INSTRUMENT PREPARED BY

VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

BOOK 548 PAD(378

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

SUPPLEMENTAL ORDER REGARDING DOCKET NUMBERVGOB 01-101&0948

ELECTIONS: UNIT F-22(hxein "Sttbjcct Drilhtg Unit" )

REPORT OF BOARD

FINDINGS AND ORDER

This Supphnnmsl Onhr h ensued by ge Bcedraa rposur h de farm utbarhcd hyde Baed et bcerbqpbaklre~IS, 1994 aad Jme 16, 1992; aad 6& Supphmcnnd Order is beag mconhd Ru tba purpose of

=-»$¹Opdcr pevhuslym tbs cspncmd mesa oa Jaausry 14,2002 wbhb was reconbd st Dead BookS39,Ptgn154 htbaOSha ofde Chrk ofde Cbcait Camt of Bedlam County, Vighia, an Januey 29, 2002,(beeh "Baenl Or@P) aad complsdag de teaud~ehctkma

Tbs Band Otde dbectsd Caecal Esegy hc. (bncin "Dasigensd OpansoP) ta mail copica af tba Beard Order

ta ell Respandcne vdtcss hteests, ifnay, wee poohd by tba saki Baed Onhr,O)nectar Shd lls egkhvb afahctkms 4$closhg tb¹ lt bsd umBsd a tlN eul cemct copy of

tba Baenl's Onbr to an R»t ~» wbass hnucae, ifsay, were pooled by caid Remi Onhr,bl bb»0»b~»bL '» b»»bb». b»bblb»w

Onhr to nabs asah¹ke wRch ddrty(30) dsps age de des ofmailhg or b~~ msppRcable, ofsaki Onhr,the cdndavit ofahcthtn Sed beeia aad anncsa¹ beesc as Exbhit A snnsr. (0 wb¹be each Respamlant bssmade ar Ibgsd ta nugo a sinely ah¹ian; (S) ge astern «faay ehcthcds) mcubr, cud (ii0 whsbcr, by remen of» b»b b»»»b «b '»».»»Ib W K»»» Cb».llave betel all tbsb r(gbts, dde, iascce¹s, astern ead chhe in Subject DrQbag Unk to tba Applkxmqb»»»»bd»b»~»»»»Ibbb»»»»~b»»lb b 'makhg atbmdy ahctkus Ifeqc ldcuggas SeRmpamhat(s), Ifany, wba ee dawned to bare bxnad; Idsatghs de

lunuase eel chime which require ascmw; ident%as ge hsnem end chkns, ifany, rnpdrmg ascmwunder Vbghh Cods tuctkm 45.1-361213K; aad bhnngm SeRcepaadcats, ifeay, wbo maybe ~bytmnm afbavhg heeel or cntcccd bno a vobetcuy ~ ——

wbb de AppgcaatTbs amdavb ofabdtkms iegcsses that Se aseow ofSmds is reprimd wbb raged to Umt F-22;

Ihtbg Byg&Onbu, de Baed acdes ge~Opceacr ta under, ccehhacnt wbb cade anademwBbde gegags sat Rather

—m,w 2. ¹mva aad ge emeed aSdsvit ofabedaas wbb Exbgde tbeetc. eely

Smds subject to meow lad mnruce tba Eseaw Agentpirst Union National Bak, Corpeate Trust pA132$ ,123Bmad Street, *~PA 19100-1199,Tahpbcun (215) 9$5-3405 cu ($00) 664-9359, Ane DaaBallhgbog or aap sn)came named by tbs Beml to astsbgcb imeest baadag resow accents(s), IRS Tax——'=='-.Number 54-1629S06, in~~wbb tbe~sat fetb h tba agbhvit ofahcdcas withExbgbbe guaenX mmcabe Rmh and accaeu to tbs Baed barefcca Tbs rsspaadeus hnsd in Exbhb B-2 to tbsASdavit afnhcdw ee di¹mbued

IPPK 548PIC(379

Mamas afrbdcr emi pgissof Amdari Tbe ccdgnntMOpscutcr eadsr tbe cspdaned (hdcr ar sball Ne mcdgdsvh whb ths Secretary af tbc Bamd udgda ten (IO) days ager tbe dhe ofneipt oAbis Ocdcr stsgug thetauue sad cmcectappyafgds Onhc wm maged to each Respaadccn wbass harvests ar claims ste subject to cscmwar wbo is hereby dhndsecd snd wbass eddnss h hnown wiSh seven sevmt (7)days gom the dme ofreccdpt ofSds Order.

