analysis of prognostic factors in chordoma using the california cancer registry
TRANSCRIPT
103SProceedings of the NASS 25th Annual Meeting / The Spine Journal 10 (2010) 1S–149S
of 9 (range 5 - 20) years. Only one out of 5 patients in the group with sub-
total resection and direct postoperative radiotherapy had local recurrence
after 11 yrs. There were no major surgical or radiotherapy complications.
The time to recurrence was significantly (11 versus 3 years) longer in the
group that received immediate RT after surgery, even after resection with
irradical margins. There was no difference in overall survival between both
surgical groups.
CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that postoperative RT is important
in the prevention of local recurrence in patients with sacrococcygeal chor-
doma, even after margin-free tumor resection.
FDA DEVICE/DRUG STATUS: This abstract does not discuss or include
any applicable devices or drugs.
doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2010.07.271
222. Impact of Tumor Histology on Resectability and Neurologic
Outcomes in Primary Intramedullary Spinal Cord Tumors
Isaac O. Karikari, MD1, Shahid M. Nimjee, MD, PhD1,
Tiffany R. Hodges, MD1, Betsy D. Hughes, MD1, Erin Cutrell, BS2,
Ciaran J. Powers, MD, PhD3, Ankit I. Mehta, MD1,
Carlos A. Bagley, MD1, Robert E. Isaacs, MD1,
Michael M. Haglund, MD, PhD1, Allan H. Friedman, MD1; 1Duke
University Medical Center, Durham, NC, USA; 2Rho Inc, Chapel Hill,
NC, USA; 3University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI, USA
BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Intramedullary spinal cord tumors
(IMSCT) are relatively rare tumors. Historically, intraoperative tumor re-
section has been based whether a plane dissection can be identified, which
is often dependent on tumor histology. Ependymomas typically demon-
strate a clear tumor and spinal cord interface whereas astrocytomas exhibit
a more infiltrative pathology. The absence of a clear plane of dissection
leads to subtotal resections of most astrocytomas in many reported studies.
The ability to achieve gross total resection independent of tumor histolog-
ical type in recent reports has brought into question of the role of tumor
histology on the extent of resection. We perform a retrospective analysis
to determine the impact of tumor histology on resectability and functional
neurological outcomes in a consecutive series of IMSCT.
PURPOSE: To analyze factors that have impact on neurological func-
tional outcome in patients who had microsurgical resection of primary in-
tramedullary spinal cord tumors (IMSCT). Characteristics of different
histological tumor entities are described.
STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: Retrospective review.
PATIENT SAMPLE: 104 consecutive patients with IMSCT treated at
a single institution between January 1998-March 2009.
OUTCOME MEASURES: An analysis of functional neurologic status at
time of last follow-up was performed in each tumor subtype based on pre-
operative and postoperative neurological status measured by the modified
McCormick Scale (MMS), presence of intraoperative plane of dissection
(POD), extent of resection (EOR) and recurrence.
METHODS: Clinical, radiographic, operative and pathologic reports were
evaluated for predictors of short and long term neurologic outcomes.
RESULTS: Ependymomas were the most common tumors 55(52.8%),
followed by astrocytomas 21(20.2%), hemangioblastomas 12(11.5%)
and miscellaneous tumors 16(15.3%). Gross total resection (GTR) was
achieved in 50(90.1%) of ependymoma, 3(14.3%) of astrocytoma, 11
(91.7%) of hemangioblastoma and 14(87.5%) of miscellaneous tumors.
Intraoperative plane of dissection was present in 55(98.2%) of ependy-
moma cases, 6(28.6%) of astrocytoma cases, 12(100%) of hemangioblas-
toma cases and 14(87.5%) of miscellaneous tumor cases. At a mean
follow-up of 41 months (1 to 132 months), we observed recurrences in
3(5.4%) ependymoma cases, 11(52.4%) astrocytoma cases, 1(6.3%) of
miscellaneous tumor cases and no recurrence in hemangioblastoma
All referenced figures and tables will be available at the Annual Mee
cases. POD and EOR were predictive of recurrence (p!0.0001). When
analyzed by location, patients with IMSCT in the conus trended towards
neurological improvement or remained stable (95%) compared to cervi-
cal (81.3%) or upper/mid thoracic tumors (81.5%), however this was not
statistically significant (p value50.66). At the time of their last follow-up
visit, 11(19%) of patents with ependymoma improved, 38(67%) re-
mained the same, and 7(12.5%) worsened. In patients with astrocytoma
1(4.8%) improved, 10(47.6%) remained the same and 10 (47.6%) wors-
ened. One (8.3%) patient with hemangioblastoma improved and 11
(91.7%) remained the same. No patient with hemangioblastoma
worsened. In the miscellaneous tumor group, 2(13.3%) improved, 13
(86.7%) remained the same and 1(6.7%) worsened. Age at time of sur-
gery was not predictive of outcome (p value 0.71). Preoperative neuro-
logical status (p50.02), tumor histology (p50.007) and presence of
POD/EOR (p!0.0001) were all predictive of functional neurological
outcomes.
