research in physics education: a resource for improving ... · tutorial components •weekly...

Researchinphysicseducation:Aresourceforimprovingstudentlearning

LillianC.McDermottPeterS.ShafferUniversityofWashington

NewPhysicsandAstronomyFacultyWorkshopNovember2017

PhysicsEducationGroupattheUniversityofWashington

PhysicsPh.D.Graduates27(1979-2017)

PhysicsPh.D.StudentsAnneAlesandriniDeanBretlandShehLitChangKevinCutlerLisaGoodhewTongWanBertXue

FacultyLillianC.McDermottPaulaHeronPeterShafferSuzanneWhite-Brahmia

Lecturers&Post-docsDonnaMessina(K-12teacher)AlexisOlsho

Coordinatedprogramofresearch,curriculumdevelopment,andinstructionsupportedinpartbygrantsfromtheNationalScienceFoundation.

2

Summaryofworkshop

• OverviewofresearchandcurriculumdevelopmentbyUWPhysicsEducationGroup

• Directexperiencewithcurriculum(aTutorialfromTutorialsinIntroductoryPhysics)

• Discussionofimpactonstudentlearning

• Generalizationsontheteachingandlearningofphysics

3

GoalsofUWPhysicsEducationGroup

• Conductresearchonlearningandteachingofphysicsconceptsandreasoning(differsfromresearchinCollegesofEducation)

• Developinstructionalproceduresthat:– areeffectiveathelpingstudentslearn(conceptsandreasoning)– yieldsimilarresultswhenusedbyfacultyatotherinstitutions

• Documentimpactandproceduresinjournalsthatarereadbyphysicsfaculty(writteninlanguageaccessibletophysicists)– Tohelpallfacultyimprovetheeffectivenessofinstruction

whetherornottheyareengagedinphysicseducationresearch.

• StrengthenthepreparationofK-12teacherstoteachphysicsandastronomybyinquiry

4

Inworkingtowardthesegoals,wehavecometoanimportantgeneralization:

Oncertaintypesofqualitativequestions,studentperformanceisessentiallythesameoverawiderangeofstudentability:

• beforeandafterstandardinstruction• incalculus-basedandalgebra-basedcourses• withandwithoutstandarddemonstrations

• withandwithoutstandardlaboratory• inlargeandsmallclasses

• regardlessofpopularityoftheinstructor

Hearinglectures,readingtextbooks,seeingdemonstrations,doinghomework,andperforminglaboratoryexperimentsoftenhavelittleeffectonstudentlearning.

5

Evidencefromresearchindicatesgap

Instructor

Student

Curriculum

Gapgreaterthanmostinstructorsrealize6

◊ Teachingbytellingisanineffectivemodeofinstructionformoststudents.

Teachingbyquestioningcanbemoreeffective.

Studentsmustbeintellectuallyactive

7

Caution:

“activelearning”doesnotalwaysleadto

“intellectualengagement”

Documentedresearchisnecessarytodeterminethedepthofunderstanding.

8

Systematicinvestigationsofstudentlearning(atthebeginning,during,andafterinstruction)

• individualdemonstrationinterviews• forprobingstudentunderstandingindepth

•writtenquestionswithexplanations(pretestsandpost-tests)

• forascertainingprevalenceofspecificdifficulties• forassessingeffectivenessofinstruction

•descriptivestudiesduringinstruction• forprovidinginsightstoguidecurriculumdevelopment

9

CurriculumDevelopmentResearch

InstructionatUW

Instructionatpilotsites

Applicationofresearchtodevelopmentofcurriculum

Research-based≠Research-validated10

Research-basedcurriculumdevelopment

Preparingprecollegeteacherstoteachphysicsandphysicalscience

– PhysicsbyInquiry–(JohnWiley&Sons,Inc.,1996)

Self-contained,laboratory-based,nolectures

Improvingstudentlearninginintroductoryphysics

– TutorialsinIntroductoryPhysics–(PrenticeHall,2002)

Supplementarytolecture-basedcourse

Tutorialsrespondtotheresearchquestion:

Isstandardpresentationofabasictopicintextbookorlectureadequatetodevelopafunctionalunderstanding?

(i.e., theabilitytodothereasoningnecessarytoapplyrelevantconceptsandprinciplesinsituationsnotexplicitlystudied)

Ifnot,

whatneedstobedone?

12

Primarycontext(atUW)fortutorials

Eachweek:• 3lectures(50minutes)

• 1laboratory(2-3hours)

• 1tutorial(50minutes)

However,tutorialscanbeusedinlecturesorlabsdependingonconstraints

13

TutorialComponents•weeklypretests• givenusuallyafterlectureonrelevantmaterialbutbeforetutorial

• tutorialsessions• smallgroups(3-4)workthroughcarefullystructuredworksheets• tutorialinstructorsquestionstudentsinsemi-Socraticmanner

• tutorialhomework

Additionalcriticalcomponents• examinationquestionsbasedontutorials

– sostudentstakeseriouslytheemphasisonunderstanding

• requiredweeklyseminarfortutorialinstructors– graduateandundergraduateinstructors,etc.– preparationincontentandinstructionalmethod– TAstakepretest,workthroughtutorial,anddiscussstudentresponses.