Emccdve Dsm~ This Onhs shall be sgccdve an the dsse ofbe ewcutim

DONEAND EXECUTEDtbis ~vL dsy af 4(Sewed, 2002, by a majority ofthe Vhyaisg

Gas and Oil Board.

STATE OF VIRQMACOUNTY OF WISE

Aducaededgsd on Sds~ofK~,2002, psaaally befom me a natcuy pubgcm cmd Sugn Ccnmkmweahh fVhgibia, sppeecdm Bsaay R. Wsmphr, bsisg duly swan did depose aad scp thatbe is Cbahman ofthe Vhginia Gas aad Oil Beard, that bs executed ths ames end wes ethariaM to do so.

Nanny

My cmmcdmioa ucphes: Tran/-aa

DONE AND FERFORMED THIS ~%cyof &~,2002, by Order ofthe Bated

B.~Direcccr oftbe Divishm ofGae 4 Oil Baaed sadFrhsdpal Esscugve to tbe Bated

STATE OF VIRGMACOUNTY OF WASHINGTON

Achnowhslgadongds j9 dsyag M~,2002,tcrsonagybegsemssnauuypublic hc and Sn the Ccccmmnweahh ofVirghg ~B.IL Wgsaa, beiag dcdy swmn dhl depose ead saythee he is Dhectar ofthe Division ofGas 4 05 Based aad Priadlsd ~to the Bomd, that be ececutcdths cmcm snd wm cea4ua Imad to do so. .Q,n

Tyime J.Davis, Nqthry

My conmissian espirm: 414&l~I /()rder Recorded Under Code ofVirginia Section 40.1-201.20

BOOK 548 PAG(380

Exbibit A

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

Appgccthm ofBuchcm» roducthm Company gu Forced Pooling ofJmcnvm in CBM Unit F-22VGOB 01-10164)94d in 0» Gcnhn Dkuhn ofBuchraum County, Viqpma

AFFJDAVlT OF Consol Energy lec. (bcriia ~~OpaaNaP) ~JNG ELECTTONS, ESCROWAND SUPPIZMENTAL ORDER

That Ibs Order cn«ued on Jcmuuy 14, 2002, by Ibc Virginia Gas and Oil Board hcreinagm "Bocnp)regangag 0» capdcncd CBM Unh wquied Ibe Applkcnt to mail a tn» aad comet copy ofsaid Onkr to ecchFern» pookd by 0» Order,

Tl»t whhk scvmr (7)days ofau»ipt ofnu~ocpy of0» Onhu rcgrrcd to at Cccgraph 2. above, yourcdgaat csm»d a uue and ccnect ocpy ofca«i Onhr to be mcged vk the Unhed Stctm heal Scrvioe to ecch

ccpoudrm named k tbe apticned Applkatica, whose address wac Imown, and to ag persons, ifany, wbo wereadded m Rug»ndtcss ct 0» hcarkg behl ia 0» apticaed samer g»t proof ofsuch magkg has previously been«utdcnd to tbs Divkbm ofGac aud Oil, 0» OJBtn cf0» Gac and Oil Jacpcckr, at Abingdca, Vhgkis;

Thm0» Onhsof the Bomd k 0»~mm«s nquhvd ag ptsscr» poolnl thereby to tender Sir wrtncn

ekcgcnc Io Ibs Unh Opera«u whhk Ihhty(30) days of0» dcm 0» Order wac reocnkd ia 0» ccmny ideatdkdabave; Iku said Order wac recorded on Jaauary 29, 2002;

