ruchita udani - work life balance
Post on 14-Apr-2018
218 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
1/46
A
COMPREHENSIVE PROJECT REPORT
ON
Work Life Balance
A Project report submitted in Partial Fulfillment of award
of MBA Degree to Gujarat Technical University
:PROJECT GUIDE:
PROF.SUNIL MISHRA
: SUBMITTED BY:
RUCHITA .R. UDANIMANALI RAJPARA
SUBMITTED TO:
M.H. GARDI INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENTRAJKOT, (ANANDPAR).
Batch:-2011-2013
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
2/46
We hereby declare that the project report entitled A study on work life
balance of the employees is the product of our own effort, to the best of our
knowledge and belief. This comprehensive Project Report is being submitted by
us, at M.H Gardi School Of Management, Rajkot, for the partial fulfillment of
the MBA course, and the report has not been submitted to any other educational
institutions for any other purpose.
Place: Rajkot
Date
(Signature)
Ruchita .R. Udani
Manali .P. Rajpara
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
3/46
Knowledge is power and ideas rule the world
This is the result of research into the work-Life Balance of the employees.
This research is aimed to support employees to balance work and personal life,
by systematic balancing between work (career, profession, goal, and ambition)
and life (family, health, enjoyment) and vice versa. It also emphases on
perceptions of organization towards work life balance. This research was
performed in the context of the finalization of the Master of Business
Administration.
For effective work life balance satisfaction, trust, motivation, benefits are
very useful tool to measure. Organizational goal also can be achieve effectively.
The information contained in the report is illustrative and by no meansexhaustive. Any comments and suggestions for effective implementation of the
projects identified in the report are welcome.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
4/46
Expression of feelings by words makes them less significant when it
comes to make statement of gratitude
The research and this report are made in cooperation with several
persons. We would like to use this opportunity to thank them.
First of all we would like to express our regards and thanks to Dr. Sandip
Solanki, Director .With a deep sense of gratitude and humble submission We
would like to express our heartiest gratefulness to our Faculty Guide Prof. Sunil
Mishra, Professor of M.H.Gardi, Rajkot, for guiding us throughout our
Comprehensive Project.
We give heartiest thanks to all d faculty members and our classmates for
supporting us throughout project.
Finally we would like to thank our parents who helped us to make this
project. We appreciate every bit of encouragement you all gave us to make this
project successful.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
5/46
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Every man and woman in this world has to balance their life. Work life
balance itself gives very broad idea about the how work and life both are very
important and both have to be balanced. The entire project is based on research.
In this project, try to find how employees are balancing their social and
work life. This entire project talks about different factors which are important
for the balancing of life. From this research studies, we will able to know that
in organization, how employees are managing their life. What kind of support
they are getting from the organization as well as from their families. Organizationas well as family is playing very important role for balancing ones life. Different
family member plays different roles to help ones to balance life.
From this research we can easily know that employees working in the
organization can balance their life very effectively. What kind of changes they
want in their organization and how they are feeling about their organization
regarding this topic. Also organization can get information and feelings of their
employees so that they can easily change their work culture if required.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
6/46
Sr. No. Particulars Page no.
1. Introduction
2. Background of the study Ten Essential Management Actions for
Creating Work Life Balance
Importance of Maintaining Work LifeBalance
What organization does for work lifebalance?
Factors influencing the evolution ofwork-life balance
3. Objective of the study
4. Problem statement
5. Literature review
Conclusion of literature
6. Hypothesis
7. References and websites
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
7/46
INTRODUCTION
Changes in the social, political and economic fabric of societies have
influenced and continue to influence both the nature of employment and its
relationship to life outside work. This project is set against a background of
changing trends in the work environment. In the 1970s the academic literature
was awash with articles assuming the continuation of trends predicting huge
increases in leisure time for the 21st century.
The following quotation sums this assumption up neatly. Until quite
recently it was widely assumed, particularly in and concerning the richer
countries, that working hours were steadily reducing, the amount of leisure timeincreasing and that these trends would continue. Many people looked forward to
a golden age of leisure (WTO, 1999: 3).
However, as national economies struggle to compete in an increasingly
competitive world economy, there are ramifications for employees. Changing
employment patterns together with changes in the demographic structure of the
workforce have resulted in a different reality for the 21st century. Instead of trying
to manage copious amounts of leisure time, many workers are instead trying to
juggle numerous responsibilities with the increased, intensified demands of work.
Such reality, and in particular, transformations in the structure of both the
workplace and the workforce imply that work practices and employers
expectations must change accordingly. The traditional assumption that
employees should be willing and able to make work their top priority in life is no
longer tenable. It is in this context that the notion of work -life balance has come
to the fore in policy debates.
Work-life balance is central to debates about quality of working life and its
relation to broader quality of life. Much has been written on the subject and this
project represents an attempt to extrapolate and synthesis the main themes
before exploring the nature of work-life balance.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
8/46
BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
Work Life Balance
Worklife balance is a broad concept including proper prioritizing between
"work" (career and ambition) on the one hand and "life" (Health, pleasure, leisure,
family and spiritual development) on the other. Related, though broader, terms
include "lifestyle balance" and "life balance". Work-life Balance also referred to as
family friendly work arrangements (FFWA), and, in international literature, as
alternative work arrangements (AWA).
To maintain work and life balance is the critical issue now a day for the
every employee. Work (career, profession, goal, and ambition) will be
counterweighted by the life (family, health, enjoyment) and vice versa. So
maintaining the right balance between two is the major task of an employee
because both are an important part of the life.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
9/46
Work-life balance is about people feeling satisfied with the way they divide
their time and energy between paid work and all the other things they need and
want to do. Work-life balance is important for people of all ages and stages of
life. It is important for individual employees who may have family responsibilities
or are active in their communities, for those who are keen to study, to keep fit, to
play sport and to enjoy life. It is also important for employers because employees
who are satisfied with their work-life balance are more likely to bring enthusiasm,
energy and commitment to their work.
