second project progress report
Post on 03-Dec-2021
3 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
ADVANCING AFGHAN TRADE
EU TRADE-RELATED ASSISTANCE
SECOND PROJECT PROGRESS REPORT
01 July 2017 - 30 June 2018
29 June 2018
3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Context of the Action ............................................................................................................................... 6
2. Executive Summary of the Action .......................................................................................................... 7
2.1 Output 1: GIRoA owns a national export strategy and action plan that was developed in a consultative process with the private sector, and has started its implementation ......................................... 7
2.2 Project Coordination and Management ............................................................................................. 8
2.3 Output 2: National public and private stakeholders are enabled to manage and coordinate the implementation of the National Export Strategy and mobilise support to implement the validated roadmaps 10
2.4 Output 3: Priority interventions identified during the National Export Strategy design process are implemented to improve regional integration and international trade competitiveness ............................... 11
2.5 Output 4: Knowledge sharing mechanisms for GIRoA staff on trade policy/negotiation formulation and implementation are established in partnership with a training institute from the region ....................... 16
2.6 Output 5: Institutional mechanisms to facilitate the implementation of the TFA are established at national level and linked with regional partners ........................................................................................... 17
2.7 Output 6: SME knowledge of how to manage national cross-border procedures and compliance with regional and/or global market requirements is built encompassing priority markets (building on NES findings) ........................................................................................................................................................ 19
2.8 Output 7: Public-private consultation process on domestic/regional key pressing trade policy/regulatory/negotiation issues is strengthened ................................................................................... 20
3. Actual Results ......................................................................................................................................... 22
4. Activities carried out during the reporting period .............................................................................. 34
4.1 OUTPUT 1: GIRoA owns a national export strategy and action plan that was developed in a consultative process with the private sector, and has started its implementation ....................................... 34
4.2 OUTPUT 2: National public and private stakeholders are enabled to manage and coordinate the implementation of the NES and mobilise support to implement the validated roadmaps ........................... 45
4.3 OUTPUT 3: Priority interventions identified during the NES design process are implemented to improve regional integration and international trade competitiveness ......................................................... 52
4.4 OUTPUT 4: Knowledge sharing mechanisms for GIRoA staff on trade policy/negotiation formulation and implementation are established in partnership with a training institute from the Region ... 66
4.5 OUTPUT 5: Institutional mechanisms to facilitate the implementation of the TFA are established at national level and linked with regional partners ........................................................................................... 79
4.6 OUTPUT 6: SME knowledge of how to manage national cross-border procedures and compliance with regional and/or global market requirements is built encompassing priority markets (building on NES findings) ........................................................................................................................................................ 88
4.7 OUTPUT 7: Public-private consultation process on domestic/regional key pressing trade policy/regulatory/negotiation issues is strengthened ................................................................................... 92
5. Overarching Focus on Trade Learning and Capacity Building for Regional Co-operation throughout all the above components ....................................................................................................... 103
6. Difficulties encountered and measures taken ................................................................................... 104
7. Implementation of the Visibility and Communication Plan .............................................................. 105
8. Request for payment ............................................................................................................................ 111
9. WORK PLAN FOR YEAR 3 ................................................................................................................... 111
ANNEX I: MEDIA REPORT: 1 JULY 2017 – 30 JUNE 2018 ........................................................................ 114
4
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS USED
ACCI Afghanistan Chamber of Commerce
ACE Afghanistan Center of Excellence
AICF Afghanistan Investment Climate Facility
AISA Afghanistan Investment Support Agency
ANPDF Afghanistan National Peace and Development Framework
ANSA Afghanistan National Standards Agency
ANTP Afghanistan National Trade Policy
ATAR Afghanistan Trade and Revenue
AWBF Afghan Women's Business Federation
BMZ Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ)
CBM Curriculum-based measurement
CEO Chief Executive Office
CWS Centre for WTO Studies, Indian Institute of Foreign Trade
DFID Department for International Development
DG Director General
DM Deputy Minister
EIF European Investment Fund
EPAA Export Promotion Agency Of Afghanistan
EU European Union
EUD European Delegation To Afghanistan
FAO Food and Agriculture Organization
GIRoA Government of Islamic Republic of Afghanistan
GIZ Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (German Development Agency)
HACCP Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point
HEC High Economic Council
ICC Afghanistan International Chamber of Commerce
IIFT Indian Institute of Foreign Trade
IMCTF Inter-Ministerial Commission on Trade Facilitation
IMCWTF Inter-Ministerial Committee on WTO and TF
ISO International Organization for Standardization
IT Information Technology
ITC International Trade Center
LEAD Leading Entrepreneurs of Afghanistan for Development
MAIL Ministry of Agriculture Irrigation and Livestock
MoIC Ministry of Commerce and Industries
MoPH Ministry of Public Health, Islamic Republic of Afghanistan
NES National Export Strategy
NFF Note For File
NNA National News Agency
NTFC National Trade Facilitation Committee
PPD Public Private Dialogue
PPDP Public-Private Development Partnership
PPT PowerPoint Presentation
5
RSVP Répondez s'il vous plaît
RTFCM Regional Trade Facilitation Committee
SIMT Strategy Implementation Management Tool
SME Small and medium-sized enterprises
SPS Sanitary and Phytosanitary
TBC To Be Confirmed
TBT Technical Barriers to Trade
TF Trade Facilitation
TFA Trade Facilitation Agreement
TSI Trade Support Institutions
UNAMA United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan
UNCTAD United Nations Conference of Trade and Development
USAID United States Agency for International Development
USD US Dollar
VC Video Conference
WTO World Trade Organization
6
1. CONTEXT OF THE ACTION
Name of beneficiary of Delegation Agreement: International Trade Centre (ITC)
Title of Action: Trade-Related Assistance for Afghanistan
EC CRIS Number: ACA/2016/376-500
Start and end date of reporting period: 1 July 2017 - 30 June 2018
Background
The Government of Islamic Republic of Afghanistan (GIRoA) recognises international trade as an important
driver of growth, for which it has prioritized trade, transit, and regional cooperation as critical elements in its
economic development strategy. It is committed to trade reforms aimed at unlocking the potential of the
country's export sector, which is evident from recent initiatives undertaken by the country such as accession
to the World Trade Organization (WTO) and ratification of WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA). However,
this changing trade environment requires solid understanding of trade issues, design and implementation of
legislative reforms and their enforcement through institutionalized mechanisms.
The three-year project, funded by the European Union (EU), worth EUR 4 550 000, will assist the GIRoA in
improving the conditions to use trade as a lever for confidence building, enhanced regional cooperation,
economic and human development and poverty reduction. It aims to strengthen human and institutional
capacity on trade policy and strategy formulation and implementation with the active engagement of the private
sector. The project, which is in line with Afghanistan National Peace and Development Framework (ANPDF)
2017 - 2021, started in August 2016 and will run until August 2019.
The projects takes into account the country-specific needs of Afghanistan related to enhanced regional trade
cooperation, particularly taking into account the focus of both the Regional Economic Cooperation Conference
on Afghanistan (RECCA) and the Heart of Asia Process on positioning Afghanistan as a regional trade hub in
Central Asia and promoting enhanced regional cooperation.
The project is being executed under the Asia Regional Multiannual Indicative Programme 2014-2020. In line
with the Agenda for Change, EU regional programmes aim at supporting a broad-based process of dialogue
and collaboration between Central Asian countries, promoting an environment conducive to a non-
confrontational approach within the region, notably in areas sensitive to overall political and social instability.
Project partners and beneficiaries
The Ministry of Industry and Commerce is in charge of trade policy formulation/trade negotiations in
Afghanistan and is the main counterpart and beneficiary of this project. National institutions and agencies such
as the Afghanistan Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI), Afghanistan National Standards Authority
(ANSA), Ministry of Agriculture, Irrigation and Livestock (MAIL), sectoral trade and investment support
organizations, universities and research institutions, the private sector and non-governmental partners also
contribute to and benefit from various project activities.
Project objectives
The foreseen impact is “enhanced trade and regional integration of Afghanistan as a lever for confidence
building, economic and human development and poverty reduction.” It is through strengthening institutional
capacity to formulate and implement effective trade policies and strategies with a special focus on regional
cooperation, engaging private sector to participate in trade policy reforms and dialogue, and building
sustainable mechanisms to invest in human capital and to ensure local ownership, that this is being advanced.
7
Results expected from the project National Export Strategy (NES) design
The GIRoA owns a NES and action plan that was developed in a consultative process with the private
sector and has started its implementation.
The NES analyses the country’s needs, constraints and opportunities (especially in the regional markets)
to provide a well-articulated roadmap to strengthen Afghanistan’s supply and export capacities, implement
trade reforms, identify regional partners and potential investment opportunities and address Small and
Medium Enterprises (SMEs’) knowledge of cross-border procedures.
The NES implementation commences with a focus on quality management, Sanitary and Phytosanitary (SPS) measures and regional regulatory cooperation:
National public and private stakeholders are enabled to manage and coordinate the implementation of the
NES and mobilize support to implement the validated roadmaps.
Priority interventions identified during the NES design process are implemented to improve regional
integration and international trade competitiveness.
Trade Policy and Facilitation
Capacity building on trade policy: Knowledge-sharing mechanisms for Afghan policymakers on trade policy
and negotiation formulation and implementation are established in partnership with a training institute from
the region. Ove 50 national policymakers will be trained.
National Trade Facilitation Committee (NTFC) strengthening: Institutional mechanisms to facilitate the
implementation of the TFA are operationalized and trained and linked with regional partners.
SME Training: Knowledge of SMEs on how to manage cross-border procedures and compliance with
regional and/or global market requirements is built (building on NES findings to include priority markets).
Consultation process: Public-private consultation processes on most pressing trade, regulatory or
negotiation issues (domestic or regional) are strengthened.
2. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY OF THE ACTION
2.1 Output 1: GIRoA owns a national export strategy and action plan that was developed in a consultative process with the private sector, and has started its implementation
Following the first consultation, preliminary draft sector and cross-sector strategic plans of action were further
elaborated through provincial consultations held in Mazar-e-Sharif, Herat and Kandahar. Bilateral meetings
with sector experts and key international buyers as well as factory visits complemented these consultations
with the objective of sharpening assessments and strategic considerations. Subsequently, NES plans of action
were refined and validated during the Second National Consultation held in Kabul in October, 2017. Further,
collective efforts were invested in securing alignment of the NES with other development initiatives or
frameworks, such as the Agri-Business Charter and the National Priority Programs on Private Sector
Development and Agriculture.
8
This highly participatory and inclusive strategy development process resulted in the realization of the National
Export Strategy (NES) of Afghanistan. The NES was developed and completed under the co-leadership of the
MoIC and ACCI, in close collaboration with MAIL and ANSA, and with the technical support of ITC.
The national and sector export strategy documents were produced and are available in both English and Dari
versions. These documents include:
A main NES document, which contains Trade Support Functional strategies, offering critical support across
value chains and acting as enablers for sector development. Trade Support Functions are: quality
management, trade facilitation, trade information and promotion, skills development, business and
professional services, and access to finance.
Individual NES priority sector strategies packaged as separate documents, but in alignment with the main
NES findings and overarching strategic objectives. Priority sectors are: dried fruits and nuts, fresh fruits and
vegetables, saffron, precious stones and jewellery, carpets, and marble and granite.
The NES and its implementation plan constitute a home-grown blueprint to guide the joint efforts of the
Government, the private sector and its international development partners to increase competitiveness of the
Afghan export sector, and to contribute to socio-economic development of the country. The NES was
presented and officially endorsed at the High Economic Council, the Afghan Council of Ministers and the
Executive Committee of Private Sector Development.
In view of building on the significant momentum gained as part of the NES design process and mobilise the
required resources for its effective implementation, a high-level official NES launch event and donor roundtable
meeting was held on 10 and 11 June, 2018 respectively. The launch ceremony of the NES served to present
main findings, strategic axes and implementation management framework and marked the official start of the
implementation phase of the Strategy.
Short-term outcomes:
An architecture that focuses national efforts on strategic orientations and priority actions for national and
sector trade development.
Improved public and private dialogue supporting the development of a national export culture.
Empowered national stakeholders capable of contributing trade policy design activities.
Large consensus reached on national and sector-specific competitiveness issues and opportunities.
Enhanced awareness of available options for export development and how to mainstream trade into
national planning and policies.
Stakeholders perceive as a priority the need to address quality and SPS issues and build a conductive
technical environment.
Improved national ability to receive and use Aid for Trade.
2.2 Project Coordination and Management
The first Project Steering Committee meeting was held in Kabul on 31 July, 2017. ITC presented progress on
all aspects of the project and responded to stakeholder inputs. The year two project workplan was presented
and approved.
A project office in Kabul was maintained to ensure the day-to-day coordination of project implementation. A
local Project Coordinator and Project Administrative Associate coordinated and implemented the project locally
supported by an ITC headquarters team based in Geneva.
9
During the reporting period four quarterly reports were carried out and shared with MoIC and EUD for their
awareness and feedback. The reports provided a brief summary of progress made for each output during the
past quarter; immediate next steps for the next quarter; a full summary of all media coverage received, and;
finally flagged key support required from MoIC and other key stakeholders.
The project was promoted through extensive media coverage of key events, including at the Herat and Kabul
NES stakeholder consultations; NES presentation and subsequent endorsement at the High Economic
Council, the Council of Ministers and the Executive Committee of Private Sector Development (PriSEC); NES
launch; Afghanistan National Trade Policy consultative meeting; trade policy learning initiative (i.e.
Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme); Afghanistan – Uzbekistan: Stakeholder consultation
to enhance trading relations; national workshops on the implementation of the WTO TFA (as part of the trade
facilitation component).
A total of 104 press releases/articles were producedfour project quarterly newsletters (extensively distributed
within the region and Afghanistan, including distributing to the members of ACCI,AWCCI, MOIC, MAIL, ANSA
and EPAA through translated Dari version).The project was also covered widely through social media forums,
including Facebook and Twitter and also featured on main news stations during the endorsement and launch
of the NES and National Trade Policy Consultation.
The AAT project team coordinated a mission to Kabul for the ITC Executive Director Arancha González
between 8 and 11 June, 2018. During her visit, high level meetings were held with Mohammad Ashraf Ghani,
President; Abdullah Abdullah, Chief Executive Officer, Humayoon Rasaw and Kamila Sidiqi, Minister and
Deputy Minister of Industry and Commerce respectively; Naheed Saravi, Deputy Minister of Finance; Pierre
Mayaudon, European Union Ambassador to Afghanistan. Additionally, Ms Gonzalez attended the launch of
the NES and related donor roundtable meeting and provided presentation; held a roundtable meeting with
Afghan business leaders / entrepreneurs, and; participated in media interviews. The presence of Ms Gonzalez
provided much visibility and guidance to the AAT project.
A project workplan for May – December 2018, was prepared and approved by MoIC. The preparing of an
interim workplan at this stage was significant as it coincided with the final endorsement of the NES in April,
2018, and the project thus entering a second phase in its lifecycle whereby in addition to continuing to
implement core agreed upon areas of focus at the outset of the project (specifically: trade policy; trade
facilitation; quality management; NES) the project would seek to enter new areas by implementing aspects of
the NES (under output 3). This approach was according to original project design. Accordingly the new agreed
areas were as follows:
Sub-output 3.1: Quality management – with also a focus on the saffron sector as pilot to reach SMEs.
Sub-output 3. 2: Building performance: Export Promotion Agency of Afghanistan (EPPA).
Sub-output 3.3: Increase access to finance for Afghan SMEs in the saffron sector.
Sub-output 3.4: Support to “Start-ups and Emerging Entrepreneurs Network” (SEEN) and “young
agripreneurship” in the saffron sector.
Sub-output 3.5: Support to the Afghanistan Women Chamber of Commerce and Industry (focus: saffron).
These interventions will be explained in more details under the sections below.
10
2.3 Output 2: National public and private stakeholders are enabled to manage and coordinate the implementation of the National Export Strategy and mobilise support to implement the validated roadmaps
A key success criterion for the success of the Afghanistan’s NES lies on the country’s ability to coordinate
activities, monitor progress and mobilize resources for its implementation. Therefore, ITC places special
attention on building and reinforcing strategy implementation management capacities of Afghan national
stakeholders, most particularly the NES Secretariat i.e. MoIC-EPAA. Accordingly, NES Secretariat members
and key MoIC staff have received initial training on NES implementation planning, management techniques
and resource mobilization. Subsequent capacity-building workshops will focus on supporting MoIC and other
ministries and agencies to develop project proposals and concept notes, based on strategic actions outlined
in the NES strategy documents. Moreover, advisory services were provided to assist the definition and
operationalization of an adequate governance structure for NES implementation management and support
mobilization.
Furthermore, an interactive strategy management system – Strategy Implementation Management Tool
(SIMT) – has been customized to the country’s needs. The SIMT will serve to increase coordination, create
reports and monitor the progress of implementation of NES’ plans of action activities. It will also contribute to
improve the synchronization and alignment of national policies and trade-related technical assistance. NES
Secretariat members and key MoIC staff were introduced and capacitated in the operationalization of the tool.
ITC pursued efforts and advisory support to position the strategy within the economic and social development
framework of the country and within national development priorities. The main objective was to improve the
efficiency of the implementation management framework and secure the level of support provided by country
counterpart organisations to maintain the momentum and therefore influence the outcome of the process. To
do so, ITC worked towards stimulating policy convergence and political cohesion around the NES so that the
strategy becomes a rallying document for trade competitiveness. Support was provided to ensure NES’
alignment with the following main existing plans, policies and initiatives to secure the institutional support and
political consideration required. Most of these documents refer to the strategy as one of their preferred tool of
implementation.
NPP on private sector development
Agri-business charter
Ministry of Mines and Petroleum’s strategy on Marble
MAIL’s plan
Industrial park proposal
Bilateral meetings and donor roundtables were organized with the double objective of apprising and sensitizing
development partners on NES' findings and related opportunities, and identifying synergies and alignment with
ongoing and planned initiatives and NES implementation. Partners include EU, USAID, Aga Khan, GIZ, DFID,
among others.
Short-term outcomes:
Awareness raised and initial conditions set towards the operationalization of an adequate governance
structure to build the required collaboration and coordination (between national and sectoral public and
private implementing institutions) to secure NES’ endorsement and implementation.
MoIC perceives the NES as an instrument to improve the ability of the country to receive and utilize Aid-
for-Trade: Identifying, prioritizing and allocating resources, including development partners’ outreach, to
successfully activate NES implementation.
11
Awareness raised and initial conditions set to set-up and enable an interactive strategy management
system to effectively monitor NES progress, assess impact, identify gaps and duplications, and measure
results.
Enhanced harmonization of donors’ support and alignment of TRTA interventions in the country.
Next steps:
Support the MoIC-EPAA and sectoral coordinating committees with tailored capacity- building trainings,
advisory support and specialized tools on NES implementation planning, management techniques and
resource mobilisation. These will contribute to:
o Defining and operationalizing an adequate governance structure to build collaboration and
coordination between national and sectoral public and private implementing institutions.
o Setting-up and enabling interactive strategy management systems to effectively monitor progress,
assess impact, identify gaps and duplications, and measure results.
o Identifying, prioritizing and allocating resources, including development partners outreach, to
successfully activate implementation.
2.4 Output 3: Priority interventions identified during the National Export Strategy design process are implemented to improve regional integration and international trade competitiveness
Background
The project design document, “Trade-Related Assistance for Afghanistan” states:
“Priority interventions identified during the National Export Strategy design process will be implemented in
order to improve regional integration and international trade competitiveness. Based on key issues identified
and detailed in action fiches developed during the NES design process, priority interventions are implemented.
The “quick win” activities implemented will create tangible results by creating the momentum necessary to
improve specific issues constraining Afghanistan trade competitiveness. Given the established need to
strengthen the quality and SPS infrastructures in Afghanistan, a number of indicative activities have already
been highlighted as priorities. These activities will be validated during the NES design process in close
consultation with the private and public sector”.
Accordingly, at the outset of the project it was agreed to already commence implementation of activities in the
area of quality management, in the knowledge that it will comprise part of the NES being developed under the
project. Therefore the below details progress on 1) Quality management; 2) Identification of priority
interventions during the NES design process and development of work plan to address during AAT project
lifecycle (Until August 2019).
Quality management
The preliminary assessment of the quality and SPS institutions, the bilateral meetings, the large consultation
with the public and private stakeholders during the design of the quality cross functional strategy of the NES
confirmed the serious challenges within its quality and SPS domain, the need to build a foundation for
developing a quality culture in the country and address institutional capacity gaps for priority services to support
enterprises in a sustainable manner. SPS measures are recognised as urgent areas to be addressed.
12
The public and private sectors have reached consensus on a Plan of Action (PoA) of the NES quality chapter
that sets the path to reach the national vision: “Quality brings changes and boosts prosperity: Afghan products
meet the regulatory and buyers’ requirements of target markets, supported by an adequate physical and
institutional quality infrastructure”. An important momentum has been built to address quality-related issues.
In addition to the initial priority action plan that was agreed with ANSA with a special focus on standardization,
technical regulations, conformity assessment and in particular certification, metrology, training capacity, the
2018 project workplan to implement key NES priority actions in the area of quality management was developed
and approved. A first series of training and capacity building workshops were prepared and delivered. Other
priorities, in particular regarding SPS, food safety, plant health and animal health that were confirmed last year
have also commenced in parallel with the development of the NES. Saffron is being selected as a pilot priority
sector to initiate implementation of enterprise related activities.
Short-term outcomes:
Awareness raised on the difference between mandatory and voluntary standards and initial conditions
required to comply with international requirements to become competitive.
Over 300 government and business stakeholders trained in the area of standards, metrology, technical
regulations, and WTO TBT and SPS Agreements through in-country and trainings in India.
Stakeholders engagement with ANSA, MAIL, Ministry of Public Health (MoPH) and MoIC, other related
quality-SPS institutions and sector associations. Additional strengthening of their roles and responsibilities
to support and facilitate formal trade.
ANSA is perceived as critical institutions for compliance with WTO post-accession commitments and
needed to support exporters.
Food safety and established coordinated efforts on food safety controls are perceived as a critical area to
address by PriSEC and government.
Procedures drafted for the development of technical regulations and standards according to international
practices.
Initial capacity built on standards development, adoption and promotion.
Initial capacity built on development of technical regulations.
Capacity built of ANSA staff of the metrology lab.
Networks with WTO SPS and TBT secretariats and partners institutions in Canada initiated to strengthen
TBT-SPS National Enquiry Points and National Notification Authorities.
Awareness and interest raised for potential partnership between a lead Italian buyer and producers of
saffron.
NES priority interventions identified and implemented
The development of the NES design through a stakeholder consultation process was finalised when the
document received endorsement by the Government of Afghanistan through its high level decision making
body - the High Economic Council, on 3 April, 2018. Accordingly, and as per AAT project design, the project
13
would then further seek to implement some key aspects of the NES during its project lifecycle (until August,
2019).
This project is contributing to this endeavour by focusing on areas agreed upon during its inception phase (i.e.
Trade policy, quality, trade facilitation) within its budget limitation. These agreed intervention will be further
continued as per the agreed work plan.
Additionally, under Output 3, ITC will prioritize strengthening the saffron sector’s export competiveness as a
pilot project (one key sector for which the NES has developed a detailed action plan). Accordingly, a work plan
of activities to be further implemented under project outputs was endorsed by MoIC in May 2018. In intervening
in saffron value chain, ITC will provide support to:
- Sub-output 3.1: Quality management – with also a focus on the saffron sector as pilot to reach SMEs.
- Sub-output 3. 2: Building performance: Export Promotion Agency of Afghanistan (EPPA)
- Sub-output 3.3: Increase access to finance for Afghan SMEs in the saffron sector
- Sub-output 3.4: Support to “Start-ups and Emerging Entrepreneurs Network” (SEEN) and “young agripreneurship” in the saffron sector
- Sub-output 3.5: Support to the Afghanistan Women Chamber of Commerce and Industry (focus: saffron)
The following details further next steps to implement this during the next year of the AAT project.
Next steps
Sub-output 3.1: Quality management – with also a focus on the saffron sector as pilot to reach SMEs
Activities will include amongst others the following:
Capacity building on standards development, adoption and promotion, including development of
awareness-raising and sensitization materials and tools (including sector specific - saffron as pilot).
Capacity building for development of training of trainers and curriculum on training on ISO standards.
Strengthening TBT and SPS NEPs and the National Notification Authority through training and twining .
Development of National Quality Policy to ensure harmonization of efforts, obtain political support and
reduce duplication and overlap.
ANSA strategic Plan and operation plan updated.
Strengthening the metrology service.
Capacity building on certifications and management system.
Enhanced knowledge and understanding on food control and food authority.
Sub-output 3. 2: Building performance: Export Promotion Agency of Afghanistan (EPAA)
Activities will include amongst others the following:
August/September:
o Undertake assisted self-assessment of EPAA (by remote via benchmarking platform)
Visit EPAA to confirm assessment result and consult on readiness roadmap
Develop readiness roadmap, including development priorities
August/September:
o Confirm training/workshop programme for September-December period
14
Sub-output 3.3: Increase access to finance for Afghan SMEs in the saffron sector
Activities will include amongst others the following:
Approach: AAT project will support SMEs in the saffron sector by building their financial management
capacity through the establishment and strength of local affordable and independent financial management
advisory services. The approach has three main objectives:
Objective one: Improve financial management skills of beneficiary enterprises:
o Activity: July/August 2018: Herat and Kabul – Joint mission with EU-funded saffron, STDF-funded
quality and NES projects.
- Objective two: Agreed work plans and expectations for next 6 to 12 months, SME beneficiaries and
financial management counsellors selected for initial phase of review, training and advisory services.
o Develop independent and affordable financial counselling support for SMEs in the target region and
sector.
o Activity: ITC mission 1: July/August 2018: Herat and Kabul – (As above) – In addition meet with First
MicroFinance Bank, Afghanistan, Afghanistan Credit and SIDA Credit Guarantee schemes and other
financing institutions such as ISDB / ITFC.
o ITC Mission 1: Financial Management Counsellors (FMCs). FMCs visit and complete profiling and
performance reviews of, SMEs and communities to work with using ITC AFI tools and methodologies .
Objective three: Working arrangements and expectations agreed with key stakeholders, work plans agreed
for next 6 to 12 months; Initial group of FMCs selected:
o ITC Mission 2: Herat and Kabul (September): Range of follow-up activities (including: FMC training
completion; Access to Finance and Investment (AFI) local Information platform concept review; Tools
and materials transfer to FMCs and FMC host organisations; Quality and progress review / advice
and coaching of FMC enterprise information gathering and reporting; Enterprise financing proposals
reviewed:
o Facilitate access to funding for qualified SMEs leveraging existing schemes, such as the Credit
Guarantee Fund Afghanistan and the SIDA’s guarantee instrument.
Sub-output 3.4: Support to “Start-ups and Emerging Entrepreneurs Network” (SEEN) and “young
agripreneurship” in the saffron sector
Activities will include amongst others the following:
July/August:
o Engagement with Start-ups and Emerging Entrepreneurs Network (SEEN)
o Undertake assisted self-assessment of SEEN (by remote via benchmarking platform)
August/September:
o Visit SEEN and develop readiness roadmap
o Identify training partners in Herat region for the saffron sector
o Plan business and technical training programme for September-December period
15
Sub-output 3.5: Support to the Afghanistan Women Chamber of Commerce and Industry (focus:
saffron)
Approach: Development of specific interventions to support AWCCI. This intervention will broadly focus on (i) the need to support the trade promotion activities of women-focused business associations in particular through building their capacity to fulfil their mandate as well as (ii) the need to enable women to tap into market opportunities through matchmaking events, support to establish business linkages with potential buyers in regional and international markets with a specific focus on saffron.