CONCLUSIONS: Tumor histology is the most important predictor of
neurologic outcomes following surgical resection as it predicts resectabil-
ity and recurrence. Gross total resection should be attempted in all IMSCT
cases where a clear plane of dissection is present intraoperatively. Surgical
management of astrocytoma still remains a challenge with significant mor-
bidity despite advances in microsurgical techniques.
FDA DEVICE/DRUG STATUS: This abstract does not discuss or include
any applicable devices or drugs.
doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2010.07.272
223. Analysis of Prognostic Factors in Chordoma Using the
California Cancer Registry
Joe Lee, MD, Nitin Bhatia, MD, Bang Hoang, MD, Argyrios Ziogas, PhD,
Jason Zell, DO, MPH; University of California, Irvine, Orange, CA, USA
BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Chordoma is the most common primary
malignant tumor of the spine. It is extremely rare and has been studied
mostly in single-institution case series. Using data from a large, popula-
tion-based cancer registry, we designed the present study to examine the
outcome of patients with chordoma and relevant prognostic factors.
PURPOSE: To examine the outcome of patients with chordoma and rel-
evant prognostic factors.
STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: Retrospective review of population-based
cancer registry.
PATIENT SAMPLE: 409 patient cases identified 1989–2007.
OUTCOME MEASURES: Chordoma-specific survival.
METHODS: A retrospective analysis of the California Cancer Registry
database was performed to identify chordoma incident patient cases diag-
nosed 1989–2007. Comparisons were made to examine differences in
demographics, disease characteristics, treatment, and survival. Survival
analyses were performed using Kaplan-Meier method with Log Rank tests
and Cox proportional hazards models.
RESULTS: 409 incident patient cases of chordoma were identified, with
257 (62.8%) males, and 152 (37.2%) females. Racial/Ethnic distribution
included 266 (65%) Whites, 7 (1.7%) Blacks, 93 (22.7%) Hispanics, and
45 (10.5%) Asian/Other. For site of presentation, there were 202
(49.4%) cranial, 106 (25.9%) spinal, and 101 (24.7%) pelvic/sacral. His-
panic race (p50.0002), younger age (!40 years; p!0.0001), and female
sex (p50.0092) were associated with cranial presentation; whereas older
age (O70 years; p!0.0001) was associated with pelvic presentation. After
adjusting for clinically relevant factors, a statistically significant decreased
risk of death for chordoma-specific survival was seen with Hispanic race
(HR50.51, 95% CI 0.28–0.93), high socioeconomic status, and surgical
treatment. An increased risk of death was seen in patients with large tumor
size (O5 cm) (HR52.05, 95% CI 1.01–4.20).
ting and will be included with the post-meeting online content.
104S Proceedings of the NASS 25th Annual Meeting / The Spine Journal 10 (2010) 1S–149S
CONCLUSIONS: This study provides new findings on the survival
patterns of chordoma, with a significantly decreased risk of death seen with
Hispanic race, high socioeconomic status, and surgical excision.
FDA DEVICE/DRUG STATUS: This abstract does not discuss or include
any applicable devices or drugs.
doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2010.07.273
224. Association of Extent of Surgical Resection and Survival in
Patients with Malignant Primary Osseous Spinal Neoplasms:
A 30-Year Population-Based Study
Debraj Mukherjee, MD1, Kaisorn Chaichana, MD1, Scott L. Parker, MD1,
Ziya Gokaslan, MD1, Joseph Cheng, MD2, Matthew McGirt, MD2; 1Johns
Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA; 2Vanderbilt
University, Nashville, TN, USA
BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Malignant primary osseous spinal neo-
plasms are aggressive tumors which remain associated with poor outcomes
despite aggressive treatment. While surgical resection has been shown to
improve short-term local control, it remains debated whether resection is
associated with improved survival.
PURPOSE: Evaluate the role of resection for patients with primary osse-
ous spinal neoplasms.
STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: Retrospective analysis.
PATIENT SAMPLE: SEER registry.
OUTCOME MEASURES: Survival.
METHODS: The SEER registry (1973–2003) was queried to identify cases
of histologically confirmed primary spinal chordoma, chondrosarcoma,
osteosarcoma, or Ewing’s sarcoma via ICD-O-2 coding. Extent of resection
was defined by intra-operative surgeon assessment or radiographic analysis
and classified as biopsy for tissue diagnosis, subtotal resection (STR), or
gross-total resection (GTR). Differentiation between intra-lesional and en-
bloc resection was not made. Association of resection with overall survival
was assessed via Cox proportional-hazards analysis adjusting for age,
radiotherapy, and extent of local tumor invasion.