Work-life balance is an important area of Human Resource Management
(HRM) that is receiving increasing attention from government, researchers,
management and employee representatives and the popular media.
Factors contributing to the interest in work-life balance issues are global
competition, renewed interest in personal lives/family values and an aging
workforce.
Other factors include increasing complexity of work and family roles, the
increased prevalence of dual income households and the expanded number [of
women entering the workforce. Though work-life balance was initially construed
as the concern for working mothers, it has been recognized as a vital issue for all
classes of employees.
Despite increased interest in work-life issues, the organizational
philosophy towards work-life concerns is varied. Many organizations still see
them as individual not organizational concerns. Some organizations resonate the
sentiment 'work is work and family is familyand basically, the two do not mix'.
Other organizations view work and personal life as competing priorities
in a zero-sum game, in which a gain in one area means a loss in the other
(Friedman et al, 2000). Hence, it would be interesting to study organizational
perspectives on work-life balance.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
10/46
Work-Life Balance does not mean an equal balance
Trying to schedule an equal number of hours for each of your various work
and personal activities is usually unrewarding and unrealistic. Life is and should
be more fluid than that.
Best individual work-life balance will vary over time, often on a daily
basis
The right balance for you today will probably be different for you tomorrow.
The right balances for you when you are single will be different when you marry,
or if you have children; when you start a new career versus when you are
nearing retirement.
There is no perfect, one-size fits all, balance you should be striving
for
The best work-life balance is different for each of us because we all havedifferent priorities and different lives.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
11/46
Ten Essential Management Actions for Creating Work Life
Balance
1. Positive Work life Balance thinking treating staff as adults who are
balancing their work commitments with their family/personal responsibilities, and
being positive about making changes to create a more flexible workplace in all
aspects of employee relations. The importance of modelling best practice work
life balance from the top cannot be underestimated.
2. Work Life Balance policy have a clear policy statement which
announces that the WA Health is committed to providing a flexible responsive
workplace, which enables all employees to balance work and family/personal
responsibilities, which is incorporated into core values statements and corporate
plans, and supported by policy guidelines outlining what that means for everyone
in the workplace.
3. Work Life Balance employer - WA Health be promoted as an employer
who respects and cares about its employees, who recognizes that they will have
family and personal responsibilities, and who provides flexiblebilities. Factors
shown to impact the most upon staff trying to balance work and life include
required hours of work, a lack of flexibility in being able to alter their working
hours, time off or leave arrangements, a lack of access to suitable childcare
arrangements, and undue stresses and tensions in the workplace which make
working life more difficult and/or even unpleasant.
4. Awareness of entitlements - increase awareness of employees entitlementsto access flexible working arrangements, and what assistance and services are
available to them directly or by referral.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
12/46
5. Work Life Balance survey conduct a survey to identify staff needs in
balancing work and family/personal life responsibilities, current awareness of
flexible work options, and suitability of current working arrangements. Incorporate
results into the human resource management plan and staff work planning
arrangements.
6. Implement flexible work practices this will provide greater flexibility to all
employees, including supervisors, managers and other senior staff, and will
ensure flexible working hours schedules, rosters and leave arrangements to
accommodate their family and personal responsibilities, without detriment or
penalty.
7. Willingness to pilot or trial initiatives all managers and supervisors to
demonstrate commitment to creating a flexible workplace that supports work life
balance by considering employees needs and requests, and be willing to pilot or
trial new initiatives and implement more flexible working arrangements.
8.Management accountability
managers to be responsible and accountable
for implementing work life balance arrangements, reducing staff turnover rates
and increasing retention rates in their work area. Managers to be made
accountable for decisions to refuse employees requests for more flexible
working arrangements
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
13/46
9. Management Training training and development programs for managers
should include human resource management skills, the benefits of creating work
life balance, and how to manage a more flexible workforce.
10.Pre-exit interviews pre-exit interviews that include questions such as
whether difficulties in balancing work and family/personal responsibilities were a
contributing factor to the employee leaving, to be conducted prior to the
employee leaving. This data to be collated analyzed and reported to senior
management. Where possible, alternative working arrangements should be
offered to assist employees remain with a better work life balance.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
14/46
Importance of Maintaining Work Life Balance
Balance is the key to lead a successful and beautiful life which includes
everything but in balance. It is important in everyones life be it in the life of anentrepreneur, student or a housewife to maintain a balance between various
aspects of their daily routine. A student must know how to balance between his
studies and curricular activities; otherwise he will fail in one or the other thing. It
is equally important that we maintain our balance between materialistic and
spiritual or religious life as well.
In our everyday life, it is the work which occupies the major part of our life
and many people get so occupied with their work that they end up neglecting
other important things of their life. In corporate world where there is huge
pressure on employees to meet their deadlines and long working hours, people
really have lost balance in their lives. There is no denial that one can not survive
without work because this is what ultimately gives you the money which is the
source of everyones survival but along with work other things are also
necessary. Sometimes some goal or target grabs so much of our attention that
we forget everything else and devote all our energy in accomplishing that goal.
Achieving goal or target is not bad but leaving everything else behind for that one
particular goal or target can be harmful for an individual.
Time management is the solution to most of our problems. Everybody is
provided with twenty four hours only but it depends upon us how we utilize them.
