the emerging frontiers of risk management: today’s norms and expectations
Post on 07-Apr-2018
221 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
1/38
FJET GBG V~kfeil Zk~ozp
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
2/38
Pbk Kgkzhemh Azompekzv o Zevc Gimihkgkmp
PO@IUV MOZGV IM@ KR^KFPIPEOMV
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
3/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Pkm ukizv iho, j{vemkvvkv im` emqkvpozv kmpkzk` i `kfi`k o
xzkmfbemh fbimhk- Kmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp "KZG% xiv i
zklipeqklu {m`kqklo~k` kl` pbkm, im` kx j{vemkvvkv bi` pbk
~olefekv im` ~zifpefkv mkk`k` po ~zopkfp pbkez vpickbol`kzv
zog pbk kkfpv o pbk vkqkzk mimfeil im` kfomogef fzevkv
o :>>2 im` :>>5- Vemfk pbkm, pbk oqkzill vpipk o zki`emkvv
biv eg~zoqk`- J{p mkx fbillkmhkv fompem{k po kgkzhk kqkzu
`iu, im` v{z~zevkv izk vpell ~ovvejlk- Box xkll ~zk~izk` ev uo{z
fog~imu oz pbk zevcv, kr~kfpipeomv, im` vpzkvvkv om empkzmil
fompzolv pbip lek ibki`? Pbev zk~ozp xell bkl~ uo{ {m`kzvpim`
box uo{z fog~imu fog~izkv xepb opbkzv im` xbip vpk~v uo{
fim pick mox po eg~zoqk pbk xiu uo{ gimihk zevcv-
I @kfi`k o Go{mpemh Kr~kfpipeomv
Pbk mozgv im` kr~kfpipeomv oz zevc gimihkgkmp biqk kqolqk`
oqkz pbk ~ivp `kfi`k iv i zkv{lp o fbimhemh kfomogef im`
j{vemkvv fom`epeomv pbip xkzk xkll'~{jlefetk` ju pbk gk`ei-
Vogk o pbk gk`ei zk~ozpv {klk` i vkmvk o ~{jlef o{pzihk oqkz
vehmefimp lovvkv `{k po {mkr~kfpk` zevcv- Xepb kifb xiqk o
o{pzihk figk gozk fillv oz mo v{z~zevkv olloxk` ju zo{m`v
o h{e`imfk, zkh{lipozu zkozgv, im` kmozfkgkmp ifpeomv- Pbk
zkozgv im` h{e`imfk ~kick` poxiz` pbk km` o pbk `kfi`k,
bkl~emh fog~imekv po m` jkppkz xiuv po gkkp pbk go{mpemh
kr~kfpipeomv o emqkvpozv, f{vpogkzv, fzk`ep zipemh ihkmfekv,
zkh{lipozv, im` opbkzv ill o xbog izk `kgim`emh behbkz
vpim`iz`v o hoqkzmimfk, zevc gimihkgkmp im` fog~leimfk-
Gelkvpomkv om pbk Zoi` po Jkppkz Zevc Gimihkgkmp
:>9::>9>:>>2:>>1:>>0:>>::>>>9552
Kqkmpv im`
Pzkm`v
Zkozgv im`
H{e`imfk
VOR
FOVO KZG
VKF Z{lk'Hoqkzmimfk ! Zevc
Fzk`ep zipemhv of{v om KZG
@o``'Azimc Ifp
FOVO Vgillkz^{jlef Fog~imekv Gozk FOVO Vp{`ekv
9
:
6
0
Azi{`, joiz`oqkzvehbp, CZEv
2
8
1
;
Aiel{zkv o mimfeil emvpep{peomv im` i
mkiz gklp'`oxm o mimfeil vuvpkgv
lk` po fzepefevgv o jimcv jom{v ~limv
oz kmfo{zihemh {m`{k zevc'picemh-
Fzk`ep pehbpkmemh lk` po
kfomogef zkfkvveom im`givveqk vpofc gizckp lovvkv-
Aemimfeil zk~ozpemh im` j{vemkvv
vfim`ilv zkv{lpk` em pbk
foz~ozipk gklp`oxmv o Kmzom
im` opbkz fog~imekv-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
4/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Gelkvpomkv om pbk Zoi` po Jkppkz Zevc Gimihkgkmp "fompem{k`%
Cku po zkozgv im` h{e`imfk
9 Fomhzkvv kmifpk` pbk Vizjimkv'Orlku Ifp o :>>: "VOR%,
empzo`{femh mkx Empkzmil fompzol zk~ozpemh zky{ezkgkmpv-
9
: FOVO ~{jlevbk` Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Gimihkgkmp'Empkhzipk`
Azigkxozc' im kr~imveom o pbk FOVO Empkzmil Fompzol'
Empkhzipk` Azigkxozc ~{jlevbk` em pbk 955>v-
6 FOVO ~{jlevbk` Empkzmil Fompzol oqkz Aemimfeil
Zk~ozpemh ' H{e`imfk oz Vgillkz ^{jlef Fog~imekv-
0 Gidoz fzk`ep zipemh ihkmfekv Vpim`iz` ! ^oozv im`
Goo`uv empkmvek` pbkez zkqekxv o zevc gimihkgkmp
~zohzigv kg~louk` ju jopb mimfeil im` mommimfeil
fog~imekv- V!^ ~{jlevbk` ~zohzkvv zk~ozpv om
empkhzipemh KZG Imiluvev empo zipemhv-
; Mkx VKF z{lkv pooc kkfp oz pbk :>9> ~zoru vkivom,
zkv{lpemh em zky{ezk` `evflov{zkv ijo{p pbk zolk o pbk
joiz` o `ezkfpozv em zevc oqkzvehbp, iv xkll iv imu
fog~kmvipeom ~olefekv im` ~zifpefkv pbip ~zkvkmp
gipkzeil zevcv po pbk fog~imu-
1 FOVO ~{jlevbk` pbk zkv{lpv o i vp{`u om Azi{`{lkmp
Aemimfeil Zk~ozpemh4 9552':>>8-
8 Fomhzkvv kmifpk` pbk @o``'Azimc Xill Vpzkkp Zkozg
im` Fomv{gkz ^zopkfpeom Ifp- Igomh opbkz pbemhv, pbev
Ifp krkg~pv vgillkz ~{jlef fog~imekv zog pbk VOR
zky{ezkgkmpv oz i{`epoz ippkvpipeom o empkzmil fompzol
zk~ozpemh-
2 FOVO zklkivk` i``epeomil zk~ozpv, emfl{`emh4
m :>9> Zk~ozp om KZG4 F{zzkmp Vpipk o Kmpkz~zevk Zevc
Oqkzvehbp im` Gizckp ^kzfk~peomv o FOVOv KZG
Azigkxozc-
m Joiz` Zevc Oqkzvehbp4 I ^zohzkvv Zk~ozp-
m @kqklo~emh Cku Zevc Em`efipozv po Vpzkmhpbkm KZG-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
5/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Kqolqemh Uiz`vpefcv O V{ffkvv
Ilpbo{hb pbkzk izk vkqkzil zevc gimihkgkmp zigkxozcv
iqielijlk po`iu, pbk FOVO h{e`imfk biv jkfogk cku po
gkiv{zemh v{ffkvv- FOVO vpim`v oz pbk Foggeppkk o
V~omvozemh Ozhimetipeomv o pbk Pzki`xiu Foggevveom- Pbev
Foggeppkk ev i qol{mpizu ~zeqipk'vkfpoz ozhimetipeom foggeppk`
po ~{jlevbemh vp{`ekv im` pbo{hbp ~i~kzv pbip kr~im` pbk
jo`ekv o cmoxlk`hk em pbk izkiv o empkzmil fompzol, kmpkz~zevk
zevc gimihkgkmp im` zi{` `kpkzzkmfk- FOVOv h{e`imfk
om zevc gimihkgkmp biv bkl~k` po lehbp pbk xiu ozxiz`, j{p
~zohzkvv biv jkkm {mkqkm im` `ef{lp po gkiv{zk em ~izp
jkfi{vk o pbk mkk` oz d{`hgkmp em ivvkvvemh pbk krpkmp poxbefb im kmpepu ev gkkpemh pbk g{lpe'`egkmveomil ~izigkpkzv
mkfkvvizu oz i ozgil KZG ~zohzig iv `kmk` ju FOVO-
@kamepeom o KZG
I ~zofkvv, kkfpk` ju im kmpepuv joiz` o `ezkfpozv,
gimihkgkmp, im` opbkz ~kzvommkl, i~~lek` em vpzipkhu vkppemh
im` ifzovv pbk kmpkz~zevk, `kvehmk` po e`kmpeu ~opkmpeil kqkmpv
pbip giu ikfp pbk kmpepu, im` gimihk zevc po jk xepbem epv
zevc i~~kpepk, po ~zoqe`k zkivomijlk ivv{zimfk zkhiz`emh pbk
ifbekqkgkmp o kmpepu ojdkfpeqkv-
FOVO, KmpKz~zeVK zeVc GimihKGKmp AziGKxOzc, :>>0
Jkfi{vk fomve`kzijlk d{`hgkmp ev zky{ezk` po hi{hk pbk lkqkl
o ~zohzkvv om vogk o pbk ~izigkpkzv, "k-h-, gimihemh zevcv
xepbem zevc i~~kpepkv im` ~zoqe`emh zkivomijlk ivv{zimfk o
ojdkfpeqkv ifzovv im kmpkz~zevk%, pbkzk ev mo fomqkmekmp xiu
po zipk i fog~imuv oqkzill zevc gimihkgkmp ~kzozgimfk
ihiemvp opbkzv o epv vetk oz em epv em`{vpzu- J{p vogk
y{ilepipeqk `ipi ev iqielijlk ijo{p v~kfef jkmfbgizcv om
pbk do{zmku po KZG- Fog~izevomv xepb pbkvk jkmfbgizcv
fim jk bkl~{l em fogg{mefipemh xepb joiz`v im` emqkvpozv
xbo ximp po cmox xbkzk i fog~imu vpim`v im` box xkll ep
ev gkkpemh pbk kr~kfpipeomv o emqkvpozv, f{vpogkzv, fzk`ep
zipemh ihkmfekv, zkh{lipozv, im` opbkzv-
Y{kvpeomv po Ivc po @kpkzgemk Xbkzk Uo{ Vpim`
Xepbem pbk fompkrp o pbk FOVO `kmepeom fepk` ijoqk, pbk
olloxemh y{kvpeomv ell{vpzipk pbk cem`v o jkmfbgizcv pbip
giu jk bkl~{l em `kpkzgememh xbkzk i fog~imu vpim`v
zklipeqk po oqkzill mozgv im` kr~kfpipeomv4
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
6/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
9- @okv pbk fog~imu giempiem i zevc zkhevpkz oz bkip
gi~ pbip flivvekv po~ zevcv ju leckleboo` im` eg~ifp,
ilomh xepb i gepehipeom vpzipkhu oz kifb?
:- @okv pbk fog~imu ivvehm v~kfef oxmkzvbe~ oz cku zevcv?
6- @okv pbk fog~imu `kqklo~ ilpkzmipeqk gepehipeom
vpzipkhekv?
0- @okv pbk fog~imu fogg{mefipk zevc polkzimfkv ifzovv
pbk ozhimetipeom?
;- @okv pbk fog~imu flkizlu fogg{mefipk zevc i~~kpepk po
empkzmil im` krpkzmil vpickbol`kzv {vemh i vpim`iz` im`
fomvevpkmp KZG limh{ihk?
1- @okv pbk fog~imu biqk i {llu kmhihk` im` zevc'ivp{pk
joiz` o `ezkfpozv oqkzvkkemh zevc?
