the influence of music on cortisol - as a marker of stress and
Post on 03-Jan-2017
218 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
1
The influence of music on cortisol - as a marker of stress and depression
IOANA CIOCA1
ABSTRACT:
Music reduces stress through different mechanisms. Firstly there are the physical and mental
relaxation mechanisms. Secondly, music helps in stress relief activities. It also reduces negative
emotions. Furthermore, music can distract from negative thoughts and activities and can help to
achieve a positive and more optimistic state of mind. Therefore music proves its effectiveness in
reducing the levels of anxiety and depression and also in improving the mood. But the music itself
reduces the amount of hormones released during stress and most studies have focused on measuring
cortisol levels before and after exposure to different types of music.
Starting from the literature on the benefits of music on cortisol levels, we aimed to
investigate the impact of classical music on salivary cortisol in a group of patients suffering from
depression. Our study confirms the information gathered from literature regarding the favorable
effect of music on cortisol. Although there are slight differences between lively and relaxing music
(in favor of the relaxing type) study shows that the favorable effect of music is maintained for both
types of music, the most important element being the satisfaction of the listener.
Keywords: music therapy, stress, depression, anxiety, cortisol, ACTH.
REZUMAT:
Muzica reduce stresul prin diferite mecanisme. În primul rând, există mecanismele fizice şi
mentale de relaxare. În al doilea rând, muzica ajută la activităţile de salvare de stres. De asemenea,
reduce emoţiile negative. În plus, muzica poate distrage atenţia de la gândurile şi activităţile
1 Psychologist, Assistant Professor in Department of Medical Psychology and Psychosomatics of
University of Medicine and Pharmacy "Carol Davila", Bucharest
2
negative şi poate ajuta pentru a realiza o stare pozitivă şi mai optimistă a minţii. Prin urmare,
muzica dovedeşte eficienţă în reducerea nivelului de anxietate şi depresie şi, de asemenea, în
îmbunătăţirea starii de spirit. Muzica reduce cantitatea de hormonii eliberati în timpul stresului şi
cele mai multe studii s-au concentrat pe măsurarea nivelului de cortizol, înainte şi după expunerea
la diferite tipuri de muzică.
Pornind de la literatura de specialitate cu privire la beneficiile muzicii asupra nivelurilor de
cortizol, ne-am propus să investighăm impactul muzicii clasice pe cortizolului salivar într-un grup
de pacienţi care suferă de depresie. Studiul nostru confirmă informaţiile culese din literatura de
specialitate în ceea ce priveşte efectul favorabil al muzicii pe cortizol. Deşi există diferenţe minore
între muzica plină de viaţă şi de relaxare (în favoarea tipului de relaxare), studiul arată că efectul
favorabil al muzicii se menţine pentru ambele tipuri de muzică, cel mai important element fiind
satisfacţia ascultătorului.
Cuvinte cheie: terapia prin muzică, stress, depresie, anxietate, cortizol, ACTH
Music improves mood and reduces depression and anxiety levels
The information gathered from literature supports the beneficial effect of music on anxiety
and depression levels of patients undergoing a difficult situation. For example, numerous studies
have shown that music can be used to reduce anxiety before and during surgery.
