“we are all relations” - university of winnipeg...“we are all relations”: indigenous course...

1
Positive Experiences Most students said the ICR had expanded their learning in a good and empathetic way, and increased their understanding of Indigenous issues. Many applauded the University and wished they could have learned these things a long time ago. Faculty had been concerned about a potential backlash from students but our findings showed a generally positive learning experience. Emergent themes were the importance of relationships, respect, and safety; eagerness to learn with and from Indigenous peoples; the desire to work together for a better, more inclusive education system and society. “We are All Relations”: Indigenous Course Requirement (ICR) Dr. Helen Lepp Friesen Tyler Andrade Department of Rhetoric, Writing, and Communications References Axworthy, L., & Kinew, W. (2013, January 11). Canada’s future: Let’s be divided no more. In The Globe and Mail. Retrieved on May 22, 2017 from http://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/canadas-future-lets-be-divided-no-more/article7199421/ Graffiti at University of Winnipeg targets First Nations. (2013, March). In CBC News. Retrieved on November 28, 2017 from http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/graffiti-at-university-of-winnipeg-targets-first-nations-1.1350599 Koblun, J. (2016). Conversations in Cultural Fluency: The Two Row Wampum. Two Row Times. Retrieved on August 2, 2017 from https://tworowtimes.com/news/conversations-in-cultural-fluency-the-two-row-wampum/ Indigenous Content Requirement. (2017). Lakehead University. Retrieved on May 24, 2017 from https://www.lakeheadu.ca/faculty-and-staff/departments/services/ai/icr Indigenous Course Requirement. (2016). The University of Winnipeg. Retrieved on May 18, 2017 from http://uwinnipeg.ca/indigenous-course-requirement/ Macdonald, N. (2015, January). Welcome to Winnipeg: Where Canada’s racism problem is at its worst. In Maclean’s. Retrieved on April 19, 2017 from http://www.macleans.ca/news/canada/welcome-to-winnipeg-where-canadas-racism-problem-is at-its-worst/ Two Row Wampum Belt. Retrieved on November 22, 2017 from http://mohawknationnews.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/two-row-old.jpg Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada. (2015, December). Calls to Action. Retrieved on May 9, 2017 from http://www.trc.ca/websites/trcinstitution/File/2015/Findings/Calls_to_Action_English2.pdf UWinnipeg Fast Facts (2017). In About U Winnipeg. University of Winnipeg. Winnipeg, Canada. Retrieved from https://uwinnipeg.ca/about/fast-facts/index.html Thank you to Catherine van Reenen for poster design assistance. Abstract This mixed-methods study consulted with students, faculty, and staff to develop insight into their experiences of the Indigenous Course Requirement (ICR) in its initial implementation in the 2016/17 academic year at The University of Winnipeg. Although students and instructors had suggestions for how to improve course content, development, delivery, and support, there were far more positive reactions to the ICR experience than negative. Description of Initiative UWSA proposed an Indigenous Course Requirement (ICR) to the University’s Senate in 2014. The ICR was approved by Senate in November 2015 and implemented in the fall of 2016 for all incoming undergraduate students (Indigenous Course Requirement, 2016). In 2016/2017, 27 courses with a total of 46 sections were offered across 9 departments. Methods & Sample Multimodal data were collected during the winter of 2017 from the following: 10 faculty and staff from six departments who participated via 30-minute voice recorded interviews. 164 students responded to a survey invitation sent to 1,230 students who had taken an ICR (13% response rate). 19 students who participated in one of three 60-90-minute focus group discussions. Challenges Most faculty, staff, and students agreed that racism and lack of knowledge exist and that education and relationships are key to changing stereotypes. Key challenges included: the pressure on Indigenous students to take on the role of token authority on “the” Indigenous experience; how to sensitively support students and staff when talking about a traumatic history; how to manage contentious discussions in class. Sharing Circle Classroom Overall Student ICR Experience Aboriginal Student Services Centre Recommendations Personal experience stories Circle method Elders in the classroom Clear information about the ICR Support services for faculty, staff, & students Hands-on learning & full immersion Many ways of communicating & evaluating Art and oral teaching Storytelling as pedagogy Learning languages More Indigenous hires Science courses for Science students “I thought it was going to be just another requirement that I was not going to enjoy as much, that the content was going to be dry or boring. I really liked the course; I learned much more than I expected to (thinking I knew enough information about the Indigenous of North America).” “The ICR course has taught me to be careful of stereotypes. Learn the history and the people before making general assumptions or agreeing with others on careless and uneducated thoughts and comments... We are on Treaty land, and we should be respectful of that.” Highlights

Upload: others

Post on 01-Aug-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: “We are All Relations” - University of Winnipeg...“We are All Relations”: Indigenous Course Requirement (ICR) Dr. Helen Lepp Friesen Tyler Andrade Department of Rhetoric, Writing,

Positive Experiences •  Moststudentssaid the ICRhadexpandedtheir

learning in a good and empathetic way, andincreased their understanding of Indigenousissues. Many applauded the University andwished they could have learned these things alongtimeago.

