annual cpd day 2015 general company law presentation is for general information only and does not...
TRANSCRIPT
WongPartnership LLP (UEN: T08LL0003B) is a limited liability law partnership registered in Singapore under the Limited Liability Partnerships Act (Chapter 163A).
ASEAN | CHINA | MIDDLE EAST
WONGPARTNERSHIP.COM
ANNUAL CPD DAY 2015
GENERAL COMPANY LAW
ANDREW ANG
9 OCTOBER 2015
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
2007
• Steering Committee (SC) formed
2011
• SC Report issued
• Public consultation on SC Report and ACRA consultation on regulatory framework for foreign entities
2012
• MOF response to public consultation
2013
• Public Consultation on draft Companies (Amendment) Bill – first and second parts
2014
• MOF response to public consultation
• Revised Companies (Amendment) Bill was passed
Introduction
• Companies (Amendment) Act 2014 was passed on 8 October 2014
(Act 36 of 2014)
2
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Introduction
• Objective of changes:
– Reduce regulatory burden, greater business flexibility, improve corporate
governance landscape
• Dual-phased implementation:
– Phase 1: around 40% effective from 1 July 2015 (in red)
– Phase 2: effective in 1Q 2016 (actual date not set - 2 months' advance notice)
• Regulations, prescribed forms, etc for Phase 2 not yet issued
• Topics covered in this session: selected key changes
3
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Responsibilities of Directors & CEOs
• Powers of Directors
– Business of company managed by or under the direction or supervision of the
directors - 157A
• Duty and liability of officers (includes Directors and CEOs and
persons employed in an executive capacity)
– Cannot make improper use of position as officer (not limited to improper use of
information acquired by virtue of his position) to gain advantage or cause
detriment to the company - 157(2)
• New definition of CEO
– Any one or more persons, by whatever name described, in direct employment /
acting for / by arrangement with the company, who is principally responsible for
the management and conduct of the company’s business or part of the
company’s business, as the case may be - 4(1)
– Replaces existing definition of "manager"
4
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Responsibilities of Directors & CEOs
• Now applicable to CEOs: disclosure of interest in transactions /
disclosure of conflict of interest / disclosure of interest in shares, etc
– Similar to requirement for Directors, with exceptions (not required for 164/165:
related corporation, participatory interests) - 156, 164/165
• For both CEOs and Directors: disclosure of interest in transactions / conflicts of interest via written means
– Disclosure now also possible by written means - 156
• Changes to definition of interest in shares
– Tracks (and updates!) Sections 4 and 130(5) SFA
– Authority to dispose / exercise control over disposal of shares = interest in shares
– 7
5
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Directors’ Appointment and Cessation
• Resignation and appointment of directors
– General meeting by ordinary resolution can appoint director - 149B
– Director can resign by giving written notice, not subject to acceptance - 145
– Both cases: unless constitution otherwise provides
• Age of Directors
– 153 repealed! No difference in treatment of directors above 70
• Changes to disqualification provisions
– Conviction or civil penalty for market misconduct subject to disqualification - 154
– New disqualification provision:
• 3 defunct struck-off companies within 5 years - 155A
• New debarment order
– Debar from future appointments as director or secretary until order is cancelled
or suspended; pre-existing appointments not affected - 155B
6
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Transactions with Directors
• Payment to Directors holding salaried employment or office, for loss
of office
– Existing provision: (subject to limited exceptions) not lawful for company to make
to any director, payment (a) by way of compensation for loss of office as an
officer of the company or subsidiary or as consideration in connection with his
retirement therefrom, or (b) in connection with the transfer of the whole or any
part of the undertaking or property of the company, UNLESS particulars of the
proposed payment have been disclosed to members and approved by the
company in general meeting
– No need shareholders' approval if amount of compensation for termination of
employment does not exceed total emoluments in year preceding termination,
payment is pursuant to existing contractual legal obligation in agreement with the
said director, and particulars of payment disclosed to shareholders upon or prior
to payment
– 168
7
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Transactions with Directors
• Loans, etc. to Directors and connected corporations (20% stake)
– Existing provision: (subject to limited exceptions) Prohibited: loan to a director of
the company or related company, or loan to company in which director(s) are
interested in 20% or more equity stake, or entry into guarantee or provision of
security in connection with a loan to such director or company
– Prohibition extended to quasi-loans, credit transactions, related arrangements
– Prohibition extended to LLPs in which director(s) are interested in 20% voting
power
– For loans to connected corporations/LLPs, exception of prior shareholders'
approval with abstention by Director and family members
– 162, 163
8
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Protecting Directors from liability
• Loan to Director to meet defence expenditure
– New exception to Sections 162 and 163: Loan to Director to meet expenditure
incurred in defending proceedings or regulatory investigation in connection with
negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust, subject to conditions (e.g.