Epinephrine, norepinephrine, ACTH and cortisol are commonly used as markers of surgical
stress, particularly abdominal surgery (Cook, 1986; White et Shaw, 1991). The increase in the
level of these hormones is proportional to the stress of surgery, which was clearly shown in
one study (Wang et al., 2002). Rider (Rider et al., 1985) have already demonstrated that music
and image therapy determine relaxation and maintain average levels of corticosteroids in subjects
who are awake. Therefore, it seems that subjective effects of music on anxiety and depression are
easily proven, but an objective demonstration regarding the physiological variables is difficult to
achieve. (Bartlett et al., 1993)
3
Music can reduce patient anxiety before surgery. It has been demonstrated that listening to
music in the pre-and postoperative period reduces anxiety related to surgery and reduces the need
for analgesics (Kaminski et Hall, 1996; Burke et al., 1995). In patients under regional anesthesia,
music decreases the need for sedation and analgesia, and also decreases plasma levels of cortisol,
epinephrine and tissue plasminogen activator-type. (Coughlan, 1994; Rhoades et Tanner, 1995)
Several pharmacological interventions have proven effective in reducing perioperative stress
hormone release under general anesthesia (Weissman, 1990; Hall et al., 2000). The beneficial
effects of music on stress and welfare and on the decrease of sedation during regional anesthesia
have already been demonstrated (Koch et al., 1998; Lepage et al., 2001). Several studies have also
shown that listening to music, sounds or therapeutic suggestions during general anesthesia may
have a positive effect on postoperative recovery and decrease the need for analgesics (Ewans et
Richardson, 1988). Other studies could not demonstrate these findings (Boeke et al., 1988).
The effects of music on cortisol, the most important marker of depression
Music reduces stress through different mechanisms. Firstly there are the physical and mental
relaxation mechanisms. Secondly, music helps in stress relief activities. It also reduces negative
emotions. Furthermore, music can distract from negative thoughts and activities and can help to
achieve a positive and more optimistic state of mind. Numerous studies have focused on the
hormones ACTH and cortisol, to investigate the effects of music on the neurohormonal pathway.
Listening to music or singing can reduce levels of cortisol released during stress. Higher levels of
cortisol can lead to decreased immune response (Roux et al., 2007; Kreutz et al., 2004). It has been
proven that listening to quiet; classical music can significantly reduce stress (Khalfa et al., 20003;
Labbe’E et al., 2007).
There are several studies that have tried to find out if the music itself reduces the amount of
hormones released during stress. Most studies have focused on measuring cortisol levels before and
after exposure to different types of music. The aim was to reduce cortisol levels or, more precisely,
to prevent the increased release of this stress hormone during invasive diagnostic and surgical
procedures. Escher investigated a group of patients undergoing endoscopy, who listened to their
favorite music during the procedure. A control group did not listen to music. The control group
4
showed a large increase in cortisol and ACTH levels in their blood. However, the group that was
listening to music presented a significantly lower level of release of these hormones. (Escher et al.,
1993) In a similar approach, but in this case surgery-related, Miluk-Kolasa and his collaborators
(Miluk-Kolasa et al.,1994) have measured cortisol levels in patients after informing them that they
would undergo surgery the next day. These researchers found that information about impending
surgery led to an increase of 50% of the cortisol level. Some patients were subjected to listening to
music while others were the control group. An hour after the announcement the patients who did
not listen to music had higher levels of cortisol compared to the group that had listened to music.
Thus, music has greatly reduced the initial increase in cortisol levels, subsequent to stress.
Schneider has studied the influence of music on stress response in patients undergoing cerebral
angiography. (Schneider et al., 2001) Patients examined without music show increased plasma
cortisol levels, indicating high levels of stress, while in patients examined with music cortisol levels
remained constant. Also, systolic blood pressure was significantly lower for the group listening to
music. These studies indicate that stress hormone levels can be reduced by exposure to music in a
medical framework.
Various pharmacological interventions are used to reduce perioperative stress hormone
release during surgery under general anesthesia. Listening to music for therapeutic use has been
studied mainly in patients who are awake and it has been shown that music has a positive effect on
postoperative recovery and can also have an analgesic role. Nilsson et al., in 2001, showed that
hysterectomised patients who listened to music under general anesthesia required fewer narcotics
for postoperative analgesia than patients who did not listen to music. According to this study it
could be hypothesized that listening to music under general anesthesia can reduce the release of
stress hormones as a result of the surgical act, which would result in lower levels of epinephrine,
norepinephrine, cortisol and ACTH. On the other hand, some studies have not been able to show
the positive effect of music under anesthesia on the neuroendocrine stress response system or
perioperative opioid consumption. Migneault has evaluated the effect of music under general
anesthesia on the neurohormonal response to surgical stress. They could not record a difference
between the plasma levels of norepinephrine, epinephrine, cortisol and ACTH of the two groups
although the initial blood hormone levels increased significantly in each group, as a result of the
surgical stimulation. (Migneault et al., 2004) In conclusion, this study could not demonstrate a
5
significant effect of music on surgical stress while using it intraoperatively under general
anesthesia.