Immediate interventions include:
2 women participants selected by AWCCI will attend an ITC flagship event “SheTrades Global” on 26-28
June, Liverpool, UK. Over 500 women from across the world will participate in the event in search of new
trade and investment opportunities.
As part of the programme the two selected participants have been / will further complete short course on
trade related topics provided by ITC.
16
2.5 Output 4: Knowledge sharing mechanisms for GIRoA staff on trade policy/negotiation formulation and implementation are established in partnership with a training institute from the region
20 Afghan officials benefited from successfully completing a 7 month “Afghanistan, WTO and International
Trade Programme”. The initiative built the capacity of participants in the area of trade policy formulation and
implementation - with a particular focus on WTO agreements and their implementation, including in the Afghan
context. The programme was implemented by the Delhi based Centre for WTO studies (CWS), following a
partnership agreement signed between MoIC, CWS and ITC in March 2017.
Under the programme, the participants – mostly officials from MoIC with a few representatives from the private
sector (ACCI), academia (Kabul University; APPRO) completed four week long trainings (comprising an
introductory and three advanced trainings) as well as one week long study tour. All participants were regularly
tested and successfully passed and thus were each awarded a certificate of completion at the end of the
programme.
In short the subjects covered included:
Why countries trade? Introduction to WTO TRIMS Agreement
Advanced WTO and FTAs
Introduction to Trade Data Sources and Analysis
Introduction to Trade Litigation Advanced Trade Litigation
Introduction to WTO and Free Trade Agreements
Advanced Trade Data Sources and Analysis
Policy Flexibilities under WTO
Afghanistan in World Trade Market Access and Trade Composition
Advanced WTO TRIPS Agreement
Introduction to Basic Provisions of GATT
Afghanistan's WTO Commitments and FTAs
New Issues: Electronic Commerce
Introduction to WTO Agreement on Agriculture
Advanced WTO Agreement on Agriculture
New Issues: Investment Facilitation
Introduction to WTO SPS and TBT Agreements
Advanced Basic Provisions of GATT
Negotiating Strategies
Introduction to Trade Remedies Advanced Trade Remedies New Issues: MSME and Gender
Introduction to GATS Advanced WTO TBT Agreement Regulatory Impact Assessment
Introduction to WTO TRIPS Agreement
Advanced WTO SPS Agreement Recent Developments in International Trade
Role of Research and Stakeholders Consultations
Advanced GATS and Services Agreements in FTAs
Study Tour
17
Additionally the training programme included a study tour, whereby participants learnt first-hand from officials Indian ministries, customs agencies, business associations, trade promotion agencies, and special export zones their 1) views of trade-related challenges; 2) involvement in trade policy formulation, implementation, trade negotiations and trade promotion; and 3) Interface between government and industry.
As part of the programme, Kabul University and APPRO benefited from CWS mentoring to develop curriculum
on trade policies and international trade. Kabul University has developed the structure and accompanying
curriculum for a course "Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade" that is anticipated to be taught over 15
lectures in Kabul following approval. The course, which is pending approval from the Ministry of Higher
Education, will provide a comprehensive overview and a detailed understanding of various aspects relating to
international trade. It covers topics from the economic, policy and legal perspectives.
Short-term outcomes
Participants were rapidly familiarized with international trade regulation and the world trading system
(particular WTO) and informed of the global picture and objectives of a trade policy in the context of
Afghanistan's wider regional and development objectives.
Developed proficient professional knowledge of the core staff in charge of trade policy
formulation/implementation so that they perform tasks in their respective functions, administrations and
governments.
Participants exposed to wide-range of organisations involved in the trade policy formulation,
implementation, negotiation, trade promotion and advocacy.
Sustainability through local ownership and expertise developed to implement home-grown curriculum.
Next steps
Two best performing participants to attend month long internship placement in Delhi, August, 2018 aimed
at enhancing their on-the-job skills.
Second intake of participants to commence 7 month programme: “Afghanistan, WTO and International
Trade Programme” in September. Fine-tuning of programme prior to then to ensure that it is responsive to
the needs of second intake.
Further advisory services for Kabul University faculty to develop/run programme "Afghanistan, WTO and
International Trade".
Development of practical advisory manual to assist practitioners
2.6 Output 5: Institutional mechanisms to facilitate the implementation of the TFA are established at national level and linked with regional partners
At the time of developing the project, the activities in this output focussed on establishing and operationalizing
Afghanistan’s National Trade Facilitation Committee (NTFC), the establishment of which is a mandatory
requirement of the WTO TFA. However, by the time the project started, Afghanistan had already established
a NTFC in the form of the Inter-Ministerial Committee on WTO and TF (IMCWTF). The institutional
arrangements governing the committee (such as terms of reference, membership, governance, timetable etc.),
which the project was designed to implement, were already in place.
ITC’s trade facilitation experts accordingly needed to revisit the project’s design and consider new activities
that would have the maximum impact in the country. During the launch event, a needs assessment was carried
out with various national stakeholders to design new activities. The new activities aim to support the
operationalization of the IMCWTF in order to raise awareness of the TFA in both the public and the private
sector as well as to implement it. These activities have been detailed below and are accompanied by an
description of progress made to date.
18
Activity 5.1: Support the implementation of the WTO TFA through technical advisory services to IMCWTF and
other government agencies
- In preparation for TFA categorization, ITC – in close collaboration with USAID ATAR project - conducted an extensive research into the implementation status of the TFA in Afghanistan, assessing the extent to which each TFA measure has been implemented in the country (both in law and in practice) and the remaining gaps / needs. With ITC technical assistance, TFA measures were categorised at a national workshop with representatives of border regulatory agencies and the private sector. Then ITC provided ongoing advisory services to the Government of Afghanistan to facilitate the endorsement of the categorization recommendation by the IMCWTF. The categorization recommendation was approved by the HEC and notified to the WTO on the 19 February 2018.
- Following the categorization workshop mentioned above and building upon extended interviews with public and private stakeholders involved in international trade in Afghanistan, ITC has developed a Trade Facilitation Strategy that has been incorporated as a dedicated in the National Export Strategy.
- The project has now moved on to the implementation phase. ITC held a prioritization and sequencing workshop in Kabul between the 12 and the 14 of May 2018, working together with IMCWTF to rank TFA measures in order of priority, then sequence the reforms over a 10-year time frame. The concrete output of this workshop was a ten-year work-plan with implementation timelines for each TF measure, which can be used as a basis for notification of timelines to the WTO. This work-plan is now being validated by the IMCWTF, in collaboration with all relevant stakeholders.
- During the Prioritization and Sequencing workshop, it emerged that the Afghan Customs authorities had developed a TFA implementation plan as part of their Five-Year Strategic Plan for Customs Modernization. Further work has been carried out by ITC, in collaboration with Customs and with the Ministry of Industry and Commerce, to ensure that the two plans are consistent with one another. Two technical notes were produced for the benefit of stakeholders, and particular emphasis was placed on the importance of border agency collaboration.
- ITC and its project partners Afghanistan Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI) have begun to organise the private sector training and awareness-raising workshops, which will be held 25 – 27 June, 2018, in Kabul. The first workshop, in Kabul, will serve to secure private sector validation of the implementation work-plan that was developed by the IMCWTF at the prioritization and sequencing workshop.
Activity 5.2: Support the capacity building and operationalization of IMCWTF and other public sector agencies
to implement the WTO TFA
Both the categorization workshop and the prioritization and sequencing workshop that were held for the IMCWTF had considerable capacity-building components built into them. Training was provided on each of the TFA measures and the nature of the commitments that have been undertaken by the Afghan government (as a signatory to the TFA). Training was also provided on the use of cost-benefit analysis to prioritize TFA measures. Lastly, training was provided on the different types of implementation plan needed to successfully implement the WTO TFA (high-level, measure-specific, agency-specific), and the essential components that should be incorporated into the implementation plans, including activities, timelines, attribution of responsibilities, budget estimates, and M&E frameworks. Over the course of the prioritization and sequencing workshop, some deficiencies in the proper functioning of the IMCWTF were identified, and initial steps have been taken to rectifying these deficiencies. The different ministries / agencies have been encouraged to send well-informed individuals to IMCWTF sessions and ensure that representation remains consistent over time, to ensure the integrity of the decision-making process. The private sector representatives (in particular, the Afghan Chambers of Commerce and Industries) have been encouraged to actively participate in IMCWTF sessions. Lastly, but perhaps most importantly, the significance of information-sharing and collaborative decision-making have been emphasized, as there was a perception among some IMCWTF members that the TFA can be implemented by individual members without the need for contributions from the other members. Activity 5.3: Increase awareness of private stakeholders on the TFA and their ability to contribute to TFA related
Public Private Dialogue (PPD within the IMCWTF and other fora)
All the material required to train the private sector and ensure their effective participation in the decision-making process has been translated and disseminated to the Afghan Chamber of Commerce and Industry, which will be using it to conduct a series of six workshops after the end of Ramadan. The local experts who will lead
19
these workshops were trained at a train-the-trainers workshop held in October 2017 in Istanbul. ITC has finalised the institutional arrangements that will structure our collaboration with ACCI and this will be signed in July.
Activity 5.4: Structure and facilitate a regional network of (existing) NTFC to encourage experience sharing as
well as a coordinated and harmonized approach towards the implementation of the TFA
Desk research has been conducted on regional trade agreements and the regional institutions responsible for
trade facilitation. The relationship between Afghanistan and its neighbours is somewhat tense, and trade
issues are sometimes politicised, particularly in relation to the security situation in the Afghanistan-Pakistan
border region. Notwithstanding these challenges, initial contacts have been made with the officials of
neighbouring countries (e.g. Tajikistan) with a view to organising a regional trade facilitation workshop in 2019.
Furthermore, contact has been made with the Afghanistan Trade Centre, a section of the Centre of Excellence
Kabul University (CEKU). CEKU has expressed interest in leveraging its human capital to develop innovative
solutions to problems between Afghanistan and its neighbours in the field of trade facilitation. A concept note
is being developed that will provide further detail on the proposed activities, but the main objective is to foster
collaboration between students at Kabul University and their regional counterparts, who will work together to
propose trade facilitation measures at the regional trade facilitation workshop that will be held in 2019.
Short term outcomes
- WTO TFA measures were categorised at a categorization workshop in Kabul. - The IMCWTF conducted a cost-benefit analysis of TFA measures at a prioritization and sequencing
workshop in Kabul. - A draft work-plan for TFA implementation was developed at the prioritization and sequencing
workshop in Kabul. The work-plan is being validated by the relevant parties. - IMCWTF received training on the WTO TFA and the proper functioning of the NTFC at workshops in
Kabul. - Train-the-trainers workshop was held in Istanbul. - Master trainers and ACCI are ready to provide training to the TFA. Institutional agreement between
ITC and ACCI has been prepared and is awaiting signature.
Next steps
- IMCWTF finalizes high-level work-plan on WTO TFA implementation. - High-level work-plan is approved by the IMCWTF and the High Economic Council. - Measure-specific and agency-specific work plans are developed for selected, high-priority measures. - Implementation of selected, high-priority measures begins in 2018. - 100 SMEs are trained on compliance with and benefits of WTO TFA through a series of six private
sector workshops held by ACCI and Master trainers. - Students at Kabul University begin work on innovative trade facilitation measures for regional trade. - Dates are set for a regional trade facilitation workshop in 2019.
2.7 Output 6: SME knowledge of how to manage national cross-border procedures and compliance with regional and/or global market requirements is built encompassing priority markets (building on NES findings)
Export management guides have been finalised for key export sectors of Afghanistan and are ready for
publication.
Building upon the national trade procedure guides, ITC is in the process of finalizing an export management
training curricula that will be delivered to 100 SMEs through local trainers. In addition, ITC has developed the
20
first draft on an SME Coaching manual that will support local export management coaches in providing in-
house coaching to SMEs. Candidates for the export management coaches positions have already been
identified and will be selected on the basis of their experience and the relevance of their sectoral experience.
Short terms outcomes
- Export management guides finalised and ready to be published. - Export management training curriculums being finalized - Draft SME coaching manual is developed - Consultants identified to act as export management coaches (EMCs) for in-house SME training.
Next steps
- ITC finalises export management training curricula with sector specific content on key sectors. - Training curricula on sector specific export procedures are delivered to SMEs - Export Management Coaches are trained using the SME Coaching manual - Export Management Coaches deliver in-house coaching on export management to SMEs.
2.8 Output 7: Public-private consultation process on domestic/regional key pressing trade policy/regulatory/negotiation issues is strengthened
Under this output, the main developments are two-fold:
Throughout the most part of 2017/2018 the project supported MoIC to draft an Afghanistan National Trade
Policy (ANTP; 2018 – 2022). The policy document undertook several rounds of drafting and internal reviews
by MoIC and ITC, as well as receiving further inputs from private sector associations, local and international
experts. Additionally a national stakeholder consultation was held on 25 November, 2017, in which more
than 70 Afghan industry leaders, small business owners, and representatives of the public sector discussed
the contents of ANTP and agreed on its key objectives intended to increase the country’s exports.
MoIC subsequently approved the ANTP in May, 2018, and is pursing further steps to have the document
officially endorsed by the government for future implementation.
Additionally, high level government agreement was obtained for the following initiatives: 1)
Afghanistan/Uzbekistan bilateral stakeholder consultations to enhance trading relations, and; 2)
Afghanistan/Kazakhstan bilateral stakeholder consultations to enhance trading relations. For both of these
initiatives agreement was obtained on its purpose – that is, to bring together regularly key government and
business stakeholders drawn from these countries to deliberate on how to tackle specific obstacles to
trading, exploit opportunities, promote investment and create business linkages. In order to do this,
relationships between the respective countries were facilitated, including a small Afghan delegation meeting
counterpart in Tashkent in May, 2018.
So as better inform the dialogues, two evidenced based policy recommendations papers were carried out
seeking to identify barriers and issues which affect trade between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan/Kazakhstan
and issue recommendations to address these issues. ACCI was supported to draft position papers on the
same subject matters in preparation for their future strong involvement in these two initiatives.
A first Afghan/Uzbek stakeholder consultation was carried out in June, 2018. A key focus of meeting was
to discuss issues faced while exporting to/through and investing in Uzbekistan, including transit fees, export
duties, visas, operationalizing trade and transit agreements between the two countries. A joint
declaration/agreement reflecting the main points of consensus has been drafted and will be signed by both
sides (Ministerial level) at the earliest. In addition the stakeholder consultation led to the signing of an MOU
between ACCI and Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Uzbekistan establishing a joint Business
Council.
21
Short terms outcomes: ANTP
MoIC technical capacity developed on trade policy formulation to stimulate export development.
Reforms identified aimed at capacitating domestic institutions, creating business enabling environment,
implementing regulations resulting from WTO commitments and undertaking further trade-enabling
reforms.
ANTP addressing issues holistically and bringing forth trade policy coherence;
Road map provided for MoIC to carry out its objectives in synergy with other ministries and their policies.
Improved public and private dialogue supporting the development of a national trade policy.
Empowered national stakeholders capable of contributing trade policy design activities.
Next steps: ANTP
Further efforts to obtain final endorsement following its endorsement by MoIC. This includes preparations
to present policy document at PRISEC meeting and the HEC.
Short terms outcomes: Bilateral stakeholder consultations
Stakeholder support for priority bilateral trade consultation to enhance Afghanistan’s regional trade
confirmed.
Government’s agreement reached on broad modalities of initiatives confirmed.
First Afghanistan – Uzbekistan consultation held in which stakeholders exposed to initiative; engage with
counterparts, and; agree upon next steps.
MOU signed between ACCI and Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Uzbekistan to establish a join
Business Council.
Issues identified conveyed to Minister of Foreign Trade, Uzbekistan, for further action.
Next steps: Bilateral stakeholder consultations
First Afghanistan/Kazakhstan meeting to be held in August in Almaty/Astana.
Follow-up on agreement actions from both Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan stakeholders meetings.
22
3. ACTUAL RESULTS
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Impact: Enhanced trade
and regional trade integration of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan as a lever for confidence building, economic and human development and poverty reduction.
Increase in Afghanistan's international trade value and volume
0 0 0 On track. To be assessed in third year of the project.
Increase in Afghanistan's regional trade value and volume
0 0 0 On track. To be assessed in third year of the project
Delivery of confidence building measures Curriculum Based Measurement (CBM) included in the implementation plan of the Heart of Asia process (Dec 2013) for the six key CBM applied by the GIRoA
0 0 0 On track. To be assessed in third year of the project
23
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Outcome:
The Government formulates and implements better-informed trade policy and a strategic vision to support trade competitiveness within the region.
Number of decisions taken by the GIRoA to improve trade services for exporters and investors as a consequence of the project (project end)
0 10
10
NES: 6 (Adoption of response
paper; PriSEC endorsement; Council of Ministers endorsement; mechanism to manage the implementation of the NES; initiative to coordinate and liaise with other donors
ANTP: 1 (decision by MoIC to table ANTP to PriSEC)
Trade facilitation: 2 (WTO TFA categorization notified to WTO; TFA prioritization endorsed by IMCWTF MoIC decision to hold PPD with Uzbekistan and send delegation to Termiz leading to signing of MOU: 1
Number of TSI's improving their performance in relation to NES development, trade facilitation, and quality support
0 5
24
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Number of policy and regulatory measures initiated by the GIRoA for improving the business environment for exporters and investors as a consequence of the project
0 5
4
National Export Strategy; Afghanistan National Trade Policy; WTO TFA Categorized and TFA prioritization endorsed by IMCWTF
Percentage of Afghan business stakeholders reporting satisfaction about trade policy and Public Private consultation process
0 20
Number of measures implemented by the GIRoA to improve trade services for exporters and investors as a consequence of the project (project end)
0 5
Output 1:
GIRoA owns a NES and action plan that was developed in a consultative process with the private sector, and has started its implementation
Endorsed NES document, including individual sector and functional strategies, in place
0 1 0 1 Completed NES Concept note, NES response
25
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Number of official GIRoA NES launch events jointly with private sector representatives of such entities as ACCI and Afghanistan Investment Support Agency (AISA)
0 1 0 1 Completed Media press articles
Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed
0 20 8 141 Completed Missions and consultations’ documented reports
Number of participants to NES workshops
0 500 222 583 Completed Participants lists and consultation’s report
Number of female participants to NES workshops
0 140 18 132 Completed Participants lists and consultation’s report
Number of research and advice provided in relation to the NES development
0 4 1 4 Completed NES Concept note, NES Response paper, EPI.
1 Main NES public-private sector stakeholders consultations are listed under Section 4 of this report. Among others, these comprise 11 consultations held as part of the Second NES consultation (national and sector-level consultations), 2 provincial-level consultations and other consultative meetings.
26
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Output 2: National public
and private stakeholders are enabled to manage and coordinate the implementation of the NES and mobilise support to implement the validated roadmaps
High-level National Export Development Council, or similar, established.
0 1 0 0 On track
NES implementation management unit (secretariat) operationalized
0 1 0 0 On track
Number of NES Implementation Management training's completed
0 4 0 3 On track.
Number of participants to NES Implementation Management trainings
0 40 0 16 On track
Number of female participants to NES Implementation Management training
0 13 0 4
Output 3. Priority
interventions identified during the National Export Strategy design process are implemented to improve regional integration and international trade competitiveness
Number of priority initiatives in Quality and SPS areas approved
0 4 1 1 Some delay. 1) ANSA Workplan: 2) NES POA for quality with priority initiatives identified: Ongoing approval related to initiatives of the NES POA: food safety control system capacity building; training and twinning on strengthening TBT and SPS NEP and NNA; and others
ANSA Workplan; NES plan of action
27
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Number of initiatives in Quality and SPS areas completed
0 4
1 Slight delay. 1 completed related to training on operationalisation of selected equipment of ANSA lab metrology; Number of initiatives are going and to be completed in third year of the project to meet this target.
Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions
0 4 1 8 Target met. 9 trainings completed to date. Further trainings to be completed in the third year of the project.
Training Programmes, list of participants, training evaluation, reports
Number of advisory services provided to implement the identified priority interventions
0 3
9 Target met. 9 advisory services provided to date. Further advisory services to be completed in the third year of the project
Output 4: Knowledge
sharing mechanisms for GIRoA staff on trade policy/negotiation formulation and
Partnership with training institution from the region is established
0 1 1 - Completed Press release, Contract between CWS and ITC
28
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
implementation are established in partnership with a training institute from the Region
Number of training modules/material produced
0 7
10 Target completed with CWS developed materials for, “Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme” Note: further progress to recorded following completion of Kabul University curriculum for home-grown programme.
Materials all evidenced in: Afghanistan, “WTO and International Trade Programme”
Number of Afghan participants successfully passing trainers' assessment
0 40
20 On track. Regular assessment as part of “WTO and International Trade Programme”; Award of certificate of completion for 20 participants passing programme
Number of Afghan participants (women) successfully passing trainers' assessment
0 10
3
On track. Regular assessment as part of
“WTO and International Trade Programme”; Award of certificate of completion for 3 women participants passing programme
Number of trainers and/or regional resource persons trained
0 2
2 Target met. 2 experts (1 – Kabul Uni and 1 APPRO)
Regular assessment under “WTO and International Trade Programme”; Award of certificate of completion
29
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Number of meetings
2 6
Target met2 Meeting reports for the following trainings – introductory training; 3 advanced trainings; 1 adhoc distance training, and; study tour.
Output 5: Institutional
mechanisms to facilitate the implementation of the TFA are established at national level and linked with regional partners
Recommendation for the establishment of a NTFC issued and endorsed by the MoIC
0
Indicator redundant. At the outset of the project the NTFC was already established therefore progress cannot be recorded on this indicator.
New suggested indicator to replace above redundant indicator: Number of recommendations towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan”
4 1x categorization recommendation endorsed by HEC and official categorization decision notified to the WTO
1x TFA prioritization and sequencing recommendation validated by IMCWTF and endorsed by MoIC
1x Trade Facilitation Strategy developed and endorsed by the HEC (included as a chapter of the NES)
2 Note: “meetings” are referred to as “trainings” here.
30
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
1x concept note on the alignment of the Customs Strategic Plan and the TFA implementation plan
Number of public and private sector representatives stating increased awareness on the WTO TFA and trade facilitation reforms
0 100 152 131
Completed Attendance sheet from events
31
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Number of participants from public and private institutions to regional events in the area of trade facilitation (project end)
0 20 4 3
0
Number of female participants from public and private institutions to regional events in the area of trade facilitation
0 3 0 On track. To be completed in third year of the project.
Number of regional events in the area of trade facilitation
0 2 0 On track. To be completed in third year of the project.
3 Updated recording figure (recorded as zero before) from first project report, as not factored for. These figures are as follows: 3 participants attended IMCWTF Member participation to first NTFC Forum in Geneva; and 1 MCWTF Member participated in Asia-Pacific Forum on Trade Facilitation
32
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Output 6:
SME knowledge of how to manage national cross-border procedures and compliance with regional and/or global market requirements is built encompassing priority markets (building on NES findings)
Number of private sector representatives who participated in the export management curriculum and pass knowledge tests
0 100 0 0 Some delay. Preparatory work being done that will contribute to this indicator. Trainings to commence in 3rd and 4th quarters in 2018.
Trainers are trained 0 5 7 Completed. Master trainers trained to deliver private sector workshops on TFA
Participant list from training, Istanbul, 2017; developed learning materials
National Trade Facilitation procedure guide published
0 1 0 Some delay. Export Management Guides are ready and agreement reached in principle to publish information through a Trade Portal.
Output 7:
Public-private consultation process on domestic/regional key pressing trade policy/regulatory/ negotiation issues is strengthened
Number of public-private dialogues/trainings held
0 8
3 In progress. Further events in third year.
Meeting reports: 1) Afghanistan National Trade Policy Consultative meeting (Nov, 2017), and 2) Afg – Uzbek: Stakeholder consultation to enhance trading relations (Jun, 2018); 3) Pre-event stakeholder consultation for Afg – Uzbek event (i.e. point 2)
33
Objectives Project indicators Baseline
Targets Actual Actual
Status Means of verification
01 Jul 2017 – 30 Jun 2018
16 Aug 2016 – 16 Aug 2019
16 Aug 2016 – 30 Jun 2017
Legend On track
Some delay
Delay
Number of policy research/material produced
0 8 1 5 In progress. Further policy research/material to be produced in year 3 to inform consultation processes.
Complete materials: 1. ANTP (2107 -2022); 2. Policy recommendations study: Trade between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan: Issues and Options for Enhancement; 3. Policy recommendations study: Trade between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan: Issues and Options for Enhancement; 4. Position paper: Trade between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan: Issues and Options for Enhancement; 5. Position paper: Trade between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan: Issues and Options for Enhancement
Number of recommendations stemming from PPD
0 10
22 Target completed. More recommendations to come in Y3.
20 from ANTP (Policy area sub-
sections); 2 from Afg-Uzbek bilateral stakeholder consultation to enhance trade relations)
34
4. ACTIVITIES CARRIED OUT DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD
4.1 OUTPUT 1: GIRoA owns a national export strategy and action plan that was developed in a consultative process with the private sector, and has started its implementation
During the first reporting period, preliminary audits and analysis of Afghanistan’s trade competitiveness,
development agenda, and key trade support institutions (TSI) were performed. An initial assessment and
strategic findings were debated and further refined through a series of Kabul-based and provincial large
consultations where over 220 public and private actors reached consensus on priority sectors’ main
competitiveness issues and essential interventions. A first sector-specific provincial consultations was held in
Mazar e-Sharif. Factory visits coupled with interviews of international buyers contributed to sharpen the initial
assessment and strategic considerations.
Moreover, quality management and SPS measures had been confirmed as highly sensitive and priority issues.
Accordingly, an initial review of the quality and SPS institutions along with a series of bilateral meetings,
consultations and capacity building workshops were held.
Additionally, a NES Response Paper was produced to present the business case for developing Afghanistan’s
NES. The Response Paper puts forward a list of priority sectors and trade support functions. It was formally
endorsed by the High Economic Council (HEC).
In short, the following activities were undertaken under the first year of the project:
1.1: Establishing strategy design and implementation management structures - NES pre-engagement
mission
1.2: Analysis of Afghanistan’s trade competitiveness, development agenda, existing trade-related
programmes, and key TSI
Structured face-to-face or Skype interviews with diaspora and international buyers-traders
1.3: Inauguration and first stakeholders’ consultation of Afghanistan’s NES
1.4: Elaboration of Afghanistan’s NES Response Paper
1.5 & 1.6: Mapping of the institutions and preliminary review of the Quality and SPS Infrastructures
1.7: Provincial NES stakeholders’ consultation in Mazar-e-Sharif and in- factory supply chain assessment
The following details progress under the second year of the project.
Activity Date/location Main Achievements Contributing to Indicator
1.1. Steering
Committee
Meeting and First
Donor
Coordination
Roundtable
July, 2017
Kabul
Endorsement of the
NES Response Paper
Discussion on priority
sectors selection
Donor coordination
group roundtable
SUB-IND 1. 6: Number of research and advice provided in relation to the NES development: 1
1.2. Provincial
NES stakeholders’
consultation in
Herat
August, 2017
Herat
Discussion and
confirmation of main
export-related issues
and immediate
SUB-IND: 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 1
35
4 In total with figure including participation in NES main stakeholder consultation and sector working group meetings. 5 In total with participation of women in NES main stakeholder consultation and sector working group meetings.
priorities of the Herat
province.