loan must be repaid if convicted / adverse judgment, within 14 days)
– 163A, 163B
• Indemnity of Director against liability
– Company cannot indemnify officer (includes Director, secretary or person
employed in executive capacity) for liability for negligence, default, breach of duty
or breach of trust
– Exception: indemnity is against liability incurred to person other than the
company, subject to exceptions
– 172 to 172B
9
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Duties of Directors:
Disclosure of Information
• Right of disclosure of company information by nominee
directors to nominating shareholder – made more flexible
A director of a company may disclose information which he has in his capacity as a
director of a company, being information that would not otherwise be available to
him, to a person:
(a) whose interests the director represents or
(b) in accordance with whose directions or instructions the director
may be required or is accustomed to act in relation to the
director’s powers and duties,
IF such disclosure is:
–not likely to prejudice the company; and
–made with the authorisation of the board of directors
(which authorisation may relate to all or any class of information, or only such
information as may be specified in the authorisation).
–158
10
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Duties of Directors:
Disclosure of Information
• Right of disclosure of company information by nominee
directors to nominating shareholder – made more flexible
– Prior to the amendment to Section 158 (pursuant to the Companies
(Amendment) Act 2014), the nominee director seeking such disclosure had to
declare at a Board meeting the name and office or position held by the person to
whom the information is to be disclosed and the particulars of such information
(former Section 158(3)(a))
– The Steering Committee for Review of the Companies Act considered that:
• Section 158 was unclear as it was capable of different interpretations
• The narrow interpretation, that specific approval from the board for each
piece of information to be disclosed, was impractical and cumbersome
• Recommended that Section 158 be amended to
– delete Section 158(3)(a)
– enable the board to determine whether the mandate should be general
or specific, subject to the overarching consideration that there should
not be prejudice caused to the company
11
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Other Changes relating to Directors
• Possible use of alternate address (applicable to Directors, secretary,
CEO)
– Section 173 currently requires individual’s “usual residential address” to be
registered in ACRA’s publicly accessible records
– Amendment will permit individual to supply an alternate address:
• An address at which the individual can be located
• Same jurisdiction as the individual’s residential address
• Cannot be a P.O. box
– Residential address will not be made publicly accessible if valid alternate address
has been supplied, but ACRA has power to restore the individual’s residential
address (with notice) to the public records if:
• Individual fails to respond to communications sent by ACRA
• Evidence shows service of document on alternate address ineffective to
bring it to the individual’s notice
– 173, 173G
12
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Key Changes for Shares and Capital
• Redenomination of shares
– New procedure to redenominate share capital from one currency to another by
way of an ordinary resolution
– 73, 73A, 73B
• Conversion of shares
– New procedure to make provision in constitution to authorise conversion of
shares of one class into another by way of special resolution
– However, non-redeemable preference shares cannot be converted into
redeemable preference shares
– 74A
• Share capital can be used to pay share issuance expenses
– Expenses (including brokerage or commission) incurred directly in the issue,
purchase or acquisition of shares
– 67, 76G
13
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Key Changes for Shares and Capital
• Share Buybacks
– Threshold of 20% issued share capital is now reflected in Companies Act
– Solvency test standardised (with Section 7A solvency statement)
– Selective off-market share buybacks now permitted for public listed companies
(not restricted to odd lots, though that was original proposal of Steering
Committee)
– 76B, 76F, 76D
• Corresponding amendment to Section 76 (prohibition against financial
assistance) will permit listed company to pay for costs associated with a
scheme/arrangement under which any shareholder may purchase/sell
shares for sole purpose of rounding off his odd-lots - 76
• Expanded use of treasury shares
– Treasury shares may be transferred for purposes of or pursuant to "any share
scheme, whether for employees, directors or other persons" (not just limited to
employees' share scheme)
– 76K
14
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Impact on Corporate Transactions
• Membership of holding company
– Current prohibition against corporation being a member of its holding company
– New exception: subsidiary obtaining shares in holding company through
distribution in specie, amalgamation or scheme of arrangement
– Subsidiary's holding of its holding company’s shares: similar regime as treasury
shares (no voting rights)
– 21
• Indoor management rule
– In favour of person dealing with company in good faith (rebuttable presumption,
no duty to enquire), powers of Directors to bind company deemed to be free of
any limitation under the company’s constitution (including any shareholders’
agreement or resolution)
– Exception: transactions with Directors and their connected persons (generally
voidable at company’s option)
– 25B, 25C, 25D
15
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Impact on Corporate Transactions
• Financial Assistance
– Section 76 prohibits the giving of financial assistance for the purpose of or in
connection with an acquisition or proposed acquisition of a person of shares in
the company or in its holding company
– No longer applicable to private companies unless they are subsidiaries of public