•  Faculty had been concerned about a potentialbacklashfromstudentsbutourfindingsshowedagenerallypositivelearningexperience.

•  Emergent themes were the importance ofrelationships, respect, and safety; eagerness tolearn with and from Indigenous peoples; thedesire to work together for a better, moreinclusiveeducationsystemandsociety.

“We are All Relations”: Indigenous Course Requirement (ICR)

Dr. Helen Lepp Friesen Tyler Andrade Department of Rhetoric, Writing, and Communications

ReferencesAxworthy,L.,&Kinew,W.(2013,January11).Canada’sfuture:Let’sbedividednomore.InTheGlobeandMail.RetrievedonMay22,2017fromhttp://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/canadas-future-lets-be-divided-no-more/article7199421/GraffitiatUniversityofWinnipegtargetsFirstNations.(2013,March).InCBCNews.RetrievedonNovember28,2017fromhttp://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/graffiti-at-university-of-winnipeg-targets-first-nations-1.1350599Koblun,J.(2016).ConversationsinCulturalFluency:TheTwoRowWampum.TwoRowTimes.RetrievedonAugust2,2017fromhttps://tworowtimes.com/news/conversations-in-cultural-fluency-the-two-row-wampum/IndigenousContentRequirement.(2017).LakeheadUniversity.RetrievedonMay24,2017fromhttps://www.lakeheadu.ca/faculty-and-staff/departments/services/ai/icrIndigenousCourseRequirement.(2016).TheUniversityofWinnipeg.RetrievedonMay18,2017fromhttp://uwinnipeg.ca/indigenous-course-requirement/Macdonald,N.(2015,January).WelcometoWinnipeg:WhereCanada’sracismproblemisatitsworst.InMaclean’s.RetrievedonApril19,2017fromhttp://www.macleans.ca/news/canada/welcome-to-winnipeg-where-canadas-racism-problem-isat-its-worst/TwoRowWampumBelt.RetrievedonNovember22,2017fromhttp://mohawknationnews.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/two-row-old.jpgTruthandReconciliationCommissionofCanada.(2015,December).CallstoAction.RetrievedonMay9,2017fromhttp://www.trc.ca/websites/trcinstitution/File/2015/Findings/Calls_to_Action_English2.pdfUWinnipegFastFacts(2017).InAboutUWinnipeg.UniversityofWinnipeg.Winnipeg,Canada.Retrievedfromhttps://uwinnipeg.ca/about/fast-facts/index.htmlThankyoutoCatherinevanReenenforposterdesignassistance.

Abstract This mixed-methods study consulted with students,faculty, and staff to develop insight into theirexperiencesoftheIndigenousCourseRequirement(ICR)in its initial implementation in the 2016/17 academicyear at TheUniversity ofWinnipeg. Although studentsand instructors had suggestions for how to improvecourse content, development, delivery, and support,there were far more positive reactions to the ICRexperiencethannegative.

Description of Initiative •  UWSAproposed an IndigenousCourseRequirement

(ICR)totheUniversity’sSenatein2014.•  The ICRwasapprovedbySenate inNovember2015

andimplementedinthefallof2016forall incomingundergraduate students (Indigenous CourseRequirement,2016).

•  In2016/2017,27courseswithatotalof46sectionswereofferedacross9departments.

Methods & Sample Multimodal data were collected during the winter of2017fromthefollowing:•  10 faculty and staff from six departments who

participated via 30-minute voice recordedinterviews.

•  164studentsrespondedtoasurveyinvitationsentto 1,230 students who had taken an ICR (13%responserate).

•  19 students who participated in one of three60-90-minutefocusgroupdiscussions.

Challenges Mostfaculty,staff,andstudentsagreedthatracismandlackofknowledgeexistandthateducationandrelationshipsarekeytochangingstereotypes. Keychallengesincluded:•  thepressureon Indigenousstudents to takeon

the roleof tokenauthorityon“the” Indigenousexperience;

•  how to sensitively support students and staffwhentalkingaboutatraumatichistory;

•  howtomanagecontentiousdiscussionsinclass.

SharingCircleClassroom OverallStudentICRExperience AboriginalStudentServicesCentre

Recommendations

Personalexperiencestories

Circlemethod

Eldersintheclassroom

ClearinformationabouttheICR

Supportservicesforfaculty,staff,

&students

Hands-onlearning&fullimmersion

Manywaysofcommunicating&evaluating

Artandoralteaching

Storytellingaspedagogy

Learninglanguages

MoreIndigenoushires

SciencecoursesforSciencestudents

“I thought it was going to be just another requirementthat Iwas not going to enjoy asmuch, that the contentwasgoing tobedryorboring. I really liked thecourse; Ilearnedmuchmore than I expected to (thinking I knewenough information about the Indigenous of NorthAmerica).”

“The ICR course has taught me to be careful ofstereotypes. Learn the history and the people beforemaking general assumptions or agreeing with others oncareless and uneducated thoughts and comments... WeareonTreatyland,andweshouldberespectfulofthat.”

Highlights