universal health coverage (uhc) and the role of private hospitals presented by: mr. stephen baker...

Universal Health Coverage (UHC) and the Role of Private

Hospitals

Presented by: Mr. Stephen Baker

Director: Halcom Management Services Ltd

25th September 2013

HMS

UHC – Definition

HMS

• “a health care system which provides health care and financial protection to all its citizens”

• "developing health financing systems so that all people have access to services and do not suffer financial hardships paying for them” World Health Organisation 2010

HMS

Universal Health Insurance or Universal Coverage? • Much of the debate about NHI to date has focused on

the breadth or population dimension. While popular perception is sometimes that those without medical schemes “have no cover”, this is not the case.

• It seems though that there is confusion between universal coverage for healthcare and universal coverage for health insurance.

• It was estimated that only some 18.6% of Namibians had health insurance cover in 2012. However everyone in the country has access to healthcare, either in the public sector or through medical schemes, or other employer-based arrangements.

• Dissatisfaction with the current national health system is dissatisfaction with the quality of the care in the public sector.

Universal Health Insurance or Universal Coverage?

To Achieve UHC

HMS

• A strong, efficient, well-run health system focused on primary, preventative, curative & Rehabilitation

• Affordability – a system for financing health services so people do not suffer financial hardship when using them.

• Access to essential medicines and technologies to diagnose and treat medical problems.

• A sufficient capacity of well-trained, motivated health workers to provide the services to meet patients’ needs based on the best available evidence.

UHC Private Stakeholders

HMS

• Revenue Collection• Individuals• Employers• All taxpayers• Brokers

• Pooling• Medical Schemes• Medical Scheme Members

• Purchasing• Medical Schemes• Medical Scheme Administrators

• Delivery• Private Hospitals• Pharmaceutical Industry• Medical Practitioners• Nurses• Pharmacists etc.

Current Private Hospital sector

HMS

• Total Private beds 578 (very little change over prior years)• 9 medical schemes cover ±182 000 lives

= 546 beds• Private sector running at capacity• Beds per 1000 =3,1• 1 GRN medical scheme covers ± 221000

lives (Psemas) = 663 beds• Total lives covered 18,6% of total

population

• Private Sector characterized by:• Quality service• Quality Facility & Equipment• Expensive• Good clinical outcomes

HMS

Current Government Hospital sector

HMS

• Total Government beds = 5092

• Approx. 1,7 million lives not insured = 5100 beds

• Beds per 1000 population = 3

• Government has enough beds

• May not all be functional

• Old facilities

• May not be in the right areas or where the need is

Findings of the “report of the Presidential Commission of enquiry into MOHSS Jan 2013”

• Shortage of health professionals

• Quality of patient care sub optimal

• Quality of training of doctors and nurses needs improvement

• Quality of facilities – “dilapidation and decay”

• Poor status of medical equipment

• Poor transport systems for referred patients

HMS

Private Hospitals Perspective of UHC

HMS

• Committed to the goals of achieving Universal access to quality healthcare in Namibia

• Willing to engage Government to develop solutions and be part of the decision making process

• Able to share data, expertise and in-depth understanding of the private sector in discussions of national health system reform

What can the Private Hospital

Sector offer

HMS

• Skills Development and Transfer

• Gap Hospitals

• Hospital management Services

• PPP’s

• Managed Care

Skills Development and Transfer

HMS

• Financial Management & Cost accounting expertise

• Benchmarking techniques• Risk Management• Clinical Standards• Critical Pathways• Information Technology• Productivity• Training• Internships

Financial Management

Zero Based Budgeting Never assume that any cost is forever! Review every structure and process to determine

what might have changed and how it has affected cost profile

Review patient profile and also detremine what changes might have taken place and how it might affect service delivery and linked resources e.g. staffing, equipment and services

Activity based costings “costing methodology that identifies activities in a hospital

and assigns the cost of each activity with resources to all products and services according to the actual utilisation”.