Regarding the reduction of cortisol levels in healthy subjects who were listening to music,
there was a randomized study performed (McKinney et al., 1997), organized in six sessions twice a
week. They found significant decreases in cortisol levels and positive effects on depression, fatigue
and mood. Decreased cortisol was significantly associated with decreased disturbance in the mood.
In conclusion, music therapy positively affects mood and significantly reduces cortisol levels in
healthy adults.
The aim of another study (Khalfa et al., 2003) was to determine whether relaxing music
compared to silence may facilitate psychological recovery after a stressful task. To achieve this
objective, the changes in salivary cortisol of 24 students were regularly monitored before and after
the Trier social stress test. The data showed that in the presence of music, salivary cortisol level
ceases to increase, while during silence it continued to rise for 30 minutes.
Although these findings seem to agree that music reduces stress hormone secretion, this is
not universally valid. For example, Brownley and his collaborators have investigated how music
affects cortisol levels in trained and untrained runners, in three conditions: relaxing music, lively
music and no music. (Brownley et al., 1995) After strenuous exercise, the authors have recorded
high levels of cortisol for fast music beats, compared to relaxing music, in both trained and
untrained runners. So, music can actually increase stress hormone levels. Indeed, if it seeks to
mobilize people in cases of stress, this effect would be desirable. For example, when work stress is
needed to motivate someone. Therefore runners can adjust their optimum levels of hormones
through music.
Other studies also show that music can both increase and decrease the release of stress
hormones. In one such study (VanderArk et Ely, 1992), participants trained in music and biology
have been exposed to music. Music did change hormone levels, but the effect did not vary
depending on the type of music (relaxing vs. energizing) but on the field of study of the subjects.
Biologists have shown a decrease in cortisol levels, however, musicians have had significant
increases in cortisol levels. Explanation is given by the fact that when interviewed, Conservatory
students were actively involved in the mental analysis of music. Some even said that they had used
6
the instruments mentally. The same authors have obtained similar results in a study by listening bad
or even tragic music, with similar test subjects (VanderArk et Ely, 1993).
Taken together, these findings indicate that there is no simple relationship between music
and stress hormones. Their interaction is not only about the type of music, but depends on other
cognitive and mental activities, that the individual experiences. This seems to be a key element in
understanding the complex interaction between music, hormones and brain.
Personal research
Based on the literature on the benefits of music on cortisol, we aimed to investigate the
impact of classical music on salivary cortisol in a group of depressed patients, hospitalized at
Obregia. For this we also formed a control group of healthy subjects.
Materials and methods
Groups
investigated
Number of
subjects
Types of investigation The
average age
Group of healthy
subjects
40 Salivary cortisol before and after the
hearing (40 subjects)
Hearing lively music (20 subjects) and
relaxing (20 subjects)
56
Group of patients
suffering from
depression
40 Salivary cortisol before and after listening
Hearing lively music (20 subjects),
relaxing (20 subjects).
61
The impact of music on cortisol levels was investigated through two sets of music:
- A set of fun, lively music:
a. Richard Wagner - "Lohengrin" 3 min 32 sec
b. Șostakovici - February 3 min
c. Bela Bartok - 1 min 27 sec
d. Sibelius - "Karelia" 3 min 2 sec
7
- A set of dreamy, relaxing, melancholic music:
a. Mendelssohn op.30 2 min 41 sec
b. Șostakovici - "Song" 2 min 59 sec
c. Faure - "After a Dream" 2 min 49 sec
d. Delius - "At Kalinda" 4 min 37 sec
Saliva was collected for measurement of salivary cortisol as an important marker of stress,
before and after listening to music (a subset with relaxing music, and a subset with lively music).