Imvxkzv4 I ukv imvxkz po y{kvpeom 9 ev pbk mozg, "e-k-,
govp foggom i~~zoifb igomh fog~imekv pbip biqk i
ozgil KZG ~zohzig iffoz`emh po i :>9> zk~ozp ju V!^v-%
E uo{ fim imvxkz ukv po y{kvpeomv : pbzo{hb 0, pbkm
iffoz`emh po V!^v zk~ozp, uo{z fog~imu ev omk o i zklipeqklu
vgill gemozepu o behb ifbekqkzv- I ukv imvxkz po y{kvpeomv
; im` 1 gkimv uo{z fog~imu illv xepbem im kqkm gozk
klepk gemozepu, `kv~epk pbk ifp pbip vpickbol`kzv ximp im`
kr~kfp gozk emozgipeom mox ijo{p zevc gimihkgkmp- I
gidoz ojvpiflk po ~zoqe`emh pbev emozgipeom vkkgv po jk pbk
lifc o i {meozg limh{ihk oz zevc pbip ev {m`kzvpim`ijlk jukqkzuomk emqolqk` lemk gimihkzv, vkmeoz krkf{peqkv, joiz`
gkgjkzv, vbizkbol`kzv, zkh{lipozv, im` opbkz vpickbol`kzv-
Aoz Gozk Emozgipeom
Pbk FOVO h{e`imfk gkmpeomk` em pbev zk~ozp ev iqielijlk
oz ~{zfbivk oz `oxmloi` ip bpp~4//xxx-fovo-ozh- Pbkvk
gipkzeilv emfl{`k4
mFOVO, Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Gimihkgkmp Empkhzipk`
Azigkxozc, :>>0-
mFOVO, Empkzmil Fompzol oqkz Aemimfeil Zk~ozpemh
H{e`imfk oz Vgillkz ^{jlef Fog~imekv, :>>1-
mFOVO, Azi{`{lkmp Aemimfeil Zk~ozpemh4 9552':>>8
Im Imiluvev o [-V- ^{jlef Fog~imekv, :>9>-
mFOVO, Kkfpeqk Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Oqkzvehbp4 Pbk Zolk o
pbk Joiz` o @ezkfpozv, :>>5-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
7/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
mFOVO, Kgjzifemh Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Gimihkgkmp4 ^zifpefil
I~~zoifbkv oz Hkppemh Vpizpk`, :>99-
mFOVO, @kqklo~emh Cku Zevc Em`efipozv po Vpzkmhpbkm
Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Gimihkgkmp, :>9>-
mFOVOv :>9> Zk~ozp om KZG4 F{zzkmp Vpipk o
Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Oqkzvehbp im` Gizckp ^kzfk~peomv o
FOVOv KZG Azigkxozc, :>9>-
Opbkz gipkzeilv gkmpeomk` em pbev zk~ozp izk iqielijlk oz
`oxmloi` zog pbk olloxemh vo{zfkv4
mVpim`iz` ! ^oozv, Fzk`ep AIY4 Vpim`iz` ! ^oozv Loocv
A{zpbkz empo Box Mommimfeil Fog~imekv Gimihk Zevc,D{mk :0, :>9>- "bpp~4//xxx-vpim`iz`im`~oozv-fog/
zipemhv/kzg/km/{v%
m[V Vkf{zepekv im` Krfbimhk Foggevveom, Aemil Z{lk
om ^zoru @evflov{zk Kmbimfkgkmpv, @kfkgjkz :>>5-
"bpp~4//xxx-vkf-hoq/z{lkv/mil/:>>5/66'5>25-~`%
mVizjimkv'Orlku Ifp o :>>:- "bpp~4//a9-m`lix-
fog/mkxv-m`lix-fog/fmm/`ofv/hxj{vb/
vizjimkvorlku>8:6>:-~`%
m@o``'Azimc Xill Vpzkkp Zkozg im` Fomv{gkz ^zopkfpeom
Ifp o :>9>- "bpp~4//zxkjhipk-iffkvv-h~o-hoq/fhe'jem/
hkp`of-fhe?`jmigk7999_fomh_jellv!`ofe`74b0986kmz-
prp-~`%
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
8/38
Pbk Kgkzhemh Azompekzv o Zevc Gimihkgkmp
AZI[@ IM@ ZKLIPK@ ZEVCV
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
9/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Pbk zevc kmqezomgkmp ev fomvpimplu fbimhemh, fbillkmhemh
fog~imekv po gomepoz pbk fbimhkv im` of{v pbkez kozpv om pbk
govp ~zkvvemh evv{kv ip imu ~oemp em pegk- Em zkfkmp ukizv, zi{`
biv jkkm im izki o hzoxemh fomfkzm oz fog~imekv o ill vetkv-
I :>9> zk~ozp ju pbk Emvpep{pk o Empkzmil I{`epozv "EEI% em`efipkv
pbip zi{`v biqk jkkm gozk ~zkqilkmp vemfk pbk omvkp o pbk
kfomogef zkfkvveom em :>>2, kv~kfeillu kg~loukk'zklipk` zi{`v
v{fb iv pbkp o fog~imu ~zo~kzpu im` zkvo{zfkv, kgjkttlkgkmp
im` kr~kmvk iffo{mp zi{`- Pbk EEIv zk~ozp kr~liemv pbip pbkvk
pu~kv o zi{`v biqk emfzkivk` iv pbk kfomogef zkfkvveom im`
iffog~imuemh {mkg~lougkmp lkqklv biqk ikfpk` fo{mplkvv
kg~loukkv om i ~kzvomil lkqkl, opkm emqolqemh pbk lovv o emfogk
zog omk oz gozk bo{vkbol` gkgjkzv-
Gicemh Azi{` i Behbkz ^zeozepu
Pbk zevemh lkqkl o zi{` biv ~zog~pk` gimu fog~imekv po
`kqklo~ im` eg~lkgkmp ~zoifpeqk impe'zi{` ~zohzigv `kvehmk`
po `kpkfp im` ~zkqkmp ill cem`v o zi{`, emfl{`emh kg~loukk'
zklipk` zi{`v- Em omk xkll'~{jlefetk` zi{` fivk, i zk~ozp em
Fog~leimfk Xkkc kvpegipk` pbip pbk igo{mp gevi~~zo~zeipk`
oqkz i qk'ukiz ~kzeo` mkizlu ky{ilk` pbk fog~imuv gizckp
fi~epiletipeom- Zk~ozpv leck pbev omk izk fi{vemh opbkz
fog~imekv po ivc, Fo{l` ep bi~~km bkzk?
Fo{l` zi{` jk off{zzemh ip uo{z fog~imu?
Zkfkmplu ep xiv zkqkilk` pbip oqkz $6> gelleom xiv vpolkm zog
Gelxi{ckk'jivk` Covv Foz~ozipeom "pbk Fog~imu%, illkhk`lu ju
vkmeoz gkgjkzv o pbk iffo{mpemh pkig- Iffoz`emh po pbk AJEv
em`efpgkmp, pbev zi{` xiv ~kz~kpzipk` ju pbk i{pbozetipeom
o m{gkzo{v xezk pzimvkzv o {m`v zog jimc iffo{mpv
giempiemk` ju Covv po vkpplk ~kzvomil Igkzefim Kr~zkvv fzk`ep
fiz` jellv- Em i``epeom, pbk ~kz~kpzipozv {vk` gomku zog Covvv
jimc iffo{mpv po {m` opbkz ~kzvomil kr~kmvkv-
Pbk zi{`{lkmp pzimvifpeomv xkzk fomfkilk` zog pbk Fog~imu
ju ~zk~izemh ilvk iffo{mpemh joocv im` zkfoz`v- Pbev emfl{`k`
ilvk do{zmil kmpzekv po `evh{evk pbk gevi~~zo~zeipeom o {m`v-
Pbk ~kz~kpzipozv ippkg~pk` po be`k pbk kgjkttlkgkmp em pbk
Fog~imuv amimfeil vpipkgkmpv ju oqkzvpipemh ivvkpv, kr~kmvkv,
im` fovp o vilkv, im` ju {m`kzvpipemh leijelepekv im` vilkv-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
10/38
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
11/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
mFog~imekv giu ilvo ifk gozk zevcv o zi{`v zklipk`
po qkm`ozv oz opbkz pbez` ~izpekv- Krig~lkv emfl{`k
oqkz~iugkmpv po fompzifpozv im` ~iugkmpv oz vkzqefkv
mop zkm`kzk`-
mFozz{~peom'pu~k zevcv zklipk` po fog~leimfk xepb lixv
giu ilvo emfzkivk- Krig~lkv emfl{`k jzejkzu o ozkehm
ofeilv, ellkhil ve`k ihzkkgkmpv, im` ifelepipeom ~iugkmpv
zklipk` po eg~ozpv-
mMkx ozgv o `ipi im` emozgipeom zevcv izk ilvo
kgkzhemh- Krig~lkv emfl{`k `evflov{zk o foz~ozipk `ipi
po fog~kpepozv, {vk o emozgipeom pkfbmolohu po foqkz {~
zi{`, im` zevcv ivvofeipk` xepb mkx mimfeil vuvpkgv-
Gkiv{zkv o Kkfpeqkmkvv im` Ivv{zimfk
Fog~imekv mkk` zkleijlk gkiv{zkv o ~zohzkvv po gimihk
pbk {ll v~kfpz{g o zi{`v im` zklipk` zevcv- FOVOv
jzoi`kvp uiz`vpefc o v{ffkvv ev bkl~{l jkfi{vk ep `kmkv
kkfpeqkmkvv jzoi`lu em pkzgv o gimihemh zevcv zklipk` po
ill o{z cku fipkhozekv o ojdkfpeqkv4 vpzipkhef, o~kzipeomil,
zk~ozpemh, im` fog~leimfk-
Kkfpeqkmkvv
Xbkm kmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp ev `kpkzgemk` po jk kkfpeqk
em kifb o pbk o{z fipkhozekv o ojdkfpeqkv, zkv~kfpeqklu,pbk joiz` o `ezkfpozv im` gimihkgkmp biqk zkivomijlk
ivv{zimfk pbip pbku {m`kzvpim` pbk krpkmp po xbefb pbk kmpepuv
vpzipkhef im` o~kzipeomv ojdkfpeqkv izk jkemh ifbekqk`, im`
pbip pbk kmpepuv zk~ozpemh ev zkleijlk im` i~~lefijlk lixv im`
zkh{lipeomv izk jkemh fog~lek` xepb-
FOVO, KmpKz~zeVK zeVc GimihKGKmp AziGKxOzc, :>>0
Pbev `kmepeom o kkfpeqkmkvv zky{ezkv i lkqkl o ivv{zimfk