Thethe: - opere«u Consol Eacrgy inc. k» nnab 'shed pnoccdune to review ag neil received aad agwrmm dccumam mccived cger g»a by mail to eccrisis whcgnr paths whose k«cuss have bees pookd have

medea wrinca checks, k sthmdy Subion, m nquhedby the capdcurd Order, @atsaid roccdunn were SBouedto hhng('f d»~ ifaay, mmk whh regard to the Subjtcs Unit; gtm 0» Bdhnviag passu» delivered, by mailor~wrinca skctionc tbc Unit Opere«u, wigun tbc thhty day ekcttam pcrkrL

lMR ' ~hlhbhhlL3~~~alhas ~m~~l bg»ir cong»d mag»ne ngbsr, hncnvnc aad claims Io AppgccrR ag as provided in 0» Board'c Order ofJaausry14,2002;

That Ibc riglns, hscrcns aad ckims of thc gdlowiug pcrccr» are ntbjcct to cccmw under the Board'c Orderpooliag the apticaed Unit, Bcmd Rcgslctkas aad Ibc Code ofVirginia

Nunc

C.JR Q590K

['%teN»tfcs»t ~eels.two»e» «o~',~ LATITUDK: 37 17 30er e«MsL IN7lsrJ wa «» ee I«r~~ee»N OWL~ eeet rMnt - MIIH x«N nertr o ~ MINERAL

~— ~ SURFACE

s teaselsc eN,~AI ~~ LI

OI6

»R ANISL INLL Ieeteert etL ee MS»I

~r ',!/ l

c swamidr y ~ NO llRLLS WIR»N

Rgb's

reel sr ee roeroNS UlwNN AcoMN0 ts s ~ ee I~ rt«F1 sslbo

WELL LOCATION PLAT

coMpANr CCNSD(. KNEftDY, INC

~D CO.

tsSITOCT: .

WELL COON(RNATES ItStOOSA STATE PLANE): STATE LA%

WELL NAME OR NUMOER C%" F22

DUADftANGLE PATTERSON

N 2D7,21D.OS E SIN,f 13.92

ELK»AllONr 1&SOt)'KIHOO USED TO OETERSANK ElgWOKW USOS TOPOORAPItlC

'OUNTT8UCHhHI&4 Scots: I w AOO'ate 49~4-01TRIS PLAT IS A NKW PIAT ~ AN UPDATED PLAT ————'OR A FINAL UICATION PtdO~,+g,

+ rDenotes tits lseetton of e well on Un»es IQcrtes Teesereehie Meea, so«e I ooo.Ietttsde end Ion»Rode lines Inffnt ~ ~r»e tnwdsr flees ss e»oen (

~ 8V

Uosneed -, 'd En»incor or Ueenssd Lend Sunrsysr'(AfF«Seel) 4 INWIT Ns.

$/p, 0(

„„539~16 g48 g8CONSOL INKRGY, INC.

U%T F-22Tract ~—~

Yahoo Pocabocaac Coal Ca/Shebeen Coal CoiSayers-P~ Cost Co. -2/3 Coal, Oil 8t Gss%rtb ceIeloaa Tbsbcr Corp. —1/3 Coal, Oil sad GasCoal LaceIca

Coal Co. —Coal behwv the TBhr SeamNorth Tbuber Corp. sa6 th'eir

btc„aa6~ 'ao„CSM Lessees (1/3)c~Co. CBM Lessee )36.66As+is

45.825'%leoass~Ca -Coal, Oil an60asCoal

Coal Cocapsey- Coal btkocv tbe Tiler ScamCotapattp CSM Lessee

Neath ~~Thaber Cirp. —Sar%co3723 Acres', 46.5375%

L%.%,~~Hebe, taviscas, a::::=eaa6 Aceitpts- Sartboa, Coag Oil th QacCoal Lcecac6h6aa6CcsehI Ceal Co. -Coal bshe the TStef Scars (942123796)sasas~ ILp' cc -olL aeloI ~(1/12'I)ls—~~=:::~Co.—~Lessee (108071)6.11Acres 7.637534

Page 1 oft 9/12IOl, 3:58PM

5002 548ekgf'384

(S) PlmiCmak TmkmlaWs, LP. *sysmasnl

Ihl OWH NW, SuW2NO

See. )%7iiWW Thee> CW )

Trumne aot adam

1222 wrw02 d2awmws

(DeodeL hn 5HIONand Nes., Ins.)