Saliva collection was done at the same time in all patients (3 P.M.).
Study assumptions
1. Cortisol levels after hearing the music are significantly low compared to cortisol levels
measured before the audition on the group of patients with depression.
2. Cortisol levels after hearing the music is significantly low compared to cortisol levels
measured before the hearing on the group of healthy subjects.
3. Salivary cortisol levels decreased similarly as a result of listening music in both groups of
depressed and healthy patients.
Statistical analysis of results
In order to analyze the differences between initial and final cortisol levels for the group of
patients with depression I used the T test for comparing two samples of correlated scores. The T test
is used to assess the statistical significance of the difference between the averages for two sets of
scores.
Paired Samples Test
Paired Differences t df Sig. (2-
8
Mean
Std.
Deviatio
n
Std.
Error
Mean
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Difference
tailed)
Lower Upper
Pair
1
CORTIZOL
INITIAL -
CORTIZOL
FINAL
2,197
5
1,2324 ,1949 1,8034 2,5916 11,27
8
39 ,000
Average salivary cortisol levels measured before listening (M = 11.14, SD = 2.74) and after
listening (M = 8.94, SD = 1.98) differ significantly (t = 11.27, DF = 39, p <0.001).
We analyzed the influence of the type of music (lively or relaxing) on the salivary cortisol
levels in depressed patients. Relaxing music produced a decrease of 21.5% in salivary cortisol level
from an average of 12.06 to one of 9.46, which is a statistically significant difference (t = 8.278, DF
= 19, p <0.001). Lively music led to a decrease of 17.88% of salivary cortisol from an average of
10.23 to an average of 8.40, which is also a statistically significant difference (t = 8.566, DF = 19, p
<0.001).
Next, we used the t test for comparing two correlated scores to test whether cortisol
levels were significantly improved after hearing music (relaxing and lively) on the group of healthy
subjects as well.
Paired Samples Test
Paired Differences
T Df
Sig. (2-
tailed)
Mean
Std.
Deviatio
n
Std.
Error
Mean
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Difference
Lower Upper
9
Paired Samples Test
Paired Differences
T Df
Sig. (2-
tailed)
Mean
Std.
Deviatio
n
Std.
Error
Mean
95% Confidence
Interval of the
Difference
Lower Upper
Pair
1
Cortizol control
inaintedeauditie
cortizol control
dupa auditie
1,445
0
,9265 ,1465 1,1487 1,7413 9,864 39 ,000
Test results (t = 9.864, p <0.001) demonstrate that there is a statistically significant
difference between the average levels of cortisol before listening (M = 7.22, SD = 2.45) and after
hearing recorded music (M = 5.78, SD = 2.43) in healthy subjects.
It also depended on the type of music (relaxing or lively). Relaxing music resulted in a
decrease of 22.74% in salivary cortisol levels from M = 7.08 to M = 5.47, statistically significant
difference (t = 6.565, DF = 19, p <0.001). Lively music produced a 17.50% decrease in cortisol
levels from M = 7.37 to M = 6.08, also a statistically significant difference (t = 8.02, DF = 19, p
<0.001).
Discussion
Hypothesis 1
Cortisol levels after hearing music are significantly low compared to cortisol levels
measured before the audition for the group of patients with depression.
Average salivary cortisol level measured before and after the audition differs significantly.
Relaxing music produced a decrease in salivary cortisol level of 21.5%, higher than lively music
10
that caused a decrease in salivary cortisol of only 17.88%. Therefore, the hypothesis is confirmed,
regardless of the type of music heard.