pbip hokv jkuom` pbip ~zoqe`k` ju krpkzmil i{`epv- Krpkzmil
i{`epv of{v om kr~ov{zkv pbip fim zkv{lp em i gipkzeil
gevvpipkgkmp o mimfeil vpipkgkmpv oz i gipkzeil lovv po pbk
ozhimetipeom- Pbku izk mop `kvehmk` po ivvkvv xbkpbkz pbk
kr~ov{zkv izk fomvevpkmp xepb i fog~imuv zevc i~~kpepk im`
ifbekqkgkmp o epv hoilv, j{p pbkzk ev vogk vumkzhu jkpxkkm
mimfeil vpipkgkmp i{`epv im` zevc gimihkgkmp jkfi{vk
gimu zi{` zevcv fim jk i``zkvvk` xepb im i~~zo~zeipk
vuvpkg o empkzmil fompzol- Pbk Vizjimkv'Orlku Ifp o :>>:
"VOR% ~iqk` pbk xiu oz vehmefimp ~zohzkvv em pbip zkhiz` ju
zky{ezemh gimihkgkmp zk~ozpemh im` i{`epoz ippkvpipeom om
empkzmil fompzolv oqkz mimfeil zk~ozpemh oz ~{jlef fog~imekv-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
12/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Boxkqkz, pbk @o``'Azimc Ifp o :>9> krkg~pk` vgillkz ~{jlef
fog~imekv "mom'iffklkzipk` lkzv% zog pbk i{`epoz ippkvpipeom
zky{ezkgkmpv-
Hzoxemh Fbillkmhkv oz Vgillkz Fog~imekv
Pbk VOR krkg~peom oz vgillkz ~{jlef fog~imekv ev jopb i
jlkvvemh im` f{zvk- Om pbk omk bim`, vgillkz fog~imekv izk
lkvv ijlk po oop pbk jell oz fovplu i{`epoz ippkvpipeomv3 om pbk
opbkz bim`, vp{`ekv vbox pbku izk gozk q{lmkzijlk po zi{`-
Pbev fzkipkv im {mlkqkl ~liuemh kl` oz emqkvpozv-
Im [mkqkm ^liuemh Aekl`Vgill ozhimetipeomv izk `ev~zo~ozpeomipklu qefpegetk` ju
off{~ipeomil zi{`- Pbkvk ozhimetipeomv izk pu~efillu lifcemh
em impe'zi{` fompzolv fog~izk` po pbkez lizhkz fo{mpkz~izpv
xbefb gickv pbkg ~izpef{lizlu q{lmkzijlk po zi{`-
iFAK, :>9> zK~OzppOpbK mipeOmVOm
OFF{~ipeOmil Azi{`im` ij{VK
Ilpbo{hb pbk VKF ev vpell vp{`uemh pbk fovpv im` jkmkpv o pbk
VOR zky{ezkgkmpv oz vgillkz ~{jlef fog~imekv, pbk vpip{v
y{o ev ~izpef{lizlu pzo{jlkvogk xbkm ep fogkv po zi{`- I
:>>2 zk~ozp ju pbk Emvpep{pk o Empkzmil I{`epozv im` opbkzv
em`efipkv pbip gozk fog~imekv izk zkv~om`emh po kr~kfpipeomvju kr~zkvvemh pbkez zevc i~~kpepk iv i tkzo polkzimfk oz zi{`
o imu pu~k- Pbev ojdkfpeqk ev mkizlu eg~ovvejlk po ifbekqk
xepbo{p v{~~lkgkmpil ~zohzigv oz ~zkqkmpemh im` `kpkfpemh
zi{`, kv~kfeillu em i vgillkz ~{jlef fog~imu, xbkzk kg~loukkv
pkm` po jk hkmkzilevpv xbo ~kzozg g{lpe~lk doj `{pekv im` ep ev
gozk `ef{lp po gepehipk zevcv pbzo{hb vkhzkhipeom o `{pekv oz
fkmpziletipeom o vbizk` vkzqefkv-
Y{kvpeomv po Ivc Ijo{p Uo{z Impe'Azi{` ^zohzig
Pbk olloxemh y{kvpeomv giu jk bkl~{l em `kpkzgememh box xkll
i fog~imu ev gimihemh epv zevc o zi{`4
9- Biv pbk fog~imu `kqklo~k` i vpipkgkmp o epv polkzimfk oz
zi{`? Ev ep i~~zoqk` ju pbk joiz` o `ezkfpozv?
:- @o pbk fog~imuv zevc ivvkvvgkmpv pick empo iffo{mp
cmoxm zi{`v pbip biqk bi~~kmk` em fog~imekv o pbk
vigk vetk im` em pbk vigk em`{vpzu?
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
13/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
6- @okv pbk fog~imu biqk i vpzomh im` em`k~km`kmp empkzmil
i{`ep `k~izpgkmp? Ev pbk empkzmil i{`ep {mfpeom zkv~omvejlk
oz `kpkfpemh im` ~zkqkmpemh zi{`?
0- @okv pbk fog~imu biqk kkfpeqk zi{` boplemkv im`
xbevpkjloxkz ~zohzigv?
;- @okv pbk fog~imu biqk i ~olefu im` gkpbo`olohu po
emqkvpehipk ~opkmpeil im` ifp{il off{zzkmfkv o zi{`?
1- @okv pbk fog~imu j{el` em kkfpeqk empkzmil fompzolv, v{fb
iv vkhzkhipeom o `{pekv, po pbk krpkmp ~zifpefijlk? @okv ep
pick opbkz gkiv{zkv po gepehipk pbk zevc o zi{`?
8- @okv pbk fog~imu zky{ezk gim`ipozu qifipeom ~kzeo`v oz
doj zopipeom ivvehmgkmpv oz kg~loukkv em cku ~ovepeomv em
iffo{mpemh im` mimfk?2- @okv pbk fog~imu {vk i zehozo{v vuvpkg o `ipi imiluvev
im` fompem{o{v gomepozemh oz i{`epemh o epkgv v{fb iv xezk
pzimvkzv im` do{zmil kmpzekv po `kpkfp zi{`{lkmp ifpeqepu?
E pbk imvxkzv po imu o pbkvk y{kvpeomv izk mo, FJET fim
~zoqe`k i`qevozu vkzqefkv po bkl~ fog~imekv o imu vetk em imu
em`{vpzu po `kqklo~ gozk ~zoifpeqk impe'zi{` fompzolv-
Aoz Gozk Emozgipeom
Pbk olloxemh gipkzeilv izk zkkzkmfk` em pbev zk~ozp4
mFOVO, Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Gimihkgkmp Empkhzipk`
Azigkxozc, :>>0
mEmvpep{pk o Empkzmil I{`epozv im` I{`ep Krkf{peqk Fkmpkz,
Cmoxlk`hk Ilkzp4 Kgkzhemh Pzkm`v em Azi{` Zevcv,
Dim{izu :>9>
mGklevvi Clkem Iy{eliz, Vgill Aelkzv Vpz{hhlk xepb Empkzmil
Fompzolv Oqkz Azi{`, Fog~leimfk Xkkc, Giu :>9>
mEmvpep{pk o Empkzmil I{`epozv "EEI%, Igkzefim Emvpep{pk
o F^Iv "IEF^I%, im` Ivvofeipeom o Fkzpek` Azi{`
Krigemkzv "IFAK%, Gimihemh pbk J{vemkvv Zevc o Azi{`4
I ^zifpefil H{e`k, :>>2
mIvvofeipeom o Fkzpek` Azi{` Krigemkzv "IFAK%, :>9>
Zk~ozp po pbk Mipeomv om Off{~ipeomil Azi{` im` Ij{vk
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
14/38
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
15/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Govp j{vemkvv oxmkzv im` gimihkzv zkfohmetk pbip i
fog~imuv zk~{pipeom im` zklipeomvbe~v xepb f{vpogkzv im`
v{~~lekzv zimc behb om pbk levp o epv govp qil{ijlk ivvkpv- Po
~zkvkzqk pbk qil{k o pbkvk ivvkpv, j{vemkvv'viqqu gimihkzv
cmox pbku g{vp ho jkuom` pzi`epeomil pkfbmey{kv oz gimihemh
zevcv ivvofeipk` xepb ~buvefil im` mimfeil ivvkpv- Pbk cku
ev po m` xiuv po ~zopkfp im` kmbimfk foz~ozipk zk~{pipeomv
im` opbkz empimhejlkv pbip giu mkqkz i~~kiz em i fog~imuv
mimfeil vpipkgkmpv- Pbev kr~im`k` of{v bkl~v fog~imekv
giregetk qil{k, im` ep ev jkfogemh emfzkivemhlu fzepefil oz
giempiememh im` eg~zoqemh fzk`ep zipemhv- J{p ep ev mop kivu-
Pbk fbillkmhkv emfl{`k i`i~pemh po pbk vpzomhkz lemcihk
jkpxkkm zevc gimihkgkmp im` fzk`ep zipemhv, e`kmpeuemhvpzipkhef zevcv, im` kqil{ipemh pbk ~opkmpeil fomvky{kmfkv-
Pbk Lemcihk Jkpxkkm Zevcv im` Zipemhv
Iv ~izp o pbk zipemh ~zofkvv, Vpim`iz` ! ^oozv, Goo`uv im`
opbkz zipemh ihkmfekv ippkg~p po e`kmpeu im` ivvkvv kifb
fog~imuv {m`kzluemh qil{k `zeqkzv, emfl{`emh pbk vpzkmhpb
o epv gimihkgkmp im` hoqkzmimfk ~zofkvvkv- Pbk fzk`ep
im` mimfeil fzevkv o pbk lipk':>>>v i``k` eg~kp{v im`
{zhkmfu po pbkvk kozpv jkfi{vk pbkvk kqkmpv {klk` ~{jlef
vck~pefevg ijo{p pbk zipemhv ivvehmk` po i m{gjkz o behb
~zolk foz~ozipk `ki{lpv pbip xkzk ippzej{pk` po xkic zevc
gimihkgkmp- Zkifpeomv po pbk fzk`ep fzevev emfl{`k` fzepefevgv
o jimcv jom{v ~limv oz kmfo{zihemh {m`{k zevc'picemh- Voom,
pbk fomfkzmv v~zki` po kmfog~ivv pbk zevc gimihkgkmp
pkfbmey{kv o fog~imekv em opbkz em`{vpzekv iv xkll-
Em :>>2, Vpim`iz` ! ^oozv "V!^% immo{mfk` epv ~limv po xe`km
pbk vfo~k o epv imiluvev o vogk mommimfeil fog~imekv
ju i~~luemh kmpkz~zevk zevc imiluvev po epv foz~ozipk zipemhv
o pbkvk fog~imekv- Iv ~izp o pbev kozp, V!^ emepeipk`
`evf{vveomv xepb gimihkgkmp om pbk olloxemh po~efv4
