what have we learned from a decade of bat research?

1

What Have We Learned from a Decade of Bat Research?

Alan M. NathanUniversity of Illinois, a-nathan@illinois.edu

22

NCAA Trends in Home Runs

Q1: Why does aluminum outperform wood?Q2: What changed in 2011?

3

“You can observe a lot by watching”---Yogi

Collision is very inefficientBat speed matters a lotBat slows down

4

Quantifying “bat performance”

Batted Ball Speed (BBS) under game conditions

BBS depends on–Pitch Speed

• a little–Bat Speed

• a lot– “collision efficiency”

• joint property of ball and bat

What determines collision efficiency?

1. Coefficient of Restitution2. Bat weight

6

1. Coefficient of Restitution (COR)

“Bounciness” of ball– ~1/2 for baseball

• Bounces to ¼ of initial height

– bat matters also

7

Contribution of Bat to COR:Vibrations and the Sweet Spot!

“sweet spot” outside

8

Vibrations, BBCOR, and the “Sweet Spot”

Evib

vf

e

+vibrations minimizedCOR maximizedBBS maximizedbest “feel”

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0

10

20

30

40

50

0 5 10 15

BB

CO

R

vibr

atio

n fra

ctio

n

distance from tip (inches)

Ball-Bat COR

vibrational energy

1234nodes

demo

9

Vibrations, BBCOR, and the “Sweet Spot”

Evib

vf

e

+

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0

10

20

30

40

50

0 5 10 15

BB

CO

R

vibr

atio

n fra

ctio

n

distance from tip (inches)

Ball-Bat COR

vibrational energy

1234nodes

10

Why are aluminum bats better?The trampoline effect

Net Result: BBCOR larger Better performance

demo

2. Weight of bat

• Not the actual weight (“swing weight” or “MOI”)– Larger when weight concentrated in barrel– Larger for wood than aluminum

• Higher swing weight means more weight in barrel– Higher collision efficiency

• Higher BBS• Higher swing weight means lower bat speed

• Lower BBS• Two offsetting factors roughly cancel out

– Leaving BBCOR as primary property determining BBS

12

An aside: Corking the Bat

• Corking the bat…– increases bat speed– decreases collision efficiency

• Which one “wins”?

Aside: A curious feature• Bat struck at barrel

– Handle starts to move only after noticeable delay

– When reflected wave reaches barrel, collision is over

• Therefore, nothing on handle end matters– knob, handle, grip, …

• Batter could just as well drop bat just before impact!

And here’s the proof:Todd Frazier’s No-Hands HR

15

The New NCAA Standard• BBCOR is “surrogate” for BBS

– Since swing weight mostly doesn’t matter• Where to “draw the line”

– 0.500…just barely above wood

16

Measuring BBCOR in Lab

1717

NCAA Trends in Home Runs

science works!~10% reduction in max BBCOR factor of ~2 reduction in HR

Other Issues

• Dealing with composite bats–BBCOR improves with use– “Accelerated Break-In” or ABI

• Effect of ball on bat performance

The bottom line:We know much more than we did 10 yrs ago about how to characterize, measure,

regulate performance of bats

19

webusers.npl.illinois.edu/~a-nathan/pob

Thanks for your attention