the competition commission of mauritius

Application of the Act to the Food Retailing Sector

20/April/2016

Sailesh RAMYEAD

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

The Retail Sector

Retail

About 22,586

licences *

Wholesale & Retail- 10%

of GDP

>10% CCM INV

F& B > 38% of

basket **

* As per CSO Statistics as at 2012, includes Retail sale in non specialised store(foodstuff predominant) and

Other retail sale in non-specialised stores (non-foodstuff predominant)

** Includes food, beverages, tobacco

Caution!Does not

mean relevant market

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

The Retail Sector

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

RBP HARM TO RETAILERS

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Harm to Retailers

[Examples]

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Collusion harm to

retailers

Price fixing

• Suppliers fix the price of their products

• Retailers cannot bargain

• Reduce margin of retailers

• Limit discounts to retailers

Market allocation

• Suppliers divide markets geographically

• Suppliers divide market in other ways

• Volume (e.g. small packs/large packs)

• Retail outlets (e.g. hypermarkets/supermarkets...)

• Again no bargaining

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Margin squeeze

Strategy for vertically integrated dominant firms (operate in both upstream and downstream)

• Suppliers/distributors and their clients (retailers) are competitors

• The strategy is to reduce the profit margin of competitors that are both customers of the dominant firm and rivals on the market for the derived product

• Charging a high price for the input and/or charging a low price for the derived product

• The anti competitive effects are the risks of foreclosure of equally efficient competitors whose access to the market is eliminated or hampered

• An equally efficient firm will be unable to compete in the downstream market on a lasting basis

• The competitors of the dominant firm cannot trade profitably in the downstream market on a sustainable basis

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Exclusive dealing/rebates

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Tying

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Refusal to Supply

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

RBP BY RETAILERS

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Retailers as buyers

• Monopoly situation – supply or acquire

• Retailers as buyers – acquire

• If > 30 or 3 retailers above 70% in acquisition market

– monopoly situation (monopsony)

• Monopsonists can breach CA if engage in conducts:

• has the object or effect of preventing, restricting or

distorting competition [in acquisition market]; or

• in any other way constitutes exploitation of the monopoly

situation

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Retailers as buyers

• The UK and EU conducted Sector Enquiries in Retail

Sector

• Generally found competition to exist to benefit of

consumers

• However found that few supermarkets to control the

market

• Buyer power was the main issue

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Joint Purchases

• Otherwise independent retailers purchase jointly

• May fall within:

• Horizontal agreements (fix purchase price):

• Section 41 - collusive

• Section 44 – non-collusive

• May also fall within merger provision

• If change in ownership and control

• Impact on competition must be taken into account

• If the group sets the selling price may also amount to price fixing

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Private Brands

• Retailer’s own brand

• Can be beneficial to competition and consumers

• Can increase inter-brand competition

• Can be cheaper and offer choice to consumers

• However, retailer must ensure not to unduly favour private

brands to the detriment of other brands

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Exclusive distribution

• Only one or few dealers authorised to sell the

product

• Exclusivity by dominant buyer!

• Need to balance the effects on competition

• On one hand can increase inter-brand competition

• On the other hand can reduce intra-brand

competition

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Resale Price Maintenance (RPM)

• Agreement between seller and reseller to fix price

• Maximum price permissible

• Minimum, fixed price and price range prohibited

• Breach by object or effect

• Reseller (dealer) would be party

• Dealer can also be found to breach the Act and be

fined

• Can lead to horizontal agreements

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Resale Price Maintenance (RPM)

• Price recommendation permitted

• However, the words ‘Recommended Price’ must

appear on the product if the price appears

• Dealer’s role

• Recommended price must NOT be binding: e.g

incentive to abide by recommended price

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Other matters

• Loyalty rebates

• Shelf space allocation

• Associations

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Cases

• Kraft Cheese

• Retroactive rebates

• Preferential shelf space

• Effect of exclusive dealing

• Supply of coolers by PBL and QBL

• Lack of space in small shops

• Effects of exclusive dealing

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Dos and Don’ts

• Do• Conduct compliance programme

• Be careful in dealing with sensitive information with

suppliers if you are also active upstream

• Take advise before entering in exclusive agreements

• Don’t • Discuss price or sensitive information with competitors

• Impose price for supplier to charge smaller outlets

• Accept products with resale price set by supplier without

words ‘recommended price’

• Abuse of your buyer power

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

Questions

COMPETITION COMMISSION OF MAURITIUS

www.ccm.mu