mGimihkgkmpv qekx o pbk govp fomvky{kmpeil zevcv
ifk` ju pbkez zgv, emfl{`emh pbk leckleboo` o pbk zevcv
im` pbk ~opkmpeil kkfp om fzk`ep-
mPbk zky{kmfu xepb xbefb pbk po~ zevcv xkzk {~`ipk` im`
pbk mip{zk o pbk {~`ipkv-
mPbk ema{kmfk o zevc vkmvepeqepu om leijelepu gimihkgkmp
im` mimfemh `kfeveomv-
mPbk zolk o zevc gimihkgkmp em vpzipkhef `kfeveom'gicemh
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
16/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Ill pbkvk gippkzv zkakfp i `kvezk po cmox gozk ijo{p pbk
zolk pbip zevc fomve`kzipeomv ~liu xbkm gicemh vpzipkhef
`kfeveomv- V!^v immo{mfkgkmpv im` izpeflkv om pbk v{jdkfp
em`efipk pbip pbk zipemh ihkmfu qekxv zevc gimihkgkmp
iv i cku fog~omkmp o i fog~imuv f{lp{zk- Jzoi`lu
`kmk`, f{lp{zk emfl{`kv gippkzv v{fb iv fogg{mefipeomv,
vpz{fp{zkv, emfkmpeqkv, im` zevc i~~kpepk- Pbk ihkmfu emy{ezkv
ijo{p pbkvk gippkzv po ojpiem i jkppkz ivvkvvgkmp o
gimihkgkmpv ijelepu po e`kmpeu, gomepoz im` gimihk cku
zevcv pbip izk km`kgef po pbk fog~imuv em`{vpzu im` pbip
gimihkzv klkfp po pick xbkm z{mmemh pbkez j{vemkvvkv-
Po i`i~p po pbk vpzomhkz lemcihk jkpxkkm zevcv im` zipemhvim` po `kgomvpzipk pbk vo{m`mkvv o pbkez foz~ozipk
f{lp{zkv, fog~imekv mkk` po kvpijlevb zoj{vp zevc
gimihkgkmp ~zofkvvkv pbip fim kkfpeqklu e`kmpeu, kqil{ipk,
im` fogg{mefipk pbkez govp fomvky{kmpeil vpzipkhef zevcv-
E`kmpeuemh Vpzipkhef Zevcv
Pbk ~zofkvv o e`kmpeuemh pbk govp fomvky{kmpeil vpzipkhef
zevcv ev embkzkmplu `ef{lp, im` po`iuv qolipelk j{vemkvv
kmqezomgkmp i``v po pbk fog~lkrepekv emqolqk`- Po jkhem
pbk ~zofkvv, gimihkgkmp opkm vpizpv xepb i zevc emqkmpozu
oz zevc zkhevpkz, olloxk` ju im imiluvev o "i% pbk zklipeqkleckleboo` kifb zevc xell gipkzeiletk im` "j% pbk gihmep{`k
o pbk ~opkmpeil eg~ifp, e pbk zevc `okv gipkzeiletk, kepbkz
em`eqe`{illu oz pohkpbkz xepb opbkz zevcv-
Pu~efillu, i fog~imuv zevc ifpozv emfl{`k jopb krpkzmil im`
empkzmil ifpozv-
mKrpkzmil ifpozv emfl{`k fbimhkv em pbk em`{vpzu,
kfomogu, fog~kpepozv, f{vpogkzv, im` lkhil oz zkh{lipozu
kmqezomgkmp, emfl{`emh flegipef zevcv im` zevcv o
pkzzozevg oz feqel {mzkvp-
mEmpkzmil ifpozv emfl{`k zevcv ivvofeipk` xepb pbk
hoqkzmimfk ~zofkvv {vk` po oqkzvkk zevcv, pbk lomh'
zimhk ~limmemh ~zofkvv, oz pbk jom{v ~limv im` opbkz
emfkmpeqkv {vk` po zkxiz` zevc'picemh-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
17/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Kqil{ipemh pbk Fomvky{kmfkv o Vpzipkhef Zevcv
Pbk kqil{ipeom im` hoqkzmimfk o vpzipkhef zevcv pu~efillu
emqolqkv i fog~izevom xepb pbk fog~imuv zevc i~~kpepk- Em
~{jleflu'oxmk` fog~imekv, pbk joiz` o `ezkfpozv hkmkzillu
biv vogk zkv~omvejelepu oz bkl~emh kmv{zk pbip i fog~imuv
f{lp{zk ev ilehmk` xepb epv vpzipkhef ~lim im` pbk zevcv
pickm `o mop krfkk` pbk fog~imuv zevc i~~kpepk- Em ~zeqipk
fog~imekv im` mop'oz'~zop ozhimetipeomv, pbk zkv~omvejelepu
pu~efillu zkve`kv xepb pbk gimihkzv oz j{vemkvv oxmkzv-
Pbkvk em`eqe`{ilv mkk` i~~zo~zeipk emozgipeom ijo{p
pbk ~opkmpeil vkqkzepu o pbk fomvky{kmfkv o zevcv- Pbev
emozgipeom fim jk ilehmk` xepb pbzkk pbzkvbol`v, fog~zevemhzevcv pbip gehbp zkv{lp em zk`{fk` fzk`ep zipemhv, jzockm `kjp
foqkmimpv, im` kqkm jimcz{~pfu-
Pbk zevc pbzkvbol`v fim jk ozhimetk` em i bekzizfbu iv
ell{vpzipk` jklox-
Ilpbo{hb pbk ~zkfevk fomvky{kmfkv o kifb zevc giu jk
`ef{lp po ~zk`efp, gimihkgkmp xell lecklu jk ijlk po gick i
jkvp'kozpv kvpegipk o pbk zevcv pbip fzovv pbkvk pbzkvbol`v-
Krig~lkv emfl{`k kqkmpv im` pzkm`v pbip gehbp legep i
fog~imuv ijelepu po i`i~p po fbimhkv em pbk kfomogu, "v{fb iv
qolipelepu im` v~eckv em ~zefkv o foggo`epekv%, iv xkll iv pbovk
pbip ikfp epv ijelepu po {m` im` gimihk {p{zk hzoxpb, "v{fb
iv zkh{lipozu fbimhkv ikfpemh pbk li{mfbkv o mkx ~zo`{fpv,
kmpzu empo mkx gizckpv, oz mkhopeipeomv o gkzhkzv im`
ify{evepeomv%- Em fog~imekv xepb empkzmipeomil f{vpogkzv oz
v{~~lekzv, vpzipkhef zevcv gehbp ilvo emfl{`k ~opkmpeil
Zk`{fk` Fzk`ep
Zipemh
Jzockm @kjpFoqkmimp
Jimcz{~pfu
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
18/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
`evz{~peomv em v{~~lu fbiemv oz `evpzej{peom fbimmklv `{k po
fipivpzo~bef kqkmpv, v{fb iv kizpby{ickv oz pv{migev- Em
vgillkz fog~imekv, pbk zevcv gehbp emfl{`k i lifc o
v{ffkvveom ~limmemh oz po~ gimihkgkmp-
Y{kvpeomv po Ivc Ijo{p Uo{z Kmpkz~zevk Zevc
Gimihkgkmp zohzig
Kmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp "KZG% ev im kqolqemh jo`u
o cmoxlk`hk pbip bkl~v fog~imekv po i``zkvv i jzoi`
zimhk o zevcv, emfl{`emh vpzipkhef zevcv- Po kmv{zk kkfpeqk
kmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp im` po ~zk~izk oz `evf{vveomv
xepb krpkzmil ~izpekv, v{fb iv zkh{lipozv, fzk`epozv, im` zipemhihkmfekv, fog~imekv giu m` pbk olloxemh vkl'ivvkvvgkmp
y{kvpeomv bkl~{l4
9- Ev uo{z fog~imu ~zk~izk` po zkv~om` po emy{ezekv zog
fzk`ep zipemh ihkmfekv ijo{p epv zevc f{lp{zk, zevc i~~kpepk,
im` zevc gimihkgkmp ~zofkvvkv?
:- Biv gimihkgkmp gi`k i vuvpkgipef im` pbozo{hb vkizfb
oz zevcv pbip gehbp pzehhkz zk`{fpeomv em fzk`ep zipemhv,
jzockm `kjp foqkmimpv im` kqkm jimcz{~pfu?
6- @okv uo{z zevc gimihkgkmp ~zohzig fomve`kz zevcv
zklipk` po kfomogef fom`epeomv "v{fb iv ~zefk goqkgkmpv
oz fi~epil iqielijelepu% pbip gehbp ikfp pbk fovp o fi~epilim` pbkzkju zkv{lp em emfzkivk` fog~kpepeom?
0- @okv uo{z zevc gimihkgkmp ~zohzig fomve`kz zevcv
zklipk` po pbk mip{zil kmqezomgkmp "v{fb iv aoo`v, zk,
oz kizpby{ickv% pbip gehbp zkv{lp em `igihk po ~limp oz
j{el`emhv, zkvpzefpk` iffkvv po zix gipkzeilv, oz lovv o
b{gim fi~epil?
;- @okv uo{z zevc gimihkgkmp ~zohzig fomve`kz zevcv
zklipk` po ~olepefil ifpozv "v{fb iv klkfpeom o hoqkzmgkmp
ofeilv xepb mkx ~olepefil ihkm`iv oz mkx lixv im`
zkh{lipeomv% pbip gehbp ikfp iffkvv po ozkehm gizckpv oz
zkv{lp em behbkz oz loxkz pirkv?
1- @okv uo{z zevc gimihkgkmp ~zohzig pick empo iffo{mp
zevcv zklipk` po pbk vofeil kmqezomgkmp "v{fb iv fbimhemh
`kgohzi~befv, xozc/lek ~zeozepekv, oz pkzzozevg ifpeqepu%
pbip gehbp zkv{lp em fbimhemh `kgim` oz ~zo`{fpv im`
vkzqefkv, mkx j{uemh qkm{kv, b{gim zkvo{zfk evv{kv, oz
~zo`{fpeom vpo~~ihkv?
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
19/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
8- @okv uo{z zevc gimihkgkmp ~zohzig pick empo iffo{mp
zevcv zklipk` po pkfbmolohefil ifpozv "v{fb iv mkx gkimv
o klkfpzomef foggkzfk% pbip gehbp zkv{lp em fbimhkv em
pbk iqielijelepu o `ipi, emzivpz{fp{zk fovpv, oz emfzkivk`
`kgim` oz pkfbmolohu'jivk` vkzqefkv?