And within these limited hours only we have to accomplish all our tasks along
with giving rest to our bodies and minds. And to manage the time, it is very
important that we set our priorities for our life. When we set our priorities, then it
becomes easy to divide our attention according them. For some people its their
work which is a priority, so they spend more time with their work. When we divide
our time according to our priorities, then there are very few chances that we will
not be leading a balanced life.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
15/46
In the end what matters is that we live a life in which we are happy and
does not hold any regret that we are missing out something because we dont
have enough time. When we will manage our time wisely according to our
priorities, then it will never be so difficult for us to maintain balance in our life.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
16/46
Economic change
Usually, when we think of work-life balance we automatically picture
examples of work encroaching upon our personal time and space. But now, the
tables are turning the scale is tipping. The pressures and stresses of our
personal lives are overshadowing our ability to be productive and focused while
at work. Economic changes like globalization, Knowledge-based economy,
deregulation, Labour shortages etc are changed.
Family and Demographic change
Changing demographics in the labor force in developed countries such as
the United Kingdom (U.K.), together with a recruiting crunch in some
organizations, have encouraged an increasing number of employers to consider
the work-life balance of their employees. At the same time, recognition of work
family disconnects, especially for working mothers, is growing. Organizations are
responding by introducing flexible work arrangements.
.
Social and Institutional Changes
If there are more number of members in the family then it will require more
attention to his/ her personal life, their Medical care and also education of their
children even he/she can not be able to treat their children equally.
Emerging Employment Relationships
Employee Relations involves the part time and contingent workers, self
employed, sub contracting, the body of work concerned with maintaining
employer-employee relationships that contribute to satisfactory productivity,
motivation, and morale. Essentially, Employee Relations is concerned with
preventing and resolving problems involving individuals which arise out of or
affect work situations.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
17/46
Changing Organization of work
Today, most of the organizations are diversified into many businesses and
due to this workload is increased even organizations does not offer flexible work
time. so, Its difficult to manage work life balance
The present world might be characterized by revolutionary innovations and
accelerated growth and development in every possible field but the other side of
the coin relates to the extended working- hours. Compounded to that are gadgets
like the web enabled mobile technology which makes one accessible to the work
environment 24X7. As a result, the one area of life which most individual's
neglect is maintaining a balance between work and family.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
18/46
What organization does for work life balance?
Work-life balance means different things to different people and different
things at different stages of life. However, any definition for anyone must
include the problems of lack of time and exhaustion. Research indicates that
failure to achieve the correct balance of effort and rest is linked to a feeling of
lack of control over your workload, plus lack of energy to fulfill personal goals
and commitments. If the balance is wrong, the result may include fatigue,
poor performance and a poor quality of life.
The organization offers a range of flexible working arrangements to help
staff achieve work/life balance.
Parental leave
Parental leave is a right for parents to take time off work to look after a young
child or make arrangements for the childs welfare. Parents can use it to spend
more time with children and strike a better balance between their work and family
commitments. This right is also open to staff who adopt children.
Staff can take from one to six months of leave all at once or month-by-
month after having a child and up until the childs 5th birthday, or within
five years of adoption.
Prior approval by hierarchy is required.
Parental leave is a right and cannot be refused but may be Postponed by
up to six months in agreement with the directorate.
Staff receives half their salary for the first month and a fixed allocation for
subsequent months.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
19/46
Part-time work
For staff who would like to work part-time, priorities other than work can assume
more importance. Part-time workers reduce their working week for various
reasons including attending to family (children and the elderly); pursuing personal
hobbies; voluntary work; studying; and many others. Staff wishing to work part-
time may benefit from this policy if their directorate gives its approval, or they
may apply for a part-time vacant post.
May work 20 or 30 hours on a daily, weekly, monthly or yearly basis.
Need approval by hierarchy.
Authorization to work part-time must be requested at least every two
years.
Family Leave
Staff may take leave for the serious illness or incapacity of immediate
family on the provision of a medical certificate.
Immediate family defined as spouse, registered non-marital partner,parent or child.
Every staff member has a right to Family Leave, which cannot be refused
or postponed.
Unpaid leave
The organization recognises that staff may at some point wish to take a
break from their career to address other priorities. The authorisation
may be for personal or professional reasons. Staff remain
bound by the EIBs Staff Regulations (see Article 31) throughout
their leave and must obtain the prior permission of the Bank if
they wish to take up professional activities during their leave.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
20/46
Time off to care for sick children
In the case of a sick child and on presentation of a medical certificate
staff may take time off to look after the child. Time off is also
authorised if a staff member is called by the crche or school to
fetch a sick child. The first day of the certified period is credited
in full and the rest of the time 50%.
Flexi-time
Staff may take up to a maximum of 4 half days a month (which
can be taken any day during the working week without being
able to use 2 half days on the same day) providing the normal
functioning of work is assured.
Crche facilities
The EIB has its own crche where you can enroll your pre-school
Children. There is a lot of demand for places and staffs are invited
to give as much notice as possible if they need a place.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
21/46
Factors influencing the evolution of work-life balance
People have always integrated the different parts of their lives and work-life
balance has long been of concern to those interested in the quality of working lifeand its relation to the broader quality of life. Indeed, the literature provides many
examples from hunter-gatherer societies through the Industrial Revolution era to
the present time.
As mentioned in the introduction to this project, recent rapid changes in the
nature of employment and its relationship to life outside work have catapulted the
issue of work-life balance to the forefront of policy debates and it is possible to
identify a number of levers of change that have brought this about. Some of the
most important of these levers are outlined briefly below.
Demographic and labour force change
one of the key factors in the promotion of flexible working arrangements has
been the increasing participation by women in the workforce. There are several
reasons for this increase including later marriage and childbirth, the ascendancy
of the dual earner family, a propensity for women to return to work after having
children, the growth of the services sector at the expense of the traditionally male
dominated manufacturing sector, and social pressures for equal opportunities for
men and women.