SUB-IND 1.4: Number of
participants to NES
workshops: 100
SUB-IND 1.5: Number of
female participants to
NES workshops: 14
This inclusive provincial
consultation also
contributed to the final
endorsement of the
strategy.
1.3. Provincial
NES stakeholders’
consultation in
Kandahar
September, 2017
Kandahar
The consultation helped confirm the main issues affecting the prioritized NES sectors of fresh fruits and vegetables, dried fruits and nuts and precious stones and jewellery.
SUB-IND: 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 1 SUB-IND 1.4: Number of
participants to NES
workshops: 80
SUB-IND 1.5: Number of
female participants to
NES workshops: 15
This inclusive provincial
consultation also
contributed to the final
endorsement of the
strategy.
1.4. Second
stakeholders’
consultation of
Afghanistan’s NES
October, 2017
Kabul
National and sector
/cross-sector plans of
action revised and
validated. Specific
suggestions and
additions to each Plan
of Action were
introduced
accordingly.
SUB-IND: 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 11
SUB-IND 1.4: Number of
participants to NES
workshops: 2834
SUB-IND 1.4: Number of
female participants to
NES workshops: 705
SUB-IND 1. 6: Number of research and advice provided in relation to the NES development: 1
36
The second national
consultation also
contributed to the final
endorsement of the
strategy.
1.5. Bilateral
meetings and
discussions with
sector experts and
relevant
stakeholders to
sharpen
assessments,
strategic
orientations and
activities of
national and
sector-level
strategy
documents
February –
November 2017
Geneva, Berlin and
Kabul
Strategic market intelligence and insights were collected to feed the NES design process. Strategic orientations and Plan of Action activities were sharpened owed to an increased understanding of demand-driven considerations.
Insights from Impact Berlin served to refine youth and returnee-related activities throughout the NES.
SUB-IND: 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 1
SUB-IND 1.4:
Number of participants to NES workshops: 50 SUB-IND 1.5:
Number of female participants to NES workshops: 20
1.6: Elaboration of
Afghanistan’s NES
Strategy
documents
February –
November 2017
Geneva and Kabul
Coherent and comprehensive export strategy documents with a five-year detailed plan of action and implementation management framework.
SUB-IND 1.1: Endorsed National Export Strategy document, including individual sector and functional strategies in place SUB-IND 1.7: Number of
trade education skills
reports: 1
1.7 Endorsement
of the NES by High
Economic Council,
PriSEC and the
Council of
Ministries
November and
April, 2018
High-level participants endorsed policy objectives of the NES, a crucial step towards implementation
SUB-IND 1.1: Endorsed National Export Strategy document, including individual sector and functional strategies in place: 1 SUB-IND: 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 2 SUB-IND 1.4:
Number of participants to
NES workshops: PRISEC
25, NES Council of
Ministers: 35
SUB-IND 1.5:
Number of female
participants to NES
workshops: PRISEC 6,
37
Activity 1.1: Steering Committee Meeting and First Donor Coordination Roundtable
Title Steering Committee Meeting and First Donor Coordination Roundtable
Location Kabul
Implementing
partners
ITC, MoIC, ACCI
Background/
context
Steering Committee: The project steering committee was established to support the AAT project’s activities; monitor its implementation and progress; ensure that the project outputs respond to the country’s priorities; and advice on next steps. The Steering Committee meeting served to take stock of progress on all AAT activities.
Donor coordination (before completion of NES documents): The NES is firmly aligned with existing aid-for-trade and TRTA initiatives ongoing in the country. This alignment includes the establishment of a donors’ round-table that has started meeting regularly to discuss synergies in their trade-related initiatives.
Results Bilateral meetings and roundtables led to the final endorsement of the
NES Response Paper.
Discussions held through different platforms led to the revision and
validation of NES priority sectors. ITC reiterated the analytical depth that
has resulted in identification of sectors with competitive advantage – the
analysis is not solely based on quantitative parameters but also derived
from the consultations, bilateral interviews and existing body of research.
Private sector support was secured to coordinate and co-organize
upcoming provincial consultations in Herat and Kandahar.
Donors noted that within the trade area, a wide range of activities are ongoing but prioritization and donor coordination has been limited. In this regard, agreement has been secured to formalize the donors group and hold regular meetings during the NES design phase and beyond.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
EPAA, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Health, Ministry of Agriculture,
Irrigation and Livestock, Afghan Customs Department, sector
associations.
NES Council of Ministers:
7
SUB-IND 1. 6: Number of research and advice provided in relation to the NES development: 3
1.8 Official launch
of the NES
June, 2018 Official launch event kick-starting the implementation phase of the Strategy
SUB-IND 1.2: Number of
official GIRoA NES launch
events jointly with private
sector representatives or
such entities such as
ACCI and ANSA: 1
38
EU Delegation and USAID
Supporting
documents
NES Response paper; Minutes of the meeting.
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 1.6: Number of research and advice provided in relation to the NES development: 1
This activity is also an essential initial step contributing to secure the final
endorsement of the NES.
Activity 1.2: Provincial NES stakeholders’ consultation in Herat
Title Provincial NES stakeholders’ consultation in Herat
Location Herat province
Implementing
partners
ITC, MoIC, ACCI
Background/
context
The Afghanistan National Export Strategy (NES) initiative falls under the auspices of the ‘Advancing Afghanistan Trade’ project, funded by the European Union, which aims to assist Afghanistan in improving the conditions to use trade as a lever for enhanced regional cooperation, economic and human development, and poverty reduction.
The provincial NES consultations complement the national consultations, to feed into the ongoing design of the country’s National Export Strategy (NES). The provincial NES consultations are crucial in making sure that stakeholders beyond the capital are included in the design of the strategy.
In this regard, Herat province plays a significant economic role in Afghanistan, as it represents a major trading hub. Moreover, Herat hosts a number of traditional and emerging industries, including sectors prioritized in the NES, such as dried fruits and nuts, carpets, handicrafts, saffron, and marble and granite.
The event was jointly organized by MOIC and ACCI, with the technical support of ITC. The consultation in Herat follows the first NES stakeholders’ consultation held in Kabul on 20-21 February and in Mazar-e-Sharif on 18 May (2017).
Results In a participatory group discussion led by the ITC team, participants identified issues and obstacles preventing enterprises in Herat from developing and maintaining export relationships in the afore-mentioned sectors. The main competitiveness constraints, pre-identified through desk research and previous consultations, were confirmed, following the ITC four-gear approach:
Supply side issues: capacity development, quality compliance,
diversification, skills development etc.
Quality of the Business environment: regulatory and procedures,
institutional support, access to finance, trade across borders etc.
Market Side issues: Marketing, Packaging, Branding and In-market
support
Participants identified tangible solutions to the most appraising
challenges under the guidance of the ITC team.
39
Stakeholder/
participant
information
Public and private sector stakeholders
Number of attendees: 100
Number of woman attendees: 14
Supporting
documents
Presentations and tools, value chain maps and problem trees,
questionnaires for factory visits.
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 1 SUB-IND 1.4: Number of participants to NES workshops: 100
SUB-IND 1.5: Number of female participants to NES workshops: 14
This inclusive provincial consultation also contributed to the final
endorsement of the strategy.
Activity 1.3: Provincial NES stakeholders’ consultation in Kandahar
Title Provincial NES stakeholders’ consultation in Kandahar
Location Kandahar
Implementing
partners
ITC, MoIC, ACCI
Background/
context
Kandahar hosts a number of traditional and emerging industries, including sectors prioritized in the NES, such as fresh fruits and vegetables, dried fruits and nuts, handicrafts, livestock and dairy products.
The event was jointly organized MOIC and ACCI, with the technical support of ITC. The consultation in Kandahar follows the first NES stakeholders’ consultation held in Kabul on 20-21 February and in Mazar-e-Sharif on 18 May (2017), as well as in Herat on 13 August (2017).
Results The consultation helped confirm the main issues affecting the prioritized NES sectors of fresh fruits and vegetables, dried fruits and nuts and precious stones and jewellery.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
Public and private sector stakeholders
Number of attendees: 80
Number of woman attendees: 15
Supporting
documents
Presentations and tools, value chain maps and problem trees,
questionnaires for factory visits.
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 1 SUB-IND 1.4: Number of participants to NES workshops: 80
SUB-IND 1.5: Number of female participants to NES workshops: 15
This inclusive provincial consultation also contributed to the final
endorsement of the strategy.
Activity 1.4. Second stakeholders’ consultation of Afghanistan’s NES
40
Title Second stakeholders’ consultation of Afghanistan’s NES
Location Kabul
Implementing
partners
ITC, MoIC, ACCI
Background/
context
The purpose of the second national consultation was to refine and validate the NES’ plans of action. The objective of this approach is to facilitate the development of highly specific plans of action, going into detailed activities, targets, and impact measures, indicating what exactly needs to be done and by whom and with what resources. Outputs from this consultative event were consolidated into the National Export Strategy documents.
Results The consultation started with introductory remarks on the overall framework of the Afghanistan’s National Export Strategy (NES), followed by a brief explanation on the design and implementation process and methodology of the NES. Information regarding the current status of the project was shared with the participants.
Consecutively, participants were separated into groups, according to their sector of expertise. During the sector-level consultation, participants guided by moderators, discussed their Plan of Action (PoA) in detail, specifically focusing on the strategic objectives, operational objectives and key activities.
The national and sector/cross-sector plans of action were revised and validated by relevant public and private sector stakeholders. Specific suggestions and additions to each Plan of Action were introduced accordingly.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
Public and private sector stakeholders participated of this event from
Kabul, as well as from Jalalabad province
Second National Consultation - Number of attendees: 120
Supporting
documents
Draft Plans of Action, Presentations and tools, dignitaries’ speeches,
press coverage, mission report
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 11 (Second NES consultation and sector-level consultations, see below) SUB-IND 1.4:
Number of participants to NES workshops:
1. Second National consultation-Number of attendees. 120
2. Dried fruits and nuts - Number of attendees: 13 3. Fresh fruits and vegetables - Number of attendees: 15 4. Carpets- Number of attendees: 15 5. Marble- Number of attendees: 11 6. Precious stones and jewellery - Number of attendees: 12 7. Saffron - Number of attendees: 4 8. Quality Management - Number of attendees: 26 9. Access to Finance - Number of attendees: 26 10. Business and professional services - Number of attendees: 22 11. Preparatory consultation of Precious stones and jewellery
sector – Number of attendees: 14
SUB-IND 1.5:
Number of female participants to NES workshops:70
1. NES main consultation: 22 2. Dried fruits and nuts - Number of attendees: 3
41
3. Fresh fruits and vegetables - Number of attendees: 6 4. Carpets- Number of attendees: 4 5. Marble- Number of attendees: 3 6. Precious stones and jewellery - Number of attendees: 11 7. Saffron - Number of attendees: 1 8. Quality Management - Number of attendees: 4 9. Access to Finance - Number of attendees: 4 10. Business and professional services - Number of attendees: 6 11. Preparatory consultation of Precious stones and jewellery
sector – Number of attendees: 6 SUB-IND 1. 6: Number of research and advice provided in relation to the NES development: 1
The second national consultation also contributed to the final
endorsement of the strategy.
Activity 1.5. Bilateral meetings and discussions with sector experts and public-private sector stakeholders and civil society representatives to sharpen assessments and strategic orientations of national and sector-level strategy documents
Title Bilateral meetings and discussions with sector experts and relevant stakeholders to sharpen assessments, strategic orientations and activities of national and sector-level strategy documents
Location Kabul, Berlin and Geneva
Implementing
partners
ITC
Background/
context
As part of the NES design process, ITC involved both public and private sector stakeholders, as well as representatives of civil society (e.g. young entrepreneurs) that are involved in, or have a bearing on, international trade and export competitiveness. The quality and relevance of the resulting export strategy relies on the full engagement of national stakeholders and their substantive inputs.
Bilateral meetings with sector experts and key international buyers as well as factory visits complemented national and provincial-level consultations with the objective of sharpening assessments and strategic considerations.
Key activities include bilateral discussions with key international buyers (e.g. McCormik, Ducros, Noberasco, Zaffy, Aromatica, Rumi Spice, Frontier Coop and Kefayat Group, among others) to gain further understanding of buyers’ perspectives and to obtain recommendations for strategic considerations (packaging and branding).
Another key activity was ITC’s participation of Impact Berlin, an event focused on young Afghan entrepreneurs to discuss start-up success practices. The event gathered 80 participants from different backgrounds, including development partners and relevant Afghan stakeholders. Participating organisations were AGHAEZ, BookClub Afghanistan, the Freie Universität, Impact Hub Berlin, the International Organisation for Migration, Kompass, Migration Hub, Samuel Hall and Philia.
Results Strategic market intelligence and insights were collected to feed the NES design process. Strategic orientations and Plan of Action activities were sharpened owed to an increased understanding of demand-driven considerations.
Insights from Impact Berlin served to refine youth and returnee-related activities throughout the NES.
42
Participant
information
Key international buyers consulted included McCormik, Ducros,
Noberasco, Zaffy, Aromatica, Rumi Spice, Frontier Coop and Kefayat
Group, among others
Impact Berlin participants included AGHAEZ, BookClub Afghanistan, the
Freie Universität, Impact Hub Berlin, the International Organisation for
Migration, Kompass, Migration Hub, Samuel Hall and Philia.
Supporting
documents
NES presentation at Impact Berlin
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 1.3: Number of public-private NES stakeholder consultations completed: 1 SUB-IND 1.4:
Number of participants to NES workshops: 50 SUB-IND 1.5:
Number of female participants to NES workshops: 20
Activity 1.6. Finalization of Afghanistan’s NES Strategy documents
Title Finalization of Afghanistan’s NES Strategy documents
Location Kabul and Geneva
Implementing
partners
The NES was developed under the leadership of MOIC, and ACCI, in
close collaboration with MAIL and ANSA.
AWCCI provided key contributions to ensure that gender-specific
concerns were integrated into the NES.
Consultations with the Ministry of Finance and the President’s Senior
Advisors accompanied the design phase while insights and expertise
from ACIM and ACCI contributed to fine-tune both the analytical
foundation and the strategic considerations
Background/
context
Afghanistan’s NES was developed based on a participatory approach during which over 500 Afghan industry leaders, small business owners, farmers and public sector representatives held consultations to reach consensus on key sector competitiveness issues and priority activities. These inclusive platforms were held throughout the country, including in Mazar-e-Sharif, Herat, Kandahar and Kabul, with participation of stakeholders coming from Nangarhār province. Women entrepreneurs and women-led business associations as well as young entrepreneurs played an important role in the consultative processes, as their success is central to the country’s economic future.
Besides in-depth research and value chain analysis, these consultations were complemented by supply chain assessments, interviews with domestic, regional and international buyers and donor coordination meetings.
The NES is aligned to the policy priorities and national goals established by the Cabinet and the High Economic Council and firmly supports the work of the NPPs and PriSEC, in areas related to socio-economic growth, private sector development, regional integration, investment, youth and women economic empowerment. Similarly, particular attention was placed in aligning the NES with Afghanistan National Trade Policy and post-WTO accession strategy.
Results The principal outputs of the NES Afghanistan design initiative are endorsed, coherent and comprehensive export strategy documents with
43
a five-year detailed plan of action and implementation management framework. These documents include:
A main NES document, which contains Trade Support Functional strategies, offering critical support across value chains and acting as enablers for sector development.
Individual NES priority sector strategies packaged as separate documents, but in alignment with the main NES findings and overarching strategic objectives. These sectors are dried fruits and nuts, saffron, carpets, marble and granite, fresh fruits and vegetables and precious stones and jewellery.
Supporting
documents
The NES Strategy documents (seven)
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 1.1: Endorsed National Export Strategy document, including individual sector and functional strategies in place: 1
SUB-IND 1.7: Number of trade education skills reports: 1
Activity 1.7. Endorsement of the NES by High Economic Council, PriSEC and the Council of Ministries
Title Endorsement of the NES by High Economic Council, PriSEC and the Council of Ministries
Location Kabul
Implementing
partners
High Economic Council, PriSEC and the Council of Ministries
Background/
context
The NES was presented at the Council of Ministers and the Executive Committee of Private Sector Development (PriSEC) where it benefited from ultimate guidance and approval. This step was prior to the NES’ ultimate endorsement by the High Economic Council.
The endorsement of NES, marks the end of a yearlong public-private consultation process to develop the National Export Strategy.
Results Afghanistan’s High Economic Council, chaired by President Mohammad Ashraf Ghani, on 3 April endorsed a National Export Strategy (NES).
HEC’s endorsement of the NES is pivotal to mobilize the national and international support required for implementation.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
The PriSEC and Council of Ministers meetings were chaired by Afghanistan’s Chief Executive Dr. Abdullah Abdullah
The meetings counted with high-level public and private sector stakeholders, among which there was: Mr. Humyoon Rasaw, Afghanistan’s Minister of Commerce and Industries, Ambassador Pierre Mayaudon, EU Head of Delegation in Afghanistan and Mr. Atiq Nusrat, Chief Executive Officer of the Afghanistan Chamber of Commerce and Industries (ACCI).
NES-Council of Ministers – Attendees: 35
PriSEC – Attendees: 25
The High Economic Council is formed by high-level authorities and chaired by President Ghani.
44
Supporting
documents
NES Strategy documents, dignitaries’ speeches, press coverage, mission report
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 1.1: Endorsed National Export Strategy document, including individual sector and functional strategies in place: 1 SUB-IND 1.4: Number of participants to NES workshops: PRISEC 25,
NES Council of Ministers: 35
SUB-IND 1.5: Number of female participants to NES workshops:
PRISEC 6, NES Council of Ministers: 7
SUB-IND 1.6: Number of research and advice provided in relation to the NES development: 3
Activity 1.8. Official launch of the NES
Title Official launch of the NES
Location Kabul
Implementing
partners
ITC, MOIC-EPAA
Background/
context
The comprehensive research and analysis undertaken to develop the NES has determined that there are sectors with high potential that can contribute to socioeconomic progress. This will not be easy but with the concerted and coherent effort expended through NES design and implementation, such growth is feasible.
The first step – NES design – is now complete, and focus must quickly turn towards implementation and implementation management and monitoring.
Results The launch ceremony of the NES marked the official start of the implementation phase of the Strategy. The launch served to capitalize on the strong momentum gained as part of the NES design process to leverage it for implementation.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
Public and private sector stakeholders participated of this event from Kabul, as well as from Jalalabad province.
Number of participants: 80
Supporting
documents
Significant media coverage was obtained through the press and television.
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 1.2: Number of official GIRoA NES launch events jointly
with private sector representatives or such entities such as ACCI
and ANSA: 1
45
4.2 OUTPUT 2: National public and private stakeholders are enabled to manage and coordinate the implementation of the NES and mobilise support to implement the validated roadmaps
During the first reporting period, key international development partners were fully apprised on all aspect of
the NES design and implementation phases through an unprecedented Donor Coordination Meeting.
Participating development partners of this meeting were United States Agency for International Development
(USAID), EU, DFID, BMZ, German Development Agency (GIZ), Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO),
UNCTAD, United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA). The Donor Coordination Meeting was
complemented by bilateral consultations and consensus was reached on the need to formalize the Donor
Coordination Group.
High-level bilateral meetings (e.g. with MoIC and MAIL ministers, senior advisor to President, ANSA Director
General(DG), ACCI’s CEO and Head of HEC Secretariat were organized to sensitize key decision makers on
the NES process and ensure that it serves the New Development Planning System as well as remains in line
with parallel and related plans and policies. The following activities advance those recorded under the AAT’s
First Project Progress Report.
In short, the following activities were undertaken under the first year of the project.
Strategy Implementation Management Tool (SIMT)
Stakeholder mobilization
The following details progress under the second year.
Activity Date/location Main Achievements Contributing to
Indicator
2.1. Initial sensitization
and coaching of key
institutions’ focal
points on sectors’ PoA
implementation
October, 2017
Kabul
- Senior and middle-
level staff of key
institutions were
appraised on sector-
level PoA strategic
objectives and
activities relevant to
their institutions/
sectors
- Sensitization on key
success factors for
translation of NES
activities into
effective and
efficient
implementation
SUB-IND 2.4 Number of
NES Implementation
Management training's
completed: 1
2.2. Advisory and
technical services
towards the definition
of operationalization of
governance structure
for NES implementation
Advisory and
technical support:
throughout the
NES design
process
Training held:
June, 2018
- EPAA designated as
the NES
implementation
Management Unit
(Secretariat).
Agreement on action
items towards
formalization and
This activity directly
contributes to achieving
the following indicators:
SUB-IND 2.1 High-level
National Export
Development Council,
or similar, established
46
operationalization of
NES Secretariat
- Discussion and
agreement on next
steps towards the
formalization of HEC
as the National
Export Dev. Council
SUB-IND 2.2 NES
implementation
management unit
(Secretariat)
operationalized
2.3. Development and
dissemination of
training material on
NES implementation
management
February 2017 –
June 2018
Geneva/Kabul
Key MOIC-EPAA
stakeholders gained
access to training
material tailored to
NES Afghanistan
implementation
management support
SUB-IND 2.3 Number of
trade capacity-building
guide published: 1
2.4. Training on
Management support to
establish and
operationalize an
effective
implementation
management
framework for NES
implementation
June, 2018
Kabul, Geneva
Key MoIC-EPAA staff
increased their
technical capacities
and gained skills on
implementation
management,
monitoring techniques
and resource
mobilization
SUB-IND 2.4. Number
of NES implementation
management trainings
completed: 1
Number of participants
to NES implementation
management trainings:
8
Number of female
participants to NES
Implementation
Management trainings:
2
2.5. Customization of
Strategy
Implementation
Management Tool
(SIMT) and training to
key officials
SIMT
Customization:
March-April 2018
Capacity-building:
June 2018
Kabul, Geneva
Customized
implementation
management tool to
the Afghanistan NES
Designated MOIC-
EPAA staff gained
knowledge on
functions of the tool
and use of the SIMT to
coordinate, report and
monitor
implementation
SUB-IND 2.4. Number
of NES implementation
management trainings
completed: 1
Number of participants
to NES implementation
management trainings:
8
Number of female
participants to NES
Implementation
Management trainings:
2
2.6. Stakeholder and
resource mobilization
to position the NES within
national development
priorities to support
implementation
Throughout the
NES design
process
Donor roundtable:
June 2018
The NES is well-
positioned within the
development priorities
of the country
Reconfirmation of
donors’ interest to
Not applicable.
47
Activity 2.1. Initial sensitization and coaching of key institutions’ focal points on sectors’ PoA
implementation
Title Initial sensitization and coaching of key institutions’ focal points on sectors’
PoA implementation
Location Kabul
Implementing partners ITC, MOIC-EPAA
Background/context During the second national consultation in Kabul, participants were
separated into groups, according to their sector of expertise (i.e. carpets,
dried fruits and nuts, fresh fruits and vegetables, saffron, marble and granite
and precious stones and jewellery).
In a participatory group discussion, participants guided by moderators,
discussed their Plan of Action (PoA) in detail, specifically focusing on the
strategic objectives, operational objectives and key activities.
Accordingly, ITC provided training/coaching to the trio of moderators, co-
moderators and rapporteurs of each of the six sector groups. They were
appraised on the main areas of their involvement during the consultation
and most importantly, they gained understanding on key features of sector-
level plans of action such as their objectives, importance and structure (i.e.
sector-specific strategic objectives, operational objectives and activities). In
order to lead sector-level discussion to revise and enrich PoAs, they were
coached on key success factors to enable the implementation of action
plans, such as responsibility attribution for the implementation of each
specific activity and the need for measurable and realistic targets.
Results Senior and middle-level staff of key institutions were appraised on the
importance, objectives and structure of sector-level PoAs. Senior and
middle-level staff were also sensitized on key success factors for translation
of NES activities into effective and efficient implementation. This exercise
contributed to increased national and institution-level ownership of each
sector strategy.
Stakeholder/participant
information
Senior and middle-level staff from national public-private institutions
relevant to each of the priority sectors, including AWCCI, MAIL, ACCI,
EPAA, among others
Kabul, Geneva formalize a framework
to coordinate Aid for
Trade interventions to
support NES
implementation
NES seen as an
instrument for
advocacy, planning
and coordination of
aid for trade initiatives
and trade-related
technical assistance
in Afghanistan
48
Supporting documents
Training material tailored to each priority sector, action plans
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 2.4 Number of NES Implementation Management training's
completed: 1
Activity 2.2. Advisory and technical services towards the definition of operationalization of governance
structure for NES implementation
Title Advisory and technical services towards the definition of
operationalization of governance structure for NES implementation
Location Kabul
Implementing partners MOIC, EPAA, ITC
Background/context A key success factor towards NES implementation is the establishment and operationalization of a high-level public and private national coordinating body and its subsidiary organ to manage NES implementation.
It is recommended that the country establishes a specific high-level and public-private committee, that acts in an advisory and endorsement capacity to the government over issues related to the Afghanistan’s National Export Strategy or affecting export competitiveness overall.
The NES high-level Council should be supported by a NES Executive Secretariat to complete the daily operational work related to implementation management of the NES.
Considering the current institutional capacity and to avoid the multiplication of committees, stakeholders underlined the imperative for the High Economic Council to play the role of the NES high-level coordinating body during a preliminary phase.
MOIC-EPAA has been acting at the NES Secretariat during the design phase of the National Export Strategy. It has been proposed that MOIC-EPAA undertakes the role of the NES Executive Secretariat.
ITC has provided technical and advisory support to enable MOIC-EPAA to lead the discussions on the establishment and formalization of the NES Implementation Management Unit and the NES Secretariat. Key activities have included coaching of EPAA on different modalities of governance structure for the NES implementation, as preparation for the NES presentation to the HEC.
In June 2018, ITC also provided capacity-building to MOIC-EPAA key staff on coordination and management modalities (e.g. sector advisory committees), as part of its Implementation Management training.
Results Key stakeholders progressed on the definition and operationalization of the
NES implementation management structure with ITC’s advisory and
technical assistance.
Progress has been made towards the formalization of EPAA as the NES
Secretariat. MOIC-EPAA discussed, identified and agreed on action items
to achieve this goal in June 2018.
Additionally, key stakeholders gained clarity and reached consensus on the
best modality of governance structure for the implementation of priority
sector strategies (i.e. Specialized committees on Agriculture, Handicraft
and Mineral products).
Finally, action items were discussed and agreed on the formalization of
HEC as the National Export Development Council.
49
Stakeholder/participant
information
MOIC-EPAA key officials
Supporting documents
Inputs sent to EPAA for NES presentation to HEC
Training material on implementation management
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
This activity directly contributes to achieving the following indicators:
SUB-IND 2.1 High-level National Export Development Council, or
similar, established: 1
SUB-IND 2.2 NES implementation management unit (Secretariat)
operationalized: 1
Activity 2.3. Development and dissemination of training material on NES implementation management
Title Development and dissemination of training material on NES
implementation management
Location Geneva/Kabul
Implementing partners ITC
Background/context Successful implementation can make the difference between a strategy that gathers dust and one that drives tangible development impact on the ground. The ability and competence of the NES Executive Secretariat need to be sufficient to ensure effective management of the NES implementation. The NES Secretariat should have knowledge of monitoring frameworks, resources mobilization and programming, communication, advocacy, etc. Without such skills, it will not be in a strong position to assume the responsibility of ensuring the implementation of the NES. It is thereafter, important to provide the Executive Secretariat with the appropriate tools and capacities to manage the NES efficiently.