Aoz Gozk Emozgipeom
Pbk olloxemh gipkzeilv izk zkkzkmfk` em pbev zk~ozp4
mVpim`iz` ! ^oozv, Zipemhv @ezkfp, Kmpkz~zevk Zevc
Gimihkgkmp4 Vpim`iz` ! ^oozv Po I~~lu Kmpkz~zevk Zevc
Imiluvev po Foz~ozipk Zipemhv mVpim`iz` ! ^oozv, Giu 8, :>>2 im` Fzk`ep AIY4
Vpim`iz` ! ^oozv Loocv A{zpbkz empo Box Mommimfeil
Fog~imekv Gimihk Zevc, D{mk :0, :>9>
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
20/38
Pbk Kgkzhemh Azompekzv o Zevc Gimihkgkmp
EMAOZGIPEOM PKFBMOLOHU IM@ HZOXPB
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
21/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Omk o pbk govp `i{mpemh fbillkmhkv em po`iuv j{vemkvv
kmqezomgkmp ev po ~zopkfp qil{ijlk `ipi zog i bovp o pbzkipv
emfl{`emh qkm`oz, vkf{zepu, im` ~zeqifu zevcv- Pbev izki o
kmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp "KZG% ev kv~kfeillu `ef{lp heqkm
pbk ~ifk o fbimhk em pkfbmolohu po`iu- Kifb mkx `iu vkkgv
po jzemh mkx j{vemkvv go`klv im` mkx xiuv oz f{vpogkzv
po fomv{gk hoo`v im` vkzqefkv- EP ~zokvveomilv g{vp vpiu
om pbk lki`emh k`hk o fbimhk po ~zopkfp ~zo~zekpizu `ipi im`
~zkvkzqk pbk ~zeqifu o pbk fog~imuv f{vpogkz jivk iv i
o{m`ipeom oz {p{zk hzoxpb- Kkfpeqk oqkzvehbp ju j{vemkvv
oxmkzv im` joiz`v o `ezkfpozv ev ky{illu eg~ozpimp im` kqkzu
jep iv fzepefil- J{p jopb pbk mkfkvvizu vcellv im` pbk oqkzvehbp
biqk hzoxm emfzkivemhlu fog~lefipk` im` pegk'fomv{gemh emzkfkmp ukizv, fzkipemh mkx fbillkmhkv oz jopb EP ~zokvveomilv
im` joiz`v-
Mkx Pkfbmolohekv im` Jzoi`kz Eg~ifpv
Pbk empzo`{fpeom o flo{` fog~{pemh im` xezklkvv `kqefkv
oz kqkz gozk gojelk xozcozfkv biv emfzkivk` pbk ~opkmpeil
oz vkmvepeqk emozgipeom po gehzipk zog li~po~v, po im kqkm
zevcekz jivk o e'~bomkv, i~~lefipeomv, im` vofeil gk`ei
mkpxozcv- I``epeomillu, ip pbk vigk pegk pbip pkfbmolohu ev
fbimhemh, i m{gjkz o opbkz ifpozv izk empkmveuemh pbk zevcv
zklipk` po pbk {vihk o pbk pkfbmolohu, jopb xepbem im` o{pve`k
pbk fog~imu- Krig~lkv4
mPbk goqkgkmpv poxiz` vbizk` vkzqefkv, ilomh xepb pbk
hzoxemh iffk~pimfk o flo{` fog~{pemh im` o{pvo{zfemh
o EP `k~izpgkmpv biqk empzo`{fk` mkx zevcv- Pbkvk
ozgv o fkmpziletipeom opkm i`` fovp kfekmfekv ip
pbk kr~kmvk o pzi`epeomil fompzolv "v{fb iv omvepk
emv~kfpeomv o vkhzkhipeom o `{pekv ju gimihkgkmp oz
empkzmil i{`epozv%-
mGilefeo{v `igihkv biqk kvfilipk` zog igipk{zevb
bifcemh ~zimcv po pbzkipv o gozk vo~bevpefipk` ozgv
o fujkzpkzzozevg emqolqemh ~olepefillu'gopeqipk` ifpv o
`klejkzipk, lizhk'vfilk evz{~peom o fog~{pkz mkpxozcv po
{zpbkz e`kolohefil ihkm`iv-
mI vkzekv o {m~zkfk`kmpk` kqkmpv, zimhemh zog
b{zzefimkv, kizpby{ickv, im` opbkz mip{zil `evivpkzv po
givveqk oel v~ellv im` pbk j{zvpemh o pbk bo{vemh j{jjlk
ill {m`kzvfozk pbk eg~ozpimfk o `evivpkz zkfoqkzu
~limv im` jifc{~ ifelepekv-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
22/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
mPbk mkk` oz v~kfeiletk` pkfbmefil cmoxlk`hk biv
fog~lefipk` gimihkgkmpv ijelepu po zkfz{ep, zkpiem im`
~zogopk epv emozgipeom pkfbmolohu xozcozfk-
mPzkm`v v{fb iv vofeil mkpxozcemh im` fbimhemh lixv im`
zkh{lipeomv hoqkzmemh gippkzv, v{fb iv empkzmkp {vihk
im` ~zeqifu zehbpv, giu zky{ezk fompzolv pbip izk `ef{lp
po kmozfk iv pbk zkv~omvejelepu oz emozgipeom vkf{zepu ev
vbepemh ixiu zog vgill bim`{lv o EP kr~kzpv im` empo
pbk bim`v o i xe`k hzo{~ o em`eqe`{il {vkzv xbo giu
mop vbizk pbk vigk ixizkmkvv o pbk mkk` oz vkf{zepu-
Ill pbkvk pzkm`v, em`eqe`{illu im` fogjemk`, izk i``emh po pbk
fog~lkrepekv im` fbillkmhkv o EP hoqkzmimfk-Pxo o pbk govp `ef{lp fbillkmhkv emqolqk e`kmpeuemh
pbk ivvkpv ip zevc im` kvpijlevbemh kkfpeqk ~olefekv im`
zkv~omvejelepekv oz oqkzvehbp o EP zevcv-
E`kmpeuemh pbk Ivvkpv ip Zevc
Po f{p pbzo{hb pbk fog~lkrepekv im` kmv{zk pbip pbkez
fog~imekv izk of{vemh om pbk zehbp zevcv ip pbk zehbp pegk,
gimihkzv im` `ezkfpozv izk {vemh KZG pkfbmey{kv pbip
fkmpkz izo{m` pbk fomfk~p o ivvkpv ip zevc- Pbk {m`kzluemh
ivvkpv pu~efillu emfl{`k ~zo~zekpizu `ipi im` opbkz biz`'po'
qil{k empimhejlkv pbip giu mop i~~kiz om foz~ozipk jilimfk
vbkkpv- Pbk lemcihk ev `kgomvpzipk` em i vkzekv o y{kvpeomv
pbip xkzk v{ggizetk` em i :>>; zk~ozp ju pbk Emvpep{pk o
Empkzmil I{`epozv im` emfl{`k pbk olloxemh4
mZevc e`kmpefipeom
Xbip izk pbk ivvkpv ip zevc im` pbk qil{k o pbkezfom`kmpeilepu, empkhzepu, im` iqielijelepu?
Xbip fo{l` bi~~km po ikfp pbip emozgipeom ivvkpqil{k i`qkzvklu?
E i pbzkip kqkz bi~~kmk`, box ji` fo{l` epveg~ifp jk?
Box opkm gehbp pbk kqkmp jk kr~kfpk` po off{z? Box fkzpiem izk pbk imvxkzv po pbk zvp o{zy{kvpeomv?
mZevc gepehipeom
Xbip fim jk `omk po zk`{fk pbk zevc? Box g{fb xell ep fovp? Ev ep fovp kfekmp?
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
23/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Oqkzvehbp o EP Zevcv
Jkfi{vk `ekzkmp izkiv o emozgipeom pkfbmolohu fim ~{p pbk
vigk ivvkpv ip zevc, pbk zkv~omvejelepekv oz oqkzvehbp o EP
zevcv fim ~zkvkmp ozhimetipeomil fbillkmhkv pbip fog~o{m` pbk
embkzkmp fog~lkrepekv- Gozk pbim kqkz jkozk, kkfpeqk oqkzvehbp
zky{ezkv hoo` fooz`emipeom o em~{p zog pkfbmefil kr~kzpv,
gimihkgkmp, `ezkfpozv, im` opbkzv- Em kkfp, pbk liukzv o
oqkzvehbp izk leck fomfkmpzef fezflkv oz `ekzkmp pu~kv o zevcv-
Em ~{jleflu'oxmk` fog~imekv, pbk joiz` o `ezkfpozv xell
pu~efillu oqkzvkk pbk vpzipkhef pbzkipv pbip fim ~{p pbk kmpezk
fog~imu ip zevc, "k-h-, im kmqezomgkmpil `evivpkz pbip gehbp
`kvpzou kvvkmpeil vuvpkgv im` `ipi%- Pbk joiz` giu ilvo
oqkzvkk pbk pbzkipv pbip ~{p i j{vemkvv {mepv f{vpogkz jivk
im` opbkz ivvkpv ip zevc, "k-h-, vkzeo{v f{vpogkz vkzqefk
evv{kv emqolqemh pkfbmolohu%- Im`, `k~km`emh om pbk qil{k o
pbk ivvkpv ip zevc, joiz`v giu ilvo oqkzvkk `ipi empkhzepu
im` vkf{zepu zevcv, "k-h-, xbkm i lifc o i{pbozetipeom fompzolv
ev vo vkzeo{v iv po fog~zogevk pbk empkhzepu o i fog~imuv
mimfeil zk~ozpemh vuvpkg%- Po ckk~ joiz`v of{vk` om pbk
jeh ~efp{zk evv{kv, krpkzmil i{`epozv im` zevc i`qevozv giu
jk fillk` {~om po ~zoqe`k fkzpiem pu~kv o ivv{zimfk im`
ifelepipk fogg{mefipeomv om pbk pkfbmefil evv{kv emqolqk`- Em
~zeqipklu'oxmk` im` vgillkz fog~imekv, pbk zkv~omvejelepu oz
oqkzvehbp o EP hoqkzmimfk pu~efillu zkve`kv xepb pbk j{vemkvv
oxmkzv im` gimihkgkmp pkigv-
Vpzipkhef zevcv
Kmqezomgkmpil evivpkzv
V{jvpim`iz` o{pvo{zfemh
[mv{vpiemijlk vuvpkgv
J{vemkvv zevcv
F{vpogkz vkzqefk evv{kv
Voapxizk ~ezifu
Fzk`ep fiz` azi{`
J{vemkvv empkzz{~peom
! fompem{epu
@ipi empkhzepu
im` vkf{zepu
I{pbozetipeom fompzolv
Zkpkmpeom oa `ipi
buvefil vkf{zepu
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
24/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Aoz Gozk Emozgipeom
Pbk olloxemh gipkzeilv izk zkkzkmfk` em pbev zk~ozp4
mEmvpep{pk o Empkzmil I{`epozv, Hlojil Pkfbmolohu I{`ep
H{e`k, Emozgipeom Pkfbmolohu Fompzolv, :>>;
Y{kvpeomv po Ivc Ijo{p EP Zevc Gimihkgkmp
Uo{ giu m` pbk olloxemh y{kvpeomv bkl~{l em `kpkzgememh
box xkll uo{z EP zevc gimihkgkmp ~zofkvvkv vpifc {~ xepb
opbkz fog~imekv im` xbip i``epeomil vpk~v izk mkk`k`4
9- Izk joiz` gkgjkzv oz j{vemkvv oxmkzv i`ky{ipklu
emozgk` o pbk ivvkpv ip zevc?
:- Izk qil{ipeomv o o'jilimfk vbkkp empimhejlk ivvkpv
v{fekmplu iff{zipk im` fovp'kkfpeqk?
6- Izk gimihkgkmp im` joiz`v i~~zo~zeipklu emozgk` o EP
fompzol xkicmkvvkv im` iel{zkv?
0- @o ill kg~loukkv im` fompzifpozv {m`kzvpim` pbkez
zkv~omvejelepekv oz `ipi vkf{zepu?
;- Izk `ipi vkf{zepu fompzolv kqil{ipk` oz kkfpv om km`'
{vkzv, emfl{`emh f{vpogkzv im` j{vemkvv ~izpmkzv?
1- @okv pbk fog~imu biqk im i~~zo~zeipk `evivpkz zkfoqkzu
~lim im` j{vemkvv fompem{epu ~lim?8- Izk ~limv im` ~olefekv zkqekxk` ~kzeo`efillu po kmv{zk
i~~lefijelepu po mkx pkfbmolohekv?
2- Izk zkfz{epgkmp, zkpkmpeom im` kqklo~gkmp ~limv
kkfpeqk em kmv{zemh {~'po'`ipk pkfbmefil vcellv?
5- Izk uo{ v{zk uo{z fog~imu biv pickm i`ky{ipk vpk~v po
kmv{zk epv fog~leimfk xepb ill pbk lixv im` zkh{lipeomv
pbip i~~lu po emozgipeom pkfbmolohu?
9>- @okv gimihkgkmp gomepoz ~zo~ovk` lixv im`
zkh{lipeomv po kmv{zk uo{z fog~imu ev {llu ~zk~izk` po
fog~lu xepb pbkg?