J.W.W. (Wsoh IWs. Dwfaoss.Successes a nedgns, al al

(1) J.W. W. Ildnoh Helm, Dwhess,smueeeem cr nsolOw

011 eaw

OADOt mrwOMN cfO.II mow

O.OON mrwIdat ala.11 auw

OAHIN% Deemed Laced

aaasa mrwINI catt wms

rw 8 mon enn ~(S) PkwOwk, LP.

'00

Nmalhw, sow w50

gaea Nmlh Tlmkor Cmp.)

Twm 0k att muw

J.W. W. Sdddh Hdm, Dorhsw,Sweeeeme m~,d d

(1) J.W. W. Sswuh Helm, Dmlaaao,SucsacwmmdodOw

1222 mrwID dwwmrw

0.11 eras

OANS aresSwt el 0.11mws

IISIN%

glmwsL ha. ~IOOHsW Rsn, laa.)

Psdslyeh

QZI ISckoh SddrWNl1 gw tdhsmkmukst IN Ow)0

DstkmaewWe, ONIS

SOON mowINI da11auw

aONO mrwSwt d 0.11mrw

OAHIN% Dwnwl 4aww

OAH100% Deunml teasel

'lm CNI Nasal fs lsswh kr DsoNL Inc. md Iagkhnd leaaumss. Ins.

Poga1el1

VIROINIh: tn Ihc Clerk's Office of ()raCiruw't Coun of Buckssss County. Tha foregoing iasmnncniwas dw day Pewtw)d inpygja afurws~~ mkh thc wrtiYrmw of~lady'~Returned Io: isf IT>ra o .~Inr r T)LOT(PA/dt rdrlr oC.LJ$4)DsPuty Clat

i

Ssh)SS Atkdl F42

Dadat 5t(ODS N-1N485ISEW H~~ SaO< 548PIC('3S4

(I) RumC»ekT,LP.'dwd

Ressuaw Cw100Panel»unshed tdw, sass 2850AS«da, QA 55606(pmu N«lh Amndwn Tknh«C«pd

Trust a& aaa ~J.W. W. Sddwh Hoke, Dedsees,9~ar Aes(5en, d al.

(1) J.W. W. Seklsh Hake, Dmhoos,Season«s or Asst(pie

(20) Koan Sddwh22M) Wed R(55oHoushn, TX 71026

(22) Mtsheh SddwhRL1 San (ISO

~55swtok IK N878

(26) Dmh Cmr Sddwh

Data«a Sass(L P&a

1222 mwtl3 af 8&85 msw

S.n msw

O.OSSI a«wSSSI af5.tt msw

&0058 mwtlN1 af S.n a«w

OASRS mswt~ danmsw

(QeaMtL h». &HIShhmd llw., Inc.)

0.01105% Deemed Lamed

(I) Plum Crmk 1" ', LP,'shadRwauass

100ps«dew Shet(t NW, Sass 2860Attsakt OA SSR)S(pnw. N«lh Amsdmn Tlmhor C«p.)

Tact 8&ace wmws

J.W.W. Sddwh Hhhs, Dmhees,uoaees«s ar Ass((tw, et el

(1) J.W. W. Sstdwh Hshs, DmdswSwores«s «Assttw

1222 mswtlS af ~mew

8.n s«w

O.OSSI mrwawe af an a«ss

152750%

(OeeMst, hc. 4H(5hksd Rss, lno.)

(22) Mhhsla SddwhRL1 Sen (ISO~,IR OW)8

(26) Daskl C«r Sshtwh(51$N. Pmmlwh t)the 82DaftwSeoth, PL' S

OA)088 mswt~ of8.n a«w

MOSS msw1)SN daft mw

OA)tt05% Dean«I Lewd

O.N105% Deemmllaaeed

Tl» cSM hawwl ls twml hy QsoMeL lno. aml H(shhnd Resoumes, h».

PeSo1 of 1

VIRGINIA: In the Clerk's OfBce of Circuit Court of Buchanan County. The foregoing instrument

Deed Book NoCYRPtand PSSe No. (( S /Y /1%$TE: James M. Be(ins, Jr., ClerkReturned to: n( (T/W w ~5~ i fHS'dL:ddf rdrlr s . ())(deputy ClerkM~0