oarsi jr1

Statistics

Jonas Ranstam PhD

Statistics

A scientific report

The idea is to try and give all the information to help others to judge the value of your contributions, not just the information that leads to judgment in one particular direction or another.

Richard P. Feynman

Statistics

Description of observed data

mean, median, mode (central tendency)standard deviation, range (dispersion)

Presentation of uncertainty

p-value, statistical significance (hypothesis testing)confidence interval, SEM (interval estimation)

Statistics

What uncertainty?

Generalization uncertainty, for example:

- From one sample of rats to all rats (the uncertainty caused by biological variability)

- From a single measurement on a single rat to all measurements of the same kind on the same rat (the uncertainty caused by using imperfect measurement instruments, i.e. reliability)

Statistics

What determines the degree of uncertainty?

1. The number of observations

2. The variability

Statistics

What is important when presenting results?

1. The number of observations

2. The variability

Reported mean concentration with ±SD (bar chart)

Observed mean concentration (dotplot)

Estimated mean concentration with 95% confidence intervals

Statistics

Why use CI instead of SEM?

Because the CI is the better measure of uncertainty

n SEM CI (for a mean value)

2 ±1 50% 3 ±1 58% 4 ±1 63% 6 ±1 64% 7 ±1 65% ∞ ±1 68%

Statistics

Other problems related to generalization uncertainty

1. Independence of observations

2. Gaussian probability distribution

3. Multiplicity

Statistics

1. Independent observations (2 treatments, 4 rats, n = ?)

n = 4

n = 8

n = 96

Statistics

Independent observations

Distinguish between:

1. Biological variation

2. Measurement reliability

Describe the sources of variation clearly in the manuscript! How many animals, repeated observations, technical replicates, etc. have been analyzed?

Statistics

Recommended reading

Churchill GA. Fundamentals of experimental design for cDNA microarrays. Nature Genetics 2002;32S:490-495.

2. Gaussian distribution

Statistics

Are your results empirically supported?

Or do they rely on your assumptions?

- Student's t-test (Gaussian, identical variance)

- Mann-Whitney U-test (identical shape and variance)

Statistics

Did you check if the assumptions were fulfilled?

- How did you do it?

- What was the result?

Describe it in the manuscript!

Statistics

3. Multiplicity

With more than one tested null hypothesis the real significance level will differ from the nominal

Statistics

3. Multiplicity

- Multiplicity corrections correct the type-1 error rate

- Multiplicity corrections increase the type-2 error rate

Statistics

3. Multiplicity

- Bonferroni is not a good method, several better exist, for example the methods developed

by Holm and Hochberg

- P-value corrections within endpoints do not solve the problem of testing multiple endpoints

Statistics

3. Multiplicity

What is your strategy for dealing with multiplicity? Are Bonferroni corrections necessary? Are all multiplicity issues addressed?

Describe it in the manuscript!

Statistics

Summary

As an author of a scientific report your task is to perform an adequate evaluation and presentation of the uncertainty and limitations of your findings.

This involves more than just calculating a p-value.

Statistics

Summary

When a well-done trial or experiment or observational study is fairly, honestly, and thoroughly reported, it will have so many warts, footnotes, and exceptions that it may be hard for the uninitiated to believe that the work was of high quality.

Frederick Mosteller

Thank you for your attention!