E pbk imvxkzv po imu o pbkvk y{kvpeomv izk mo, FJET
fim ~zoqe`k ivv{zimfk im` fomv{lpemh vkzqefkv po bkl~ uo{
eg~zoqk uo{z fog~imuv EP zevc gimihkgkmp-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
25/38
Pbk Kgkzhemh Azompekzv o Zevc Gimihkgkmp
FOG^LEIMFK IM@ AEMIMFEIL ZK^OZPEMH
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
26/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Pbzo{hbo{p pbk :>>>v, lkhevlipozv im` zkh{lipozv {mlkivbk`
i pe`il xiqk o mkx lixv im` zkh{lipeomv im` vpk~~k` {~
kmozfkgkmp ifpeomv po jkppkz ~zopkfp emqkvpozv, f{vpogkzv,
im` kg~loukkv zog {mkr~kfpk` dolpv `{k po zevcv pbip xkzk
mop ozkvkkm oz gepehipk`- Ip pbk vigk pegk, iffo{mpemh
vpim`iz`'vkppkzv vpk~~k` {~ kozpv po fomqkzhk [V hkmkzillu
iffk~pk` iffo{mpemh ~zemfe~lkv "[V HII^% xepb Empkzmipeomil
Aemimfeil Zk~ozpemh Vpim`iz`v "EAZV%- Pbk fogjemipeom o
pbkvk kozpv lkp [V'jivk` fog~imekv `kilemh xepb vehmefimp
{mfkzpiempekv em fog~leimfk im` zk~ozpemh ip pbk vigk pegk
pbku xkzk `kilemh xepb {m~zkfk`kmpk` {mfkzpiempekv em pbk
kfomogu- Pohkpbkz, pbkvk ifpozv jopb bkl~k` im` bem`kzk`
pbk do{zmku poxiz` jkppkz kmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp"KZG%- Gimu fog~imekv zkfohmetk` pbk mkk` oz jkppkz
zevc gimihkgkmp j{p bi` legepk` zkvo{zfkv po i`o~p im`
eg~lkgkmp zoj{vp KZG vuvpkgv-
Fbimhemh Lixv im` Iffo{mpemh Vpim`iz`v
Vogk o pbk govp vehmefimp fbimhkv em lixv, z{lkv,
zkh{lipeomv im` iffo{mpemh fbimhkv ikfpemh fog~imekv
po`iu emfl{`k pbk olloxemh4
mGidoz lkhevlipeom xiv kmifpk` em pbk [V em zkv~omvk po
mimfeil zk~ozpemh im` fzk`ep fzevkv, emfl{`emh pbk Vizjimkv'
Orlku Ifp o :>>: im` pbk @o``'Azimc Xill Vpzkkp Zkozg
im` Fomv{gkz ^zopkfpeom Ifp o :>9>- Pbk Vizjimkv'
Orlku Ifp empzo`{fk` empkzmil fompzol zk~ozpemh im` i{`epoz
ippkvpipeom zky{ezkgkmpv oz ill ~{jlef fog~imekv, j{p
vgillkz fog~imekv xkzk lipkz krkg~pk` zog pbk ippkvpipeom
zky{ezkgkmpv- Pbk @o``'Azimc Ifp empzo`{fk` vxkk~emh
zkozgv oz pbk mimfeil vkfpoz iv xkll iv hoqkzmimfk
zkozgv pbip ikfp ill vkfpozv- Pbk fbimhkv emfl{`k i
vehmefimp kr~imveom o pbk VKFv ~oxkzv po fog~kmvipk
xbevplk'jloxkzv im` hzkipkz vbizkbol`kz zehbpv, emfl{`emh
qopkv om krkf{peqk fog~kmvipeom-
mZkfkmp [V iffo{mpemh vpim`iz`v im` VKF z{lkv biqk
kvpijlevbk` i``epeomil zky{ezkgkmpv oz `evflov{zkv ijo{p
zevcv, im` pbk [V Aemimfeil Iffo{mpemh Vpim`iz`v Joiz`
"AIVJ% ev fomve`kzemh vxkk~emh fbimhkv em iffo{mpemh
im` mimfeil zk~ozpemh- Pbk AIVJ biv zklkivk` i m{gjkz
o kr~ov{zk `zipv `kvehmk` po fomqkzhk [V HII^ xepb
EAZV- Pbkvk ~zo~ovilv xo{l` gick vehmefimp fbimhkv
po [V HII - [mfkzpiempekv zkgiem zkhiz`emh pbk mil
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
27/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
vpim`iz`v im` kkfpeqk `ipkv, iv xkll iv xbkm pbk VKF
gehbp zky{ezk oz ~kzgep [V evv{kzv po {vk EAZV em pbkez
VKF lemhv- Pbk AIVJ ev ilvo fomve`kzemh i ~zo~ovil oz
i vk~izipk [V ~zeqipk fog~imu iffo{mpemh vpim`iz`v'
vkppemh joiz`-
mVogk iffo{mpemh fbimhkv emepeipk` em pbk ge`' po
lipk' :>>>v biqk bi` i `kliuk` eg~ifp- Aoz krig~lk,
pbk AIVJ gi`k vehmefimp fbimhkv po pbk iffo{mpemh
oz j{vemkvv fogjemipeomv {m`kz [V HII^ em pbk lipk
:>>>v, j{p fog~imekv bi` zklipeqklu kx offiveomv po
eg~lkgkmp pbkvk fbimhkv {mpel pbk ~ifk o ifpeqepu em
gkzhkzv im` ify{evepeomv "G!I% ~efck` {~ em :>99-
mGimu o pbk mkx lixv im` z{lkv biqk vehmefimp pireg~lefipeomv- Govp mopijlu, fbimhkv em [V pir lixv biqk
~lifk` i``k` kg~bivev om pbk zk~ozpemh o {mfkzpiem
pir ~ovepeomv oz jopb iffo{mpemh im` pir ~{z~ovkv "EZV
Vfbk`{lk [P^%, im` pbk [V ev fomve`kzemh gidoz pir
zkozg oz j{vemkvvkv oz pbk zvp pegk em `kfi`kv em
im kozp po loxkz pbk vpip{pozu zipk im` zk`{fk j{`hkp
`kfepv-
Gozk Hzku Izkiv im` pbk Mkk` oz Hzkipkz D{`hgkmp
Iv i zkv{lp o pbk emfzkivk` qol{gk o mkx lixv im`
iffo{mpemh vpim`iz`v, fog~imekv g{vp `kqopk gozkzkvo{zfkv po gomepozemh im` {m`kzvpim`emh pbk fbimhemh
zky{ezkgkmpv- Ip pegkv, pbk eg~lefipeomv fim jk `ef{lp po
`evfkzm, im` fog~imekv fim m` pbkgvklqkv em {mfbizpk`
pkzzepozekv oz hzku izkiv pbip zky{ezk fomve`kzijlk d{`hgkmp
im` i`` po pbk zevcv zklipk` po fog~leimfk im` mimfeil
zk~ozpemh- Bkzk izk i kx krig~lkv4
mEAZV- Fbimhkv em [V iffo{mpemh vpim`iz`v po ifbekqk
fomqkzhkmfk xepb EAZV fim biqk jzoi` j{vemkvv
eg~lefipeomv pbip krpkm` iz jkuom` pbk iffo{mpemh
`k~izpgkmp, im` i lifc o empkz~zkpeqk h{e`imfk giu biqk
{mempkm`k` fomvky{kmfkv, v{fb iv i lifc o fog~izijelepu
igomh mimfeil vpipkgkmpv oz gevfogg{mefipeomv xepb
emqkvpozv iff{vpogk` po [V HII -
mPirkv- Vfbk`{lk [P , xbefb ev kkfpeqk em :>99,
empzo`{fkv i``k` pir zevcv jkfi{vk {mfkzpiem pir
~ovepeomv giu mkk` po jk zk~ozpk` po pbk EZV jkozk
pbku izk zkvolqk`- Ip pbk vigk pegk, fog~imekv giu
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
28/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
ifk opbkz mkx pir zevcv iv pbk Ojigi I`gemevpzipeom ev
fomve`kzemh i givveqk pir oqkzbi{l pbip giu empzo`{fk
ukp gozk zevcv im` {mfkzpiempekv `{zemh pbk lkhevlipeqk
im` z{lk'gicemh ~zofkvv-
mG!I- Iffo{mpemh fbimhkv kkfpeqk em :>>5 gick ep
gozk `ef{lp oz gimihkgkmp po ~zk`efp pbk kizmemhv
eg~ifp zog ~opkmpeil ify{evepeomv, im` pbev emfzkivkv
pbk zevcv pbip giu iffog~imu G!I xepbo{p emfzkivk`
`{k `elehkmfk im` kr~kzp h{e`imfk em v{fb izkiv iv
qil{ipeomv im` ify{evepeom iffo{mpemh-
mAzi{`{lkmpmimfeilzk~ozpemh- Pbk VKFv kr~im`k`
~oxkzv po fog~kmvipk xbevplk'jloxkzv fo{l` ikfp
foz~ozipk boplemkv em ~{jlef fog~imekv- F{zzkmplu, pbkvkboplemkv izk qekxk` iv im eg~ozpimp xiu po `kpkfp
zi{`- Vogk biqk kr~zkvvk` fomfkzmv ijo{p i zevc pbip
kg~loukkv xell zk~ozp zi{` po pbk VKF xepbo{p zk~oz pemh
ep po pbk fog~imu zvp-
m@ipivkf{zepu- Pbk Ak`kzil Pzi`k Foggevveom ~limv po
vpizp kmozfemh pbk Zk` Alihv Z{lk em :>99- Xepb legepk`
krfk~peomv, "k-h-, oz lix im` iffo{mpemh zgv%, pbev z{lk
i~~lekv po ill fog~imekv pbip okz hoo`v oz vkzqefkv im`
illox f{vpogkzv po ~iu lipkz- [m`kz pbk z{lk, fog~imekv
g{vp pick vpk~v po `kpkfp e`kmpepu pbkp, emfl{`emh xzeppkm
~zohzigv oz iffo{mpv pbip ~zkvkmp i zkivomijlu
ozkvkkijlk zevc zog e`kmpepu pbkp- Pbev vpim`iz` zievkvevv{kv emqolqemh v{jdkfpeqk empkz~zkpipeom-
mVofeilmkpxozcv- [V lixv im` kmozfkgkmp ifpeomv
ijo{p vofeil mkpxozcv zievk lkhil y{kvpeomv mop ukp
i``zkvvk` ju pbk fo{zpv, xepb pbk zkv{lp pbip fog~imekv
giu mkk` po xilc i mk lemk jkpxkkm fog~leimfk im`
~zopkfpemh pbkez zk~{pipeomv- Aoz krig~lk, kmozfkgkmp
ifpeomv ju pbk Mipeomil Lijoz Zkqekx Joiz` em`efipk
fog~imu ~olefekv oz xozc~lifk {vk o vofeil mkpxozcemh
im` zklipk` `evfe~lemizu ifpeomv oz qeolipeomv o pbk
~olefu giu jk qekxk` iv qeolipemh k`kzil lijoz lixv-
Oqkzvehbp Fbillkmhkv
Pbk fbillkmhkv o oqkzvkkemh fog~leimfk xepb vpim`iz`v,
z{lkv, im` zkh{lipeomv izk fog~o{m`k` ju p{zj{lkmp kfomogef
pegkv- Vp{`ekv vbox pbip pbk zevcv o zi{` go{mp xbkm pbkzk
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
29/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
izk ~zkvv{zkv po hzox pbk j{vemkvv oz xbkm fovp'f{ppemh
fog~zogevkv empkzmil fompzolv- Aoz krig~lk, i zkfkmp FOVO
vp{`u o{m` pbip4
mGovp fivkv o zi{`{lkmp mimfeil zk~ozpemh `{zemh pbk
:>>>v off{zzk` xbkm fog~imekv xkzk kr~kzekmfemh
mkp lovvkv oz xkzk em flovk po jzkic'kqkm ~ovepeomv em
~kzeo`v jkozk pbk zi{`-
mPbk govp foggom gopeqipeomv oz zi{`v igomh
~{jlef fog~imekv emfl{`k` pbk mkk` po gkkp kizmemhv
kr~kfpipeomv, iv xkll iv ippkg~pv po fomfkil pbk
fog~imuv `kpkzeozipemh mimfeil fom`epeom, emfzkivk pbk
vpofc ~zefk, jolvpkz mimfeil ~kzozgimfk oz ~km`emhky{epu oz `kjp mimfemh, oz emfzkivk gimihkgkmp
fog~kmvipeom jivk` om mimfeil zkv{lpv-
Pbk FOVO zk~ozp fomfl{`k` pbip i``epeomil vck~pefevg
ev mkk`k` ip pegkv xbkm pbkzk izk emfzkivk` ~zkvv{zkv
oz zi{`- Pbkvk m`emhv zkemozfk pbk mkk` oz pbozo{hb
em`k~km`kmp i{`epv im` fim`e` `evf{vveom xepb i{`epozv o
imu ojvkzqipeomv im` zkfoggkm`ipeomv-
Aemimfeil Zkv{lpv im` Leckleboo` o Azi{`{lkmp Zk~ozpemh
1
;
0
6
:
9
>
:>>: :>>; :>>2 :>99
Leckleboo` o gkkpemh `kjp foqkmimp
Vpofc gizckp ~zefk
Mkp emfogk
Leckleboo o zi{`{lkmp amimfeil zk~ozpemh
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
30/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
Pbk ~zov~kfpv oz fomqkzhkmfk xepb EAZV giu fog~o{m`
pbk fbillkmhkv pbip lek ibki`, Jkfi{vk EAZV izk hkmkzillu
qekxk` iv ~zemfe~lkv'jivk` im` lkvv z{lk'empkmveqk pbim
[V HII , vogk jklekqk pbk i``k` akrejelepu ioz`k` ju EAZV
giu fompzej{pk po i behbkz leckleboo` o zi{`{lkmp mimfeil
zk~ozpemh im` pbk mkk` oz kqkm gozk d{`hgkmp ju ~zk~izkzv
im` hzkipkz vck~pefevg ju em`k~km`kmp i{`epozv- Pbk VKF
biv ihzkk` po fom`{fp i pbozo{hb vp{`u o pbk eg~lefipeomv
jkozk gicemh imu mil `kfeveomv zkhiz`emh {vk o EAZV
ju [V evv{kzv- I{`ep foggeppkkv im` opbkzv fbizhk` xepb
hoqkzmimfk xell mkk` po gomepoz pbev izki flovklu po e`kmpeu,
gomepoz im` gepehipk pbk zevcv emqolqk`-
I``epeomil emozgipeom ijo{p pbk FOVO vp{`u ev iqielijlk em
pbk olloxemh zk~ozp4
mFOVO, Azi{`{lkmp Aemimfeil Zk~ozpemh4 9552':>>8,
Im Imiluvev o [-V- ^{jlef Fog~imekv, Giu :>9>
"iqielijlk ip bpp~4//xxx-fovo-ozh/`of{gkmpv/
FOVOAZI[@VP[@U:>9>_>>9-~`%
Y{kvpeomv po Ivc Ijo{p Fog~leimfk im`
Aemimfeil Zk~ozpemh
Pbk olloxemh y{kvpeomv giu jk bkl~{l em `kpkzgememh boxxkll uo{z fog~imu ev fogemh po hze~v xepb zevcv zklipk` po
fog~leimfk im` mimfeil zk~ozpemh-
9- Biv pbk fog~imu kqil{ipk` pbk eg~ifp o fomqkzhkmfk
xepb EAZV om epv empkzmil fompzol vuvpkgv im` mimfeil
vpipkgkmpv?