companies
– Exceptions to FA widened to cover:
• Distribution by way of dividends lawfully made / in the course of winding up
• Allotment of bonus shares
• Redemption of redeemable shares
• Payments by company of costs for odd-lot rounding scheme/arrangement
– 76
– New non-material prejudice exception - 76(9BA)
• Interest of company and its shareholders or its ability to pay creditors
• Board resolution that FA is fair and reasonable and should be given, with
grounds, to be lodged with ACRA
16
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Impact on Shareholder Rights
• Differential Rights
– By default, for all companies, one share confers one vote, subject to constitution
– Public companies: different classes of shares possible subject to constitution
specifying rights. Can issue shares with special, limited, conditional or no voting
rights if approved by special resolution
– 64, 64A
• Derivative actions
– Derivative actions under Section 216A refer to actions taken out by shareholder
(or other person) in the name and on behalf of the Company, with leave of Court
– Now also applicable to public listed companies, and includes arbitration
– 216A
• Buyout remedy
– In winding-up application to Court on the basis of Directors acting in own
interests or unfairly, Court may (if just and equitable) order shares to be
purchased by company or other member, instead of ordering a winding-up
– 254
17
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Impact on Amalgamations
• Short-form amalgamation
– now allows for subsidiary to be the surviving entity as well
– 215D
• Changes relating to solvency
– solvency threshold
• Past: directors of each amalgamating company to be satisfied that
amalgamated company will be able to pay debts as they fall due during next
12 months after effective amalgamation date
• Now: directors of each amalgamating company to be satisfied that
amalgamated company will be able to pay debts as they fall due as at
effective amalgamation date
– 215D(2)(c), 215J
18
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Key Changes for General Meetings
• Multiple proxies
– Member who is "relevant intermediary" can appoint 1 proxy per share or shares
(current default is 2 proxies, subject to constitution; scheme meetings excluded):
• licensed bank holding shares as nominee
• capital markets services licensee holding shares as custodian
• CPF Board holding shares as intermediary under CPF legislation
– This applies to all companies; cannot exclude by constitution
– Such a proxy also has the right to vote on show of hands
– 181
• Proxy Forms – restriction on timing for submission
– To be submitted at least 72 hours before meeting (from 48 hours)
– 178 (corresponding change to new 81SJ SFA)
• Right of shareholder to demand poll at general meeting
– Reduced threshold from 10% to 5% (of total voting rights)
– 178
19
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Registers
• All companies: Register of Directors, CEOs, secretaries and auditors
maintained by ACRA
– 173 to 173I
– All companies still have to maintain Registers of CEOs' and Directors' shareholdings
– Transitional provisions: what was lodged with ACRA before date of coming into force
will be entered into the Register of Directors, CEOs, secretaries and auditors; e.g.
formerly registered "managers" will be entered as CEOs. - 173D
20
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Registers
• Private companies: Register of Members maintained by ACRA
– 196A (existing Register of Members provisions will only apply to public companies)
– Consequential changes – certain private company corporate actions will take effect
only upon lodgment of the relevant forms / documents with ACRA
• e.g. redemption of redeemable preference shares (70), alteration of share capital
(71), conversion of shares (74A), buyback (76B), cancellation or disposal of
treasury shares (76K)
• changes to share transfer provisions (126 to 130AE)
– Transitional provisions:
• Pre-existing private company to give information for Register of Members to
ACRA, within the earlier of (a) 6 months from date of this amendment coming into
force, and (b) date when first return under Section 197 is required to be lodged
with ACRA - 196B
• Existing Register of Members maintained by company must be kept for 7 years
after last member on the Register ceases to be member - 196D
21
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Impact on Company Administration
• "memorandum and articles of association = "constitution"
– Transitional provision: M&AA in force immediately before date of this amendment
coming into force collectively deemed as the constitution - 4(13)
• Table A (Fourth Schedule) replaced by model constitution
– Minister may prescribe model constitutions for private companies and companies
limited by guarantee - 36
– Model constitutions not yet made available by Minister
• Share certificates
– Requirement to state amount paid up on the shares removed (but still required to
state amount unpaid, if any) - 123
22
This presentation is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek specific legal advice before acting on the contents set out herein.
Impact on Company Administration
• Electronic communications – new implied / deemed consent provision
– Express consent: electronic communications with members currently permitted
only if there is agreement in writing: 387A, 387B
– Implied / Deemed consent: new provisions to allow for implied / deemed consent
as provided under constitution - 387C
• Constitution to provide for use and manner of electronic communications
• Implied consent: constitution states that member agrees to receive notices
or documents by way of electronic communications and has no right of
election for physical copies
• Deemed consent: constitution gives member opportunity to elect for either
electronic communications or physical copies within specified time, and
member fails to elect
– Regulations for the above not yet made by Minister
• Company records may be in electronic form
– Company records can be in both hard copy or in electronic form - 395
23