A consequence of this trend is that employers have started to pay greater
attention to the needs of employees with caring responsibilities, a trend that is
further reinforced by the increasing number of lone parents in the workforce. In
the Irish context of high levels of economic growth and consequent labour market
shortages, employers need to retain female employees and also need to attract
women returnees to work.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
22/46
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
23/46
Developments/increasing pressure at work
Analysts maintain that the pressures in work, for those in work, have been
intensifying over recent years. The rising information load, the need for speed of
response and the importance attached to quality of customer service and its
consequences have all been cited as reasons. People are working longer hours
and under greater pressure. Intensity is taken to refer to the proportion of time
spent working at very high speeds and to tight deadlines.
Developments/increasing pressure in life outside work
There is growing concern in communities that the quality of home and community
life is deteriorating (Guest, 2001). Various explanations associated with affluence
have been put forward: the growth of single parent families, the privatisation of
family life and the lack of local resources and facilities. There is a higher
proportion of women than ever before from all social classes participating in the
workforce (in Western industrial society). Added to this is the increased pressure
of work which is reflected in longer hours, more exhaustion and the necessity of
evening and weekend work. The result is a decrease in quality family time.
The consequences, according to Guest (2001:2) include increases in juvenile
crime, more drug abuse, a reduction in care of the community and in community
participation and less willingness to take responsibility for care of elderly relatives
and for the disadvantaged. While steps to redress these concerns transcend
work and employment, it is nevertheless argued that the demands of work
contribute to a reduced participation in non-work activities resulting in an
imbalance.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
24/46
Changing attitudes and values of people in work
It is sometimes argued that the issue of work-life balance has been stimulated by
management writers such as Tulgan (1996) who advocated the arrival of
Generation X6, a cohort of workers who give greater priority to seeking a balance
between work and the rest of life. Furthermore, it is suggested that this
generation of workers are not as willing to show unlimited commitment to the
organisation. One reason put forward for this is the decline in availability of
secure, progressive careers as a result of instability in organisations. There is
less justification therefore for employees to be committed.
A further reason, it is argued, is that Generation X workers have a more
independent mindset and are therefore more willing to change. 6 Generation X
(those born between 1963 and 1977) now form the core of the workforce.
Generation Y or the net-generation is coming on-stream fast. Research by Bruce
Tulgan on Gen-Xers has shown that they have a significantly different approach
to employment: they see themselves as free-agents, are impatient with old-style
hierarchical structures, are willing to negotiate and move jobs in order to achieve
their goals.
And his research shows that this free-agent mindset is migrating to workers from
different generations. All of the writings on managing your own career and the
ending of the life-time contract of employment merely increase the spread of the
free-agent mindset.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
25/46
Trends in Human Resource Management (HRM) practice
The development of Human Resource Management (HRM) within organisations
has also played a role in the promotion of flexible working arrangements,
particularly in the context of best practice and employer of choice concepts.
Equality, equity and diversity concerns/meeting legislation requirements
The introduction of equality legislation and the increasing need in Ireland, for
example, to comply with EU legislation, requires greater cognisance by
employers of employee needs.
Increase in certain types of sickness and disease
Lewis et. al (2001) point to an increase in certain types of sickness and disease
as another possible lever for change. This may take the form of an increase in
sick leave absences from work. In other contexts it is the spread of HIV/AIDS
which affects many workers.
Furthermore, this disease has wiped out whole generations of carers, leaving
grandparents or extended family to raise children. Workplaces have to respond
to these trends.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
26/46
Objective of the study
We come across individuals who let off their frustration at work, either by
criticizing their friends, colleagues or family members. This kind of behavior
not only wastes valuable time, but also our energy. Balancing work with life
will help in enhancing focus on positive side of all things. It tries to avoid
criticism. It concentrates on the simple principle of doing what should be done.
Maintaining such balance can improve the overall performance of an
Individual Work is but one dimension of life and should not distort our personal
life.
The vice-versa is also true as work is means of livelihood. The concept of
balancing work and life is important in more than one way. The concept is
gaining prominence since it helps in leading a balanced life, at the work place
as well as at home. Maintaining balance encourages the optimum working
hours that ultimately enhances the overall efficiency
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
27/46
PROBLEM STATEMENT
Work-life balance is an increasingly hot topic in boardrooms and government
halls today. Over the coming decade it will be one of the most important
issues that executives and human resource.
In this we want to study that how working women and men balance their
working and personal life.
This Research aims to identify work life balance of employees
The research emphasizes on importance of work life balance as an
important area of Human Resource Development in the present day
competitive world.
The research provides suitable suggestions to evolve meaningful, relevant
and effective maintaining work life balance that will help to industry for
future actions.
From the study we will come to know about the actual scenario of work life
balance.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
28/46
LITERATURE REVIEW
Review of related literature is an important step in undertaking research. It helps
in clarifying and defining the problem, stating objectives, formulating hypotheses,
selecting appropriate design and methodology of research as well as interpreting
the results in the light of the research work already undertaken. In this chapter,
an endeavor has been made to provide an overview of various aspects of this
study through the review of existing literature. The sources referred include
various journals, books, doctoral theses, working papers, reports, magazines
related to human resource, internet sites, newspapers etc.
Bardoel et al. (2008) identified the major themes and research methods that
have dominated work life research in Australia and New Zealand between the
period 2004-07. The identified themes were grouped in eight categories, i.e.,
organization approaches to work life and work family issues, work characteristics,
Occupations/industries, government policy and legislation, health outcome issues
related to work life, family structure and children, gender and other additional
themes. With regard to the research methods, out of the total 86 papers
examined, 73% of the papers were empirical while 27% were conceptual.
