virginia s. tong, lmsw vp, cultural competence oct. 19, 2010

1

Virginia S. Tong, LMSWVP, Cultural Competence

Oct. 19, 2010

A COMPARISON OF PATIENT SATISFACTION BETWEEN CHINESE AND SPANISH SPEAKING PATIENTS IN AN AMBULATORY CLINIC

2Total # of patients served in 2009 - 482,917

3

Demographics*: Ethnicity & Poverty Rate

Ethnicity

Latino/Hispanic 37%

Chinese 27%

Jewish Orthodox 10%

Arabic 7%

Russian 7%

Poverty Rate

Southwest Brooklyn 22.2%

United States 12.4%* Source 2000 Census Data

28% of Residents Live Below 100% Federal Poverty Level

* Lutheran Family Health Centers and Lutheran Medical Center

Brooklyn’s

Chinatown:

Fastest Growing

Population In

Brooklyn

Largest Arabic Community In NYC

Largest Latino Population In Brooklyn

4

LHC is the largest employer in the community. Our employees reflect our patient population:

LHC: STAFF LANGUAGES - 2009

Spanish24%

English39%

Other21%

Arabic2%

Chinese8%

Russian5%

Italian1%

LHC: PATIENTS BY LANGUAGE - 2009

Chinese6%

Arabic1%

Other4%Russian

1%

Spanish30%

English58% We celebrate 30 ethnic and

religious holidays

We speak 73 languages

5

Patients’ experiences with health care providers influence their perception of health care quality.

Surveys of these experiences determine whether HCP are meeting the needs of their patients and lead to improvements in care.

Significant patient satisfaction difference between races, ethnicity and language level.

Not represent actual differences in quality of care. Represent variations in perceptions, expectations,

and questionnaire response styles depends on ethnic group, race, or English proficiency.

Introduction

6

Background Lutheran Family Health Center conducting patient satisfaction

survey in 4 languages (Spanish, Chinese, Russian and Arabic) for many years Cross cultural study of responses never done Strange phenomenon at Brooklyn Chinese Family Health Center

despite: Totally bilingual/bicultural staff standing room only patients long waiting time for appointments successful balance sheet

LOWEST PATIENT SATISFACTION SCORES IN SYSTEM

7

Brooklyn Chinese Family Health Center

8

Research Project

Created Research Team to study problem

Min Kyung Zimilevich MD, Win Win Myint MD, Ana Guerra MD, Kell Julliard MA, Virginia Tong MSW, Anna Chu, RN

Departments of Family Medicine, Clinical Research Office and Cultural Competence

9

To analyze dimensions of satisfaction related to culture and clinic performance.

To determine if Chinese speaking patients consistently rate their satisfaction differently than Spanish speaking patients for comparable care.

Goal

10

Disparities in the perception of health care among different ethnic and racial groups

Asian patients have lower level of satisfaction than other races.

Hispanics who have lower English proficiency have lower level of satisfaction.

Analysis of Research Studies

11

Compared satisfaction ratings in a clinic serving both Chinese and Spanish patients- Family Physician Health Center.

Examined survey results from 2005 to 2007 grouped by primary language spoken by each patient.

Rating choices were: Great, Good, Fair, Poor, Don’t know.

Assessed survey questions re: appointments, registration, the facility, respect and safety, waiting time, and relationships with nurse/medical assistants and doctors.

Chi square tests were used to determine difference in satisfaction by language. Alphas set at 0.05.

Methodology

12

Family Physician Health Center

13

Family Physician Family Health Center Approximately 25% Chinese and 50% Spanish

speaking patients

Staff: Chinese and Spanish speakers, primary care providers predominantly English only speakers.

FPHC provides: Pediatric, Ob/GYN, and adult services.

14

TO OUR VALUED PATIENTS: Your comments are very important to us and will help us improve services.

Is this your first visit to this Health Center? ………. Yes ○ No ○

How are you doing in the following areas? Poor Fair Good Great Don’t

knowEasy of scheduling at the Health Center…….. ….,, ○ ○ ○ ○ ○Cleanliness of the Health Center ………………………. ○ ○ ○ ○ ○Our effort to treat all people with equality …… ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ Our effort to keep your personal information confidential …………………………….. ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ Our respect for your privacy in the exam room ○ ○ ○ ○ ○ Amount of time you wait to see your provider ○ ○ ○ ○ ○Courtesy and friendliness of nursing staff … ○ ○ ○ ○ ○Concern showed for your health problem …… ○ ○ ○ ○ ○How well your doctor listens to you and answers your questions ………………………. ○ ○ ○ ○ ○Your confidence in this doctor/provider ……. ○ ○ ○ ○ ○Overall, the likelihood you would recommend this Center to others, if needed ………….. ○ ○ ○ ○ ○

Patient Satisfaction Survey – Primary Care

15

Total of 273 patients responded the survey at the FPHC from 2005 to 2007.