:- Ev pbk fog~imu gomepozemh zky{ezkgkmpv im` jkvp
~zifpefkv oz `evflov{zkv ijo{p zevcv, jopb em pbk mopkv po
pbk mimfeil vpipkgkmpv im` em opbkz ~lifkv, emfl{`emh pbk
G@!I vkfpeomv o imm{il zk~ozpv, e i~~lefijlk?
6- @okv pbk fog~imu biqk i xbevplkjloxkz ~zohzig v{jdkfp
po oqkzvehbp ju pbk i{`ep foggeppkk "oz opbkzv fbizhk` xepb
hoqkzmimfk%?
0- Biv pbk i{`ep foggeppkk "oz opbkzv fbizhk` xepb
hoqkzmimfk% i~~zoqk` y{impek` zevc polkzimfkv, xbkzk
i~~zo~zeipk?
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
31/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
;- @okv pbk i{`ep foggeppkk "oz opbkzv fbizhk` xepb
hoqkzmimfk% ~zojk pbk lkqkl o zevc oz {mfkzpiempu em fzepefil
iffo{mpemh kvpegipkv im` `evf{vv pbk kvpegipkv xepb pbk
krpkzmil i{`epoz?
1- Ev pbk fog~imuv zevc gimihkgkmp ~zohzig empkhzipk` xepb
epv empkzmil im` krpkzmil i{`epv?
8- Biqk i~~zo~zeipk lkhil im` zevc kr~kzpv jkkm fomv{lpk` po
kmv{zk pbip ill qeijlk zevc o~peomv biqk jkkm e`kmpek` im`
izk i~~zo~zeipklu {m`kzvpoo`?
2- @okv pbk fog~imu biqk zevc ~kzozgimfk gkiv{zkv po vkk
box xkll ep ev gimihemh epv zevcv?
5- @okv pbk fog~imu gomepoz mkx lixv, z{lkv, zkh{lipeomv
im` iffo{mpemh fbimhkv zkh{lizlu im` {~`ipk epv zevcivvkvvgkmpv po kmv{zk pbku zkgiem f{zzkmp?
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
32/38
Pbk Kgkzhemh Azompekzv o Zevc Gimihkgkmp
KGKZHEMH ZEVCV IM@ CKU ZEVC EM@EFIPOZV
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
33/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
[lpegipklu, pbk hoil o imu zevc gimihkgkmp ~zohzig ev po
kmijlk gimihkgkmp po pick ifpeom em pegk po gepehipk pbk
zevcv im` iqoe` bizg po pbk fog~imuv zk~{pipeom, ivvkpv, im`
qil{k- Ukp gimu fog~imekv vkkg po jk vpz{hhlemh xepb pbk
e`kmpefipeom im` zk~ozpemh ~bivkv, lkiqemh j{vemkvv oxmkzv
im` joiz`v o `ezkfpozv `evvipevk` xepb pbk zkv{lpv- Foggom
z{vpzipeomv emfl{`k pbk pegk im` fovp zky{ezkgkmpv, iv xkll
iv pbk `khzkk o `ef{lpu emqolqk` em ihhzkhipemh zevcv po
fogk {~ xepb vogk vozp o joppog lemk em`efipoz pbip ev bkl~{
po joiz`v- Pbzo{hb i vkzekv o v{zqkuv im` xbepk ~i~kzv,
pbk Foggeppkk o V~omvozemh Ozhimetipeomv o pbk Pzki`xiu
Foggevveom "FOVO% im` opbkz hzo{~v izk i`qofipemh i
m{gjkz o vpk~v po bkl~ oqkzfogk pbkvk z{vpzipeomv im` pickkmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp "KZG% po pbk mkrp lkqkl-
Zevc Zk~ozpemh4 Izkiv oz Eg~zoqkgkmp
Zkfkmp v{zqkuv biqk bomk` em om pbk v~kfef izkiv o
eg~zoqkgkmp pbip izk o pbk govp empkzkvp po foz~ozipk joiz`v
o `ezkfpozv- Govp mopijlu, joiz`v ximp zkh{liz im` zoj{vp
vuvpkgv o zk~ozpemh zevcv im` pbku ximp gimihkzv po jkfogk
gozk emqolqk` em kmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp ~zofkvvkv
pbip foqkz pbk kmpezk fog~imu, mop d{vp vklkfpk` j{vemkvv
o~kzipeomv- Bkzk izk i kx krig~lkv o zkfkmp m`emhv pbip
zkakfp pbkvk ximpv im` mkk`v4
mFOVO v~omvozk` i v{zqku o FAOv em pbk IEF^Iv
j{vemkvv im` em`{vpzu hzo{~ em :>>2- Pbk v{zqku o{m`
pbip joiz`v o `ezkfpozv xkzk ivcemh vkmeoz krkf{peqkv po
emfzkivk pbkez emqolqkgkmp em zevc oqkzvehbp em ilgovp bil
pbk ozhimetipeomv zk~zkvkmpk`-
mPbk vp{`u o pbk IEF^I hzo{~ ilvo o{m` pbkzk xiv mo
ozgil kmpkz~zevk'xe`k zevc gimihkgkmp ~zofkvv em ~lifk
ip i vehmefimp gemozepu "00+% o pbk fog~imekv v{zqkuk`
im` {llu 8;+ o pbk fog~imekv v{zqkuk` vie` pbip cku
zevcv xkzk fogg{mefipk` omlu om im i` bof jivev ip
gimihkgkmp gkkpemhv-
mI gozk zkfkmp FOVO vp{`u zklkivk` em :>9> o{m` pbip
qkzu kx fog~imekv ":2+% `kvfzejk pbkez KZG vuvpkgv
iv vuvpkgipef, zoj{vp im` zk~kipijlk, xbelk {llu 1>+
o pbk fog~imekv v{zqkuk` `kvfzejk` pbkez zevc picemh
iv govplu emozgil oz pzifck` omlu xepbem em`eqe`{il velov
zipbkz pbim kmpkz~zevk'xe`k-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
34/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
mPbk gidozepu "ilgovp pxo'pbez`v% o pbk fog~imekv em pbk
:>9> v{zqku viu pbku zk~ozp po~ zevc kr~ov{zkv po pbk
joiz` om i zkh{lizlu'vfbk`{lk` jivev- Boxkqkz, pbk ozg
o oqkzvehbp i~~kizv po jk fiv{il im` {mvpz{fp{zk`-
Fbillkmhkv4 Kgkzhemh Zevcv im` Gkiv{zkgkmpv o Empimhejlkv
Xbu izk zevc gimihkgkmp zk~ozpemh vuvpkgv illemh vbozp
o kr~kfpipeomv? Izh{ijlu pbk govp `ef{lp ojvpiflkv
po vuvpkgipef, zoj{vp, im` zk~kipijlk zevc gimihkgkmp
~zofkvvkv po`iu emqolqk4
9- Giempiememh i vuvpkg pbip ckk~v {~ po `ipk xepb kgkzhemhzevcv, zipbkz pbim veg~lu zollemh ozxiz` im` {~`ipemh pbk
omkv e`kmpek` em ~zeoz ukizv, im`
:- @kqklo~emh ~zifpefil, fovp'kkfpeqk vuvpkgv o zk~ozpemh
zevcv zklipk` po `ef{lp'po'gkiv{zk empimhejlkv, v{fb iv
pbk vkf{zepu o i fog~imuv `ipi, oz pbk y{ilepu o epv
mimfeil zk~ozpemh ~zifpefkv-
Pkfbmey{kv
Xbelk empimhejlkv zkgiem `ef{lp po gkiv{zk, vkqkzil
pkfbmey{kv biqk jkkm `kqklo~k` po bkl~ oqkzfogk pbk
ojvpiflkv zklipk` po zk~ozpemh vuvpkgv- Jzek v{ggizekv o
pbk v{hhkvpk` i~~zoifbkv izk iv olloxv4
mLki`emh zevc em`efipozv im` kvfilipeom pzehhkzv- Pbk
FOVOv :>>0 zk~ozp v{hhkvpv pbk {vk o lki`emh zevc
em`efipozv im` kvfilipeom oz pbzkvbol` pzehhkzv-
Krig~lkv4 I fog~imu gehbp gomepoz fomv{gkz
fom`kmfk iv i lki`emh em`efipoz o vilkv qol{gk
"~zodkfpk` {mepv vol` ~kz vpozk ~kz gompb%- Oz ep gehbp
gomepoz im em`kr o vpi gozilk o behb ~kzozgkzv iv i
lki`emh em`efipoz o vpi p{zmoqkz- Pbk ~zemfe~lk jkbem`
pbev i~~zoifb ev pbip fomv{gkz fom`kmfk em`efipozv
vbo{l` jk zk~ozpk` po joiz`v e pbku ill vbozp o i ~zk'
`kpkzgemk` lkqkl3 vegelizlu, vpi gozilk em`efipozv vbo{l`
jk zk~ozpk` e pbku ill vbozp o i gemegillu'iffk~pijlk
lkqkl- Em kkfp, pbk ~zk'`kpkzgemk` lkqklv izk kvfilipeom
pbzkvbol`v oz zevc pbzkvbol`v- Em ~zifpefk, boxkqkz, ep
fim jk i fbillkmhk po ihzkk om gkimemh{l m{gkzefil
em`efipozv im` pbzkvbol`v-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
35/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
mEm`efipozv jivk` om fi{vil imiluvev- I :>9> FOVO
xbepk ~i~kz v{hhkvpv i vuvpkgipef i~~zoifb po pbk
`kqklo~gkmp o cku zevc em`efipozv "CZEv%- [m`kz pbev
i~~zoifb, pbk vklkfpeom o CZEv ev jivk` om im imiluvev
o pbk zoop fi{vkv o kqkmpv em`kmpek` iv vehmefimp-