14

Exampleoftutorial:Dynamicsofrigidbodies

• Pretest- Pleasecompleteonyourown;takenomorethanabout5minutestoanswer.

• Tutorial-Workinsmallgroupsfollowedbyfull-workshopdiscussions(nottypicalofstudenttutorialsessions)

• Discussionofimpactoftutorialandgeneralizationsonmethod

15

Smallgroupactivity:page1Aspoolispulledacrossafrictionlesstableasshown.Thehandpullshorizontally.Thethreadhasbeenwrappedmanytimesaroundthebottomofthespool.

• Predict whetherthespoolwillrotate.Explain.

• Predict whetherthecenterofthespoolwillmoveandifso,inwhichdirection.Explain.

Asinstructors,discussanswersthatstudentsmightgiveandwhattheanswersmightindicateaboutstudentthinking.

16

Testyouranswersbyobservingtheexperimentonatablewith friction.

Whatdoyourobservationssuggestwouldhappenifthetablewerefrictionless?

Largegroupactivity

Spoolonvarioustables(varyingfriction)

Spoolonairtable(negligiblefriction)

Examplesofstudentresponsestospoolsquestionfrompage1(e.g., whengivenaspretest)

Thespoolwillrotateandnottranslate

• “Theforceofthestringwillcausetorque....Thereisnoforceapplieddirectlytothespooltomakeitgoforward.”

Thespoolwilltranslateandnotrotate

• “Thereisnofrictionsothe… particlesontheotherside[ofthespool]havenoforcekeepingitput- sothespoolwillnotrotate.”

• “onafrictionlesssurface… tensionwillnotgeneraterotationbecausethereisnoforceintheoppositedirection… forrotation… theremustbeaforceinthepositiveandnegativedirectiononthespooland… thereisnonegativeforce.”

19

Beliefthatforcenotatcenterofmassresultsinrotationonly.

Beliefthatforcenotatcenterofmassresultsonlyintranslationofentireobject-- unlessanotherforceactstorotateobject

Smallgroupactivity:page2Ablockandspoolareeachpulledacrossalevel,frictionlesssurfacebyastring.• Predict theorderinwhichtheycrossthefinishline.

• Threestudentsdiscusstheexperiment.1. Thespoolrotatesandbothfinishatthesametime …

samemassandnetforcesothecentershavethesameacceleration.Thetensionshavethesameeffectontranslationalmotion.

2. Thespoolcrossesaftertheblock.Sometensionisusedtorotatethespool.Whenaforcecausesrotation,ithaslesseffectontranslation.

3. Iagreethespoolrotatesandcrosseslater,butIwasthinkingaboutenergy.Theyhavethesametotalkineticenergyatthefinishline.SincethespoolhassomerotationalKE,itmusthavelesstranslationalKE.

Withwhichstudentdoyouagree?

Continuetopage3whenyouandyourpartnersareready. 20

Smallgroupactivity:page3

Twoidenticalspoolsareconnectedbyathreadthatrunsoveranidealpulley.ThethreadiswrappedaroundspoolAmanytime,butisattachedtoafixedpointonspoolB.

Thespoolsarereleasedfromthesameheightatthesametime.

• Predict whetherspoolAwillhitthefloorbefore,after, oratthesametimeas spoolB.

• Drawthefollowingdiagramsforeachspool,correspondingtoatimeshortlyafterrelease:o anextendedfree-bodydiagram

o a(point)free-bodydiagram

• Whatwouldeachstudentonthepreviouspagepredict?

Wewilldiscusstheanswersandobserveavideoasgroup.21

Dynamicsofrigidbodies,page3

• Drawforeachspool:• anextendedfree-bodydiagram• a(point)free-bodydiagram

22

Dynamicsofrigidbodies,page3

• Drawforeachspool:• anextendedfree-bodydiagram• a(point)free-bodydiagram

23

Dynamicsofrigidbodies,page3

• Whatwouldeachstudentonthepreviouspagepredict?

1. Theyhavethesamemassandsamenetforcesothecentersofmasshavethesameacceleration.Thetensionshavethesameeffectontranslationalmotion.

2. Sometensionisusedtorotatethespool.Whenaforcecausesrotation,ithaslesseffectontranslation.

3. Iwasthinkingaboutenergy.Theyhavethesametotalkineticenergyatthefinishline.SincethespoolhassomerotationalKE,itmusthavelesstranslationalKE.

Sameforces,samemassà AlandsatsametimeasB

24

Dynamicsofrigidbodies,page3

• Whatwouldeachstudentonthepreviouspagepredict?