RESULTS: 827 patients were identified with non-metastatic primary osse-
ous spinal neoplasms (215 Chordoma, 282 Chondrosarcoma, 158 osteosar-
coma, 172 Ewings Sracoma), Table 1. Tumors were more frequently
located in the sacrum/pelvis vs. mobile spine for both surgically resected
(74% vs. 26%) and biopsied lesions (88% vs. 12%). Surgical resection
versus biopsy was associated with improved overall survival independent
of age, radiotherapy, or extent of local tumor invasion for chordoma
[HR, 0.34; p50.05], chondrosarcoma [HR, 0.14; p50.001], and osteosar-
coma [HR, 0.42; p50.005], but not Ewings sarcoma [HR, 0.56; p50.10],
Figure 1. GTR vs. STR was not associated with survival benefit for any
tumor type.
CONCLUSIONS: Surgical resection may play a role in prolonging sur-
vival in the multi-modality treatment of patients with primary spinal chor-
doma, chondrosarcoma, or osteosarcoma demonstrated prolonged overall
survival. The value of surgical resection for Ewings sarcoma may be
limited.
FDA DEVICE/DRUG STATUS: This abstract does not discuss or include
any applicable devices or drugs.
doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2010.07.274
All referenced figures and tables will be available at the Annual Mee
225. Chordoma of the Mobile Spine: A 15-Year Experience at the
Massachusetts General Hospital
Andrew J. Schoenfeld, MD1, Francis X. Pedlow, MD2,
Francis J. Hornicek, MD, PhD2, Joseph H. Schwab, MD, MS2; 1William
Beaumont Army Medical Center/Texas Tech University Health Sciences
Center, El Paso, TX, USA; 2Massachusetts General Hospital,
Boston, MA, USA
BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Chordoma of the spine presents a difficult
surgical challenge. Surgical excision is considered the standard of care, yet
complete excision is not always possible. Several authors have identified
recurrence, metastases and inadequate surgical margins as risk factors
for decreased survival.
PURPOSE: This study sought to describe the epidemiology, treatment and
complications in a series of patients treated with surgery and/or radiation
for spinal chordoma at our institution. We also sought to determine the ef-
fect of type of surgical resection, presence of local recurrence, and metas-
tases on patient outcome.
STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: Retrospective case series at a tertiary aca-
demic referral center.
PATIENT SAMPLE: All cases of chordoma involving the spine located
above the sacrum and below the clivus treated surgically at our institution
between 1992 and 2007.
OUTCOME MEASURES: Survivorship analysis was performed using
Kaplan Meier methodology. Kaplan Meier methodology was also used
to calculate disease specific survival and to compare survival between pa-
tients who had received en-bloc and intralesional resections.
METHODS: Weperformed a retrospective review of cases of chordoma in-
volving the spine located above the sacrum and below the clivus treated sur-
gically at our institution between 1992 and 2007. Medical charts, radiology
reports, pathology reports and operative notes were reviewed for all patients.
Available imaging studies were also examined. Survivorship analysis was
performed using Kaplan Meier methodology. Kaplan Meier methodology
was also used to calculate disease specific survival and to compare survival
between patients who had received en-bloc and intralesional resections. The
effect of type of resection, surgicalmargins, presence of local recurrence, and
metastasis on disease-specific survival were also investigated. Nonparamet-
ric and parametric variables were assessed with the use of the Mann-
Whitney-U statistic, and analysis-of -variance, respectively.
RESULTS: Twenty-six patients were treated surgically for spinal chordoma
in the period under study. Twenty-four were also treated with radiation with
a mean dose of 70 Gy (range 11–101.6). The median overall survival for all
patients in this series was 98.7 months (SE 13.6, 95% CI 72–125). Nine pa-
tients were treated with an en-bloc resection and 8 of these had no evidence
of disease at the time of last evaluation. Eleven of 17 patients treated with
intralesional resections died from disease. Patients treated with en-bloc re-
section had an increased survival compared to those who underwent intrale-
sional excision (p50.002). Similarly, en-bloc resection was associated with
a decreased risk of local recurrence. (p50.02) Eight (31%) patients devel-
oped local recurrences and 3 (11.5%) developed metastasis. Local recur-
rence was associated with a trend toward decreased survival (p50.06).
CONCLUSIONS: En-bloc resection was associated with improved over-
all survival and a reduced risk of local recurrence. There was a trend to-
ward local recurrence having an adverse impact on survival.
FDA DEVICE/DRUG STATUS: This abstract does not discuss or include
any applicable devices or drugs.
doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2010.07.275
ting and will be included with the post-meeting online content.