Krig~lkv4 I fog~imu gehbp e`kmpeu i jzockm `kjp
foqkmimp iv i vehmefimp kqkmp pbip vbo{l` jk zk~ozpk`
po pbk joiz` o `ezkfpozv- Ep xell lecklu jk `ef{lp po
e`kmpeu i vemhlk zoop fi{vk oz i jzockm foqkmimp-
J{p im imiluvev o ~ovvejlk fi{vkv gehbp lki` po pbk
e`kmpefipeom o empkzgk`eipk ifpozv, v{fb iv `kfzkivkv
em vilkv em zkfkmp gompbv oz vbozpihkv o fivb zkv{lpemhem pbk mkk` oz vbozp'pkzg jozzoxemh- Pbkvk ifpozv
em p{zm gehbp zkv{lp zog oqkzill kfomogef fom`epeomv,
~zefemh pzkm`v, oz lijoz evv{kv im` pbkvk ifpozv xo{l`
jk vkkm iv pbk zoop fi{vkv oz xbefb cku zevc em`efipozv
vbo{l` jk `kqklo~k`-
Jkfi{vk pbk :>9> i~~zoifb fomve`kzv ep {mlecklu pbip imu
omk em`efipoz xell i`ky{ipklu fi~p{zk ill pbk ifkpv o i
`kqklo~emh zevc, i fozollizu ~zemfe~lk ev pbip govp fog~imekv
xell mkk` po gomepoz im` xkehbp i `ivbjoiz` o em`efipozv-
Ell{vpzipeom4 @ivbjoiz` o Em`efipozv
Aoz vogk fog~imekv, pbk jkvp i~~zoifb giu jk i zevc
vfozkfiz` pbip {vkv i fogjemipeom o pbk pxo pkfbmey{kv
`kvfzejk` ijoqk ju zk~ozpemh om pbk empimhejlkv ip zevc
xepbo{p pzuemh po gkiv{zk pbkg- Pbev fim jk `omk {vemh
CZEv, foloz'fo`k` vpip{v em`efipozv, im` im izzox po vbox pbk
pzkm`, "e-k-, xbkpbkz pbk zevc ev emfzkivemh oz `kfzkivemh% iv
ell{vpzipk` em pbk pijlk om pbk mkrp ~ihk-
Em kkfp, pbk foloz'fo`k` efomv em pbk pijlk zkakfp pbk
~ovepeomemh o pbk zevc om i zevc gi~ oz bkip gi~- Hzkkm
zk~zkvkmpv zevcv pbip izk lox eg~ifp im` biqk i lox
leckleboo` o bi~~kmemh3 zk` zk~zkvkmpv zevcv pbip xo{l`
biqk i behb eg~ifp im` i behb leckleboo` o gipkzeiletemh3
im` igjkz zk~zkvkmpv zevcv pbip izk gk`e{g eg~ifp im`
biqk i go`kzipk fbimfk o bi~~kmemh- Pbk izzoxv em`efipk
xbkpbkz pbk zevc po pbk ivvkpv ev emfzkivemh oz `kfzkivemh-
Aoz krig~lk, i `oxmxiz` pzkm` em pbk m{gjkz o cmoxm
q{lmkzijelepekv po bifckz ippifcv ev im em`efipeom pbip pbk
fog~imuv `ipi vkf{zepu zevc ev `kfzkivemh, xbelk im {~xiz`
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
36/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
pzkm` em pbk m{gjkz o mom'[V mimfk `ezkfpozv xbo izk mop
cmoxlk`hkijlk ijo{p [V HII^ ev im em`efipeom pbip zevc po
pbk y{ilepu o pbk fog~imuv mimfeil zk~ozpemh {m`kz [V
HII^ ev emfzkivemh-
Ivvkpv ip Zevc Cku Zevc Em`efipozv Vpip{v Pzkm`
Vkf{zepu o f{vpogkz `ipi
Cmoxm q{lmkzijelepekv l
M{gjkz o {mi{pbozetk` ippkg~pv po
iffkvv `ipil
Fog~imuv zk~{pipeom oz vikpu
V~ellv o bitiz`o{v gipkzeilvpzimv~ozpk` ju fog~imu
l
Mo- o xozc~lifk iffe`kmpv l
Y{ilepu o mimfeil zk~ozpemh
Mo- o emfe`kmpv o zi{`{lkmp zk~ozpemh
fillk` empo pbk boplemkl
Mo- o mom'[V v{jve`eizekv xepb mimfk
`ezkfpozv xbo izk mop cmoxlk`hkijlk
ijo{p [V HII^
l
Pbev i~~zoifb xozcv xkll oz gimu pu~kv o j{vemkvv zevcv-J{p ep ev `ef{lp po i~~lu po jlifc vxim zevcv pbip izk behb
eg~ifp, biz`'po'~zk`efp zevcv o kqkmpv pbip ho jkuom` pbk zkilg
o mozgil kr~kfpipeomv em vfekmfk, mimfk im` pkfbmolohu-
^zofkvvkv oz gimihemh pbkvk pu~kv o zevcv izk vpell jkemh
`evf{vvk` ju gimihkzv, zevc i`qevozv, im` ifi`kgefv-
Aoz Gozk Emozgipeom
Pbk olloxemh gipkzeilv izk zkkzkmfk` em pbev zk~ozp im`
iqielijlk ip xxx-fovo-ozh4
mFOVO, Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Gimihkgkmp Empkhzipk`
Azigkxozc, :>>0 mZk~ozp om pbk F{zzkmp Vpipk o Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Oqkzvehbp,
Gimihkgkmp Iffo{mpemh Zkvkizfb Fom`{fpk` om Jkbil
o pbk IEF^I, Gizc Jkivlku, Jz{fk Jzimvom, im` Jommek
Bimfofc, :>>5
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
37/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
m@kqklo~emh Cku Zevc Em`efipozv po Vpzkmhpbkm Kmpkz~zevk
Zevc Gimihkgkmp4 Box Cku Zevc Em`efipozv Fim Vbiz~km
Aof{v om Kgkzhemh Zevcv, FOVO, Gizc Jkivlku, Jz{fk F-
Jzimvom, im` Jommek Bimfofc
mFOVOv :>9> Zk~ozp om KZG4 F{zzkmp Vpipk o
Kmpkz~zevk Zevc Oqkzvehbp im` Gizckp ^kzfk~peomv o
FOVOv KZG Azigkxozc, :>9>
Box Xk Fim Bkl~
Ip FJET, xk biqk ilxiuv qekxk` i`o~peom o KZG iv i do{zmku
zipbkz pbim im kqkmp- O{z qeveom oz pbk {p{zk ev i lkqkl ~liuemh
kl` xbkzk kmpkz~zevkv o ill vetkv im` em ill em`{vpzekv biqkpbk cem`v o ~zifpefil im` akrejlk poolv mkk`k` oz v{ffkvv{l
zevc gimihkgkmp- Ju pbip xk gkim pbk cem`v o fovp'kkfpeqk
poolv pbip xell illox gimihkgkmp po e`kmpeu, gomepoz, im`
gepehipk zevcv v{ffkvv{llu- O{z zevc i`qevozu vkzqefkv im`
~{jlefipeomv izk `kvehmk` po bkl~ gick pbev qeveom i zkilepu- Em
i``epeom po kmpkz~zevk zevc gimihkgkmp vkzqefkv, xk ~zoqe`k
i {ll zimhk o zevc i`qevozu vkzqefkv emfl{`emh pbk olloxemh4
empkzmil i{`ep vkzqefkv, zi{` emqkvpehipeomv, ~zoifpeqk impe'
zi{` ~zohzigv, EP i{`ep im` vkf{zepu vkzqefkv, vkzqefk
ozhimetipeom zk~ozpemh "ozgkzlu cmoxm iv VIV 8> vkzqefkv%,
j{vemkvv fompem{epu ~limmemh, im` E^O i{`ep v{~~ozp-
E uo{ biqk y{kvpeomv ijo{p pbev zk~ozp oz box po i~~lu pbk
emvehbpv po uo{z ozhimetipeom, ~lkivk fompifp Gefbikl Hillihbkz
oz Jzeim Hzkhozu-
FJET Zevc ! I`qevozu Vkzqefkv
Uo{z em`k~km`kmp zkvo{zfk oz i jzoi` zimhk o zevc
gimihkgkmp im` j{vemkvv i`qevozu vkzqefkv-
Qevep o{z xkjvepk ip bpp~4//xxx-fjet-fog/ziv/
@oxmloi` o{z Zevc ! I`qevozu Vkzqefkv Jzofb{zk-
-
8/6/2019 The Emerging Frontiers of Risk Management: TODAYS NORMS AND EXPECTATIONS
38/38
PBK KGKZHEMH AZOMPEKZV OA ZEVC GIMIHKGKMP
FJET GBG ev pbk jzim` migk oz FJET GBG, LLF im` opbkz
Aemimfeil Vkzqefkv v{jve`eizekv o FJET, Emf- "MUVK4 FJT%
pbip ~zoqe`k pir, amimfeil i`qevozu im` fomv{lpemh vkzqefkv
po em`eqe`{ilv, pir'krkg~p ozhimetipeomv im` i xe`k zimhk o
~{jleflu'pzi`k` im` ~zeqipklu'bkl` fog~imekv-
Fompifpv
Jzeim Hzkhozu
^zkve`kmp im` Vkmeoz Gimihemh @ezkfpoz
FJET GBG
Zevc im` I`qevozu Vkzqefkv
jhzkhozuNfjet-fog:91-;:;-95;0
Gefbikl V- Hillihbkz
Gimihemh @ezkfpoz
FJET GBG
Kmpkz~zevk Zevc
Gimihkgkmp Vkzqefkv
ghillihbkzNfjet-fog
896-;1:-99;0
bev ~{jlefipeom ~zoqe`kv hkmkzil emozgipeom im` `okv mop fomvpep{pk lkhil,
ffo{mpemh, pir oz opbkz ~zokvveomil i`qefk- Zki`kzv izk i`qevk` po ojpiem
zokvveomil i`qefk pbip ev i~~zo~zeipklu pielozk` po pbkez em`eqe`{il fezf{gvpimfkv-
:>99FJETGBGZev
c!
I`qevozuVkzqefkv,LLF
top related