topic 3.a2: integration of conservation interventions on...

COST TD1406

Innovation in the intelligent management of HBs

Luisa Migliorati (LMI - I) & Christian Degrigny (CDE - FR): moderatorsMaria Bostenaru (MBO – RO), Carla Cruz (CCR – PT), Anne-Cathrine Flyen (ACF - NO), Miljenko Jurkovic (MJU - HR), Anna Lobovikov-Katz (ALK - IL), Maris Mandel (MMD - EE), Marko Marinkovic (MMK – RS), Juliette Rollier (JRO – FR), Todorka Samardzioska (TSA - MK), Alice Tavares Costa (ATC - PT), Piero Tiano (PTI - I)

Topic 3.A2: Integration of conservation interventions on HBs in their surroundings

Objective and proposing contributors:

guidelines for the integration of conservation

interventions on HBs in their surroundings. Values and

aesthetics of materials. Challenges of replacing original

materials, etc. (MMD)

Legibility and invasiveness of conservation work towards

the surroundings. (CDE, MJU, MMK, PTI)

Use of appropriate conservation materials that match

well aesthetically and technologically with preserved

parts of HBs and its surroundings and that ensure

adequate reversibility of the intervention performed.

(MBO, CCR, CDE, ACF, MJU, ALK, MMK, TSA, PTI)

Dear All,

as you proposed to participate in topic 3.A2, we ask you to

send us two or three photos of integration of damaged

parts of HBs in your country. It can be a good work

integrating with the building and the environment or a bad

one damaging structure, aesthetics. You should write also a

comment with a few entries, if you have all the data:

Country, location, HB typology, chronology, which part

is the photo referred to, restoration type and

chronology, good/bad integration with the building,

good/bad integration with the environment, why in your

opinion.

Could you also tell us if you, in your Country, already have a

unique guideline for integration of damaged parts of

HBs?

questionnaire

Answers related to the topic from:

Alice Tavares, Marko Marinković, Christian

Degrigny, Juliette Rollier

Answers not pertaining: (better in topic 3A3)

Maris Mändel, Maria Bostenaru

Maris Mändel

Location: Estonia,

Harju county, Loo village

HB type: former windmill

Built: end of the 19th century

Restoration: 2011-2013

Comment: a bold approach, contemporary materials

(glass, metal) in contrast with the old limestone ruins

definitely make the building much more attractive, the

architectural realization could be more refined though.

(The building is not listed.)

Location: Estonia, Narva town

HB type: church

Built: 1881-1884

Restoration: 2004-2008

Restored part: tower

Comment: Rebuilding the tower was

essential for restoring the integrity of the

church and restoring its position as a

landmark. Restored tower is built of

reinforced concrete and cladded with

limestone plates in order to make it look

outside as it was originally. Concrete is

left exposed in the interior though.

Location: Estonia, Harju county,

Vääna village

HB type: former stable and coach

house of Vääna manor

Built: 19th century

Restoration: 2014

Restored part: roof and arcade

Comment: This could be an example

of spatial reconstruction – the

integrity of the building is restored but

in the closer look the new parts are

clearly distinguishable. The arcade is

made of exposed concrete which

grey color harmonizes well with the

old limestone wall it is connected to.

Maria Bostenaru

Bucharest building

damaged in the

Revolution of

1989 and rebuilt

Examlp

Topic 3 A2

Some reminding from Riga

Integration of damaged parts of HBs aims at

- Protecting and consolidating the structure in such a way as to prevent further collapse

- facilitating communication/understanding for the general public

Integration of damaged parts of HBs must take intoaccount

- material which has to be consistent with the preserved parts in respect of weight, structural behaviour, aesthetics

- climate, including prevailing wind, temperaturevariations, rising damp

- visual impact

Portugal, Vila Verde: the Church São Mamede -13th century

Abandoned from 19th centuryRestoration works: from 1998 till 2015

Credits A. Costa

Credits A. Costa

Serbia, Sabac: the “Sabacka tvrdjava” – 15th century

Research and restoration work: 2004, 2005-07, 2009-10

Credits Marko Marinkovic

Credits Marko Marinkovic

Serbia, near Novi Sad: church of the “HramSvetih arhangelaMihajla i Gavrila” Monastery Kovilj - 18th

century

Restoration works: September 2005 - 2006

Credits Marko Marinkovic

France, Region Rhône-Alpes, Bagnols Castle: Middle Ages, 17th century

Restoration work: wall paintings

Credits Juliette Rollier

France, Southern Burgundy: Château de Germolles –end of 14th century

Restoration worksat the entrancegate: XXI c.

Antoine-Jean Duclaux (Lyon, 1783-Lyon, 1868),

Christian Degrigny

Germolles entrance gate, around 1819, château de Germolles.

Italy, Teramo: the

Roman theatre –

Augustan age

Restoration work: early

‘70ies of XX c.

credits L. Migliorati

travertine outsidegypsum sandstone inside

Restorationbricks

theatre

Renaissance

workers

district

fortress

Italy, Peltuinum Roman town-theatre

Credits L. Migliorati

Credits L. Migliorati