1. Theyhavethesamemassandsamenetforcesothecentersofmasshavethesameacceleration.Thetensionshavethesameeffectontranslationalmotion.

2. Sometensionisusedtorotatethespool.Whenaforcecausesrotation,ithaslesseffectontranslation.

3. Iwasthinkingaboutenergy.Theyhavethesametotalkineticenergyatthefinishline.SincethespoolhassomerotationalKE,itmusthavelesstranslationalKE.

Sameforces,samemassà AlandsatsametimeasB

ThaslesseffectonAsoAhaslargernetforcedownà AlandsbeforeB

25

Dynamicsofrigidbodies,page3

• Whatwouldeachstudentonthepreviouspagepredict?

1. Theyhavethesamemassandsamenetforcesothecentersofmasshavethesameacceleration.Thetensionshavethesameeffectontranslationalmotion.

2. Sometensionisusedtorotatethespool.Whenaforcecausesrotation,ithaslesseffectontranslation.

3. Iwasthinkingaboutenergy.Theyhavethesametotalkineticenergyatthefinishline.SincethespoolhassomerotationalKE,itmusthavelesstranslationalKE.

Threedifferentpredictions

Sameforces,samemassà AlandsatsametimeasB

ThaslesseffectonAsoAhaslargernetforcedownà AlandsbeforeB

Sametotalenergy,Ahasrotationalandkineticà AlandsafterB

26

Spoolsconnectedby

string

Smallgroupactivity:page4

F.Supposeyouwanttodecidehowagivenforceaffectsthetranslationalmotionofthecenterofmassofanobject.Shouldyouconsider:

•whereontheobjecttheforceisexerted?

• howtheforceisaffectingtherotationalmotionoftheobject?

IntheTutorialhomework, studentsreconciletheirresultswithworkandenergy

28

Assessmentsofstudentlearning

• Pretests:Afteralllecture&textbookinstructionbutbeforetutorial.

oProvidemotivationfortutorialandyieldinsightsintostudentreasoningoManyversionsusedtotestaspectsofstudentunderstanding

• Post-tests: AfterallinstructionincludingTutorialandTutorialHomework.

oTypicallysomewhatmoredifficultorindifferentcontextthanpretests

Note:Resultsareusuallyindependentofinstructorortextbookwithvariationsof𝑎𝑏𝑜𝑢𝑡 ±5%fromclasstoclass.

"StudentunderstandingoftheapplicationofNewton‘ssecondlawtorotatingrigidbodies,”H.G.Close,L.S.Ortiz,andP.R.L.Heron,Am.J.Phys. 81 (6)2013 29

ResultsfrommanyPretests&Post-tests

Pucks Block-and-spool

Pretest Post-test Pretest Post-test

Correct(Equalacceleration/time) 20% 70% 5% 80%

Treatingtranslation asreducedifaforcealsoresultsinrotation 65% <15% 80% <10%

30

Manyyearsofresearchrequiredtoobtainsatisfactoryresults:

• Version1:o ‘Unconnectedspools’o Studentdialogue(butwithouthavingstudentsapplyeachstudent’sreasoningtonewcase)

à someimprovement:20%to40%correct

• Versions2&3o‘Unconnectedspools’oQuestionsaddedtoaddressdirectlytheideathattheeffectofaforceontranslationisdecreasediftheforcealsocausesrotation.

• Version4:o ‘Connectedspools’experimentdevelopedtotargetkeyideadirectly(sincetheforcesonbothspoolsarethesame).

31

à onlysmallgains(studentscouldstate‘translationisindependentofpointofapplication’,yetanswermanyquestionsincorrectly.

à ~70%to80%correct

Practical criterion for effectiveness of a tutorial:

Post-test performance of introductory studentsmatches (or surpasses)

pretest performance of graduate students.

(GraduateTAs~30%correctoncircularpucksquestion)

32

Generalizationbasedonfindingsfromresearch:

Itisinsufficientfortheinstructorto

• giveclearexplanations

• showdemonstrations

• assignproblemsandprovidesolutions

• beinformedaboutstudentdifficulties

Activementalengagementbythestudents,themselves,isnecessary.

On qualitative problems:

• much better

Onquantitativeproblems(e.g.,endofchapter):– typicallysomewhatbetter

– sometimesmuchbetter

Effectoftutorialsonstudentperformance

Assessments of student learning at UW and beyond on many topics

despite less time devoted to solving standard problems

Onretention:– sometimesmuchbetter

34

The tutorials are one example of how, with a small time allotment, a research-based curriculum can help:

•make physics meaningful to students

• provide a foundation for quantitative problem solving

• develop scientific reasoning ability

evenunderconstraintsoflargeclasssize,breadthofcoverage,fastpace,limitedtime

35

The perspective that teaching is a science, as well as an art, is an effective approach for:

• setting high (yet realistic) standards

• assessing the extent to which meaningful learning takes place

• helping students meet expectations

36