Majority of the empirical papers used quantitative methodology. As many as 51%
used survey method for data collection while the remaining 49% were fairly split
among case studies, focus group and interviews. Out of 63 empirical papers, 20
were classified priori with variables identified and relationships proposed before
any theory was apparent. The remaining 43 articles were classified as post hoc
as there were no specific relationships proposed before data collection and
analysis.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
29/46
In order to have a justified and in-depth review of the literature, the studies have
been classified under the following headings:
Work family conflict/work life balance studies
Individual related variables and Work life balance/work family conflict
Family related variables and Work life balance/work family conflict
Work related variables and Work life balance/work family conflict
Family and Work related variables and Work life balance / work family conflict
Individuals strategies for work life balance
Organizations strategies for work life balance.
Organizations initiatives and programmes for work life balance
WORK FAMILY CONFLICT / WORK LIFE BALANCE STUDIES
Some researchers like Gutek et al. (1991), Frone et al. (1992a), Williams andAlliger (1994), Eagle et al. (1997), Frone et al. (1997), Hammer et al. (1997),
Hsieh etal. (2005), Wesley and Muthuswamy (2005), Kinnunen and Mauno
(2007) and Rajadhyaksha and Ramadoss (2010) have focused on assessing
work family conflict/work life balance among employees in various settings and
also identified the direction of spillovers. Gutek et al. (1991) conducted a study
using two separate samples of employed people with families, a systematically
selected sample of psychologists and a volunteer sample of managers. The
findings indicated that the two types of perceived work family conflict (work
interference with family and family interference with work) were clearly separable
and relatively independent of each other. The people perceived less family
interference with work than work interference with family. However, when Frone
et al. (1997) developed and tested an integrative model of work family interface
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
30/46
using a sample of 372 employed adults who were married and/or parents, the
findings supported the indirect reciprocal relation between work to family and
family to work conflict. Family to work conflict was found to have indirect
influence on work to family conflict via work distress and work overload. Work to
family conflict had indirect impact on family to work conflict via increased parental
overload. Rajadhyaksha and Ramadoss (2010) tested the model given by Frone
etal. (1997) on a sample of 405 women in India and found that Indian data
moderately supported within and cross domain relationship hypothesized in the
model.
INDIVIDUAL RELATED VARIABLES AND WORK LIFE BALANCE/WORK
FAMILY CONFLICT
A number of individual variables, viz. gender, age, marital status, emotional
intelligence, etc. affecting/ related to work life balance/work family conflict have
beenstudied. Studies by Gutek et al. (1991), Williams and Alliger (1994), Higgins
etal.(1994), Loscocoo (1997), Aryee et al. (1999b), Grzywacz etal. (2007),
Rajadhyaksha and Velgach (2009) reported gender differences with respect to
work family conflict. Gutek et al. (1991) indicated that women reported more work
interference in family than men, despite spending about same number of hours in
paid work as men. Although women spent more hours in family work than men,
they reported the same level of family interference in work. Williams and Alliger
(1994) found that spillover of unpleasant moods occur both from work to family
settings and from family to work though evidence for the spillover of pleasant
moods was weak.
Both family to work and work to family spillovers were stronger for women than
men. Further, it was found that extent to which work interfered with family for a
given day was found to be positively related to self reported job involvement for
that day. Extent to which family interfered with work on a given day was found to
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
31/46
be positively related to distress in family roles during the day, family intrusion into
work during the day and self reported family involvement for that day.
Higgins et al. (1994) examined the impact of gender and life cycle stage on
three components of work family conflict (i.e. role overload, interference from
work to family and interference from family to work). The results indicated
significant differences for gender and life cycle. Women reported experiencing
significantly greater role overload than men. Again women were found to
experience greater work to family interference than men. Interference was
highest when the children were young, and lowest in families with older children.
Further, women reported significantly higher levels of family interference with
work than men in early years, but interferences levels were comparable to mens
in the third life cycle stage (i.e. children 10 to 18 years).
FAMILY RELATED VARIABLES AND WORK LIFE BALANCE/ WORK
FAMILY CONFLICT
Family related variables such as spouse support, spouse work hours, couples
employment status, number of children, parental responsibilities, home
responsibilities have been studied in relation to work life balance/conflict. Suchet
and Barling (1986) in a study of interrole conflict, spouse support and marital
functioning found that support from ones husband may assist employed mothers
cope with their own interrole conflict, as husbands supportive behaviour and
attitude might help in reducing the opposing role demands on, and unrealistic
role expectations of employed mothers.
Loerch et al. (1989) examined the relationships among family domain variables
and three sources of work family conflict (time, strain and behaviour based) for
both men and women. Family domain variables examined included time based
(number of children, spouse work hours per week, couples employment status)
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
32/46
strain based (conflict within family, spouse support, quality of experience in
spouse or parent role) and behaviour based antecedents, family intrusions
(parental, marital, home responsibilities) and role involvement. The results
indicated that the time based antecedents (number of children, spouse work
hours, couples employment status) were not significantly related to any form of
work family conflict for men or women. Strain based antecedent, conflict within
family, was found to have a positive relationship with work family conflict.
However, the negative relationship of other strain based antecedents (spouse
support, quality of spouse and parental experiences) and work family conflict was
not supported. The behaviour based antecedent, role congruity, was not
significantly related to any form of work family conflict. The variable of role
involvement significantly predicted only the time based conflict for men.
Adams et al. (1996) developed and tested a model of the relationship between
work and family. The results suggested that higher levels of family emotional and
instrumental support were associated with lower levels of family interfering with
work.
WORK RELATED VARIABLES AND WORK LIFE BALANCE /WORK FAMILY
CONFLICT
Relationship between work related variables, viz. task variety, task autonomy,
task complexity, role conflict, work schedule flexibility, number of hours worked
andwork life balance/work family conflict have been studied.
The studies by Greenhaus et al. (1989), Voydanoff (2004), Butler et al. (2005)
found task autonomy to be associated with work family conflict. Greenhaus et al.
