prepare(d) for impact - becquerel prize · wafer-based silicon pv: a personal swot strengths...

www.ecn.nl

Prepare(d) for impact photovoltaics on its way to terawatt-scale use

Wim Sinke

Contents

• The photovoltaic technology portfolio

- wafer-based silicon in perspective

• Meeting expectations: from gigawatts to terawatts

- can wafer-based silicon deliver?

• Outlook

- the benefits of diversity

Contents

• The photovoltaic technology portfolio

- wafer-based silicon in perspective

• Meeting expectations: from gigawatts to terawatts

- can wafer-based silicon deliver?

• Outlook

- the benefits of diversity

The many faces of wafer-based silicon PV

Early vision (Bell)

SunPower ECN Imec

Spain (Aesol)

Sanyo

Bolivia

Mali City of the Sun, NL Floriade, NL

Cell & module technologies (flat plate)

Commercial: thin films - silicon

- copper-indium/gallium-diselenide (CIGS)

- cadmium telluride (CdTe)

Module efficiencies 7 ~ 13% First Solar Helianthos Würth Solar

Pilot production and laboratory:

emerging and novel technologies - super-low-cost concepts

- super-high-efficiency concepts ECN/Holst Centre Amolf

Commercial: wafer-based

crystalline silicon - monocrystalline

- multicrystalline

- ribbons

Module efficiencies 13 ~ 19% Toyota

Cell & module technologies (concentrator)

Commercial: multi-junction III-V

semiconductors

Module efficiencies 25 ~ 30%

Abengoa/Concentrix

(FhG-ISE)

PV technology shares

7 25-10-

2013

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2030 2050

Wafers and thin films; flat-plate& concentrator

Concentrator PV; emergingtechnologies

Thin-film CIGS

Thin-film CdTe

Thin-film Si

Wafer-based Si

Sources:

- Photon International 03 2011

- Solar Generation 6

- Arnulf Jaeger-Waldau (private comm.)

- own estimates

terawatts

installed

gigawatts

installed

megawatts

installed

Contents

• The photovoltaic technology portfolio

- wafer-based silicon in perspective

• Meeting expectations: from gigawatts to terawatts

- can wafer-based silicon deliver?

• Outlook

- the benefits of diversity

9

Wafer-based silicon PV: a personal SWOT

Strengths Weaknesses

Opportunities

Threats

10

Wafer-based silicon PV: a personal SWOT

Strengths

• high efficiency

• extensive track record

reliability & lifetime

• synergy with micro-

& nanoelectronics industry

Weaknesses

Opportunities

Threats

11

Wafer-based silicon PV: a personal SWOT

Strengths

• high efficiency

• extensive track record

reliability & lifetime

• synergy with micro-

& nanoelectronics industry

Weaknesses (current)

• poorly integrated processing

• significant materials cost

component

• suboptimal aesthetics of some

products

Opportunities

Threats

12

Wafer-based silicon PV: a personal SWOT

Strengths

• high efficiency

• extensive track record

reliability & lifetime

• synergy with micro-

& nanoelectronics industry

Weaknesses (current)

• poorly integrated processing

• significant materials cost

component

• suboptimal aesthetics of some

products

Opportunities

Threats

13

Wafer-based silicon PV: a personal SWOT

Strengths

• high efficiency

• extensive track record

reliability & lifetime

• synergy with micro-

& nanoelectronics industry

Weaknesses (current)

• poorly integrated processing

• significant materials cost

component

• suboptimal aesthetics of some

products

Opportunities

• further increase total-area

efficiency

• reduce materials consumption

& use low-cost materials

• implement advanced device

designs & processes

Threats

14

Wafer-based silicon PV: a personal SWOT

Strengths

• high efficiency

• extensive track record

reliability & lifetime

• synergy with micro-

& nanoelectronics industry

Weaknesses (current)

• poorly integrated processing

• significant materials cost

component

• suboptimal aesthetics of some

products

Opportunities

• further increase total-area

efficiency

• reduce materials consumption

& use low-cost materials

• implement advanced device

designs & processes

Threats

15

Wafer-based silicon PV: a personal SWOT

Strengths

• high efficiency

• extensive track record

reliability & lifetime

• synergy with micro-

& nanoelectronics industry

Weaknesses (current)

• poorly integrated processing

• significant materials cost

component

• suboptimal aesthetics of some

products

Opportunities

• further increase total-area

efficiency

• reduce materials consumption

& use low-cost materials

• implement advanced device

designs & processes

Threats

Selected options

for improvement: • heterojunctions

• rear-contact /rear junction

cell designs

• n-type silicon

• Al2O3 surface passivation

• kerfless wafer cutting

• advanced light trapping

• seeded ingot casting

• high quality solar grade silicon

• Cu replacing Ag

• new encapsulants

• tandems

• more

16

Wafer-based silicon PV: a personal SWOT

Strengths

• high efficiency

• extensive track record

reliability & lifetime

• synergy with micro-

& nanoelectronics industry

Weaknesses (current)

• poorly integrated processing

• significant materials cost

component

• suboptimal aesthetics of some

products

Opportunities

• further increase total-area

efficiency

• reduce materials consumption

& use low-cost materials

• implement advanced device

designs & processes

Threats

• innovations remain in the lab

• cost reduction curve saturates

at too high level (what is

needed for very large scale

use?)

• image of “technology of the

past”

Contents

• The photovoltaic technology portfolio

- wafer-based silicon in perspective

• Meeting expectations: from gigawatts to terawatts

- can wafer-based silicon deliver?

• Outlook

- the benefits of diversity

The benefits of diversity

Evolution of technology portfolio and module

efficiencies (IEA PV Roadmap, 2010)

Crystalline silicon: first generation PV?

Crystalline silicon: first generation PV?

PVSAT-6, Southampton, UK, 25 March 2010 22

Summary

Thank you:

• my colleagues at ECN and at Utrecht University

• the members of the European Photovoltaic Technology

Platform

• the people at EPIA, WIP, Eurec and JRC

• the CrystalClear team

• the Becquerel committee

• the European Commission and the Dutch Ministry of

Economic Affairs

• my family: Ineke, Koen, Pelle and Corijn

• you, the audience

• all other PV advocates around the world

9 March

2010

24

24

©Greenpeace