In preparation for the capacity-building sessions of MOIC-EPAA officials on implementation management, corresponding training material was developed and disseminated to relevant stakeholders.
Results Key MOIC-EPAA stakeholders gained access to training material tailored to NES Afghanistan implementation management support, including a step-by-step guidance on the use and main features of the Strategy Implementation Management Tool
Stakeholder/participant
information
MOIC-EPAA key officials
Supporting documents
Training material on implementation management, SIMT and resource
mobilization
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 2.3 Number of trade capacity-building guide published: 1
Activity 2.4: Training on Management support to establish and operationalize an effective implementation management framework for NES implementation
Title Training on Management support to establish and operationalize an
effective implementation management framework for NES
implementation
Location Geneva and Kabul
Implementing partners ITC
Background/context The effective contribution of the NES to export development will largely depend on the ability of Afghanistan to plan, mobilize resources, coordinate activities and monitor implementation.
50
ITC’s intervention will continue to capacitate the NES Executive Secretariat i.e. MOIC- EPAA and sectoral advisory committees so as to guarantee that initiatives implemented are aligned to NES priorities.
The ultimate goal is to ensure the strategy’s priorities, as defined by national stakeholders, receive adequate support, are translate into implementable projects, and contribute to national targets.
Results Implementation management support to key institutions to manage and coordinate NES implementation has been initiated. While distance support has been continuous, a face-to-face training was organized in June 2018. MoIC-EPAA staff’ skills and capacity were strengthen to manage NES implementation. MoIC-EPAA staff further increased their knowledge and skills on management and monitoring techniques and resource mobilization.
Stakeholder/participant
information
Number of attendees: 8 (MoIC and EPAA staff)
Supporting documents
Training material, NES Strategy documents
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 2.4. Number of NES implementation management trainings
completed: 1
Number of participants to NES implementation management
trainings: 8
Number of female participants to NES Implementation Management
trainings: 2
Activity 2.5: Customization of Strategy Implementation Management Tool (SIMT) and training to key
officials
Title Customization of Strategy Implementation Management Tool (SIMT)
and training to key officials
Location Geneva and Kabul
Implementing partners ITC
Background/context In addition to building capacities and advisory support, a customizable tool is provided by ITC to ensure that MoIC will have the instruments required to effectively plan, coordinate, measure and prioritise the strategy implementation process. This tool (SIMT) has been developed based on ITC’s global experience and the identified emerging requirements of partner countries. The SIMT serves as a single window for organizing, monitoring and measuring implementation activities within a country.
Results The online SIMT has been tailored to the Afghanistan NES and all NES Plans of Action have been uploaded into the system.
National partners and designated NES Secretariat increased their knowledge and technical capacities on main functionalities and operationalization of the SIMT for reporting and monitoring of NES implementation.
The SIMT was officially deployed and data collection on trade-related interventions has begun.
Stakeholder/participant
information
Attendees: MoIC and EPAA staff
Supporting documents
SIMT Online platform, NES Strategy documents
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 2.4. Number of NES implementation management trainings
completed: 1
Number of participants to NES implementation management
trainings: 8
51
Number of female participants to NES Implementation Management
trainings: 2
Activity 2.6. Stakeholder and resource mobilization to position the NES within national development
priorities to support implementation
Title Stakeholder and resource mobilization to position the NES within
national development priorities to support implementation
Location Kabul, Geneva
Implementing partners ITC
Background/context ITC worked towards stimulating policy convergence and political cohesion around the NES with the overall objective of securing institutional support and political consideration towards NES implementation.
The majority of international development partners already acknowledged that the NES provides them with the proper implementation plan and framework as well as favourable conditions for operation (i.e. political endorsement, private sector buy-in and improved collaboration with national institutions and IOs).
Next step consists in capitalizing on the significant momentum gained as part of the NES design process and leveraging it for a smooth and efficient implementation.
Results ITC endeavoured to position the NES within the policy framework of the country. ITC provided support through coordination (bilateral consultations, regular exchanges with relevant national institutions) and provision of insight and expertise to ensure NES’ alignment with key policies and planned initiatives (e.g. Industrial Park Proposal). As a result, relevant national plans, policies and initiatives refer to the strategy as one of their preferred tool for implementation. These include among others, the NPP on Private Sector, Development, the Agribusiness Charter and the Ministry of Mines and Petroleum’s strategy on marble.
Key international development partners were fully appraised and sensitized on all aspect of the NES design and implementation phases through a Donor Coordination Roundtable in June 2018, followed by bilateral meetings.
Development partners re-confirmed their interest to formalize/define a framework for the development community to coordinate and deliver its Aid for Trade to support NES implementation. Donors identified synergies and alignment with ongoing and planned initiatives and NES implementation.
ITC has also drafted project proposals and pitch books for key activities, which are derived from the NES’ findings and PoAs with the objective of contributing to their implementation through resource mobilization.
Stakeholder/participant
information
Donor stakeholder meeting – attendees: 20High-level participants from USAID, EU, SIDA, DFID, German Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development (BMZ), GIZ, among others.
52
4.3 OUTPUT 3: Priority interventions identified during the NES design process are implemented to improve regional integration and international trade competitiveness
During the first reporting period, in parallel to the design of the cross functional quality management under the
NES, training and initial capacity building activities were kicked off. These activities focused mainly on
sensitisation on TBT and SPS Agreements; preparation of training on standardization and technical
regulations; ANSA’s AAT priority work plan was approved and procedures related to standards and technical
regulations were drafted.
In the second year focus was on implementing selected priority activities identified with stakeholders: priorities
were extracted from ANSA work plan and priorities “1” from the NES Quality Cross functional strategy agreed
during the ongoing consultations with stakeholders.
In short, the following activities were undertaken under the first year of the project.
2-day workshop on WTO TBT and SPS Agreements
ANSA Priority Plan
2-day workshop on Code of Good Practices for standards development, adoption, and promotion
1-day workshop on development of Technical Regulations
Half-day Awareness Workshop On Standardization
The following details progress under the second year.
Activity
Date/Location Main Achievements Contributing to Indictor
Under Output 3. Priority interventions identified during the National Export Strategy design process
are implemented to improve regional integration and international trade competitiveness
Under Act. 3.2 Advisory services to ANSA to develop services (standards, certification, training
center) and other Ministries and TSIs to implement priorities in the quality and SPS Area
Training workshop
on code of good
practices for
development,
adoption, and
promotion of
standards and
related manual
4-5 July 2017
ANSA, Kabul
Increased awareness on
the code of good practice
for preparation, adoption
and implementation of
standards, as well as on
the work of the technical
committees.
Knowledge gained on the
development of national
standards and building a
roadmap for the next
steps.
Enhanced collaboration
with ISO.
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of
trainings delivered to
identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions: 1
53
Training workshop
on development of
technical regulations
and related
procedures
8 July 2017
ANSA, Kabul
Increased awareness on
procedures for
development of technical
regulations as a tool to
improve the practicability
of technical regulations to
ensure safety of goods
and services.
Increased knowledge on
TBT and SPS agreements
and their implementation.
Review / adaption of draft
procedure for
development of technical
regulations
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of
trainings delivered to
identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions: 1
Awareness
workshop on role
and importance of
standardization
9 July 2017
ANSA, Kabul
Increased awareness on:
The role and
importance of
standards, and
standard development
process;
Capacity needed to
meet standards and
requirements for ANSA
to develop a sound
quality infrastructure
Advised ANSA to use and
customise the training
materials for other
sensitisation workshops
(e.g. 5th national
conference on saffron)
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of
trainings delivered to
identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions: 1
Contribution to the
5th National
conference on
saffron; market
information and
identification of
buyer’s linkages
6 November 2017
Conference call at
the national
conference:
Geneva/Milan/Kabul
11 January 2018
and 15 February
2018, Milan
November - June
2018
Awareness built on
buyers’ saffron
requirements, on
possibility for
collaboration with Italian
lead company and on
saffron international and
national requirements at
the 5th national
conference on saffron
Ongoing discussion on
market linkages
3 sessions of the booklet
on requirements
completed
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of
trainings delivered to
identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions: 1
Training workshop
on Development of
technical regulations
19 December, 2017,
Kabul
Participants improved
their understanding on
good regulatory practices.
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of
trainings delivered to
identified institutions: 1
54
Draft procedure for
development of technical
regulations was enhanced
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions: 1
Working Document -
National Quality
Policy of Afghanistan
February – April
2018
Kabul, Afghanistan
A working document on
the National Quality Policy
is developed and shared
with National Consultant
for fine-tuning prior to
further dissemination to
stakeholders for
comments.
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions
Webinar on
Strengthening the
Standardization
service of ANSA -
ISOlutions
12 March 2018,
Online
(Geneva/Kabul)
Improved knowledge on
the design and provision
of solutions and training
on ISOlution that fits
Afghanistan needs.
Follow up ongoing with
ISO and ANSA to
facilitate access to
ISOlutions.
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of
trainings delivered to
identified institutions:1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions: 1
Three-week training
on mass, volume,
length and
calibration of
metrology for ANSA
laboratory
technicians
01 – 18 May 2018
New Delhi (India)
Knowledge and practical
exposure for three lab
technicians was acquired
enabling them to 1)
operationalize metrology
laboratory equipment, and
2) develop a road map for
improvement and
implementation.
Collaboration with the
National Physical
Laboratory of India (NPLI)
fostered.
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of
trainings delivered to
identified institutions: 1
Concept note on
training programmes
to strengthen
National Notification
Authority (NNA) and
National Enquiry
Points (NEP) on
Technical Barriers to
Trade (TBT) and
Sanitary and
Phytosanitary
Measures (SPS) and
first video training
session
8 May 2018
Online
(Geneva/Kabul)
Concept note on training
programme for
strengthening the NNA
and NEPs developed for a
series of 4 video training
sessions and coaching
programmes in
collaboration with WTO
TBT and SPS Secretariat.
4 questionnaires
developed and shared as
baseline of the NNA and
NEPs and analysis of
resultants compiled
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions: 1
55
Under Act. 3.2 Advisory services to ANSA to develop services (standards, certification, and training
centre) and other Ministries and TSIs to implement priorities in the quality and SPS Area
Title Training Workshop on Code of Good Practices for Development,
Adoption, and Promotion of Standards and related Manual
Date 4 – 5 July 2017
Location ANSA premises, Kabul, Afghanistan
Implementing
partners
ITC, ANSA, MoIC
Background/context The workshop is part of a series of workshops organised by ITC with ANSA and MoIC to address key priorities identified by stakeholders in the NES with the objective to strengthen the capacity to develop standards and technical regulations in accordance to WTO agreements.
This first workshop focussed on the principles of standard development and adoption of international standards, as well as the new drafted procedures for standard development, adoption and promotion.
ANSA has already adopted the Code of Good Practice for Preparation, Adoption and Implementation of Standards/ Annex 3 of WTO Agreement on TBT. However, the existing Procedure for Establishment and Operation of Technical Committee does not meet the requirements for the implementation of the code of good practice.
In relation to the above-mentioned, a workshop on July 4 – 5 2017 was implemented by ITC on the following topics: principles of WTO Agreements on TBT and SPS, Code of good practice for preparation, adoption and implementation of standards and on the review of the draft procedure.
1st video session initiated
jointly with WTO but not
completed due to internet
problems
Concept note on
strengthening the
food safety and food
control with training
programmes
designed in India
May 2018
Concept note developed
to sensitise stakeholders
on mechanism of food
control authorities in
different countries. In
collaboration with the
Food Safety Standards
Authority of India (FSSAI)
training agenda
developed for 8Afghan
high level officials on food
control and validation of
selection process of
participants ongoing
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of
advisory services provided
to implement the identified
priority interventions: 1
56
Results Increased awareness on the code of good practice for preparation, adoption and implementation of standards, as well as the work of the technical committees. The participants also gained knowledge on the development of national standards and building a roadmap for the next steps and the collaboration with ISO.
The draft Procedure for Development and Promotion of Standards was reviewed and amended. ANSA confirmed to follow up on its adoption to streamline the standard development activities, adoption of international standards and promotion of standards. The Procedure for Development and Promotion of Standards was developed based on the principles set out in ISO Directive 21 – Part 1 and 2 as well as the WTO TBT/Annex 3 – Code of Good Practice for Preparation, Adoption and Implementation of Standards.
The participant discussed the challenges in development and implementation of standards in Afghanistan, the need for capacity building and different approaches to be adopted by ANSA in order to ensure access to standards.
Stakeholder
/participant
information
46 participants from ANSA and other Ministries and private sector.
Participant evaluation Overall, the workshop was assessed as ‘Excellent’ by the participants which helped them to improve their understanding of the best practices.
Supporting
documents
Report on workshop, including agenda, presentations achievements and
participants’ evaluation. Revised draft manual.
Contribution towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of advisory services provided to implement the
identified priority interventions: 1
Title Training workshop on development of technical regulations and related
procedures
Date 08 July 2017
Location ANSA premises, Kabul, Afghanistan
Implementing
partners
ITC, ANSA, MoIC
Background/context The workshop is part of a series of workshops organised by ITC with ANSA and MoIC to address key priorities identified by stakeholders in the NES with the
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18
overall Quality of Workshop
Content of the Workshop
Time for and Content of Discussion
Relevance of Workshop for your work
Facilities and Logistics
Presenters' command of the subject
Participants' Evaluation
5 4 3 2 1
57
objective to strengthen the capacity to develop standards and technical regulations in accordance to WTO Agreements.
The 2nd workshop, facilitated by ITC Senior Adviser and ITC Adviser on Quality and by an ITC National Consultant on quality, was conducted on 08 July 2017 on procedure for development of technical regulations, aiming to provide an introduction to the latter.
Technical Regulation is a document, which lays down product characteristics or their related processes and production methods, including the applicable administrative provisions, with which compliance is mandatory. WTO Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade sets out the principles for development of technical regulations. In terms of the Post-Accession Strategy adopted by the government of Afghanistan, ANSA is responsible for coordination of the implementation of WTO TBT agreement. Currently, there is no procedure on how to develop technical regulations in order to comply with the requirements of TBT agreement.
In order to assist in that, ITC drafted a procedure for development of technical regulations. The document was prepared based on the principles of WTO TBT agreement and those of the Standardization Law of Afghanistan.
Results During the workshop the crucial need for coordination among regulatory bodies in order to ensure efficiency of the technical regulations, reducing barriers to trade and providing facilitation for cross-border trade was discussed.
The emphasis was on the facilitating role of the procedures for development of technical regulations as a tool to improve the practicability of technical regulations to ensure safety of goods and services.
In addition, the participant discussed the challenges in development and enforcement of technical regulations in Afghanistan, the needs for capacity building, and need to replicate the workshop in order to cover more regulatory bodies and get a common viewpoint on the document.
The draft Procedure was commented in details and finetuned. It was agreed to conduct a 2nd workshop to be held at MoIC with more regulatory bodies representative.
Stakeholder
/participant
information
42 participants from ANSA and other relevant ministries and private sector
representatives
Participant evaluation Overall the workshop was evaluated as ‘very good and useful’ by the
participants which helped them to learn the main principles of the agreement on
technical barriers to trade requirements for development of technical
regulations.
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
overall Quality of Workshop
Content of the Workshop
Time for and Content of Discussion
Relevance of Workshop for your work
Facilities and Logistics
Presenters' command of the subject
Participants' Evaluation
5 4 3 2 1
58
Supporting
documents
Report on workshop, including agenda, presentations achievements and
participants’ evaluation. Revised draft manual.
Contribution towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of advisory services provided to implement the
identified priority interventions: 1
Title Awareness workshop on role and importance of standardization
Date 09 July 2017
Location ANSA premises, Kabul, Afghanistan
Implementing
partners
ITC, ANSA, MoIC
Background/context The workshop is part of a series of workshops organised by ITC with ANSA and MoIC to address key priorities identified by stakeholders in the NES with the objective to strengthen the capacity to develop standards and technical regulations in accordance to WTO Agreements. The third event was a half-day awareness workshop was on role and importance of standardization for the private sector. The workshop was facilitated by ITC and ANSA representatives.
It has been observed that awareness of the role and importance of standards is limited among the public and private sector in Afghanistan. The majority of Afghan businesses have limited knowledge of international standards and existing standard development activities at ANSA. This effects the capacity for compliance with standards and Afghan goods and services being able to compete in regional and international markets.
Results A detailed presentation on standard development at national level, international standards and developing countries, international standardization bodies and their principles, standards and policy and standards and sustainable development was delivered. Participants learnt practical and real-life examples of the role of standardization.
In addition, a presentation by ANSA on development and promotion of national standards and participation of ANSA in regional and international standardization efforts was provided.
Participants were made aware of: 1) access, capacity of meeting standards and requirements for ANSA to play an active role in developing a sound quality infrastructure in the country, and; 2) ANSA standards available in the area of Saffron.
ANSA was advised to use and customise the presentations in other awareness events, such as the 5th national conference on saffron.
Stakeholder
/participant
information
79 participants from various public and private organisations, including:
ACCI, ANSA, ASIA, CRIDA, MAIL, MOIC, MOPW, MRRD, NEPA, UPK
Participant evaluation The feedback received from the participants following the workshop was very
positive. Some participants confirmed they were not aware of national
standards adopted by ANSA.
As per one participant anecdotal feedback: “The Afghanistan Stone Industrial
Association (ASIA) wants to take an effective step on Standardization of
Industry, especially on stone sector. So, we thank you for making this effective
59
step on standardization of products and especially on industry. We hope ASIA
to be a permanent assistant in your side.”
Supporting
documents
Report on workshop including the agenda, participants list, presentations.
Contribution towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of advisory services provided to implement the
identified priority interventions: 1
Title 5th National conference on saffron, market information on saffron and
identification of buyer’s linkages
Date 6 November 2017 (national conference – Kabul and via video conference);
11 January, 15 February 2018 – meetings with buyer and technical service
providers;
Ongoing interactions until June 2018.
Location Kabul, Milan, Geneva (in-person meetings and via video-conference)
Implementing partners MAIL, ANSA, ITC
Background/context Saffron is a priority sector of the NES, with one key priority to improve its
competiveness being to sensitise Afghan producers on international buyers’
requirements and to activate market linkages. Italy is a key target market for
saffron from Afghanistan. Interactions have been initiated with a lead Italian
company of saffron and with specialised technical institutes (University of
Milan) to develop long term collaboration. Within this framework ITC
contributed to ensuring at the national conference on saffron:
- Inclusion of a technical session on national standards delivered by ANSA,
including development of materials.
- Video conference session with the Italian company and ITC team on
buyer’s requirements.
Post-event a number of follow-up activities were undertaken, including:
- Activities to identify potential suppliers to be engaged with the lead
company, the model to apply their quality protocol and the service providers
to support with quality compliance.
- A booklet and database on saffron mandatory, voluntary and buyer’s
requirements in India, China, EU is under development and will be widely
distributed upon completion.
Results More than 200 stakeholders in the saffron sector sensitised by ANSA on
saffron international requirements and services offered; on the requirements of
an Italian lead company and possibility for collaboration as potential buyer.
Proposal for collaboration and services to characterise the quality of saffron
and commercial opportunities drafted through various meetings with University
of Milan and Italian company.
Completed three sessions of the booklet on international requirements and
mandatory requirements related to SPS and TBT for China, India, EU plus
sensitisation guidance information on the different areas.
Stakeholder 200 stakeholders from public and private sectors
60
/participant
information
Participant evaluation Feedback from the participants at the fifth national conference was positive.
Two suppliers contacted directly the Italian lead company to explore supplying
opportunities.
Supporting documents
Agenda, presentations made at the fifth national conference.
Draft booklet of saffron requirements.
Drat proposal for collaboration.
Contribution towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of advisory services provided to implement the
identified priority interventions: 1
Title Training workshop on development of technical regulations and related
procedure
Date 19 December 2017
Location MoIC, Kabul, Afghanistan
Implementing
partners
ITC, MoIC, ANSA
Background/context On 8 July 2017 ITC conducted in Kabul a one-day workshop on “Development of Technical Regulations - TRs)” jointly with ANSA with the objective to: 1) sensitise Regulatory Bodies on Good Regulatory Practices; 2) consult with stakeholders on the guidelines/procedure for developing TRs. The workshop reviewed the draft procedure for the development of TRs and comments on the procedure were collected.
Given the broad spectrum of regulatory bodies involved in the development of TRs in Afghanistan and the need to sensitise and engage them in the process, the participants recommended MoIC to host a second one-day workshop on “Procedure for Development of Technical Regulations (TRs)”. In turn MoIC requested ITC to implement this workshop.
Results The workshop achieved the following objectives:
1) Sensitisation of Afghan regulatory bodies on good regulatory practices;
2) Stakeholders consulted and input obtained to inform revision of draft procedure for developing TRs.
In further detail:
Senior officers of all regulatory bodies in Afghanistan, ANSA standardization officers and experts, consumer protection, private sector representatives improved their understanding on good regulatory practices and have commented on the draft procedure for developing TRs. This would lead to a procedure being developed in consultation with all interested parties and being relevant and applicable to the context and needs of the country. The procedure on TRs was further improved and submitted for adoption.
A comprehensive and practical procedure for development of TRs was prepared by ITC and reviewed, commented by participants clause by clause. The document further detailed the TRs drafting, the need for risk assessment, coordination mechanism among the regulatory bodies and compliance with the principles of WTO TBT agreement. The procedure is to be submitted to high level committees for standards for approval by ANSA.
Stakeholder
/participant
information
42 participants, from various organizations such as ANSA standardization
officers and experts, consumer protection and private sector representatives,
as the following: ANSA, ACCI, MoPW, MoPH, NEPA.
61
Participant evaluation Positive evaluation from the side of the participants on the training and on the
manual.
Supporting
documents
List of participants; agenda; procedure for development of TRs.
Contribution towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of advisory services provided to implement the
identified priority interventions: 1
Title Webinar on strengthening the standardization service of ANSA
Date 12 March 2018
Location Online (web-based)
Implementing partners ISO, ITC and ANSA
Background/context In order to enhance the capacity of ANSA and the delivery of standardization services, ITC facilitates collaboration between the International Organisation for Standardization (ISO) and ANSA for the design and provision of solutions and training on ISOlution that fits Afghanistan needs.
Accordingly a webinar (1.5 hours in length) was held for ISO, and ANSA representatives, where the ISOlutions standards development processes were explained with details on each step to better guide the participants and identify next steps.
Results Increased knowledge on ISOlutions standards development processes.
ANSA clarified pertinent questions / raised questions - Including the lack of feature to support the right to left writing; ANSA shall assess the implications during the trial.
The ISOlution may assist ANSA to overcome challenges related to physical participation to meetings.
NSB template was filled in by ANSA following the webinar, trial initiated to assess the suitability of the ISOlutions.
Stakeholder
/participant information
12 participants (including 2 women) from ANSA attended the webinar.
Participant evaluation Participants acknowledged that this is a helpful training to better understand
the requirements and the next steps to be followed.
Supporting documents
Training report
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions: 1
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of advisory services provided to implement the
identified priority interventions:1
Title Working document –National Quality Policy of Afghanistan
Date February 2018 – Ongoing
62
Location Remote
Implementing partners ITC, ANSA
Background/context One of the priority actions identified in the NES is the development and endorsement of a National Quality Policy (NPQ). ITC initiated the process by developing the working document of the NPQ to be further circulated for comments.
Results As a result of this activity, a draft working document on the NPQ has been developed and will be further circulated for comments and review of ANSA, MoIC, MoPH, MAIL, ministries responsible for environment protection, labour, ACCI, consumer association, and other key stakeholders.
It is planned to conduct a one-day workshop to gather all the comments and continue the work on it. Once the comments are incorporated, a validation workshop will be held.
Stakeholder
/participant information
ITC, ANSA and other relevant stakeholders
Supporting documents
Draft National Quality Policy of Afghanistan
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 3.4: Number of advisory services provided to implement the
identified priority interventions: 1
Title Three-week training on mass, volume, length and calibration of
metrology for ANSA laboratory technicians
Date 01 – 18 May 2018
Location New Delhi, India
Implementing partners ITC, ANSA, National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in India
Background/context In order to enhance the capacity of ANSA and improvement of their services, ITC organized through NPL a three-week training for laboratory officials from the ANSA metrology team. Three technicians were selected based on their role, experience and educational background and underwent the training held in the NPL premises in New Delhi.
Off-site advisory service is provided by ITC Advisers to guide on the
application of the learning by ANSA participants to operationalise their labs.
Results As a result of the training, knowledge and practical exposure was acquired enabling ANSA to initiate the process to operationalize the equipment in their metrology lab and develop a road map for improvement and implementation.
In addition, collaboration with NPLI was built fostering future partnership opportunities.
A short film, participant interviews, and feature articicle was produced to sensitise on metrology and the impact of the training.
Stakeholder
/participant information
Three technicians underwent for the training, in include the General manager of metrology labs; Technician of mass’s lab, and; Technician of length’s lab.
Participant evaluation Participants acknowledged that this is a helpful training to be applied in their
Kabul based laboratories. In addition, a request for a training on the legal
metrology was received and under consideration by ITC.
Supporting documents
Report on the training; certificate of completion.
63
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 3.3: Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions: 1
Title Concept note on training programmes to strengthen NNA and TBT and
SPS NEP and 1st video training
Date 8 May 2018
Location Online (Geneva/Kabul)
Implementing partners ITC, MOIC
Background/context The NES cross-functional strategy on Quality and SPS identifies the need to strengthen the Quality and SPS technical infrastructure as a priority to facilitate trade. One of the key priorities identified by stakeholders and as per the WTO post accession commitments is to strengthen and operationalise the TBT and SPS National Enquiry Points (NEPs) and the National Notification Authority (NNA). MoIC has a dedicated WTO focal point whose role is to coordinate the efforts of the different agencies responsible for reaching a satisfactory level of compliance to the requirements of the TBT and SPS Agreements. At present, ANSA operates the WTO TBT NEP, while the General Directorate of Planning and Program Coordination of MAIL is mandated for the SPS NEP. Furthermore, the designation of single central government authority responsible for the implementation at national level of certain provisions concerning notification procedures – a National Notification Authority (NNA) - is also required. Within the above context, ITC provides technical assistance to strengthening the NEP and NNA as one of the NES priorities. ITC’s proposed interventions envisage training and capacity building activities delivered in collaboration with WTO TBT and SPS Secretariats and other partners. Canada is consulted as partner. In order to enhance the capacity of the National Enquiry Points (NEP) and the National Notification Authorities (NNA) on TBT and SPS, a concept note for the development of the capacity building activities had been formulated, questionnaire to assess baselines and series of video training sessions planned.
Results As a result of of this activity, a concept note was presented to stakeholders. It sets 4 steps in the capacity development projects, as the following:
1. Baseline assessment - a questionnaire has been developed by ITC to
assess the capacity of the NNA and NEP. In total four questionnaires
were sent and filled in by the respective focal points and results analysed
with the NEP and NNA for needs assessment.
2. Video training sessions - a series of training activities were planned in
partnership with the WTO to provide in-depth knowledge on the
agreements and the different tools. The first one was organized on 07
May online, more than 25 participants in Kabul joined the session. Due to
internet connection problems faced at MOIC, the training was
interrepputed and had to be rescheduled. Alternative video facilities are
being identified.
