within 48 hours or 30 days of anesthesia/Number of anesthesia casesData source: ORMIS/ASPIRE database query 12/7/2011 41
Transfusions Number of Transfusions
• Surgical Services with most occurrence's of transfusions• Population with most occurrences of transfusions
Plastics and Pediatric Orthopedic Population at Risk • Morbidity (Occurrences) are low in the pediatric surgical populations high number of occurrence were
transfusion in the plastics and pediatric orthopedic populations• Patients congenital malformations and Extensive or physiologically-destabilizing surgery
The need to address the severity grading of occurrences • Not all transfusions are clinically regarded as equal• For example: transfusion for craniosysnostosis compared to patient with a spinal fusion
With the low event rate in children • The need to utilize national data to assess if other institutions are seeing the same occurrence of transfusions.
To assess the patients who experience transfusion To validate that transfusions are seen in the plastics and pediatric orthopedic populations
Review transfusion practices with Pediatric Orthopedic and Plastic Surgery Attending and Anesthesiologist
Decision to collect more data on transfusion practices
42
SPECIFIC Areas for Quality Initiatives
Reduce unplanned intubations
Validate ASA scores across the institution
Reduce intraoperative and post operative transfusions
43
44
Preoperative Cardiac Risk Assessment for Patients Requiring Non-cardiac Surgery
Determine if child is appropriate for a non-cardiac surgery Identify risk factors for surgery which may be surgery related or
patient related Does the NSQIP-P collect the correct preoperative variables and
correct cardiac variables Collaborate with all NSQIP-P hospitals to analyze data for further
revision of cardiac variables Is the collection of cardiac variables valid and reliable Can the NSQIP-P variables become a standardized tool to
stratify surgery risk for pediatric cardiac patients requiring non-cardiac surgery
45
How to Utilize Data for Improvement Assess the surgical complications that would be prevented
Assess the revenue that would be realized from preventing complications
Assess the of patient days that would be available to the institution because we were not caring for Children suffering these increased complications
Sharing of Best Practices
46
CollaborativesWorking Together to Improve Surgical Care
“National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP®) participating hospitals that come together to discuss best practices, quality improvement initiatives and/or to compare their surgical outcomes in a positive learning environment (ACS, 2012).”
“Discuss surgical outcomes, quality improvement opportunities and experiences with hospitals that share similar interests and concerns (ACS, 2012).”
“Group calls and meetings facilitate the exchange of ideas and problem-solving (ACS, 2012).”
“Enhanced data sharing and specialized reports that go beyond the standard semiannual and online benchmarking reports to compare the results of each collaborating site to the collaborative as a whole, and the collaborative as a whole to all sites nationwide (ACS, 2012).”
“Some collaboratives have partnered with payors to offset the cost of collaboration or provide collaborative coordination (ACS, 2012).”
American College of Surgeions (2012). Collaboratives. Retreived from: http://site.acsnsqip.org/participants/collaboratives/ 47
Current Adult Collaboratives Regional Collaboratives:
Connecticut Surgical Quality Collaborative (nine sites) Florida Surgical Care Initiative (67 sites) Illinois Surgical Quality Improvement Collaborative (10 sites) Nebraska Collaborative (four sites) Oregon NSQIP Consortia (seven sites) Pennsylvania Collaborative (10 sites) Tennessee Surgical Quality Collaborative (21 sites) Upstate New York Surgical Quality Initiative (six sites) Virginia Collaborative (five sites)
System-Wide Collaboratives: Clarian Health System (two sites) Department of Defense/Tricare (16 sites) Fraser Health-Canada (three sites) Kaiser Permanente Northern California (six sites) Kaiser Permanente Southern California (four sites) Mayo Clinic Surgical Quality Collaborative (four sites) Partners HealthCare (five sites)
Virtual Collaboratives: ACS NSQIP Colectomy Collaborative ACS NSQIP Glucose Control Collaborative
48
Future Direction The ACS NSQIP Pediatric is an opportunity to advance children’s surgery and measure the
quality of care being delivered to children across the United States and internationally
Provides Risk adjusted clinical surgical data and Annual Data Reports with hierarchal modeling, which has never been available
Risk –adjusted data driven quality improvement initiatives to improve outcomes and reduce complications
Local use of this risk-adjusted data to enable participating hospitals to compare their results to others institutions nationally and begin research
Define specific preoperative variables and procedure outcomes based on CPT Codes
Development of surgical specialty service preoperative and outcome variables
The ability to develop risk adjusted standardized tools to stratify surgical risk
Collaboration of hospitals across the country to develop better quality measures and share Best Practices
49
NSQIP- Pediatric Data
Translates into Improved Care
Which makes a difference in the life of a
child
50
51
Thank You
Questions?
52
top related