Among 273, 56 (20.5%) were Chinese speakers, and 113 (41.4%) were Spanish speakers.

Surveys studied

16

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

Ability to get an appointment

Cleanliness of our facility

Our effort to treat all people with equality

Our effort to keep personal information confidential

Our respect for privacy in the exam room

Amount of time you wait to see your provider

Courtesy and friendliness

Concern for your health problem – Nurse/MA

Concern showed for your questions by provider

Your confidence in doctor/provider

Likelihood to recommend this health center to others

percentage

Chinese Spanish

Figure 1: Percentage of great scores between Chinese and Spanish speakers at FPHC during 2005 ~ 2007

*

**

**

*

**

17

Figure 2: Percentage of great and good scores between Chinese and Spanish speakers at FPHC during 2005 ~ 2007

0 20 40 60 80 100 120

Ability to get an appointment

Cleanliness of our facility

Our effort to treat all people with equality

Our effort to keep personal information confidential

Our respect for privacy in the exam room

Amount of time you wait to see your provider

Courtesy and friendliness

Concern for your health problem – Nurse/MA

Concern showed for your questions by provider

Your confidence in doctor/provider

Likelihood to recommend this health center to others

P ercentage

Chinese Spanish

**

18

0

20

40

60

80

100

2005 2006 2007

Year

Perc

en

tag

es

0

20

40

60

80

100

2005 2006 2007

YearP

erce

nta

ges

Figure 3: Confidence in providers between Chinese and Spanish speakers at FPHC during 2005 ~ 2007

Great Great & Good

─▲─ Chinese−■− Spanish

19

Figure 4: Satisfaction with waiting time at the health center between Chinese and Spanish speakers at FPHC during 2005 ~ 2007

0

20

40

60

80

100

2005 2006 2007

Year

Percen

tag

es

0

20

40

60

80

100

2005 2006 2007Year

Per

cen

tag

es

Great Great & Good

─▲─ Chinese−■− Spanish

20

Figure 5: Satisfaction with friendliness of Nurse/MA between Chinese and Spanish speakers at FPHC during 2005 ~ 2007

0

20

40

60

80

100

2005 2006 2007

Year

Perc

en

tag

es

0

20

40

60

80

100

2005 2006 2007

YearP

erce

nta

ges

Great Great & Good

─▲─ Chinese−■− Spanish

21

Chinese speakers gave fewer “great” ratings of satisfaction and combined “great and good” ratings compared with Spanish speakers.

The gap between “great” scores of Spanish speakers and Chinese speakers was consistently greater than between combined “great and good”.

Multiple studies show level of satisfaction is greater if seen by physicians of their own race and culture.

Results

22

Asian Americans are considerably less satisfied than other racial or ethnic groups in U.S.

Our study confirm that Asian Americans, in this case Chinese, give lower ratings as compared to Hispanics → cultural practice

Studies show that Asian Americans choose responses in the middle of the scale whereas Hispanics and Blacks display more extreme responses.

Discussion

23

Hispanics in our study graded low satisfaction on waiting time but they were highly satisfied with the attention given by the provider.

Level of empathy with patients determine level of satisfaction.

Discussion

24

Convenient sampling Self- administered questionnaire Semiannual survey only at FPHC No data re: patient demographics sex, age,

socioeconomic background, diagnosis, health insurance unable to adjust for confounding factors related to

patient satisfaction

Limitations of study

25

All pts graded low on waiting time, ability to schedule an appointment → need improvement.

Both groups rated high their experience with MA/RN. Education to all staff to become culturally competent. Compare responses to different questions within a

specific culture → can compare similar culture at different clinics.

Need to develop validated culturally specific survey instruments.

Recommendations

26

Chinese speaking patients in our study graded level of satisfaction significantly lower than Spanish speakers and more noticeable regarding scores of “great” than of “great and good” combined.

Conclusion

27

Conclusion

There are disparities in the perception of health care among different ethnic and racial groups Asian patients have lower level of satisfaction

than other races. Hispanics who have lower English proficiency

have lower level of satisfaction. Patient Satisfaction surveys and results have cultural

biases which need to be taken into account. Recommendations to link reimbursement to patient

satisfaction scores need to be reviewed for cultural bias and equity to providers serving diverse patients.

28

Thank you

Questions or comments, please contact:

Virginia S. Tong Vice President, Cultural Competence

Lutheran HealthCare5800 Third Avenue

Brooklyn, N. Y. 11220718-630-7236 / vtong@lmcmc.com