3. Follow up activities - to ensure practical application on the issues related
to the NNA and NEP roles and responsibilities. Two assgnments were
circulated to the selected stakeholders
64
4. Twinning module - a training attachment of selected staff in charge of
NEP TBT and SPS is proposed to be done in a foreign country where the
NNA and NEP have fully functional organizational system in place.
Discussion is in place with Canada as hosting country to host the training
in August 2018. This will also build a long-term cooperation between the
partnering countries and ensure information and practical exchange.
5. Joint collaboration with WTO Secretariats is instrumental to further
engage Afghanistan in WTO post accession committments.
The activities are planned to take place between June - December 2018.
Stakeholder
/participant information
MOIC, ANSA, MAIL and other relevant stakeholders involved in SPS and TBT matters. More than 25 participants attended the 1st video session – that had to be interrupted.
Participant evaluation Participants confirmed the value of the programme and content. Dissatisfaction was raised related to the poor internet connectivity and the challenges to host video conferences. Alternative means and facilities are to be identified (i.e. training abroad, reliable video conference facilities) to further engage WTO Secretariats since delegates cannot travel for security reasons to Kabul.
Supporting documents
The Concept Note Technical Assistance Activities to
Strengthen TBT and SPS National Enquiry Points (NEPs) and the National Notification Authority (NNA) document; 4 Questionnaires with related analysis; programme of the 4 sessions, presentations and assignments for the 1st and 2nd sessions.
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
Number of trainings delivered to identified institutions – 1
Number of advisory services provided to implement the identified
priority interventions - 1
Title Concept note on strengthening the food safety and food control with
training programmes designed in India
Date May 2018
Location Geneva/Kabul
Implementing partners ITC, MOIC, MAIL, MOPH and ANSA
Background/context The NES quality function details the deficiencies of the SPS framework, including the weak status of various institutions that significantly reduce the potential synergy that could bring to improving export competitiveness, trade facilitation and consumer protection. To further collaborate and coordinate among the institutions, stakeholders identified the NES priority action is to establish a National Food Safety Authority. Currently the national food control system is carried out through MAIL - for fresh agricultural products and partially processed products, while MOPH controls processed foods. This leads to overlap on the roles and responsibilities and confusion, thus a need for efficient coordination as priority remains. During the last meeting of The Executive Committee on Private Sector Development (PriSEC), held late March, 2018, on the discussion related to the way forward on the development of the SPS capacity in the country, PriSEC flagged the need to expedite the process on the establishment of a National Food Safety Authority. They mentioned the following: “The proposal here is to establish a Food Safety Authority (similar to Food and Drug Administration in the US), which is urgently needed and extremely important for the increasing export” potential of Afghanistan”. In addition, it was also mentioned “The first step should be for technical representatives
65
from MOIC, MAIL, MOPH and ANSA to meet and agree on the outline of the framework.” This meeting will be followed by decisions on the next steps, where “ITC will provide the necessary support”. The dialogue held among the members of PriSEC’s further confirmed the urgency of providing technical assistance in the support of the establishment of National Food Safety Authority. ITC obtained clearance from government of India to organise with the Food Safety Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) a 2-week training for 8 high-level officials drawn from Afghan safety authorities on Indian and international practices. The selection process of participants was initiated at national level. ITC was requested by representative of PriSEC to hold the training and provide a concept note indicating different models of authorities. Subsequently, the Government of India endorsed the request to host two week training for 8 officials.
Results High attention raised on the need to streghten the food safety control system and engagement by stakeholders to collaborate.
High ranking officials from MAIL, MoPH, ANSA, MoIC expressed interest and support to the FSSAI programme and gave extended feedback and requests.
Concept Note on the Establishment of National Food Safety Authority has been developed. It underlines the current problems in the country and the different mechanisms put in place by other authorities as per FAO guidelines. The next steps in the proposal are: Establishment of a Task Force (Working Group on National Food Safety Authority), Experience sharing with oher countries, Training attachment in India, assistance by an expert on development of a road may and identification of model of the National Food Control Systems. Concept note under circulation at national level. The timeline for this activity is May – September 2018.
One MoPH high level representative selected to attend WTO workshop on inspection and controls in Geneva by the SPS Secretariat in July 2018.
Stakeholder
/participant information
ITC, ANSA, MAIL, MoPH, MoIC.
Participant evaluation Pending feedback from stakeholders
Supporting documents
Concept Note on Establishment of National Food Safety Authority; training
programme at FSSAI; endorsement of the Government of India to host the
programme.
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievement
Number of advisory services provided to implement the identified
priority interventions - 1
66
4.4 OUTPUT 4: Knowledge sharing mechanisms for GIRoA staff on trade policy/negotiation formulation and implementation are established in partnership with a training institute from the Region
During the first reporting period, a partnership arrangement between MoIC, CWS, ITC was completed at the
outset. It was agreed that CWS would deliver “Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme” over
an approximately two-year period commencing in April 2017 and end not later than 30 June 2019. The
programme was aimed at building the capacity of MoIC and other trade-related ministries and implementing
agencies/government officers. CWS and MoIC will work together so as to ensure local ownership for the
training programme is built so that it can be implemented locally following the involvement of CWS.
In order to formalise the partnership arrangement officials from both MoIC, CWS and ITC met on 31 March,
2017, New Delhi, India. At the meeting, officials were able to agree upon the modalities of work between the
three organisations and the work plan.
It was agreed that the programme will cover, amongst other things, trade analysis, trade diplomacy, trade
litigation and professional monitoring of compliance and effects of trade agreements. In-class training will be
followed up by an “on the job” coaching providing targeted support to the participating officers. By the end of
the programme, participants will be expected to have enhanced their understanding of the professional skills
in these areas.
As a first activity, a need assessment was initiated of the current level of technical capacities of the country’s
officers in responding to multilateral, regional and bilateral obligations stemming from WTO and other trade
agreements. In addition, gaps were identified in the skills of officers and institutions in formulating, coordinating
and implementing trade policy/regulatory reforms and preparing for and conducting trade negotiations. The
results of the need assessment would further inform the training curriculum developed under the programme.
In short, the following activities were undertaken under the first year of the project.
Overall: Afghanistan’s MoIC partners with Indian CWS
Needs assessment for Trade Policy and Trade Negotiations Training and Certification for Government
Officials in Afghanistan
The following details progress under the second year.
Activity Date/location Main Achievements Contributing to indicator
Activity 4.2: Governmental officers training programme is designed and implemented
Introductory Training
(As part of
Afghanistan, WTO
and International
Trade Programme)
9 – 13 Oct,
2017, Delhi,
India
20 stakeholders built
knowledge on the key
concepts of the WTO and
its agreement (all passing
text)
Participants exposed to
teachings of leading
international institute.
SUB-IND: 4.3: Number of
Afghan participants
successfully passing trainers'
assessment: 20
SUB-IND: 4.4: Number of
Afghan participants (women)
successfully passing trainers'
assessment: 3
67
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of
meetings: 1
First Advanced
Training (As part of
Afghanistan, WTO
and International
Trade Programme)
8-12. Jan,
2018, Delhi,
India
19 stakeholders built
knowledge in advanced
trade policy matters (all
passing text)
Participants exposed to
teachings of leading
international institute.
SUB-IND: 4.3: Number of
Afghan participants
successfully passing trainers'
assessment: 19
SUB-IND: 4.4: Number of
Afghan participants (women)
successfully passing trainers'
assessment: 3
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of
meetings: 1
Second Advanced
Training (As part of
Afghanistan, WTO
and International
Trade Programme)
5 - 9 Feb, 2018,
Delhi, India
19 stakeholders built
knowledge in advanced
trade policy matters (all
passing text)
Participants exposed to
teachings of leading
international institute.
SUB-IND: 4.3: Number of
Afghan participants
successfully passing trainers'
assessment: 19
SUB-IND: 4.4: Number of
Afghan participants (women)
successfully passing trainers'
assessment: 2
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of
meetings: 1
Third Advanced
Training (As part of
Afghanistan, WTO
and International
Trade Programme)
9-13 April
2018, Delhi,
India
17 stakeholders built
knowledge in advanced
trade policy matters (all
passing text)
Participants exposed to
teachings of leading
international institute.
SUB-IND: 4.3: Number of
Afghan participants
successfully passing trainers'
assessment: 17
SUB-IND: 4.4: Number of
Afghan participants (women)
successfully passing trainers'
assessment: 2
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of
meetings: 1
Study Tour (As part
of Afghanistan, WTO
and International
Trade Programme)
16-20 April
2018, Delhi.
India
Participants learnt the
Indian practice of trade
policy formulation,
implementation, trade
negotiations and trade
promotion in India, by
visiting nine key Ministries/
organisations involved in
these areas.
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of
meetings: 1
68
Advisory services
(As part of
Afghanistan, WTO
and International
Trade Programme)
Ongoing
Mechanism for attending
to request from
participants established
through Trade Policy
Hotline;
Technical support
provided on range on trade
policy matters.
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of
meetings: 1
Internship
programme (As part
of Afghanistan, WTO
and International
Trade Programme
6 - 28 August
2018, Delhi.
India
Two best performing
participants were identified
following regular
assessments by CWS
Programme for interns
designed by CWS and
agreed by MoIC
(programme will occur
between 6-31 August
2018).
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of
meetings
SUB-IND: 4.3: Number of
Afghan participants
successfully passing trainers'
assessment
Activity 4.3: Training modules on trade policy are developed in cooperation with Afghan Universities
Mentorship (As part
of Afghanistan, WTO
and International
Trade Programme)
Ongoing
Both Kabul University and
APPRO have built their
knowledge of curriculum
that would best inform a
home-grown curriculum on
trade policies and
international trade;
Kabul University has
developed the structure
and accompanying
curriculum for a course
"Afghanistan, WTO and
International Trade"
Number of trainers and/or
regional resource persons
trained : 2
SUB-IND: 4.2: Number of
training modules/material
produced
Development of
training material (As
part of Afghanistan,
WTO and
International Trade
Programme)
Ongoing
Full set of learning
materials have been
provided to MoIC/further
stakeholders for long-term
usage.
Participants were
provided tailor-made
training material/readings
at the beginning of the
course to cover the entire
SUB-IND: 4.2: Number of
training modules/material
produced: 10
69
Title Introductory Training
Date/Location 9 – 13 October 2017, Delhi, India,
Implementing partners CWS (India based); MoIC; ITC
Background/context The initiative is aimed at building Afghan capacity (MoIC) in the area of trade
policy formulation and implementation (with a particular focus on WTO
agreements and their implementation, including in the Afghan context). The
programme, is being implemented in partnership with the Delhi based Centre
for WTO studies (CWS) under the overall guidance on ITC.
This was the first training of the programme, with 20 Afghan participants
attending. It was inaugurated by Ms. Kamila Sidiqi, the Deputy Minister of
Commerce and Industry, Government of Afghanistan. Ms. Rita Teaotia,
Commerce Secretary, Government of India also graced the occasion.
Results As an introductory course, 20 stakeholders were familiarised on the following
topics:
Key concepts of the WTO and its agreements; Types of data, and sources
of data, relevant for international trade; Economic rationale for international
trade, introduction to WTO and FTAs; Afghanistan in world trade; Basic
provisions of GATT; Agreement on Agriculture and understanding country-
level schedules, trade remedies, policy flexibilities under Agreement on
Subsidies and Countervailing Measures; Standards and SPS-TBT
agreements; GATS and understanding services schedule of commitments;
Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights and
flexibilities thereunder; Trade litigation and WTO's Dispute Settlement;
Understanding and role of research and stakeholder consultations in trade
policy making.
Participants were regularly tested throughout the training and overall all (20)
received a past mark.
Stakeholder/ participant
information
20 participants – drawn from MOIC, Administrative Office of the President,
Kabul University, ACCI, APPRO.
3 women participants.
Supporting documents
Training report; course materials; press release.
programme / better inform
their learning.
70
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievements
SUB-IND 4.3: Number of Afghan participants successfully passing
trainers' assessment: 20
SUB-IND 4.4: Number of Afghan participants (women) successfully
passing trainers' assessment: 2
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of meetings: 1
Title First Advanced Training
Date/Location 8-12 January 2018, Delhi, India
Implementing partners CWS (India based); MoIC; ITC
Background/ context The initiative is aimed at building Afghan capacity (MoIC) in the area of
trade policy formulation and implementation (with a particular focus on
WTO agreements and their implementation, including in the Afghan
context). The programme, is being implemented in partnership with the
Delhi based Centre for WTO studies (CWS) under the overall guidance on
ITC.
This second training followed a prior introductory training held between 9 –
13 October 2017.
Results 19 participants were familiarized on the following topics:
- Introduction to basics of trade data- Trade Classification Systems, such
as HS, ISIC, SITC and BEC; Detailed discussion of the Harmonised
System of Nomenclature; WTO tariff profile and Multilateral Trade
Negotiation (MTN) Product categorisation; and basic excel exercises
on “Vlookup” function and generation of “Pivot” tables.
- World Integrated Trade Solutions (WITS) and analysis of trade data of
Afghanistan- generating WITS Query; basic grouping tasks in WITS
query; query on MFN tariffs, mapping tariffs with HS codes; and linking
trade data with MFN tariff data.
- Practical exercise on trade data analysis- creating product and country
grouping; creation of SAARC group and assessment of the trade with
world; exercise on working with mirror data in WITS; exercise on
direction of trade; exercise on trade indicators and tariff schedules; and
exercise on Bound Rate, Applied Rate and tariff overhang.
- Market access and trade composition- composition of Afghanistan's
exports and imports (using mirror data) for MTN product group; and
direction of trade.
- Market access and trade indicators - identifying MTN category of low
share but high growth; and demonstration of calculation on trade
balance, unit value and revealed comparative advantage (RCA); and
Afghanistan’s WTO tariff commitments and FTA.
71
- WTO Agreement on Agriculture - why study AoA; importance of AoA
for Afghanistan; 3 pillars of AoA; Afghanistan's Tariff Schedule.
- Domestic support (DS) - Green box, Amber box and other components
of DS; Afghanistan's commitments on DS; DS notification template; DS
notification of Afghanistan; analysis of some DS programmes;
discussion of WTO’s Committee on Agriculture (CoA) and responding
to questions in CoA.
- Export Competition – theoretical consideration on export subsidies;
flexibility as an LDC; and Afghanistan’s Schedule on export subsidies.
- Brief discussion of Doha negotiations.
- Practical Exercises on Agreement on Agriculture – notifications; WTO
Tool kit; AG-IMS; compliance of notifications; questions and answer
raised in Committee on Agriculture (AG-IMS).
- Data Sources for Agriculture – FAOSTAT; USDA; GAIN reports; World
Bank; and Index Mundi.
- Review of key principles of GATT and practical exercise on key
principles of GATT.
Participants were regularly tested throughout the training and overall all (19)
received a past mark.
Stakeholder/ participant
information
19 – drawn from MOIC, Administrative Office of the President, Kabul
University, ACCI, APPRO
Supporting documents Training report; course materials; press release.
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievements
SUB-IND 4.3: Number of Afghan participants successfully passing
trainers' assessment: 19
SUB-IND: 4.4: Number of Afghan participants (women) successfully
passing trainers' assessment: 3
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of meetings: 1
Title Second Advanced Training
Location 5 - 9 February 2018, Delhi, India
Implementing partners CWS (India based); MOIC; ITC
Background/ context The initiative is aimed at building Afghan capacity (MoIC) in the area of
trade policy formulation and implementation (with a particular focus on
WTO agreements and their implementation, including in the Afghan
context). The programme, is being implemented in partnership with the
72
Delhi based Centre for WTO studies (CWS) under the overall guidance on
ITC.
This second training followed a prior introductory and first advanced
training.
Results 19 participants were familiarized on the following topics:
- Introduction to basics of trade data- Trade Classification Systems, such
as HS, ISIC, SITC and BEC; Detailed discussion of the Harmonised
System of Nomenclature; WTO tariff profile and Multilateral Trade
Negotiation (MTN) Product categorisation; and basic excel exercises
on “Vlookup” function and generation of “Pivot” tables.
- World Integrated Trade Solutions (WITS) and analysis of trade data of
Afghanistan- generating WITS Query; basic grouping tasks in WITS
query; query on MFN tariffs, mapping tariffs with HS codes; and linking
trade data with MFN tariff data.
- Practical exercise on trade data analysis- creating product and country
grouping; creation of SAARC group and assessment of the trade with
world; exercise on working with mirror data in WITS; exercise on
direction of trade; exercise on trade indicators and tariff schedules; and
exercise on Bound Rate, Applied Rate and tariff overhang.
- Market access and trade composition- composition of Afghanistan's
exports and imports (using mirror data) for MTN product group; and
direction of trade.
- Market access and trade indicators - identifying MTN category of low
share but high growth; and demonstration of calculation on trade
balance, unit value and revealed comparative advantage (RCA); and
Afghanistan’s WTO tariff commitments and FTA.
- WTO Agreement on Agriculture - why study AoA; importance of AoA
for Afghanistan; 3 pillars of AoA; Afghanistan's Tariff Schedule.
- Domestic support (DS) - Green box, Amber box and other components
of DS; Afghanistan's commitments on DS; DS notification template; DS
notification of Afghanistan; analysis of some DS programmes;
discussion of WTO’s Committee on Agriculture (CoA) and responding
to questions in CoA.
- Export Competition – theoretical consideration on export subsidies;
flexibility as an LDC; and Afghanistan’s Schedule on export subsidies.
- Brief discussion of Doha negotiations.
- Practical Exercises on Agreement on Agriculture – notifications; WTO
Tool kit; AG-IMS; compliance of notifications; questions and answer
raised in Committee on Agriculture (AG-IMS).
- Data Sources for Agriculture – FAOSTAT; USDA; GAIN reports; World
Bank; and Index Mundi.
- Review of key principles of GATT and practical exercise on key
principles of GATT.
73
Participants were regularly tested throughout the training and overall all (19)
received a past mark.
Stakeholder/ participant
information
19 – drawn from MoIC, Administrative Office of the President, Kabul
University, ACCI, APPRO
Supporting documents Training report; course materials; press release.
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievements
SUB-IND 4.3: Number of Afghan participants successfully passing
trainers' assessment: 19
SUB-IND 4.4: Number of Afghan participants (women) successfully
passing trainers' assessment: 3
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of meetings: 1
Title Third Advanced Training
Date / Location 9-13 April 2018, Delhi, India
Implementing partners CWS (India based); MoIC; ITC
Background/ context The initiative is aimed at building Afghan capacity (particularly the Ministry
of Industry and Commerce - MoIC) in the area of trade policy formulation
and implementation (with a particular focus on WTO agreements and their
implementation, including in the Afghan context). The programme, is being
implemented in partnership with the Delhi based Centre for WTO studies
(CWS) under the overall guidance on ITC.
This third training followed a prior introductory as well as first and second
advanced trainings.
Results 17 participants were familiarized on the following topics:
- Dispute Settlement Understanding: Detailed provisions; procedures
and case studies.
- Negotiating strategies: Definition; types; strategies used by different
countries and responses; preparing for negotiations and simulation
exercise.
- Policy flexibilities under WTO: Detailed provisions under GATT,
TRIMS, Subsidies Agreement and TRIPS Agreement; case studies.
- New issues at the WTO: Electronic commerce; Investment facilitation;
MSME; and Trade and gender.
- TRIPS Agreement: Detailed provisions; flexibilities; case studies;
TRIPS and public health; case studies on TRIPS and public health.
- Regulatory impact assessment: Theoretical approaches and practical
application.
74
- Recent developments in international trade: GATT article XXI and
resort by US to the security exception; counter-action by China; recent
disputes raised by the US and China against each other; and Section
301 of US Trade Act - provisions and past WTO jurisprudence.
- Revision of key provisions of WTO agreements.
Participants were regularly tested throughout the training and overall all (19)
received a past mark.
Stakeholder/ participant
information
17 participants – drawn from MOIC, Administrative Office of the President,
Kabul University, ACCI, APPRO
Supporting documents Training report; course materials.
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievements
SUB-IND: 4.3: Number of Afghan participants successfully passing
trainers' assessment: 17
SUB-IND: 4.4: Number of Afghan participants (women) successfully
passing trainers' assessment: 2
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of meetings: 1
Title Study Tour
Location 16-20 April, 2018, Delhi, India
Implementing partners CWS (India based); MOIC; ITC
Background/ context The initiative is aimed at building Afghan capacity (particularly the Ministry
of Industry and Commerce - MoIC) in the area of trade policy formulation
and implementation (with a particular focus on WTO agreements and their
implementation, including in the Afghan context). The programme, is being
implemented in partnership with the Delhi based Centre for WTO studies
(CWS) under the overall guidance of ITC.
During 16-20 April 2018, the participants from Afghanistan undertook a
study tour of key Ministries/ organisations involved in trade policy
formulation, implementation, trade negotiations and trade promotion in
India.
This study tour followed an introductory training and three advanced
trainings.
Results Participants leant the Indian practice of trade policy formulation,
implementation, trade negotiations and trade promotion in India, by visiting
nine key Ministries/ organisations involved in these areas.
Stakeholder/ participant
information
18 participants drawn from MoIC, Administrative Office of the President,
Kabul University, ACCI, APPRO
Supporting documents Training report; course materials.
75
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievements
SUB-IND 4.6: Number of meetings: 1
Title Internship programme
Implementing partners CWS
Background/context As part of the Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme, the
two best performing participants would intern for one month at the CWS. As
the CWS works closely with the Department of Commerce, Government of
India, this will also provide the 2 interns with considerable exposure to the
working of the Department of Commerce. This will assist the participants in
sharpening their on-the-job skills.
Results Two best performing participants were identified following regular
assessments by CWS.
Programme for interns designed by CWS and agreed by MoIC (programme
will occur between 6-31 August 2018).
Supporting documents
Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme: Report on First
Intake of Participants.
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievements
Number of trainers and/or regional resource persons trained
Number of meetings
Activity 4.3: Training modules on trade policy are developed in cooperation with Afghan Universities
Title Mentorship
Date/Location Ongoing / Delhi (In-person) and distance interactions
Implementing partners MoIC, ITC, CWS
Background/context As part of the partnership between MoIC and CWS a mentoring programme
would be implemented. CWS would work closely with the identified university
(ies)/institution(s) for developing curriculum on trade policies and
international trade. This would be done through a combination of in-person
interaction (as part of selected participant, one from each institution,
attending seven month “Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade
Programme” and distance interactions through emails and Skype. Every
attempt would be made to use examples from Afghanistan to explain key
concepts in the module.
Accordingly, CWS conducted a mentorship programme for the Kabul
University and the Afghanistan Public Policy Research Organization
76
(APPRO) – the two MoIC identified beneficiary institutions for this initiative.
The objective of the programme was to mentor the two organizations in
developing a structured course on trade policy for officials and other
stakeholders in Afghanistan as a contribution to a sustainable transfer of
knowledge on WTO issues.
As CWS has worked closely with both Kabul University and APPRO to
develop curriculum on trade policies and international trade. This included
one academic from both institutions attending 7 month “Afghanistan, WTO
and International Trade Programme”.
Results Both Kabul University and APPRO have built their knowledge of curriculum
that would best inform a home-grown curriculum on trade policies and
international trade;
Kabul University has developed the structure and accompanying curriculum
for a course "Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade" (see Annex VII)
that is anticipated to be taught over 15 lectures in Kabul following approval.
At present, Kabul University has approved the course and it is pending
approval from the Ministry of Higher Education. The course will provide a
comprehensive overview and a detailed understanding of various aspects
relating to international trade. It covers topics from the economic, policy and
legal perspectives.
Stakeholder/ participant
information
Kabul University – 1 participant
APPRO – 1 participant
Supporting documents
Structure and accompanying curriculum for a course "Afghanistan, WTO and
International Trade", proposed to be taught at Kabul University.
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievements
Number of training modules/material produced: 0 (Kabul University has
developed structure and accompanying curriculum for a course
"Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade". Further finalisation still to be
confirmed)
Title Development of training material
Implementing partners MoIC, CWS, ITC
Background/context As part of “Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme”,
participants, CWS developed a tailor-made training materials/reading
materials for this programme to give to participants comprising of 10
modules. The modules (150 pages in length) covers the following areas:
1) Why do countries trade
2) Introductions to WTO and FTAs
3) Introduction to Trade Data
4) Afghanistan and World Trade
5) Afghanistan and the Agreement on Agriculture
6) TBS and SPS
7) Trade Remedies
77
8) Intellectual Property Rights
9) General Agreement on Trade in Services
10) Trade Litigation
Subsequently it was translated into Dari and given to each participant.
Additionally prior to each training participants received an extensive reading
list and further notes.
Results Full set of learning materials have been provided to MoIC for long-term
usage.
Participants were provided tailor-made training material/readings at the
beginning of the course to cover the entire programme / better inform their
learning.
Supporting documents
Training material/reading material as presented in “Afghanistan, WTO and
International Trade Programme: Report on First Intake of Participants”.
Contribution towards
programmes indicator’s
achievements
SUB-IND 4.2: Number of training modules/material produced: 10 (i.e.
one for each topic mentioned above)
Title Advisory services
Date/Location Ongoing / distance
Implementing partners CWS; MoIC; ITC
Background/context In the context of, Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme,
CWS interacted through emails for addressing any queries that they had
regarding the technical content of the trainings, as well as addressing job-
related questions. As part of this, CWS set up a Trade Policy Hotline –
whereby participants can obtain technical advice on trade policy matters that
they are facing in their work and or through the trainings. A dedicated e-mail
ID (cws.hotline@iift.edu) was set up for participants to respond.
An additional ad-hoc training was held through Skype videoconference on
with the purpose on refreshing information gained from the first introductory
training and also respond to questions.
Results Mechanism for attending to request from participants established through
Trade Policy Hotline.
Technical support provided on range on trade policy matters.
Supporting documents
Concept note for Trade Policy Hotline; report for ad-hoc training
79
4.5 OUTPUT 5: Institutional mechanisms to facilitate the implementation of the TFA are established at national level and linked with regional partners
During the first reporting period, the project focused on enhancing the capacity of the Members of the IMCWTF on the WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement and on initiating the TFA categorization process in accordance with Afghanistan legal obligations under the WTO.
The improved understanding of trade facilitation by IMCWTF Members allowed ITC to deepen its technical assistance services in year 2. Building upon the achievements of the first reporting period, ITC has facilitated several working sessions/workshops with IMCWTF Members and private sector representatives to finalize the categorization of the TFA obligations. Through continuous advisory services to the government of Afghanistan, ITC also contributed to the validation of the categorization by the High-Economic Council and the subsequent notification to the WTO of Afghanistan categorization decision. Simultaneously, the ITC has supported the development a trade facilitation strategy that has been included as a dedicated chapter of the NES and developed 10 years TFA implementation work plan taking into account government and businesses priorities for reform and the complexity of different TFA obligations. ITC is now supporting the Government of Afghanistan in aligning the Customs Strategic Plan with the TFA implementation work plan to ensure consistency in the timing and modalities of trade facilitation reforms across all border regulatory agencies.
Activity Date/location Main
Achievements
Contributing to indicator
Under Activity 5.1: Support the implementation of the WTO TFA through technical advisory
services to IMCWTF and other government agencies & Activity 5.2: Support the capacity
building and operationalization of IMCWTF and other public sector agencies to implement the
WTF TFA
WTO Trade
Facilitation
Agreement -
categorization
workshop
25, July, Kabul
Endorsed
recommendations for
the categorization of
the TFA obligations
by the IMCWTF
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
SUB-IND 5.2: Number of public
and private sector
representatives stating
increased awareness on the
WTO TFA and trade facilitation
reforms: 47
Notification of
TFA
categorization
decision to the
WTO
19, February, Kabul Official notification of
the categorization
decision to the WTO
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
Development of a
National Trade
Facilitation
Strategy (i.e.