(1989) examined different types of work domain pressures as sources of work
family conflict among two career couples. The results showed that work role
stressors (role conflict and role ambiguity) accounted for a significant portion of
the variance in time based and strain based conflict for both men and women.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
33/46
The task characteristics (autonomy and complexity) were found to be associated
with work family conflict and were somewhat stronger for women than for men.
Work schedule characteristics were found to be generally unrelated to work
family conflict. Among women, it did not explain significant portion of variance in
either time based or strain based conflict and among men, it was related to only
strain based conflict.
Voydanoff (2004) used a differential salience-comparable salience approach to
examine the effects of work demands and resources on work to family conflict
and facilitation. The data was obtained from the 1997 National Study of Changing
Workforce (NSCW) and consisted of 1,938 employed adults living with a family
member. The model includes within domain work demands and resources and
boundary spanning resources as sources of work to family conflict and
facilitation. The results showed that time based demands (work hours and extra
work without notice) and strain based demands (job insecurity and time pressure)
are positively associated with work to family conflict. It was found that enabling
resources (autonomy and learning opportunities) and psychological rewards
(respect and meaningful work) were positively related to work to family
facilitation. These resources (except learning opportunities) showed negative
relation with work to family conflict. Time based family support policies (parental
leave and time off for family) and work family organizational support (supportive
work family culture and supervisor work family support) showed negative
association with conflict, and positive relationship to work to family facilitation.
tendency to work long hours outside the home might find that home life is even
further marginalized by work life.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
34/46
FAMILY AND WORK RELATED VARIABLES AND WORK LIFE BALANCE /
WORK FAMILY CONFLICT
A few studies undertaken by Pleck et al. (1980), Aryee (1992), Grzywacz and
Marks (2000), Saltzstein et al. (2001), Frye and Breaugh (2004), Luk and Shaffer
(2005), Kinnunen and Mauno (2007) examined the relationship among different
Family and work related variables and work life balance / work family conflict.
Pleck et al. (1980) in a survey study of workers found that substantial minority
of workers living in families experienced conflict between work and family life.
Parents reported more conflict than other couples. Specific working conditions,
such as excessive hours at work, scheduling and physically or psychologically
demanding were associated with experiencing work family conflict, which in turn
was related to diminished job satisfaction and contentment with life in general.
Aryee (1992) examined the impact of five antecedent sets of work and family
domain variables on three types of work-family conflict (job-spouse, job-parent
and job-homemaker) and the impact of these types of work family conflict on well
being and work outcome measures.
Antecedents studied included life role salience, family stressors (parental
demands, responsibility for household chores, lack of spouse support), work
stressors (task variety, task complexity, task autonomy, role conflict, role
overload, role ambiguity) and work schedule stressors (hours worked per week,
work schedule inflexibility). Results indicated that married professional women in
the study experienced moderate amounts of each type of work-family conflict.
It was found that number of hours worked per week rather than work schedule
flexibility affects work family conflict. Role stressors explained the most variance
in job spouse and jobhomemaker conflicts while task characteristics explained
the most variance in jobparent conflict. Task autonomy emerged as a negative
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
35/46
and significant predictor of all three types of conflict. Task variety was positively
and significantly related to job parent and job-homemaker conflicts. Spouse
support showed a significant negative relation with job-spouse conflict and
parental demands were significantly positively related to job parent conflict.
However, household responsibility was not found to be related to any type of
conflict.
The three types of work-family conflict explained only modest amount of the
variance in the well-being and work outcome measures.
The study used the data from employed adults participating in the National
Survey of Midlife Development in the United States (N = 1,986). The findings
showed that work and family factors that facilitated development (decision
latitude, family support) were associated with less negative and more positive
spillover between work and family. On the other hand, work and family barriers
(job pressure, family disagreements) were associated with more negative
spillover and less positive spillover between work and family. Negative spillover
between work and family (work to family and family to work) shared some
correlates, such as pressure at work, and spouse disagreement. However,
spouse affectual support was an important correlate of negative spillover from
family to work but not negative spillover from work to family.
Similarly, decision latitude was strongly associated with both positive spillover
from work to family and family to work, whereas spouse affectual support was a
strong correlate of positive spillover from family to work but unassociated with
positive spillover from work to family.
The findings indicated that a variety of family friendly policies and practices were
used to varying degrees by these diverse groups of employees. Further, the job
related factors (job demands, job involvement) were found to be the most
significant determinants of satisfaction with work family balance and job
satisfaction.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
36/46
In addition, it was found that organizational understanding had more impact on
both satisfaction with work family balance and job satisfaction than all family
friendly policies.
It was found that the number of work hours, the use of family-friendly
policies and reporting to a supportive supervisor were predictive of work-family
conflict. Family friendly policies and reporting to a supportive supervisor were
found to have negative correlation with work-family conflict whereas hours
worked was positively related .With regard to family-work conflict, having child
care responsibility and reporting to a supportive supervisor were predictive of
such conflict. Child care responsibility showed a positive relation, while reporting
to a supportive supervisor was negatively related to such conflict. The study also
found that work family conflict was predictive of job satisfaction and family
satisfaction. However, family work conflict predicted neither job satisfaction nor
family satisfaction.
INDIVIDUALS STRATEGIES FOR WORK LIFE BALANCE
Individuals adopt strategies such as accommodation, negotiation to enhance
their work life balance or reduce work family conflict. Singh (2001) in his
qualitative study used work/life border theory to explore how British and
Swedish managers dealt with competing commitments. A sample of 35
managers (18 Swedish, 17 British ; 18 males and 17 females) ranging from
directors to project managers, aged between 28 to 59 years, was taken and
semi-structured interviews were held on site in UK and Sweden. The study
showed a tension between managers own needs for more balanced work lives
and corporate attitudes to balance - seekers and career choices.