Hypothesis 2
Cortisol levels after hearing the music is significantly low compared to cortisol levels
measured before the hearing for the lot of healthy subjects.
T test results show that there is a statistically significant difference between the levels of
cortisol before and after hearing recorded music, for the healthy subjects as well. Depending on the
type of music (relaxing or lively) the results differed slightly. Relaxing music resulted in a 22.74%
decrease in salivary cortisol levels, compared to lively music that caused a 17.5% decrease in
cortisol levels - both statistically significant differences. Thus, hypothesis 2 is also confirmed, for
both types of music.
Hypothesis 3
Salivary cortisol levels decreased similarly as a result of listening to music for both
groups of depressed and healthy patients.
Average cortisol levels before and after hearing the music in the two groups
investigated.
11
Salivary cortisol levels decreased by approximately 20% in both groups (healthy and
depressed patients). Therefore, there is no statistically significant difference between final and
initial cortisol levels between the groups of depressed and healthy subjects. (F = 0.221, p <0.640).
Hypothesis 3 is confirmed: salivary cortisol levels decreased similarly in both groups investigated,
after listening to music.
Conclusions
Our study confirms the data gathered from the literature regarding the favorable effect of
music on cortisol levels. Although there are slight differences between lively and relaxing music (in
favor of relaxing) study shows that the favorable effect of music is maintained for both types. In
addition, the most important factor is the satisfaction of the listener, since 98% of subjects (healthy
and depressed) said they appreciated the music very much. When asked how much they enjoyed
what they heard the majority said they enjoyed a lot. Interestingly enough, before the audition, the
vast majority of subjects reported other musical preferences, such as pop or folk music and not so
much symphonic, instrumental, opera or operetta. Therefore, we can conclude that the symphonic
music has a beneficial effect on cortisol levels for both depressed and healthy subjects, regardless of
the musical preferences of the listeners but directly related to the degree of pleasure produced by
12
listening to music. This study needs to be continued by extending the number of participants,
broadening the types of music heard (including the selection of other pieces of symphonic music
and also using the subjects’ favorite music), but also by increasing the frequency and listening time.
Bibliography
1. Cook, J. (1986) Music as an intervention in the oncology setting. Cancer Nursing; 9:23-28;
2. White, J & Shaw, C. (1991) Music therapy: a means of reducing anxiety in the myocardial
infarction patient. Wisconsin Medical Journal; 90:434 – 37;
3. Wang SM, Kulkarni L, Dolev J, Kain ZN. (2002) Music and preoperative anxiety: a
randomized, controlled study, Anesthesia and Analgesia; 94(6):1489-94;
4. Rider, M., Floyd, J., Kirkpatrick, J. (1985) The Effect of Music, Imagery, and Relaxation on
Adrenal Corticosteroids and the Re-entrainment of Circadian Rhythms. Journal of Music
Therapy; 22:46-58;
5. Bartlettt, D., Kaufman, D., Smeltekop, R. (1993) The Effects of Music Listening and
Perceived Sensory Experiences on the Immune System as Measured by Interleukin-1 and
Cortisol. Journal of Music Therapy; 30:194 – 209;
6. Kaminski, J., Hall, W. (1996) The Effect of Soothing Music on Neonatal Behavioral States in
the Hospital Newborn Nursery. Neonatal Network; 15:45-54;
7. Burke, M., Walsh, J., Oehler, J., & Gingras, J. (1995) Music Therapy Following Suctioning:
Four Case Studies. Neonatal Network; 14:41-49;