July to October
2017
The Trade
Facilitation Strategy
is endorsed by HEC
(along with the NES)
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA
80
dedicated NES
chapter)
issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
TFA Prioritization
and Sequencing
Workshop
12 – 14, May 2018
WTO TFA measures
have been
categorised. Cost-
benefit analysis of
each measure has
been conducted.
Measures have been
prioritized and a 10
years high-level
work-plan has been
developed.
IMCWTF trained on
TFA, cost-benefit
analysis,
implementation
planning, private
sector participation,
inter-ministerial
collaboration and
coordination of
reforms.
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
SUB-IND 5.2: Number of public
and private sector
representatives stating
increased awareness on the
WTO TFA and trade facilitation
reforms: 35
Private sector
workshop to
review TFA
implementation
plan developed by
IMCWTF
24, June, 2018 Representatives of
the business
community reviewed
and proposed
amendment to the
TFA implementation
plan developed by
IMCWTF Members
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan
SUB-IND 5.2: Number of public
and private sector
representatives stating
increased awareness on the
WTO TFA and trade facilitation
reforms: 42
Alignment of
Customs Strategic
Plan with TFA
25, June, 2018 Technical note
shared with
Government of
Afghanistan
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
Activity 5.3: Increase awareness of private stakeholders on the TFA and their ability to contribute to TFA related PPD within the IMCWTF and other fora
Train-the-trainers
event in Istanbul
October 2017
All training material
adapted to the needs
of Afghanistan and
translated in Pashto
and Dari.
81
Activity 5.1: Support the implementation of the WTO TFA through technical advisory services to IMCWTF and other government agencies & Activity 5.2: Support the capacity building and operationalization of IMCWTF and other public sector agencies to implement the WTF TFA
Title WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement - categorization workshop
Date/Location 25 July, Kabul
Implementing
partners
MoIC, USAID, ITC
Background/
context
The technical committees work was focused on categorising 36 key reforms
measures, as stipulated by the TFA, into three possible categories:
- Category A: provisions that the member will implement by the time
the Agreement enters into force (or in the case of a least-developed
country within one year after entry into force)
- Category B: provisions that the member will implement after a
transitional period following the entry into force of the Agreement
- Category C: provisions that the member will implement on a date
after a transitional period following the entry into force of the
Agreement and requiring the acquisition of assistance and support
for capacity building.
The TFA entered into force on 22 February and creates legally binding
obligations for Afghanistan to improve transparency, predictability, fairness,
and efficiency of the cross-border trade environment. As per the TFA,
Afghanistan is in the process of self-designating the provisions of the TFA
into these three possible categories. Moving forward, Afghanistan will be
required to build upon the committee recommendations, prepare an action
plan for the implementation of reforms and notify to the WTO before 22
February 2018.
Effective implementation of the WTO obligations is seen as key in reducing
the time and cost of trade in the country and thereby create a more
conducive business environment for traders. Under the AAT project, ITC is
working with both government and the private sector to this end.
6 To deliver trainings on the WTO TFA.
Five master trainers
have been trained to
deliver training to the
private sector on the
WTO TFA.
SUB-IND 6.2: Trainers are trained:6 7 SUB-IND 5.2: Number of public and private sector representatives stating increased awareness on the WTO TFA and trade facilitation reforms: 7
82
ITC, in collaboration with MoCI and USAID organized a 2 days’ workshop
with Members of the IMCWT to categorize each of the 36 obligations of the
WTO Trade Facilitation Agreement. During the workshop, ITC presented
each measure of the Agreement and facilitated discussion on Afghanistan
current compliance status vis-à-vis its international obligations. Discussions
focused on existing gaps in terms of: legal frameworks, organisational and
institutional structures, standard operating procedures, IT equipment and
procedures automations, capacity of border regulatory agencies staff.
Results Endorsed recommendations for the categorization of the Trade Facilitation
Agreement (TFA) obligations (11 category A measures, 14 category B
measures, 11 category C measures)
Stakeholder/
participant
information
47 participants from Ministries, border regulatory agencies and business
associations Members of the IMCWTF
Participant
evaluation
Not available
Supporting
documents
Workshop presentations, categorization recommendations, activity report
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
SUB-IND 5.2: Number of public and private sector representatives
stating increased awareness on the WTO TFA and trade facilitation
reforms: 47
83
Title Advisory services: categorization recommendation validation by HEC
and official notification of categorization decisions to the WTO
Date/Location From July 2017 to February 2018, Kabul and Geneva
Implementing
partners ITC, MoCI, Special Adviser to the President of Afghanistan
Background/
context
Following the categorization workshop organized by ITC and USAID, ITC
provided continuous advisory services to the Government of Afghanistan to
further refine and document the categorization recommendations
formulated by the IMCWTF and facilitate its adoption by the High-Economic
Council and its official notification to the WTO.
Results
The categorization recommendation is validated by the High-Economic
Council. The categorization decision is officially notified to the WTO
according to the requirements under WTO-TFA Section 2.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
ITC, MoIC, Special Adviser to the President of Afghanistan
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
Title Advisory services: Development of a National Trade Facilitation
Strategy as a dedicated chapter of the NES
Date/Location July to November 2017, Kabul, Geneva
Implementing
partners
Members of the IMCWTF and representatives of the Afghan business
community
Background/
context
Afghanistan is engaged in numerous development efforts, including through
strengthening the private-sector-led market economy. This entailed cutting
the high costs to trade for Afghan traders and simplifying the regulatory
business and investment framework. In this context, trade facilitation
reforms have become a priority. The ITC has thus supported the
development a trade facilitation strategy to improve the transparency,
fairness, predictability and efficiency of cross-border operations. This
strategy has been developed through consultations with public and private
stakeholders in Afghanistan and building upon the recommendations
stemming from TFA categorization workshops. The national trade
facilitation strategy has become an integral part the Afghanistan National
Export Strategy developed by ITC in close cooperation with the
Government of Afghanistan
Results The national trade facilitation strategy is developed and endorsed by the
High-Economic Council
Supporting
Document Technical note to the Special Adviser to the President of Afghanistan
Stakeholder/
participant
information
Members of the IMCWTF and representatives of the Afghan business
community
Contribution
towards
programmes
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
84
indicator’s
achievement
Title Prioritization and Sequencing Workshop
Date/Location 12 – 14 May, Kabul
Implementing
partners
Ministry of Industry and Commerce, Inter-Ministerial Committee on WTO and
Trade Facilitation
Background/
context
Over the course of 2017, significant progress was made towards meeting
Afghanistan’s commitments under the WTO TFA agreement. The TFA
measures were categorised, the categorisations were endorsed by the high-
level inter-ministerial committee on WTO and Trade Facilitation (IMCWTF),
then approved by the High Economic Council and notified to the WTO. This
three-day workshop built on that progress by gathering public and private
trade facilitation stakeholders to discuss prioritisation, sequencing and
implementation of the upcoming Trade Facilitation reforms.
The objectives of the workshop were as follows
briefly discuss each of the TFA measures and the possible
implementation modalities;
prioritise and sequence the reforms
develop an over-all implementation strategy and work-plan;
develop in-depth implementation plan for select, high-priority TFA
measures;
select measures to be implemented with technical assistance from
ITC;
select measures for which ITC can assist in the elaboration of project
proposals to be submitted to development partners for further
technical assistance.
Results Workshop participants conducted cost-benefit analysis of each TFA
measures, then ranked them in order of priority. A high-level implementation
was developed and is currently being validated.
In the process, workshop participants were trained on the TFA, on CBA
methodology, on implementation planning, on the importance of private
sector inputs and on inter-ministerial collaboration.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
See participant evaluation + participant list from Danish
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
SUB-IND 5.2: Number of public and private sector representatives
stating increased awareness on the WTO TFA and trade facilitation
reforms: 35
85
Title Advisory services: Alignment of Customs Strategic Plan with TFA
implementation plan developed by IMCWTF
Date/Location 25 June 2017, MoCI, Kabul
Implementing
partners ITC, MoCI, ACD
Background/
context
During the Sequencing and Prioritization workshop that was held in Kabul
on the 12-14 May 2018, it emerged that the Afghan Customs Department
had developed its own TFA implementation plan and incorporated it into its
Five-Year Strategic Plan for Customs Modernization. However, the
development of the plan had been done without consultation with other
border authorities or the private sector. The plan was also based on some
misunderstandings of the TFA’s legal obligations, such as the notion that all
Category B measures must be implemented within a period of five years
from ratification.
A meeting was held with MOIC and ACD, and a technical note delivered to
all participants, to provide clarification on the legal obligations contained in
the TFA and to impart some best practices in TFA implementation. The
technical note also included a comparison of the Customs Plan for TFA
implementation (Strategic Goal 6 of the Customs Modernization Plan) and
the draft work-plan developed by the IMCWTF during the Prioritization and
Sequencing Workshop that was held in May.
Both MOIC and ACD are now in a position to align the two plans, by
consulting with the relevant parties and with each other. The plans will likely
be aligned, and the IMCWTF draft work plan finalised, at a meeting of the
IMCWTF. The plan will then be approved at the level of the High Economic
Council.
Results
Recommendations for the alignment of the Customs Strategic Plan with the
IMCWTF draft work plan for TFA implementation delivered. Stakeholders
trained on TFA legal obligations and best practices in TFA implementation.
Supporting
Document Technical note shared with Government of Afghanistan
Stakeholder/
participant
information
Mr. Mudabber, Head of IMCWTF at the MOIC
Mr. Sadat, Afghan Customs Department
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
86
Activity 5.3: Increase awareness of private stakeholders on the TFA and their ability to contribute to TFA related PPD within the IMCWTF and other for a
Title Private sector trainings: pedagogical material development
Date/Location July 2017 to October 2017
Implementing
partners ITC
Background/
context
For businesses, especially for SMEs, operationalizing the TFA is a path
towards internationalization, which will allow them to access international
value chains at lower cost and at greater speeds. SMEs can most benefit
from the Agreement by having a sound understanding of how the new
procedures and requirements will complement their business priorities. Like
other WTO agreements, the degree to which the intended benefits of the
TFA can be actually realized will depend upon how it is implemented in
national law and practice. While implementation is the primary responsibility
of the WTO members, businesses play a critical role in the consultative
process to advice authorities as to how the Agreement is best applied in the
national environment.
ITC has partnered with ACCI to empower selected ACCI representatives
(i..e Master trainers) to deliver TFA related trainings to the business
community in Kabul and province. The objective of the trainings to be
delivered by ACCI is to assist businesses in understanding the terms,
potential benefits and practical use of each of the technical measures of the
TFA and to equip the business community with the necessary technical and
advocacy skills to successfully contribute to the design, implementation and
monitoring of the TFA.
In this context, ITC developed training materials to assist ACCI master
trainers in delivering capacity building services to private sector, including a
training manual, 4 PowerPoint presentations and 4 worksheets. All training
material has been made available in Dari. In addition, ITC has developed a
tailor made methodology to empower 7 national Master trainers from ACCI
to deliver TFA trainings autonomously to the private sector in Kabul and
provinces.
Results
Customized methodology and training material to empower Master trainers
developed. Training material for private sector workshop developed and
translated.
National Master Trainers are empowered to deliver private sector workshop
on the TFA
Supporting
Document
Training material for the ToT event and training material for private sector
workshop available
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 6.2 Trainers are trained7
7 To deliver trainings on WTO TFA
87
Title Private sector workshops: training of ACCI Master Trainers
Date/Location October 2017, Istanbul, Turkey
Implementing
partners ITC, ACCI
Background/
context
ITC has partnered with ACCI to empower selected ACCI representatives
(i..e Master trainers) to deliver TFA related trainings to the business
community in Kabul and province. The objective of the trainings to be
delivered by ACCI is to assist businesses in understanding the terms,
potential benefits and practical use of each of the technical measures of the
TFA and to equip the business community with the necessary technical and
advocacy skills to successfully contribute to the design, implementation and
monitoring of the TFA.
ITC has organized a training-of-trainer event to equip 7 ACCI Master
trainers with necessary technical and pedagogical material to deliver TFA
related private sector trainings autonomously.
Results 7 ACCI Master trainers are empowered to deliver TFA private sector
trainings autonomously in Kabul and provinces
Supporting
Document Event reports
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 6.2Trainers are trained8: 7
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation
of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan
Title Private sector workshop to review TFA implementation plan
developed by IMCWTF
Date/Location 25 June 2017, ACCI premises, Kabul
Implementing
partners ITC, ACCI, MoCI
Background/
context
Private sector participation in the Prioritization and Sequencing workshop
that was held in Kabul from 12-14 May 2018 was below expectations.
Given the importance of securing private sector inputs into Trade
Facilitation reforms, ITC and MOIC agreed to organise another workshop,
specifically for the private sector, during which traders would be given the
opportunity to provide their views on the draft TFA implementation work-
plan that was developed by the IMCWTF.
The workshop was organised by the Afghanistan Chamber of Commerce
and Industries (ACCI) and participation was excellent over the three days.
Two days were devoted to training the participants on the content of the
TFA, and the last day was spent forging consensus on the
8 To deliver trainings on the WTO TFA.
88
recommendations that will be delivered to the IMCWTF. A clear set of
recommendations were developed, in the form of a Gantt chart, with the full
backing of all the participating traders, ACCI and MOIC.
Results Private sector recommendations on the draft implementation work-plan
developed by the IMCWTF, in the form of a Gantt chart.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
See Danish participant evaluation form.
Contribution
towards
programmes
indicator’s
achievement
SUB-IND 5.1 - Number of recommendation towards the implementation of the TFA issued and/or endorsed by the Government of Afghanistan: 1
SUB-IND 5.2: Number of public and private sector representatives
stating increased awareness on the WTO TFA and trade facilitation
reforms: 42
4.6 OUTPUT 6: SME knowledge of how to manage national cross-border procedures and compliance with regional and/or global market requirements is built encompassing priority markets (building on NES findings)
The activities carried out in the current reporting period built on the work that was done by ACE on the development of the Export Management Guides. Given the number and complexity of the procedures that had to be documented, the development of the guides took longer than expected. Now that they have been completed, further work will be done to disseminate the information to the private sector, and to train traders on export management practices. Under this output, work will also begin on the transfer of the information currently contained in the Export Management guides, onto an online platform (through the development of a trade portal). This will allow the information collected in the last reporting period to be more easily accessed by users and more easily updated when they change.
Activity Date/location Main
Achievements
Contributing to indicator
6.1: Develop,
National Trade
Procedures Guide
for SMEs priority
import/export
sectors
Meeting with MoIC
and World Bank on
15th of May in Kabul
5 National Trade Procedures Guides for SMEs are developed (publication and dissemaintaiton of guides to be confirmed by PSC)
SUB-IND 6.3: National Trade Facilitation procedure guide published
6.2: Develop an
SME export
management and
compliance
training
curriculum
Continuous work:
Geneva & Kabul
Export management training curricula soon to be finalized
SUB-IND 6.1: Number of private sector representatives who participated in the export management curriculum and pass knowledge tests
89
Activity 6.1: Develop, publish and disseminate a National Trade Procedures Guide for SMEs and entrepreneurs, in print as well as online
Title Development of National Trade Procedures guides for SMEs in
entrepreneurs
Location Kabul/Geneva
Implementing
partners
Afghanistan Centre of Excellence (ACE)
Background/
context
The project aims to strengthen the capacities of SMEs to manage cross-
border procedures and engage in exports of 5 key sectors in Afghanistan.
This will be done through the dissemination of national export procedures
guides for each priority sector where key formalities, documents and
procedural requirements are detailed in a user-friendly manner and
practical steps to complete an export transaction in Afghanistan will be
provided. Each export guide also contains a section on requirements of 2
or 3 main destination markets for that sector as well as a brief sector
analysis and other practical information that may be useful for the trader.
Results Consultants and local partners ACE carried out field work in Afghanistan to
document all the requirements and develop the guides. The guides have
been finalised but not published. As a matter of fact, ITC has been informed
that export formality in Afghanistan were currently under review which
questions the relevance of publication and disseminations of the guides.
Guidance from the PSC is required on this matter.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
ACE, ACCI, sector specific exporters, ACCI, EPAA, Customs.
Supporting
documents
Export Management Guides
Activity 6.2: Develop SME export management and compliance training curriculum
Title Develop an SME export management and compliance training
curriculum
Location Kabul/Geneva
6.3: Develop an
SME coaching
manual to assist
local coaches to
deliver in-house
advisory services
to SMEs
Continuous work:
Geneva & Kabul
The SME Coaching Manual soon to be finalized
SUB-IND 6.1: Number of private sector representatives who participated in the export management curriculum and pass knowledge tests
6.4: Identify local
coaches to
provide in-house
advisory services
to SMEs
Interview of
potential export
management
coach, Kabul 14th
and 16th July
The future local export management coaches are identified
SUB-IND 6.1: Number of private sector representatives who participated in the export management curriculum and pass knowledge tests
90
Implementing
partners
ITC
Background/
context
The project seeks to develop a training curriculum to support SMEs to
comply with Afghanistan's cross-border procedural and regulatory
requirements in relation with export transactions to its main trading partners
(such as EU, regional countries). The scope of the training is limited to the
export administrative and logistics processes: obtaining export licences and
permits, collecting, filling and submitting the export documentation to the
relevant border regulatory agencies, hiring and maintaining successful
relationships with customs brokers and freight forwarders. The training will
not cover the production processes nor the commercial processes that are
not linked to the export processes (i.e. marketing, contract negotiation,
invoicing).
Results ITC has developed a training curriculum composed of 6 modules, each
module comprising of 2 lectures and 1 case study. These modules so far
focus on the generic export management modules and will be further
enriched with Afghanistan specific and sector specific information contained
in the National Trade Procedure guides
Once the training is fully developed, ITC will hire local consultants to deliver
the trainings to SMEs..
Stakeholder/
participant
information
ACCI, ACE
Supporting
documents
Training curriculum (to be finalized)
Activity 6.3 - Develop an SME coaching manual to assist local coaches to deliver in-house advisory services to SMEs
Title Develop an SME coaching manual
Location Kabul/Geneva
Implementing
partners
ITC
Background/
context
The project seeks to provide in-house coaching services to exporting SMEs
with a view to improve their ability to comply with international trade
requirements. The in-house coaching services will be delivered by local
Export Management Coaches through a train-the-coach methodology. In
this context, ITC is developing coaching manual to assist the EMC in
providing effective advisory services to SMEs. This coaching manual will
provide methodological directions to the EMCs (i.e. how to plan, structure,
organize and deliver advisory missions) and include key tools (i.e. export
check lists, template job descriptions, template SOP for managing
consignment…) and reference material (e.g. Afghanistan specific training
material, incoterms tables, template shipping documents…). The
overarching objective is to guide EMC on supporting exporting businesses
to efficiently process international trade transaction and comply with
administrative export requirements in Afghanistan
Results ITC has developed a first draft of the coaching manual covering 5 key
topics: packaging, labelling, mandatory certification/registration and buyers
91
standards, Customs, International Shipping, Export Planning. Once the
SME coaching manual is finalized, ITC will empower local Export
Management Coaches to provide in-house advisory services to SMEs
Stakeholder/
participant
information
Top Stars, Core Drillers, Agroindust, SMC Group
Supporting
documents
SME Coaching Manual (to be finalized)
92
Activity 6.4 - Identify local coaches to provide in-house advisory services to SMEs
Title Identify local coaches to provide in-house advisory services to SMEs
Location Kabul, 14th-16th July
Implementing
partners
ITC, Top Stars, Core Drillers, Agroindust, SMC Group
Background/
context
The project seeks to provide in-house coaching services to exporting SMEs
with a view to improve their ability to comply with international trade
requirements. The in-house coaching services will be delivered by local
Export Management Coaches through a train-the-coach methodology. In
this context, ITC has been looking for suitable candidates to act as Export
Management Coaches
Results ITC has identified 4 partners that will act as Export Management Coaches
to provide in-house advisory services to SMEs
Stakeholder/
participant
information
Top Stars, Core Drillers, Agroindust, SMC Group
Supporting
documents
Quotations from selected provides.
4.7 OUTPUT 7: Public-private consultation process on domestic/regional key pressing trade policy/regulatory/negotiation issues is strengthened
Afghanistan National Trade Policy: 2018 - 2022
At the outset of the project, and upon the specific request of MoIC, ITC was requested to provide technical
support for the development of a national trade policy five year plan. Therefore, ITC, in consultation with MoIC,
developed work plan to develop the policy document. Following extensive fact-finding and a review of policy
related documents as well as previously drafted national trade policy documents, a first draft version of the
“Afghanistan National Trade Policy: 2018 - 2022 ” was drafted. The draft utilised an ITC developed
methodology which assesses trade policy instruments that impact each stage of the supply chain.
A review process of ANTP was then initiated by MoIC, which included preparations for a national stakeholder
consultation meeting to present the findings and obtain feedback for incorporation.
Bilateral stakeholder consultation to enhance trade relations between Afghanistan and neighbouring countries
It was further confirmed that the project will support regular bilateral stakeholder consultation between
Afghanistan and Iran (or alternatively Afghanistan and Uzbekistan) aimed at enhancing trading relations. ITC
recommended and subsequently gained the initial approval for the methodology/timeframes for undertaking
bilateral consultations, intended to occur over the next two-year period. Much ground work, needs analysis,
consultation with stakeholders and their endorsement was undertaken to confirm this key direction.
93
However progress was stalled during the first half of the second year of the AAT project, owing to change of
Government of Afghanistan priority to favour Iran to engage with for this initiative. Eventually, the Government
of Afghanistan confirmed that it would prefer to pursue this initiative with Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan.
Subsequently, ITC together with Government of Afghanistan set about sensitizing and gaining the support of
Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan counterparts to this initiative, which was eventually confirmed only in May, 2018.
The initiative has been appreciated due to its timely relevance, focus on evidence-based research, bringing
key stakeholders together and generation of key recommendations.
In short, the following activities were undertaken under the first year of the project.
Needs assessment for the operationalisation of a PPD platform on trade policy (study)
Draft policy document: ANTP (2018 -2022)
Supporting bilateral stakeholder consultations to enhance trading relations between Afghanistan and
Iran/Uzbekistan
The following details progress under the second year.
Activity Date/location Main
Achievements
Contributing to
indicator
Under Act. 7.2: Research materials/position papers through peer review (whenever local
capacity exists) are produced
Policy document:
ANTP (2107 -2022)
February 2017 -
ongoing
Kabul/Geneva
First document to
define a national trade
policy for Afghanistan
Defining of
overarching objectives
and specific policy
recommendations
MoIC endorsement of
final document
SUB-IND 7.2:
Number of policy
research materials
produced: 1
Policy
recommendations
study: Trade between
Afghanistan and
Uzbekistan: Issues
and Options for
Enhancement
August, 2017 –
December 2017,
Kabul/Geneva
Enhanced knowledge
of barriers to bilateral
trade identified and
recommendations
generated to address
SUB-IND 7.2:
Number of policy
research materials
produced: 1
94
MoIC equipped with
well-informed inputs to
inform future bilateral
stakeholder
consultations with
Uzbekistan
Policy
recommendations
study: Trade between
Afghanistan and
Kazakhstan: Issues
and Options for
Enhancement
August, 2017 –
December 2017,
Kabul/Geneva
Enhanced knowledge
of barriers to bilateral
trade identified and
recommendations
generated to address
MoIC equipped with
well-informed inputs to
inform future bilateral
stakeholder
consultations with
Kazakhstan
SUB-IND 7.2:
Number of policy
research materials
produced: 1
ACCI position paper:
Trade between
Afghanistan and
Uzbekistan: Issues
and Options for
Enhancement
August, 2017 –
December 2017,
Kabul/Geneva
ACCI technical
research on trade
matters augmented
ACCI better equipped
to advocate inputs
during bilateral
stakeholder
consultations
MoIC better informed
of private sector input
SUB-IND 7.2:
Number of policy
research materials
produced: 1
ACCI position paper:
Trade between
Afghanistan and
Kazakhstan: Issues
and Options for
Enhancement
August, 2017 –
December 2017,
Kabul/Geneva
ACCI technical
research on trade
matters augmented
ACCI better equipped
to advocate inputs
during bilateral
stakeholder
consultations
MoIC better informed
of private sector input
SUB-IND 7.2:
Number of policy
research materials
produced: 1
Under Act. 7.3: Public-private policy consultations (included at bilateral/ and regional level) are organized
95
Activity 7.2: Research materials/position papers through peer review (whenever local capacity exists) are produced
Title Policy document: ANTP - 2017-2022
Location Kabul/Geneva
Implementing
partners
MoIC, ITC
Background/
context
In the era of globalization, trade has become an all-pervasive part of economic life. Trade issues affect, and are affected by, almost all other economic and social policies. A trade policy can, therefore, constitute a potent tool for the government to achieve economic objectives and influence growth and development. Effective trade policies can promote economic
ANTP National
Stakeholder
Consultation
25 November, 2017,
Kabul
Platform provided for public and private sector stakeholders to deliberate on good policy for export development. Agreement on key policy objectives to increase national exports.
SUB-IND 7.1: Number of public-private dialogues/trainings held: 1 Number of recommendations stemming from PPD: 20
Afghanistan –
Uzbekistan:
Stakeholder
consultation to
enhance trading
relations
&
Pre-event mission to
Tashkent
20 June, 2018, Termiz,
Uzbekistan
18 May, 2018,
Tashkent, Uzbekistan
Stakeholder consultation platform for engaging between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan to enhance trading relations established. Issues faced while exporting to/through and investing in Uzbekistan, including transit fees, export duties, visas, operationalizing trade and transit agreements identified. A joint declaration/agreement reflecting the main points of consensus. MOU signed between ACCI and Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Uzbekistan to establish a join Business Council.
SUB-IND 7.1: Number of public-private dialogues/trainings held: 2 Number of recommendations stemming from PPD: 2
96
development by encouraging more productive investment, which will lead to a more internationally competitive private sector. To date, Afghanistan has not had a national trade policy. MoIC has requested ITC for technical assistance in developing an ANTP (2017 - 2022). A previous draft was considered not sufficient, hence the request by the MoIC for the assistance of ITC. ITC recommended and subsequently gained the approval for the methodology/timeframes for the development of the national trade policy document in the course on 2017. ITC’s unique approach looks at how trade policy instruments affect each stage of the trader's supply chain, and subsequently how “right” policy choices can be implemented to enhance its functioning and thus increase export competitiveness.
Required activities, timeframes for developing the policy document were set and agreed upon with MoIC. Some of the main activities included development of structure, review of existing policy documents/relevant papers, development of issue paper, stakeholder consultations, review/incorporation of inputs.
The policy document undertook several rounds of drafting and internal reviews by MoIC and ITC, as well as receiving further inputs from private sector associations, local and international experts. Additionally a national stakeholder consultation was held on 25 November in which more than 70 Afghan industry leaders, small business owners, and representatives of the public sector discussed the contents of ANTP and agreed on its key objectives intended to increase the country’s exports.
MoIC subsequently approved the ANTP in May, 2018, and is pursing further steps to have the document officially endorsed by the government for future implementation – including approval by PRISEC and HEC.
Results MoIC technical capacity developed on trade policy formulation to stimulate export development.
Reforms identified aimed at capacitating domestic institutions, creating business enabling environment, implementing regulations resulting from WTO commitments and undertaking further trade-enabling reforms.