Findings suggested that four kinds of strategies were used by the managers for
maintaining work life balance. These included accommodating family terms,
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
37/46
negotiating with the family, accommodating the organization and staggering
commitments. The study showed that managers enact their work life balance
strategies with both their employer and their family, particularly their partner, who
also enacts boundaries between home and employer, so there are four parties to
the negotiation or accommodation of needs. Some managers use their own
views as reference points for dealing with subordinates need for work life
balance.
Powell and Greenhaus (2006) examined how individuals manage incidents of
work-family conflict that pose difficult choices for them. The study examines two
interrelated processes: a) the actions that individuals take to avoid conflict in
such incidents; and b) the choices they make when the conflict cannot be
avoided. First, they may try to mobilize tangible support from a role sender in
either the work or family domain to reschedule one of the activities.
If successful, this strategy avoids workfamily conflict by enabling individuals to
participate fully in both activities. If support mobilization is unsuccessful or not
attempted, individuals decide whether to participate partially in some combination
of both activities or to participate solely in either the work or family activity. It was
found that individuals use multiple cues in deciding how to respond to situations
of potential work family conflict.
ORGANIZATIONS STRATEGIES FOR WORK LIFE BALANCE
Organizations adopt strategies such as separation and integration as
responses to non-work. Kirchmeyer (1995) identified three types of
organizational responses to non work (separation, integration, respect) and used
the data collected from 221 managers, active in multiple domains, to assess the
effectiveness of these organizational responses.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
38/46
Separation was a response where employers were concerned mainly with
workers fulfilling their work responsibilities, and viewedworkers non work lives
as solely the concern of workers themselves. In the case of integration
response, employers treated work and non work as related worlds that affected
one another, and acted to reduce the gap between them in an effort to help
workers manage their multiple domains. Respect referred to the employer
acknowledging and valuing the non work participation of workers, and committing
to support it. The effectiveness of these responses was assessed in terms of
their ability to reduce the negative spillover from non-work, and to enhance both
organizational commitment and the positive side of spillover. Integration and
respect responses revealed positive correlations with organizational commitment,
whereas separation response showed a negative correlation. It was found that
the type that enhanced the flexibility of the work- non work boundary and
involved the employer in providing resources for workers to fulfill non-work
responsibilities themselves proved most effective.
ORGANIZATIONS INITIATIVES AND PROGRAMMESFOR WORK LIFE BALANCE
A number of work life balance initiatives/ programmes have been undertaken
by the organizations and various researchers like Kossek et al., 1994; Osterman,
1995 ; Thomas and Ganster, 1995; Milliken et al., 1998; Newman and Mathews,
1999; Maxwell and McDougall, 2004; and Doherty, 2004 have attempted, to
identify these programmes and to study reasons for provision of these
programmes, benefits accruing to employees and organizations as a result of
these programmes and barriers in implementation of these programmes.
The organizations make a wide variety of work life arrangements to enhance the
work life balance of employees. Kossek et al. (1994), Kirchmeyer (1995),
Osterman, (1995), Galinsky and Johnson (1998), Konard and Mangel (2000),
Guest (2002), Maxwell and McDougall (2004), Coughlan (2005), and Cieri et al.
(2005) studied and
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
39/46
identified different work life arrangements. These included: parental leave,
paternity leave, maternity leave, adoption leave, sabbaticals, flexible work
timings, job sharing, job splitting, flexi time, compressed working week, annual
hours system, banking of hours, telecommuting, supervisory training in work
family sensitivity, onsite day care, emergency child care, elder care
arrangements.
A number of studies have highlighted the reasons for the provision of work life
balance programmes by various organizations. Kossek et al. (1994) forwarded
three reasons for provision of employer sponsored child care. It was argued that
child care problems interfering with work efficiency could be eliminated by
provision of child care programmes and it enhanced managements control over
the workforce. Another reason was to follow the actions of other successful
organizations and give a signal that the organization is progressive and cares
about employees needs. Yet another reason was the coercive pressures from
the government or society.
Osterman (1995) explained variation across firms in the implementation of
work/family programmes by examining how these are related to the employment
strategy of organizations. The data was collected from an original survey of
American private sector establishments and its labour force. The survey collected
data on the presence or absence of a variety of work/family programmes, as well
as on a broad range of characteristics of the establishment and its labour force. It
was found that organizations whose core employees were professional or
technical workers were significantly more likely to provide work/family
programmes than the organizations with service workers or blue collar
employees. The results also showed that the firms that wanted to implement high
performance or high commitment work systems were more likely to adopt
work/family programmes.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
40/46
Conclusion of the literature
On the basis of literature reviewed above, the following major conclusions can
be drawn:
Work to family conflict is more prevalent as compared to family to work
conflict.
No definite conclusions can be drawn with respect to the gender differences in
work life balance. However, on the basis of the studies which reported gender
differences, it can be concluded that women experience more work family
conflict.
Emotional intelligence has been found to be positively related to work life
balance.
The higher the importance accorded to work in life, the higher is the work
family conflict.
Spouse support has been found to be negatively related to family to work
conflict.
Higher the parental demands, higher is the work family conflict.
Job related variables (task autonomy and work schedule flexibility) have been
found to be positively related to work life balance.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
41/46
Since the approach of work life balance was initially conceived in terms of
work family conflict / work family balance, and work life balance concept has
come to the fore recently, hence much research is focused on work family
conflict rather than work life balance which is a broader term and includes work
and rest of the life (including family).