8. Coughlan, A. (1994) Music therapy in ICU. Nursing Times; 90:35;
9. Rhoades, R. & Tanner, G.(1995) Medical Physiology. Boston, Little, Brown and Company;
10. Weissman C. (1990) The metabolic response to stress: an overview and update.
Anesthesiology;73:308–27;
11. Hall R, Adderley N, MacLaren RN. (2000) Does intrathecal morphine alter the stress response
following coronary artery bypass grafting surgery? Canadian Journal Anaesthesiology.;
47:463–6;
12. Koch ME, Kain ZN, Ayoub C, Rosenbaum SH. (1998) The sedative and analgesic sparing
effect of music. Anesthesiology; 89:300–6;
13
13. Lepage C, Drolet P, Girard M. (2001) Music decreases sedative requirements during spinal
anesthesia. Anesthesiology Analgezy; 93: 912–6;
14. Evans C, Richardson PH. (1988) Improved recovery and reduced postoperative stay after
therapeutic suggestions during general anesthesia. Lancet; 2:491–3;
15. Boeke S, Bonke B, Bouwhuis-Hoogerwerf ML. (1988) Effects of sounds presented during
general anaesthesia on postoperative course. British Journal of Anaesthesiology.; 60:697–702;
16. Roux FH, Bouic PJ, Bester MM. (2007) The effect of Bach's magnificat on emotions,
immune, and endocrine parameters during physiotherapy treatment of patients with infectious
lung conditions, Journal of Music Therapy, 44(2):156-68;
17. Kreutz G, Bongard S, Rohrmann S, Hodapp V, Grebe D. (2004) Effects of choir singing or
listening on secretory immunoglobulin A, cortisol, and emotional state. Journal of Behavioral
Medicine, 27(6):623-35;
18. Khalfa S, Bella SD, Roy M, Peretz I, Lupien SJ. (2003) Effects of relaxing music on salivary
cortisol level after psychological stress. Annual New York Academy Science, 999:374-6;
19. Labbe' E, Schmidt N, Babin J, Pharr M. (2007) Coping with stress: the effectiveness of
different types of music. Applied Psychophysiology Biofeedback, 32(3-4):163-8;
20. Escher J, Höhmann U., Anthenien L., Dayer E., Bosshard C., Schweiz R.C. (1993) Music
during gastroscopy, Med Wochenschr 123(26):1354-8;
21. Miluk-Kolasa B, Obminski Z, Stupnicki R, Golec L. (1994) Effects of music treatment on
salivary cortisol in patients exposed to pre-surgical stress. Experimental and Clinical
Endocrinology.;102(2):118-20;
22. Schneider N, Schedlowski M, Schürmeyer TH, Becker H.(2001) Stress reduction through
music in patients undergoing cerebral angiography, Neuroradiology; 43(6):472-6;
23. Nilsson U, Rawal N, Unestahl LE. (2001) Improved recovery after music and therapeutic
suggestions during general anaesthesia: a double-blind randomised controlled trial. Acta
Anaesthesiology Scandinavian; 45:812–7;
24. Migneault, B., Girard, F., Albert, C, Chouinard, P, Boudreault, D., Provencher, D., Todorov,
A., Ruel, M., Girard, D.C. (2004) The Effect of Music on the Neurohormonal Stress Response
to Surgery Under General Anesthesia, Anesth Analg.; 98:527–32;
14
25. McKinney C.H., Antoni M.H., Kumar M., Tims F.C., McCabe P.M. (1997) Effects of guided
imagery and music (GIM) therapy on mood and cortisol in healthy adults, Health
Psychology.;16(4):390-400;
26. Brownley K.A., McMurray
R.G., Hackney
A.C. (1995) Effects of music on physiological and
affective responses to graded treadmill exercise in trained and untrained runners, International
Journal of Psychophysiology, Volume 19, Issue 3, Pages 193-201;
27. VanderArk, S.D. and Ely, D. (1992). Biochemical and galvanic skin responses to music
stimuli by college students in biology and music. Perceptual Motor Skills 74, 1079-1090;
28. VanderArk, S.D. and Ely, D. (1993). Cortisol, biochemical, and galvanic skin responses to
music stimuli of different preference values by college students in biology and
music. Perceptual Motor Skills 77, 227-234;
top related