ANTP addressing issues holistically and bringing forth trade policy coherence.
Road map provided for MoIC to carry out its objectives in synergy with other ministries and their policies.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
MoIC; ACCI
Supporting
documents
ANTP (2018 -2022) – (also translated into Dari); Issue paper.
Contributing to
indicator
SUB-IND 7.2: Number of policy research materials produced: 1
Title Policy recommendations study: Trade between Afghanistan and
Uzbekistan: Issues and Options for Enhancement
97
Location Kabul/Geneva
Implementing
partners
MoIC, ITC
Background/
context
The AAT project is supporting bilateral stakeholder consultations to enhance
trading relations between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan. A main aim of these
consultations is to address a number of barriers relating to policy, regulatory
and procedural issues, which present an obstacle to advancing bilateral
trading relations, and in particular exports from Afghanistan to Uzbekistan.
To better inform these consultation, and upon the request of MoIC a study
was commissioned to identify barriers and issues which affect trade between
Afghanistan and Uzbekistan.
In order to identify and assess barriers to bilateral trade, the study was
completed through a combination of desk research – including the review of
literature and media reports on trade irritants, trade and tariff databases,
international benchmarking exercises – and stakeholder interviews,
undertaken by a local expert associated with the Afghanistan Chamber of
Commerce and Industry (ACCI). In total, more than 30 traders and
businesses, and government staff from relevant ministries and agencies,
have been consulted.
Results Enhanced knowledge of barriers to bilateral trade identified and
recommendations generated to address.
MoIC equipped with well-informed inputs to inform future bilateral
stakeholder consultations with Uzbekistan.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
MoIC;
Supporting
documents
Trade between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan – Issues and options for
enhancement; Concept paper; PPT
Contributing to
indicator
SUB-IND 7.2: Number of policy research materials produced: 1
Title Policy recommendations study: Trade between Afghanistan and
Kazakhstan: Issues and Options for Enhancement
Location Kabul/Geneva
Implementing
partners
MoIC, ITC
Background/
context
The AAT project is supporting bilateral stakeholder consultations to enhance
trading relations between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan. A main aim of these
consultations is to address a number of barriers relating to policy, regulatory
and procedural issues, which present an obstacle to advancing bilateral
trading relations, and in particular exports from Afghanistan to Kazakhstan.
98
To better inform these consultation, and upon the request of MoIC a study
was commissioned to identify barriers and issues which affect trade between
Afghanistan and Kazakhstan.
In order to identify and assess barriers to bilateral trade, the study was
completed through a combination of desk research – including the review of
literature and media reports on trade irritants, trade and tariff databases,
international benchmarking exercises – and stakeholder interviews,
undertaken by a local expert associated with the ACCI. In total, more than
30 traders and businesses, and government staff from relevant ministries
and agencies, have been consulted.
Results Enhanced knowledge of barriers to bilateral trade identified and
recommendations generated to address.
MoIC equipped with well-informed inputs to inform future bilateral
stakeholder consultations with Kazakhstan.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
MoIC
Supporting
documents
Trade between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan – Issues and options for
enhancement; Concept paper; PPT.
Contributing to
indicator
SUB-IND 7.2: Number of policy research materials produced: 1
Title Position paper: Trade between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan: Issues and
Options for Enhancement
Location Kabul/Geneva
Implementing
partners
ACCI, ITC
Background/
context
The AAT project is supporting bilateral stakeholder consultations to enhance
trading relations between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan. A main aim of these
consultations is to address a number of barriers relating to policy, regulatory
and procedural issues, which present an obstacle to advancing bilateral
trading relations, and in particular exports from Afghanistan to Uzbekistan.
To better inform these consultation, private sector input/advocacy was
considered. Accordingly ACCI was commissioned to complete a position
paper, detailing obstacles for trade with Uzbekistan as well as approach to
address them.
Accordingly ACCI carried out the study through desktop research and
reaching out to their membership.
Results ACCI identifies ten key obstacles hindering the advancement of bilateral trade identified and identifies two dimensional approach to address.
ACCI technical capacity on trade matters enhanced for improved advocacy.
MoIC better understand private sector concerns for future bilateral stakeholder consultations with Uzbekistan.
99
Supporting
documents
Trade between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan – Issues and options for
enhancement; Concept paper; PPT.
Contributing to
indicator
SUB-IND 7.2: Number of policy research materials produced: 1
Title Position paper: Trade between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan: Issues
and Options for Enhancement
Location Kabul/Geneva
Implementing
partners
ACCI, ITC
Background/
context
The AAT project is supporting bilateral stakeholder consultations to enhance
trading relations between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan. A main aim of these
consultations is to address a number of barriers relating to policy, regulatory
and procedural issues, which present an obstacle to advancing bilateral
trading relations, and in particular exports from Afghanistan to Kazakhstan.
To better inform these consultation, private sector input/advocacy was
considered. Accordingly ACCI was commissioned to complete a position
paper, detailing obstacles for trade with Kazakhstan as well as approach to
address them.
Accordingly ACCI carried out the study through desktop research and
reaching out to their membership.
Results ACCI identifies ten key obstacles hindering the advancement of bilateral
trade identified and identifies two dimensional approach to address.
ACCI technical capacity on trade matters enhanced for improved advocacy.
MoIC better understand private sector concerns for future bilateral
stakeholder consultations with Uzbekistan.
Supporting
documents
Trade between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan – Issues and options for
enhancement; Concept paper; PPT
Contributing to
indicator
SUB-IND 7.2: Number of policy research materials produced: 1
Activity 7.3: Public-private policy consultations (included at bilateral/ and regional level) are organized
Title ANTP National Stakeholder Consultation
Implementing
partners
Organized by MoIC and ACCI, with the technical support of ITC
Background/
context
The ANTP stakeholders' consultation brought together Afghan industry leaders, small business owners, representatives from the public sector, academia, independent researchers and key government policy makers to
100
deliberate on the content and structure of a proposed ANTP, a five year plan document. The ANTP consultation was held to ensure that stakeholders beyond the public sector are involved in the formulation of the policy. ANTP is deemed as a first policy document that holistically addresses issues related to trade. It projects a great deal of reforms which are aimed at capacitating domestic institutions, creating business enabling environment, implementing regulations resulting from WTO commitments and undertaking further trade-enabling reforms. Prior to the meeting the ANTP policy document has undertaken several rounds of drafting and internal reviews by MoIC and ITC, as well as received further inputs from private sector associations, local and international experts. This meeting together with other consultations held for National Export
Strategy contribute to Afghanistan's efforts connect to regional and
international markets, generate employment opportunities, improve the
business environment and explore means of sustainable growth.
Results Stakeholders at different levels from different public and private sector
institutions brought together to discuss upon key priorities, which would
accelerate export development.
Agreement found on key priorities - These ranged from extending market
access of Afghan goods and services to regional and international markets,
rationalizing tariff policy, enhancing the export competitiveness of Afghan
products to promoting the domestic production).
MoIC provided a platform to gather stakeholder input.
Private sector provided a platform for their advocacy efforts with
government.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
73 (Including Afghan industry leaders, small business owners, and representatives of the public sector)
Supporting
documents
Draft ANTP policy document,; meeting report; press release
Contributing to
indicator
SUB-IND 7.1: Number of public-private dialogues/trainings held: 1 Number of recommendations stemming from PPD: 20
Title Supporting bilateral stakeholder consultations to enhance trading
relations between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan
Location Kabul, Tashkent, Termiz Geneva
Implementing
partners
MoIC, ACCI, UZCCI, MOFT
Background/
context
Building from a recent upscaling of collaboration between Afghanistan and
Uzbekistan to expand trading and cross border cooperation, the AAT project
is supporting bilateral public private stakeholder consultations between the
101
two countries. In particular there remain a number of obstacles which relate
to policy, regulatory and procedural issues which present an obstacle to
advancing cooperation most optimally. There is also a further need to build-
off and create new trading opportunities aided by the targeted policies and
incentives provided by both governments.
The Government of Afghanistan has confirmed its approval for prioritizing both Uzbekistan for holding bilateral consultations. The focal points on the Afghan government side are the Ministry of Commerce and Industry in liaison with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. The Government of Uzbekistan has also indicated their interest for the
approach to be taken. ITC in collaboration with the two governments
undertook further steps to ensure the initiatives realisation. In particular, ITC
facilitated a pre-public private dialogue (PPD) meeting in Tashkent on 18th
May between a delegation of Uzbekistan (Mr Sakhib Saifnazarov, Deputy
Minister of Foreign Trade - MOFT; Mr Faizov, Head of UZAF Trading
Company, Mr Abdusalamov, Head of Department, International
Cooperation, MOFT; and Mr Ibragimov, Focal point for PPD programme) and
Afghanistan (Mr Arif Harat, Commercial Attaché in Uzbekistan; Mr Reza
Saboori, Office of Special Representative of the President for CIS countries;
and Mr Nazary, Third Secretary, Afghanistan Embassy in Uzbekistan). The
purpose of the meeting was to share the concept and agenda of the
envisaged PPD, provide clarifications, and firm up the willingness and suport
of the MOFT of Uzbekistan to accommodate the event.
While the MOFT of Uzbekistan further confirmed its interest and support for the initiative, and in collaboration with Afghan counterparts agreed upon a number of follow-up steps. The demand for bilateral public-private dialogue has been further boosted by the signing of the Afghanistan-Uzbekistan trade and transit agreements in December 2017; notably, an effective implementation of these agreements will require close and ongoing dialogue between the private sectors of the two countries. Finally, r the AAT project had produced a background study identifying the major constraints faced by Afghan exporters while trading with or through Uzbekistan. This study was instrumental in assisting MoIC in drafting the agenda as well as in developing PPTs for the PPD. ACCI had also used the findings of the background note to produce a position paper on the issues to be tackled when trading with/through Uzbekistan. (See Activity 7.2 above for more information)
- The event It was mutually agreed that the PPD would take place in Termiz, Uzbekistan,
on 20th June.
The objectives of the event were to:
Foster the consultative process between both countries on trade and
investment related issues. The initial ambition was to assist in
addressing procedural, regulatory and/or operational issues
affecting trade/investment through regular meetings organized
under the project. Ultimately, the Afghan side wanted this platform
to be a vehicle for the operationalization of the Trade and Transit
agreement signed by both countries in December 2017. In particular,
it was felt that this platform could feed the joint committee envisaged
102
under the Trade and Transit agreement whose mandate is to
supervise the implementation of the two signed documents.
Provide an opportunity for businessmen/women of both countries to
make contacts and prospect for potential future deals.
Results Awareness raised of approach for regular bilateral stakeholder consultations
to advance trading relations.
Stakeholder consultation platform for engaging between Afghanistan and
Uzbekistan to enhance trading relations established. Stakeholders exposed
to initiative; engage with counterparts, and; agree upon next steps.
Issues faced while exporting to/through and investing in Uzbekistan,
including transit fees, export duties, visas, operationalizing trade and transit
agreements identified.
A joint declaration/agreement reflecting the main points of consensus.
MOU signed between ACCI and Chamber of Commerce and Industry of
Uzbekistan to establish a join Business Council.
Stakeholder/
participant
information
MoIC (Afghanistan); Permanent Mission of the Republic of Uzbekistan to the United Nations Office and other International Organisations in Geneva, Uzbekistan Chamber of Commerce (Through MoFA); ACCI; MoFT – Uzbekistan; Approximately 50 Afghan and Uzbekistan public and private stakeholders attended the event.
Supporting
documents
Mission report; media articles
Contributing to
indicator
SUB-IND 7.1: Number of public-private dialogues/trainings held: 1 Number of recommendations stemming from PPD: 2
103
5. OVERARCHING FOCUS ON TRADE LEARNING AND CAPACITY BUILDING FOR REGIONAL CO-OPERATION THROUGHOUT ALL THE ABOVE COMPONENTS
A focus of this project is to promote trade learning throughout all the above components. The following provides a brief summary the ways in which these are be done (these inputs have also been detailed in the project document in more details).
Overall
- Continuation of project website, which also provides access to ITC Trade Academy.
Output 1 & 2 :
- Capacity building in strategy design and implementation: Staff from MoIC, EPAA learnt ITC’s
Strategy Design and Implementation Management (NES implementation training - Ongoing).
- Skills development strategy completed and integrated into the Main NES document.
Output 3
- Over 300 government and business stakeholders trained in the area of standards, metrology, technical regulations, and WTO TBT and SPS Agreements through in-country and in India trainings.
Output 4
- Implementation of 7 month “Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme”
benefitted 20 Afghan officer.
Output 5
- Workshops on the WTO TFA Agreement and categorization
- Development of train-the-trainer module of ITC’s SME training module on WTO TFA
- Training of 7 trainers to teach on WTO TFA.
Output 6
- Completion of export management guides in Afghanistan to outline all step by step export
procedures to benefit SMEs .
Output 7
- Awareness raising and building common understanding among policymakers and
businesses of trade and investment related issues between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan.
104
6. DIFFICULTIES ENCOUNTERED AND MEASURES TAKEN Overall
Uncertainties in the security situation.
Output 1 & 2
Public sector capacity of key institutions such as MoIC, ANSA, MAIL etc. is definitely restricted and requires
immediate support. While the NES will address institutional deficiencies in detail, the current capacity
challenges are expected to pose some challenges during the NES implementation. ITC will continue to
provide implementation management capacity-building throughout 2018.
In view of potential limiting external and internal factors to the implementation of priority 1 activities during
2018, a priority revision will be carried out. ITC will provide advisory services and technical assistance to
Coordinating bodies to carry out a priority-revision exercise, in light of the aptitudes of appointed lead
institutions and the absorption capacity of the sector itself.
Output 3
Training and advisory services in the area of quality and in particular in SPS require highly specialized
technical expertise. Due to the security situations, many international experts having been contacted by
ITC expressed concern to conduct missions to Afghanistan. Some training such as Lead Auditor Course
would be conducted abroad. ITC will extend the network of experts willing to go to Afghanistan in order to
build more local capacity.
Considering the rapid turn-over at government institutions, the training should target as many technical staff
of an entity as possible in order to ensure sustainability of the capacity developed. Furthermore, the project
is considering some form of binding with the relevant institutions to utilize the capacity and conduct regular
training internally.
Outputs 5 & 6
Some challenges were encountered with regards to the IMCWTF. Inconsistent representation from the
different governmental bodies compromised the integrity of the decision-making process. Private sector
participation was disappointing. Moreover, there was some difficulty in promoting inter-ministerial
collaboration on implementation planning.
ITC staff needs to abide by UNDP’s security recommendations. This causes some challenges in mission
planning.
Output 7
It proved challenging to gain timely final approval of the ANTP five year policy document and also agree
upon next steps to advance forward for implementation. However through ongoing collaboration these
obstacles have been overcome.
Raising awareness and gaining input and support for bilateral PPDs in the diverse capitals of Kabul,
Tashkent and Astana proved challenging. However, through much effort, including leveraging contacts and
supporting an Afghan delegation mission to Tashkent to meet with counterparts, both initiatives have
commenced.
105
7. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE VISIBILITY AND COMMUNICATION PLAN Information below is reported on the basis of the Project Communication and Visibility Plan.
It is to be noted that, under all Outputs, reports, training materials, presentations, event agendas, etc. have
been formatted in line with the project visual templates, as validated by the EU Delegation, for dissemination
to government officials, the private sector, the media, development partners and other stakeholders.
a. Project visibility during the period under reporting AAT Website
Project website is being updated on a regular basis to cover:
Latest news
Outputs activities
Newsletters
Workshop / Trainings / Conferences reports/ articles
Publications
Pictures
Links to further national and regional stakeholders
Additional new sections have been created, including:
Films and interviews
AAT Facebook Group
As of 24 June, 2018, there had been 2,588 page visits and the average time spent by viewers on a page was
2.15 minutes.
Films produced The following were produced:
Afghanistan National Export Strategy film: “Peace through Prosperity, Prosperity through Trade” (including
Short version of 4 minutes and longer version of 8.30 minutes)
One year on- Stakeholder interviews:
o Kamila Siddiqi, Deputy Minister (160 views) o Mr. Atiqullah Nusrat, CEO ACCI (151 views) o Naqibullah Faiq, Director General ANSA (119 views) o Zabihullah Mudabber, WTO Director of MolC, (217 views)
Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme - Advancing Afghan Trade Project (9.30 min)
Trade policy learning participant interviews (2 – 3 minutes):
o Making the most of Afghanistan's WTO accession: Zabihullah Mudabber (Youtube: 150 views) o Gaining new skills for trade-led growth in Afghanistan: Reza Farzam (Youtube: 43 views) o Promoting Afghan trade through WTO rules: Ellaha Shaheen (Youtube: 43 views) o Teaching Afghan trade policy: Ehsan Saadat (119 views)
106
These films were widely distributed through Youtube; ITC – Facebook/Twitter; AAT project website; AAT
quarterly newsletter; AAT Facebook group; local social media; MoIC’s website, etc. For a full media report see
Annex I.
Advancing Afghan Trade - quarterly newsletter
During the reporting period, an additional 4 issues were circulated (August, 2017; November 2017; March
2018 and June 2018), with its main purpose being to introduce the project, its main outputs and some of the
activities completed to date.
It was published and distributed to a mailing list of approximatively 2800 heads/senior executives from more
than 210 unique organization like Ministries, Diplomatic Missions, Commerce Associations, Embassies, SMEs
and many more spanning across 10 different countries including Afghanistan, Brussels, India, Iran,
Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz Republic, Pakistan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan. The mailing list also included
the heads of all European missions based in Kabul. Additionally both ACCI and AWCCI distributed a Dari
translated version of the newsletter to their respective membership basis.
In total there are 4300 recipients of the newsletter (Including - ACCI: 1,000 entrepreneurs; AWCCI: 500 women
entrepreneur; AAT contact list; further sharing with MOIC, MAIL, ANSA and EPAA).
Note: For issue 5, figures are not available as yet and will be provided in the next AAT yearly report.
Press Coverage
The project continued to gain major media attention both within Afghanistan, the region and abroad.
A total of 104 separate media articles were published during the period. Complete versions of the ITC press
releases produced and further media coverage received can be seen in Annex I.
Social media coverage
ITC specific (Twitter and ITC Facebook page) ITC ran 10 social media campaigns to publicise main activities of the project. The tweets were featured on both the ITC corporate Twitter and Facebook pages, and were retweeted on many occasions during the campaigns. For outreach, statistics see Section B below. Facebook group Developed and operating since May 12, 2017. Currently, there are 403 members (up from 144 after the first
year), with many of them being stakeholders drawn from business associations, government and exporters.
Many of them have been involved in our project implementation activities are so well informed on its projects
purpose.
The group is administered by ITC and posts regular updates in regards to project implementation as well as
profiling relevant initiatives, reports completed from other organization in Afghanistan and region.
The group allows for professional networking, awareness raising and sharing of information. For outreach
statistics see Section B below.
Social media coverage – beyond ITC Events and work done by ITC have been appreciated and spread multiple times on the social media profiles
of prominent individuals, including Mohammad Ashraf Ghani, President; Abdullah Abdullah, Chief Executive
Officer, Atiqullah Nusrat, CEO, ACCI; organizations like EUD, MoIC, ACCI, AWCCI.
107
Certificates
Produced and distributed after the trainings organized by the AAT, with logos of all parties, including the EU.
Visibility templates
In use for project banner; publications; PPT backdrop; notebook; brochures, etc. The templates show most
favourable to the project, implementing partners and present a common identity.
Project references
Effort is being undertaken to ensure that the project is referred to. Notably the project will feature in the: 1) ITC Annual Report – 2017 (Including case study story) 2) DEVCO Annual Report AAT project brochure
Widely distributed to the stakeholders at all major events and displayed on project website (versions in English,
Dari and Pashtu).
b. Progress vis-à-vis communication objectives
Tool Indicators
Press release 4 press releases/media advisories produced Number of readers (ITC website): 2,588 Number of media using the press release: 33 different media companies published media regarding the project
Project "newsletter"
Number of issues: 4 Number of subscribers: 4300 (Including - ACCI: 1,000 entrepreneurs; AWCCI: 500 women entrepreneur; AAT contact list; further sharing with MOIC, MAIL, ANSA and EPAA
ITC website; project's website
Number of visits: 2,588 Number of downloads of material: 511
Media channels Number of articles published: 104 press articles/releases published, TV and radio items produced about the project
Information material (leaflet, brochures)
Number of information material:16
Including:
- Supporting Bilateral Stakeholder Consultations to Enhance Trading Relations Between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan: Concept Note (English version)
- Supporting Bilateral Stakeholder Consultations to Enhance Trading Relations Between Afghanistan and Kazakhstan: Concept Note (Russian version)
- Supporting Bilateral Stakeholder Consultations to Enhance Trading Relations Between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan: Concept Note (English version)
108
- Supporting Bilateral Stakeholder Consultations to Enhance Trading Relations Between Afghanistan and Uzbekistan: Concept Note (Russian version)
- Quarterly Snapshot Progress Reports (September - 2017, December – 2017, March – 2018, June – 2018)
- Afghanistan, WTO and International, Trade Programme: Concept note
- Afghanistan National Export Strategy film: “Peace through Prosperity, Prosperity through Trade”
- One year on- Stakeholder interviews:
o Kamila Siddiqi, Deputy Minister
o Atiqullah Nusrat, CEO ACCI
o Naqibullah Faiq, Director General ANSA
o Zabihullah Mudabber, WTO Director of MolC
- Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme - Advancing Afghan Trade Project
- Trade policy learning participant interviews (2 – 3 mins):
o Making the most of Afghanistan's WTO accession: Zabihullah Mudabber
o Gaining new skills for trade-led growth in Afghanistan: Reza Farzam
o Promoting Afghan trade through WTO rules: Ellaha Shaheen (
o Teaching Afghan trade policy: Ehsan Saadat
Social media Twitter / LinkedIn / Facebook:
Twitter / Facebook: Number of posts: 152 Total reach: 1112K people Total engagement: N/A
Facebook group:
New followers (%): 64.26 Followers start: 144 Followers end: 403 Total engagement: N/A
Synergies created between outputs
Synergies between NES, quality management (QM), trade policy (TP), trade facilitation (TF) and new sub-outputs.
The NES offers an overarching framework for creating synergies with other components. Both TF and QM
have their individual crosscutting/trade support function strategy as part of the overall NES.
109
There are also synergies between NES and Output 6 whereby the selection of key export sectors (on which
the guides and trainings will be based) was done in line with the findings of the NES.
The NES informed the design of the following sub-outs which will be implemented under the current AAT
project:
Sub-output 3.1: Quality management – with also a focus on the saffron sector as pilot to reach SMEs
Sub-output 3.2: Building performance: Export Promotion Agency of Afghanistan (EPAA)
Sub-output 3.3:Increase access to finance for Afghan SMEs in the saffron sector.
Sub-output 3.4: Support to “Start-ups and Emerging Entrepreneurs Network” (SEEN) and “young
agripreneurship” in the saffron sector
Sub-output 3.5:Support to the Afghanistan Women Chamber of Commerce and Industry (focus: saffron)
Additionally the ANTP is aligned with NES (Reference is made in the NES to this alignment).
NES design / trade policy and local initiatives Key international development partners were fully apprised on all aspect of the NES design and
implementation phases through Donor Coordination Meetings (USAID, EU, Department for International
Development (DFID), EU, BMZ, GIZ, FAO, UNCTAD, UNAMA) followed by bilateral consultations to make
sure that the NES capitalizes on recent partners’ initiatives. Consensus reached on the need to formalize the
Aid for Trade Coordination Committee and on the fact that the NES framework provides a robust conduit for
joining forces on trade-related issues. This is since it offers national and international development partners
with the proper implementation plan and framework as well as favourable conditions for operation (i.e. political
endorsement, private sector buy-in and donors/IOs collaboration).
The NES is aligned to the policy priorities and national goals established by the Cabinet and the High Economic
Council and firmly supports the work of the NPPs and PriSEC, in areas related to socio-economic growth,
private sector development, regional integration, investment, youth and women economic empowerment.
Similarly, particular attention was placed in aligning the NES with ANTP and post-WTO accession strategy.
Similarly the ANTP is aligned to the NPP on Private Sector Development.
AAT supporting bilateral stakeholder consultations processes with Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan to enhance
trading relations is aligned NPP reform priority #11. These processes, which AAT is supporting MoIC with, can
contribute to Sub-priority 5 bullet point:“(5) Expedite the development of an alternative transit route through
Central Asia by: Reviewing and revising the current bilateral trade and transit agreements with the Central
Asian countries and trying to make them multilateral”. The purposes of these bilateral stakeholder consultations
is to make trading relations between the countries / and beyond through transit smoother. It will focus on
movement of goods / people.
QM Linkages with ITC e-commerce project for China where the AAT project has encouraged to include saffron and
dry fruits. Few saffron companies have been included in buyer-seller meeting and further capacity building
initiatives.
In the effort to build synergies among projects and donors, ITC was invited to develop a proposal for a small
pilot project component aiming at the promotion and commercialisation of packed premium Afghan saffron
towards identified buyers in export markets and a better understanding of the target buyers’ requirements. This
pilot component, if approved, would complement a new large project “Support to agricultural high-value chains
in western Afghanistan” requested by the Ministry of Agriculture, Irrigation and Livestock (MAIL) and Ministry
110
of Finance (MoF) which is proposed to be funded by the Italian Government. This large project would aim to
improve agricultural production, productivity and marketing of agriculture high value-chains such as saffron,
dairy products, grape by approx. 6000 small agro-producers in two provinces of Western Region.
TF Participants to the prioritization and sequencing workshop placed a great deal of emphasis on transparency
measures in the TFA. ITC identified a synergy between the national priorities regarding TFA implementation
(Output 5) and the Export Management Guides developed under Output 6. In order to facilitate the regular
update of Export Management Information, it was decided in principle that the information in the Export
Management Guides should be published online through a Trade Portal to be developed upon request of the
MoIC.
111
8. REQUEST FOR PAYMENT To be submitted at a later stage
9. WORK PLAN FOR YEAR 3
Pierre / Edwin input needed
Afghanistan Afghan Trade Project: EU Trade-related assistance
Upcoming Activities: 1st July 2018 - 30th June 2019
Activities 2018 2019
Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb March April May June
Outcome: The Government formulates and implements better informed trade policy and a strategic vision to support trade competitiveness within the region.
Output 1: Government of Afghanistan owns a national export strategy and action plan that was developed in a consultative process with the private sector, and has started its implementation
Output completed
Activity: Preliminary analysis of trade competitiveness, development agenda, existing trade-related programmes, and key trade support institutions
Activity: NES Pre-engagement mission to support the setup of the NES design structures (Navigator, Core Team, secretariat, etc.) as well as to secure PaP buy-in and support
Activity: Finalize preliminary audits, analysis and formalize NES design structures
Activity: Mapping and assessment of the institutional trade support landscape, including a review of quality and SPS infrastructures
Activity: Inauguration event and first NES Stakeholders’ Consultation to further assess trade performance, initiate sector selection and define national level strategic orientations
Activity: Draft, finalise and translate the Strategic Trade Development Roadmap (Competitiveness assessment, sector and cross-sector selection, strategic orientations & initial recommendations)
Activity: Organise Second Stakeholders Consultation to complete participative value-chain analysis of prioritized sectors and cross-sector functions (incl. Provincial consultations)
Activity: Complete initial strategic recommendations and action matrix
Activity: Organise Third Stakeholders’ Consultation to refine strategic orientations and confirm action plan for the priority sectors and cross-sector functions
Activity: Consolidate, finalise and translate the National Export Strategy document (consolidation, editing, formatting) and its plans of action
Activity: Organise Launching event for official endorsement of the National Export Strategy by the Government of Afghanistan
Output 2: National public and private stakeholders are enabled to manage and coordinate the implementation of the National Export Strategy and mobilise support to implement the validated roadmaps
Activity: Management support to establish and operationalize an effective implementation management framework for successful implementation, tracking and
112
measurement and mobilisation of support for the implementation of the NES action plans (NES Coordination mechanism)
Activity: Support the MoCI and other stakeholders with capacity- building trainings, direct support and tools on NES implementation planning, management techniques and resource mobilisation, including a particular focus on the implementation of quality & standards related solutions.