HMS

Benchmarking

“The comparison of one’s own hospital to other similar systems (not every hospital is the same and the objective is not meet what others are achieving but to stimulate the thinking as to find better ways of delivering the same, if not improved, services and at more cost effective levels)”

“If you can’t measure it, you can’t improve it”

Statistics based on Unit Values Nursing Staff cost per patient Average Length of Stay Medicine costs per patient day (PPD) Catering costs PPD Laundry costs PPD Fixed overheads per bed Maintenance costs per bed Admin cost per bed

Clinical Standards

StandardsDetermine the “best practice” way of doing things,

documenting then measuring compliance Identify what needs to be done to achieve optimum

quality of service and clinical outcomesDevelop, implement, monitor and continuous

improvement of SOP’s Hospital accreditation

Information Technology

Use of Technology Professional resources are in seriously short

supply therefore, it is compelling that management finds ways to complement available resources, particularly Nursing staff

The “digital” or “paper-less” hospital which implements IT solutions to develop an electronic patinet record (EPR/EMR)

Less forms and less people intervention thereby reducing propensity for errors

HMS

GAP Hospitals

HMS

“ Gap Hospitals are typically private hospitals designed, built and operated to cater for lower revenue models than existing medical insurance pays: i.e. for NHI, UHC, Psemas etc.”

• Typical state of the art hospital costs N$ 2.5 – N$ 2.7 million per bed i.e.: N$ 250 –N$ 270 million for a 100 bed hospital

• GAP hospital costs > N$ 1.7 million per bed• More compact, optimally designed: 60 sq. per

bed compared to 90-100• Single story (lifts cost 1 million each)• Conservative finishes• Rationalise on the latest medical equipment• Short point to point distances, optimising

efficiency• Financial focus is on balancing project capex with

revenue streams and opex from proposed case mix

HMS

• Result:

• GAP hospitals are cheaper to operate and staff

• Can produce the same IRR on 26% less fees, can also allow risk sharing models i.e.: Per Diems, Capitation etc.

• Produce the same quality of patient care

• Can be scaled according to demand (30-40 bed hospitals are viable)

• Due to flexibility can be located in lower population areas, increasing access to care.

• GAP hospitals are viable in an NHI setting

Hospital Management

Services

HMS

• Provide management services to existing hospitals

• Develop centers of excellence i.e.: (Psychiatric, Level 1 Trauma, Radiation Oncology, Cardiology units)

PPP’s

HMS

• To develop UHC private sector is able and willing to engage in PPP’s

• Proposals were made for the Level 1 Trauma Hospital in 2012, inclusive of N$ 200 million in funding in response to MVA requests. MVA are now going to issue another expression of interest.

• The bulk of forecasted expenditure on PPP’s from the private sector would be hospital construction/renovation

HMS

Hospital construction or expansion

Clinic construction or expansion

Clinical services

Ancillary medical and accomodation services

Medical equipment services

Hospital Management

0.00% 10.00% 20.00% 30.00% 40.00% 50.00% 60.00% 70.00%

69.10%

14.10%

8.70%

6.70%

0.70%

0.60%

Why PPP’s in Healthcare

HMS

•  Improving cost efficiency

•  Improving quality of services

•  Modernizing facilities, equipment & services •  Increasing access to underserved areas & populations

What is a PPP in healthcare

HMS

• Government pays Private Operator service

payments but only once facility is

operational

• Government defines service and output

requirements. Inputs, design, etc. to bidders

• Buying services, not equipment & facilities.

• Private party is typically responsible for all

or part of the capital financing

• Payment is tied to performance not

inputs/milestones

Managed Care

HMS

“The management of an episode of care from pre-admission to discharge”

Objectives:• Reduce cost of each episode of care• Reduce length of stay • Improve patient outcomes• Ensure appropriateness of treatment

SummaryHMS

Thank You

HMS