Secondly, much emphasis has been laid on studying the outcomes of work
family conflict or work life balance as compared to the antecedents especially in
the context of work life balance. Again, the researchers who studied the
antecedents, focused mainly on the work or family related variables; and have
not taken individual related variables into account. There are hardly any studies
to be found in the Indian context, and hence the issue of work life balance is wide
open for research in India.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
42/46
HYPOTHESIS
H0: There is work life balance of employees working in organisation.
H1: There is no work life balance of employees working in organization.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
43/46
REFERENCES
Adams, G.A., King, L.A., & King, D.W. (1996). Relationships of job and family
involvement, family social support, and work-family conflict with job and life
satisfaction. Journal of Applied Psychology, 81(4), 411-420.
Alam, M.S., Biswas, K., & Hassan, K. (2009). A Test of association between
working hour and work family conflict: A glimpse on Dhakas female white
collar professionals. International Journal of Business and Management, 4(5),
27-35.
Aryee, S. (1992). Antecedents and outcomes of work-family conflict among
married professional women: Evidence from Singapore. Human Relations,
45(8), 813-835.
Aryee, S., & Luk, V. (1996). Balancing two major parts of adult life
experience: work and family identity among dual-earner couples. Human
Relations, 49(4), 465-487.
Aryee, S., Fields, D., & Luk, V. (1999a). A cross-cultural test of a model of the
workfamily interface. Journal of Management, 25(4), 491-511.
Aryee, S., Luk, V., Leung, A. & Lo, S. (1999b). Role stressors, interrole
conflict and well being: the moderating influence of spousal support and
coping behaviors among employed parents in Hong Kong. Journal of
Vocational Behavior, 54, 259-278.
Bagger, J., Li, A., & Gutek, B.A. (2008). How much do you value your family
and does it matter? The joint effects of family identity salience, family-
interfacewith- work and gender. Human Relations, 61(2), 187-211.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
44/46
Baral, R. (2010). Work-family enrichment: Benefits of combining work and
family. Retrieved October 7, 2010, from http://www.paycheck.in/main/work-
andpay/ women-paycheck/articles/work-family-enrichment-benefits-of-
combiningwork- and-family.
Bardoel, E.A ., Cieri, H.D., & Santos, C. (2008). A review of work-life research
in Australia and New Zealand. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources,
46(3), 316-333.
Bhargava, S. & Baral, R. (2009). Antecedents and consequences of work
family enrichment among Indian managers. Psychological Studies, 54, 213-
225.
Butler, A.B., Grzywacz, J.G., Bass, B.L., & Linney, K.D. (2005). Extending the
demands control model: a daily diary study of job characteristics, work family
conflict and work- family facilitation. Journal of Occupational and
Organizational Psychology, 78, 155-169.
Carlson, D.S. (1999). Personality and role variables as predictors of three
forms of work- family conflict. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 55, 236-253.
Carlson, D.S. and Kacmar. K.M. (2000). Work-family conflict in the
organization: Do life role values make a difference? Journal of Management
26 (5), 1031-1054.
Carmeli, A. (2003). The relationship between emotional intelligence and work
attitudes, behavior and outcomesAn examination among senior managers.
Journal of Managerial Psychology, 18(8), 788-813.
http://www.paycheck.in/main/work-andpay/http://www.paycheck.in/main/work-andpay/http://www.paycheck.in/main/work-andpay/http://www.paycheck.in/main/work-andpay/http://www.paycheck.in/main/work-andpay/ -
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
45/46
Cieri, H.D., Holmes, B., Abbott, J., & Pettit (2005). Achievements and
challenges for work/life balance strategies in Australian organizations.
International Journal of Human Resource Management 16(1), 90-103.
Coughlan, A. (2005). Work-life balance: An introduction to work-life
balance issues and a preliminary exploration of work-life balance culture in
NUI, Maynooth. Quality Promotion Office, National University of Ireland,
Maynooth (NUIM).
Thomas, L.T., & Ganster, D.C. (1995). Impact of family-supportive work
variables onwork-family conflict and strain: A control perspective. Journalof Applied Psychology, 80(1), 6-15.
Voydanoff, P. (2004). The effects of work demands and resources on work
to- family conflict and facilitation. Journal of Marriage and Family, 66,
398-412.
Waters, M.A., & Bardoel, E.A. (2006). Workfamily policies in the context
of higher education: Useful or symbolic? Asia Pacific Journal of Human
Resources 44(1), 67-82.
Wesley, J.R. & Muthuswamy, P.R. (2005). Work-family conflict in India- An
empirical study. SCMS Journal of Indian Management, October-
December, 95-102.
White, M., Hill, S., McGrovern, P., Collins, M., & Smeaton, D. (2003).
Highperformance management practices, working hours and work-life
balance. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 41(2), 175-195.
Williams, K.J., & Alliger, G.M. (1994). Role stressors, mood spillover, and
perceptions of work family conflict in employed parents. Academy of
Management Journal,37(4), 837-868.
-
7/30/2019 Ruchita Udani - Work Life Balance
46/46
WEBSITES:
http://qpo.nuim.ie/quality/documents
http://www.cprn.org/
www.roffeypark.com
http://www.wlbn.net/index2.htm
www.familyfriendly.ie
www.families-project.com
www.workliferesearch.org
www.leeds.ac.uk/esrcfutureofwork
www.worklifebalancecentre.org
www.jrf.org.uk
www.socialdialogue.net
http://www.workliferesearch.org/wi.asp
www.roffeypark.com
http://164.36.164.20/work-lifebalance/how_dev_intro.html
www.intel.com
http://qpo.nuim.ie/quality/documentshttp://qpo.nuim.ie/quality/documentshttp://www.cprn.org/http://www.cprn.org/http://www.roffeypark.com/http://www.roffeypark.com/http://www.roffeypark.com/http://www.cprn.org/http://qpo.nuim.ie/quality/documents
top related