Output 3. Priority interventions identified during the National Export Strategy design process are implemented to improve regional integration and international trade competitiveness
Activity: Implementation of priority interventions identified in the NES design process, potentially linked to market profiles, trade intelligence, trade visits, B2B meetings, etc.
Activity: Advisory services to ANSA to develop services (standards, certification, training centre) and other Ministries and TSIs to implement priorities in the quality and SPS areas
Sub-activity: 3.1: Quality management – with also
a focus on the saffron sector as pilot to reach SMEs
Sub-activity: 3. 2: Building performance: Export Promotion Agency of Afghanistan (EPPA) Note: Focus will be on strengthening of EPAA’S role in leading the implementation management of the NES Afghanistan – which links this intervention to Output 2
Sub-activity 3.3: Increase access to finance for Afghan SMEs in the saffron sector.
Sub-output 3.4: Support to “Start-ups and
Emerging Entrepreneurs Network” (SEEN) and “young agripreneurship” in the saffron sector
Sub-output 3.5: Support to the Afghanistan
Women Chamber of Commerce and Industry (focus: saffron)
Output 4: Knowledge sharing mechanisms for GIRoA staff on trade policy/negotiation formulation and implementation are established in partnership with a training institute from the Region
Activity: Needs assessment for trade capacity building of MoCI and governmental agencies is conducted
Activity completed
Activity: Governmental officers training programme is designed and implemented
Activity: Training modules on trade policy are developed in cooperation with Afghan Universities
Output 5: Institutional mechanisms to facilitate the implementation of the TFA are established at national level and linked with regional partners
Activity: Support the implementation of the WTO TFA through technical advisory services to IMCWTF and other government agencies
113
Activity: Support the capacity building and operationalization of IMCWTF and other public sector agencies to implement the WTF TFA
Activity: Increase awareness of private stakeholders on the TFA and their ability to contribute to TFA related PPD within the IMCWTF and other fora
Activity: Structure and facilitate a regional network of (existing) National Trade Facilitation Committees to encourage experience sharing as well as a coordinated and harmonized approach towards the implementation of the TFA
Output 6: SME knowledge of how to manage national cross-border procedures and compliance with regional and/or global market requirements is built encompassing priority markets (building on NES findings)
Activity: Conduct needs assessment of SME export management and compliance training and information requirements
Activity completed
Activity: Develop, publish and disseminate a National Trade Procedures Guide for SMEs and entrepreneurs, in print as well as online
Activity: Develop SME export management and compliance training curriculum with a blended learning approach (i.e. face-to-face sessions complemented by on the job coaching)
Activity: Train the trainers to facilitate e-learning session and to deliver face-to-face trainings
Activity completed
Activity: Organize and facilitate the delivery of four full curriculum (e-learning modules and face-to-face modules)
Output 7: Public-private consultation process on domestic/regional key pressing trade policy/regulatory/ negotiation issues is strengthened
Activity: Needs assessment for the operationalization of a PPD platform on trade policy is conducted
Activity completed
Activity: Research materials/position papers through peer review (whenever local capacity exists) are produced
Activity: Public private dialogue on policy /regulatory issues (bilateral/regional)
Activity: Training of private sector organizations on issues to be further addressed through public private consultations are organized
Activity: Advisory services
114
ANNEX I: MEDIA REPORT: 1 JULY 2017 – 30 JUNE 2018
OVERALL9
PROJECT QUARTERLY NEWSLETTERS
Second project newsletter o http://www.intracen.org/uploadedFiles/intracenorg/Content/Redesign/Projects/AAT/Newslett
er02.pdf
Third project newsletter
o http://www.intracen.org/uploadedFiles/intracenorg/Content/Redesign/Projects/AAT/Advancin
g%20Afghan%20Trade%20-%20Newsletter%20Issue%203.pdf
Forth project newsletter
o http://www.intracen.org/uploadedFiles/intracenorg/Content/Redesign/Projects/AAT/Advancin
gAfghanTrade-NewsletterIssue4.pdf
Fifth project newsletter
o Produced. To be distributed early July, 2018
KEY FIGURE INTERVIEWS: AAT PROJECT ONE YEAR ON
Kamila Sidiqi, Deputy Minister of Commerce interview
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6qIjpnfKDb0
Atiqullah Nusrat, CEO ACCI, Interview
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_6m3Xo3Pnc&feature=youtu.be
Zabihullah Muddaber, WTO Director of MOCI, Interview
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oe2bj18djJA&feature=youtu.be
Mr. Naqibullah Faiq, Director General ANSA, Interview
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SJdC3QgwrT4
Mr Hashim Aslami, Saffron Advisor, Ministry of Agriculture, Irrigation and Livestock (MAIL)
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vAbdWdBY1k0&feature=youtu.be
FIRST AAT PSC MEETING, KABUL, 31 JULY, 2017
Pajhwok
9 Note – immense coverage of the project was received on social media forums such as Facebook and Twitter, but will not be displayed here due to difficulties in accurately reporting this information. For more information on AAT social media coverage see section VII above.
115
Progress in Afghanistan regional trade reviewed Pajhwok.com
o https://www.pajhwok.com/en/2017/08/03/progress-afghanistan-regional-trade-reviewed
Wasdam
Private, public sector meet to review progress in reconnecting Afghanistan to regional markets
Wasdam.com
o http://wadsam.com/afghan-business-news/private-public-sector-meet-review-progress-
reconnecting-afghanistan-regional-markets-232/
EUD
Private, public sector meet to review progress in reconnecting Afghanistan to regional markets
o https://eeas.europa.eu/ https://eeas.europa.eu/delegations/afghanistan/30702/private-
public-sector-meet-review-progress-reconnecting-afghanistan-regional-markets_en
ITC
Private, public sector meet to review progress in reconnecting Afghanistan to regional markets
o http://www.intracen.org/news/Private-public-sector-meet-to-review-progress-in-
reconnecting-Afghanistan-to-regional-markets/
WASDAM
یبرا خصوصی سکتور و دولت فتیپ بررسی شر یزارهابا با افغانستان دوباره اتصال یمنطقو کند می ملاقات
http://dari.wadsam.com/ http://dari.wadsam.com/%D8%AF%D9%88%D9%84%D8%AA-%D9%88-
%D8%B3%DA%A9%D8%AA%D9%88%D8%B1-%D8%AE%D8%B5%D9%88%D8%B5%DB%8C-
%D8%A8%D8%B1%D8%A7%DB%8C-%D8%A8%D8%B1%D8%B1%D8%B3%DB%8C-
%D9%BE%DB%8C%D8%B4%D8%B1%D9%81%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D8%AA/
INTERNATIONAL TRADE FORUM MAGAZINE (ITC)
Afghanistan: enabling trade for economic growth and regional cooperation, 27 Oct. 2017
o http://www.tradeforum.org/news/Afghanistan-enabling-trade-for-economic-growth-and-
regional-cooperation/
ITC ANNUAL REPORT
Various references and article “Laying the policy groundwork to advance Afghan trade”
o http://www.intracen.org/uploadedFiles/intracen.org/Content/About_ITC/Corporate_Docume
nts/Annual-Report-2017-web.pdf
RECCA VII
Speech by ITC Executive Director at Regional Economic Cooperation Conference on Afghanistan
Recca VII
http://www.intracen.org/news/Speech-by-ITC-Executive-Director-at-Regional-Economic-Cooperation-
Conference-on-Afganistan-Recca-VII/
o https://youtu.be/Opmn5W4izl8
116
OUTPUT 1 & 2
Film of initiative
Afghanistan National Export Strategy film: “Peace through Prosperity, Prosperity through Trade”
https://youtu.be/f55dacQVwSU
NES LAUNCH, SAPIDAR PALACE, KABUL, 10 JUNE 2018
Delegation of the European Union to Afghanistan
Afghanistan Launches National Export Strategy
o https://eeas.europa.eu/delegations/afghanistan/46213/afghanistan-launches-national-
export-strategy_en
MoIC:
H.E. Minster Rasaw met with the Executive Director of ITC
o http://moci.gov.af/fa/news/138691
H.E. Deputy Minister Sidiqi met with the Executive Director of ITC
o http://moci.gov.af/fa/news/138690
NES in the News:
National TV News June 10th 2018:
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FBzt9ZB4sU0
o (NES News from 13:43 – 17:43)
Tolo TV 6 PM News June 10th 2018:
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wg64ivX7AE
o (NES news from 19:20 – 22:05 minutes)
Shamshad TV News June 10th 2018:
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Eo85rKHMhL4
o (NES News from 33:18 – 35:47 minutes)
Ariana TV News June 10th 2018:
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bqw1Y2SiTBk
o (NES News from 16:47 – 19:10)
BBC Farsi: NES Implementation Started
o http://www.bbc.com/persian/afghanistan-44430292
ToloNews (Eng): New Export Strategy Aims To Rectify Trade Balance Deficit
o https://www.tolonews.com/business/new-export-strategy-aims-rectify-trade-balance-deficit
Hushdar News (Dari): NES is operation onwards
o https://www.hushdar.com/2018/06/10/afghanistan-national-export-strategy/
Daily Afghanistan Ma (Dari): NES has been launched to empower country exports
o http://www.dailyafghanistan.com/national_detail.php?post_id=143822
117
Azhance Afghan Khabar (Dari): NES launched
o http://afkhabar.com/%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA%DB%8C%
DA%98%DB%8C-%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-
%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%AF%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA-
%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%BA%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%A7%D9%86-
%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%AA%D8%AA%D8%A7%D8%AD-
%DA%AF%D8%B1%D8%AF%DB%8C%D8%AF
The Times of Central Asia (Eng): Afghanistan launches National Export Strategy with EU support
o https://www.timesca.com/index.php/news/19857-afghanistan-launches-national-export-
strategy-with-eu-support
Afghapaper (Dari): CEO in NES Launching Ceremony
o http://afghanpaper.com/nbody.php?id=151851
DidPress (Dari) Implementation of NES is very important for reducing the Poverty, Unemployment
and a for sustainable peace:
o https://didpress.com/%D8%B9%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-%D8%B4%D8%AF%D9%86-
%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA%DA%98%DB%8C-
%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-
%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%AF%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA%D8%8C-%D8%AF%D8%B1-
%DA%A9%D8%A7%D9%87%D8%B4-%D9%81/
Shafaqna (Dari) A step towards increasing Afghanistan ’s export, NES is operational.
o http://af.shafaqna.com/FA/0210650
Implementation of National Exports Strategy To Reduce Poverty, Unemployment In Afghanistan,
CE
o http://www.bakhtarnews.com.af/eng/business/item/33528-implementation-of-national-
exports-strategy-to-reduce-poverty-unemployment-in-afghanistan-ce.html
Afganistán tiene muchas oportunidades para aumentar exportaciones, según ITC
o http://www.hoy.es/agencias/201806/12/afganistan-tiene-muchas-oportunidades-
1211190.html
- Afganistán tiene muchas oportunidades para aumentar exportaciones, según ITC
o http://www.larioja.com/agencias/201806/12/afganistan-tiene-muchas-oportunidades-
1211190.html
Afganistán tiene muchas oportunidades para aumentar exportaciones, según ITC
o https://www.elconfidencial.com/ultima-hora-en-vivo/2018-06-12/afganistan-tiene-muchas-
oportunidades-para-aumentar-exportaciones-segun-itc_1544620/
Afghanistan launches National Export Strategy
o http://www.portugalglobal.pt/PT/PortugalNews/Paginas/NewDetail.aspx?newId=%7B56C2
DDD5-F6E5-4E49-9878-D2FEA13A6B2E%7D
Afghanistan launches National Export Strategy
o http://menafn.com/1097001546/Afghanistan-launches-National-Export-Strategy
Afganistán tiene muchas oportunidades para aumentar exportaciones, según ITC
o http://www.finanzas.com/noticias/economia/20180612/afganistan-tiene-muchas-
oportunidades-3859098.html
118
Implementation of national exports strategy to reduce poverty, unemployment in Afghanistan, CE
o https://www.facebook.com/thekabultimes/photos/a.1431054987142018.1073741828.1430
742150506635/2102388510008659/?type=3&theater
CM Meeting: Dr. Abdullah Praises ANDSF Performance
o http://www.bakhtarnews.com.af/eng/politics/item/33549-cm-meeting-dr-abdullah-praises-
andsf-performance.html
ITC Website
- Afghanistan launches National Export Strategy
o http://www.intracen.org/news/Afghanistan-launches-National-Export-Strategy/
ITC Executive Director speech at the launch of the Afghanistan’s National Export Strategy
o http://www.intracen.org/news/ITC-Executive-Director-speech-at-the-launch-of-
Afghanistans-National-Export-Strategy/
NATIONAL EXPORT STRATEGY ENDORSEMENT, PRESIDENTIAL PALACE, 03 APRIL KABUL
High Economic Council (HEC) approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o https://president.gov.af/fa/2018/04/03/4318
MOCI:
HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy (MOCI’s website)
o http://moci.gov.af/fa/news/1385633
European Union Delegation – Afghanistan:
61) President Ghani endorses Afghan national export strategy (EUD Website)
o https://eeas.europa.eu/headquarters/headquarters-homepage/42638/node/42638_pt
ITC:
ITC website:
o http://www.intracen.org/news/Afghan-government-endorses-development-of-export-
strategy/
The endorsement of NES on Media (National and International news Agencies):
HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy (Kabul Times)
o http://thekabultimes.gov.af/index.php/newsnational/16843-hec-approves-afghanistan-
national-exports-strategy.html
Azadi Radio: HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o https://da.azadiradio.com/a/29144783.html
Sana News Agency: HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o http://sana.af/%D8%A7%D9%82%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%AF%DB%8C/%D8%A
7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA%DA%98%DB%8C-
%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%AF%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA-
119
%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%BA%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%A7%D9%86-
%D8%AA%D8%B5%D9%88%DB%8C%D8%A8-%D8%B4/
Khabarnegaran Jawan News: HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o https://www.yjc.ir/fa/news/6489648/%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%
AA%DA%98%DB%8C-%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-
%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%AF%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA-
%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%BA%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%A7%D9%86-
%D8%A8%D9%87-%D8%AA%D8%B5%D9%88%DB%8C%D8%A8-
%D8%B1%D8%B3%DB%8C%D8%AF
Afghanpaper.com: HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o http://www.afghanpaper.com/nbody.php?id=149296
Sada-e-Afghan (Ava): HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o http://www.avapress.com/fa/news/161179/%D8%AA%D8%B5%D9%88%DB%8C%D8%A
8-%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA%DA%98%D9%8A-
%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%AF%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA-
%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%BA%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%A7%D9%86
Did News Agency: HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o https://didpress.com/23843-2/
Fars News Agency: Ghani Introduced Afghanistan National Export Strategy
o http://af.farsnews.com/politics/news/13970115000199
Pajhwok News Agency: Afghanistan National Export Strategy Endorsed
o https://www.pajhwok.com/dr/2018/04/03/%D8%A7%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%B1%D8%A7
%D8%AA%DB%8C%DA%98%DB%8C-%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-
%D8%B5%D8%A7%D8%AF%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA-
%D8%A7%D9%81%D8%BA%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AA%D8%A7%D9%86-
%D8%AA%D8%B5%D9%88%DB%8C%D8%A8-%D8%B4%D8%AF
HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o http://rta.org.af/eng/2018/04/04/hec-approves-afghanistan-national-exports-strategy/
HEC approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o https://baztab.news/article/562343
HEC Approves Afghanistan National Exports Strategy
o http://www.bakhtarnews.com.af/eng/business/item/32629-hec-approves-afghanistan-
national-exports-strategy.html
MEDIA COVERAGE FOR NATIONAL EXPORT STRATEGY KEY MEETINGS (PRISEC & COUNSEL OF MINISTERS) TO ADVANCE PLAN (27 NOVEMBER, KABUL) Local media Wadsam newspaper
120
Afghanistan eyes greater participation in regional trade
o http://wadsam.com/afghan-business-news/afghanistan-eyes-greater-participation-regional-
trade-232/
Anis newspaper:
The PRiSEC meeting held at CEO Abdullah Abdullah Office (Qasr-e-Spdar), In presence of
Representatives from Government Offices and International Organizations. (Article is in Dari, News
about the NES)
o http://dailies.gov.af/site/anis/anis/economic3/43490-%D9%86%D8%B4%D8%B3%D8%AA-
%DA%A9%D9%85%DB%8C%D8%AA%D9%87-
%D8%A7%D8%AC%D8%B1%D8%A7%DB%8C%DB%8C-
%D8%B3%DA%A9%D8%AA%D9%88%D8%B1-
%D8%AE%D8%B5%D9%88%D8%B5%DB%8C-
%D8%A8%D8%B1%DA%AF%D8%B2%D8%A7%D8%B1-%D8%B4%D8%AF.html
17th PRiSEC Meeting Held (Article is in Dari)
o http://ceo.gov.af/fa/news/380178
- Coverage for both National Trade Policy and National Export Strategy (mentioned together)
4 Traders
International Trade Centre: Major strides made towards Afghan export strategy and trade policy
o http://www.intracen.org/Major-strides-made-towards-Afghan-export-strategy-and-trade-
policy/
Daily Outlook Afghanistan
Major strides made towards Afghan export strategy and trade policy
o http://www.4-traders.com/news/ITC-International-Trade-Centre-Major-strides-made-towards-
Afghan-export-strategy-and-trade-policy--25580198/
o
Outlookafghanistan
Export Strategy, Trade Policy Clear 2 Major Hurdles
o http://www.outlookafghanistan.net/national_detail.php?post_id=19571
o
Portugal Global
Major strides made towards Afghan export strategy and trade policy
o http://www.portugalglobal.pt/PT/PortugalNews/Paginas/NewDetail.aspx?newId=%7B9582A6
9C-905E-49C4-BBCF-58B8CEE7BB71%7D
MENA
Afghanistan eyes greater participation in regional trade
o http://menafn.com/1096157795/Afghanistan-eyes-greater-participation-in-regional-trade
NES STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATON, 13 AUGUST, HERAT,
121
Consultation held in Herat to discuss trade challenges & opportunitism
o http://wadsam.com/afghan-business-news/consultation-held-herat-discuss-trade-challenges-
opportunities/
Herat province explore ways forward for Afghanistan’s National Export Strategy
o https://eeas.europa.eu/delegations/afghanistan_en/31117/Herat%20province%20explore%2
0ways%20forward%20for%20Afghanistan%E2%80%99s%20National%20Export%20Strate
gy
Afghanistan: consultation held in Herat City to discuss international trade challenges
o https://ivotoniut.blogspot.ch/
Afghanistan’s NES consultation held in Herat
o http://www.iaccim.com/
o http://www.iaccim.com/index.php/2014-11-15-05-52-18/2015-05-01-02-45-42/770-2017-08-
14-11-30-09
Afghanistan has 90% of imports and 10% of exports
o http://8am.af/
o http://8am.af/1396/05/23/afghanistan-has-90-of-imports-and-10-of-exports/
Afghanistan’s NES consultation held in Herat
o http://www.avapress.com/vdcepv8zfjh8ezi.b9bj.html
Herat province explore ways forward for Afghanistan’s National Export Strategy
o http://www.intracen.org/news/
o http://www.intracen.org/news/Herat-province-explore-ways-forward-for-Afghanistans-
National-Export-Strategy/
OUTPUT 4
AFGHANISTAN, WTO AND INTERNATIONAL TRADE PROGRAMME
Film of initiative
Afghanistan, WTO and International Trade Programme - Advancing Afghan Trade Project
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TF_isTDI4YU&feature=youtu.be
Participant interviews:
Making the most of Afghanistan's WTO accession: Zabihullah Mudabber
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G7QKFbJBWng&index=5&t=0s&list=PLqTcg0La86zio3i8
8DynfL5X4kT0Wm7Me
Gaining new skills for trade-led growth in Afghanistan: Reza Farzam
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfZhIQOyf9c&t=0s&list=PLqTcg0La86zio3i88DynfL5X4k
T0Wm7Me&index=7
Promoting Afghan trade through WTO rules: Ellaha Shaheen
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YvSXWB5DOkI&t=0s&list=PLqTcg0La86zio3i88DynfL5X
4kT0Wm7Me&index=6
Teaching Afghan trade policy: Ehsan Saadat
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H_dtgqEEXsE&t=0s&list=PLqTcg0La86zio3i88DynfL5X4
kT0Wm7Me&index=8
ITC
122
Building trade policy capacity in Afghanistan through triangular cooperation
o http://www.intracen.org/news/Building-trade-policy-capacity-in-Afghanistan-through-
triangular-cooperation/
New training programme for Afghan trade officials kicks off in New Delhi
o http://www.intracen.org/news/New-training-programme-for-Afghan-trade-officials-kicks-off-in-
New-Delhi/
Embassy of Afghanistan in New Delhi, India
Ministry of Commerce and Industry Officials' Capacity Building at World Trade Study Centre in New
Delhi
o http://newdelhi.mfa.af/media-center-4/news/1026-ministry-of-commerce-and-industry-
employees-capacity-building-at-world-trade-study-centre-in-new-delhi
Centre for WTO studies
Inauguration of Trade Capacity Building for Afghanistan under CWS-ITC Project from CWS/IIFT
o http://wtocentre.iift.ac.in/pdf/Press%20Release%20CWS-
ITC%20Afghan%20Programme%20091017.pdf
ITC
New training programme for Afghan trade officials kicks off in New Delhi, 17 Oct. 2017
o http://www.intracen.org/news/New-training-programme-for-Afghan-trade-officials-kicks-off-in-
New-Delhi/
Embassy of the Republic of Afghanistan, India
Ministry of Commerce and Industry Officials' Capacity Building at World Trade Study Centre in New
Delhi
o http://newdelhi.mfa.af/media-center-4/news/1026-ministry-of-commerce-and-industry-
employees-capacity-building-at-world-trade-study-centre-in-new-delhi
CWS
Inauguration of Trade Capacity Building for Afghanistan Under CWS-ITC Project
http://wtocentre.iift.ac.in/pdf/Press%20Release%20CWS-
ITC%20Afghan%20Programme%20091017.pdf
OUTPUT 5 & 6
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE WTO TRADE FACILITATION AGREEMENT
European Union External Action – Press release
Afghan Government and private sector working together to implement the WTO Trade Facilitation
Agreement with support from EU and ITC
o https://eeas.europa.eu/headquarters/headquarters-homepage/44791/afghan-government-
and-private-sector-working-together-implement-wto-trade-facilitation_en
123
OUTPUT 7
AFGHANISTAN AND UZBEKISTAN STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION TO ENHANCE TRADING
RELATIONS (20, JUNE, TERMIZ, UZBEKISTAN)
ToloNews:
TOLOnews 6pm News 22 June 2018 (PPD News from 18:53 – 21:30 minutes)
o https://youtu.be/KQBWN_cpkdA?t=1138
Afghanistan, Uzbekistan To Establish Free Trade Zone
o https://www.tolonews.com/business/afghanistan-uzbekistan-establish-free-trade-zone
ENN Uzbekistan:
Uzbekistan and Afghanistan to hold the first round of dialogue between public and private sectors
o https://expats.news/uz/uzbekistan-and-afghanistan-to-hold-the-first-round-of-dialogue-
between-public-and-private-sectors/
Uzbekistan National News Agency:
Businessmen of Uzbekistan and Afghanistan meet in Termez
o http://uza.uz/en/business/businessmen-of-uzbekistan-and-afghanistan-meet-in-termez-20-
06-2018
The Time of Central Asia:
Afghanistan and Uzbekistan to set up free trade zone
o https://www.timesca.com/index.php/news/19914-afghanistan-and-uzbekistan-to-set-up-free-
trade-zone
European Union:
European Union supports advancing trade between Uzbekistan and Afghanistan
o https://eeas.europa.eu/delegations/uzbekistan/46925/european-union-supports-advancing-
trade-between-uzbekistan-and-afghanistan_en
NATIONAL TRADE POLICY STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATION, 25 NOVEMBER, KABUL
Tolo news
Draft Five-Year Trade Policy Set To Be Finalized
o http://www.tolonews.com/business/draft-five-year-trade-policy-set-be-finalized
TV Dari News (ANTP news from 17:56 – 20:31 mins)
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKi7pcDTXyg
TV BAZAR program
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-OLGyUKmZ9Y
Shamshad
Shamshad TV Pashto news at 12 (ANTP news from 8:10 – 10:15 mins)
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KgvBpHE8sx4
124
Arianna TV
Arianna TV News 6pm (ANTP news from 17:48 – 20:23 min)
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GJAtCLsaoLI
1TV News
1TV News 6pm (ANTP news from 19:54 – 23:24 min)
o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_JS4kt8NlHs
ANTP in Local News (news agencies websites)
o Afghanistan makes ANTP to get connected with International Markets (Azadi Radio Pashto
News)
azadiradio
Afghanistan makes ANTP to get connected with International Markets (Azadi Radio Dari News)
o https://da.azadiradio.com/a/28876347.html
Jamhor News Agency
Afghanistan National Trade Policy Introduced (Jamhor News Agency, Article in Dari)
o http://www.jomhornews.com/fa/news/99459/
Bakhtarnews
Afghanistan National Trade Policy Presented to Consultation (Article by Bakhtarnews in Dari)
o http://www.bakhtarnews.com.af/dari/business/item/89142-
%D9%BE%D8%A7%D9%84%DB%8C%D8%B3%DB%8C-%D9%85%D9%84%DB%8C-
%D8%AA%D8%AC%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%AA-%D8%A8%D9%87-
%D9%86%D8%B8%D8%B1-%D8%AE%D9%88%D8%A7%D9%87%DB%8C-
%DA%AF%D8%B0%D8%A7%D8%B4%D8%AA%D9%87-%D8%B4%D8%AF.html
- Coverage for both National Trade Policy and National Export Strategy (mentioned together)
4 Traders
International Trade Centre: Major strides made towards Afghan export strategy and trade policy
o http://www.intracen.org/Major-strides-made-towards-Afghan-export-strategy-and-trade-
policy/
Daily Outlook Afghanistan
Major strides made towards Afghan export strategy and trade policy
o http://www.4-traders.com/news/ITC-International-Trade-Centre-Major-strides-made-towards-
Afghan-export-strategy-and-trade-policy--25580198/
o
Outlookafghanistan
Export Strategy, Trade Policy Clear 2 Major Hurdles
o http://www.outlookafghanistan.net/national_detail.php?post_id=19571
o
Portugal Global
125
Major strides made towards Afghan export strategy and trade policy
o http://www.portugalglobal.pt/PT/PortugalNews/Paginas/NewDetail.aspx?newId=%7B9582A6
9C-905E-49C4-BBCF-58B8CEE7BB71%7D
MENA
Afghanistan eyes greater participation in regional trade
o http://menafn.com/1096157795/Afghanistan-eyes-greater-participation-in-regional-trade
top related